Literature review: Impact of Chilean needle grass ... - Weeds Australia
Literature review: Impact of Chilean needle grass ... - Weeds Australia
Literature review: Impact of Chilean needle grass ... - Weeds Australia
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
to Bouchenak-Khelladi et al. 2009). The earliest fossil <strong>grass</strong> pollen has been found in the early Tertiary, with doubtful earlier<br />
records from the Cretaceous (Thomasson 1986), and presumed records (Monoporites) from 70-60 mybp (Prasad et al. 2005).<br />
Grass pollen first appears in the <strong>Australia</strong>n record in the Paleocene (Macphail et al. 1994), at the end <strong>of</strong> the Paleocene (c. 58<br />
mybp) (Keith 2004), or about 50 mybp (Keith 2004).<br />
Undoubted fossils, with seeds very similar to modern Stipa, Piptochaetium and Phalaris, occur in rocks dated to the mid-Tertiary<br />
(c. 35 mybp) long after the family first evolved (Stebbins 1972). Bouchenak-Khelladi et al. (2009) indicate that the BEP clade<br />
(Bambusoideae, Ehrhartoideae and Pooideae), which includes Stipeae, originated in the Paleocene (57 mypb), while the other<br />
major clade, including most C 4 species, is younger, originating in the late Eocene (40 mybp). C 4 physiology was probably well<br />
developed by the Miocene (Thomasson 1986), the oldest origin in <strong>grass</strong>es being approximately 30.9 mybp (Christin et al. 2009,<br />
Bouchenak-Khelladi et al. 2009).<br />
Tsvelev (1977 1984) convincingly argued that Poaceae first evolved in response to colder and drier conditions in mountainous<br />
areas with an increasingly continental climate. Stebbins (1986) argued a probable origin from Joinvillea-like ancestors<br />
(Joinvilleaceae) and differentiation into major families in lowland, open tropical savannahs with seasonal droughts; the non<br />
sequitur <strong>of</strong> a <strong>grass</strong>-less savannah going unremarked. A South American (Gondwanan) origin for the family has been suggested<br />
on the basis <strong>of</strong> the distribution <strong>of</strong> extant taxa, with diversification <strong>of</strong> subclades in Gondwana by the late Cretaceous (Prasad et al.<br />
2005). Although considerable diversification within the family took place in the mid-Miocene (Piperno and Sues 2005), most<br />
modern tribes probably existed by the Paleocene (early Tertiary, c. 50 mybp), probably along with many modern genera<br />
(Tsvelev 1984, Jones 1999a). The Stipeae probably arose from primitive Pooideae (Stebbins 1986) which existed at least as early<br />
as 70 mybp (Prasad et al. 2005).<br />
Jones (1999a) cited authors who argued the tropical origin <strong>of</strong> <strong>grass</strong>lands in areas that were cooling and developing seasonal<br />
aridity, in forest-savannah ecotone. Poaceae are uncommon in the fossil record until the mid-Miocene (16-11 mybp) (Piperno<br />
and Sues 2005) and “only became widespread 25 to 15 million years ago when cool, dry conditions kicked in” (O’Donoghue<br />
2008 p. 39). The unimportance <strong>of</strong> mammals, except for South American gonwanatherians, with typical grazing adaptations such<br />
as hypsodont teeth until the Oligocene and Miocene also indicates that <strong>grass</strong>es were a minor component <strong>of</strong> vegetation before this<br />
time (Prasad et al. 2005).<br />
Barkworth and Everett (1986 p. 261) noted that the character sets that define non-<strong>Australia</strong>n supra-specific stipoid taxa do not<br />
occur in <strong>Australia</strong>n taxa, even though <strong>Australia</strong>n stipoids in aggregate possess almost all <strong>of</strong> these characters. They believed that<br />
Stipeae originated in Gondwana, suggesting a late Jurassic or Cretaceous (c. 135 mybp) origin for the tribe (Jones 1999a).<br />
Tsvelev (1977) more or less agreed, noting that the impoverished stipoid flora <strong>of</strong> Africa (excluding the Mediterranean areas)<br />
probably resulted from repeated long dry periods and the absence <strong>of</strong> high mountain refugia. Africa began to split from the South<br />
American section <strong>of</strong> Gondwana in the mid to late Mesozoic (c. 165-70 mybp) leaving <strong>Australia</strong> and South America still linked<br />
through Antarctica by the early Tertiary (c. 65 mybp) (Barlow 1981). Separation <strong>of</strong> Antarctica and <strong>Australia</strong> occurred in the<br />
Paleocene (53-50 mybp) and accelerated in the middle-late Eocene (c. 43-36 mybp) (McGowran et al. 2000). Several authors<br />
have favoured the Gondwanan centre <strong>of</strong> origin <strong>of</strong> Stipa (sens. lat.) including Moraldo (1986 p. 205) who placed it in the ‘suture<br />
zones between South American, Antarctica and <strong>Australia</strong>’.<br />
South America has a very rich stipoid flora, paralleled only by that <strong>of</strong> Eurasia (Tsvelev 1977). The current centre <strong>of</strong> diversity <strong>of</strong><br />
Nassella is Argentina with c. 72 species, with greatest diversity in the north west, and 26 indigenous species. Uruguay has 23+<br />
spp., and the greatest diversity in Bolivia and Chile is in the central Andes, adjacent to Argentina (Reyna and Barkworth 1994,<br />
Barkworth and Torres 2001, Barkworth 2006). The pampas or Rio de la Plata <strong>grass</strong>lands have 25 Nassella species (Gardener et<br />
al. 1996b).<br />
Whether the genus evolved in the Pampas region is not known. There are no macr<strong>of</strong>ossil Stipeae known from South America<br />
(Barkworth 2006). Tsvelev (1977) considered Oligocene (36-25 mybp) fossil panicles from Colorado to be Stipa florissanti<br />
(Knowlt.) MacGinitie, and noted that the American <strong>grass</strong> specialist Agnes Chase considered them identical with the extant<br />
species Stipa mucronata (now Nassella mucronata (Kunth) R.W. Pohl. Barkworth). Everett (1986) accept the Miocene North<br />
American Berriochloa primaeva Thomasson to be the earliest stipoid fossil. According to Barkworth (1990) “nasselloid” fossils<br />
are present in Late Miocene-Early Pliocene (c. 13-5 mybp) deposits in the USA. These have Nassella-like lemma epidermal<br />
patterns, and were considered to be Nassella by Thomasson (1986). Other described fossil stipoids from the USA include<br />
Oligocene and Miocene Stipidium and Stipa and Oligocene Piptochaetium (Thomasson 1986). Barkworth and Torres (2001)<br />
appeared to accept four North American fossil Nassella species, but point out that only a single Nassella sp. is today present in<br />
the areas <strong>of</strong> Colorado, Kansas and Nebraska where the fossils were found. Tsvelev (1977) accepted lower Miocene fossils as<br />
Nassella and Piptochaetium spp. along with other <strong>grass</strong>es, indicating that prairie <strong>grass</strong>lands existed at that time. Johnson (1972)<br />
prematurely considered this fossil record provided geological evidence <strong>of</strong> a stipoid evolutionary ‘hot-spot’ in the high plains <strong>of</strong><br />
Nebraska during the Tertiary and argued for a North American focal point <strong>of</strong> polyploidisation.<br />
Barkworth and Everett (1986) considered that American stipoids consisted <strong>of</strong> groups derived directly from Gondwana, such as<br />
Nassella (in the narrow sense) and Piptochaetium, and from a separate independent group that initially occupied Eurasia, notably<br />
Achnatherum. According to Barkworth (1990) citing Tsvelev (1977), the North American Stipa sens. lat. evolved from South<br />
American taxa, and European taxa from North American, however this is not evident in my reading <strong>of</strong> Tselev (1977), who<br />
argued that stipoids in South America evolved in parallel with those in North America and Eurasia over a very long period prior<br />
to the Pliocene, and that they first evolved around the Tethys sea between Africa and Eurasia when all the continental masses<br />
were joined in Pangaea (i.e. in the Triassic period c. 200 mybp). Tsvelev (1977) thought that evolution <strong>of</strong> the Stipeae in all areas<br />
simultaneously involved elongation <strong>of</strong> the spikelet and all its parts, and the lengthening <strong>of</strong> the awns, usually correlated with<br />
elongation <strong>of</strong> the glume apices to prevent premature shedding <strong>of</strong> the floret. Based on anatomical and distributional data, he had<br />
no doubt that Stipa sens. lat. evolved before the formation <strong>of</strong> lowland <strong>grass</strong>lands and considered Achnatherum to be the most<br />
primitive stipoid genus.<br />
25