December 2012 (issue 128) - The Sussex Archaeological Society
December 2012 (issue 128) - The Sussex Archaeological Society
December 2012 (issue 128) - The Sussex Archaeological Society
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
N u m b e r 1 2 8 D E C E M B E R 2 0 1 2<br />
Culver <strong>Archaeological</strong> Project<br />
Best Finds of the Year<br />
Excavations at Fishbourne<br />
Piltdown Conference Report<br />
Arts Council Award for Museums<br />
www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
Membership Matters<br />
MEMBERSHIP<br />
OPENING LINES<br />
Opening Lines<br />
Lorna’s Notebook<br />
A round-up of all that’s new in the membership department<br />
Welcome to the <strong>December</strong><br />
edition of <strong>Sussex</strong> Past &<br />
Present.<br />
Subscriptions increase for<br />
2013<br />
It is with regret that we have<br />
had to increase our subscriptions<br />
slightly with effect from 1 January<br />
2013, as agreed at this year’s AGM.<br />
Many of you (though not all) are<br />
due to renew your subscription to<br />
the <strong>Society</strong> at the beginning of the<br />
year, and it would really help us if<br />
you would check your membership<br />
card now, and, if you are due for<br />
renewal on 1 January, arrange<br />
for payment straightaway. This<br />
will save the cost of sending out<br />
reminder notices, which is usually<br />
done in late January. Of course, if<br />
you pay by direct debit, you need<br />
take no further action – you will be<br />
notified in writing of the date and<br />
amount of the collection.<br />
Subscription Type & Description<br />
O Standard Individual £35<br />
J Joint (2 adults/same address) £50<br />
F1 Family (1 adult + children) £41<br />
F2 Family (2 adults + children) £53<br />
S Student £17<br />
AFF Affiliated <strong>Society</strong> £35<br />
+B Hardback copy of SAC +£6<br />
+POST Overseas postage charge +£13<br />
If you do not currently pay by<br />
direct debit, do please download<br />
a copy of the mandate from the<br />
Membership section of our website<br />
www.sussexpast.co.uk and return<br />
it to me. Other ways in which you<br />
can pay are:<br />
- cheque, payable to “<strong>Sussex</strong><br />
Past” and sent to me at Bull House<br />
- online at http://sussexpast.<br />
co.uk/payment<br />
- by credit card over the phone,<br />
Tuesday to Friday, 10am – 3pm<br />
Saturday 22 September:<br />
Piltdown Centenery<br />
Conference:<br />
Truth and Lies from<br />
the Deep <strong>Sussex</strong> Past<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Society</strong>’s <strong>2012</strong> autumn<br />
conference in Lewes was a great<br />
success and attracted attention<br />
from the BBC both at local and<br />
national levels. Speakers from the<br />
Natural History Museum, the British<br />
Museum, London, Bournemouth<br />
and Southampton Universities and<br />
the University of Witwatersrand<br />
in South Africa gathered to<br />
commemorate the centenary of<br />
this notorious fraud and to examine<br />
the evidence against the chief<br />
suspects while placing the fraud in<br />
its historical context and concluding<br />
with a look at the real evidence of<br />
early habitation still coming to light<br />
at the Piltdown site. See page<br />
10 for a report of the conference.<br />
Members who were unable to<br />
attend may like to know that we are<br />
hoping it may be possible to upload<br />
some of the talks (sound files only)<br />
from the conference and make<br />
them available for you to listen to<br />
again via our website. <strong>The</strong>re have<br />
been some technical <strong>issue</strong>s about<br />
this in relation to trying to make the<br />
Battle of Lewes conference talks<br />
available on line, so we cannot<br />
guarantee success, but we are still<br />
looking into this possibility.<br />
Christmas Shopping<br />
and the <strong>Society</strong><br />
A reminder – especially useful<br />
for this time of year - that if you<br />
shop online you can raise a little<br />
additional money for the <strong>Society</strong><br />
at no extra cost by using www.<br />
easyfundraising.org.uk as your<br />
portal for purchases. Simply register<br />
and choose <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong><br />
<strong>Society</strong> as your cause, and the<br />
retailers listed on the site will make<br />
a small donation to us every time<br />
you buy something. <strong>The</strong>re are<br />
no additional costs to you as the<br />
consumer, and you still buy directly<br />
from the retailers’ own websites<br />
– the only difference is that you<br />
reach your chosen retailer’s site<br />
by logging onto easyfundraising.<br />
org first. Amazon, British Airways,<br />
John Lewis and Boots the Chemist<br />
are among the hundreds of retailers<br />
who participate, and every donation,<br />
however small, will help us.<br />
Membership as a Gift<br />
While on the topic of Christmas,<br />
have you considered giving<br />
membership of the <strong>Society</strong> as a gift<br />
to your friends or relatives I am<br />
always happy to arrange this, and<br />
the welcome pack can be posted<br />
either directly to the recipient or to<br />
the purchaser to be handed over<br />
in person. Given the pressure on<br />
the post at this time of year, I would<br />
suggest that you contact me to<br />
arrange this as soon as possible<br />
if you would like to arrange a gift<br />
membership.<br />
May I wish you all a good 2013.<br />
Lorna Gartside<br />
Membership Secretary<br />
MEMBERSHIP<br />
DEPARTMENT<br />
Bull House, 92 High Street<br />
Lewes, BN7 1XH<br />
Tues-Fri 10am-3pm<br />
Answering machine<br />
outside these hours<br />
01273 405737<br />
members@sussexpast.co.uk<br />
SUSSEX<br />
Past &<br />
Present<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong><br />
<strong>Society</strong> Newsletter<br />
N u m b e r 1 2 8<br />
D E C E M B E R 2 0 1 2<br />
Contents<br />
2 Membership Matters<br />
3 Opening Lines<br />
4 Culver Project<br />
5 Culver Project<br />
6 Best Finds of the Year<br />
7 Alan Stevens Obituary<br />
8 President & CEO Letters<br />
9 Excavations at Fishbourne<br />
10 Piltdown Conference<br />
11 Arts Council Grant<br />
12 Library & Bookshop<br />
13 Book Reviews<br />
14 Book Reviews<br />
15 Book Reviews<br />
16 Snippets<br />
Published by the <strong>Sussex</strong><br />
<strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong>, Bull<br />
House, Lewes, E <strong>Sussex</strong>, BN71XH<br />
Tel: 01273 486260<br />
Fax: 01273 486990<br />
Email: adminlewes@sussexpast.<br />
co.uk<br />
Editor: Wendy Muriel<br />
Email: spp@sussexpast.co.uk<br />
Research Editor: Luke Barber<br />
ISSN 1357-7417<br />
Cover: <strong>The</strong> Barbican at Lewes Castle<br />
Photo: Wendy Muriel<br />
Your <strong>Society</strong><br />
...has weathered a difficult year!<br />
This year has been a difficult and tasking year for the <strong>Society</strong>. <strong>The</strong><br />
weather, Jubilee and Olympics have had a detrimental effect on<br />
visitor numbers to our properties and reduced visitor numbers results<br />
in reduced admission revenue and shop sales. Lewes Castle and Anne<br />
of Cleves House have done better than the other properties, perhaps a<br />
reflection of their town locations and that they are still benefiting from the<br />
refurbishment work that was carried out on them in the last few years.<br />
That is the bad news. Those visitors who braved the weather have<br />
given very good reports of their visits and members of staff have worked<br />
wonders in difficult conditions. <strong>The</strong> catering company at Fishbourne went<br />
into liquidation last year leaving us without any catering on the site. <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Society</strong> is now running the catering in house and great improvements are<br />
expected. <strong>The</strong> in-house catering at Michelham has proved very popular<br />
and is attracting return visits from patrons. Many members and visitors<br />
have remarked on the catering which is bringing in return visits to the<br />
Priory. It is also hoped to have a café open at Anne of Cleves in the<br />
future. <strong>The</strong> Trustees recognise that having good catering facilities at all<br />
our properties should be part of the visitor offer.<br />
Weddings at Lewes Castle and Anne of Cleves have increased in<br />
number and are contributing towards the cost of running the properties<br />
and it is hoped that the improvements at Michelham Priory will also<br />
increase revenue from weddings. Another positive is that more visitors<br />
are signing up to the Gift Aid scheme whereby the <strong>Society</strong> can claim back<br />
tax at no cost to the visitors.<br />
Thanks to funding from the Friends, the gatehouse kiosk at Michelham<br />
Priory is currently being rebuilt to improve the first impressions of the site.<br />
<strong>The</strong> out-of-date kiosk was not an asset to the lovely gatehouse. One of<br />
the best impressions of Michelham is that view of the house and gardens<br />
from the archway beneath the gatehouse.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Committee structure of the Trustees is being altered to reflect<br />
the current needs of the <strong>Society</strong> and give more support to staff. <strong>The</strong><br />
great work of the Education and Museum teams is being given more<br />
prominence and the Friends groups given more support. It is hoped that<br />
a joint Friends’ committee will be formed to allow better communication<br />
between the various properties’ Friends groups. A new Friends of Lewes<br />
Castle will also be formed.<br />
It is lovely to see up to 120 school children at a time enjoying the sights<br />
at Michelham or Fishbourne, dressing up in character and absorbing the<br />
history. At Michelham they learn about the evacuation during World War II<br />
and at Fishbourne about the Roman occupation. <strong>The</strong> education provided<br />
by the <strong>Society</strong> forms part of our revenue and helps to inform future<br />
generations of our heritage. We hope they return with their parents!<br />
<strong>The</strong>re are many positive things happening in the <strong>Society</strong> at present and,<br />
at the end of the season, we look forward to a better result next year.<br />
Richard Akhurst<br />
Chair of Council<br />
<strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
Excavations<br />
CULVER PROJECT<br />
CULVER PROJECT<br />
Excavations<br />
Research<br />
Culver <strong>Archaeological</strong> Project<br />
An intriguing first seven years<br />
For the last seven years<br />
the Culver <strong>Archaeological</strong><br />
Project (CAP), under director Rob<br />
Wallace, has been investigating<br />
the historical environment of the<br />
Upper Ouse Valley in the parishes<br />
of Barcombe and Ringmer. In 2005<br />
Rob had discovered a substantial<br />
Roman road running to the east<br />
of the Barcombe villa complex,<br />
heading north east through the<br />
fields of Culver Farm, where CAP’s<br />
subsequent fieldwork has been<br />
undertaken (Fig 1).<br />
Fig.1 Map of Culver Farm showing the main features and field locations. <br />
In 2005-6 a series of evaluation<br />
trenches were dug in Pond Field and<br />
its northern neighbour Culver Mead<br />
which established the existence<br />
and bearing of the road as well as<br />
showing roadside activity. In 2007<br />
a larger open area excavation in<br />
Pond Field exposed 20m of the<br />
road together with an area each<br />
side which showed clearly the<br />
substantial nature of the road<br />
and the intensity of the roadside<br />
industrial activity. This area was<br />
targeted again in 2010.<br />
In 2009 the main emphasis moved<br />
to the south west, to Court House<br />
Field, where 50m of closely packed<br />
flint road foundations some 400mm<br />
deep were uncovered (Fig 2). <strong>The</strong><br />
area chosen was over a discernible<br />
kink in the road noticed from the<br />
previous year’s geophysics results.<br />
Whilst a fine section of road was<br />
exposed and recorded the reason<br />
for the changes of direction was not<br />
altogether clear, although a series<br />
of crossing palaeo-channels might<br />
have made this area unstable.<br />
Fig 2. <strong>The</strong> section of Roman road exposed in<br />
2009. Photo: D Millum<br />
Seven years digging had<br />
produced over 6000 sherds of<br />
pottery that needed specialist<br />
analysis and reporting. A substantial<br />
Margary Grant from the <strong>Sussex</strong><br />
<strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong> (SAS), plus<br />
a smaller sum from the University<br />
of <strong>Sussex</strong> Archaeology <strong>Society</strong><br />
(USAS), allowed the project to<br />
employ Malcolm Lyne to undertake<br />
the analysis. Malcolm was the ideal<br />
choice since, as an acknowledged<br />
expert on Roman pottery in the<br />
area, he could coordinate the<br />
Culver assemblage with that of his<br />
own classification of pottery fabrics<br />
for the Barcombe villa.<br />
He concluded that nearly all the<br />
Roman pottery from Culver was of<br />
3rd to early 4th century date. Over<br />
93% of the sherds came from the<br />
excavations in Pond Field with only<br />
382 from Culver Mead and just<br />
19 from the excavation in Court<br />
House Field, which unlike the fields<br />
to the north showed no road side<br />
settlement. 71 different fabrics<br />
were present, 29 coarse, 34 fine, 5<br />
mortaria and 3 of amphora.<br />
<strong>The</strong> trenches in Culver Mead in<br />
2006 had revealed 3 water-logged<br />
timbers that were radiocarbon<br />
dated to c. cal AD240-430 and<br />
Malcolm’s report similarly confirms<br />
the pottery assemblage to AD250-<br />
400. He also highlights a fragment<br />
of a lamp or chimney similar to an<br />
example from the triangular temple<br />
at Verulamium (Lyne <strong>2012</strong>).<br />
<strong>The</strong> bulk of the Pond Field<br />
assemblages were of handmade<br />
local East <strong>Sussex</strong> Wares with the<br />
largest derivable amount coming<br />
from the nearby Wickham Barn<br />
kilns. Other British coarsewares<br />
were represented including Alice<br />
Holt greyware. <strong>The</strong> finewares<br />
included fragments of beakers in<br />
Colchester colour-coat, Oxford red<br />
colour-coat, Lower Nene Valley and<br />
New Forest. <strong>The</strong> Samian included<br />
both Central and Eastern Gaulish<br />
products (Lyne <strong>2012</strong>).<br />
Fig 3. Moselkeramik carafe rim from Arlon.<br />
Photo: D Millum<br />
One of the most interesting<br />
sherds was part of the rim of a late<br />
3rd century carafe in a metallic<br />
black colour-coat ware from the<br />
Arlon kilns in Lorraine Belge (Fig<br />
3); a very unusual product to find<br />
anywhere in Britain (Lyne <strong>2012</strong>).<br />
Whilst the road undoubtedly<br />
had a far longer period of use, as<br />
indicated by the Flavius Honorius<br />
silver Siliqua of AD395-402 (Fig 4)<br />
Fig 5. Magnetometer survey results from Pond Field. Image: D Staveley 2011<br />
found in the corner of Court House<br />
Field, the main period of roadside<br />
activity in Pond Field would seem<br />
to fall into the later 3rd to early 4th<br />
century. This presumes that the<br />
Samian and some other finer wares<br />
were already old, possibly handeddown,<br />
items and date from prior to<br />
the period of lower class working<br />
activity at the site. Two exceptions<br />
would seem to be a small pit by the<br />
northwest baulk of the excavation<br />
which contained an assemblage of<br />
34 sherds dated to the late 2nd and<br />
early 3rd centuries and a clay lined<br />
pit, also located to the west of the<br />
road, which contained pottery dating<br />
to mid or even later 4th century. A<br />
Fig 4. Scan of the Flavius Honorius silver<br />
Siliqua.<br />
Photo: D Millum<br />
subsequent magnetometer survey<br />
has revealed interesting anomalies<br />
to the west of these features which<br />
deserve further investigation.<br />
An important aspect of the<br />
investigations undertaken by CAP<br />
has been the use of geophysical<br />
surveys both using electrical<br />
resistance and magnetic variation<br />
techniques to produce images of<br />
the subterranean features. <strong>The</strong>se<br />
have been particularly useful in<br />
tracing the route of the Roman<br />
road and suggesting areas of<br />
roadside activity. Major surveys in<br />
2008 and 2011 have highlighted<br />
some interesting areas for future<br />
excavation as well as suggesting<br />
that not all Roman roads are<br />
perfectly straight (Fig 5).<br />
A great deal of interpretation is<br />
still needed to integrate this new<br />
information into the excavation<br />
reports which are currently in<br />
production but the financial<br />
assistance of SAS & USAS has<br />
allowed an early completion of<br />
these documents to become a real<br />
possibility.<br />
David Millum & Rob Wallace<br />
co-directors of the Culver<br />
<strong>Archaeological</strong> Project<br />
www.culverproject.co.uk<br />
davidmillum@mypostoffice.<br />
co.uk<br />
<strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
Feature<br />
FLO ROUND-UP<br />
ALAN STEVENS<br />
Obituary<br />
Best Finds of the Year<br />
<strong>The</strong> Finds Liaison Officer reports on significant finds of <strong>2012</strong><br />
This is the fourth annual roundup<br />
of some of the best finds<br />
recorded in <strong>Sussex</strong> by the Portable<br />
Antiquities Scheme (PAS). Since<br />
our last report we have created<br />
1274 records of 1346 finds from<br />
East and West <strong>Sussex</strong>, resulting in<br />
a total of 18,505 records in <strong>Sussex</strong>.<br />
This year’s recorded finds range in<br />
date from a Mesolithic flint pick, c.<br />
8300 - 3500 BC (SUSS-64E778)<br />
to a wide array of Post Medieval<br />
and early Modern objects. Two<br />
examples include a Georgian gilt<br />
fob seal with an inlaid glass seal<br />
depicting a female classical figure<br />
(SUSS-A737F6) and the largest<br />
animal bell recorded for <strong>Sussex</strong>,<br />
probably used for an ox or bull<br />
(SUSS-716BD3); it is larger in<br />
dimension than a tennis ball!<br />
In addition, our efforts to<br />
encourage volunteer self-recording<br />
this year have produced more than<br />
200 records on the PAS database.<br />
This is a reflection of the enthusiasm<br />
of some of our <strong>Sussex</strong> finders<br />
and their willingness to become<br />
more involved with the Portable<br />
Antiquities Scheme database. For<br />
further information about finds<br />
mentioned here or to discover<br />
recent finds in your area, please<br />
explore our website at www.finds.<br />
org.uk.<br />
<strong>The</strong> following discoveries are<br />
some of the most interesting from<br />
the past year and are highlighted<br />
due to their personal significance or<br />
their importance within the <strong>Sussex</strong><br />
landscape.<br />
Forty-five items of Treasure have<br />
been declared in <strong>Sussex</strong> over the<br />
past year and this first find is one of<br />
them. PAS record SUSS-628524<br />
is a silver Medieval seal (13th-<br />
14th C AD) inlaid with a Roman<br />
carnelian intaglio (c. 1st-3rd C AD),<br />
discovered in East <strong>Sussex</strong>. <strong>The</strong><br />
seal is inscribed as belonging to<br />
an Alan of ‘Duntune’, the Medieval<br />
spelling of Dutton in Cheshire. It<br />
is possible that this individual<br />
belonged to the de Dutton line,<br />
which originated in this country with<br />
the Norman invasion; ‘Duntune’ is<br />
later recorded as a place-name in<br />
the Domesday Book. <strong>The</strong> Roman<br />
intaglio (above) depicts a winged<br />
Victory driving a two-horse chariot<br />
called a ‘biga’ and is likely to<br />
have been either found or ordered<br />
specially for its use in the seal. This<br />
seal would have reflected a wealthy<br />
individual’s personal taste and<br />
decision to incorporate an ancient<br />
object within a newer personal seal<br />
design. Hopefully, future research<br />
will help us to better understand<br />
this unique object.<br />
<strong>The</strong> second object (above),<br />
SUSS-761CD0, has been identified<br />
as the hilt of a late Hallstatt B3<br />
Urnfield sword, dating to the Late<br />
Bronze Age (1150-700 BC). It is the<br />
only sword hilt of its kind recorded<br />
on the PAS database and would<br />
have been an expensive and special<br />
piece of personal armour during the<br />
period of transition from Bronze Age<br />
to Iron Age in <strong>Sussex</strong>. It is unusual<br />
to find this type of object away<br />
from a larger hoard or burial, and as<br />
such has proven to be mysterious.<br />
<strong>The</strong> sword hilts of this period were<br />
decorated with coiled arms and<br />
incised design; they would have<br />
been coveted by their owner.<br />
This year, West <strong>Sussex</strong> has<br />
produced some particularly<br />
interesting finds from the Roman<br />
period. Amongst them is a delicate<br />
cast copper-alloy figurine of Cupid<br />
(SUSS-591C64 - below), a lead<br />
votive axehead (SUSS-571122) and<br />
a contemporary copy of a Roman<br />
nummus combining the obverse<br />
of a coin of Constantius II and the<br />
reverse of Magnentius (SUSS-<br />
4DCAC2). All of these objects help<br />
us to better understand the ritual<br />
and practical needs of <strong>Sussex</strong><br />
inhabitants between AD 43-410.<br />
<strong>The</strong> final object I’ve chosen to<br />
highlight was selected not because<br />
of its rarity on the database, but<br />
because of its significance to the<br />
area in which it was found. SUSS-<br />
93B5D3 (above right) is a very late<br />
Bronze Age socketed axehead<br />
with a facetted body, flared blade<br />
and small loop. This axehead was<br />
discovered within a short distance<br />
of Wolstonbury Hill, a wellknown<br />
prehistoric site. Within the<br />
axehead, modern cartridges were<br />
found which suggests perhaps that<br />
this object has been discovered<br />
previously and re-interred in nearby<br />
soil. It is therefore possible that this<br />
axehead comes directly from the<br />
Wolstonbury site. It was discovered<br />
by a Friend of Wolstonbury and<br />
relinquished to the Wolstonbury<br />
Trust for keeping as part of the<br />
collection. According to the Trust,<br />
the discovery of an axehead in<br />
direct association to Wolstonbury<br />
is exceedingly rare and as such,<br />
could tell us more about late Bronze<br />
Age activity within the site.<br />
As this year draws to a close, I<br />
must say good bye to two excellent<br />
colleagues: Lucy Ellis and Claire<br />
Goodey. As Finds Liaison Assistant<br />
and Headley Bursary intern for<br />
the past six months, Lucy has<br />
cheerfully tackled every aspect of<br />
Finds Liaison work: from meeting<br />
with finders; to identifying and<br />
recording finds; to participating in<br />
outreach; to helping with a metal<br />
detecting rally. Claire Goodey has<br />
been a dedicated volunteer for<br />
three years and is responsible for<br />
recording nearly 400 records onto<br />
the database. Her exemplary work<br />
in anything that needs to be done,<br />
whether identifying artefacts or<br />
keeping the FLO organised (no small<br />
task!) will be missed. Due to their<br />
efforts and those of the rest of my<br />
volunteer staff, we have managed to<br />
take in more finds, while providing<br />
a service to a swelling number of<br />
finders in <strong>Sussex</strong>.<br />
Stephanie Smith<br />
Finds Liaison Officer, <strong>Sussex</strong><br />
Alan Stevens<br />
1934-<strong>2012</strong><br />
Alan Stevens, who died on 24 March, will be recalled by many<br />
members as a constant attendee at lectures, walks and<br />
conferences. Born at Hove in 1934, he joined the <strong>Society</strong> as a boy,<br />
coming under the influence of Hove archaeologist Eric Holden and<br />
going on outings while still at school. Suffering badly from examination<br />
nerves, he reached Lancaster University as one of its earliest mature<br />
students, having held posts in a series of prep schools while he<br />
worked to gain the necessary A-levels. <strong>The</strong> occupation at which he<br />
excelled, though, was lecturing for the WEA and the University of<br />
Kent in history and archaeology, with a special interest in vernacular<br />
architecture.<br />
Alan enlivened occasions he attended with his constant spirit of<br />
intellectual enquiry, taking notes and where necessary challenging<br />
lecturer or walk leader. He was keen both to learn and to impart his<br />
own knowledge to others - a polymath with whom you could discuss<br />
many subjects besides history and archaeology, notably politics and<br />
music.<br />
Alan was certainly an eccentric. On outings, in whatever weather,<br />
he would carry, sometimes underneath his anorak, a large rucksack<br />
containing inter alia a folding umbrella to keep the rain away. At a<br />
meeting of the <strong>Society</strong>’s Events committee he hosted circa 1992<br />
I remember him offering sugar for tea as wrapped portions he’d<br />
collected from restaurants and cafes, presented in a large waste<br />
paper basket!<br />
Sadly, he never put much of his learning into print, a sole contribution<br />
to Collections being part of the Stretham (Henfield) moated site<br />
report in Volume 147. For a time, though, he wrote up events in the<br />
<strong>Society</strong>’s Newsletter, humorously claiming the title of ‘Hon Reporter’.<br />
Many books from his extensive collection have been donated to the<br />
<strong>Society</strong>, either for its own library or for sale in the Barbican House<br />
bookshop.<br />
Tim Hudson<br />
<strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
Letters<br />
THE PRESIDENT & CEO<br />
FISHBOURNE EXCAVATION<br />
Excavations<br />
Research<br />
Dear Members...<br />
At the <strong>Society</strong>’s AGM this year I was honoured to be elected President. Thank you.<br />
During the course of the meeting, Item 7 covered proposals to change four of our Articles of Association,<br />
part of the governing document of the <strong>Society</strong>. <strong>The</strong> changes suggested were based upon a version of the<br />
Articles of Association entitled “amended in 2006”. After the meeting, I scrutinised this document and noticed<br />
errors. This led me to a detailed examination of previous General Meeting agendas and minutes since 1994. I<br />
discovered that the AGM of 2006 had no amendment resolution to the Articles of Association, so any version<br />
dated 2006 is unapproved.<br />
Since 1995, the only amendment made to the Articles was that approved by the members at AGM 2004 in<br />
East Grinstead. This amendment was based on advice from the Charity Commission and allowed there to be<br />
between 10 and 14 Council Members, rather than exactly twelve. Thus the correct version of the Articles of<br />
Association should be those which include the headings -Adopted on 25th June 1994, Amended on 20th May<br />
1995, Amended on 5th June 2004. This is now on the <strong>Society</strong>’s website members’ area.<br />
Please note that the numbering of the Articles in the correct version is so different from that in the erroneous<br />
2006 draft that the voting for changing specific numbered articles at the <strong>2012</strong> AGM is completely undermined.<br />
None of the numbers matched because some articles had been deleted. Also, unauthorised wording had been<br />
inserted. In consequence, the resolutions passed in good faith under Agenda Item 7 at AGM <strong>2012</strong> are null and<br />
void.<br />
No culprit should be sought. This error lies with corruption of data several years ago through cumulative<br />
mistakes in saving computer files or when replacing equipment. Office and paper filing procedures will be<br />
tightened up. It remains for me to extend an apology to the membership on behalf of present and former<br />
Council Members and staff that this error has occurred. I confirm that our Articles of Association remain those<br />
dated 2004.<br />
Caroline Wells<br />
President<br />
Firstly I would like to wish you all a very merry Christmas and to thank you for your support over the last<br />
year. I know many of you have attended our excellent conferences and events and that member visits to<br />
our properties are at a record level. We are all looking forward to the 150th edition of the <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong><br />
Collections next year, this will be a real landmark for the <strong>Society</strong> and we will celebrate this achievement.<br />
In February and March next year we plan to hold two further Members’ Open Discussion sessions; the dates<br />
can be found in the Noticeboard section (see opposite). As previously these represent an opportunity to share<br />
details of the current <strong>issue</strong>s facing the <strong>Society</strong> and to hear and record the views of members. A record of<br />
the discussions during the three sessions held earlier this year are on the Members’ section of the <strong>Society</strong>’s<br />
website. This is very valuable as it provides a record which staff and trustees can use to understand the views<br />
of members who attended and contributed to the sessions.<br />
Over the next period the Trustees and senior staff will be collating all the information about the activities which<br />
the <strong>Society</strong> has undertaken this year. This process will help direct the planning for next year and beyond. As<br />
previously, the major <strong>issue</strong> of the financial performance of the <strong>Society</strong> will be at the heart of any considerations<br />
about future resourcing and structures. <strong>The</strong> views of members, received through the discussion sessions,<br />
together with various surveys and individual correspondence, will be fed into the process of forward planning.<br />
<strong>The</strong> meetings next year represent an opportunity to share with you the outcome of these deliberations and<br />
decisions. I think we are all painfully aware that the <strong>Society</strong> is very reliant on the income from our properties<br />
and that the appalling weather this summer has had a significant effect on this. <strong>The</strong> Trustees will be faced with<br />
very real challenges in terms of looking at what we can offer and how we do it. Quite simply there will have to<br />
be changes based on the reality of what we can actually afford to do. This should not detract from our ability to<br />
appreciate the excellent achievements of our staff, Trustees and volunteers during <strong>2012</strong> and there is still much<br />
to celebrate.<br />
Tristan Bareham<br />
Chief Executive<br />
Excavations at Fishbourne<br />
Old spoil heaps still have a story to tell!<br />
For the first time since 2002,<br />
a research excavation has<br />
been undertaken at Fishbourne<br />
Roman Palace, but this was not<br />
an excavation in the conventional<br />
sense. In March this year we took<br />
a sample of approximately one<br />
tonne from the spoil heaps created<br />
in the 1960s when the Palace was<br />
originally excavated. Of course,<br />
the sample was of mixed and<br />
unstratified excavation waste. It<br />
contained modern artefacts such<br />
as bottle tops, nails and 20th<br />
century coins that were left by<br />
the archaeologists nearly 50 years<br />
ago, but crucially also any Roman<br />
material that they did not recover or<br />
deliberately discarded.<br />
No excavation will recover all<br />
of the artefacts from the site. Bias<br />
against small or modern objects<br />
or those that are difficult to spot<br />
will always exist. This bias will<br />
vary according to the experience<br />
and interests of the excavators,<br />
the resources available and even<br />
the weather conditions. For these<br />
reasons the bias is unique to<br />
each site. <strong>The</strong> intention of the<br />
Fishbourne sample is, through very<br />
fine sieving and careful sorting,<br />
to recover as close to 100% of<br />
the artefacts as possible. This will<br />
give an impression of what was<br />
not recovered from the site when<br />
it was excavated. In turn this will<br />
allow a wholesale reassessment<br />
of the artefacts recovered in the<br />
1960s and stored in the Collections<br />
Discovery Centre at Fishbourne. It<br />
may become apparent, for example,<br />
that the ratio of grey ware pottery<br />
to Samian in the stored archive is<br />
as much a reflection of the higher<br />
visibility of the highly coloured<br />
Samian as it is an indication of the<br />
status of the site. It will also be a<br />
chance to recover from Fishbourne<br />
very small objects such as fish<br />
Family fun at the Festival of British Archaeology<br />
bones, small mammal remains and<br />
seeds for the first time.<br />
This is an unusual project and<br />
places the Palace at the forefront of<br />
current thinking when it comes to<br />
the interpretation of stored archives.<br />
Work is ongoing, but if anything<br />
can be guaranteed at this stage,<br />
the project will provide researchers<br />
with something to think about for<br />
years to come.<br />
Allied to the project, the staff at<br />
Fishbourne took the opportunity<br />
to extend the sample trenches and<br />
enable some of the Palace visitors to<br />
have a go at excavation themselves.<br />
As part of the <strong>2012</strong> Festival of British<br />
Archaeology visitors of all ages<br />
were invited to visit the spoil heaps,<br />
borrow a trowel and experience the<br />
excitement of discovering artefacts<br />
for themselves. Roman tesserae<br />
and 1960s nails seemed to elicit<br />
similar levels of excitement! Over<br />
a thousand artefacts were found<br />
ranging from relatively recent<br />
objects such as a halfpenny piece<br />
dated 1974 and the older style<br />
1960s ring pulls from drinks cans to<br />
Photo: <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />
pieces of pot and bone. Probably<br />
the most interesting find was a<br />
small fragment of high quality<br />
Samian pottery (shown below). It is<br />
decorated with part of an image of<br />
a running animal, possibly a dog or<br />
a horse.<br />
Participants were also given the<br />
chance to try their hand at surveying,<br />
site planning, sample sorting and<br />
to meet our conservation team.<br />
<strong>The</strong> event was a great success and<br />
plans are afoot to repeat it in some<br />
(probably larger) form next year.<br />
Dr Rob Symmons<br />
Curator, Fishbourne Roman Palace<br />
<strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong>
Feature<br />
CONFERENCE REPORT<br />
GRANT AWARD<br />
Feature<br />
<strong>The</strong> Piltdown Conference<br />
Truth and Lies from the Deep <strong>Sussex</strong> Past<br />
<strong>The</strong> subtitle for this conference<br />
could easily have been “What<br />
you don’t know about Piltdown”<br />
and all of the speakers made the<br />
audience think about the wellknown<br />
story afresh.<br />
John Farrant started the<br />
proceedings on a historical note,<br />
exploring some of the questions<br />
about the relationship between the<br />
<strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong> and<br />
the Piltdown discoveries. Charles<br />
Dawson’s family background<br />
was described and his increasing<br />
involvement with the <strong>Society</strong> after<br />
his move to Uckfield in 1889, which<br />
saw his promotion of his projects at<br />
the Lavant Caves and at Hastings<br />
Castle. We were left to wonder<br />
how much his estrangement from<br />
the <strong>Society</strong> after the Castle Lodge<br />
affair contributed to his switch<br />
to an interest in the Palaeolithic,<br />
which, at that time SAC left to the<br />
geologists.<br />
Beccy Scott (British Museum)<br />
& Andy Shaw (Southampton<br />
University) took us through<br />
the archaeological and<br />
palaeontological context for<br />
Piltdown and built a convincing<br />
case that the construction of the<br />
Piltdown collection looked more<br />
to 19th century interpretations of<br />
deep human prehistory than they<br />
Robert Kruszynski, from the Natural History Museum, fascinated delegates with a display of casts of<br />
the main specimens from the Piltdown collection.<br />
Photo: E Livesey<br />
did to the ensuing 20th century.<br />
An intriguing point made here was<br />
that the investigations at Barnfield<br />
Pit (Swanscombe) started in 1912<br />
and the way in which Smith &<br />
Dewey worked there is much more<br />
in tune with modern methods than<br />
the rather dilettante approach at<br />
Piltdown.<br />
Robert Kruszynski (Natural<br />
History Museum) gave us an account<br />
both of the curation of the Piltdown<br />
material at the Natural History<br />
Museum and tantalised us with an<br />
account of the research currently<br />
being done on the specimens. He<br />
stole the show with an exhibit of<br />
casts of the main specimens and<br />
some of the original flints from the<br />
Piltdown collection.<br />
John McNabb (Southampton<br />
University) put the discovery of<br />
Piltdown into the context of 1912<br />
as a remarkable year - Scott in<br />
the Antarctic, the Titanic’s maiden<br />
voyage and the publication of<br />
Tarzan of the Apes. He explained<br />
his reanalysis of the lithics and<br />
convincingly argued that these had<br />
been intended to reveal a sequence<br />
from Pliocene eoliths through to<br />
the Pleistocene Chellean, with the<br />
Piltdown cranium placed in the<br />
middle of this. Some of the later<br />
finds were argued to be attempts<br />
to re-establish this sequence when<br />
interpretations strayed from what<br />
had originally been intended.<br />
Miles Russell (Bournemouth<br />
University) reviewed Charles<br />
Dawson’s overall archaeological<br />
career, pulling out the dubious and<br />
often “transitional” finds which<br />
mark this out. <strong>The</strong> unanswered<br />
question about Dawson is still “why<br />
did he do it”<br />
Francis Thackeray (University<br />
of the Witwaterstrand) brought<br />
Teilhard de Chardin into the frame.<br />
Although one of the original workers<br />
at Piltdown, and the discoverer<br />
of the canine tooth, Teilhard was<br />
remarkably silent on the subject<br />
of Piltdown. However, Thackeray’s<br />
work on the archive of his letters<br />
has revealed some hints that, at<br />
the least, Teilhard knew there was<br />
something amiss with Piltdown.<br />
<strong>The</strong> possibility that he was also<br />
involved in the hoax as a joker was<br />
raised.<br />
Matt Pope (Institute of<br />
Archaeology) brought the day to<br />
its end with a stimulating overview<br />
of Palaeolithic research in <strong>Sussex</strong><br />
from the 19th to the 21st century.<br />
Overall this was an excellent<br />
conference which showed clearly<br />
the relevance of the history of<br />
Palaeolithic research to our present<br />
understanding and put the bizarre<br />
goings on at Piltdown into their<br />
proper context.<br />
Liz Somerville<br />
Museums Receive Grant<br />
Arts Council funding for conservation support across South-East<br />
<strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />
is a long-standing member<br />
of the <strong>Sussex</strong> Museums Group<br />
(SMG) which is a coalition of over<br />
40 museums and galleries from<br />
East and West <strong>Sussex</strong> that aims<br />
to provide support, advice and<br />
leadership within the sector. In<br />
May this year the <strong>Society</strong> was<br />
invited by the Arts Council England<br />
(ACE) to submit, on behalf of<br />
SMG, a proposal for a project<br />
that would provide conservation<br />
advice to <strong>Sussex</strong> museums. <strong>The</strong><br />
original intention was to fund a<br />
freelance conservator who would<br />
be based at the conservation lab<br />
at Fishbourne Roman Palace, but<br />
provide support remotely as well<br />
as through site visits, training and<br />
workshops. However, the need for<br />
conservation advice is not limited<br />
to <strong>Sussex</strong> alone. <strong>The</strong> Arts Council<br />
decided in August to provide<br />
a grant of £75,000 to fund the<br />
delivery of conservation support<br />
to museums over the much wider<br />
area of Surrey and Kent as well as<br />
<strong>Sussex</strong>. A conservator will still be<br />
based at Fishbourne, but they will<br />
now work alongside another based<br />
at Chatham in Kent. <strong>The</strong> project will<br />
last for 6 months, but it is hoped<br />
that further funding will be secured<br />
so that it can be extended.<br />
<strong>The</strong> conservator based at Fishbourne will<br />
work alongside the existing team of volunteer<br />
conservators. Here the team use X-radiography<br />
to assess the extent of corrosion in metal artefacts<br />
to identify and prioritise work.<br />
Photo: <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />
<strong>The</strong> aim of the project is to<br />
conserve objects from museums<br />
that require remedial work, but<br />
more importantly to equip museum<br />
staff with the knowledge and<br />
Friends of Fishbourne Roman Palace<br />
confidence to undertake work<br />
themselves where possible (as<br />
well as teaching them to recognize<br />
when not to conserve an item).<br />
<strong>The</strong> conservators will establish a<br />
network that will help museums<br />
locate the expertise and funding<br />
that they need as well as setting up a<br />
resource-base providing access to<br />
otherwise expensive conservation<br />
equipment and consumables. Most<br />
importantly, they will undertake a<br />
survey of the conservation needs<br />
within the region. It is hoped that<br />
the information gained through<br />
this process will be able to feed in<br />
to future funding applications so<br />
that subsequent projects can be<br />
focused as effectively as possible.<br />
<strong>The</strong> staff at Fishbourne Roman<br />
Palace are looking forward to<br />
welcoming a new member to their<br />
ranks. This is especially true of the<br />
existing volunteer conservation<br />
team, who will continue to use the<br />
lab in the Collections Discovery<br />
Centre.<br />
Dr Robert Symmons<br />
Curator, Fishbourne Roman Palace<br />
<strong>The</strong> ‘Friends of Fishbourne Roman Palace’ was founded a few years ago with the help and encouragement<br />
of the <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong> to offer limited financial support to the Palace, limited because,<br />
although we are on a sound financial footing, we are still quite a small organization. To become more<br />
ambitious in our assistance to the Palace we need a larger membership so we are taking this opportunity to<br />
bring the Friends to the attention of SAS members, particularly in West <strong>Sussex</strong> and Hampshire.<br />
We have provided the Palace with a monitor screen and associated equipment to enable the events of<br />
each day to be displayed in the reception area, saving the staff having to hand out pieces of paper and<br />
explain everything to each visitor; we are financing the much-needed refurbishment of the display notices<br />
in the Garden Museum; we have purchased a trolley for the Collections Discovery Centre and a memorial<br />
bench for the garden, all of which the Palace and SAS had no funds to cover.<br />
For further information on the Friends please see the SAS website or contact the Membership Secretary,<br />
Anne Wingfield-Hayes, 01243 527495. And if you do see your way to joining and helping us, thanks in<br />
advance.<br />
10 <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong> 11
Library<br />
LIBRARY & BOOKSHOP<br />
BOOK REVIEWS<br />
Books<br />
Library News<br />
am sure you all realise how much we depend on donations and<br />
I bequests to keep the Library supported. Just over 5 years ago<br />
we were fortunate to receive a bequest, specifically to the Library,<br />
from the late Thomas Masson Moore of Lewes, to be used for the<br />
purchase of books. He had been a regular user of the Library in the<br />
time of Joyce Crow and Ken Dickins, and was well-known to both of<br />
them. This has enabled us to purchase several desirable items which<br />
we could not otherwise have afforded, such as the Cambridge Urban<br />
History of Britain (3 vols), as well as providing additional support for<br />
general purchases.<br />
We have now reached the end of this fund, so this is an opportune<br />
moment to remind Members and users of the Library to think of us<br />
when writing their wills, and indeed if they can afford to donate at<br />
other times. I notice that Thomas Masson Moore also left bequests<br />
to the Wallace Collection and the Blue Cross (an animal charity), so<br />
like him please consider several directions for your funds – everything<br />
will be appreciated!<br />
I list below some recent additions to the Library (all <strong>2012</strong>):<br />
ALLEN, Michael J, Editor<br />
Is there a British Chalcolithic<br />
ANDERSON-WHYMARK, Regional perspectives on Neolithic pit<br />
Hugo, Editor<br />
deposition<br />
GARDNER, James<br />
GILCRIST, Roberta<br />
GREHAN, John<br />
McCOOEY, Christopher<br />
WILKINSON, Louise J<br />
A History of the Brighton Workhouses<br />
Medieval Life: archaeology and the life<br />
course<br />
Battleground of <strong>Sussex</strong>: a military<br />
history of <strong>Sussex</strong> from the Iron Age to<br />
the present day<br />
Smuggling on the South Coast<br />
Eleanor De Montfort<br />
We are grateful to the following for their donations to the Library:<br />
DG Bate; C & J Brent; J Hobbs; M Norman; T Sully; A Vincent;<br />
R Wallace.<br />
Esme Evans<br />
Hon. Librarian<br />
Bookshop<br />
THE delicious Apples and Orchards<br />
in <strong>Sussex</strong> is on the shelf at £15. Super<br />
book, with central chapters on the<br />
history of apple growing in <strong>Sussex</strong><br />
nestling comfortably between a<br />
guide to <strong>Sussex</strong> apple varieties<br />
and interviews with professional<br />
fruit growers in <strong>Sussex</strong>, along with<br />
other delights. <strong>The</strong> illustrations and<br />
overall design are very tasty too.<br />
Elsewhere in this newsletter<br />
you will read the obituary of Alan<br />
Stevens. Through the generosity of<br />
Alan’s main beneficiary his books<br />
have come to the <strong>Society</strong>. Quite a<br />
few will go to enhance your Library<br />
while the rest will gradually work<br />
their way into the bookshop stock.<br />
Further to this, I’m hoping to have<br />
catalogued some of the highervalue<br />
books by the New Year.<br />
Shelf price will be sensible with the<br />
usual reduction of 10-15% to SAS<br />
members.<br />
If you are interested in receiving a<br />
copy of whatever it is that I produce<br />
please send me either your email<br />
address, or an A5 sae if you’d like<br />
a hard copy. I’m at castlebooks@<br />
sussexpast.co.uk and Barbican<br />
House Bookshop, 169 High Street,<br />
Lewes, BN7 1YE.<br />
John Bleach<br />
Barbican House Bookshop<br />
<strong>The</strong> Borough<br />
and Manor of<br />
New Shoreham<br />
Some Records of its<br />
People & Places<br />
<strong>The</strong> 1782 Manor<br />
Survey Annotated<br />
NEARLY one hundred years<br />
ago, in 1921, Henry Cheal first<br />
published his pioneering <strong>The</strong> Story<br />
of Shoreham. He died in 1954, but<br />
left extensive notes which Michael<br />
Norman, a long-time resident of<br />
Shoreham and former honorary<br />
curator of Marlipins Museum, has<br />
been using, editing and adding to<br />
since 1951.<br />
This new book is an edited and<br />
organised version of a survey<br />
of the Manor of New Shoreham<br />
which was undertaken in 1782 by<br />
the surveyor Joseph Hodgkinson<br />
for the Duke of Norfolk, the then<br />
Lord of the Manor. Subsequently<br />
the original survey was annotated<br />
by the Duke’s steward. This survey<br />
is now the property of the current<br />
Duke, who retains the copyright,<br />
but the publication in this volume<br />
of the Survey’s contents, together<br />
with notes and suggestions of<br />
the author/editor, allows the<br />
historian and also the more casual<br />
reader to gain an insight into the<br />
development of the historic core<br />
of New Shoreham. <strong>The</strong> book also<br />
contains maps, some annotated,<br />
including copies of Hodgkinson’s<br />
of 1782, to show the situations of<br />
the extensive number of properties<br />
which are listed in the Manorial<br />
rolls. <strong>The</strong> long-lost shipyards along<br />
the river bank, like the one where<br />
the Ropetackle Centre now stands,<br />
are clearly shown and discussed,<br />
with added information concerning<br />
developments after 1782.<br />
A cursory study reveals<br />
fascinating aspects of Shoreham.<br />
For example, the book reproduces<br />
a memorandum which mentions<br />
an Act ‘passed in the Thirty third<br />
Year of His late Majesty’ (probably<br />
1771) which state that all ships and<br />
vessels entering Shoreham Harbour<br />
were obliged to pay Duty in order to<br />
maintain the harbour. In the same<br />
memorandum it is stated that the<br />
Lord of the Manor also received<br />
£20 per annum for allowing a toll<br />
bridge to replace his income from<br />
the ferry which it displaced. <strong>The</strong><br />
Memorandum lists the ferry tolls,<br />
ranging from one shilling for any<br />
four-wheeled carriage to six pence<br />
for twenty sheep or cows.<br />
In another example, there was<br />
an area described in 1782 as<br />
‘A Tenement, Black Smiths Shp<br />
Build g . Yard & Premises’ which was<br />
situated on the river bank on the<br />
High Street, westward from West<br />
Street. This area was cut in half<br />
when the new bridge was built in<br />
1833. <strong>The</strong> Fountain Inn stood on<br />
this site, and this was succeeded<br />
by the Bridge Inn. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Sussex</strong><br />
<strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong> apparently<br />
met at the Bridge Inn on occasion.<br />
This Bridge Inn was demolished<br />
when the High Street was widened<br />
in 1938/9, and replaced by the<br />
current manifestation of the Inn.<br />
<strong>The</strong> material in the book relates<br />
principally, but not exclusively, to<br />
Shoreham. For example, a dispute<br />
concerning a piece of land two acres<br />
in extent in the Parish of Southwick<br />
is described. This dispute between<br />
a Nathal. Hall [apparently a<br />
brewer] and Colvill Bridger Esq. [of<br />
Buckingham House] was current in<br />
1782, and no rent had been paid for<br />
9 years. Rents and lessees for this<br />
land are listed back to 1660. This<br />
matter is of current interest because<br />
it was apparently a descendant of<br />
this Nathaniel Hall, a landowner<br />
also called Nathaniel Hall, who<br />
undertook the first excavation<br />
of Southwick Roman Villa in the<br />
1840s.<br />
<strong>The</strong> survey reveals that the<br />
Hannington family, later proprietors<br />
of the late-lamented Hannington’s<br />
department store in Brighton, were<br />
also Shoreham landholders.<br />
This book is an absolute<br />
goldmine, and will be invaluable<br />
to researchers of Shoreham’s<br />
places and personalities. I hope<br />
that Michael Norman will receive<br />
the recognition and gratitude of<br />
all who benefit from his work,<br />
which is a fitting and welcome<br />
accompaniment and extension to<br />
Cheal’s History.<br />
Jeffery Leigh<br />
Michael W D Norman, 2011. Limited<br />
edition published by the author<br />
(a copy has been generously<br />
donated to the Barbican House<br />
Library - see opposite).<br />
<strong>The</strong> Archaeology of<br />
the South Downs<br />
National Park - An<br />
Introduction<br />
THE <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />
is the centre for archaeological<br />
research in the county and has<br />
been since 1846 publishing<br />
annual volumes on the history and<br />
archaeology of the county. From<br />
this huge archive of research many<br />
synthetic books and articles have<br />
come. With the establishment of<br />
South Downs National Park it is<br />
entirely appropriate that the first<br />
book specifically on the Park derives<br />
from the <strong>Society</strong>. John Manley’s<br />
12 <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong> 13
Books<br />
BOOK REVIEWS<br />
BOOK REVIEWS<br />
Books<br />
beautifully written, illustrated and<br />
presented book is the first in a<br />
new series on many aspects of<br />
the South Downs. <strong>The</strong> words and<br />
pictures evoke a mysterious place<br />
where people lived, farmed, met<br />
others, defended places, made<br />
religious centres and kept in touch<br />
with their ancestors.<br />
With some 400,000 years of<br />
archaeology present on the South<br />
Downs, Dr Manley has had to<br />
be somewhat selective in his<br />
approach. Instead of attempting<br />
a history of the South Downs<br />
set down chronologically he has<br />
opted to let each section tell the<br />
story of some enduring activity;<br />
like gathering resources from the<br />
earth, buildings people lived in,<br />
meeting places, beliefs, defensive<br />
displays and keeping in touch with<br />
the ancestors. This approach could<br />
have made an understanding of the<br />
area and its archaeology somewhat<br />
difficult for newcomers to the South<br />
Downs, but it does not; instead<br />
it clearly links the past with the<br />
present. <strong>The</strong> South Downs was<br />
not always an empty agricultural<br />
landscape; great gatherings have<br />
always taken place, from the<br />
Neolithic causewayed enclosures<br />
some 6000 years ago to the Amex<br />
Community Stadium of today.<br />
So why is this book so special<br />
and why should every member of<br />
the SAS buy one today Firstly at a<br />
stroke it will update your knowledge<br />
of the archaeology of the South<br />
Downs. Whether your interests are<br />
in prehistory, the Middle Ages, or<br />
modern land use there is something<br />
in this book for you. It is also a great<br />
entry to the archaeology of the<br />
South Downs for people interested<br />
in the area without any former<br />
interest in archaeology.<br />
For the last couple of months<br />
it has sat on my coffee table and<br />
numerous passing friends, relatives<br />
and neighbours have picked it up<br />
and asked where they could get a<br />
copy. This is exactly what the SAS<br />
is for – getting people interested in<br />
the past of <strong>Sussex</strong>. This book will<br />
do that. Buy a copy now, both for<br />
yourself and as an entry to the past<br />
in <strong>Sussex</strong> for all your friends and<br />
neighbours.<br />
Peter Drewett<br />
By John Manley, <strong>2012</strong>.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Sussex</strong> Archaeology <strong>Society</strong>,<br />
Lewes.<br />
ISBN 978-0-904973-22-8.<br />
Paperback, 87 Pages, £8.95<br />
A History of<br />
the Brighton<br />
Workhouses<br />
THIS book deals with an <strong>issue</strong><br />
which is timely, for we are again<br />
debating what we can afford to<br />
spend on benefits, how they can<br />
be fairly distributed and monitored<br />
so those who can work are<br />
encouraged to do so and how to<br />
provide for children, disabled and<br />
elderly people who need care. This<br />
book demonstrates that in the past<br />
many people lacked families who<br />
could afford to care for them or who<br />
would seek do so and that then as<br />
now, a system of basic support of<br />
some form was needed. <strong>The</strong> big<br />
difference between the debates<br />
from the Tudor period until the<br />
mid-1940s and nowadays is that<br />
all expenditure was met directly by<br />
local ratepayers.<br />
Thus this book is a study of the<br />
<strong>issue</strong>s of local management and<br />
accountability in the context of ‘the<br />
poor’ - ‘localism’ in action. Rates<br />
(now called Council Tax) were<br />
collected locally as they are today<br />
but the state did not recycle money<br />
from income tax and business rates<br />
in to local government as it does<br />
now, currently forming the greater<br />
part of the money spent locally.<br />
Local taxpayers, quite a small part<br />
of the local community, paid for<br />
everything that was either a legal<br />
requirement such as care of the<br />
poor, or desirable such as running<br />
the public gardens. Local meetings<br />
about expenditure were often<br />
lively. Ratepayers wanted cheating<br />
stopped and accountability. In<br />
this book there are examples of<br />
governors of the workhouse, staff,<br />
inmates and those on weekly pay<br />
abusing the system.<br />
<strong>The</strong> parish of Brighton was only<br />
responsible for its own poor; the<br />
three workhouses (of 1727, 1822<br />
and 1860s) were funded by its<br />
residents and did not take in poor<br />
from other parishes that are now<br />
within the City. <strong>The</strong>se had to go<br />
to other workhouses. By the early<br />
18th century it also paid a weekly<br />
amount to poor people who, in<br />
the view of the overseers, might<br />
find work or for other reasons<br />
were best left in their own home, a<br />
practice which continued into the<br />
1940s and was the precursor to the<br />
benefits system. <strong>The</strong> preference<br />
was to keep people employed,<br />
both within the workhouse and also<br />
by keeping weekly income tightly<br />
controlled. <strong>The</strong> strength of the book<br />
is the detailed study of the period<br />
between the 1850s and the end of<br />
the Poor Law in the mid 1940s. <strong>The</strong><br />
lives of inmates and of employees<br />
of the workhouse and the Industrial<br />
School at Warren Road reflect how<br />
hard it must have been to be poor<br />
and also how to manage a fair and<br />
effective means of supporting those<br />
in need. We have perhaps had our<br />
attitudes to the Workhouse overly<br />
strongly affected by the novels of<br />
Dickens and others who depicted<br />
them as a nightmare. But few of<br />
the critics even tried to find a more<br />
effective solution to a system of<br />
care which would not totally absorb<br />
local revenues or result in one town<br />
or parish becoming a target due<br />
to the quality of treatment offered<br />
by many people who did not live<br />
locally.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re are a couple of errors in the<br />
early section; for example the ‘Great<br />
Storm’ of 1703 did not destroy many<br />
fishermen’s dwellings below the cliff<br />
(there is plenty of archival evidence<br />
to disprove this wonderful piece of<br />
18th century journalism) and, when<br />
Brighton’s fortunes declined, many<br />
of the young people did as they<br />
would today and ‘upped sticks’.<br />
Mr Gardner is to be applauded<br />
for wading through many sources<br />
and bringing to our attention the<br />
great dilemma of the 19th century<br />
– how does one deal with the care<br />
of the poor in rapidly expanding<br />
towns where employment was so<br />
cyclical as in Brighton. What we<br />
have to remember is that with the<br />
workhouses, weekly pay, soup<br />
kitchens, mendacity charities,<br />
dispensaries and hospitals all<br />
aimed at helping the poor, local<br />
people tried hard to help. This book<br />
reveals how difficult it was to ensure<br />
that treatment was reasonable and<br />
fair and not subject to exploitation.<br />
<strong>The</strong> debate on how best to do this<br />
continues.<br />
Sue Berry<br />
By James Gardner, <strong>2012</strong>. Published<br />
by the author: 5 East Way, Lewes,<br />
BN7 1NG. ISBN 978-0-9536101-1-<br />
2. 442pp with illustrations. £19.95.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Glynde<br />
Butterflies<br />
Stoolball Team<br />
1866-1887<br />
England’s first<br />
female sports stars<br />
IT is most appropriate, in this<br />
Olympic year when the President<br />
of the IOC at the opening of<br />
London <strong>2012</strong> emphasised the role<br />
of the British in codifying so many<br />
games and sporting events, that<br />
Andrew Lusted has published this<br />
work on stoolball. Following on<br />
the success of several previous<br />
publications relating to Glynde,<br />
Andrew has turned his attention to<br />
the 19th century sporting ladies of<br />
his home village and others close<br />
by who were, it transpires from his<br />
research, world leaders in the field<br />
of women’s team games.<br />
Two <strong>Sussex</strong> firsts are recorded in<br />
this interesting report of the prowess<br />
of the delightfully named Glynde<br />
Butterflies, Chailey Grasshoppers,<br />
Waldron Bees, and Selmeston<br />
Harvest Bugs, and other local<br />
ladies sports teams.<br />
<strong>The</strong> origins of stoolball are little<br />
understood and versions of the<br />
game may originally have been<br />
played in many parts of England.<br />
<strong>The</strong> modern game is confined<br />
almost exclusively to the south<br />
eastern counties, predominantly<br />
in <strong>Sussex</strong> but also extending<br />
west into Hampshire, north into<br />
Surrey and east into Kent, with<br />
one remarkable outlier in Sutton<br />
Coldfield in Birmingham. <strong>The</strong><br />
game has long interested sport<br />
historians as articles in our own<br />
collections by John Lowerson<br />
(1995) and John Goulstone (1998)<br />
testify. One notable supporter was<br />
Sir William Grantham of Barcombe<br />
who actively promoted the game,<br />
albeit somewhat eccentrically, in<br />
the early 20th century. Sir William’s<br />
significant collection of memorabilia<br />
and his scrap books are held in the<br />
working papers room in the library<br />
at Barbican House. As a trainee<br />
teacher at Bishop Otter College in<br />
the 1950s I recall being introduced<br />
to the (to me) unfamiliar game,<br />
because we were almost certain<br />
to come upon it when we were<br />
unleashed upon local schools for<br />
our school practices. More recently,<br />
but still some time ago, one of my<br />
daughters played for a junior team in<br />
Crowborough. Many of the present<br />
day clubs field mixed teams but in<br />
origin it was exclusively a women’s<br />
game – introduced, perhaps, to<br />
provide a female equivalent to<br />
cricket.<br />
In the course of his research<br />
into stoolball Andrew uncovered<br />
documentary evidence for a female<br />
cricket team playing regularly at<br />
Glynde, several years before the<br />
Yorkshire club team who claim<br />
to be the oldest established in<br />
the country. In addition he proves<br />
without doubt that the first rules<br />
of stoolball were established and<br />
published in the East <strong>Sussex</strong> News,<br />
probably at the instigation of the<br />
indefatigable Glynde Butterflies, in<br />
1867. This is earlier than the rules<br />
of any other women’s team sport.<br />
Most striking too is the evidence<br />
for universal participation in the<br />
sport. Considering the class<br />
conscious times it is revealing that<br />
here in <strong>Sussex</strong>, on the sports field<br />
at least, village girls, the daughters<br />
of the manse and of the local squire,<br />
all participated in the local teams.<br />
If you know anyone who has an<br />
interest in Stoolball this book is a<br />
must; a stocking filler for Christmas<br />
perhaps.<br />
Pamela Combes<br />
By Andrew Lusted, 2011.<br />
Copies available in Barbican House<br />
bookshop or direct from the author at<br />
Welsted, Glynde, Lewes, BN8 6SU.<br />
Price £7.00 plus £1.20 postage,<br />
cheques payable to Andrew Lusted.<br />
14 <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong> 15
Snippets<br />
Help Protect Local<br />
Historic Gardens<br />
THE <strong>Sussex</strong> Gardens Trust (www.<br />
sussexgardenstrust.org.uk) is a<br />
charity promoting the conservation<br />
and appreciation of gardens and<br />
parks in our area, and part of a family<br />
of 35 gardens trusts around Britain<br />
working together under the umbrella<br />
of the Association of Gardens<br />
Trusts (www.gardenstrusts.org.<br />
uk). We are embarking on a project<br />
to develop Local Lists of significant<br />
parks and gardens which will<br />
be incorporated into the local<br />
authority’s Historic Environment<br />
Record. We aim to ensure that<br />
important sites are recorded and<br />
protected from development. Our<br />
campaign is supported by a new<br />
government initiative to encourage<br />
the development of Local Lists<br />
through partnerships between<br />
local organisations like the <strong>Sussex</strong><br />
Gardens Trust and local authorities.<br />
Local Lists record and recognise<br />
sites of historic and cultural interest<br />
to the community, including<br />
buildings, monuments and special<br />
places, as well as parks, gardens<br />
and designed landscapes. <strong>The</strong><br />
south-east especially suffers from<br />
development pressures of many<br />
kinds, and without the information<br />
and recognition given in a Local List,<br />
many historic sites are vulnerable<br />
to inappropriate change or lack of<br />
proper maintenance. Gardens can<br />
suffer from decay or damage to<br />
built structures, views can become<br />
blocked by self-sown trees, water<br />
features no longer function as<br />
intended, surfaces of paths and<br />
drives become degraded, and<br />
garden buildings are subject to<br />
damp, cracking and even collapse.<br />
We want to prevent this happening<br />
to the gardens we value in <strong>Sussex</strong>,<br />
but we need help to make this<br />
possible.<br />
We offer training courses in<br />
how to research a site, including<br />
practical sessions on identifying<br />
historic features on maps, using<br />
archive resources and carrying out<br />
a site survey. We will establish the<br />
purpose of Local Listing, explaining<br />
why it is important for conserving<br />
our garden heritage and how you<br />
can contribute. You will also be<br />
introduced to the methodology<br />
of writing up a site report using<br />
the format developed by English<br />
Heritage for the National Heritage<br />
List, where all types of heritage of<br />
national importance are recorded<br />
(www.english-heritage.org.uk/<br />
list). <strong>The</strong> training courses are free of<br />
charge and lunch and refreshments<br />
are provided.<br />
Please contact Jennie Starr<br />
who will be happy to discuss how<br />
you can contribute to the project<br />
and enrol you on our next training<br />
course. Tel 01323 461310 or email<br />
starrhouse@clara.co.uk.<br />
<strong>The</strong> South Downs<br />
Series<br />
THE ‘South Downs Series’ is a<br />
novel and exciting venture for the<br />
<strong>Society</strong>: a series of books (edited<br />
by Robin Milner-Gulland, member<br />
of Council, and John Manley, the<br />
<strong>Society</strong>’s Research Fellow), of<br />
which John Manley’s ‘Archaeology<br />
of the South Downs National Park:<br />
an Introduction’ is the first to<br />
appear. A generous grant from the<br />
SDNP Authority, and a gift from a<br />
private donor, have covered the<br />
initial publication costs. We trust<br />
that sales will make a contribution<br />
to the <strong>Society</strong>’s finances, and that<br />
the volumes will raise its public<br />
profile.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y are quite short (each<br />
about 20,000 words of text),<br />
keeping costs down, but lavishly<br />
produced with around 100 colour<br />
illustrations, some of them specially<br />
commissioned aerial photos and<br />
maps etc. <strong>The</strong>y will be on sale at all<br />
the <strong>Society</strong>’s properties open to the<br />
public, as well as local bookshops.<br />
<strong>The</strong> books are written by<br />
specialists but intended for a wide<br />
public. <strong>The</strong> next two, already at<br />
an advanced stage of preparation,<br />
will be on Geology and Physical<br />
Landscape (by David Robinson)<br />
and Wildlife and Biodiversity (by<br />
Robin Crane with Rendel Williams).<br />
<strong>The</strong>se three together will make<br />
a wonderful overview of varied<br />
aspects of the South Downs area; I<br />
know of no comparable series.<br />
Depending on their success -<br />
and first signs in the case of John’s<br />
book augur well - it is to be hoped<br />
that the project will continue:<br />
indeed the great Peter Brandon<br />
had already roughed out a scheme<br />
for such a book before his recent<br />
death. Further ideas welcome!<br />
Robin Milner-Gulland<br />
Next Issue<br />
THE <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present<br />
newsletter is published three<br />
times a year, in April, August and<br />
<strong>December</strong>. <strong>The</strong> next <strong>issue</strong> will be<br />
published in April 2013; the copy<br />
deadline is 15th February. Letters<br />
and ‘snippets’ are welcome;<br />
longer items should be kept to a<br />
maximum of 500 words unless prior<br />
arrangements have been made with<br />
the editor, Wendy Muriel, at spp@<br />
sussexpast.co.uk, or Luke Barber<br />
on 01273 405733. Please note<br />
that we require images with most<br />
contributions, preferably in high<br />
quality colour format. To submit<br />
digitally, please use MS Word<br />
(preferably 97-2003 format) for text<br />
and send images in JPEG or TIFF<br />
formats, at a minimum resolution<br />
of 600dpi. Correspondence and<br />
details of events should be sent to<br />
Wendy Muriel, Editor, <strong>Sussex</strong> Past &<br />
Present, Bull House, 92 High Street,<br />
Lewes, East <strong>Sussex</strong>, BN7 1XH, or<br />
emailed to the above address.<br />
Rates for insertions into the<br />
newsletter, which goes out to over<br />
2000 members, start at £100 (plus<br />
minimum handling charge of £20).<br />
Contact Lorna Gartside on 01273<br />
405737 for details.<br />
16<br />
<strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />
www.sussexpast.co.uk