RESEARCH METHOD COHEN ok

RESEARCH METHOD COHEN ok RESEARCH METHOD COHEN ok

12.01.2015 Views

MEASURING ASSOCIATION 533 Box 24.26 APearsonproduct-momentcorrelation The attention given to teaching and learning at the school How well students apply themselves to learning Discussion and review by educators of the quality of teaching, learning and classroom practice Pearson correlation Sig. (2-tailed) N Pearson correlation Sig. (2-tailed) N Pearson correlation Sig. (2-tailed) N Discussion and review by educators The attention How well of the quality given to students of teaching, teaching and apply learning and learning at the themselves classroom school to learning practice 1.000 · 1000 0.060 0.058 1000 0.066* 0.036 1000 0.060 0.058 1000 1.000 · 1000 0.585** 0.000 1000 0.066* 0.036 1000 0.585** 0.000 1000 1.000 · 1000 Chapter 24 *Correlationissignificantatthe0.05level(2-tailed). ** Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed). Curvilinearity The correlations discussed so far have assumed linearity, that is, the more we have of one property, the more (or less) we have of another property, in a direct positive or negative relationship. A straight line can be drawn through the points on the scatterplots (a regression line). However, linearity cannot always be assumed. Consider the case, for example, of stress: a little stress might enhance performance (‘setting the adrenalin running’) positively, whereas too much stress might lead to a downturn in performance. Where stress enhances performance there is a positive correlation, but when stress debilitates performance there is a negative correlation. The result is not a straight line of correlation (indicating linearity) but a curved line (indicating curvilinearity). This can be shown graphically (Box 24.27). It is assumed here, for the purposes of the example, that muscular strength can be measured on a single scale. It is clear from the graph that muscular strength increases from birth until fifty years, and thereafter it declines as muscles degenerate. There is a positive correlation between age and muscular Box 24.27 Alinediagramtoindicatecurvilinearity Muscular strength 50 40 30 20 10 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 Age strength on the left-hand side of the graph and anegativecorrelationontheright-handsideof the graph, i.e. a curvilinear correlation can be observed. Hopkins et al. (1996: 92) provide another example of curvilinearity: room temperature and comfort. Raising the temperature a little can make for greater comfort – a positive correlation – while raising it too greatly can make for discomfort – a negative correlation. Many correlational statistics

534 QUANTITATIVE DATA ANALYSIS assume linearity (e.g. the Pearson productmoment correlation). However, rather than using correlational statistics arbitrarily or blindly, the researcher will need to consider whether, in fact, linearity is a reasonable assumption to make, or whether a curvilinear relationship is more appropriate (in which case more sophisticated statistics will be needed, e.g. η (‘eta’) (Cohen and Holliday 1996: 84; Glass and Hopkins 1996, section 8.7; Fowler et al. 2000: 81–89) or mathematical procedures will need to be applied to transform non-linear relations into linear relations. Examples of curvilinear relationships might include: pressure from the principal and teacher performance pressure from the teacher and student achievement degree of challenge and student achievement assertiveness and success age and muscular strength age and physical control age and concentration age and sociability age and cognitive abilities. Hopkins et al. (1996)suggestthatthevariable ‘age’ frequently has a curvilinear relationship with other variables, and also point out that poorly constructed tests can give the appearance of curvilinearity if the test is too easy (a ‘ceiling effect’ where most students score highly) or if it is too difficult, but that this curvilinearity is, in fact, spurious, as the test does not demonstrate sufficient item difficulty or discriminability (Hopkins et al. 1996: 92). In planning correlational research, then, attention will need to be given to whether linearity or curvilinearity is to be assumed. Coefficients of correlation The coefficient of correlation, then, tells us something about the relations between two variables. Other measures exist, however, which allow us to specify relationships when more than two variables are involved. These are known as measures of ‘multiple correlation’ and ‘partial correlation’. Multiple correlation measures indicate the degree of association between three or more variables simultaneously. We may want to know, for example, the degree of association between delinquency, social class background and leisure facilities. Or we may be interested in finding out the relationship between academic achievement, intelligence and neuroticism. Multiple correlation, or ‘regression’ as it is sometimes called, indicates the degree of association between n variables. It is related not only to the correlations of the independent variable with the dependent variables, but also to the intercorrelations between the dependent variables. Partial correlation aims at establishing the degree of association between two variables after the influence of a third has been controlled or partialled out. Guilford and Fruchter (1973) define apartialcorrelationbetweentwovariablesasone which nullifies the effects of a third variable (or a number of variables) on the variables being correlated. They give the example of correlation between the height and weight of boys in a group whose age varies, where the correlation would be higher than the correlation between height and weight in a group comprised of boys of only the same age. Here the reason is clear – because some boys will be older they will be heavier and taller. Age, therefore, is a factor that increases the correlation between height and weight. Of course, even with age held constant, the correlation would still be positive and significant because, regardless of age, taller boys often tend to be heavier. Consider, too, the relationship between success in basketball and previous experience in the game. Suppose, also, that the presence of a third factor, the height of the players, was known to have an important influence on the other two factors. The use of partial correlation techniques would enable a measure of the two primary variables to be achieved, freed from the influence of the secondary variable. Correlational analysis is simple and involves collecting two or more scores on the same group of subjects and computing correlation coefficients.

MEASURING ASSOCIATION 533<br />

Box 24.26<br />

APearsonproduct-momentcorrelation<br />

The attention given to teaching and<br />

learning at the school<br />

How well students apply themselves<br />

to learning<br />

Discussion and review by educators<br />

of the quality of teaching, learning and<br />

classroom practice<br />

Pearson correlation<br />

Sig. (2-tailed)<br />

N<br />

Pearson correlation<br />

Sig. (2-tailed)<br />

N<br />

Pearson correlation<br />

Sig. (2-tailed)<br />

N<br />

Discussion<br />

and review<br />

by educators<br />

The attention How well of the quality<br />

given to students of teaching,<br />

teaching and apply learning and<br />

learning at the themselves classroom<br />

school to learning practice<br />

1.000<br />

·<br />

1000<br />

0.060<br />

0.058<br />

1000<br />

0.066*<br />

0.036<br />

1000<br />

0.060<br />

0.058<br />

1000<br />

1.000<br />

·<br />

1000<br />

0.585**<br />

0.000<br />

1000<br />

0.066*<br />

0.036<br />

1000<br />

0.585**<br />

0.000<br />

1000<br />

1.000<br />

·<br />

1000<br />

Chapter 24<br />

*Correlationissignificantatthe0.05level(2-tailed).<br />

** Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).<br />

Curvilinearity<br />

The correlations discussed so far have assumed<br />

linearity, that is, the more we have of one property,<br />

the more (or less) we have of another property, in a<br />

direct positive or negative relationship. A straight<br />

line can be drawn through the points on the<br />

scatterplots (a regression line). However, linearity<br />

cannot always be assumed. Consider the case, for<br />

example, of stress: a little stress might enhance<br />

performance (‘setting the adrenalin running’)<br />

positively, whereas too much stress might lead to a<br />

downturn in performance. Where stress enhances<br />

performance there is a positive correlation, but<br />

when stress debilitates performance there is a<br />

negative correlation. The result is not a straight<br />

line of correlation (indicating linearity) but a<br />

curved line (indicating curvilinearity). This can be<br />

shown graphically (Box 24.27). It is assumed here,<br />

for the purposes of the example, that muscular<br />

strength can be measured on a single scale. It<br />

is clear from the graph that muscular strength<br />

increases from birth until fifty years, and thereafter<br />

it declines as muscles degenerate. There is a<br />

positive correlation between age and muscular<br />

Box 24.27<br />

Alinediagramtoindicatecurvilinearity<br />

Muscular strength<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90<br />

Age<br />

strength on the left-hand side of the graph and<br />

anegativecorrelationontheright-handsideof<br />

the graph, i.e. a curvilinear correlation can be<br />

observed.<br />

Hopkins et al. (1996: 92) provide another<br />

example of curvilinearity: room temperature and<br />

comfort. Raising the temperature a little can make<br />

for greater comfort – a positive correlation – while<br />

raising it too greatly can make for discomfort – a<br />

negative correlation. Many correlational statistics

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!