Pitfalls and Pipelines - Philippine Indigenous Peoples Links

Pitfalls and Pipelines - Philippine Indigenous Peoples Links Pitfalls and Pipelines - Philippine Indigenous Peoples Links

17.11.2014 Views

88 Pitfalls and Pipelines: Indigenous Peoples and Extractive Industries Other Types of “Nuclear Fallout” In addition, nuclear bomb testing—made with uranium mined from indigenous lands—has been concentrated on indigenous lands globally. The US weapons testing sites in the South West USA have resulted in irradiation of the soils in this arid and windy region and have—according to the American Cancer Society—resulted in heightened levels of cancers in the surrounding and down-wind regions. 69 The British and French both conducted testing on indigenous lands without permission or consent being given, or in some cases, even informing the traditional land holders and the most adjacent and affected peoples. And increasingly in the USA, for example, the storage of nuclear waste is being concentrated on indigenous lands, supposedly representing a job creating option for a poor region. 70 The management of radioactive waste further requires the development of a safe secure and globally managed system of storage that must operate without any serious error for millennia to come. Given even the short history of failure and mismanagement, natural and man made disasters associated with the nuclear industry, and that inevitably follows any human sustained effort, this seems the most irresponsible and hopeless of options. Therefore, for many affected indigenous peoples any revival of the nuclear power industry is a prospect viewed with fear and resignation to the continuation of related illness and death. 71 1.3.5 Conclusion Climate change has grave implications for all peoples. It is, however, most likely to have the most adverse effects on those who live already in more extreme and challenging environments. The threats to indigenous peoples from greater extremes of weather and changes in climate are potentially severe. The threats can be severely exacerbated by irresponsible mining activities, both directly and indirectly.

Chapter 1.3: Indigenous Peoples, Mining and Climate Change 89 The record of the industry in their disregard for the future is truly alarming. It should be clear that self regulation is not sufficient to provide adequate protection. This is especially true where vital issues like the protection of lives and livelihoods, human rights and environmental protection are concerned. It will more likely require heavy investment, restrictions on areas of operations, and planning to minimize new mining and maximize alternatives—including recycling, reuse and substitution. Stricter regulation of the mining industry and adequate independent monitoring are essential features for the future. Box 1: Coal’s Contribution to Carbon Emissions As fossil fuels are burned to produce energy, the carbon in the fuel reacts with oxygen to form carbon dioxide gas (CO2). Most of this is released into the atmosphere. Burning coal (which consists of “free” carbon) produces more carbon dioxide per unit of energy generated than any other fossil fuel. Compared to natural gas (which consists mostly of the carbon-compound methane, CH4), coal releases 66 percent more CO2 per unit of energy generated. Coal mining also releases methane into the atmosphere. Methane is 20 times more powerful than carbon dioxide as a greenhouse gas. 72 In the USA in 2006, 26 percent of energy-related methane release was a direct result of the mining of buried coal strata. 73 Around the world, about seven percent of annual methane emissions originate from coal mining. 74 This methane could be used to produce energy more efficiently than the coal itself. 75 Methane can theoretically be captured from underground strata before opencast mining takes place, but while this is increasingly spoken of it is, as yet rarely done. It is easier to capture methane from underground mine,s but this too is an underdeveloped methodology. Coal mining and the burning of coal for energy generation, cement manufacture and steel production have been among the major engines of global warming. This has been the case for more than 200 years of industrialization. Despite increasing understanding of this dangerous legacy, however, coal production and use continues to accelerate. According to the 2010 BP Statistical Review of World Energy, 76 2009 was the first year since 2002 that coal was not the fastest growing fuel

88 <strong>Pitfalls</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Pipelines</strong>: <strong>Indigenous</strong> <strong>Peoples</strong> <strong>and</strong> Extractive Industries<br />

Other Types of “Nuclear Fallout”<br />

In addition, nuclear bomb testing—made with uranium<br />

mined from indigenous l<strong>and</strong>s—has been concentrated on indigenous<br />

l<strong>and</strong>s globally. The US weapons testing sites in the<br />

South West USA have resulted in irradiation of the soils in this<br />

arid <strong>and</strong> windy region <strong>and</strong> have—according to the American<br />

Cancer Society—resulted in heightened levels of cancers in<br />

the surrounding <strong>and</strong> down-wind regions. 69 The British <strong>and</strong><br />

French both conducted testing on indigenous l<strong>and</strong>s without<br />

permission or consent being given, or in some cases, even<br />

informing the traditional l<strong>and</strong> holders <strong>and</strong> the most adjacent<br />

<strong>and</strong> affected peoples.<br />

And increasingly in the USA, for example, the storage of<br />

nuclear waste is being concentrated on indigenous l<strong>and</strong>s, supposedly<br />

representing a job creating option for a poor region. 70<br />

The management of radioactive waste further requires the<br />

development of a safe secure <strong>and</strong> globally managed system of<br />

storage that must operate without any serious error for millennia<br />

to come. Given even the short history of failure <strong>and</strong><br />

mismanagement, natural <strong>and</strong> man made disasters associated<br />

with the nuclear industry, <strong>and</strong> that inevitably follows any<br />

human sustained effort, this seems the most irresponsible <strong>and</strong><br />

hopeless of options.<br />

Therefore, for many affected indigenous peoples any revival<br />

of the nuclear power industry is a prospect viewed with<br />

fear <strong>and</strong> resignation to the continuation of related illness <strong>and</strong><br />

death. 71<br />

1.3.5 Conclusion<br />

Climate change has grave implications for all peoples. It<br />

is, however, most likely to have the most adverse effects on<br />

those who live already in more extreme <strong>and</strong> challenging environments.<br />

The threats to indigenous peoples from greater<br />

extremes of weather <strong>and</strong> changes in climate are potentially<br />

severe. The threats can be severely exacerbated by irresponsible<br />

mining activities, both directly <strong>and</strong> indirectly.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!