01.09.2014 Views

Boyer diss 2009 1046..

Boyer diss 2009 1046..

Boyer diss 2009 1046..

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Assessment of metatarsal association and attribution.—As discussed in the<br />

descriptions, all but a left MT IV and a right MT V appear to belong to P. cookei. This<br />

interpretation is not as thoroughly supported as those for the metacarpals mainly because<br />

(1) there are fewer and less complete metatarsals than metacarpals in UM 87990 and (2)<br />

there are fewer complete comparative metatarsal specimens available. The most<br />

speculative of the attributions for the metatarsals described above is that of MT II, given<br />

its fragmentary nature and unusual morphology (compared to MT III and IV). However,<br />

this attribution is actually supported by comparisons to N. intermedius material.<br />

Measurements of proximal and distal fragments of MT I-V preserved with N. intermedius<br />

USNM 442229 show that its MT II is similar to the element identified as such for UM<br />

87990 in being more robust than MT III and IV (Table 4.23). An additional similarity<br />

between MT II of USNM 442229 and UM 87990 is that both have a distal end that is<br />

proportionally dorsoventrally shallower than those of the other metatarsals. These same<br />

proportional features also appear to characterize the MT II of Dryomomys szalayi UM<br />

41870, although quantitative data are not available for comparison at this time (<strong>Boyer</strong> and<br />

Bloch, 2008). The identification of P. cookei’s MT III and IV is supported by the<br />

similarity of the proximal ends of these bones to those of MT III and IV of USNM<br />

442229. Dentally-associated skeletal remains of cf. P. churchilli (SMM P77.33.517)<br />

from Wannagan Creek of North Dakota also include fairly complete proximal ends of<br />

MT III and IV. Again, these are nearly identical to those of N. intermedius and P. cookei.<br />

As discussed above, the same P. churchilli specimen also includes a nearly complete MT<br />

V. A composite plesiadapid foot can thus be assembled (Figs. 4.33, 39C) using<br />

information from these three specimens along with information from the tarsals.<br />

358

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!