10.11.2012 Views

NSS Bulletin Autumn 09 - National Secular Society

NSS Bulletin Autumn 09 - National Secular Society

NSS Bulletin Autumn 09 - National Secular Society

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

challenging religious privilege<br />

<strong>Bulletin</strong><br />

<strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong><br />

Issue 43 www.secularism.org.uk<br />

Thought for<br />

the Day: is a<br />

breakthrough<br />

imminent? continues<br />

Ritual Slaughter:<br />

a victory that<br />

looked impossible<br />

Animal welfare regulations require<br />

animals to be stunned before<br />

slaughter – the one exemption<br />

being for the production of kosher<br />

and halal meat. Meat produced in<br />

this way – with the animal’s throat<br />

cut while it is conscious – is<br />

increasingly the only meat sold in a<br />

number of retail and catering<br />

outlets or provided in some<br />

schools, for example. So, many of<br />

us are unknowingly eating meat – or<br />

food derived from it – that has been<br />

slaughtered without pre-stunning.<br />

continues on page 6, col 3 3<br />

President Barroso<br />

shares a joke with<br />

Keith. See the full<br />

story of our<br />

Brussels meeting<br />

on page 4.<br />

New hopes for an end to the<br />

discrimination inherent in Thought for<br />

the Day were raised when the BBC<br />

Trust accepted a complaint from the<br />

<strong>NSS</strong> (as well as complaints from a<br />

small number of individuals) calling<br />

for the programme to be opened up<br />

to non-religious voices.<br />

The BBC Trust is the Corporation’s<br />

governing body and “operationally<br />

independent of BBC management”,<br />

continues on page 3, col 3 3<br />

The <strong>Society</strong> has been providing top<br />

level assistance, briefings and<br />

lobbying to various Government<br />

departments. Keith Porteous Wood<br />

along with Ministers, senior MPs<br />

and senior civil servants was<br />

invited to a reception launching the<br />

Equality Bill. He took the<br />

opportunity to lobby them and this<br />

led to further invitations to put our<br />

views to them later both in writing<br />

and in person.<br />

Keith and <strong>NSS</strong> vice President<br />

Carla Revere have been involved in<br />

a number of intensive briefing<br />

sessions, for example with<br />

Equalities Minister Michael Foster<br />

Subscribe to Newsline, the weekly e-newsletter from the<br />

<strong>NSS</strong> at www.secularism.org.uk You can also follow us on:<br />

Hopes are raised for<br />

Swanage community<br />

school provision<br />

Dorset County Council has gone<br />

back to the drawing board after<br />

plans to close the only remaining<br />

community school within fifteen<br />

miles met with overwhelming<br />

opposition. As we reported in the<br />

previous <strong>Bulletin</strong>, when Swanage<br />

First School was earmarked for<br />

closure the <strong>NSS</strong> swung into action<br />

and put Dorset County Council under<br />

considerable pressure over their<br />

proposal. The <strong>NSS</strong> offered support<br />

to local residents who objected to<br />

the plans and instructed our lawyers<br />

to issue the Council with a formal<br />

letter detailing the legal problems<br />

on page 2, col 3 3<br />

Equality Bill: Putting the<br />

Government under pressure<br />

and with Dr Evan Harris MP. Carla<br />

and Keith have spent a great deal<br />

of time helping Evan over recent<br />

months with research, information<br />

and suggested amendments for the<br />

Bill. He also attended the Equality<br />

Bill Committee in the Commons to<br />

be on hand to assist Evan. We are<br />

grateful for the support of two<br />

members of the Labour <strong>National</strong><br />

Executive who are Honorary<br />

Associates (pictured overleaf).<br />

Much of our work has been<br />

focused on reducing the<br />

discrimination against teachers in<br />

religious schools who are not of the<br />

school’s faith. Carla Revere, who is<br />

continues on page 2, col 1 3


7 “Equality Bill” continued<br />

a barrister, has played a major role<br />

in uncovering what we believe to be<br />

the Government’s untenable<br />

position in allowing the<br />

discrimination to continue.<br />

We have demonstrably held the<br />

Government to account. Michael<br />

Foster described our round table<br />

meeting as “very productive” and<br />

the detailed answer to the many<br />

points we raised ran to seven<br />

pages. Evan has been generous in<br />

his thanks for our research going to<br />

the heart of some difficult and<br />

rarely-explored but crucial areas.<br />

Some of these have formed the<br />

basis for some of his probing<br />

Vice President Anna Behan and<br />

Keith Porteous Wood met senior<br />

staff at the Department for<br />

Communities and Local Government<br />

(DCLG), which includes the<br />

Government Equalities Office. We<br />

raised concerns about the Equality<br />

Bill, but most of the discussion was<br />

about a euphemistically titled<br />

“Charter of Excellence”, a voluntary<br />

code intended to apply to religious<br />

organisations bidding for “Faith<br />

Based” Welfare (FBW).<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> opposed this Charter<br />

because we believe prohibition of<br />

discrimination should be mandatory<br />

rather than voluntary. The Charter<br />

was far too weak and, not being<br />

policed, would therefore give faith<br />

groups unjustified preference in<br />

tendering to run services. It would<br />

2<br />

amendments. Keith watched a<br />

Government Minister almost<br />

physically squirming under Evan’s<br />

relentless cross examination on<br />

this Bill. We admire him for so often<br />

being the MP who puts Government<br />

Ministers under the most scrutiny.<br />

However, as the Government<br />

heads towards the General Election,<br />

it is less willing to take on the<br />

churches, minority religions and the<br />

increasingly powerful right-wing<br />

media. The <strong>Society</strong>’s work on the<br />

Bill is therefore evolving into a<br />

damage-limitation exercise where<br />

we are doing our level best to head<br />

off the worst excesses.<br />

Clockwise from top left:<br />

Michael Foster MP, Carla<br />

Revere, Dr Evan Harris MP,<br />

Michael Cashman MEP,<br />

Angela Eagle MP<br />

Faith based welfare:<br />

Government drops Charter<br />

not even have required an<br />

undertaking from bidders for public<br />

money not to discriminate in<br />

employment against those of the<br />

" wrong" faith or none, something<br />

that in any case should be made<br />

unlawful.<br />

We are pleased to say that the<br />

Government has dropped the<br />

Charter. We hope it was as a result<br />

of our protestations, rather than<br />

because the religious were not even<br />

prepared to accept a voluntary code.<br />

Both Labour and Conservatives<br />

support the increase and spread of<br />

FBW, so we are moving from<br />

opposition in principle to damage<br />

limitation here too. So, while we<br />

continue to raise serious concerns<br />

at every opportunity, the emphasis<br />

has shifted to the mechanisms.<br />

7 “Swanage” continued<br />

they risked by failing to provide a<br />

community school. One would be a<br />

legal challenge under the Human<br />

Rights Act for contravening parents’<br />

rights to educate their children in<br />

Swanage First School<br />

line with their beliefs. Sources tell<br />

us that they are taking our letter<br />

seriously.<br />

Under the original plans, Swanage<br />

First and St Mark’s CofE First<br />

Schools would have been closed<br />

and replaced with a new primary<br />

which would “respect the faith<br />

tradition” of St Mark’s. Parents<br />

would then be left with no<br />

alternative to a religious school.<br />

The Council will now launch a new<br />

public consultation in early 2010<br />

and the <strong>NSS</strong> will be closely<br />

monitoring the situation and doing<br />

all we can to ensure that there will<br />

be a community school in the area<br />

in future. The wording of the<br />

document announcing the<br />

consultation also suggests that<br />

Dorset has taken on board these<br />

concerns.<br />

We suspect that a, perhaps<br />

secondary, reason for the<br />

consultation is to distance Dorset<br />

from a decision to retain a<br />

community school so as not to<br />

antagonise the local Anglican<br />

diocese, which we suspect to have<br />

played a key role in the original<br />

proposals.<br />

Submissions<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> works away behind the<br />

scenes, submitting consultation<br />

documents to Government and<br />

other agencies. Recently, we<br />

have written an RE guidance<br />

submission and also raised the<br />

issue in the TES. We contributed<br />

to the UK consultation on the<br />

European Commission Proposal<br />

for Equal Treatment Directive<br />

(Discrimination in provision of<br />

goods and services) and to the<br />

Broadcast Advertising Standards<br />

Code on condom and abortion<br />

advice centre advertising.<br />

<strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong>


Scotland<br />

There has been a fierce tussle<br />

fought out in the pages of the<br />

Herald (published in Glasgow)<br />

between the <strong>NSS</strong> and a Scottish<br />

cleric David Keddie over Religious<br />

Observance in Scottish schools.<br />

He claimed new Scottish<br />

guidelines marked a radical<br />

departure from the traditional<br />

Christian-based assemblies that<br />

used to be held in schools in favour<br />

of a much more inclusive, nonspecifically<br />

faith-based school and<br />

pupil-centred approach to the<br />

development of “spiritual<br />

development”. We countered with<br />

quotes from the guidelines showing<br />

they were far from being as<br />

enlightened or pluralistic as Dr<br />

Keddie would have the readers<br />

believe. We pointed out the<br />

guidelines went out of their way not<br />

to forbid or even criticise worship in<br />

the formal curriculum, and even<br />

gave examples of where – not just<br />

in RC schools – confessional (i.e.<br />

proselytising) teaching was<br />

“appropriate”.<br />

We opined that “there are plenty<br />

of pupils not of the faith of the<br />

school or the “faith community”,<br />

even if their parents are. It is no<br />

longer legitimate for publicly-funded<br />

schools to force-feed captive pupils<br />

with confessional religion – if this<br />

happens at all it should be for the<br />

home and place of worship.”<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> also took on Scottish<br />

justice secretary Kenny MacAskill in<br />

the Herald and the Scotsman for his<br />

references to a ‘higher power’ giving<br />

the supposed Libyan/PanAm<br />

Camp for enquiring minds<br />

Camp Quest, the first UK summer camp aimed mainly<br />

at children from non-believing families, received an<br />

astonishingly hostile press when it was launched this<br />

year, e.g. “Dawkins sets up kids’ camp to groom<br />

atheists” as front page news. Yet <strong>NSS</strong> Honorary<br />

Associate Richard Dawkins had only made a modest<br />

contribution, and played no part in the management of<br />

the camp.<br />

Terry Sanderson and Keith Porteous Wood spent a<br />

couple of days putting the record straight on both TV<br />

and radio. They pointed to the double standard: one<br />

small camp encouraging children to think for<br />

themselves made repeated national headlines, while<br />

the hundreds or thousands of larger Christian camps<br />

where children are told what to think and believe pass<br />

unremarked.<br />

More information at www.camp-quest.org.uk<br />

bomber Megrahi terminal cancer. We<br />

were also quoted in Scotland on<br />

Sunday following the news that the<br />

SNP candidate for the forthcoming<br />

Glasgow North-East by-election is a<br />

member of Opus Dei.<br />

We are delighted that Iain Banks,<br />

identified as an <strong>NSS</strong> Honorary<br />

Associate, has spoken out in The<br />

Sunday Times against faith schools<br />

in Scotland, emphasising the<br />

sectarianism aspect.<br />

Iain Banks<br />

Wales<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> bitterly attacked the<br />

Archbishop of Wales for opposing<br />

proposals that older pupils in Wales<br />

should not be allowed to opt out of<br />

Collective Worship at school. Our<br />

7 “Thought for the Day” continued<br />

which is cause for hope.<br />

Its complaints procedure can be<br />

accessed only after all the internal<br />

avenues within the BBC have been<br />

exhausted. So, the <strong>NSS</strong>’s complaint<br />

first had to pass through the usual<br />

brush-off stages of the BBC’s normal<br />

complaints procedure and has now<br />

been accepted for adjudication by<br />

the Trust sometime in the autumn.<br />

Only around seventy complaints a<br />

year make it this far.<br />

Our complaint runs to twelve<br />

pages of detailed argument, and<br />

notes that the <strong>NSS</strong>'s first complaint<br />

was in 1962.<br />

The news that the BBC Trust was<br />

considering the change made<br />

headlines around the world, and the<br />

<strong>NSS</strong> figured prominently in the<br />

stories.<br />

comments were picked up by the<br />

Church of England Newspaper. The<br />

proposals are prompted by the<br />

equivalent change made in England<br />

directly as a result of the <strong>NSS</strong>’s<br />

efforts.<br />

DONATIONS<br />

The Council expresses its profuse thanks to all members who have<br />

made donations over the summer, particularly one of £1,000. The <strong>NSS</strong><br />

would also like to thank the growing number of members taking out<br />

standing orders as these help us to plan ahead with our campaigns<br />

and running costs.<br />

If you would like to make a donation, start a standing order or<br />

remember the <strong>NSS</strong> in your will to support our work in decades to<br />

come, please click the Donate button on the website or contact the<br />

office for details. We don’t receive any other funding, so your support<br />

is both sorely needed and greatly valued.<br />

Students group appoints<br />

new president<br />

We congratulate Jenna Catley on her<br />

appointment as president of The <strong>National</strong><br />

Federation of Atheist, Humanist and<br />

Jenna<br />

Catley<br />

<strong>Secular</strong> Student Societies. The task of this group is an<br />

important one: it is essential that students are offered<br />

an alternative to the increasingly aggressive tactics of<br />

religious groups on campus. The more secularist<br />

groups that can be encouraged to form or expand, the<br />

better. The <strong>NSS</strong> does all it can to encourage the AHS.<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> has a growing number of student members,<br />

some of whom have gone on to set up groups<br />

themselves.<br />

Any students who wish to volunteer – even if they<br />

cannot afford to join – are invited to contact Tessa<br />

Kendall at admin@secularism.org.uk<br />

<strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong> 3


<strong>NSS</strong> at top table in Europe<br />

(see photo on front page)<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> was among several nonreligious<br />

organisations from around<br />

Europe invited to a formal lunch with<br />

Jose Manuel Barroso, the President<br />

of the European Commission at its<br />

Brussels HQ in June.<br />

Keith Porteous Wood raised the<br />

topic of sharia law and asked that<br />

the Commission do more to protect<br />

Human Rights from the onslaught of<br />

religious demands.<br />

He cautioned against taking for<br />

granted Human Rights advances that<br />

had been made; they need to be<br />

defended from attack. He pointed to<br />

the UN Human Rights Council where<br />

even the Universal Declaration is<br />

being undermined by rival and less<br />

demanding Islamic versions.<br />

Examples are the Cairo Declaration<br />

on “Human Rights” in Islam in which<br />

Sharia is mentioned around a dozen<br />

times and the Arab Charter on<br />

Human Rights.<br />

Other attendees at the lunch were<br />

astonished when he informed them<br />

In June, the General Assembly<br />

(AGM) of the International Humanist<br />

and Ethical Union was held in<br />

Conway Hall, London. Keith’s<br />

reappointment as an international<br />

representative for IHEU was ratified.<br />

This status is helpful, for example, in<br />

matters associated with the United<br />

Nations Human Rights Council.<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> hosted and co-chaired a<br />

meeting of the International Liaison<br />

Committee of Atheists and<br />

Freethinkers (ILCAF). This was<br />

followed by an <strong>NSS</strong> reception for<br />

delegates with IHEU’s president,<br />

Sonja Eggerickx, as guest of honour.<br />

Anna Behan<br />

that only Sharia ‘scholars’ are<br />

permitted to discuss Sharia at the<br />

UN Council on Human Rights.<br />

There was surprise and concern<br />

at his description of the rise of the<br />

influence of Sharia law in the UK,<br />

where Sharia tribunals, claiming to<br />

be “official”, are spreading their<br />

influence and activities. Keith had<br />

directed a senior EU Justice<br />

Directorate lawyer to one such site<br />

and even she thought it was an<br />

official one, she later admitted.<br />

Those most at risk are women,<br />

whose evidence is deemed to be<br />

worth only half that of a man’s.<br />

Keith called for every EU citizen to<br />

be subject only to democraticallydetermined<br />

and Human Rights<br />

compliant laws. He urged Member<br />

States to carefully consider the<br />

example set by Canadian provinces<br />

in outlawing religious arbitration of<br />

all kinds.<br />

There were nods of agreement<br />

when Keith asserted that the Pope<br />

The reception was also attended by<br />

members of the <strong>NSS</strong> and of our<br />

sister French organisation Libre<br />

Pensée. The evening concluded with<br />

a much-appreciated performance of<br />

Terry Sanderson’s show about the<br />

war-time heroism of Marlene<br />

Dietrich, “the world’s most<br />

glamorous atheist”. We were<br />

pleased to reciprocate the hospitality<br />

we receive when attending functions<br />

at kindred organisations abroad.<br />

The final event was an IHEU<br />

conference on Untouchability. This is<br />

largely a product of the Hindu caste<br />

system, but it is little-known that its<br />

was stepping up the Vatican’s<br />

institutional homophobia; not only by<br />

discriminating against priests for<br />

homosexual activity, but for their<br />

very orientation. He branded as<br />

deplorable the Vatican’s attempted<br />

interference in legislation to give gay<br />

people equal rights around Europe.<br />

He sat down amid laughter after<br />

joking that this was ironic – given the<br />

Catholic Church’s attitudes towards<br />

homosexuals — that they should<br />

employ such a high proportion of gay<br />

men in its priesthood.<br />

Reassuringly, President Barroso<br />

later responded constructively,<br />

picking up some of the <strong>NSS</strong>’s<br />

points, particularly the question of<br />

Sharia law, about which we are now<br />

engaged in talks with European<br />

Commission officials.<br />

<strong>NSS</strong> staff member Stephen Evans<br />

presented President Barroso with a<br />

copy of the Civitas book, One Law<br />

for All which echoes our concerns<br />

about Sharia law.<br />

International conferences at London’s Conway Hall<br />

influence pervades even some parts<br />

of the UK where a high proportion of<br />

the population are from Hindu<br />

backgrounds. We were delighted that<br />

Honorary Associate Lord Desai<br />

(himself from a Hindu background)<br />

and Lord Avebury both spoke. The<br />

<strong>NSS</strong> was on the panel for the closing<br />

session and has worked with Lord<br />

Avebury on an amendment to the<br />

Equality Bill to cover caste<br />

discrimination that has been taken<br />

up by the LibDems. <strong>NSS</strong> Honorary<br />

Associate Dr Evan Harris MP also<br />

proposed an amendment on similar<br />

lines in the Commons.<br />

Anna at disestablishment book launch<br />

Following our high level work with University College’s Constitutional Unit, the<br />

generally acknowledged leading authority on such matters, Anna Behan was<br />

invited to the launch of a new book about disestablishment: Church and State in<br />

21st Century Britain: the Future of Church Establishment. As an independent<br />

observer noted: “She also asked a very shrewd question viz.: ‘Upon what<br />

principled basis did the CofE seek to continue in its present status?’ There was<br />

no answer.<br />

4 <strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong>


Council of Europe and religion<br />

The Council of Europe held a<br />

conference at its HQ in Strasbourg<br />

in June on Religious Education and<br />

the role it is alleged to play in<br />

improving intercultural relations.<br />

(The conference is the second in<br />

an annual series initiated at a<br />

summit on The Religious Aspect of<br />

Intercultural Dialogue in San<br />

Marino in 2007 where Keith<br />

Porteous Wood and Terry<br />

Sanderson played an active<br />

damage-limitation role).<br />

Keith attended as an<br />

international representative of the<br />

International Humanist and Ethical<br />

Union (to which the <strong>NSS</strong> is<br />

affiliated). Keith found himself in<br />

conflict with the representatives of<br />

the Roman Catholic and Russian<br />

Orthodox churches.<br />

He acknowledged the need for<br />

minimising friction between those<br />

of different religious and cultural<br />

backgrounds. The majority of<br />

participants were representing<br />

religious traditions however, and<br />

thought that inter-faith conflict and<br />

suspicion could be reduced if<br />

students were to learn about each<br />

others’ religions in depth.<br />

Keith, clearly in a minority,<br />

rejected this saying that while<br />

students should be acquainted with<br />

the basic tenets of the major<br />

religions, the way to reduce tension<br />

is not to dwell on differences.<br />

Instead, we should be<br />

EU Ambassador to the Council of Europe (Mme Pavan-<br />

Woolfe) and Advisor to the European Commission<br />

President, Jose Manuel Barroso (Georg Cesar das Neves)<br />

with Keith at the Council of Europe in Strasbourg<br />

concentrating on what unites us<br />

rather than what divides us. He<br />

suggested sport, with all cultures<br />

playing together in the same team.<br />

Music would be another example.<br />

The religious delegates were<br />

keen to refer to what they<br />

described as “religious facts” that<br />

students were supposed to learn.<br />

He objected to this and to<br />

everyone being required to<br />

“respect” everyone else’s beliefs.<br />

Everyone should of course have<br />

the freedom to believe what they<br />

wish, providing they are not<br />

harming others. But freedom of<br />

speech entails being able to<br />

criticise elements of doctrine,<br />

especially those that are inhumane<br />

or discriminatory.<br />

Even less popular was our<br />

protest that there should not be<br />

proselytising or confessional<br />

teaching of religion in schools,<br />

especially state-funded ones.<br />

However little headway we<br />

made, it is important that the voice<br />

of dissent was clearly heard, even<br />

though the conference has no<br />

executive power. Keith picked up<br />

signals of support from some<br />

participants, but more importantly,<br />

Council members, diplomats and<br />

Council staff.<br />

Parliamentary prayers: abolish or modernise?<br />

Shortly after John Bercow was appointed Speaker of the House of Commons, on<br />

a modernising ticket, we wrote to him to suggest the Commons should abandon<br />

prayers. We explained why they were inappropriate and suggested that, if the<br />

Commons just could not bring itself to remove them completely, a period of<br />

silent reflection might be more appropriate. The worst of all options, we argued,<br />

would be some sort of multi-faith prayers option.<br />

Speaker John Bercow<br />

<strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong> 5


From pub to Pakistan…Council activity<br />

Dan Bye spoke to Leeds Skeptics in the Pub on<br />

How to annoy a skeptic.<br />

Elizabeth O’Casey attended a WAFE (International<br />

Federation of Women Against Fundamentalism and<br />

for Equality) meeting in the House of Lords, on the<br />

limits of tolerance. She also went to a lecture and<br />

discussion on Sharia law and arbitration in<br />

religious contexts at the Institute of Advanced<br />

Legal Studies. In both meetings she raised issues<br />

regarding the treatment and subjugation of women<br />

by Islam and the consistent denial of women's<br />

agency through Islamic legal, traditional, and<br />

sartorial practices. Elizabeth also attended a<br />

Liberty conference and spoke from the floor about international legislation<br />

on the defamation of religion. She is involved in both the student campaign<br />

and the campaign against religious slaughter.<br />

Peter Vlachos spread the secular message during a week-long lecture trip<br />

to a progressive university in Pakistan.<br />

Dan Bye<br />

<strong>Secular</strong> Medical Forum<br />

In June, the <strong>Secular</strong> Medical Forum<br />

represented the <strong>NSS</strong> at the General Medical<br />

Council consultative conference on End of<br />

Life Treatment and Care. The SMF broadly<br />

welcomed the proposed new guidelines and<br />

continues to push for a further shift of<br />

emphasis towards increasing patient<br />

autonomy up to and including the end of life.<br />

There is stiff opposition to this from religious organisations. The SMF<br />

welcomed distinguished scientist, author and TV presenter Simon Singh to<br />

their reception at the BMA annual representatives’ meeting in Liverpool. In<br />

response to the Advertising Standards consultation on broadcasting<br />

standards, the SMF expressed concern that anti-choice organisations delay<br />

women’s access to abortion while rarely being transparent about their true<br />

agenda.<br />

At the end of June, doctors voted down an evangelical Christian motion<br />

at the BMA conference that would have given carte blanche for religious<br />

medical practitioners to “share their faith” with patients without any risk of<br />

suspension. This was prompted by the Nurse Petrie case in which the <strong>NSS</strong>,<br />

almost alone, supported her employers. Terry Sanderson’s support of the<br />

BMA’s decision was reported widely.<br />

However, the BMA conference did pass some minor “faith creep”<br />

motions.<br />

For further information or speaker requests please visit the website<br />

www.secularmedicalforum.org.uk or contact Dr Antony Lempert by email<br />

antony@secularmedicalforum.org.uk or telephone the <strong>NSS</strong> on 020 7404 3126<br />

The LSS continues to expand its membership<br />

to promote law and policy making based on<br />

principles of equal rights and respect for all. It<br />

helps individuals and organisations by<br />

providing legal advice and assistance on<br />

issues of discrimination and human rights law<br />

relating to religious privilege.<br />

6<br />

Elizabeth O’Casey<br />

Lawyers’ <strong>Secular</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />

7 “Ritual Slaughter” continued<br />

The LSS is regularly contacted by journalists<br />

who it is happy to assist.<br />

Membership of the LSS is open to all<br />

lawyers, practising and non-practising, and to<br />

law students. Information on membership and<br />

research resources can be found on the<br />

website www.lawyerssecularsociety.org<br />

The focus of our latest campaign<br />

was quickly diverted from the UK to<br />

Brussels when we learned of<br />

attempts being made in the<br />

European Parliament to remove the<br />

Member States’ option not to insist<br />

on pre-stunning, even for religious<br />

slaughter. Most EU countries did<br />

give exemptions, but the new rules<br />

would make religious exemption<br />

mandatory in all Member States.<br />

We lobbied our MEPs and senior<br />

politicians in the UK prior to the<br />

first vote, at the Agriculture<br />

Committee, and again at the vote<br />

in the European Parliament. We<br />

organised a petition of MPs to write<br />

to the Rt Hon Hilary Benn, the<br />

DEFRA minister, and were assisted<br />

by a former DEFRA minister who<br />

was supportive.<br />

The only voting bloc opposing the<br />

mandatory religious exemption was<br />

ALDE, the European LibDems, to<br />

which our Honorary Associate<br />

Sophie in ’t Veld MEP is affiliated.<br />

We were grateful for their support.<br />

It is not a large bloc, however, and<br />

we were not successful in turning<br />

the tide – at that stage. Well<br />

placed Jewish organisations have<br />

clearly been planning this ambush<br />

for a long time and were<br />

particularly active. Any argument<br />

presented as the preservation of<br />

religious liberty trumps all,<br />

regardless of the cruelty<br />

implications.<br />

The Parliament’s votes are<br />

subject to ratification by the Council<br />

of Ministers. This comprises the<br />

Ministerial representatives of<br />

Member States, and we had lobbied<br />

the relevant UK Minister.<br />

We were therefore delighted<br />

when the final text agreed by the<br />

Council of Ministers ignored the<br />

Parliament’s stance and retained<br />

Member States’ rights to decide<br />

whether or not to grant these<br />

exemptions.<br />

<strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong>


MEDIA<br />

There was no let-up for the <strong>NSS</strong><br />

during the summer months as we<br />

kept up our high profile in media.<br />

Religion in schools was a recurring<br />

theme. We spoke out in the<br />

Telegraph and on the Press<br />

Association newswires against<br />

indoctrination in response to<br />

Archbishop Vincent Nichols’ call for<br />

more religion in schools and we<br />

criticised new RE guidance and<br />

‘forced worship’ in religious<br />

assemblies in the Times<br />

Educational Supplement.<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> was also extensively<br />

quoted in the TES when Dorset<br />

County Council withdrew their plans<br />

to leave Swanage without a<br />

community school. <strong>NSS</strong> Executive<br />

Director, Keith Porteous Wood, also<br />

spoke out against faith-based<br />

education in the Independent’s<br />

article about Britain’s first Hindu<br />

faith school. Our comments were<br />

picked up by Asian News<br />

International and were carried<br />

across various worldwide media<br />

outlets.<br />

When the media went into a<br />

frenzy over Camp Quest, the <strong>NSS</strong><br />

Above: Times Educational<br />

Supplement, 7/8/<strong>09</strong><br />

was first on the scene, defending<br />

the secular summer camp across<br />

national and local BBC radio and<br />

television.<br />

Our debaptism certificate<br />

continues to provoke a response. It<br />

was the feature of a USA Today<br />

article where Stephen Evans was<br />

quoted. USA Today is the world’s<br />

second largest English speaking<br />

circulation newspaper and the story<br />

was inevitably picked up by various<br />

American media.<br />

Still across the pond, Keith<br />

Porteous Wood made an<br />

appearance on the popular Penn &<br />

Teller show. The episode in question<br />

offered robust, and often humorous,<br />

Keith Porteous Wood on<br />

the Penn & Teller show<br />

Above: Evening<br />

Standard, 16/7/<strong>09</strong><br />

criticism of the Vatican. The show<br />

was subsequently pulled from the<br />

CBS owned Showtime website<br />

following a furious attack from<br />

conservative Catholics.<br />

<strong>NSS</strong> President Terry Sanderson<br />

was widely quoted throughout<br />

national, local and electronic media<br />

on a range of subjects such as<br />

Thought for the Day in the Telegraph<br />

to the Press Association’s coverage<br />

of so called “gay cure” therapies.<br />

Terry was also widely quoted when a<br />

Christian motion at the BMA<br />

conference sought to allow doctors<br />

to pray for patients. Anthony<br />

Lempert from the <strong>Secular</strong> Medical<br />

Forum and Stephen Evans also<br />

weighed in on Radio 5 Live.<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> also featured in an indepth<br />

Mail on Sunday investigation<br />

into sharia law in Britain. The only<br />

mention in the three page article of<br />

any constructive response was<br />

about the <strong>NSS</strong> having raised the<br />

matter with President Barroso.<br />

Since the last <strong>Bulletin</strong> we have<br />

appeared in almost all national<br />

dailies,<br />

numerous<br />

regional and<br />

local papers<br />

and several specialist ones. We<br />

have been on several BBC TV<br />

and independent channels as<br />

well as an assortment of<br />

national, regional and local<br />

radio stations.<br />

Social Networking<br />

You can now follow the <strong>NSS</strong> on<br />

Twitter http://twitter.com/NatSecSoc as<br />

well as joining us on Facebook.<br />

www.facebook.com/<br />

group.php?gid=2433689604<br />

Left: Telegraph,<br />

14/7/<strong>09</strong><br />

<strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong> 7


Denis and Jim bid farewell<br />

Denis Cobell writes:<br />

I will not be standing as a candidate<br />

for Council at the next <strong>NSS</strong> AGM.<br />

Like my fellow Council member and<br />

long-time vice president, Jim<br />

Herrick, I have spent over 30 years<br />

on Council – including almost ten as<br />

President.<br />

I was 37 when I joined the<br />

Council, in 1976. It met then at the<br />

Fabian <strong>Society</strong> in Dartmouth Street,<br />

Westminster with Barbara Smoker<br />

as President and Bill McIlroy as<br />

Secretary.<br />

The most notable victory during<br />

my 33 years on Council was the<br />

abolition of the Blasphemy Laws.<br />

I am not leaving the <strong>NSS</strong> and still<br />

hope to offer my services when the<br />

need arises, and will continue to<br />

represent the <strong>NSS</strong> at the<br />

International Conscientious<br />

Objectors’ Day memorial, every year<br />

VOLUNTEERS<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> would like to thank all of<br />

our volunteers for their invaluable<br />

time and effort. Particular thanks<br />

go to:<br />

BRAD DAVIS of WhiteLight who<br />

designs the <strong>Bulletin</strong>, Annual Report<br />

and our promotional material.<br />

SEAN CLARK and ANTHONY<br />

DICKENS of Cuttlefish.com for<br />

distributing Newsline and<br />

maintaining our website.<br />

A new fundraising event for the <strong>NSS</strong><br />

5 & 6 NOVEMBER<br />

Full details:<br />

www.secularism.org.uk/divas<br />

Denis<br />

Cobell<br />

Jim Herrick<br />

on 15 May at noon in Tavistock<br />

Square; military exemption has<br />

often been more readily granted on<br />

religious grounds. I shall continue to<br />

be active with one of the <strong>NSS</strong>’s<br />

affiliate Groups: Lewisham<br />

Humanists.<br />

The <strong>NSS</strong> has seen a big growth in<br />

membership in the past decade and<br />

now has many younger Council<br />

members who have great potential<br />

and specialist backgrounds; so I<br />

leave with the knowledge that the<br />

<strong>NSS</strong> is in good hands.<br />

BARRY THORPE for his invaluable<br />

research.<br />

CLAUDINE BAXTER and ALASTAIR<br />

BANTON for their work in the office<br />

and at our events.<br />

DENIS PENALUNA for his continuing<br />

research work.<br />

RICHARD CRAIG for being our<br />

spokesman in the South West.<br />

TRANSLATORS<br />

NEEDED<br />

Volunteer translators are needed<br />

for world-class secular website.<br />

Academic rigour or professional<br />

qualifications are required, as<br />

this involves translating<br />

documents into English. It’s hard<br />

work, but there’s no time<br />

pressure and it offers a chance<br />

to make a difference.<br />

More information available<br />

from Tessa Kendall at<br />

admin@secularism.org.uk.<br />

<strong>Secular</strong>ist of the Year, 2010<br />

Please put a note in your diaries to keep Saturday afternoon 13<br />

February free.<br />

MEMBERS’ COMPETITION<br />

Win tickets for<br />

Inherit the Wind<br />

The Old Vic theatre in London is<br />

staging Inherit the Wind from 18<br />

September to 20 December. The<br />

play, starring Kevin Spacey and<br />

David Troughton, directed by Trevor<br />

Nunn, is based on the infamous<br />

Scopes monkey trial of 1925 when<br />

a school teacher was accused in a<br />

test case of violating a Tennessee<br />

statute by teaching Darwin’s theory<br />

of evolution. The <strong>NSS</strong> has two free<br />

tickets and a programme to give<br />

away to members – the tickets<br />

would be for Sundays 4th, 11th or<br />

18th October at 5pm or Thursdays<br />

15th or 22nd October at 7.30pm<br />

(subject to availability). To enter,<br />

please answer the following<br />

question:<br />

The atheist journalist HL<br />

Mencken famously covered the<br />

Scopes trial in the American press.<br />

What is the name of the character<br />

in Inherit the Wind based on<br />

Mencken?<br />

Please email your answer with<br />

your full name to<br />

admin@secularism.org.uk or post it to<br />

the office to arrive by 24<br />

September. More information about<br />

the play can be found here:<br />

www.oldvictheatre.com<br />

Issue 43 <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong><br />

<strong>Bulletin</strong><br />

<strong>National</strong> <strong>Secular</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />

25 Red Lion Square,<br />

London WC1R 4RL<br />

Telephone: (020) 7404 3126<br />

Fax: 0870 762 8971<br />

www.secularism.org.uk<br />

Executive Director<br />

Keith Porteous Wood FCCA<br />

kpw@secularism.org.uk<br />

Senior Off ce Staff<br />

Tessa Kendall and Stephen Evans<br />

admin@secularism.org.uk<br />

8 <strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong>

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!