Boyer diss 2009 1046..

Boyer diss 2009 1046.. Boyer diss 2009 1046..

pages.nycep.org
from pages.nycep.org More from this publisher
01.09.2014 Views

zero or less were excluded from geometric mean calculations (e.g., the distance that the greater trochanter of the femur projects proximal to the femoral head could easily be positive, zero or negative in a taxon of any absolute size). Particular variable sets used to create geometric means are cited in relevant table legends below. The resulting geometric mean ratios were then natural-log transformed. Whether it is necessary to use logarithms of ratios is debated (e.g., Jungers et al., 1995). I chose to do so here based on the fact that it frequently improves normality of distributions of ratios (Sokal and Rohlf, 1997). Furthermore my own experimentation with different data formats lead me to use logs rather than raw ratios. For instance, a version of the analysis of humeral variables performed on un-logged ratios captured less variance, and captured it less evenly in the first two coordinates, than the logged version of the same data (see additional discussion in Chapter 5). Body mass estimation.—Body mass is estimated for P. cookei and other plesiadapids using six limb bone lengths and six diameters. Two different sets of regressions are used: Gingerich (1990) generated regressions from data of Alexander et al. (1979). This dataset samples a phylogenetically diverse array from shrews to elephants. An unpublished dataset of primates from the UMMZ collection is used to generate a parallel set of regressions. The results of these two sets of regressions are presented and compared. Intrinsic hand proportions.—A reconsideration of digit proportions of P. cookei using methods and the comparative data set of Kirk et al. (2008) is undertaken. 280

Organization of results Each bone is discussed in its own Results section. Each of these sections has as many as three subsections: description, function, and comparisons. The first of these subsections is always the description. Descriptions include minimal comparative and soft anatomical references. Subsections assessing functional features of each bone and comparing P. cookei to other extant and fossil taxa (mainly other plesiadapids) often follow each description. Following the results sections focusing on specific bones, results of comparative analyses that integrate the morphology and measurements from many regions of the skeletons are presented (i.e., those analyses that cannot logically be included under the heading of a particular bone or set of bones). 281

zero or less were excluded from geometric mean calculations (e.g., the distance that the<br />

greater trochanter of the femur projects proximal to the femoral head could easily be<br />

positive, zero or negative in a taxon of any absolute size). Particular variable sets used to<br />

create geometric means are cited in relevant table legends below. The resulting<br />

geometric mean ratios were then natural-log transformed. Whether it is necessary to use<br />

logarithms of ratios is debated (e.g., Jungers et al., 1995). I chose to do so here based on<br />

the fact that it frequently improves normality of distributions of ratios (Sokal and Rohlf,<br />

1997). Furthermore my own experimentation with different data formats lead me to use<br />

logs rather than raw ratios. For instance, a version of the analysis of humeral variables<br />

performed on un-logged ratios captured less variance, and captured it less evenly in the<br />

first two coordinates, than the logged version of the same data (see additional discussion<br />

in Chapter 5).<br />

Body mass estimation.—Body mass is estimated for P. cookei and other<br />

plesiadapids using six limb bone lengths and six diameters. Two different sets of<br />

regressions are used: Gingerich (1990) generated regressions from data of Alexander et<br />

al. (1979). This dataset samples a phylogenetically diverse array from shrews to<br />

elephants. An unpublished dataset of primates from the UMMZ collection is used to<br />

generate a parallel set of regressions. The results of these two sets of regressions are<br />

presented and compared.<br />

Intrinsic hand proportions.—A reconsideration of digit proportions of P. cookei<br />

using methods and the comparative data set of Kirk et al. (2008) is undertaken.<br />

280

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!