Increasing our energy... - Zorlu Enerji
Increasing our energy... - Zorlu Enerji
Increasing our energy... - Zorlu Enerji
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Increasing</strong><br />
<strong>our</strong> <strong>energy</strong>...<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Contents<br />
2 <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group<br />
4 <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group in Brief<br />
5 <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.<br />
7 <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.: Milestones<br />
8 Financial Highlights<br />
10 <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.’s Power Plants<br />
12 Chairman’s Message<br />
14 <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group CEO’s Assessment<br />
18 Board of Directors<br />
20 Senior Management<br />
22 Management’s Assessment and Analysis of Operational Results<br />
32 <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group, People and the Environment<br />
36 Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
47 Profit Distribution Policy<br />
48 Statutory Auditor’s Report Summary<br />
49 Resolution of the Board of Directors<br />
50 Independent Auditor’s Report<br />
108 Investor Information
<strong>Increasing</strong> <strong>our</strong> <strong>energy</strong>...<br />
We, as <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy, seek to return to the Earth that<br />
which it takes from the Earth as <strong>energy</strong>. We keep growing<br />
and adding power to Turkey with <strong>our</strong> investments which<br />
reflect all technological developments for efficient and<br />
high-quality <strong>energy</strong> generation and which are based on<br />
local and renewable <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces.<br />
...we add power to Turkey.<br />
Page 1<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group is one of the strongest<br />
player in <strong>energy</strong> sector with its integrated<br />
operations backed up its strategy of<br />
diversifying res<strong>our</strong>ces and services.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group: Diversity in res<strong>our</strong>ces and services…<br />
The foundations of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group were laid down in 1993 with<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. The Group has strengthened<br />
its presence in various fields of the <strong>energy</strong> sector thanks to its<br />
integrated operations including electricity generation and sales,<br />
natural gas generation, distribution and sales, project development<br />
to “turnkey” delivery of power plants and long-term maintenance<br />
and operation agreements.<br />
With:<br />
• 5 natural gas fired power plants,<br />
• 7 hydroelectric power plants,<br />
• 1 geothermal power plant,<br />
• 1 wind power plant,<br />
• 1 fuel-oil power plant<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group had a total installed capacity of 660 MW<br />
at the end of 2009. Our Group’s total installed capacity should<br />
reach 738 MW once the Gökçedağ wind power plant (135 MW)<br />
becomes fully operational in June 2010.<br />
The <strong>energy</strong> generated at Group’s power plants provides high-quality<br />
and continuous <strong>energy</strong> to the DUY (Stabilization & Reconciliation)<br />
system, as well as industrial and commercial companies.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group, aiming to become a regional player, takes pains<br />
to make use of opportunities in markets in Europe, Asia and the<br />
Middle East, in addition to the Turkish market, where demand for<br />
<strong>energy</strong> and privatization efforts are intensifying. Projects carried out<br />
in Russia, Pakistan and Israel are important steps taken by the Group<br />
in reaching this goal.<br />
Besides electricity generation, the Group continues its natural gas<br />
exploration, drilling and generation activities in the Thrace region,<br />
while also distributes natural gas in Gaziantep and the Thrace<br />
regions.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group, acting upon the principle of earning with the<br />
community, pays attention that its investments do not give damage<br />
to the environment and social life and cares for the development of<br />
regions where it operates<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group’s competencies and competitive<br />
strengths<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group has well utilized the advantage of being one<br />
of the first companies penetrating the sector, anticipated the most<br />
proper way the opportunities offered by the market thanks to its<br />
vision and leading identity, and turned the potential into success.<br />
Taking firm steps towards being a global <strong>energy</strong> power, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
Group<br />
• diversifies its portfolio with renewable <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces such as<br />
hydro, wind and geothermal <strong>energy</strong> by best utilizing the renewable<br />
<strong>energy</strong> potential;<br />
• distributes risks in the most appropriate manner possible, both by<br />
res<strong>our</strong>ce and by country level; maintains its competitive position by<br />
adapting well to changing market dynamics;<br />
• uses the latest technologies at its plants, which raise <strong>energy</strong><br />
efficiency economically and environmentally, while popularizing<br />
these practices throughout the sector;<br />
• sustains its operations to ensure security of <strong>energy</strong> supply through<br />
environment-friendly and sustainable-preserving methods by making<br />
use of national res<strong>our</strong>ces in the most efficient manner;<br />
• expands its operations by keeping a close view of developments<br />
in the field of <strong>energy</strong> in target countries outside of Turkey where<br />
<strong>energy</strong> demand is high;<br />
• reflects its achievements in terms of cost-efficiency, productivity<br />
and quality to its projects and services.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group shapes its strategies around two central pivots<br />
in order to solidify its strength on both national and international<br />
platforms:<br />
Efficient service in various fields of the <strong>energy</strong> sector<br />
With its currently increasing capacity, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group also<br />
covers the electricity and steam needs of industrial and commercial<br />
corporations in addition to those of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group. Through<br />
its companies, each specialized in their own field, the Group<br />
also operates in a wide array of business lines such as natural<br />
gas exploration, generation and wholesale, geothermal <strong>energy</strong><br />
exploration and drilling, turnkey power plant installation services for<br />
industrial corporations, natural gas sales and distribution services<br />
aiming to meet the natural gas needs of enterprises and homes, and<br />
maintenance and operation services for industrial corporations which<br />
operate power plants.<br />
In line with its strategy of diversifying res<strong>our</strong>ces and services,<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group also keeps view of electricity generation and<br />
distribution tenders within the scope of privatization, wind power<br />
plant and natural gas contract transfer tenders.<br />
Projects carried out in a wide geographical area<br />
Having participated in partnerships in power plant projects to be<br />
built by the private sector for the first time in Moscow, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
Group is also interested in projects in other developing markets.<br />
Projects in Pakistan (a 50 MW wind power plant) and Israel (4 natural<br />
gas cogeneration power plants with a total capacity of 1,085 MW),<br />
which are currently at the project finance stage, reflect the Group’s<br />
vision to transfer its existing know-how and experience to different<br />
regions.<br />
Page 2<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy in Turkey<br />
Natural gas power plants Hydroelectric power plants Wind power plant<br />
Geothermal power plant Natural gas distribution Natural gas production<br />
Lüleburgaz<br />
Trakya Region<br />
Marmara Region<br />
Yalova<br />
Rize<br />
Bursa<br />
Ankara<br />
Tokat<br />
Erzurum<br />
Kars<br />
Eskişehir<br />
Erzincan<br />
Tunceli<br />
Kayseri<br />
Van<br />
Denizli<br />
Osmaniye<br />
Gaziantep<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity<br />
Generation Inc.<br />
(Listed on the ISE).<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Natural Electricity<br />
Generation Inc.<br />
(142.6 MW)<br />
Others<br />
Natural Gas Distribution<br />
Companies<br />
Turkey<br />
Electricity Generation<br />
(517.5 MW)<br />
100% 5 Natural Gas Power Plants<br />
83.7% Rotor Electric Power<br />
Production Inc.<br />
83.7% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Hydroelectric Power<br />
Production Inc.<br />
7 Hydroelectric Power Plants<br />
1 Geothermal Power Plant<br />
1 Fuel-oil Power Plant<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Industrial<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Electricity Energy Import,<br />
Export and Wholesale Trade<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Natural Gas Import, Export<br />
and Wholesale Trade<br />
Gazdaş Gaziantep Natural Gas<br />
Distribution<br />
Thrace Region Natural Gas<br />
Distribution<br />
73% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Geothermal Energy<br />
Electricity Generation Inc.<br />
83.7% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Wind Energy<br />
Electricity Generation<br />
Natural Gas Exploration<br />
+ Generation<br />
73% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas<br />
100% Amity Oil<br />
International<br />
51% Rosmiks LLC<br />
100% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Pakistan<br />
25% Dorad Energy<br />
51% Ashdod Energy<br />
51% Ramat Negev Energy<br />
27% Solad Energy<br />
100% Bundoran Financial<br />
Corporation<br />
Page 3<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Group in Brief<br />
With 23,000 employees and over TL 10 billion<br />
in total assets, the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group continues to<br />
grow, raising the popularity of its “<strong>Zorlu</strong>” name<br />
in the global arena, and raises trust in its<br />
brand in line with the philosophy of “We will<br />
go furthest in the direction we are going; we<br />
will climb to the top of where we go; we will be<br />
the best at what we do…”<br />
Home textile Consumer durables Energy Real Estate<br />
Korteks<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong>teks<br />
The biggest fully integrated<br />
producer of polyester yarn in<br />
Turkey<br />
Vestel <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group <strong>Zorlu</strong> Real Estate<br />
The leading OEM/ODM provider<br />
of TVs, white goods, and digital<br />
products for the European market<br />
One of the primary players in the<br />
domestic market with an installed<br />
capacity of 660 MW at the end<br />
of 2009<br />
Became operational in 2006<br />
The largest home textile<br />
manufacturer in Europe<br />
Among the top three players of<br />
the European LCD market with a<br />
market share of 15% in the last<br />
quarter of 2009<br />
Accounted for nearly 6.4% of<br />
the total electricity generated<br />
by the private sector in Turkey<br />
(excluding BOO, BOT & TOR)<br />
Aims to develop & invest in<br />
high quality residential, office,<br />
shopping centre and hotel<br />
projects at prime locations in<br />
Turkey & abroad.<br />
Production bases in Turkey and<br />
Russia<br />
Ongoing investments in Russia,<br />
projects at the project finance<br />
stage in Pakistan and Israel<br />
Its ongoing project: <strong>Zorlu</strong> Center<br />
- Zincirlikuyu, Istanbul: a mixed<br />
used real estate development<br />
project<br />
Among the top three players in<br />
the domestic market with the<br />
Vestel brand<br />
Also active in natural gas<br />
production, trading and<br />
distribution<br />
Page 4<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity<br />
Generation Inc.: The flagship<br />
of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy),<br />
the original company from which <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group was<br />
formed, was set up as an auto producer to generate the<br />
electricity and steam needed by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group textile factories.<br />
Over time, the Company began supplying electricity and<br />
steam to non-group industrial concerns as well. At the end<br />
of 2009, the Company’s five thermal power plants had<br />
an aggregate installed capacity of 460 MW and a steam<br />
manufacturing capacity of 192 tons/h<strong>our</strong>.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. achieved significant<br />
ground in its renewable <strong>energy</strong> investments in 2009. The<br />
Company aims to attain an installed capacity of 135 MW by<br />
bringing 54 turbines into operation at the Gökçedağ wind<br />
power plant by June 2010.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. is one of the most<br />
rapidly growing <strong>energy</strong> companies in Europe, while also<br />
drawing attention in the global arena. <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity<br />
Generation Inc., ranked 138th in the list of the top 500<br />
companies published annually by the Istanbul Chamber of<br />
Industry in 2007, improved its rank to 100th in 2008.<br />
A company mindful of environmental, natural and social<br />
values<br />
As a company mindful of the environmental, natural, and<br />
social values in which it operates, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity<br />
Generation Inc., has equipped all its power generation<br />
plants with water injection systems which ensure that NOX<br />
emissions are within the limits prescribed by the World Bank.<br />
In this way, waste heat is used to produce steam instead of<br />
being discharged into the atmosphere, resulting<br />
in more environmentally friendly power generation while<br />
helping prevent global warming. <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity<br />
Generation Inc., the first auto producer in Turkey to have<br />
been awarded full quality certification, boasts an integrated<br />
management system and holds TS/EN ISO 9001: 2000,<br />
OHSAS 18001, and ISO 14001 certificates.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. first completed a<br />
public offering of 20% of its shares in 2000. Currently, 32%<br />
of the Company’s shares are traded on the Istanbul Stock<br />
Exchange. As the first <strong>energy</strong> company in Turkey whose<br />
shares are publicly traded, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation<br />
Inc. is also the only publicly-traded member of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
Group.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.<br />
boasts an integrated management system<br />
with TS/EN ISO 9001: 2000, OHSAS 18001,<br />
and ISO 14001 certificates.<br />
Page 5<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
Shareholding Structure (%)<br />
Korteks 18%<br />
41% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding<br />
Other 9%<br />
Publicly Held 32%<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.<br />
Turkey<br />
Electricity Generation<br />
(517.5 MW)<br />
100% 5 Natural Gas Power Plants<br />
83.7% Rotor Electric Power<br />
Production Inc.<br />
83.7% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Hydroelectric Power<br />
Production Inc.<br />
73% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Geothermal Energy<br />
Electricity Generation Inc.<br />
83.7% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Wind Energy<br />
Electricity Generation<br />
Natural Gas Exploration<br />
+ Generation<br />
International<br />
51% Rosmiks LLC<br />
100% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Pakistan<br />
25% Dorad Energy<br />
51% Ashdod Energy<br />
51% Ramat Negev Energy<br />
27% Solad Energy<br />
100% Bundoran Financial<br />
Corporation<br />
73% <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas<br />
100% Amity Oil<br />
Ranked 100th among top 500 companies<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc., ranked 138th in<br />
the list of the top 500 companies published annually by the<br />
Istanbul Chamber of Industry in 2007, improved its rank to<br />
100th in 2008.<br />
Page 6<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.: Milestones<br />
1993<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.) is<br />
set up to provide the electricity and steam needs of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group’s industrial<br />
concerns.<br />
1997<br />
Auto producer agreements are signed with the Ministry of Energy and<br />
Natural Res<strong>our</strong>ces. Construction work begins on two <strong>energy</strong> plants in<br />
Lüleburgaz and Bursa.<br />
The Company’s first plant, generating 7 MW electricity and 20 tons/h<strong>our</strong><br />
steam, is commissioned in Lüleburgaz.<br />
1998<br />
The LM2500 unit, with an installed capacity of 26 MW in combined-cycle<br />
power plant in Bursa is brought on stream on a simple-cycle basis. With the<br />
commissioning of a 9 MW steam turbine, its combined-cycle production<br />
capacity reached 35 MW. With the completion of these investments, <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Energy is now able to fulfill all of the electricity needs of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group.<br />
1999<br />
Combined-cycle power plants with 43 MW of capacity are completed by<br />
the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Power Plant Construction Group in Bursa and Lüleburgaz<br />
and commissioned on simple-cycle basis. Total production capacity reached<br />
135 MW.<br />
With an electrical switching plant being installed in Bursa, the Company<br />
is now in a position to sell up to half of the electricity it generates to<br />
non-group companies.<br />
2000<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İnşaat Ticaret A.Ş. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> Industrial and<br />
Energy Facilities Construction & Trade Inc.) is set up.<br />
Total production capacity reached 156 MW of electricity and 150 tons/<br />
h<strong>our</strong> of steam. With as much as 70% of capacity now being sold outside<br />
the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy has firmly established its position in Turkey’s<br />
<strong>energy</strong> market.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy undertook its initial public offering and shares representing<br />
20% of the Company’s paid-in capital are listed on the Istanbul Stock<br />
Exchange.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İşletme ve Bakım Hizmetleri A.Ş. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M<br />
Power Plant Operation and Maintenance Services Inc.) is set up.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas Petrol, Gaz ve Petrokimya Ürünleri İnşaat Sanayii ve<br />
Ticaret A.Ş. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas Petroleum, Gas, and Petrochemical Products<br />
Construction, Industry & Trade Inc.) is set up.<br />
2001<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy is awarded the ISO 9001/2000 Quality Management System<br />
certification.<br />
The number of non-<strong>Zorlu</strong> customers approaches 200.<br />
2003<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong>si İthalat, İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> Electricity<br />
Energy Import, Export and Wholesale Trade Inc.) is established.<br />
2004<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy and <strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M receive their OHSAS 18001 Occupational<br />
Health & Safety Assessment Series and ISO 14001 Environmental<br />
Management System certifications.<br />
2005<br />
A decision is taken to participate with a 25% stake in Dorad Energy Ltd, with<br />
a planned installed capacity of 800 MW, in Israel.<br />
A contract is signed for the first privately-owned electrical power plant<br />
project in Moscow and the plant’s foundations are laid.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas received natural gas exploration license and won natural gas<br />
distribution tenders for Gaziantep-Kilis and for Kırklareli-Tekirdağ-Edirne.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy joins the ranks of Europe’s 100 fastest-growing companies.<br />
The Kayseri Power Plant enters operation on a simple-cycle basis. Trade<br />
Finance Magazine hails <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy’s Kayseri power plant project as “the<br />
year’s most successful financing project”.<br />
2006<br />
An electricity generation agreement covering a 20-year period is signed with<br />
Pakistan’s Alternative Energy Development Board to set up of a wind power<br />
plant in Pakistan.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy wins the tender to build two hydroelectric power plants on<br />
the Dalaman River in Muğla at Sandalcık-Sami Soydam (124 MW) and Narlı<br />
(80 MW). Feasibility studies begin immediately.<br />
2007<br />
Takeover of the wind power plant license of Rotor Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Work begins in Osmaniye to construct a wind power plant which, with an<br />
installed capacity of 135 MW, is planned to be the biggest facility of its kind<br />
at a single location in Turkey.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy won the tender of the General Directorate of State Hydraulic<br />
Works for the planned construction of a 60MW hydroelectric power plant in<br />
Tirebolu in the province of Giresun.<br />
The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group signs the United Nations Global Compact.<br />
2008<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy signs a Carbon Emission Sales Contract with EcoSecurities for<br />
the 135 MW wind power plant in Osmaniye.<br />
In addition to its 135 MW wind power plant investment in Osmaniye, Rotor<br />
Elektrik Üretim A.Ş., receives two more production licenses from the Energy<br />
Market Regulatory Authority for 60 MW and 50 MW wind power plants in<br />
the same region.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy won the privatization tender related to nine power plants with<br />
a total installed capacity of 141 MW altogether owned by Ankara Doğal<br />
Elektrik Üretim ve Ticaret A.Ş. (ADÜAŞ), submitting a winning bid of<br />
US$ 510 million in the tender.<br />
In addition to the Lüleburgaz Natural Gas Combined-Cycle Power Plant,<br />
work begins for the establishment of the 75 MW combined-cycle power<br />
plant.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy receives 100% stake of Amity Oil International Inc.<br />
2009<br />
The capacity of the Lüleburgaz Power Plant rises to 115.3 MW.<br />
Within the framework of restructuring efforts carried out within the <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Energy Group, stakes held by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. in<br />
the following companies were transferred to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding Inc. and other<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Group companies in June: <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. (ADÜAŞ’s<br />
assets), Trakya Bölgesi Doğal Gaz Dağıtım A.Ş. (Thrace Region Natural<br />
Gas Distribution Inc.), Gazdaş Gaziantep Doğal Gaz Dağıtım A.Ş. (Gazdaş<br />
Gaziantep Natural Gas Distribution Inc.), <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Gaz İthalat İhracat ve<br />
Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> Natural Gas Import, Export and Wholesale Inc.),<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İnşaat Ticaret A.Ş. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> Industrial and<br />
Energy Facilities Construction & Trade Inc.), <strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri<br />
İşletme ve Bakım Hizmetleri A.Ş. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M Power Plant Operation and<br />
Maintenance Services Inc.) and <strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong>si İthalat İhracat ve<br />
Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> Electricity Energy Import, Export and Wholesale<br />
Trade Inc.), and <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> ve İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. (<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
and Construction Industry and Trade Inc.)<br />
With the cash capital increase, the Company’s capital was raised from<br />
TL 81,665,350 to TL 281,665,350.<br />
23 turbines with a total capacity of 57.5 MW were brought into operation<br />
at the Gökçedağ wind power plant by the end of 2009.<br />
Page 7<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Financial Highlights<br />
(US$ million) 2009 2008*<br />
Revenues 353.8 410.9<br />
Gross Profit 83.0 82.1<br />
Operating Profit 173.0 35.8<br />
EBITDA 201.3 64.0<br />
Net Income/Loss 63.3 (260.1)<br />
Total Assets 1,603.5 1,714.6<br />
Shareholders’ Equity 152.3 (0.2)<br />
Net Financial Debt 888.2 1,177.9<br />
Gross Profit Margin (%) 23.5% 20.0%<br />
EBITDA Margin (%) 56.9% 15.6%<br />
CMB based financials<br />
* The Company undertook affiliate sales in 23.06.2009 accordingly financial indicators for the year 2009 shown in the table above covers the results for the continuing<br />
operations. For the compatibility of the current financial statements, 2008 financial statements are classified.<br />
EBITDA and EBITDA Margin*<br />
(US$ million)<br />
100<br />
80<br />
60<br />
40<br />
20<br />
64<br />
16%<br />
85<br />
30%<br />
1,000<br />
24% 888<br />
20% 800<br />
10%<br />
Net Financial Debt<br />
(US$ million)<br />
1,200<br />
600<br />
400<br />
200<br />
1,178<br />
Shareholders’ Equity<br />
(US$ million)<br />
175<br />
150<br />
125<br />
100<br />
75<br />
50<br />
25<br />
0.24<br />
152<br />
0<br />
2008 2009* 0% 0 2008 2009 0 2008<br />
2009<br />
* Excluding the revenues that were obtained through<br />
participation sales carried out on 23.06.2009.<br />
+33%<br />
The Company’s EBITDA rose by 33% to<br />
US$ 85 million, excluding income from<br />
participation sales.<br />
Page 8<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity<br />
Generation Inc.<br />
Share Information (US$) 2009<br />
Number of Shares 281,665,350<br />
Number of Shares (Free Float) 90,076,579<br />
Maximum share price during year 2.24<br />
Minimum share price during year 0.43<br />
Year-end Price 2.08<br />
Annual Return 279%<br />
Average Annual Volume 6,605,536<br />
As of the end of 2009,<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation<br />
Inc. was quoted on the following<br />
stock exchange indices:<br />
> ISE-100<br />
> ISE-ALL<br />
> ISE-National-Services<br />
> ISE-Electricity<br />
Market Capitalization 586,841,998<br />
Market Capitalization<br />
(US$ million)<br />
Comparative Share Performance<br />
(US$)<br />
ZOREN<br />
ISE<br />
700<br />
600<br />
500<br />
400<br />
300<br />
200<br />
100<br />
0<br />
15/01/09 18/06/09 17/12/09<br />
4.5<br />
4.0<br />
3.5<br />
3.0<br />
2.5<br />
2.0<br />
1.5<br />
1.0<br />
0.5<br />
0<br />
01/01/09<br />
01/06/09 01/12/09<br />
Annual return on shares<br />
in US$ terms: 279%<br />
While the ISE100 index rose by 100% in US$ terms in 2009,<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. shares notched up a<br />
279% return in US$ terms.<br />
Page 9<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.’s Power Plants*<br />
Lüleburgaz Power Plant<br />
Type<br />
Natural Gas Cogeneration Power Plant<br />
Capacity<br />
115.3 MW Electricity + 162 tons/h<strong>our</strong> steam<br />
Bursa Power Plant<br />
(Organized Industrial Zone)<br />
Type<br />
Natural Gas Combined-Cycle Power Plant<br />
Capacity<br />
90 MW Electricity<br />
Kayseri Power Plant<br />
(Organized Industrial Zone)<br />
Type<br />
Natural Gas Combined-Cycle Power Plant<br />
Capacity<br />
188.5 MW Electricity<br />
Page 10<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Yalova Power Plant<br />
(İpek Kağıt - Altınova)<br />
Type<br />
Natural Gas Cogeneration Power Plant<br />
Capacity<br />
15.9 MW Electricity + 30 tons/h<strong>our</strong>s steam<br />
Ankara Power Plant<br />
(Organized Industrial Zone)<br />
Type<br />
Natural Gas Combined-Cycle Power Plant<br />
Capacity<br />
50.3 MW Electricity<br />
Wind Power Plant<br />
Gökçedağ Wind Power Plant<br />
(Osmaniye)<br />
Type<br />
Renewable Wind Power Plant<br />
Capacity<br />
57.5 MW Electricity<br />
* As of the end of 2009<br />
Page 11<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Chairman’s Message<br />
Ensuring <strong>energy</strong> supply security and sustainable<br />
development<br />
The security of <strong>energy</strong> supply and sustainable<br />
development have been the leading items on the<br />
agenda both in the world and in <strong>our</strong> country. Factors<br />
such as rising <strong>energy</strong> prices, continuing dependence on<br />
conventional <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces in the near future, the<br />
failure to use renewable <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces effectively<br />
despite increasing global <strong>energy</strong> demand and the fact<br />
that developments on new <strong>energy</strong>-related technologies<br />
remain unable to meet increasing demand all raise<br />
countries’ concerns on the security of <strong>energy</strong> supply.<br />
Moreover, while the impacts of the economic crisis, which began in<br />
the USA in 2008, on global demand have precipitated a significant<br />
fall in industrial manufacturing, new investments almost ground to<br />
a halt. The negative impacts of these developments are also seen<br />
on ongoing projects, as well as the projects that are in the planning<br />
stage.<br />
The 2.3% fall in <strong>energy</strong> demand in 2009 was the first fall ever<br />
experienced since 1981. Following this period of decline, it is clear<br />
that <strong>energy</strong> consumption will begin to recover from 2010. According<br />
to projections set out by the International Energy Agency (IEA),<br />
assuming that current <strong>energy</strong> policies are pursued, global <strong>energy</strong><br />
demand in 2030 will be 40% higher than its 2007 level, representing<br />
an increase at a CAGR of 1.5%. During this period, coal and natural<br />
gas are still expected to remain the most important res<strong>our</strong>ces in<br />
electricity generation, while the share of oil will drop.<br />
The share of use of renewable <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces in electricity<br />
generation is projected to rise from the current 18% to 22% by<br />
2030. Wind power will make the biggest contribution to the increase<br />
in use of renewable res<strong>our</strong>ces.<br />
Reducing the environmental impacts of production activities in<br />
the <strong>energy</strong> sector will continue to stand before us as an important<br />
phenomenon in the coming periods as well in tackling global<br />
warming and climate change. Elimination of these negative impacts<br />
again depends on the deliberate and decisive efforts of <strong>energy</strong> sector<br />
players, as it is calculated that <strong>energy</strong> sector based greenhouse gas<br />
emissions will increase from their current 28.8 billion tons to 40.2<br />
billion tons by 2030.<br />
To ensure supply security...<br />
Applying sustainable <strong>energy</strong> policies in a disciplined manner, which<br />
primarily aim to diversify <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces and maximize the<br />
utilization of Turkey’s domestic res<strong>our</strong>ces, as well as tending to use<br />
renewable res<strong>our</strong>ces, principally wind <strong>energy</strong>, will play a key role in<br />
ensuring supply security.<br />
Page 12<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Improvements in parallel with technological developments,<br />
principally <strong>energy</strong> efficiency, the increasing use of nuclear <strong>energy</strong><br />
and renewable <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces - which are alternative to fossil<br />
fuels - and R&D activities (carbon capture and storage and clean coal<br />
technologies) focused on minimizing environmental impacts are the<br />
most fundamental measures being taken to reduce gas emissions.<br />
Turkey’s picture in the field of <strong>energy</strong> and <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
According to 2009 figures, in Turkey, which has 44,500 MW total<br />
installed capacity and a consumption amount of 200 billion kWh/<br />
year, domestic res<strong>our</strong>ces are not employed effective enough<br />
and natural gas is still responsible for nearly 50% of electricity<br />
generation. In accordance with projections based on a base-demand<br />
scenario prepared by the Turkish Electricity Transmission Company<br />
(TEİAŞ), Turkey’s electricity demand and total installed capacity<br />
should double by 2017.<br />
The Electricity Energy Market and Supply Security Paper published<br />
in 2009 sets out aims to utilize Turkey’s entire domestic coal and<br />
hydroelectric potential and to increase the total installed wind<br />
power capacity to 20,000 MW and total installed geothermal power<br />
capacity to 600 MW by 2023. The report also envisages that 5%<br />
of Turkey’s electricity generation should be provided from nuclear<br />
<strong>energy</strong> by 2020.<br />
Applying sustainable <strong>energy</strong> policies in a disciplined manner, which<br />
primarily aims to ensure res<strong>our</strong>ce diversity and maximum utilization<br />
of Turkey’s domestic res<strong>our</strong>ces as well as tending to use renewable<br />
res<strong>our</strong>ces, especially wind power, will play a key role in providing<br />
supply security.<br />
Another vital issue is to employ rapid decision-making mechanisms,<br />
always bearing in mind that any delay in investment could give<br />
rise to <strong>energy</strong> bottlenecks, and that <strong>energy</strong> investments must be<br />
considered in a medium and long-term perspective.<br />
Taking significant steps to utilize Turkey’s existing potential and<br />
to meet the country’s rising <strong>energy</strong> needs, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group is a<br />
strong and leading participant in the sector with its domestic and<br />
international investments.<br />
As well as generating electricity, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group also carries out<br />
natural gas exploration, drilling, generation and distribution activities<br />
to discover and process <strong>our</strong> country’s res<strong>our</strong>ces. Our ultimate goal<br />
is to be one of the determinant and indispensable players in <strong>our</strong><br />
country’s <strong>energy</strong> growth.<br />
Sustainability is the primary target.<br />
Earth, air and water - the basic res<strong>our</strong>ces of <strong>energy</strong> – face serious<br />
threats from developing technology and the rapidly rising population<br />
in the 21st century. Both organizations and individuals have<br />
significant responsibilities with respect to efficient and sustainable<br />
use of natural res<strong>our</strong>ces.<br />
Aware of its own responsibility, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group accomplishes<br />
permanent projects that prioritize use of domestic res<strong>our</strong>ces and<br />
create sustainable economic values.<br />
The Group also carries out activities to assess the environmental<br />
impacts as well as the social impacts of its investments, while<br />
expanding the scope of its social responsibility approach by putting<br />
effort into contributing to such ultimate targets as economic and<br />
social development of regions of its presence and maximization of<br />
public welfare.<br />
The United Nations Global Compact (UN Global Compact), of<br />
which <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group is a member of, represents an important guide<br />
in implementing these practices that are based on multi-directional<br />
social responsibilities.<br />
After <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding signed the Global Impact in 2007, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding<br />
published its first Progress Report in 2009, in which it set out the<br />
practices related to sustainability. Efforts aimed at sustainability<br />
and practices carried out by the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group in light of the<br />
Global Compact are presented herein for the information of <strong>our</strong><br />
stakeholders.<br />
A last few lines…<br />
As we always mention, we steadfastly stick to the self-sacrificing<br />
and responsible model that the sector requires of us, which never<br />
neglects the fact that we provide a public service in the <strong>energy</strong><br />
sector. The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group seeks to return to the Earth that<br />
which it takes from the Earth as <strong>energy</strong>.<br />
Our Group will continue to grow and add power to Turkey with its<br />
investments based on domestic and renewable <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces,<br />
which also reflect the technological developments with respect to<br />
efficient and high-quality <strong>energy</strong> generation.<br />
I, as a member of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group family, extend my<br />
sincerest wishes to everyone, especially <strong>our</strong> social stakeholders.<br />
Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Chairman of the Board of Directors<br />
Curbing the environmental<br />
impacts of production activities<br />
in the <strong>energy</strong> sector stands as an<br />
important challenge in the coming<br />
periods, along with tackling global<br />
warming and climate change.<br />
Page 13<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group CEO’s Assessment<br />
Despite the challenging impacts of the crisis and the<br />
adverse investment environment in 2009, the <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Energy Group pressed ahead with its investments,<br />
increasing its installed capacity and proving once again<br />
that it is one of the strongest players in the <strong>energy</strong> sector.<br />
Our Group met 6.4% of total electricity produced by<br />
private producers in Turkey, generating 2.8 billion kWh<br />
of electricity (2.3 billion kWh of which was generated<br />
by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.) in 2009<br />
predominantly through natural gas fired power plants.<br />
Industrial production and electricity consumption, which<br />
diminished as the global crisis precipitated a recession in<br />
the real sector, naturally paved the way for a decline in<br />
electricity generation. However, thanks to <strong>our</strong> effective<br />
marketing and sales activities, we managed to close the<br />
year with an increase in revenues.<br />
We give priority to renewable and domestic <strong>energy</strong><br />
res<strong>our</strong>ces, to prevent <strong>energy</strong> shortages.<br />
Despite being highly dependent on foreign countries for its <strong>energy</strong>,<br />
due to the lack of oil and natural gas reserves, Turkey does offer<br />
significant advantages thanks to the alternative <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces,<br />
which it has recently been investing in, as well as its existing<br />
potential.<br />
In 2009, Turkey was a net importer of <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces. 74% of<br />
Turkey’s total <strong>energy</strong> supply was met through imports, with more<br />
than 90% in oil and natural gas, and 20% of its coal.<br />
The share of renewable res<strong>our</strong>ces in electricity generation remains<br />
quite limited; hydroelectric power accounted to 18.5% of electricity<br />
generation in 2009. Turkey offers 48,000 MW in wind <strong>energy</strong><br />
potential, about 20% of which is deemed extremely efficient.<br />
However, the share of wind <strong>energy</strong> in national electricity production<br />
remains below 1%, while only 0.3% of geothermal res<strong>our</strong>ces are<br />
being used.<br />
We must make more use of the wind <strong>energy</strong>.<br />
Our country offers a wind <strong>energy</strong> potential of 48,000 MW, around 20% of<br />
which is extremely efficient. However, wind <strong>energy</strong> still only accounts for<br />
less than 1% of national electricity generation.<br />
Page 14<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
This reveals the importance of canalizing an ever increasing level of<br />
“domestic and renewable” res<strong>our</strong>ces in <strong>energy</strong> production, in which<br />
<strong>our</strong> Group bases and shapes its strategies. The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group<br />
believes that the most important way to overcome the <strong>energy</strong><br />
bottleneck facing Turkey is to invest in domestic and renewable<br />
res<strong>our</strong>ces.<br />
Production activities and investments to go on…<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. had reached a total installed<br />
capacity of 517.5 MW by the end of 2009 at its five natural gas<br />
power plants located in Ankara, Yalova, Bursa, Lüleburgaz and<br />
Kayseri and the Gökçedağ wind power plant, which was partially<br />
brought into operation by August 2009. When other eight renewable<br />
<strong>energy</strong> plants of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group, under which <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
Electricity Generation Inc. operates, are taken into account, the total<br />
capacity of the Group reaches 660 MW.<br />
Besides improvements in existing power plants, with an additional<br />
investment at Lüleburgaz Plant, the capacity was further increased<br />
by 50 MW at firsthand in 2009. With the capacity increase more<br />
than 80%, the plant’s total installed capacity has reached 115.3 MW.<br />
Provision of finance and pre-investment efforts as well as the<br />
Environmental Impact Evaluation process are currently under way<br />
for the 124 MW capacity Sami Soydam hydroelectric power plant<br />
located on the Dalaman River and the Narlı hydroelectric power<br />
plant, with a capacity of 80 MW.<br />
Efforts to obtain a license for a 29MW capacity hydroelectric power<br />
plant in Tirebolu, Giresun are under way.<br />
Work is rapidly progressing on the Tereshkovo and Kojukhovo<br />
natural gas power plant investments (each 340MW) in Russia. We<br />
have invested nearly US$ 700 million in these power plants. The<br />
first phase (170 MW) of the Tereshkovo plant is planned to enter<br />
operation in the first half of 2010, while the first phase (170 MW)<br />
of the Kojukhovo plant is planned to become operational in the last<br />
quarter of 2010.<br />
In Israel, we are in the final stages to start a 800MW capacity<br />
power plant project. In addition, three more power plant projects’<br />
investment agreements have been signed. These three projects<br />
that have planned capacities of 55 MW, 110 MW and 120 MW are<br />
currently at project financing stage.<br />
Putting priority on geothermal <strong>energy</strong><br />
The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group considers stepping up investments in<br />
geothermal <strong>energy</strong> as one of its high-priority fields of activity in<br />
Turkey, which ranked 6th globally in geothermal <strong>energy</strong>. The Group<br />
carries out exploration, drilling and reservoir-locating efforts in<br />
Kızıldere, Denizli, Alaşehir, Manisa, and Simav, Kütahya. In addition<br />
to <strong>our</strong> existing plant, we have started pre-construction work of<br />
a new 60MW capacity geothermal power plant in Kızıldere after<br />
having received the necessary license.<br />
The Kızıldere geothermal plant in Denizli is the most important<br />
geothermal <strong>energy</strong> project carried out by the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group<br />
and is located in the richest region of Turkey in terms of capacity.<br />
The reinjection system at the plant was brought into operation<br />
in 2009 in what was one of <strong>our</strong> most significant achievements<br />
this year, as this system had been inoperable since the plant<br />
was founded. This system, that maintains water levels and the<br />
sustainability of the reservoir, allows all of the used geothermal<br />
water, which remains after <strong>energy</strong> production, to be injected back to<br />
the wells.<br />
We completed Turkey’s biggest wind power plant.<br />
We covered significant ground in 2009, particularly renewable<br />
<strong>energy</strong> investments. We aim to reach a total installed capacity of<br />
135 MW by June 2010, by bringing 54 turbines into operation at the<br />
Gökçedağ wind power plant.<br />
We plan to raise <strong>our</strong> total installed capacity in Osmaniye to<br />
245 MW with two new wind power plants, which we plan to build<br />
with two licenses of 50 MW and 60 MW capacities, respectively.<br />
The project finance process still continues with respect to the 50<br />
MW capacity wind power investment in Jhimpir, in the city of Thatta<br />
in southern Pakistan.<br />
The Gökçedağ wind power plant<br />
met all the criteria related to<br />
the Gold Standard and became<br />
the world’s biggest project to<br />
have been awarded with the<br />
Gold Standard in the Voluntary<br />
Emission Reduction market.<br />
Page 15<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group CEO’s Assessment<br />
We crown <strong>our</strong> achievements with awards.<br />
Within two years following the signing of the Carbon Emission Sales<br />
Contract, the Gökçedağ wind power plant met all the criteria related<br />
to the Gold Standard and became the world’s biggest project which<br />
has been awarded with the Gold Standard in the Voluntary Emission<br />
Reduction market.<br />
While <strong>our</strong> project’s contribution to sustainable development was<br />
approved at the highest level, it is also deemed worthy of an award<br />
by NGOs as an investment that is mindful of environmental and<br />
natural values as well as animal rights.<br />
Moreover, the EUR 130 million loan contract signed with the<br />
Institute of International Finance, European Bank for Reconstruction<br />
and Development, European Investment Bank, Deniz Bank and HSBC<br />
for the financing of the Gökçedağ wind power plant was awarded<br />
as the “Best Wind Power Plant Project Finance in 2009” within the<br />
scope of Euromoney Project Finance Awards.<br />
Towards a low carbon economy<br />
Expressions such as “reduction of carbon emission to the<br />
atmosphere” and “erasing carbon footprints”, which were added<br />
to <strong>our</strong> agenda within the framework of reducing the impacts of<br />
economic activity on global warming, are on the verge of coming<br />
into focus of all manufacturing activities.<br />
The Carbon Emission Sales Contract, which the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group<br />
signed with EcoSecurities with respect to the Gökçedağ wind power<br />
plant, is a first in Turkey in this field. The Gökçedağ wind power<br />
plant should generate nearly 500,000 MWh of electricity per year<br />
with zero CO 2<br />
emissions.<br />
After the verification process which will be carried out when the<br />
plant reaches full capacity, carbon certificates will be traded in<br />
the voluntary carbon market. We have granted EcoSecurities, all<br />
the rights of the project related to annual carbon emission and<br />
authorization to trade in voluntary markets until 2012 within the<br />
framework of the agreement reached.<br />
In line with its environment-friendly approach and sense of<br />
corporate responsibility, the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group plans to participate<br />
actively in the carbon market in 2010 by conducting emission<br />
calculations at all its power plants. As all countries have revealed<br />
their targets with respect to the reduction of carbon emissions, the<br />
carbon market is expected to become more active and gradually gain<br />
importance in the coming periods.<br />
We erase <strong>our</strong> carbon footprints<br />
According to 2007 figures, Turkey’s total greenhouse gas emissions<br />
were estimated to be equivalent to 372.6 million tons of CO 2<br />
.<br />
Energy-based emissions have the biggest share in the total CO 2<br />
-<br />
equivalent emission with a 77% share.<br />
The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group prevents nearly 600,000 tons of CO 2<br />
gas<br />
emissions at its power plants which operate with renewable <strong>energy</strong><br />
such as wind and hydroelectric. When calculated over 5 tons per<br />
capita, emission of about 120,000 people in Turkey is erased. In<br />
other words, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group is able to erase the footprints of all its<br />
employees including their families.<br />
We conduct alternative projects for clean <strong>energy</strong>.<br />
The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group conducts various active business<br />
development and demonstration projects in respect to alternative<br />
<strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces such as solar <strong>energy</strong>, which promise a big potential<br />
but are not yet widespread. The Group also carries out R&D<br />
activities for clean <strong>energy</strong> generation with methods such as coal<br />
gasification. Our Group performs R&D studies on the “Solar Thermal<br />
Energy” technology in cooperation with Hitit Solar, a company<br />
operating under <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding. This system, which is based on the<br />
principle of generating electricity with steam provided from solar<br />
<strong>energy</strong>, has successfully passed the testing stage, while improvement<br />
work is still under way.<br />
R&D studies regarding another project titled “electricity generation<br />
based on the coal gasification technology” aim to minimize the<br />
harmful damage of coal to the environment.<br />
We must reduce carbon emissions.<br />
The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group prevents nearly 600,000 tons of CO 2<br />
emissions at its power plants operating with renewable <strong>energy</strong>,<br />
such as wind and hydroelectric <strong>energy</strong>.<br />
Page 16<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
The <strong>energy</strong> generation pilot plant based on the coal gasification<br />
technology which will be established with the cooperation<br />
between the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group and TÜBİTAK (The Scientific and<br />
Technological Research Council of Turkey) – TEYDEB (Technology<br />
and Innovation Funding Programs Directorate) is a project which<br />
will pioneer other studies to be carried out with respect to the<br />
efficient use of <strong>energy</strong> by removing the damage given by coal to the<br />
environment. The plant is planned to become operational by the end<br />
of 2011.<br />
We strive to make a difference for the regions where we<br />
invest<br />
The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group attaches particular importance to<br />
conducting research on the social and environmental impacts of<br />
its investments, taking measures which will minimize the negative<br />
impacts as much as possible and continuously monitoring such<br />
effects.<br />
Research on the environmental and social circumstances of the<br />
region was initiated as soon as a decision was taken to build the<br />
Gökçedağ wind power plant in Osmaniye. A ‘Research Study on<br />
the Existing Social Circumstances’ was conducted in order to<br />
anticipate the socioeconomic circumstances of the region and<br />
detailed socioeconomic research was carried out to get information<br />
on the average education level of people and to understand the<br />
capabilities of their manpower living in 21 towns. We began to<br />
award scholarships acting upon the findings of these researches, and<br />
we are very proud to report that we supported the education of 82<br />
university and college students in 2009 through the Mehmet <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Foundation.<br />
Our Group believes in the importance of people in the region<br />
laying claim to these <strong>energy</strong> investments, conducting the necessary<br />
research to ensure that investors function as a leverage in<br />
development efforts in the region and implementing development<br />
projects with the participation and cooperation of people.<br />
We increase <strong>our</strong> <strong>energy</strong> for the future<br />
We put effort into fulfilling <strong>our</strong> liabilities with respect to preparing<br />
a better future for <strong>our</strong> country and <strong>our</strong> world with an increasing<br />
amount of <strong>energy</strong> each year.<br />
Our ongoing investments and the projects we have designed<br />
represent important steps in terms of security of <strong>energy</strong> supply in<br />
and after 2011, by which time we project that the economy will gain<br />
sustainability and demand for electricity will rapidly increase. We<br />
try to realize <strong>our</strong> aim to rapidly increase the number of renewable<br />
<strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces and plants in <strong>our</strong> portfolio in coming years, with<br />
excitement and with firm steps.<br />
In closing, I would like to extend my sincerest thanks to <strong>our</strong> Board of<br />
Directors for their continuous support and contributions that help us<br />
reach <strong>our</strong> targets, to <strong>our</strong> employees and to all <strong>our</strong> stakeholders.<br />
Murat Sungur Bursa<br />
Energy Group CEO and Member of the Board of Directors<br />
Within the scope of the ‘Environmental Impact Research’, migration<br />
periods of the birds were observed and a research study was<br />
conducted to understand how the power plant would affect such<br />
migration, considering the fact that the region is on the migration<br />
path of birds.<br />
This approach appears before us as an indispensible phenomenon<br />
which we will apply in <strong>our</strong> new projects and investments though it is<br />
quite new for <strong>our</strong> country.<br />
Our ongoing investments and the<br />
projects we have designed represent<br />
important steps in securing <strong>energy</strong><br />
supply in and beyond 2011, by<br />
which time we envisage that<br />
economy will gain sustainability,<br />
paving the way for rapid growth in<br />
demand for electricity.<br />
Page 17<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Board of Directors<br />
Zeki ZORLU<br />
Chairman of the Board of<br />
Directors<br />
(1939 - Denizli) Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong> began his<br />
career in a family company operating<br />
in the textiles sector and opened<br />
his first textiles store in Trabzon.<br />
Having founded Korteks in 1976,<br />
which was established in Babadağ,<br />
Denizli and which continued in<br />
Istanbul, Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong> laid down the<br />
foundations of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding which<br />
today has 25,000 employees and 60<br />
companies. In addition to its new<br />
investments in the textiles sector,<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Group entered the electronics<br />
and white goods sector with Vestel,<br />
which was acquired in 1994, the<br />
<strong>energy</strong> sector in 1996 and the real<br />
estate sector in 2006. As well as<br />
serving as the Co-Chairman of the<br />
Board of Directors of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding,<br />
Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong> is also serving as the<br />
Chairman of the Group companies<br />
operating in the textiles and <strong>energy</strong><br />
sectors.<br />
Melih E. ARAZ<br />
Vice Chairman<br />
(1948 - Istanbul) Melih E. Araz<br />
graduated from the Faculty<br />
of Political Sciences at Ankara<br />
University in 1972. After having<br />
completed an MBA at the Kelley<br />
School of Business within the<br />
University of Indiana, he continued<br />
his education at the Harvard<br />
Business School in the field of “Top<br />
Level Management”. Commencing<br />
his career at the Citibank N.A.’s<br />
organization in Turkey, Mr. Araz<br />
assumed top level duties in a variety<br />
of units in the Istanbul, Izmir,<br />
Bahrain, Athens and New York<br />
branches and took on important<br />
responsibilities in the foundation and<br />
expansion of the Citibank<br />
organization. Later, being appointed<br />
as the CEO/General Manager at<br />
Interbank A.Ş., Mr. Araz played a<br />
leading role in bringing Interbank<br />
to a respected position in the<br />
corporate and investment banking<br />
fields in Turkey. Mr. Araz now serves<br />
as a consultant for a variety of<br />
companies in the fields of finance<br />
and strategic management, and is<br />
also the Vice Chairman of the Board<br />
of Directors of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Inc., the<br />
Managing Director at Ata Yatırım<br />
A.Ş., and a Board Member at Şenocak<br />
Holding A.Ş., Klimasan A.Ş., Izmir<br />
Enternasyonel Otelcilik A.Ş. and<br />
Entegre A.Ş.<br />
Olgun ZORLU<br />
Board Member<br />
Having graduated from university in<br />
the UK, Olgun <strong>Zorlu</strong> began his career<br />
in 1986 and gained managerial<br />
experience in the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group’s<br />
textiles companies. He started to<br />
serve as a Board Member for <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Holding in 1998. In addition to being<br />
a member of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Board<br />
of Directors, Mr. <strong>Zorlu</strong> also serves<br />
on the boards of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding and<br />
other group companies.<br />
Page 18<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Murat Sungur BURSA<br />
Board Member<br />
Burak İ. OKAY<br />
Board Member<br />
Selen ZORLU MELİK<br />
Board Member<br />
(1975 - Trabzon) Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Melik graduated from the Faculty<br />
of Economics and Administrative<br />
Sciences in the Department of<br />
Business Administration at Uludağ<br />
University. She started her career<br />
in Deniz Bank in 1998. Following<br />
her internship at DenizBank Bursa<br />
Branch, she joined Management<br />
Trainee Program in 1999 at the<br />
same bank. Having served in several<br />
positions at the Deniz Bank’s Head<br />
Quarter, she attended Marketing<br />
Certificate Program at the University<br />
of California Berkley (USA) in 2001.<br />
In 2002 she started to work in<br />
Korteks, the textile manufacturing<br />
and trade company of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group<br />
and became a Member of the Board<br />
at the same company in 2004. She<br />
joined <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group as a<br />
Vice-President and a Board Member<br />
in 2005.<br />
(1954 - Mersin) Murat Sungur<br />
Bursa graduated from the Middle<br />
East Technical University in<br />
1977. Following his education in<br />
American Hobart School of Welding<br />
Technology, he completed an MBA<br />
in Business Administration-Product<br />
Management at Gazi University.<br />
He began his career in Industrial<br />
Training and Development Centre as<br />
a mechanical engineer in 1977.<br />
Having served several positions<br />
in the public sector between<br />
1986-1991, Mr. Bursa served<br />
as the General Manager of the<br />
Environmental Impact Assessment<br />
and Planning Department at the<br />
Ministry of Environment between<br />
1991-1994. Between 1995-1998,<br />
he was appointed as Deputy<br />
Undersecretary at the Ministry<br />
of Environment, and then as an<br />
Undersecretary at the Ministry.<br />
In 2003 he started to work as<br />
Director in Prime Ministry’s Project<br />
Implementation Unit. He joined<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group in 2006 as CEO<br />
and as a Board Member.<br />
Prof Dr. A. Can TUNCAY<br />
Board Member<br />
(1944 - Ankara) Prof Dr. A. Can<br />
Tuncay graduated from the Faculty<br />
of Law at Ankara University in 1966.<br />
After completing his advocacy<br />
internship, he was admitted to<br />
the Faculty of Law at the Istanbul<br />
University in 1968 as an assistant<br />
lecturer. He was awarded a PhD<br />
in law in 1975 and became an<br />
assistant professor of law in<br />
1980. Having been promoted as<br />
a professor in 1988, Mr. Tuncay<br />
lectured in the Department of Law<br />
on Occupational and Social Security<br />
at the Istanbul Faculty of Law for<br />
32 years. He retired from his post<br />
at Istanbul University in 2000. He<br />
was appointed as a Board Member<br />
of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group in 2006, and<br />
has been working at Bahçeşehir<br />
University as a lecturer at the<br />
Department of Law on Occupational<br />
and Social Security since 2003. He<br />
was appointed the dean of the same<br />
department in October 2009. Mr. A.<br />
Can Tuncay is also a legal advisor at<br />
a number of domestic and foreign<br />
companies.<br />
(1967 - Ankara) Burak İ. Okay<br />
graduated from the Faculty of Law<br />
at the Ankara University in 1990.<br />
After completing the international<br />
law certificate program in New<br />
York, he started his career at the<br />
Department of Legal Consultancy in<br />
İşbank. He later went on to work in<br />
Garanti Bank, MNG Bank and Nortel<br />
Networks Netaş respectively and<br />
then served at the Bener Law Firm as<br />
an executive. Joining <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group in<br />
2006, he played an active role in the<br />
configuration of the law department<br />
serving all the Group companies.<br />
Mr. Okay still serves as the Law<br />
Coordinator of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group<br />
and is a Board Member of the <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Energy Group since 2007.<br />
Page 19<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Senior Management<br />
Murat Sungur BURSA<br />
CEO of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group,<br />
Board Member<br />
Please refer to page 19 for the CV of<br />
Murat Sungur Bursa.<br />
Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong> MELİK<br />
Deputy CEO of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
Group, Board Member<br />
Please refer to page 19 for the CV of<br />
Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong> Melik.<br />
İ. Sinan AK<br />
Assistant General Manager,<br />
Finance<br />
(1971 - Ankara) İ. Sinan Ak has<br />
graduated from Istanbul Technical<br />
University with a BSc degree in<br />
Engineering Management. He<br />
began his career as a bond dealer<br />
in Evgin Securities in 1996. He<br />
completed an MBA c<strong>our</strong>se from Old<br />
Dominion University (USA) with a<br />
concentration on finance. He then<br />
joined <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group in June 2000.<br />
He served in various positions and<br />
companies within the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group<br />
as follows: between 2000-2002 in<br />
Vestel Communications as finance<br />
chief; between 2002-2006 in Vestel<br />
White Goods as finance manager<br />
and since 2006 in <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
as Assistant General Manager. He<br />
is currently the Assistant General<br />
Manager responsible for finance at<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation<br />
Inc.<br />
Serhat ŞİMŞEK<br />
Assistant General Manager,<br />
Production and Trade<br />
(1968 - Elazığ) Serhat Şimşek<br />
graduated from the Electrical<br />
Engineering Department at Yıldız<br />
Technical University in 1990. He<br />
started his career in Tekfen as an<br />
engineer and undertook a number<br />
of managerial positions in Temel<br />
Su, Shell and Trakya İplik. He joined<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy in February 2001 and<br />
has served as an Assistant General<br />
Manager responsible for production<br />
and trade in <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity<br />
Generation Inc. since 2007.<br />
Page 20<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Gökmen TOPUZ<br />
Assistant General Manager,<br />
Investments<br />
(1972 - Istanbul) Gökmen Topuz<br />
has graduated from the Department<br />
of Electrical Engineering at Istanbul<br />
Technical University in 1995. He<br />
got his MBA degree at Yeditepe<br />
University. He started his career as a<br />
Project Manager in MAN Desentrale<br />
Energie Systeme. He served in<br />
various managerial positions in<br />
Wartsila-Enpa, Kale Energy, Piramit<br />
Energy between 1998-2007. He<br />
has been serving at <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
Electricity Generation Inc. since<br />
2007 as Assistant General Manager<br />
responsible for investments.<br />
Bülent ÇİLİNGİR<br />
Director, Procurement and<br />
Logistics<br />
(1963 - Ankara) Bülent Çilingir<br />
has graduated from Middle East<br />
Technical University Department of<br />
Civil Engineering and completed an<br />
MSc degree at the same university<br />
in 1985. He started his career as<br />
a Project Manager in Kutlutaş<br />
Construction in 1985. Between<br />
1989-2003 he has undertaken<br />
several managerial positions<br />
in Bayındır Holding, Bayındır<br />
Construction, Erel Technology Group.<br />
In 2003 he started to work as a<br />
consultant in the <strong>energy</strong> field and he<br />
joined <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy as Procurement<br />
and Logistics Director in 2006.<br />
A. Tansel VARAN<br />
Director, Human Res<strong>our</strong>ces and<br />
Corporate Communications<br />
(1970 - Istanbul) A. Tansel Varan<br />
graduated from the Faculty of<br />
Economics and Finance Istanbul<br />
University and completed an MA<br />
degree in economics from the<br />
University of Vienna in 1996. He<br />
attended a Business English and<br />
Internet Certificate<br />
Program at the University of<br />
California Berkley (USA) in 1997<br />
before joining Anadolu Group as<br />
a Management Trainee later in<br />
1997, going on to serve in various<br />
managerial positions within the<br />
Group. He worked as a Human<br />
Res<strong>our</strong>ces Manager in Doğan Group<br />
and Ak-Al Tekstil between 2002-<br />
2005 and joined <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy in<br />
December 2005 as Human Res<strong>our</strong>ces<br />
and Corporate Communications<br />
Director.<br />
Page 21<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
We are growing stronger<br />
in Turkey and in the<br />
international arena.<br />
Page 22<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Management’s Assessment and Analysis of Operational Results<br />
Developments in the Turkish Electricity Sector<br />
Consumption of electricity in Turkey declined by 2.3% in 2009<br />
compared to 2008, and fell to 193,472 million kWh, parallel to the<br />
effects of the global crisis.<br />
Electricity demand in Turkey has grown at an annual compound<br />
rate of 7.2% since 1985 in line with economic development,<br />
industrialization and urbanization. The economic recession that<br />
affected the whole world in 2009 in line with the global crisis, and<br />
also led to a drop in demand for electricity in Turkey as well. Turkey,<br />
which had a total installed capacity of 44,556 MW at the end of<br />
2009, is set to at least double its current capacity within the next<br />
decade, in line with the projected increase in electricity demand.<br />
Although the contraction in demand, caused by the crisis, postponed<br />
fears of a supply bottleneck, Turkey is still expected to encounter<br />
electricity shortages by 2014 under a scenario of high demand, or<br />
by 2015 in a scenario of low demand, according to the report titled<br />
“Turkish Electrical Energy 10-Year Generation Capacity Projection”<br />
published by TEİAŞ (Turkey Electricity Transmission Corporation).<br />
Also taking into account the minimum 3 or 4-year investment<br />
period required for <strong>energy</strong> investments and the additional capacity<br />
needs which are expected to arise in the coming periods, measures<br />
must be taken and investments must be started immediately in<br />
order to stave off a supply shortage in the coming year.<br />
Efforts are underway to liberalize the sector, aimed at creating a<br />
more favorable investment environment to meet the electricity<br />
demand in the coming period and to raise efficiency. The State<br />
Planning Organization published the “Electricity Energy Market and<br />
Supply Security Strategy Paper” on May 21st, 2009 in order to guide<br />
this process. The document covers the following:<br />
• stages of the targeted market structure in the sector,<br />
• privatization,<br />
• targets with respect to res<strong>our</strong>ces to be used in electricity supply in<br />
mid- and long-term, and<br />
• steps to be taken to ensure supply security.<br />
During this liberalization process, the following developments took<br />
place in 2009 on the privatization side:<br />
Production:<br />
The Strategy Document published by the SPO sets out plans to<br />
group the production plants to be privatized under various portfolios,<br />
and to reevaluate and finalize existing portfolio groups. Parallel<br />
to this objective, the privatization process of production plants<br />
got underway in 2009. Within this framework, the Privatization<br />
Administration called for tenders with respect to the privatization<br />
of 52 hydroelectric power plants, belonging to the Electricity<br />
Generation Company, under 19 different portfolio groups through<br />
the method of “transfer of operating rights”, and decided that<br />
companies participating in tenders may apply for preliminary<br />
qualification until February 19th, 2010 at the latest.<br />
Distribution:<br />
The Privatization of the Başkent, Meram and Sakarya Electricity<br />
Distribution electricity distribution grids, which all belong to the<br />
Turkish Electricity Distribution Company, was completed and<br />
their share transfers were completed. Final negotiations were<br />
also completed in the privatization procedure of the Aras, Çoruh,<br />
Osmangazi and Yeşilırmak Electricity Distribution grids; however,<br />
shares of these companies have not yet been transferred. The<br />
tenders for the Çamlıbel, Fırat, Uludağ and Vangölü Electricity<br />
distribution grids were called by the Privatization Administration,<br />
while a total of 43 investors had applied for preliminary qualification<br />
as of December 16th, 2009.<br />
The privatization procedure regarding other distribution grids<br />
belonging to the Turkish Electricity Distribution Company, which<br />
were included within the framework of the privatization program by<br />
the Privatization Administration, is expected to begin in due c<strong>our</strong>se.<br />
The SPO’s Strategy Document set out that the privatization of all<br />
distribution grids targeted to be completed by the end of 2010.<br />
Within the same framework, the “Medium Term Program (2010-<br />
2012)” report, prepared by the Undersecretariat of State Planning<br />
Organization and published in the official gazette dated September<br />
16th, 2009, stated that privatizations would be completed,<br />
with priority given to distribution grids, and that private sector<br />
investments would be supported consistently as part of efforts<br />
to establish a liberalized electricity market. The report also stated<br />
that work on nuclear power plants would begin to support res<strong>our</strong>ce<br />
diversity and supply security, the usage of domestic and renewable<br />
res<strong>our</strong>ces in electricity generation would be accelerated in order<br />
Consumption of electricity in Turkey declined by 2.3% in<br />
2009, falling to 193,472 million kWh.<br />
Page 23<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Management’s Assessment and Analysis of Operational Results<br />
to reduce Turkey’s excessive import dependency on natural gas,<br />
The report also proposed the establishment of effective application<br />
mechanisms aimed at increasing <strong>energy</strong> efficiency.<br />
In April 2009, the Energy Market Regulatory Authority (EMRA)<br />
amended the respective regulation on determining electricity<br />
production and consumption prices on an h<strong>our</strong>ly basis, and set<br />
out the cash-based responsibilities of system participants during<br />
this period. The aim was to improve the current system within the<br />
scope of the Stabilization & Reconciliation (DUY), which was put<br />
in practice in August 2006 in order to ensure security of supply,<br />
enc<strong>our</strong>age competition and provide some degree of easing to the<br />
private sector. The amendment took effect as of<br />
December 1st, 2009.<br />
Developments in the Turkish Natural Gas Sector<br />
Since 1987 when natural gas was presented as an alternative <strong>energy</strong><br />
res<strong>our</strong>ce to meet Turkey’s rapidly growing demand for <strong>energy</strong>,<br />
demand for natural gas has grown very rapidly. Consumption of<br />
natural gas in Turkey grew at a compounded annual rate of 21%<br />
during this period, up from 0.5 billion m 3 in 1987 to 32 billion m 3 in<br />
2009.<br />
Demand for natural gas is determined by electricity production and<br />
household and industrial consumption. As a result of the ongoing<br />
global crisis, consumption of natural gas declined by 11% year-onyear<br />
in 2009. EMRA projected natural gas consumption of 37 billion<br />
m 3 for 2010.<br />
460 MW<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.’s<br />
natural gas power plant has a combined<br />
installed capacity of 460 MW and 192 tons/<br />
h<strong>our</strong> of steam.<br />
F<strong>our</strong> new companies entered the natural gas market in 2008 and<br />
2009. These companies import natural gas based on the contracts<br />
that they took over from BOTAŞ (Petrolium Pipeline Corporation).<br />
Moreover, gas imports in the form of spot LNG began in 2009<br />
through the privately owned Aliağa LNG terminal.<br />
Activities in Turkey<br />
Electricity Production<br />
Natural Gas Power Plants<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.’s electricity power plants<br />
located in Lüleburgaz, Bursa, Ankara, Kayseri, and Yalova supply<br />
electricity and steam to a customer base consisting of industrial<br />
concerns. These plants have a total installed capacity of 460 MW of<br />
electricity and 192 tons/h<strong>our</strong> of steam.<br />
Within the framework of the capacity increase project at the<br />
Lüleburgaz Power Plant, an additional capacity of 50 MW became<br />
operational in 2009 on a simple-cycle basis with the additional<br />
investment initiated in 2008 and the power plant’s total installed<br />
capacity has reached 115.3 MW with new additions.<br />
The biggest wind power project in Turkey: The Gökçedağ wind<br />
power plant<br />
The Gökçedağ wind power plant in Osmaniye, the biggest project<br />
reflecting <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.’s vision regarding<br />
renewable and alternative <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces, is also the biggest wind<br />
power project in Turkey.<br />
An additional capacity increase of<br />
50 MW was initially provided at<br />
the natural gas cogeneration plant<br />
in Lüleburgaz with the additional<br />
investment made in the plant, bringing<br />
the total installed capacity of the power<br />
plant to 115.3 MW.<br />
Page 24<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Rotor Elektrik Üretim A.Ş., a Group company, holds an electricity<br />
production license for a period of 25 years for the 135MW capacity<br />
Osmaniye Power Plant. The Company also received two further<br />
production licenses from the Energy Market Regulatory Authority for<br />
wind power projects with 60 MW and 50 MW capacities in the same<br />
region.<br />
Project and engineering work at Gökçedağ wind power plant,<br />
which will be developed by Rotor on the license area and which is<br />
planned to have a capacity of 135 MW in the first phase. Within the<br />
framework of the contract signed with GE Energy, 54 wind turbines,<br />
each with a capacity of 2.5 MW, should be brought into operation as<br />
of June 2010, raising the plant’s total installed capacity to 135 MW.<br />
The second phase investments, with an additional capacity of 110<br />
MW, are planned to be undertaken in the coming periods. With two<br />
new plants to be constructed in Sarıtepe (50 MW) and Demirciler<br />
(60 MW), the Group aims to reach a total installed capacity of 245<br />
MW in Osmaniye.<br />
Carbon Market, Turkey and the Gökçedağ wind power plant<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. carried out the first<br />
carbon emission project of Turkey at the Gökçedağ wind<br />
power plant owned by Rotor Elektrik Üretimi A.Ş. The first<br />
eight turbines at the Gökçedağ wind power plant were brought<br />
into operation in August 2009; with 23 turbines becoming<br />
operational by year-end 2009, total capacity reached 57.5<br />
MW. This represented a total reduction of 13,000 tons in<br />
CO 2<br />
emissions under the Gold Standard. The annual emission<br />
reduction amount expected from the Gökçedağ wind power<br />
plant, with its total installed capacity of 135 MW, is equivalent<br />
to 302,675 tons of CO 2<br />
. Carbon certificates will be traded in<br />
voluntary markets following the verification process. All the<br />
rights with respect to annual carbon emission specific to the<br />
project were assigned to EcoSecurities PLC which is authorized<br />
to trade such certificates in voluntary markets and which was<br />
purchased by JP Morgan in September 2009. EcoSecurities<br />
PLC was assigned the right to trade carbon certificates until<br />
2012 within the framework of the VERPA (Voluntary Emission<br />
Reduction Purchase Agreement) which was signed in 2008.<br />
About the Gökçedağ wind power plant<br />
Once it reaches full capacity, the Gökçedağ wind power plant is<br />
expected to generate nearly 500 million kWh of electricity per<br />
year. If this amount of electricity were produced by thermal<br />
power plants, approximately 300,000 tons of CO 2<br />
would be<br />
emitted into the atmosphere, while the Gökçedağ wind power<br />
plant will generate the same amount of electricity with no CO 2<br />
emissions. Given that a tree in a tropical region absorbs 20-22<br />
kg of CO 2<br />
per year, the Gökçedağ wind power plant would<br />
therefore reduce CO 2<br />
emissions by the amount equal to an<br />
average of 14.5 million trees per year; taking into the climate<br />
and dominant vegetation type in Turkey, the number of trees<br />
in question may rise to as much as 200 million.<br />
Each wind turbine is 85 meters tall, as tall as a 30-storey<br />
building.<br />
The blades of the wind turbines are 50 meters long. Their overall<br />
diameter of 100 meters is equal to that of a football field.<br />
Each turbine weighs 356 tons.<br />
The service road connecting the turbines is 40 km long, longer<br />
than Bosporus Bridge in Istanbul which is 32 km.<br />
The turbines are installed on foundations located 960-1,620<br />
meters above sea level; the highest spot where the turbines are<br />
located is equal to one third of the height of the Mount Ağrı.<br />
Each turbine will generate 9.3 million kWh of <strong>energy</strong> per year.<br />
The wind power plant’s annual <strong>energy</strong> production capacity will<br />
be enough to provide lighting to nearly 170,000 homes.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. demonstrated its<br />
environmental awareness with the ground breaking signing of a<br />
Carbon Emission Sale Contract with the Ireland-based EcoSecurities<br />
Group PLC at the beginning of 2008. The contract covers <strong>energy</strong><br />
production without carbon emission at the power plant and will be<br />
effective until the end of 2012.<br />
300.000<br />
The Gökçedağ wind power plant will<br />
prevent 300,000 tons of CO 2<br />
from being<br />
emitted into the atmosphere.<br />
The Gökçedağ wind power plant in<br />
Osmaniye, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity<br />
Generation Inc.’s biggest project<br />
in its vision for renewable and<br />
alternative <strong>energy</strong>, is also Turkey’s<br />
biggest wind power plant project.<br />
Page 25<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Management’s Assessment and Analysis of Operational Results<br />
The Gökçedağ wind power plant is the biggest project in the<br />
world to receive the Gold Standard.<br />
The Gökçedağ wind power plant met all the criteria related to<br />
the Gold Standard within two years following the signing of the<br />
Carbon Emission Sale Contract and was awarded the Gold Standard<br />
in the Voluntary Emission Reduction market. The Gold Standard,<br />
which is based on such requirements as “sustainable development”,<br />
“environmental awareness”, “being accepted by local stakeholders”,<br />
etc., necessitates a process composed of the following phases for the<br />
approval of projects: social and environmental impact analysis of the<br />
project, evaluation of these impacts and project-related expectations<br />
together with local stakeholders and approval of the project by an<br />
independent institution. The Gökçedağ wind power plant is the<br />
world’s biggest project to have been awarded the Gold Standard.<br />
The award for “investments which demonstrate care for<br />
environmental and natural values, and animal rights”<br />
The Gökçedağ wind power plant Farm won acclaim from prominent<br />
NGOs in the environment field, due to its sensitivity on the<br />
preservation of the social and ecological environment. In 2009, the<br />
power plant was handed the environmental award in the category of<br />
“investments that are mindful of environmental and natural values,<br />
and animal rights” by the Association of Friends for Nature and the<br />
Istanbul Environmental Council, which the association is a member of.<br />
The Gökçedağ wind power plant was awarded as “Best Wind<br />
Power Project Finance in 2009” in Europe<br />
Project Finance, a publication owned by Euromoney, has been<br />
issuing “Project Finance Awards” for 11 years, with awards based<br />
on criteria such as financing of industrial projects, innovation, best<br />
application, solution capability, repeatability, duration of use, etc.<br />
In this year’s evaluation, the EUR130 million loan contract signed<br />
with the Institute of International Finance, European Bank for<br />
Reconstruction and Development, the European Investment Bank,<br />
Deniz Bank and HSBC for the financing of the Gökçedağ wind power<br />
plant was awarded the “Best Wind Power Project Finance in 2009”<br />
as part of the Euromoney Project Finance Awards.<br />
Natural Gas Exploration and Production<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.’s oil and gas exploration<br />
activities are carried out by group companies <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas and<br />
Amity Oil. These companies carry out natural gas exploration,<br />
drilling and production activities in 19 regions throughout Turkey for<br />
which they hold licenses, predominantly in Thrace.<br />
Although <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas has been undertaking exploration and<br />
drilling activities, no natural gas reserves have yet been found and as<br />
yet there is no natural gas production. The Company also received a<br />
wholesale license on 26 September, 2009 and began to trade natural<br />
gas over the national transmission grid in 2010 within the scope of<br />
the rights granted by this license.<br />
Amity Oil International had nearly 294 million m 3 of natural gas<br />
reserves at the end of 2009.<br />
EUR 130<br />
million<br />
The EUR 130 million loan contract, signed<br />
for the financing of the Gökçedağ wind<br />
power plant was awarded as the “Best<br />
Wind Power Plant Project Finance in 2009”<br />
in Europe.<br />
Page 26<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
International Operations<br />
Electricity Production<br />
Natural Gas Power Plants<br />
Projects in Russia<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. is currently building two<br />
natural gas power plants in Moscow:<br />
• Tereshkovo (340 MW & 150 Gcal heat)<br />
• Kojukhovo (340 MW & 270 Gcal heat)<br />
Rosmiks Ltd., which <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy became a partner of with a<br />
51% stake to carry out <strong>energy</strong> power plant projects in Russia, was<br />
awarded Moscow municipality contracts to build two electricity and<br />
city heating plants: Tereshkovo (340 MW) and Kojukhovo (340 MW).<br />
Construction work began in 2006.<br />
By the end of 2009, the first phase investments (170 MW for<br />
Tereshkovo and 170 MW for Kojukhovo) of both natural gas power<br />
plants had largely been completed. Testing and commissioning<br />
activities began at the Tereshkovo plant, which is targeted to be<br />
brought into operation on a simple-cycle basis in the first half of<br />
2010.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy is currently involved in investments in Russia,<br />
Israel and Pakistan. The <strong>energy</strong> sectors of these countries<br />
offer many characteristics which resemble the situation<br />
which prevails in Turkey:<br />
• Strong demand which is growing at rates above the global<br />
average<br />
• Substantial need for investments considering expected supply<br />
shortages in the coming years<br />
• Regulated markets with state control on both electricity<br />
generation and distribution<br />
• Liberalization process already started, indicating an upward<br />
adjustment on the pricing side given strong demand and supply<br />
shortage.<br />
Because of the changes occurring in lines outside the Kojukhovo<br />
power plant area, the construction schedule was revised, and the<br />
plant is now targeted to be brought into operation by Q4/2010,<br />
according to the new schedule. Work on the second phase<br />
investments is planned to get underway once the first phase<br />
investments have been completed.<br />
Engineering services for both Russian plants are being provided by<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Industrial while operation and maintenance services are under<br />
the responsibility of <strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M.<br />
Russian Electricity Sector<br />
Russia, the world’s f<strong>our</strong>th largest consumer of electricity after<br />
the USA, China and Japan, must now step up its investments<br />
in <strong>energy</strong> generation and transmission, as its infrastructure is<br />
becoming insufficient to meet demand for electricity.<br />
Nearly 63% of the electricity generated in Russia is provided<br />
from thermal power plants, 21% from hydroelectric power<br />
plants and 16% from nuclear power plants. According to<br />
projections, in addition to its current installed capacity of 220<br />
GW, Russia may need an additional 130 GW capacity by 2030,<br />
in parallel with growing demand for electricity.<br />
In Moscow, where <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. is<br />
undertaking investment, demand for electricity is growing at<br />
rates above the national growth levels due to the high rates<br />
of urbanization and industrial development. While demand for<br />
electricity grew by 1.9% nationally in 2008, the rate was 3.1%<br />
for Moscow.<br />
The government of the Russian Federation is effecting<br />
a gradual transition from regulated bilateral production<br />
agreements to freely-negotiated ones by 2011. As of July<br />
2009, the regulated market has accounted for 50% of the<br />
total market. This liberalization is expected to lead to an<br />
overall rise in electricity prices, having a positive impact on the<br />
profitability of the market players.<br />
At the end of 2009, first phase investments (170 MW for<br />
Tereshkovo and 170 MW for Kojukhovo) of both natural<br />
gas power plants had largely been completed.<br />
By the end of 2009, the first<br />
phase investments (170 MW<br />
for Tereshkovo and 170 MW for<br />
Kojukhovo) of both natural gas<br />
power plants had largely been<br />
completed.<br />
Page 27<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Management’s Assessment and Analysis of Operational Results<br />
Projects in Israel<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. is one of the first private<br />
sector firms to undertake electricity production in Israel. The<br />
Company has f<strong>our</strong> cogeneration power plant projects in Israel<br />
with a total installed capacity of 1,085 MW. These projects are to<br />
be undertaken by joint ventures that the Company enters into.<br />
The projects are currently at the final stage of obtaining project<br />
financing.<br />
Dorad Project<br />
The largest undertaking in Israel in this category is the Dorad project,<br />
which involves the construction of an 800 MW combined-cycle<br />
natural gas power plant at Ashkelon by Dorad Energy Ltd, a company<br />
in which <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc holds a 25% stake.<br />
Once it is completed, the power plant should boast the largest<br />
privately-owned installed capacity in Israel, contributing about 8%<br />
to the country’s total installed capacity.<br />
A 17-year natural gas procurement agreement has been signed<br />
with EMG, an Egyptian firm, in late 2007, which will be in effect as<br />
of 2011. All agreements, permits and licenses with regards to the<br />
project have been completed, with the exception of the electricity<br />
connection contract, which is expected to be signed before financerelated<br />
procedures are completed.<br />
Together with its Israeli partner, Edeltech Holding Ltd, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
Electricity Generation Inc. has three other projects which include the<br />
construction of natural gas-fired cogeneration power plants that will<br />
supply electricity and steam to industrial concerns in Israel.<br />
Ashdod Project<br />
Ashdod Energy Ltd, in which <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.<br />
controls a 51% stake, plans to carry out a cogeneration power plant<br />
investment with production capacities of approximately 55 MW of<br />
electricity and 20 tons/h<strong>our</strong> of steam.<br />
Ramat Negev Project<br />
Energy Ltd, which plans to undertake an investment in a cogeneration<br />
power plant in Israel with a production capacity of approximately 120<br />
MW of electricity and 17 tons/h<strong>our</strong> of steam.<br />
Solad Project<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. also controls a 26.5% stake<br />
in Solad Energy Ltd, which plans to undertake an investment in a<br />
cogeneration power plant in Israel with production capacities of<br />
approximately 110 MW of electricity and 100 tons/h<strong>our</strong> of steam.<br />
Engineering services for the Group’s investments in Israel are being<br />
provided by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Industrial while operation and maintenance<br />
services are under the responsibility of <strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M.<br />
Israel’s Electricity Sector<br />
Per-capita electricity consumption in Israel is 6,380 kWh - very<br />
close to the European average of 6,440 kWh. According to<br />
2008 figures, the total installed capacity of the country stands<br />
at 11,600 MW, while the market is almost entirely dominated<br />
by a single state-owned company, the Israel Electricity<br />
Corporation (IEC), with a 98.5% share in annual electricity<br />
consumption. <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. is one of<br />
the first private sector firms to undertake electricity production<br />
in Israel.<br />
1.085 MW<br />
4 natural gas power plants which will have a<br />
total production capacity of 1,085 MW.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy is conducting f<strong>our</strong><br />
projects to build cogeneration<br />
power plants which will operate<br />
with natural gas in order to<br />
provide the electricity and steam<br />
needed by the industrial concerns<br />
in Israel.<br />
Page 28<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Renewable Energy Power Plants<br />
Pakistan Wind Power Plant Project<br />
In 2006 <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. signed an agreement<br />
with Pakistan’s Alternative Energy Development Board (AEDB) to<br />
set up a wind power plant in Pakistan. Under this agreement, AEDB<br />
granted <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy a license in the wind <strong>energy</strong> development zone<br />
in Thatta in the Jimphir region. The Company will develop a wind<br />
power plant here and operate it for a period of 20 years. The first<br />
phase of the project is a 49.5 MW plant with an option to increase<br />
its capacity to 300 MW.<br />
As in <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.’s other investments,<br />
EPC services for this project are being provided by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Industrial<br />
while long-term operation and maintenance services are under the<br />
responsibility of <strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M.<br />
Pakistan’s Electricity Sector<br />
According to the most recent data, a total of 98,350 GWh of<br />
electricity was generated in Pakistan in 2006. However, total<br />
electricity consumption in the country was only 72,712 GWh.<br />
The discrepancy is attributed to a dilapidated transmission and<br />
distribution infrastructure, as well as to a significant level of<br />
“informal” use.<br />
Despite the considerable potential for electrical power s<strong>our</strong>ces,<br />
Pakistan suffers from a serious supply-side shortage. As matters<br />
currently stand, only 65-70% of the country’s 162 million<br />
people have access to electricity at all, a fact which points to a<br />
potentially massive increase in future demand.<br />
According to publicly-available figures, a projected CAGR of<br />
6-7% in electricity consumption will result in a supply-side<br />
shortfall of 14,000 MW in Pakistan by 2020.<br />
Pakistan offers plentiful renewable <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces as yet<br />
largely unused, and is therefore a market ripe for renewable<br />
<strong>energy</strong> production investments. In its report published in 2006,<br />
the Pakistani Government declared that the massive potential<br />
for hydroelectric, solar and wind <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces was not<br />
sufficiently used, and that the government would enc<strong>our</strong>age<br />
investment in these fields.<br />
Innovative Power, Renewable<br />
and Clean Energy<br />
Solar Thermal Energy<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. performs R&D studies<br />
on “Solar Thermal Energy” technology in cooperation with Hitit<br />
Solar, a company operating under <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding.<br />
This technology, which is based on the principle of solar focusing<br />
through parabolic mirrored panels, produces hot steam which<br />
turns turbines, thus generating electricity. The evidence is that<br />
this technology offers better results for bigger power plants.<br />
Within the framework of the R&D activities, research was<br />
conducted into the technologies currently employed in USA<br />
and Spain and potentials of improvement were determined.<br />
Engineering studies were conducted in line with the data<br />
gathered, as well as new designs were developed and<br />
international patents were received. In order to perform applied<br />
tests, the Denizli Pilot Project with a theoretical capacity of 200<br />
kWe was started. While tests resulted as planned, efforts are<br />
under way on some of the potential improvements identified.<br />
Electricity Production Pilot Plant based on the Coal<br />
Gasification Technology<br />
The pilot power plant based on the coal gasification technology<br />
is a project that will pioneer other efforts with respect to the<br />
efficient use of <strong>energy</strong> by eliminating the damage given by coal<br />
to the environment.<br />
R&D activities carried out with regards to electricity production<br />
based on the coal gasification technology aim to minimize the<br />
harmful impact of coal on the environment. By means of R&D<br />
activities to be performed at the plants, coal will be gasified<br />
through partial combustion and toxic substances and particles<br />
in the gas will be confined by cleaning the gas. The coal gas<br />
generated with this method will be clean and environmentfriendly<br />
just like natural gas.<br />
The plant will be established with the cooperation between <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Energy Electricity Generation Inc. and TÜBİTAK (The Scientific<br />
and Technological Research Council of Turkey) – TEYDEB<br />
(Technology and Innovation Funding Programs Directorate).<br />
Within the framework of this cooperation, TEYDEB provides the<br />
Group TL 1.5 million worth funding and research support with<br />
zero interest for the R&D activities to be carried out at the plant<br />
(the plant has a value of 8 million TL).<br />
Electricity generation based on the coal gasification technology<br />
is a method particularly popular in the USA, Germany, Japan,<br />
Austria, Denmark and the Netherlands. The construction of the<br />
plant is planned to begin by the end of 2010, and it is expected<br />
to be operational by the end of 2011.<br />
The first phase of the Pakistan<br />
Wind Power Plant Project, which is<br />
still at the financing stage, is a 49.5<br />
MW plant with an option to expand<br />
its capacity to 300 MW.<br />
Page 29<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Management’s Assessment and Analysis of Operational Results<br />
Developments in Production<br />
2009 production performances<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.’s current production<br />
accounts for 5.4% of all the electricity produced by privately-owned<br />
concerns in Turkey today.<br />
Production December 2008 December 2009<br />
ELECTRICITY (kWh) 2,687,512,200 2,266,935,686<br />
STEAM (ton) 745,677 576,138<br />
NATURAL GAS (sm 3 ) (*) 67,071,262 66,942,245<br />
* Our natural gas production company is Amity Oil International Pty.Ltd.<br />
In line with the ongoing global crisis, reduced industrial activity and<br />
consumption levels were reflected as 16% and 23% YoY respective<br />
declines in electricity and steam production in 2009, while natural<br />
gas production was close to its previous year level.<br />
Assessment of Sales and Financial Situation<br />
In 2009, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. sold a total of<br />
2,655 GWh of electricity, 81% of which was supplied to Turkey’s<br />
“DUY” (“Stabilization & Reconciliation”) market, while 14% of it was<br />
purchased by other <strong>Zorlu</strong> companies and 5% by non-group industrial<br />
and commercial companies within the framework of bilateral<br />
agreements.<br />
Sales December 2008 December 2009<br />
ELECTRICITY (Production) (kWh) 22,622,383,748 2,202,214,479<br />
ELECTRICITY (Commercial) (kWh) 116,727,400 453,160,950<br />
STEAM (ton) 745,677 576,138<br />
NATURAL GAS (Production) (sm 3 ) (*) 64,071,262 66,942,245<br />
NATURAL GAS (Commercial) (sm 3 ) (*) 24,259,395 28,895,308<br />
* Natural gas sales are made by Amity Oil International Pty.Ltd.<br />
Electricity Sales (kWh) 2008 Share 2009 Share<br />
DUY 2,062,445,798 75% 2,137,967,029 81%<br />
OTHERS 676,665,350 25% 517,408,400 19%<br />
TOTAL SALES 2,739,111,148 100% 2,655,375,429 100%<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc. recorded operating profit<br />
of US$ 173 million in 2009, including a one-off US$ 116 million<br />
(TL 180 million) net gains from participation sales realized in June<br />
2009. The Company’s EBITDA (excluding one of participation sales<br />
gains) was up 33% YoY to US$ 85 million. The company’s EBITDA<br />
margin increased from 15.6% in 2008 to 24% in 2009.<br />
The participation sales and the cash capital increase of TL<br />
200 million, carried out in June within the framework of the<br />
“restructuring plan”, aim to pave the way for new investments in<br />
the balance sheet in line with simplifying the Company’s subsidiary<br />
structure, as well as strengthening its equity base and decreasing<br />
debt level. Accordingly, net financial debt declined to US$ 888<br />
million with shareholders equity improving to US$152 million at end<br />
of 2009.<br />
Investment Expenditures<br />
Total investment expenditures in 2009 amounted to US$<br />
470 million, a large part of which was allocated to first-phase<br />
investments on two natural gas combined-cycle power plants (170<br />
MW x 2) in Russia and to the Gökçedağ wind power plant (135 MW)<br />
in Bahçe, Osmaniye. Work on adding a 75 MW combined-cycle<br />
plant to the existing natural gas plant at Lüleburgaz, which started in<br />
2008, continued in 2009 and the first phase investment (50 MW) of<br />
this power plant was commissioned on a simple-cycle basis in 2009.<br />
Other investments carried out during the reporting period involved<br />
exploration expenses jointly performed by Amity Oil and <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Petrogas for natural gas wells opened in Marmara and Southeastern<br />
Anatolian regions.<br />
With regards to the ongoing first phase investments comprising<br />
of two natural gas power plants (170 MW Tereshkovo + 170 MW<br />
Kojukhovo) in Moscow, Russia, Tereshkovo plant is expected to<br />
become operational on a simple-cycle basis in the first half of 2010,<br />
while Kojukhovo plant is expected to come on stream in Q4/2010.<br />
In the wind power plant investment, currently being built by Rotor<br />
Electric Power Generation Inc. in Osmaniye, a total of 57.5 MW of<br />
the capacity became operational by the end of 2009, and the wind<br />
power plant is expected to be in operation with its entire installed<br />
capacity of 135 MW by June 2010, operating with 54 wind turbines,<br />
each with 2.5 MW capacity.<br />
In 2009, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Inc.<br />
sold a total of 2,655 GWh of electricity, 81% of which<br />
was supplied to Turkey’s “DUY” (“Stabilization<br />
& Reconciliation”) market, while 14% of it was<br />
purchased by other <strong>Zorlu</strong> companies and 5% by<br />
non-group industrial and commercial companies<br />
within the framework of bilateral agreements.<br />
Page 30<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
We strive for<br />
sustainability...<br />
Page 31<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group, People and the Environment<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group specifies and complies with standards whose<br />
aims are to improve employee health and safety and to minimize<br />
the environmental impact of its operations. These standards are<br />
themselves manifestations of the total quality philosophy which lies<br />
at the heart of the Group’s corporate culture, and which is reflected<br />
in its Integrated Management System.<br />
The Integrated Management System is intended to increase<br />
productivity, to ensure that employees at every level personally<br />
identify with their work, and to fulfill social responsibilities while<br />
continuously striving to make additional progress in all these areas. A<br />
corporate intranet and system application product (SAP) applications<br />
are extensively used to enc<strong>our</strong>age and support integrated<br />
management system practices among all employees.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy carries out its operation within the framework of ISO<br />
9001: 2000 Quality Management System, ISO 14001 Environmental<br />
Management System, and OHSAS 18001 Occupational Health &<br />
Safety Assessment Series certifications.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy was the first auto producer in Turkey to receive quality<br />
certification. The Company’s quality system was first certified for<br />
full compliance with all criteria in 2001 by S&Q Mart-CERT with the<br />
issuance of its TS/EN ISO 9001: 2000 Quality Management System<br />
certificate. <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy received its OHSAS 18001 Occupational<br />
Health & Safety Assessment Series certificate and its ISO 14001<br />
Environmental Management System certificate, both from BVQI in<br />
2004.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group Environment Policy<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group regards the environment as an asset that it<br />
holds in trust for future generations. As a concomitant of its sense<br />
of social responsibility, the Group engages in activities to foster<br />
environmental awareness in order to create a more livable world.<br />
It conducts its activities within the framework of an environment<br />
management system whose basis is the conservation of natural<br />
res<strong>our</strong>ces and the environment.<br />
In line with this and in the conduct of all of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group’s<br />
activities:<br />
• Materials and technologies are chosen on the basis of their ability<br />
to minimize the adverse effects of their environmental impact.<br />
• Energy and natural res<strong>our</strong>ces are used in the most productive<br />
manner possible.<br />
• Systems are developed to prevent pollution from occurring at its<br />
potential s<strong>our</strong>ces.<br />
• All forms of waste and effluent (solid, liquid, gas) are kept under<br />
control and disposed of in ways that will not cause environmental<br />
harm.<br />
• National and international environmentally related laws and<br />
regulations are strictly complied with.<br />
• Group and subcontractor personnel are trained to increase their<br />
environmental awareness.<br />
• New investments are considered and analyzed from the<br />
standpoint of their environmental impact.<br />
• Greenhouse gas emissions are continuously followed and managed<br />
in order to minimize the impacts of global climate change.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy also demonstrates its environmental awareness<br />
through the advanced technological infrastructure that it employs<br />
and its activities aimed at promoting <strong>energy</strong> efficiency:<br />
• <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy has equipped all its power generation plants<br />
with water injection systems which ensure that nitrogen oxide<br />
(NOX) emissions are below prescribed limits. This system, which<br />
prevents thermal pollution of the atmosphere by transforming<br />
waste heat into steam, is just one example of the Company’s<br />
approach to environmentally friendly <strong>energy</strong> generation.<br />
Although the legally prescribed emission discharge limit for gas<br />
turbines is 80 mg/m 3 , <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy’s power plants are fitted<br />
with infrastructure which may reduce this to as low as 20 mg/<br />
m 3 . Even though all of the measurements conducted at <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Energy power plants exhibit values below the legally prescribed<br />
minimums, continuous efforts are undertaken to further reduce<br />
these numbers to lower levels.<br />
• A project was carried out at the Bursa Power Plant to make use<br />
of the heat contained in water released through the cooling<br />
system’s evaporation units and prevent it from being discharged<br />
into the atmosphere. As a result of this project, the first of its<br />
kind undertaken in Turkey, the plant generates an additional 1.5-<br />
2 MW of electricity. The technological infrastructure installed at<br />
the Bursa power plant enables the measurement and monitoring<br />
of the plant’s emissions from anywhere in Turkey over the<br />
internet.<br />
• <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy’s thermal power plants will begin to employ<br />
online flue gas measurement and monitoring systems with<br />
environmentally friendly technologies, which are new to the<br />
<strong>energy</strong> sector.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group Occupational Health and Safety Policy<br />
The question of the health and safety of the Group’s personnel is<br />
one of the fundamental issues to which <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group attaches<br />
priority to in the conduct of all of its activities. <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy has<br />
formulated and implemented both environment assessment and<br />
threat identification and risk assessment plans with respect to<br />
environmental and occupational safety wherever it is engaged in<br />
activities.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy also demonstrates<br />
its environmental awareness<br />
through the advanced technology<br />
infrastructure that it employs<br />
and its measures aimed at <strong>energy</strong><br />
efficiency.<br />
Page 32<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
The fundamental tenets of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group’s occupational<br />
health and safety policy are to prevent accidents in the conduct of<br />
operation, construction and maintenance activities, to cause no harm<br />
to people or to installations, and to take any measures necessary to<br />
meet these requirements. To this end, group companies:<br />
• Always identify dangers in advance and take measures with the<br />
participation of all employees against the risks of loss, accident, or<br />
damage in line with health and safety principles.<br />
• In order to reduce the adverse impact that their activities may<br />
have on human health, ensure that all employees, contractors,<br />
subcontractors and customers are aware of health and safety<br />
issues, and to this end, support them through training, cooperate<br />
with all organizations that are on the lookout for public interests.<br />
• Ensure that incidents and accidents are reported truthfully and that<br />
lessons are learned so as to prevent recurrences and to improve<br />
performance on such issues.<br />
• Reward those who make contributions to improvements in health<br />
and safety issues.<br />
• Ensure that the Emergency Management Plan is capable of<br />
operating at the highest level of performance.<br />
• Comply with the requirements of all current laws and regulations<br />
applicable to health and safety issues.<br />
• Check, review and improve occupational health and safety<br />
management system practices continuously and on a regular basis.<br />
• Consider occupational disorder and working safety factors of new<br />
plants and processes at the project stage.<br />
All <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy employees are aware of providing occupational<br />
health and safety and raising the Group’s performance in this field.<br />
Executives commissioned at all workplaces belonging to <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Energy are responsible for ensuring that this policy is applied within<br />
their own units, and for taking necessary action with respect to their<br />
own operations.<br />
Corporate Social Responsibility<br />
The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group addresses the matter of social responsibility<br />
along two axes: corporate responsibility and corporate social<br />
responsibility.<br />
The domain of corporate responsibility consists of all issues which<br />
involve the principles of corporate behavior, human rights, business<br />
conduct, the environment, and combating corruption and which are<br />
of direct concern to the Group’s activities. In this context, the UN<br />
Global Compact - to which <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding is a signatory – is given<br />
utmost consideration in all of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group’s activities.<br />
In 2009, the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group published its first Progress Report<br />
within the framework of the United Nations Global Compact. The<br />
report sets out efforts aimed at sustainability and practices carried<br />
out by the companies under the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group.<br />
The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group aims to ensure its back office operations are<br />
as green as possible. Having placed <strong>our</strong> concerns related to climate<br />
change as an integral part of all aspects of <strong>our</strong> corporate culture, we<br />
take measures to conserve <strong>energy</strong> and water, while also reducing the<br />
use of expendables such as paper. As well as reducing consumption,<br />
<strong>our</strong> Group also extensively practices recycling.<br />
Under the heading of corporate social responsibility, the Group seeks<br />
to create added value for society through solutions to environmental<br />
and social problems. Always keeping the public good firmly in sight<br />
in the fulfillment of <strong>our</strong> social responsibilities, we act as society<br />
expects us to, supporting projects which conform to the Group social<br />
responsibility strategy and which are based on models successfully<br />
employed in other countries.<br />
Given that <strong>energy</strong> efficiency and <strong>energy</strong> conservation are of the<br />
utmost concern to the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group in the area of social<br />
responsibility, the Group ensures such issues are a component of its<br />
environmentally related training and education activities. The <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Energy Group contributes to education through the Mehmet <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Foundation, awarding scholarship to 82 university students from<br />
disadvantaged economic backgrounds.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy planted 25,000 saplings and established a memorial<br />
forest of 3,000 trees in Osmaniye.<br />
The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group always takes the potential environmental<br />
and social impact of its activities into account wherever it invests.<br />
When formulating environmental and developmental projects,<br />
it seeks to give priority to places in which investments are to be<br />
undertaken. Projects to inform the general public are conducted,<br />
dealing with such issues as renewable <strong>energy</strong>, <strong>energy</strong> efficiency,<br />
<strong>energy</strong> conservation, environmental awareness and the preservation<br />
of natural assets. Under the heading of corporate communication<br />
activities, attention is paid to projects with substantial, enduring, and<br />
quantifiable social benefits.<br />
Children’s Communication Project<br />
Aware of its responsibilities and duties with respect to leaving a<br />
habitable and sustainable world for future generations, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
always stresses the importance of <strong>energy</strong> generation based on<br />
renewable <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces and strives to raise social awareness in<br />
this area.<br />
The Group developed the “Children’s Communication Project”<br />
in order to ensure that elementary students view <strong>energy</strong> as part<br />
of their daily lives, and to draw their attention to their individual<br />
responsibilities with respect to the efficient and effective use of<br />
<strong>energy</strong> by teaching them about <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces.<br />
The “Green Dragon” was created to help ensure children learn to<br />
respect nature and to raise their awareness of the world’s <strong>energy</strong><br />
bottleneck, by informing them of renewable <strong>energy</strong> res<strong>our</strong>ces,<br />
their importance and the advantage of <strong>energy</strong> produced by means<br />
of wind, and the book titled ‘Wind Energy with <strong>Zorlu</strong>’ which<br />
tells the story of entertaining cartoon characters and addresses<br />
elementary students. It is an initial step of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy’s Children<br />
Communication Project.<br />
In 2009, the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group published<br />
its first Progress Report within the<br />
framework of the United Nations<br />
Global Compact. The report sets out<br />
the efforts being undertaken by the<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group which are aimed<br />
at sustainability.<br />
Page 33<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group, People and the Environment<br />
The aim of the <strong>energy</strong> concept, which is explained from the<br />
perspective of the mascot standing for <strong>energy</strong>, is to simplify<br />
children’s anticipation of the issue and to adopt the idea.<br />
Corporate Communication Strategy<br />
The essential elements of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group’s corporate<br />
communication strategy are as follows:<br />
• Build on the Group’s corporate reputation.<br />
• Strengthen existing perceptions to bring them in line with desired<br />
perceptions and take action to ensure that they remain so.<br />
• Strengthen communication with all stakeholders.<br />
• Foster identification with corporate values, continuously<br />
strengthening the communication and sharing.<br />
• Undertake and meet social responsibilities in designated areas.<br />
• Engage in communication on a planned and continuous basis.<br />
In the public mind, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group enjoys a reputation for<br />
reliability, strength, and c<strong>our</strong>age that comes from the <strong>Zorlu</strong> name.<br />
The Group further strengthens this reputation by pointing to the<br />
social dimensions inherent in <strong>energy</strong> in the conduct of its business,<br />
in its communication activities, and by emphasizing that it is an<br />
organization which is widely trusted and recognized as an authority<br />
in the formulation and implementation of the national <strong>energy</strong> policy.<br />
Taking the ultimate objective in corporate communication activities<br />
beyond any existing positive perceptions, the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group<br />
ensures that it is recognized as<br />
an organization which is<br />
• Knowledgeable and experienced,<br />
• Pioneering, specialized and a point of reference in the sector,<br />
• Preferred,<br />
• Transparent, well managed and has corporate and social<br />
responsibilities; and a business partner which is<br />
• Respectful of the environment,<br />
• Trusted around the world; and an employer which<br />
• Attaches importance to the happiness of its employees in their<br />
public and private lives,<br />
• Contributes to the betterment and career progression of its<br />
personnel.<br />
Human Res<strong>our</strong>ces<br />
Believing that superior performance is a natural outcome of<br />
employee satisfaction, the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group bases its human<br />
res<strong>our</strong>ces policies on the tenets of:<br />
• Recruiting and hiring people with the qualities and talents needed<br />
to make effective use of developments in the <strong>energy</strong> sector in line<br />
with the Group’s aims,<br />
• Creating national and international career progression<br />
opportunities for its employees that will enable them to fully use<br />
their potential, develop their creativity and competency and improve<br />
their individual and team performance,<br />
• Support the work environment through effective communication<br />
and motivation.<br />
Within the framework of these principles, the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group<br />
strives to create a nimble, proactive organizational structure that will<br />
allow all group companies to achieve their goals and to formulate<br />
and implement human res<strong>our</strong>ces policies which are supported<br />
by feedback, thereby enhancing employee competency and<br />
productivity.<br />
These efforts are supported by a fair and competitive evaluation and<br />
compensation system which is based on the competencies required<br />
by the position, the qualities of the individual, job accountability<br />
as well as training and experience, and which seeks to achieve high<br />
levels of performance. At the same time, both professional and<br />
personal training sessions are provided with the aim of supporting<br />
the individual growth and development of <strong>our</strong> employees.<br />
The <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Group has 202 employees, 107 of whom hold<br />
university level and graduate degrees.<br />
Pursuing planned growth in line with its vision and goals, the <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Energy Group consistently diversifies and develops its corporate<br />
human res<strong>our</strong>ces practices in line with its growth. The Group plans<br />
to accelerate its efforts to implement the project “each director is a<br />
HR executive” in which company executives will also be included, to<br />
improve recruitment instruments and to broaden the scope of the<br />
management system so as to cover all group personnel by means<br />
of targets that have been regularly achieved since 2008, and to<br />
integrate these efforts into the performance management system, in<br />
order to increase the number of Human Res<strong>our</strong>ces Practices moved<br />
over to an electronic environment. The Group will also implement<br />
the individual rewarding system and internalize human res<strong>our</strong>ces<br />
processes.<br />
Planned communication activities, satisfaction surveys and<br />
evaluation interviews are conducted in order to increase employee<br />
communication and to foster an awareness of corporate citizenship<br />
among them. The Group believes that an awareness of corporate<br />
aims and of management decisions and practices is important<br />
in raising employee loyalty and supporting job performance. For<br />
this reason, all management decisions are disseminated among<br />
all employees through the Company’s internal communication<br />
channels.<br />
In the public mind, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
Group enjoys a reputation for<br />
reliability, strength, and c<strong>our</strong>age<br />
that stems from the <strong>Zorlu</strong> name.<br />
Page 34<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Corporate Governance<br />
Principles Compliance Report<br />
and Financial Information<br />
Page 35<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
Statement of Compliance with Corporate Governance Principles<br />
In parallel with the activities related to Corporate Governance commenced in 2005 at <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation, corporate<br />
governance mechanisms were started to be run across the Company. In the first phase of these activities, a series of amendments were made<br />
to the Company’s articles of incorporation so as to be able to offer an egalitarian, accountable, responsible and transparent structure to the<br />
shareholders. While these amendments served to grant the rights envisaged by the Corporate Governance Principles to minority shareholders,<br />
radical changes were made to the management structure in pursuance of “better governance”. Following the revisions made to the articles of<br />
incorporation, Corporate Governance practices were carried on with the establishment of Corporate Governance mechanisms at the Company.<br />
While the Board of Directors was vested in greater efficiency with independent members, it was aimed to further increase the efficacy in<br />
management by the Audit Committee set up under the Board of Directors.<br />
Activities undertaken in 2009 with a view to further increasing the compliance of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation are summarized below:<br />
• Investor Relations website has been further improved in line with the CMB Corporate Governance Principles.<br />
• From 01 January 2009, a “Follow-up” process has been introduced in Internal Audit reports in order to monitor the risks that were shared<br />
with the Board of Directors, During the process that was also approved by the Audit Committee, process owners were expected to follow up<br />
the risks indicated on the basis of the 4T approach; i.e.”Terminate”, “Tolerate”, “Treat”, and “Transfer”, using one or more of these elements in<br />
combination. Risk management approaches adopted and implemented accordingly have been regularly shared with the Board of Directors at<br />
appropriate intervals using follow-up reports.<br />
• “Corporate Principles Guide” which is prepared in order to establish the working principles for the directors and employees of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy<br />
Group of Companies, and of third parties with which the company cooperates, is at the stage of printing.<br />
In the implementation of Corporate Governance Principles, certain principles that do not conform to the Company’s structure and that are<br />
regarded as potential obstacles against its activities were excluded. These principles and the reasons for opting not to comply therewith are<br />
summarized below:<br />
• Cumulative voting: The Company does not implement cumulative voting method.<br />
However, the representation to be provided by cumulative voting on the Board of Directors is achieved by the presence of independent<br />
members on the Board.<br />
• The Company’s articles of incorporation contain no provisions stipulating that material decisions such as “demergers and share exchanges,<br />
buying, selling, or leasing substantial amounts of tangible/intangible assets, or donations and grants, or giving guarantees such as surety ship,<br />
mortgage in favor of third parties” are required to be taken at a general meeting. The underlying reason is that the nature of the sector in which<br />
the Company is active requires it to buy, sell, or lease quite frequently. Having to hold a general meeting every time such a transaction takes<br />
place is considered to be impossible and thus, no such article has been included in the articles of incorporation. This matter is not applied in<br />
order to ensure that deals are made quickly and to prevent opportunities from being missed.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy hereby espouses a transparent and open management style and aims to establish its approach to management that is responsible<br />
and accountable towards all of its shareholders in general and to its minority shareholders in particular.<br />
The new steps to be taken in time in keeping with Corporate Governance Principles will be publicly disclosed on the Company’s website.<br />
Page 36<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
PART I- SHAREHOLDERS<br />
1.1 Investor Relations Unit<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation carries out its relations with shareholders through <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group of Companies Investor Relations and<br />
Corporate Finance Department. Information for this department which carries out <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy’s relations with shareholders is as follows:<br />
Figen Çevik serves as the director of Corporate Finance and Investor Relations Unit.<br />
The Corporate Finance and Investor Relations Unit can be reached via the Company’s website; also it can be contacted at the phone number 0<br />
212 422 01 07 or by sending an email to yatirimci@zoren.com.tr. The direct phone line of the Corporate Finance and Investor Relations Unit also<br />
provides a continual means of access.<br />
The principal activities carried out by the Unit in 2009 are summarized below:<br />
TEB Investment, Investors Conference, Frankfurt<br />
TEB Investment, Investors Conference, London<br />
Ata Investment, Investors Conference, New York<br />
In addition to the above, about 30 one-on-one meetings.<br />
During the reporting period, the Unit received about 90 queries by e-mail and about 120 by telephone. All these queries were carefully<br />
responded to verbally and/or in writing within the framework of the Company’s public disclosure policy and in such a way so as not to reveal any<br />
trade secrets.<br />
1.2 Shareholder’s exercise of their right to obtain information<br />
During 2009, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Investor Relations Department received 210 queries from investors, all of which have been responded to in detail. The<br />
breakdown of these queries is presented below:<br />
Query by<br />
Number<br />
E-mail 90<br />
Fax -<br />
Letter -<br />
Phone 120<br />
Total 210<br />
The Investor Relations Unit provided detailed responses to all 210 queries received in 2009. Of the queries received by the Unit, 70% was related<br />
to operational and financial performance, 10% to share price, and the remaining 20% to various topics including investments, information on<br />
general meeting, etc.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy website and material event disclosures were the tools used in 2009 for the disclosure of developments that might have an impact<br />
on the shareholders’ exercise of their rights. Efforts have been completed in the first quarter of 2008, which were aimed at revamping the<br />
Company’s website so as to be able to communicate maximum amount of information in the shortest time possible and on the principles of<br />
timeliness, accuracy, completeness, and in a quick and intelligible manner. In these efforts, care has been paid to ensure that the website covers<br />
all of the considerations stated in the CMB’s Corporate Governance Principles.<br />
Page 37<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
During 2006 annual general meeting, an article regarding the appointment of a special auditor in the form of an amendment to the articles of<br />
incorporation has been presented to the shareholders. The said article read “Shareholders representing five percent of the Company’s publiclyheld<br />
shares may demand appointment of a special auditor for specific auditing of a certain material event. In the event such demand is rejected<br />
by the general assembly, shareholders representing at least one twentieth of the Company’s capitalization shall be entitled to request the<br />
appointment of a special auditor from a competent c<strong>our</strong>t for the examination and clarification of the predicament.” No request was made during<br />
the reporting period for the appointment of a special auditor.<br />
1.3 Information on general meetings<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation held its 2008 annual general meeting on 28 May 2009 at 13:30 at the address Organized Industrial Zone<br />
Pembe Cad. No: 13 Bursa.<br />
The invitation for the meeting including the meeting agenda has been made within due time as set out in the law and the Company’s articles of<br />
incorporation by being published in the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette issue 7305 dated 06 May 2009 and in the Dünya newspaper and Bursa<br />
Hakimiyet newspaper, both dated 05May 2009, for publicly- and privately-held shares, and also posted on the Company website accessible at<br />
www.zoren.com.tr.<br />
While the general meeting is open to the participation of stakeholders and the media, neither stakeholders nor the media representatives<br />
attended the meeting.<br />
Out of 8,166,535,000 shares corresponding to the Company’s total capitalization of TL 81,665,350; 5,310,550,437 shares representing TL<br />
53,105,504.37 in capital were present in person and 10,394,900 shares representing TL 103,949 in capital were present in proxy at the meeting.<br />
Accordingly, the meeting quorum set forth by the law and the Company’s articles of incorporation was secured.<br />
To facilitate participation of the holders of registered shares in the general meeting, no deadlines are set for registration in the shareholders’<br />
register.<br />
Prior to the general meeting, the annual report, financial statements, and the articles of incorporation were made available for the inspection of<br />
shareholders at the Company’s headquarters and at the address <strong>Zorlu</strong> Plaza 34310 Avcılar/İstanbul. All this information was also published on<br />
the corporate website together with the general meeting announcement and agenda.<br />
Shareholders were allowed to direct questions during the general meeting. All questions posed by shareholders were answered in detail by the<br />
related company managers.<br />
Shareholders introduced no motions during the meeting.<br />
The Company’s articles of incorporation contain no provisions requiring material decisions such as “demergers or buying, selling, or leasing<br />
substantial amounts of assets and property” to be taken at a general meeting. The reason for this is the fact that the nature of the sector in which<br />
the Company is active requires it to buy, sell, and lease quite frequently, and having to hold a general meeting every time such a transaction takes<br />
place is not deemed to be possible. Hence, it has been refrained from including such an article in the articles of incorporation.<br />
The minutes of the general meetings are made available for the examination of shareholders at the Company’s own headquarters and at the<br />
address <strong>Zorlu</strong> Plaza 34310 Avcılar/İstanbul. Additionally, all announcements, documents, and other materials related to general meetings are<br />
accessible to shareholders and to all other stakeholders on the Company’s website.<br />
Page 38<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
1.4 Voting rights and minority rights<br />
All of the shares of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation entail equal rights with respect to voting rights. There are no privileges with respect to<br />
voting rights or participation in dividends.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas Petroleum, Gas and Petrochemical Products, Construction, Industry and Trade Inc., Rotor Electric Power Production Inc., <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Hydroelectric Power Production Inc., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Geothermal Energy Electricity Generation Inc., Amity Oil International Pty. Ltd., Solbar Energy Ltd.,<br />
Dorad Energy Ltd., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Pakistan Limited, ICFS International LLC, Ashdod Energy Ltd., and Ramat Negev Energy Ltd., which are the<br />
investments of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation, do not have a stake in the Company.<br />
Due to the fact that the independent members on the Board of Directors have the capability to perform their duties without yielding to any<br />
influence, they equally protect and represent the rights of all shareholders including those of minority shareholders at the Board of Directors.<br />
The Company does not implement cumulative voting method.<br />
1.5 Dividend distribution policy and timing<br />
The Company’s shares provide no privileges concerning distribution of profits. Each share of stock is entitled to an equal dividend.<br />
The proposal for distribution of profits earned in 2008 covered in item 8 of the Company’s general meeting agenda was explained to the<br />
participants and was ratified at the General Meeting by majority of votes against one abstention.<br />
No dividend distribution was made due to the fact that the financial statements showed loss, which were drawn up according to the Capital<br />
Market Law, the Communiqué Serial: XI No: 25 concerning “Accounting Standards in the Capital Markets”, and the tax laws.<br />
At the 2008 General Meeting convened on 28 May 2009, the shareholders have been informed that the Company will continue to implement<br />
the dividend distribution policy set out by the Board of Directors decision dated 07 May 2007 and numbered 2007/9 that reads as follows<br />
pursuant to Article 5 of the CMB Communiqué Serial: IV, No: 27: “The Company will distribute dividends that are equal to minimum 25% of the<br />
attributable profit in cash or in the form of bonus shares to the shareholders in 2007 and in subsequent years, in line with the provisions of the<br />
articles of incorporation. The amount of dividends to be distributed shall be proposed depending on national and global economic conditions and<br />
the Company’s growth plan by the Board of Directors each year at the general meeting.”<br />
1.6 Transfer of shares<br />
The Company’s articles of incorporation contain provisions restricting the transfer of shareholding interests.<br />
Article 21 of the articles of incorporation reads “Shares in the Company may be freely transferred without prejudice to the provisions of the<br />
Turkish Commercial Code, CMB Legislation, EMRA Legislation, and these articles of incorporation”.<br />
Article 6, subparagraph 9 of the articles of incorporation reads “The approval of the EMRA will be obtained each time in case of share<br />
acquisitions which are concluded with acquiring the shares which represent five percent or more of the company capital by a real person or legal<br />
entity either directly or indirectly and exceeding five percent of the legal entity capital by the shares which belong to a shareholder and/or the<br />
share transfers which are concluded with decreasing the shares which belong to a shareholder below the above-stated rates or in similar other<br />
cases. This provision is also valid in case of pledging the shares by acquiring the voting right.”<br />
Article 21, subparagraph 4 of the articles of incorporation reads “Any transfer of at least 5% of the company’s registered shares requires the<br />
consent of the Energy Market Regulatory Authority (EMRA), pursuant to Article 6 of these articles of association and in line with EMRA<br />
regulations.”<br />
Page 39<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
PART II- PUBLIC DISCLOSURE AND TRANSPARENCY<br />
2.1 Company disclosure policy<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation’s disclosure policy has been formulated in 2005 in line with the CMB’s Corporate Governance Principles. The<br />
disclosure policy has been revised and publicly disclosed on 25 August 2009 by being published in the İstanbul Stock Exchange Daily Bulletin<br />
and the Company’s website (www.zoren.com.tr).<br />
The issues addressed by the Company’s public disclosure policy are summarized below:<br />
• The clarity, timeliness, and truthfulness of public disclosures<br />
• The contents of public disclosures<br />
• The frequency and the ways in which information may be publicly disclosed<br />
• Disclosure tools<br />
• Individuals authorized to make disclosures<br />
• Relations of Board members and executives with the media<br />
• Meetings with investors<br />
• Disclosures to be made to the press and media<br />
• Disclosure of Future-Oriented Information<br />
• Prohibited Disclosure / Quiet Period<br />
• Effectiveness of the website<br />
• Follow-up news, rumors and speculations<br />
• Designating individuals with administrative responsibility<br />
• Maintaining confidentiality of insider information<br />
The disclosure policy has been approved by the board of directors. The Board of Directors is responsible for monitoring, reviewing and improving<br />
the disclosure policy. The Investor Relations Unit, which is planned to be set up, will be responsible for the supervision and monitoring of the<br />
disclosure policy.<br />
2.2 Disclosure of material events<br />
During 2009, the Company made a total of 55 material event disclosures, which were sent to the CMB and the ISE. Additional information<br />
was requested by the ISE for two of the disclosures made and by the CMB for three others, upon which necessary explications were provided<br />
forthwith. The Investor Relations Unit is responsible for the disclosure of material events.<br />
Since the Company is not quoted on any overseas stock exchange, the disclosures made were limited to Turkey.<br />
2.3 The corporate website and its content<br />
The Company has an easily accessible and active website. The website covers all of the information listed in Article 1.11.5 of Section II of the<br />
CMB’s Corporate Governance Principles, as well as information which are not addressed in Section II but are of significance with respect to<br />
Corporate Governance Principles.<br />
The corporate website is accessible at the address www.zoren.com.tr and its content is kept up-to-date.<br />
Page 40<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
2.4 Disclosure of the Company’s ultimate controlling shareholder(s)<br />
The shareholding structure of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Co. Inc. is presented below:<br />
SHAREHOLDERS SHAREHOLDING INTEREST (%) NOMINAL SHARE VALUE (TL‘000)<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. 41.2 115,898<br />
Korteks 17.5 49,425<br />
Publicly held 32.0 90,080<br />
Others 9.3 26,262<br />
Total 100.0 281,665<br />
The shareholding structure of the parent company, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding Co. Inc., is presented below<br />
SHAREHOLDERS SHAREHOLDING INTEREST (%) NOMINAL SHARE VALUE (TL‘000)<br />
Ahmet Nazif <strong>Zorlu</strong> 47 1,482,850<br />
Olgun <strong>Zorlu</strong> 32 1,009,600<br />
Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong> 15 473,250<br />
Türkan <strong>Zorlu</strong> 1 31,550<br />
Zülal <strong>Zorlu</strong> 1 31,550<br />
Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong> Melik 1 31,550<br />
Fatma Şehenaz Çapkınoğlu 1 31,550<br />
Şehminur Aydın 1 31,550<br />
Mehmet Emre <strong>Zorlu</strong> 1 31,550<br />
Total 100 3,155,000<br />
2.5 Public disclosure of those who may have access to insider information<br />
• <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation formulated a policy on insider trading to be enforced internally, as well as for achieving compliance with the<br />
Capital Market Law and applicable legislation.<br />
• The list of the personnel with regular access to internal data is prepared by the Investor Relations Directorate pursuant to CMB’s Communique<br />
Serial VIII No.54 and updated whenever there is a change. The individuals recorded in the list are re-notified in writing by obtaining their<br />
signature on the subject of obligations defined in the relevant legislation and the sanctions applicable in case of abusive use and improper<br />
distribution of such data. The individuals in the list are not authorized to disclose the internal data to other parties, including their family<br />
members, before its official release to public; they cannot make comments and declare opinion on the undisclosed internal data relating to<br />
Company’s shares. If an opinion is declared or disclosure is made to the third parties about the internal data, the Company shall immediately<br />
make a material event disclosure on the subject.<br />
PART III- STAKEHOLDERS<br />
3.1 Keeping stakeholders informed<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation redesigned its website so as to keep stakeholders informed on matters concerning them, and made available<br />
all kinds of information relating to the Company in line with the Corporate Governance Principles. In addition, the Company has the intranet<br />
system to keep employees informed, whereby the information on the Company can be accessed subject to limits of authorization. All kinds of<br />
information geared towards employees are provided in detail on the intranet.<br />
With respect to keeping customers and suppliers informed, informative meetings are organized as and when such requests are received from<br />
them.<br />
Page 41<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
One-to-one or collective meetings are held with investors and brokers, if so requested thereby.<br />
3.2 Stakeholder participation in management<br />
Stakeholders do not participate in the management. However, importance is attached to ensure participation of employees in the Board meetings<br />
at certain intervals, so as to offer them the chance to voice their opinions directly. There is no model designed to involve other stakeholders in the<br />
management.<br />
3.3 Human res<strong>our</strong>ces policy<br />
The HR policy is devised to cover the recruitment, promotion, dismissal, training, performance appraisal and compensation systems.<br />
The training activities to be carried out for the purpose of supporting professional and personal development of employees are structured;<br />
the Training Catalogue was prepared which offers the employees the chance to choose training programs in line with their needs. Designed to<br />
monitor all the training activities in parallel with career plans, the training portal went live.<br />
There is no representative assigned to conduct the Company-employee relationships. Upon appointment, independent members will represent<br />
employees along with all other stakeholders in the Board of Directors.<br />
The employees are treated equally and without any discrimination whatsoever in all matters involving training, career development, promotion,<br />
etc. No complaints have been received from the employees regarding discrimination.<br />
3.4 Relations with customers and suppliers<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation gives utmost importance to customer satisfaction. The requests of customers are responded to within the<br />
shortest time possible, and all res<strong>our</strong>ces are put into immediate action for resolution of problems forthwith.<br />
Also the Customer Care Unit has been set up to ensure customer satisfaction. The Unit mostly extends technical and financial support.<br />
Intermediary services are also offered in relation to the problems the customers experience with the regulatory authorities such as the EMRA and<br />
the Treasury. In line with the EMRA regulation, the customers’ counters have been replaced by the Company and modems have been installed to<br />
enable remote monitoring of counters.<br />
Because the Company is not in direct relationship with its customers, customer satisfaction is predominantly related to the high level of discount<br />
rates.<br />
3.5 Social responsibility<br />
In all of its activities, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy carefully takes into consideration the United Nations Global Compact which is signed by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding and<br />
which covers all Group companies.<br />
During 2009, the Company had all necessary legal examinations carried out concerning environmental impact of all its establishments and<br />
projects. Environmental impact of all projects is reviewed. According to environmental impact reports, no violations of environmental protection<br />
have been established to date and all of the Company’s practices are carried out with a keen eye on the environment factor.<br />
Page 42<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
In addition, environmental and social impacts are monitored in all activities, and efforts are spent to develop projects aimed at enhancing the<br />
quality of life of the local people. For example, with respect to its environmental impact Gökçedağ Wind Power Plant is regularly monitored, bird<br />
migrations are followed-up, and various projects involving the local people are launched. Mehmet <strong>Zorlu</strong> Foundation granted scholarships to 82<br />
local students attending university. In addition to a memorial forest of 3000 saplings, a forestation effort for planting 25,000 saplings was put in<br />
place in the field.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy gives priority to raise <strong>energy</strong> awareness among the children and parallel to it the Company started publishing a series of children’s<br />
books. The initial book titled <strong>Zorlu</strong> ile Rüzgar <strong>Enerji</strong>si (Wind Energy with <strong>Zorlu</strong>) will be followed by other books related to renewable <strong>energy</strong><br />
s<strong>our</strong>ces. In addition, the Company will commence educational activities in order to educate the local elementary school students on renewable<br />
<strong>energy</strong> s<strong>our</strong>ces, <strong>energy</strong> efficiency and saving, and raising their awareness on these topics.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy places much importance on making sure that its projects become an integral part of the locality and are owned by the local people.<br />
To achieve this, the Company organizes gatherings and meetings to inform the local people in relevant regions before launching the projects.<br />
During the meeting held for Gökçedağ Wind Power Plant, detailed information has been provided to the local people, while their opinions and<br />
expectations were also found out.<br />
During the investment phase, two broad-based surveys were conducted in the region by research companies. The Social Status Survey and<br />
Manpower Survey were conducted which provided insight into the socio-economic status of the people in Bahçe and Hasanbeyli districts and<br />
21 villages affiliated, where the power plant is located. The results from the surveys were shared with the public in meetings organized by the<br />
Environment Foundation of Turkey. Attended by the NGO, academics, scientists, local administrators and a large local crowd, the meeting served<br />
as a platform for discussion of the types of projects that would respond to the real needs of the people.<br />
In this frame, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation has completed the accreditation for ISO 14001 environmental management system certificate.<br />
The company proactively takes environmental aspects into consideration in all of its activities.<br />
The Company also holds ISO 14001 Environmental Management System, ISO 9001:2000 Quality Management System and OHSAS 18001<br />
Occupational Health and Safety System certificates relating to the protection of the environment.<br />
In 2009, the Company caused no harm to the environment and no lawsuits were lodged against the Company on account of environmental<br />
damage.<br />
PART IV- BOARD OF DIRECTORS<br />
4.1 Structure and composition of the Board of Directors and independent members<br />
The Board of Directors of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation is composed of seven members. Almost all of the Board members are nonexecutive<br />
members.<br />
Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong>, the chairman of the Board, serves as a non-executive member.<br />
Page 43<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
The chairman of the Board and chief executive officer are different individuals.<br />
Member Position Classification<br />
Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong> Chairman of the Board of Directors Non-executive<br />
Elmas Melih Araz Vice Chairman of the Board of Directors Non-executive<br />
Murat Sungur Bursa Member Executive<br />
Olgun <strong>Zorlu</strong> Member Non-executive<br />
Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong> Melik Member Executive<br />
Aziz Can Tuncay Member Non-executive<br />
Burak İsmail Okay Member Non-executive<br />
In keeping with Corporate Governance, two independent members have been elected to the Board of Directors which is composed of seven<br />
members in total.<br />
Independent members satisfy the independence criteria set forth in the CMB’s Corporate Governance Principles Communiqué.<br />
No restrictions are imposed on Board members’ undertaking one or more duties outside the Company.<br />
4.2 Qualifications of Board members<br />
As a result of the amendment made to the articles of incorporation, minimum qualifications required of the Board members are now incorporated<br />
in the articles of incorporation. Qualifications that are included in the articles of incorporation fully coincide with those stipulated in articles 3.1.1,<br />
3.1.2 and 3.1.5 of Section IV of the CMB’s Corporate Governance Principles.<br />
4.3 Mission, vision and strategic goals of the Company<br />
The mission and vision of the Company have been spelled out and publicly disclosed by the Board of Directors.<br />
Mission: Be the leading power in Turkey and a regional power in the world in all segments of the <strong>energy</strong> sector.<br />
Vision: Generate and distribute safe, quality, environmentally-compatible and sustainable <strong>energy</strong>; create value for <strong>our</strong> shareholders, customers<br />
and employees based on effective, market- and customer-focused activities.<br />
The Board of Directors approves the strategic goals formulated by executives.<br />
The Board of Directors of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation takes care to obtain the opinions and suggestions of the relevant units while setting<br />
the strategic goals. Suggestions relating to strategic goals are reported to the Board of Directors and work is undertaken so as to implement<br />
these goals as soon as possible. The extent to which the goals are attained is measured by monitoring the results on the basis of activities<br />
quarterly when financial statements are drawn up and at year-end. Once a year, the Board of Directors conducts an annual review of the degree<br />
to which the Company has accomplished its objectives, as well as its activities and past performance.<br />
Page 44<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
4.4 Risk management and internal control mechanism<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Board of Directors uses the SAP system at the Company for purposes of risk management and internal<br />
control. The SAP system enables running/recording of all integrated work processes on computer systems at the establishments, thus increasing<br />
the speed and productivity of the relevant establishment. The system also gives employees and managers access to all kinds of information and<br />
reports that concern them in line with the scopes of their authorizations.<br />
In addition, a program has been created on the Company’s intranet system for monitoring problems related to internal control, which is<br />
effectively operated. Any issue that arises at any level is referred to the relevant manager and resolved.<br />
The Board of Directors of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation defined existing and potential risks and formulated the policies in relation to the<br />
same.<br />
4.5 Authorities and responsibilities of Board members and executives<br />
The authorities and responsibilities of Board members are defined in the articles of incorporation.<br />
The authorities and responsibilities of the Board of Directors, which are also covered in the articles of incorporation, are stated below:<br />
• Defining and publicly disclosing the Company’s mission and vision, and monitoring and supervising the accomplishment of the targets set;<br />
• Representing the Company before shareholders and third parties, formulating the Company principles therefore;<br />
• Approving the Company’s annual budget and business plans;<br />
• Observing the compliance of the Company’s activities to applicable legislation, articles of incorporation and internal regulations;<br />
• Ensuring that the Company books are duly kept;<br />
• Drawing up the Company’s balance sheet and profit and loss statements, preparing the annual report, and making the same available for<br />
examination by shareholders prior to the general meeting;<br />
• Submitting a proposal to the general assembly concerning the distribution of profit;<br />
Page 45<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
• Summoning the general assembly for ordinary or extraordinary meeting and satisfying the procedure related to general meetings;<br />
• Overseeing that the decisions passed by shareholders at general meetings are enforced;<br />
• Setting the rules to be complied with by the Company employees, including the code of ethics;<br />
• Formulating and publicly disclosing the Company’s public disclosure policy;<br />
• Setting up the committees that will function under the Board of Directors, electing their members, defining their operating principles, and<br />
ensuring that they operate effectively and productively;<br />
• Taking into consideration the recommendations of the Corporate Governance Committee in relation to the Company’s senior executives.<br />
4.6 Operating principles of the Board of Directors<br />
Agendas for Board meetings are determined by the chairman and the members of the Board of Directors. Requests received from executives are<br />
taken into consideration in determining the agenda items.<br />
During 2009, the Board of Directors met 29 times, and all decisions were passed unanimously.<br />
In line with Corporate Governance Principles, a secretariat has been set up under the Board of Directors at the Company. The secretariat is<br />
responsible for keeping the minutes of the Board meetings and archiving them. The secretariat also keeps the Board members informed in<br />
a timely and simultaneous manner and delivers the agenda and related information and reports to the Board members at least one week in<br />
advance of each meeting.<br />
It has been decided that difference of opinions that may be voiced at Board meetings and detailed justifications for dissenting votes must be<br />
entered into the record and forwarded to statutory auditors in written form; however, to date there has never been such an instance. Upon<br />
approval of the articles of incorporation at the general meeting, justifications for dissenting votes cast by independent members by reason of<br />
difference of opinions will be publicly disclosed on the corporate website.<br />
It is made sure that the Board members are personally present at Board meetings that will vote on the issues stipulated in article 2.17.4 of Section<br />
IV of the CMB’s Corporate Governance Principles as requiring the actual attendance of Board members at meetings.<br />
No Board members, including the chairman, have weighted voting and/or vetoing rights. Each member, including the chairman, possesses an<br />
equal vote.<br />
4.7 Prohibition on doing business or competing with the Company<br />
The agenda item concerning <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Board members’ doing business or competing with the Company is laid down for<br />
the approval of shareholders each year at the general meetings.<br />
No board member did any business or competed with the Company during the year.<br />
If any event occurs relating to the prohibition of doing business and competing with the Company, any conflict of interest that might arise there<br />
from will be publicly disclosed within the frame of Corporate Governance Principles.<br />
4.8 Code of Ethics<br />
The Company’s code of ethics has been spelled out in writing and made known to the employees. Utmost care is given to ensure compliance with<br />
the code of ethics that is formulated for the Board of Directors, the Company and its employees.<br />
Page 46<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Corporate Governance Principles Compliance Report<br />
4.9 Number, structure and independence of the committees established by the Board of Directors<br />
Pursuant to article 3 of the CMB Communiqué Serial: X, No: 19, the Board of Directors established the Audit Committee so as to ensure healthy<br />
oversight of financial and operational activities. The Corporate Governance Committee has not been set up as yet. However, with the election<br />
of independent members to the seats on the Board of Directors, it is planned to establish the Corporate Governance Committee chaired by an<br />
independent head in line with the CMB’s Corporate Governance Principles. Within the frame of this plan, the detailed operating principles of the<br />
Committee are formulated in writing.<br />
The detailed work plans of the Audit Committee and the Corporate Governance Committee are put into writing.<br />
The Audit Committee is composed of two individuals: Melih E. Araz and Olgun <strong>Zorlu</strong>. Melih E. Araz, who is an independent Board member,<br />
serves as the head of the Audit Committee.<br />
The articles of incorporation stipulate that the Audit Committee must meet at least f<strong>our</strong> times a year (once in each quarter). The Board<br />
secretariat is responsible for recording the decisions made, and keeping the minutes of the meetings held by the Audit Committee.<br />
The Committee carries out its activities in accord with the detailed operating principles put into writing.<br />
4.10 Financial benefits provided to the Board of Directors<br />
The attendance fees to be paid to the members of the Board of Directors are determined at the general meeting. In 2009, the members of the<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation Board of Directors were paid TL 60,000 in total, which is commensurate with precedents in the sector. The<br />
statutory auditors were paid TL 2,580 a year each.<br />
There is no performance measurement for the Board members. No rewarding system reflecting the Company’s performance has been set up.<br />
The Company has extended no loans or credits to any Board member or manager.<br />
Profit Distribution Policy<br />
Under a resolution passed at a meeting of the Board of Directors of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Electricity Generation held at the Company headquarters on 7<br />
May 2007, it has been decided to distribute at least 25% of the Company’s net distributable profits, including 2007 profits, to shareholders in<br />
accordance with the dividend policy specified by the Board as cash payments or in the form of shares of stock. At the Ordinary General Meeting<br />
convened on 28 May 2009, the General Assembly has been informed that the said decision of 07 May 2007 concerning profit distribution<br />
policy will continue to be implemented as it is. The amount of dividend to be paid is to be recommended by the Board of Directors at the ordinary<br />
general meeting of shareholders that is held every year on the basis of national and international economic conditions and the company’s growth<br />
plans.<br />
Page 47<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Statutory Auditor’s Report Summary<br />
TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF ZORLU ENERJİ ELEKTRİK ÜRETİM A.Ş.<br />
Title of Association<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Center<br />
Organize Sanayi Bölgesi Pembe Cad. No: 13 Bursa<br />
Capital TL 281,665,350<br />
Field of Activity<br />
Electricity and steam production<br />
Auditor(s) name, period in office,<br />
being partner or company’s personnel<br />
Şerif Arı – 1 Year Hakan Eştürk– 1 Year<br />
not partner nor personnel<br />
Number of Board Meetings 4-6<br />
and Audit Commission meetings<br />
Content of audit, audit dates and result<br />
Number and results of counting’s which has been<br />
performed on association’s cashier desk in<br />
accordance with Turkish Trade Law’s 353rd<br />
article’s 1st anecdote’s 3rd definition<br />
Audit dates and results that has been performed in<br />
accordance with Turkish Trade Law’s 353rd<br />
article’s 1st anecdote’s 4th definition<br />
Complaints or frauds perceived, and<br />
legal proceedings<br />
In the audits made on the legal books and documents of the company, it has<br />
been concluded that records are kept fairly and accurately in compliance with<br />
accounting rules and principles.<br />
Cashier’s desk counting was made f<strong>our</strong> times and it was resolved that stocks are<br />
in compliance with the records.<br />
There are no securities delivered by mortgage or guarantee or bailment to<br />
company according to the monthly audits<br />
There are no complaints or frauds perceived.<br />
We have audited the accounts and transactions of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. at the period of 01.01.2009-31.12.2009 in accordance with<br />
Turkish Trade Law, association’s primary agreement, other regulations and general accounting principles.<br />
In <strong>our</strong> opinion, the financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of association as of 31 December 2009 and<br />
the dividend distribution proposal is in accordance with general laws and association’s primary agreement. We present approval of the Balance<br />
Sheet and the Income Statement and acquittance of Board of Directors.<br />
Şerif ARI<br />
Auditor<br />
Hakan EŞTÜRK<br />
Auditor<br />
Page 48<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Resolution of the Board of Directors<br />
RESOLUTION DATE : 07.05.2010<br />
RESOLUTION NO : 2010/12<br />
PARTICIPANTS<br />
MEETING AGENDA<br />
: Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Elmas Melih Araz<br />
Olgun <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong> Melik<br />
Murat Sungur Bursa<br />
Aziz Can Tuncay<br />
Burak İsmail Okay<br />
: approval of the 2009 annual report<br />
The Board of Directors of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim Anonim Şirketi convened at the company’s headquarters under the chairmanship of Mr.<br />
Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong> and discussed the subjects on the agenda and adopted the below-mentioned resolutions.<br />
The Board of Directors who convened for the meeting decided unanimously to accept the 2009 Annual Report, which has been presented to the<br />
Board of Directors and is attached hereto, and to make the report available to shareholders.<br />
BOARD OF DIRECTORS<br />
Zeki <strong>Zorlu</strong> Elmas Melih Araz Olgun <strong>Zorlu</strong> Selen <strong>Zorlu</strong> Melik<br />
Chairman Vice Chairman Board Member Board Member<br />
Murat Sungur Bursa Aziz Can Tuncay Burak İsmail Okay<br />
Board Member Board Member Board Member<br />
Page 49<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Independent Auditor’s Report<br />
To The Shareholders and Board of Directors of<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
We have audited the accompanying statement of consolidated financial position of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. (the “Company”) and its<br />
subsidiaries listed under note 1 (the “Group”), as at 31 December 2009, and the consolidated statements of income, the consolidated statements<br />
of comprehensive income, changes in equity and cash flow for the year then ended and a summary of significant accounting policies and other<br />
explanatory notes.<br />
Management’s responsibility for the financial statements<br />
Management is responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of these financial statements in accordance with International Financial<br />
Reporting Standards. This responsibility includes: designing, implementing and maintaining internal control relevant to the preparation and fair<br />
presentation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, selecting and applying appropriate<br />
accounting policies; and making accounting estimates that are reasonable in the circumstances.<br />
Auditor’s responsibility<br />
Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these financial statements based on <strong>our</strong> audit. We conducted <strong>our</strong> audit in accordance with<br />
International Standards on Auditing. Those standards require that we comply with ethical requirements and plan and perform the audit to obtain<br />
reasonable assurance whether the financial statements are free from material misstatement.<br />
An audit involves performing procedures to obtain audit evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. The procedures<br />
selected depend on the auditor’s judgment, including the assessment of the risks of material misstatement of the financial statements, whether<br />
due to fraud or error. In making those risk assessments, the auditor considers internal control relevant to the entity’s preparation and fair<br />
presentation of the financial statements in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances but not for the purpose of<br />
expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the entity’s internal control. An audit also includes evaluating the appropriateness of accounting<br />
policies used and the reasonableness of accounting estimates made by management as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the<br />
financial statements.<br />
Page 50<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Independent Auditor’s Report<br />
We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for <strong>our</strong> audit opinion.<br />
Opinion<br />
In <strong>our</strong> opinion the consolidated financial statements present fairly in all material respects, the consolidated financial position of the Group as<br />
at 31 December 2009 and of its consolidated financial performance and its consolidated cash flows for the year then ended in accordance with<br />
International Financial Reporting Standards.<br />
EREN Bağımsız Denetim ve Yeminli Mali Müşavirlik A.Ş.<br />
Member Firm of GRANT THORNTON International<br />
Aykut Halit<br />
Partner<br />
Istanbul, 08.04.2010<br />
Page 51<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Statements of Consolidated Financial Position at 31 December 2009 and 2008<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Assets Note 2009 2008<br />
Current assets<br />
Cash and cash equivalents 7 43.191 7.574<br />
Trade receivables 8 192.562 122.447<br />
Inventories 9 6.948 39.162<br />
Other assets 10 103.236 148.852<br />
Total current assets 345.937 318.035<br />
Non-current assets<br />
Financial assets 11 830 7.626<br />
Exploration and evaluation assets 12 27.981 22.426<br />
Property, plant and equipment 13 1.977.641 1.574.056<br />
Intangible assets 14 36.523 635.725<br />
Other assets 167 --<br />
Deferred tax asset 19 18.803 30.654<br />
Total non-current assets 2.061.945 2.270.487<br />
Total assets 2.407.882 2.588.522<br />
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.<br />
Page 52<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Statements of Consolidated Financial Position at 31 December 2009 and 2008<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Liabilities and equity Note 2009 2008<br />
Current liabilities<br />
Borrowings 15 532.087 337.769<br />
Trade payables 16 176.512 147.369<br />
Taxation on income 19 990 9.389<br />
Provision for expenses 17 1.175 2.696<br />
Other liabilities 18 10.712 12.742<br />
Total current liabilities 721.476 509.965<br />
Non-current liabilities<br />
Borrowings 15 849.352 1.458.787<br />
Trade payables 16 126.181 56.089<br />
Employee termination benefits 20 1.251 2.388<br />
Other liabilities 18 428.554 527.337<br />
Deferred tax liability 19 57.446 34.054<br />
Total non-current liabilities 1.462.784 2.078.655<br />
Equity<br />
Share capital 21 392.613 192.613<br />
Translation reserve (18.988) (28.654)<br />
General reserves (163.432) (247.491)<br />
Equity attributable to owners of the parent 210.193 (83.532)<br />
Minority interest 13.429 83.434<br />
Total equity 223.622 (98)<br />
Commitments and contingencies 22 -- --<br />
Total liabilities and equity 2.407.882 2.588.522<br />
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.<br />
Page 53<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Statements of Consolidated Income for the Years Ended 31 December 2009 and 2008<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Note 2009 2008<br />
Continuing operations<br />
Revenue 547.389 531.291<br />
Cost of sales (419.710) (426.951)<br />
Gross profit 127.679 104.340<br />
Selling expenses (-) (6.570) (7.477)<br />
General and administrative expenses (-) (30.588) (41.759)<br />
Other income 24 186.031 2.679<br />
Other expense (-) 24 (14.525) (12.408)<br />
Operating profit 262.027 45.375<br />
Financing income 25 394.349 427.547<br />
Financing expense (-) 25 (515.626) (551.449)<br />
Profit (loss) before taxation 140.750 (78.527)<br />
Taxation on income (-) 19 (6.461) (41.691)<br />
Profit (loss) from continuing operations for the year 134.289 (120.218)<br />
Discontinued operations<br />
Loss from discontinued operations (net of income tax) 27 (37.463) (152.191)<br />
Net profit (loss) for the year 96.826 (272.409)<br />
Net profit (loss) attributable to:<br />
Equity holders of the Company 89.595 (333.186)<br />
Minority interest 7.231 60.777<br />
Earnings (loss) per share (TL, full) 6 0,01 (0,04)<br />
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.<br />
Page 54<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Statements of Consolidated Comprehensive Income for the Years Ended 31.12.2009 and 2008<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
2009 2008<br />
Profit (loss) for the year 96.826 (272.409)<br />
Translation differences 12.470 (44.416)<br />
Other comprehensive income (loss) 12.470 (44.416)<br />
Total comprehensive income (loss) for the year 109.296 (316.825)<br />
Attributable to:<br />
Equity holders of the Company 99.261 (361.045)<br />
Minority interest 10.035 44.220<br />
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.<br />
Page 55<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Statements of Consolidated Changes in Equity for the Years Ended 31.12.2009 and 2008<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Share Translation General Total attributable to Minority Total<br />
capital reserve reserves owners of parent interest equity<br />
Balance at 01 January 2008 192.613 (795) 76.511 268.329 47.487 315.816<br />
Changes in minority interest -- -- 9.184 9.184 (9.184) --<br />
Cash increase in subsidiaries share capital -- -- -- -- 911 911<br />
Transactions with owners 192.613 (795) 85.695 277.513 39.214 316.727<br />
Net loss for the year -- -- (333.186) (333.186) 60.777 (272.409)<br />
Other comprehensive loss:<br />
Translation differences -- (27.859) -- (27.859) (16.557) (44.416)<br />
Total comprehensive loss for the year -- (27.859) -- (27.859) (16.557) (44.416)<br />
Balance at 31 December 2008 192.613 (28.654) (247.491) (83.532) 83.434 (98)<br />
Cash increase in share capital 200.000 -- -- 200.000 -- 200.000<br />
Changes in minority interest -- -- (1.894) (1.894) 1.894 --<br />
Cash increase in subsidiaries share capital -- -- -- -- 1.346 1.346<br />
Disposal of subsidiaries -- -- -- -- (83.318) (83.318)<br />
Consolidated subsidiary as from 01 January-1.2 -- -- (3.642) (3.642) 38 (3.604)<br />
Transactions with owners 392.613 (28.654) (253.027) 110.932 3.394 114.326<br />
Net profit for the year -- -- 89.595 89.595 7.231 96.826<br />
Other comprehensive income:<br />
Translation differences -- 9.666 -- 9.666 2.804 12.470<br />
Total comprehensive income for the year -- 9.666 -- 9.666 2.804 12.470<br />
Balance at 31 December 2009 392.613 (18.988) (163.432) 210.193 13.429 223.622<br />
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.<br />
Page 56<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Statements of Consolidated Cash Flows for the Years Ended 31.12.2009 and 2008<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Note 2009 2008<br />
Profit (loss) before taxation from continuing operations 140.750 (78.527)<br />
Loss before taxation from continued operations (36.314) (169.089)<br />
Adjustment to reconcile profit (loss) before taxation to net<br />
cash provided from operating activities: 29 706 137.702<br />
Operating profit (loss) before changes in working capital 105.142 (109.914)<br />
Changes in operating assets and liabilities<br />
Trade receivables (220.562) (107.628)<br />
Inventories (3.751) (5.360)<br />
Other assets (2.761) (89.114)<br />
Trade payables 288.311 133.666<br />
Other liabilities 109.014 234.953<br />
Payments of employee termination benefits (1.144) (375)<br />
Net cash provided by operating activities 274.249 56.228<br />
Cash flows from investing activities<br />
Purchases of property, plant and equipment 13 (717.602) (735.842)<br />
Proceeds from sale of property, plant and equipments 1.391 415<br />
Purchases of intangible assets 14 (1.644) (603.018)<br />
Purchases of exploration and evaluation assets 12 (9.884) (8.377)<br />
Natural gas drilling expenses 1.356 2.761<br />
Net cash used in investing activities (726.383) (1.344.061)<br />
Cash flows from financing activities<br />
Cash increase in share capital 200.000 --<br />
Changes in financial assets (12.060) 14.462<br />
Proceeds from sale of subsidiaries 85.281 --<br />
Cash increase in subsidiaries share capital 1.346 911<br />
Proceeds from borrowings 530.174 1.731.783<br />
Repayments of borrowings (265.187) (382.437)<br />
Interest paid (123.590) (24.133)<br />
Interest received 33.111 2.378<br />
Net cash provided by financing activities 449.075 1.342.964<br />
Translation differences 39.189 (58.209)<br />
Net increase (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents 36.130 (3.078)<br />
Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of year 7 7.061 10.139<br />
Cash and cash equivalents at end of year 7 43.191 7.061<br />
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.<br />
Page 57<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
1. ORGANISATION AND NATURE OF ACTIVITIES<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. (the “Company” or “<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong>”) is a member of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group of Companies which is under the control<br />
of the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Family. The Company and its subsidiaries were established to meet the <strong>energy</strong> requirements of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group and other industrial<br />
companies.<br />
The Company is registered with Capital Market Board and its shares have been quoted at the Istanbul Stock Exchange (“ISE”) since 2000. As of<br />
31.12.2009, the composition of shareholders and their respective percentage ownership are summarized as follows:<br />
Shareholding %<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. 41,2<br />
Korteks Mensucat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. 17,5<br />
Shares open to the public (ISE) 32,0<br />
Other shareholders 9,3<br />
The registered office address of the Company is Nilüfer Organize Sanayi Bölgesi, Pembe Caddesi, No: 13 Bursa/Turkey.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Group of companies; their field of activities and countries of operation are listed below:<br />
Company Field of activity Country<br />
Electricity, steam production and maintenance services<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. Production of electricity and steam Turkey<br />
Rosmiks International B.V. Financial services Holland<br />
Rosmiks LLC Production of electricity Russia<br />
ICFS International LLC Financial services USA<br />
Rotor Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. Production of electricity Turkey<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Hidroelektrik <strong>Enerji</strong> Üretim A.Ş. Production of electricity Turkey<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Jeotermal Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. Production of electricity Turkey<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd. Production of electricity Pakistan<br />
Bundoran Financial Corporation Financial services BVI<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Rüzgar <strong>Enerji</strong>si Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. Production of electricity Turkey<br />
Natural gas extraction and distribution services<br />
Amity Oil International Pty. Ltd. Natural gas drilling and exploration Turkey<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas, Petrol, Gaz ve Petrokimya Ürünleri İnşaat Sanayii A.Ş. Natural gas drilling and exploration Turkey<br />
As of 31 December 2009, the number of personnel employed was 328 (31.12.2008: 891).<br />
The financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2009 (including comparatives) were approved by the board of directors on<br />
08.04.2010.<br />
100,0<br />
Page 58<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
1.1. ELECTRICITY SEGMENT<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. (Bursa/Turkey) – <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy was established in 1993 for the purpose of generating electricity and steam. The<br />
total capacity of the Company’s f<strong>our</strong> natural gas combined cycle plants and two cogeneration plants are as follows:<br />
Type of License Validity Steam Electricity Production capacity<br />
Field of Activity power plant start date of license production capacity production/power per year KW/H<strong>our</strong><br />
Bursa Natural gas 07.09.2004 25 years -- 90,0 MW 756.864.000<br />
Ankara Natural gas 07.09.2004 25 years -- 50,3 MW 423.003.000<br />
Kayseri Natural gas 07.09.2004 25 years -- 188,5 MW 1.585.210.000<br />
Kırklareli Natural gas 07.09.2004 25 years 162 t/s 115,3 MW 856.000.000<br />
Yalova Natural gas 21.07.2005 15 years 30 t/s 15,9 MW 133.713.000<br />
Total 192 t/s 460 MW 3.754.790.000<br />
The Company sells 74% of its products to Türkiye Elektrik Dağıtım A.Ş. (“TEDAŞ”), 21% to group companies (note 26) and remaining 5% to<br />
third parties.<br />
On 20 June 2007, The Company acquired two hydroelectric power plant licenses from EPDK, construction of these two plants has not yet<br />
started, in Denizli and Muğla regions with capacities of 127,8 MW and 82,5 MW respectively for 49 years.<br />
Rosmiks International B.V. (“Holland”) - This company was established in 2006 for the purpose of providing financial support to two <strong>energy</strong> plant<br />
projects in Russia with a capacity of 340 MW and 2.500.00 Gcal/year and owns 100% of Rosmiks LLC.<br />
Rosmiks LLC (“Russia”) - Rosmiks LLC was established for the purpose of building and operating two <strong>energy</strong> plants respectively in “Kozukhovo”<br />
and “Tereskhova” regions in Russia with a capacity of 340 MW and 2.500.000 Gcal/year each. Rosmiks LLC started these projects around mid<br />
2007 and plans to complete them in year 2010 and operate them thereafter.<br />
ICFS International LLC (“The United States of America”) - ICFS was established in the USA in 2005 and owns 100% of Rosmiks International BV<br />
established in Holland.<br />
Rotor Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) - Rotor was established for the purpose of building wind power plants and was acquired by <strong>Zorlu</strong><br />
Energy Group in 2007.<br />
Rotor has obtained “Wind Energy Power Plant License” from EMRA for the construction of a wind power plant (52 wind turbines) with a 135 MW<br />
capacity in Osmaniye and commenced its construction in July 2008. As of the balance sheet date, 23 wind turbines with a capacity of 57,5 MW<br />
and as of 31 March 2010 additional 15 wind turbines with a capacity of 37,5 MW have started electricity production. The management plans to<br />
complete the remaining 16 wind turbines with a capacity of 40 MW by 30 April 2010.<br />
In accordance with the Board of Directors decision dated 16.11.2009 and numbered 2009/9 Rotor has transferred to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Rüzgar <strong>Enerji</strong>si<br />
Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. its license which was obtained for 25 years for the construction of two wind <strong>energy</strong> power plants in different regions of<br />
Osmaniye with a capacity of 50 MW and 60 MW.<br />
Page 59<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Hidroelektrik <strong>Enerji</strong> Üretim A.Ş. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) - <strong>Zorlu</strong> Hidroelektrik was established in 2007 for the purpose of building hydroelectric<br />
power plants and other power plants based on renewable <strong>energy</strong> s<strong>our</strong>ces.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Jeotermal Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) – <strong>Zorlu</strong> Jeotermal was established in 2008 to develop projects for <strong>energy</strong> power plants,<br />
especially hydroelectric and thermal power plants based on all forms of renewable <strong>energy</strong> s<strong>our</strong>ces to produce <strong>energy</strong>, steam and heat.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Jeotermal has taken over of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas Alaşehir Geothermal license on 30 July 2009.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd. (“Karachi/Pakistan”) <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Limited was incorporated on 13 September 2007 as an unlisted public<br />
limited company. The sole object for establishment of the company is to set up a project for electric power generation through wind. The<br />
principal activity of the company is to generate and sell electric power. Power generation plant is situated at Nooriabad Jhimpir Link Road, near<br />
HESCO Grid Station, Jhimpir, with a capacity of 1,2 MW of each 5 and 1,5 MW of each 29 wind <strong>energy</strong> power plants. Three wind <strong>energy</strong> power<br />
plants of the first phase have started production.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Rüzgar <strong>Enerji</strong>si Elektrik Üretim A.Ş., (“<strong>Zorlu</strong> Rüzgar”)<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Rüzgar was established in 2009 to develop projects for <strong>energy</strong> power plants, based especially on wind power and other forms of renewable<br />
<strong>energy</strong> s<strong>our</strong>ces to produce electricity, steam and heat.<br />
1.2. NATURAL GAS SEGMENT<br />
Amity Oil International Pty. Ltd. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) - Amity Oil is a company established in Australia but is solely engaged in petroleum and<br />
natural gas exploration and production through its only branch in Turkey.<br />
Amity Oil has continued its exploration, drilling and production activities with 4 exploration licenses and 1 operation license in the Thrace region<br />
in 50% - 50% partnership with Türkiye Petrolleri Anonim Ortaklığı (“TPAO”). Amity Oil also has 1 fully owned exploration licenses in the Thrace<br />
region and 1 in Adana region.<br />
Amity Oil sells all of its natural gas to Trakya Doğal Gaz produced in 24 wells licensed in the region (Göçerler, Çayırdere, Adatepe, Doğu Adatepe,<br />
Velimeşe, Batı Velimeşe, Eskitaşlı, Reisdere and Dikilitaş) with TPAO and the other 3 wells’ natural gas to TPAO.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas, Petrol, Gaz ve Petrokimya Ürünleri İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) – <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas, Petroleum, Gas and<br />
Petrochemical Products, Construction Company was established in 2000 to engage in natural gas distribution, petroleum and petrochemical<br />
production as well as marketing of petroleum and natural gas.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas has seven exploration licenses in the Marmara Petroleum Region two of which are owned in partnership with companies named<br />
Çalık <strong>Enerji</strong> Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. “Çalık” and Maya Petrol Gaz Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. “Maya”; the partnership shares of the two licenses are 25%,<br />
25% and 50% respectively for Çalık, Maya and the Company. In addition <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas has three exploration licenses in the İzmir Petroleum<br />
Region nr: XVII and two exploration licenses in the Muğla Petroleum Region nr: XVIII, thus bringing the total number of licenses to twelve.<br />
2. BASIS OF PRESENTATION OF THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS<br />
The financial statements of the Group have been prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (“IFRS”) as developed<br />
and published by the International Accounting Standards Board (“IASB”).<br />
Page 60<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
The Company, which is quoted at the Istanbul Stock Exchange, maintains its books of account and prepares its statutory financial statements<br />
in accordance with the Turkish Commercial Code, accounting policies prescribed by the Turkish Capital Markets Board and tax legislation and<br />
since 1994 has adopted the Uniform Chart of Accounts issued by the Ministry of Finance (collectively “Turkish Practices”). Its subsidiaries<br />
which are incorporated in Turkey maintain their books of account and prepare their statutory financial statements in accordance with the<br />
Turkish Commercial Code and Tax Legislation and the Uniform Chart of Accounts issued by the Ministry of Finance. The foreign subsidiaries<br />
maintain their books of account and prepare their statutory financial statements in their local currencies and in accordance with the regulations<br />
of the countries in which they operate. The financial statements of overseas subsidiaries are converted into Turkish Lira (TL) by closing rate<br />
method. The consolidated financial statements have been prepared from statutory financial statements of the Company and its subsidiaries<br />
and presented in Turkish Lira (TL) with adjustments and reclassifications for the purpose of fair presentation in accordance with IFRS. Such<br />
adjustments mainly comprise deferred taxation, employee termination benefits, fixed assets and borrowing costs, receivables, interest expense<br />
accruals on bank loans.<br />
Measurement currency and reporting currency<br />
The financial statements have been prepared under the historical cost convention, other than financial assets which are stated at fair value.<br />
According to the law numbered 5083 related to the currency of Republic of Turkey and the decision of the Council of Ministers dated<br />
04.04.2007 numbered 2007/11963 the expression of “new” has been cancelled on New Turkish Lira and New Kurush effective from 01.01.2009.<br />
After this conversion 1 New Turkish Lira is held equal to 1 Turkish Lira and 1 New Kurush is held equal to 1 Kurush. All laws, legislations,<br />
administrative and legal transactions, c<strong>our</strong>t decisions, commercial papers and all kind of documents referencing New Turkish Lira will be<br />
considered in Turkish Lira with the conversion rate mentioned above. Beginning from 01.01.2009, in the presentation of financial statements<br />
New Turkish Lira has been replaced by Turkish Lira. In the attached financial statements, this conversion has been made retrospectively for<br />
convenience purposes.<br />
Standards, amendments and interpretations to existing standards that are not yet effective and have not been adopted early by the Company<br />
At the date of authorisation of these financial statements, certain new standards, amendments and interpretations to existing standards have<br />
been published but are not yet effective, and have not been adopted early by the Company.<br />
a) Standards, amendments and interpretations effective in July 2009:<br />
• IAS 27, (Amendments) “Consolidated and Separate Financial Statements”<br />
• IAS 28, “Investments in Associates”<br />
• IAS 31, “Interest in Joint Ventures” “Application of the Purchase Method”<br />
• IAS 38, (Amendments) “Intangible Assets”<br />
• IFRS 3, (Revised) “Business Combinations”<br />
• IFRIC 17, “Distributions of Non-cash Assets to Owners”<br />
b) Standards, amendments and interpretations effective in January 2010 but not early adopted by the Company:<br />
• IAS 1, (Amendments) “Presentation of Financial Statements”<br />
• IAS 24, “Related Party Disclosures”<br />
• IFRS 2, (Amendments) “Share Based Payment”<br />
• IFRS 5, (Amendments) “Non-Current Assets Held For Sale And Discontinued Operations”<br />
• IFRS 9, “Financial Instruments: Classification and Measurement”<br />
Page 61<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Management of the Group anticipates that all of the pronouncements detailed in (a) and (b) above will be adopted in the Group’s accounting<br />
policy for the first period beginning after the effective date of the pronouncement. Management of the Group has decided that these new<br />
standards and interpretations have been issued but are not expected to have a material impact on the Company’s financial statements.<br />
Comparable financial information and reclassification of prior period financial statements<br />
The balance sheets with the accompanying notes as of 31.12.2009 and 31.12.2008 and statement of income, cash flow and changes in equity<br />
with the accompanying notes for the year ended 31.12.2009 and 31.12.2008 are presented as comparatively.<br />
As of 31.12.2008, Group’s statement of income and its related notes are restated for the accounting and presentation of IFRS 5 “Non current<br />
Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued Operations”.<br />
Critical accounting estimates, assumptions and judgments<br />
The preparation of financial statements in conformity with IFRS requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect reported<br />
amounts of assets and liabilities and disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the financial statements, and the reported<br />
amounts of revenues and expenses during the reporting period. Actual results could differ from these estimates. These estimates are reviewed<br />
periodically and as adjustments become necessary they are reported in earnings in the periods in which they become known.<br />
The key assumption concerning the future and other key s<strong>our</strong>ces of estimation uncertainty at the balance sheet date and the significant<br />
judgments are set out below:<br />
- Allowance for doubtful debts reflect the amount set aside for the losses in the future related to receivables which exist the balance sheet<br />
date but which, in the opinion of the management carry the risk of collection due to current economic conditions. When evaluating whether<br />
receivables has suffered a loss in value the past performance of the debtors, their credibility in the market and their performance between the<br />
balance sheet date and report date together with changed circumstances are taken in the considerations. In addition the collaterals existing<br />
at balance sheet date together with new collaterals obtained between the balance date and report date are also taken into consideration. The<br />
allowance for doubtful receivables as of the balance sheet dates are explained under note 8.<br />
-When setting aside the provision for legal claims the probability of losing the related case and the results expected to be suffered in the event<br />
that the legal counsel of the Group and management of the Group make their best estimates to calculate the provision required.<br />
- Property, plant and equipment and intangible assets held for use in the production or supply of goods or services, or for administrative<br />
purposes, are stated in the balance sheet at cost, less any subsequent accumulated depreciation and subsequent accumulated impairment<br />
losses. The Group estimates that the useful lives of tangible and intangible assets. Depreciation is charged using the straight line basis over the<br />
useful lives which depend on the best estimation of the management. Useful lives of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets are<br />
reviewed at each balance sheet dates and make changes if necessary.<br />
- As explained in note 3 Natural gas exploration/evaluation expenses are costs directly associated with exploration are capitalized under<br />
“Exploration and evaluation assets” until the reserves are evaluated. If it is determined that commercial discovery has not been achieved, these<br />
costs are charged to expense. Once commercial reserves are found, exploration and evaluation assets are tested for impairment and transferred<br />
to “Natural gas drilling cost” account and depreciation and/or amortization is charged during the exploration and evaluation phase. Depreciation<br />
is charged using the straight line basis over the useful lives using the unit-of-production method which depend on the best estimation of the<br />
management. Useful lives of natural gas reserves are reviewed at each balance sheet date and changes are made if necessary.<br />
Page 62<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
- Deferred tax assets are accounted for only where it is likely that related temporary differences and accumulated losses will be recovered<br />
through expected future profits. When accounting for deferred tax losses it is necessary to make important estimations and evaluations with<br />
regard to taxable profits in the future periods. As mentioned under note 19 the related companies of the Group included in the consolidated<br />
statements have taxable losses of TL 74.796 (2008: TL 134.314) carried forward to future periods and deferred tax assets have been calculated<br />
on basis of the expectation that taxable profits will be created in future periods.<br />
Offsetting<br />
Financial assets and liabilities are offset and the net amount reported in the balance sheet when there is a legally enforceable right to set off the<br />
recognized amounts and there is an intention to settle on a net basis or realize the asset and settle the liability simultaneously.<br />
3. SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES<br />
The significant accounting policies followed in the preparation of the accompanying financial statements are summarized below:<br />
Basis of consolidation<br />
The consolidated financial statements incorporate the financial statements of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> and entities controlled by <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong>. Control is<br />
achieved where the Company has the power to govern the financial and operating policies of an entity so as to obtain benefits from its activities.<br />
For the purpose of consolidated financial statements <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> and its subsidiaries will be referred to collectively as the “Group”.<br />
2009 2008<br />
Ownership Economic Ownership Economic<br />
Consolidated companies interest (%) interest (%) interest(%) interest (%)<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> O/M <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İşletme ve Bakım Hizmetleri A.Ş. -- -- 40,0 24,0<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong> Üretim A.Ş. -- -- 99,0 97,2<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İnşaat Ticaret A.Ş. -- -- 20,0 20,0<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas, Petrol, Gaz, Petrokimya Ürünleri İnşaat Sanayii ve Ticaret A.Ş. 73,0 73,0 100,0 78,2<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong>si İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. -- -- 3,0 2,2<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğalgaz İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. -- -- 3,0 2,2<br />
Trakya Bölgesi Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. -- -- 30,0 10,2<br />
Gazdaş Gaziantep Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. -- -- 30,0 10,2<br />
Amity Oil International Pty. Ltd. 100,0 100,0 100,0 100,0<br />
Rosmiks International B.V. 100,0 51,0 100,0 51,0<br />
Rosmiks LLC 100,0 51,0 100,0 51,0<br />
ICFS International LLC 51,0 51,0 51,0 51,0<br />
Rotor Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. 85,0 83,7 95,0 86,1<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Hidroelektrik <strong>Enerji</strong> Üretim A.Ş. 85,0 83,7 95,0 86,1<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Jeotermal Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. 73,0 73,0 100,0 78,2<br />
Bundoran Financial Corporation 100,0 100,0 100,0 100,0<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd. 100,0 100,0 -- --<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Rüzgar <strong>Enerji</strong>si Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. 85,0 83,7 -- --<br />
Page 63<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
In accordance with the Board of Directors decision dated on 23.06.2009 and numbered 2009/15, the management of Group had decided to<br />
sell its shares of <strong>Zorlu</strong> O/M <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İşletme ve Bakım Hizmetleri A.Ş., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong> Üretim A.Ş., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong><br />
Tesisleri İnşaat Ticaret A.Ş., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong> İthalat İhracat A.Ş., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğalgaz İthalat İhracat A.Ş., Trakya Bölgesi Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. and<br />
Gazdaş Gaziantep Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş.. Therefore, IFRS 5 has been applied in the presentation of these companies as of the dates on which the<br />
effective control ceased (note 27).<br />
The balance sheet and income statement of the subsidiaries are consolidated on a line by line basis, and the carrying value of the investment<br />
held by the Company is eliminated against related equity and reserves accounts.<br />
The results of subsidiaries acquired or disposed of during the year are included in the consolidated income statement from the effective date of<br />
acquisition or up to the effective date of disposal as appropriate.<br />
All intra-group transactions, balances, income and expenses are eliminated on consolidation.<br />
Minority interests in the net assets of consolidated subsidiaries are identified separately from the Group’s equity therein. Minority interests<br />
consist of the amount of those interests at the date of the original business combination and the minority’s share of changes in equity since the<br />
date of the combination. Losses applicable to the minority in excess of the minority’s interest in the subsidiary’s equity are allocated against the<br />
interests of the Group except to the extent that the minority has a binding obligation and is able to make an additional investment to cover the<br />
losses.<br />
The Company has always exercised effective control over the management of each of the companies included in the group consolidation.<br />
Business combinations<br />
The acquisition of subsidiaries is accounted for using the purchase method. The cost of the acquisition is measured at the aggregate of the fair<br />
values, at the date of exchange, of assets given, liabilities incurred or assumed, and equity instruments issued by the Group in exchange for<br />
control of the acquire, plus any costs directly attributable to the business combination. The acquirer’s identifiable assets, liabilities and contingent<br />
liabilities that meet the conditions for recognition under IFRS 3 are recognized at their fair values at the acquisition date.<br />
Goodwill arising on acquisition is recognized as an asset and initially measured at cost, being the excess of the cost of the business combination<br />
over the Group’s interest in the net fair value of the identifiable assets, liabilities and contingent liabilities recognized. If, after reassessment,<br />
the Group’s interest in the net fair value of the acquirer’s identifiable assets, liabilities and contingent liabilities exceeds the cost of the business<br />
combination, the excess is recognized immediately in profit or loss.<br />
The interest of minority shareholders in the acquire is initially measured at the minority’s proportion of the net fair value of the assets, liabilities<br />
and contingent liabilities recognized.<br />
Page 64<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Foreign currency translations<br />
Foreign currency transactions and translation - Transactions in foreign currencies during the period have been translated into TL at the exchange<br />
rates prevailing at dates of these transactions. Balance sheet items denominated in foreign currencies have been translated at the exchange<br />
rates prevailing at the balance sheet dates. Exchange gains or losses arising from settlement and translation of foreign currency items have been<br />
included in the income or expense accounts as appropriate.<br />
The foreign exchange rates used by the Company are as follows:<br />
2009 2008<br />
US Dollar 1,5057 1,5123<br />
EUR 2,1603 2,1408<br />
Foreign entities - Foreign consolidated subsidiaries are regarded as foreign entities since they are financially, economically and organizationally<br />
autonomous. Their reporting currencies are the respective local currencies. Financial statements of foreign consolidated subsidiaries are<br />
translated at year-end exchange rates with respect to the balance sheet and at exchange rates at the dates of the transactions with respect to the<br />
income statement. All resulting translation differences between the closing balances and opening balances due to the difference in inflation and<br />
devaluation are included in currency translation adjustment in equity.<br />
Property, plant and equipment<br />
Property, plant and equipment held for use in the production or supply of goods or services, or for administrative purposes, are stated in the<br />
balance sheet at cost, restated in equivalent purchasing power at 31 December 2005 less any subsequent accumulated depreciation and<br />
subsequent accumulated impairment losses.<br />
The carrying values of property, plant and equipment are reviewed for impairment when events or changes in circumstances indicate the carrying<br />
value may not be recoverable. If any such indication exists and where the carrying values exceed the estimated recoverable amount, the assets or<br />
cash-generating units are written down to their recoverable amount. The recoverable amount of property, plant and equipment is the greater of<br />
net selling price and value in use. In assessing value in use, the estimated future cash flows are discounted to their present value using a pre-tax<br />
discount rate that reflects current market assessments of the time value of money and the risks specific to the asset. For an asset that does not<br />
generate largely independent cash inflows, the recoverable amount is determined for the cash-generating unit to which the asset belongs.<br />
Property, plant and equipment in the c<strong>our</strong>se of construction for production, rental or administrative purposes, or for purposes not yet determined,<br />
are carried at cost, less any identified impairment loss. Cost includes professional fees and, for qualifying assets, borrowing costs capitalized in<br />
accordance with the Company’s accounting policy. Depreciation of these assets, on the same basis as other property assets, commences when<br />
the assets are ready for their intended use.<br />
Depreciation is charged so as to write off the cost or valuation of assets, other than land and properties under construction, over their estimated<br />
useful lives, using the straight line basis over the following years stated below:<br />
Useful life<br />
Land improvements 25 – 30<br />
Buildings 25 – 30<br />
Leasehold improvements 3 – 5<br />
Plant and machinery 17 – 25<br />
Motor vehicles 3 – 5<br />
Furniture and fixtures 3 – 10<br />
Page 65<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Assets held under finance leases are depreciated over their expected useful lives on the same basis as owned assets or, where shorter, the term<br />
of the relevant lease. The gain or loss arising on the disposal or retirement of an asset is determined as the difference between the sales proceeds<br />
and the carrying amount of the asset and is recognized in income.<br />
Leases<br />
Finance lease - Assets held under finance leases are recognized as assets of the Company at their fair value at the date of acquisition. The<br />
corresponding liability to the Company is included in the balance sheet as a finance lease obligation. Finance costs, which represent the<br />
difference between the total leasing commitments and the fair value of the assets acquired, are charged to the income statement over the term<br />
of the relevant lease so as to produce a constant periodic rate of interest on the remaining balance of the liability for each accounting period.<br />
Operating lease - Leases of assets under which all the risks and rewards of ownership are effectively retained by the lessor are classified as<br />
operating leases. Lease payments on operating lease are recognized as an expense on a straight-line basis over the lease term.<br />
Intangible assets<br />
Purchased intangible assets - Intangible assets acquired separately are reported at cost less accumulated amortisation and accumulated<br />
impairment loss. Amortisation is charged on as straight line basis over their useful live. The estimated useful life and amortisation method are<br />
reviewed at the end of each annual reporting period, with the effect of any changes in estimate being accounted for on a prospective basis.<br />
The useful lives of intangible assets are as follows:<br />
Useful life<br />
Wind <strong>energy</strong> production rights 25<br />
Natural gas drilling rights 20<br />
Hydroelectric <strong>energy</strong> production rights 30<br />
Thermal <strong>energy</strong> production rights 29<br />
Other intangible assets- Other intangible assets including information systems, development expense of information systems and other<br />
determinable rights, are capitalized and amortized on a straight line basis over their estimated useful lives, not exceeding a period of 5 years.<br />
Impairment of intangible assets – Where an indication of impairment exists, the carrying amount of any intangible asset is assessed and written<br />
down immediately to its recoverable amount.<br />
Natural gas exploration expenses<br />
Exploration and evaluation assets - Costs directly associated with exploration are capitalized until the evaluation of reserves. If it is determined<br />
that commercial discovery has not been achieved, these costs are charged to expense (note 12).<br />
Capitalisation is made within property, plant and equipment or intangible assets according to the nature of the expenditure. Once commercial<br />
reserves are found, exploration and evaluation assets are tested for impairment and transferred to development tangible and intangible assets<br />
and depreciation and/or amortization is charged during the exploration and evaluation phase.<br />
Development tangible and intangible assets- Expenditure on the construction, installation or completion of infrastructure facilities, such as<br />
platforms, pipelines and the drilling of commercially proven development wells, is capitalized within tangible and intangible assets according<br />
to nature. When development is completed on a specific field, it is transferred to property, plant and equipment and/or intangible assets.<br />
Depreciation and/or amortization are charged during the exploration and evaluation phase.<br />
Page 66<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Depreciation/amortization - Natural gas properties/intangible assets related to commercially proven development wells are depreciated/<br />
amortized using the unit-of-production method. Unit-of-production rates are based on proved developed reserves, which are oil, gas and other<br />
mineral reserves estimated to be recovered from existing facilities using current operating methods.<br />
Impairment – exploration and evaluation assets - An impairment loss is recognized for the amount by which the exploration and evaluation<br />
assets’ carrying amount exceeds their recoverable amount. The recoverable amount is the higher of the exploration and evaluation assets’ fair<br />
value less costs to sell and their value in use.<br />
Inventories<br />
Inventories are stated at the lower of cost and net realizable value. Costs comprise direct materials and, where applicable, direct lab<strong>our</strong> costs<br />
and those overheads that have been incurred in bringing the inventories to their present location and condition but excludes borrowing cost.<br />
Cost is calculated by using the weighted average method. Net realizable value represents the estimated selling price less all estimated costs to<br />
completion and costs to be incurred in marketing, selling and distribution.<br />
Impairment<br />
The carrying amounts of the Group’s assets are reviewed at each balance sheet date to determine whether any indication of impairment exists. If<br />
any such indication exists, the asset’s recoverable amount is estimated and an impairment loss is recognised in the income statement whenever<br />
the carrying amount of the asset exceeds its recoverable amount.<br />
Related parties<br />
Parties are considered to be related if one party has the ability to control the other party or exercise significant influence over the other party<br />
in making the financial and operating decisions. For the purpose of these financial statements shareholders are referred to as related parties.<br />
Related parties also include individuals that are principle owners, management and members of the Group’s Board of Directors and their families.<br />
Revenue recognition<br />
Revenue is recognized to the extent that it is probable that the economic benefits will flow to the Group and the revenue can be reliably<br />
measured. Revenue is shown net of value added and sales taxes, discounts and returns. Revenue from the rendering of services is recognized by<br />
reference to the stage of completion of the transaction when the following conditions are met:<br />
• the amount of revenue can be measured reliably,<br />
• the flow of economic benefits to the entity is probable,<br />
• the stage of completion at the period end can be measured reliably and<br />
• the costs incurred to date can be measured reliably.<br />
Revenue for services provided initially is measured at the fair value of the consideration receivable. Expenses is included in operating expenses<br />
at cost unless the expense was permitted or required to be included in the financial statements on another basis. Cost is the fair value of the<br />
consideration given for the materials or services used in the production of goods or provision of services. Cost of sales is presented as a separate<br />
line item on the face of the income statement for the functional analysis of expenditures is chosen for the format of the income statement.<br />
Other revenues earned by the Group are recognized on the following bases:<br />
Rental income – on an accrual basis.<br />
Interest income – on an effective yield basis.<br />
Page 67<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Borrowing cost<br />
Borrowing cost directly attributable to the acquisition, construction or production of qualifying assets, which are assets that necessarily take<br />
a substantial period of time to get ready for their intended use or sale, are added to the cost of those assets, until such time as the assets are<br />
substantially ready for their intended use or sale. Borrowing costs of qualifying assets are not added to the cost of those assets for the period<br />
during which construction to get them ready for their intended use or sale is suspended. Investment income earned on the temporary investment<br />
of specific borrowings pending their expenditure on qualifying assets is deducted from the cost of those assets. Other borrowing costs are<br />
expensed in the period in which they are incurred and reported in “financing expense”.<br />
Bank borrowings<br />
Interest-bearing bank loans and overdrafts are recognized at fair value at initial recognition which equate to the proceeds received, net of direct<br />
issue costs. Finance charges, including premiums payable on settlement or redemption, are accounted for on an accruals basis and are added to<br />
the carrying amount of the instrument to the extent that they are not settled in the period in which they arise.<br />
Discontinued operations and non current assets held for sale<br />
Discontinued operation is a major line of business or geographical area of operations that is part of a single co-ordinated plan to dispose of or is<br />
held for sale.<br />
Net assets related to the discontinued operations are measured at fair value less cost to sell. A single amount on the face of the income<br />
statements comprising the total of the post-tax profit or loss of discontinued operations and post-tax gain or loss recognised on the disposal<br />
of the assets constituting the discontinued operation is disclosed. Also, the net cash flows of the discontinued operations associated with the<br />
operating, investment and financing activities are disclosed in note 27.<br />
Group of assets and liabilities are classified as held for sale if their carrying amount will be recovered principally through a sale transaction, not<br />
through continuing use. Liabilities directly associated with those assets are also classified similarly. Disposal group assets are measured at the<br />
lower of its carrying amount after deduction of the liabilities directly associated with those assets and its fair value less costs to sell.<br />
Income taxes<br />
Tax expense (income) is the aggregate amount included in the determination of net profit or loss for the period in respect of current and deferred<br />
tax.<br />
Deferred income tax is provided, using the liability method, on all temporary differences at the balance sheet date between the tax bases of<br />
assets and liabilities and their carrying amounts for financial reporting purposes. Deferred income tax liabilities are recognized for all taxable<br />
temporary differences.<br />
The carrying amount of deferred income tax assets is reviewed at each balance sheet date and reduced to the extent that it is no longer probable<br />
that sufficient taxable profit will be available to allow all or part of the deferred income tax asset to be utilized.<br />
Deferred income tax assets and liabilities are measured at the tax rates that are expected to apply to the period when the asset is realized or the<br />
liability is settled, based on tax rates (and tax laws) that have been enacted or substantively enacted at the balance sheet date.<br />
Employee termination benefits<br />
Under Turkish lab<strong>our</strong> law, the Group and its Turkish subsidiaries are required to pay termination benefits to each employee who has completed<br />
one year of service and whose employment is terminated without due cause, or who retires in accordance with social insurance regulations or is<br />
called up for military service or dies.<br />
Page 68<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Provisions<br />
Provisions are recognized when the Group has a present obligation (legal or constructive) as a result of a past event, it is probable that an outflow<br />
of res<strong>our</strong>ces embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation and a reliable estimate can be made of the amount of the<br />
obligation. Where the Group expects a provision to be reimbursed, for example under an insurance contract, the reimbursement is recognized as<br />
a separate asset but only when the reimbursement is virtually certain.<br />
Financial assets<br />
Financial assets other than hedging instruments are divided into the following categories:<br />
• available-for-sale financial assets<br />
• held-to-maturity investments.<br />
Financial assets are assigned to the different categories on initial recognition, depending on the characteristics of the instrument and its purpose.<br />
A financial instrument’s category is relevant for the way it is measured and whether any resulting income and expenses is recognized in profit or<br />
loss or directly in equity.<br />
Generally, the Group recognizes all financial assets using settlement day accounting. An assessment of whether a financial asset is impaired<br />
is made at least at each reporting date. All income and expense relating to financial assets are recognized in the income statement line item<br />
“finance costs” or “finance income”, respectively.<br />
Available-for-sale financial assets are non-derivative financial assets that do not qualify for inclusion in any of the other categories of financial<br />
assets. The Group’s available-for-sale financial assets include unconsolidated investments. Unconsolidated investments which are not quoted at<br />
any stock exchange are reported at cost less any impairment charges, as its fair value can currently not be reliably estimated.<br />
Gains and losses arising from financial instruments classified as available-for-sale are only recognized in profit or loss when they are sold or<br />
when the investment is impaired. In the case of impairment, any loss previously recognized in equity is transferred to the income statement.<br />
Losses recognized in the income statement on equity instruments are not reversed through the income statement but charged to equity. Losses<br />
recognized in prior period consolidated income statements resulting from the impairment of debt securities are reversed through the income<br />
statement, if the subsequent increase can be objectively related to an event occurring after the impairment loss was recognized in profit or loss.<br />
Held-to-maturity investments are non-derivative financial assets with fixed or determinable payments and fixed maturity. Investments are<br />
classified as held-to-maturity if it is the intention of the Group’s management to hold them until maturity. The Group currently holds time<br />
deposits that fall into this category.<br />
Held-to-maturity investments are subsequently measured at amortized cost using the effective interest method. In addition, if there is objective<br />
evidence that the investment has been impaired, the financial asset is measured at the present value of estimated cash flows. Any changes to the<br />
carrying amount of the investment are recognized in profit or loss.<br />
Trade receivables<br />
Trade receivables are measured at initial recognition at fair value and are subsequently measured at amortized cost using the effective interest<br />
rate method to set an allowance for unearned interest. Appropriate allowances for estimated irrecoverable amounts are recognized in profit or<br />
loss when there is objective evidence that the asset is impaired. The allowance recognized is measured as the difference between the asset’s<br />
carrying amount and the present value of estimated future cash flows discounted at the effective interest rate computed at initial recognition.<br />
Page 69<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Trade payables<br />
Trade payables are initially measured at fair value and are subsequently measured at amortized cost using the effective interest rate method to<br />
set an allowance for unearned interest.<br />
Recognition and derecognition of financial instruments<br />
The Company recognizes a financial asset or financial liability in its balance sheet when and only when it becomes a party to the contractual<br />
provisions of the instrument. The Company derecognizes a financial asset or a portion of a financial asset when and only when it loses control of<br />
the contractual rights that comprise the financial asset or a portion of a financial asset or when a financial asset or a portion of a financial asset<br />
expires. The Company derecognizes a financial liability when and only when a liability is extinguished and that is when the obligation specified in<br />
the contract is discharged, cancelled and expires.<br />
Earnings per share<br />
Earnings per share (“EPS”) disclosed in the income statements are determined by dividing net income by the weighted average number of<br />
shares that have been outstanding during the related year or period and taking into account bonus issues and right issues. There is no difference<br />
between basic and diluted earnings per share for any class of shares for any of the years.<br />
Commitments and contingencies<br />
Transactions that may give rise to contingencies and commitments are those where the outcome and the performance of which will be ultimately<br />
confirmed only on the occurrence or non-occurrence of certain future events, unless the expected performance is not very likely. Accordingly,<br />
contingent losses are recognised in the financial statements if a reasonable estimate of the amount of the resulting loss can be made. Contingent<br />
gains are reflected only if it is probable that the gain will be realized.<br />
Cash and cash equivalents<br />
For the purpose of cash flow statement, cash and cash equivalents comprise cash in hand; deposits with banks and other financial institutions<br />
with the original maturity of three months or less.<br />
Page 70<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
4. BUSINESS COMBINATIONS<br />
Consolidated subsidiaries as from 01 January 2009<br />
In the preceding financial statements for the year ended 31.12.2008, <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd., was not consolidated due to the fact that it was<br />
deemed to be immaterial individually and in aggregate to the results and financial position of Group. In the current year financial statements the<br />
Group consolidated <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd. on the grounds that it became active and material individually and in aggregate to the results and<br />
financial position of Group. As the effect of not consolidating <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd. in the comparative financial statements was not material,<br />
the Group did not restate prior year financial statements and presented the cumulative effect thousand of TL 3.642 on the opening general<br />
reserve on 01.01.2009 in the statement of equity. The balance sheet items of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd. as of 31.12.2008 are set out below for<br />
further disclosure purposes:<br />
31.12.2008<br />
Cash and cash equivalents 41<br />
Inventories 12<br />
Property, plant and equipment 27.944<br />
Intangible assets 14<br />
Other assets 854<br />
Total assets 28.865<br />
Total liabilities 30.785<br />
Paid in capital 331<br />
Reserves 1.391<br />
Accumulated deficit (3.642)<br />
Total equity (1.920)<br />
Total liabilities and equity 28.865<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Rüzgar <strong>Enerji</strong>si Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. was established on 09.11.2009 and was consolidated to the accompanying consolidated financial<br />
statements as of 31.12.2009.<br />
Page 71<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
5. SEGMENT INFORMATION<br />
The Group is currently organized into two major product divisions. The basis on which the group reports its primary and secondary segment<br />
information is as follows:<br />
Electricity, steam production and maintenance services (Electricity segment):<br />
Production and sales by <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> - Turkey<br />
Production and sales by Rosmiks LLC (under construction) - Russia<br />
Production and sales by Rotor (under construction) - Turkey<br />
Production and sales by <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd - Pakistan<br />
Production and sales by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Hidroelektrik (under construction) - Turkey<br />
Production and sales by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Jeotermal - Turkey<br />
Financial services to <strong>energy</strong> segment by ICFS, Rosmiks International and Bundoran – USA, Holland and BVI<br />
Production and sales by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Rüzgar - Turkey<br />
Natural gas extraction and distribution services (Natural gas segment):<br />
Production and sales by Amity Oil - Turkey<br />
Production and sales by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas - Turkey<br />
A. Business segments 2009 2008<br />
Revenue<br />
Electricity 486.327 474.083<br />
Natural gas 61.062 57.208<br />
547.389 531.291<br />
Gross profit<br />
Electricity 95.960 72.790<br />
Natural gas 31.719 31.550<br />
127.679 104.340<br />
Operating profit<br />
Electricity 243.577 28.837<br />
Natural gas 18.450 16.538<br />
262.027 45.375<br />
Capital expenditure<br />
Electricity 705.948 1.294.912<br />
Natural gas 23.182 52.325<br />
729.130 1.347.237<br />
Page 72<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
2009 2008<br />
Segment assets<br />
Electricity 2.274.042 2.435.852<br />
Natural gas 133.840 152.670<br />
2.407.882 2.588.522<br />
Depreciation and amortisation charge<br />
Continuing operations<br />
Electricity and steam 39.606 33.071<br />
Natural gas 3.964 4.315<br />
43.570 37.386<br />
Discontinued operations<br />
Electricity and steam 9.488 7.265<br />
Natural gas 1.936 1.947<br />
B. Geographical segments<br />
11.424 9.212<br />
54.994 46.598<br />
Segment assets<br />
Turkey 1.173.364 1.681.637<br />
Russia 1.205.814 904.444<br />
Rest of the world 28.704 2.441<br />
2.407.882 2.588.522<br />
Capital expenditure<br />
Turkey 406.590 712.436<br />
Russia (construction in progress) 293.863 634.801<br />
Other 28.677 --<br />
Revenue<br />
More than 98% (2008: 97%) of sales are generated in Turkey.<br />
729.130 1.347.237<br />
Page 73<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
6. EARNINGS PER SHARE<br />
2009 2008<br />
Earnings (loss) per share from continuing operations:<br />
Profit (loss) from continuing operations 134.289 (120.218)<br />
Profit (loss) from continuing operations attributable to minority interest 5.037 (60.777)<br />
Profit (loss) from continuing operations attributable to<br />
equity holders of the parent 139.326 (180.995)<br />
Weighted average number of shares 12.440.507.603 8.166.535.000<br />
Earnings (loss) per share from continuing operations – (TL, full) 0,01 (0,02)<br />
Loss per share from discontinued operations:<br />
Loss from discontinued operations (37.463) (152.191)<br />
Loss from discontinued operations attributable to minority interest (12.268) --<br />
Loss from discontinued operations attributable to equity holders of the parent (49.731) (152.191)<br />
Weighted average number of shares 12.440.507.603 8.166.535.000<br />
Loss per share from continuing operations – (TL, full) (0,00) (0,02)<br />
Earnings (loss) per share:<br />
Profit (loss) for the year 96.826 (272.409)<br />
Loss attributable to minority interest (7.231) (60.777)<br />
Profit (loss) from attributable to equity holders of the parent 89.595 (333.186)<br />
Weighted average number of ordinary shares in issue 12.440.507.603 8.166.535.000<br />
Earnings (loss) per share, - (TL, full) 0,01 (0,04)<br />
Page 74<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
7. CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS<br />
2009 2008<br />
Cash in hand 56 92<br />
Demand deposit at banks 9.414 5.852<br />
Time deposit at banks 33.721 1.630<br />
Cash and cash equivalents 43.191 7.574<br />
Bank overdrafts (-) -- (513)<br />
Cash and cash equivalents presented in cash flow statement 43.191 7.061<br />
As of 31.12.2009, the maturity of time deposits vary between 04.01.2010 and 11.01.2010 (2008: 02.01.2009).<br />
8. TRADE RECEIVABLES<br />
Current accounts<br />
- Third parties 105.526 89.601<br />
- Related parties, note 26 96.856 26.439<br />
Notes receivable<br />
- Third parties 874 15.672<br />
- Related parties, note 26 -- 1.951<br />
203.256 133.663<br />
Unearned interest on receivables (-) (348) (1.108)<br />
Allowance for doubtful receivables (-) (10.346) (10.108)<br />
Movement in the allowance for doubtful receivables is as follows:<br />
192.562 122.447<br />
Opening balance, 01.01 10.108 3.589<br />
Charge for the year 238 6.519<br />
Ending balance, 31.12 10.346 10.108<br />
The allowance for doubtful trade receivables were set against the receivables aged as follows:<br />
0-3 months 1.301 2.053<br />
3-6 months 1.265 2.067<br />
Over 6 months 7.780 5.988<br />
10.346 10.108<br />
Page 75<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
9. INVENTORIES<br />
2009 2008<br />
Raw materials 2.529 3.462<br />
Spare parts 4.032 35.654<br />
Merchandise 1.509 1.332<br />
8.070 40.448<br />
Allowance for diminution in value (-) (1.122) (1.286)<br />
Allowance for diminution in value of inventories is as follows:<br />
6.948 39.162<br />
Raw materials 1.122 1.122<br />
Merchandise -- 164<br />
Movement of allowance for diminution in value of inventories is as follows:<br />
1.122 1.286<br />
Opening balance, 01.01 1.286 1.090<br />
Charge for the year -- 196<br />
Disposal (-) (164) --<br />
Ending balance, 31.12 1.122 1.286<br />
10. OTHER ASSETS<br />
Current<br />
Prepaid expenses 4.839 4.601<br />
Income accruals 17.432 38.646<br />
VAT receivable 48.932 38.492<br />
Work advances 248 187<br />
Due from personnel 20 61<br />
Prepaid taxes 837 48.052<br />
Advances given 1.229 2.670<br />
Due from related parties (note 26) 26.407 9.190<br />
Other 3.292 6.953<br />
103.236 148.852<br />
Income accruals relate to natural gas and electricity provided to customers up to the balance sheet date but invoiced in the following month.<br />
Page 76<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
11. FINANCIAL ASSETS<br />
Unquoted investments whose fair value cannot be measured reliably are carried at cost and classified as available-for-sale financial assets.<br />
2009 2008<br />
Long term financial assets<br />
Equity investments 764 800<br />
Unconsolidated investments 66 6.826<br />
830 7.626<br />
Share %<br />
Amount<br />
Entity Country 2009 2008 2009 2008<br />
Equity investment<br />
Solbar Energy Ltd. Israel 27% 27% 764 764<br />
Dorad Energy Ltd. Israel 25% 25% 36 36<br />
Allowance for unconsolidated investments (-)<br />
Dorad Energy Ltd. Israel (36) --<br />
764 800<br />
Unconsolidated subsidiaries<br />
Ramat Negev Energy Ltd. Israel 51% 51% 1.412 1.412<br />
Ashdod Energy Ltd. Israel 51% 51% 3.387 3.387<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Intergas GMBH Austria 100% 100% 66 66<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd. Pakistan -- 100% -- 12.328<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> ve İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. Turkey -- 80% -- 951<br />
Yeni Gürsöğüt <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. Turkey 89% 89% 45 45<br />
Allowance for unconsolidated subsidiaries (-)<br />
Ramat Negev Energy Ltd. Israel (1.412) --<br />
Ashdod Energy Ltd. Israel (3.387) --<br />
Capital commitments (-)<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd. Pakistan -- (10.606)<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> ve İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. Turkey -- (712)<br />
Yeni Gürsöğüt <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. Turkey (45) (45)<br />
66 6.826<br />
830 7.626<br />
Page 77<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd. was consolidated to the accompanying consolidated financial statements as from 01.01.2009 (note 4).<br />
As of the balance sheet dates, the companies listed under “equity investments” and “unconsolidated investments” in which the Company has<br />
controlling interest or significant influence are not consolidated or equity accounted as they are immaterial individually and in aggregate to the<br />
results and financial position of the Group.<br />
The movement of equity investment is given below:<br />
2009 2008<br />
Opening balance, 01.01 800 800<br />
Allowance for equity investment (-) (36) --<br />
Ending balance, 31.12 764 800<br />
The movement of unconsolidated subsidiaries is given below:<br />
Opening balance, 01.01 6.826 4.982<br />
Increase (decrease) in fair value, net -- 1.857<br />
Disposals (-) (239) (13)<br />
Allowance for equity investment (-) (4.799) --<br />
Consolidated subsidiaries (-) (1.722) --<br />
Ending balance, 31.12 66 6.826<br />
12. EXPLORATION AND EVALUATION ASSETS<br />
Amount<br />
Balance at, 01 January 2008 18.743<br />
Additions 8.377<br />
Expensed drilling costs (2.761)<br />
Transfer to natural gas drilling costs (1.933)<br />
Balance at, 31 December 2008 22.426<br />
Additions 9.884<br />
Expensed drilling costs (1.356)<br />
Transfer to natural gas drilling costs (2.973)<br />
Balance at, 31 December 2009 27.981<br />
Costs directly associated with exploration well are capitalised until the evaluation of reserves. If it is determined that commercial viability has not<br />
been achieved these costs are charged to expense; if determined as commercially viable these costs are transferred to “natural gas drilling costs”<br />
under “Property, plant and equipment”.<br />
Page 78<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Expensed exploration wells that commercial discovery has not been achieved are as follows:<br />
2009 2008<br />
Diyarbakır (Çınar and Ovabağ wells) -- 659<br />
Gaziantep (Yavuzeli well) -- 10<br />
Gaziantep (Keysun well) -- 155<br />
Tekmeşe (first well) -- 460<br />
Enez (İpsala well) -- 1.477<br />
Siirt (İdil well) 115 --<br />
Doğubeyciler (second well) 458 --<br />
Taşpınar well 15 --<br />
Banarlı well 768 --<br />
13. PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT<br />
1.356 2.761<br />
Translation Consolidated Disposal of<br />
2008 Additions Disposals reserve subsidiary subsidiaries Transfers 2009<br />
Cost<br />
Land 6.071 -- -- -- -- (477) -- 5.594<br />
Land improvements 78.841 467 (675) -- -- (91.692) 26.603 13.544<br />
Buildings 24.016 2.643 -- (31) -- (707) 572 26.493<br />
Leasehold improvements 130 29 -- -- -- (123) -- 36<br />
Plant and machinery 531.973 21.701 (499) -- -- (3.988) 241.709 790.896<br />
Motor vehicles 1.115 92 (90) (19) -- (201) -- 897<br />
Furniture and fixtures 10.237 2.038 (419) (49) 47 (4.329) 1.065 8.590<br />
Natural gas drilling cost 14.123 -- -- -- -- -- 2.973 17.096<br />
Construction work in progress 1.120.573 690.632 -- (26.500) 27.900 (177.851) (272.967) 1.361.787<br />
1.787.079 717.602 (1.683) (26.599) 27.947 (279.368) (45) 2.224.933<br />
Accumulated depreciation<br />
Land improvements 10.430 1.197 (2) -- -- (3.321) -- 8.304<br />
Buildings 4.252 813 -- (10) -- (9) -- 5.046<br />
Leasehold improvements 36 16 -- -- -- (29) -- 23<br />
Plant and machinery 185.950 38.030 (114) (6) -- (3.084) -- 220.776<br />
Motor vehicles 469 165 (52) (19) -- (110) -- 453<br />
Furniture and fixtures 4.383 1.233 (35) -- 2 (1.467) -- 4.116<br />
Natural gas drilling cost 7.503 1.071 -- -- -- -- -- 8.574<br />
213.023 42.525 (203) (35) 2 (8.020) -- 247.292<br />
Net book value 1.574.056 1.977.641<br />
Page 79<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Translation<br />
2007 Additions Disposals reserve Transfers 2008<br />
Cost<br />
Land 5.955 39 -- -- 77 6.071<br />
Land improvements 23.960 3.780 (247) -- 51.348 78.841<br />
Buildings 23.781 -- -- 74 161 24.016<br />
Leasehold improvements 49 80 -- -- 1 130<br />
Plant and machinery 529.729 116 -- -- 2.128 531.973<br />
Motor vehicles 961 138 (21) 37 -- 1.115<br />
Furniture and fixtures 7.055 3.004 (6) 41 143 10.237<br />
Natural gas drilling cost 12.190 -- -- -- 1.933 14.123<br />
Construction in progress 432.223 728.685 -- 13.524 (53.859) 1.120.573<br />
1.035.903 735.842 (274) 13.676 1.932 1.787.079<br />
Accumulated depreciation<br />
Land improvements 8.230 2.214 (14) -- -- 10.430<br />
Buildings 3.424 818 -- 10 -- 4.252<br />
Leasehold improvements 21 15 -- -- -- 36<br />
Plant and machinery 153.984 31.960 -- 6 -- 185.950<br />
Motor vehicles 309 175 (21) 6 -- 469<br />
Furniture and fixtures 3.105 999 -- 279 -- 4.383<br />
Natural gas drilling cost 6.284 1.219 -- -- -- 7.503<br />
175.357 37.400 (35) 301 -- 213.023<br />
Net book value 860.546 1.574.056<br />
The Group’s policy is to trace all material and significant fixed asset additions under construction in progress and transfer to the related fixed<br />
asset accounts when the construction process is completed. As of 31.12.2009 “Construction in Progress” account for new investments in tangible<br />
fixed assets amounted to TL 1.361.787 (2008: TL 1.120.573) which was broken down as follows:<br />
Construction of two 340 MW <strong>energy</strong> power plants by Rosmiks LLC in Russia amounting to TL 1.063.978 (2008: TL 898.072).<br />
Page 80<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Investments by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy Pakistan in Pakistan wind <strong>energy</strong> power plants with a capacity of 49,5 MW amounting to TL 36.152.<br />
Investments in progress by <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy comprising gas turbine of 42 MW and generator assembly in Lüleburgaz, Turkey, amounting to TL 4.447<br />
(2008: TL 44.279), <strong>energy</strong> investments in Israel amounting to TL 32.280 (2008: TL 23.137) and investments in hydroelectric power stations<br />
amounting to TL 6.232 (2008: TL 1.192).<br />
Investment by Rotor at Osmaniye Turkey comprising 54 wind turbines with total capacity of 135 MW amounting to TL 218.633 (2008: TL<br />
127.555) and other investments totalled TL 65 (2008: TL 6.157).<br />
As of 31.12.2008 investments for installation of natural gas pipelines in Lüleburgaz, Edirne, Çerkezköy, Kırklareli and Tekirdağ and investment by<br />
Trakya Gaz and in Gaziantep by Gaziantep Gaz totalling TL 20.181.<br />
The financing expenses capitalized under construction in progress during 2009 totalled TL 41.388 (2008: TL 128.876).<br />
Guarantees given to secure bank loans are set out in note 22.<br />
14. INTANGIBLE ASSETS<br />
Disposal of Consolidated<br />
2008 Additions subsidiaries subsidiary Transfer 2009<br />
Cost<br />
Wind <strong>energy</strong> production rights 16.709 -- -- 15 45 16.769<br />
Natural gas drilling rights 24.596 -- (9) -- -- 24.587<br />
Hydroelectric <strong>energy</strong> production rights 493.919 -- (493.919) -- -- --<br />
Thermal <strong>energy</strong> production rights 108.799 -- (108.799) -- -- --<br />
Other intangible assets 7.534 1.644 (3.866) -- -- 5.312<br />
651.557 1.644 (606.593) 15 45 46.668<br />
Accumulated amortization<br />
Wind <strong>energy</strong> production rights 1.170 668 (1.255) 1 -- 584<br />
Natural gas drilling rights 4.039 1.230 -- -- -- 5.269<br />
Hydroelectric <strong>energy</strong> production rights 5.488 8.232 (13.720) -- -- --<br />
Thermal <strong>energy</strong> production rights 1.209 1.813 (3.022) -- -- --<br />
Other intangible assets 3.926 526 (160) -- -- 4.292<br />
15.832 12.469 (18.157) 1 -- 10.145<br />
Net book value 635.725 36.523<br />
Page 81<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
2007 Additions 2008<br />
Cost<br />
Wind <strong>energy</strong> production rights 16.709 -- 16.709<br />
Natural gas drilling rights 24.596 -- 24.596<br />
Hydroelectric <strong>energy</strong> production rights -- 493.919 493.919<br />
Thermal <strong>energy</strong> production rights -- 108.799 108.799<br />
Other intangible assets 7.234 300 7.534<br />
48.539 603.018 651.557<br />
Accumulated amortization<br />
Wind <strong>energy</strong> production rights 502 668 1.170<br />
Natural gas drilling rights 2.809 1.230 4.039<br />
Hydroelectric <strong>energy</strong> production rights -- 5.488 5.488<br />
Thermal <strong>energy</strong> production rights -- 1.209 1.209<br />
Other intangible assets 3.323 603 3.926<br />
6.634 9.198 15.832<br />
Net book value 41.905 635.725<br />
During 2008 the Group won the tender for the operating license of Tercan, Kuzgun, Mercan, İkizdere, Çıldır, Beyköy and Ataköy Hydroelectric<br />
power plants and the thermal power plant in Denizli for a period of 30 years and for acquisition of the ownership of natural gas power plant<br />
located in Van for total of USD 510 million equivalent to TL 602.718 which has been reflected to intangible assets as “Hydroelectric <strong>energy</strong><br />
rights” and “Thermal <strong>energy</strong> rights”.<br />
Page 82<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
15. BORROWINGS<br />
2009 2008<br />
Current<br />
Bank borrowings 149.017 134.008<br />
Finance lease liabilities, net -- 45<br />
149.017 134.053<br />
Current portion of long term borrowings<br />
Bank borrowings 383.070 203.716<br />
Non-current<br />
Bank borrowings 849.352 1.458.787<br />
On 08 May 2009, the Company had signed a loan agreement with International Finance Corporation, European Bank for Reconstruction and<br />
Development, European Investment Bank, HSBC Bank Plc and Denizbank A.Ş. Bahrain Branch amounting to EUR 130 million with a maturity of 10<br />
to 12 years for financing its investments in Osmaniye/Turkey. As of 31.12.2009, Rotor had obtained EUR 85 million loan in accordance with the<br />
above mentioned agreement.<br />
Page 83<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Summary maturity schedule of bank loans is given below:<br />
2009 EUR (‘000) USD (‘000) TL TL equivalent<br />
Due in one year 14.185 239.668 140.575 532.087<br />
One to two years 13.023 203.142 -- 334.004<br />
Two to three years 11.583 144.647 -- 242.818<br />
Three to f<strong>our</strong> years 8.836 69.949 -- 124.411<br />
F<strong>our</strong> to five years 8.212 9.156 -- 31.527<br />
Five and over five years 45.730 11.824 -- 116.592<br />
Total bank borrowings 101.569 678.386 140.575 1.381.439<br />
2008 EUR USD TL TL equivalent<br />
Due in one year 6.827 186.375 41.254 337.724<br />
One to two years 6.106 216.633 -- 340.686<br />
Two to three years 9.748 398.748 -- 623.894<br />
Three to f<strong>our</strong> years 2.322 112.509 -- 175.117<br />
F<strong>our</strong> to five years 2.095 49.033 -- 78.638<br />
Five and over five years 5.279 151.525 -- 240.452<br />
Total bank borrowings 32.377 1.114.823 41.254 1.796.511<br />
Group had given various letters of guarantee to financial institutions for obtained bank loans (note 22).<br />
Page 84<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
16. TRADE PAYABLES<br />
2009 2008<br />
Current<br />
Current accounts<br />
- Third parties 163.456 136.616<br />
- Related parties, note 26 13.417 11.741<br />
176.873 148.357<br />
Unearned interest on payables (-) (361) (988)<br />
176.512 147.369<br />
Non-current<br />
Trade payables<br />
- Third parties 65.732 56.089<br />
- Related parties, note 26 60.449 --<br />
126.181 56.089<br />
17. PROVISION FOR EXPENSES<br />
Current<br />
Provision for share of TRT 411 320<br />
Legal claims and other provisions 764 2.376<br />
Movement of provision for expenses is as follows:<br />
1.175 2.696<br />
Legal claims<br />
Provision for share of TRT<br />
Opening balance, 01.01 2.376 320<br />
Additions -- 91<br />
Payment (-) (1.612) --<br />
Ending balance, 31.12 764 411<br />
Page 85<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
18. OTHER LIABILITIES<br />
2009 2008<br />
Current<br />
Income tax and social security premiums payable 9.676 3.886<br />
Advances received 106 6.946<br />
Due to personnel 295 867<br />
Due to related parties, note 26 -- 224<br />
Other 635 819<br />
10.712 12.742<br />
Non-current<br />
Deposits and guarantees received -- 2.896<br />
Due to related parties, note 26 428.554 524.441<br />
19. TAXATION ON INCOME<br />
a) Current taxation<br />
428.554 527.337<br />
Profit (loss) before tax 140.750 (78.527)<br />
Domestic tax rate 20% 20%<br />
Tax calculated at domestic tax rates applicable to profits in the respective countries (28.150) 15.705<br />
Taxable losses -- (10.258)<br />
Tax exemption 10.695 20.100<br />
Disallowable expenses (4.250) (41.984)<br />
Unused investment allowances -- (34.877)<br />
Tax rate effect of foreign countries -- 487<br />
Income not subject to tax 15.244 9.136<br />
(6.461) (41.691)<br />
Page 86<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
The Group’s taxation on income is as follows:<br />
Current tax charge 4.440 5.402<br />
Deferred tax charge 2.021 36.289<br />
6.461 41.691<br />
In Turkey, the corporation tax rate on the profits for the calendar year 2009 is 20% (2008: 20%). Taxable profits are calculated by modifying<br />
accounting income for certain exclusions and allowances for tax purposes from the profit disclosed in the statutory income. No other taxes are<br />
paid unless profits are distributed.<br />
In Turkey no taxes are withheld from undistributed profits, profits added to share capital (bonus shares) and dividends paid to other resident<br />
companies. Other than those, profits distributed in dividend to individuals and non-resident companies are subject to withholding at the rate of<br />
15%.<br />
In Turkey, the tax legislation does not permit a parent company and its affiliates to file a consolidated tax return. Therefore, provision for taxation<br />
charge, as reflected in the accompanying consolidated financial information, has been calculated on a separate-entity basis.<br />
The exemption period granted on profits from the sale of investment shares and immovable property by Corporation Tax Law transitory articles<br />
No. 28 and 29 expired on 31 December 2004. However this exemption was re-enacted by Law No. 5281 on permanent basis in effect from 1<br />
January 2005. Accordingly, 75% of profits from the sale of investments and immovable’s held for a minimum of two years will be tax exempt<br />
provided the sale proceeds are collected within two years and 75% of the profit is added to share capital or is kept in a special reserve account<br />
for a minimum of five years<br />
Page 87<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
In Turkey companies were allowed to deduct 40% of the value of fixed assets (exceeding TL 6.000) purchased after 24 April 2003 (investment<br />
allowances) from their taxable profits as investment incentive. Such investment deduction is also not subject to income tax withholding. The<br />
investment deductions not used in any year because of insufficient profits may be carried to future periods. Investment allowances related to<br />
fixed assets purchased or to be purchased under Investment Incentive Certificates granted or applied for before 24 April 2003, may be based<br />
on up to 100% of the investment value in fixed assets, but these are subject to tax at 19.8%. Investment allowances have been cancelled as from<br />
1 January 2006 but investment allowances earned prior to this date may be used up to 31 December 2008; any balance unused after this date<br />
may not be carried forward; if this option is exercised the balance of taxable profit after deduction of investment allowances is to be taxed at<br />
30%.<br />
Tax losses that are reported in the Corporation Tax in Turkey return may be carried forward and deducted from the corporation tax base for a<br />
maximum of five consecutive years.<br />
The Turkish Tax Procedural Law does not include a procedure for formally agreeing tax assessments. Tax returns must be filed within three and<br />
half months of the year-end and may be subject to investigation, together with their underlying accounting records, by the tax authorities at any<br />
stage during the following five years.<br />
Taxes included in the balance sheet are shown below:<br />
2009 2008<br />
Corporation and income taxes 4.436 21.861<br />
Prepaid taxes (-) (3.446) (12.472)<br />
990 9.389<br />
Deferred taxation<br />
The Group recognizes deferred tax assets and liabilities based upon temporary differences between its financial statements as reported for<br />
IFRS purposes and its statutory tax financial statements. These differences usually result in the recognition of revenue and expenses in different<br />
reporting periods for IFRS and tax purposes.<br />
Page 88<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
The composition of cumulative temporary differences and the related deferred tax assets/liabilities in respect of items for which deferred tax has<br />
been provided at the balance sheet dates using the expected future tax rates were as follows:<br />
Cumulative temporary difference<br />
Deferred tax<br />
2009 2008 2009 2008<br />
Deferred tax asset<br />
Employee termination benefits 1.251 2.388 250 478<br />
Provision for expenses 1.945 1.533 389 307<br />
Doubtful debts provision expense 9.385 9.386 1.877 1.877<br />
Taxable loss carried forward 74.796 134.314 14.959 26.863<br />
Other 6.638 5.643 1.328 1.129<br />
18.803 30.654<br />
Deferred tax liability<br />
Temporary differences arising<br />
from restating non-monetary assets 285.668 163.495 57.134 31.875<br />
Unearned interest on payables 427 9.715 85 1.943<br />
Other 1.135 1.179 227 236<br />
Movement of deferred tax liability is given below:<br />
57.446 34.054<br />
38.643 3.400<br />
2009 2008<br />
Opening balance, 01.01 3.400 887<br />
Deferred tax effect of unconsolidated subsidiaries 39.943 --<br />
Translation differences 85 (419)<br />
Deferred tax charge 2.021 36.289<br />
Deferred tax effect of discontinued operations (6.806) (33.357)<br />
Ending balance, 31.12 38.643 3.400<br />
20. EMPLOYEE TERMINATION BENEFITS<br />
In accordance with existing social legislation in Turkey, the Group is required to make lump-sum termination indemnities to each eligible<br />
employee who has completed one year of service with the Group, and whose employment is terminated due to retirement or for reasons other<br />
than resignation or misconduct.<br />
The amount of indemnity is the equivalent of one month’s salary for each year of service subject to a ceiling which is TL 2.365,16 as of 31.12.2009<br />
(2008: TL 2.173,19) on historical cost basis).<br />
The Company has no other obligation for employee termination other than the retirement pay above.<br />
Page 89<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
In the accompanying consolidated financial statements, the Group reflected a liability for termination benefits based upon factors derived using<br />
their experience of personnel terminating their services and being eligible to receive retirement pay and discounted to present value at the<br />
balance sheet date by using average market yield, expected inflation rates and an appropriate discount rate.<br />
Movement of reserve for retirement pay is given below:<br />
2009 2008<br />
Opening balance, 01.01 2.388 1.366<br />
Unconsolidated subsidiaries (1.651) --<br />
Additions 1.658 1.397<br />
Disposals (1.144) (375)<br />
Ending balance, 31.12 1.251 2.388<br />
Personnel cost:<br />
Key personnel salaries and other short term benefits 2.207 2.533<br />
Number of personnel at period end: 328 891<br />
21. SHARE CAPITAL<br />
As a result of raising the share capital of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> from TL 81.665 to TL 281.665 the newly issued shares with total nominal value of TL<br />
200.000 have been sold by using preferential right between 18.09.2009 and 02.10.2009. The number of 89.002 and 100.601 shares on which<br />
the preferential right had not been used, with a totally nominal value TL 189.603 were sold in primary market by public offerings on 09.10.2009<br />
and 12.10.2009, respectively.<br />
The Company has increased its share capital ceiling from TL 190.000 to TL 500.000 based on the Board of Directors decision dated 23.12.2008.<br />
The authorized share capital of the Company comprised 50.000.000.000 shares (2008: 19.000.000.000 shares) and the issued and paid up<br />
share capital comprised 28.166.535.000 shares (2008: 8.166.535.000 shares) of par value Kurush 1 each as of the balance sheet dates.<br />
The Group’s new capital structure is as follows:<br />
As of 31.12.2008 As of 31.12.2009<br />
before share capital increase<br />
after share capital increase<br />
Shareholding Cash Shareholding<br />
Shareholding % amount increase Shareholding % amount<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. 43,2% 35.288 80.610 41,2% 115.898<br />
Korteks Mensucat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. 17,5% 14.330 35.095 17,5% 49.425<br />
Shares held by public 29,4% 24.016 66.064 32,0% 90.080<br />
Other 9,9% 8.031 18.231 9,3% 26.262<br />
100,0% 81.665 200.000 100,0% 281.665<br />
Page 90<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
As of the balance sheet dates, the shareholders of the Company and their percentage shareholdings were as follows:<br />
Shareholding % Shareholding amount<br />
2009 2008 2009 2008<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. 41,2% 43,2% 115.898 35.288<br />
Korteks Mensucat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. 17,5% 17,5% 49.425 14.330<br />
Shares held by public 32,0% 29,4% 90.080 24.016<br />
Other shareholders 9,3% 9,9% 26.262 8.031<br />
Share capital 100,0% 100,0% 281.665 81.665<br />
Inflation adjustment of share capital 110.948 110.948<br />
392.613 192.613<br />
The ultimate parent of the Company is <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. which is located at Ambarlı, Petrol Ofisi Dolum Tesisleri Yolu, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Plaza, Avcılar/<br />
Istanbul- Turkey.<br />
22. COMMITMENTS AND CONTINGENCIES<br />
Contingent assets<br />
2009 2008<br />
a. Obtained from customers and suppliers<br />
Letters of guarantee 56.932 137.539<br />
Checks and notes 4.892 8.025<br />
Contingent liabilities<br />
a. Letters of guarantee, checks and notes given<br />
On behalf of incorporated body 61.295 48.775<br />
On behalf of consolidated subsidiaries 5.597 32.842<br />
On behalf of other <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group of companies 15.373 --<br />
82.265 81.617<br />
b. C<strong>our</strong>t cases started by the Group and pending as of 31.12.2009 amounted to TL 25.015 (2008: TL 24.695) and as of the same date c<strong>our</strong>t cases<br />
started and pending against the Group amounted to TL 566 (2008: TL 430).<br />
c. <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. guaranteed the bank loans amounting to USD 750 million which were obtained on 29.08.2008 and 06.06.2008.<br />
d. As of 31.12.2009, the Group mortgaged its property, plant and equipment to the extent of USD 60.000.000 and USD 1.150.000. Additionally,<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. was guarantor for the loans obtained for long term investments by the Group.<br />
Page 91<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
e. As of 31.12.2009, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas, Petrol, Gas ve Petrokimya Ürünleri İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş., a subsidiary of the Company, has signed<br />
natural gas purchase agreement with Enerco <strong>Enerji</strong> Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. to purchase natural gas amounting to 50.000.000 m3 for the first year<br />
and 975.000.000 m3 for the next five years.<br />
23. NATURE OF EXPENSES<br />
Nature of expenses consists of cost of sales, selling, general and administrative expenses.<br />
2009 2008<br />
Direct materials and merchandise expenses 312.314 333.997<br />
Employee and personnel expenses 16.364 16.288<br />
Energy expenses 13.016 8.918<br />
Depreciation and amortization 43.570 37.386<br />
Outs<strong>our</strong>cing expenses 12.856 12.327<br />
Repair and maintenance expenses 18.873 12.349<br />
Energy transmission line distribution expenses 1.792 2.744<br />
Türkiye Elektrik İletim A.Ş. rounding correction expenses 24.145 18.637<br />
Other 13.938 33.541<br />
24. OTHER INCOME AND OTHER EXPENSE<br />
456.868 476.187<br />
Provisions released 44 1.910<br />
Profit on sale of property, plant and equipment 1.113 163<br />
Income on insurance claims 374 542<br />
Profit on sale of financial assets 181.243 --<br />
Other 3.257 64<br />
Other income 186.031 2.679<br />
Loss on sale of financial assets 6.780 --<br />
Drilling expenses (note 12) 1.356 2.761<br />
Loss on sale of property, plant and equipment 1.206 --<br />
Tax penalty for TRT -- 9.626<br />
Provision for unconsolidated subsidiaries 4.835 --<br />
Other 348 21<br />
Other expense 14.525 12.408<br />
Other income and other expense include profit/(loss) on sale of subsidiaries, <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik Üretimi A.Ş., <strong>Zorlu</strong> O/M <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri<br />
İşletme ve Bakım Hizmetleri A.Ş., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İnşaat Ticaret A.Ş., <strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong>si İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret<br />
A.Ş., Trakya Bölgesi Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş., Gazdaş Gaziantep Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. and <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğalgaz İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş.,<br />
of the Company and <strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas, Petrol, Gaz ve Petrokimya Ürünleri İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. amounting to TL 181.243 and TL 6.780,<br />
respectively (note 27).<br />
Page 92<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
25. FINANCING INCOME AND FINANCING EXPENSE<br />
2009 2008<br />
Foreign exchange gain 359.710 424.592<br />
Interest income 33.111 2.378<br />
Unearned interest on payables 1.528 577<br />
Financing income 394.349 427.547<br />
Foreign exchange loss 358.108 457.971<br />
Interest expense 131.805 85.541<br />
Unearned interest on receivables 17.874 5.249<br />
Bank commissions and other financing expenses 7.839 2.688<br />
Financing expense 515.626 551.449<br />
26. RELATED PARTY DISCLOSURE<br />
In the c<strong>our</strong>se of conducting its business, the Group conducted various business transactions with related parties on commercial terms. These<br />
comprised the following:<br />
i) Year end balances with related parties<br />
Trade receivables Trade payables Other assets Other liabilities<br />
2009<br />
Korteks Mensucat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. 5.204 -- -- --<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong>teks Tekstil Ticaret ve Sanayi A.Ş. 2.451 -- -- --<br />
Trakya Bölgesi Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. 65.051 6.327 -- 423<br />
Gazdaş Gaziantep Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. 16.113 -- 8.728 --<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong> Üretim A.Ş. 3.753 -- -- --<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> O/M <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İşletme ve Bakım Hizmetleri A.Ş. -- -- 17.611 --<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. -- 6.363 -- 369.075<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İnşaat Ticaret A.Ş. -- 60.449 -- 52.684<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong>si İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. -- -- -- 1.763<br />
Other related parties 4.253 653 68 4.609<br />
96.825 73.792 26.407 428.554<br />
Page 93<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Trade receivables Trade payables Other assets Other liabilities<br />
2008<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. -- 8.926 -- 524.441<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong>teks Tekstil Ticaret ve Sanayi A.Ş. 2.114 5 -- --<br />
Korteks Mensucat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. 2.900 136 -- --<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Pakistan Ltd. 21.265 -- 9.190 --<br />
Other related parties 2.004 2.574 -- 224<br />
ii) Transactions carried out with related parties during the year:<br />
28.283 11.641 9.190 524.665<br />
Operating Other Financing Financing<br />
Sales expenses income income expense<br />
2009<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. 650 5.779 32.469 39.595 40.306<br />
Korteks Mensucat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. 44.261 227 -- -- 2.366<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong>teks Tekstil Ticaret ve Sanayi A.Ş. 22.476 100 36 -- 649<br />
Trakya Bölgesi Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. 22.612 -- 673 3.742 2.423<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İnşaat Ticaret A.Ş. -- 10 1.037 17.324 16.984<br />
Other related parties 5.961 3.689 2.020 8.202 4.443<br />
95.960 9.805 36.235 68.863 67.171<br />
2008<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. -- 6.584 -- 85.652 42.543<br />
Korteks Mensucat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. 38.848 435 -- -- --<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong>teks Tekstil Ticaret ve Sanayi A.Ş. 23.082 43 29 -- --<br />
Other related parties 511 514 169 140 5.106<br />
62.441 7.576 198 85.792 47.649<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong>teks Tekstil Ticaret ve Sanayi A.Ş. is a subsidiary of the equity holder of the Company named <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş.<br />
Page 94<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
27. DISCONTINUED OPERATIONS<br />
Company Field of activity Country<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik Üretimi A.Ş. Production of electricity Turkey<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> O/M <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İşletme ve Bakım Hizmetleri A.Ş. Energy facility maintenance services Turkey<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İnşaat Ticaret A.Ş. Energy facility construction services Turkey<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong>si İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. Purchase and sale of electricity Turkey<br />
Trakya Bölgesi Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. Natural gas distribution Turkey<br />
Gazdaş Gaziantep Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. Natural gas distribution Turkey<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğalgaz İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. Purchase and sales of natural gas Turkey<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik Üretimi A.Ş. (Istanbul/Turkey) - <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik was established in 2008 to build and operate hydroelectric power<br />
plants as well as power stations based on all forms of renewable energies.<br />
On 05 March 2008 the Group has won the tender for the operating licenses of Tercan, Kuzgun, Mercan, İkizdere, Çıldır, Beyköy and Ataköy<br />
Hydroelectric power plants and the thermal power plant in Denizli for a period of 30 years and for acquisition of the ownership of natural gas<br />
power plant located in Van all owned by Ankara Doğal Elektrik Üretim ve Ticaret A.Ş. for USD 510 million. The tender was organised by the<br />
Turkish Privatisation Administration and approved on 07.05.2008. In accordance with the agreement signed on 01.09.2008, the consideration<br />
for the tender was met fully in cash.<br />
Type of Date of License Production of Production capacity<br />
Region power plant license obtained period electric/Power per year KW h<strong>our</strong><br />
Van Fuel oil 21.08.2008 49 years 15,0 MW 2.300.000<br />
Denizli Thermal 21.08.2008 29 years 15,0 MW 83.000.000<br />
Tokat Hydroelectric 21.08.2008 30 years 5,5 MW 8.000.000<br />
Eskişehir Hydroelectric 21.08.2008 30 years 16,8 MW 59.000.000<br />
Kars Hydroelectric 21.08.2008 30 years 15,4 MW 46.800.000<br />
Rize Hydroelectric 21.08.2008 30 years 18,6 MW 109.000.000<br />
Erzurum Hydroelectric 21.08.2008 30 years 20,9 MW 24.000.000<br />
Tunceli Hydroelectric 21.08.2008 30 years 20,4 MW 85.000.000<br />
Erzincan Hydroelectric 21.08.2008 30 years 15,0 MW 45.000.000<br />
Total 142,6 MW 462.100.000<br />
In accordance with the decision of the Energy Market Regulatory Authority (EMRA) dated on 21 August 2008, the license period of the thermal<br />
power plant in Denizli/Sarayköy is 29 years 3 months and 17 days to be valid on 01 September 2008.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İşletme ve Bakım Hizmetleri A.Ş. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) <strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M power plant operation and maintenance services<br />
company was established 2000 to provide operational and maintenance services to power plants. <strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M has cooperation agreements with<br />
and provides operation and maintenance services in Turkey to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy’s power stations. Internationally it provides services for the power<br />
stations in Greece, India and Kuwait. <strong>Zorlu</strong> O&M will provide operation and maintenance services to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy’s Russia and Israel power plant<br />
projects. The contract for operation and maintenance services of power plants in Israel and Pakistan has been signed.<br />
Page 95<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İnşaat Ticaret A.Ş. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) – <strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel became operational in 2000 for the purpose of<br />
developing, implementing and providing financial support to industrial and <strong>energy</strong> plant projects.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel is also responsible for the construction of power plants in Moscow (Russia) and Lüleburgaz (Turkey), and construction and<br />
mounting (EPC) of 4 combine cycle plants in Israel and the wind <strong>energy</strong> power plant under construction in Osmaniye (Turkey) and Pakistan. The<br />
validity of “Construction and Service Certificate” license obtained on 14.06.2007 is for 10 years.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong> İthalat İhracat A.Ş. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) - <strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik was established in 2003 for the purpose of procurement of<br />
wholesale electricity from domestic s<strong>our</strong>ces, free trade zones and international grid-connected countries for distribution; on wholesale and retail<br />
basis. The validity of the license obtained on 23.10.2003 is for 10 years.<br />
Trakya Bölgesi Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) – This company was established in 2005 for the purpose of city gas distribution.<br />
On August 2006, Trakya Doğal Gaz won the tender of city gas distribution in Tekirdağ, Muratlı, Edirne, Kırklareli, Kavaklı, Babaeski, Lüleburgaz,<br />
Evrensekiz, Büyükkarıştıran, Misinli, Ulaş, Çerkezköy, Kapaklı, Kızılpınar, Karaağaç, Velimeşe, Veliköy, all in the Thrace region for 30 years starting<br />
on 25.01.2006. As a condition of the tender the price for unit service and depreciation was determined as “0” (zero) cent/kwh and the price for<br />
subscription deposits as “0” (zero) USD for the first 8 years. After 8 years, natural gas sales conditions will be determined by EMRA.<br />
Gazdaş Gaziantep Doğalgaz Dağıtım A.Ş. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) – This company was established in 2005 for the purpose of city gas distribution.<br />
On August 2005, Gazdaş won the tender of city gas distribution in Gaziantep, Kilis and Nizip all in Southeast Anatolia region for 30 years<br />
starting on 24.02.2006. As a condition of the tender the price for unit service and depreciation was determined as “0” (zero) cent/kwh and the<br />
price for subscription deposits as “0” (zero) USD for the first 8 years. After 8 years, natural gas sales conditions will be determined by EMRA.<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğalgaz İthalat İhracat A.Ş. (“Istanbul/Turkey”) – <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğalgaz was established in 2003 for the purpose of wholesale procurement<br />
and distribution of compressed natural gas (“CNG”) and/or liquefied natural gas (“LNG”) to other wholesale companies, free trade zones and<br />
countries abroad; owns license for wholesale and retail sales and direct sales to consumers .<br />
Based on the Board of Directors decision dated 23.06.2009 the Company sold the following shares:<br />
340.000 shares and 85.000 shares in Trakya Bölgesi Doğal Gaz Dağıtım A.Ş. respectively to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. for TL 340 and to <strong>Zorlu</strong>teks<br />
Tekstil Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 85;<br />
500.000 shares and 125.000 shares in Gazdaş Gaziantep Doğal Gaz Dağıtım A.Ş. respectively to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. for TL 500 and to <strong>Zorlu</strong>teks<br />
Tekstil Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 125;<br />
500.000 shares and 500.000 shares in <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Gaz İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. respectively to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Hometeks Tekstil Ürünleri<br />
Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 5 and to <strong>Zorlu</strong>teks Tekstil Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 5;<br />
500.000 shares and 500.000 shares in <strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong>si İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. respectively to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Hometeks Tekstil<br />
Ürünleri Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 5,2 and to <strong>Zorlu</strong>teks Tekstil Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 5,2;<br />
950.000 shares and 50.000 shares in <strong>Zorlu</strong> Endüstriyel ve <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İnşaat Ticaret A.Ş. respectively to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. for TL 16.827 and<br />
to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Dış Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 886;<br />
950.000 shares and 50.000 shares in <strong>Zorlu</strong> O/M <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri İşletme ve Bakım Hizmetleri A.Ş. respectively to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. for TL 2.097<br />
and to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Dış Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 110;<br />
790.000 shares and 10.000 shares in <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> ve İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. respectively to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. for TL 790 and to Deniz<br />
Destek Oto Alım Satım Kiralama Temizlik Hizmetleri ve İnşaat A.Ş. for TL 10;<br />
47.500.000 shares and 500.000 shares in <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik Üretimi A.Ş. respectively to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Holding A.Ş. for USD 40.591.600 and to Deniz<br />
Destek Oto Alım Satım Kiralama Temizlik Hizmetleri ve İnşaat A.Ş. for USD 427.280. All transfer transactions were completed on the same date<br />
as the Board decision.<br />
Page 96<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Petrogas Petrol Gaz ve Petrokimya Ürünleri İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş., a subsidiary of the Group with a 73% economic interest sold<br />
shares as follows:<br />
500.000 shares and 500.000 in <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Gaz İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. respectively to <strong>Zorlu</strong>teks Tekstil Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. for<br />
TL 5 and to <strong>Zorlu</strong>hometeks Tekstil Ürünleri Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 5;<br />
500.000 shares and 500.000 shares in <strong>Zorlu</strong> Elektrik <strong>Enerji</strong>si İthalat İhracat ve Toptan Ticaret A.Ş. respectively to <strong>Zorlu</strong>teks Tekstil Sanayi ve<br />
Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 5,2 and to <strong>Zorlu</strong>hometeks Tekstil Ürünleri Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 5,2;<br />
50.000 shares in <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> ve İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş. to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Dış Ticaret A.Ş. for TL 50;<br />
500.000 shares in <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik Üretimi A.Ş. shares to <strong>Zorlu</strong> Dış Ticaret A.Ş. for USD 427.280.<br />
The fair value of <strong>Zorlu</strong> Doğal Elektrik Üretim AŞ. was ascertained by an independent valuation company on basis of Discounted Cash Flow<br />
method. In accordance with the valuation report of the said company dated 22.06.2009 the fair value of the Company amounted to USD<br />
42.728.000 and the value of the related transfer of shares was accounted for on basis of this valuation.<br />
Profit and loss resulting from the operations of the subsidiaries which has been disposed were consolidated by eliminating all inter company<br />
transactions until the date of cessation of control and presented in the statement income as discontinued operations in line with IFRS 5.<br />
a. Results of discontinued operations<br />
Discontinued operations<br />
2009 2008<br />
Revenue 106.931 135.735<br />
Cost of sales (-) (72.543) (123.259)<br />
Gross profit 34.388 12.476<br />
Selling expenses (-) (6.892) (4.970)<br />
General and administrative expenses (-) (10.090) (17.032)<br />
Other income 1.093 735<br />
Other expense (-) (1.263) (13)<br />
Operating profit (loss) 17.236 (8.804)<br />
Financing income 21.723 44.166<br />
Financing expense (-) (75.273) (204.451)<br />
Loss before taxation (36.314) (169.089)<br />
Taxation on income (1.149) 16.898<br />
Loss from discontinued operations for the year (37.463) (152.191)<br />
Page 97<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
b. Cash flow from (used in) discontinued operations<br />
2009 2008<br />
Net cash used in operating activities (21.142) (104.239)<br />
Net cash used in investing activities (26.230) (560.961)<br />
Net cash provided by financing activities 65.229 612.209<br />
28. FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS<br />
17.857 (52.991)<br />
Financial risk management objectives and policies<br />
The Group is exposed to market risk through its use of financial instruments and specifically to currency risk, interest rate risk and certain other<br />
price risks, which result both from its operating and investing activities. The Group’s risk management is coordinated at its headquarters, in<br />
close co-operation with the board of directors, and focuses on actively securing the Group’s short to medium term cash flows by minimizing the<br />
exposure to financial markets. Long term financial investments are managed to generate lasting returns.<br />
The Group does not actively engage in the trading of financial assets for speculative purposes nor does it write options. The most significant<br />
financial risks to which the Group is exposed to are described below.<br />
Credit risk<br />
The Group’s exposure to credit risk is limited to the carrying amount of financial assets recognized at the balance sheet date.<br />
Credit risk concerns the risk that a loss will be suffered by a party due to the reason that the other party to the transaction is unable to meet its<br />
obligations.<br />
The Group continuously monitors defaults of customers and other counterparties, identified either individually or by group, and incorporates<br />
this information into its credit risk controls. Where available at reasonable cost, external credit ratings and/or reports on customers and other<br />
counterparties are obtained and used. The Group’s policy is to deal only with creditworthy counterparties.<br />
The Group management considers that all the financial assets shown above under paragraph liquidity risk that are not impaired for each of the<br />
reporting dates under review are of good credit quality.<br />
In respect of trade and other receivables, the Group is not exposed to any significant credit risk exposure to any single counterparty or any group<br />
of counterparties having similar characteristics. The credit risk for liquid funds and other short-term financial assets is considered negligible,<br />
since the counterparties are reputable banks with high quality external credit ratings.<br />
Page 98<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
As of balance sheet dates, the Group’s exposure to credit risk is as summarised below:<br />
Receivables<br />
Trade receivables Other receivables<br />
Related Third Related Third Bank Derivative<br />
2009 party party party party amounts instruments Other<br />
Secured portion of maximum credit risk with collateral -- 1.188 -- -- -- -- --<br />
A. Carrying amount of financial assets that are<br />
not overdue and not impaired 17.293 74.692 26.407 2.548 43.135 -- 56<br />
B. Carrying amount of assets that are overdue<br />
but not impaired 79.532 21.045 -- 764 -- -- --<br />
- Carrying amount secured with collateral -- (1.188) -- -- -- -- --<br />
C. Carrying amount of assets that are impaired -- -- -- -- -- -- --<br />
- Overdue (gross carrying amount) -- 10.346 -- -- -- -- --<br />
- Impairment -- (10.346) -- -- -- -- --<br />
Total risk as of 31.12.2009 96.825 95.737 26.407 3.312 43.135 -- 56<br />
Receivables<br />
Trade receivables Other receivables<br />
Related Third Related Third Bank Derivative<br />
2008 party party party party amounts instruments Other<br />
Secured portion of maximum credit risk with collateral -- 6.301 -- -- -- -- --<br />
A. Carrying amount of financial assets that are<br />
not overdue and not impaired 28.283 90.134 9.190 5.246 7.482 -- 92<br />
B. Carrying amount of assets that are overdue but not impaired -- 4.030 -- 1.768 -- -- --<br />
- Carrying amount secured with collateral -- (6.301) -- -- -- -- --<br />
C. Carrying amount of assets that are impaired<br />
- Overdue (gross carrying amount) -- 10.108 -- -- -- -- --<br />
- Impairment -- (10.108) -- -- -- -- --<br />
Total risk as of 31.12.2008 28.283 94.164 9.190 7.014 7.482 -- 92<br />
Page 99<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
As of the balance sheet dates, aging of overdue trade receivables is given below:<br />
Receivables 2009<br />
Trade receivables<br />
Other receivables<br />
Not more than 30 days 38.837 --<br />
Within 1 month to 3 months 37.644 --<br />
Within 3 months to 12 months 29.150 --<br />
Within 1 year to 5 years 4.673 --<br />
More than 5 years 619 764<br />
Total 110.923 764<br />
Carrying amount secured with collateral (1.188) --<br />
Receivables 2008<br />
Trade receivables<br />
Other receivables<br />
Not more than 30 days -- --<br />
Within 1 month to 3 months 2.514 --<br />
Within 3 months to 12 months 8.035 --<br />
Within 1 year to 5 years 3.589 1.768<br />
Total 14.138 1.768<br />
Carrying amount secured with collateral (6.301) --<br />
Foreign currency risk<br />
The majority of the Group’s transactions are carried out in Euros and US Dollars. Exposure to currency exchange rates arise from the Group’s<br />
bank loans and due to related parties which are primarily denominated in US Dollars and Euros.<br />
Foreign exchange risk arises from future commercial transactions, recognized assets and liabilities and net investments in foreign operations.<br />
Page 100<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
The Group manages its currency exposure risk by organizing a balanced distribution between its foreign currency assets and commitments and<br />
by matching off the liabilities and receivables and its net currency position.<br />
USD EUR RUR GBP TL equivalent<br />
2009<br />
Cash and cash equivalents 22.799 251 142.931 -- 42.019<br />
Trade receivables 56.405 -- 13.575 -- 85.608<br />
Other receivables 18.280 -- -- -- 27.524<br />
Total foreign currency assets 97.484 251 156.506 -- 155.151<br />
Current borrowings 239.668 14.185 -- -- 391.512<br />
Non-current borrowings 438.718 87.384 -- -- 849.352<br />
Trade payables 14.319 33.302 -- 136 93.827<br />
Other payables 92 -- -- -- 139<br />
Total foreign currency liabilities 692.797 134.871 -- 136 1.334.830<br />
Net foreign currency position (595.313) (134.620) 156.506 (136) (1.179.679)<br />
Import 192.234 -- -- -- 297.405<br />
Export 1.515 -- -- -- 3.273<br />
Page 101<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
USD EUR RUR GBP TL equivalent<br />
2008<br />
Cash and cash equivalents 171 66 10.250 -- 929<br />
Trade receivables 665 168 8.109 -- 1.784<br />
Advances received 2.105 117 -- -- 3.435<br />
Other receivables 24.707 -- 20.016 -- 38.398<br />
Total foreign currency assets 27.648 351 38.375 -- 44.546<br />
Current borrowings 186.375 6.847 -- -- 296.515<br />
Non-current borrowings 928.448 25.549 -- -- 1.458.787<br />
Trade payables 8.588 12.314 539.516 27 67.248<br />
Due to related parties and other 112.330 -- -- -- 169.876<br />
Total foreign currency liabilities 1.235.741 44.710 539.516 27 1.992.426<br />
Net foreign currency position (1.208.093) (44.359) (501.141) (27) (1.947.880)<br />
Import 33.892 -- -- -- 43.738<br />
Export 608 1.987 -- -- 4.561<br />
On basis of the above an increase of 1% in the foreign exchange rates against the Turkish Lira as of 31 December 2009 will amount to a loss of TL<br />
11.797 (2008: TL 19.479) and a decrease will amount to profit of the same amount.<br />
Interest rates risk<br />
Interest rate risk arises because changes in interest rates may affect profitability as disclosed in financial statements.<br />
The Group is subject to interest rate risk as a result of differences in balancing off the dates or timing differences related to assets and liabilities<br />
maturing or to be subjected to price revision. The Group manages its interest rate risk by applying risk management strategies whereby it strives<br />
to balance off the dates of changes in interest rates related to assets and liabilities.<br />
Page 102<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
The Group’s interest rate position is as follows:<br />
2009 2008<br />
Fixed interest rate financial instruments<br />
Financial assets-time deposits<br />
- Time deposits 33.721 1.630<br />
Financial liabilities 427.458 78.906<br />
Variable interest rate financial instruments<br />
Financial liabilities 953.981 1.717.650<br />
As of balance sheet dates, the Group’s annual effective interest rates are as follows:<br />
2009 (%) USD EUR RUR TL<br />
Assets<br />
Cash and cash equivalents 1,7% -- 6,9% --<br />
Trade receivables 0,2% -- -- 7,3%<br />
Liabilities<br />
Borrowings 6,9% 7,0% -- 2,6%<br />
Trade payables 0,2% 0,5% -- 7,3%<br />
2008 (%) USD EUR RUR TL<br />
Assets<br />
Cash and cash equivalents -- -- -- 15,0%<br />
Trade receivables 0,4% 2,4% -- 15,5%<br />
Liabilities<br />
Borrowings 7,2% 7,6% -- 18,9%<br />
Trade payables 0,4% 2,6% -- 16,1%<br />
Page 103<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
As of 31.12.2009, if the variable interest rates of bank borrowing increased or decreased of +1% and -1% and if all other variables are held<br />
constant the result before tax would have been influenced favorably or unfavorably by TL 1.711 (2008: TL 5.525) for an increase and for a<br />
decrease in value of TL.<br />
Liquidity risk<br />
Liquidity risk comprises the risk that the Group becomes unable to find its payment requirements.<br />
The Group manages its liquidity needs by carefully monitoring scheduled debt servicing payments for long-term financial liabilities as well as<br />
cash-outflows due in day-to-day business. Liquidity needs are monitored in various time bands, on a day-to-day and week-to-week basis, as well<br />
as on the basis of a rolling 30 day projection. Long-term liquidity needs for a 180 day and 360 day lookout period are identified monthly.<br />
The breakdown of liabilities according to their contractual maturity is based on the maturity dates from the date of the balance sheet is given<br />
below:<br />
Book Total cash Within 3 to 12 Over<br />
2009 value out flow 3 months months 1 to 5 years 5 years<br />
Contractual maturities<br />
Borrowings 1.381.439 1.656.779 167.952 441.608 831.467 215.752<br />
Trade payables 301.852 300.479 174.298 -- 126.181 --<br />
Other liabilities 420.592 420.592 10.035 -- 410.334 223<br />
2.103.883 2.377.850 352.285 441.608 1.367.982 215.975<br />
Expected maturities<br />
Trade payables 841 841 841 -- -- --<br />
Other liabilities 18.674 18.674 677 -- 17.997 --<br />
19.515 19.515 1.518 -- 17.997 --<br />
Book Total cash Within 3 to 12 Over<br />
2008 value out flow 3 months months 1 to 5 years 5 years<br />
Contractual maturities<br />
Borrowings 1.796.556 2.348.398 144.716 199.119 1.246.388 758.175<br />
Trade payables 189.047 191.490 79.391 54.658 57.441 --<br />
Other liabilities 539.617 539.617 11.734 566 524.441 2.876<br />
2.525.220 3.079.505 235.841 254.343 1.828.270 761.051<br />
Expected maturities<br />
Trade payables 14.411 14.411 14.411 -- -- --<br />
Other liabilities 461 461 461 -- -- --<br />
14.872 14.872 14.872 -- -- --<br />
Page 104<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Capital risk management<br />
The Group’s capital management objectives are:<br />
• ensure the Group’s ability to continue as a going concern; and<br />
• to provide an adequate return to shareholders,<br />
by pricing products and services commensurately with the level of risk<br />
The Group monitors capital on the basis of the carrying amount of equity plus its total of current and non current borrowings (net debt) less cash<br />
and cash equivalents as presented on the face of the consolidated balance sheet.<br />
The Group sets the amounts of capital in proportion to its overall financing structure i.e. equity and financial liabilities. The Group manages<br />
the capital structure and makes adjustments to it in the light of changes in economic conditions and the risk characteristics of the underlying<br />
assets. In order to maintain or adjust the capital structure the Group may adjust the amount of dividends paid the shareholders, return capital to<br />
shareholders, issue new shares or sell assets to reduce debt.<br />
The Group’s capital to overall or financing ratio developed as follows:<br />
2009 2008<br />
Total borrowings (note 15) 1.381.439 1.796.556<br />
Less : Cash and cash equivalents (note 7) (43.191) (7.574)<br />
Net debt 1.338.248 1.788.982<br />
Total equity 223.622 (98)<br />
Overall financing 1.561.870 1.788.884<br />
Net debt to overall financing ratio 86% 100%<br />
Fair value of financial instruments<br />
Fair value is the amount at which a financial instrument could be exchanged in a current transaction between willing parties, other than in a<br />
forced sale or liquidation, and is best evidenced by a quoted market price, if one exists.<br />
The estimated fair values of financial instruments have been determined by the Group using available market information, management’s<br />
judgment and appropriate valuation methodologies. The following disclosure of the estimated fair value of financial instruments is made with<br />
the requirements of IAS 32. To the extent relevant and reliable information is available from the financial markets in Turkey; the fair value of the<br />
financial instruments of the Group is based on such market data. The fair values of the remaining financial instruments of the Group can only be<br />
estimated. The estimates presented herein are not necessarily indicative of the amounts the Group could realize in a current market exchange.<br />
The following methods and assumptions were used to estimate the fair value of the Group’s financial instruments:<br />
Page 105<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
Financial assets<br />
Monetary assets for which fair value approximates carrying value:<br />
-Balances denominated in foreign currencies are translated at year-end exchange rates. The fair value of certain financial assets carried at cost,<br />
including cash and due from banks, marketable securities plus the respective accrued interest are considered to approximate their respective<br />
carrying values.<br />
-The carrying value of the trade receivables net of provisions for uncollectible are considered to approximate their fair values.<br />
Financial liabilities<br />
Monetary liabilities for which fair value approximates carrying value:<br />
-The fair values of short-term bank loans and other monetary liabilities are considered to approximate their respective carrying values due to<br />
their short-term nature.<br />
-The fair values of long-term bank borrowings which are denominated in foreign currencies and translated at year-end exchange rates are<br />
considered to approximate their carrying values.<br />
Page 106<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the Year Ended 31 December 2009<br />
(All amounts in thousands of Turkish Lira (“TL”) unless indicated otherwise.)<br />
29. SUPPLEMENTARY CASH FLOW INFORMATION<br />
2009 2008<br />
Depreciation of property plant and equipment, note 13 42.525 37.400<br />
Amortization of intangible assets, note 14 12.469 9.198<br />
Provision for employee termination benefits, note 20 1.658 1.397<br />
Provision (release) for diminution in value of inventories, note 9 (164) 196<br />
Loss (profit) on sale of property, plant and equipment 89 (176)<br />
Increase (decrease) in provisions (1.521) (4.667)<br />
Profit on sale of subsidiaries (174.463) --<br />
Provision for unconsolidated subsidiaries, note 11 4.835 --<br />
Interest income, note 25 (33.111) (2.378)<br />
Interest expense, note 25 131.805 85.541<br />
Unearned interest on receivables, note 25 17.874 5.249<br />
Unearned interest on payables, note 25 (1.528) (577)<br />
Provision for doubtful receivables, note 8 238 6.519<br />
706 137.702<br />
Continued operations<br />
Cost of sales 41.066 35.237<br />
Operating expenses 2.504 2.149<br />
43.570 37.386<br />
Discontinued operations 11.424 9.212<br />
54.994 46.598<br />
Page 107<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş.<br />
Investor Information<br />
Ordinary General Meeting<br />
In line with a resolution passed at a meeting of the Board of Directors of <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş., the Company’s ordinary general<br />
meeting for 2009 will be held on 31 May 2010 at 14:00 am at the address of Bursa Organize Sanayi Bölgesi Sarı Cad. No: 29 - Bursa.<br />
Independent Auditor<br />
Engin Bağımsız Denetim ve Serbest Muhasebecilik Mali Müşavirlik A.Ş.<br />
Member of Grant Thornton International<br />
Yıldız Posta Cad. Dedeman İşhanı No: 48, Kat: 5<br />
34349 Gayrettepe-İstanbul<br />
Financial Information and Company News<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Elektrik Üretim A.Ş. annual reports, financial statements, auditor’s reports, explanations on special events and other information<br />
about the Company may be obtained from the Company’s website at http://zorluenerji.com.tr/ as well as from the <strong>Zorlu</strong> Group Investor Relations<br />
Department by email or telephone.<br />
Investor Relations<br />
Figen Çevik<br />
Corporate Finance and Investor Relations Director<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Plaza 34310 Avcılar İstanbul Turkey<br />
Phone: (+90 212) 422 01 07<br />
Email: yatirimci@zoren.com.tr<br />
Page 108<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Energy 2009 Annual Report
Contact<br />
Bursa (Head Office):<br />
Istanbul:<br />
Kırklareli:<br />
Ankara:<br />
Kayseri:<br />
Yalova:<br />
Organize Sanayi Bölgesi, Pembe Cadde,<br />
No: 13 16159 Bursa, Turkey<br />
Phone: +90 224 242 5616<br />
Fax: +90 224 242 5611<br />
<strong>Zorlu</strong> Plaza 34310 Avcılar - Istanbul, Turkey<br />
Phone: +90 212 456 2300<br />
Fax: +90 212 422 0099<br />
Büyükkarıştıran Kasabası, Teyyare Meydanı Mevkii<br />
39760 Lüleburgaz - Kırklareli, Turkey<br />
Phone: +90 288 427 31 70<br />
Fax: +90 288 427 31 77<br />
ASO 1.Organize Sanayi Bölgesi, Büyük Selçuklu Caddesi<br />
No: 1 06935 Sincan - Ankara, Turkey<br />
Phone: +90 312 267 1929<br />
Fax: +90 312 267 1939<br />
Organize Sanayi Bölgesi, 6. Cadde,<br />
No: 21 38070 Melikgazi - Kayseri, Turkey<br />
Phone: +90 352 321 2420<br />
Fax: +90 352 321 2918<br />
İpek Kağıt Fabrikası, <strong>Zorlu</strong> <strong>Enerji</strong> Tesisleri,<br />
Tokmakköyü 77700 Altınova - Yalova, Turkey<br />
Phone: +90 226 462 8900<br />
Fax: +90 226 462 8899<br />
Rotor Electric Power Yeni Sanayi Sitesi Yanı 8500<br />
Production Inc.<br />
Bahçe - Osmaniye<br />
Phone: +90 328 861 22 45<br />
Fax: +90 328 861 22 40<br />
Produced by Tayburn Kurumsal<br />
Tel: (90 212) 227 04 36 Fax: (90 212) 227 88 57<br />
www.tayburnkurumsal.com
www.zorluenerji.com.tr