30 May 2013 - ICTY

30 May 2013 - ICTY 30 May 2013 - ICTY

europeanrights.eu
from europeanrights.eu More from this publisher
31.10.2014 Views

49236 day. 5189 Based on the daily medical reports of the RMO and in the absence of objections from the Prosecution and the Simatović Defence, the Trial Chamber decided to proceed with the scheduled court sessions in Stanišić’s absence on 16 July, 26 August, 27 August, and 14 September 2009. 5190 2437. On 30 November 2009, Stanišić participated in proceedings via the video-conference link from the UNDU for the first time. 5191 On 20 January 2010, Stanišić attended the trial proceedings in person for the first time. 5192 On 5 July 2010, Stanišić was not present in court after being urgently sent to hospital. 5193 As Stanišić had not waived his right to be present, the Trial Chamber dealt only with procedural matters in his absence. 5194 On 22 June, 29 September, 11 November 2010, and 24 November, 13, 14, and 15 December 2011 Stanišić waived his right to be present in court during house keeping sessions and on the basis that he felt unable to attend court. 5195 2438. On 1 September 2009, the Trial Chamber decided, inter alia, that the frequency of reporting by the gastroenterologist should be decreased. 5196 On 17 September 2010, the Trial Chamber, considering the changed circumstances in relation to the health of Stanišić and his participation in the court proceedings, amended the modalities for trial again. 5197 It decided, inter alia, to increase the hearings schedule from two to three days a week. 5198 On 17 August 2012, the Trial Chamber, considering that apart from the closing arguments no further court sessions were scheduled in this case, amended the modalities for trial to discontinue the reporting regime of the RMO and medical specialists. 5199 2439. Provisional Release. Between July 2009 and July 2012, the Trial Chamber denied Stanišić provisional release on several occasions based on various grounds, including: 5189 Absence from Court Form, 15 July 2009, p. 1; Non-Attendance in Court Form, 15 July 2009; T. 1944-1946; Reasons for Decision Denying the Stanišić Defence Request to Adjourn the Court Proceedings and for Decision to Proceed with the Court Session of 15 July 2009 in the Absence of the Accused, 16 October 2009, paras 7-8. 5190 T. 2016-2017, 2045-2046, 2099-2100, 2189-2190. 5191 T. 2201-2202. 5192 T. 2736. 5193 T. 6102. 5194 T. 6102-6103. 5195 T. 5909-5910, 7498, 9055, 15068, 15578-15579, 15675-15676, 15761-15762; Absence from Court Form, 29 September 2010, p. 1; Absence from Court Form, 11 November 2010, p. 1; Absence from Court Form, 24 November 2011; Absence from Court Form, 13 December 2011, p. 1; Absence from Court Form, 14 December 2011, p.1; Absence from Court Form, 15 December 2011, p.1. 5196 Second Decision Amending Modalities for Trial, 1 September 2009, para. 2, Annex A, paras 3, 7, Annex B, paras 3, 7; Corrigendum to Second Decision Amending Modalities for Trial, 7 September 2009, para. 1, Annex B, para. 3. 5197 Third Decision Amending Modalities for Trial, 17 September 2010. 5198 Ibid., at para. 13, Annex A, para. 1, and Annex B, para. 1. 5199 Order Cancelling Regular Medical Reporting, 17 August 2012. Case No. IT-03-69-T 882 30 May 2013

49235 complications surrounding his health; the lack of compelling humanitarian grounds; and the premature nature of the request for provisional release. 5200 However, Stanišić was also repeatedly granted provisional release during the aforementioned time period. 5201 Similarly, during the same time period, the Trial Chamber granted Simatović provisional release on several occasions. 5202 2440. On 16 July 2012, the Chamber granted requests of both Accused for provisional release and on 7 December 2012, the Accused were ordered to return by 24 January 2013 in anticipation of the closing arguments. 5203 On 15 May 2013, the Trial Chamber terminated the provisional release of the Accused and ordered that they return to the Tribunal on or before 27 May 2013, in anticipation of the pronouncement of the Judgement on 30 May 2013. 5204 2441. Adjournments and other reasons for delays not related to the health of Stanišić. On 27 August 2009, Simatović requested an adjournment of the trial following the death of his lead counsel, Mr Jovanović, on 2 August 2009. 5205 In various decisions, the Trial Chamber decided not to have any regular court hearings for the remainder of August, the whole of September, and beginning of October 2009. 5206 On 15 October 2009, the Trial Chamber decided, inter alia, that the hearings in the case would recommence during the week of 30 November 2009, which they did. 5207 On 23 February 2010, the Trial Chamber granted an urgent defence request for adjournment between 1 March and 12 April 2010, in order for the Defence to adequately prepare for the continuation of the proceedings. 5208 5200 Decision on Urgent Stanišić Defence Motion for Provisional Release during the Upcoming Court Recess, 22 July 2009, para. 23; Decision on Urgent Stanišić Defence Motion for Provisional Release, 31 March 2010, para. 31; Decision on Urgent Stanišić Defence Motion for Provisional Release on Humanitarian and Compassionate Grounds, 16 August 2010, paras 7, 9-11; Decision on Stanišić Defence Motion for Provisional Release, 16 July 2012, para. 6. 5201 Public Redacted Version of “Decision on Urgent Stanišić Defence Motion for Provisional Release” of 11 October 2010, 23 November 2010, paras 13-14; Decision on Urgent Stanišić Request for Provisional Release, 21 April 2011, paras 11, 14. 5202 Decision on Simatović Defence Motion for Provisional Release During the Upcoming Court Recess, 10 July 2009, para. 15; Urgent Order Varying Conditions of Franko Simatović’s Provisional Release, 4 August 2009, p. 2; Decision on Simatović Defence Motion for Provisional Release During the Winter Court Recess, 10 December 2010, para. 8. 5203 Order in Relation to the Provisional Release of the Accused, 7 December 2012, paras 3-4. 5204 Scheduling Order for Pronouncement of Judgement and Order Terminating Provisional Release of the Accused, 15 May 2013. 5205 Request of Franko Simatović for Adjournment of Proceedings, 27 August 2009. 5206 See T. 2186; Scheduling Order, 11 September 2009. 5207 Decision on Motion for Adjournment of Proceedings by the Simatović Defence, 15 October 2009, para. 30 (i); T. 2201. 5208 Decision on Urgent Simatović Defence Request for Adjournment, 23 February 2010. Case No. IT-03-69-T 883 30 May 2013

49236<br />

day. 5189 Based on the daily medical reports of the RMO and in the absence of objections from<br />

the Prosecution and the Simatović Defence, the Trial Chamber decided to proceed with the<br />

scheduled court sessions in Stanišić’s absence on 16 July, 26 August, 27 August, and 14<br />

September 2009. 5190<br />

2437. On <strong>30</strong> November 2009, Stanišić participated in proceedings via the video-conference<br />

link from the UNDU for the first time. 5191 On 20 January 2010, Stanišić attended the trial<br />

proceedings in person for the first time. 5192 On 5 July 2010, Stanišić was not present in court<br />

after being urgently sent to hospital. 5193 As Stanišić had not waived his right to be present, the<br />

Trial Chamber dealt only with procedural matters in his absence. 5194 On 22 June, 29<br />

September, 11 November 2010, and 24 November, 13, 14, and 15 December 2011 Stanišić<br />

waived his right to be present in court during house keeping sessions and on the basis that he<br />

felt unable to attend court. 5195<br />

2438. On 1 September 2009, the Trial Chamber decided, inter alia, that the frequency of<br />

reporting by the gastroenterologist should be decreased. 5196 On 17 September 2010, the Trial<br />

Chamber, considering the changed circumstances in relation to the health of Stanišić and his<br />

participation in the court proceedings, amended the modalities for trial again. 5197 It decided,<br />

inter alia, to increase the hearings schedule from two to three days a week. 5198 On 17 August<br />

2012, the Trial Chamber, considering that apart from the closing arguments no further court<br />

sessions were scheduled in this case, amended the modalities for trial to discontinue the<br />

reporting regime of the RMO and medical specialists. 5199<br />

2439. Provisional Release. Between July 2009 and July 2012, the Trial Chamber denied<br />

Stanišić provisional release on several occasions based on various grounds, including:<br />

5189 Absence from Court Form, 15 July 2009, p. 1; Non-Attendance in Court Form, 15 July 2009; T. 1944-1946;<br />

Reasons for Decision Denying the Stanišić Defence Request to Adjourn the Court Proceedings and for Decision<br />

to Proceed with the Court Session of 15 July 2009 in the Absence of the Accused, 16 October 2009, paras 7-8.<br />

5190 T. 2016-2017, 2045-2046, 2099-2100, 2189-2190.<br />

5191 T. 2201-2202.<br />

5192 T. 2736.<br />

5193 T. 6102.<br />

5194 T. 6102-6103.<br />

5195 T. 5909-5910, 7498, 9055, 15068, 15578-15579, 15675-15676, 15761-15762; Absence from Court Form, 29<br />

September 2010, p. 1; Absence from Court Form, 11 November 2010, p. 1; Absence from Court Form, 24<br />

November 2011; Absence from Court Form, 13 December 2011, p. 1; Absence from Court Form, 14 December<br />

2011, p.1; Absence from Court Form, 15 December 2011, p.1.<br />

5196 Second Decision Amending Modalities for Trial, 1 September 2009, para. 2, Annex A, paras 3, 7, Annex B,<br />

paras 3, 7; Corrigendum to Second Decision Amending Modalities for Trial, 7 September 2009, para. 1, Annex<br />

B, para. 3.<br />

5197 Third Decision Amending Modalities for Trial, 17 September 2010.<br />

5198 Ibid., at para. 13, Annex A, para. 1, and Annex B, para. 1.<br />

5199 Order Cancelling Regular Medical Reporting, 17 August 2012.<br />

Case No. IT-03-69-T 882<br />

<strong>30</strong> <strong>May</strong> <strong>2013</strong>

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!