01.09.2014 Views

Boyer diss 2009 1046..

Boyer diss 2009 1046..

Boyer diss 2009 1046..

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

described plesiadapid bones including those of P. tricuspidens (MNHN BR-3-L, MNHN<br />

R 450, MNHN BR-16-L and MNHN R 444), N. intermedius (USNM 442229), and N.<br />

gidleyi (AMNH 17379). They found that these taxa had limbs that were shorter than<br />

those of extant gliders, arboreal nongliders and paromomyids, but similar in proportional<br />

length to those of terrestrial sciurids. Although the authors did not discuss the<br />

significance of this finding, the results support the view of Gingerich (1976).<br />

Hamrick (2001) plotted third digit ray proportions (metacarpal, proximal phalanx<br />

and intermediate phalanx) of archontan mammals on ternary diagrams (a graph with three<br />

axes where each axis represents the length of one of the bones of a digit ray in the form<br />

of its percentage of the entire digit ray length). He included measurements from<br />

undescribed bones of P. cookei (UM 87990) and found them to plot with scandentians<br />

and to be separated from those of modern primates. He argued that euprimate manual<br />

digit proportions were a “novel” innovation associated with the evolutionary origin and<br />

subsequent adaptive radiation of the clade.<br />

Bloch and <strong>Boyer</strong> (2002) added to Hamrick’s (2001) ternary diagram by plotting<br />

digits of P. cookei and other plesiadapiforms (although they do not indicate which<br />

particular specimens were plotted). They also provided the first figure (p. 1609, fig. 5B)<br />

of a digit ray based on bones of P. cookei (UM 87990). They showed that nonplesiadapid<br />

plesiadapiforms plot with euprimates and suggested that P. cookei is derived<br />

in having scandentian-like proportions. Thus, they disagreed with Hamrick’s (2001)<br />

suggestion that euprimates were characterized by a change in finger proportions<br />

compared to plesiadapiforms. Instead, they concluded that long fingers, and the manual<br />

272

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!