12.09.2014 Views

The Category P Features, Projections, Interpretation

The Category P Features, Projections, Interpretation

The Category P Features, Projections, Interpretation

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

212<br />

b. *<strong>The</strong>re is hard to believe [t to have been a crime committed t].<br />

.<br />

Further, Epstein (1989) notes that TCs do not show the same kind of scope<br />

ambiguity as show constructions with non-thematic subjects, such as the raising<br />

constructions. Consider (76), with the typical raising verb seem. It is ambiguous, as<br />

the quantified nominal many people can either have scope over the entire clause (due<br />

to its surface position) (i), or it can have scope over the embedded clause only (due to<br />

its base generated position) (ii):<br />

(76) Many people i seem [t i to be having a good time].<br />

(i) many people i [seem [x i have a good time]]<br />

(<strong>The</strong>re are many people who seem to have a good time)<br />

(ii) [seem [many people i [x i have a good time]]<br />

(It seems that there is a large group of people having a good time).<br />

However, in the parallel TC, only the wide-scope reading is attested (77i):<br />

(77) Many people are easy to talk to.<br />

(i) many people i [easy to talk to x i ]<br />

(Many people are such that it is easy to talk to them)<br />

(ii) *easy [many people i [to talk to x i ]<br />

(It is easy to talk to a large group of people)<br />

Comparable Hebrew examples are given in (78) and (79). Using a raising<br />

predicate nir’im (‘seem’) in (78) results in ambiguity. However, once the predicate is<br />

a tough one (79), only the wide-scope reading remains (79i): 54<br />

(78) harbe yeladim nir’im ayefim<br />

many children seem tired<br />

(i) many children i [seem [x i tired]]<br />

(ii) seem [many children i [x i tired]]<br />

54 Thus I totally disagree with Engelhardt’s (1998) claim that (79) has also the narrow-scope reading.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!