28.10.2014 Views

xavGE

xavGE

xavGE

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

A public company and its shareholders<br />

(although certain of such transactions<br />

must be reported on Form 4, pursuant to<br />

Rule 16a-3(f)).<br />

To the extent that an exemption<br />

exists from the reporting requirements of<br />

Section 16(a) in respect of any transaction<br />

in a security, the short-swing profit<br />

recapture provisions of Section 16(b)<br />

likewise do not apply to such transaction<br />

(see Rule 16a-10). Rule 16a-10 does<br />

not apply in the reverse; an exemption<br />

from the short-swing profit recapture<br />

provisions of Section 16(b) does not<br />

automatically provide an exemption<br />

from the reporting requirements of<br />

Section 16(a).<br />

An insider must file Form 4 with the<br />

SEC and with each national securities<br />

exchange on which any security of the<br />

company is listed within 10 days of<br />

the end of each month in which any<br />

reportable change in position occurs with<br />

respect to any security as to which it has<br />

a direct or indirect pecuniary interest.<br />

Every transaction during such month<br />

must be reported, even if acquisitions<br />

and dispositions during such month<br />

even out.<br />

For purposes of beneficial<br />

ownership, a person can be deemed to<br />

own beneficially not only securities<br />

owned directly by such person but<br />

also securities underlying derivative<br />

instruments convertible into or<br />

exchangeable for securities. For<br />

example, the holder of an option<br />

convertible into securities within 60<br />

days will be deemed, for the purposes<br />

of Section 13(d) (and determining a<br />

person’s status as an insider under<br />

Section 16(a)), to indirectly beneficially<br />

own the underlying securities, whether<br />

or not the option has been exercised.<br />

Thus, derivative securities owned by<br />

an insider that are, within 60 days,<br />

convertible into or exercisable for<br />

more than 5% of a security will create<br />

a reporting obligation under Section<br />

13(d) with respect to the underlying<br />

securities. If such derivative securities<br />

are, within 60 days, convertible into<br />

or exercisable for more than 10% of<br />

a security, such holder will also be<br />

deemed an insider of the company of<br />

such security subject to the reporting<br />

obligations under Section 16(a).<br />

7.5 Related party transactions<br />

Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP<br />

It is not uncommon, pre-IPO, for the<br />

company to do business informally<br />

with family members or without giving<br />

due consideration to whether certain<br />

transactions are done on an arm’s-length<br />

basis. Once the company conducts its<br />

IPO, however, it needs to be careful about<br />

so-called “related party transactions”<br />

because they can present potential or<br />

actual conflicts of interest and create<br />

the appearance that decisions are<br />

based on considerations other than the<br />

best interests of the company and its<br />

stockholders.<br />

Definition: The SEC defines a “related<br />

party transaction” as:<br />

• any individual or series of transactions,<br />

including any financial transaction,<br />

arrangement or relationship;<br />

• in which the company participates;<br />

• where the amount involved exceeds<br />

$120,000; and<br />

• in which any related person had or<br />

will have a direct or indirect material<br />

interest.<br />

A “related person” includes:<br />

• any director or executive officer of the<br />

company;<br />

• any nominee for director, if the<br />

information is being provided in a<br />

proxy statement;<br />

• any beneficial owner of more than 5%<br />

of any class of the company’s voting<br />

securities; and<br />

• any immediate family member of the<br />

people listed above (i.e., any child,<br />

stepchild, parent, stepparent, spouse,<br />

sibling, mother-in-law, father-in-law,<br />

son-in-law, daughter-in-law, brotherin-law<br />

or sister-in-law of such people)<br />

and any person. other than a tenant<br />

or employee, sharing the household of<br />

such people.<br />

Reasons for concern: The company should<br />

care about related party transactions for a<br />

number of reasons:<br />

• It makes good business sense—Related<br />

party transactions may involve terms<br />

that are not as competitive as might<br />

otherwise be achieved, preventing the<br />

company from best accomplishing its<br />

financial or strategic goals.<br />

• Some related party transactions are<br />

prohibited—Under the securities<br />

laws, the company is prohibited from<br />

making loans to directors or executive<br />

officers. Any such loans would have<br />

to be unwound prior to the company’s<br />

IPO. Other related party transactions<br />

can cause a director not to be<br />

considered independent for service on<br />

the company’s compensation or audit<br />

committee for tax or securities law<br />

purposes.<br />

• Stockholders care—Related party<br />

transactions signal a possible conflict<br />

of interest to investors. They can call<br />

into question whether the company<br />

puts the best interests of the company<br />

and its stockholders first, tarnishing<br />

the legitimacy of management and<br />

damaging valuation of the company’s<br />

securities.<br />

• The SEC cares—The SEC considers<br />

disclosure regarding related party<br />

transactions as integral to a materially<br />

complete picture of financial<br />

relationships with the company.<br />

As a result, securities regulations<br />

require detailed disclosure on these<br />

transactions in proxy statements,<br />

annual reports and registration<br />

statements, including Form S-1.<br />

The disclosure must cover such<br />

information as the name of the<br />

related person and the basis on<br />

which the person is a related person,<br />

the related person’s interest in the<br />

transaction with the company, the<br />

approximate dollar value of the<br />

transaction and any other information<br />

regarding the transaction that is<br />

material to investors in light of<br />

the circumstances of the particular<br />

transaction.<br />

• Stock exchanges care—The listing rules<br />

of the various stock exchanges require<br />

the company to think carefully about<br />

related party transactions. For example,<br />

under NASDAQ rules, an independent<br />

body of the company’s board of<br />

directors must conduct ongoing review<br />

and oversight of all related party<br />

transactions for potential conflict-ofinterest<br />

situations. Similarly, the NYSE<br />

recommends a similar process and also<br />

78 NYSE IPO Guide

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!