14.01.2015 Views

December 2012 (issue 128) - The Sussex Archaeological Society

December 2012 (issue 128) - The Sussex Archaeological Society

December 2012 (issue 128) - The Sussex Archaeological Society

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

N u m b e r 1 2 8 D E C E M B E R 2 0 1 2<br />

Culver <strong>Archaeological</strong> Project<br />

Best Finds of the Year<br />

Excavations at Fishbourne<br />

Piltdown Conference Report<br />

Arts Council Award for Museums<br />

www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong>


Membership Matters<br />

MEMBERSHIP<br />

OPENING LINES<br />

Opening Lines<br />

Lorna’s Notebook<br />

A round-up of all that’s new in the membership department<br />

Welcome to the <strong>December</strong><br />

edition of <strong>Sussex</strong> Past &<br />

Present.<br />

Subscriptions increase for<br />

2013<br />

It is with regret that we have<br />

had to increase our subscriptions<br />

slightly with effect from 1 January<br />

2013, as agreed at this year’s AGM.<br />

Many of you (though not all) are<br />

due to renew your subscription to<br />

the <strong>Society</strong> at the beginning of the<br />

year, and it would really help us if<br />

you would check your membership<br />

card now, and, if you are due for<br />

renewal on 1 January, arrange<br />

for payment straightaway. This<br />

will save the cost of sending out<br />

reminder notices, which is usually<br />

done in late January. Of course, if<br />

you pay by direct debit, you need<br />

take no further action – you will be<br />

notified in writing of the date and<br />

amount of the collection.<br />

Subscription Type & Description<br />

O Standard Individual £35<br />

J Joint (2 adults/same address) £50<br />

F1 Family (1 adult + children) £41<br />

F2 Family (2 adults + children) £53<br />

S Student £17<br />

AFF Affiliated <strong>Society</strong> £35<br />

+B Hardback copy of SAC +£6<br />

+POST Overseas postage charge +£13<br />

If you do not currently pay by<br />

direct debit, do please download<br />

a copy of the mandate from the<br />

Membership section of our website<br />

www.sussexpast.co.uk and return<br />

it to me. Other ways in which you<br />

can pay are:<br />

- cheque, payable to “<strong>Sussex</strong><br />

Past” and sent to me at Bull House<br />

- online at http://sussexpast.<br />

co.uk/payment<br />

- by credit card over the phone,<br />

Tuesday to Friday, 10am – 3pm<br />

Saturday 22 September:<br />

Piltdown Centenery<br />

Conference:<br />

Truth and Lies from<br />

the Deep <strong>Sussex</strong> Past<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Society</strong>’s <strong>2012</strong> autumn<br />

conference in Lewes was a great<br />

success and attracted attention<br />

from the BBC both at local and<br />

national levels. Speakers from the<br />

Natural History Museum, the British<br />

Museum, London, Bournemouth<br />

and Southampton Universities and<br />

the University of Witwatersrand<br />

in South Africa gathered to<br />

commemorate the centenary of<br />

this notorious fraud and to examine<br />

the evidence against the chief<br />

suspects while placing the fraud in<br />

its historical context and concluding<br />

with a look at the real evidence of<br />

early habitation still coming to light<br />

at the Piltdown site. See page<br />

10 for a report of the conference.<br />

Members who were unable to<br />

attend may like to know that we are<br />

hoping it may be possible to upload<br />

some of the talks (sound files only)<br />

from the conference and make<br />

them available for you to listen to<br />

again via our website. <strong>The</strong>re have<br />

been some technical <strong>issue</strong>s about<br />

this in relation to trying to make the<br />

Battle of Lewes conference talks<br />

available on line, so we cannot<br />

guarantee success, but we are still<br />

looking into this possibility.<br />

Christmas Shopping<br />

and the <strong>Society</strong><br />

A reminder – especially useful<br />

for this time of year - that if you<br />

shop online you can raise a little<br />

additional money for the <strong>Society</strong><br />

at no extra cost by using www.<br />

easyfundraising.org.uk as your<br />

portal for purchases. Simply register<br />

and choose <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong><br />

<strong>Society</strong> as your cause, and the<br />

retailers listed on the site will make<br />

a small donation to us every time<br />

you buy something. <strong>The</strong>re are<br />

no additional costs to you as the<br />

consumer, and you still buy directly<br />

from the retailers’ own websites<br />

– the only difference is that you<br />

reach your chosen retailer’s site<br />

by logging onto easyfundraising.<br />

org first. Amazon, British Airways,<br />

John Lewis and Boots the Chemist<br />

are among the hundreds of retailers<br />

who participate, and every donation,<br />

however small, will help us.<br />

Membership as a Gift<br />

While on the topic of Christmas,<br />

have you considered giving<br />

membership of the <strong>Society</strong> as a gift<br />

to your friends or relatives I am<br />

always happy to arrange this, and<br />

the welcome pack can be posted<br />

either directly to the recipient or to<br />

the purchaser to be handed over<br />

in person. Given the pressure on<br />

the post at this time of year, I would<br />

suggest that you contact me to<br />

arrange this as soon as possible<br />

if you would like to arrange a gift<br />

membership.<br />

May I wish you all a good 2013.<br />

Lorna Gartside<br />

Membership Secretary<br />

MEMBERSHIP<br />

DEPARTMENT<br />

Bull House, 92 High Street<br />

Lewes, BN7 1XH<br />

Tues-Fri 10am-3pm<br />

Answering machine<br />

outside these hours<br />

01273 405737<br />

members@sussexpast.co.uk<br />

SUSSEX<br />

Past &<br />

Present<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong><br />

<strong>Society</strong> Newsletter<br />

N u m b e r 1 2 8<br />

D E C E M B E R 2 0 1 2<br />

Contents<br />

2 Membership Matters<br />

3 Opening Lines<br />

4 Culver Project<br />

5 Culver Project<br />

6 Best Finds of the Year<br />

7 Alan Stevens Obituary<br />

8 President & CEO Letters<br />

9 Excavations at Fishbourne<br />

10 Piltdown Conference<br />

11 Arts Council Grant<br />

12 Library & Bookshop<br />

13 Book Reviews<br />

14 Book Reviews<br />

15 Book Reviews<br />

16 Snippets<br />

Published by the <strong>Sussex</strong><br />

<strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong>, Bull<br />

House, Lewes, E <strong>Sussex</strong>, BN71XH<br />

Tel: 01273 486260<br />

Fax: 01273 486990<br />

Email: adminlewes@sussexpast.<br />

co.uk<br />

Editor: Wendy Muriel<br />

Email: spp@sussexpast.co.uk<br />

Research Editor: Luke Barber<br />

ISSN 1357-7417<br />

Cover: <strong>The</strong> Barbican at Lewes Castle<br />

Photo: Wendy Muriel<br />

Your <strong>Society</strong><br />

...has weathered a difficult year!<br />

This year has been a difficult and tasking year for the <strong>Society</strong>. <strong>The</strong><br />

weather, Jubilee and Olympics have had a detrimental effect on<br />

visitor numbers to our properties and reduced visitor numbers results<br />

in reduced admission revenue and shop sales. Lewes Castle and Anne<br />

of Cleves House have done better than the other properties, perhaps a<br />

reflection of their town locations and that they are still benefiting from the<br />

refurbishment work that was carried out on them in the last few years.<br />

That is the bad news. Those visitors who braved the weather have<br />

given very good reports of their visits and members of staff have worked<br />

wonders in difficult conditions. <strong>The</strong> catering company at Fishbourne went<br />

into liquidation last year leaving us without any catering on the site. <strong>The</strong><br />

<strong>Society</strong> is now running the catering in house and great improvements are<br />

expected. <strong>The</strong> in-house catering at Michelham has proved very popular<br />

and is attracting return visits from patrons. Many members and visitors<br />

have remarked on the catering which is bringing in return visits to the<br />

Priory. It is also hoped to have a café open at Anne of Cleves in the<br />

future. <strong>The</strong> Trustees recognise that having good catering facilities at all<br />

our properties should be part of the visitor offer.<br />

Weddings at Lewes Castle and Anne of Cleves have increased in<br />

number and are contributing towards the cost of running the properties<br />

and it is hoped that the improvements at Michelham Priory will also<br />

increase revenue from weddings. Another positive is that more visitors<br />

are signing up to the Gift Aid scheme whereby the <strong>Society</strong> can claim back<br />

tax at no cost to the visitors.<br />

Thanks to funding from the Friends, the gatehouse kiosk at Michelham<br />

Priory is currently being rebuilt to improve the first impressions of the site.<br />

<strong>The</strong> out-of-date kiosk was not an asset to the lovely gatehouse. One of<br />

the best impressions of Michelham is that view of the house and gardens<br />

from the archway beneath the gatehouse.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Committee structure of the Trustees is being altered to reflect<br />

the current needs of the <strong>Society</strong> and give more support to staff. <strong>The</strong><br />

great work of the Education and Museum teams is being given more<br />

prominence and the Friends groups given more support. It is hoped that<br />

a joint Friends’ committee will be formed to allow better communication<br />

between the various properties’ Friends groups. A new Friends of Lewes<br />

Castle will also be formed.<br />

It is lovely to see up to 120 school children at a time enjoying the sights<br />

at Michelham or Fishbourne, dressing up in character and absorbing the<br />

history. At Michelham they learn about the evacuation during World War II<br />

and at Fishbourne about the Roman occupation. <strong>The</strong> education provided<br />

by the <strong>Society</strong> forms part of our revenue and helps to inform future<br />

generations of our heritage. We hope they return with their parents!<br />

<strong>The</strong>re are many positive things happening in the <strong>Society</strong> at present and,<br />

at the end of the season, we look forward to a better result next year.<br />

Richard Akhurst<br />

Chair of Council<br />

<strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />

www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong>


Excavations<br />

CULVER PROJECT<br />

CULVER PROJECT<br />

Excavations<br />

Research<br />

Culver <strong>Archaeological</strong> Project<br />

An intriguing first seven years<br />

For the last seven years<br />

the Culver <strong>Archaeological</strong><br />

Project (CAP), under director Rob<br />

Wallace, has been investigating<br />

the historical environment of the<br />

Upper Ouse Valley in the parishes<br />

of Barcombe and Ringmer. In 2005<br />

Rob had discovered a substantial<br />

Roman road running to the east<br />

of the Barcombe villa complex,<br />

heading north east through the<br />

fields of Culver Farm, where CAP’s<br />

subsequent fieldwork has been<br />

undertaken (Fig 1).<br />

Fig.1 Map of Culver Farm showing the main features and field locations. <br />

In 2005-6 a series of evaluation<br />

trenches were dug in Pond Field and<br />

its northern neighbour Culver Mead<br />

which established the existence<br />

and bearing of the road as well as<br />

showing roadside activity. In 2007<br />

a larger open area excavation in<br />

Pond Field exposed 20m of the<br />

road together with an area each<br />

side which showed clearly the<br />

substantial nature of the road<br />

and the intensity of the roadside<br />

industrial activity. This area was<br />

targeted again in 2010.<br />

In 2009 the main emphasis moved<br />

to the south west, to Court House<br />

Field, where 50m of closely packed<br />

flint road foundations some 400mm<br />

deep were uncovered (Fig 2). <strong>The</strong><br />

area chosen was over a discernible<br />

kink in the road noticed from the<br />

previous year’s geophysics results.<br />

Whilst a fine section of road was<br />

exposed and recorded the reason<br />

for the changes of direction was not<br />

altogether clear, although a series<br />

of crossing palaeo-channels might<br />

have made this area unstable.<br />

Fig 2. <strong>The</strong> section of Roman road exposed in<br />

2009. Photo: D Millum<br />

Seven years digging had<br />

produced over 6000 sherds of<br />

pottery that needed specialist<br />

analysis and reporting. A substantial<br />

Margary Grant from the <strong>Sussex</strong><br />

<strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong> (SAS), plus<br />

a smaller sum from the University<br />

of <strong>Sussex</strong> Archaeology <strong>Society</strong><br />

(USAS), allowed the project to<br />

employ Malcolm Lyne to undertake<br />

the analysis. Malcolm was the ideal<br />

choice since, as an acknowledged<br />

expert on Roman pottery in the<br />

area, he could coordinate the<br />

Culver assemblage with that of his<br />

own classification of pottery fabrics<br />

for the Barcombe villa.<br />

He concluded that nearly all the<br />

Roman pottery from Culver was of<br />

3rd to early 4th century date. Over<br />

93% of the sherds came from the<br />

excavations in Pond Field with only<br />

382 from Culver Mead and just<br />

19 from the excavation in Court<br />

House Field, which unlike the fields<br />

to the north showed no road side<br />

settlement. 71 different fabrics<br />

were present, 29 coarse, 34 fine, 5<br />

mortaria and 3 of amphora.<br />

<strong>The</strong> trenches in Culver Mead in<br />

2006 had revealed 3 water-logged<br />

timbers that were radiocarbon<br />

dated to c. cal AD240-430 and<br />

Malcolm’s report similarly confirms<br />

the pottery assemblage to AD250-<br />

400. He also highlights a fragment<br />

of a lamp or chimney similar to an<br />

example from the triangular temple<br />

at Verulamium (Lyne <strong>2012</strong>).<br />

<strong>The</strong> bulk of the Pond Field<br />

assemblages were of handmade<br />

local East <strong>Sussex</strong> Wares with the<br />

largest derivable amount coming<br />

from the nearby Wickham Barn<br />

kilns. Other British coarsewares<br />

were represented including Alice<br />

Holt greyware. <strong>The</strong> finewares<br />

included fragments of beakers in<br />

Colchester colour-coat, Oxford red<br />

colour-coat, Lower Nene Valley and<br />

New Forest. <strong>The</strong> Samian included<br />

both Central and Eastern Gaulish<br />

products (Lyne <strong>2012</strong>).<br />

Fig 3. Moselkeramik carafe rim from Arlon.<br />

Photo: D Millum<br />

One of the most interesting<br />

sherds was part of the rim of a late<br />

3rd century carafe in a metallic<br />

black colour-coat ware from the<br />

Arlon kilns in Lorraine Belge (Fig<br />

3); a very unusual product to find<br />

anywhere in Britain (Lyne <strong>2012</strong>).<br />

Whilst the road undoubtedly<br />

had a far longer period of use, as<br />

indicated by the Flavius Honorius<br />

silver Siliqua of AD395-402 (Fig 4)<br />

Fig 5. Magnetometer survey results from Pond Field. Image: D Staveley 2011<br />

found in the corner of Court House<br />

Field, the main period of roadside<br />

activity in Pond Field would seem<br />

to fall into the later 3rd to early 4th<br />

century. This presumes that the<br />

Samian and some other finer wares<br />

were already old, possibly handeddown,<br />

items and date from prior to<br />

the period of lower class working<br />

activity at the site. Two exceptions<br />

would seem to be a small pit by the<br />

northwest baulk of the excavation<br />

which contained an assemblage of<br />

34 sherds dated to the late 2nd and<br />

early 3rd centuries and a clay lined<br />

pit, also located to the west of the<br />

road, which contained pottery dating<br />

to mid or even later 4th century. A<br />

Fig 4. Scan of the Flavius Honorius silver<br />

Siliqua.<br />

Photo: D Millum<br />

subsequent magnetometer survey<br />

has revealed interesting anomalies<br />

to the west of these features which<br />

deserve further investigation.<br />

An important aspect of the<br />

investigations undertaken by CAP<br />

has been the use of geophysical<br />

surveys both using electrical<br />

resistance and magnetic variation<br />

techniques to produce images of<br />

the subterranean features. <strong>The</strong>se<br />

have been particularly useful in<br />

tracing the route of the Roman<br />

road and suggesting areas of<br />

roadside activity. Major surveys in<br />

2008 and 2011 have highlighted<br />

some interesting areas for future<br />

excavation as well as suggesting<br />

that not all Roman roads are<br />

perfectly straight (Fig 5).<br />

A great deal of interpretation is<br />

still needed to integrate this new<br />

information into the excavation<br />

reports which are currently in<br />

production but the financial<br />

assistance of SAS & USAS has<br />

allowed an early completion of<br />

these documents to become a real<br />

possibility.<br />

David Millum & Rob Wallace<br />

co-directors of the Culver<br />

<strong>Archaeological</strong> Project<br />

www.culverproject.co.uk<br />

davidmillum@mypostoffice.<br />

co.uk<br />

<strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />

www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong>


Feature<br />

FLO ROUND-UP<br />

ALAN STEVENS<br />

Obituary<br />

Best Finds of the Year<br />

<strong>The</strong> Finds Liaison Officer reports on significant finds of <strong>2012</strong><br />

This is the fourth annual roundup<br />

of some of the best finds<br />

recorded in <strong>Sussex</strong> by the Portable<br />

Antiquities Scheme (PAS). Since<br />

our last report we have created<br />

1274 records of 1346 finds from<br />

East and West <strong>Sussex</strong>, resulting in<br />

a total of 18,505 records in <strong>Sussex</strong>.<br />

This year’s recorded finds range in<br />

date from a Mesolithic flint pick, c.<br />

8300 - 3500 BC (SUSS-64E778)<br />

to a wide array of Post Medieval<br />

and early Modern objects. Two<br />

examples include a Georgian gilt<br />

fob seal with an inlaid glass seal<br />

depicting a female classical figure<br />

(SUSS-A737F6) and the largest<br />

animal bell recorded for <strong>Sussex</strong>,<br />

probably used for an ox or bull<br />

(SUSS-716BD3); it is larger in<br />

dimension than a tennis ball!<br />

In addition, our efforts to<br />

encourage volunteer self-recording<br />

this year have produced more than<br />

200 records on the PAS database.<br />

This is a reflection of the enthusiasm<br />

of some of our <strong>Sussex</strong> finders<br />

and their willingness to become<br />

more involved with the Portable<br />

Antiquities Scheme database. For<br />

further information about finds<br />

mentioned here or to discover<br />

recent finds in your area, please<br />

explore our website at www.finds.<br />

org.uk.<br />

<strong>The</strong> following discoveries are<br />

some of the most interesting from<br />

the past year and are highlighted<br />

due to their personal significance or<br />

their importance within the <strong>Sussex</strong><br />

landscape.<br />

Forty-five items of Treasure have<br />

been declared in <strong>Sussex</strong> over the<br />

past year and this first find is one of<br />

them. PAS record SUSS-628524<br />

is a silver Medieval seal (13th-<br />

14th C AD) inlaid with a Roman<br />

carnelian intaglio (c. 1st-3rd C AD),<br />

discovered in East <strong>Sussex</strong>. <strong>The</strong><br />

seal is inscribed as belonging to<br />

an Alan of ‘Duntune’, the Medieval<br />

spelling of Dutton in Cheshire. It<br />

is possible that this individual<br />

belonged to the de Dutton line,<br />

which originated in this country with<br />

the Norman invasion; ‘Duntune’ is<br />

later recorded as a place-name in<br />

the Domesday Book. <strong>The</strong> Roman<br />

intaglio (above) depicts a winged<br />

Victory driving a two-horse chariot<br />

called a ‘biga’ and is likely to<br />

have been either found or ordered<br />

specially for its use in the seal. This<br />

seal would have reflected a wealthy<br />

individual’s personal taste and<br />

decision to incorporate an ancient<br />

object within a newer personal seal<br />

design. Hopefully, future research<br />

will help us to better understand<br />

this unique object.<br />

<strong>The</strong> second object (above),<br />

SUSS-761CD0, has been identified<br />

as the hilt of a late Hallstatt B3<br />

Urnfield sword, dating to the Late<br />

Bronze Age (1150-700 BC). It is the<br />

only sword hilt of its kind recorded<br />

on the PAS database and would<br />

have been an expensive and special<br />

piece of personal armour during the<br />

period of transition from Bronze Age<br />

to Iron Age in <strong>Sussex</strong>. It is unusual<br />

to find this type of object away<br />

from a larger hoard or burial, and as<br />

such has proven to be mysterious.<br />

<strong>The</strong> sword hilts of this period were<br />

decorated with coiled arms and<br />

incised design; they would have<br />

been coveted by their owner.<br />

This year, West <strong>Sussex</strong> has<br />

produced some particularly<br />

interesting finds from the Roman<br />

period. Amongst them is a delicate<br />

cast copper-alloy figurine of Cupid<br />

(SUSS-591C64 - below), a lead<br />

votive axehead (SUSS-571122) and<br />

a contemporary copy of a Roman<br />

nummus combining the obverse<br />

of a coin of Constantius II and the<br />

reverse of Magnentius (SUSS-<br />

4DCAC2). All of these objects help<br />

us to better understand the ritual<br />

and practical needs of <strong>Sussex</strong><br />

inhabitants between AD 43-410.<br />

<strong>The</strong> final object I’ve chosen to<br />

highlight was selected not because<br />

of its rarity on the database, but<br />

because of its significance to the<br />

area in which it was found. SUSS-<br />

93B5D3 (above right) is a very late<br />

Bronze Age socketed axehead<br />

with a facetted body, flared blade<br />

and small loop. This axehead was<br />

discovered within a short distance<br />

of Wolstonbury Hill, a wellknown<br />

prehistoric site. Within the<br />

axehead, modern cartridges were<br />

found which suggests perhaps that<br />

this object has been discovered<br />

previously and re-interred in nearby<br />

soil. It is therefore possible that this<br />

axehead comes directly from the<br />

Wolstonbury site. It was discovered<br />

by a Friend of Wolstonbury and<br />

relinquished to the Wolstonbury<br />

Trust for keeping as part of the<br />

collection. According to the Trust,<br />

the discovery of an axehead in<br />

direct association to Wolstonbury<br />

is exceedingly rare and as such,<br />

could tell us more about late Bronze<br />

Age activity within the site.<br />

As this year draws to a close, I<br />

must say good bye to two excellent<br />

colleagues: Lucy Ellis and Claire<br />

Goodey. As Finds Liaison Assistant<br />

and Headley Bursary intern for<br />

the past six months, Lucy has<br />

cheerfully tackled every aspect of<br />

Finds Liaison work: from meeting<br />

with finders; to identifying and<br />

recording finds; to participating in<br />

outreach; to helping with a metal<br />

detecting rally. Claire Goodey has<br />

been a dedicated volunteer for<br />

three years and is responsible for<br />

recording nearly 400 records onto<br />

the database. Her exemplary work<br />

in anything that needs to be done,<br />

whether identifying artefacts or<br />

keeping the FLO organised (no small<br />

task!) will be missed. Due to their<br />

efforts and those of the rest of my<br />

volunteer staff, we have managed to<br />

take in more finds, while providing<br />

a service to a swelling number of<br />

finders in <strong>Sussex</strong>.<br />

Stephanie Smith<br />

Finds Liaison Officer, <strong>Sussex</strong><br />

Alan Stevens<br />

1934-<strong>2012</strong><br />

Alan Stevens, who died on 24 March, will be recalled by many<br />

members as a constant attendee at lectures, walks and<br />

conferences. Born at Hove in 1934, he joined the <strong>Society</strong> as a boy,<br />

coming under the influence of Hove archaeologist Eric Holden and<br />

going on outings while still at school. Suffering badly from examination<br />

nerves, he reached Lancaster University as one of its earliest mature<br />

students, having held posts in a series of prep schools while he<br />

worked to gain the necessary A-levels. <strong>The</strong> occupation at which he<br />

excelled, though, was lecturing for the WEA and the University of<br />

Kent in history and archaeology, with a special interest in vernacular<br />

architecture.<br />

Alan enlivened occasions he attended with his constant spirit of<br />

intellectual enquiry, taking notes and where necessary challenging<br />

lecturer or walk leader. He was keen both to learn and to impart his<br />

own knowledge to others - a polymath with whom you could discuss<br />

many subjects besides history and archaeology, notably politics and<br />

music.<br />

Alan was certainly an eccentric. On outings, in whatever weather,<br />

he would carry, sometimes underneath his anorak, a large rucksack<br />

containing inter alia a folding umbrella to keep the rain away. At a<br />

meeting of the <strong>Society</strong>’s Events committee he hosted circa 1992<br />

I remember him offering sugar for tea as wrapped portions he’d<br />

collected from restaurants and cafes, presented in a large waste<br />

paper basket!<br />

Sadly, he never put much of his learning into print, a sole contribution<br />

to Collections being part of the Stretham (Henfield) moated site<br />

report in Volume 147. For a time, though, he wrote up events in the<br />

<strong>Society</strong>’s Newsletter, humorously claiming the title of ‘Hon Reporter’.<br />

Many books from his extensive collection have been donated to the<br />

<strong>Society</strong>, either for its own library or for sale in the Barbican House<br />

bookshop.<br />

Tim Hudson<br />

<strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />

www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong>


Letters<br />

THE PRESIDENT & CEO<br />

FISHBOURNE EXCAVATION<br />

Excavations<br />

Research<br />

Dear Members...<br />

At the <strong>Society</strong>’s AGM this year I was honoured to be elected President. Thank you.<br />

During the course of the meeting, Item 7 covered proposals to change four of our Articles of Association,<br />

part of the governing document of the <strong>Society</strong>. <strong>The</strong> changes suggested were based upon a version of the<br />

Articles of Association entitled “amended in 2006”. After the meeting, I scrutinised this document and noticed<br />

errors. This led me to a detailed examination of previous General Meeting agendas and minutes since 1994. I<br />

discovered that the AGM of 2006 had no amendment resolution to the Articles of Association, so any version<br />

dated 2006 is unapproved.<br />

Since 1995, the only amendment made to the Articles was that approved by the members at AGM 2004 in<br />

East Grinstead. This amendment was based on advice from the Charity Commission and allowed there to be<br />

between 10 and 14 Council Members, rather than exactly twelve. Thus the correct version of the Articles of<br />

Association should be those which include the headings -Adopted on 25th June 1994, Amended on 20th May<br />

1995, Amended on 5th June 2004. This is now on the <strong>Society</strong>’s website members’ area.<br />

Please note that the numbering of the Articles in the correct version is so different from that in the erroneous<br />

2006 draft that the voting for changing specific numbered articles at the <strong>2012</strong> AGM is completely undermined.<br />

None of the numbers matched because some articles had been deleted. Also, unauthorised wording had been<br />

inserted. In consequence, the resolutions passed in good faith under Agenda Item 7 at AGM <strong>2012</strong> are null and<br />

void.<br />

No culprit should be sought. This error lies with corruption of data several years ago through cumulative<br />

mistakes in saving computer files or when replacing equipment. Office and paper filing procedures will be<br />

tightened up. It remains for me to extend an apology to the membership on behalf of present and former<br />

Council Members and staff that this error has occurred. I confirm that our Articles of Association remain those<br />

dated 2004.<br />

Caroline Wells<br />

President<br />

Firstly I would like to wish you all a very merry Christmas and to thank you for your support over the last<br />

year. I know many of you have attended our excellent conferences and events and that member visits to<br />

our properties are at a record level. We are all looking forward to the 150th edition of the <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong><br />

Collections next year, this will be a real landmark for the <strong>Society</strong> and we will celebrate this achievement.<br />

In February and March next year we plan to hold two further Members’ Open Discussion sessions; the dates<br />

can be found in the Noticeboard section (see opposite). As previously these represent an opportunity to share<br />

details of the current <strong>issue</strong>s facing the <strong>Society</strong> and to hear and record the views of members. A record of<br />

the discussions during the three sessions held earlier this year are on the Members’ section of the <strong>Society</strong>’s<br />

website. This is very valuable as it provides a record which staff and trustees can use to understand the views<br />

of members who attended and contributed to the sessions.<br />

Over the next period the Trustees and senior staff will be collating all the information about the activities which<br />

the <strong>Society</strong> has undertaken this year. This process will help direct the planning for next year and beyond. As<br />

previously, the major <strong>issue</strong> of the financial performance of the <strong>Society</strong> will be at the heart of any considerations<br />

about future resourcing and structures. <strong>The</strong> views of members, received through the discussion sessions,<br />

together with various surveys and individual correspondence, will be fed into the process of forward planning.<br />

<strong>The</strong> meetings next year represent an opportunity to share with you the outcome of these deliberations and<br />

decisions. I think we are all painfully aware that the <strong>Society</strong> is very reliant on the income from our properties<br />

and that the appalling weather this summer has had a significant effect on this. <strong>The</strong> Trustees will be faced with<br />

very real challenges in terms of looking at what we can offer and how we do it. Quite simply there will have to<br />

be changes based on the reality of what we can actually afford to do. This should not detract from our ability to<br />

appreciate the excellent achievements of our staff, Trustees and volunteers during <strong>2012</strong> and there is still much<br />

to celebrate.<br />

Tristan Bareham<br />

Chief Executive<br />

Excavations at Fishbourne<br />

Old spoil heaps still have a story to tell!<br />

For the first time since 2002,<br />

a research excavation has<br />

been undertaken at Fishbourne<br />

Roman Palace, but this was not<br />

an excavation in the conventional<br />

sense. In March this year we took<br />

a sample of approximately one<br />

tonne from the spoil heaps created<br />

in the 1960s when the Palace was<br />

originally excavated. Of course,<br />

the sample was of mixed and<br />

unstratified excavation waste. It<br />

contained modern artefacts such<br />

as bottle tops, nails and 20th<br />

century coins that were left by<br />

the archaeologists nearly 50 years<br />

ago, but crucially also any Roman<br />

material that they did not recover or<br />

deliberately discarded.<br />

No excavation will recover all<br />

of the artefacts from the site. Bias<br />

against small or modern objects<br />

or those that are difficult to spot<br />

will always exist. This bias will<br />

vary according to the experience<br />

and interests of the excavators,<br />

the resources available and even<br />

the weather conditions. For these<br />

reasons the bias is unique to<br />

each site. <strong>The</strong> intention of the<br />

Fishbourne sample is, through very<br />

fine sieving and careful sorting,<br />

to recover as close to 100% of<br />

the artefacts as possible. This will<br />

give an impression of what was<br />

not recovered from the site when<br />

it was excavated. In turn this will<br />

allow a wholesale reassessment<br />

of the artefacts recovered in the<br />

1960s and stored in the Collections<br />

Discovery Centre at Fishbourne. It<br />

may become apparent, for example,<br />

that the ratio of grey ware pottery<br />

to Samian in the stored archive is<br />

as much a reflection of the higher<br />

visibility of the highly coloured<br />

Samian as it is an indication of the<br />

status of the site. It will also be a<br />

chance to recover from Fishbourne<br />

very small objects such as fish<br />

Family fun at the Festival of British Archaeology<br />

bones, small mammal remains and<br />

seeds for the first time.<br />

This is an unusual project and<br />

places the Palace at the forefront of<br />

current thinking when it comes to<br />

the interpretation of stored archives.<br />

Work is ongoing, but if anything<br />

can be guaranteed at this stage,<br />

the project will provide researchers<br />

with something to think about for<br />

years to come.<br />

Allied to the project, the staff at<br />

Fishbourne took the opportunity<br />

to extend the sample trenches and<br />

enable some of the Palace visitors to<br />

have a go at excavation themselves.<br />

As part of the <strong>2012</strong> Festival of British<br />

Archaeology visitors of all ages<br />

were invited to visit the spoil heaps,<br />

borrow a trowel and experience the<br />

excitement of discovering artefacts<br />

for themselves. Roman tesserae<br />

and 1960s nails seemed to elicit<br />

similar levels of excitement! Over<br />

a thousand artefacts were found<br />

ranging from relatively recent<br />

objects such as a halfpenny piece<br />

dated 1974 and the older style<br />

1960s ring pulls from drinks cans to<br />

Photo: <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />

pieces of pot and bone. Probably<br />

the most interesting find was a<br />

small fragment of high quality<br />

Samian pottery (shown below). It is<br />

decorated with part of an image of<br />

a running animal, possibly a dog or<br />

a horse.<br />

Participants were also given the<br />

chance to try their hand at surveying,<br />

site planning, sample sorting and<br />

to meet our conservation team.<br />

<strong>The</strong> event was a great success and<br />

plans are afoot to repeat it in some<br />

(probably larger) form next year.<br />

Dr Rob Symmons<br />

Curator, Fishbourne Roman Palace<br />

<strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />

www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong>


Feature<br />

CONFERENCE REPORT<br />

GRANT AWARD<br />

Feature<br />

<strong>The</strong> Piltdown Conference<br />

Truth and Lies from the Deep <strong>Sussex</strong> Past<br />

<strong>The</strong> subtitle for this conference<br />

could easily have been “What<br />

you don’t know about Piltdown”<br />

and all of the speakers made the<br />

audience think about the wellknown<br />

story afresh.<br />

John Farrant started the<br />

proceedings on a historical note,<br />

exploring some of the questions<br />

about the relationship between the<br />

<strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong> and<br />

the Piltdown discoveries. Charles<br />

Dawson’s family background<br />

was described and his increasing<br />

involvement with the <strong>Society</strong> after<br />

his move to Uckfield in 1889, which<br />

saw his promotion of his projects at<br />

the Lavant Caves and at Hastings<br />

Castle. We were left to wonder<br />

how much his estrangement from<br />

the <strong>Society</strong> after the Castle Lodge<br />

affair contributed to his switch<br />

to an interest in the Palaeolithic,<br />

which, at that time SAC left to the<br />

geologists.<br />

Beccy Scott (British Museum)<br />

& Andy Shaw (Southampton<br />

University) took us through<br />

the archaeological and<br />

palaeontological context for<br />

Piltdown and built a convincing<br />

case that the construction of the<br />

Piltdown collection looked more<br />

to 19th century interpretations of<br />

deep human prehistory than they<br />

Robert Kruszynski, from the Natural History Museum, fascinated delegates with a display of casts of<br />

the main specimens from the Piltdown collection.<br />

Photo: E Livesey<br />

did to the ensuing 20th century.<br />

An intriguing point made here was<br />

that the investigations at Barnfield<br />

Pit (Swanscombe) started in 1912<br />

and the way in which Smith &<br />

Dewey worked there is much more<br />

in tune with modern methods than<br />

the rather dilettante approach at<br />

Piltdown.<br />

Robert Kruszynski (Natural<br />

History Museum) gave us an account<br />

both of the curation of the Piltdown<br />

material at the Natural History<br />

Museum and tantalised us with an<br />

account of the research currently<br />

being done on the specimens. He<br />

stole the show with an exhibit of<br />

casts of the main specimens and<br />

some of the original flints from the<br />

Piltdown collection.<br />

John McNabb (Southampton<br />

University) put the discovery of<br />

Piltdown into the context of 1912<br />

as a remarkable year - Scott in<br />

the Antarctic, the Titanic’s maiden<br />

voyage and the publication of<br />

Tarzan of the Apes. He explained<br />

his reanalysis of the lithics and<br />

convincingly argued that these had<br />

been intended to reveal a sequence<br />

from Pliocene eoliths through to<br />

the Pleistocene Chellean, with the<br />

Piltdown cranium placed in the<br />

middle of this. Some of the later<br />

finds were argued to be attempts<br />

to re-establish this sequence when<br />

interpretations strayed from what<br />

had originally been intended.<br />

Miles Russell (Bournemouth<br />

University) reviewed Charles<br />

Dawson’s overall archaeological<br />

career, pulling out the dubious and<br />

often “transitional” finds which<br />

mark this out. <strong>The</strong> unanswered<br />

question about Dawson is still “why<br />

did he do it”<br />

Francis Thackeray (University<br />

of the Witwaterstrand) brought<br />

Teilhard de Chardin into the frame.<br />

Although one of the original workers<br />

at Piltdown, and the discoverer<br />

of the canine tooth, Teilhard was<br />

remarkably silent on the subject<br />

of Piltdown. However, Thackeray’s<br />

work on the archive of his letters<br />

has revealed some hints that, at<br />

the least, Teilhard knew there was<br />

something amiss with Piltdown.<br />

<strong>The</strong> possibility that he was also<br />

involved in the hoax as a joker was<br />

raised.<br />

Matt Pope (Institute of<br />

Archaeology) brought the day to<br />

its end with a stimulating overview<br />

of Palaeolithic research in <strong>Sussex</strong><br />

from the 19th to the 21st century.<br />

Overall this was an excellent<br />

conference which showed clearly<br />

the relevance of the history of<br />

Palaeolithic research to our present<br />

understanding and put the bizarre<br />

goings on at Piltdown into their<br />

proper context.<br />

Liz Somerville<br />

Museums Receive Grant<br />

Arts Council funding for conservation support across South-East<br />

<strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />

is a long-standing member<br />

of the <strong>Sussex</strong> Museums Group<br />

(SMG) which is a coalition of over<br />

40 museums and galleries from<br />

East and West <strong>Sussex</strong> that aims<br />

to provide support, advice and<br />

leadership within the sector. In<br />

May this year the <strong>Society</strong> was<br />

invited by the Arts Council England<br />

(ACE) to submit, on behalf of<br />

SMG, a proposal for a project<br />

that would provide conservation<br />

advice to <strong>Sussex</strong> museums. <strong>The</strong><br />

original intention was to fund a<br />

freelance conservator who would<br />

be based at the conservation lab<br />

at Fishbourne Roman Palace, but<br />

provide support remotely as well<br />

as through site visits, training and<br />

workshops. However, the need for<br />

conservation advice is not limited<br />

to <strong>Sussex</strong> alone. <strong>The</strong> Arts Council<br />

decided in August to provide<br />

a grant of £75,000 to fund the<br />

delivery of conservation support<br />

to museums over the much wider<br />

area of Surrey and Kent as well as<br />

<strong>Sussex</strong>. A conservator will still be<br />

based at Fishbourne, but they will<br />

now work alongside another based<br />

at Chatham in Kent. <strong>The</strong> project will<br />

last for 6 months, but it is hoped<br />

that further funding will be secured<br />

so that it can be extended.<br />

<strong>The</strong> conservator based at Fishbourne will<br />

work alongside the existing team of volunteer<br />

conservators. Here the team use X-radiography<br />

to assess the extent of corrosion in metal artefacts<br />

to identify and prioritise work.<br />

Photo: <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />

<strong>The</strong> aim of the project is to<br />

conserve objects from museums<br />

that require remedial work, but<br />

more importantly to equip museum<br />

staff with the knowledge and<br />

Friends of Fishbourne Roman Palace<br />

confidence to undertake work<br />

themselves where possible (as<br />

well as teaching them to recognize<br />

when not to conserve an item).<br />

<strong>The</strong> conservators will establish a<br />

network that will help museums<br />

locate the expertise and funding<br />

that they need as well as setting up a<br />

resource-base providing access to<br />

otherwise expensive conservation<br />

equipment and consumables. Most<br />

importantly, they will undertake a<br />

survey of the conservation needs<br />

within the region. It is hoped that<br />

the information gained through<br />

this process will be able to feed in<br />

to future funding applications so<br />

that subsequent projects can be<br />

focused as effectively as possible.<br />

<strong>The</strong> staff at Fishbourne Roman<br />

Palace are looking forward to<br />

welcoming a new member to their<br />

ranks. This is especially true of the<br />

existing volunteer conservation<br />

team, who will continue to use the<br />

lab in the Collections Discovery<br />

Centre.<br />

Dr Robert Symmons<br />

Curator, Fishbourne Roman Palace<br />

<strong>The</strong> ‘Friends of Fishbourne Roman Palace’ was founded a few years ago with the help and encouragement<br />

of the <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong> to offer limited financial support to the Palace, limited because,<br />

although we are on a sound financial footing, we are still quite a small organization. To become more<br />

ambitious in our assistance to the Palace we need a larger membership so we are taking this opportunity to<br />

bring the Friends to the attention of SAS members, particularly in West <strong>Sussex</strong> and Hampshire.<br />

We have provided the Palace with a monitor screen and associated equipment to enable the events of<br />

each day to be displayed in the reception area, saving the staff having to hand out pieces of paper and<br />

explain everything to each visitor; we are financing the much-needed refurbishment of the display notices<br />

in the Garden Museum; we have purchased a trolley for the Collections Discovery Centre and a memorial<br />

bench for the garden, all of which the Palace and SAS had no funds to cover.<br />

For further information on the Friends please see the SAS website or contact the Membership Secretary,<br />

Anne Wingfield-Hayes, 01243 527495. And if you do see your way to joining and helping us, thanks in<br />

advance.<br />

10 <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />

www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong> 11


Library<br />

LIBRARY & BOOKSHOP<br />

BOOK REVIEWS<br />

Books<br />

Library News<br />

am sure you all realise how much we depend on donations and<br />

I bequests to keep the Library supported. Just over 5 years ago<br />

we were fortunate to receive a bequest, specifically to the Library,<br />

from the late Thomas Masson Moore of Lewes, to be used for the<br />

purchase of books. He had been a regular user of the Library in the<br />

time of Joyce Crow and Ken Dickins, and was well-known to both of<br />

them. This has enabled us to purchase several desirable items which<br />

we could not otherwise have afforded, such as the Cambridge Urban<br />

History of Britain (3 vols), as well as providing additional support for<br />

general purchases.<br />

We have now reached the end of this fund, so this is an opportune<br />

moment to remind Members and users of the Library to think of us<br />

when writing their wills, and indeed if they can afford to donate at<br />

other times. I notice that Thomas Masson Moore also left bequests<br />

to the Wallace Collection and the Blue Cross (an animal charity), so<br />

like him please consider several directions for your funds – everything<br />

will be appreciated!<br />

I list below some recent additions to the Library (all <strong>2012</strong>):<br />

ALLEN, Michael J, Editor<br />

Is there a British Chalcolithic<br />

ANDERSON-WHYMARK, Regional perspectives on Neolithic pit<br />

Hugo, Editor<br />

deposition<br />

GARDNER, James<br />

GILCRIST, Roberta<br />

GREHAN, John<br />

McCOOEY, Christopher<br />

WILKINSON, Louise J<br />

A History of the Brighton Workhouses<br />

Medieval Life: archaeology and the life<br />

course<br />

Battleground of <strong>Sussex</strong>: a military<br />

history of <strong>Sussex</strong> from the Iron Age to<br />

the present day<br />

Smuggling on the South Coast<br />

Eleanor De Montfort<br />

We are grateful to the following for their donations to the Library:<br />

DG Bate; C & J Brent; J Hobbs; M Norman; T Sully; A Vincent;<br />

R Wallace.<br />

Esme Evans<br />

Hon. Librarian<br />

Bookshop<br />

THE delicious Apples and Orchards<br />

in <strong>Sussex</strong> is on the shelf at £15. Super<br />

book, with central chapters on the<br />

history of apple growing in <strong>Sussex</strong><br />

nestling comfortably between a<br />

guide to <strong>Sussex</strong> apple varieties<br />

and interviews with professional<br />

fruit growers in <strong>Sussex</strong>, along with<br />

other delights. <strong>The</strong> illustrations and<br />

overall design are very tasty too.<br />

Elsewhere in this newsletter<br />

you will read the obituary of Alan<br />

Stevens. Through the generosity of<br />

Alan’s main beneficiary his books<br />

have come to the <strong>Society</strong>. Quite a<br />

few will go to enhance your Library<br />

while the rest will gradually work<br />

their way into the bookshop stock.<br />

Further to this, I’m hoping to have<br />

catalogued some of the highervalue<br />

books by the New Year.<br />

Shelf price will be sensible with the<br />

usual reduction of 10-15% to SAS<br />

members.<br />

If you are interested in receiving a<br />

copy of whatever it is that I produce<br />

please send me either your email<br />

address, or an A5 sae if you’d like<br />

a hard copy. I’m at castlebooks@<br />

sussexpast.co.uk and Barbican<br />

House Bookshop, 169 High Street,<br />

Lewes, BN7 1YE.<br />

John Bleach<br />

Barbican House Bookshop<br />

<strong>The</strong> Borough<br />

and Manor of<br />

New Shoreham<br />

Some Records of its<br />

People & Places<br />

<strong>The</strong> 1782 Manor<br />

Survey Annotated<br />

NEARLY one hundred years<br />

ago, in 1921, Henry Cheal first<br />

published his pioneering <strong>The</strong> Story<br />

of Shoreham. He died in 1954, but<br />

left extensive notes which Michael<br />

Norman, a long-time resident of<br />

Shoreham and former honorary<br />

curator of Marlipins Museum, has<br />

been using, editing and adding to<br />

since 1951.<br />

This new book is an edited and<br />

organised version of a survey<br />

of the Manor of New Shoreham<br />

which was undertaken in 1782 by<br />

the surveyor Joseph Hodgkinson<br />

for the Duke of Norfolk, the then<br />

Lord of the Manor. Subsequently<br />

the original survey was annotated<br />

by the Duke’s steward. This survey<br />

is now the property of the current<br />

Duke, who retains the copyright,<br />

but the publication in this volume<br />

of the Survey’s contents, together<br />

with notes and suggestions of<br />

the author/editor, allows the<br />

historian and also the more casual<br />

reader to gain an insight into the<br />

development of the historic core<br />

of New Shoreham. <strong>The</strong> book also<br />

contains maps, some annotated,<br />

including copies of Hodgkinson’s<br />

of 1782, to show the situations of<br />

the extensive number of properties<br />

which are listed in the Manorial<br />

rolls. <strong>The</strong> long-lost shipyards along<br />

the river bank, like the one where<br />

the Ropetackle Centre now stands,<br />

are clearly shown and discussed,<br />

with added information concerning<br />

developments after 1782.<br />

A cursory study reveals<br />

fascinating aspects of Shoreham.<br />

For example, the book reproduces<br />

a memorandum which mentions<br />

an Act ‘passed in the Thirty third<br />

Year of His late Majesty’ (probably<br />

1771) which state that all ships and<br />

vessels entering Shoreham Harbour<br />

were obliged to pay Duty in order to<br />

maintain the harbour. In the same<br />

memorandum it is stated that the<br />

Lord of the Manor also received<br />

£20 per annum for allowing a toll<br />

bridge to replace his income from<br />

the ferry which it displaced. <strong>The</strong><br />

Memorandum lists the ferry tolls,<br />

ranging from one shilling for any<br />

four-wheeled carriage to six pence<br />

for twenty sheep or cows.<br />

In another example, there was<br />

an area described in 1782 as<br />

‘A Tenement, Black Smiths Shp<br />

Build g . Yard & Premises’ which was<br />

situated on the river bank on the<br />

High Street, westward from West<br />

Street. This area was cut in half<br />

when the new bridge was built in<br />

1833. <strong>The</strong> Fountain Inn stood on<br />

this site, and this was succeeded<br />

by the Bridge Inn. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Sussex</strong><br />

<strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong> apparently<br />

met at the Bridge Inn on occasion.<br />

This Bridge Inn was demolished<br />

when the High Street was widened<br />

in 1938/9, and replaced by the<br />

current manifestation of the Inn.<br />

<strong>The</strong> material in the book relates<br />

principally, but not exclusively, to<br />

Shoreham. For example, a dispute<br />

concerning a piece of land two acres<br />

in extent in the Parish of Southwick<br />

is described. This dispute between<br />

a Nathal. Hall [apparently a<br />

brewer] and Colvill Bridger Esq. [of<br />

Buckingham House] was current in<br />

1782, and no rent had been paid for<br />

9 years. Rents and lessees for this<br />

land are listed back to 1660. This<br />

matter is of current interest because<br />

it was apparently a descendant of<br />

this Nathaniel Hall, a landowner<br />

also called Nathaniel Hall, who<br />

undertook the first excavation<br />

of Southwick Roman Villa in the<br />

1840s.<br />

<strong>The</strong> survey reveals that the<br />

Hannington family, later proprietors<br />

of the late-lamented Hannington’s<br />

department store in Brighton, were<br />

also Shoreham landholders.<br />

This book is an absolute<br />

goldmine, and will be invaluable<br />

to researchers of Shoreham’s<br />

places and personalities. I hope<br />

that Michael Norman will receive<br />

the recognition and gratitude of<br />

all who benefit from his work,<br />

which is a fitting and welcome<br />

accompaniment and extension to<br />

Cheal’s History.<br />

Jeffery Leigh<br />

Michael W D Norman, 2011. Limited<br />

edition published by the author<br />

(a copy has been generously<br />

donated to the Barbican House<br />

Library - see opposite).<br />

<strong>The</strong> Archaeology of<br />

the South Downs<br />

National Park - An<br />

Introduction<br />

THE <strong>Sussex</strong> <strong>Archaeological</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />

is the centre for archaeological<br />

research in the county and has<br />

been since 1846 publishing<br />

annual volumes on the history and<br />

archaeology of the county. From<br />

this huge archive of research many<br />

synthetic books and articles have<br />

come. With the establishment of<br />

South Downs National Park it is<br />

entirely appropriate that the first<br />

book specifically on the Park derives<br />

from the <strong>Society</strong>. John Manley’s<br />

12 <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />

www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong> 13


Books<br />

BOOK REVIEWS<br />

BOOK REVIEWS<br />

Books<br />

beautifully written, illustrated and<br />

presented book is the first in a<br />

new series on many aspects of<br />

the South Downs. <strong>The</strong> words and<br />

pictures evoke a mysterious place<br />

where people lived, farmed, met<br />

others, defended places, made<br />

religious centres and kept in touch<br />

with their ancestors.<br />

With some 400,000 years of<br />

archaeology present on the South<br />

Downs, Dr Manley has had to<br />

be somewhat selective in his<br />

approach. Instead of attempting<br />

a history of the South Downs<br />

set down chronologically he has<br />

opted to let each section tell the<br />

story of some enduring activity;<br />

like gathering resources from the<br />

earth, buildings people lived in,<br />

meeting places, beliefs, defensive<br />

displays and keeping in touch with<br />

the ancestors. This approach could<br />

have made an understanding of the<br />

area and its archaeology somewhat<br />

difficult for newcomers to the South<br />

Downs, but it does not; instead<br />

it clearly links the past with the<br />

present. <strong>The</strong> South Downs was<br />

not always an empty agricultural<br />

landscape; great gatherings have<br />

always taken place, from the<br />

Neolithic causewayed enclosures<br />

some 6000 years ago to the Amex<br />

Community Stadium of today.<br />

So why is this book so special<br />

and why should every member of<br />

the SAS buy one today Firstly at a<br />

stroke it will update your knowledge<br />

of the archaeology of the South<br />

Downs. Whether your interests are<br />

in prehistory, the Middle Ages, or<br />

modern land use there is something<br />

in this book for you. It is also a great<br />

entry to the archaeology of the<br />

South Downs for people interested<br />

in the area without any former<br />

interest in archaeology.<br />

For the last couple of months<br />

it has sat on my coffee table and<br />

numerous passing friends, relatives<br />

and neighbours have picked it up<br />

and asked where they could get a<br />

copy. This is exactly what the SAS<br />

is for – getting people interested in<br />

the past of <strong>Sussex</strong>. This book will<br />

do that. Buy a copy now, both for<br />

yourself and as an entry to the past<br />

in <strong>Sussex</strong> for all your friends and<br />

neighbours.<br />

Peter Drewett<br />

By John Manley, <strong>2012</strong>.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Sussex</strong> Archaeology <strong>Society</strong>,<br />

Lewes.<br />

ISBN 978-0-904973-22-8.<br />

Paperback, 87 Pages, £8.95<br />

A History of<br />

the Brighton<br />

Workhouses<br />

THIS book deals with an <strong>issue</strong><br />

which is timely, for we are again<br />

debating what we can afford to<br />

spend on benefits, how they can<br />

be fairly distributed and monitored<br />

so those who can work are<br />

encouraged to do so and how to<br />

provide for children, disabled and<br />

elderly people who need care. This<br />

book demonstrates that in the past<br />

many people lacked families who<br />

could afford to care for them or who<br />

would seek do so and that then as<br />

now, a system of basic support of<br />

some form was needed. <strong>The</strong> big<br />

difference between the debates<br />

from the Tudor period until the<br />

mid-1940s and nowadays is that<br />

all expenditure was met directly by<br />

local ratepayers.<br />

Thus this book is a study of the<br />

<strong>issue</strong>s of local management and<br />

accountability in the context of ‘the<br />

poor’ - ‘localism’ in action. Rates<br />

(now called Council Tax) were<br />

collected locally as they are today<br />

but the state did not recycle money<br />

from income tax and business rates<br />

in to local government as it does<br />

now, currently forming the greater<br />

part of the money spent locally.<br />

Local taxpayers, quite a small part<br />

of the local community, paid for<br />

everything that was either a legal<br />

requirement such as care of the<br />

poor, or desirable such as running<br />

the public gardens. Local meetings<br />

about expenditure were often<br />

lively. Ratepayers wanted cheating<br />

stopped and accountability. In<br />

this book there are examples of<br />

governors of the workhouse, staff,<br />

inmates and those on weekly pay<br />

abusing the system.<br />

<strong>The</strong> parish of Brighton was only<br />

responsible for its own poor; the<br />

three workhouses (of 1727, 1822<br />

and 1860s) were funded by its<br />

residents and did not take in poor<br />

from other parishes that are now<br />

within the City. <strong>The</strong>se had to go<br />

to other workhouses. By the early<br />

18th century it also paid a weekly<br />

amount to poor people who, in<br />

the view of the overseers, might<br />

find work or for other reasons<br />

were best left in their own home, a<br />

practice which continued into the<br />

1940s and was the precursor to the<br />

benefits system. <strong>The</strong> preference<br />

was to keep people employed,<br />

both within the workhouse and also<br />

by keeping weekly income tightly<br />

controlled. <strong>The</strong> strength of the book<br />

is the detailed study of the period<br />

between the 1850s and the end of<br />

the Poor Law in the mid 1940s. <strong>The</strong><br />

lives of inmates and of employees<br />

of the workhouse and the Industrial<br />

School at Warren Road reflect how<br />

hard it must have been to be poor<br />

and also how to manage a fair and<br />

effective means of supporting those<br />

in need. We have perhaps had our<br />

attitudes to the Workhouse overly<br />

strongly affected by the novels of<br />

Dickens and others who depicted<br />

them as a nightmare. But few of<br />

the critics even tried to find a more<br />

effective solution to a system of<br />

care which would not totally absorb<br />

local revenues or result in one town<br />

or parish becoming a target due<br />

to the quality of treatment offered<br />

by many people who did not live<br />

locally.<br />

<strong>The</strong>re are a couple of errors in the<br />

early section; for example the ‘Great<br />

Storm’ of 1703 did not destroy many<br />

fishermen’s dwellings below the cliff<br />

(there is plenty of archival evidence<br />

to disprove this wonderful piece of<br />

18th century journalism) and, when<br />

Brighton’s fortunes declined, many<br />

of the young people did as they<br />

would today and ‘upped sticks’.<br />

Mr Gardner is to be applauded<br />

for wading through many sources<br />

and bringing to our attention the<br />

great dilemma of the 19th century<br />

– how does one deal with the care<br />

of the poor in rapidly expanding<br />

towns where employment was so<br />

cyclical as in Brighton. What we<br />

have to remember is that with the<br />

workhouses, weekly pay, soup<br />

kitchens, mendacity charities,<br />

dispensaries and hospitals all<br />

aimed at helping the poor, local<br />

people tried hard to help. This book<br />

reveals how difficult it was to ensure<br />

that treatment was reasonable and<br />

fair and not subject to exploitation.<br />

<strong>The</strong> debate on how best to do this<br />

continues.<br />

Sue Berry<br />

By James Gardner, <strong>2012</strong>. Published<br />

by the author: 5 East Way, Lewes,<br />

BN7 1NG. ISBN 978-0-9536101-1-<br />

2. 442pp with illustrations. £19.95.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Glynde<br />

Butterflies<br />

Stoolball Team<br />

1866-1887<br />

England’s first<br />

female sports stars<br />

IT is most appropriate, in this<br />

Olympic year when the President<br />

of the IOC at the opening of<br />

London <strong>2012</strong> emphasised the role<br />

of the British in codifying so many<br />

games and sporting events, that<br />

Andrew Lusted has published this<br />

work on stoolball. Following on<br />

the success of several previous<br />

publications relating to Glynde,<br />

Andrew has turned his attention to<br />

the 19th century sporting ladies of<br />

his home village and others close<br />

by who were, it transpires from his<br />

research, world leaders in the field<br />

of women’s team games.<br />

Two <strong>Sussex</strong> firsts are recorded in<br />

this interesting report of the prowess<br />

of the delightfully named Glynde<br />

Butterflies, Chailey Grasshoppers,<br />

Waldron Bees, and Selmeston<br />

Harvest Bugs, and other local<br />

ladies sports teams.<br />

<strong>The</strong> origins of stoolball are little<br />

understood and versions of the<br />

game may originally have been<br />

played in many parts of England.<br />

<strong>The</strong> modern game is confined<br />

almost exclusively to the south<br />

eastern counties, predominantly<br />

in <strong>Sussex</strong> but also extending<br />

west into Hampshire, north into<br />

Surrey and east into Kent, with<br />

one remarkable outlier in Sutton<br />

Coldfield in Birmingham. <strong>The</strong><br />

game has long interested sport<br />

historians as articles in our own<br />

collections by John Lowerson<br />

(1995) and John Goulstone (1998)<br />

testify. One notable supporter was<br />

Sir William Grantham of Barcombe<br />

who actively promoted the game,<br />

albeit somewhat eccentrically, in<br />

the early 20th century. Sir William’s<br />

significant collection of memorabilia<br />

and his scrap books are held in the<br />

working papers room in the library<br />

at Barbican House. As a trainee<br />

teacher at Bishop Otter College in<br />

the 1950s I recall being introduced<br />

to the (to me) unfamiliar game,<br />

because we were almost certain<br />

to come upon it when we were<br />

unleashed upon local schools for<br />

our school practices. More recently,<br />

but still some time ago, one of my<br />

daughters played for a junior team in<br />

Crowborough. Many of the present<br />

day clubs field mixed teams but in<br />

origin it was exclusively a women’s<br />

game – introduced, perhaps, to<br />

provide a female equivalent to<br />

cricket.<br />

In the course of his research<br />

into stoolball Andrew uncovered<br />

documentary evidence for a female<br />

cricket team playing regularly at<br />

Glynde, several years before the<br />

Yorkshire club team who claim<br />

to be the oldest established in<br />

the country. In addition he proves<br />

without doubt that the first rules<br />

of stoolball were established and<br />

published in the East <strong>Sussex</strong> News,<br />

probably at the instigation of the<br />

indefatigable Glynde Butterflies, in<br />

1867. This is earlier than the rules<br />

of any other women’s team sport.<br />

Most striking too is the evidence<br />

for universal participation in the<br />

sport. Considering the class<br />

conscious times it is revealing that<br />

here in <strong>Sussex</strong>, on the sports field<br />

at least, village girls, the daughters<br />

of the manse and of the local squire,<br />

all participated in the local teams.<br />

If you know anyone who has an<br />

interest in Stoolball this book is a<br />

must; a stocking filler for Christmas<br />

perhaps.<br />

Pamela Combes<br />

By Andrew Lusted, 2011.<br />

Copies available in Barbican House<br />

bookshop or direct from the author at<br />

Welsted, Glynde, Lewes, BN8 6SU.<br />

Price £7.00 plus £1.20 postage,<br />

cheques payable to Andrew Lusted.<br />

14 <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />

www.sussexpast.co.uk www.sussexpast.co.uk <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong> 15


Snippets<br />

Help Protect Local<br />

Historic Gardens<br />

THE <strong>Sussex</strong> Gardens Trust (www.<br />

sussexgardenstrust.org.uk) is a<br />

charity promoting the conservation<br />

and appreciation of gardens and<br />

parks in our area, and part of a family<br />

of 35 gardens trusts around Britain<br />

working together under the umbrella<br />

of the Association of Gardens<br />

Trusts (www.gardenstrusts.org.<br />

uk). We are embarking on a project<br />

to develop Local Lists of significant<br />

parks and gardens which will<br />

be incorporated into the local<br />

authority’s Historic Environment<br />

Record. We aim to ensure that<br />

important sites are recorded and<br />

protected from development. Our<br />

campaign is supported by a new<br />

government initiative to encourage<br />

the development of Local Lists<br />

through partnerships between<br />

local organisations like the <strong>Sussex</strong><br />

Gardens Trust and local authorities.<br />

Local Lists record and recognise<br />

sites of historic and cultural interest<br />

to the community, including<br />

buildings, monuments and special<br />

places, as well as parks, gardens<br />

and designed landscapes. <strong>The</strong><br />

south-east especially suffers from<br />

development pressures of many<br />

kinds, and without the information<br />

and recognition given in a Local List,<br />

many historic sites are vulnerable<br />

to inappropriate change or lack of<br />

proper maintenance. Gardens can<br />

suffer from decay or damage to<br />

built structures, views can become<br />

blocked by self-sown trees, water<br />

features no longer function as<br />

intended, surfaces of paths and<br />

drives become degraded, and<br />

garden buildings are subject to<br />

damp, cracking and even collapse.<br />

We want to prevent this happening<br />

to the gardens we value in <strong>Sussex</strong>,<br />

but we need help to make this<br />

possible.<br />

We offer training courses in<br />

how to research a site, including<br />

practical sessions on identifying<br />

historic features on maps, using<br />

archive resources and carrying out<br />

a site survey. We will establish the<br />

purpose of Local Listing, explaining<br />

why it is important for conserving<br />

our garden heritage and how you<br />

can contribute. You will also be<br />

introduced to the methodology<br />

of writing up a site report using<br />

the format developed by English<br />

Heritage for the National Heritage<br />

List, where all types of heritage of<br />

national importance are recorded<br />

(www.english-heritage.org.uk/<br />

list). <strong>The</strong> training courses are free of<br />

charge and lunch and refreshments<br />

are provided.<br />

Please contact Jennie Starr<br />

who will be happy to discuss how<br />

you can contribute to the project<br />

and enrol you on our next training<br />

course. Tel 01323 461310 or email<br />

starrhouse@clara.co.uk.<br />

<strong>The</strong> South Downs<br />

Series<br />

THE ‘South Downs Series’ is a<br />

novel and exciting venture for the<br />

<strong>Society</strong>: a series of books (edited<br />

by Robin Milner-Gulland, member<br />

of Council, and John Manley, the<br />

<strong>Society</strong>’s Research Fellow), of<br />

which John Manley’s ‘Archaeology<br />

of the South Downs National Park:<br />

an Introduction’ is the first to<br />

appear. A generous grant from the<br />

SDNP Authority, and a gift from a<br />

private donor, have covered the<br />

initial publication costs. We trust<br />

that sales will make a contribution<br />

to the <strong>Society</strong>’s finances, and that<br />

the volumes will raise its public<br />

profile.<br />

<strong>The</strong>y are quite short (each<br />

about 20,000 words of text),<br />

keeping costs down, but lavishly<br />

produced with around 100 colour<br />

illustrations, some of them specially<br />

commissioned aerial photos and<br />

maps etc. <strong>The</strong>y will be on sale at all<br />

the <strong>Society</strong>’s properties open to the<br />

public, as well as local bookshops.<br />

<strong>The</strong> books are written by<br />

specialists but intended for a wide<br />

public. <strong>The</strong> next two, already at<br />

an advanced stage of preparation,<br />

will be on Geology and Physical<br />

Landscape (by David Robinson)<br />

and Wildlife and Biodiversity (by<br />

Robin Crane with Rendel Williams).<br />

<strong>The</strong>se three together will make<br />

a wonderful overview of varied<br />

aspects of the South Downs area; I<br />

know of no comparable series.<br />

Depending on their success -<br />

and first signs in the case of John’s<br />

book augur well - it is to be hoped<br />

that the project will continue:<br />

indeed the great Peter Brandon<br />

had already roughed out a scheme<br />

for such a book before his recent<br />

death. Further ideas welcome!<br />

Robin Milner-Gulland<br />

Next Issue<br />

THE <strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present<br />

newsletter is published three<br />

times a year, in April, August and<br />

<strong>December</strong>. <strong>The</strong> next <strong>issue</strong> will be<br />

published in April 2013; the copy<br />

deadline is 15th February. Letters<br />

and ‘snippets’ are welcome;<br />

longer items should be kept to a<br />

maximum of 500 words unless prior<br />

arrangements have been made with<br />

the editor, Wendy Muriel, at spp@<br />

sussexpast.co.uk, or Luke Barber<br />

on 01273 405733. Please note<br />

that we require images with most<br />

contributions, preferably in high<br />

quality colour format. To submit<br />

digitally, please use MS Word<br />

(preferably 97-2003 format) for text<br />

and send images in JPEG or TIFF<br />

formats, at a minimum resolution<br />

of 600dpi. Correspondence and<br />

details of events should be sent to<br />

Wendy Muriel, Editor, <strong>Sussex</strong> Past &<br />

Present, Bull House, 92 High Street,<br />

Lewes, East <strong>Sussex</strong>, BN7 1XH, or<br />

emailed to the above address.<br />

Rates for insertions into the<br />

newsletter, which goes out to over<br />

2000 members, start at £100 (plus<br />

minimum handling charge of £20).<br />

Contact Lorna Gartside on 01273<br />

405737 for details.<br />

16<br />

<strong>Sussex</strong> Past & Present <strong>December</strong> <strong>2012</strong><br />

www.sussexpast.co.uk

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!