SEXUAL ABUSE AND EXPLOITATION OF BOYS IN SOUTH ASIA A ...

SEXUAL ABUSE AND EXPLOITATION OF BOYS IN SOUTH ASIA A ... SEXUAL ABUSE AND EXPLOITATION OF BOYS IN SOUTH ASIA A ...

unicef.irc.org
from unicef.irc.org More from this publisher
12.11.2012 Views

ut it neither defines pornography nor addresses the abuse of children in the production of child pornographic materials. The Electronic Transaction Ordinance 2005 expands the limited scope of the previous two acts by prohibiting publication of pornography on electronic media. Again, pornography is not defined, the prohibition is limited to materials that offend ‘public morality and decency’ and the impact on the child is not taken into consideration. 288 The recently proposed amendment to the Children’s Act by the Central Child Welfare Board attempts to add substance to legislation on pornography by including child sexual abusive images in its definition of sexual exploitation and abuse: …taking unnatural photos, publishing or distributing pornographic photos in electronic media…and showing pornographic material by means of deception, force, or any other influence, including fear, threat or making the child unconscious, or by giving or not giving money or other goods. 289 6.2.4 Other forms of sexual exploitation 6.2.4.1 Prostitution The strength of the laws to address sexual exploitation is limited by inadequate definition of terms. For ‘prostitution’, the Nepal Children’s Act uses the vague term ‘immoral profession’, and the Human Trafficking and Transportation (Control) Act 2007 (HTTA) has no definition for the word. The HTTA, Part 1(2e) defines ‘exploitation’ as “… an act of keeping human beings as slave and bonded and this word also implies to remove human organ except otherwise determined by existing law” 290 , thus eliminating many forms of sexual exploitation. Exploitation of children through prostitution is not expressly prohibited in Nepalese law. Instead it is addressed through laws against trafficking in human beings in the HTTA, laws regarding rape in the Country Code and general laws protecting children’s rights. Nepal’s laws do not specifically prohibit the ‘voluntary’ prostitution of adults per se. At the same time, they do not indicate that children, due to their age, cannot be considered to ‘voluntarily’ engage in prostitution. Under the section on rape in the Country Code, sexual intercourse with a girl under the age of 16 is considered rape. The 1963 Country Code did not directly address the rape of boys, although this was addressed in a subsequent amendment that penalized rape of persons above the age of 16 and removed the gender distinction. 291 However, this law does not protect children aged 16 to 18 who are commercially sexually exploited from being considered ‘voluntary’ prostitutes. The HTTA is primarily intended to address the trafficking of adult women into prostitution. The law emphases ‘trafficking’ and ‘transportation’ of victims rather than their sexual exploitation. In the HTTA, enforced prostitution is one of several disparate acts by which a 288 Electronic Transaction Ordinance 2004. 289 Central Child Welfare Board, Ministry of Women, Children and Social Welfare, Government of Nepal, 2007, unpublished draft of proposed bill to amend the Children’s Act. 290 Human Trafficking and Transportation (Control) Act 2007. 291 11 th Amendment to the Country Code of Nepal (Muluki Ain) 1963. 96

person “shall be deemed to have committed trafficking in persons”. 292 Others include selling or buying a person, causing to be engaged in prostitution, removing human organs and having sexual intercourse with a prostitute. This follows from Part 2.4 (a) (b) (c) (d) of the Act. Though the HTTA lacks a gender focus on girls as opposed to boys, it does not directly mention the prostitution of children. Engaging children in prostitution is only addressed in section 15 on punishment, which imposes a greater sentence for trafficking children. This lack of definition and clarity on the scope of child prostitution, coupled with the dependence of police and prosecutors on laws regarding trafficking and rape, allows situations of boy sexual exploitation to go unaddressed. For example, the legislation does not address restaurant employers or institutional attendants who ‘rent’ boys to clients or foreign sex abusers who provide boys with shelter, clothing and schooling in exchange for sexual services. In addition, the legislation results in the double victimization of children. As police have no clear guidelines for filing child prostitution offences, both boys and girls who are forced into prostitution are often arrested under the Some Public (Offences and Penalties) Act 1970 (‘engaging in obscene acts in a public place’). 293 Boys in particular may be arrested under the sodomy laws of the Country Code, which punishes persons for the undefined offence ‘unnatural sexual acts’. 294 6.2.4.2 Exploitation in travel and tourism No legislation in Nepal directly addresses sexual exploitation of children in travel and tourism, nor does the country have any extraterritorial agreements with other countries for the prosecution of internationals who abuse Nepalese children. 6.2.4.3 Trafficking for sexual exploitation Human trafficking is primarily addressed through the HTTA 2007, which repealed the Human Trafficking (Control) Act 1986. The HTTA supersedes but is still complemented by provisions of the Country Code, including those addressing the removal of a person under 16 from his/her lawful guardian or parents, taking a person out of the country with intention of sale and prohibition of slavery. 295 The HTTA reflects longstanding concern in Nepal with the trafficking of girls and women to India, and the relative lack of concern about sexual exploitation of children through prostitution as well as trafficking within the country. The HTTA also emphasizes punishment of the trafficker/transporter rather than the long-term exploiter, whether brothel owner or sex abuser. The penalty for the trafficker (transporter) is twice as high as for the person who receives the person for prostitution. In addition, the punishment for taking a person to another country is approximately twice that of taking a person from one place to another in Nepal. This follows from Part 4 (15) of the HTTA. Thus, punitive measures inadequately address sexual exploitation of boys through prostitution, because the mechanism of boys’ entry into 292 Human Trafficking and Transportation (Control) Act 2007. 293 Some Public (Offences and Penalties) Act 1970. 294 Country Code of Nepal (Muluki Ain) 1963. 295 Country Code of Nepal (Muluki Ain) 1963. 97

ut it neither defines pornography nor addresses the abuse of children in the production of<br />

child pornographic materials. The Electronic Transaction Ordinance 2005 expands the limited<br />

scope of the previous two acts by prohibiting publication of pornography on electronic media.<br />

Again, pornography is not defined, the prohibition is limited to materials that offend ‘public<br />

morality and decency’ and the impact on the child is not taken into consideration. 288<br />

The recently proposed amendment to the Children’s Act by the Central Child Welfare Board<br />

attempts to add substance to legislation on pornography by including child sexual abusive<br />

images in its definition of sexual exploitation and abuse:<br />

…taking unnatural photos, publishing or distributing pornographic photos in<br />

electronic media…and showing pornographic material by means of deception,<br />

force, or any other influence, including fear, threat or making the child<br />

unconscious, or by giving or not giving money or other goods. 289<br />

6.2.4 Other forms of sexual exploitation<br />

6.2.4.1 Prostitution<br />

The strength of the laws to address sexual exploitation is limited by inadequate definition of<br />

terms. For ‘prostitution’, the Nepal Children’s Act uses the vague term ‘immoral profession’,<br />

and the Human Trafficking and Transportation (Control) Act 2007 (HTTA) has no definition<br />

for the word. The HTTA, Part 1(2e) defines ‘exploitation’ as “… an act of keeping human<br />

beings as slave and bonded and this word also implies to remove human organ except<br />

otherwise determined by existing law” 290 , thus eliminating many forms of sexual exploitation.<br />

Exploitation of children through prostitution is not expressly prohibited in Nepalese law.<br />

Instead it is addressed through laws against trafficking in human beings in the HTTA, laws<br />

regarding rape in the Country Code and general laws protecting children’s rights. Nepal’s<br />

laws do not specifically prohibit the ‘voluntary’ prostitution of adults per se. At the same<br />

time, they do not indicate that children, due to their age, cannot be considered to ‘voluntarily’<br />

engage in prostitution. Under the section on rape in the Country Code, sexual intercourse with<br />

a girl under the age of 16 is considered rape. The 1963 Country Code did not directly address<br />

the rape of boys, although this was addressed in a subsequent amendment that penalized rape<br />

of persons above the age of 16 and removed the gender distinction. 291 However, this law does<br />

not protect children aged 16 to 18 who are commercially sexually exploited from being<br />

considered ‘voluntary’ prostitutes.<br />

The HTTA is primarily intended to address the trafficking of adult women into prostitution.<br />

The law emphases ‘trafficking’ and ‘transportation’ of victims rather than their sexual<br />

exploitation. In the HTTA, enforced prostitution is one of several disparate acts by which a<br />

288 Electronic Transaction Ordinance 2004.<br />

289 Central Child Welfare Board, Ministry of Women, Children and Social Welfare, Government of Nepal, 2007,<br />

unpublished draft of proposed bill to amend the Children’s Act.<br />

290 Human Trafficking and Transportation (Control) Act 2007.<br />

291 11 th Amendment to the Country Code of Nepal (Muluki Ain) 1963.<br />

96

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!