Entire Transcript in Adobe Acrobat Format - National Reference ...

29
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
the protocol, has the individual consented, and has the
community in some way offered its consultation. Those are
the three possibilities. If you just do the math you have
got nine permutations. We have got more than nine boxes,
which means that some of the boxes are going to overlap.
That is just on a simple level.
I think by going through each of those boxes
you are going to see that the -- I mean, your view of what
the kind of protections you want may be different from my
view but, in fact, there is going to be some collapse
there. There has to be some collapse. We do not have
other kinds of protections or we have not proposed a lot of
other kinds of protections.
Now your moral intuition that these, in fact,
initially look different is exactly why the commission, and
I firmly believe why many of the other groups have come
with making lots more divisions there, collected in an
anonymous manner, you know, made anonymizable, et cetera.
But, in fact, I mean again to reiterate I think we have
come to the view because we have actually tried to work
through the boxes and said, "Well, you know, the protection
we think is appropriate here recognizing that there is
going to be some trade offs, in fact, look the same in
these two boxes and that they are not conceptually