to download - Voice Male Magazine
to download - Voice Male Magazine
to download - Voice Male Magazine
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Inside:<br />
• A Home<strong>to</strong>wn Challenge <strong>to</strong> Racism<br />
• Beyond the Isolation of Men<br />
• A Feminist Wife Embraces<br />
Men's Work<br />
• Young Men of Cofor Speaking Out<br />
• Gay & Queer: What's in a Name?
From the Edi<strong>to</strong>r<br />
Two Sides of Fathering<br />
The catchphrases "i_nvolved fathering"<br />
and "fathers' rights" have been at the<br />
forefront of an important debate raging<br />
across the country as more and more<br />
moms and dads .try <strong>to</strong> walk without stumbling<br />
through the still somewhat unfamiliar<br />
landscape of 21st-century American family<br />
life.<br />
On .one side of the debate are the growing<br />
number of men, whether in intact families or<br />
single-fathering, who have heeded the message<br />
of their own hearts or their children's<br />
mothers (or both) <strong>to</strong> see their role as fathers<br />
as a central component of their identity.<br />
These men, often swimming upstream .<br />
against assigned expectations for fathers, are<br />
involved in ways seldom seen in previous<br />
generations. They don't go after the bfg promotion<br />
at work; they arrange their schedules<br />
so they can take the kids <strong>to</strong> the dentist. They<br />
rarely miss a soccer game or school play. At<br />
home, they cook and clean and recognize<br />
that they don't have <strong>to</strong> make the big decisions<br />
unilaterally in order <strong>to</strong> feel good about<br />
themselves. They are getting support from<br />
dads' groups when their ktds are small; from<br />
parenting classes that involve fathers early<br />
and often. And they are also getting support<br />
from their partners or wives, current or ex,<br />
who recognize the simple fact that it is good<br />
for kids <strong>to</strong> have their dads actively involved<br />
in their lives and it is good for dads <strong>to</strong> be<br />
actively involved.<br />
Mothers of all stripes deserve a lot of<br />
credit for opening up the parenting circle<br />
wide enough <strong>to</strong> let fathers in. After all, raising<br />
children has long been seen as a<br />
woman's domain, not <strong>to</strong> be encroached upon<br />
by the masculine hand that <strong>to</strong>uches and<br />
directs so much of society. Even if the workload<br />
was gravely unbalanced, at least women<br />
knew that the realm of babies and children<br />
was theirs alone. Now, with the phenomenon<br />
of involved fathering, when a high~conflict<br />
separation or divorce looms large, a<br />
household's personal problem can easily<br />
grow in<strong>to</strong> a serious social threat <strong>to</strong> the stability<br />
of families and the safety of women<br />
and children.<br />
For many separated or divorced fathers,<br />
unsure of how family life in the era of<br />
involved fathering is "supposed" <strong>to</strong> be, there<br />
is confusion, frustration, and often anger.<br />
Sometimes those feelings are triggered by a<br />
family court judge awarding more time <strong>to</strong> an<br />
ex-partner <strong>to</strong> be with the children.<br />
Sometimes those feelings are triggered<br />
because a father is still angry at his ex-wife<br />
for ending the relationship or because he<br />
feels unsure about how <strong>to</strong> take care of the<br />
kids by himself. Many such fathers see their<br />
children's mothers as actively trying <strong>to</strong> deny<br />
2<br />
By Rob Okun<br />
' them access <strong>to</strong> their<br />
children, and more<br />
than a few get<br />
involved in what are<br />
often called "fathers'<br />
rights" groups. It's not<br />
uncommon <strong>to</strong> see<br />
handfuls of men with signs advo~ating th~<br />
rights of dads picketing in front of family<br />
courts in many states, inCluding several in<br />
the Northeast.<br />
Some may very well be getting a raw deal.<br />
If so, it is essential t;hat divorce lawyers, psychotherapists,<br />
family service court officers,<br />
media<strong>to</strong>rs, guardians ad litem and judges<br />
educate themselves about those circumstances<br />
and take steps <strong>to</strong> intervene when a<br />
man has been inacc.urately targeted as part of<br />
a strategy in a contentious cus<strong>to</strong>dy complaint.<br />
However, a dangerously high number<br />
of cases have involved fathers with a documented<br />
his<strong>to</strong>ry of abuse. Some have been<br />
arrested for domestic assault and battery;<br />
some have had restraining orders taken out<br />
against them-not as a strategy, but because<br />
they have threatened <strong>to</strong> h,urt or have hurt<br />
their former partners. Sometimes their chHdren,<br />
<strong>to</strong>o, have been at risk.<br />
Thankfully; the old-school response <strong>to</strong><br />
domestic violence-violence behind a family's<br />
closed doors is nobody's business-has<br />
evolved in<strong>to</strong> sophisticated trainings for<br />
police, social service agencies, physicians,<br />
school personnel, and emergency room staff<br />
<strong>to</strong> recognize signs of abuse. Society has said<br />
loudly and clearly that it won't <strong>to</strong>lerate bat-·<br />
tering.<br />
Nonviolent fathers looking for a fair<br />
shake in cus<strong>to</strong>dy cases where they have<br />
legitimate claims deserve support. But those<br />
who are intimidating their children's mothers,<br />
harassing the court, or affiliating themselves<br />
with groups more interested in sustaining<br />
conflict than in the well-being of<br />
their children have forfeited any such claim.<br />
· They'd be well advised <strong>to</strong> s<strong>to</strong>p wasting precious<br />
time tearing down their children's<br />
mothers and concentrate instead on building<br />
up their relationships with their children.<br />
Involved, non-abusive fathers may have<br />
their hands full raising their children, but<br />
they have much <strong>to</strong> teach the fathers who've<br />
crossed the line. Maybe some of them who<br />
coach a team or juggle a carpool will find<br />
time <strong>to</strong> show up when the fathers' rights<br />
dads are picketing the court and will take a<br />
few minutes <strong>to</strong> talk with them. Maybe they'll<br />
band <strong>to</strong>gether, <strong>to</strong>o, <strong>to</strong> say there is another<br />
way.<br />
TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />
FEATURE ARTICLES<br />
A Feminist Wife Embraces Men's Work 8<br />
By Wtllow Broche<br />
Men Together: Pho<strong>to</strong>s of 19th-Century<br />
<strong>Male</strong> Friendships 10<br />
Edited by David Deitcher<br />
Beyond the Isolation of Men 13<br />
By Michael Burke<br />
Book Review: Kate Bomstein's<br />
Gender Outlaw 15<br />
By Mark Ribble<br />
Losing My <strong>Voice</strong> 19<br />
By Patrick Lemmon<br />
COLUMNS & OPINION<br />
From the Edi<strong>to</strong>r 2<br />
Direc<strong>to</strong>r's <strong>Voice</strong> 3<br />
Mail Bonding 4<br />
Men@Work<br />
Four <strong>to</strong> Receive MRC Awards 5<br />
<strong>Voice</strong>s of Youth: Young Men of Color<br />
Speaking Out 12<br />
By An<strong>to</strong>nio Lewis<br />
ColorLines: A Home<strong>to</strong>wn Challenge<br />
<strong>to</strong> Racism 14<br />
By j eff Harris<br />
OutLines: Gay and Queer: What's in<br />
a Name? 16<br />
By Michael Greenebaum<br />
GBQ Resources 17<br />
Fathering: Fathering Through the S<strong>to</strong>rm 18<br />
By jeff Kelly Lowenstein<br />
Men &: Health: Meditation: It's Not<br />
What You Think 20<br />
By joe Zaske<br />
Notes from Survivors: Healing from<br />
Sexual Addiction 21<br />
By Louis Castagno<br />
MRC Programs &: Services 23<br />
Resources 24<br />
Thank You 25<br />
Calendar 26<br />
I<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong> is published quarterly by the Men 's<br />
Resource Center of Western Ma ss!lchusetts, mailed<br />
<strong>to</strong> donors and subscribers, and distributed at select<br />
locations throughout Western Massachusetts.<br />
The mission of the Men's Resource Center of Western<br />
Massachusetts is <strong>to</strong> support men and develop men's<br />
leadership in challenging all forms of oppression in<br />
our lives, our families, and ou r communities. Our programs<br />
support men <strong>to</strong> overcome the damaging effects<br />
of rigid and stereotyped masculinity, and simultaneously<br />
confront men's patterns of personal and sodetal<br />
violence and abu se <strong>to</strong>ward women, children, and<br />
other men.<br />
Membership<br />
The MRC is funded by individual and organizational<br />
contributions, and fees for services. Please join us in<br />
our vision of men healing, growing, ending violence.<br />
Annual subscription and membership is $25. Send <strong>to</strong><br />
MRC, 236 Pleasant St, Amherst, MA 01002<br />
Main Office: 236 Nonh Pleasant Street • Amherst, MA<br />
01002 • 413.253.9887 • Fax: 413.253.4801<br />
Springfidd Office: 29 Howard Street • Springfield, MA<br />
01105 • 413.734.3438 -Hampshire<br />
Community<br />
Email: mrc@valinet.com<br />
un111ec1~<br />
Website: www.mensresourcecenter.org<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
Administrative Staff<br />
Exsclltlrs Direc<strong>to</strong>r- Steven Botkin<br />
Associate Direc<strong>to</strong>r- Rob Okun<br />
Dlnc<strong>to</strong>r of Operations - Carl Erikson<br />
Admltllstratlrs Assistant - Spirit Joseph<br />
Men Overcoming VIolence<br />
Dlnc<strong>to</strong>rs - Russell Bradbury-Carlin<br />
C/11/t:al Supsrrtsor - Steven Botkin<br />
Parlller Serrlcss Coordina<strong>to</strong>r (on leave) - Sara Elinoff<br />
IBferlm Plllfllsr Services Coordl1a<strong>to</strong>r -Jan Eidelson<br />
lltalcB Ctltlrtllna<strong>to</strong>rtcourt Ualso11 - Steve Trudel<br />
F11111kll1 Co1111ty CoDitilna<strong>to</strong>r - Joy Kaubin<br />
#lamptiBI CODify Coordina<strong>to</strong>r - Scott Girard<br />
NDrlh Q11abbl1 Community Educa<strong>to</strong>r- Tom Sullivan<br />
Group LBadsrs -Russell Bradbury-Carlin, Eve<br />
Bogdanove. Sara Elinofl, Karen Fogliatti, Scali Girard, Steve<br />
Jefferson, Joy Kaubin, Devon Klein, Dot LaFratta, Gary<br />
Newcomb, Rob Okun, Tom Sullivan, Sieve Trudel<br />
IBfBfll - Helen Lee<br />
Hampden County Programs<br />
Direc<strong>to</strong>r of Immigrant and Refuges Program -<br />
Juan Carlos Arean<br />
Youth Programs<br />
CIHirtll11at11r - Jeff Harris<br />
Hll/yDicB GIDUP LBadBt - Gary Bullard<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong><br />
EdHor- Rob Okun<br />
Ma•aglllg Ednor - Michael Burke<br />
Se11lor Edi<strong>to</strong>r - Steven Botkin<br />
Designer- candid design<br />
CDpf EdltDtS- Michael Dover. Maurice Posada<br />
Support Programs<br />
Dl111c<strong>to</strong>r -Allan Arnaboldi<br />
Support Group Facilita<strong>to</strong>rs<br />
Allan Arnaboldi, Michael Baumgartner. Ken Bernstein, Slephen<br />
Bradley, Michael Burke, Jim Devlin, Carl Erikson, Tim Gordon,<br />
Ken Howard, Rick Kapler. Arne Korstvedt, Damien Licata, Gabor<br />
Lukacs, Rick Martin, Bob Mazer. Peter McAvoy, Jim Napolitan,<br />
Tom Schuyt, Chris Shanahan, Sheldon Snodgrass, Bob<br />
Sternberg<br />
Board of Direc<strong>to</strong>rs<br />
Chair - Michael Dover<br />
VIce-Chair - Thorn Herman<br />
Clerk/TrsasutBr- Peter Jessop<br />
Members - Mario Cruz. Jenny Daniell, Nancy Girard, Tom<br />
Gardner. Ty Jouber/, Yoko Ka<strong>to</strong>. Brenda L6pez, Matt Ouellet<br />
Sudhakar Vamathevan<br />
Advisory Board<br />
Michael Bardsley, Dean Cycon, Bailey Jackson. Luis Melendez.<br />
Matthew Morse, Cheryl Rivera, Elili!beth Scheibel, Diane<br />
Troderrnan, Felice Yeske/<br />
Edi<strong>to</strong>r's Note<br />
Opinions expressed herein may not represent the views of all<br />
staff. board, or ~rembers of the MRC. We welcome letters,<br />
articles, news items, article ideas, and events of interest. We<br />
encourage unsolicited manuscripts, but cannot be responsible<br />
<strong>to</strong>r their loss. Manuscripts will be returned and responded<br />
<strong>to</strong> if accompanied by a stamped return envelope. Send <strong>to</strong><br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>, 236 N. Pleasant St., Amherst, MA 01002.<br />
Advertising<br />
For rates and deadlines call <strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong> Advertising at<br />
(413) 253-9887. Ex/. 22.<br />
Direc<strong>to</strong>r's <strong>Voice</strong> ----------- By Steven Botkin<br />
Don't Ask/Don't Tell:<br />
A Challenge <strong>to</strong> Change<br />
Several years ago the U.S. military<br />
adopted the "don't ask/don't tell" policy<br />
<strong>to</strong> deal with (or avoid) the issue of<br />
gay men and lesbians serving in the armed<br />
forces . Seen by some as an improvement<br />
over the "no gays in the military" policy,<br />
this plan offered a compromise: as long as<br />
you stay "in the closet" and don't let anyone<br />
know about your sexual orientation, the<br />
military won't ask you and you can stay in<br />
the service. Silence and invisibility have<br />
been the price a job and, for many, a career.<br />
And now we hear the Boy Scouts of ·<br />
America (BSA) using the same don't<br />
ask/don't tell strategy in an attempt <strong>to</strong><br />
maintain their traditional opposition <strong>to</strong><br />
homosexuality without appearing <strong>to</strong> discriminate.<br />
"Although the BSA makes no<br />
effort <strong>to</strong> discover the sexual orientation of<br />
any person, we believe an avowed homosexual<br />
is not a role model for the faithbased<br />
values espoused in the Scout Oath<br />
and Law" (BSA website). The message is<br />
very clear. Nobody asks and nobody tells.<br />
You are qualified <strong>to</strong> be in scouting only if<br />
you agree <strong>to</strong> pledge allegiance <strong>to</strong> a very<br />
straight and very narrow definition of masculinity.<br />
It is easy <strong>to</strong> criticize the military and the<br />
Boy Scouts for their overtly oppressive policies.<br />
However, these two institutions, bastions<br />
of masculinity in our culture, have<br />
simply made explicit one of the fundamental<br />
rules of male socialization: if you want<br />
<strong>to</strong> be a "real man," you don't ask and you<br />
don't tell. And the impact of this social policy<br />
affects us all.<br />
Don't ask why boys don't cry or play<br />
with dolls. Don't ask why Daddy hits<br />
Mommy. Don't ask about the flicker of sadness<br />
or fear in your friend's eyes. Don't ask<br />
if you could give him a hug. Don't ask for<br />
attention <strong>to</strong> your own pain or fear. Don't<br />
ask for a shoulder <strong>to</strong> lean on ... or cry on.<br />
Don't tell about the violence you have<br />
seen or heard. Don't tell about how you ·<br />
were abused. Don't tell about the ways you<br />
were violent or abusive. Don't tell how<br />
much you are hurt or scared. Don't tell<br />
about your feelings at all. Don't tell about<br />
your desires, or about your hopes, or your<br />
dreams. Don't tell about who you really are<br />
and what you really want.<br />
Even .before we have entered the Scouts<br />
or joined the military, we are taught the<br />
don't ask/don't tell policy. No matter what<br />
our sexual orientation, we learn not <strong>to</strong> tell<br />
or be anything that' would expose us as not<br />
fitting in<strong>to</strong> the dominant definition of masculinity.<br />
We also learn not<br />
<strong>to</strong> ask other men anything<br />
that could expose<br />
them. Together we learn<br />
<strong>to</strong> pledge allegiance <strong>to</strong> a<br />
straight and narrow<br />
model of manhood.<br />
Silence and invisibility is<br />
the price for our safety<br />
and acceptance.<br />
But what would happen<br />
if men began <strong>to</strong> break this silence,<br />
question the mask of masculinity, and tell<br />
the truth about our experiences and our<br />
feelings? What would happen if we joined<br />
<strong>to</strong>gether <strong>to</strong> pledge allegiance <strong>to</strong> our wonderful<br />
diversity of maleness/femaleness and<br />
challenge the institutions, laws, and culture<br />
that promote don't ask/don't tell policies?<br />
What would happen if we created an organization<br />
that could be a focal point for supporting<br />
a growing community of men and<br />
women committed <strong>to</strong> asking and telling?<br />
For the past 19 years at the Men's<br />
Resource Center we have been exploring<br />
answers <strong>to</strong> these questions. Each week<br />
more than 100 men in Men Overcoming<br />
Violence groups and women in MOVE partners'<br />
groups meet <strong>to</strong> tell one another about<br />
their experiences with violence and abuse,<br />
and ask how <strong>to</strong> have nonviolent relation- ·<br />
ships. Each week men come <strong>to</strong>gether in<br />
four different drop-in suppon groups (two<br />
general groups, one for gay/bisexuaVquestioning<br />
men, and one for survivors of childhood<br />
abuse) <strong>to</strong> ask one another about their<br />
authentic selves and tell one another their<br />
real feelings. And each week young men<br />
join in two (soon <strong>to</strong> be three) leadership<br />
and violence prevention groups <strong>to</strong> create a<br />
new culture of masculinity where asking<br />
and telling are valued as signs of integrity<br />
and strength rather than punished or<br />
shamed as signs of weakness.<br />
Each ~ear we join <strong>to</strong>gether as a community<br />
<strong>to</strong> affirm our commitment <strong>to</strong> challenging<br />
and changing the don't ask/don't tell<br />
culture of masculinity and <strong>to</strong> honor 111en<br />
and women who do ask and tell. On<br />
November 1 you are invited <strong>to</strong> join the<br />
Men's Resource Center at our sixth annual<br />
Challenge & Change Celebration (see s<strong>to</strong>ry<br />
on page 5). We are no longer willing <strong>to</strong> be<br />
silent and isolated. We are coming out!<br />
Fall2001<br />
3
..<br />
WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU<br />
Write us! Please send typewritten, double-spaced letters <strong>to</strong>: VOICE MALE , MRC, 236 North<br />
Pleasant Street, Amherst, MA 01002 or FAX us at (413) 253-4801,<br />
E-mail: mrc@valinet.com; include address and phone. Letters may be edited for<br />
clarity and length. Deadline for the Winter 2002 Issue is November 10, 2001.<br />
l<br />
l<br />
.<br />
3<br />
r<br />
]<br />
3<br />
e<br />
(<br />
J<br />
C<br />
h<br />
:t<br />
Working Against Racism<br />
It was most encouraging <strong>to</strong> see the good<br />
turnout in Amherst last May at the rally<br />
for Robert Green (whose business was the<br />
target of a racist attack; see related s<strong>to</strong>ry,<br />
page 14), and <strong>to</strong> hear the excellent presentations<br />
from the various groups. I wish we<br />
could be more a.ctive in the work of implementing<br />
these resolutions, but we're getting<br />
old (almost 90) and the vigil is about<br />
all we can do. We're especially aware of<br />
connections on and in all our issues, such<br />
as the ones we deal with a lot: prisons,<br />
prisoners and the death penalty, police<br />
brutality, etc., with racism.<br />
It's good <strong>to</strong> know the Men's Resource<br />
Center is there working with MEN!<br />
Thankfully, women are getting more of<br />
their due.<br />
Lee and Margaret Holt<br />
Amherst, Mass .<br />
Supporting Men Works<br />
MRC, thank you for being there! When I<br />
moved here for graduate school last fall, I<br />
was so nervous about finding a supportive<br />
place for a young gay guy. Thankfully an<br />
acquaintance mentioned it <strong>to</strong> me at the<br />
S<strong>to</strong>newall Center open house. Everybody<br />
was great <strong>to</strong> me and I can easily say these<br />
past eight months have been the best of<br />
my life-with no small contribution from<br />
the MRC. I am grateful and awed at what<br />
good people can do when so inspired.<br />
Thank you.<br />
Can't Live Without You<br />
George F. Roberson<br />
Hinsdale, Mass.<br />
Thanks <strong>to</strong> my friendship with Paul Zelizer,<br />
direc<strong>to</strong>r of the Taos men's center (Men's<br />
Resource Center of Northern New<br />
Mexico), I have been aware of the work of<br />
. the Men's Resource Center (of Western<br />
Massachusetts) and the existence of <strong>Voice</strong><br />
<strong>Male</strong> for some years. The issues of VM I<br />
picked up at the recent NOMAS Men &:<br />
Masculinity conference in Denver, however,<br />
were so full of superb articles that I<br />
decided I could live no longer without a<br />
subscription. Thank you many times both<br />
for the work that the MRC is doing <strong>to</strong> heal<br />
the gender wounds of so many people, and<br />
for the thoughtful, well-written articles in<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>. Good wishes in the continuation<br />
of your valuable work.<br />
Bruce C. Bar<strong>to</strong>n<br />
Little<strong>to</strong>n, Colo.<br />
CAN YOU HELP?<br />
The MRC needs:<br />
PC compatible scanner<br />
Color Printer<br />
Digital Camera<br />
Contact: Carl Erikson<br />
(413) 253-9887, Ext. 13<br />
!<br />
c<br />
1<br />
a<br />
.(<br />
'(<br />
I<br />
Internal Mediation -Life Beyond Therapy<br />
"Internal Mediation" is based on "The Work of Byron Katie" and Thorn Herman is a certified<br />
Practitioner of the Work. Internal Mediation is a simple and radical process that fundamentally alters our<br />
relationship <strong>to</strong> our thoughts.<br />
Thorn can be invited <strong>to</strong> present Internal Mediation <strong>to</strong> groups in a workshop setting. When invited<br />
Thorn works by donation. He also works with clients individually through his psychotherapy practice in<br />
Northamp<strong>to</strong>n and Greenfield, MA<br />
For more information check out Thorn's web site at:<br />
4<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
MEN(®WORK<br />
Challenge & Change 2001<br />
Four <strong>to</strong> Receive Men's Resource Center Annual Award<br />
The Men's Resource Center has selected<br />
four people <strong>to</strong> receive awards at its sixth<br />
annual Challenge &: Change Celebration on<br />
Thursday, November 1, at the Inn at<br />
Northamp<strong>to</strong>n. This year's honorees include<br />
an Amherst guidance counselor, two leaders<br />
in the area's nonprofit sec<strong>to</strong>r, and a student<br />
advocate for gay, lesbian, bisexual and<br />
transgendered (GLBT) people.<br />
Challenge &: Change award recipients<br />
include Barry Brooks, guidance counselor at<br />
Amherst Regional Middle School, and<br />
David Sharken, executive direc<strong>to</strong>r of the<br />
Food Bank of Western Massachusetts. John<br />
Kazlauskas, Jr., a recent graduate of the<br />
University of Massachusetts and an activist<br />
on GLBT issues, is receiving the Ozzy Klate<br />
Memorial Youth Award, and Kristi Nelson,<br />
executive direc<strong>to</strong>r of the Women's Fund of<br />
Western Massachusetts, is the first recipient<br />
of the organization's Challenge &: Change<br />
Woman's Award.<br />
Barry Brooks has<br />
been a guidance counselor<br />
at Amherst<br />
Regional Middle<br />
School and Amherst<br />
Regional High School<br />
since 1977. Born in<br />
Washing<strong>to</strong>n, D.C., he<br />
attended segregated<br />
public schools there<br />
until I956, then<br />
attended and graduated from Mount<br />
Hennon School in Northfield, Mass. He<br />
received his B.S. from Springfield College in<br />
1964. After teaching in Connecticut, he<br />
and his family moved <strong>to</strong> Amherst in 1971,<br />
where he attended the Graduate School of<br />
Education at the University of Massachusetts<br />
and became the first direc<strong>to</strong>r of the A Better<br />
Chance (ABC) House in Amherst. He continues<br />
<strong>to</strong> serve on ABC's board of direc<strong>to</strong>rs.<br />
Barry has been a basketball coach and track<br />
and field official at the high school, has<br />
served as vice president of the African<br />
American Music Society of Springfield, and<br />
is a member of Black Men of Greater<br />
Springfield. He is also a staff member at the<br />
W.E.B. DuBois Academy, a Saturday school<br />
sponsored by that organization. He has<br />
hosted a weekly jazz program on the radio<br />
for the past 18 years. "Year in and year out,<br />
Barry has been there for the young people<br />
of Amherst and he has extended the reach<br />
of his heart and mind <strong>to</strong> Springfield as<br />
well," said Steven Botkin, MRC executive<br />
direc<strong>to</strong>r. "He is a corners<strong>to</strong>ne' of our community<br />
and we are honored <strong>to</strong> call him a<br />
friend and ally"<br />
David Sharken has<br />
been working at the<br />
Food Bank of Western<br />
Massachusetts for<br />
nearly 10 years and<br />
has been its executive<br />
direc<strong>to</strong>r for the past<br />
six, expanding the<br />
organization's.outreach<br />
and food distribution<br />
efforts as well as<br />
strengthening nutrition education and community<br />
service learning programs. David<br />
was also instrumental in creating the<br />
Massachusetts Emergency Food Assistance<br />
Program <strong>to</strong> provide a larger flow of nutritious<br />
food at no cost <strong>to</strong> emergency<br />
providers throughout the Commonwealth.<br />
"David is a key voice for people in need<br />
across the region," says Rob Okun, MRC<br />
associate direc<strong>to</strong>r. "He's a constant presence,<br />
reminding us that, amidst apparent<br />
plenty, there is hunger. He demonstrates,<br />
<strong>to</strong>o, that we all can be part of the solution."<br />
Previous <strong>to</strong> his food bank experience,<br />
David managed economic and community<br />
development activities for U.S. Rep.<br />
john Olver. He has been a consultant on<br />
non-profit management and actively<br />
worked on community and public policy<br />
issues for 20 years. He has a master's<br />
degree in Public Policy from Claremont<br />
Graduate School and a B.A. in organizational<br />
development from the University of<br />
Michigan. David currently serves on the<br />
national delegation of America's Second<br />
Harvest, the national network of food<br />
banks. He also is on the board of direc<strong>to</strong>rs<br />
of the Council of Social Agencies of<br />
Hampshire County, the regional Federal<br />
Emergency Management Agency, the<br />
Human Services Forum of Hampden<br />
County, and the New England Anti-Hunger<br />
Network. ,<br />
john Kazlauskas,<br />
Jr., graduated summa<br />
cum laude from the<br />
University of<br />
Massachusetts earlier<br />
this year with majors<br />
in sociology and<br />
English and a minor<br />
in women's studies.<br />
He was president of<br />
the distinguished visi<strong>to</strong>rs<br />
program, a resident assistant, and a<br />
member of the S<strong>to</strong>newall Center's speakers'<br />
bureau. John also helped organize a<br />
statewide Action for Campus<br />
Transformation (ACT) conference and was<br />
a peer educa<strong>to</strong>r on issues around sexual<br />
harassment. His senior project, an educational<br />
film titled Speak Up!: Improving the<br />
Lives of GLBT Youth , is being nationally distributed<br />
<strong>to</strong> high schools and colleges<br />
through the Media Education Foundation<br />
of Northamp<strong>to</strong>n. He won one of three Class<br />
of 1941 Humanitarian Awards from the<br />
UMass Honors Program this year and was<br />
on the Youth Resource Honor Roll in<br />
2000-a list of the 100 <strong>to</strong>p activists for<br />
GLBT youth in the nation. He is now<br />
attending New York University, pursuing an<br />
M.A. in an interdisciplinary program studying<br />
both film and activism/social inequality,<br />
building on the work he did as an undergraduate.<br />
"The Ozzy Klate Award is for<br />
young men who demonstrate a deep commitment<br />
<strong>to</strong> developing leadership and community<br />
involvement along with a passion<br />
for creative expression and innovation,"<br />
said Botkin. "john fits these criteria perfectly<br />
We're glad <strong>to</strong> have the chance <strong>to</strong><br />
honor a young man doing good work that<br />
we support."<br />
Kristi Nelson has<br />
worked in nonprofit<br />
management and<br />
development for the<br />
past 15 years, raising<br />
millions of dollars for<br />
causes ranging from<br />
the environment <strong>to</strong><br />
hospice care. As executive<br />
direc<strong>to</strong>r of the<br />
Women's Fund of Western Massachusetts,<br />
she recently completed a campaign <strong>to</strong> raise<br />
$5 million for the fund's endowment, mobilizing<br />
women's resources on behalf of the<br />
needs of women and girls. Kristi serves on<br />
the advisory boards of Cancer Connection,<br />
Class Action, and the Men's Resource<br />
Center. She also recently participated as the<br />
community member of the MRC's Strategic<br />
Planning Committee, which designed and<br />
oversaw the development of a five-year plan<br />
for the organization. "I was privileged <strong>to</strong><br />
work with Kristi on our strategic planning,"<br />
said Michael Dover, MRC board chair. "Her<br />
passion and energy was always palpable at<br />
our meetings, as was her considerable experience<br />
and wisdom. It continues <strong>to</strong> be a<br />
distinct privilege <strong>to</strong> have her presence as an<br />
ally She's given us so much it seemed only<br />
fitting that Kristi would be selected <strong>to</strong> be<br />
our first female award recipient."<br />
Tickets for the November 1st dinner at<br />
the Inn at Northamp<strong>to</strong>n are $30 with<br />
options available <strong>to</strong> be a patron, sponsor or<br />
host. For more information call the MRC at<br />
(413) 253-9887, Ext. 22.<br />
Fall2001<br />
5
MEN(®WORK<br />
New Board Members Join Men's Resource Center<br />
The Men's Resource Center's (MRC)<br />
board of direc<strong>to</strong>rs said a reluctant farewell<br />
<strong>to</strong> one member and welcomed three new<br />
members not long ago. Shellie Taggart, a<br />
domestic violence specialist with the<br />
Massachusetts Department of Social<br />
Services and a board member since 1997,<br />
left the board <strong>to</strong> pursue a master's degree in<br />
public policy. She will continue as a member<br />
of the MRC's Anti-Racism Committee,<br />
which examines the organization's efforts <strong>to</strong><br />
challenge racism as a key part of its mission.<br />
"Shellie has been a tremendous asset<br />
<strong>to</strong> the board," said its chair, Michael Dover.<br />
"She has combined head and heart in<br />
everything she's done with and for us. She<br />
brought the perspective of someone who<br />
has worked in the battered women's movement,<br />
has worked <strong>to</strong> end racism in communities<br />
and workplaces, and as a supervisor<br />
for a major state agency. We will miss her<br />
wisdom, insight, and spirit."<br />
joining the board are Wilham Dowd,<br />
Jack Hornor, and Matt Ouellett. Bill Dowd<br />
is president of Blair, Cutting and Smith<br />
Insurance Agency Group in Amherst. An<br />
Amherst native, Bill first joined the MRC<br />
board's Development Committee as a community<br />
member. He is a member of the<br />
Bill Dowd<br />
Amherst Rotary and<br />
has been active in the<br />
state insurance association.<br />
He and his wife<br />
Bonnie have three children,<br />
two nine-year-old<br />
sons and a 13-year-oid<br />
daughter.<br />
Jack Hornor, an<br />
independent fund-rais-<br />
ing consultant, grew<br />
up in New York City<br />
and worked for many years as a teacher. In<br />
1990 Jack came out of the closet, and<br />
moved <strong>to</strong> "a welcoming community,"<br />
Northamp<strong>to</strong>n. He chairs the Northamp<strong>to</strong>n<br />
Housing Partnership. Jack has served on<br />
the boards of a variety of local gay and lesbian<br />
organizations,<br />
and in 1995 was the<br />
chief fund-raiser for<br />
the Domestic<br />
Partnership Coalition.<br />
Jack was a charter<br />
member of the MRC<br />
Advisory Board, and<br />
chairs its<br />
Development<br />
Committee. He and<br />
Jack Hornor<br />
his partner, Ron Skinn,<br />
live in Northamp<strong>to</strong>n.<br />
Dr. Matthew<br />
Ouellett is associate<br />
direc<strong>to</strong>r of the Center<br />
For Teaching ( CFT),<br />
University of<br />
Massachusetts<br />
Amherst, where he<br />
works with faculty and<br />
teaching assistants <strong>to</strong> Matt Ouellet<br />
develop skills for<br />
teaching and learning in the diverse classroom.<br />
He presents workshops on teaching,<br />
diversity, and social justice issues regionally<br />
and nationally. Matt is also adjunct lecturer<br />
at Smith College School for Social Work,<br />
teaching courses on the implications of<br />
racism for clinical social work practice, and<br />
at the UMass School of Education, where<br />
he is conducting research on the Safe<br />
Schools Project for Gay and Lesbian Youth<br />
in high schools. He and his partner, Ron<br />
Parent, live in Springfield.<br />
For more inlormation about the MRC<br />
board and its members, contact Michael<br />
Dover at ( 413) 253-9887, ext. 16.<br />
From Here <strong>to</strong> Maternity: Adding and Subtracting at MOVE<br />
After nearly a decade as one of the central<br />
players in the Men Overcoming Violence<br />
program (MOVE) at the Men's Resource<br />
Center, Sara Elinoff has gone on a year's<br />
maternity leave. Sara, the first woman <strong>to</strong><br />
work at the MRC, -created MOVE's pioneering<br />
partner support services in 1992 (with<br />
inspiration from MRC board member Nancy<br />
Girard). Partner services offer regular contact,<br />
including a weekly support group, for<br />
partners and ex-partners of men in the<br />
MRC's state-certified program for men acting<br />
abusively in their families. In addition <strong>to</strong><br />
serving as partner services coordina<strong>to</strong>r, for<br />
the past two and a half years Sara has served<br />
as co-direc<strong>to</strong>r of MOVE, sharing the position<br />
with Russell<br />
Bradbury-Carlin and<br />
for the past year, she<br />
has co-led one of the<br />
weekly MOVE groups.<br />
"Sara's commitment<br />
<strong>to</strong> ending domestic<br />
violence is a source of<br />
inspiration for all of us<br />
in this challenging<br />
field," Bradbury-Carlin<br />
said. "Going back <strong>to</strong> Sara Elinoff<br />
1985 when she began<br />
working in the battered-women's<br />
movement,<br />
Sara has been a<br />
tireless advocate for<br />
women. What has<br />
been inspiring about<br />
working with her has<br />
been her ability <strong>to</strong><br />
embrace working with<br />
men." Sara's article Jan Eidelson<br />
"What's a Nice<br />
Feminist Like Me Doing in a Place Like<br />
This?" in the Winter 1999 issue of <strong>Voice</strong><br />
<strong>Male</strong> chronicles her journey from working at<br />
a battered-women's shelter <strong>to</strong> working at the<br />
Men's Resource Center. "We celebrate with<br />
Sara and her family and look forward <strong>to</strong> her<br />
strong ongoing connection <strong>to</strong> the MRC,"<br />
said MRC executive direc<strong>to</strong>r Steven Botkin.<br />
"Most of all we look forward <strong>to</strong> a new member<br />
joining the MRC family."Joining Elinoff<br />
on maternity leave is partner outreach counselor<br />
Mary Dupont-Brandt. "Mary's steady.<br />
presence and dedication <strong>to</strong> MOVE's mission<br />
has been admirable. We'll miss her," said<br />
Bradbury-Carlin.<br />
While Elinoff is on leave Bradbury-Carlin<br />
will assume responsibility as direc<strong>to</strong>r qf<br />
MOVE. Elinoff is being replaced by interim<br />
partner services coordina<strong>to</strong>r, Jan Eidelson,<br />
who began work in August. Eidelson, who<br />
most recently was working as a counselor at<br />
the New England Learning Center for<br />
Women in Transition (NELCWIT) , the<br />
Greenfield, Mass.-based battered-women's<br />
program: has a long his<strong>to</strong>ry<br />
of working in the<br />
field , primarily in<br />
Philadelphia.<br />
Also joining the<br />
MOVE staff is Karen<br />
Fogliatti, a seasoned batterer<br />
intervention counselor<br />
who worked in the<br />
field for several years in<br />
the Athol-Orange, Mass.<br />
area. Fogliatti, who also Karen Fogliatti<br />
began work in August, will be co-leading<br />
three groups a week.<br />
She had previously worked as a community<br />
domestic violence awareness educa<strong>to</strong>r<br />
in the Athol-Orange area and is a longtime<br />
ally and colleague of the MOVE program<br />
and the MRC.<br />
6<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
MEN(@WORK<br />
l<br />
Fathers at Work<br />
The Silent Epidemic<br />
Same Sex Domestic Violence<br />
Assistance for young, low-income, noncus<strong>to</strong>dial<br />
fathers wanting <strong>to</strong> provide financial<br />
and emotional support for their children<br />
may be on the way. A three-year, $10<br />
million program by the Charles Stewart<br />
Matt Foundation is bei!lg initiated <strong>to</strong> help<br />
fathers whose incomes fall below the<br />
poverty line for a single adult find jobs<br />
and learn new employable skills. The<br />
foundation's Fathers at Work Initiative<br />
wants <strong>to</strong> help such fathers in developing<br />
careers, finding jobs, and acquiring skills.<br />
"If young, low-income fathers are <strong>to</strong><br />
fulfill their financial responsibility <strong>to</strong> their<br />
children, there must be a greater impact<br />
on the personal and social barriers <strong>to</strong><br />
employment that those men face," said<br />
William S. White, Matt Foundation president.<br />
White hopes lessons learned from the<br />
project will help shape future policy<br />
debates on social welfare and child support<br />
reform.<br />
Six organizations were chosen by the<br />
foundation <strong>to</strong> work on the initiative. Each<br />
will receive around $800,000 over the next<br />
three and a half years <strong>to</strong> plan and implement<br />
the program. The organizations<br />
include the Center for Employee<br />
Opportunities in New York City; Chicago<br />
Employment Services, Inc.; Impact<br />
Services Corporation in Philadelphia;<br />
Rubicon Programs, Inc., in Richmond,<br />
California; Total Action Against Poverty in<br />
Roanoke, Virginia; and Vocational<br />
Foundation in New York .. More information<br />
can be found at the foundation's website,<br />
www.mott.org/.<br />
Gay Fatherhood on TV<br />
A video documentary about gay fathers<br />
is in the works for public television. San<br />
Francisco Bay area filmmaker Johnny<br />
Symons is directing and producing the documentary-in-progress<br />
with a focus on the<br />
personal, social, and political impact of gay<br />
men raising children. Producers say the<br />
film will portray five gay men, coupled or<br />
single, who have made a conscious choice<br />
<strong>to</strong> form their own nuclear families either<br />
through adoption, foster parenting, or surrogacy.<br />
For more information about the<br />
film, write daddies@ix.netcom.com.<br />
Surveys conducted over the past five<br />
years by the Gay Men's Domestic<br />
Violence Project (a statewide social service<br />
agency with a satellite office in<br />
western Massachusetts) have revealed<br />
that one in four gay, bisexual and transgendered<br />
(GBT) men have experienced<br />
domestic violence. The demographics<br />
gathered in these surveys also show<br />
that men from a wide range of backgrounds<br />
have been victimized by abusive<br />
partners. Men from all age ranges,<br />
ethnicity and income levels report having<br />
been abused at some point by an<br />
intimate partner. According <strong>to</strong> The<br />
Network!La Red; Ending Abuse in<br />
Lesbian, Bisexual Women and<br />
Transgender Communities (another<br />
statewide<br />
agency), the<br />
same ratio of<br />
one-in-four<br />
applies <strong>to</strong><br />
women in<br />
those communities.<br />
Notably, the<br />
one-in-four<br />
ratio is equivalent<br />
<strong>to</strong> the<br />
results that<br />
the U.S.<br />
Justice Department has released based<br />
on their surveys of heterosexual<br />
women. To date, no surveys have been<br />
conducted of heterosexual males,<br />
although the Centers for Disease<br />
Control has recently released a report<br />
stating that one in five victims of<br />
domestic violence are men (straight and<br />
GBT).<br />
It is apparent that domestic violence<br />
does not discriminate based on age,<br />
income, ethnicity background, sex, gender<br />
or sexual orientation. Domestic<br />
violence can and does happen in all<br />
types of relationships. With the accompanying<br />
"side effects" of physical trauma,<br />
mental health disorders, homelessness,<br />
and loss of economic stability (<strong>to</strong><br />
name a few) , it also becomes apparent<br />
that domestic violence is a very serious<br />
public health threat.<br />
Why does the issue of same sex<br />
domestic violence receive so little exposure<br />
in the media? Perhaps because the<br />
issue is rarely talked about within the<br />
Gay Lesbian Bisexual and Transgender<br />
community (GLBT) where fear of further<br />
oppression may inhibit a thorough<br />
examination. As an oppressed group,<br />
the GLBT community may be hesitant<br />
<strong>to</strong> address issues many are afraid will<br />
further "stain" the community. Also,<br />
there is protectionism· of "queer love,"<br />
which endorses over-protection of same<br />
gender relationships and unwillingness<br />
<strong>to</strong> recognize abuse when it happens.<br />
Some idolize "queer love" as a deconstruction<br />
of many of the power differences<br />
in heterosexual relationships.<br />
This defensiveness can build community<br />
denial about abusive relationships.<br />
Domestic violence of any kind is<br />
about power<br />
and controlone<br />
person<br />
exercising<br />
power and<br />
control over<br />
another, and<br />
the victim is<br />
losing his or<br />
her power<br />
and control<br />
over his or<br />
her life. The<br />
fear, isolation,<br />
and embarrassment that follows can be<br />
paralyzing, and many victims feel they<br />
cannot speak out. Talking about what<br />
has happened, sharing s<strong>to</strong>ries, and<br />
reaching out <strong>to</strong> those who you think<br />
might need help are all good ways <strong>to</strong><br />
start addressing this silent epidemic.<br />
Volunteers are needed, from sta{fing<br />
a hot line <strong>to</strong> providing a temporary<br />
"safe home." To find out about helping,<br />
call any of the following organizations:<br />
Gay Men's Domestic Violence Project,<br />
800-832-1901; The Network /La Red:<br />
Ending Abuse in Lesbian, Bisexual<br />
Women and Transgender Communities,<br />
617-423-SAFE; Violence Recovery<br />
Program at Fenway Communi~y Health,<br />
800-834-3242.<br />
- Mark Cannien<br />
Mark Cannien is the Western<br />
Massachusetts coordina<strong>to</strong>r for the Gay<br />
Men's Domestic Violence Project.<br />
Fall2001<br />
7
A Feminist Wife Embraces Men's Work<br />
Sleeping with the Enemy<br />
By Willow Brocke<br />
As a feminist, I can talk for hours about<br />
the living, breathing reality of women's<br />
economic, social and sexual oppression.<br />
However, when I first heard about the<br />
men's movement I was highly suspicious.<br />
"Why do they need a movement?" I thought.<br />
"They already own and control everythingwhat's<br />
their problem?" The whole thing<br />
smelled of backlash <strong>to</strong> me. Then I met my husband<br />
and started learning <strong>to</strong> love a man--close<br />
up. Slowly I began <strong>to</strong> understand what some of<br />
the issues might be. I know that as a woman I<br />
will always remain an outsider <strong>to</strong> the men's<br />
movement and would never attempt <strong>to</strong> define<br />
the nature of male oppression. I also know that<br />
my husband's struggle <strong>to</strong> reevaluate what it<br />
means <strong>to</strong> be a man has not been undertaken in<br />
a vacuum. When you share the same bed,<br />
bathroom, kitchen table and bank account<br />
with someone, you feel the bumps and stretches<br />
of their personal growth. I had two choices:<br />
resist the changes or grow with him. So, like<br />
any normal marriage partner, I did both.<br />
Laundry Rights<br />
I'm sure my early feminist friends would<br />
tell me that falling in love with the "enemy"<br />
clouds one's political judgment. Perhaps they're<br />
right, but when the dating-fire died down and<br />
we began <strong>to</strong> have those future-of-our-relationship<br />
discussions, I'm sure it was the feminist in<br />
me who decided she'd better hold on <strong>to</strong> this<br />
one. We were having an argument in my apartment<br />
one afternoon when it suddenly dawned<br />
on me that during the whole irritating dialogue,<br />
he had been washing, drying, and folding<br />
my laundry! He wasn't doing it <strong>to</strong> impress<br />
me. In fact he was frustrated as heck with<br />
me-he was doing it because it was there.<br />
At that moment, the light bulb came on<br />
over my heart-along with the words: I can<br />
work with this. The point is that my husband<br />
"gets it." He is one of those men who honestly<br />
does half of the housework and child care. He<br />
is fair; and he's been that way for 10 years now.<br />
So when he began <strong>to</strong> challenge me about my<br />
sexist behavior, I had <strong>to</strong> admit he had earned<br />
the right.<br />
Defensive Driving<br />
"I really hate it when you do that," he said<br />
one evening on the way home from a dinner<br />
party.<br />
"What?" I asked, already defensive as I<br />
pulled out on<strong>to</strong> the highway.<br />
"Make sweeping generalizations about<br />
men ." I rewound the party in my head. "You<br />
mean when Larry called the guys downstairs· <strong>to</strong><br />
play pool?"<br />
"Yes," he said. "I heard you say something<br />
about 'the boys and their <strong>to</strong>ys,' and then you<br />
laughed."<br />
I was caught; it was a sweeping generalization.<br />
But wasn't it true? Didn't men generally<br />
seem <strong>to</strong> avoid meaningful conversation with<br />
each other by distracting themselves with some<br />
kind of game, gadget or activity?<br />
"Why play pool then?" I asked, confident<br />
of my observation. "Why not just talk <strong>to</strong> each<br />
other?" This was when he really started <strong>to</strong><br />
sound exasperated-! realized this was going<br />
<strong>to</strong> be more than a friendly debate.<br />
"If you'd been paying attention," he<br />
declared, "you might have noticed that for the<br />
hour before we went downstairs we were trying<br />
<strong>to</strong> talk-but the women were dominating<br />
the conversation. Not just in terms of sheer<br />
verbiage but also re-interpreting, re-defining,<br />
and re-directing what the men said."<br />
"We did not!" I denied. "Give me an example!<br />
" I always ask for examples when I know<br />
I'm losing an argument.<br />
"Remember when Doug was trying <strong>to</strong> talk<br />
about how much he enjoyed taking his son<br />
Jamie on a fishing trip last month?" he asked.<br />
I did. He continued, "Before he could even ·<br />
get the s<strong>to</strong>ry out, his wife started telling everyone<br />
the trip had been a kind of 'initiation' for<br />
Jamie."<br />
"Yeah, so?" I asked defiantly.<br />
"The point," he concluded, "is that this is<br />
his wife's interpretation of what was important<br />
about the trip. We never got <strong>to</strong> hear the rest of<br />
Doug's s<strong>to</strong>ry because the women started talking<br />
about the whole 'male initiation' thing<br />
Doug gave up."<br />
"Oh," I said, starting <strong>to</strong> see that he might<br />
have a fledgling point. After a couple more<br />
equally good examples, I was beginning <strong>to</strong><br />
understand the retreat <strong>to</strong> the pool table in a<br />
different light and realized why my sweeping<br />
generalization had sunk the eight ball on the<br />
first shot.<br />
Holding Back the Flood<br />
Over the next few weeks, with my husband's<br />
help, I began <strong>to</strong> see a pattern of interaction<br />
I had- not been aware of. My words were<br />
defining the emotional, moral and relational<br />
aspects of our life <strong>to</strong>gether. Words like "appropriate,"<br />
"assertive," "compassionate," "fair,"<br />
"compromise," and "consultative" were all<br />
helpful terms for negotiating our relationship-but<br />
they were all coming out of my<br />
mouth-arid they were flooding the place.<br />
Why was this happening? It was happening<br />
because I was good at it. I'd been practicing<br />
since the day I'd read the sign on the kindergarten<br />
wall that stated in no uncertain terms<br />
that girls were made of "sugar and spice and<br />
everything nice." Before the year was out, my<br />
kinder girl friends and I had already started a<br />
dub <strong>to</strong> save the bugs that the "mean" boys had<br />
wounded. It was our job <strong>to</strong> understand how<br />
the bugs felt-we were the girls. Practicing the<br />
language of emotion, compassion, and connection<br />
was not only expected of us, it was our<br />
responsibility; we were in training <strong>to</strong> hold families<br />
<strong>to</strong>gether. While the boys were doing the<br />
bug squashing that was expected of them, we<br />
were busy squishing our substantial power in<strong>to</strong><br />
the language of relationships.<br />
Apparently, now that kindergarten was<br />
over, my husband was trying <strong>to</strong> let me know<br />
that my rapid-fire ability <strong>to</strong> define and shape<br />
our emotional landscape with words was interfering<br />
with his ability <strong>to</strong> define it for himself.<br />
As much as I hated <strong>to</strong> admit it, if my husband<br />
was calling me sexist-it was probably a fair<br />
call.<br />
Now for the Hard Part<br />
Nothing is true for everyone-all the time.<br />
Some women are terrible at expressing their<br />
feelings and some men are wonderful at it.<br />
However, if there is a general pattern of men<br />
and women "squishing" our power in<strong>to</strong> gender-acceptable<br />
"inner" and "outer" domains,<br />
8<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
what will help us find a better balance?<br />
It's a <strong>to</strong>ugh question. If we want <strong>to</strong> shift<br />
the balance of gender power, not only do<br />
men have <strong>to</strong> loosen their grip on the political<br />
and economic world-including definitions<br />
of the terms-we women have <strong>to</strong> be<br />
willing <strong>to</strong> loosen our grip on verbally<br />
exploring and mapping the emotional landscape<br />
between people. How can we do this?<br />
Well, these days my husband attends a<br />
men's group where he talks about his experiences<br />
and builds close relationships-9n<br />
his own terms. What does he say there? Is<br />
he finding the best words? I have no idea.<br />
That's why it's so important that he goesand<br />
I don't.<br />
Things are also different at horne now.<br />
And since my husband and I are both family<br />
counselors, we }lave a habit of offering our<br />
experience <strong>to</strong> others. Here are a few tripletested<br />
suggestions for learning <strong>to</strong> share the<br />
emotional word-space in your relationship<br />
(see sidebar at right) .<br />
Following these suggestions may prove<br />
<strong>to</strong> have a powerful effect on the terms of<br />
your relationship. What I notice is that my<br />
definitions of relationship issues no longer<br />
cancel my husband's out-he's got his own<br />
words for what's going on and he's not<br />
afraid <strong>to</strong> use them. You might think this creates<br />
more conflict in our relationship but it<br />
doesn't.<br />
Just as women who "make it" in business<br />
often bring a fresh perspective <strong>to</strong> the<br />
maledominated world of commerce, men<br />
who learn <strong>to</strong> speak the language of the h'eart<br />
have a lot <strong>to</strong> teach women about how <strong>to</strong><br />
love the people we love-without losing<br />
ourselves.<br />
Taking the time <strong>to</strong> listen and value my<br />
husband's experience of the relational world<br />
has not weakened my perspective as a feminist-only<br />
expanded it. I may be a lone<br />
voice on the way <strong>to</strong> the feminist forum, but,<br />
l suspect that women will never really be<br />
free <strong>to</strong> express their collective power in the<br />
world until men are free <strong>to</strong> express the collective<br />
contents of their hearts-and vice<br />
versa. So take a load off, feminist sisters.<br />
Sharing the power of the emotional domain<br />
is a lot like getting help with the dirty laundry-it<br />
frees you up <strong>to</strong> do other things.<br />
Willow Brocke is a counselor, writer, mother,<br />
and graduate student who lives in<br />
Summerland, British Columbia. This article is<br />
reprinted with permission from Synchronicity:<br />
The <strong>Magazine</strong>, PO Box 63118, RPO West<br />
Hillhurst, Calgary AB T2N 455 Canada.<br />
YCHOSYNTHEStS<br />
spiritual psychology<br />
for a new millennium<br />
®-Two year certification program in holistic counseling<br />
® Month~ weekend format- Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 'OJ through june '02<br />
® Designed for Human Service Professionals and students<br />
® Now accepting applications<br />
® loin us for our twcn~·second consecutive<br />
® Ct:Us available<br />
Free Introduc<strong>to</strong>ry. Even<br />
Friday. September 14, 7:00-8:30pm<br />
The Synthesis Center<br />
Fall2001<br />
9
Men in an Age of Innocence<br />
Pho<strong>to</strong>s of 19th-Century <strong>Male</strong> Friendships<br />
Edited by David Deitcher<br />
W<br />
en we think of American manhood in<br />
he 19th century, images of frontiersmen,<br />
cowboys, rotund tycoons, and<br />
rawboned urban 'workingmen may come <strong>to</strong> mind.<br />
But a new book of pho<strong>to</strong>graphs depicting male<br />
friendships from that time casts our notions of<br />
early American masculinity in another, quite different<br />
light.<br />
In Dear Friends: American Pho<strong>to</strong>graphs of Men<br />
Together, 1840-1918 (Abrams, $35.00), art his<strong>to</strong>rian<br />
David Deitcher has brought <strong>to</strong>gether more than<br />
100 rare pho<strong>to</strong>graphs commemorating male friendships<br />
from this era. Drawing on daguerreotypes,<br />
tintypes, early postcards, and ambrotypes from<br />
public and private collections, the book vividly<br />
portrays the common practice among 19th-century<br />
American men of commemorating their friendships<br />
with a visit <strong>to</strong> the local pho<strong>to</strong>grapher. In so doing,<br />
it sheds new light on our perhaps misconceived<br />
ideas about male physical intimacy during these<br />
decades.<br />
On the News Hour with jim Lehrer, Richard<br />
Rodriguez called these pho<strong>to</strong>graphs "most effective<br />
Subjects unknown, c.l910. Pho<strong>to</strong>grapher unknown. Inscription in the negative reads: "#28.<br />
Cowboy 'Dance Stag'." Postmarked on verso: "WinnerS. Dak., Oct. 20, lilleg.l."<br />
Collection of Henry Weintraub.<br />
Left: Subjects unknown,<br />
c.l885. Pho<strong>to</strong>grapher<br />
unknown. Collection of<br />
Herbert Mitchell.<br />
Right: Subjects unknown,<br />
c.l870. Pho<strong>to</strong>grapher<br />
unknown. Collection of<br />
Henry Weintraub.<br />
10<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
Subjects unknown, c.l907. Pho<strong>to</strong>grapher unknown. Inscription<br />
reads: "Have not received an answer yetljust foolish<br />
picture lOne in return please. 'C." Posnnarked on verso: "Ford<br />
(?) City, April13 PM 1907." Collection of Peter Miller.<br />
and unsettling," adding, "l dare anyone,<br />
homosexual or heterosexual, <strong>to</strong> tell me<br />
exactly what these pho<strong>to</strong>graphs mean."<br />
Indeed, the book's author, who teaches at<br />
Cooper Union in New York City, notes that<br />
in the late Vic<strong>to</strong>rian period, far from being<br />
physically inhibited, as we might suppose,<br />
men commonly established intimate, even<br />
passionate relationships with other men.<br />
They "posed for pho<strong>to</strong>graphers holding<br />
hands, entwining limbs, or resting in the<br />
shelter of each other's accommodating bodies,<br />
innocent of the suspicion that such<br />
behavior would later arouse." Yet while such<br />
pho<strong>to</strong>graphs have long been collected by gay<br />
men, Deitcher reminds us that they remain<br />
essentially mysterious or ambiguous in<br />
meaning: "they are powerless <strong>to</strong> communicate<br />
anything more than the following: This<br />
is how these men looked on that day when<br />
they sat for the pho<strong>to</strong>grapher."<br />
On these pages are selections from the<br />
book. For more information on Dear Friends:<br />
American Pho<strong>to</strong>graphs of Men Together,<br />
1840-1918, contact Harry N. Abrams, Inc.,<br />
100 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. lOOll,<br />
(212) 206-7715.<br />
Fall2001 11
<strong>Voice</strong>s of Youth ----------------------By An<strong>to</strong>nio Lewis<br />
.Young Men of Color Speaking Out<br />
Since last spring a group of young men<br />
of color, including me, has been<br />
meeting at the Men's Resource Center<br />
(MRC) having free-ranging conversations<br />
about our place in contemporary society.<br />
For a couple of hours each week, over<br />
pizza, we get <strong>to</strong> know one another and<br />
take a hard look at important issues surrounding<br />
our emerging masculinity. We<br />
named our group the Taking Action<br />
Committee (TAC) .<br />
Led by MRC youth programs coordina<strong>to</strong>r<br />
Jeff Harris, TAC is part of the men's<br />
center's broader set of youth programs.<br />
Since starting up, we've organized a picnic<br />
attended by 60 younger and older men of<br />
color, and a leadership forum where<br />
younger and older men carne <strong>to</strong>gether <strong>to</strong><br />
talk about men's lives, manhood, and<br />
political and social change.<br />
I see TAC as a place where young men<br />
of color can have in-depth discussions<br />
about racism and prejudice. We get <strong>to</strong>gether<br />
on Wednesday afternoons in a big living<br />
room at the MRC offices. We're a mix of<br />
high school students from Amherst<br />
Regional High School who live at the A<br />
Better Chance (ABC) House in Amherst,<br />
and college students from the University<br />
of Massachusetts. We talk about major<br />
issues that affect and reflect our position<br />
as young men of color in society.<br />
TAC discusses ways <strong>to</strong> break racial barriers<br />
and <strong>to</strong> uncover better ways of dealing<br />
with them. Some of the <strong>to</strong>pics we've taken<br />
up include "What It Means <strong>to</strong> Be on a<br />
Journey <strong>to</strong> Healthy Manhood" and "How<br />
Leadership Can Help Young Men of Color<br />
Deal with Oppression." The group offers<br />
techniques and collaborative ideas that can<br />
actually be used in real-life situations. TAC<br />
is also a time set apart from everyday life<br />
where we, as young men of color, can talk<br />
about our feelings and interpretations of<br />
life. My first experiences of the group were<br />
about getting <strong>to</strong> know new people who<br />
were going through the same things, dealing<br />
with the same problems I was dealing<br />
with and had gone through my whole life.<br />
Negative generalizations regarding people<br />
of color have been deeply imbedded in<br />
American society. The Taking Action<br />
Committee is a program that challenges<br />
these negative generalizations and, in this<br />
way, tries <strong>to</strong> rebuild America's foundations.<br />
The group enables young people of color <strong>to</strong><br />
witness real, older role models who aren't<br />
afraid <strong>to</strong> talk about important issues normally<br />
hidden in the outskirts of society.<br />
TAC is an elaborate venting session of sorts<br />
that can reduce the everyday stresses that<br />
have unhealthy effects on our lives. Racism<br />
is a way of life in America, and <strong>to</strong> us as<br />
adolescents TAC represents hope in continuing<br />
the struggle against it.<br />
From the beginning, my impressions of<br />
the group were positive because, for the<br />
first time, I was able <strong>to</strong> witness young men<br />
of color speaking as though there were no<br />
constraints. It was as though we were in a<br />
different world, or even a bubble, not caring<br />
what might happen if we really<br />
addressed how we feel. My impression of<br />
those college students actually giving back<br />
<strong>to</strong> us younger men was good, because they<br />
had not forgotten that they were once in<br />
our same position. Our group felt like a<br />
tight-knit family, even from the first session.<br />
We vented-some of us for the first timeabout<br />
problems we all faced and we all<br />
shared.<br />
It was extremely valuable <strong>to</strong> participate<br />
in this group, because so rarely do people<br />
of color come <strong>to</strong>gether <strong>to</strong> talk about the<br />
issues that stress us every day. Sometimes<br />
we do not even realize what the p~oblerns<br />
are, so they pass us by without our having<br />
the opportunity <strong>to</strong> resolve them. I feel it is<br />
very important for me <strong>to</strong> continue in TAC,<br />
because the group enables people of color<br />
<strong>to</strong> take time <strong>to</strong> talk about what we actually<br />
live.<br />
It seems as though we take time for<br />
everything else in life, even if it does not<br />
affect our future, so I feel that it is our<br />
obligation and,<br />
even more, <strong>to</strong><br />
our benefit, <strong>to</strong><br />
take time once a<br />
week <strong>to</strong> talk<br />
about issues and<br />
problems that<br />
have affected us<br />
since birth.<br />
Having discussions<br />
on <strong>to</strong>pics<br />
appealing <strong>to</strong> us<br />
allows us <strong>to</strong> distribute<br />
our knowledge <strong>to</strong> one another, so<br />
that each of us becomes a teacher, as well as<br />
a learner.<br />
To people of color of all ages, I would<br />
strongly recommend corning <strong>to</strong> meetings<br />
like those in TAC. I have found them <strong>to</strong> be<br />
extremely enlightening sessions that have<br />
changed, supported, and strengthened my<br />
own views about racism, prejudice, and,<br />
overall, society's perceptions of people of<br />
color. For me, the benefits became immediately<br />
apparent.<br />
I first found out about the Taking Action<br />
Committee from my father and, later on,<br />
the details were filled in by one of my<br />
friends. He had <strong>to</strong>ld me that there were<br />
incentives <strong>to</strong> joining the program, such as<br />
money and food. I have <strong>to</strong> say that one<br />
hour in<strong>to</strong> the discussions my original<br />
motive for going-the "incentives"-had<br />
changed. My motivation and goal had now<br />
become <strong>to</strong> teach others and <strong>to</strong> make sure<br />
others knew they had an ear <strong>to</strong> tell their<br />
s<strong>to</strong>ries <strong>to</strong>. As soon as I and others felt this<br />
satisfaction of listening, and being heard,<br />
future attendance was not an issue. Every<br />
group member was present on a consistent<br />
basis, making TAC overall a strong and lasting<br />
program. I'm glad the group has started<br />
up again so I'll be able <strong>to</strong> talk about real-life<br />
issues with other young men of color. I<br />
hope more young men of color will join us.<br />
An<strong>to</strong>nio Lewis, 17, is a senior at Amherst<br />
(Mass.) Regional High School. For more<br />
information about the Taking Action<br />
Committee of Mens Resource Center youth<br />
programs, contact jeff Harris at ( 413) 253-<br />
9887, Ext. 31, or mrc@valinet.com.<br />
12<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
The Isolation of Men<br />
Living on an Island<br />
By Michael Burke<br />
No man is an Island," john<br />
Donne famously wrote,<br />
about four centuries ago.<br />
Yet many men have lived as if they<br />
were: on the surface, independent<br />
and self-sufficient; but inside, isolated<br />
and alone. I've been one of<br />
them.<br />
As a volunteer facilita<strong>to</strong>r of the<br />
Men's Resource Center's regular<br />
open men's support group, I'm<br />
always curious about what brings<br />
new men <strong>to</strong> the group each week.<br />
Often they're propelled by crisisthe<br />
end of a relationship, loss of a<br />
job, a difficult time with a partner-and<br />
they're looking for help<br />
from men who've been through it.<br />
Some are drawn mainly by the<br />
urge <strong>to</strong> connect with other men.<br />
In both cases, I've heard men admit, "I<br />
have no friends." Or, "I don't have any men<br />
friends-all my friends are women." Or<br />
even, "I'm lonely. There's no one I can talk ..<br />
<strong>to</strong>. I've been feeling isolated and depressed.<br />
Sadly, these are common themes in men's<br />
s<strong>to</strong>ries. I've experienced them myself.<br />
I first noticed my own isolation as a<br />
senior in college. A relationship with a<br />
woman I'd known since high school had<br />
just ended, and in addition <strong>to</strong> feeling jealousy<br />
(another man was involved) and the<br />
pain of loss, I experienced a sudden emptiness:<br />
the realization that I had no fnends. I<br />
had invested most of my social and emotional<br />
energy in the relationship, and when<br />
that evaporated, I looked around me <strong>to</strong> see<br />
only a wasteland, denuded of social supports.<br />
I did have a couple of friends going <strong>to</strong><br />
school in other places, but I didn't feel comfortable<br />
enough <strong>to</strong> pick up the phone and<br />
let them know what was going on. My family<br />
was nearby, but I couldn't talk <strong>to</strong> them<br />
about it. I had coworkers I liked, but I hadn't<br />
seen the need or taken the time <strong>to</strong> cultivate<br />
them as friends. AbruptJy ·sunk in<strong>to</strong> a<br />
near-suicidal depression, I was living on a<br />
desert island whose stark landscape is familiar<br />
<strong>to</strong> many men: alone with my thoughts<br />
and my pain, barely able <strong>to</strong> get up and make<br />
my bed and eat something, let alone leave<br />
my apartment, I had no one I could trust <strong>to</strong><br />
share my feelings, no one I could ask: "Am I<br />
crazy? Am I going <strong>to</strong> be OK?" .<br />
One night, desperate and sad, wantmg<br />
only <strong>to</strong> make the pain s<strong>to</strong>p hurting, I called<br />
a suicide hotline and spoke <strong>to</strong> a volunteer,<br />
then went <strong>to</strong> see a therapist. As I heard<br />
Fall2001<br />
myself talk about taking my own life, it<br />
frightened me, sobered me, and I knew I<br />
couldn't do it. Scratch that off the list.<br />
Somehow I picked myself up--I threw<br />
myself in<strong>to</strong> my final year of college, started<br />
weightlifting and writing poetry, and slowly<br />
began <strong>to</strong> develop friendships with the<br />
coworkers I hadn't made time for before<br />
(and who'd dismissed me as pompous and<br />
aloof since I wouldn't engage with them).<br />
Some of these relationships were not ideal,<br />
but they met critical needs for me at the<br />
time. I began <strong>to</strong> recover a sense of who I<br />
was, and <strong>to</strong> put things back <strong>to</strong>gether in my<br />
life.<br />
Flash forward eight years, <strong>to</strong> 1991.<br />
Married now, with a four-month-old baby, I<br />
had just finished grad school in California<br />
(which I loved) and moved <strong>to</strong><br />
Massachusetts (which I hated). I didn't want<br />
<strong>to</strong> be here, I was cut off from all my gradschool<br />
buddies, I was struggling <strong>to</strong> learn <strong>to</strong><br />
be a father and I was unemployed <strong>to</strong> boot.<br />
jobs I was qualified for weren't plentiful at<br />
the time, so I began working at home doing<br />
freelance book editing (something I'd done<br />
part-time before), taking care of my daughter<br />
while my wife, then a grad student herself,<br />
was in school.<br />
This was not a role I was prepared for,<br />
and looking back, I can see that I was<br />
dep~essed much of the time. Socially, I had<br />
no supports whatsoever; all the people I .<br />
worked for were just distant voices on the<br />
phone; we had one car, and my big escap~<br />
was <strong>to</strong> go <strong>to</strong> the post office <strong>to</strong> express-mat! a<br />
project. Finally our next-door neighbor<br />
introduc·ed me <strong>to</strong> a pickup basketball game<br />
that happened twice a week. A good num-<br />
her of regulars showed up, and I came<br />
<strong>to</strong> really like some of those guys. just<br />
getting out and running around, joking<br />
with other men my age and older,<br />
was incredibly good for me-but I<br />
never got <strong>to</strong> know any of them as<br />
friends. Most I didn't know beyond<br />
first names, and what they were like<br />
on the court. One day after a game<br />
some of the African-American men sat<br />
down <strong>to</strong> talk about the churches they<br />
attended; I eavesdropped while cooling<br />
down, fascinated, as they talked<br />
not about religion, but about fellowship.<br />
They sought out churches where<br />
they felt welcomed and comfortablewhere<br />
they found community. They<br />
knew something important, some-<br />
Justin Freed l k f<br />
thing I had yet <strong>to</strong> oo or.<br />
It <strong>to</strong>ok me over four years, and another<br />
crisis <strong>to</strong> realize that I needed <strong>to</strong> connect<br />
with ~en in a real way: My wife and I had<br />
another child, but instead of cementing our<br />
relationship it seemed <strong>to</strong> threaten its very<br />
existence. Once again I was depressed, but I<br />
didn't know it. I was isolated, but only<br />
dimly aware; someone else (a female friend)<br />
had <strong>to</strong> tell me, and a couples' counselor<br />
(also a woman) fortunately gave me the<br />
phone number for a drop-in men's group.<br />
After a few weeks of dithering, I finally got<br />
up the courage <strong>to</strong> go.<br />
That group--the MRC's Sunday night<br />
group in Amherst-was a catalyst for me <strong>to</strong><br />
change my life, and it proba~ly went a lo~~<br />
way <strong>to</strong>ward saving my marnage (though Its<br />
important <strong>to</strong> note that relationships don't<br />
get "fixed" in men's groups). I became a regular<br />
participant, going back week after<br />
week and since 1997 I've been a volunteer<br />
facili~a<strong>to</strong>r. Getting involved with the MRC<br />
in that and other capacities has helped me<br />
connect with other men who, like me, are<br />
also struggling with isolation, friendship,<br />
fatherhood, sexuality; relationships, work,<br />
and the like. Identifying and dealing with<br />
my depression, a recurring theme in my life,<br />
has helped me <strong>to</strong> know myself, and <strong>to</strong> practice<br />
self-care. I have good and understanding<br />
friends now whom I trust, with whom I<br />
can share and be myself, and among whom I<br />
feel relaxed and whole. Some of them struggle<br />
with depression and isolati~n <strong>to</strong>o, so<br />
even when we're in the grip of It, we can<br />
often talk about it honestly and feel better.<br />
End of s<strong>to</strong>ry? Have I "beate1;1" isolation<br />
and depression? It's always a temptation,<br />
especially when I'm acting in the role of<br />
continued on page 22<br />
13
-------------------By Jeff Harris<br />
A Home<strong>to</strong>wn Challenge <strong>to</strong> Racism<br />
W<br />
hat year is it, 2001 or 1971? What<br />
makes me ask this question?<br />
Recently, a man I've known since<br />
I was a youth in my home<strong>to</strong>wn of Amherst,<br />
Mass. (where the Men's Resource Center is<br />
headquartered), had a rock thrown through<br />
the window of his typewriter and computerbusiness.<br />
KKK was typed on display<br />
machines in front of the s<strong>to</strong>re. When that<br />
happened, it made me think of my father's<br />
attempts <strong>to</strong> start his own business in<br />
Amherst in the 1970s. It was the time of the<br />
Vietnam War, Watergate, racial problems,<br />
and only one black-owned business in the<br />
area-that I knew of-my father's.<br />
My father was Fred Harris, and he owned<br />
and operated Amherst Bowling Alley on the<br />
main street in <strong>to</strong>wn. I was so proud of him!<br />
I was ten years old and my father trusted me<br />
<strong>to</strong> help run the alley while he <strong>to</strong>ok on a second<br />
job <strong>to</strong> make ends meet. We had no real<br />
support from our extended family, or from<br />
the financial community. The biggest problem<br />
we faced was not owning the building<br />
that housed the bowling alley, which, unfortunately,<br />
was for sale. My dad approached<br />
every bank in the Amherst-Northamp<strong>to</strong>n<br />
area for financial help <strong>to</strong> acquire the building<br />
but everywhere he turned he was rejected.<br />
We thought a bowling alley in a community<br />
with three colleges would be seen as a<br />
gold mine of an idea. We were disappointed<br />
that the financial community did not agree.<br />
Someone encouraged Dad <strong>to</strong> try nearby<br />
Springfield. Happily, the second bank he<br />
approached there gave him the loan. Once<br />
he received it, though, the owner of the<br />
building decided <strong>to</strong> sell <strong>to</strong> someone else.<br />
My father was heartbroken. So was I. Dad<br />
had received 17 "no's" before the bank in<br />
Springfield accepted his application. It felt<br />
' like there was a conspiracy against us.<br />
The 1970s were a special time for me. It<br />
was my father and me against the world!<br />
With the struggles of minorities, the liberating<br />
anthems of the sixties calling for equality<br />
and peace, I thought it was only a matter<br />
of time before other minorities in Amherst ·<br />
would try <strong>to</strong> start their own businesses. I<br />
thought my father's efforts would, in a small<br />
way, help pave the road for others. But 30<br />
years later, as I walk the streets of Amherst it<br />
feels like not much has changed. I look at<br />
the s<strong>to</strong>refronts and it saddens me that you<br />
can count the number of black-owned businesses<br />
on one hand.<br />
The question that plagues me is, Why<br />
hasn't it changed? What keeps minorities<br />
from flourishing? Is it white racism, classism,<br />
and domination, or is it the black slav-<br />
ery mentality, the effect of 400 years of<br />
oppression? Both sides could argue that the<br />
past is the past and people need <strong>to</strong> move on.<br />
I do not agree. The sins and the successes<br />
of the ances<strong>to</strong>rs will and do come back <strong>to</strong><br />
haunt or help future generations. Think<br />
about it! If physical and mental abuse is<br />
passed down from one generation <strong>to</strong> the<br />
next, how much harder will it be <strong>to</strong> eliminate<br />
the views and opinions of an entire<br />
nation? For black Americans, 400 years of<br />
being <strong>to</strong>ld you are worth nothing, coupled<br />
with family divisions and a lack of generational<br />
wealth, leaves a deep scar on the spirit.<br />
For whites, 400 years of <strong>to</strong>tally controlling<br />
another group, and generations of accumulated<br />
wealth, invite feelings of great confidence<br />
and a desire <strong>to</strong> keep things as they<br />
are.<br />
When the man I'd known as a boy,<br />
Robert Green, had his s<strong>to</strong>re vandalized I was<br />
outraged. But at the same time, I was proud<br />
<strong>to</strong> work at the Men's Resource Center<br />
because it <strong>to</strong>ok a leadership role in the community's<br />
response <strong>to</strong> the attack, including<br />
helping <strong>to</strong> organize a rally <strong>to</strong> show support<br />
for Mr. Green and his family. A few hundred<br />
people attended a moving rally on the <strong>to</strong>wn<br />
common, which was great. But I was disappointed<br />
that only a handful of blacks came<br />
out in support. I was pleased there were<br />
many representatives from the Amherst<br />
business community, but the fact that my<br />
people did not show their support bothered<br />
me. 1 went home burdened by the day's<br />
events. Feelings ran deep; something had<br />
hit a nerve. As I rocked my daughter. <strong>to</strong><br />
sleep that night, I tried <strong>to</strong> put my finger on<br />
what had really happened that day. I talked<br />
with my wife, and <strong>to</strong> God, trying <strong>to</strong> put closure<br />
on what for me had been a hard day.<br />
put of what happened .I was inspired <strong>to</strong><br />
try <strong>to</strong> make a difference in Amherst. I was<br />
fortunate <strong>to</strong> be able <strong>to</strong> be part of a team that<br />
began planning a<br />
gathering we called a<br />
Men of Color<br />
Leadership Forum.<br />
The group would be<br />
an opportunity for<br />
young men of color<br />
<strong>to</strong> come <strong>to</strong>gether<br />
with older men of<br />
color <strong>to</strong> learn from<br />
their experiences and<br />
<strong>to</strong> benefit from their .<br />
wisdom. The idea of the forum would be <strong>to</strong><br />
help young minority men develop in<strong>to</strong><br />
strong, healthy men, <strong>to</strong> grow <strong>to</strong> become<br />
good husbands and fathers-leaders of<br />
<strong>to</strong>morrow.<br />
I was so elated that it was hard <strong>to</strong> pace<br />
myself. I made phone calls, sent out mailers,<br />
and called all of my old friends <strong>to</strong> invite<br />
them <strong>to</strong> the gathering. Finally the day<br />
arrived. Much <strong>to</strong> my surprise and disappointment<br />
only four people showed up. Out<br />
of 60 invitations only four people showed<br />
up! The same feeling I had at the rally came<br />
rushing back. "Where is the black support<br />
in this <strong>to</strong>wn? "<br />
I grew up here. My mother and grandmother<br />
were born in this area. I know<br />
almost every black family that lives in the<br />
area. Why is it so hard <strong>to</strong> get minorities <strong>to</strong><br />
support minorities? What is it? We survived<br />
the slave ships, kept our spirits alive<br />
through centuries of bondage, and rallied<br />
and fought <strong>to</strong>gether after slavery for the<br />
same rights and privileges as whites.<br />
Do people feel the fight is over? Did the<br />
dream really die with Martin Luther King<br />
and Malcolm X? I can assure you it did not.<br />
I am more committed <strong>to</strong> making change<br />
than ever before. I am proud <strong>to</strong> be working<br />
at the Men's Resource Center coordinating<br />
youth groups and services. It's a challenge I<br />
love <strong>to</strong> face every day. The future looms<br />
bright because I know there are people out<br />
there, young and older, who want <strong>to</strong> see<br />
· things change for the better. I challenge all<br />
of you reading these words <strong>to</strong> get involved,<br />
<strong>to</strong> s<strong>to</strong>p saying how bad things are without<br />
trying <strong>to</strong> make a difference· <strong>to</strong> improve<br />
things yourselves. This article began with<br />
the question, Is it 1971 or 2001? When it<br />
comes <strong>to</strong> identifying progress in challenging<br />
racism, it's up <strong>to</strong> each of us <strong>to</strong> say what year<br />
it really is.<br />
jeff Harris is direc<strong>to</strong>r of youth programs at<br />
the Mens Resource Center and the father of<br />
two daughters .<br />
14<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
Book Review---------------------- By Mark Ribble .<br />
Your Gender Is ... a) <strong>Male</strong> b) Female c) Neither d) Yes!<br />
What do you call "a fanatical cult,<br />
demanding blind obedience <strong>to</strong><br />
mostly unwritten, unagreedupon<br />
rules, regulations, and qualifications"?<br />
.If you guessed GENDER (or even<br />
if you didn't), you should check out Kate<br />
Bomstein's Gender Outlaw: On Men,<br />
Women, and the Rest of Us. But don't<br />
expect an angry rant, a vanguardist political<br />
exhortation, or a dry cultural examination.<br />
Rather, Bornstein takes up the question<br />
of gender and gender transgression in<br />
a playful, hopeful, and democratic way,<br />
without sacrificing the deadly serious<br />
nature of her inquiry or the very serious<br />
consequences of both adhering <strong>to</strong> and<br />
transgressing gender.<br />
Within the pages of Gender Outlaw<br />
you'll find a smorgasbord of styles, <strong>to</strong>pics,<br />
and ideas, including chapters on FAQs<br />
about the meaning of transgender and<br />
transsexual; a list of the "rules of gender"<br />
(actually written by a sociologist); deeply<br />
personal reflections on Bornstein's own<br />
his<strong>to</strong>ry and identity; the details of how<br />
genital reassignment surgery works; fierce<br />
political statements on gender, sexuality,<br />
power, and identity; satirical takes on pop<br />
culture and contemporary politics; and<br />
even the full text of Bornstein's play<br />
Hidden: A Gender.<br />
Throughout, Bornstein weaves <strong>to</strong>gether<br />
analysis and narrative in a way that challenges<br />
us <strong>to</strong> radically rethink the way we<br />
understand gender (yes, even us progressive<br />
feminists and pro-feminists). In a<br />
political arena where much work has been<br />
done on redefining the categories of man<br />
and woman <strong>to</strong> allow new spaces where<br />
women don't have <strong>to</strong> be demure bimbos<br />
and men don't have <strong>to</strong> be domineering<br />
jocks, Bornstein takes a whole different<br />
approach. Instead of redefining the categories,<br />
Bornstein suggests that we get real<br />
and scrap the categories al<strong>to</strong>gether. The<br />
fact is that our cultural and, yes, even our<br />
biological notions of gender are upheld by<br />
human regula<strong>to</strong>ry practices that (often violently)<br />
force us in<strong>to</strong> one box or the other.<br />
And while feminists and pro-feminists<br />
argue that consent is the most important<br />
aspect of nearly all human interaction, we<br />
overlook the fact that gender itself is not<br />
consensual. We are given no choice and<br />
few routes of escape.<br />
Bornstein also contests the idea that<br />
we'll eventually be able <strong>to</strong> break down our<br />
cultural hang-ups on gender roles, so that<br />
men and women can have both "masculine"<br />
and "feminine" attributes and that all<br />
power· differentials between the two genders<br />
will eventually be broken down.<br />
"Gender implies class," Bornstein argues,<br />
"and class presupposes inequality. Fight<br />
rather for the deconstruction of gender"<br />
it would bring equality much faster than<br />
fighting for equality between natural genders.<br />
But Bornstein never gets metaphysical<br />
or argues that gender is all in our heads.<br />
Having lived life passing as both man and<br />
woman at various times (as well as plenty<br />
of time not quite passing as either),<br />
Bomstein can all <strong>to</strong>o well attest <strong>to</strong> the very<br />
real effects of gendered life. She writes,<br />
"The differences in the way men and<br />
women are treated are real. And the fact is<br />
this difference in treatment has no basis in<br />
the differences between men and women.<br />
I was the same person, and I was treated<br />
entirely differently. I got real interested in<br />
feminist theory-real fast."<br />
Her personal reflections, as well as her<br />
political analysis, always focus on how<br />
power is gendered, and she has a special<br />
insight in<strong>to</strong> male privilege. "It <strong>to</strong>ok my<br />
becoming a woman <strong>to</strong> discover my 'male<br />
behavior'-that is, exhibiting male privilege,"<br />
she writes. '"<strong>Male</strong> privilege' is<br />
assuming one has the right <strong>to</strong> occupy any<br />
space or person by whatever means, with<br />
or without permission. It's a sense of entitlement<br />
that is unique <strong>to</strong> those who have<br />
been raised male<br />
in most cultures . .<br />
. <strong>Male</strong> privilege is,<br />
in a word, violence."<br />
You'll have<br />
<strong>to</strong> pick up the<br />
book yourself <strong>to</strong><br />
read all about<br />
Bornstein's<br />
encounter with<br />
male privilege during<br />
her gender<br />
transition, male<br />
privilege among male-<strong>to</strong>-female transsexuals,<br />
and the detailed understanding she<br />
developed while she began <strong>to</strong> concurrently<br />
lose and <strong>to</strong> give up the male privilege she<br />
once blindly enjoyed.<br />
Even if you vehemently disagree with<br />
Bornstein's perspective or analysis, this<br />
book is worth reading, if for nothing more<br />
than the exposure <strong>to</strong> a set of ideas so at<br />
odds with most popular discourse.<br />
Bornstein would never see this book as an<br />
end point, but rather a starting point for<br />
discussion of gender that isn't afraid <strong>to</strong><br />
challenge the sacred tenets of both mainstream<br />
and progressive groups. In her<br />
refusal <strong>to</strong> let us get away with taking gender<br />
as natural or inevitable, she forces us<br />
<strong>to</strong> be more honest with ourselves, even if<br />
that might mean questioning our basic<br />
frameworks of gender and power.<br />
And if you've a brave soul, check out<br />
Bornstein's My Gender Workbook<br />
(Routledge, 1998), which will take you on<br />
an interactive personal journey through<br />
your own experience of gender through a<br />
series of questions and exercises. Well<br />
worth it if you're willing <strong>to</strong> do some hard<br />
looking, but not for the faint of heart!<br />
Mark Ribble is a volunteer at the Mens<br />
Resource Center and the Everywomans<br />
Center at the University of Massachusetts .<br />
He formally coordinated the Activist Mens<br />
Network for the MRC. He will graduate from<br />
Hampshire College in the spring.<br />
Fall 2001<br />
15
Gay & Bisexual <strong>Voice</strong>s ---------------- By Michael Greenebaum<br />
nes<br />
Gay & Queer: What's in a Name?<br />
I<br />
recently attended my (shudder) fiftieth<br />
high school reunion. It was good <strong>to</strong> see<br />
old friends, but it was strange <strong>to</strong> be<br />
"Mike" once again. "Mike" was a high<br />
school and college kid; somewhere along<br />
the line he became "Michael," more formal,<br />
more distant, more inward. Mike was out<br />
there, friendly, social. Michael is private.<br />
Mike was clueless; Michael has a clue.<br />
Mike was sexless; Michael is queer.<br />
Was Mike queer, <strong>to</strong>o? Not possible;<br />
queer didn't exist in the forties. Neither<br />
did "gay," for that matter. In the forties,<br />
those people (we?) were fairies or pansies.<br />
Those people walked with mincing gait,<br />
wore pink shirts, flitted about on<br />
Thursdays. And, of course, Mike did none<br />
of those things. It was not that girls, those<br />
formidable and exotic creatures, exerted<br />
any sexual attraction on Mike. He loved<br />
girls; he could talk about art and music<br />
and religion and world government with<br />
them. Girls had ideas, at least the girls<br />
who were his friends did. Boys exercised<br />
no sexual attraction on Mike, either. Mike<br />
solved the problem of sex by having none<br />
of it.<br />
This little excursion in<strong>to</strong> au<strong>to</strong>biography<br />
is really leading up <strong>to</strong> the question: What if<br />
the term "queer" had existed in the forties?<br />
What, even, if "gay" had been in use then?<br />
What, in other words, might have been the<br />
difference for me if affirmative, gutsy<br />
names for the confusing, alluring yearnings<br />
I suppressed had been available?<br />
"Gay" has an equivocal his<strong>to</strong>ry, and<br />
some straight people express regret that its<br />
original meaning of frivolous and weightless<br />
joy is no longer availaple <strong>to</strong> them. But<br />
that transformation is complete, and "gay"<br />
is now weighted with tremendous irony.<br />
Happiness and sadness se~m \rreparably<br />
linked by this label of choice. Being gay is<br />
both a burden and a joy; but then, so is life<br />
for most people. Burdens and joys are distributed<br />
without regard <strong>to</strong> sexual preference<br />
or sexual orientation. "Gay" and<br />
"straight" have become ways people<br />
describe themselves, without much emotional<br />
content or commitment. One does<br />
not seem <strong>to</strong> be affirming much of anything<br />
by claiming either of them.<br />
That is why, for some gay men, the term<br />
seems a bit pallid in a society still cursed<br />
with individual and institutional homopho-<br />
bia. To be sure, sometimes we want <strong>to</strong><br />
remind everyone that we are part of the<br />
human family, that orientation <strong>to</strong>wards or<br />
preference for same-sex partners is parallel<br />
<strong>to</strong> orientation. <strong>to</strong>wards or preference for<br />
opposite sex partners. In these cases, "gay"<br />
is a convenient and often acceptable label.<br />
But sometimes, we (or at least some) want<br />
<strong>to</strong> be more assertive and affirming about<br />
our essential identities. We want <strong>to</strong> claim<br />
that just those things our haters use against<br />
us are the very things we assert and affirm.<br />
Our sexuality is sometimes just one of<br />
those things, but at other times it is the<br />
central thing. For many, "queer" is the<br />
name that captures and identifies what we<br />
want <strong>to</strong> assert and affirm-that in spite of<br />
grief and oppression our sexuality is a<br />
source of pride and joy, as our local queer<br />
shop reminds us.<br />
"Queer" is a <strong>to</strong>ugh, hard-edged, inyour-face<br />
identity. It is still used against us<br />
by those we discomfit. When we transform<br />
it in<strong>to</strong> a positive and affirmative identity,<br />
we are part of a long his<strong>to</strong>rical tradition<br />
of oppressed groups who have challenged<br />
their oppressors by appropriating<br />
their labels of hate.<br />
"Queer" has two other distinct virtues,<br />
at least <strong>to</strong> this queer man. First, it is inclusive.<br />
"Queer" is as much an umbrella as it<br />
is a label. Gay men, lesbians, bisexual men<br />
and women and transsexuals are accommodated<br />
under its sheltering embrace. When<br />
I call myself queer, I am not only making a<br />
statement of identity but also a statement<br />
of affiliation. I am joining a community,<br />
and it is th~ community I prefer. It<br />
includes women, and for me life without<br />
women would<br />
be unfulfilled.<br />
One of the<br />
great joys of<br />
coming <strong>to</strong><br />
terms with my<br />
sexuality later<br />
in life is that<br />
at last 1 don't<br />
have <strong>to</strong> be<br />
afraid of<br />
women; I<br />
don't have <strong>to</strong><br />
worry about<br />
being in a false position when I am with<br />
them. I love women and I love being with<br />
them. The queer community includes<br />
women, and hurray for that! It includes<br />
transsexuals, who must be about the most<br />
courageous people I know. It in'cludes<br />
drag queens and drag kings and other variations<br />
on the theme of gender bending.<br />
Thank you <strong>to</strong> all these queer people for<br />
transforming gender from a fixed <strong>to</strong> a fluid<br />
and nuanced notion. They have done a<br />
great service <strong>to</strong> all of us and enriched the<br />
ways we have of being human.<br />
But there is another reason I am queer.<br />
For a number of years I answered <strong>to</strong> the<br />
label "bisexual." It felt antiseptic and clinical,<br />
but it was all we had. Like "homosexual,"<br />
it seems off-putting, intrusive and<br />
sloppy. "Bisexual" sounds like it is drawn<br />
from one of those huge medical <strong>to</strong>mes. It<br />
makes me feel like a scientific object, an<br />
example of a condition. "Bisexual" is<br />
intrusive since it implies something about<br />
·my sexual activity, which is nobody's business.<br />
"Queer" suits me fine. Often, when I<br />
call myself queer, people read that as gay.<br />
That's fine; often I feel gay. I love my gay<br />
friends; they are an important part of my<br />
life. But queer is what I am; the queer<br />
community is my community. It is inclusive,<br />
embracing and affirming. Slowly but<br />
surely, Michael is introducing Mike <strong>to</strong> his<br />
new friends .<br />
Writer-musician Mi chael Greenebaum was<br />
an elementary school principal in Amherst,<br />
. Mass ., for 20 years. He received a Challenge<br />
& Change Award from the Men's Resource<br />
Center in 1999.<br />
16<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
GBQ Resources<br />
For more information or new entries contact us<br />
at (413) 253-9887 Ext. 10 mrc@valinet.com<br />
Noon- 2 p.m. last Sunday of each month<br />
September 30<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 28<br />
November 25<br />
The MRC provides bagels, cream cheese, and coffee. Pot-luck dishes are welcome. For Information: 413 253-9887 Allan Arnaboldi, Ext. 10.<br />
MEN'S RESOURCE CENTER<br />
A MALE-POSITIVE. I'RCHEMINIST,<br />
GAY-AFFIRMATIVE,<br />
ANTI-RACIST ORGANIZATION<br />
1J6 H. PLEASANT STREET, AMHERST<br />
Fall2001 ------------------------------------- 17
Fathering --------------------By jeff Kelly Lowenstetn<br />
Fathering Through the S<strong>to</strong>rm<br />
'' wat will he say he's thankful<br />
for?" I asked myself<br />
when my adopted son<br />
approached the front of the line at his first<br />
grade Thanksgiving pageant. A wave of<br />
classmates before him expressed gratitude<br />
for God, family, friends, and their<br />
Pokemon cards. I imagjned Aidan striding<br />
forward and thanking me for being<br />
there.<br />
I held my breath as Aidan sprang <strong>to</strong> the<br />
microphone and spoke in a loud, firm<br />
voice. "My name is Aidan Kelly, and I am<br />
thankful for animals that fly." Silence,<br />
then a crescendo of approving<br />
laughter filled the room as he<br />
walked <strong>to</strong>ward me.<br />
Afterward, an elderly woman<br />
approached Aidan as we walked<br />
back across the parking lot.<br />
"Aren't you the boy who was<br />
thankful for animals that fly?" she<br />
asked, leaning down <strong>to</strong> meet his<br />
eyes.<br />
Aidan looked up shyly. "Yes."<br />
"That was a very original<br />
answer. Unique. Happy<br />
Thanksgiving," the woman said,<br />
then walked away.<br />
"See, I <strong>to</strong>ld you it was stupid,"<br />
Aidan whispered after he determined<br />
that the woman was out of<br />
earshot.<br />
"It wasn't stupid, Aidan. She<br />
thought it was a great answer. She loved<br />
it. I did, <strong>to</strong>o. And I love you, buddy boy," I<br />
said, giving him a quick tickle in the ribs<br />
and taking his hand in mine.<br />
"Thanks, Daddy," he answered, looking<br />
up at me as I opened the doors and we<br />
assumed our seats in my car. I froze, seatbelt<br />
in hand. Daddy: I'm still not used <strong>to</strong><br />
that word. As his stepfather, am ~ really<br />
his "daddy"? For me, the word conjures<br />
up so many conflicting images. My<br />
thoughts flash back uneasily <strong>to</strong> my father's<br />
physical and emotional absence during my<br />
childhood. To the years I labored in therapy<br />
<strong>to</strong> understand Dad's experience of<br />
being sent, at age five, from Germany <strong>to</strong><br />
England <strong>to</strong> escape Hitler. Though I wanted<br />
desperately <strong>to</strong> respond <strong>to</strong> Aidan, I said<br />
nothing. We started driving home. A<br />
cloud of silence gathered like an<br />
approaching s<strong>to</strong>rm.<br />
The s<strong>to</strong>rm cloud broke in the evening.<br />
The two of us were playing Monopoly on<br />
the living room floor after dinner, buying<br />
and selling properties with abandon. After<br />
multiple trades, Aidan owned three<br />
monopolies, while two belonged <strong>to</strong> me.<br />
Aidan rolled the dice, counted out the<br />
spaces, and realized that he had landed on<br />
Park Place.<br />
"That will be $1,700, please," I said.<br />
"Thank you so much for visiting our<br />
humble hotel. We hope you come again."<br />
I was surprised <strong>to</strong> hear myself mouth the<br />
same cheerful phrases Dad had used with<br />
The author and his son Aidan Kelly Lowenstein.<br />
me when I was Aidan's age.<br />
"$1,700?! Why you ... " Smiling broadly,<br />
he reached across the board and<br />
slapped me on the back of my head.<br />
I knew that he hadn't meant <strong>to</strong> hurt<br />
me, but the blow stung, then pulsed like a<br />
fresh bee sting. I wheeled on him. "Aidan,<br />
what are you doing?" My voice was rising.<br />
"You don't hit people. You just don't do<br />
it!" I yelled, jabbing my finger in his face.<br />
"Now apologize!"<br />
Tiny ringlets of water sprung up<br />
around the edges of his widened eyes.<br />
"No. It was your fault. The hotel cost <strong>to</strong>o<br />
much. It's not fair," he said, folding his<br />
-arms and getting <strong>to</strong> his feet.<br />
I wanted <strong>to</strong> calm myself, but his words<br />
had the effect of picadors stabbing an<br />
angry bull. "Come on, .Aidan," I hissed,<br />
feeling my whole purpose in life shrink<br />
in<strong>to</strong> extracting the words "I'm sorry" from<br />
him. "Don't try <strong>to</strong> put it on anything else.<br />
You hit me. You were. wrong. Now just<br />
apologize and move on."<br />
His tears flowed as he sped up the'<br />
stairs. "No, I won't!" he screamed. "I hate<br />
you and I never want <strong>to</strong> see you again!"<br />
He brushed by his mother, who had heard<br />
the commotion, slammed his bedroom<br />
door, and turned the lock.<br />
I left the apartment and started speedwalking<br />
around the nearby park. I slowed<br />
my pace and my anger subsided. Shame<br />
spread through me as I replayed the scene<br />
in my head over and over again, hoping<br />
each time for a different ending.'<br />
I felt that special pain<br />
reserved for those of us who vow<br />
we will treat our kids differently,<br />
only <strong>to</strong> find ourselves acting in<br />
exactly the same ways our parents<br />
did. My brothers and I had<br />
dubbed my father "Time Bomb<br />
Eddie" for his hair-trigger temper,<br />
which would erupt spontaneously,<br />
like a volcano. I had<br />
sworn many times that I would<br />
never yell at my children.<br />
I opened the door slowly,<br />
walked upstairs and found Aidan<br />
asleep. His mother had coaxed<br />
him <strong>to</strong> bed by reading <strong>to</strong> him,<br />
then lying down with him until<br />
he s<strong>to</strong>pped squirming. We went<br />
downstairs and plopped down on the<br />
couch. Not looking at each other or<br />
speaking about the fight, we inserted the<br />
film Kolya in<strong>to</strong> the VCR.<br />
Set in the waning days of Soviet-era<br />
Czechoslovakia, the movie revolves<br />
around Kolya, a five-year-old Russian boy<br />
abandoned by his mother and placed on<br />
the doorstep of a middle-aged Czech<br />
musician who lives alone. Dressed in a<br />
suit, with a runny nose and rivulets of<br />
tears streaming down his face, Kolya<br />
stares at the floor, unable <strong>to</strong> utter a word<br />
<strong>to</strong> his reluctant guardian.<br />
"That's how old your father was when<br />
he left Germany," Aidan's mother said.<br />
My chest tightened, and my long-held<br />
definition of my father flared up like an<br />
inflamed tendon. I started <strong>to</strong> tell her that<br />
she did not understand, that she could not<br />
18<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
know how little I had received from<br />
Dad. But she spoke the truth. I stayed<br />
up for a long time afterward, thinking<br />
about what she'd said.<br />
The next morning Aidan climbed<br />
in<strong>to</strong> our bed and wrapped himself<br />
around his mother. His blue-green eyes<br />
proclaimed, "Mine. I got here first.<br />
Don't get any ideas about taking her<br />
away." I smiled at him, and said little.<br />
"jeff, do you want <strong>to</strong> have a Lego<br />
war?" he finally asked.<br />
"Sure. Let's go," I replied, steeling<br />
myself <strong>to</strong> accept my 42nd consecutive<br />
defeat with equanimity. We walked<br />
down <strong>to</strong> the living room, where Aidan<br />
folded his left leg underneath him in his<br />
cus<strong>to</strong>mary crouch, and assembled his<br />
fleet of Legos at a dizzying clip.<br />
"Hey, Aidan."<br />
"What," he answered flatly, not looking<br />
up from his ship.<br />
I swallowed. "I'm sorry I got mad and<br />
yelled at you last night. You were wrong<br />
<strong>to</strong> hit me, but I shouldn't have lost my<br />
temper."<br />
"Uh-huh." He kept working.<br />
Fifteen minutes later, he placed his<br />
king, an intricate structure with impenetrable<br />
laser shields and unimaginable<br />
firepower, <strong>to</strong> one side and approached<br />
me.<br />
"Daddy," he said, snuggling impossibly<br />
close, his wiry arms reaching around<br />
my s<strong>to</strong>mach and meeting in the back.<br />
"I love you, bud."<br />
"Not 'buddy.' Say 'son."'<br />
I felt the freeze again, but also something<br />
calm and soothing. I paused for a<br />
minute, aware of the Rubicon I had<br />
already crossed in my heart and was<br />
about <strong>to</strong> name. "I love you, son," I said<br />
softly.<br />
"Call me Aidan." Quietly.<br />
"I love yqu, Aidan."<br />
"No. Call me 'Aidan, my son."' More<br />
of a command this time.<br />
"I· love you, Aidan, my son."<br />
"No. Call.me 'my ~on Aidan.'"<br />
I suppressed a giggle.. "I love you,<br />
my son Aidan." ·<br />
"Actually, just call me Aidan. I love<br />
you, <strong>to</strong>o, Daddy. Now get off of me."<br />
He extricated himself from my embrace,<br />
and finished creating the king that<br />
would single-handedly annihilate my .<br />
squad.<br />
jeff Kelly Lowenstein _is a freelance<br />
writer living in Easthamp<strong>to</strong>n, Mass.<br />
Fall2001<br />
losing My <strong>Voice</strong><br />
Until my senior year in college, I<br />
had never lost my voice. Sure,<br />
sometimes I got hoarse, and<br />
sometimes I didn't feel much like talking<br />
(that may be hard for some of you <strong>to</strong><br />
believe), but somehow my voice was always<br />
there when I wanted <strong>to</strong> say something.<br />
That changed in a rather amusing way<br />
during my final semester of college. It was<br />
during the first few weeks of classes, and I<br />
was taking my first women's studies class.<br />
We had <strong>to</strong> write a short reflection paper<br />
about our voices (I don't really remember<br />
the assignment exactly), and I had written<br />
what I thought was a good piece, recognizing<br />
the power and privilege that I had<br />
grown up with in using my voice. We were<br />
expected <strong>to</strong> present what-we had written <strong>to</strong><br />
the class, but I woke up that morning andfor<br />
the first time in my life-! had absolutely<br />
no voice.<br />
It wasn't just a case of ha~ing <strong>to</strong> shout <strong>to</strong><br />
be heard or it hurting when I talked; no<br />
matter how hard I<br />
tried, I couldn't even<br />
get a decent whisper<br />
going. This wasn't<br />
completely out of the<br />
blue-! had been feeling<br />
pretty lousy-but<br />
it was certainly<br />
unprecedented, not<br />
<strong>to</strong> mention rather<br />
poetic, given the<br />
paper I was supposed<br />
<strong>to</strong> present.<br />
I'd like <strong>to</strong> think that my subconscious is<br />
more su,btle than this usually, but this case<br />
doesn't seem <strong>to</strong> call for much education <strong>to</strong><br />
identify the psychological processes going<br />
on here. I struggled through the presentation,<br />
with much laughter and amusement<br />
from my classmates, and I was fine again<br />
within a few days. At the same time,<br />
though, I feel like I learned a valuable lesson.<br />
I had heard of the idea that men are<br />
generally rewarded for and encouraged <strong>to</strong><br />
participate in class while women are punished<br />
for and ignored when trying <strong>to</strong> speak<br />
up-even in classes with feminist teachersbut<br />
I had never really imagined that I was<br />
· part of that process, despite the fact that I<br />
have always been the most outspoken person<br />
in any dass I <strong>to</strong>ok. I just had a lot <strong>to</strong><br />
by Patrick Lemmon<br />
say, right? I<br />
wasn't really<br />
preventing others<br />
from speaking-in<br />
fact,<br />
couldn't it be<br />
said that I was<br />
encouraging<br />
them <strong>to</strong> speak<br />
by offering<br />
provocative and<br />
interesting comments<br />
for them<br />
<strong>to</strong> respond <strong>to</strong>?<br />
Anyway, I noticed during that class that<br />
many more people-particularly the womenspoke<br />
when I wasn't saying anything, and I<br />
also realized that they had a lot of really<br />
interesting and even provocative things <strong>to</strong><br />
say. I paid much more attention <strong>to</strong> how<br />
much I talked in that class for the rest of<br />
the semester, and it was amazing how often<br />
by simply giving myself a second before<br />
shooting my hand in<br />
the air, I could know<br />
that my ideas weren't<br />
always all that interesting,<br />
and that someone<br />
else often-dare I say<br />
usually?-had something<br />
even more enlightening<br />
<strong>to</strong> offer if I wasn't taking<br />
up space.<br />
I would like <strong>to</strong> say<br />
that I learned <strong>to</strong> respect<br />
silence and <strong>to</strong> pay more<br />
attention <strong>to</strong> other people's voices through<br />
that experience, but this is not a fairy tale.<br />
I still struggle <strong>to</strong> accept the idea that what I<br />
have <strong>to</strong> S11Y may not be the most important<br />
thing in the world for everyone <strong>to</strong> hear. But<br />
I di~ _hear a lot of voices that I might not<br />
have heard that day, and I know that I<br />
would regret it if I played a part in silencing<br />
them once again.<br />
Patrick Lemmon is co-direc<strong>to</strong>r of Men Can<br />
S<strong>to</strong>p Rape (MCSR), a Washing<strong>to</strong>n, D.C.<br />
based organization providing trainings and<br />
workshops in metropolitan Washing<strong>to</strong>n and<br />
elsewhere around the U.S. For more information<br />
contact MCSR at pmcgann@<br />
mencans<strong>to</strong>prape.orgl; (202) 265-6530; or<br />
www.mencans<strong>to</strong>prape.org/.<br />
19
Men & Health ----------------------By Joe Zoske<br />
Meditation: It's Not What You Think<br />
W<br />
e live in a noisy society. And<br />
it's getting worse. Decibel-level<br />
studies tell us that, as does our<br />
common sense. The machinery and technology<br />
of the modern world surround us,<br />
assault our senses, permeate our every<br />
waking moment. Our brains seem <strong>to</strong> be<br />
permanently "online," connected <strong>to</strong> a<br />
constant flow of external information and<br />
sound.<br />
Our culture has an aversion <strong>to</strong> silence.<br />
Even the remote wilderness. is no longer a<br />
safe haven from beepers, radios, or cell<br />
phone chatter: All this noise has the effect<br />
of keeping us from hearing ourselveswhat<br />
the Quakers call "the still small<br />
voice within."<br />
It is challenging <strong>to</strong> take time for<br />
conscious reflection, especially in a<br />
fast-paced, impatient society that<br />
encourages us <strong>to</strong> do rather than <strong>to</strong> be,<br />
<strong>to</strong> value our things more than ourselves,<br />
<strong>to</strong> worry about the future while<br />
missing the significance of the present.<br />
How can we possibly foster a healthy<br />
male spirit, if we do not experience<br />
quiet, and the opportunity <strong>to</strong> check in<br />
with ourselves? Meditation offers such<br />
a method <strong>to</strong> still the mind, and <strong>to</strong> discover<br />
the benefits of regular inner<br />
silence.<br />
The concept of meditation is very simple,<br />
the techniques of meditation very<br />
straightforward. The practice of meditation<br />
can be very challenging.<br />
Fundamentally, meditation means<br />
focusing our attention upon ourselves in<br />
a relaxed, nonjudgmental manner.<br />
Noticing how we truly are in that<br />
moment, and allowing that calm awareness<br />
<strong>to</strong> guide us in our actions. Often, it<br />
begins with sitting quietly and simply<br />
watching one's breath for a few minutes,<br />
stilling the mind and the body. In time,<br />
we learn <strong>to</strong> observe the stream of<br />
thoughts flowing through our mind.<br />
lessening our grasp on unhelpful, habitual<br />
ways of thinking and being more aware<br />
in each moment, we can better adapt <strong>to</strong><br />
the constant change life brings.<br />
Meditation is multi-level. It can serve<br />
us as a <strong>to</strong>ol, a process, or·a lifestyle. Its<br />
benefits can be relaxation, a reduction in<br />
stress symp<strong>to</strong>ms, and an increase in selfawareness.<br />
ft can help us cope with significant<br />
moments in our lives. We also<br />
gain the opportunity <strong>to</strong> learn about ourselves,<br />
and <strong>to</strong> make choices that reflect<br />
more of who we truly are.<br />
What can men specifically gain from<br />
meditation? First, experiencing restful<br />
alertness helps reawaken the intuitive self,<br />
which men so often are taught <strong>to</strong> set aside<br />
in deference <strong>to</strong> logic. Second, it fosters a<br />
nurturing relationship <strong>to</strong> our mind and<br />
body, which contradicts the outward daring<br />
men so often live. Third, the practice<br />
of contemplation helps forge a sense of<br />
discipline, a grounding for those who are<br />
overly confused or restless in their lives.<br />
Meditation is particularly male-compatible<br />
because it is simple (though not<br />
easy); it is a private experience (no risk of<br />
public exposure or shame); it keeps us in<br />
control of ourselves; it is pragmatic (low<br />
cost, portable, no special abilities, etc.);<br />
and it requires no competition. In short,<br />
meditation provides men with a sanctuary<br />
from many sources of suffering, and offers<br />
a training ground <strong>to</strong> explore deep masculinity<br />
and humanness.<br />
Cautions are few. Some men are<br />
uncomfortable at closing their eyes (that's<br />
okay, it's not a requirement). Some men<br />
fall asleep (an important realization of<br />
how fatigued we might be, or how ·burdened<br />
we are). Some men turn meditation<br />
practice in<strong>to</strong> work (again, it's about being,<br />
not doing). Some men become unsettled<br />
by the awakening <strong>to</strong> their inner experience,<br />
unaccus<strong>to</strong>med <strong>to</strong> noticing the workings<br />
of their mind.<br />
like exercise, however, if we don't like<br />
what we're doing, can't stick with a routine,<br />
or if it doesn't<br />
suit our body or<br />
interests, there are<br />
many others from<br />
which <strong>to</strong> choose.<br />
The best exercise is<br />
the one we will do,<br />
the one we enjoy,<br />
the one that brings /<br />
us the benefits we<br />
seek. Meditation is the same way.<br />
Pick a technique that is right for you.<br />
Books provide private and personal guidance<br />
that can be helpful <strong>to</strong> beginners.<br />
Popular authors who write in very accessible<br />
ways include Thich Nhat Hanh, Jon<br />
Kabat Zinn, and Jack Kornfield. Cassette<br />
and video programs are as close as the<br />
public library. Classes are available in<br />
locations such as a local Y, school, or<br />
community center. Meditation training<br />
· centers exist throughout the Northeast,<br />
an.d some religious-based meditation<br />
may be offered through one's house of<br />
worship.<br />
If someone is consistently in a more<br />
extreme emotional state (very anxious<br />
or depressed) .or lives with a psychiatric<br />
condition, then caution is warranted.<br />
Finding a skilled teacher would then be<br />
advisable.<br />
There's no time like the present <strong>to</strong><br />
begin. So, take a deep breath and let it<br />
out with a sigh. Breathe naturally and let<br />
your body relax a little. Breathe naturally<br />
and notice where your mind is. Don't<br />
judge anything. Just smile. In this stillness<br />
ask yourself, "In the very next<br />
moments of this day, what do I really<br />
need <strong>to</strong> do?"<br />
As you try meditation, remember: Be<br />
open <strong>to</strong> new insights. Remain patient and<br />
humble as you learn and practice. Enjoy<br />
the process of self-discovery. It is your<br />
mind, your thoughts, your life .. . and that<br />
is all truly wonderful.<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong> m e n~ health columnist Joe<br />
Zaske is an administra<strong>to</strong>r in the social work<br />
program at Siena College in New York, and<br />
a me n~ health consultant based in Albany.<br />
Responses <strong>to</strong> his columns are welcome and<br />
can be made <strong>to</strong> zoskej@crisny.org.<br />
20<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
Notes from Survivors<br />
Healing from Sexual Addiction<br />
By Louis Castagno<br />
The article "Pornography's<br />
Manipulation of Men," by<br />
Anonymous (<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong> , Spring<br />
2001), written by a woman whose marriage<br />
had ended due <strong>to</strong> the addiction of<br />
her ex-husband <strong>to</strong> pornography and other<br />
destructive sexual behaviors, <strong>to</strong>uched me<br />
deeply. Why? Because for 40 years, I was<br />
nearly a carbon copy of her husband.<br />
The main difference between his sexual<br />
fantasies and mine is that in mine, I was<br />
the willing "victim" of powerful, seductive,<br />
sexually dominant women, experiencing<br />
pleasure, pain, and humiliation<br />
sequentially or simultaneously. In order <strong>to</strong><br />
gratify my addictive cravings, I utilized<br />
both "female domination" pornography<br />
(pho<strong>to</strong>s, s<strong>to</strong>ries, etc.) and the services,<br />
paid or freely given, of women who<br />
offered <strong>to</strong> act out my fantasies with me.<br />
While on one hand I have always<br />
abhorred violence against women in any<br />
form, <strong>to</strong>day I am aware that I supported<br />
such violence by using women, in fantasy<br />
or in reality, as objects for my sexual<br />
desires rather than full-fledged humans<br />
with feelings, hopes, dreams, skills, and<br />
intelligence. This behavior degraded all<br />
of us, whether we were known <strong>to</strong> each<br />
· other or not.<br />
I was also moved by the recent murder<br />
of a young male-<strong>to</strong>-female transgendered<br />
man not far from where I live.<br />
Following years of persecution, harassment,<br />
and abuse from other students in<br />
school, he was brutally beaten and left <strong>to</strong><br />
die by another man his age. After the<br />
murder, the assailant boasted <strong>to</strong> male<br />
friends that he had "beaten up a fag, "<br />
which resulted in his arrest. While the<br />
laws of this state do not consider attacks<br />
based upon sexual or gender orientation<br />
"hate crimes," it is clear that it was hate<br />
and fear that fueled the killing of this<br />
young man.<br />
Although I never knew the victim, I<br />
feel a strong connection with him, for I<br />
have been partially transgendered all my<br />
life. As a boy, my failure <strong>to</strong> conform <strong>to</strong> the<br />
attitudes and behaviors stereotypically<br />
considered "masculine" resulted in much<br />
bullying from other boys. While I never<br />
reached the point of actual surgical gender<br />
reassignment, my strong identification<br />
with femininity led me <strong>to</strong> strongly consider<br />
reassignment at one point. Married,<br />
with a child and a professional career, I<br />
indulged in cross-dressing and, after separation<br />
from my wife, lived part-time as a<br />
woman. Being somewhere near the<br />
halfway point on the gender identification<br />
scale, I have often felt like adding the category<br />
"both" <strong>to</strong> questionnaires that ask<br />
whether I am male or female.<br />
I felt the need <strong>to</strong> keep both my sexually<br />
addictive behavior and my transgendered<br />
behavior and identity a secret from<br />
all but a few people in my life. This "double<br />
life" led <strong>to</strong> the ending of my first marriage,<br />
conflict in the early years of my current<br />
marriage, and the loss of a professional<br />
position when a pho<strong>to</strong> of myself<br />
cross-dressed fell in<strong>to</strong> the wrong hands.<br />
Most of my life was characterized by<br />
lying, hiding, fear, shame, lack of control,<br />
and hopelessness that things would ever<br />
be different. I spent hundreds of hours in<br />
psychotherapy trying <strong>to</strong> "change," with<br />
few concrete results.<br />
In my early 50s, I began attending<br />
meetings of the 12-step program Sex and<br />
Love Addicts Anonymous. Slowly and<br />
painfully, I was able <strong>to</strong> pull away from the<br />
destructive sexual behaviors I had pursued<br />
for so many years. As the strength of<br />
my recovery increased, I found a very special<br />
psychotherapist who helped me<br />
recover several repressed memories from<br />
my childhood. The most powerful of<br />
these was of being sexually abused and<br />
assaulted by my mother from early childhood<br />
<strong>to</strong> my teens. Once the feelings of<br />
rage, devastation, and betrayal that resulted<br />
from recapturing these memories<br />
began <strong>to</strong> settle down, I was able <strong>to</strong> understand<br />
how these chlldhood events had<br />
contributed <strong>to</strong> my dysfunctional sexual<br />
behavior.<br />
As the Serenity Prayer says, I am learning<br />
<strong>to</strong> accept what I cannot change, and<br />
working up the courage <strong>to</strong> change what I<br />
can. I accept that I am a survivor of incest<br />
·and have a strong identification with femininity,<br />
but I understand now that these do<br />
not make me "less of a man," as many in<br />
our culture would have us believe. The<br />
work I have done in men's support groups<br />
over the past 25 years has contributed<br />
greatly <strong>to</strong> this change in perception.<br />
My work has involved helping young<br />
men and women understand the often<br />
dysfunctional process of gender socialization<br />
in our culture, and supporting them<br />
in making choices that are right for them<br />
rather than based on social pressure. I<br />
have been a sexual assault prevention<br />
educa<strong>to</strong>r in schools and colleges, working<br />
with young men <strong>to</strong> help them perceive<br />
women as deserving respect<br />
rather than sexual exploitation.<br />
I agree wholeheartedly with<br />
"Anonymous" that the sexual objectification<br />
of women, whether by the<br />
pornography industry, the media, the<br />
advertising industry, 6r the minds of<br />
individual men and women, severely<br />
dis<strong>to</strong>rts oui' relationships in this culture.<br />
Although this mountain is overwhelming<br />
in size, each of us must do our<br />
part <strong>to</strong> reduce it, rock by rock.<br />
On an individual level, I alone am<br />
responsible for my thoughts and behavior,<br />
no matter how surrounded I may be by<br />
"stimulation." Perhaps I will never be 100<br />
percent successful in converting my inner<br />
sexual landscape <strong>to</strong> a place of utter beauty,<br />
but I choose each day <strong>to</strong> replace the<br />
destructive behaviors of my past with<br />
demonstrations of caring and concern for<br />
others as fellow humans. This often difficult<br />
struggle has given me much compassion<br />
for other other men and women who<br />
strive for psychosexual health in an<br />
insane culture. God help us all bring<br />
internal and external peace <strong>to</strong> a world that<br />
desperately needs it.<br />
Louis Castagno is a writer and educa<strong>to</strong>r<br />
in Oie fields of violence prevention and gender<br />
studies.<br />
Fall2001 ---------------------------------------------------------------21
The Isolation of Men<br />
co•1tinued from page 13<br />
gro.up facilita<strong>to</strong>r, <strong>to</strong> put forth an essentially<br />
positive fac;ade <strong>to</strong> represent my life-a sort of<br />
Potemkin village that I can whitewash and<br />
pretend is real, and "the whole s<strong>to</strong>ry": just<br />
don't look behind the walls. At such<br />
moments, I can even delude myself in<strong>to</strong><br />
thinking that it's an issue only for "those<br />
other guys" wl\o aren't so far along, while I've<br />
moved past it in<strong>to</strong> wholeness.<br />
.But then I have <strong>to</strong> remind myself not just<br />
how far I've come, but where I've been. I've<br />
been isolated-enduring periods when I was<br />
without friends and without support. I've<br />
been depressed-experiencing times when no<br />
matter what I did I couldn't enjoy it, couldn't<br />
hear the song of life above the hum of negative<br />
chatter going on in my head-and it <strong>to</strong>ok<br />
a therapist's diagnosis <strong>to</strong> make me aware of it,<br />
and <strong>to</strong> start me working on that problem.<br />
At times I've depended on women-either<br />
my p
MRC PROGRAMS & SERVICES<br />
SUPPORT GROUP PROGRAMS<br />
· Open Men's Group - 7-9 p.m. Sunday evenings at the MRC<br />
Amherst office, Tuesday evenings 7-9 p.m. at 218 State St.,<br />
Northamp<strong>to</strong>n. A facilitated drop-in group for men <strong>to</strong> talk<br />
about their lives and <strong>to</strong> support each other.<br />
· Men Who Have Experienced Childhood Abuse and Neglect -<br />
Specifically for men who have experienced any kind of childhood<br />
abuse or neglect. 7-8:30 p.m. Friday evenings at the<br />
MRC.<br />
· Gay, Bisexual, & Questioning 7-9 p.m. Monday evenings at the<br />
MRC. Discussion group on issues of sexual orientation.<br />
· GBQ Brunch- Last Sunday of the month, Noon- 2 p.m. at<br />
the MRC.<br />
FATHERING PROGRAMS<br />
A variety of resources are available -Fathers and Family<br />
Network monthly workshops, lawyer referrals, parenting guidance,<br />
workshops, educational presentations and conferences.<br />
Group and individual counseling for new and expectant, separated/divorced,<br />
gay, step, adoptive and other fathers/father figures.<br />
YOUTH PROGRAMS<br />
· Radio Active Youth (RAY): Monthly youth radio show on<br />
WMUA (91.1 FM); third Monday each month at 5:30p.m.<br />
Young Men of Color Leadership Project, Amherst<br />
Young Men's Leadership DevelopmenUViolence Prevention, Holyoke &<br />
Northamp<strong>to</strong>n.<br />
MEN OVERCOMING VIOLENCE (MOVE)<br />
MRC state-certified batterer intervention program serves both<br />
voluntary and cour.t-mandated men who have been physically<br />
violent or verbally/emotionally abusive. Fee subsidies ;~vailable.<br />
· Basic Groups: Groups for self-referred (20 weeks) and court-mandated<br />
(40 weeks) men are held in Amherst, Athol, Ware,<br />
Springfield, and Greenfield.<br />
· Follow-up: Groups for men who have completed the basic program<br />
and want <strong>to</strong> continue in their recovery are available in<br />
Northamp<strong>to</strong>n and Amherst.<br />
· Partner Services: Free phone support, resources, referrals and<br />
weekly support groups are available for partners of men in the<br />
MOVE program.<br />
· Prison Groups: A weekly MOVE group is held at the Hampshire<br />
County jail and House of Corrections.<br />
· Community Education and Training: Workshops and training on<br />
domestic violence and clinical issues in batterer intervention are<br />
available.<br />
· Speakers' Bureau: Formerly abusive men who want <strong>to</strong> share their<br />
experiences with. others <strong>to</strong> help prevent family violence are<br />
available <strong>to</strong> speak at schools and human service programs.<br />
WORKSHOPS AND TRAINING<br />
Available <strong>to</strong> colleges, schools, human service organizations, and<br />
businesses on <strong>to</strong>pics such as "Sexual Harassment Prevention and<br />
Response," "Strategies and Skills for Educating Men," "Building<br />
Men's Community," and "Challenging Homophobia," among<br />
other <strong>to</strong>pics. Specific trainings and consultation available.<br />
PUBLICATIONS<br />
· <strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>: Published.quarterly, the MRC magazine includes<br />
articles, essays, reviews and resources, and services related <strong>to</strong><br />
men and masculinity<br />
'<br />
· Children, Lesbians, and Men: Men 's Experiences as Known and<br />
Anonymous Sperm Donors, a 60-page manual which answers<br />
the questions men have, with first-person accounts by men<br />
and women "who have been there."<br />
RESOURCE AND REFERRAL SERVICES<br />
Information about events, counselors, groups, local, regional and<br />
national activities, and support programs for men.<br />
Interested In A<br />
Men's Resource Center<br />
Speaker? .<br />
A Workshop or Training?<br />
Contact Carl Erikson at (413) 253-9887<br />
mrc@valinet.com<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
Subscribe Now!<br />
Subscribe <strong>to</strong> <strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong> and keep informed about the Men's Resource Center of Western Massachusetts and news of changing men . With<br />
your subscription comes news of the MRC, which includes mailings of MRC events and, of course, <strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>.<br />
YES!<br />
Name: ------------------------------------<br />
Address:<br />
I want <strong>to</strong> subscribe <strong>to</strong> <strong>Voice</strong><br />
<strong>Male</strong> and support the MRC.<br />
City: ________ ~-------<br />
State: ____ Zip:<br />
Phone:--------- Email: -----------------<br />
I 0 Other 0$500 0$250 0$100 0$50 0$35 0$18<br />
I $<br />
Basic<br />
Student/<br />
1 ---- Please consider one of these special contributions M~mbe rs hip Limited Income 1<br />
._ ________________________ _______ ....<br />
Mail <strong>to</strong>: MRC 236 No. Pleasant St., Amherst, Mass. 01002<br />
1<br />
Fall2001 23<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
I<br />
1 1
MM:t Resources<br />
Resources lor Gay, Bisexual and Questioning Men<br />
(on page 11}<br />
The American Cancer Society<br />
(413) 734-6000 Prostate support groups,<br />
patient support groups, nutritional supplements,<br />
dressings and supplies, literature, lowcost<br />
housing, and transportation.<br />
Brattleboro Area AIDS Project<br />
(802) 254-4444; free, confidential HIV/AIDS<br />
services, including support, prevention counseling<br />
and volunteer opportunities.<br />
Children's Aid and Family Service<br />
(413) 584-5690 Special needs adoption services.<br />
Counseling for individuals, families and<br />
children, with a play therapy room for working<br />
with children. Parent aid program for parents<br />
experiencing stress.<br />
HIV Testing Hotline<br />
(800) 750-2016<br />
Interfaith Community Cot Shelter<br />
582-9505 (days) or 586-6750 (evenings)<br />
Overnight shelter for homeless individuals -<br />
123 Hawley St., Northamp<strong>to</strong>n. Doors open at<br />
6 PM.<br />
Sex & Love Addicts Anonymous (SLAA)<br />
(800) 7 49-6879 Referrals available for 12-step<br />
groups throughout New England.<br />
RESOURCES<br />
TRY Resource/Referral Center for Adoption<br />
Issues<br />
Education and support services for<br />
adoptees, adoptive parents, professionals, etc.<br />
Support group meetings first Wednesday and<br />
third Sunday of each month. Ann Henry -<br />
(413) 584-6599.<br />
.ll1lm:I1fl Resources<br />
Men's Resource Center of Western<br />
Massathusetts: www.mrc-wma.com<br />
National Men's Resource Center<br />
National calendar of events, direc<strong>to</strong>ry of men's<br />
services and a listing of books for positive<br />
change in men's roles and relationships.<br />
www.menstuff.org<br />
The Men's Issues Page:<br />
www.vix.com/pub/men/index.html<br />
100 Black Men, Inc.: .<br />
www.1 OObm.org<br />
Pro-feminist men's groups listing: www.feminist.com/pro.htm<br />
Pro-feminist mailing list:<br />
http://coombs.anu.edu.au/- gorkin<br />
/profem.html<br />
At Home Dad: www.parentsplace.com/readroom<br />
/athomedad<br />
The Fathers Resource Center:<br />
www.slowlane.com/frc<br />
National Fatherhood Initiative:<br />
www.cytc. umn. ed u/Fathernet<br />
The Fatherhood Project: www.<br />
fatherhoodproject.org<br />
<strong>Magazine</strong>s<br />
Achlles Heel (from Great Britain): www.stejonda.<br />
demon .co. uk/achilles<br />
/issues.html<br />
XY:men, sex politics (from Australia):<br />
http://coombs.anu.edu.au/-gorkin/XY<br />
/xyinfro.htm<br />
Ending Men's Violence Real Men:<br />
www.cs.utk.edu/- bartley/other/reaiMen.html<br />
The Men's Rape Prevention Project:<br />
www.mrpp.org/intro.html<br />
Quitting Pornography, Men Speak Out:<br />
www.geocities.com/CapitaiHill/1139<br />
/quitporn.html<br />
Ready <strong>to</strong> Change Your Life?<br />
Men's Group Therapy 413-586-7454<br />
Psychotherapy for:<br />
Couples - Families<br />
Individuals<br />
Reed Schimmelfing<br />
MSW, LICSW<br />
Offices In Northamp<strong>to</strong>n<br />
Sam Femiano, Th.D., Ed,D.<br />
LICENSED CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGIST<br />
Individual and group psychotherapy<br />
Therapy groups for male survivors of childhood abuse<br />
25 MAIN STREET- NORTHAMPTON , MA 01060 ;.<br />
Volunteers Needed<br />
AIDS CARE/ Hampshire County<br />
(413) 586-82898 Help make life easier and<br />
friendlier for our neighbors affected by HIV or<br />
AIDS. Men are especially needed.<br />
Big Brothers/Big Sisters of Hampshire<br />
County<br />
We are looking for men <strong>to</strong> be Big Brothers in<br />
the Hampshire County area. Big Brothers act<br />
as men<strong>to</strong>rs and role models <strong>to</strong> boys who need<br />
a caring adult friend. To learn more about<br />
being a Big Brother, call (413) 253-2591.<br />
Planned Parenthood of Western<br />
Massachusetts<br />
413 732-2363 Outreach volunteers wanted <strong>to</strong><br />
help distribute information about Planned<br />
Parenthood's services, promote safe sex practices,<br />
and rally support for<br />
pro-choice legislation at various events.<br />
Men's Resource Center<br />
(413) 253-9887 Distribution, ad sales and<br />
mailings for <strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>, general office work,<br />
special projects. etc. Flexible schedules.<br />
TEL: 413-586-0515 • Fax: 413-584-8903 • EMAIL: PATSAM®JAVANET.COM<br />
24<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong>
Thank You!<br />
The Men's Resource Center is truly a community<br />
organization. We have grown <strong>to</strong><br />
where we are now because hundreds of people<br />
have shared our inspiration and commitment,<br />
and contributed their time, services,<br />
and money <strong>to</strong>ward a vision of personal and<br />
social transformation. As our programs and<br />
services continue <strong>to</strong> grow in size and scope,<br />
we see that the size and scope of our community<br />
support also expand. We are filled<br />
with deep gratitude at the outpouring of<br />
support. We hope the following acknowledgments<br />
communicate a sense of being<br />
part of a growing community of support.<br />
Thank you.<br />
Computer Support: Bill Fleming<br />
Donated Space: Hampshire Community<br />
Action Commission<br />
Gardening: Craig Stevens<br />
In-Kind Donations: Henion Bakery<br />
Telephone System Support: Jim Levey<br />
As always, we extend our gratitude <strong>to</strong> the<br />
MRC Board of Direc<strong>to</strong>rs and Advisory Board<br />
for the ongoing guidance and support they<br />
give <strong>to</strong> this organization and all who are a<br />
part of it. We are also grateful <strong>to</strong> our volunteers<br />
who support us in so many ways.<br />
The Mythic Warrior<br />
-A 9-month Training for Men -<br />
Meeting one weekend a month for nine months, beginning in<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber, 2001, we will enact a modem-day hero's journey, a<br />
Men's Sean:h for Masculinity and the Sacred.<br />
Using der}th psychology, ritual. initia<strong>to</strong>ry activities, and group<br />
processes, we will cross the threshold of the sacred, developing<br />
personal and male rituals <strong>to</strong> support and guide us through life,<br />
creaing self-trust and a healthy mB;SCulinity <strong>to</strong> heal ourselves,<br />
families, and communities ..<br />
"Life transforming ... "- D.C. , Collinsville, CT<br />
For further information contact Sparrow Hart:<br />
(802) 387-6624 or (SJHII7'0W@Jogether.itet) .<br />
Or write: Cin:les of Air and S<strong>to</strong>ae ••••<br />
PO Box 48, Putney, VT 05346<br />
WANT TO BECOME<br />
A FACILITATOR OF<br />
AN MRC SUPPORT<br />
GROUP?<br />
Join us for our free annual<br />
Training for Facilita<strong>to</strong>rs<br />
Nov 2001-lan 2002<br />
:RuouRcE . M~-·<br />
\CENTER(· .<br />
\ , •.<br />
~<br />
For more information call<br />
Allan Arnaboldi<br />
Direc<strong>to</strong>r of<br />
Support Programs<br />
at the<br />
MEN'S RESOURCE<br />
CENTER<br />
413-253-9887<br />
Konza Massage<br />
Deep tissue, sports, structural body work<br />
and relaxation therapy for men<br />
Joseph Babcock<br />
413.587.4334<br />
A.M.T.A Member Very Reasonable Rates Nationally Certified<br />
Robert Mazer<br />
psychotherapy for men in transition,<br />
men seeking movement in their lives<br />
free initial consultation I flexible fees<br />
staff member at the Synthesis Center in Amherst 256-0772<br />
Fall2001<br />
--~------------------------------------------------------------------ 25
September 28-30<br />
North Oxford, Massachusetts<br />
Massachusetts Men's Gathering 25<br />
Semi-annual participant-led weekend.<br />
Workshops, talent show, poetry, drumming. Cost:<br />
$80-$150 sliding scale, including food & lodging.<br />
Information: www.massmensgathering.org;<br />
(617) 282-3521, Chris.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 5, 9:00 a.m.-12 noon<br />
Springfield, Massachusetts<br />
Race, Class, Sex-Role Stereotypes, and Sexual<br />
Orientation: The Cultural Context Model<br />
First of three Advanced Clinical Trainings by the<br />
Training Institute of the Center for Human<br />
Development. Purpose: <strong>to</strong> present the theoretical<br />
underpinnings, concepts & practice of the cultural<br />
context model of family therapy. For human<br />
services professionals. CEUs available (before<br />
mailing your registration, call for their availability<br />
for your discipline). Cost: Per training: $35,<br />
CEU charge $5; for the series of three: $90, CEU<br />
charge $15. At: 332 Birnie Ave. Information:<br />
(413) 439-2254, Sara Lockard.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 5-7<br />
Bos<strong>to</strong>n, Massachusetts<br />
A Legacy of Struggle, Pride and Commitment<br />
Pa' Fuera, Pa' Lante (Out and Forward)<br />
Northeast Regional Latino Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual<br />
and Transgender Conference. Purpose: <strong>to</strong> bring<br />
<strong>to</strong>gether LGBT Latinos from the Northeast &<br />
Puer<strong>to</strong> Rico <strong>to</strong> address their issues. ("Noche<br />
Cultural," a night of music, dance, show & poetry<br />
on Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 6 at Jorge Hernandez Cultural<br />
Center). At: UMass. Information & Registration:<br />
info@pafuerapalante.org;<br />
www.pafuerapalante.org.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 10-12<br />
St. Petersburg, Florida<br />
Also: November 7-9, Washing<strong>to</strong>n, DC; & December<br />
5-7, San An<strong>to</strong>nio, TX<br />
Working with Young Fathers: Building<br />
Skills for Practitioners<br />
Conducted by The National Center for Strategic<br />
Nonprofit Planning and Community Leadership<br />
(NPCL). For practitioners and program administra<strong>to</strong>rs.<br />
Limited <strong>to</strong> 25. Information:<br />
www.npcl.org; Tel. 888-528-NPCL; (202) 822-<br />
6725; Fax (202) 822-5699; NPCL 2000 L Street,<br />
NW, Suite 815, Washing<strong>to</strong>n, DC 20036.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 10-14<br />
Bos<strong>to</strong>n, Massachusetts<br />
Also: December 4-9, Santa Fe, New Mexico<br />
Gender Reconciliation-Residential Intensive<br />
Sponsor: Shavano Institute. Introduction <strong>to</strong><br />
processes for res<strong>to</strong>ring mutual trust and providing<br />
authentic intimacy between men and women.<br />
Cost: $500-$575 plus $65 per day for double<br />
accommodations & 3 vegetarian meals.<br />
Scholarships available. Information: Tel. (720)<br />
890-0336; gende!®shavano.org; Fax (720) 890-<br />
0339; www.shavano.org; Shavano Institute, P.O.<br />
Box 17904, Boulder, Colorado 80308.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 12-14<br />
Maine<br />
(Also on other dates & elsewhere in the U.S. &<br />
abroad)<br />
New Warrior Training Adventure<br />
Sponsored by The ManKind Project. Purpose: for<br />
men <strong>to</strong> examine their selves & lives, deepen self-<br />
26<br />
CALENDAR.<br />
understanding, discover the warrior within (a<br />
man of highly focused energy), and change their<br />
lives <strong>to</strong> fulfill their potential. Discussions, games,<br />
visualizations, journaling, individual work. Cost:<br />
$550-650, according <strong>to</strong> location, including meals<br />
& lodging. Information: www.mkp.org; Andy<br />
Towlen: (617) 256-8999; newengland@mkp.org;<br />
49 Carle<strong>to</strong>n St., New<strong>to</strong>n, MA 02458.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 18, 9:00 a.m.-12 noon<br />
Springfield, Massachusetts<br />
Exploring and Supporting Identity<br />
Development in Gay, Lesbian, Bi-Sexual<br />
and Transgendered Clients<br />
Second of three Advanced Clinical Trainings by<br />
the Training Institute of the Center for Human<br />
Development. Purpose: <strong>to</strong> explore how sexuality<br />
and gender issues are relevant <strong>to</strong> clinical practice.<br />
Information: See above, under Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 5.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 25-28<br />
New York, New York<br />
Healing The Sexual Victimization of<br />
Boys and Men<br />
9th International Conference of the National<br />
Organization of <strong>Male</strong> Sexual Victimization<br />
(NOMSV). (The Men's Resource Center is an<br />
Affiliate Sponsor.) Workshops, seminars, and<br />
presentations. For survivors, professionals,<br />
women, and others. Safe room for survivors.<br />
CEUs & scholarships available. Cost: $95-$210;<br />
students $50-$180. At: John Jay College of<br />
Criminal]ustice, City University of New York;<br />
899 lOth Ave. Information: 800-738-4181;<br />
www.malesurvivor.org; nomsv@malesurvivor.org;<br />
NOMSV. 5505 Connecticut Ave., NW -#103,<br />
Washing<strong>to</strong>n, DC 20015-2601.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 26<br />
Northamp<strong>to</strong>n, Massachusetts<br />
Cultivating Hope, Harvesting Action<br />
3rd Annual Conference on Rural Poverty &<br />
Social Change. Sponsored by Franklin<br />
Community Action Corporation. At: The Inn at<br />
Northamp<strong>to</strong>n. Information: Tel. (413) 774-2318<br />
x 129; www.fcac.net; Fax (413) 773-3834;<br />
info@fcac.net.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 27, 9:00 a.m.-5:00 p.ni.<br />
San Rafael, California<br />
2nd International Conference on Men's Health<br />
Presented by MenAlive, American Society on<br />
Aging, & others. For health professionals &<br />
interested men & women. CEUs available. Cost:<br />
$125 including lunch & free copy of The<br />
Warrior~ journey Home: Healing Men, Healing the<br />
Planet by Jed Diamond. At: Embassy Suites<br />
Hotel, 101 Mcinnis Pkwy, San Rafael, CA 94903;<br />
Tel. 1-800-EMBASSY; Fax (415) 499-9268;<br />
wWw.embassysuites.com. Information &<br />
Registration: www.menalive.com. Registration<br />
also: Tel. (707) 823-3601, Hari Meyers;<br />
MenAlive, do Hari Meyers, P.O. Box 5,<br />
Sebas<strong>to</strong>pol, CA 95473.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 29-30<br />
Scottsdale, Arizona<br />
Advanced Gender Certificate Training Program<br />
Offered by The Scottsdale National Gender<br />
Institute. For professional improvement in<br />
designing & implementing gender cultural<br />
changes in the workplace. Limited <strong>to</strong> 25.<br />
Information: Tel. (480) 473-0426; Fax (480)<br />
473-0427; info@gendertraining.com; www.<br />
gendertraining.com; The Scottsdale National<br />
Gender Institute, 4611 E. Sands Drive, Phoenix,<br />
AZ 85050.<br />
Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 31-November 2<br />
Scottsdale, Arizona<br />
Closing the Gap, Scaling the Heights: Men and<br />
Women Together<br />
8th Annual Conference Gender Diversity<br />
Training Conference. Speakers from AT&T,<br />
Kodak, & other companies. Limited <strong>to</strong> 200.<br />
Information: See above, under Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 29-30,<br />
but address postal mail <strong>to</strong>: National Association<br />
of Gender Diversity Training at given address.<br />
November 1, 9:00 a.m.-12 Noon<br />
Springfield, Massachusetts<br />
Implications for Clinical Work with the<br />
Latino Population<br />
Third of three Advanced Clinical Trainings by<br />
the Training Institute of the Center for Human<br />
Development. Purpose: <strong>to</strong> cover the role of<br />
Latino culture in clinical practice. Information:<br />
See above, under Oc<strong>to</strong>ber 5.<br />
November 1, 5:30-8 p.m.<br />
Northamp<strong>to</strong>n, Massachusetts<br />
Sixth Annual MRC Challenge and Change<br />
Celebration<br />
Honoring members of our community whose<br />
lives and work embody the ideals of the MRC.<br />
See article, page 5.<br />
November 2-4<br />
Vienna, Austria<br />
1st World Congress on Men's Health<br />
Organized by the University of Vienna Medical<br />
School and other international institutions.<br />
Lectures, symposia, plenary sessions. Topics<br />
largely medical, partly psycho-socio-econo-cultural.<br />
CME credits available. Cost: 250-350 euros<br />
+ 20% tax; travel, food, lodging extra.<br />
Information:<br />
www.healthandage.com/htmVmin/wcmh200011in<br />
dex.htm; Mr. R. Nedoschill at: Fax 43-1-512-<br />
8091-80; Tel. 4 3-1-512-8091-0;<br />
medicalconnection@icos.co.at.<br />
November 6<br />
Worcester, Massachusetts<br />
Leading the Way: Peers Preventing Dating<br />
Violence and Sexual Assault<br />
Jane Doe Inc. 2001 Youth Conference. Purposes:<br />
<strong>to</strong> learn from peer-led prevention models around<br />
the state; provide education and information <strong>to</strong><br />
service providers; foster collaboration between<br />
school staff and agencies providing services <strong>to</strong><br />
youth. For youth and adult service providers. At:<br />
College of the Holy Cross. Information: (617)<br />
248-0922, ext. 216; TTY (617) 263-2200.<br />
November 7<br />
Bos<strong>to</strong>n, Massachusetts<br />
True Heroes of Sport and Hall of Fame Induction<br />
17th Annual Sport in Society Awards Banquet &<br />
Induction of Dick Schaap in<strong>to</strong> Hall of Fame.<br />
Sponsored by the Center for the Study of Sport<br />
in Society. Northeastern University. At: Fairmont<br />
Copley Plaza Hotel. Information: (617) 373-<br />
9889; www.sportinsociety.org; Center for the<br />
Study of Sport in Society, Northeastern<br />
University, 360 Hunting<strong>to</strong>n Ave., Bos<strong>to</strong>n, MA<br />
02115-5000.<br />
<strong>Voice</strong> _<strong>Male</strong>
November 8-10<br />
Kissimmee, Florida<br />
11th International Conference on Sexual<br />
Assault and Harassment on Campus<br />
Organized by Safe Schools Coalition, Inc.<br />
Participating organizations: American<br />
Federation of Teachers,.American School<br />
Counselor Association, and many others. For<br />
all concerned. Cost: $295-$330; students:<br />
$110-$145. For airline discounts at e>arly booking,<br />
call1-800-524-1223, state you're travelling<br />
<strong>to</strong> this conference, and give index no.<br />
18181659. At: Hyatt Orlando Hotel, 6375 W.<br />
Irlo Bronson Memorial Hwy. (For discounted<br />
room rates call407-396-1234 before Oct. 5).<br />
Information: Tel. 800-537-4903; Fax 941-778-<br />
6818; ssc@tampabay.rr.com; Safe Schools<br />
Coalition, Inc., 5351 Gulf Drive, P.O. Box 1338,<br />
Holmes Beach; FL 34218-1338;<br />
www.ed.mtu.edu/safe.<br />
November 13-18<br />
Boulder, Colorado<br />
Gender Reconciliation-Year-Long Training<br />
1st of 4 week-lorig modules spread over one<br />
year, offered by the Shavano Institute for (1)<br />
professionals and others <strong>to</strong> develop skills of<br />
facilitating gender reconciliation and (2) those<br />
solely seeking gender reconciliation. Cost of all<br />
4 modules: $2500-3500 plus about $65 per day<br />
for multiple occupancy & meals. Scholarships<br />
available. Information: See above, under Oc<strong>to</strong>ber<br />
10-14.<br />
November 30-December 2<br />
Wallingford, Pennsylvania<br />
Changing a Culture: Building Bridges<br />
Connecting Differences<br />
Conference sponsored by the Men's<br />
International Peace Exchange (MIPE). Purpose:<br />
<strong>to</strong> create a culture of peace among people(s) of<br />
· different faiths, races, classes, genders, generations,<br />
nationalities, political preferences; and<br />
sexual orientations. Presentations and discussions.<br />
For all concerned. Social work CEUs<br />
may be available. Information: Men's<br />
International Peace Exchange, P.O. Box 36,<br />
Swarthmore, PA 19081-0036.<br />
February 22-24, 2002<br />
West Greenwich, Rhode Island<br />
Rhode Island Men's Gathering<br />
Purpose: <strong>to</strong> connect, learn and gain support.<br />
Participant-led, optional workshops and spontaneous<br />
indoor, outdoor, musical & artistic<br />
R&R. For men of all ages and wa lks of life.<br />
Cost: $85-$125 sliding scale, including meals<br />
and lodging. Partial scholarships available. At:<br />
forested Environmental Education Center, W.<br />
Al<strong>to</strong>n Jones Campus, U. of Rhode Island.<br />
Information: (401 ) 231-4785, john Blakeslee;<br />
www.members. tripod.com/rimensgathering;<br />
SnowRI@juno .com; P.O. Box 17441, Esmond,<br />
RI 02917. (No calls after 8 p.m. please.)<br />
Please send all calendar listings for events from<br />
December 1, 2001 <strong>to</strong> March 31, 2002-and<br />
beyond <strong>to</strong>: <strong>Voice</strong> <strong>Male</strong> Calendar,<br />
mposada@crocker.com with cc <strong>to</strong><br />
mrc@valinet.com; or MRC, 236 No. Pleasant<br />
St., Amherst, MA 01002; Fax (413) 253-4801.<br />
Deadline for Winter issue: Nov. 5.<br />
IS THIS YOU?<br />
If you can answer "Yes" <strong>to</strong><br />
II'!J of these questions, you<br />
Q Po 'fOU call 'four wlf• or girlfritnd may have a problem with<br />
namM?<br />
abuse. Without help, it<br />
Q Po 'fOU put htr cicNn and 111ab could get worse. At Men<br />
htr fttl bad about hti"NNf7<br />
Overcoming Violence, you<br />
0 h-t 'fOU tN"IIIM'f jtal-7 fan learn <strong>to</strong> change. Call us<br />
0 Po 'fOU control what Mit dote, and <strong>to</strong> schedule a confidential<br />
whotll eht - and talu <strong>to</strong>? appointment with one of<br />
0 lbvt 'fOU tvtr 111adt ang~ or our trained staff. We can<br />
tlmat•ntng gtetum <strong>to</strong>ward htr? help ... before it's <strong>to</strong>o late.<br />
0 lbvt 'fOU tvtr vtrball'f tlmllltlltd<br />
htr?<br />
0 llavt 'fOU tvtr pundltd a wall or<br />
MOVE<br />
cDelf01W poeetee'- In angtr? MEN OVERCOMING<br />
0 lbvt 'fOU tvtr hit or elappt
Join Us<br />
Awards • Dinner • Music<br />
/<br />
6th Annu~ Ch4llenge & Change Celebration<br />
Thursday, November 1, 2001 • 5:30pm- 8:00pm<br />
Inn at Northamp<strong>to</strong>n • 1 Atwood Drive, Northamp<strong>to</strong>n<br />
Exit 18 ~ffl-91 -<br />
Honoring:<br />
Barry Brooks, Guidance Couns~lor, Amherst Regional Middle School<br />
John Kazlauskas, Jr.*' Video Producer, Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual. Transgender issues for students<br />
K.risti Nelson, Executive Direc<strong>to</strong>r, Women's Fund ofWe!Ytern Massachusetts<br />
David Sharken, Executive Direc<strong>to</strong>r, Food Bank ofWestern Massachusetts<br />
* Ozzy Klate Memorial Youth Award<br />
..