12.09.2014 Views

The Category P Features, Projections, Interpretation

The Category P Features, Projections, Interpretation

The Category P Features, Projections, Interpretation

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

86<br />

asserted ‘belief’. In other words, we do expect Yosi to have some properties which<br />

can cause Dan to believe in him.<br />

This intuitive contrast between (88) and (89) regarding the relevance of the<br />

properties of the object to the meaning of the verb is not accidental. Consider the<br />

following observation.<br />

<strong>The</strong> property/ies of the object can be made (linguistically) explicit, as in (90a),<br />

(91a). In context, (90a) and (91a) can be replaced by (90b), (91b), respectively. (90b),<br />

(91b) are (at least) strong implications of (90a), (91a), and therefore they are<br />

interchangeable. Crucially, there is no such relation between (92a) (some property of<br />

Dan) and (92b). (92a) featuring the verbs ‘love’/’hate’ does not imply (92b), although<br />

it may be the case that both are (accidentally) true. <strong>The</strong>refore, replacing (92a) by<br />

(92b) is impossible.<br />

(90) a. I believe in Dan’s potential.<br />

b. I believe in Dan.<br />

(91) a. I rely on Dan’s punctuality/honesty.<br />

b. I rely on Dan.<br />

(92) a. I love/hate Dan’s sense of humor/honesty.<br />

b. I love/hate Dan.<br />

I propose that the irrelevance of the properties of the object to the meaning of the<br />

verb correlates with the /-c specification of the internal theta-cluster assigned by the<br />

verb. <strong>The</strong> following can be viewed as the rationale behind the proposed correlation.<br />

Assuming that an object is a name and the sum of its properties, it is the properties,<br />

rather than the name, which can cause something. If the properties of an<br />

object/argument are irrelevant to the meaning (expressed by a verb), but only the<br />

name is, the object cannot be interpreted as the cause.<br />

In light of that, consider the following pair, where the irrelevance vs. relevance of<br />

the properties of the object is especially clear:<br />

(93) Despite the fact that it was a bad movie, in any possible respect, I liked it.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!