Agenda with Maps and Applications (21Mb) - pdf - Selby District ...

Agenda with Maps and Applications (21Mb) - pdf - Selby District ... Agenda with Maps and Applications (21Mb) - pdf - Selby District ...

02.07.2014 Views

contamination and given the sensitivity of the groundwater we would prefer to see connection to mains drainage. The Environment Agency’s comments are based on the understanding that the applicants are connecting to mains drainage for foul as stipulated in the information submitted within this planning application. If this is not the case the Environment Agency would wish to be reconsulted. We are likely to object until sufficient evidence has been submitted to state why mains drainage has not bee the preferred method of foul drainage. The applicants will need to undertake a non mains drainage assessment to satisfy the Agency. 1.4.10 Yorkshire Water Services Ltd No objections subject to conditions being attached in order to protect the local aquatic environment and Yorkshire Water Infrastructure. 1.4.11 Selby Area Internal Drainage Board Details on the application indicate that surface water could potentially be directed to various surface water systems. The Council will need to be satisfied that all the existing systems or new systems have sufficient capacity to accommodate all additional flows on completion of the development. Also the Council will need to be satisfied that all systems downstream from the main have sufficient capacity. It is essential the developer discusses in detail the method and rate of disposal of surface water run-off from the development. Surface water from the site will eventually enter systems maintained by the Internal Drainage Board. Subject to the Council including a condition with respect to the above it is unlikely the Internal Drainage Board would pass any other comment. 1.4.12 Yorkshire Wildlife Trust (YWT) The development site is partially in a Site of Importance for Nature Conservation (SINC), less than a kilometre from the Sherburn Willows SSI and the Sherburn Willows Nature Reserve which is managed by the Yorkshire Wildlife Trust, and there are also a number of species and habitats within the site which are valuable for nature conservation. The development site is therefore important for biodiversity and adequate mitigation is essential. The surveys and ecological assessment appear to have been done correctly and at appropriate times of the year. However we have comments on the following aspect of the development: Proximity to Sherburn Willows Nature Reserve and SSSI We welcome the measures taken in the EIA to avoid changes in local drainage and abstraction which would affect the SSSI, however we do not believe enough consideration has taken place regarding visitor pressure placed on Sherburn Willows Nature Reserve. Therefore we believe the following measures are necessary: 110

• The provision of well designed open spaces within the development area itself for the exercising of dogs and community use so that Sherburn Willows is protected to some extent from excessive pressure; • The Trust would like to see a part time reserve officer funded who could co-ordinate with local residents and provide information and interpretation of the reserve and the surrounding area. Interpretation signage which would indicate the importance and value of the reserve would be welcomed. New residents could then understand the reserve’s value and how wildlife can be protected. • The developers could also fund membership of the Yorkshire Wildlife Trust for new residents which would aid understanding of local wildlife and the reserve. • The Trust would be happy to discuss options with the developer. The cumulative effect of the development and its location at Sherburn in Elmet We feel there should be more emphasis in Chapter 13 of the Environmental Statement (Summary of Effects and Conclusions) on the cumulative impact of the proposed development. The proposal has a considerable impact and its future impact in combination with other potential residential developments to meet local housing targets should be considered at this stage. We can agree with the ES reasoning that the development of a Phase 2 and 3 allocated site to meet housing requirements at this location will reduce the development pressure on nearby sensitive sites but only in terms of direct land take. This development is likely to exert considerable pressure on Sherburn Willow Nature Reserve and more accountability should be taken of this indirect negative impact of the development on such sensitive areas, and subsequent measures taken to mitigate against such impacts in so far as practicable. Water Vole Protection As acknowledged in the Water Vole Survey chapter of the Environmental Impact Statement the site has been shown to have a population of water vole and the ditches have high value for water vole. Surveys revealed active use of the ditches and watercourse neighbouring the site by water voles. The development needs to take into consideration connectivity of ditches, provision of habitat for water vole through SUDS and wetland, protection of ditches with well managed hedgerow containing thorny native species to protect water vole and avoid negative impacts. The Trust would want a condition that a management plan for ditches is in place, referencing the above document and sufficiently funded for the lifetime of the development Hedgerow Protection With regard to planned creation of new hedgerow along the south of the site and other panned hedgerows it would be recommended that a 5m buffer should be retained both sides of all hedgerows on the edge of the development, no hedgerows incorporated in individual gardens, 111

• The provision of well designed open spaces <strong>with</strong>in the development<br />

area itself for the exercising of dogs <strong>and</strong> community use so that<br />

Sherburn Willows is protected to some extent from excessive<br />

pressure;<br />

• The Trust would like to see a part time reserve officer funded who<br />

could co-ordinate <strong>with</strong> local residents <strong>and</strong> provide information <strong>and</strong><br />

interpretation of the reserve <strong>and</strong> the surrounding area.<br />

Interpretation signage which would indicate the importance <strong>and</strong><br />

value of the reserve would be welcomed. New residents could then<br />

underst<strong>and</strong> the reserve’s value <strong>and</strong> how wildlife can be protected.<br />

• The developers could also fund membership of the Yorkshire<br />

Wildlife Trust for new residents which would aid underst<strong>and</strong>ing of<br />

local wildlife <strong>and</strong> the reserve.<br />

• The Trust would be happy to discuss options <strong>with</strong> the developer.<br />

The cumulative effect of the development <strong>and</strong> its location at Sherburn<br />

in Elmet<br />

We feel there should be more emphasis in Chapter 13 of the<br />

Environmental Statement (Summary of Effects <strong>and</strong> Conclusions) on<br />

the cumulative impact of the proposed development. The proposal has<br />

a considerable impact <strong>and</strong> its future impact in combination <strong>with</strong> other<br />

potential residential developments to meet local housing targets should<br />

be considered at this stage. We can agree <strong>with</strong> the ES reasoning that<br />

the development of a Phase 2 <strong>and</strong> 3 allocated site to meet housing<br />

requirements at this location will reduce the development pressure on<br />

nearby sensitive sites but only in terms of direct l<strong>and</strong> take. This<br />

development is likely to exert considerable pressure on Sherburn<br />

Willow Nature Reserve <strong>and</strong> more accountability should be taken of this<br />

indirect negative impact of the development on such sensitive areas,<br />

<strong>and</strong> subsequent measures taken to mitigate against such impacts in so<br />

far as practicable.<br />

Water Vole Protection<br />

As acknowledged in the Water Vole Survey chapter of the<br />

Environmental Impact Statement the site has been shown to have a<br />

population of water vole <strong>and</strong> the ditches have high value for water vole.<br />

Surveys revealed active use of the ditches <strong>and</strong> watercourse<br />

neighbouring the site by water voles. The development needs to take<br />

into consideration connectivity of ditches, provision of habitat for water<br />

vole through SUDS <strong>and</strong> wetl<strong>and</strong>, protection of ditches <strong>with</strong> well<br />

managed hedgerow containing thorny native species to protect water<br />

vole <strong>and</strong> avoid negative impacts. The Trust would want a condition<br />

that a management plan for ditches is in place, referencing the above<br />

document <strong>and</strong> sufficiently funded for the lifetime of the development<br />

Hedgerow Protection<br />

With regard to planned creation of new hedgerow along the south of<br />

the site <strong>and</strong> other panned hedgerows it would be recommended that a<br />

5m buffer should be retained both sides of all hedgerows on the edge<br />

of the development, no hedgerows incorporated in individual gardens,<br />

111

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!