28.10.2014 Views

xavGE

xavGE

xavGE

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

The IPO process<br />

• document review by the company’s and<br />

underwriters’ counsel, including:<br />

• charter documents of the company<br />

and its material subsidiaries;<br />

• minutes of meetings of<br />

shareholders, the board of directors<br />

and key committees, and materials<br />

prepared for board and committee<br />

meetings;<br />

• material contracts, including<br />

shareholders’ agreements and joint<br />

venture agreements, and forms of<br />

contracts;<br />

• filings, correspondence and other<br />

communications with supervisory<br />

and regulatory authorities;<br />

• materials relating to intellectual<br />

property, including licenses,<br />

patents and trademarks;<br />

• materials relating to pending<br />

litigation, including counsel’s<br />

litigation letters to auditors;<br />

• auditors’ letters to management;<br />

• D&O questionnaires; and<br />

• other documents that may<br />

further the legal due diligence<br />

investigation.<br />

Corporate governance due diligence:<br />

Underwriters and their counsel typically<br />

review the company’s corporate governance<br />

policies and Sarbanes-Oxley compliance<br />

programs. Issues to be considered may<br />

include:<br />

• the company’s disclosure controls and<br />

procedures and internal controls;<br />

• the company’s code of ethics,<br />

exemptions to the code and past<br />

waivers;<br />

• the independence of the board of<br />

directors;<br />

• the company’s policy on handling<br />

whistleblower complaints;<br />

• the company’s document retention<br />

policy; and<br />

• nonaudit services provided by the<br />

company’s independent auditors.<br />

Legal opinion and negative comfort letter:<br />

It is typically a condition to closing the<br />

IPO that counsel for the company and<br />

the underwriters provide both a legal<br />

opinion and a negative comfort letter,<br />

or “Rule 10b-5 letter.” The due diligence<br />

investigation provides counsel with the<br />

basis for these letters, and the letters<br />

in turn form part of the due diligence<br />

process on which offering participants<br />

rely. Opinions usually cover such matters<br />

as observance of corporate formalities,<br />

existence of the company and material<br />

subsidiaries and matters relating to<br />

the securities themselves. They may<br />

also address compliance with material<br />

contracts, among many other matters.<br />

The negative comfort letter generally<br />

says that nothing has come to the<br />

attention of counsel that would cause<br />

counsel to believe that the registration<br />

statement or prospectus is false or<br />

misleading in any material respect.<br />

Identifying potential problems: The due<br />

diligence process also aims to identify<br />

potential impediments to the transaction.<br />

Examples include contractual rights<br />

of another party that the IPO could<br />

trigger or modify, because it results<br />

in a change in the company’s share<br />

ownership. Provisions of this kind<br />

may exist in financing documentation,<br />

agreements with or among the company’s<br />

shareholders (e.g., preemptive or<br />

registration rights) or other important<br />

contracts or governmental authorizations.<br />

The process should also identify risks<br />

to future financial performance or<br />

competitive position and limitations<br />

on operational or financial flexibility.<br />

Examples include upcoming expiration<br />

or renewal dates, or early termination<br />

provisions, in customer or supplier<br />

contracts, government authorizations or<br />

IP licenses.<br />

Paper data room v virtual data room: A<br />

secure repository for the documents to be<br />

reviewed during the due diligence process<br />

is critical. The company or its counsel may<br />

host a “paper data room,” in which hard<br />

copies of proprietary business documents<br />

and financial data are made available for<br />

inspection. The paper data room has<br />

obvious limitations, given that participants<br />

may be spread across several cities, states<br />

or countries. Not only is inspection limited<br />

to the hours of operation of the host but<br />

review of documents for out-of-town<br />

participants is inconvenient.<br />

The “virtual data room” provides<br />

an excellent solution to the challenges<br />

presented by a traditional paper data room.<br />

Virtual data rooms can offer secure, webbased<br />

access to documents, particularly in<br />

convenient PDF format, and parallel access<br />

for each of the review groups. Moreover,<br />

the use of a virtual data room eliminates<br />

the need for travel and increases<br />

efficiencies by making documents available<br />

around the clock.<br />

The following points can be important<br />

factors in selecting a virtual data room<br />

provider:<br />

• Established track record—The provider<br />

should have proven technology and a<br />

strong customer-focused background.<br />

• Leading technology—The ideal solution<br />

should integrate leading technology,<br />

support industry standards and work<br />

with globally accepted data formats.<br />

• Project management expertise—<br />

Confidentiality is paramount, as is the<br />

provider’s ability to understand the<br />

transactional business environment<br />

and assign project managers who<br />

are educated and experienced in the<br />

specific transaction at hand.<br />

• Global production facilities—Choosing<br />

a provider with document-scanning<br />

facilities in cities around the world<br />

will ensure that accelerated document<br />

capture is quick and efficient.<br />

• User support—It should be possible to<br />

make changes and address questions<br />

immediately, for all users and in<br />

multiple languages.<br />

• Security—Security processes on<br />

application, staff and infrastructure;<br />

SSAE 16 Type II, multilocation data<br />

hosting with zero-downtime network<br />

guarantee; database replication<br />

at multiple locations; and a core<br />

competency in handling sensitive<br />

financial and business information are<br />

critical. (A SSAE 16 Type II service<br />

auditor’s report (or a SOC 1 Report)<br />

includes the service auditor’s opinion<br />

on the fairness of the presentation of<br />

the service organization’s description<br />

of the system, the suitability of the<br />

design of the system to achieve the<br />

specified control objectives, and<br />

whether the system was operating<br />

effectively during the period under<br />

review.)<br />

• Rapid deployment—Top-tier providers<br />

should be able to provide the tools to<br />

create indexes in minutes, not days, and<br />

enable document review in real time as<br />

documents are captured, processed and<br />

posted.<br />

NYSE IPO Guide<br />

39

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!