Law Firms Who's Who - Business Plus Online
Law Firms Who's Who - Business Plus Online
Law Firms Who's Who - Business Plus Online
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
APRIL 2013<br />
SURVEY<br />
<strong>Law</strong> <strong>Firms</strong><br />
<strong>Who</strong>’s <strong>Who</strong><br />
Detailed Listing of Ireland’s<br />
Top Commercial <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Firms</strong> and the<br />
Views of Managing Partners
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
Silver Lining<br />
After The Bust<br />
Cleaning up after the crash is keeping Dublin’s top commercial law firms busy,<br />
writes NICK MULCAHY<br />
Most of the builders they worked with<br />
have gone bust but the law firms<br />
remain. Lining the docks on both<br />
sides of the river, though mostly on<br />
the southside, Ireland’s large commercial<br />
law firms inhabit glass and steel palaces<br />
containing hundreds of staff. Some areas<br />
of the practices, such as M&A, aren’t as<br />
busy as they used to be, but other areas are<br />
booming. In the fallout from the bust,<br />
there is a lot of cleaning up to be done.<br />
The offices of McCann FitzGerald are<br />
situated by the Liffey opposite the Convention<br />
Centre and down the road from the<br />
Grand Canal Theatre. The entire district<br />
was run-down and derelict 20 years ago<br />
and now McCanns is flanked by commercial<br />
law peers Matheson, Dillon Eustace,<br />
Beauchamps and ByrneWallace, with A&L<br />
Goodbody across the river. Mason Hayes<br />
& Curran is located closer to the Google<br />
digital action in Barrow Street while still<br />
clustered near the city’s Georgian squares<br />
are Arthur Cox, William Fry, Maples and<br />
Calder, Eversheds, Eugene F Collins and<br />
LK Shields.<br />
The McCann building is a fantastic<br />
edifice, designed by Scott Tallon Walker,<br />
with a large atrium looking up to the spiral<br />
of floors above. On the external walkways,<br />
it is incredibly quiet, more like a library<br />
than a hive of activity. Behind the closed<br />
doors, over 200 partners, solicitors and<br />
trainees are beavering away on mountains<br />
of documents, and their thousands of<br />
clauses and terms, that grease the wheels<br />
of international commerce.<br />
In Dublin terms, McCann FitzGerald<br />
is as blueblood as they come. Alexis<br />
FitzGerald, one of the founding partners<br />
in 1947, was a Fine Gael politician and<br />
special adviser to Garret FitzGerald (no<br />
relation) when he was Taoiseach in the<br />
1980s. So it comes as no surprise to learn<br />
that when the Central Bank needed legal<br />
counsel this year about the liquidation of<br />
IBRC and its consequences, they turned to<br />
McCanns. Not that McCanns is the only<br />
safe pair of hands that civil servants can<br />
turn to. In the IBRC wind-up, the Department<br />
of Finance took counsel from Arthur<br />
Cox, a firm that is equally well connected.<br />
Meanwhile the liquidators, KPMG, turned<br />
to A&L Goodbody.<br />
John Cronin is McCann’s chairman and<br />
though he is a less overtly political animal<br />
than the firm’s founder, McCanns is<br />
currently doing well from state work. Most<br />
large state work goes out to tender and if<br />
the same big firms share most of the big<br />
contracts, the firms insist that’s because<br />
they have the resources to get the work<br />
done. McCanns has been selected as the<br />
lead Irish law firm for the sale of Bord<br />
Gáis’s energy business, and Cronin<br />
describes that tender as “highly competitive”.<br />
Last year the firm advised BGE on a<br />
bond issue, and provided the same service<br />
for two other state entities, AIB and ESB.<br />
McCanns is also advising Shannon Airport<br />
Authority in connection with its separation<br />
from the DAA.<br />
The IBRC wind-up and the Bord Gais<br />
selloff are both consequences of the<br />
bust. So too is the shuffling of<br />
distressed loan portfolios that is<br />
keeping nearly all the big Dublin firms<br />
busy. McCanns has aggressive Aussie<br />
finance house Pepper Home Loans as a<br />
client, business the firm won in a pitch.<br />
Pepper has bought over GE Money and GE<br />
Capital’s mortgage and consumer loan<br />
books.<br />
Serious about law: McCann<br />
FitzGerald’s offices in the southside<br />
Docklands<br />
BUSINESS PLUS APRIL 2013 54
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
McCanns was also involved in the spinning<br />
out of car loan books from Permanent<br />
TSB and Bank of Scotland, two deals<br />
to separate buyers that were both bust<br />
fallouts too. A&L Goodbody was also<br />
involved in the PTSB sale. Also benefiting<br />
from the Irish Life restructuring has been<br />
Matheson, which advised the state recently<br />
on the €1.3bn sale of the insurance<br />
company to Great-West Life.<br />
Liam Quirke’s firm also advised a<br />
domestic Irish bank on the disposal of<br />
loans on 400 properties in the UK and<br />
Germany worth €650m that had to be<br />
relinquished due to bailout deleveraging<br />
requirements. And when AIB was forced<br />
to get rid of AIB Investment Managers,<br />
Dillon Eustace was on hand to advise the<br />
South African buyer, Prescient.<br />
Another large piece of distress-related<br />
work in the past year involving McCann<br />
FitzGerald was the examinership of<br />
eircom. Arthur Cox and A&L Goodbody<br />
also benefited from this process, as did<br />
Walkers Ireland. Maples and Calder is<br />
advising Grant Thornton, the liquidator<br />
of Treasury Holdings and 15 of its<br />
subsidiaries. “This is the largest and<br />
potentially most complex compulsory<br />
liquidation in Ireland in recent years with<br />
multi-jurisdictional issues and litigation<br />
arising,” says Managing Partner, Andrew<br />
Doyle.<br />
Another bumper piece of boom fallout<br />
work relates to tracking down the<br />
disputed assets of Sean Quinn and his<br />
family. As part of its legacy work for<br />
IBRC, McCanns oversaw the tracing of<br />
assets and bank monies in Russia, Ukraine,<br />
Cyprus, India, Belize and Sweden. Even<br />
overseas scandals are good for Irish law<br />
firms. The fallout from the Bernie Madoff<br />
scandal in America has been generating<br />
fees for Dillon Eustace and Mason Hayes<br />
& Curran in Commercial Court litigation,<br />
where over $1bn is at stake.<br />
Then there is legal work that has little<br />
enough to do with the Irish economy. For<br />
instance, insurance giant MetLife has set<br />
up a legal base in Ireland with a view to<br />
pan-EU legal consolidation. This has to do<br />
with European solvency regulations and<br />
the lawyers who worked on this one<br />
certainly earned their corn.<br />
Cronin explains: “We advised on a tripartite<br />
cross-border merger pursuant to<br />
which an Italian insurance undertaking<br />
and an Irish insurance undertaking were<br />
merged into a second Irish insurance<br />
undertaking. We believe this is the first<br />
time a tri-partite merger (with two<br />
domestic merging entities) has occurred<br />
in Ireland.”<br />
At Eversheds, its tax group has recently<br />
advised the Nasdaq-quoted Premiere<br />
Global Services on the restructuring of its<br />
cross-border share incentive schemes and<br />
the tax implications for staff in Ireland, the<br />
UK and Germany. Matheson advised<br />
another Nasdaq firm, SS&C Technologies,<br />
in relation to its purchase of GlobeOp<br />
Financial Services, including tax aspects of<br />
its worldwide group reorganisation.<br />
At Matheson they’ve also been involved<br />
in the securitisation of 39,000 Norwegian<br />
car loans originated by a Spanish bank. In<br />
December, the same firm did the legals for<br />
a $100m high-yield bond offering by<br />
Syncreon, the global logistics firm whose<br />
continued on page 56
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
Legal giant Arthur Cox employs around 300 lawyers in Dublin and in its offices abroad<br />
trading presence in Ireland is minimal.<br />
Walkers, an international law firm that set<br />
up in Dublin in 2010, claimed a first with<br />
its involvement in getting away $60m and<br />
€130m of ‘catastrophe bonds’ through a<br />
special purpose reinsurance vehicle. “This<br />
was the first transaction of its kind in the<br />
market,” says Managing Partner, Garry<br />
Ferguson.<br />
Then there’s the acquisition of Cooper<br />
Industries by New Eaton, a $11.8bn mega<br />
deal that has mostly to do with business<br />
activity in America but drew in Irish<br />
lawyers because Cooper is registered here.<br />
So McCanns was involved, as were Arthur<br />
Cox, A&L Goodbody and Matheson, in the<br />
fourth-largest deal worldwide in 2012.<br />
American firms have a huge presence in<br />
Ireland and the Dublin law firms benefit as<br />
a result. A lot of the work relates to tax planning<br />
and that’s not something the firms<br />
tend to crow about these days. But they talk<br />
about the deals. Last year Matheson advised<br />
Goldman Sachs on the sale of its hedge fund<br />
administration business to State Street,<br />
which was advised on the deal by William<br />
Fry. Meanwhile Dillon Eustace acted for<br />
Continental Airlines in its merger with<br />
United Airlines and continues to act for the<br />
combined entity in relation to its ongoing<br />
corporate and regulatory affairs.<br />
Aviation finance is a Dublin speciality<br />
and there is a cluster effect. Such is the<br />
knowledge base and experience in Dublin<br />
in this area that mega-deals are routed<br />
through Irish law firms. Maples and<br />
Calder has been involved recently with<br />
Aircraft Lease Securitisation, an assetbacked<br />
securitisations vehicle with a portfolio<br />
of 50 aircraft valued at approximately<br />
$1bn.<br />
continued on page 58<br />
‘A force in the<br />
corporate<br />
sphere’<br />
Chambers Europe 2012<br />
40 Upper Mount Street, Dublin 2 | T: +353 1 661 0866<br />
E: hgarvey@lkshields.ie | www.lkshields.ie
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
The fourteen Dublin law firms<br />
with over 50 lawyers employ<br />
1,700 solicitors between them.<br />
But in the legal world there’s always<br />
room for the entrepreneurs who<br />
plough their own furrow. Clerkin<br />
Lynch, established in 2008, has just<br />
two partners, Kevin Lynch and Niall<br />
Clerkin, and the total headcount is<br />
nine people.<br />
“We recently moved to larger<br />
offices to deal with the expansion of<br />
the firm and we have hired more staff<br />
to help with our workload,” says<br />
Lynch. In recent months, the firm<br />
has been involved in two Supreme<br />
Court appeals. One related to the law<br />
on security for costs applications and<br />
Carving Out A Niche<br />
the other concerned the copyright<br />
protection of computer programmes.<br />
“We are pleased with the progress<br />
we have made through very<br />
challenging economic conditions,”<br />
adds Lynch. “Setting up a business in<br />
such difficult times has helped us to<br />
empathise with our business-owner<br />
clients. We attract innovative<br />
businesses as clients in such sectors<br />
as energy efficiency, digital media<br />
and telecommunication networks.<br />
Clients appreciate our fixed-price<br />
approach to the provision of our<br />
legal services. Doing a good job for<br />
our clients and providing value for<br />
money has been our most effective<br />
marketing tool.”<br />
Kevin Lynch, co-founder of Clerkin Lynch<br />
A&L Goodbody was involved in<br />
Sumitomo Mitsui Banking’s $7.2bn acquisition<br />
of RBS Aerospace, the biggest-ever<br />
global sale of an aircraft leasing business.<br />
Meanwhile Walkers advised a financial<br />
institution on the acquisition of a portfolio<br />
of aircraft, valued in excess of $500m,<br />
across seven jurisdictions outside Ireland.<br />
And there are regular M&A deals too.<br />
Matheson advised Jazz Pharmaceuticals on<br />
its Nasdaq listing while Maples and Calder<br />
was lead advisor to FleetMatics for its IPO<br />
on the New York Stock Exchange. In the<br />
Caribbean, LK Shields was lead adviser last<br />
year in the sale of Karib Cable, the leading<br />
cable system operator in St Lucia, St<br />
Vincent & the Grenadines and Antigua.<br />
John Cronin and his colleagues at<br />
McCann FitzGerald advised Ladbrokes<br />
on its complicated takeover of Dermot<br />
Desmond’s Betdaq and counselled<br />
Vodafone on its joint venture with Three<br />
Ireland regarding cellphone masts. Also in<br />
the telecoms arena, Mason Hayes & Curran<br />
advised the government on the €800m<br />
auction of sale of 4G wireless spectrum.<br />
The same firm advised Polarlake on its<br />
sales to Bloomberg last year and also<br />
advised energy company SSE on its<br />
purchase of Endessa. William Fry did the<br />
legals for Skillsoft when it bought Thirdforce,<br />
while on the domestic front the<br />
reshaping of Glanbia generated fee income<br />
for Frys and McCann FitzGerald.<br />
For all the big firms, the National Asset<br />
Management Agency is the gift that keeps<br />
on giving. Nama spent €10m on legal fees<br />
in the first six months of 2012, following on<br />
from annual totals of some €20m in 2011<br />
and €10m in 2010. Arthur Cox has billed<br />
the agency over €4m since its establishment<br />
while Maples and Calder and A&L<br />
Goodbody have been paid more than<br />
€2.5m each. Other firms drinking from the<br />
Nama trough include McCann Fitzgerald<br />
(€2.4m), Matheson (€2.1m), William Fry<br />
(€1.9m), ByrneWallace (€1.7m) and<br />
Eversheds (€1.5m).<br />
And, happily, there seems to be no end in<br />
sight for the recovery process at Ireland Inc.<br />
Survey continued on page 60
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
Insight From The<br />
Managing Partners<br />
The people in charge of Ireland’s large, medium and small corporate law<br />
firms tell Chris Sparks that business at the moment is quite satisfactory<br />
Emer Gilvarry<br />
Mason Hayes & Curran<br />
Commercial law firms in Ireland operate as<br />
partnerships rather than limited companies<br />
so they don’t file accounts. The only top<br />
firm to reveal a modicum of financial<br />
information is Mason Hayes & Curran,<br />
where Emer Gilvarry has been Managing<br />
Partner for six years. Last year, the firm<br />
announced that its turnover in 2011 was<br />
€42.2m, an increase of 8% on 2010. “We<br />
strongly believe in the importance of<br />
openness and aligning ourselves with the<br />
businesses that we serve,” says Gilvarry.<br />
She adds: “We are the fastest-growing<br />
full-service law firm in Ireland with 10<br />
years of consistent expansion. In the last<br />
decade we have doubled our revenues and<br />
personnel and are now part of the ‘Big Six’<br />
Irish legal firms, with 64 partners and<br />
offices in Dublin, London and New York.”<br />
Unusually for a law firm, MH&C has<br />
adopted a full open-plan office layout.<br />
“Nobody in the firm has their own office,<br />
allowing our people to easily interact with<br />
each other,” says Gilvarry. “This lack of<br />
hierarchy means that we are solely<br />
dedicated to the efficient provision of<br />
quality legal services.”<br />
The firm specialises in sectors such as<br />
financial services, energy, healthcare and<br />
technology and is particularly well known<br />
‘We are now part of the<br />
Big Six Irish legal firms’<br />
for its dispute resolution work. Gilvarry is<br />
an experienced litigator and MH&C is a<br />
go-to firm for litigation. The firm is advising<br />
on Ireland’s highest-value litigation case,<br />
relating to the collapse of Bernard Madoff<br />
Investment Securities, where €1.4bn is at<br />
stake. MH&C also represented Paul<br />
Connolly in his dispute last year with<br />
Independent News & Media.<br />
Corporate Social Responsibility has been<br />
rising up the agenda of the big law firms<br />
in recent years and Gilvarry’s firm actively<br />
supports the visual arts. “We are proud to<br />
have one of the best contemporary<br />
corporate art collections in Dublin from<br />
up-and-coming, Irish, UK and Eastern<br />
European artists,” she says. “Our ethos is<br />
to approach every aspect of our business<br />
with an unrivalled dynamism and dedication,<br />
to continually strive for the betterment of<br />
ourselves and those around us.”<br />
‘There has been a rise in capital markets activity’<br />
Brian O’Gorman<br />
Arthur Cox<br />
Brian O’Gorman (43) became Managing<br />
Partner of Arthur Cox in November 2011.<br />
A corporate partner, he specialises in<br />
mergers and acquisitions, public<br />
takeovers, equity capital markets and<br />
private equity. Prior to joining Arthur Cox,<br />
O’Gorman spent a number of years in<br />
London and Hong Kong with a leading<br />
London law firm and a leading<br />
investment bank.<br />
Arthur Cox is at the centre of many of<br />
the big deals involving the state. Recently<br />
the firm advised on the liquidation of<br />
IBRC and the exchange of government<br />
bonds for €30.6bn worth of promissory<br />
notes. On the commercial front, Arthur<br />
Cox advised eircom on its restructuring<br />
last year, the largest successful<br />
examinership ever in Ireland. The<br />
transaction involved the write-down of<br />
40% of the debt of eircom to €2.3bn,<br />
from €4.1bn. The firm also helped Aer<br />
Lingus see off Ryanair for the third time.<br />
To strengthen its presence with FDI<br />
clients, last year Arthur Cox established<br />
an office in Silicon Valley. “I hope that the<br />
economy has reached the bottom,” says<br />
O’Gorman. “There have been a few<br />
positive signs: increased interest by<br />
private equity houses in Irish assets, more<br />
enquiries about M&A transactions and<br />
an increase in capital markets activity.”<br />
BUSINESS PLUS APRIL 2013 60
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
Andrew Doyle<br />
Maples and Calder<br />
Managing Partner Andrew Doyle is the<br />
lawyer responsible for building up Maples<br />
and Calder’s presence in Dublin from a<br />
standing start in 2006 to a serious player at<br />
the top tier of corporate law. Doyle has<br />
advised on numerous high-profile private<br />
equity investment and buyout transactions<br />
and he also advises on a broad range of<br />
M&A and other corporate transactions.<br />
“All areas in the Dublin office have had a<br />
busy year and we have grown our team to<br />
over 200 people,” he says. “Our objective<br />
in Ireland is not to be the largest law firm;<br />
it is to be, and to be known, as the law firm<br />
of excellence in our chosen areas of<br />
expertise, and we believe we deliver on<br />
this objective.”<br />
Maples ramped up its insurance litigation<br />
capability last year by hiring Peter Lennon,<br />
who was formerly in partnership in his own<br />
firm, and a team of three other lawyers.<br />
“Peter has been practising as a litigator<br />
for over 20 years, primarily in the area of<br />
insurance dispute resolution advising on<br />
defensive insurance claims, and provides<br />
specific insurance advice to all of the major<br />
under-writers in the Irish market,”<br />
explains Doyle.<br />
‘All areas in the Dublin office have had a busy year’<br />
In a first for Irish legal services, Maples<br />
and Calder has established a dedicated<br />
Irish Advocacy Service for clients engaged<br />
in corporate and commercial litigation. This<br />
move is in anticipation of changes to legal<br />
procedures outlined in the Legal Services<br />
Regulation Bill 2011, and Maples' clients<br />
will be offered the option of having their<br />
solicitor perform the role traditionally<br />
performed by junior counsel, including<br />
advocating their case in court.<br />
“This will ensure continuity of service<br />
and will eliminate the duplication of work<br />
that often occurs between solicitors and<br />
junior counsel,” says Doyle. “Maples will, of<br />
course, continue to appoint counsel<br />
in appropriate cases.”<br />
Survey continued on page 62<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
In today’s fast-moving global economy, it’s business insight<br />
that makes the difference. Trust is essential and when that’s<br />
combined with strategic advice and strong commercial<br />
experience, working with Mason Hayes & Curran becomes<br />
an easy choice. With 65 dedicated partners we give clients<br />
the edge in Ireland.<br />
For an informed perspective, call Mason Hayes & Curran.<br />
It’s the smart solution.
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘Irish corporates were active in outbound acquisitions’<br />
Myra Garrett<br />
William Fry<br />
Myra Garrett (49) has been Managing Partner<br />
of William Fry since 2008. She specialises in<br />
corporate finance, including mergers and<br />
acquisitions, public takeovers, IPOs and<br />
corporate governance. She says that 2012 was<br />
busy for the firm, with the market buoyed by<br />
renewed interest from international investors.<br />
“This meant positive levels of activity in<br />
mergers and acquisitions and, very<br />
encouragingly, a lot more transactions<br />
involving the acquisition of prime property<br />
assets and loan portfolios. Our real estate<br />
colleagues are seeing levels of activity they<br />
have not seen for some years. Irish corporates<br />
were also active in outbound acquisitions,<br />
which is very positive.”<br />
Garrett adds that demand continues to<br />
grow for expertise in specialist areas such as<br />
corporate governance, financial regulation,<br />
administrative sanction procedures and<br />
pensions.<br />
“Litigation was also busy with increased<br />
bank enforcement, commercial contract<br />
disputes and a definite increase in IP<br />
litigation.”<br />
On the M&A front, where Frys has a strong<br />
reputation, recent deals involving the firm<br />
include State’s Street’s acquisition of the<br />
Goldman Sach’s hedge fund administration<br />
business, the spinout of Glanbia Ingredients,<br />
Gordon Brothers’ purchase of Clery’s and<br />
Skillsoft’s acquisition of Thirdforce.<br />
“We are client focused, results driven and<br />
consistently deliver an excellent service,” says<br />
Garrett. “We created 46 new positions in<br />
William Fry in the last six months, ranging from<br />
partner level through to 25 new entrants into<br />
our 2013 Trainee Programme.”<br />
In September 2012, the firm opened an<br />
office in London headed by senior corporate<br />
partner, Stephen Keogh.<br />
‘Sales of loan portfolios have become a key feature of the M&A landscape’<br />
John Cronin<br />
McCann FitzGerald<br />
John Cronin (54) has been Chairman of<br />
McCann FitzGerald since May 2008. He has<br />
extensive experience in banking, structured<br />
finance and capital markets and “takes<br />
control of projects and handles them in an<br />
extremely efficient manner”, according to<br />
legal directory Chambers. In the past 12 to<br />
18 months, the firm has been doing well<br />
from legal work relating to sales of Irish<br />
loan portfolios by financial institutions.<br />
“These have become a key feature of the<br />
M&A landscape,” says Cronin. “This trend<br />
has come about as Irish banks attempt to<br />
deleverage approximately €70bn of loans,<br />
and foreign banks seek to close their<br />
positions in the Irish market. These sales<br />
have attracted a large number of<br />
international private equity funds, hedge<br />
funds and investment firms and McCann<br />
FitzGerald has acted on a significant number<br />
of these loan sale transactions.”<br />
McCanns has also benefited as stateowned<br />
corporates regain access to the<br />
international capital markets, with the firm<br />
advising last year on a series of publicly<br />
offered bond issues by AIB Mortgage Bank,<br />
ESB and Bord Gáis. More recently, the firm<br />
was at the centre of the liquidation of IBRC<br />
and unwinding of the promissory notes,<br />
advising the Central Bank. As McCanns<br />
ended up as an unsecured creditor of IBRC,<br />
this was a real case of Chinese Walls in<br />
action.<br />
Part of Cronin’s development strategy for<br />
the firm is nurturing links with China and<br />
India. “In those countries we have<br />
participated in government-led trade<br />
delegations as well as conducting partner-led<br />
trips to key clients and contacts of the firm,”<br />
says Cronin. “These trips promote<br />
opportunities in the areas of aircraft<br />
financing, funds and investment<br />
management, financial services and<br />
corporate acquisitions, areas in which this<br />
firm is internationally recognised.”<br />
Survey continued on page 64<br />
Driven by clients needs<br />
Providing focused expertise<br />
Delivering successful solutions<br />
Let us talk to you about your business...<br />
Contact: Catherine Guy, Managing Partner<br />
T: +353 1 691 5678 E: cguy@byrnewallace.com<br />
ByrneWallace, 88 Harcourt Street, Dublin 2, Ireland<br />
T: +353 1 691 5000 W: www.byrnewallace.com
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘We have continued to win<br />
more corporate clients’<br />
‘Our strategic focus differentiates us<br />
from our competitors’<br />
Hugh Garvey<br />
LK Shields<br />
Hugh Garvey (46) has been Managing Partner<br />
of LK Shields since 2005. His primary practice<br />
is in commercial litigation and dispute<br />
resolution and legal directory Chambers<br />
Global describes Garvey as a ‘first-class<br />
lawyer who can efficiently deal with<br />
proceedings or promptly settle things out<br />
of court as required'.<br />
According to Garvey, commercial litigation<br />
is a busy service line for LK Shields, which<br />
also has a strong reputation in the M&A<br />
arena. In the past year, LK Shields advised<br />
the shareholders of Simply Zesty on the sale<br />
to UTV New Media; Unit4 <strong>Business</strong> Software<br />
Holding in its acquisition of Mentec <strong>Plus</strong><br />
Integrated Solutions; Mobile Travel<br />
Technologies in relation to an equity<br />
investment by DFJ Esprit; and Aegis Media<br />
in the acquisition of Lucidity Digital. The firm<br />
also acted for Saongroup in the acquisition<br />
of China HR.com from Monster Worldwide,<br />
and was lead adviser in the sale of Caribbean<br />
cable company Karib Cable to Columbus<br />
International Inc.<br />
“Over the past year we have continued<br />
to win more corporate clients, domestically<br />
and internationally, and have expanded our<br />
services to meet their needs,” says Garvey.<br />
“The firm was founded 25 years ago on the<br />
basis that we could provide high-quality<br />
and solutions-focused legal services. Those<br />
attributes remain a core part of our<br />
philosophy. Our clients know that their<br />
legal needs will be proactively met by an<br />
experienced partner who shares their<br />
passion for the success of their business.”<br />
Liam Quirke<br />
Matheson<br />
Matheson Ormsby & Prentice, one of<br />
Dublin’s largest law firms, was fondly<br />
known around town as MOPs. No longer.<br />
Last October the firm rebranded as<br />
Matheson. In charge since 2003 is<br />
Managing Partner Liam Quirke (51), a<br />
top tax lawyer. Matheson has a very<br />
strong practice related to multinationals<br />
and tax, and international companies<br />
and financial institutions now account<br />
for more than 70% of the firm’s<br />
business. These include 27 of the<br />
world’s 50 largest banks and more<br />
than half of the Fortune 100<br />
companies, says the firm.<br />
“The principal business objective of<br />
our firm is to meet the most important<br />
legal needs of international companies<br />
and financial institutions doing business<br />
in and though Ireland better than our<br />
competitors,” says Quirke. “It is this<br />
strategic focus that differentiates us<br />
from our competitors. Our entire<br />
organisation, our systems, our<br />
resources, our investment decisions are<br />
all aligned to meeting their legal needs.<br />
No other firm in Ireland prioritises the<br />
needs of such companies and financial<br />
institutions in this manner.”<br />
Matheson employs over 600 people<br />
across its four offices in Dublin, London,<br />
New York and Palo Alto, including 75<br />
partners and tax principals and over<br />
350 legal and tax professionals. But<br />
there’s more to Matheson than tax<br />
counsel. “Our investment funds,<br />
banking, finance, aircraft, insurance,<br />
derivatives, pharma, technology, social<br />
media and online clients have all had<br />
extensive legal needs in the past year,”<br />
says Quirke.<br />
On the M&A front, the firm advised<br />
Eaton Corporation on its $11.8bn<br />
acquisition of Cooper Industries, the<br />
largest single M&A transaction in<br />
Ireland during 2012, and also advised<br />
Goldman Sachs on the sale of its hedge<br />
fund administration business to State<br />
Street. “We also recently advised the<br />
Irish state on the €1.3bn sale of Irish<br />
Life to Great-West Life,” says Quirke.<br />
Large law firms regularly garner<br />
awards from the trade press but the<br />
gong that probably gave Quirke most<br />
satisfaction last year was inclusion in a<br />
Financial Times ranking of the most<br />
innovative law firms in Europe. The FT<br />
panel described Matheson as “the goto-firm<br />
for international companies<br />
doing business in Ireland".<br />
BUSINESS PLUS APRIL 2013 64
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘The food and distribution, financial services and energy sectors are performing well’<br />
Alan Murphy<br />
Eversheds<br />
Eversheds is the only full-service<br />
international law firm in Ireland and one<br />
of its selling points is a range of multijurisdictional<br />
offerings with a single point<br />
of contact. Managing Partner Alan Murphy<br />
(42) has been in charge since 2009 and<br />
his practice has a particular focus in the<br />
healthcare and leisure sectors, and project<br />
managing real estate and other legal<br />
services for large multinationals across<br />
multiple jurisdictions.<br />
According to Murphy: “We have seen<br />
increased activity in corporate and<br />
commercial for services such as technology,<br />
life sciences, IP, data protection, fundraising<br />
and globally managed services such as<br />
company secretarial. Also the food and<br />
distribution, financial services and energy<br />
sectors are performing well. There has been<br />
increased interest from international<br />
investors in the Irish commercial property<br />
market. We have also witnessed a larger<br />
role for venture capital and private equity<br />
firms as a source of fundraising for Irish<br />
business looking to expand.”<br />
Murphy says that his firm is now actively<br />
competing for business that would<br />
previously have been the preserve of the<br />
bigger firms. “We have over 4,500 people<br />
who provide services to the private and<br />
public sector business and finance<br />
community. Access to all these services<br />
is provided through 43 international<br />
offices in 26 jurisdictions.”<br />
As an example of how this international<br />
reach works in practice, Murphy cites the<br />
sale last year of the Sean Quinn-owned<br />
Belfry Hotel in England, with support from<br />
the Eversheds office in Cardiff. “This was a<br />
complex international transaction including<br />
lawyers from the USA, ROI, UK and<br />
Luxembourg and tackling difficult issues<br />
such as worldwide Mareva injunctions and<br />
the seller’s historic debt syndicate,” says<br />
Murphy.<br />
He adds: “One of the significant cases<br />
in which we acted concerned High Court<br />
proceedings which resulted in the<br />
appointment of a receiver over our client’s<br />
occupational pension schemes being<br />
discharged. This was the first time a lender<br />
had sought to attach a defaulting<br />
borrower’s pension scheme assets in this<br />
way in a pre-retirement situation. The<br />
decision represents a very significant<br />
precedent in terms of concluding that<br />
assets within occupational pension schemes<br />
in a pre-retirement scenario are not capable<br />
of attachment by creditors.”<br />
Survey continued on page 66
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
Julian Yarr<br />
A&L Goodbody<br />
Julian Yarr (42) was appointed Managing<br />
Partner at A&L Goodbody in 2010. He is a<br />
corporate/M&A lawyer and he was in charge<br />
of the firm’s London office for seven years.<br />
Yarr’s external focus has been expanding the<br />
firm’s international strategy and presence. In<br />
the past two years A&L Goodbody has further<br />
developed offices in London, New York and<br />
Palo Alto and established international<br />
lawyer programmes with China and India.<br />
‘Specialist areas such as aircraft finance had a busy year’<br />
Inside the firm, Yarr has overseen a<br />
technology upgrade and new client-service<br />
delivery models.<br />
According to Yarr, 2012 was busy for the<br />
firm, particularly the second half of the year.<br />
“Initial indications are that this looks set to<br />
continue in 2013,” he says. “We saw some<br />
significant transactions and trends, particularly<br />
involving the international market, in M&A,<br />
complex corporate restructurings, the sale of<br />
financial institutions’ loan books and<br />
improvement in the commercial property<br />
market.<br />
“Specialist areas such as aircraft finance,<br />
technology and investment funds also had a<br />
busy year. This in part reflects the increasing<br />
positive sentiment of Ireland internationally.<br />
This has been a gradual and positive<br />
development, rather than a surprise, and one<br />
which we became increasingly aware of<br />
through our international offices and clients.”<br />
A&L Goodbody is a major player in the<br />
North’s legal market. Opened in 2007, the<br />
Belfast office has grown to over 50 staff led by<br />
10 partners. Experian recently ranked the office<br />
as the top M&A legal advisor in Northern<br />
Ireland. The firm has also established a<br />
dedicated German group. “This enhances the<br />
services that we provide to German<br />
corporations and financial institutions doing<br />
business in Ireland, as well as Irish companies<br />
operating in Germany,” says Yarr.<br />
“We believe that the level of instructions is<br />
based on our reputation for providing the<br />
highest quality of legal advice and service<br />
available in Ireland or internationally.”<br />
‘We are very conscious of the quick turnaround that our clients expect’<br />
Richard Martin<br />
Ronan Daly Jermyn<br />
Ronan Daly Jermyn has 70 lawyers with<br />
total personnel at 150. It is the largest<br />
regional law firm in Ireland, with offices<br />
in Cork and Galway, and Richard Martin<br />
(46) was appointed Managing Partner in<br />
October 2012. He headed up the<br />
commercial litigation team at RDJ for 10<br />
years prior to his appointment and has<br />
particular expertise in the areas of<br />
professional indemnity and media law.<br />
“Commercial Litigation continues to be<br />
very busy, with particular emphasis on<br />
professional indemnity and bank recovery<br />
work,” says Martin. “Insolvency and<br />
restructuring work is also very busy and<br />
the firm continues to invest in high-quality<br />
lawyers. We are very conscious of the<br />
quick turnaround that our clients expect in<br />
order that they can efficiently and<br />
effectively operate in their markets, and of<br />
the need for us to ensure that we are fully<br />
resourced to meet their needs.”<br />
Although RDJ has enjoyed revenue<br />
growth in the past year, Martin’s belief is<br />
that the economy will hop along the<br />
bottom for a while. He explains: “Some<br />
level of sustained activity is being seen in<br />
the property sector and there are<br />
transactions taking place in the SME<br />
sector in particular. Much has been spoken<br />
about improvement in credit conditions<br />
and the notion that the banks are back<br />
lending. The difficulty that our clients are<br />
seeing is that the conditions attached to<br />
those loans are often so onerous as to<br />
render the drawdown of the loan either<br />
unattainable or highly unattractive.”
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘We have extensive understanding of the privately owned business market’<br />
Catherine Guy<br />
ByrneWallace<br />
ByrneWallace expanded rapidly during the<br />
property boom and Managing Partner<br />
Catherine Guy (46), appointed in June<br />
2012, headed up the property department<br />
and has a strong track record in largescale<br />
commercial development projects.<br />
“While we are a large firm we are not the<br />
largest,” says Guy. “But we have a very<br />
broad reach in terms of our experience<br />
and are very proud of what we do and<br />
how we help our clients.<br />
“We work with numerous<br />
multinationals but the single biggest<br />
centre of commercial activity in Ireland is<br />
the privately owned business market, and<br />
we position ourselves as a partner of<br />
choice to this sector. We have an extensive<br />
understanding of this market and the<br />
conditions in which it operates.”<br />
Guy says her firm was busy over the<br />
past year assisting some clients to manage<br />
through difficult times but also advising<br />
progressive indigenous and international<br />
companies. “We have been very active<br />
with transactions and have added to our<br />
team with senior hires. We advised on the<br />
sale of Shanakiel Hospital in Cork, a<br />
creative MBO of a chain of DIY stores by<br />
Home Projects Centre, and for Averda in<br />
its acquisition of City Bins. In the<br />
technology sector, we advised Swrve who<br />
raised $6.25m in a funding round.”<br />
ByrneWallace has a strong practice in the<br />
life science and medical device sectors and<br />
advised Azur Pharma on its merger with<br />
Jazz Pharmaceuticals, Amarin on a $100m<br />
hybrid debt financing and Mainstay on a<br />
$20m funding. “A recurring theme has been<br />
our involvement in a number of deals<br />
involving foreign investors, mostly US based,<br />
establishing companies and operations in<br />
Ireland,” says Guy.<br />
She adds that understanding what<br />
clients want and need has never been<br />
more important. “Focusing on quality,<br />
efficiency and experience is a key part<br />
of our service.”<br />
Survey continued on page 68
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
John White<br />
Beauchamps<br />
John White (39) became Managing Partner<br />
of Beauchamps in September 2011 and set<br />
the firm on a growth path. In the past two<br />
years the number of solicitors has increased<br />
from 50 to 70, due to the acquisition of<br />
Landwell Solicitors and more recently the<br />
practice of Felix McTiernan Solicitors.<br />
“We expect this growth to continue as<br />
we win larger assignments from significant<br />
organisations,” says White. “The banking,<br />
enforcement and restructuring areas of the<br />
firm have been extremely busy in the last<br />
year. One interesting area is the trend<br />
towards outsourcing work from banks and<br />
other large undertakings. We have won this<br />
type of work from a number of new clients<br />
in the past 12 months.”<br />
‘We have kept tight control on our cost base’<br />
White is primarily a mergers and<br />
acquisitions lawyer but also provides<br />
strategic business law advice to some of<br />
the firm’s larger clients. He recently acted<br />
for the Pamela Scott fashion chain on its<br />
appointment of an examiner. “We did not<br />
expand rapidly during the boom and we<br />
have kept tight control on our cost base.<br />
We are therefore in a position to provide<br />
fee solutions to clients that work for them,<br />
including fixed fees and carrying out work<br />
on a retainer basis.<br />
“We have high-calibre and experienced<br />
solicitors in all of the key business law<br />
areas and this has enabled us to grow our<br />
market share in corporate, banking,<br />
restructuring and international referrals.”<br />
‘Our service is proactive and client driven’<br />
Michael Lavelle<br />
Lavelle Coleman<br />
Michael Lavelle (53) is a founding<br />
partner of Lavelle Coleman and is<br />
Managing Partner. His focus is<br />
commercial law and commercial<br />
litigation, with an expertise in insolvency.<br />
“We provide a service which is proactive<br />
and client driven,” he says. “I believe the<br />
lawyers in Lavelle Coleman are<br />
commercially driven, approachable and<br />
are good communicators without being<br />
overly legalistic. The firm’s litigation<br />
expertise and service were recognised in<br />
2012, when we were named IICM<br />
litigation specialist of the year.”<br />
A notable case last year was action<br />
taken by the firm on behalf of investment<br />
bond investors against ACC Bank, which<br />
was settled after the hearing of the case<br />
commenced. The firm also acted for the<br />
US trustee in the bankruptcy of the<br />
estate of David Drumm, the former Anglo<br />
Irish Bank boss, which created new law<br />
on inter-jurisdictional bankruptcies.<br />
Lavelle says that the firm is receiving<br />
an increasing amount of instructions<br />
from banks and insolvency practitioners<br />
and litigation was the busiest section of<br />
the practice in the past year. He adds:<br />
“The level of instructions in property<br />
transactions has increased significantly<br />
and there has been an increase in<br />
commercial transactions, although some<br />
of the restructures on which we have<br />
been instructed are bank driven.<br />
“We have strengthened our banking<br />
and insolvency teams and positioned<br />
ourselves to deal with an increasing<br />
amount of institutional work.”<br />
‘There is unquestionably more deal activity’<br />
Larry Fenelon<br />
Leman Solicitors<br />
Leman, established in 2007, has grown<br />
in the teeth of the recession to 14<br />
lawyers currently. Larry Fenelon (36)<br />
is Managing Partner and he heads up<br />
the litigation team and practices in all<br />
areas of ADR.<br />
“There is unquestionably more deal<br />
activity,” say Fenelon. “All departments<br />
recorded growth in the firm in the past<br />
year. Corporate and commercial activity<br />
has noticeably improved and litigation<br />
continues to show continued growth.<br />
International business is going very well,”<br />
he adds.<br />
“We recruit the best lawyers from the<br />
top firms. Our service level is better, our<br />
business is run efficiently and our charge<br />
out rate is very competitive.”<br />
BUSINESS PLUS APRIL 2013 68
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘Our Cayman office has gone from strength to strength’<br />
Mark Thorne<br />
Dillon Eustace<br />
Mark Thorne has been with Dillon Eustace<br />
since it was established in 1992, becoming<br />
a partner in 1999 and Managing Partner in<br />
2004. The major recent development at the<br />
firm has been the establishment of an office<br />
in the Cayman Islands in April 2012, the<br />
first Irish law firm to do so. “Our newly<br />
established Cayman office has gone from<br />
strength to strength, winning a significant<br />
number of mandates from clients<br />
establishing investment and structured<br />
finance products in the Cayman Islands and<br />
in addition gaining significant instructions<br />
in the financial services litigation arena,”<br />
says Thorne.<br />
According to Thorne, Dillon Eustace has<br />
the leading investment and asset<br />
management team in Ireland. “In the area of<br />
regulatory and compliance, our unit has been<br />
busy in relation to the introduction of new<br />
corporate governance codes and Central<br />
Bank examinations and administrative<br />
sanctions regimes,” says Thorne.<br />
“In our distressed asset and banking<br />
unit, we have been involved in a number<br />
of very high-profile non-performing loan<br />
portfolio acquisitions and financings,” he<br />
adds. As an example, Thorne cites acting<br />
for the purchaser, in relation to its due<br />
diligence, acquisition and financing, of<br />
the ‘Project Kildare’ portfolio of Irish real<br />
estate-backed loans, with a nominal<br />
value of €675m, from EBS/AIB.<br />
In financial litigation, the firm has<br />
represented a significant number of<br />
plaintiffs in the Irish-based Madoff-related<br />
litigation. “The firm acts for 50 investors<br />
in an Irish-domiciled fund and we also<br />
acted in the main lead investor action<br />
representing Kalix Fund Ltd, who were the<br />
first investor to issue proceedings,” Thorne<br />
explains.<br />
According to Thorne, a significant<br />
proportion of his firm’s clients are non-Irish.<br />
“Accordingly we have always benchmarked<br />
our service level and quality of advice<br />
against the largest international firms,”<br />
he says. “Our domestic Irish business is<br />
increasing as the international clients for<br />
whom we have acted for many years turn<br />
their attentions to this economy, and local<br />
corporates learn that they can enjoy<br />
international-quality service and advice<br />
from us on their own doorstep.”<br />
Survey continued on page 70<br />
We can...<br />
At Dillon Eustace our many years of experience mean we can<br />
provide clear, focused advice, without ever losing sight of the bigger<br />
picture. We offer national and international corporates, banks, asset<br />
managers and insurers our expertise in:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
...see the wood<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
For more information contact:<br />
Mark Thorne at:<br />
e-mail: mark.thorne@dilloneustace.ie<br />
Dillon Eustace,<br />
33 Sir John Rogerson’s Quay, Dublin 2.<br />
Tel: +353 1 667 0022 Fax: +353 1 667 0042<br />
www.dilloneustace.ie
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
Garry Ferguson<br />
Walkers Ireland<br />
Walkers is the second Cayman Islands<br />
headquartered firm to set up a base in<br />
Dublin in recent years. Unlike Maples and<br />
Calder, which established in Ireland by<br />
subsuming an indigenous firm, Walkers<br />
was a total startup in 2010.<br />
Walkers also has offices in the British<br />
Virgin Islands, Delaware, Dubai, Hong Kong,<br />
Jersey, London and Singapore, with over 500<br />
staff employed. In Dublin the primary focus<br />
is funds and financial services including<br />
capital markets and aviation finance, and<br />
taxation as it applies to these areas.<br />
Recruits have come from top Dublin firms<br />
and from London law firms, and the fee<br />
earner complement is now 30, with total<br />
staff of 43. The aim is to grow headcount<br />
by 20% in the coming 12 months.<br />
The first lawyer to be hired was Garry<br />
Ferguson (38), a specialist in structured<br />
finance. He is now Managing Partner in<br />
Dublin after Vicki Hazelden, who managed<br />
the practice until January, stepped down.<br />
Ferguson joined Walkers from Matheson,<br />
attracted by the entrepreneurial<br />
opportunity of building up a new corporate<br />
law firm from scratch.<br />
Ferguson, who worked as a tax adviser in<br />
KPMG earlier in his career, says that the<br />
recruitment process in Walkers is rigorous.<br />
He explains that the objective is to<br />
ensure that not only are new hires good<br />
lawyers but that they also fit in with the<br />
‘We have consistently exceeded our ambitious targets’<br />
tight-knit culture of the firm.<br />
A significant portion of Walker’s funds<br />
and financial services work is sourced from<br />
the firm’s other offices but Ferguson says<br />
more than half of such work is generated<br />
by the Dublin office itself. “Overall the firm<br />
has shown very strong growth across all<br />
practice areas. We have consistently<br />
exceeded our fairly ambitious targets and<br />
we are probably a year ahead of where we<br />
expected to be as regards headcount<br />
and turnover,” says Ferguson.<br />
Though Walkers is small in terms of<br />
headcount compared with the leading<br />
corporate firms in Dublin, Ferguson insists<br />
that his firm goes toe to toe with the legal<br />
giants in the international niche areas that<br />
it plays in. On the domestic front, Walkers is<br />
embarking this year on building up its niche<br />
corporate and commercial arm, as well as<br />
launching a new practice area in regulatory<br />
and compliance services.<br />
‘We have continued to win more corporate clients’<br />
Stephen Walker<br />
WhitneyMoore<br />
WhitneyMoore signalled its growth<br />
ambitions earlier this year when it merged<br />
with Moriarty & Co, a five-lawyer practice<br />
specialising in bank litigation. “We view<br />
the merger as a positive addition to<br />
WhitneyMoore that will enhance the<br />
service offering we provide to our clients,”<br />
says Stephen Walker (49), who has been<br />
Managing Partner since January 2010.<br />
Walker practises across a broad range<br />
of commercial areas such as mergers and<br />
acquisitions, corporate finance, venture<br />
capital, joint ventures and corporate<br />
restructuring. WhitneyMoore also has<br />
litigation expertise and acted for<br />
McCambridges in its successful passing off<br />
action against Brennans. “Our intellectual<br />
property practice has continued to build<br />
upon its international reputation,<br />
attracting new clients pursuing actions<br />
in the Irish courts to protect their<br />
intellectual property rights,” says Walker.<br />
WhitneyMoore also advised San Leon<br />
Energy on its acquisition last year of<br />
London-based Aurelian Oil & Gas plc.<br />
“While the number of M&A transactions<br />
remains significantly down on peak<br />
activity, we have seen a surprisingly high<br />
level of early stage venture capital<br />
investments,” says Walker. “We have<br />
advised a large number of new client<br />
companies in successfully concluding<br />
investment rounds.”<br />
Walker insists that instructing<br />
WhitneyMoore is a ‘sound financial<br />
choice’ for any business client. He<br />
explains: “As a medium-sized firm,<br />
WhitneyMoore is large enough to have<br />
the experience and resources necessary<br />
to provide specialist advice, yet small<br />
enough to retain direct partner<br />
involvement in all matters and keep<br />
our rates competitive.”<br />
BUSINESS PLUS APRIL 2013 70
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘I don’t expect a dramatic recovery<br />
in property-related activity’<br />
Peter Walsh<br />
Orpen Franks<br />
Peter Walsh (37) joined Orpen Franks<br />
in 1999 and was elected Managing<br />
Partner in March 2009. He acts for<br />
corporates and financial institutions<br />
in various projects and now increasingly<br />
in restructuring, enforcement<br />
and insolvency. Recent high-profile<br />
matters involving the firm include<br />
acting for the liquidator of the Pierse<br />
Group and the examinership of the<br />
Pilot Training College in Waterford. “We are<br />
particularly pleased with the success in the Commercial<br />
Court action in the area of pyrite damage,<br />
where we acted for James Elliott Construction<br />
against stone supplier, Irish Asphalt,” says Walsh.<br />
Walsh adds that commercial litigation and<br />
insolvency, coupled with general commercial activity<br />
dealing with contracts and procurement, are<br />
resilient. “It is these areas of practice we will be<br />
looking to grow. With litigation, it is a question of<br />
managing the cashflow and timing of payments.<br />
Conveyancing is still very quiet, and though there<br />
was an upturn in the residential market at the end<br />
of 2012, I certainly don’t expect a dramatic recovery<br />
in the property-related activity. In the debt recovery<br />
and insolvency arenas, we have become very active<br />
for financial institutions, insolvency practitioners<br />
and individual borrowers.”<br />
What attracts clients to Orpen Franks? “Capacity,<br />
responsiveness, accessibility, results and value,” is<br />
Walsh’s response, adding that the firm has recruited<br />
three solicitors in the past year. “We have a good<br />
record of retention and development of quality<br />
professional staff coming from the trainee<br />
programme through to partner level,” he adds.<br />
‘We are better at understanding the<br />
needs of our commercial clients’<br />
Joanne Griffin<br />
Kilroys<br />
In January 2013, Joanne Griffin took<br />
over from Eamon Jones as Managing<br />
Partner of Kilroys, a law firm that has<br />
been in business for nearly 60 years.<br />
Griffin was a lecturer until 1996 when<br />
she joined Kilroys as a trainee. She<br />
qualified as a solicitor in 1999 and was<br />
appointed partner in 2003. Griffin has<br />
extensive expertise of dealing with<br />
company restructurings,<br />
amalgamations and mergers and the<br />
structures and taxation issues arising<br />
in connection with such transactions.<br />
Kilroys also advises company<br />
directors being pursued by the ODCE,<br />
and counsels clients in proceedings<br />
involving liquidators, receivers and<br />
examiners. “Commercial litigation has<br />
been very strong in the past 12<br />
months, though we see this area<br />
slowing in terms of new instructions,”<br />
says Griffin. “We have seen an increase<br />
in commercial instructions work in the<br />
insurance, retail and financial sectors.”<br />
Griffin says that one of Kilroys’ key<br />
selling points is the availability of<br />
partners to deal with client matters on<br />
a day-to-day basis. “We are primarily a<br />
partner driven firm and this is what<br />
many corporate clients look for,” she<br />
explains. “It means that we are better<br />
at understanding the needs of our<br />
commercial clients and we can identify<br />
closely with management requirements<br />
in our client companies.”<br />
In Griffin’s opinion, credit in the<br />
economy is extremely tight. “Cash is<br />
king and transactions that are<br />
happening involve international clients<br />
and are funded with cash resources<br />
primarily and with little leverage. In<br />
the final quarter of 2012 there was<br />
a realisation that an indefinite hold<br />
cannot be put on commercial<br />
transaction work, restructurings and<br />
acquisitions. There is a more upbeat,<br />
can-do attitude in terms of clients<br />
making decisions. Legal costs budgets,<br />
whilst still very tight, recognise the<br />
benefits of timely and proportionate<br />
legal advices.”
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘We are seeing more activity on the lending side’<br />
Sean Twomey<br />
Eugene F Collins<br />
Managing Partner Sean Twomey joined<br />
Eugene F Collins as a result of a merger<br />
with George D Fottrell and Sons in 2003.<br />
Twomey and David Cantrell, EFC’s boss at<br />
the time, were the driving forces behind the<br />
merger and Twomey succeeded Cantrell in<br />
2009. He says his role spans formulating<br />
the firm's strategy, developing the business<br />
and maintaining close links with many of<br />
the firm's most important clients.<br />
Twomey specialises in banking and<br />
commercial property and he has extensive<br />
experience in commercial property lending<br />
and acts for all major lending institutions.<br />
He also advises on lending restructurings<br />
and enforcement of securities, as well as<br />
the property aspects of mergers and<br />
acquisitions and of joint venture<br />
transactions.<br />
Eugene F Collins is celebrating its 120th<br />
year in business in 2013 and its Managing<br />
Partner is happy to talk up the reasons for<br />
the firm’s longevity. “Our firm has a long<br />
and established history of giving first-rate<br />
legal advice and exceptional client service,”<br />
says Twomey. “We know that our<br />
knowledge, coupled with our ability to<br />
provide relevant business-centric legal<br />
solutions, will help our clients to continue<br />
to succeed in their business. We have<br />
striven to attract and retain leading legal<br />
talent and the reputation of our partners<br />
reflects the expertise and professionalism<br />
of a long-standing firm.”<br />
Twomey says the firm has seen an<br />
increase in corporate activity. “Our capital<br />
markets team has been busy, giving advises<br />
to the likes of Johnson and Johnson, IBRC<br />
and Bord Gais. Our banking team is busy<br />
too; we are seeing more activity on the<br />
lending side and there are a number of<br />
restructurings going on. We continue to<br />
work with all the major banks, Nama and<br />
the leading insolvency practitioners. Our<br />
media lawyers have also dealt with a<br />
number of high-profile defamation cases.”<br />
Survey continued on page 74<br />
OUR PRIORITY<br />
IS YOU.<br />
Eugene F. Collins is a partner led law firm<br />
which commits to partner involvement in<br />
managing each client's legal requirements.<br />
We have built our business and our reputation on the simple<br />
but fundamental principle of seeking at all times to give a<br />
first-class legal service to our clients while building solid<br />
and trusted relationships with clients. Visit efc.ie<br />
Temple Chambers<br />
3 Burlington Road<br />
Dublin 4, Ireland<br />
T +353 1 202 6400<br />
F +353 1 667 5200<br />
DX 25<br />
E lawyer@efc.ie<br />
W www.efc.ie<br />
Celebrating 120 Years in <strong>Business</strong>
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘Today’s client is a more<br />
discerning customer’<br />
‘Many of our clients have weathered the<br />
downturn in good shape’<br />
Brian Gill<br />
Callan Tansey<br />
Callan Tansey is the<br />
largest law firm in<br />
Connacht, employing<br />
55 people at its offices<br />
in Sligo and Boyle.<br />
Brian Gill (40) has<br />
been Managing<br />
Partner since October<br />
2011 and he believes<br />
that law firms have to<br />
re-evaluate the traditional business model that<br />
sustained them in times gone by. “Today’s client<br />
is a more discerning customer and law firms<br />
must adapt or face the consequences,” he says.<br />
Gill adds that 2012 was challenging for the<br />
firm. “Thankfully our activity and instruction levels<br />
have held up, particularly in litigation. The early<br />
signs in 2013 are good. There is an increase in<br />
corporate advisory work as SMEs face the<br />
challenges of the depressed economic climate.”<br />
Gill describes Callan Tansey as the ‘go to’ law<br />
firm for both private and corporate clients in the<br />
North West and Connacht. “We promote a highperformance<br />
culture amongst our staff which is<br />
dedicated to securing excellent value for money<br />
outcomes for all our clients,” he explains.<br />
“We have implemented a staff performance<br />
programme which involves a unique 360-degree<br />
peer-review process, critiqued by international<br />
consultants. Given the increasing importance of<br />
risk management in the legal services sector, we<br />
were delighted to secure the Q6000 Gold<br />
Standard accreditation for risk management from<br />
the Irish Institute of Legal Standards & Research.”<br />
John C. O’Connor<br />
O’Connor Solicitors<br />
Does having a good legal firm<br />
strengthen a company’s chances of<br />
surviving a recession? Yes it does,<br />
according to John C. O’Connor,<br />
Managing Partner of O’Connor<br />
Solicitors in central Dublin. “Our<br />
business clients value the quality of<br />
service and cost effectiveness of the<br />
practice,” he says. “We seek to develop<br />
a close working relationship with all of<br />
our clients, together with a detailed<br />
understanding of their businesses. This<br />
leads to a progressive and efficient<br />
method of dealing with legal issues<br />
that arise. Many of these clients have<br />
weathered the economic downturn in<br />
good shape and we would like to think<br />
these factors are all connected.”<br />
O’Connor’s areas of expertise include<br />
regulatory law and he advises a<br />
number of governing bodies, trade<br />
unions and charities. “The firm has<br />
continued to perform strongly in the<br />
healthcare and regulatory areas,”<br />
says O’Connor. “Employment law<br />
and commercial leasing have been<br />
particularly busy and we have also seen<br />
additional work in the charity sector in<br />
anticipation of the full implementation<br />
of the Charities Act.”<br />
O’Connor believes that some<br />
economic green shoots are starting to<br />
emerge. “Landlords are now becoming<br />
more realistic about rental income,<br />
realising the danger of having property<br />
vacant for long periods. Therefore<br />
businesses are in a position to move,<br />
expand and develop and are no longer<br />
as constrained by high rents. We are<br />
also starting to see the first signs of<br />
improved credit conditions for SMEs<br />
and increased volumes of lending to<br />
individuals in connection with<br />
residential purchasing.”
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘Enforcement and insolvency<br />
work continue to be busy’<br />
David Phelan<br />
Hayes Solicitors<br />
David Phelan (38) became Managing<br />
Partner of Hayes Solicitors in May<br />
2011. He heads up the firm’s<br />
commercial law team and has<br />
specific expertise relating to the<br />
manufacturing and retail sectors.<br />
He also advises on regulatory<br />
matters and has represented<br />
numerous businesses and individuals<br />
in Competition Authority<br />
investigations and criminal prosecutions. Phelan<br />
also advises on intellectual property issues.<br />
Hayes recently represented PTSB Finance in the<br />
sale of an assorted loan portfolio to a European<br />
bank and the establishment of First Citizen Finance.<br />
“There are encouraging signs of M&A activity<br />
increasing over the last six months or so, which<br />
hopefully is one sign of a recovery in business<br />
activity,” says Phelan. “Enforcement and insolvency<br />
work continue to be busy, which has been a trend<br />
over the last few years.”<br />
According to Phelan, Hayes focuses on achieving<br />
pragmatic solutions for clients in a way that gives<br />
them value for money. “We are conscious that all<br />
businesses need to keep their legal spend to a<br />
minimum and we provide service to our clients on<br />
that basis,” he explains. “We have continued to<br />
grow our numbers in a measured way so as to meet<br />
the needs of existing clients and a number of new<br />
clients won over the course of the year.”<br />
‘The level of M&A activity in the past year<br />
was surprising’<br />
Orlaith O’Brien<br />
McEvoy Partners<br />
Orlaith O’Brien (41) is a founding<br />
partner of McEvoy Partners and is<br />
Managing Partner. She has guided a<br />
number of Irish and UK companies<br />
through the AIM listing process and<br />
she works with these clients on their<br />
fundraisings, acquisitions and<br />
disposals. The boutique practice is a<br />
regular award winner from legal<br />
journals for its M&A counsel and the<br />
firm is also active in commercial<br />
property, corporate restructuring and<br />
litigation.<br />
According to O’Brien: “The level of<br />
M&A activity in the past year was<br />
surprising, given that the ability to<br />
obtain bank funding remains difficult.<br />
We have been engaged in quite a<br />
number of corporate restructurings and<br />
in M&A transactions, and also in<br />
advising private equity and venture<br />
capital investors in relation to various<br />
investments. Of particular note, we<br />
advised Mater Private Hospital in a<br />
joint venture arrangement in the<br />
opening of a new private hospital in<br />
Cork.”<br />
O’Brien says her firm takes a teambased<br />
approach to problem solving<br />
and legal advice. “The partners work<br />
closely with the other solicitors within<br />
the firm in a cost-effective team<br />
environment,” she says. “As many of<br />
our solicitors previously worked in<br />
large corporate firms, we provide the<br />
expertise and professionalism of a<br />
large corporate law firm combined<br />
with the personal service and flexibility<br />
associated with a smaller boutique<br />
firm.”<br />
She adds: “The firm’s ability to<br />
deliver practical commercial advice and<br />
results within deadlines, and its<br />
dedication and personal service to<br />
clients, has ensured client loyalty and<br />
attracted a steady stream of new<br />
commercial clients.”<br />
Survey continued on page 76
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘There has been an increase<br />
in property transactions’<br />
‘I have been surprised at the level of<br />
M&A activity’<br />
Cómhnall Tuohy<br />
Kane Tuohy<br />
Cómhnall Tuohy<br />
(42) was appointed<br />
Managing Partner<br />
of Kane Tuohy on<br />
the founding of the<br />
firm in February<br />
2009. He specialises<br />
in commercial<br />
litigation, largescale<br />
debt recovery,<br />
enforcement of security and employment law,<br />
for which he has a proven reputation.<br />
Tuohy says the firm has benefited from<br />
increased activity in its insolvency, corporate<br />
restructuring, litigation, property and banking<br />
departments, resulting in new hires. “There<br />
has also been a notable demand for advice in<br />
commercial transactions and agreements,<br />
and in the handling of debt, both from the<br />
perspective of the creditor and the debtor,”<br />
says Tuohy.<br />
“There has been a significant increase in<br />
activity in property transactions, mostly due<br />
to distressed property sales. There has been<br />
an increase too in instructions in private<br />
residential property sales and purchases, along<br />
with an increase in landlord and tenant work,<br />
particularly in the food sector.”<br />
In Tuohy’s view, there has been no noticeable<br />
improvement in credit conditions in the economy,<br />
apart from the agricultural sector and loan restructuring.<br />
“The economy is still adjusting and each<br />
sector is different in terms of bottoming out.”<br />
Neil Keenan<br />
LKG Ballagh<br />
LKG Ballagh was created in 2012 by<br />
the merger of Lavery Kirby Gilmartin<br />
with partners in KMB Solicitors. The<br />
firm is led by Managing Partner James<br />
Flynn while Neil Keenan is its Head of<br />
Corporate and Commercial and is the<br />
public face of the firm. “The merger<br />
has resulted in us being able to<br />
develop a number of specialist practice<br />
groups within the firm,” says Keenan.<br />
LKG Ballagh’s clients include Eddie<br />
O’Connor’s Mainstream Renewable<br />
Power and Keenan advised on that<br />
company’s raising of around €60m<br />
from Macquaire Capital in 2012. “This<br />
was a complex transaction and one<br />
that we were delighted to have been<br />
involved with,” says Keenan. “The firm<br />
also acted in a number of substantial<br />
equity fundraising transactions by<br />
companies who have developed<br />
alternative energy technologies,<br />
including Endeco and Aer Bio. We also<br />
acted for the AIB Seed Capital Fund<br />
and the Western Development<br />
Commission on a range of equity<br />
investments and disposals.”<br />
Keenan adds: “We have found the<br />
past year particularly busy in corporate<br />
transactions. I have been surprised at the<br />
level of M&A activity, particularly disposals<br />
of Irish businesses to foreign investors.<br />
There are a lot of good early stage<br />
businesses raising funds at the seed and<br />
early stage capital stage and a number<br />
of VCs who are active at this level.”<br />
In Keenan’s view, there is an<br />
increased need in the Irish market for<br />
boutique commercial firms who are<br />
entrepreneurial and business focused.<br />
“We believe there are very few firms<br />
such as ours who have a track record<br />
in handling large and complex<br />
corporate transactions, as well as<br />
banking and finance and large<br />
litigation cases, without the overhead<br />
and additional cost that goes with a<br />
large commercial firm.<br />
“I would like to see more state and<br />
bank work being spread beyond the<br />
large city centre firms, as there are<br />
many firms throughout the country<br />
who can offer an expert and efficient<br />
service without the seemingly<br />
extraordinary costs that some of the<br />
larger firms seem to be charging to<br />
some of the state agencies.”
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
‘There has been a sharp increase in professional<br />
indemnity claims’<br />
‘The economy has just<br />
about touched bottom’<br />
Katie da Gama<br />
DAC Beachcroft<br />
International law firm DAC Beachcroft set<br />
up a Dublin office five years ago, headed<br />
by senior partner Katie da Gama. Globally<br />
DAC has around 2,500 lawyers and support<br />
staff and the expansion into Dublin was<br />
prompted by demand from London market<br />
insurers for the establishment of an Irish<br />
firm that would provide a continuity of<br />
service. The firm specialises in insurance<br />
law, professional indemnity claims, injury<br />
matters, healthcare and clinical risk,<br />
commercial litigation and employment law.<br />
“There has been a sharp increase in<br />
professional indemnity claims during the<br />
past year,” says da Gama. “These have<br />
been focused on both the solicitors'<br />
and construction professionals’ arena.<br />
The volume of commercial litigation<br />
has increased and a key theme is claims<br />
against financial institutions and/or<br />
financial advisors connected with the<br />
alleged mis-selling of financial products<br />
and investments.”<br />
In the past year, DAC Beachcroft has<br />
recruited 13 people to bring the staff total<br />
in the Dublin office to 39. “We have<br />
expanded into two new areas of practice,<br />
namely injury risk fraud and employment<br />
law,” says da Gama. “We are a truly<br />
specialist, global firm and we put our clients<br />
at the centre of everything we do. We also<br />
offer innovative and flexible pricing models.”<br />
Daniel Hughes<br />
Hughes &<br />
Associates<br />
Most solicitors<br />
in Ireland are<br />
self-employed<br />
and Daniel Hughes<br />
of Hughes &<br />
Associates has just<br />
been shortlisted<br />
for the ‘Sole<br />
Practitioner of the Year’ award at the Danske<br />
Bank Irish <strong>Law</strong> Awards 2013. Hughes has<br />
developed a strong litigation practice and he<br />
says there has been a significant increase in<br />
the advices being sought by directors in their<br />
personal capacity.<br />
“Our practice provides comprehensive legal<br />
advice on a par with larger firms but with<br />
significantly reduced fees,” says Hughes. “We<br />
have recently relocated to new offices on<br />
Eustace Street in Dublin 2. We have<br />
implemented a new IT system with cloud<br />
computing, and we anticipate a significant<br />
growth in our practice in the next 18 months<br />
and a requirement for further personnel.”<br />
Hughes believes that the economy has just<br />
about touched bottom. “I am starting to see<br />
an appetite by clients to develop new startup<br />
businesses and there has been more positivity<br />
among clients in the last six months.”<br />
Survey continued on page 78
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
To what extent have credit conditions improved<br />
and has the Irish economy bottomed out?<br />
Andrew Doyle (Maples and Calder):<br />
There are signals from our market which<br />
would draw us to the conclusion that<br />
there are positive times ahead for<br />
Ireland’s economy:<br />
● Increasing interest in Irish corporates<br />
from overseas financial investors.<br />
● Increased availability of credit,<br />
development and turnaround capital<br />
with the investments being made by the<br />
NPRF in funds managed by BlueBay,<br />
Better Capital and Carlyle. This could<br />
have a very significant effect on the<br />
transactional landscape.<br />
● An increase in corporate confidence<br />
in line with recovery in equity capital<br />
markets.<br />
● Ireland continues to punch well above<br />
its weight in attracting inward<br />
investment.<br />
We are seeing some increase in loan<br />
origination and in new money<br />
refinancings to existing clients. Obviously<br />
the banks are being prudent in relation to<br />
some existing clients in restructuring<br />
debt appropriately to the reality of the<br />
situation. We are also seeing some fresh<br />
credit being provided by Nama/IBRC in<br />
appropriate circumstances.<br />
Neil Keenan (LKG Ballagh): All the<br />
indications are that the economy has<br />
touched bottom and that a slow<br />
improvement has started. There has<br />
definitely been an increase in business<br />
startups and corporate activity, in<br />
inward investment and even in property<br />
activity in certain areas. The macro<br />
indicators such as the slight rise in<br />
house prices in Dublin, the stabilisation<br />
in the unemployment numbers and the<br />
limited return to the bond markets are<br />
all positive.<br />
I am finding that there has only been<br />
a very limited improvement in credit<br />
conditions. The SME sector to which I<br />
have a substantial exposure through my<br />
presidency of the Dún Laoghaire<br />
Rathdown Chamber of Commerce is<br />
still struggling to get credit. Our clients<br />
are also finding that decisions by banks<br />
are slow and the terms of facilities<br />
difficult to negotiate, and that lenders<br />
are slow to agree deals that are quite<br />
obviously in the best interests of the<br />
borrower and the bank. However, there<br />
does appear to be an increased appetite<br />
to provide credit to certain sectors, such<br />
as the renewable energy sector.<br />
John White (Beauchamps): Credit<br />
conditions for businesses, particularly<br />
SMEs, continue to be very tough. There<br />
is no real sense of banks lending any<br />
more than they did this time last year, or<br />
indeed credit conditions easing. More<br />
trust and increased credit has returned<br />
to trading arrangements between<br />
corporates because the weaker players in<br />
many industries have gone into<br />
receivership or liquidation. Banks are<br />
now more willing to facilitate<br />
restructuring plans and this is an<br />
encouraging sign.<br />
Demand is certainly increasing for<br />
centrally located commercial property<br />
space and Beauchamps has seen the<br />
number of international referrals double<br />
in the last year. This is a strong<br />
indication that outside the country, at<br />
least, the bottom is being called.<br />
Catherine Guy (ByrneWallace): The<br />
retail sector is currently under significant<br />
pressure. Many multiunit retailers are<br />
having difficulties in negotiating more<br />
manageable lease terms and rental<br />
payments with landlords. Other sectors<br />
that are also in difficulty include services<br />
and construction. Five of the top ten<br />
construction companies have become<br />
insolvent since 2007 and that has<br />
resulted in a significant knock-on effect<br />
on suppliers and subcontractors.<br />
However, activity levels on the<br />
transactional side have been creeping up<br />
over the last six months and we are very<br />
confident that this acceleration will<br />
continue.<br />
<br />
LKG Ballagh is a dynamic and entrepreneurial law<br />
firm that will deliver a results focused and Partner<br />
led service.<br />
Find out more and see our impressive track record<br />
and client testimonials at lkgballagh.ie<br />
Partners pictured from left to right:<br />
James Flynn Head of Private Client,<br />
David Ballagh Head of Commercial Property,<br />
Agatha Taylor Head of Litigation,<br />
Neil Keenan Head of Corporate and Commercial.<br />
lkgballagh.ie | Tel: 01 231 1430<br />
The Forum, 29-31 Glasthule Road, Glasthule, Co Dublin.<br />
Consultation Rooms at Lower Pembroke Street, Dublin 2.
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
Brian Gill (Callan Tansey): Overall, the<br />
credit squeeze remains tight for<br />
corporate clients. Over the last two<br />
years the government’s focus has been<br />
on improving its own credit lines to the<br />
outside world. The focus now needs to<br />
shift to the domestic market and a more<br />
robust approach needs to be adopted<br />
with the banks regarding the flow of<br />
credit to business. Consumer<br />
confidence has not yet improved,<br />
hampered no doubt by the scourges of<br />
high unemployment and high personal<br />
debt. The impact of the public sector<br />
pay talks will also play a key role in<br />
shaping the economic landscape during<br />
this coming year.<br />
Mark Thorne (Dillon Eustace): Credit<br />
conditions for our clients have improved<br />
significantly. Over the last year we have<br />
seen additional credit available from<br />
Irish and non-Irish banks, and indeed<br />
non-bank lenders, particularly in the<br />
area of healthcare and nursing home<br />
development. We have also seen a<br />
number of international banks looking<br />
to finance acquisitions of distressed<br />
commercial property-backed loan<br />
portfolios, and again we see this to be a<br />
very positive sign.<br />
Sean Twomey (Eugene F Collins): We<br />
are seeing a number of restructurings<br />
taking place. This would involve<br />
refinancing and this seems to be<br />
available. The credit conditions would<br />
not be as favourable as before, as the<br />
banks are looking for higher margins,<br />
but credit is slowly coming back to the<br />
‘Clients are<br />
looking forward<br />
rather than<br />
standing still’<br />
market. I think Ireland’s economy has<br />
reached the bottom. All the economic<br />
indicators are heading the right way.<br />
We still have a lot of work and<br />
adjustment to do but there seems to be<br />
light at the end of the tunnel.<br />
Alan Murphy (Eversheds): We believe<br />
the austerity measures have helped to<br />
restore international confidence in<br />
the Irish economy. The perception of<br />
Ireland abroad is very positive and<br />
international clients respect the efforts<br />
Ireland is making in dealing with its<br />
problems. There is definitely a<br />
perception internationally that Ireland<br />
is starting to recover and is the<br />
standout achieving economy among<br />
the bailout countries. Lending<br />
conditions remain tight, though we are<br />
seeing movement in credit facilities by<br />
lending institutions to trading<br />
companies in food, manufacturing and<br />
technology sectors. Other forms of<br />
investment, such as private equity,<br />
funds and private investors, are taking<br />
precedent.<br />
Michael Lavelle (Lavelle Coleman):<br />
Credit conditions have shown some<br />
improvement. In the past year, we have<br />
seen an increase in property purchases<br />
and there is evidence of more stability.<br />
Clients seem to be more likely to look<br />
at business and investment<br />
opportunities. There are fewer job<br />
losses, less instructions in redundancy<br />
related employment issues and<br />
evidence of some clients creating jobs.<br />
Clients are looking forward rather than<br />
standing still. Ireland remains a<br />
destination of choice for foreign<br />
investors and Ireland Inc is still very<br />
much open for business. Lavelle<br />
Coleman is seeing increased activity in<br />
the technology sector in particular and<br />
is advising companies on establishing<br />
businesses in Ireland.<br />
David Phelan (Hayes Solicitors):<br />
Based on what we hear from clients,<br />
credit conditions haven’t significantly<br />
improved over the past year and good,<br />
strong businesses continue to have<br />
difficulty in having the banks engage<br />
with them as they would want.<br />
However, there definitely seems to<br />
be more of a feeling of optimism now<br />
that we have turned a corner than any<br />
other time over the last couple of<br />
years. The strong retail sector<br />
performance in December, an upturn<br />
in levels of merger and acquisition<br />
activity and increasing activity (and in<br />
some cases values) in the residential<br />
property market all appear<br />
encouraging.<br />
continued on page 80
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
Hugh Garvey (LK Shields): The fact<br />
that Ireland is once more seen as a<br />
location in which there is value to be<br />
had is a very welcome development.<br />
That perception, combined with an<br />
environment where there is less<br />
uncertainty internationally, has led to<br />
greater levels of commercial activity<br />
and a greater sense of optimism.<br />
However, it is no secret that the<br />
domestic economy remains challenging.<br />
Conditions for the availability of credit<br />
have improved for those (often foreignbased)<br />
seeking to invest in the Irish<br />
economy compared with credit<br />
availability for those conducting business<br />
in the economy.<br />
Emer Gilvarry (Mason Hayes &<br />
Curran): There is greater confidence in<br />
Ireland at the moment. Conditions seem<br />
to have stabilised and businesses can<br />
plan more efficiently. We are unlikely to<br />
see hockey stick growth in the near<br />
future but many organisations are just<br />
happy to have stability. The international<br />
perception is very different to the local<br />
view, as Ireland is seen as a land of<br />
opportunity at the moment by global<br />
investors. Ireland still has the same<br />
great benefits of an educated work force,<br />
good corporate tax rate and strong<br />
business culture, but now has a reduced<br />
cost base, which makes it extremely<br />
attractive for investment. Investors are<br />
seeing real value now in Irish assets and<br />
recent sales such as the Gasworks<br />
building and Bank of Ireland HQ<br />
demonstrate that people are willing to<br />
invest if the price is right.<br />
‘The international<br />
perception is very<br />
different to the<br />
local view’<br />
John Cronin (McCann FitzGerald): For<br />
small companies and businesses it<br />
continues to be difficult to raise finance.<br />
For large PLCs the refinancing of<br />
facilities is difficult but such deals are<br />
being completed. For such PLCs and<br />
certain state/semi-state organisations the<br />
US private placement market is open.<br />
Orlaith O’Brien (McEvoy Partners): The<br />
ability to obtain credit remains difficult<br />
for our clients and we haven’t seen any<br />
major change over the last year. One<br />
would think that there is a lot of good<br />
value to be had for property investors<br />
but we haven’t really seen too many<br />
foreign investors coming in to snap up<br />
bargains. Perhaps there is a perception<br />
among such investors that even a modest<br />
rise in interest rates could have a<br />
material impact on borrowers’ ability to<br />
cope. In such circumstances, property<br />
prices could drop even further. Having<br />
said that, there are some positive signs.<br />
Peter Walsh (Orpen Franks): Our<br />
traditional industries of food and<br />
tourism show great potential for growth<br />
and I believe producers and providers in<br />
this area are becoming very attuned to<br />
this. Recent concerns over food safety<br />
and provenance heightens the<br />
importance of this area and creates<br />
opportunity for native producers.<br />
Transactional activity in the nonproperty<br />
arena is okay but it is primarily<br />
operating in circumstances where there<br />
are no funding requirements from<br />
domestic banks. I would not be planning<br />
our own business around the likelihood<br />
of an increase in transactional activity.<br />
Myra Garrett (William Fry): There are<br />
welcome signs that the Irish economy<br />
has turned a corner with employment<br />
and house prices stabilising and Irish<br />
medium-term bond yields rallying from<br />
over 8% in early 2012 to under 4%<br />
currently. The inroads made by the<br />
government in restructuring our<br />
sovereign debt repayments are very<br />
positive and the international<br />
community has been impressed by the<br />
Irish reaction to the crisis. There is<br />
definite increase in transactional activity<br />
as well as more interest from<br />
international investors in Irish property<br />
assets and in acquisitions of Irish<br />
corporates.<br />
There has been a steady increase in<br />
the provision of new or refinanced credit<br />
facilities for cash-generative corporate<br />
business. We have seen both Irish pillar<br />
banks, AIB and Bank of Ireland, as well<br />
as foreign banks such as Barclays and<br />
Rabobank providing finance facilities,<br />
including acquisition finance.<br />
Survey continued on page 82
COMPANY PROFILE<br />
ROCHFORD BRADY GROUP<br />
Information As You Need it<br />
Supported by a vastly experienced searching team, Rochford Brady<br />
offers a comprehensive package for your legal information requirements<br />
At Rochford Brady we provide our clients with evolving solutions to<br />
enable access to complex and technical property data relating to<br />
specific sites for use in Commercial Development, Infrastructure<br />
Projects and Renewable Energy.<br />
When investigating sites for development,<br />
our clients must access a range of data<br />
on the site for feasibility, scoping,<br />
planning and acquisition. Traditionally<br />
this data is accessible although often<br />
from diverse sources and our clients<br />
must then undertake the timeconsuming<br />
and cumbersome task of<br />
appraising the data and manually<br />
assembling titles and reports.<br />
At Rochford Brady, we have innovated<br />
the way that our clients order and<br />
assemble this information by<br />
developing a new land-referencing<br />
mapping tool. It’s easily navigated, and<br />
layers of information can be turned on<br />
and off to allow clear interpretation<br />
of the data in the context of the site.<br />
Detailed reports are linked to the map<br />
as PDF documents and are available by<br />
simply selecting a location on the map.<br />
Land referencing brings together a<br />
comprehensive suite of property data<br />
from diverse sources and combines<br />
them behind an interactive GIS map<br />
providing a powerful tool that improves<br />
the efficiency and effectiveness of<br />
interpreting the site data, and enhances<br />
information governance and data<br />
management.<br />
Rochford Brady can carry out<br />
planning and licensing searches<br />
in all counties, and search in all<br />
registries, including:<br />
Companies Registration Office<br />
Registry of friendly societies<br />
Closing searches<br />
Copy folio/file plans<br />
Folio inspections<br />
Registry of deeds<br />
Licensing<br />
Planning<br />
Probate<br />
Sheriffs' offices<br />
Title registration<br />
Birth, marriage & death certificates<br />
Mapping searches<br />
Town agency<br />
Judgments Office<br />
Bankruptcy<br />
Credit reports<br />
UK Companies House<br />
Worldwide company searches<br />
Fitness and probity searches<br />
CONTACT DETAILS<br />
For more information, contact<br />
our sales team on 01 707 6200.<br />
BUSINESS PLUS APRIL 2013 81
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
LISTING DATA<br />
Partner and solicitor numbers<br />
are for Ireland only and are<br />
sourced from the <strong>Law</strong> Society<br />
Directory 2012. Practice<br />
descriptions are drawn from<br />
the law firms’ websites and<br />
submissions.<br />
<strong>Law</strong> <strong>Firms</strong><br />
<strong>Who</strong>’s <strong>Who</strong><br />
Arthur Cox<br />
www.arthurcox.com<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 232<br />
Managing Partner: Brian<br />
O’Gorman<br />
Arthur Cox is all-island firm, with<br />
offices in Dublin and Belfast. The<br />
firm also has offices in London,<br />
New York and Silicon Valley.<br />
Ciarán Bolger is taking over<br />
from Eugene McCague as<br />
chairman of Arthur Cox<br />
this May<br />
Recent awards include Legal<br />
Adviser of the Year for Ireland<br />
2012, for the sixth consecutive year<br />
(FT/Mergermarket), and Republic of<br />
Ireland <strong>Law</strong> Firm of the Year 2012<br />
at the <strong>Law</strong>yer European Awards. In<br />
2012, Arthur Cox established a<br />
presence in Silicon Valley. The firm<br />
recently announced that Ciarán<br />
Bolger has been appointed<br />
chairman with effect from 1 May.<br />
He succeeds Eugene McCague,<br />
who returns to full-time client work<br />
having served for two terms as<br />
chairman.<br />
Matheson<br />
www.matheson.com<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 231<br />
Managing Partner: Liam Quirke<br />
Matheson has offices in Dublin,<br />
London, New York and Palo Alto.<br />
The primary focus of Matheson is<br />
to serve the Irish legal needs of<br />
international companies and<br />
financial institutions doing business<br />
in and through Ireland. Clients<br />
include 27 of the world’s 50 largest<br />
banks and more than half of the<br />
Fortune 100 companies. The firm is<br />
headquartered in Dublin and also<br />
has offices in London, New York<br />
and Palo Alto. It recently won the<br />
‘Client Choice’ award for Ireland<br />
2013, International <strong>Law</strong> Office, for<br />
the seventh time. Matheson was<br />
the first law firm to be recognised<br />
as one of the ‘50 Best Workplaces<br />
in Ireland’.<br />
A&L Goodbody<br />
www.algoodbody.com<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 222<br />
Managing Partner: Julian Yarr<br />
Headquartered in Dublin, with<br />
offices in Belfast, London, New<br />
York and Palo Alto, A&L Goodbody<br />
has a total staff of 580. The firm<br />
advises domestic and global<br />
corporations, financial institutions,<br />
intermediaries and government.<br />
The focus on the international<br />
market is evident by the level of<br />
instructions from a number of<br />
jurisdictions across the globe. In<br />
2012 the firm was awarded Irish<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Firm of the Year (Chambers<br />
Europe); No.1 Irish M&A <strong>Law</strong> Firm<br />
(Mergermarket, Bloomberg,<br />
Thomson Reuters) and it is the<br />
only Irish law firm to be ranked in<br />
Tier 1 in all practice areas by the<br />
International Financial <strong>Law</strong><br />
Review. Nine new partners were<br />
announced by the firm in the past<br />
12 months.<br />
McCann FitzGerald<br />
www.mccannfitzgerald.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 197<br />
Chairman: John Cronin<br />
McCann FitzGerald’s recent<br />
awards include <strong>Law</strong> Firm of the<br />
Year 2012 (International Financial<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Review); Ireland Client<br />
Service <strong>Law</strong> Firm of the Year 2012<br />
(Chambers Europe); and Ireland’s<br />
Most Innovative <strong>Law</strong> Firm 2012<br />
(FT Innovative European <strong>Law</strong>yers<br />
report). Notable deals involving<br />
the firm over the past year include<br />
Pepper Home Loans acquisition of<br />
GE Money’s Irish mortgage<br />
business; joint venture between
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
Vodafone Ireland and Three<br />
Ireland; Petroceltic’s merger with<br />
Melrose Resources; separation of<br />
Shannon Airport from the Dublin<br />
Airport Authority; €1.1bn bond<br />
issue by ESB; examinership of<br />
eircom; and acquisition of Cooper<br />
Industries by New Eaton Ltd.<br />
The firm has funded the new<br />
position of McCann FitzGerald<br />
Chair of Corporate <strong>Law</strong> at Trinity<br />
College Dublin. “This reflects our<br />
commitment to the culture of<br />
learning and continuous<br />
improvement,” says Chairman<br />
John Cronin. McCanns also funds<br />
early learning and legal aid<br />
programmes in the Docklands<br />
area where it is based. Inside the<br />
firm, five new partners were<br />
appointed while all 48 new<br />
qualifiers have been retained.<br />
William Fry<br />
www.williamfry.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 164<br />
Managing Partner: Myra Garrett<br />
William Fry is one of Ireland’s<br />
largest corporate law firms and<br />
has been firmly established in the<br />
top tier for many decades. Clients<br />
include many of the leading<br />
global and domestic companies<br />
operating in Ireland, government<br />
bodies, financial institutions and<br />
entrepreneurs. Recent awards<br />
include <strong>Law</strong> Firm of the Year 2012<br />
(Irish <strong>Law</strong> Awards); Best Firm for<br />
Women in <strong>Business</strong> 2012<br />
(Euromoney <strong>Law</strong> Awards); Most<br />
Innovative Deal for the financial<br />
restructuring of the Quinn Group<br />
and sale of Quinn Insurance<br />
(Finance Dublin Awards). In the<br />
past six months the firm has<br />
created 46 new positions, ranging<br />
from partner level through to 25<br />
new entrants into the Trainee<br />
Programme. In September 2012,<br />
the firm opened an office in<br />
London headed by senior<br />
corporate partner, Stephen Keogh.<br />
“We are client focused, results<br />
driven and consistently deliver an<br />
excellent service,” says Managing<br />
Partner Myra Garrett.<br />
Mason Hayes & Curran<br />
ww.mhc.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 134<br />
Managing Partner: Emer<br />
Gilvarry<br />
Mason Hayes & Curran says it is<br />
the fastest-growing full-service law<br />
firm in Ireland with personnel<br />
numbers and revenues doubling in<br />
the last decade. The firm’s buoyant<br />
practice areas span technology,<br />
financial services, energy,<br />
healthcare, employment, insolvency<br />
and litigation. “At the very core of<br />
our firm is a deep and intuitive<br />
understanding of the technology<br />
sector and this spreads across a<br />
variety of practice areas, from<br />
strategic commercial agreements<br />
to tax structures for large blue chip<br />
organisations,” explains Managing<br />
Partner, Emer Gilvarry. “Technology<br />
is a competency that we have<br />
developed over many decades both<br />
in our work practices and legal<br />
services. We see ourselves at the<br />
heart of the new economy, where<br />
business and technology connect.”<br />
ByrneWallace<br />
www.byrnewallace.com<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 95<br />
Managing Partner: Catherine<br />
Guy<br />
The firm positions itself as a<br />
partner of choice for privately<br />
owned indigenous firms. “We have<br />
an extensive understanding of this<br />
market and the conditions in which<br />
it operates,” says Managing<br />
Partner Catherine Guy. “We have<br />
worked with many companies<br />
since their inception and some of<br />
our clients have been with us for<br />
over 20 years, a strong testament<br />
to the quality and adaptability of<br />
our service offering.” In the past<br />
year, ByrneWallace has taken on a<br />
number of junior and senior<br />
solicitors to meet the increased<br />
levels of activity. “We continue to<br />
be very active in both general<br />
business advisory work and in the<br />
smart economy sector,” says Guy.<br />
“Understanding what clients want<br />
and need has never been more<br />
continued on page 84<br />
Hughes & Associates<br />
Solicitors<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
●<br />
Commercial Litigation & Insolvency<br />
Debt Recovery & Litigation<br />
Corporate & Commercial<br />
Bankruptcy <strong>Law</strong><br />
Employment <strong>Law</strong><br />
DAC Beachcroft Dublin<br />
An International <strong>Law</strong> Firm in Dublin<br />
Insurance, professional indemnity, defendant personal injury,<br />
health, commercial litigation and employment.<br />
DAC Beachcroft Dublin is part of the DAC Beachcroft Group,<br />
a leading international law firm with coverage across the UK,<br />
Europe, Asia- Pacific, North and Latin America.<br />
T: +353 1 231 9600<br />
www.dacbeachcroft.com/dublin<br />
Hughes & Associates Solicitors<br />
Meeting House Square<br />
13 Eustace Street<br />
Dublin 2<br />
Tel: 01 891 0020<br />
Fax: 01 891 0021<br />
Web: www.hughessolicitors.ie<br />
Email: info@hughessolicitors.ie<br />
Auckland · Birmingham · Bristol · Dublin · Edinburgh · Glasgow · Leeds · London · Madrid · Manchester<br />
Mexico City · Newcastle · Newport · Santiago · Singapore · Wellington · Winchester
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
A new trend in law firms is Of Counsel, i.e. lawyers who are<br />
employed but who are not partners or associates. At<br />
Beauchamps, Felix McTiernan (right) has been appointed<br />
Of Counsel in the firm’s litigation practice. Also pictured is<br />
Managing Partner John White<br />
important. Focusing on quality,<br />
efficiency and experience is a key<br />
part of our service.”<br />
Eversheds<br />
www.eversheds.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 74<br />
Managing Partner: Alan Murphy<br />
A full-service international law<br />
firm, Eversheds offers a range of<br />
multi-jurisdictional offerings across<br />
26 countries with a single point of<br />
contact. Practice areas include<br />
corporate and commercial, life<br />
sciences, banking, healthcare,<br />
employment, pensions, litigation,<br />
energy and funds. Firm-specific<br />
global products span company<br />
secretarial services, international<br />
real estate management services,<br />
and international data protection<br />
management services. In the past<br />
year the firm has appointed three<br />
new partners: Darragh Blake<br />
(banking and finance); Pamela<br />
O’Neill (commercial litigation); and<br />
Ian Devlin (financial services and<br />
pensions). The firm has also<br />
formalised its data protection team<br />
headed by Kate Colleary.<br />
Beauchamps<br />
www.beauchamps.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 70<br />
Managing Partner: John White<br />
John White became managing<br />
partner in September 2011. A few<br />
months later the firm acquired<br />
Landwell Solicitors, the Irish<br />
branch of the international<br />
network of corporate law firms<br />
connected to PwC. This year the<br />
firm has acquired the practice of<br />
Felix McTiernan Solicitors. The firm<br />
is in growth mode and over the<br />
past two years the number of<br />
solicitors in Beauchamps has<br />
increased from 50 to 70.<br />
Dillon Eustace<br />
www.dilloneustace.ie<br />
Partners/ Solicitors: 68<br />
Managing Partner: Mark Thorne<br />
The firm’s key practice areas<br />
include financial services, banking,<br />
capital markets, corporate M&A,<br />
litigation, dispute resolution, real<br />
estate and taxation. The firm has a<br />
global outlook and reach with<br />
offices in Dublin, Tokyo, Hong<br />
Kong and New York. The firm has<br />
also established an office in the<br />
Cayman Islands, providing<br />
Cayman law financial services and<br />
litigation advice to its extensive<br />
financial services client base. The<br />
firm has been heavily involved in<br />
the acquisition and financing of<br />
very significant non-performing<br />
loan and distressed loan portfolios<br />
in the past 12 months and<br />
advising numerous international<br />
clients in relation to acquisitions<br />
of Irish corporates, real estate and<br />
financial assets.<br />
Maples and Calder<br />
www.maplesandcalder.com<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 64<br />
Managing Partner: Andrew<br />
Doyle<br />
Maples and Calder is the first<br />
international law firm to seriously<br />
target the full-service offerings of<br />
the large domestic firms. Maples<br />
in Dublin now comprises over<br />
200 people and notable<br />
developments in 2012 included<br />
the hiring of insurance litigator<br />
Peter Lennon and the<br />
establishment of an Advocacy<br />
Service, offering clients the option<br />
of bypassing junior counsel in<br />
court litigation. Says Managing<br />
Partner Andrew Doyle: “Our<br />
objective in Ireland is not to be<br />
the largest law firm; it is to be,<br />
and to be known as, the law firm<br />
of excellence in our chosen areas<br />
of expertise and we believe we<br />
deliver on this objective. “<br />
Ronan Daly Jermyn<br />
www.rdj.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 54<br />
Managing Partner: Richard<br />
Martin<br />
Ronan Daly Jermyn has total<br />
personnel of 150. It is the largest<br />
regional law firm in Ireland with<br />
offices in Cork and Galway. RDJ<br />
firm represents local, national<br />
and international clients engaged<br />
in a wide range of activities, as<br />
well as public sector bodies and<br />
governmental agencies. The main<br />
areas of commercial practice<br />
include corporate, M&A, inward<br />
investment, IT and e-commerce,<br />
tax, intellectual property,<br />
employment, insolvency and debt<br />
recovery, banking and finance,<br />
media, construction and<br />
procurement, commercial property,<br />
litigation, insurance and<br />
professional indemnity. The firm<br />
received the Chambers Europe<br />
Client Service Award for Ireland<br />
and was named Irish Insurance<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Firm of the Year 2012 by<br />
Acquisition International.
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
Eugene F Collins<br />
www.efc.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 52<br />
Managing Partner: Sean Twomey<br />
Two recent important partner<br />
appointments at Eugene F Collins<br />
have been Joanne Finn, head of the<br />
EU, Competition and Regulated<br />
Markets group, and Sharon<br />
McCaffrey, who specialises in<br />
corporate work. “These strategic<br />
appointments add to our capacity<br />
to provide first-class advice to our<br />
clients and reflects the increase in<br />
corporate activity,” says Managing<br />
Partner Sean Twomey. “We<br />
continue to be involved in a<br />
number of high-profile litigation<br />
cases. We have acted for virtually<br />
all accountants that take insolvency<br />
appointments and we have been<br />
involved in every significant<br />
insolvency case this year.”<br />
LK Shields<br />
www.lkshields.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 51<br />
Managing Partner: Hugh Garvey<br />
The firm provides legal advice on all<br />
aspects of commercial-related<br />
ventures and disputes. The work of<br />
the business, litigation and dispute<br />
resolution, and commercial property<br />
departments are complemented by<br />
dedicated units in disciplines<br />
including banking and financial<br />
services; corporate restructuring<br />
and insolvency; employment,<br />
pensions and employee benefits;<br />
EU, competition and regulated<br />
markets; intellectual property; and<br />
technology. Says Managing Partner<br />
Hugh Garvey: “Over the past year<br />
our expertise, experience and focus<br />
on the provision of a high-quality<br />
service has served us well and<br />
assisted us to achieve some<br />
significant business wins. This year<br />
we celebrate 25 years in business.”<br />
Hayes solicitors<br />
www.hayes-solicitors.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 35<br />
Managing Partner: David Phelan<br />
Hayes solicitors is a corporate and<br />
commercial law firm, dealing also<br />
in the areas of employment,<br />
media law, healthcare, property<br />
and family law. Managing Partner<br />
David Phelan is a member of the<br />
<strong>Business</strong> <strong>Law</strong> Committee of the<br />
Dublin Solicitors Bar Association,<br />
tutors in commercial law, is a<br />
registered trade mark agent and a<br />
member of the <strong>Business</strong><br />
Opportunities Task Force of Dublin<br />
Chamber of Commerce.<br />
Holmes O’Malley Sexton<br />
www.homs.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 32<br />
Managing Partner: Harry Fehily<br />
The firm is based in Limerick and<br />
has an office in Dublin, where the<br />
firm is focused on expanding.<br />
WhitneyMoore<br />
www.whitneymoore.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 29<br />
Managing Partner: Stephen<br />
Walker<br />
WhitneyMoore is a wellestablished<br />
Dublin law firm with a<br />
culture of providing consistently<br />
high-quality legal advice promptly,<br />
efficiently and cost effectively. The<br />
firm has particular expertise in<br />
corporate and commercial advice,<br />
employment, insolvency and<br />
corporate recovery, intellectual<br />
property, litigation, private client<br />
and property. WM is particularly<br />
recognised for its work in the<br />
automotive, aviation, medical<br />
devices, pharmaceutical, renewable<br />
energy, natural resources and<br />
technology sectors.<br />
DAC Beachcroft<br />
www.dacbeachcroft.com<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 25<br />
Managing Partner: Katie da<br />
Gama<br />
The Dublin office of international<br />
law firm DAC Beachcroft opened<br />
in March 2009 and has grown to<br />
its current size of 39 people,<br />
including 12 partners. The firm<br />
specialises in insurance law,<br />
professional indemnity claims,<br />
injury matters, healthcare and<br />
continued on page 86
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
clinical risk, commercial litigation<br />
and employment law.<br />
Lavelle Coleman<br />
www.lavellecoleman.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 21<br />
Managing Partner: Michael<br />
Lavelle<br />
The firm is renowned for its<br />
litigation expertise, particularly class<br />
actions, covering various areas of<br />
general, professional negligence<br />
and commercial litigation.<br />
Employment law is another<br />
specialty, and general commercial<br />
work. According to managing<br />
partner Michael Lavelle: “The firm<br />
is receiving more and more<br />
instructions from banks and other<br />
financial institutions. The firm’s<br />
litigation practice is continuing to<br />
grow and the firm has specialised<br />
in many multi-party actions in<br />
recent years.”<br />
McDowell Purcell<br />
www.mcdowellpurcell.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 20<br />
Managing Partner: Thomas<br />
O’Malley<br />
The firm acts for financial<br />
institutions, professional regulatory<br />
bodies, public and privately owned<br />
companies, property developers,<br />
renewable energy developers,<br />
liquidators, receivers and private<br />
clients.<br />
Walkers Ireland<br />
www.walkersglobal.com<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 17<br />
Managing Partner: Garry<br />
Ferguson<br />
Walkers was established in Dublin<br />
in 2010 and is part of a global law<br />
firm that has a presence in the<br />
British Virgin Islands, Delaware,<br />
Dubai, Hong Kong, Jersey, London<br />
and Singapore, with over 500 staff<br />
employed. In Dublin, the primary<br />
focus is funds and financial services,<br />
including capital markets and<br />
aviation finance and related<br />
taxation issues. The Dublin office<br />
has eight partners, five Of Counsel<br />
and 17 other fee earners.<br />
Callan Tansey<br />
www.callantansey.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 16<br />
Managing Partner: Brian Gill<br />
Callan Tansey is the largest law<br />
firm in Connacht, employing 55<br />
people at its offices in Sligo and<br />
Boyle. Brian Gill has been<br />
Managing Partner since October<br />
2011 and he says that the<br />
changing face of the legal market<br />
means that law firms have to<br />
radically evaluate the traditional<br />
business model that sustained<br />
them in times gone by. “Today’s<br />
client is a more discerning<br />
customer and law firms must<br />
adapt or face the consequences,”<br />
says Gill.<br />
Orpen Franks<br />
www.orpenfranks.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 12<br />
Managing Partner: Peter Walsh<br />
The firm’s activities centre on the<br />
litigation, commercial and<br />
insolvency arenas. It operates on a<br />
full-service basis and has<br />
expanded its services in the area<br />
of insolvency and recovery, and<br />
security enforcement. Managing<br />
Partner Peter Walsh says the firm’s<br />
key attributes are capacity,<br />
responsiveness, accessibility,<br />
results and value.<br />
O’Connor Solicitors<br />
www.oclegal.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 11<br />
Managing Partner: John C.<br />
O’Connor<br />
O’Connor Solicitors advises<br />
numerous professional bodies and<br />
also has a broad range of<br />
commercial clients. The firm has a<br />
Regulatory <strong>Law</strong> department and<br />
increased staff numbers to deal<br />
with rising demand in the<br />
regulatory and employment law<br />
practice areas.<br />
Kilroys<br />
www.kilroys.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 10<br />
Managing Partner: Joanne<br />
Griffin<br />
Kilroys is the Irish member firm of<br />
the International Alliance of <strong>Law</strong><br />
<strong>Firms</strong>, an international association<br />
of medium-sized commercial law<br />
firms. “It has continued to be<br />
advantageous to our clients doing<br />
business outside Ireland in that<br />
we are able to refer them quickly<br />
to colleagues in the Alliance,” says<br />
the firm’s new Managing Partner,<br />
Joanne Griffin. “It has also been<br />
beneficial for inward referrals<br />
from Alliance clients wishing to do<br />
business in Ireland.”<br />
McEvoy Partners<br />
www.mcevoypartners.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 10<br />
Managing Partners: Orlaith<br />
O’Brien, June Hynes<br />
Niche commercial practice with<br />
expertise in M&A, capital markets,<br />
insolvency, corporate restructuring<br />
and commercial litigation,<br />
particularly in banking and<br />
property-related matters.<br />
Kane Tuohy<br />
www.kanetuohy.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 9<br />
Managing Partner: Cómhnall<br />
Tuohy<br />
The firm says it is benefiting from<br />
a general appetite from the<br />
business sector to resolve or<br />
deal with individual issues, which<br />
is providing some momentum in<br />
the market and more business<br />
positivity. According to Managing<br />
Partner Cómhnall Tuohy: “We<br />
have joined an international legal<br />
network which has led to an<br />
expansion in commercial enquiries<br />
and activity. We have increased<br />
turnover on a year-on-year basis<br />
while staff size has also<br />
increased.”<br />
Leman<br />
www.leman.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 9<br />
Managing Partner: Larry<br />
Fenelon<br />
Leman was established in 2007.<br />
The firm has corporate and<br />
commercial, commercial property,<br />
dispute resolution and<br />
employment teams. It focuses on<br />
ICT, data, sport, retail, education,<br />
professional services, land<br />
development and inward<br />
investment. The firm has added<br />
one partner, three solicitors<br />
and one trainee in the last 12
BP SURVEY<br />
COMMERCIAL LAW<br />
months. It received the ‘Q’ Mark<br />
in 2012 and received the ILO<br />
‘International Client Choice’<br />
award in 2013.<br />
LKG Ballagh<br />
www.lkgballagh.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 8<br />
Managing Partner: James Flynn<br />
LKG Ballagh was created in<br />
2012 by the merger of LKG<br />
Solicitors with partners in KMB<br />
Solicitors. The firm has acted on<br />
complex, high-value corporate<br />
transactions and in 2012 advised<br />
Mainstream Renewable Power on<br />
various corporate transactions,<br />
including a €60m fundraise from<br />
Macquarie Capital. “The firm<br />
punches above its weight in the<br />
calibre of its clients and the<br />
transactions which it has<br />
handled,” says corporate partner<br />
Neil Keenan.<br />
Hughes & Associates<br />
www.hughessolicitors.ie<br />
Partners/Solicitors: 3<br />
Managing Partner: Daniel<br />
Hughes<br />
Principal Daniel Hughes is a<br />
litigation expert, particularly in the<br />
insolvency arena. The practice<br />
recently relocated to new offices<br />
close to the Four Courts and has<br />
upgraded its IT system. Hughes<br />
has been shortlisted for the ‘Sole<br />
Practitioner of the Year’ award at<br />
the forthcoming Danske Bank Irish<br />
<strong>Law</strong> Awards 2013.<br />
Clerkin Lynch<br />
www.clerkinlynch.com<br />
Partners: 2<br />
Partners: Niall Clerkin, Kevin<br />
Lynch<br />
The firm is now in its fifth year<br />
and reports another year of<br />
growth. The firm has been<br />
involved in a number of Supreme<br />
Court Appeals this year in<br />
addition to its continued growth<br />
in the commercial law aspect of<br />
the practice, which focuses on<br />
owner-led and family-owned<br />
businesses.<br />
Other <strong>Law</strong> <strong>Firms</strong> With Commercial Focus<br />
Crowley Millar<br />
www.crowleymillar.com<br />
Doherty Ryan<br />
www.dohertyryan.com<br />
Eames Solicitors<br />
www.eames.ie<br />
Flynn O’Driscoll<br />
www.fod.ie<br />
Gartlan Furey<br />
www.gartlanfurey.ie<br />
Gleeson McGrath Baldwin<br />
www.gmgb.ie<br />
Gore & Grimes<br />
www.goregrimes.ie<br />
Hayes McGrath<br />
www.hayesmcgrath.ie<br />
Holohan Solicitors<br />
www.holohanlaw.com<br />
Holme Roberts & Owen<br />
www.hro.ie<br />
Ivor Fitzpatrick & Co.<br />
www.ivorfitzpatrick.ie<br />
McGuire Desmond<br />
www.mcguiredesmond.com<br />
McKeever Rowan<br />
www.mckr.ie<br />
Murray Flynn Maguire<br />
www.murrayflynn.ie<br />
Noel Smyth & Partners<br />
www.nspartners.ie<br />
O’Rourke Reid<br />
www.orourkereid.com<br />
Philip Lee<br />
www.philiplee.ie<br />
Reddy Charlton McKnight<br />
www.rcmck.com<br />
Vincent Beatty & Co<br />
www.vblaw.ie<br />
Waters & Associates<br />
www.watersandassociates.ie<br />
William J Brennan & Co.<br />
www.williamjbrennan.com<br />
INNOVATIVE<br />
COST EFFECTIVE<br />
SPECIALISTS<br />
● International <strong>Business</strong><br />
● ICT<br />
● Retail<br />
● Sport<br />
● Professional Services<br />
● Education<br />
● Land Development<br />
SERVICES<br />
● <strong>Business</strong><br />
● Property<br />
● Disputes<br />
● Employment<br />
WHY US?<br />
Leman Solicitors, 8-34 Percy Place, Dublin 4<br />
Tel: +353 1 639 3000 www.leman.ie<br />
Your<br />
<strong>Business</strong><br />
is<br />
Our<br />
<strong>Business</strong><br />
Corporate & Commercial<br />
Corporate Recovery<br />
Commercial Disputes<br />
& Litigation<br />
Intellectual Property<br />
Employment <strong>Law</strong><br />
Private Client<br />
Property<br />
Contact: Stephen Walker, Therese Rochford or Mark Ryan<br />
Wilton Park House, Wilton Place, Dublin 2, Ireland<br />
T: +353 1 611 0000 F: +353 1 611 0090<br />
E: ecomms@whitneymoore.ie W: www.whitneymoore.ie