NSS Bulletin Autumn 09 - National Secular Society
NSS Bulletin Autumn 09 - National Secular Society
NSS Bulletin Autumn 09 - National Secular Society
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
challenging religious privilege<br />
<strong>Bulletin</strong><br />
<strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong><br />
Issue 43 www.secularism.org.uk<br />
Thought for<br />
the Day: is a<br />
breakthrough<br />
imminent? continues<br />
Ritual Slaughter:<br />
a victory that<br />
looked impossible<br />
Animal welfare regulations require<br />
animals to be stunned before<br />
slaughter – the one exemption<br />
being for the production of kosher<br />
and halal meat. Meat produced in<br />
this way – with the animal’s throat<br />
cut while it is conscious – is<br />
increasingly the only meat sold in a<br />
number of retail and catering<br />
outlets or provided in some<br />
schools, for example. So, many of<br />
us are unknowingly eating meat – or<br />
food derived from it – that has been<br />
slaughtered without pre-stunning.<br />
continues on page 6, col 3 3<br />
President Barroso<br />
shares a joke with<br />
Keith. See the full<br />
story of our<br />
Brussels meeting<br />
on page 4.<br />
New hopes for an end to the<br />
discrimination inherent in Thought for<br />
the Day were raised when the BBC<br />
Trust accepted a complaint from the<br />
<strong>NSS</strong> (as well as complaints from a<br />
small number of individuals) calling<br />
for the programme to be opened up<br />
to non-religious voices.<br />
The BBC Trust is the Corporation’s<br />
governing body and “operationally<br />
independent of BBC management”,<br />
continues on page 3, col 3 3<br />
The <strong>Society</strong> has been providing top<br />
level assistance, briefings and<br />
lobbying to various Government<br />
departments. Keith Porteous Wood<br />
along with Ministers, senior MPs<br />
and senior civil servants was<br />
invited to a reception launching the<br />
Equality Bill. He took the<br />
opportunity to lobby them and this<br />
led to further invitations to put our<br />
views to them later both in writing<br />
and in person.<br />
Keith and <strong>NSS</strong> vice President<br />
Carla Revere have been involved in<br />
a number of intensive briefing<br />
sessions, for example with<br />
Equalities Minister Michael Foster<br />
Subscribe to Newsline, the weekly e-newsletter from the<br />
<strong>NSS</strong> at www.secularism.org.uk You can also follow us on:<br />
Hopes are raised for<br />
Swanage community<br />
school provision<br />
Dorset County Council has gone<br />
back to the drawing board after<br />
plans to close the only remaining<br />
community school within fifteen<br />
miles met with overwhelming<br />
opposition. As we reported in the<br />
previous <strong>Bulletin</strong>, when Swanage<br />
First School was earmarked for<br />
closure the <strong>NSS</strong> swung into action<br />
and put Dorset County Council under<br />
considerable pressure over their<br />
proposal. The <strong>NSS</strong> offered support<br />
to local residents who objected to<br />
the plans and instructed our lawyers<br />
to issue the Council with a formal<br />
letter detailing the legal problems<br />
on page 2, col 3 3<br />
Equality Bill: Putting the<br />
Government under pressure<br />
and with Dr Evan Harris MP. Carla<br />
and Keith have spent a great deal<br />
of time helping Evan over recent<br />
months with research, information<br />
and suggested amendments for the<br />
Bill. He also attended the Equality<br />
Bill Committee in the Commons to<br />
be on hand to assist Evan. We are<br />
grateful for the support of two<br />
members of the Labour <strong>National</strong><br />
Executive who are Honorary<br />
Associates (pictured overleaf).<br />
Much of our work has been<br />
focused on reducing the<br />
discrimination against teachers in<br />
religious schools who are not of the<br />
school’s faith. Carla Revere, who is<br />
continues on page 2, col 1 3
7 “Equality Bill” continued<br />
a barrister, has played a major role<br />
in uncovering what we believe to be<br />
the Government’s untenable<br />
position in allowing the<br />
discrimination to continue.<br />
We have demonstrably held the<br />
Government to account. Michael<br />
Foster described our round table<br />
meeting as “very productive” and<br />
the detailed answer to the many<br />
points we raised ran to seven<br />
pages. Evan has been generous in<br />
his thanks for our research going to<br />
the heart of some difficult and<br />
rarely-explored but crucial areas.<br />
Some of these have formed the<br />
basis for some of his probing<br />
Vice President Anna Behan and<br />
Keith Porteous Wood met senior<br />
staff at the Department for<br />
Communities and Local Government<br />
(DCLG), which includes the<br />
Government Equalities Office. We<br />
raised concerns about the Equality<br />
Bill, but most of the discussion was<br />
about a euphemistically titled<br />
“Charter of Excellence”, a voluntary<br />
code intended to apply to religious<br />
organisations bidding for “Faith<br />
Based” Welfare (FBW).<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> opposed this Charter<br />
because we believe prohibition of<br />
discrimination should be mandatory<br />
rather than voluntary. The Charter<br />
was far too weak and, not being<br />
policed, would therefore give faith<br />
groups unjustified preference in<br />
tendering to run services. It would<br />
2<br />
amendments. Keith watched a<br />
Government Minister almost<br />
physically squirming under Evan’s<br />
relentless cross examination on<br />
this Bill. We admire him for so often<br />
being the MP who puts Government<br />
Ministers under the most scrutiny.<br />
However, as the Government<br />
heads towards the General Election,<br />
it is less willing to take on the<br />
churches, minority religions and the<br />
increasingly powerful right-wing<br />
media. The <strong>Society</strong>’s work on the<br />
Bill is therefore evolving into a<br />
damage-limitation exercise where<br />
we are doing our level best to head<br />
off the worst excesses.<br />
Clockwise from top left:<br />
Michael Foster MP, Carla<br />
Revere, Dr Evan Harris MP,<br />
Michael Cashman MEP,<br />
Angela Eagle MP<br />
Faith based welfare:<br />
Government drops Charter<br />
not even have required an<br />
undertaking from bidders for public<br />
money not to discriminate in<br />
employment against those of the<br />
" wrong" faith or none, something<br />
that in any case should be made<br />
unlawful.<br />
We are pleased to say that the<br />
Government has dropped the<br />
Charter. We hope it was as a result<br />
of our protestations, rather than<br />
because the religious were not even<br />
prepared to accept a voluntary code.<br />
Both Labour and Conservatives<br />
support the increase and spread of<br />
FBW, so we are moving from<br />
opposition in principle to damage<br />
limitation here too. So, while we<br />
continue to raise serious concerns<br />
at every opportunity, the emphasis<br />
has shifted to the mechanisms.<br />
7 “Swanage” continued<br />
they risked by failing to provide a<br />
community school. One would be a<br />
legal challenge under the Human<br />
Rights Act for contravening parents’<br />
rights to educate their children in<br />
Swanage First School<br />
line with their beliefs. Sources tell<br />
us that they are taking our letter<br />
seriously.<br />
Under the original plans, Swanage<br />
First and St Mark’s CofE First<br />
Schools would have been closed<br />
and replaced with a new primary<br />
which would “respect the faith<br />
tradition” of St Mark’s. Parents<br />
would then be left with no<br />
alternative to a religious school.<br />
The Council will now launch a new<br />
public consultation in early 2010<br />
and the <strong>NSS</strong> will be closely<br />
monitoring the situation and doing<br />
all we can to ensure that there will<br />
be a community school in the area<br />
in future. The wording of the<br />
document announcing the<br />
consultation also suggests that<br />
Dorset has taken on board these<br />
concerns.<br />
We suspect that a, perhaps<br />
secondary, reason for the<br />
consultation is to distance Dorset<br />
from a decision to retain a<br />
community school so as not to<br />
antagonise the local Anglican<br />
diocese, which we suspect to have<br />
played a key role in the original<br />
proposals.<br />
Submissions<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> works away behind the<br />
scenes, submitting consultation<br />
documents to Government and<br />
other agencies. Recently, we<br />
have written an RE guidance<br />
submission and also raised the<br />
issue in the TES. We contributed<br />
to the UK consultation on the<br />
European Commission Proposal<br />
for Equal Treatment Directive<br />
(Discrimination in provision of<br />
goods and services) and to the<br />
Broadcast Advertising Standards<br />
Code on condom and abortion<br />
advice centre advertising.<br />
<strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong>
Scotland<br />
There has been a fierce tussle<br />
fought out in the pages of the<br />
Herald (published in Glasgow)<br />
between the <strong>NSS</strong> and a Scottish<br />
cleric David Keddie over Religious<br />
Observance in Scottish schools.<br />
He claimed new Scottish<br />
guidelines marked a radical<br />
departure from the traditional<br />
Christian-based assemblies that<br />
used to be held in schools in favour<br />
of a much more inclusive, nonspecifically<br />
faith-based school and<br />
pupil-centred approach to the<br />
development of “spiritual<br />
development”. We countered with<br />
quotes from the guidelines showing<br />
they were far from being as<br />
enlightened or pluralistic as Dr<br />
Keddie would have the readers<br />
believe. We pointed out the<br />
guidelines went out of their way not<br />
to forbid or even criticise worship in<br />
the formal curriculum, and even<br />
gave examples of where – not just<br />
in RC schools – confessional (i.e.<br />
proselytising) teaching was<br />
“appropriate”.<br />
We opined that “there are plenty<br />
of pupils not of the faith of the<br />
school or the “faith community”,<br />
even if their parents are. It is no<br />
longer legitimate for publicly-funded<br />
schools to force-feed captive pupils<br />
with confessional religion – if this<br />
happens at all it should be for the<br />
home and place of worship.”<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> also took on Scottish<br />
justice secretary Kenny MacAskill in<br />
the Herald and the Scotsman for his<br />
references to a ‘higher power’ giving<br />
the supposed Libyan/PanAm<br />
Camp for enquiring minds<br />
Camp Quest, the first UK summer camp aimed mainly<br />
at children from non-believing families, received an<br />
astonishingly hostile press when it was launched this<br />
year, e.g. “Dawkins sets up kids’ camp to groom<br />
atheists” as front page news. Yet <strong>NSS</strong> Honorary<br />
Associate Richard Dawkins had only made a modest<br />
contribution, and played no part in the management of<br />
the camp.<br />
Terry Sanderson and Keith Porteous Wood spent a<br />
couple of days putting the record straight on both TV<br />
and radio. They pointed to the double standard: one<br />
small camp encouraging children to think for<br />
themselves made repeated national headlines, while<br />
the hundreds or thousands of larger Christian camps<br />
where children are told what to think and believe pass<br />
unremarked.<br />
More information at www.camp-quest.org.uk<br />
bomber Megrahi terminal cancer. We<br />
were also quoted in Scotland on<br />
Sunday following the news that the<br />
SNP candidate for the forthcoming<br />
Glasgow North-East by-election is a<br />
member of Opus Dei.<br />
We are delighted that Iain Banks,<br />
identified as an <strong>NSS</strong> Honorary<br />
Associate, has spoken out in The<br />
Sunday Times against faith schools<br />
in Scotland, emphasising the<br />
sectarianism aspect.<br />
Iain Banks<br />
Wales<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> bitterly attacked the<br />
Archbishop of Wales for opposing<br />
proposals that older pupils in Wales<br />
should not be allowed to opt out of<br />
Collective Worship at school. Our<br />
7 “Thought for the Day” continued<br />
which is cause for hope.<br />
Its complaints procedure can be<br />
accessed only after all the internal<br />
avenues within the BBC have been<br />
exhausted. So, the <strong>NSS</strong>’s complaint<br />
first had to pass through the usual<br />
brush-off stages of the BBC’s normal<br />
complaints procedure and has now<br />
been accepted for adjudication by<br />
the Trust sometime in the autumn.<br />
Only around seventy complaints a<br />
year make it this far.<br />
Our complaint runs to twelve<br />
pages of detailed argument, and<br />
notes that the <strong>NSS</strong>'s first complaint<br />
was in 1962.<br />
The news that the BBC Trust was<br />
considering the change made<br />
headlines around the world, and the<br />
<strong>NSS</strong> figured prominently in the<br />
stories.<br />
comments were picked up by the<br />
Church of England Newspaper. The<br />
proposals are prompted by the<br />
equivalent change made in England<br />
directly as a result of the <strong>NSS</strong>’s<br />
efforts.<br />
DONATIONS<br />
The Council expresses its profuse thanks to all members who have<br />
made donations over the summer, particularly one of £1,000. The <strong>NSS</strong><br />
would also like to thank the growing number of members taking out<br />
standing orders as these help us to plan ahead with our campaigns<br />
and running costs.<br />
If you would like to make a donation, start a standing order or<br />
remember the <strong>NSS</strong> in your will to support our work in decades to<br />
come, please click the Donate button on the website or contact the<br />
office for details. We don’t receive any other funding, so your support<br />
is both sorely needed and greatly valued.<br />
Students group appoints<br />
new president<br />
We congratulate Jenna Catley on her<br />
appointment as president of The <strong>National</strong><br />
Federation of Atheist, Humanist and<br />
Jenna<br />
Catley<br />
<strong>Secular</strong> Student Societies. The task of this group is an<br />
important one: it is essential that students are offered<br />
an alternative to the increasingly aggressive tactics of<br />
religious groups on campus. The more secularist<br />
groups that can be encouraged to form or expand, the<br />
better. The <strong>NSS</strong> does all it can to encourage the AHS.<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> has a growing number of student members,<br />
some of whom have gone on to set up groups<br />
themselves.<br />
Any students who wish to volunteer – even if they<br />
cannot afford to join – are invited to contact Tessa<br />
Kendall at admin@secularism.org.uk<br />
<strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong> 3
<strong>NSS</strong> at top table in Europe<br />
(see photo on front page)<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> was among several nonreligious<br />
organisations from around<br />
Europe invited to a formal lunch with<br />
Jose Manuel Barroso, the President<br />
of the European Commission at its<br />
Brussels HQ in June.<br />
Keith Porteous Wood raised the<br />
topic of sharia law and asked that<br />
the Commission do more to protect<br />
Human Rights from the onslaught of<br />
religious demands.<br />
He cautioned against taking for<br />
granted Human Rights advances that<br />
had been made; they need to be<br />
defended from attack. He pointed to<br />
the UN Human Rights Council where<br />
even the Universal Declaration is<br />
being undermined by rival and less<br />
demanding Islamic versions.<br />
Examples are the Cairo Declaration<br />
on “Human Rights” in Islam in which<br />
Sharia is mentioned around a dozen<br />
times and the Arab Charter on<br />
Human Rights.<br />
Other attendees at the lunch were<br />
astonished when he informed them<br />
In June, the General Assembly<br />
(AGM) of the International Humanist<br />
and Ethical Union was held in<br />
Conway Hall, London. Keith’s<br />
reappointment as an international<br />
representative for IHEU was ratified.<br />
This status is helpful, for example, in<br />
matters associated with the United<br />
Nations Human Rights Council.<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> hosted and co-chaired a<br />
meeting of the International Liaison<br />
Committee of Atheists and<br />
Freethinkers (ILCAF). This was<br />
followed by an <strong>NSS</strong> reception for<br />
delegates with IHEU’s president,<br />
Sonja Eggerickx, as guest of honour.<br />
Anna Behan<br />
that only Sharia ‘scholars’ are<br />
permitted to discuss Sharia at the<br />
UN Council on Human Rights.<br />
There was surprise and concern<br />
at his description of the rise of the<br />
influence of Sharia law in the UK,<br />
where Sharia tribunals, claiming to<br />
be “official”, are spreading their<br />
influence and activities. Keith had<br />
directed a senior EU Justice<br />
Directorate lawyer to one such site<br />
and even she thought it was an<br />
official one, she later admitted.<br />
Those most at risk are women,<br />
whose evidence is deemed to be<br />
worth only half that of a man’s.<br />
Keith called for every EU citizen to<br />
be subject only to democraticallydetermined<br />
and Human Rights<br />
compliant laws. He urged Member<br />
States to carefully consider the<br />
example set by Canadian provinces<br />
in outlawing religious arbitration of<br />
all kinds.<br />
There were nods of agreement<br />
when Keith asserted that the Pope<br />
The reception was also attended by<br />
members of the <strong>NSS</strong> and of our<br />
sister French organisation Libre<br />
Pensée. The evening concluded with<br />
a much-appreciated performance of<br />
Terry Sanderson’s show about the<br />
war-time heroism of Marlene<br />
Dietrich, “the world’s most<br />
glamorous atheist”. We were<br />
pleased to reciprocate the hospitality<br />
we receive when attending functions<br />
at kindred organisations abroad.<br />
The final event was an IHEU<br />
conference on Untouchability. This is<br />
largely a product of the Hindu caste<br />
system, but it is little-known that its<br />
was stepping up the Vatican’s<br />
institutional homophobia; not only by<br />
discriminating against priests for<br />
homosexual activity, but for their<br />
very orientation. He branded as<br />
deplorable the Vatican’s attempted<br />
interference in legislation to give gay<br />
people equal rights around Europe.<br />
He sat down amid laughter after<br />
joking that this was ironic – given the<br />
Catholic Church’s attitudes towards<br />
homosexuals — that they should<br />
employ such a high proportion of gay<br />
men in its priesthood.<br />
Reassuringly, President Barroso<br />
later responded constructively,<br />
picking up some of the <strong>NSS</strong>’s<br />
points, particularly the question of<br />
Sharia law, about which we are now<br />
engaged in talks with European<br />
Commission officials.<br />
<strong>NSS</strong> staff member Stephen Evans<br />
presented President Barroso with a<br />
copy of the Civitas book, One Law<br />
for All which echoes our concerns<br />
about Sharia law.<br />
International conferences at London’s Conway Hall<br />
influence pervades even some parts<br />
of the UK where a high proportion of<br />
the population are from Hindu<br />
backgrounds. We were delighted that<br />
Honorary Associate Lord Desai<br />
(himself from a Hindu background)<br />
and Lord Avebury both spoke. The<br />
<strong>NSS</strong> was on the panel for the closing<br />
session and has worked with Lord<br />
Avebury on an amendment to the<br />
Equality Bill to cover caste<br />
discrimination that has been taken<br />
up by the LibDems. <strong>NSS</strong> Honorary<br />
Associate Dr Evan Harris MP also<br />
proposed an amendment on similar<br />
lines in the Commons.<br />
Anna at disestablishment book launch<br />
Following our high level work with University College’s Constitutional Unit, the<br />
generally acknowledged leading authority on such matters, Anna Behan was<br />
invited to the launch of a new book about disestablishment: Church and State in<br />
21st Century Britain: the Future of Church Establishment. As an independent<br />
observer noted: “She also asked a very shrewd question viz.: ‘Upon what<br />
principled basis did the CofE seek to continue in its present status?’ There was<br />
no answer.<br />
4 <strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong>
Council of Europe and religion<br />
The Council of Europe held a<br />
conference at its HQ in Strasbourg<br />
in June on Religious Education and<br />
the role it is alleged to play in<br />
improving intercultural relations.<br />
(The conference is the second in<br />
an annual series initiated at a<br />
summit on The Religious Aspect of<br />
Intercultural Dialogue in San<br />
Marino in 2007 where Keith<br />
Porteous Wood and Terry<br />
Sanderson played an active<br />
damage-limitation role).<br />
Keith attended as an<br />
international representative of the<br />
International Humanist and Ethical<br />
Union (to which the <strong>NSS</strong> is<br />
affiliated). Keith found himself in<br />
conflict with the representatives of<br />
the Roman Catholic and Russian<br />
Orthodox churches.<br />
He acknowledged the need for<br />
minimising friction between those<br />
of different religious and cultural<br />
backgrounds. The majority of<br />
participants were representing<br />
religious traditions however, and<br />
thought that inter-faith conflict and<br />
suspicion could be reduced if<br />
students were to learn about each<br />
others’ religions in depth.<br />
Keith, clearly in a minority,<br />
rejected this saying that while<br />
students should be acquainted with<br />
the basic tenets of the major<br />
religions, the way to reduce tension<br />
is not to dwell on differences.<br />
Instead, we should be<br />
EU Ambassador to the Council of Europe (Mme Pavan-<br />
Woolfe) and Advisor to the European Commission<br />
President, Jose Manuel Barroso (Georg Cesar das Neves)<br />
with Keith at the Council of Europe in Strasbourg<br />
concentrating on what unites us<br />
rather than what divides us. He<br />
suggested sport, with all cultures<br />
playing together in the same team.<br />
Music would be another example.<br />
The religious delegates were<br />
keen to refer to what they<br />
described as “religious facts” that<br />
students were supposed to learn.<br />
He objected to this and to<br />
everyone being required to<br />
“respect” everyone else’s beliefs.<br />
Everyone should of course have<br />
the freedom to believe what they<br />
wish, providing they are not<br />
harming others. But freedom of<br />
speech entails being able to<br />
criticise elements of doctrine,<br />
especially those that are inhumane<br />
or discriminatory.<br />
Even less popular was our<br />
protest that there should not be<br />
proselytising or confessional<br />
teaching of religion in schools,<br />
especially state-funded ones.<br />
However little headway we<br />
made, it is important that the voice<br />
of dissent was clearly heard, even<br />
though the conference has no<br />
executive power. Keith picked up<br />
signals of support from some<br />
participants, but more importantly,<br />
Council members, diplomats and<br />
Council staff.<br />
Parliamentary prayers: abolish or modernise?<br />
Shortly after John Bercow was appointed Speaker of the House of Commons, on<br />
a modernising ticket, we wrote to him to suggest the Commons should abandon<br />
prayers. We explained why they were inappropriate and suggested that, if the<br />
Commons just could not bring itself to remove them completely, a period of<br />
silent reflection might be more appropriate. The worst of all options, we argued,<br />
would be some sort of multi-faith prayers option.<br />
Speaker John Bercow<br />
<strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong> 5
From pub to Pakistan…Council activity<br />
Dan Bye spoke to Leeds Skeptics in the Pub on<br />
How to annoy a skeptic.<br />
Elizabeth O’Casey attended a WAFE (International<br />
Federation of Women Against Fundamentalism and<br />
for Equality) meeting in the House of Lords, on the<br />
limits of tolerance. She also went to a lecture and<br />
discussion on Sharia law and arbitration in<br />
religious contexts at the Institute of Advanced<br />
Legal Studies. In both meetings she raised issues<br />
regarding the treatment and subjugation of women<br />
by Islam and the consistent denial of women's<br />
agency through Islamic legal, traditional, and<br />
sartorial practices. Elizabeth also attended a<br />
Liberty conference and spoke from the floor about international legislation<br />
on the defamation of religion. She is involved in both the student campaign<br />
and the campaign against religious slaughter.<br />
Peter Vlachos spread the secular message during a week-long lecture trip<br />
to a progressive university in Pakistan.<br />
Dan Bye<br />
<strong>Secular</strong> Medical Forum<br />
In June, the <strong>Secular</strong> Medical Forum<br />
represented the <strong>NSS</strong> at the General Medical<br />
Council consultative conference on End of<br />
Life Treatment and Care. The SMF broadly<br />
welcomed the proposed new guidelines and<br />
continues to push for a further shift of<br />
emphasis towards increasing patient<br />
autonomy up to and including the end of life.<br />
There is stiff opposition to this from religious organisations. The SMF<br />
welcomed distinguished scientist, author and TV presenter Simon Singh to<br />
their reception at the BMA annual representatives’ meeting in Liverpool. In<br />
response to the Advertising Standards consultation on broadcasting<br />
standards, the SMF expressed concern that anti-choice organisations delay<br />
women’s access to abortion while rarely being transparent about their true<br />
agenda.<br />
At the end of June, doctors voted down an evangelical Christian motion<br />
at the BMA conference that would have given carte blanche for religious<br />
medical practitioners to “share their faith” with patients without any risk of<br />
suspension. This was prompted by the Nurse Petrie case in which the <strong>NSS</strong>,<br />
almost alone, supported her employers. Terry Sanderson’s support of the<br />
BMA’s decision was reported widely.<br />
However, the BMA conference did pass some minor “faith creep”<br />
motions.<br />
For further information or speaker requests please visit the website<br />
www.secularmedicalforum.org.uk or contact Dr Antony Lempert by email<br />
antony@secularmedicalforum.org.uk or telephone the <strong>NSS</strong> on 020 7404 3126<br />
The LSS continues to expand its membership<br />
to promote law and policy making based on<br />
principles of equal rights and respect for all. It<br />
helps individuals and organisations by<br />
providing legal advice and assistance on<br />
issues of discrimination and human rights law<br />
relating to religious privilege.<br />
6<br />
Elizabeth O’Casey<br />
Lawyers’ <strong>Secular</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />
7 “Ritual Slaughter” continued<br />
The LSS is regularly contacted by journalists<br />
who it is happy to assist.<br />
Membership of the LSS is open to all<br />
lawyers, practising and non-practising, and to<br />
law students. Information on membership and<br />
research resources can be found on the<br />
website www.lawyerssecularsociety.org<br />
The focus of our latest campaign<br />
was quickly diverted from the UK to<br />
Brussels when we learned of<br />
attempts being made in the<br />
European Parliament to remove the<br />
Member States’ option not to insist<br />
on pre-stunning, even for religious<br />
slaughter. Most EU countries did<br />
give exemptions, but the new rules<br />
would make religious exemption<br />
mandatory in all Member States.<br />
We lobbied our MEPs and senior<br />
politicians in the UK prior to the<br />
first vote, at the Agriculture<br />
Committee, and again at the vote<br />
in the European Parliament. We<br />
organised a petition of MPs to write<br />
to the Rt Hon Hilary Benn, the<br />
DEFRA minister, and were assisted<br />
by a former DEFRA minister who<br />
was supportive.<br />
The only voting bloc opposing the<br />
mandatory religious exemption was<br />
ALDE, the European LibDems, to<br />
which our Honorary Associate<br />
Sophie in ’t Veld MEP is affiliated.<br />
We were grateful for their support.<br />
It is not a large bloc, however, and<br />
we were not successful in turning<br />
the tide – at that stage. Well<br />
placed Jewish organisations have<br />
clearly been planning this ambush<br />
for a long time and were<br />
particularly active. Any argument<br />
presented as the preservation of<br />
religious liberty trumps all,<br />
regardless of the cruelty<br />
implications.<br />
The Parliament’s votes are<br />
subject to ratification by the Council<br />
of Ministers. This comprises the<br />
Ministerial representatives of<br />
Member States, and we had lobbied<br />
the relevant UK Minister.<br />
We were therefore delighted<br />
when the final text agreed by the<br />
Council of Ministers ignored the<br />
Parliament’s stance and retained<br />
Member States’ rights to decide<br />
whether or not to grant these<br />
exemptions.<br />
<strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong>
MEDIA<br />
There was no let-up for the <strong>NSS</strong><br />
during the summer months as we<br />
kept up our high profile in media.<br />
Religion in schools was a recurring<br />
theme. We spoke out in the<br />
Telegraph and on the Press<br />
Association newswires against<br />
indoctrination in response to<br />
Archbishop Vincent Nichols’ call for<br />
more religion in schools and we<br />
criticised new RE guidance and<br />
‘forced worship’ in religious<br />
assemblies in the Times<br />
Educational Supplement.<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> was also extensively<br />
quoted in the TES when Dorset<br />
County Council withdrew their plans<br />
to leave Swanage without a<br />
community school. <strong>NSS</strong> Executive<br />
Director, Keith Porteous Wood, also<br />
spoke out against faith-based<br />
education in the Independent’s<br />
article about Britain’s first Hindu<br />
faith school. Our comments were<br />
picked up by Asian News<br />
International and were carried<br />
across various worldwide media<br />
outlets.<br />
When the media went into a<br />
frenzy over Camp Quest, the <strong>NSS</strong><br />
Above: Times Educational<br />
Supplement, 7/8/<strong>09</strong><br />
was first on the scene, defending<br />
the secular summer camp across<br />
national and local BBC radio and<br />
television.<br />
Our debaptism certificate<br />
continues to provoke a response. It<br />
was the feature of a USA Today<br />
article where Stephen Evans was<br />
quoted. USA Today is the world’s<br />
second largest English speaking<br />
circulation newspaper and the story<br />
was inevitably picked up by various<br />
American media.<br />
Still across the pond, Keith<br />
Porteous Wood made an<br />
appearance on the popular Penn &<br />
Teller show. The episode in question<br />
offered robust, and often humorous,<br />
Keith Porteous Wood on<br />
the Penn & Teller show<br />
Above: Evening<br />
Standard, 16/7/<strong>09</strong><br />
criticism of the Vatican. The show<br />
was subsequently pulled from the<br />
CBS owned Showtime website<br />
following a furious attack from<br />
conservative Catholics.<br />
<strong>NSS</strong> President Terry Sanderson<br />
was widely quoted throughout<br />
national, local and electronic media<br />
on a range of subjects such as<br />
Thought for the Day in the Telegraph<br />
to the Press Association’s coverage<br />
of so called “gay cure” therapies.<br />
Terry was also widely quoted when a<br />
Christian motion at the BMA<br />
conference sought to allow doctors<br />
to pray for patients. Anthony<br />
Lempert from the <strong>Secular</strong> Medical<br />
Forum and Stephen Evans also<br />
weighed in on Radio 5 Live.<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> also featured in an indepth<br />
Mail on Sunday investigation<br />
into sharia law in Britain. The only<br />
mention in the three page article of<br />
any constructive response was<br />
about the <strong>NSS</strong> having raised the<br />
matter with President Barroso.<br />
Since the last <strong>Bulletin</strong> we have<br />
appeared in almost all national<br />
dailies,<br />
numerous<br />
regional and<br />
local papers<br />
and several specialist ones. We<br />
have been on several BBC TV<br />
and independent channels as<br />
well as an assortment of<br />
national, regional and local<br />
radio stations.<br />
Social Networking<br />
You can now follow the <strong>NSS</strong> on<br />
Twitter http://twitter.com/NatSecSoc as<br />
well as joining us on Facebook.<br />
www.facebook.com/<br />
group.php?gid=2433689604<br />
Left: Telegraph,<br />
14/7/<strong>09</strong><br />
<strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong> 7
Denis and Jim bid farewell<br />
Denis Cobell writes:<br />
I will not be standing as a candidate<br />
for Council at the next <strong>NSS</strong> AGM.<br />
Like my fellow Council member and<br />
long-time vice president, Jim<br />
Herrick, I have spent over 30 years<br />
on Council – including almost ten as<br />
President.<br />
I was 37 when I joined the<br />
Council, in 1976. It met then at the<br />
Fabian <strong>Society</strong> in Dartmouth Street,<br />
Westminster with Barbara Smoker<br />
as President and Bill McIlroy as<br />
Secretary.<br />
The most notable victory during<br />
my 33 years on Council was the<br />
abolition of the Blasphemy Laws.<br />
I am not leaving the <strong>NSS</strong> and still<br />
hope to offer my services when the<br />
need arises, and will continue to<br />
represent the <strong>NSS</strong> at the<br />
International Conscientious<br />
Objectors’ Day memorial, every year<br />
VOLUNTEERS<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> would like to thank all of<br />
our volunteers for their invaluable<br />
time and effort. Particular thanks<br />
go to:<br />
BRAD DAVIS of WhiteLight who<br />
designs the <strong>Bulletin</strong>, Annual Report<br />
and our promotional material.<br />
SEAN CLARK and ANTHONY<br />
DICKENS of Cuttlefish.com for<br />
distributing Newsline and<br />
maintaining our website.<br />
A new fundraising event for the <strong>NSS</strong><br />
5 & 6 NOVEMBER<br />
Full details:<br />
www.secularism.org.uk/divas<br />
Denis<br />
Cobell<br />
Jim Herrick<br />
on 15 May at noon in Tavistock<br />
Square; military exemption has<br />
often been more readily granted on<br />
religious grounds. I shall continue to<br />
be active with one of the <strong>NSS</strong>’s<br />
affiliate Groups: Lewisham<br />
Humanists.<br />
The <strong>NSS</strong> has seen a big growth in<br />
membership in the past decade and<br />
now has many younger Council<br />
members who have great potential<br />
and specialist backgrounds; so I<br />
leave with the knowledge that the<br />
<strong>NSS</strong> is in good hands.<br />
BARRY THORPE for his invaluable<br />
research.<br />
CLAUDINE BAXTER and ALASTAIR<br />
BANTON for their work in the office<br />
and at our events.<br />
DENIS PENALUNA for his continuing<br />
research work.<br />
RICHARD CRAIG for being our<br />
spokesman in the South West.<br />
TRANSLATORS<br />
NEEDED<br />
Volunteer translators are needed<br />
for world-class secular website.<br />
Academic rigour or professional<br />
qualifications are required, as<br />
this involves translating<br />
documents into English. It’s hard<br />
work, but there’s no time<br />
pressure and it offers a chance<br />
to make a difference.<br />
More information available<br />
from Tessa Kendall at<br />
admin@secularism.org.uk.<br />
<strong>Secular</strong>ist of the Year, 2010<br />
Please put a note in your diaries to keep Saturday afternoon 13<br />
February free.<br />
MEMBERS’ COMPETITION<br />
Win tickets for<br />
Inherit the Wind<br />
The Old Vic theatre in London is<br />
staging Inherit the Wind from 18<br />
September to 20 December. The<br />
play, starring Kevin Spacey and<br />
David Troughton, directed by Trevor<br />
Nunn, is based on the infamous<br />
Scopes monkey trial of 1925 when<br />
a school teacher was accused in a<br />
test case of violating a Tennessee<br />
statute by teaching Darwin’s theory<br />
of evolution. The <strong>NSS</strong> has two free<br />
tickets and a programme to give<br />
away to members – the tickets<br />
would be for Sundays 4th, 11th or<br />
18th October at 5pm or Thursdays<br />
15th or 22nd October at 7.30pm<br />
(subject to availability). To enter,<br />
please answer the following<br />
question:<br />
The atheist journalist HL<br />
Mencken famously covered the<br />
Scopes trial in the American press.<br />
What is the name of the character<br />
in Inherit the Wind based on<br />
Mencken?<br />
Please email your answer with<br />
your full name to<br />
admin@secularism.org.uk or post it to<br />
the office to arrive by 24<br />
September. More information about<br />
the play can be found here:<br />
www.oldvictheatre.com<br />
Issue 43 <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong><br />
<strong>Bulletin</strong><br />
<strong>National</strong> <strong>Secular</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />
25 Red Lion Square,<br />
London WC1R 4RL<br />
Telephone: (020) 7404 3126<br />
Fax: 0870 762 8971<br />
www.secularism.org.uk<br />
Executive Director<br />
Keith Porteous Wood FCCA<br />
kpw@secularism.org.uk<br />
Senior Off ce Staff<br />
Tessa Kendall and Stephen Evans<br />
admin@secularism.org.uk<br />
8 <strong>Bulletin</strong> <strong>Autumn</strong> 20<strong>09</strong>