Eastern Adelaide Teacher resource.pdf - Army Museum of South ...
Eastern Adelaide Teacher resource.pdf - Army Museum of South ...
Eastern Adelaide Teacher resource.pdf - Army Museum of South ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Attunga Garden - Burnside Memorial Hospital<br />
Kokoda Trail - St Agnes<br />
St Peter’s Memorial<br />
Payneham Memorial Gardens<br />
Kokoda Trail - St Agnes<br />
War Trophy - Kensington<br />
Avenue <strong>of</strong> Trees<br />
Rose Park<br />
War Memorials<br />
and Commemorative Sites<br />
in the <strong>Eastern</strong> Area<br />
- <strong>Teacher</strong> Resource
Memorial Burnside District Fallen Soldiers’ Memorial and ‘Avenue <strong>of</strong> Trees’<br />
Address Alexandra Avenue and Prescott Terrace, Rose Park<br />
Background Information<br />
C. Webb-Gilbert designed the distinctive Burnside District Fallen<br />
Soldiers’ Memorial. The memorial was unveiled on the 14<br />
December 1924. It features a bronze figure <strong>of</strong> a World War I -<br />
Great War - soldier leaning forward with his left arm extended<br />
towards the ground and giving aid to a comrade. The bronze figure<br />
is mounted on a two-tier pedestal <strong>of</strong> granite. There are four bronze<br />
plaques fixed to the pedestal which list the 'fallen' World War I<br />
soldiers from the Burnside District. A fifth plaque honours the<br />
fallen from World War II, Korea and Vietnam.<br />
The memorial is situated at the eastern end <strong>of</strong> a strip <strong>of</strong> parkland<br />
running down the centre <strong>of</strong> Alexandra Avenue from Prescott Terrace to Fullarton Rd. The<br />
parkland is lined with “Trees <strong>of</strong> Remembrance”, each planted in memory <strong>of</strong> a Burnside<br />
district soldier killed in the Great War. Numbered memorial plaques honouring these men<br />
are spaced along both Alexandra Ave and Prescott Terrace.<br />
Student Activities<br />
On Site<br />
(1) How many names appear on the Burnside District Fallen Soldiers’ Memorial?<br />
a) 91<br />
b) 83<br />
c) 87<br />
87 names<br />
(2) What do you think the pose <strong>of</strong> the soldier on the Burnside District Fallen<br />
Soldiers’ Memorial suggests he may be doing during battle?<br />
He is bending down to give aid (succour) to a fallen comrade. The pose suggests he is about<br />
to lift a friend to his feet.<br />
(3) How many surnames appear more than once on the Memorial? Write these<br />
names down.<br />
11 names<br />
They are;<br />
Fordham<br />
Frerichs<br />
Hughes<br />
Keely<br />
Sando<br />
Shepley<br />
Slape<br />
Suhard<br />
Tucker<br />
Roberts<br />
Robin<br />
1
(4) When was the ‘Avenue <strong>of</strong> Trees’<br />
planted and consecrated to the<br />
memory <strong>of</strong> Burnside District’s fallen<br />
soldiers in World War I?<br />
19 July 1919<br />
Source: Plaque Close St, West Side<br />
(5) Can you find any evidence that not<br />
all trees in the ‘Avenue <strong>of</strong> Trees’ are<br />
the ones that were originally<br />
planted? What is it?<br />
In 1955 several trees were cut down and removed for street widening. New trees were<br />
planted when the alterations were completed and have the appearance <strong>of</strong> younger<br />
healthier trees.<br />
(6) Following World War I, the Burnside community erected this magnificent<br />
monument to the fallen and dedicated individual tributes to these local<br />
soldiers by the planting <strong>of</strong> a tree in their memory. These gestures clearly<br />
indicate the gratitude to the soldiers who had served and sense <strong>of</strong> loss felt<br />
by local families for those men who had lost their lives.<br />
World War I ended nearly ninety years ago. What significance do these<br />
war memorials have for the local community and Australia generally<br />
today?<br />
The tributes show that World War I was a significant event in the history <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Burnside district and greatly affected the local community. The fact that some trees<br />
were replaced in 1955 and that the Burnside Council still carefully maintains the area,<br />
suggests the war memorials are still considered an important part <strong>of</strong> the area’s cultural<br />
heritage.<br />
The impact <strong>of</strong> World War I in cities and towns throughout Australia was pr<strong>of</strong>ound. It<br />
represented an important period during which Australian troops proved themselves on<br />
the world stage. This period saw the birth <strong>of</strong> the Anzac legend, which has played an<br />
important role in the emergence <strong>of</strong> our national identity.<br />
(7) Count the trees with no memorial plaques. What are their numbers? What<br />
reasons might there be for these soldiers’ names not to be recorded on<br />
individual plaques?<br />
The numbers <strong>of</strong> the trees are 54, 60 and 76 found on two plaques located on Prescott<br />
Terrace. The cost <strong>of</strong> plaques for some families may have been prohibitive and others<br />
for various reasons may have preferred anonymity for their fallen relative.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: Photos on the next page show the two granite blocks with the missing<br />
names. Both are located on Prescott Terrace.<br />
2
No<br />
names<br />
Classroom<br />
(8) What are some <strong>of</strong> the obvious and significant<br />
differences between the Burnside District Fallen<br />
Soldiers’ Memorial and that <strong>of</strong> the more traditional<br />
St Peters “stone digger” which is pictured right?<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
The figure on the Burnside District Fallen Soldiers’<br />
Memorial appears more life like than the St Peters “stone<br />
digger”.<br />
The soldier on the Burnside memorial appears to be in<br />
action, armed with a rifle in one hand and simultaneously<br />
in the act <strong>of</strong> aiding a fallen comrade with the other.<br />
It is someone doing his duty and at the same time showing<br />
compassion for his wounded mate.<br />
By contrast<br />
<br />
<br />
The St Peters War Memorial features a soldier standing at<br />
attention with his head bowed and with his rifle upside down in a stance, which is<br />
known as “resting on arms reversed”. It is a traditional military mark <strong>of</strong> respect for<br />
fallen comrades.<br />
The St Peters soldier appears somewhat sombre, pallid and stiff in contrast to the<br />
soldier featured on the Burnside memorial. Nevertheless it is still a dignified and<br />
reverent tribute to the fallen.<br />
(9) Private Horace Utting Fordham was a former student <strong>of</strong><br />
Norwood Primary School whose name appears amongst<br />
the names <strong>of</strong> the fallen on the Burnside District Fallen<br />
Soldiers’ Memorial. Visit the Australian War Memorial<br />
website at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases > Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour<br />
Enter Private Fordham’s name, select First World War, 1914 – 1918, and click<br />
on search. Locate the correct soldier and from the Circular Information find out<br />
the following<br />
3
How old was he when he lost his life?<br />
24 years <strong>of</strong> age<br />
On what date did he enlist?<br />
Enlistment Date August 1914<br />
Where and how did he lose his life?<br />
Location <strong>of</strong> death: Mena Camp, Egypt<br />
Cause <strong>of</strong> death: Smallpox<br />
According to his family was he the first <strong>South</strong> Australian soldier to lose his life<br />
overseas?<br />
From the “Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour” information we learnt that his family believed he was the<br />
second <strong>South</strong> Australian to lose his life overseas. Given the date <strong>of</strong> his death this<br />
could well be correct.<br />
What other relative <strong>of</strong> Horace Fordham lost his life during World War I?<br />
Roy O. Fordham<br />
What was this relative’s occupation (calling) before the war and where did he<br />
lose his life?<br />
Occupation (calling): Accountant<br />
Place <strong>of</strong> death: In the region <strong>of</strong> Bullecourt, France<br />
(10) MC is an abbreviation for the Military Cross which is a military award.<br />
Find out why Lieutenant J K Robin MC, whose name is listed on the<br />
Burnside District Fallen Soldiers’ Memorial, was recommended for this<br />
award by accessing the Australian War Memorial website at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases > Honours and Awards > Honours<br />
and Awards Recommendations: First World War.<br />
Enter the name Robin and ‘click’ on search. You will then need to open the<br />
document, which contains the original recommendation.<br />
Student Note: The block type reads SOMME and MOUQUET FARM. The Somme<br />
River in France was the area <strong>of</strong> a major British <strong>of</strong>fensive known as the Battle <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Somme, which was launched on July11916. Mouquet Farm was the scene <strong>of</strong> fierce<br />
fighting involving Australians during this battle which cost around one million lives<br />
over a three and half month period.<br />
The Military Cross recommendation for Lt. Robin reads in part,<br />
“for showing exceptional coolness and bravery in<br />
reconnaissance for positioning and firing <strong>of</strong> guns (trench<br />
mortars). On two occasions, his guns repelled an enemy<br />
bombing attack in the area <strong>of</strong> the Somme River. Throughout<br />
days <strong>of</strong> heavy and continuous shelling at Mouquet Farm, his<br />
coolness and bearing had a most steadying effect on the gun<br />
crews under him”.<br />
4
(11) The memorial trees in the “Avenue <strong>of</strong> Trees”, which line Alexandra<br />
Avenue and Prescott Terrace, are evergreen.<br />
Why do you think the local community chose this type <strong>of</strong> tree?<br />
<br />
<br />
The fact that the leaves never fall is symbolic <strong>of</strong> the enduring tribute to those from<br />
the Burnside district who were killed during World War I.<br />
The evergreen trees are also symbolically linked to the Christian belief <strong>of</strong> eternal<br />
life.<br />
5
Memorial Burnside Council Chambers – Honour Rolls<br />
Address Within the Mayoral Chambers, Greenhill Road, Tusmore<br />
Background Information<br />
Over 2,000 men and women from the Burnside Council<br />
district served their country during World Wars I (Great War)<br />
and II. Following the First World War, the people <strong>of</strong> the<br />
district commenced fundraising in order to provide suitable<br />
memorials to honour those who served in the Great War. As<br />
in many other Australian communities, wooden honour rolls<br />
were constructed listing the names <strong>of</strong> local citizens who<br />
served, and those who died, during what was believed would<br />
be the war to end all wars.<br />
Perhaps the best known soldier commemorated on the<br />
Burnside Council Honour Rolls is Lieutenant Colonel William<br />
Charles Nightingale (W.C.N) Waite, DSO, MC, VD who<br />
served in the Boer War, World War I and as Director <strong>of</strong> Recruiting in <strong>South</strong> Australia<br />
during World War II. This lean and tough man was known affectionately by many as<br />
"Mr Anzac" because he led <strong>Adelaide</strong>'s Anzac Day parade twenty nine times on a<br />
dashing white charger (horse). He also served a term as the Mayor <strong>of</strong> Burnside and<br />
the Colonel Waite Oval, at Kensington Gardens Reserve, is named in his honour.<br />
Perhaps his greatest exploit was during World War I at Gallipoli. As the <strong>of</strong>ficer in<br />
charge <strong>of</strong> the 8 th Battery, he received the order to ceasefire at 1700hrs (5pm) on<br />
December 19 1915, the day before the evacuation <strong>of</strong> Gallipoli. However, as Colonel<br />
Waite later recalled, “I determined to have something special to remember it (the<br />
evacuation) by, (so) at 1705 hrs (5.05pm) I ordered crew <strong>of</strong> No. 4 gun to fire again. I<br />
risked a Court <strong>of</strong> Inquiry, I suppose, but none was ordered. So we fired, without<br />
challenge, the last shot from Anzac”. He retained the shell case, which he mounted<br />
and inscribed and kept on his mantelpiece following his return to Australia.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: As the Mayoral Chambers are not open to the public you will need to<br />
ring the Burnside Council Offices on 08 8366 4229 and speak to the Communications<br />
Officer to organise access.<br />
Student Activities<br />
On Site<br />
(1) Where are the Burnside Council Honour Rolls located within the Burnside<br />
Town Hall?<br />
Do you think an alternate location might be more appropriate given their<br />
significance to Burnside’s history?<br />
They are located near the Mayor’s chambers on the south west side <strong>of</strong> the Burnside<br />
Town Hall, in an area that does not have public access for reasons <strong>of</strong> security. They<br />
were initially easily accessible to the public. Students could argue that their original<br />
7
location is inappropriate given their historical significance and that they should moved<br />
to a location where they are on full public view.<br />
(2) List three features relating to the design, wording or<br />
names listed on the larger <strong>of</strong> the Burnside Council<br />
Honour Rolls.<br />
Some features include;<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
A complete list <strong>of</strong> names <strong>of</strong> those from Burnside who served<br />
during World War I.<br />
A distinctive header which appears on the honour roll.<br />
Some women's names appear on the honour roll.<br />
Wording includes the terms “King and Empire”, highlighting the strong ties<br />
between Australia and Britain.<br />
Many surnames appear on multiple occasions suggesting the impact <strong>of</strong> the war on<br />
individual families.<br />
Those who lost their lives appear with crosses after their names.<br />
(3) How many names <strong>of</strong> those from the Burnside community appear on the<br />
large Burnside Council Honour Roll?<br />
Of these what number and what percentage died <strong>of</strong> all causes?<br />
Total Names Killed in action (K.I.A) Died <strong>of</strong><br />
Wounds/Disease(DOW/DOD)<br />
Total Names Killed in action (K.I.A) Died <strong>of</strong><br />
Wounds/Disease(DOW/DOD)<br />
386 23 60<br />
(4) Approximately one in five or six <strong>of</strong> the Australians who served in the First<br />
World War did not return home. What percentage <strong>of</strong> those whose names<br />
are listed on the Burnside Council Honour Roll lost their lives?<br />
How do the Burnside figures compare with the national average and what<br />
does this suggest about the impact <strong>of</strong> the war on communities throughout<br />
Australia?<br />
83 soldiers lost their life and a total <strong>of</strong> 386 served.<br />
83 ÷ 386 = 22%.<br />
Based on this figure the losses in Burnside were a little higher than the national<br />
average.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: The average percentage recorded on local memorials <strong>of</strong> those not<br />
returning to Australia was approximately 18%. Of the 330,000 Australians that went<br />
overseas during World War I in excess <strong>of</strong> 60,000 lost their lives. It is worth informing<br />
students that approximately 50% <strong>of</strong> those who did return had injuries or wounds <strong>of</strong><br />
some kind which would have impacted significantly on the servicemen, their family<br />
and their local community.<br />
8
(5) How many medical staff, including both doctors and nurses, can you locate<br />
amongst the names?<br />
Seven nurses and two (male) doctors’ names appear on the honour roll.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: The names <strong>of</strong> these nurses are D.A.H. Brinsley, M. Lenton, E.M.<br />
Laity, L.A. Marchant, J.J. Marchant, I Rodgers and Rodgers. The doctors are Dr W.J.<br />
Close and Dr R. Haste.<br />
(6) What is the significance <strong>of</strong> the second smaller honour roll, which is also<br />
located near the mayoral chambers?<br />
It contains the names <strong>of</strong> those members <strong>of</strong> the Burnside council who served during the<br />
First World War including Waite.<br />
(7) Transcribe all the details, including his title and war decorations, relating<br />
to Colonel Waite on the smaller honour roll.<br />
Lt. Col. W.C.N Waite, DSO, MC, VD<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: William Charles Nightingale Waite was born in <strong>Adelaide</strong> in 1880.<br />
When he was a schoolboy, first at St. Bartholomew's Church <strong>of</strong> England School at<br />
Norwood and later at Prince Alfred College, he carried the dream <strong>of</strong> being a soldier.<br />
Colonel Waite served in the Boer War (1899-1902). He re enlisted at the outbreak <strong>of</strong><br />
World War I and served at Gallipoli and then on the Western Front as an artillery<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficer. He was appointed the Director <strong>of</strong> Recruiting in <strong>South</strong> Australia during World<br />
War II. His public duties included a period as the Mayor <strong>of</strong> Burnside.<br />
Lieutenant Colonel Waite was known affectionately by many as "Mr Anzac" because<br />
he led <strong>Adelaide</strong>'s Anzac Day parade 29 times riding a dashing white horse. In 1962, a<br />
veteran <strong>of</strong> 82, he was a delegate <strong>of</strong> the <strong>South</strong> African War Veteran's Association to<br />
the Boer War Diamond Jubilee celebrations in London. He was due to sail from Outer<br />
Harbour at noon on April 25 <strong>of</strong> that year. "You won't have time for the march this<br />
year, Bill," friends told him. "Miss the march?" he said, "Not on your life. I would<br />
rather miss the trip." But he missed neither. As chief Marshall he was first <strong>of</strong>f the<br />
mark, first to finish and was driven down to the harbour in a fast car in an operation <strong>of</strong><br />
typical military precision. Lt Col Waite died, aged 93 on the 27 December 1973. The<br />
Colonel Waite Oval, at Kensington Gardens Reserve, is named in honour <strong>of</strong> this great<br />
Burnside citizen soldier.<br />
Source: History <strong>of</strong> Burnside Chapter 7 Burnside at War Page 98 and<br />
http://www.lighthorse.org.au/Pershist/waite.htm<br />
Classroom<br />
(8) <strong>South</strong> Australia sent nine contingents <strong>of</strong> soldiers to <strong>South</strong> Africa between<br />
1899 and 1902 to fight in the <strong>South</strong> African or Boer War. By accessing the<br />
Australian War Memorial website at<br />
9
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases> Nominal Rolls > Boer War<br />
Nominal Roll<br />
Enter the name Waite and click on search. Find out in which contingents,<br />
Corporal and subsequently Lieutenant W.C.N. (William Charles Nightingale)<br />
Waite served?<br />
1 (MNTD RIFLES) CNTGNT and 6 (IMPERIAL) CNTGNT<br />
(9) During the First World War, Lieutenant Colonel Waite served as an<br />
artillery <strong>of</strong>ficer at Gallipoli and on the Western Front (France and<br />
Belgium), where he won a number <strong>of</strong> military honours. By accessing the<br />
Australian War Memorial website at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases > Honours and Awards > Honours<br />
and Awards (Recommendations: First World War)<br />
Enter his surname and click on search. Locate the record for W.C.N. (William<br />
Charles Nightingale) Waite. Click on the recommendation to find out why he<br />
won the Distinguished Service Order (DSO).<br />
The recommendation reads “For specially meritorious service and devotion to duty as<br />
an Artillery Group Commander in FRANCE, from June 1916 to February 25 th 1917”<br />
and then provides further details <strong>of</strong> the achievements <strong>of</strong> the artillery battery under his<br />
command.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: <strong>Teacher</strong>s may wish to explain that accurate and timely artillery fire<br />
was crucial to the success or failure <strong>of</strong> most large scale attacks on enemy positions<br />
during World War I. Techniques for firing artillery improved throughout the war and<br />
the process <strong>of</strong> planning artillery support became extremely sophisticated. This<br />
generally involved many types <strong>of</strong> guns firing simultaneously to provide defensive<br />
barrages for advancing troops and to bombard a range <strong>of</strong> enemy targets. These<br />
included enemy artillery positions, which could be detected by the flashes that<br />
emanated from their barrels when they were fired.<br />
(10) One surname that appears five times on the large Burnside Council<br />
Honour Roll is Sando. Two <strong>of</strong> the soldiers, S.J and L.H Sando, have a cross<br />
next to their names. By accessing the Australian War Memorial’s website<br />
at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases > Roll Of Honour<br />
Enter the name Sando, select First World War, 1914 -1918 and ‘click’ on search.<br />
Locate the records <strong>of</strong> these two men and from the ‘Circular Information” find<br />
out the following;<br />
What age was he Sydney Joseph Sando when he lost his life?<br />
19 years and 10 months<br />
10
What relations were Sydney Joseph and Leslie Hurtle Sando?<br />
Brothers<br />
Where did they go to school?<br />
Rose Park<br />
Where and when did Sydney Joseph Sando lose his life?<br />
Pozieres, France August 12 1916<br />
What was Leslie Hurtle Sando’s calling (occupation)?<br />
Lithographer<br />
Where and when did Leslie Hurtle Sando lose his life?<br />
Mericourt, France, September 29 1918<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: Commencing 1 July 1916, the Battle at Pozieres, which was part <strong>of</strong><br />
the Battle <strong>of</strong> the Somme, was one <strong>of</strong> the first major battles involving Australian troops<br />
on the Western Front. Australian troops were withdrawn exhausted from the area near<br />
the Hindenburg Line in October 1918 and saw no further action. It is interesting to<br />
note the younger brother died in the first major campaign involving Australians on the<br />
Western Front and the older brother lost his life in the last major campaign prior to<br />
Australian troops being withdrawn from the Western Front.<br />
(11) By accessing the Commonwealth War Graves website at<br />
www.cwgc.org<br />
Enter the name Sando and the initials <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong> the brothers into the ‘Debt <strong>of</strong><br />
Honour Register’, select World War I and the year <strong>of</strong> his death. Locate the<br />
correct record and print a certificate in his honour.<br />
The certificate will include a photo <strong>of</strong> the place where the soldier is buried or<br />
commemorated.<br />
(12) Why do you think so many people lost their lives during World War I<br />
which for the most part involved opposing armies engaged in trench<br />
warfare?<br />
The loss <strong>of</strong> life is highlighted by the breakdown <strong>of</strong> those killed from the major<br />
combatants, which appears on the next page.<br />
Country<br />
Approximate number <strong>of</strong> lives lost<br />
Great Britain and her Empire 1,000,000<br />
France 1,300,000<br />
Russia 1,700,000<br />
Germany and its allies 3,500,000<br />
Losses <strong>of</strong> life per day <strong>of</strong> the war exceeded 5,500<br />
11
These figures above demonstrate the extremely high loss <strong>of</strong> life <strong>of</strong> which a major<br />
contributing factor were the conditions encountered in trench warfare, which typified<br />
the fighting during World War I.<br />
Students’ answers should mention the causes and consequences <strong>of</strong> trench warfare in<br />
explaining the loss <strong>of</strong> life.<br />
One major cause <strong>of</strong> this immense loss <strong>of</strong> life is that the countries involved didn't<br />
realise the destructive power <strong>of</strong> the weapons developed since the last European war<br />
almost 50 years earlier. These included;<br />
The bolt action 303 Lee Enfield Rifle, which by 1915, had a range <strong>of</strong> nearly a mile<br />
(approximately 1.6 kms) and could fire 15 rounds a minute.<br />
The even more devastating Vickers Machine Gun that fired 600 rounds a minute.<br />
The impact <strong>of</strong> modern artillery such as the howitzer (cannon) which could fire<br />
shells eight miles (approximately 12 kilometres).<br />
The toll that would be taken by grenades, flamethrowers and (eventually) gas that<br />
progressively became part <strong>of</strong> World War I arsenals.<br />
It is no surprise that by the end <strong>of</strong> 1914 both sides had dug into the earth like moles in<br />
a desperate attempt to stay alive.<br />
The resulting trench system on the Western Front not only covered the equivalent<br />
<strong>of</strong> 25,000 miles (enough to encircle the world) but also stretched non-stop from<br />
Belgium to Switzerland.<br />
The effect <strong>of</strong> the appalling conditions in the trenches resulted in all manner <strong>of</strong><br />
diseases and deaths related to poor sanitation, extreme weather conditions and the<br />
lack <strong>of</strong> modern medicines.<br />
Soldiers who did not die by gunfire were <strong>of</strong>ten buried in the mud, which was the<br />
result <strong>of</strong> incessant shellfire, whilst others drowned in water in shell holes whilst<br />
seeking cover from enemy fire.<br />
Source: http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/trench.htm and for information on the<br />
Lee Enfield rifle http://members.optushome.com.au/lee-enfield/gh1.htm<br />
12
Memorial Burnside War Memorial Hospital<br />
Address 120 Kensington Road, Toorak Gardens<br />
Background Information<br />
The establishment <strong>of</strong> a community hospital in Burnside was<br />
first suggested in August 1943 at a meeting <strong>of</strong> the Burnside<br />
Council's Post-War Reconstruction and Development<br />
Committee. In November 1943, the council adopted the<br />
committee's recommendation that a hospital costing up to<br />
£100,000 be built and that it become the area's principal<br />
memorial to the fallen service personnel <strong>of</strong> World War I<br />
(Great War) and II.<br />
In February 1944, local resident Mr Otto von Rieben <strong>of</strong>fered<br />
his property Attunga for this purpose. His generous <strong>of</strong>fer<br />
was accepted unanimously by the council and a community<br />
fundraising campaign began. In April 1949, von Rieben's<br />
home was converted into a convalescent hospital for 21<br />
patients as the first part <strong>of</strong> the War Memorial Hospital<br />
scheme. It was closed in September 1956, having cared for<br />
around 1,400 patients.<br />
Burnside War Memorial Hospital was opened on 26 October 1956. Today, Burnside<br />
is a progressive, not-for-pr<strong>of</strong>it private hospital, which underwent a multi-million<br />
dollar redevelopment in 2002.<br />
Student Activities<br />
On Site<br />
(1) In what year was the Burnside War Memorial Hospital opened? (Refer to<br />
the above notes.)<br />
26 October 1956<br />
(2) Examine the War Memorial hanging in the entrance <strong>of</strong> the hospital.<br />
What is the significance <strong>of</strong> the flowers featured in this coloured print?<br />
The hanging establishes the connection between the hospital and its construction as a<br />
‘living’ war memorial following World War II. The flowers featured on the hanging<br />
are poppies. In English literature <strong>of</strong> the nineteenth century, poppies symbolised sleep<br />
or a state <strong>of</strong> oblivion; this symbolism was carried into the literature <strong>of</strong> the First World<br />
War, when a new, more powerful symbolism was attached to the poppy - that <strong>of</strong> the<br />
sacrifice <strong>of</strong> shed blood. Poppies are also significant because they survived the horrors<br />
<strong>of</strong> battlefield conditions and continued to grow.<br />
The sight <strong>of</strong> the poppies on the battlefield at Ypres in 1915 moved Lieutenant Colonel<br />
John McCrae to write the poem In Flanders Fields. The words <strong>of</strong> this poem<br />
13
eventually inspired the sales <strong>of</strong> poppies by charities to assist those soldiers injured and<br />
maimed during the war. This practice commenced in the early 1920’s and continues<br />
today.<br />
The hanging with its multitude <strong>of</strong> poppies would immediately suggest to most visitors<br />
that the hospital has some link with Australia’s involvement in war, especially the<br />
local Burnside community.<br />
Source: http://www.awm.gov.au/commemoration/customs/poppies.htm<br />
(3) The Attunga Garden is located next to the<br />
Burnside War Memorial Hospital entrance.<br />
Locate the arbour and associated memorial<br />
plaque.<br />
Who does it recognise and when was it<br />
unveiled?<br />
It recognises the surviving servicemen and women <strong>of</strong> World War II and also those<br />
who kept Australia running through the war years. The plaque was unveiled on 2<br />
April 1995.<br />
Classroom<br />
(4) Tributes to those who served during wars such as the Burnside War<br />
Memorial Hospital are <strong>of</strong>ten described as living memorials. Comment on<br />
the choice <strong>of</strong> a hospital as a living “War Memorial”.<br />
The sentiments and practical purposes associated with war memorials help give them<br />
their meaning. It is the choice <strong>of</strong> a particular sentiment or purpose over another that<br />
provides a range <strong>of</strong> alternative possibilities for war remembrance. War memorials that<br />
perform a public service such as hospitals draw upon the sentiment which seeks to<br />
improve the human condition by looking after the sick and injured. They also have the<br />
practical benefits <strong>of</strong> serving the specific needs <strong>of</strong> the veteran community who may<br />
have war related or other medical needs. By dedicating such buildings as hospitals<br />
and schools as war memorials, this public purpose is linked to the worthy values<br />
associated with the war that is being commemorated. Students may therefore suggest<br />
specific values, such as looking after one’s mates and service to the community which<br />
make a hospital an appropriate choice as a war memorial. <strong>Teacher</strong>s may wish to<br />
contrast this choice against something like a water desalination plant, which may be<br />
an important community asset but does not have the sentimental or practical<br />
associations <strong>of</strong> a school or hospital.<br />
(5) Design a cover for a submission to your local/district council informing<br />
them <strong>of</strong> the options available for building a new war memorial. A central<br />
feature <strong>of</strong> the cover should be a picture <strong>of</strong> the type/style <strong>of</strong> memorial you<br />
would like to see endorsed by council. You could choose a building or other<br />
structure, monument, memorial garden or any other appropriate tribute.<br />
Images can be obtained by accessing<br />
14
www.tributes<strong>of</strong>honour.info<br />
Or by searching the internet using the key words “War Memorial”. You should<br />
include a paragraph at the back <strong>of</strong> the poster explaining the reasons for your<br />
choice.<br />
(6) Research the history and significance <strong>of</strong> the poppy that is traditionally sold<br />
on Remembrance Day. For information refer<br />
www.awm.gov.au > encyclopedia > poppies<br />
The Flanders poppy has been a part <strong>of</strong> the 11 November, Armistice or Remembrance<br />
Day rituals, since the early 1920s and is also increasingly being used as part <strong>of</strong><br />
ANZAC Day observances. During the First World War, the red poppies were seen to<br />
be among the first living plants that sprouted from the devastation <strong>of</strong> the battlefields<br />
<strong>of</strong> northern France and Belgium. Soldiers' folklore had it that the poppies were vivid<br />
red from having been nurtured in ground drenched with the blood <strong>of</strong> their comrades.<br />
The sight <strong>of</strong> the poppies on the battlefield at Ypres in 1915 moved Lieutenant Colonel<br />
John McCrae to write the poem In Flanders Fields. Flanders poppies also featured<br />
prominently in several other literary responses to the carnage on the Western Front.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: An American, Moina Michael, read McCrae's poem and was so<br />
moved by it that she wrote a reply and decided to wear a red poppy as a way <strong>of</strong><br />
keeping faith, as McCrae urged in his poem. Moina worked for the American YMCA<br />
and at a meeting <strong>of</strong> YMCA secretaries from other countries, held in November 1918,<br />
she discussed the poem and her poppies. Madame Guerin, the French YMCA<br />
secretary, was similarly inspired and she approached organisations throughout the<br />
allied nations to sell poppies to raise money for widows, orphans and needy veterans<br />
and their families.<br />
The poppy soon became widely accepted throughout the allied nations as the flower<br />
<strong>of</strong> remembrance to be worn on Armistice Day, which is now known as Remembrance<br />
Day.<br />
15
Memorial Campbelltown Soldiers Memorial<br />
Address Corner <strong>of</strong> Gorge Road and Lower North East Road, Campbelltown<br />
Background Information<br />
This World War I (Great War) memorial features a<br />
soldier in full uniform with his head bowed and<br />
standing at "Resting on Arms Reversed”, which is a<br />
traditional military mark <strong>of</strong> respect for fallen<br />
comrades.<br />
The white marble statue <strong>of</strong> the soldier, which faces<br />
west, is mounted on a red granite pedestal. All the<br />
details on this memorial are in gold leaf. It contains the<br />
names <strong>of</strong> those men from the Campbelltown district<br />
who served and those who lost their lives during<br />
World War I.<br />
The memorial is located in front <strong>of</strong> the St Martins<br />
Anglican Church.<br />
The memorial was unveiled on the 5 July 1925.<br />
Student Activities<br />
On Site<br />
(1) The Campbelltown Soldiers Memorial is an example <strong>of</strong> a “stone digger”,<br />
which was a popular style <strong>of</strong> Australian war memorial in the 1920s and 30s.<br />
Sketch or photograph the monument. In a few lines briefly describe the<br />
memorial, its location and the soldier’s stance.<br />
The Campbelltown Memorial features<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
A white marble statue <strong>of</strong> a World War I soldier standing at “Resting on Arms<br />
Reversed” which is a traditional mark <strong>of</strong> respect for the fallen.<br />
The soldier with his left hand over his right and the rifle muzzle on his left boot.<br />
The soldier mounted on a polished granite three-tier pedestal, which is on a<br />
granite block with a concrete slab below.<br />
All details on the memorial are in gold leaf.<br />
The statue faces west and is located on the corner <strong>of</strong> Gorge Road and Lower North<br />
East Road, a prominent north eastern road junction. It is on the elevated side <strong>of</strong> the<br />
road junction and overlooks the surrounding Campbelltown district. At the time <strong>of</strong> its<br />
construction Campbelltown was a thriving agricultural and market gardening<br />
community.<br />
17
(2) How many soldiers’ names are listed on the Campbelltown Soldiers<br />
Memorial? Complete the table below.<br />
The Fallen Returned to Australia Total who served<br />
The Fallen Returned to Australia Total who served<br />
15 79 94<br />
(3) Approximately one in five <strong>of</strong> the Australians who served in the First World<br />
War did not return home. What percentage <strong>of</strong> those whose names are listed<br />
on the Campbelltown Soldiers Memorial lost their lives?<br />
What does this suggest about the impact <strong>of</strong> the war across Australian<br />
communities?<br />
Approximately 19% <strong>of</strong> those whose names are listed lost their lives. It suggests that<br />
communities across the country bore equally the impact and suffering caused by the<br />
First World War.<br />
(4) Write down the full name and initials <strong>of</strong> the soldier whose name starts Mc<br />
that appears under the inscription “IN MEMORY OF THOSE WHO<br />
PAID THE SUPREME SACRIFICE” to use for further research when you<br />
return to the classroom.<br />
Mc Donald J.F.W.<br />
(5) Write down the names and initials <strong>of</strong> the other two soldiers from<br />
Campbelltown with the same surname commencing with Mc who also<br />
appear on the monument under the heading <strong>of</strong> “IN HONOUR OF THOSE<br />
WHO SERVED IN THE GREAT WAR 1914 –1919”?<br />
Mc Donald E.J.<br />
Mc Donald H.E.<br />
Classroom<br />
(6) Complete the table below by accessing the Australian War Memorial<br />
website at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases > Nominal Rolls ><br />
First World War Nominal Rolls – Nominal Roll<br />
Enter the soldiers’ surnames, from the Campbelltown Soldiers Memorial, that<br />
appear in the table on the next page. Each soldier’s service number is included to<br />
assist you to find the correct person listed within the pages <strong>of</strong> the Nominal Roll.<br />
18
Service<br />
No.<br />
Rank<br />
Abbrev<br />
Christian<br />
Names<br />
1715 Ey<br />
1647 Gilks<br />
3888 Hamblem<br />
Family Name Unit Date <strong>of</strong><br />
Enlisting<br />
Fate*<br />
Date <strong>of</strong> return<br />
to Australia<br />
or death<br />
Service<br />
No.<br />
Rank<br />
Abbrev<br />
.<br />
Christian<br />
Names<br />
1715 Sgt Archibald<br />
Leslie<br />
1647 S/Sgt Albert<br />
Stanley<br />
3888 Pte Roy<br />
Augustus<br />
Family Name Unit Date <strong>of</strong><br />
Enlisting<br />
Ey<br />
Gilks<br />
RTA = Return to Australia<br />
Hamblem<br />
15 th<br />
Battalion<br />
27 th<br />
Battalion<br />
48 th<br />
Battalion<br />
Fate*<br />
Date <strong>of</strong> return<br />
to Australia<br />
or death<br />
2.1.15 RTA 11.12.18<br />
6.4.16 RTA 1.4.19<br />
12.11.17 RTA 12.7.19<br />
(7) Complete the following details about the soldier whose name and initials<br />
you recorded in Question (4) on your visit to the Campbelltown Soldiers<br />
Memorial. The information can be found by accessing the Australian War<br />
Memorial website at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases > Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour<br />
Enter his name, select First World War, 1914 -1918 and ‘click’ on search. Locate<br />
the correct soldier and click on ‘Circular Information’ to answer the following<br />
questions.<br />
McDonald J.F.W.<br />
At what age did he come to Australia?<br />
25 years <strong>of</strong> age<br />
What was his calling (occupation)?<br />
Labourer<br />
What was the date and cause <strong>of</strong> his death?<br />
April 21 1918, Typhus<br />
What was his age at the time <strong>of</strong> his death?<br />
37<br />
Had he served in any previous conflict? If so, what and<br />
where?<br />
Yes, The Boer War<br />
Were any <strong>of</strong> his relatives also killed during the war? Give details.<br />
Two Brothers in Law<br />
19
Memorial Kensington and Norwood Soldiers’ Memorial<br />
Address Immediately south <strong>of</strong> Norwood Parade and Osmond Terrace, Norwood<br />
Background Information<br />
The First World War (Great War) was a significant but tragic<br />
time for the Kensington and Norwood community, with 183<br />
local men losing their lives during the four-year conflict. The<br />
Kensington and Norwood Soldiers' Memorial Committee was<br />
formed to plan a suitable memorial and undertake fundraising<br />
to raise money to erect the monument. The grey granite<br />
memorial was the result. Architect H.F.R. Chisolm designed<br />
it. Local contractors Dawes and Chisolm completed the<br />
bronze work. A crowd <strong>of</strong> around 3,000 local people turned out<br />
on Sunday 3 June 1923 to see the memorial unveiled. A<br />
prominent Norwood landmark, the Kensington and Norwood<br />
Soldiers’ Memorial, is located in a garden setting that features<br />
red and white roses. The gardens are further dedicated to the<br />
memory <strong>of</strong> those who paid the supreme sacrifice during<br />
World War II.<br />
Student Activities<br />
On Site<br />
(1) List five features <strong>of</strong> the Kensington and Norwood Soldiers’ Memorial and<br />
its surrounding gardens.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
The memorial column is set in a rose garden and is part <strong>of</strong> a road plantation<br />
running down the centre <strong>of</strong> Osmond Terrace, Norwood.<br />
It is a very high grey granite memorial with a tapered square cut column, a<br />
pedestal and two-tier base on a concrete slab.<br />
At the front and back <strong>of</strong> the columns are bronze wreaths.<br />
It displays the names <strong>of</strong> the fallen in alphabetical order.<br />
There are additional inscriptions on plaques bearing the names <strong>of</strong> the Kensington<br />
and Norwood Soldiers’ Memorial Committee, The Kensington and Norwood<br />
Mayor, architects, contractors and makers <strong>of</strong> the bronze work.<br />
It also bears inscriptions relating to the dedication <strong>of</strong> the surrounding gardens and<br />
the lower plaque reads “ERECTED BY THE CITIZENS OF KENSINGTON<br />
AND NORWOOD TO THE MEMORY OF THOSE WHO FELL IN THE<br />
GREAT WAR”.<br />
(2) When the roses in the memorial garden are in bloom, they are coloured red<br />
and white. These same coloured blooms are also seen in other war<br />
memorial gardens. The best known example in <strong>Adelaide</strong> is in Pennington<br />
Gardens, near the Cross <strong>of</strong> Sacrifice, which is the location <strong>of</strong> the annual<br />
service that follows the Anzac Day march.<br />
What do you think is the symbolic significance <strong>of</strong> this choice <strong>of</strong> colours?<br />
21
The red roses represent the blood shed in battle and<br />
white represents purity and rebirth.<br />
(3) Comment on the location <strong>of</strong> the Kensington and<br />
Norwood Soldiers’ Memorial.<br />
Do you think this is a good site for this<br />
monument?<br />
It occupies a prominent location close to Norwood Parade and leads to other<br />
important commemorative sites, which are located further south along Osmond<br />
Terrace. Situated on a plantation, it can be safely visited by the public. It is also near<br />
the Norwood Primary School, where many <strong>of</strong> the fallen had studied. Given the<br />
available sites for a war memorial in the area, this seems to be an ideal location.<br />
However, students may be able to suggest some alternatives. It is worth noting that,<br />
whilst many World War I war memorials have had to be relocated over the years, the<br />
Kensington and Norwood Soldiers’ Memorial has remained in its original location<br />
which suggests that it was a good choice.<br />
(4) Locate the following names on the Kensington and Norwood Soldiers’<br />
Memorial and record their rank and initials for further research. Note:<br />
PTE = Private and LCE-CPL = Lance Corporal which are army ranks.<br />
FUNNELL<br />
VEITCH<br />
WINKLER<br />
FUNNELL<br />
VEITCH<br />
WINKLER<br />
LCE-CPL. A.H. (Rank = Lance Corporal)<br />
PTE. W.R (Rank = Private)<br />
PTE. C.W (Rank = Private)<br />
Classroom<br />
(5) Using the details <strong>of</strong> the three soldiers you have recorded in Question (4)<br />
answer the following questions by accessing the Australian War Memorial<br />
website at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Details > Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour<br />
Enter their full name, select ‘First World War, 1914-1918’ and click search. (You<br />
may need to page through the list <strong>of</strong> people with the same surname to find the<br />
correct soldier). The details you require will appear in the Circular Information<br />
which form part <strong>of</strong> the “Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour” records.<br />
What were his Christian names?<br />
What was his occupation or “calling”?<br />
Where did he go to primary school?<br />
Where did he lose his life?<br />
How old was he when he lost his life?<br />
What was his association(s) with Norwood?<br />
22
FUNNELL A. H.<br />
What were his Christian names?<br />
What was his occupation or “calling”?<br />
Where did he go to primary school?<br />
Where did he lose his life?<br />
How old was he when he lost his life?<br />
What were his association(s) with Norwood?<br />
Arthur Harold<br />
Clerk<br />
Beulah Rd, Norwood (Norwood<br />
Primary School)<br />
Noriel, France<br />
23 years <strong>of</strong> age<br />
Born, primary educated and<br />
parents lived in Norwood<br />
VEITCH W.R.<br />
What were his Christian names?<br />
What was his occupation or “calling”?<br />
Where did he go to primary school?<br />
Where did he lose his life?<br />
How old was he when he lost his life?<br />
What was his association(s) with Norwood?<br />
William Robert<br />
Mason labour(er)/Monumental<br />
Mason<br />
Norwood State School<br />
Villers-Bretonneux, France<br />
31 years and 11 months<br />
Born at Kent Town and educated<br />
at Norwood Primary School.<br />
WINKLER C.W.<br />
What were his Christian names?<br />
Charles William<br />
What was his occupation or “calling”?<br />
Coach Driver<br />
Where did he go to primary school?<br />
Wallaroo <strong>South</strong><br />
Where did he lose his life?<br />
Near Harbouiers, (Harbonnieres)<br />
France<br />
How old was he when he lost his life? 21<br />
What was his association(s) with Norwood? His mother lived in Kent Town.<br />
No other connection can be<br />
established from Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour<br />
particulars.<br />
(5) Access the Commonwealth War Graves Website at<br />
www.cwgc.org<br />
Enter the name and initials <strong>of</strong> the soldier in the ‘Debt <strong>of</strong> Honour Register’ and<br />
select World War I. Click on the name and, when it loads, check details against<br />
those found in Question (5). If correct, click on ‘certificate’.<br />
Students just need to print the certificate, which will include an image <strong>of</strong> the cemetery<br />
or site in which these soldiers are buried or commemorated in either France or<br />
Belgium.<br />
23
(6) The Norwood and Kensington community chose to name their memorial as<br />
the Kensington and Norwood Soldiers’ Memorial rather than the<br />
Kensington and Norwood War Memorial.<br />
What do you think is the significance <strong>of</strong> this choice <strong>of</strong> name?<br />
Student answers should note the memorial commemorates the service and sacrifice <strong>of</strong><br />
local citizens and not the war itself, which cost so many lives and resulted in so much<br />
suffering.<br />
24
Memorial Kensington and Norwood War Trophies (cannons)<br />
Address Osmond Terrace, Norwood<br />
Background Information<br />
War trophies are captured objects that<br />
have been taken from the battlefield.<br />
The history <strong>of</strong> claiming trophies or<br />
spoils <strong>of</strong> war from defeated enemies<br />
dates back thousands <strong>of</strong> years. During<br />
World War I, trophies captured by the<br />
Allies were specially marked with a tag<br />
which included the name <strong>of</strong> the unit that<br />
captured the piece and the date and time.<br />
Soldiers carried these labels into battle<br />
ready to tag captured items according to<br />
War Office regulations. During World<br />
War I, Australian troops captured large numbers <strong>of</strong> guns <strong>of</strong> all types. The ground<br />
taken and consequently the trophies claimed by Australian soldiers far exceeded the<br />
comparative size <strong>of</strong> our contribution to the allied forces on the Western Front. Many<br />
items were acquired including rifles, trench mortars, machine guns and various<br />
artillery pieces, including one large gun, the Amiens Gun, which was mounted on a<br />
railway carriage at Harbonnieres, France. After the war, items such as the Amiens<br />
Gun were transported back to Australia. Under the Australian War Trophies Act <strong>of</strong><br />
1919, communities were allocated these trophies in recognition <strong>of</strong> their contribution<br />
to Australia's war effort.<br />
In addition to <strong>of</strong>ficial war trophies claimed by the government individual soldiers also<br />
brought back other items <strong>of</strong> memorabilia from the Boer War and subsequent conflicts.<br />
These were <strong>of</strong>ten easily carried items, some <strong>of</strong> which were obtained from enemy<br />
soldiers. Some <strong>of</strong> these had personal or cultural significance to the original owners<br />
and their relatives. A small number <strong>of</strong> these items, mostly acquired during the Second<br />
World War, have been returned to thankful relatives over recent years. However, the<br />
great majority <strong>of</strong> Australia’s wartime memorabilia remains in private hands with some<br />
forming part <strong>of</strong> displays in local Returned and Services League (RSL) halls. The term<br />
wartime memorabilia includes a wide range <strong>of</strong> objects and material. Common items<br />
include wartime diaries, swords, flags, letters, badges, postcards, buttons, weapons,<br />
uniforms, hats and helmets, ration cards, medals, weapons, ammunition and trench art.<br />
Student Activities<br />
On Site<br />
(1) The war trophy (large gun) which is located closest to the Kensington and<br />
Norwood Soldiers’ Memorial was captured by the Australian Light Horse<br />
in the Middle East during World War I. It is a World War I howitzer.<br />
What is the number <strong>of</strong> the gun, its German maker and the year <strong>of</strong><br />
manufacture <strong>of</strong> this gun? Hint: Check the back <strong>of</strong> the breech.<br />
25
Number 460<br />
Fr. H.KRUPP<br />
1915<br />
(2) The war trophy closest to the Burnside Fallen Soldiers’ Memorial on<br />
Prescott Terrace, Rose Park also has some visible markings.<br />
In what year do you think it was manufactured?<br />
Whilst the manufacturer’s name does not appear on this cannon what<br />
marking suggests it might have been made by the same company as the<br />
cannon nearer the Kensington and Norwood Soldiers’ Memorial?<br />
1915<br />
The three inscriptions Kp, which appear on the gun, suggest that it is also a Krupp<br />
cannon. Krupp was a major manufacturer <strong>of</strong> armaments during the First World War.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: Krupp began to make steel cannons in the 1840s mainly for the<br />
Russian, Turkish, and Prussian armies. Low non-military demand and government<br />
subsidy meant that the company specialised more and more in weapons. By the late<br />
1880s the manufacture <strong>of</strong> armaments represented around 50% <strong>of</strong> Krupps total output.<br />
In World War I, Krupp's sold cannons to the Central Powers as well as to the Entente,<br />
a policy which turned out to be highly pr<strong>of</strong>itable. After Hitler came to power on<br />
January 30 th 1933, the Krupp works became the centre for German rearmament. Its<br />
factories were heavily bombed during World War II and some plans to World War I<br />
vintage weapons were destroyed making restoration for some <strong>of</strong> these pieces quite<br />
difficult.<br />
Classroom<br />
(3) The Australian Government actively lobbied the<br />
British Government after World War I to send war<br />
trophies back to Australia to be allocated to the<br />
Australian War Memorial and communities whose<br />
local men had contributed to the war effort.<br />
Why do you think the Australian Government thought this was so<br />
important?<br />
The First World War was the first conflict in which Australia was engaged as an<br />
independent nation. During World War I, around 330,000 Australians served overseas<br />
with more than 60,000 losing their lives. Australians fought at Gallipoli, where they<br />
proved both their resilience and fighting qualities. They were subsequently involved<br />
in a number <strong>of</strong> major battles on the Western Front and played an important role in the<br />
decisive stage <strong>of</strong> the First World War from March to October 1918.<br />
During this time, Australians captured a large number <strong>of</strong> trophies relative to the size<br />
<strong>of</strong> our contribution to the British war effort. Australian units tagged these when they<br />
were captured and the trophies were subsequently shipped to England for distribution<br />
after the war. The Prime Minister, W.M. Hughes”, who was known as the “Little<br />
Digger” for his support <strong>of</strong> Australian soldiers, actively lobbied to ensure that trophies<br />
26
captured by Australians were returned to Australia. In his argument to obtain release<br />
<strong>of</strong> the war trophies by British authorities, Hughes pointed out the relatively short<br />
history <strong>of</strong> Australia and the need to establish our own cultural legacy. He contrasted<br />
this with the long history <strong>of</strong> Britain, which already had many spoils <strong>of</strong> past victories<br />
on public display. Whilst some <strong>of</strong> these trophies were given to what has become the<br />
Australian War Memorial in Canberra, the great majority were allocated to cities and<br />
towns throughout Australia in recognition <strong>of</strong> their local soldiers’ contributions<br />
towards the war effort. They served as a visible and continuing reminder <strong>of</strong> the role<br />
Australians played in the Great War. These trophies can still be seen on display in<br />
parks and gardens throughout Australia. A number have been fully restored in recent<br />
years as local councils and community groups seek to preserve these important links<br />
with the past.<br />
(4) The best known and largest war trophy captured by Australians during<br />
World War I was the so called Amiens Gun which is currently on display at<br />
the Australian War Memorial in Canberra.<br />
Briefly summarise the history <strong>of</strong> the capture <strong>of</strong> this gun and comment on<br />
the role played by Australian soldiers between August and October 1918.<br />
The capture <strong>of</strong> the Amiens Gun by Australian and British soldiers was a significant<br />
achievement. During the summer <strong>of</strong> 1918, it had been used by the Germans to fire on<br />
the city <strong>of</strong> Amiens, about 25 kilometres away. Attempts had been made by the Allies<br />
to destroy this powerful weapon, but to no avail. During the August 8 advance, the<br />
train, on which the gun was mounted, was attacked by a British aircraft, causing the<br />
German soldiers on board to evacuate. Although RAF aircraft and British cavalry<br />
were the first to engage the gun, the advancing Australian infantry quickly claimed it.<br />
The capture <strong>of</strong> the Amiens Gun was one <strong>of</strong> many significant achievements <strong>of</strong><br />
Australian troops in France between March and October 1918. As the trench warfare<br />
<strong>of</strong> World War I moved to semi open warfare following the slowing <strong>of</strong> the German<br />
Spring Offensive <strong>of</strong> March 1918, Australian troops displayed unique personal and<br />
fighting qualities which saw them play a vital role in this decisive phase <strong>of</strong> the war.<br />
After assisting in the defence <strong>of</strong> Amiens in August 1918, Australian troops were<br />
successful in breaking through sections <strong>of</strong> the Hindenburg Line which was the last<br />
and strongest <strong>of</strong> the German <strong>Army</strong>'s defences and consisted <strong>of</strong> three well-defended<br />
trench systems. It has been argued that this feat remains Australia’s most significant<br />
single contribution to the course <strong>of</strong> world history.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: Throughout September 1918, Australian forces had helped the British<br />
army to secure positions from which an attack on the Hindenburg Line could be<br />
launched. On 18 September 1918, a preliminary attack was launched when Australian<br />
troops reached the first part <strong>of</strong> the Hindenburg Line. On 29 September, the line was<br />
finally broken. Australian and United States troops spearheaded this battle. The<br />
fighting lasted four days and resulted in heavy losses on both sides. Eventually, the<br />
Allies broke through the third and final stage <strong>of</strong> the Hindenburg Line, and the<br />
Germans were forced to fall back. An attack on 5 October was to be the last in which<br />
Australian troops would take part. Australians took the Montbrehain village, and with<br />
that success, the Hindenburg Line was completely broken. The defence <strong>of</strong> this sector<br />
was then handed over to the Americans, while the Australians, exhausted and depleted<br />
by heavy casualties, were withdrawn for a rest. Following this action, Germany<br />
27
commenced the process that would eventually result in the signing <strong>of</strong> the Armistice,<br />
which took effect at 11 am on the 11 November 1918.<br />
Tomorrow we are to take part in the greatest and most important battle that we<br />
have yet been in, for we are to assault the Hindenburg Line, the famous trench<br />
system which the Germans have boasted is impregnable.<br />
- Diary entry, Captain Francis Fairweather, 28 September 1918.<br />
Source: www.awm.gov.au > Encyclopedia > Amiens Gun and<br />
http://www.awm.gov.au/1918/battles/hindenburg.htm<br />
(5) Perhaps the best-known war trophies to be found in <strong>South</strong> Australia are<br />
two Crimean War cannons presently located at the Torrens Parade<br />
Grounds. No Australian soldiers fought in the Crimean War, which is best<br />
known for the “Charge <strong>of</strong> the Light Brigade”. Find out how and why <strong>South</strong><br />
Australia came into possession <strong>of</strong> the two Russian Crimean War cannons.<br />
Refer<br />
http://argo.net.au/andre/tropheysCWENFIN.htm<br />
Australia's isolation and early distribution <strong>of</strong> war trophies into the care <strong>of</strong> local<br />
communities, or military authorities, have been major factors in their survival,<br />
including one small group <strong>of</strong> trophies from the Crimean War (1853-56). At the end <strong>of</strong><br />
the Crimean War, a large number <strong>of</strong> trophies were supplied to Britain and distributed<br />
to cities and towns in the United Kingdom and her Empire. An address to the House<br />
<strong>of</strong> Commons during 1863 provides a list <strong>of</strong> 1165 Russian guns taken at Sebastopol.<br />
Included on the list are 730 iron guns and 324 iron carronades. The trophies were to<br />
be distributed among the Australian colonies in accordance with their contribution to<br />
the Patriotic Fund. Australian colonies donated the following amounts in pounds to<br />
the Patriotic Fund designated to assist the war effort:<br />
Colony<br />
Amount<br />
New <strong>South</strong> Wales £64 916<br />
<strong>South</strong> Australia £6,297<br />
Tasmania £28,375<br />
Victoria £47,711<br />
Western Australia £818<br />
In recognition <strong>of</strong> these large contributions, each colony, except Western Australia,<br />
was awarded a pair <strong>of</strong> Russian trophy guns. <strong>Adelaide</strong>'s two trophies were first<br />
installed in the Botanic Gardens during February 1859. In 1867 they were used to<br />
announce the arrival <strong>of</strong> the Duke <strong>of</strong> Edinburgh. Some time later, they were removed<br />
from the gardens and were handed over to the military authorities, which placed them<br />
in front <strong>of</strong> the armoury, which was located on North Terrace. One <strong>of</strong> the guns was<br />
fired daily as <strong>Adelaide</strong>’s time signal for midday. In the mid 1930s, they were moved<br />
to their present position on the Torrens Parade Ground. They were subsequently<br />
moved to the Keswick <strong>Army</strong> Barracks but were returned to the Torrens Parade<br />
Ground in 2004 where they are currently on display.<br />
28
(6) Whilst the Australian Government has generally claimed and distributed<br />
larger war trophies individual service people have usually collected smaller<br />
items known as wartime memorabilia.<br />
By searching the internet or examining the collection <strong>of</strong> a local RSL sub<br />
branch, identify four items <strong>of</strong> wartime memorabilia. Refer<br />
www.dva.gov.au > Media Centre > Publications ><br />
Memories and Memorabilia > Memorabilia<br />
Students may mention specific items such as diaries, badges, militaria etc. However<br />
they all fall into the following general categories.<br />
1. Written and printed material including personal letters and diaries and <strong>of</strong>ficial<br />
government documents.<br />
2. Photographs.<br />
3. Medals and ribbons.<br />
4. Wartime souvenirs and mementoes.<br />
(7) In some cases, servicemen and women obtain possessions from the enemy<br />
which may have personal and/or cultural significance.<br />
What sort <strong>of</strong> items might these be and do you think they should be<br />
returned to their owners where possible? Refer<br />
www.dva.gov.au > Media Centre > Publications > Memories and Memorabilia ><br />
Memorabilia<br />
Personal items could include anything from<br />
cigarette boxes to samurai swords. Students’<br />
answers should demonstrate that they understand<br />
the potential significance <strong>of</strong> such items. Good<br />
examples <strong>of</strong> items <strong>of</strong> both personal and cultural<br />
significance are Japanese personal flags, some <strong>of</strong><br />
which found their way back to Australia. These<br />
flags carried messages from family and friends and<br />
were carried into battle by Japanese soldiers. Of<br />
course, it is not practical or possible to return all<br />
such items. In recent years, the Australian War Memorial in Canberra returned some<br />
<strong>of</strong> the personal effects <strong>of</strong> a Japanese mini-sub crewman killed in the attack on Sydney<br />
Harbour to his aging mother when she visited Australia. This process can work both<br />
ways. In late 1997, a watch worn by an Australian World War II pilot killed in France<br />
in August 1944 was returned to his only surviving relative, a sister. The engraving on<br />
the back indicated that his local town had originally presented the watch to the pilot.<br />
Returned to Australia, it has become an important link, reaching back across the<br />
years, for the family and the local community as well as actively promoting positive<br />
international relations between nations, which previously had been at war.<br />
Source: http://www.dva.gov.au/media/publicat/memories/page_08.htm<br />
(8) Comment on the significance <strong>of</strong> wartime memorabilia and the importance<br />
<strong>of</strong> keeping some items in local Returned and Services League (RSL)<br />
clubrooms and local museums.<br />
29
Some items <strong>of</strong> wartime memorabilia, which are either rare or are <strong>of</strong> national<br />
importance, belong in the Australian War Memorial or other similar large museums.<br />
However, most wartime memorabilia has the greatest significance to the service<br />
person to whom it belonged. Often items, which are highly valued by the individual<br />
serviceman and women, are found in many wartime collections. What is unique about<br />
these items are the stories associated with them, such as the circumstances under<br />
which they were acquired and how they subsequently came to be returned to<br />
Australia. This information will enable future generations to interpret their<br />
significance. Those members <strong>of</strong> the community to whom the item belonged can best<br />
tell these stories. It is for this reason that wartime memorabilia should remain within<br />
the community to which the service person belonged as it forms an important part <strong>of</strong><br />
that community’s history<br />
30
Memorial Magill Soldiers Memorial<br />
Address Corner <strong>of</strong> Magill Road and Penfold Road, Magill<br />
Background Information<br />
The Magill Soldiers Memorial is a white marble<br />
monument comprising an obelisk, mounted on a pedestal<br />
<strong>of</strong> granite. At the base <strong>of</strong> the obelisk, superimposed in<br />
marble, are the Australian and British flags.<br />
Brigadier-General R.L. Leane unveiled the memorial on<br />
the 14 November 1920. Raymond Lionel Leane was a<br />
decorated First World War (Great War) commander. He<br />
was one <strong>of</strong> the first men ashore at Anzac Cove and was<br />
twice wounded at Gallipoli, including a wound to the head<br />
received when an enemy shell struck him following the<br />
successful attack on an enemy position that became<br />
known as Leane's Trench. In 1925, he was appointed the<br />
Chief Commissioner <strong>of</strong> Police in <strong>South</strong> Australia.<br />
Following the end <strong>of</strong> World War II, an additional plaque commemorating those who<br />
served during this conflict was added to the memorial.<br />
Student Activities<br />
On Site<br />
The memorial was first erected in the former Magill<br />
Primary School, which is now the site <strong>of</strong> the Pepper<br />
St Art Centre and Community Studio. It was moved<br />
to its present site, in the present Magill Primary<br />
School in 1956. The memorial was restored and<br />
rededicated in 1966.<br />
(1) What two wars are commemorated on the Magill Soldiers Memorial? By<br />
checking the inscriptions on the Magill Soldiers Memorial in which years<br />
did these conflicts begin and end? Hint: World War II dates are partly<br />
surrounded by a wreath.<br />
During The Great War (World War I) - 1914-1919<br />
World War II - 1939 – 1945<br />
(2) Complete the following inscription found on the side <strong>of</strong> the monument<br />
facing the Magill intersection.<br />
ERECTED BY THE RESIDENTS OF MAGILL<br />
FOR SOLDIERS WHO MADE THE<br />
SUPREME SACRIFICE<br />
DURING THE GREAT WAR 1914 -1919<br />
31
(3) How many soldiers whose names appear on the monument lost their lives<br />
during the First World War?<br />
How many others had died by 1920 from the effects <strong>of</strong> war?<br />
Assuming these figures were reflected throughout Australia, how many<br />
Australians might have lost their lives as a result <strong>of</strong> the effects <strong>of</strong> war by<br />
1920. To assist in your calculations 60,000 Australians lost their lives<br />
during the Great War.<br />
29 died during the war and 5 due to the effects <strong>of</strong> war.<br />
5/29 X 60,000 = Approx 10,335 would have potentially died by the end <strong>of</strong> 1920 due<br />
to the effects <strong>of</strong> war if these figures represented a national trend.<br />
(4) How many surnames appear more than once on the Magill Soldiers<br />
Memorial? List these names. Note the initials <strong>of</strong> the family with the<br />
surname starting with K. These will be used for further research when you<br />
return to the classroom.<br />
The four family names that appear twice are CRABB, JURY, KENNEDY and MAIN.<br />
The Kennedy’s initials are S.C. and R.<br />
Classroom<br />
(5) Both the Australian and British flags appear on the monument. Why would<br />
the flag <strong>of</strong> another country appear on an Australian war memorial?<br />
Whilst an independent country, Australia was still a part <strong>of</strong><br />
the British Empire in the early 20 th century. Given its<br />
colonial history, in 1914 Australia, still had strong political,<br />
social, cultural, military and commercial ties with Great<br />
Britain. A sense <strong>of</strong> Australian nationalism was still<br />
emerging and many Australians still saw themselves as<br />
British and looked to the mother country for leadership,<br />
recognition and support. The epitaph, chosen by one <strong>South</strong><br />
Australian mother after the war, which appears on a grave<br />
marker at Gallipoli, reads, “He died like a Britisher”.<br />
Source: http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/war/wwone/australia_02.shtml<br />
(6) List some reasons why so many Australians were willing to enlist to serve in<br />
the First World War?<br />
There were many reasons soldiers enlisted. Some <strong>of</strong> these include:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Loyalty to the British Empire.<br />
The desire for adventure.<br />
The result <strong>of</strong> friends or relatives joining up.<br />
The chance <strong>of</strong> overseas travel.<br />
32
Concern about a German victory and its impact on Australia.<br />
Chance to show what Australians could do on the battlefield.<br />
Outrage at reported German atrocities in Belgium early in the war.<br />
To visit the motherland (Great Britain) and ancient civilisations.<br />
Chance to play a role on the world stage in the “war to end all wars”.<br />
The impact <strong>of</strong> recruiting drives and community pressure.<br />
Christian commitment.<br />
(7) Using the information recorded in Q(4) about the family name starting<br />
with the letter K, visit the Australian War Memorial website at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases > Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour.<br />
Enter their surname and christian name (R is Reginald and S.C. is Sidney<br />
Clarence), select the First World War, 1914 –1918 and ‘click’ on search. Open<br />
the Circular Information and find out what three things were especially tragic<br />
about their deaths in respect to their relationship, place and time <strong>of</strong> death.<br />
Reginald and Sidney Clarence Kennedy were brothers. Both <strong>of</strong> them lost their lives at<br />
Ypres (Belgium) within a few days <strong>of</strong> each other on 28/9/17 and 4/10/17 respectively.<br />
(8) The names <strong>of</strong> M.J.R. and N.B.L. Crabb appear on<br />
the Magill Soldier’s Memorial.<br />
By accessing the Australian War Memorial Roll <strong>of</strong><br />
Honour find out if they were related.<br />
By looking at the notes in the Circular Information<br />
what happened to Murray on the 20 - 21<br />
September 1917?<br />
Murray John Rossiter and Norman Benjamin Lyndon Crabb were brothers.<br />
Murray was gassed on 20-21/9/1917.<br />
(9) Poison gas was a horrible weapon that was used during the First World<br />
War. During the period <strong>of</strong> its use on the Western Front, over 16,000<br />
Australians were gassed, with over 300 being killed by poison gas exposure.<br />
One particularly terrible form <strong>of</strong> chemical, which was first used in 1917,<br />
was known as “Mustard Gas”. Find out about the effects and problems<br />
with its use.<br />
Mustard Gas<br />
Germany unveiled an enhanced form <strong>of</strong> gas weaponry, which became known as<br />
mustard gas, an almost odourless chemical which was contained in artillery shells,<br />
against the Russians at Riga in September 1917. The serious blisters it caused, both<br />
internally and externally, brought on several hours after exposure, distinguished<br />
mustard gas from other types <strong>of</strong> poison gas used during World War One. Protection<br />
against mustard gas proved more difficult than against either chlorine or phosgene gas<br />
which had been used previously in the war. The use <strong>of</strong> mustard gas - sometimes<br />
proved to have mixed benefits. While inflicting serious injury upon the enemy, the<br />
33
chemical remained potent in soil for weeks after release: making capture <strong>of</strong> infected<br />
trenches a dangerous undertaking.<br />
Source: www.firstworldwar.com/weaponry/gas.htm<br />
(10) Why do you think that this memorial was initially erected at the site <strong>of</strong> the<br />
old Magill Primary School and in 1956 was moved next to the current<br />
Magill Primary School grounds?<br />
Many Magill residents who served during the First World War had been educated at<br />
the Magill Primary School and would have had relatives who also attended the school.<br />
The school community would have been proud <strong>of</strong> the contribution <strong>of</strong> their former<br />
students and those who had died in the service <strong>of</strong> their country. The school grounds<br />
would have therefore been seen as an appropriate location for the community’s tribute<br />
to its local soldiers. The move in 1956 may have reflected the desire <strong>of</strong> community<br />
leaders to ensure that the sacrifices made in World War I and II were not lost on the<br />
younger generation whose freedom and liberty former students had fought to<br />
preserve. The location is a prominent corner one, which is adjacent to the original<br />
Magill settlement.<br />
34
Memorial Norwood Primary School Memorial<br />
Address 96 Beulah Road (corner Osmond Terrace), Norwood<br />
Background Information<br />
Norwood Primary School was opened in 1851 and became<br />
<strong>South</strong> Australia's first Model Primary School. Norwood<br />
and surrounding districts had a substantial population and<br />
the status <strong>of</strong> a model school meant that Norwood Primary<br />
School attracted many students. In 1918, the Headmaster <strong>of</strong><br />
the school had the inspiration <strong>of</strong> building a memorial to the<br />
old scholars <strong>of</strong> the school who died in the First World War<br />
(Great War) with the active involvement <strong>of</strong> his current<br />
students. The children contributed pennies for bricks and<br />
then laid them together. The Headmaster made a cardboard<br />
model <strong>of</strong> the memorial and, although many <strong>of</strong> the fathers<br />
helped with the heavier work, the children did the actual<br />
building. During the school's Jubilee year in 1951, a plaque was added to honour<br />
those old scholars who had fought and died during World War II. Inside the school is<br />
a magnificent honour roll listing the names <strong>of</strong> all past students who served during the<br />
Great War. Many <strong>of</strong> these names also appear on the nearby Norwood and Kensington<br />
and Burnside War Memorials.<br />
Student Activities<br />
On Site<br />
(1) Complete the following text that appears on the plaque on the Norwood<br />
Primary School Memorial in front <strong>of</strong> the school. This plaque can be seen<br />
from the footpath and does not require entry into the school grounds.<br />
IN MEMORY<br />
OF<br />
THE BRAVE LADS<br />
WHO ATTENDED THIS SCHOOL<br />
AND WHO DIED<br />
FOR LIBERTY AND COUNTRY<br />
IN THE GREAT WAR 1914-1918.<br />
ERECTED BY BY THE CHILDREN OF THE NORWOOD PRIMARY SCHOOL<br />
AND BUILT WITH THEIR OWN HANDS.<br />
Classroom<br />
(2) Why do you think the Norwood Primary School<br />
headmaster considered it important that the<br />
school children build this monument with their<br />
own hands?<br />
Why do you think he chose an obelisk design?<br />
35
Consider both the practical and symbolic significance <strong>of</strong> the choice <strong>of</strong> this type <strong>of</strong><br />
war memorial.<br />
The headmaster probably thought that as it was former students who served in World<br />
War I that it was most fitting that current day students also build the memorial. No<br />
doubt the work involved in the construction <strong>of</strong> the war memorial would have<br />
promoted a sense <strong>of</strong> ownership and provided cause for reflection by the students on<br />
the contribution made by their predecessors in the Great War that might otherwise not<br />
have been the case.<br />
Obelisks are relatively easy to construct compared to other memorials such as those<br />
that involve carving human figures. They are high structures and therefore tend to<br />
stand out. Another practical advantage <strong>of</strong> obelisks is that they have at least four<br />
inscription faces. Obelisks have their origins in Egyptian, Greek and Roman<br />
architectural styles. The standard obelisk, <strong>of</strong> which the Norwood Primary school war<br />
memorial is a form, is shaped like a finger or ray <strong>of</strong> the sun. It is Egyptian in origin<br />
and originally represented “Ra” the Egyptian Sun God. Their symbolic significance as<br />
a choice for a war memorial lies in the fact that “Ra” was the giver <strong>of</strong> life. Pointing<br />
skywards also has connotations <strong>of</strong> being closer to God.<br />
36
Memorial Tea Tree Gully War Memorial and ‘Avenue <strong>of</strong> Trees’<br />
Address North East Road and Memorial Drive, Tea Tree Gully<br />
Background Information<br />
The Tea Tree Gully community's tribute to the<br />
men from their area, who served their country<br />
during the two World Wars, consists <strong>of</strong><br />
<br />
<br />
the Tea Tree Gully War Memorial in the<br />
form <strong>of</strong> an Arch and<br />
the Avenue <strong>of</strong> Trees.<br />
The arch is made <strong>of</strong> two brick pillars with a<br />
wrought iron arch spanning the entrance to<br />
Memorial Drive and the Avenue <strong>of</strong> Trees. On<br />
each <strong>of</strong> the pillars is a bronze plaque with the names <strong>of</strong> those men from the local<br />
district who served during World War I (Great War) and World War II.<br />
The Avenue <strong>of</strong> Trees runs along both sides <strong>of</strong> Memorial Drive down to the Tea Tree<br />
Gully oval. A tree was planted for each World War I and II soldier who served from<br />
the area. Originally, each tree had a plaque placed on it, but by 2005 none <strong>of</strong> the<br />
plaques remain.<br />
Student Activities<br />
On Site<br />
(1) Count the number <strong>of</strong> names that are listed on the World War I plaque that<br />
is located on the eastern side (left-hand) pillar <strong>of</strong> the war memorial. Then<br />
count the names that have crosses adjacent to them and calculate what<br />
percentage lost their lives during the war.<br />
24 and 5.<br />
5 ÷ 24 x 100 = Approx. 21%<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: This was about the national average for the<br />
First World War with one in every five or six soldiers not<br />
returning. The figures indicate that Tea Tree Gully, like<br />
many communities, was equally and tragically impacted on<br />
by Australian involvement during the First World War.<br />
(2) Record the names and initials <strong>of</strong> the First World<br />
War soldiers with crosses adjacent to them for<br />
further research?<br />
37
Names <strong>of</strong> fallen are;<br />
Angove E.L<br />
Elliott E.R.<br />
Lewis W.<br />
Lucas W.<br />
Phillips A.V.<br />
(3) Examine the names on the World War I and II plaques on the Tea Tree<br />
Gully War Memorial.<br />
What do they suggest about changes in the population in the area that<br />
occurred between the two wars?<br />
The names on the plaques suggest that Tea Tree Gully was a relatively small<br />
community during World War I with some well established families such as Angove<br />
and Phillips living in the area. Records indicate that the population was around 2,000<br />
at the outbreak <strong>of</strong> World War I. The new names on the World War II plaque suggest<br />
that by this time some <strong>of</strong> the old families had moved, or did not have children <strong>of</strong><br />
military age, and that there had been an influx <strong>of</strong> new residents. The numbers<br />
enlisting also suggest considerable population growth occurred in Tea Tree Gully area<br />
between the wars, which is consistent with the general population growth that<br />
occurred in Australia at that time.<br />
(4) Complete the table below by recording the names and initials <strong>of</strong> those First<br />
World War soldiers who have capital letters adjacent to them for further<br />
research when you return to the classroom. These letters are abbreviations<br />
for military awards for bravery or exceptional service. There are four in<br />
total.<br />
Name<br />
Military Award<br />
M.S.M<br />
D.C.M<br />
M.M.<br />
M.M<br />
Name<br />
BEAMES A.E.<br />
BEAMES H.H<br />
BOWEN V.S.<br />
PHILLIPS J.H<br />
Military Award<br />
M.S.M<br />
D.C.M<br />
M.M.<br />
M.M<br />
(5) Compare the percentages <strong>of</strong> those Tea Tree Gully servicemen who lost<br />
their lives during the First World War and Second World War in relation<br />
to those who served. What does this suggest about the numbers who served<br />
in both wars and the likelihood <strong>of</strong> survival? Can you suggest why there is<br />
such a significant difference in survival rates?<br />
38
First World War 5 ÷ 24 = 21%<br />
Second World War 5 ÷ 56 = 9%<br />
The figures suggest that many more Australians served during World War II. In fact<br />
just under one million Australians served in World War II compared to approximately<br />
330,000 in World War I.<br />
The comparative percentages also suggest that the likelihood <strong>of</strong> a service person<br />
surviving World War I was considerably less than during World War II.<br />
Some factors affecting casualty rates included;<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
The tactics that were employed during the First World War, especially the period<br />
<strong>of</strong> trench warfare, which included frontal attacks by massed infantry against<br />
heavily defended positions.<br />
The ratio <strong>of</strong> personnel who served in the trenches or front lines, as opposed to<br />
support jobs in the First World War was much greater than in the Second World<br />
War.<br />
Many Australians, who served in the armed forces during World War II, were<br />
based in Australia in the event that the mainland was invaded. With some<br />
exceptions, such as parts <strong>of</strong> Northern Australia, the risk to life in these areas was<br />
minimal.<br />
Improvements in the treatment <strong>of</strong> the wounded also reduced the numbers who lost<br />
their lives during World War II. These included the application <strong>of</strong> surgical lessons<br />
learned from World War I and other advances in medicine, which reduced the<br />
numbers <strong>of</strong> those who, died from infection in the Second World War. Of<br />
particular importance in fighting bacterial infection was the development <strong>of</strong><br />
sulphur drugs in the 1930’s and the development <strong>of</strong> a powdered form <strong>of</strong> penicillin<br />
in 1941, which proved to be the most powerful antibacterial agent <strong>of</strong> World War<br />
II.<br />
History <strong>of</strong> penicillin: http://inventors.about.com/library/inventors/blpenicillin.htm<br />
(6) Record the names and initials <strong>of</strong> the servicemen on the World War II<br />
plaque with a cross next to their name.<br />
Dillon L.J.<br />
Hobbs H.C.<br />
Newman P.F.<br />
Smart E.R.<br />
Tregeagle J.R.<br />
(7) Record the name and initials <strong>of</strong> the last person to appear<br />
on the First World War plaque.<br />
Whitmore A.E.<br />
39
Classroom<br />
(8) As a tribute to those ten servicemen from Tea Tree Gully, who lost their<br />
lives in the two World Wars, the local community planted the ‘Avenue <strong>of</strong><br />
Trees’. These trees originally had plaques bearing the names <strong>of</strong> the fallen.<br />
They have now all disappeared. Write a letter <strong>of</strong> 50 –100 words to the<br />
editor <strong>of</strong> the local paper arguing for these plaques to be replaced.<br />
Student answers should reflect the contribution and sacrifice made by these ten<br />
servicemen during the two World Wars.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: Students may also be encouraged to write to their local member <strong>of</strong><br />
Parliament or local RSL branch requesting that they argue for the replacement <strong>of</strong><br />
these plaques.<br />
(9) The very last name on the Tea Tree Gully World War I plaque, which you<br />
recorded in Question (7), is that <strong>of</strong> a famous World War I veteran who died<br />
on July 26 2002 aged 102. His first name was Albert. However he was<br />
better known as Bert. Use the internet to find out why he was so important.<br />
Albert (Bert) Whitmore will be remembered because he was the last <strong>of</strong> the World<br />
War I Australian Light Horsemen and the last <strong>South</strong> Australian World War I veteran.<br />
He was honoured by a State Funeral when he passed away. The Australian Light<br />
Horse were mounted infantry. Light Horsemen served at Gallipoli with distinction and<br />
some also served on the Western front. However they are best known for their<br />
campaigns in Egypt and the Middle East from 1916-1918.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: By birth, upbringing and training, Whitmore fitted<br />
into the mould <strong>of</strong> a Light Horseman perfectly. Born, as he said, "way<br />
out in the bush" in the then hamlet <strong>of</strong> Tea Tree Gully, 20km north<br />
east <strong>of</strong> <strong>Adelaide</strong>, he was put in the saddle before he could walk. His<br />
first job on leaving primary school was mustering sheep on<br />
horseback. The 17-year-old was still riding to and from his <strong>Adelaide</strong><br />
Hills job as an apprentice baker when he enlisted on March 5, 1917,<br />
putting his age up and passing the riding test at first go. Trained in<br />
Mitcham in <strong>South</strong> Australia and in Seymour, Victoria, he joined the<br />
9 th Light Horse Regiment and sailed for Port Suez. He was taught<br />
desert warfare before joining the campaign at Gaza, just west <strong>of</strong><br />
Beersheba, which his countrymen had just captured. The 9 th Light<br />
Horse then liberated Gaza from Turkish and German occupation to<br />
open the way to Jerusalem. Whitmore rode into the fray in the<br />
successful third battle for Gaza.<br />
Riding north along the Mediterranean coast, they occupied Jaffa, Bethlehem and<br />
finally Jerusalem. "It was like riding through the Bible," Whitmore said. He then<br />
served in the Jordan Valley with the 9 th , and "rode <strong>of</strong>f at a gallop" on the famous Es<br />
Salt Raid in April 1918 to help the Allied Light Horse advance from the east towards<br />
enemy positions still held by enemy forces in Palestine. In this operation, they rode<br />
over the high plateau at Moab to the River Jordan, helping to gain and then guard an<br />
Allied crossing despite enemy fire at Es Salt. When enemy forces counterattacked<br />
40
from the west over the river, cutting <strong>of</strong>f the easier <strong>of</strong> two escape routes, they had to<br />
retreat. With numerous casualties and outbreaks <strong>of</strong> disease, the Light Horse had only<br />
800 effective rifles remaining. "As soon as our meagre rations were consumed,"<br />
Whitmore recalled, "we decided to try and ride our way out <strong>of</strong> the trap." They climbed<br />
over "terrible limestone cliffs and crags like mountain goats" to escape. Many horses<br />
fell hundreds <strong>of</strong> metres to their death. Similarly to the evacuation at Gallipoli, their<br />
successful retreat passed into military textbooks as one <strong>of</strong> history's most epic retreats.<br />
Whitmore's adventures were cut short when he contracted malaria during a recordbreaking<br />
Jordan Valley heat wave. "When one <strong>of</strong> our chaps saw me, he said: 'We'll<br />
never see Whit again' - but they carted me <strong>of</strong>f to hospital and I pulled through," he<br />
said. Having recovered, Bert served as army camp quartermaster at Ezbekieh<br />
Gardens, Cairo, before setting sail for Australia in August 1919.<br />
Farewelling the Australian Light Horse, their Commander, General Allenby thanked<br />
them for helping "conquer Palestine and Syria". He said, "the Australian Light<br />
Horseman combines a splendid physique and restless activity <strong>of</strong> mind, rendering him<br />
somewhat impatient <strong>of</strong> rigid and formal discipline, but giving him the gift <strong>of</strong><br />
adaptability mounted or on foot. Eager in advance and staunch in defence, the<br />
Australian Light Horseman has proved himself equal to the world's best, earning the<br />
gratitude <strong>of</strong> the Empire and admiration <strong>of</strong> the world".<br />
Back in <strong>Adelaide</strong>, Bert returned to Tea Tree Gully by horse and buggy before setting<br />
<strong>of</strong>f again on horseback with a government surveying party to pioneer the Riverland,<br />
founding the town <strong>of</strong> Barmera. He helped build the town and worked as the local<br />
butcher for most <strong>of</strong> his life. He married Kathleen Whitehead in 1931 and fathered two<br />
children, Murray and Shirley. He also served with the Engineers in World War II as<br />
staff sergeant and was presented with the 80th Anniversary Armistice Remembrance<br />
Medal in 1999. Albert Whitmore had two children, eight grandchildren and 16 greatgrandchildren.<br />
He is the only individual honoured by a plaque on the Australian Light<br />
Horse Memorial on East Terrace.<br />
Source: http://www.lighthorse.org.au/Pershist/whitmore.htm<br />
(10) You recorded four names at the Tea Tree Gully War Memorial, in<br />
Question (4), <strong>of</strong> men who won military awards in the First World War. In<br />
order to find out why they received the honour or award visit the<br />
Australian War Memorial website at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases > Honours and Awards ><br />
Honours and Awards (Recommendations: First World War)<br />
Enter each soldier’s surname and click on search. Locate their records, click on<br />
the recommendation to find out why they won these awards. Make sure to<br />
include the full name <strong>of</strong> the award in your answer.<br />
Beames A.E<br />
Meritorious Service Medal<br />
His medal “For conspicuous energy and devotion to duty” referred to the period 25 th<br />
February 1918 until the night <strong>of</strong> 16/17 September 1918.<br />
41
Beames H.H.<br />
Distinguished Conduct Medal<br />
On 21 October 1917 he was involved in the rescue <strong>of</strong> soldiers when an ammunition<br />
dump was shelled in Zonnebeke in Belgium. The rescues were conducted under<br />
heavy fire “and set a fine example <strong>of</strong> bravery under trying conditions”.<br />
Bowen V.S.<br />
Military Medal<br />
“On September 29 1918 Private Bowen moved well forward <strong>of</strong> our troops taking with<br />
him a supply <strong>of</strong> bombs (grenades) which he used to stop an enemy attack.”<br />
Phillips J.H.<br />
Military Medal<br />
On the 2/3 <strong>of</strong> June 1918 with two other soldiers he captured three German Machine<br />
guns. “Throughout the action he showed great courage and dash and set a fine<br />
example to the men <strong>of</strong> his platoon who witnessed the act”.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: Those words in quotation marks taken from actual citation.<br />
(11) Complete the table below for four <strong>of</strong> the First World War soldiers who<br />
have a cross against their names. You can find the information on the<br />
Australian War Memorial website at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases > Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour<br />
Enter each soldier’s surname, select First World War 1914 - 1918 and ‘click’ on<br />
search. The details you require will appear in the Circular Information, which<br />
forms part <strong>of</strong> the “Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour” records. Once the table is completed<br />
summarise the information to build a pr<strong>of</strong>ile <strong>of</strong> the soldiers from the Tea Tree<br />
Gully area who lost their lives during World War I.<br />
Name Birthplace Married Age Rank School<br />
Edward Lawrence<br />
ANGOVE<br />
Ernest Robert<br />
ELLIOTT<br />
Walter LEWIS<br />
Albert Victor<br />
PHILLIPS<br />
Name Birthplace Married Age Rank School<br />
Edward Lawrence<br />
ANGOVE<br />
Sussex England Yes 34 Lieutena<br />
nt<br />
Tea Tree Gully<br />
Public School<br />
Ernest Robert<br />
ELLIOTT<br />
Milbrook S.A. Unsure 25 Private Hope Valley Public<br />
School<br />
Walter LEWIS Tea Tree Gully Yes 29 Private Golden Grove Public<br />
School<br />
Albert Victor<br />
PHILLIPS<br />
Tea Tree Gully Unsure 25 Private Tea Tree Gully<br />
42
Pr<strong>of</strong>ile<br />
They were all young men.<br />
Around one quarter were born in England.<br />
At least half were married.<br />
They mainly served in the army as privates.<br />
Most attended public (government) schools.<br />
They all came from Tea Tree Gully and surrounding districts.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: Whilst this sample <strong>of</strong> Tea Tree Gully soldiers is too small to draw<br />
conclusions it does provide some useful insights for students.<br />
It is worth noting that around 30% <strong>of</strong> the original Anzacs were born in Great<br />
Britain.<br />
Whilst single men were initially preferred as recruits, many soldiers, who served<br />
overseas during World War I, were married.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> those who served in World War I were privates. This is the lowest rank in<br />
the army and therefore represented the largest number <strong>of</strong> soldiers who lost their<br />
lives.<br />
The level <strong>of</strong> education <strong>of</strong> these men reflects contemporary standards with most<br />
having only attended primary school.<br />
The entry standards for age for World War I recruits were 18-35 in August 1914<br />
and these were changed to 18-45 in April 1917. The average age <strong>of</strong> 28 is therefore<br />
probably close to the mean age <strong>of</strong> World War I recruits.<br />
This small group does provide some basic clues as to the types <strong>of</strong> men who<br />
enlisted throughout Australia during World War I.<br />
(12) With what business, that is still operating just west <strong>of</strong> the Tea Tree Gully<br />
War Memorial, do you think Edward Lawrence Angove was associated?<br />
Hint: Look at the occupation on the Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour record.<br />
Angoves Winery – He was Vigneron according to his “Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour” record.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: This information appears on his Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour details. Students may<br />
guess this from knowing the name and location <strong>of</strong> Angove’s winery. He was skilled<br />
winemaker who was being groomed to take over the Angove family winery.<br />
(13) Complete the table below about three <strong>of</strong> the Tea Tree Gully soldiers whose<br />
names you recorded in Question (6) and who lost their lives during World<br />
War II. By accessing the Australian War Memorial website at<br />
www.awm.gov.au > Biographical Databases > Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour<br />
Enter each soldier’s surname, select ‘Second World War 1939 –1945’ and then<br />
‘click’ on search. The details you require will appear in the Circular<br />
Information, which forms part <strong>of</strong> the “Roll <strong>of</strong> Honour” records. Once the table is<br />
completed summarise the information to build a pr<strong>of</strong>ile <strong>of</strong> the soldiers from the<br />
Tea Tree Gully area who lost their lives during World War II.<br />
43
Name Birthplace Married Age Place <strong>of</strong> burial Date <strong>of</strong> Death<br />
Leslie James<br />
DILLON<br />
Peter Frederick<br />
NEWMAN<br />
Jesse Roy<br />
TREGEAGLE<br />
Name Birthplace Married Age Place <strong>of</strong> burial Date <strong>of</strong> Death<br />
Leslie James Tea Tree Yes 24 Tobruk ( Libya) 9/7/41<br />
DILLON<br />
Gully<br />
Peter Frederick<br />
NEWMAN<br />
Jesse Roy<br />
TREGEAGLE<br />
<strong>Adelaide</strong> Yes 23 New Guinea<br />
(Bonama War<br />
Cemetery) Pt<br />
Moresby)<br />
Tea Tree<br />
Gully<br />
No 33 New Guinea<br />
(Finschhafen<br />
Cemetery)<br />
27/12/42<br />
1/10/43<br />
Pr<strong>of</strong>ile<br />
The soldiers were all young men.<br />
They were all born in the Tea Tree Gully/<strong>Adelaide</strong> area.<br />
Two out <strong>of</strong> three were married.<br />
They lost their lives in North Africa (1) and New Guinea (2)<br />
They died between the years 1941 – 43.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: Whilst this is too small a group to draw conclusions it is the case that<br />
most men serving in the Australian <strong>Army</strong> during World War II were relatively young<br />
with an average age <strong>of</strong> 26. This is approximately the average age <strong>of</strong> the three soldiers<br />
from Tea Tree Gully.<br />
Australian soldiers served in two major theatres during World War II, namely the<br />
Middle East which included North Africa from 1940 –1942 and the <strong>South</strong> West<br />
Pacific which included New Guinea from 1941 – 1945. The soldiers from Tea Tree<br />
Gully were involved in some <strong>of</strong> the pivotal campaigns in these two major theatres. In<br />
fact the locations <strong>of</strong> the deaths <strong>of</strong> these men correlates with some <strong>of</strong> the hardest fought<br />
and best known battles in Australian military history. Their involvement illustrates to<br />
students the local contribution and impact on small communities <strong>of</strong> these major<br />
battles and campaigns during World War II.<br />
(14) Summarise the World War II battles or campaigns in which these three<br />
servicemen lost their lives by searching the internet under the words “Rats<br />
<strong>of</strong> Tobruk” for L.J Dillon, Kokoda Track or Trail for P.F Newman and<br />
Finschhafen or Huon Peninsula for J.R Tregeagle.<br />
Leslie James Dillon was a “Rat <strong>of</strong> Tobruk’ and lost his life during the famous siege <strong>of</strong><br />
the Libyan port which lasted from May to December 1941.<br />
44
<strong>Teacher</strong>s information on the Seige <strong>of</strong> Tobruk<br />
Tobruk, like Gallipoli, is a name that means much in the war<br />
annals <strong>of</strong> Australia. Between April and August 1941 up to<br />
14,000 Australians, under the command <strong>of</strong> Lieutenant-<br />
General Leslie Morshead, were besieged in Tobruk by a<br />
German-Italian army commanded by General Erwin Rommel.<br />
The Allied garrison, largely Australian, grimly defended the<br />
strategically important fort. At night, the Royal Navy and the<br />
Royal Australian Navy service kept the garrison supplied by<br />
means <strong>of</strong> the "Tobruk ferry" which included the Australian<br />
destroyers Napier, Nizam, Nestor and Vendetta that were also<br />
known as the “scrap iron flotilla” due to the age <strong>of</strong> the ships.<br />
The German propagandist Lord Haw Haw (William Joyce) derided the allied troops<br />
as the "Rats <strong>of</strong> Tobruk", because they lived underground during the day to escape<br />
bombing raids by German aircraft. The term “rats” was proudly embraced by the<br />
defenders <strong>of</strong> Tobruk as an ironic compliment.<br />
Tobruk was a nut the Germans and Italian forces could not crack. Its defence held up<br />
Rommel’s advance towards Egypt and the vital allied sea link the Suez Canal. If<br />
successful in his North African campaign, Rommel then could have advanced further<br />
east and threatened the Middle East oilfields. Under the inspired leadership <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Australian General Morshead, <strong>of</strong>fensive tactics achieved the task <strong>of</strong> defending<br />
Tobruk. These tactics included regular night patrols deep into enemy held territory. Its<br />
defence was a thorn in the side <strong>of</strong> the German army, upsetting not only plans for an<br />
attack on Egypt, but also giving the allies time to build up its forces for a counter<br />
attack. This occurred in November 1941 and the siege at Tobruk finally ended after<br />
242 days when the garrison broke out to join up with the British Eighth <strong>Army</strong>, which<br />
affected the relief <strong>of</strong> Tobruk on 10 th December 1941. The Australian casualties at the<br />
siege <strong>of</strong> Tobruk were 3,009 killed or wounded and 941 taken prisoner.<br />
Source: www.awm.gov.au/encyclopedia/tobruk/<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s note: William Joyce was executed after the war for his treasonous<br />
propaganda.<br />
Peter Frederick Newman was a Lance Corporal with the <strong>South</strong> Australian 2/27 th<br />
Battalion, which was involved during the final stages <strong>of</strong> delaying <strong>of</strong> the Japanese<br />
advance along the Kokoka track at Efogi and Brigade Hill in September 1942.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s information on the Kokoda Track<br />
In July 1942 the Japanese landed troops at Buna and Gona on the Papuan north coast.<br />
Their plan was to capture Port Moresby. The barrier between the Japanese forces in<br />
the north and Port Moresby on the south coast was the Owen Stanley Range - a steep,<br />
rugged series <strong>of</strong> mountains crossed only by a few foot tracks, the most important <strong>of</strong><br />
which was the Kokoda Track. At the end <strong>of</strong> June, one thousand Australian militiamen,<br />
‘Maroubra’ Force, had been ordered to hold Kokoda and its airfield against any<br />
possible Japanese attack.<br />
45
By the end <strong>of</strong> July, the Australian militia, who were outnumbered, inexperienced and<br />
had an average age <strong>of</strong> 20, were carrying out a fighting retreat. It was not until late in<br />
August that reinforcements from the battle hardened 7 th Division, Australian Imperial<br />
Force (A.I.F.) who had fought in the Middle East began to reach them. However<br />
Japanese advances continued through the trackless jungle on the flanks <strong>of</strong> positions<br />
that the Australians defended along the track. The Australians were unable to counter<br />
attack at this stage but continued with a policy <strong>of</strong> fighting withdrawals delaying the<br />
enemy advance and stretching the Japanese supply lines to their limit.<br />
By mid-September the Australians had dug in at Imita Ridge, fifty kilometres from<br />
Port Moresby, and were ordered to hold that position. A fight to the death was<br />
expected but the Japanese, worn down by Australian resistance, lacking sufficient<br />
supplies and fearing an American attack on their base at Buna, at the order <strong>of</strong> their<br />
Emperor, began to withdraw.<br />
During October and November 1942, the Australians pursued the Japanese through<br />
the stinking mud and treacherous, slippery tracks as they moved back along the<br />
Kokoda Track. The Japanese advance through the rain-sodden jungles <strong>of</strong> Papua had<br />
been turned into a retreat but, even though many <strong>of</strong> them were sick and starving, it<br />
was always a fighting retreat. Most <strong>of</strong> the hardest fighting was around the Japanese<br />
bases at Buna and Gona, where they had determined to fight to the death to maintain a<br />
foothold in Papua. The Papuan campaign ended with the surrender <strong>of</strong> Japanese<br />
survivors in this area on 22 January 1943.<br />
Source: www.anzacday.org.au/history/ww2/bfa/kokoda.html<br />
Jesse Roy Tregeagle was killed at Finschhafen during the campaigns on the Huon<br />
Peninsula in Papua New Guinea, which prevented the Japanese from using this area<br />
on the northern coast as a base in Papua New Guinea. This effectively eliminated any<br />
future Japanese threat to both Papua and the Australian mainland.<br />
<strong>Teacher</strong>s information on the campaign on the Huon Peninsula<br />
The Australian 9 th Division captured Finschhafen, on the Huon Peninsula in New<br />
Guinea on 2 October 1943. The Australians made an amphibious landing north <strong>of</strong><br />
Finschhafen, which was the largest large-scale, seaborne invasion by Australian<br />
troops since the landing at Gallipoli in 1915. It suffered a number <strong>of</strong> air attacks and<br />
stiff resistance from Japanese marines but was able to advance. Resistance from the<br />
Japanese garrison at Finschhafen ended on 1 October with an air and artillery<br />
bombardment, and the Australians entered the town with no further opposition. Heavy<br />
fighting continued around Sattelburg, to the north. Finschhafen became the Australian<br />
base for the long Huon Peninsula campaign <strong>of</strong> 1943-44. By early 1944 the entire<br />
Huon Peninsula was in allied hands. The successful campaign on the Huon Peninsula<br />
was critical in preventing the Japanese from reinforcing their troops in New Guinea<br />
and isolating those who remained.<br />
Source: http://minister.dva.gov.au/media_releases/2001/sep/history144.htm<br />
46