26.12.2014 Views

remaking chinatex - Asia Today International

remaking chinatex - Asia Today International

remaking chinatex - Asia Today International

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

In this Issue<br />

®<br />

Face-saving solution<br />

needed for Hong Kong<br />

SAFTA - services will<br />

be the big winner<br />

'Risky' to float yuan<br />

ASEAN revisits energy<br />

INTERNATIONAL<br />

Jonathan Story<br />

August/September 2003<br />

REMAKING<br />

CHINATEX:<br />

Brand names the<br />

key – and China<br />

is buying!<br />

Chinatex President<br />

and CEO Zhao Boya<br />

Annual subscription (Australia) including password to ASIA TODAY ONLINE $130 (inc GST), Airmail to Hong Kong HK$850, Singapore S$190, Europe/USA/Canada US$110.<br />

Print Post Approved<br />

PP240725/00001<br />

Twentieth year of publication<br />

www.asiatoday.com.au


GLOBAL ORGANIZERS OF INSTITUTIONAL<br />

FINANCE & INVESTMENT CONFERENCES<br />

THE FIFTH ANNUAL<br />

Masters of<br />

held in conjunction with<br />

Investment Management<br />

15-16 October 2003 • The Island Shangri-La • Hong Kong<br />

TOPICS TO BE DISCUSSED INCLUDE:<br />

• <strong>International</strong> Roundtable Investment Discussion with Pension Funds from 3 Continents<br />

• Investment in China: Qualified Foreign Institutional Investor (QFII) Scheme & Pension Reform<br />

• Absolute Return Strategies: The Best Strategies and How to Implement Them<br />

• Hedge Fund, Hedge Fund Indices and the Issue of Transparency<br />

• Indexing Strategies in a High Volatility/Low Return Environment<br />

• Enhanced Indexing for Risk Controlled Alpha<br />

• Corporate Governance and Socially Responsible Investing<br />

• Transaction Costs, Trading Strategies & Transition Management<br />

• Rethinking Asset Allocations in <strong>Today</strong>’s Challenging Market<br />

• The Many Uses of ETFs: <strong>International</strong> Investment, Sector Rotation & Hedging<br />

Sponsors include:<br />

For More Information, Please Visit:<br />

www.imn.org/a525/atm/<br />

Email: mail@imn.org<br />

Call: (212) 768-2800 ext. 1<br />

Fax: (212) 768-2484<br />

information management network


ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL<br />

Volume 21, No. 4, August/September 2003<br />

Twentieth Year of Publication<br />

®<br />

Published in Australia since 1983 by East <strong>Asia</strong> News and Features (Australia) Pty. Limited (ABN 48 343 588 913). Office address: Level 29<br />

Chifley Tower, 2 Chifley Square, Sydney NSW, Australia. Production Office: Level 1, 1463 Pittwater Road, Narrabeen NSW 2101, Australia.<br />

Telephone (612) 9970-6477. Fax (61 2) 9913-2003. Mailing address (all correspondence): Box N7, Grosvenor Place Post Office, Sydney NSW<br />

1220, Australia. E-mail . Website .<br />

INTERNATIONAL<br />

REMAKING CHINATEX: China's National Textile Imports and Exports Corporation is buying up offshore cotton<br />

plantations and will acquire interests in companies engaged in fashion design in Europe, the US and Japan. Chinatex<br />

President and Chief Executive Zhao Boya details his strategic plan in our exclusive report. 5-7<br />

MORE 'FREEDOM' FOR HONG KONG Hong Kong will be given more freedom in a solution to the current crisis<br />

which is fashioned to both reinforce China's emerging status on the international stage and to play for domestic<br />

consumption, according to China analyst Jonathan Story, Professor of <strong>International</strong> Political Economy at INSEAD. He<br />

says a face-saving operation is needed 7-9<br />

'RISKY' TO FLOAT THE YUAN: Morgan Stanley Chief Economist Stephen Roach is urging<br />

China to resist pressure for a revaluation - he says Japan has led the way in Chinabashing<br />

over the past year. ABN AMRO believes that when revaluation does come, it is<br />

likely to be a one-off move of 15-20 per cent 9<br />

Zhao Boya:<br />

A US$200 million shopping list.<br />

ASEAN REVISITS ENERGY GRIDS: ASEAN is again moving towards a cross-border<br />

gas and electricity grid. It has approved a Master Plan for power inter-connection, but<br />

emergence of common gas and power markets where energy is traded appears to be<br />

some way off 10-11<br />

Jonathan Story<br />

ADVISORIES 'SELF-DEFEATING': Issuing travel advisories against countries hit by terrorism plays into the hands of those who want to disrupt<br />

business, says Richard Gordon, Philippines Tourism Secretary and current Chairman of the Pacific Area Travel Association 13<br />

SERVICES THE BIG WINNER FROM SAFTA: Australia's new Free Trade Agreement with Singapore is expected to bring immediate benefits for<br />

those involved in the finance, business services and education sectors, says Simon Taskunas, a solicitor with Freehills in Perth 17<br />

Everyone will be<br />

talking the same language.<br />

Business.<br />

Expand your international networks, forge trade relations and identify new opportunities.<br />

The <strong>Asia</strong> Pacific Cities Summit brings business and government together to discuss<br />

mutually beneficial opportunities, issues and set long term goals. The only forum of its<br />

kind in the <strong>Asia</strong>-Pacific region, it’s a great opportunity for you to meet with some of the<br />

region’s brightest minds, make new contacts and do business. This year’s topic is Emerging<br />

Futures of the City - focusing on the key issues which affect quality of life and economic<br />

opportunities in our cities.<br />

Numbers are limited so to ensure your place in the future of regional business, visit<br />

www.apcsummit.org or call +61 7 3403 6179 for an information pack.<br />

Register online now by visiting<br />

www.apcsummit.org<br />

An initiative of<br />

In partnership with<br />

20 - 22 October 2003<br />

Brisbane Queensland Australia<br />

BUP0000078<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003 3


TNT Delivers<br />

to and from over 200 countries around the globe.<br />

Importing swimwear from Taipei<br />

Exporting toys to Paris<br />

TNT <strong>International</strong> offers you a faster and<br />

more reliable freight service to and from<br />

over 200 countries worldwide.<br />

Well over one hundred flights arrive into<br />

Australia each week carrying time-sensitive<br />

freight for TNT <strong>International</strong> customers.<br />

An equal number of departures leaving<br />

Australia take shipments worldwide.<br />

TNT <strong>International</strong> provides its customers<br />

with advanced technology capabilities that<br />

deliver cutting-edge track and trace functions.<br />

This allows you to track your consignment<br />

from pick-up to delivery.<br />

For faster and more reliable imports and<br />

exports call TNT <strong>International</strong> on<br />

13 11 50


OPINION<br />

IN JANUARY 2001, then-<br />

President BJ Habibie undertook<br />

the Big Bang — the decentralisation of<br />

power to Indonesia's regions.<br />

It was a bold gamble by Habibie to quell<br />

growing political unrest in the provinces<br />

during the chaotic post-Soeharto days. But<br />

from the very beginning, it was obvious<br />

that Indonesia was far from ready for<br />

devolution. Most crucially, the laws that<br />

were to set the rules for the regions were<br />

not properly in place.<br />

Since then, Jakarta has bumbled along —<br />

resolving some problems while others<br />

remain. A key issue is the question of revenue<br />

raising and taxes. In the early days,<br />

inexperienced local level bureaucrats took<br />

advantage of the right to raise revenue to<br />

impose their own taxes, including wildcat<br />

taxes, especially in resource-rich regions.<br />

The targets were often foreign investors.<br />

They created an extremely unpredictable<br />

business environment.<br />

The World Bank undertook a review of<br />

Indonesia's Big Bang in a report published<br />

in July. In it, the Bank says that<br />

mending weaknesses in the various regulations<br />

will take time. Amendments are<br />

required in key sectors, namely laws and<br />

perhaps even the constitution.<br />

Quite simply, the present system<br />

is not working, says the<br />

Bank. The current legislation<br />

allows local governments to<br />

issue regional taxes as long as<br />

they comply with the principle<br />

stated in the decentralisation<br />

law. The regions have strong<br />

incentives to impose improper<br />

taxes and levies and Jakarta<br />

does not have the capacity to<br />

supervise, nor the willingness<br />

to cancel, illegal taxes, says the<br />

report.<br />

The way forward, it suggests, is to<br />

restrict regional taxes and levies to a limited<br />

closed list. At the same time the<br />

regions should be granted additional taxing<br />

powers more suited to a local administration.<br />

The report says land and building<br />

tax, considered a local tax in most<br />

countries around the world, is one such<br />

potential tax. In Indonesia, Jakarta<br />

shares revenue from this tax with the<br />

regions.<br />

A further option is to strengthen the<br />

regions’ own revenue base by increasing<br />

the maximum rate allowed on existing<br />

BJ HABIBE’S ‘BIG BANG’<br />

Revisiting Indonesia’s regional tax laws<br />

FLORENCE<br />

CHONG<br />

REMAKING CHINATEX<br />

CHINA'S National Textile<br />

Imports and Exports<br />

Corporation is buying up<br />

offshore cotton plantations<br />

and will be seeking<br />

to acquire interests in<br />

companies engaged in<br />

fashion design in Europe,<br />

the US and Japan . . .<br />

By FLORENCE CHONG<br />

Editor ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL<br />

THE TASK BEFORE Zhao Boya is<br />

considerable. He is charged with<br />

transforming a traditional foreign trade company<br />

into a diversified group involved in the<br />

manufacture of branded garments and in the<br />

production and export of fabrics.<br />

As President and Chief Executive of China<br />

National Textile Imports and Exports<br />

Corporation, known as Chinatex, Zhao sees<br />

China owning companies engaged in design in<br />

Europe, the United States and Japan.<br />

Over the next five years, Chinatex will<br />

increase investment onshore and offshore. This<br />

will include acquisition of cotton plantations<br />

overseas (including Australia) to feed its<br />

expanding manufacturing operations at home.<br />

Central to the plan is restructuring of the<br />

Zhao Boya:<br />

China will expand into the branded goods business.<br />

State-owned enterprise from a monolithic,<br />

anachronistic body into a dynamic 21st century<br />

company. Since taking over the helm in 1998,<br />

taxes. Rate for regional taxes<br />

such as car, hotel and restaurant<br />

surcharges are limited by<br />

Jakarta, and almost all regional<br />

governments charge the maximum<br />

rate allowed.<br />

While the central government<br />

should probably continue<br />

setting a ceiling on local taxes,<br />

the report also says that new<br />

local taxes could be considered.<br />

It is being debated in Indonesia<br />

today whether the regions<br />

should be entitled to a<br />

surcharge on personal income tax and<br />

local business taxes or payroll tax.<br />

Understandably a poor country like<br />

Indonesia, especially the resource-poor<br />

regions, need all the revenue possible to<br />

cover public expenditure. But local<br />

governments must learn from the bigger<br />

regions that to be seen to be rapacious is<br />

the surest way to remain poor.<br />

Without business confidence, there<br />

will be no investment, and no investment<br />

means no tax revenue.<br />

■ Bank Mandiri IPO may set trend for<br />

investors, page 11.<br />

BRAND NAMES<br />

THE KEY -<br />

AND CHINA<br />

IS BUYING . . .<br />

Zhao has overseen a gradual<br />

shift away from trading to an<br />

expanded range of activities.<br />

The <strong>remaking</strong> of Chinatex<br />

underlines the urgent change<br />

facing China's many Stateowned<br />

foreign trading corporations,<br />

set up to trade<br />

in commodities.<br />

Like all foreign trade companies,<br />

when created in 1951<br />

Chinatex became a window to<br />

the world. In the intervening<br />

years, Chinatex has grown to<br />

be a billion-dollar company.<br />

Zhao says Chinatex has an<br />

annual turnover of US$1<br />

billion and assets valued at<br />

US$1 billion. About 70 per<br />

cent of revenue comes from<br />

trade and 30 per cent from<br />

other businesses.<br />

But such anachronistic foreign<br />

trade companies belong<br />

to an era when China was a<br />

closed economy. They are a<br />

contradiction in a China that is moving<br />

quickly to integrate with the global economy.<br />

Continued page 6<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003 5


ISSN 1445-4300<br />

PUBLISHER<br />

Barry Pearton<br />

EDITOR<br />

Florence Chong<br />

Volume 21, No. 4, August/September 2003<br />

CORRESPONDENTS<br />

Hong Kong – K.K. Chadha, James Yapp,<br />

India – N. Hariharan, Rajendra Bajpai; Indonesia –<br />

Tom McCawley; Japan – Russell McCulloch;<br />

Malaysia – Ronnie Tan; Pakistan – M. Ziauddin;<br />

Philippines – Abby Tan; Singapore – Andrew Symon;<br />

Taiwan – Matthew Smith; Thailand – Robert Horn;<br />

Indo-China – Steve Joel.<br />

ADVERTISING<br />

REPRESENTATIVES<br />

AUSTRALIA<br />

Sydney: ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL, Level 29<br />

Chifley Tower, 2 Chifley Square, Sydney NSW 2000.<br />

tel (61 2) 9970-6477. fax (61 2) 9913-2003. Email:<br />

asiatoday@bigpond.com Visit www.asiatoday.com.au<br />

Brisbane: The Media Workshop, Suite 3, 211<br />

Logan Road, Woolloongabba QLD 4102. Tel (61 7)<br />

3391-6633, Fax (61 7) 3891-5602.<br />

Contact: John McDonald<br />

email John McD@Themediaworkshop.com.au<br />

Adelaide: HWR Media Specialists, 109<br />

Conyngham Street, Frewville SA 5063. Tel (61 8)<br />

8379-9522, Fax (61 8) 8379-9735. Contact: Terese<br />

Brandau-Stranks, email: tbrandaustranks@hwrmedia.com.au<br />

Perth: Hogan Media Services, PO Box 849,<br />

Applecross, Canning Bridge WA 6153. Tel (61 8)<br />

9315-9223. Fax (61 8) 9315-9224. Contact: Brenna<br />

Learmonth. email brenna@hoganmedia.com.au<br />

OVERSEAS<br />

Hong Kong/China: Top Rider Communications<br />

Co, Room 1205 Carnival Commercial Building, 18<br />

Java Road, North Point, Hong Kong. Tel (852) 2887-<br />

6238, Fax (852) 2578-2688. email<br />

trider@ctimail3.com Contact: Katharine Lee.<br />

India: Times Response, 2nd Floor, The Times of<br />

India Building, Dr D N Road, Mumbai 400 001. Tel (91<br />

22) 273-1154, 235-3574, 235-3636. Fax (91 22) 273-<br />

1145, 273-1948. Contact: Victor David Sassoon,<br />

General Manager, <strong>International</strong> Media Representation,<br />

email victor.sassoon@timesgroup.com Also in New<br />

Delhi, tel (91 11) 349-2064, fax (91 11) 349-2108;<br />

Bangalore, tel (91 80) 559-7473 fax (91 80) 558-<br />

6732; Chennai, tel (91 44) 434-2121, fax (91 44)<br />

432-3636; Calcutta, tel (91 33) 248-5502, fax (91 33)<br />

220-8627.<br />

Indonesia: PT Medianet IntiSarana, Aurum<br />

Building, 1st Floor, Jl Ampera Raya No 37, Cilandak,<br />

Jakarta 12560. Tel (62 21) 7884-5705, Fax (62 21)<br />

7884-5704. Contact: Prilly Brahmana, email: mediana@centrin.net.id<br />

INTERNATIONAL<br />

®<br />

Japan: Nikkei <strong>International</strong> Ltd., 1-9-5 Otemachi<br />

Chiyoda-ku Toyko 100-8066. Tel (81 3) 5255-0751, Fax<br />

(81 3) 5255-0752 Contact Ken Machida, email:<br />

kenichi.machida@nex.nikkei.co.jp<br />

Korea: BISCOM, 521 Midopa Building, 145 Dangjudong,<br />

Chongno-ku, Seoul. 110-071. Tel (82 2) 739-<br />

7840, Fax (82 2) 732-3662, email: biscom@unitel.com.kr<br />

Philippines: Eastgate Publishing Corporation, 704<br />

Prestige Tower Condominium, Emerald Avenue, Ortigas<br />

Center, Pasig City 1605, Philippines. Tel (63 2) 633-<br />

4004-6, Fax (63 2) 635-9221, email:<br />

lorie@eastgateph.com<br />

Contact: Lorie Fernandez.<br />

Singapore: Pacom Media Pte Ltd, 52 Foch Road<br />

#02-01, Singapore 209274. Email:<br />

pacom@pacific.net.au Tel (65) 392-3188, Fax (65) 392-<br />

3086. Contact: Karen Chan.<br />

Taiwan: Spacemark Media Services, 2nd Fl, 22-18,<br />

Section 1, Chang-An East Road, Taipei, Taiwan. Tel<br />

(886 2) 2522 2282, Fax (886 2) 2522 2281. Contact:<br />

Tammy Hsu.<br />

Thailand: Joel Publicity, Suite 3, 8th Floor, Suriwong<br />

Business Centre, Panjaphut Building, Suriwong Road.<br />

Bangkok 10500. Tel (66 2) 236 4984/5, Fax (66 2) 238<br />

4971. Contact: Steve Joel.<br />

PUBLISHER’S REPRESENTATIVES<br />

USA/CANADA<br />

InterMark3 <strong>International</strong> Communications, Inc.<br />

5929 Albervan Street, Shawnee, KS 66216 USA.<br />

Tel (91 3) 248-7770, Fax (91 3) 248-7771<br />

Contact: Fred Baehner,<br />

email: fbaehner@mail.intermark3.com<br />

EUROPE<br />

LIVEpr, 4th Floor, 124 Victoria Street, London SW1E<br />

5LA United Kingdom. Tel (44 20) 7630-1100, Fax (44<br />

870) 121-5572, email asiatoday@livepr.net<br />

Contact: Ross Clarke, David Wallen.<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL ONLINE<br />

The full text of ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL back to July<br />

1993 is available on-line through LEXIS-NEXIS. For details,<br />

visit the LEXIS NEXIS website at www.lexis-nexis.com<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL is available from Proquest<br />

Information and Learning in one of the following formats:<br />

microform or electronic. For details, visit the Proquest home<br />

page at www.umi.com or email UNU@umi.uk.com<br />

Visit us at www.asiatoday.com.au<br />

COPYRIGHT© All material in ASIA TODAY<br />

INTERNATIONAL is copyright.<br />

Reproduction in whole or in part is not permitted without<br />

written permission of the publisher.<br />

Member of Circulations Audit Board<br />

Audited nett circulation, 8,424 copies per<br />

issue (12 months to March 2003)<br />

From page 5<br />

THE CHINATEX PLAN<br />

Chinatex's role was – and is – to import wool<br />

and cotton to feed the Chinese textile industry<br />

which, in turn, produces the raw materials<br />

needed to run its large garment-making sector.<br />

Chinatex then exports garments to China's markets<br />

around the world.<br />

But Chinatex has already moved a long way<br />

from its original role. <strong>Today</strong>, it has more than<br />

30 subsidiaries and overseas enterprises, and<br />

40 manufacturing plants. The businesses cover<br />

production and sale of all textiles, ranging from<br />

raw materials, yarns and fabric to readymade<br />

garments.<br />

Zhao has no illusion that the long-term<br />

future of Chinatex lies in its ability to adapt<br />

to changes in both the global and<br />

Chinese economies.<br />

Chinatex has hired strategy consultants<br />

Roland Berger from Germany to map out a<br />

strategic plan for the next five years. The<br />

review emphasises that garments will remain<br />

the core strategic business, but the plan calls<br />

for increased trading activities which will be<br />

complemented by investment – especially to<br />

build up brand names.<br />

❝Chinatex has already<br />

moved a long way<br />

from its original role. It<br />

has more than 30 subsidiaries<br />

and overseas<br />

enterprises, and 40<br />

manufacturing plants.❞<br />

"China is not known for international brand<br />

names. We are seen as a processor rather than<br />

a maker of branded goods," Zhao says. He is<br />

seeking design capability through investment<br />

in well-established design companies in<br />

Europe, the US and Japan.<br />

As an example, the Chinatex subsidiary in<br />

Germany, Mode Contor Hamburg Chinatex,<br />

will engage fashion designers from Germany<br />

and Denmark to help launch Chinatex into the<br />

world of high fashion. Last year, Chinatex<br />

signed an agency agreement with Tom Tailor<br />

of Germany, a company known for its casual<br />

wear, and said to be the "latest brand for the<br />

young in Europe and the US". Under the agreement,<br />

Chinatex will be responsible for production,<br />

allocation, promotion and sales of Tom<br />

Tailor products in China.<br />

"We think it will be difficult to parade<br />

internationally-known brands in China<br />

because fashion comes from Europe and the<br />

United States," says Zhao. Chinatex will<br />

expand into the branded goods business both<br />

through training of its own staff and by<br />

acquiring mid-sized brand names in Europe<br />

and Japan. Chinatex has interests in two companies<br />

in the US – one based in Los Angeles,<br />

the other in New York. It is continuing to look<br />

for acquisitions.<br />

Over the next five years, Zhao expects the<br />

Group to spend up to US$200 million investing<br />

to broaden its business base. "This is only a<br />

rough plan," he explains. "But we hope to<br />

invest in two kinds of operations within five<br />

years or more. One is to buy some mature<br />

Continued page 7<br />

6<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003


BUSINESS OUTLOOK: CHINA<br />

SQUARING UP TO HK PROBLEMS<br />

From page 6<br />

businesses in China to enlarge our capability in<br />

producing, retailing garments and finishing<br />

fabrics. The second is to buy mature businesses<br />

in overseas countries, especially in<br />

Europe, the US and Hong Kong. (This will<br />

enable us) to build up our international<br />

name brand garments, retailing networks<br />

and design capability – for both our domestic<br />

and global markets."<br />

As China's standard of living rises, Zhao sees<br />

a growing market at home. Chinatex intends to<br />

meet China's growing demand for quality garments,<br />

which will be driven by the middle<br />

class. Chinatex will also give priority to fabrics.<br />

Its corporate aim is to become one of China's<br />

"most influential" fabric suppliers, working<br />

closely with dealers in key markets. It also<br />

seeks a higher share of the domestic market.<br />

"We want to produce combed wool for the<br />

production of woollen fabrics and garments,"<br />

he says. Chinatex will also invest in factories,<br />

and already has a target acquisition in South<br />

China. He says Chinatex will become a producer<br />

of woollen fabrics.<br />

Chinatex is a key player today in the import<br />

of raw wool to China. Zhao says the company<br />

is responsible for one quarter of all wool<br />

purchased from Australia, worth a total of<br />

AUD1.5 billion last year. Australia has onethird<br />

of the Chinese wool market. China also<br />

imports wool from New Zealand, South<br />

America and South Africa.<br />

As part of its internal restructuring, Zhao says<br />

Chinatex wool-buying operations will be<br />

streamlined. Since 1982, the company has<br />

operated Chinatex (Aus) Wool Co Pty Ltd,<br />

based in Sydney, to bid for Australian wool.<br />

This company secures half of Chinatex's total<br />

imports from Australia. The other half is handled<br />

by another Chinatex company, based in<br />

Beijing. From next year, says Zhao, there will<br />

be just one company, headed by Gong Zheng-<br />

Yi, who is currently Managing Director of the<br />

Sydney-based firm.<br />

At around US$200 million a year, Zhao says<br />

Chinatex's wool business is smaller than its<br />

US$250-million-a-year cotton business. "We<br />

export cotton, but not woollen products," he<br />

says. Cotton products range from fabrics to garments<br />

to raw yarns and manchester.<br />

Currently, Zhao says, Chinatex owns three<br />

cotton spinning and weaving factories which<br />

have 200,000 spindles and about 2,000 weaving<br />

looms. "We have capacity to produce<br />

around 15 million pieces of garments now.<br />

This makes us one of the largest manufacturers,<br />

he says. Chinatex also buys from other Chinese<br />

manufacturers, giving it a total annual volume<br />

of 30 million pieces.<br />

Since 1996, Chinatex has been investing in<br />

cotton farms in Australia. With its latest acquisitions,<br />

says Zhao, Chinatex will have a total of<br />

four farms, covering 50 sq km, located in<br />

Moree, northern NSW.<br />

Of China's accession to WTO, Zhao says:<br />

"If we didn't join the WTO, we would not<br />

enjoy the benefits of global agreements<br />

shared by WTO members – especially after<br />

the quota system for the textile trade is<br />

abandoned." Under the Agreement on<br />

Textiles and Clothing (ATC), negotiated during<br />

the Uruguay Round, WTO members are<br />

to abandon a quota system, which has dominated<br />

the global textile trade since the early<br />

1960s, by 2004. By 2005, importing<br />

countries will no longer be able to<br />

discriminate between exporters.<br />

In fact, the ATC itself will no<br />

longer exist.<br />

As a developing economy, China<br />

was a beneficiary of the quota system,<br />

although increasingly it has lost<br />

preferential treatment under that system.<br />

However, under plans initiated<br />

by the European Union, least developed<br />

countries continue to have<br />

preferential access to developed<br />

markets. Other developed countries,<br />

including the United States and Australia, also<br />

offer special access to their markets for leastdeveloped<br />

countries.<br />

In terms of scale of economy and availability<br />

of labour, China ranks as the most competitive<br />

player in the garments and textiles sector.<br />

According to the World Trade Organisation,<br />

China held 11.4 per cent of global exports trade<br />

in textiles in 2001, compared with 6.9 per cent<br />

in 1990. In value, China's export trade<br />

Zhao Boya:<br />

Buying one quarter of all<br />

wool purchased from<br />

Australia.<br />

amounted to almost US$17 billion.<br />

China imported food worth<br />

US$15.43 billion, or 10.9 per cent of<br />

the global import share.<br />

"Until 2004, (we will not be able)<br />

to have a scientific idea about the<br />

competitiveness of different countries<br />

– because of the quota system,"<br />

says Zhou. "But once the quota system<br />

is gone, we will have a better<br />

idea of which countries are the most<br />

competitive producers." Zhao says<br />

China has the advantage of having a<br />

competent and skilled workforce.<br />

He says the Chinese Government would like<br />

to see China keep its position as a major player<br />

in the global market. Certainly, he says, over the<br />

next 10 to 20 years the sector will continue to<br />

be an important employer of Chinese workers.<br />

COPYRIGHT ©: All material in ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL is<br />

copyright and remains the property of the publisher, East <strong>Asia</strong><br />

New and Features (Australia) Pty. Limited. Reproduction in<br />

whole or in part is not permitted without written permission of<br />

the publisher.<br />

More 'freedom' for HK<br />

HONG KONG will be given<br />

more freedom in a solution<br />

to the current crisis which<br />

is fashioned to both reinforce<br />

China's emerging<br />

status on the international<br />

stage and to play for<br />

domestic consumption,<br />

according to a leading student<br />

of Chinese affairs . . .<br />

BEIJING IS EXPECTED to use a<br />

variation of the dramatic exit formula<br />

it employed after bungling the SARS outbreak<br />

to hopefully restore the confidence of<br />

Hong Kong people in China’s leadership,<br />

according to China analyst Jonathan Story.<br />

Since the Tung Administration<br />

pushed to pass a National Security<br />

Bill, known locally as Article 23,<br />

Hong Kong has been gripped by distrust<br />

of and anger towards its<br />

Government. The controversy has<br />

become the most serious challenge<br />

to the leadership of Chief Executive<br />

Tung Chee-hwa.<br />

Story says Beijing realises that if<br />

the Hong Kong situation is not<br />

resolved, it has the potential to<br />

become a major problem — with<br />

implications for the Mainland itself. "The population<br />

(in Hong Kong) is disturbed, and, unless<br />

managed properly, this will become a major<br />

political problem," Story told ASIA TODAY<br />

INTERNATIONAL. If the past is a guide, some<br />

face-saving operation will be needed."<br />

Story, whose latest book, China: The Race<br />

to Market, has just been released, has specialised<br />

in observing the transformation of<br />

command to market economies over three<br />

Jonathan Story:<br />

China learned the hard<br />

way in the SARS crisis.<br />

decades. He believes Beijing is involved in<br />

behind-closed-door negotiations with Tung<br />

and Hong Kong opposition leaders to seek a<br />

solution to the imbroglio.<br />

"Over the next four weeks, I expect China to<br />

find a face-saving way out of the crisis in Hong<br />

Kong," says Story, who is Professor of<br />

<strong>International</strong> Political Economy at INSEAD, the<br />

leading French academic institution. Beijing<br />

will resolve the political controversy in Hong<br />

Kong, he says, because it is confronted by the<br />

reality of China's inclusion in the global village.<br />

China learned the hard way in the handling<br />

of the SARS crisis. Its initial denial led to global<br />

condemnation of government inaction.<br />

Stung by the criticism, Beijing took drastic<br />

action, including the sacking of Health<br />

Minister Zhang Wenkang and Beijing's mayor,<br />

Meng Xeunong. Story expects Beijing to seek<br />

an "exit" from the Hong Kong imbroglio in<br />

similar dramatic fashion.<br />

Asked whether Tung will be<br />

replaced, Story says the most likely<br />

outcome will be to elevate Tung to a<br />

more "honorable" position, and to<br />

install a Secretary who will be, in<br />

effect, the Chief Executive. He says<br />

the manner in which China resolves<br />

the Hong Kong problem will be<br />

fashioned partly to reinforce its<br />

emerging status on the international<br />

stage. But, more importantly, it will<br />

play for domestic consumption.<br />

The upshot will be a Hong Kong<br />

that is given more freedom — but<br />

that can come about only if there is a degree of<br />

confidence and trust between the Mainland<br />

and the democratic movement in Hong Kong,<br />

says Story. "If there is a breakdown in confidence<br />

there will be repercussions for Beijing —<br />

and China's credibility could suffer. My hunch<br />

is that an awful lot of effort is now under way<br />

to allow Hong Kong to live as a more open<br />

Continued page 8<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003 7


CHINA MUDDLING THROUGH<br />

OCEANIA<br />

From page 7<br />

society." While the hard-line Article 23 will<br />

remain, some compromise will be reached that<br />

the people of Hong Kong can accept. Story<br />

also believes Hong Kong will move towards<br />

domestic election of a Chief Administrator in<br />

2007, as stated in the Basic Law.<br />

His rationale is that 2007 is the year before<br />

the 2008 Beijing Olympics — an event that can<br />

cement China's position in the global community.<br />

In 1962, Japan hosted the Games, and this<br />

marked a turning point for Japan — it began to<br />

"invade" the world with its products. In 1988,<br />

South Korea played Games host — an event<br />

that was credited for ushering in an end to martial<br />

law and the beginning of democratisation.<br />

"I anticipate subtle changes in the (Chinese)<br />

Government between now and the Olympics,<br />

and this does not exclude political changes,"<br />

says Story. He expects an improvement in<br />

China's handling of human right issues, leading<br />

eventually to more transparency — a step<br />

towards a more open society.<br />

Since the early 1990s, direct elections have<br />

been held in China at village level. Story says<br />

these elections are very important, born out<br />

of necessity to appease agitated peasants<br />

infuriated with the practices and corruption<br />

of local government officials. And Shenzhen,<br />

the first coastal economic zone, will learn<br />

from Hong Kong to improve local governance.<br />

The fundamental glue holding China<br />

together today is its party state — and Hong<br />

Kong is an exception.<br />

8<br />

23 years of<br />

Award-winning<br />

Services to <strong>Asia</strong><br />

FREIGHT RATE HOTLINE 1800 000 686<br />

Shippers in the know ship COSCO<br />

– for Five Star Customer Service!<br />

Reliability and Service.<br />

A great Five Star tradition.<br />

Five Star Shipping and Agency Company Pty Ltd<br />

(a wholly-owned COSCO Group Company)<br />

Sydney: Tel (02) 9373 9588 Fax (02) 9299 7988<br />

Melbourne: Tel (03) 9258 2600 Fax (03) 9614 6260<br />

Brisbane: Tel (07) 3215 1100 Fax (07) 3220 0234<br />

Fremantle: Tel (08) 9336 4238 Fax (08) 9336 4231<br />

Adelaide: Burns Philp Shipping Tel (08) 8447 5655 Fax (08) 8341 1827<br />

Ship COSCO for Five Star Service<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003<br />

❝I anticipate subtle<br />

changes in (the<br />

Chinese) Government<br />

between now and the<br />

Olympics, and this<br />

does not exclude<br />

political changes❞<br />

Chinese people do not wish to revisit the<br />

past, says Story. Millions of Chinese have<br />

markedly raised their standard of living. China<br />

has muddled through to get to where it is, and<br />

Story expects it will continue to muddle<br />

through in future, dealing with partial reforms,<br />

and hoping that millions more of its people<br />

will enjoy greater prosperity.<br />

China has to manage itself as it opens its<br />

market, says Story. One lesson came with the<br />

massive April 1999 demonstrations by the<br />

Falungong cult, which used mobile phones to<br />

rally its members. Market reform has contributed<br />

to promoting conditions for a more<br />

garrulous society. At the same time, the<br />

monopoly of the party State is shrinking.<br />

China's leadership wants to succeed — and has<br />

done so, so far.<br />

Political changes will be gradual, says Story,<br />

because China will not go for the Big Bang —<br />

the way Society leader Mikhail Gorbachev<br />

introduced glasnost (openness) under perestroika,<br />

a programme of economic, political<br />

and social restructuring.<br />

Story says events in Indonesia in 1998,<br />

although Indonesia was not a communist<br />

country, shocked China. "Indonesia is a 'patrimonial<br />

society' that was forced into rapid<br />

changes in the wake of the 1997 financial<br />

Continued page 9


BUSINESS OUTLOOK<br />

BEIJING PRESSURED TO REVALUE<br />

From page 8<br />

crisis. The speed of political and economic<br />

reforms has set Indonesia back, he says (the<br />

standard of living has fallen to a post-1997<br />

level). "The interesting question is how far<br />

Indonesia can go now."<br />

He expects China to be more pro-active in<br />

geopolitical issues, and says the most critical<br />

issue today is North Korea. On its own, and<br />

with limited resources, Beijing realises that it<br />

has to work with other nations, most notably<br />

the United States. He says relations with<br />

Washington warmed considerably when<br />

former president Jiang Zemin called George<br />

W Bush the day after the September 11 attack<br />

on New York and Washington.<br />

As the last surviving Communist state, China<br />

does not have a model on which to go forward.<br />

It has come too far to turn back to pre-<br />

1978, when China embarked on its open door<br />

policies. Story says the Chinese will have to<br />

learn by experimentation. Its approach to market<br />

and political reform has been exploratory.<br />

This explains why huge diversity of practice<br />

across China exists.<br />

S&P puts Hong Kong<br />

ratings on watch<br />

WHATEVER the political outcome<br />

of protests in Hong Kong, sovereign<br />

ratings will depend on the<br />

Government's ability to tackle fiscal overruns<br />

successfully, while pursuing a coherent<br />

macro-economic mix, Standard & Poor's said<br />

in a statement. The ratings will also depend<br />

on Hong Kong maintaining its fiscal,<br />

economic and financial autonomy.<br />

The ratings agency said major public misgivings<br />

include the Government's inability to<br />

correctly identify problems, co-ordinate or<br />

design policies consistently and transparently,<br />

and articulate a coherent strategy.<br />

"Going forward, the Administration will have<br />

to adapt to and accommodate this political culture,<br />

which calls for more open governance<br />

and public debate," S&P said, adding that this<br />

year's budget deficit was likely to widen to<br />

more than 7 per cent of GDP because of the<br />

SARS outbreak. "Better governance in future,<br />

as perceived by the public and investors, might<br />

boost confidence and help sustain a recovery."<br />

S&P said current political development<br />

remains fluid. "Without sufficient support in<br />

the legislature, the Government would be<br />

largely ineffective, and this would lead to a<br />

worse policy environment. Alternatively, a<br />

more reduced role could be envisaged for<br />

(Chief Executive Tung Chee-hwa) in order to<br />

mollify the public.<br />

"If Mr Tung steps down, which is likely to<br />

occur only with the nod from Beijing, policy<br />

uncertainty could be alleviated by a Beijingsanctioned<br />

successor plan, or at least an<br />

interim Government that depends on the<br />

existing bureaucracy," S & P said.<br />

HK banks to trade yuan<br />

■ CHINA is reportedly considering allowing<br />

Hong Kong lenders to provide personal yuan<br />

banking services to Hong Kong residents in an<br />

extension of the new Closer Economic<br />

Partnership Arrangement with Hong Kong.<br />

'Risky' to float the yuan<br />

A REPORT from Morgan<br />

Stanley's Chief Economist,<br />

Stephen Roach, urges<br />

China to resist pressure for<br />

a revaluation. It says Japan<br />

has led the way in Chinabashing<br />

over the past year<br />

. . .<br />

BEIJING HAS AGAIN come under<br />

pressure to revalue its currency following<br />

recent devaluation of the US dollar.<br />

Critics argue that the weaken US currency has<br />

given China an unfair competitive edge in the<br />

global market. The currency is unofficially<br />

pegged at around 8.30 renmibi to a dollar.<br />

Stephen Roach, Chief Economist with<br />

Morgan Stanley in New York, was in China in<br />

July and firmly believes Beijing should not bow<br />

to pressure. “Assuming the dollar has a good<br />

deal further to go on the downside, as I suspect<br />

— perhaps as much as 20 per cent over<br />

the next couple of years — most believe that<br />

China’s current competitive advantage will<br />

become all the more pronounced,” he writes in<br />

a recent report, The Scapegoating of China.<br />

Roach says the Chinese are acutely sensitive<br />

to global opinion, and are quite concerned at<br />

this obvious shift in sentiment. “Although<br />

Chinese officials remain unwavering in their<br />

commitment to the renminbi’s peg, I was asked<br />

repeatedly for my thoughts on how to handle<br />

this delicate issue. I urged the Chinese to stay<br />

the course — to leave their RMB policy<br />

unchanged,” he says.<br />

China does not compete on the basis of an<br />

undervalued currency, he adds. It competes<br />

mainly in terms of labour costs, technology,<br />

quality control, infrastructure and reform. He<br />

believes that if China was to revalue the RMB<br />

upward by 10 per cent, its exports would suffer<br />

only minimal loss of market share.<br />

Until China completely reforms its capital<br />

markets, it would be premature and risky to<br />

float its currency, says Roach. “That’s a critical<br />

lesson of the <strong>Asia</strong>n financial crisis that an impatient<br />

world should not lose sight of when putting<br />

pressure on China.”<br />

The general perception is that China is grabbing<br />

the world’s exports market. Roach (and<br />

many other prominent economists espouse<br />

the same view) argues that Chinese subsidiaries<br />

of global multinationals — and<br />

Chinese joint ventures with industrial-world<br />

partners — accounted for 65 per of China’s<br />

total exports from 1994 to 2003. In that time,<br />

China’s annual exports soared from US$121 billion<br />

to US$365.4 billion.<br />

Roach is scathing of those countries which<br />

are critical of China’s currency policy.<br />

“Unwilling to accept responsibility for their<br />

own shortcomings, the wealthy economies of<br />

the industrial world are making China a scapegoat<br />

for their weak recoveries,” he says. “That’s<br />

especially true of Japan, which has led the way<br />

in China-bashing over the past year.”<br />

Roach points out that the Japanese yen averaged<br />

close to 300 yen against the US dollar in<br />

the 1970s and about 220 yen in the 1980s —<br />

compared to the 115-120 range today. “It<br />

strikes me as extremely hypocritical for Japan<br />

to criticise China for emulating a strategy that<br />

was central to its own development model,” he<br />

says. “Putting pressure on China to revalue its<br />

currency is a poor excuse for Japan’s inability<br />

or unwillingness to reform.”<br />

He is equally critical of the motives of<br />

Washington. America’s largest trade deficit is<br />

now with China — a US$103 billion shortfall in<br />

2002, and on track to exceed that amount in<br />

2003. Roach argues that trade deficits should<br />

not come as a surprise for a savings-short US<br />

economy. “If America weren’t trading with<br />

China, those deficits would have to occur with<br />

other nations — Canada, Mexico, other Latin<br />

economies, Japan, or possibly even Europe. If<br />

the United States wants to reduce its trade<br />

deficit, it must come to grips with more fundamental<br />

problems of its own — namely, a<br />

rapidly-vanishing national savings rate,” he says.<br />

One-off lift likely<br />

■ ABN AMRO says Chinese authorities will try<br />

to keep the US$/RMB exchange rate steady as<br />

far as possible, and that when they do let the<br />

RMB appreciate, it is likely to be a one-off<br />

move of 15-20 per cent. The bank says there is<br />

now US$151 billion in foreign currency<br />

deposits in banks in China. If the Bank of<br />

China announced overnight a widening of the<br />

exchange rate band or allowed a gradual<br />

appreciation, China corporates and individuals<br />

would be unlikely to continue keeping their<br />

money in US$.<br />

"The People's Bank of China is now buying<br />

US$600 million every day to keep the currency<br />

steady," ABN AMRO says, adding that two factors<br />

are holding back the decision to allow the<br />

RMB to appreciate. The Chinese government is<br />

still concerned about deflation - it will want to<br />

see higher inflation before giving up the unofficial<br />

peg; and there is no guarantee that the<br />

speculative capital inflow would disppear after<br />

a 15-20 per cent appreciation.<br />

China to capture<br />

electronics growth<br />

CHINA IS EXPECTED to capture<br />

77 per cent of an estimated US$60<br />

billion increase in electronics manufacturing<br />

in emerging markets by 2005, says a new<br />

report from the <strong>International</strong> Finance<br />

Corporation.<br />

China's share of global production will then<br />

exceed that of Western Europe. Engineering<br />

and design will also move to emerging markets<br />

– with labour costs up to 80 per cent<br />

lower than developed regions, says the IFC.<br />

The study by IFC and management<br />

Continued page 10<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003 9


BUSINESS OUTLOOK<br />

ELECTRONICS - WHERE THE GROWTH IS<br />

From page 9<br />

consulting firm Booz Allen Hamilton, found<br />

that electronics production activity in emerging<br />

markets will nearly double, from US$65 billion<br />

in 2001 to US$125 billion by 2005 – and will<br />

account for 43 per cent of total worldwide<br />

manufacturing growth. More than threefourths<br />

(77 per cent) of the growth in developing<br />

countries will be in China, with China<br />

increasing its share of global electronics production<br />

from eight to 14 per cent, a growth<br />

rate twice as fast as any other country.<br />

The study estimates that electronics production<br />

in China will be a US$80 billion<br />

business by 2005. Emerging market growth<br />

outside of China will be primarily in other<br />

developing Southeast <strong>Asia</strong>n countries,<br />

Eastern Europe and Mexico.<br />

Gains in developing countries will not be<br />

limited to manufacturing. Higher-value services<br />

such as engineering and design functions<br />

will increasingly migrate to developing<br />

nations over the next few years, although<br />

this transition will trail the more rapid shift<br />

in production.<br />

India and Russia in particular have an abundance<br />

of highly-skilled labour, with labour<br />

costs up to 80 per cent lower than in the<br />

developed world.<br />

The SARS epidemic has raised concern<br />

about economic growth in China and other<br />

emerging markets. However, a follow-up to<br />

the original survey found that most respondents<br />

expect SARS to have a very limited and<br />

only temporary effect on the shift of electronics<br />

production towards developing markets.<br />

According to 22 per cent<br />

of senior executives surveyed,<br />

SARS should have no<br />

impact on the movement of<br />

electronics manufacturing to<br />

China, 64 per cent expect<br />

only a slight temporary<br />

impact, and only 14 per<br />

cent expect it to have even<br />

a moderate impact on this<br />

trend. None of the respondents<br />

expect SARS to have a<br />

significant impact on the<br />

long-term growth of electronics production in<br />

developing markets.<br />

"This dramatic increase in production clearly<br />

demonstrates the growing strength of<br />

emerging markets," said Dick Ranken, director<br />

of IFC's Global Manufacturing and Services<br />

Department. "In fact, a main driver of this<br />

trend is the rising importance of economies<br />

such as China as end-user markets for these<br />

products, which increases their competitive<br />

advantage in the manufacturing process."<br />

"Emerging markets offer cost savings that<br />

are critical for survival in today's hyper-competitive<br />

environment," said Barry Jaruzelski,<br />

Booz Allen Vice President. "Large multinational<br />

corporations are leading the drive to<br />

emerging markets - and taking their smaller<br />

suppliers with them."<br />

The report highlights several other major<br />

findings:<br />

■ In emerging markets, final assembly, displays,<br />

and semiconductors will provide the<br />

❝Emerging markets<br />

offer cost savings that<br />

are critical for survival<br />

in today's hyper-competitive<br />

environment.<br />

Large multinationals<br />

are leading the drive<br />

to emerging markets.❞<br />

highest level of growth<br />

through 2005.<br />

■ China will continue to<br />

hold commanding positions<br />

in key value chain elements<br />

such as assembly, displays,<br />

and semiconductors, as it<br />

evolves into the hub of<br />

electronics manufacturing.<br />

By 2005, 45 per cent of all<br />

high volume assembly will<br />

occur in China.<br />

■ The <strong>Asia</strong> Pacific region,<br />

particularly China, currently dominates electronics<br />

manufacturing in emerging markets:<br />

— 83 per cent of electronic displays manufactured<br />

in emerging markets are produced in<br />

the <strong>Asia</strong> Pacific region, with 44 per cent from<br />

China;<br />

— For connectors and cables, 78 per cent of<br />

the emerging markets' output is from the <strong>Asia</strong><br />

Pacific region, including 66 per cent from<br />

China; and<br />

— Eastern Europe and Latin America<br />

account for 25 per cent and 16 per cent,<br />

respectively, of battery production in emerging<br />

markets.<br />

■ By sector, production growth will be led<br />

by computers and peripherals, with an estimated<br />

$47 billion increase between 2001<br />

and 2005, followed by consumer electronics<br />

($20 billion), handheld devices ($16 billion),<br />

automotive electronics, and telecom (both<br />

$11 billion).<br />

ASEAN revisits regional energy grids<br />

ASEAN is again moving<br />

towards a cross-border gas<br />

and electricity grid. It has<br />

approved a Master Plan for<br />

power inter-connection,<br />

but emergence of common<br />

gas and power markets<br />

where energy is traded is<br />

some way off . . .<br />

From ANDREW SYMON<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL Correspondent<br />

SINGAPORE:<br />

A more integrated,<br />

co-operative approach to meeting<br />

energy demand is slowly emerging among<br />

Southeast <strong>Asia</strong>n countries.<br />

Following progress in removal of tariff<br />

barriers to trade in goods under the ASEAN<br />

Free Trade Agreement (AFTA), attention is<br />

being given to promotion of cross-border<br />

gas and power supply to more efficiently<br />

meet energy demand. In July, the 10 ASEAN<br />

member states approved a comprehensive<br />

Master Plan for power interconnection. The<br />

plan proposes 11 main new transmission<br />

interconnections between countries, to be<br />

built by 2020. It complements a plan for<br />

inter-country gas transmission connections,<br />

which ASEAN ministers agreed to last year.<br />

Currently, there are three cross-border<br />

power transmission lines - from Laos to<br />

Thailand, supplying hydro power to<br />

Thailand; and two-way interconnections<br />

between Thailand and peninsular Malaysia,<br />

and Malaysia and Singapore. There are also<br />

cross-border gas pipelines in operation, taking<br />

gas from Myanmar to Thailand, from<br />

peninsular Malaysia to Singapore and from<br />

Indonesia to Singapore.<br />

The ministers endorsed the power plan during<br />

a meeting at Langawi Island, Malaysia, on<br />

July 3. In a statement issued after the meeting,<br />

they welcomed progress made in the Trans-<br />

ASEAN gas pipeline and the ASEAN power<br />

grid projects and said they “look forward to<br />

working collectively to provide greater stability<br />

and security of energy supply in the<br />

ASEAN region”. Strong private sector participation<br />

in the gas and power interconnection<br />

projects is necessary, they say. Ministers recommended<br />

development of an enabling<br />

framework to ensure construction is carried<br />

out on a commercial basis.<br />

The power plan broadly divides the region<br />

into two. There is a “west system”, featuring<br />

new interconnections within the Mekong<br />

region - Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand<br />

and Vietnam - and also between Thailand and<br />

peninsular Malaysia; Malaysia and Sumatra in<br />

Indonesia; peninsular Malaysia and Singapore;<br />

Singapore and Batam in Indonesia; and<br />

Singapore and Sumatara. Thailand is put forward<br />

as a hub for the west system. Power from<br />

the Mekong region, much of it hydro-produced<br />

from Laos and Myanmar, would be transmitted<br />

or “wheeled” through Thailand to countries to<br />

the south — providing the tariff is competitive<br />

to the production cost of the gas and coal-fired<br />

power plants in the south.<br />

An “east system” proposes interconnections<br />

between the different countries on Borneo<br />

island - Brunei, the Malaysian states of Sabah<br />

and Sarawak, and Indonesian Kalimantan. A<br />

long-distance submarine interconnection with<br />

the Philippines and the Borneo system was<br />

found not to be economically viable in the<br />

period to 2020. Similarly a once-mooted submarine<br />

link between Borneo and peninsular<br />

Malaysia was not considered viable.<br />

Earlier, Malaysia had proposed that the<br />

planned Bakun hydro dam project in Sarawak<br />

could supply the peninsula and possibly the<br />

Philippines as it would generate far more<br />

power than the relatively small economy of<br />

Sarawak would need. This dam has long been<br />

controversial because of feared environmental<br />

damage to the Rejang river system and its<br />

impact on local communities. A smaller dam<br />

project is now contemplated.<br />

The power study was carried out by the<br />

Heads of ASEAN Power Utilities (Hapua). The<br />

gas plan was developed by the ASEAN<br />

Council on Petroleum, which represents<br />

national oil companies.<br />

The Hapua co-ordinator for the power<br />

Continued page 11<br />

10<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003


ASEAN'S ENERGY BID<br />

From page 10<br />

study, Prutichai Chonglertyanichkul,<br />

Assistant Director of System Planning at the<br />

Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand,<br />

said interconnection could result in significant<br />

savings. “Each country does not need to<br />

install as much power generation. You can<br />

reduce the reserve margin each country would<br />

otherwise need if it pursues self-sufficiency,”<br />

he said. “If you stand alone, when the system<br />

is not meeting full demand, then you may have<br />

to stand down some power plants because<br />

demand is not sufficient. If systems are interconnected,<br />

then this can be avoided as power<br />

plants can still operate by transferring power to<br />

another country.”<br />

There were also environmental benefits. “If<br />

you stand alone, you will need more power<br />

plants, producing more carbon dioxide emissions<br />

and so on,” he said. Politically, the power<br />

interconnections would encourage closer relations<br />

between countries. But concerns over<br />

supply security could still make it difficult for<br />

countries to commit too much of their power<br />

supply needs to generators in neighbouring<br />

countries, Prutichai added.<br />

Some propose that ASEAN members should<br />

enter into an energy treaty that could guarantee<br />

that member countries would not interrupt supply,<br />

similar to the law governing cross border<br />

supply in Europe.<br />

More cross-border links, however, do not<br />

mean rapid emergence of common gas and<br />

power markets where energy is traded — as is<br />

the case to various degrees in North America,<br />

Europe, Australia and New Zealand. Policies in<br />

Southeast <strong>Asia</strong>n countries vary significantly.<br />

Some states, such as Malaysia, are not prepared<br />

to entirely liberalise gas and power supply<br />

industries for fear of shortages and price spikes,<br />

as occurred in California.<br />

Only Singapore has a power pool market.<br />

The Philippines plans to establish one, while<br />

Thailand has reversed its earlier intention to<br />

institute a power market. Private power supply<br />

through independent generators selling under<br />

long-term contacts, if not in power-pooling systems,<br />

is supported throughout the region nevertheless,<br />

especially as State-owned power<br />

companies alone are not able to finance all the<br />

needed generation plant.<br />

Bank Mandiri IPO<br />

may set trend in<br />

investor sentiment<br />

From TOM MCCAWLEY<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL Correspondent<br />

'OMANDIRI' in Bahasa Indonesia,<br />

the national language, means independent.<br />

On July 14, Bank Mandiri, Indonesia’s<br />

largest State-owned bank by assets, took a<br />

major step towards its own independence. It<br />

made a strong debut on the Jakarta Stock<br />

Exchange, following on initial public offering<br />

earlier in July.<br />

Despite a small bomb blast at the Parliament,<br />

Bank Mandiri shares rose 26 per cent as foreigners<br />

who had missed the earlier IPO rushed<br />

to buy. It was a proud day for officials who<br />

Continued page 13<br />

CHINA - INDIA - INDONESIA - JAPAN - MALAYSIA<br />

MYANMAR - SINGAPORE - THAILAND - VIETNAM<br />

Having Difficulty<br />

Establishing Your Business<br />

in an Overseas Market<br />

<strong>International</strong> Business Network (IBN) are specialists in:<br />

offshore business development; international trade;<br />

country-specific marketing strategies; local representation,<br />

advice and assistance.<br />

IBN has successfully assisted over 700 companies worldwide<br />

to establish and accelerate their Overseas Business<br />

Development in <strong>Asia</strong> through our Business Process<br />

Outsourcing (BPO) services.<br />

Our principal BPO services include:<br />

● In-country representation by professionally qualified local industry specialists<br />

● Country specific promotion and marketing<br />

● Business planning & establishment services<br />

● Primary market research<br />

● Feasibility studies<br />

● Market analysis<br />

● Competitor analysis<br />

● Product sourcing & supply<br />

● <strong>International</strong> franchise development and support services<br />

● <strong>International</strong> market research and target market evaluation<br />

● Investment feasibility studies<br />

● Partner identification, selection and facilitation<br />

● Business acquisition & consultation services<br />

● Distribution network establishment & development<br />

IBN's ancillary BPO services include:<br />

● Brand positioning<br />

● Company profiling<br />

● Country and industry briefs<br />

● Due diligence<br />

● Work permits and visa services<br />

● Immigration counselling<br />

INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS<br />

NETWORK PTY LTD<br />

INTERNATIONAL CORPORATE CONSULTANTS<br />

STRATEGICALLY POSITIONED IN 15 KEY BUSINESS<br />

CENTRES THROUGHOUT ASIA. (33 BUSINESS CENTRES WORLDWIDE)<br />

For confidential obligation free enquiries<br />

please contact our Head Office in Sydney on<br />

Tel: +61 2 9281 5455 Fax: +61 2 9281 5405<br />

Toll Free: 1300 726 333<br />

Email: info@internationalbiznet.com<br />

Web: www.internationalbiznet.com<br />

®<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003 11


GLOBAL ORGANIZERS OF INSTITUTIONAL<br />

FINANCE & INVESTMENT CONFERENCES<br />

conference topics developed with<br />

Frank J. Fabozzi<br />

The Second Annual<br />

Korean ABS/MBS<br />

September 29, 2003<br />

The Westin Chosun • Seoul, South Korea<br />

THE LATEST DEVELOPMENTS IN THE KOREAN<br />

ABS/MBS MARKETS<br />

RATING AGENCY PERSPECTIVES ON THE<br />

KOREAN ABS/MBS MARKET<br />

KOREAN ABS NEW MARKET DEVELOPMENTS<br />

AND ASSET CLASSES<br />

TAX AND ACCOUNTING ISSUES<br />

For information on sponsorship<br />

opportunities, Please contact Cheryl Fallick<br />

at +1- 212-901-0531<br />

JOIN US AND YOUR INDUSTRY COLLEAGUES TO DISCUSS:<br />

ISSUER AND INVESTOR PERSPECTIVES ON<br />

THE KOREAN MARKET<br />

CROSS BORDER SECURITIZATION<br />

TRANSACTIONS<br />

LEGAL ISSUES WITH CROSS BORDER MBS<br />

APPLICATION OF SWAPS FOR THE KOREAN<br />

ABS MARKET<br />

KOREAN ABS/MBS CONFIRMED SPONSORS INCLUDE:<br />

TITANIUM<br />

USING SECURITIZATION TO IMPROVE ASSET<br />

LIABILITY MANAGEMENT AND FLEXIBILITY:<br />

INTERNATIONAL MBS COMES IN THE<br />

KOREAN MARKET<br />

INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES USING CDOs<br />

NON-PERFORMING LOANS<br />

K-REITS<br />

ACTIVITY IN OTHER ASIAN SECTORS<br />

PLATINUM<br />

GOLD<br />

SILVER<br />

BRONZE<br />

For More Information, Please Visit:<br />

www.imn.org/a454/atm/<br />

Email: mail@imn.org<br />

Call: +1-212-768-2800 Ext. 1<br />

Fax: +1-212-768-2484<br />

information management network


BUSINESS OUTLOOK<br />

From page 10<br />

remember when Bank Mandiri, just four years<br />

ago, was created from four failed state banks,<br />

their assets pooled and bad loans written off.<br />

Mandiri was fortified by the Indonesian Bank<br />

Restructuring Agency (IBRA), with bonds that<br />

still make up most of its assets.<br />

Now, the successful IPO is a strong sign that<br />

international sentiment is shifting not only for<br />

Indonesian stocks, but for the wider economy.<br />

The launch was carefully timed to coincide<br />

with rising confidence in the market. So far, the<br />

Jakarta Stock Exchange is up by more than 25<br />

per cent this year. Indonesia is likely to graduate<br />

from the US$5 billion <strong>International</strong><br />

Monetary Fund loan programme at the end of<br />

2003. It's officials have praised the macro-economic<br />

management of the government of<br />

Megawati Sukarnoputri.<br />

In a bid to stimulate investment, Bank<br />

Indonesia has lowered its interest rates to their<br />

lowest levels in nine years. Indonesia’s oncebattered<br />

currency, the rupiah, is up by 20 per<br />

cent this year. The good macro-economic news<br />

has helped persuade investors that Bank<br />

Mandiri is a good buy. In late June, the government<br />

increased the size of the offering from<br />

15 to 20 per cent due to strong demand, mainly<br />

from overseas investors. In fact, most<br />

investor demand came from outside Indonesia.<br />

At the end of book-building in late June, foreign<br />

investors accounted for 80 per cent of the<br />

issue. Two-thirds came from institutions, which<br />

are traditionally unwilling to commit major<br />

funds to Indonesia. Indonesia recently sold<br />

stakes in Bank Niaga (to Malaysia’s Commerce<br />

Asset Holdings Bhd), an in Bank Danamon (to<br />

Temasek Holdings of Singapore, the Singapore<br />

government's investment wing).<br />

Bank Mandiri is attractive for several reasons.<br />

It is the largest stock in the banking sector after<br />

Bank Negara Indonesia and Bank Central <strong>Asia</strong>,<br />

counting among the top 10 capitalised stocks<br />

on the exchange. At current prices, Bank<br />

Mandiri's publicly available stock is worth<br />

around US$400 million. Mandiri is relatively<br />

cheap - priced at 1.06 times its book value<br />

compared to 1.5 for Bank Danamon, another<br />

major bank.<br />

Importantly, Mandiri has growth potential. It<br />

is a major platform for entry into a market of<br />

210 million people. The bank has assets of<br />

some Rp260 trillion ($31.65 billion). As of<br />

March 31, Mandiri had 700 branches, with<br />

some eight million customers.<br />

Local analysts claim Mandiri's share price will<br />

keep rising. In mid-July, the bank was added to<br />

the influential Morgan Stanley Capital<br />

<strong>International</strong> Standard Indices. The move is<br />

likely to boost confidence in the stock as overseas<br />

funds often use the MSCI as a benchmark<br />

for decision-making.<br />

Concerns remain over the quality of Bank<br />

Mandiri’s assets. Most of the bank’s income<br />

come from bonds issued when the bank was<br />

recapitalised in the <strong>Asia</strong>n crisis of 1997-98. The<br />

bank is also finding it difficult to loan as corporate<br />

defaults remain at a high level.<br />

The Government's low interest policy also<br />

poses risks for Mandiri. If the bank does not<br />

resume large-scale corporate lending this year,<br />

earnings could be damaged. After the success<br />

of the Mandiri launch, the government is likely<br />

to push ahead with an IPO in another major<br />

State-owned bank, Bank Rakyat Indonesia.<br />

TOURISM SHAPES UP AFTER SARS<br />

Advisories 'self-defeating'<br />

ISSUING travel advisories<br />

against countries hit by<br />

terrorism plays into the<br />

hands of those who<br />

want to disrupt business,<br />

says Richard Gordon,<br />

Philippines Tourism<br />

Secretary and current<br />

Chairman of the Pacific<br />

Area Travel Association . . .<br />

THE PHILIPPINES suffered another<br />

setback on July 27 when para-military<br />

groups “hijacked” a downtown office<br />

block in Manila. To Richard Gordon, the man<br />

who is working doubly hard to restore confidence<br />

in his country’s tourism industry, it is<br />

yet another public relations nightmare.<br />

Bad news, it seems, never ends. And what<br />

Gordon, the Philippines Tourism Secretary,<br />

fears most is “stigmatisation” that comes from<br />

such incidents.<br />

During a visit to Australia to help rebuild<br />

the image of the Philippines as a tourist destination,<br />

Gordon was at pains to stress that the<br />

Philippines has more than 7,000 islands, and<br />

that incidents in Manila or in Minandao should<br />

not tarnish the rest of the country.<br />

Recurrence of terrorist acts is like a rollercoaster<br />

ride for those in charge of tourism.<br />

Gordon says there has been a paradigm shift<br />

in global terrorism, with terrorists graduating<br />

from hijacking planes to using the<br />

planes themselves as weapons.<br />

“The world has to put on a brave<br />

front in dealing with terrorism. We<br />

have to learn to cope,” he says.<br />

Countries have taken precautions,<br />

but they must also realise that issuing<br />

travel advisories against countries<br />

hit by terrorists is self-defeating,<br />

in a sense playing into the<br />

hands of those who want to disrupt<br />

business and tourism.<br />

Following an agreement reached<br />

at an <strong>Asia</strong>n tourism Ministerial meeting<br />

this year, Southeast <strong>Asia</strong>n countries have<br />

agreed to share intelligence and information.<br />

Gordon, who is also Chairman for 2003-4 of<br />

the Pacific Area Travel Association (PATA) and<br />

concurrently World Tourism Organisation<br />

Commissioner for East <strong>Asia</strong>, says the outbreak<br />

of SARS led to concerned countries advising<br />

their own citizens to avoid travelling to affected<br />

areas. This provided a sobering experience<br />

for countries like Canada, which for the first<br />

time realised the flow-on impact of travel<br />

advisories — which affect not only the<br />

tourism and transportation sectors but ripple<br />

out to insurance companies and the wider<br />

business community as visitors cancel trips.<br />

Gordon says he does not argue against the<br />

use of travel advisories, but governments<br />

need to be “smarter in issuing them”. He says<br />

they ought to be region-specific. He also says<br />

the world did not issue travel advisories<br />

Richard Gordon:<br />

Governments need to<br />

be smarter in issuing<br />

advisories.<br />

against Japan after the Sarin gas incident in<br />

Tokyo, or the United States after September 11<br />

terrorist attacks on New York and Washington<br />

in 2001.<br />

But the global tourism industry is resilient,<br />

says Gordon. It has started to recover from the<br />

impact of SARS, which is estimated to have<br />

cost some US$11 billion (AUD17 billion) in<br />

international tourism revenue in the two worst<br />

months of the outbreak. SARS affected the<br />

major travel hubs of the region — Singapore,<br />

Hong Kong, Taiwan and China.<br />

Intra-<strong>Asia</strong> travel is a major contributor to<br />

tourism in the region. Of the 132 million visits<br />

to <strong>Asia</strong>n destinations last year, Gordon says 84<br />

million were intra-<strong>Asia</strong> travel. <strong>Asia</strong> is the<br />

world’s second-largest market after the US.<br />

This is why the financial costs of SARS were<br />

higher than those of September 11 or the<br />

October 18 2002 Bali bombing. Gordon says it<br />

will take six months for the industry to recover<br />

from the fall-out of SARS. Airline capacity is<br />

increasing, and regional initiatives are now in<br />

place, offering attractive deals for long-haul<br />

visitors to <strong>Asia</strong>.<br />

It is crucial, Gordon says, that the industry<br />

regains the confidence of travellers.<br />

As well, he says, Southeast <strong>Asia</strong>n countries<br />

have undertaken a key initiative in offering<br />

special airfare and hotel packages to lure<br />

long-haul travellers back to the region.<br />

Regional airlines and hotels are participating<br />

in these special fares and room rates to<br />

encourage long-haul tourists to visit multiple<br />

destinations. Travellers pay US$120 extra for<br />

each sector, for example from Manila to Hong<br />

Kong, or Hong Kong to Singapore,<br />

with five-star hotels charging from<br />

US$70 a night.<br />

Domestically, Gordon has made<br />

“long weekends” official policy in<br />

the Philippines, ensuring that public<br />

holidays which fall during the week<br />

are moved to the Friday or Monday.<br />

The only day that cannot be moved<br />

is Labour Day. “We do this in consultation<br />

with business,” he says. “As<br />

long as we tell them in advance, they<br />

support the idea.” He says the long<br />

weekends have resulted in a 20 per<br />

cent rise in domestic tourism. “This is good for<br />

our transportation industry, hotels and resorts.”<br />

Last year tourism generated US$82 billion<br />

worldwide. Long-term growth is projected at<br />

5.5 per cent, although growth dropped to 4.3<br />

per cent last year.<br />

Tourism is the positive face of globalisation,<br />

Gordon says. It is one sector that can produce<br />

immediate benefits to the people of a country<br />

that opens its doors to the world. The most<br />

important thing is that those involved in the<br />

industry do not have to have college degrees.<br />

He says tourism have been credited with raising<br />

the standard of living of millions of people in<br />

poor countries. Not only is tourism a key generator<br />

of foreign exchange to <strong>Asia</strong>. With China<br />

and India being part of <strong>Asia</strong>,<br />

the region is potentially the largest single<br />

market for global tourism.<br />

■ Business Travel, page 30.<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003 13


ASIA PULSE<br />

THE INFORMATION HEARTBEAT OF ASIA<br />

The information heartbeat of <strong>Asia</strong><br />

ASIA PULSE is a joint venture involving the resources<br />

of (AAP) - AAP Information Services Pty Ltd (Australia);<br />

(ANTARA) - LKBN ANTARA (Indonesia); (Bernama) -<br />

Bernama (Malaysia); (Nikkei) - Nihon Keizai Shimbun Inc<br />

(Japan); (ONA) - Oman News Agency (Oman); (IRNA) -<br />

Islamic Republic Newsagency (Iran); (PNA) - Philippines<br />

News Agency (Philippines); (PPI) - Pakistan Press<br />

<strong>International</strong> (Pakistan); (PTI) - The Press Trust of India<br />

Ltd (India); (Yonhap) - Yonhap News Agency (Korea);<br />

(VNA) - Vietnam News Agency (Vietnam); and (XIC) -<br />

Xinhua Information Centre (China).<br />

TRIAL RUN ON THREE GORGES<br />

YICHANG — The first power generator of<br />

China’s Three Gorges Project, the largest of<br />

its kind in the world, has been connected to<br />

the power grid to begin generating electricity.<br />

Yang Qing, vice-general manager of the<br />

China Yangtze River Three Gorges Project<br />

Development Corporation, said the generating<br />

unit will supply 12.9 million kwh per day<br />

to the Central China and East China Power<br />

Grids. The unit will have to pass a 30-day<br />

trial operation period before beginning commercial<br />

production in mid-August.<br />

SAMSUNG SALES UP IN INDIA<br />

NEW DELHI — Samsung India has posted a<br />

70 per cent increase in sales turnover to<br />

Rs12,150 million (US$262.9 million) for the<br />

six months ending June 30, 2003. Flat television<br />

sales grew 275 per cent to 150,000 units,<br />

and there was a 116 per cent increase in<br />

colour television sales at 690,000 units.<br />

Refigerator sales were up by 55 per cent at<br />

180,000 units, washing machines up 70 per<br />

cent, and microwave and airconditioners up<br />

82 per cent and 81 per cent respectively for<br />

the half.<br />

J-POWER OPTS FOR WIND POWER<br />

TOKYO — Electric Power Development Co.,<br />

known as J-Power, plans in 2004 to build<br />

Japan’s largest wind power generation plant<br />

in Fukushima Prefecture, investing 10 billion<br />

yen (US$84.35 million) to install about 30<br />

wind power generators with a combined output<br />

of 60,000kw, enough to supply about<br />

36,000 households with electricity for a year.<br />

J-Power plans to sell the entire output to<br />

Tokyo Electric Power Co., starting in 2005.<br />

SINGAPORE’S GDP DOWN<br />

SINGAPORE — Singapore’s gross domestic<br />

product [GDP] contracted 4.3 per cent<br />

year-on-year in real terms in the second<br />

quarter of 2003, according to advance<br />

government estimates. On an annualised<br />

quarter-on-quarter basis, real GDP fell by<br />

11.8 per cent, compared with growth of 1.2<br />

per cent in the previous quarter. GDP<br />

growth in the second quarter was<br />

predictably weak as a result of the weak<br />

global environment and the SARS outbreak.<br />

NO TAIWAN CEILING FOR FTTS<br />

TAIPEI — Qualified foreign institutional<br />

investors will no longer be subject to a ceiling<br />

of US$3 billion on their investments. Also gone<br />

is a requirement that money pledged by foreign<br />

investors in the local stock market must be<br />

brought into Taiwan within two years.<br />

However, the investors’ licenses to buy and sell<br />

stock on the local bourse will be suspended if<br />

they fail to funnel any money into the market<br />

within three years of obtaining permission.<br />

HK RECOVERING FROM SARS<br />

HONG KONG — Air traffic figures for June<br />

at Hong Kong <strong>International</strong> Airport showed<br />

life slowly returning to normal for the local<br />

aviation industry. The effect of SARS was still<br />

apparent, with June total passenger traffic<br />

figure down 57.2 per cent compared with the<br />

same month last year, but it was an improvement<br />

on May, when passenger traffic was<br />

down 79.9 per cent from the same month<br />

last year.<br />

PIRELLI INVESTING IN INDONESIA<br />

JAKARTA — Pirelli has announced plans to<br />

establish a tyre factory in Indonesia with an<br />

investment of US$100 million and a production<br />

capacity of 5,000 pieces per day. The factory<br />

will concentrate on tyres for four-wheeled<br />

vehicles and light trucks.<br />

GM TO EXPAND IN INDIA<br />

MUMBAI — General Motors Corporation will<br />

invest Rs6,000 million (US$129.7 million) in its<br />

Indian subsidiary during the current fiscal<br />

year. The parent company has received clearance<br />

to invest up to Rs13,800 million in<br />

General Motors India for new products and<br />

development purposes.<br />

INSURANCE COVER UP IN CHINA<br />

BEIJING — The combined premiums of<br />

Chinese and foreign insurance companies in<br />

China topped 212.61 billion yuan (US$25.7<br />

billion) in the first half of this year, up 32 per<br />

cent year-on-year. Total payments for the sixmonth<br />

period were 26.7 billion (US$3.23 billion),<br />

five billion yuan more than last year.<br />

The outbreak of SARS stimulated domestic<br />

demand for insurance.<br />

TOYOTA JV IN GUANGZHOU<br />

NAGOYA — Toyota Motor Corp. aims to start<br />

joint production of passenger cars with China’s<br />

Guangzhou Automobile Group Co. by 2005.<br />

The two plan to establish an equally-owned<br />

joint venture this year and to invest slightly<br />

more than 30 billion yen (US$254 million) to<br />

build a factory. Initially, 30,000 units of the<br />

Camry will be produced each year. By boosting<br />

its presence in southern China, where many of<br />

the wealthy live, Toyota hopes to obtain a 10<br />

per cent share of the Chinese market by 2010.<br />

US BUYING BIG FROM VIETNAM<br />

HANOI — The US is Vietnam’s top importer<br />

and the British Virgin Islands is pouring most<br />

money into the country, according to half-year<br />

government statistics. Growing at 183 per cent,<br />

US sales accounted for one-fifth of Vietnam’s<br />

total export turnover in the first six months of<br />

the year followed by Indonesia, Portugal and<br />

South Africa, with growth of 114, 83 and 75 per<br />

cent, respectively. Deputy Trade Minister, Mai<br />

Van Dau, attributed the performance to all-out<br />

efforts from the government and businesses to<br />

promote trade and tap new markets.<br />

CONSUMERS CLOSING WALLETS<br />

SEOUL — Consumer confidence declined to<br />

an all-time low in June due to concerns over<br />

the moribund economy and sluggish growth,<br />

the National Statistical Office (NSO) said. The<br />

report showed that, regardless of the size of<br />

monthly income, people will spend less in the<br />

coming months than they did in the past.<br />

TELECOMS BIDS IN PAKISTAN<br />

ISLAMABAD — The government has<br />

announced the opening of its fixed-line telephone<br />

sector to private investors after abolishing<br />

the monopoly of the state-run Pakistan<br />

Telecommunication Company Limited [PTCL]<br />

earlier this year. “Licences will be issued to private<br />

operators for a period of 20 years,” said<br />

Federal Minister for Information Technology<br />

Awais Leghari, adding that licences will be<br />

issued to private companies for fixed-telephony<br />

in Pakistan through a transparent process with<br />

open bids.<br />

THAI AIRWAYS TO OFFER SHARES<br />

BANGKOK — Thai Airways <strong>International</strong> said<br />

it will seek to raise 15 billion baht (US$360 million)<br />

through a share offering in November by<br />

issuing 300 million new shares to the public.<br />

Thai Airways plans to cut government ownership<br />

to 70 per cent from 93 per cent by selling<br />

the shares, the Bangkok Post said. The airline<br />

made a net profit of 8.3 billion baht in the first<br />

six months of the current financial year.<br />

PANVA GAS EXPANDS IN CHINA<br />

CHENGDU — The Hong Kong-based Panva<br />

Gas Holdings Limited plans to invest HK$3<br />

billion (US$389 million) exploring gas<br />

resources in Sichuan Province, southwest<br />

China, within the next two to three years.<br />

Sources with the Hong Kong company<br />

said it will step into the Sichuan gas market<br />

by taking over gas companies in the<br />

province and establishing joint ventures.<br />

Panva Gas has set up more than 20 joint<br />

ventures on the Chinese mainland since<br />

1997., for a total investment of HK$1 billion<br />

(US$130 million), and has taken over three<br />

gas companies in Sichuan.<br />

©<strong>Asia</strong> Pulse Pte Ltd.<br />

Each day <strong>Asia</strong> Pulse creates up to 250 items of news, business<br />

opportunities, expert commentary and industry profiles. <strong>Asia</strong> Pulse is<br />

a unique joint venture involving the resources of <strong>Asia</strong>’s major news<br />

and information groups.<br />

Contact: <strong>Asia</strong> Pulse Production Centre<br />

Phone: (612) 9322 8634<br />

Fax: (612) 9322 8639<br />

http://www.asiapulse.com<br />

Email: apulse@ozemail.com.au<br />

14<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003


BUSINESS OUTLOOK<br />

WHERE ECONOMIES ARE HEADING<br />

<strong>Asia</strong>n construction slowdown on way<br />

THE construction sector in<br />

Singapore and Hong Kong<br />

is expected to contract<br />

significantly in 2003, compunded<br />

by the impact of<br />

SARS, according to a new<br />

BIS Shrapnel report . . .<br />

BECAUSE OF slower-than-expected<br />

global economic recovery, particularly<br />

in the US, and the SARS impact, growth in<br />

the construction sector in East and Southeast<br />

<strong>Asia</strong> is expected to contract in 2003, according<br />

to BIS Shrapnel.<br />

Writing in the BIS Shrapnel research series<br />

Building and Construction <strong>Asia</strong> Pacific, 2002<br />

to 2005, co-authors Adeline Wong and Jason<br />

Anderson suggest that the construction sector<br />

in Singapore and Hong Kong will contract significantly<br />

in 2003, compounded by the impact<br />

of SARS. The co-authors expect the SARS outbreak<br />

to fracture a previously fragile recovery<br />

in these economies.<br />

Meanwhile, construction activity in South<br />

Korea and the Philippines is expected to move<br />

into a downswing in 2003, with activity in<br />

China, Indonesia, Malaysia, Taiwan and<br />

Thailand to experience moderate growth.<br />

The paper forecasts construction in most<br />

<strong>Asia</strong>n countries to achieve some recovery in<br />

2004 and 2005, setting the stage for stronger<br />

growth in the second half of the decade.<br />

China: The residential and non-residential<br />

building sector in China is expected to remain<br />

steady in 2003, before growth gathers momentum<br />

in 2004 and 2005 underpinned by strong<br />

underlying demand for affordable housing, and<br />

for commercial and industrial property amid<br />

further market deregulation in 2005.<br />

Total building completions in Beijing and<br />

Shanghai are forecast to increase by 2-5 per<br />

cent in 2003. Completions are, however,<br />

expected to fall back in 2004, mainly as a<br />

result of a stock build-up and a recent ban on<br />

construction loans to developers of high-end<br />

residential units.<br />

By 2005, construction growth is expected<br />

across all four cities — Beijing, Shanghai,<br />

Guangzhou and Shenzhen — with Beijing<br />

recording strongest growth. Growth in Beijing<br />

over the three years to 2007 will be underpinned<br />

by building activity undertaken to<br />

spruce up the city for the 2008 Olympic<br />

Games, and also by Olympic Games-related<br />

building projects.<br />

Hong Kong: The construction sector is<br />

expected to continue into its fifth year of<br />

downturn in 2003 and is not expected to bottom<br />

out until 2004, when gross value of construction<br />

work performed will to be 33 per cent<br />

below its 1998 record peak. The protracted<br />

downturn is ascribed mainly to the depressed<br />

residential property sector. A rebound of three<br />

per cent in aggregate construction value is forecast<br />

for 2005, principally due to a recovery in<br />

the residential construction market.<br />

Indonesia: The rebound in Indonesia’s<br />

construction sector is expected to continue<br />

over the next three years, but growth is forecast<br />

to be lower than during the previous three<br />

years. Total completion value in 2005 will still<br />

be 30 per cent below the levels of the mid-<br />

1990s. Stronger growth is expected from the<br />

retail building sector in response to tightening<br />

prime retail space supply.<br />

Malaysia: Despite a persistent supply<br />

overhang across the property sector, the construction<br />

sector in Malaysia is expected to<br />

continue to average annual growth of two per<br />

cent over the three years to 2005. The sector<br />

will be sustained mainly by infrastructure, low<br />

to medium-cost housing and institutional<br />

building projects. The commercial and industrial<br />

building sector will remain constrained by<br />

high vacancy levels.<br />

Philippines: Construction sector growth is<br />

expected to contract nine per cent in 2003, due<br />

to a significant decline in non-residential building<br />

activity as retail building activity falls back<br />

from an exceptionally high level in 2002. The<br />

sector is forecast to rebound moderately in<br />

2004 and 2005, backed by steady, solid growth<br />

in residential and retail building, and infrastructure<br />

projects.<br />

Singapore: Construction demand in<br />

Singapore is expected to contract 22 per cent in<br />

2003 because of a significant downswing in<br />

non-residential building and subdued residential<br />

and civil engineering activity. The rebound<br />

forecast for 2004 is from a low base, mainly<br />

backed by residential redevelopment and<br />

retrofitting activity as well as retail and office<br />

refurbishments. New building activity is expected<br />

to gather some strength in 2005, in response<br />

to an economic recovery.<br />

South Korea: Residential building activity<br />

is expected to move into a two-year steep<br />

downturn in 2003 and 2004, due to excess<br />

housing stock. Overall construction demand is<br />

expected to decline by six per cent in 2003 and<br />

remain subdued in 2004. However, a<br />

resumption of growth in building activity is<br />

forecast for 2005, backed by a pick-up in<br />

demand for residential, commercial and industrial<br />

property.<br />

Taiwan: Taiwan’s construction sector is<br />

expected to stabilise in 2003, backed by a five<br />

per cent rebound in the civil engineering construction<br />

sector. Growth is forecast to resume<br />

in 2004 and 2005 at an annual average of 11<br />

per cent. Residential and non-residential<br />

building sector growth is, however, off a lowbase.<br />

The residential building sector is expected<br />

to continue to be constrained by a chronic<br />

excess in housing supply. However, a turnaround<br />

in non-residential building activity will<br />

be supported by a pick-up in demand for<br />

office and factory buildings through stronger<br />

economic growth and rising direct trade with<br />

mainland China.<br />

Thailand: Over the 2003-2005 forecast<br />

period, construction sector growth is expected<br />

to strengthen, supported by a continued<br />

rebound in the residential building sector<br />

and a turnaround in the non-residential and<br />

civil engineering sectors. Residential building<br />

activity has been boosted by a pick-up in<br />

new housing demand. Over the forecast<br />

period, the residential building sector will be<br />

aided further by the Government’s aim to<br />

build 600,000 low-cost units over the 2003-<br />

2007 period. The non-residential building<br />

sector will be underpinned by retail, hotel<br />

and industrial building activity amid<br />

strengthening business confidence.<br />

Visit www.bis.com.au<br />

Real recovery this time<br />

By ROGER DONNELLY, Chief Economist,<br />

Export Finance and Insurance Corporation<br />

FOR 18 MONTHS now, the world<br />

economy has been showing several<br />

signs of getting back onto its feet after the 2000<br />

dot.com crash and subsequent 2000-01 slowdown,<br />

only to stumble back every time into<br />

very weak growth.<br />

In the March quarter, GDP was dead flat in<br />

the eurozone, and growth only 0.6 per cent pa<br />

in Japan and 1.9 per cent pa in America. In the<br />

current June quarter, <strong>Asia</strong>, excluding Japan, is<br />

slumping, because of SARS, the eurozone continues<br />

to tread water, and Japan looks as if it's<br />

shrinking again.<br />

Pessimists are saying the worst isn't over.<br />

The Bank of Japan has cut its interest rate to<br />

zero. The Federal Reserve has cut interest<br />

rates 550 basis points over the past 2 1/2 years<br />

to 1 per cent. And the Japanese and American<br />

governments have also been energetically<br />

priming the fiscal pumps through spending<br />

boosts and tax cuts.<br />

Yet despite this, economies are failing to<br />

pick up; excess capacity is lingering; businesses<br />

are having to offer steep discounts to shift<br />

production; inflation is falling to 1 per cent pa<br />

or below in America and the eurozone; while<br />

the deflation that Japan has been experiencing<br />

for the past four years is getting worse.<br />

What if central banks cut interest rates all<br />

the way to zero and activity still doesn't rev<br />

up That's the really frightening question.<br />

Inflation could fall to zero, and then become<br />

deflation — sustained. Real interest rates<br />

would rise. Falling prices and falling demand<br />

could feed off and reinforce each other. We<br />

could be staring at a situation that resembled<br />

at best Japan since its bubble burst in 1990 -<br />

or at worst, the Great Depression.<br />

Fortunately, this doesn't look likely. The<br />

drags of war, high oil prices and SARS are starting<br />

to fade. Thanks to the recent world sharemarket<br />

rally and decline in long bond rates,<br />

financial conditions - the cost of capital - have<br />

eased considerably. (Though the recent bond<br />

selloff will have to be watched.)<br />

A lot of post-bubble balance sheet adjustment<br />

has already been undertaken - deleveraging,<br />

Continued page 16<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003 15


From page 15<br />

BUSINESS OUTLOOK<br />

recapitalisation, write-off of excess capacity. And<br />

there is much monetary and fiscal stimulus still<br />

to come out of the pipeline - including from the<br />

recent US$350b American tax cut.<br />

Besides, if worse comes to worst, central<br />

bankers led by the US Federal Reserve have<br />

professed themselves ready to do all it takes to<br />

ward of deflation - including buying long-dated<br />

government bonds and extending credit direct<br />

to business - all a far cry from their dazzled-bythe-headlights<br />

inaction in the 1930s.<br />

So yes, we believe the stars are finally coming<br />

into line for a recovery. We are currently<br />

calling a return to trend growth of about 3 1/2<br />

pre cent for the world economy by end-2003 or<br />

early 2004. No vigorous rebound - there isn't<br />

the pent-up demand. Still, these would be conditions<br />

conducive to a gradual pick-up in<br />

exports after their downtrend this past two<br />

years. One snag could be the US dollar correction<br />

currently under way. This has the potential<br />

to push Japan and the eurozone into recession<br />

by undermining their export and import-competing<br />

industries - unless the authorities in<br />

those areas manage to stimulate more domestic<br />

demand-led growth.<br />

In addition, the counterpart of further US<br />

dollar weakness could be further A$ strength.<br />

That would be a headwind for exporters to battle<br />

as they patiently wait for their overseas markets<br />

to leave the doldrums. It needn't work that<br />

way - markets may soon judge that it's time to<br />

pile back into US dollar assets again, given the<br />

way America continues to outgrow the eurozone<br />

and Japan. But for all that, US dollar<br />

depreciation is a stress worth subjecting your<br />

business plan to. Another stress worth thinking<br />

about is a further slide in activity in Japan,<br />

which is looking very weak.<br />

Thankfully, the expansionary impulses finally<br />

seem to be overcoming the drags. So<br />

although there have been a lot of false starts,<br />

this time a recovery could be on for real, even<br />

if it is a little weak and accompanied by a<br />

stronger Australian dollar.<br />

Malaysia to lift it’s<br />

domestic spending<br />

MALAYSIA could be <strong>Asia</strong>'s next<br />

domestic consumption story, according<br />

a report by ABN AMRO. It says Malaysia is<br />

striving to transform its economy from one that<br />

is largely agriculture/mining and manufacturing-based<br />

to one that is competitive in downstream<br />

support services.<br />

"Medium-term, the real excitement with<br />

Malaysia lies in the possibility of a spurt in consumption<br />

turning to sustained structural<br />

domestic demand," the report says. "Malaysia<br />

stands out because its surplus savings are the<br />

largest in <strong>Asia</strong> and its demographics arguably<br />

the most attractive."<br />

ABN AMRO says both Malaysia's and<br />

Singapore's corporate earnings and absolute<br />

share prices have, in the past, been closely<br />

influenced by global growth cycles. "This time<br />

round, a weak US$ and continued robust<br />

demand for resources/commodities are providing<br />

somewhat of a saving grace for both countries.<br />

We are expecting a moderate recovery in<br />

both economies and corporate earnings<br />

over the second half."<br />

16<br />

ASIA TODAY INTERNATIONAL AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2003

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!