01.01.2015 Views

ARTICLE 1: - emits - ESA

ARTICLE 1: - emits - ESA

ARTICLE 1: - emits - ESA

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>ESA</strong>/REG/001, rev. 2<br />

Annex III,rev.1<br />

Page 31<br />

1.4 Establishment and handling of the evaluation criteria and weighting factors<br />

Pursuant to Article 25 of the Procurement Regulations and based on the proposal made<br />

by the Joint Secretaries, the TEB shall establish the evaluation criteria and sub-criteria,<br />

if any, and the associated weighting factors.<br />

Evaluation criteria including sub-criteria are applied by the TEB to determine the<br />

strengths and weaknesses of a tender by separate evaluations of its various aspects. The<br />

identification of specific significant evaluation criteria is more essential than the<br />

identification of a multitude of criteria covering all possible minor aspects, which<br />

should be treated as sub-criteria.<br />

The number of evaluation criteria shall never be less than two and no more than five.<br />

1.4.1 Evaluation criteria shall be established and published for each ITT. Once<br />

approved, the evaluation criteria and sub-criteria shall be binding for the evaluation.<br />

1.4.2 The TEB shall be free to establish such evaluation criteria as it sees fit, provided<br />

that all significant parts of the ITT are covered.<br />

Guideline<br />

Evaluation criteria may be selected from the following list:<br />

- understanding of and compliance with the requirements,<br />

- quality,<br />

- approach and suitability of the proposed design,<br />

- suitability of facilities and of support programme,<br />

- overall organisation and management methods,<br />

- costing and planning,<br />

- manpower deployment,<br />

- experience and capacity of the Tenderer,<br />

- compliance with substantive tender and contract conditions,<br />

- Industrial procurement Plan ( Make or Buy) etc.<br />

1.4.3 When establishing criteria and sub-criteria, the TEB shall inasmuch as possible<br />

follow established practice and shall take into consideration the following:<br />

i. evaluation criteria shall be well defined, logically distinct and avoid duplication;<br />

ii.<br />

iii.<br />

iv.<br />

where the TEB decides to appoint tender evaluation panels, the evaluation<br />

criteria should, as far as possible, be arranged under aspects corresponding to<br />

the field of reference of each panel;<br />

sub-criteria when used shall breakdown the evaluation criteria into their various<br />

aspects and shall cover all aspects of the evaluation criteria to which they refer<br />

and shall not be used as means of introducing new criteria; and,<br />

evaluation criteria shall not create unfair advantage for one economic operator<br />

over another.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!