Entire Transcript in Adobe Acrobat Format - National Reference ...

144
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
DR. CHILDRESS: Sorry, I was not up --
DR. EMANUEL: No, no, this is confusing. Part
of the reason is I was trying to get -- or had e-mailed to
Henrietta a lot of the permutations that we had gone
through and debated and discussed so people have a better
sense.
So if you look here at what we have -- and I
may not be completely accurate -- migrated to is a general
consent and not presumed consent with an opt out.
If you would like me to defend the idea of a
presumed consent with an opt out I would offer you --
DR. CHILDRESS: No, I was not interested in
defending it but rather challenging it.
DR. EMANUEL: Right. No, I actually think it
is a reasonable position but --
DR. MURRAY: But we are not adopting it.
DR. EMANUEL: But I am a minority and am
willing to give in.
DR. CHILDRESS: That takes care of it. I am
sorry. I was on the wrong iteration of this.
DR. MURRAY: Harold?
DR. SHAPIRO: I have what I think is a very
small question, small aspect of what you are doing, but you
have focused on clinical samples as I understand it in your