30.06.2014 Views

CIE Mesopic photometry – implementation for outdoor lighting - SDR

CIE Mesopic photometry – implementation for outdoor lighting - SDR

CIE Mesopic photometry – implementation for outdoor lighting - SDR

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

<strong>CIE</strong> <strong>Mesopic</strong> <strong>photometry</strong> –<br />

<strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong><br />

<strong>lighting</strong><br />

Liisa Halonen, Grega Bizjak<br />

1 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

Rods and Cones<br />

Introduction<br />

2 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

1


Introduction<br />

Photopic and scotopic vision<br />

3 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

Luminous efficiency function (<strong>CIE</strong> 1924)<br />

L K<br />

m<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

0<br />

K m =683 lm/W<br />

dLe<br />

V<br />

d<br />

<br />

<br />

d<br />

Photopic vision<br />

4 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

2


Photopic vision<br />

Gibson & Tyndall (1923)<br />

5 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

Photopic vision<br />

Different modifications,<br />

especialy in blue region<br />

of spectrum (Judd 1951,<br />

Vos 1978).<br />

V m (λ) – <strong>CIE</strong> 1988:<br />

as a supplement not<br />

replacement.<br />

6 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

3


Field of vision<br />

2° and 10° field of vision<br />

7 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

Scotopic vision<br />

V’(λ) – <strong>CIE</strong> 1951<br />

K’ m =1700 lm/W<br />

Photopic and Scotopic vision<br />

Same value of 683 lm/W<br />

at 555 nm.<br />

8 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

4


Photopic and scotopic vision<br />

At night we are more sensitive to blue light and K m is<br />

larger:<br />

white light<br />

is better than<br />

yelow light!<br />

9 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

Photopic and scotopic vision<br />

Luminous efficacy of different light sources<br />

Light source<br />

Luminous efficacy lm/W<br />

Photopic<br />

Scotopic<br />

100 W HPS 95 61<br />

180 W LPS 180 41<br />

100 W HP MH 85 142<br />

36 W CFL 4000 K 93 141<br />

10 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

5


Photopic and scotopic vision<br />

Luminances at <strong>outdoor</strong> (street) <strong>lighting</strong> are not in<br />

photopic or scotopic region but in mesopic!<br />

11 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

<strong>Mesopic</strong> vision<br />

Photopic: <strong>Mesopic</strong>: Scotopic:<br />

from 5 cd/m 2 from 5·10 -3 cd/m 2 from 10 -6 cd/m 2<br />

to 10 +4 cd/m 2 to 5 cd/m 2 to 5·10 -3 cd/m 2<br />

12 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

6


<strong>Mesopic</strong> <strong>photometry</strong><br />

Between 2000 and 2005 two models of mesopic <strong>photometry</strong><br />

were developed:<br />

• X-mode (Rea at al., 2004)<br />

• MOVE – model (Eloholma,) 2005<br />

13 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

Both models share the same idea:<br />

<strong>Mesopic</strong> <strong>photometry</strong><br />

<br />

<br />

xV<br />

(<br />

<br />

) <br />

(1 <br />

x<br />

)<br />

V '(<br />

)<br />

M ( x<br />

)<br />

Vmes <br />

<br />

14 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

7


<strong>Mesopic</strong> Photometry<br />

But gives different results:<br />

15 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

<strong>Mesopic</strong> <strong>photometry</strong><br />

<strong>CIE</strong> 191:2010 – Recomended System <strong>for</strong> <strong>Mesopic</strong> Photometry<br />

Based on Visual Per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

M ( m)<br />

V mV ( )<br />

(1 m)<br />

V '( )<br />

mes<br />

0 m 1<br />

<br />

L<br />

mes<br />

<br />

V<br />

683<br />

(<br />

mes<br />

)<br />

0<br />

<br />

V<br />

mes<br />

( )<br />

L ( )<br />

e<br />

d<br />

m … coefficient, depends on the visual adaptation conditions<br />

M(m) … normalizing function such that maximum value of V mes (λ) is 1<br />

V mes (λ) … the value of V mes (λ) at 555 nm<br />

16 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

8


<strong>Mesopic</strong> <strong>photometry</strong><br />

To calculate the mesopic values one needs:<br />

• background photopic p luminance (i.e. adaptation<br />

luminance) and<br />

• S/P – ratio.<br />

17 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

Photopic and scotopic vision<br />

At least one problem left to be solved:<br />

in order to determine the background photopic<br />

luminance (adaptation luminance), we first need to<br />

define visual adaptation field:<br />

• size of visual adaptation fiels;<br />

• eye movement;<br />

• ????<br />

<strong>CIE</strong> JTC 001 – Implementation of <strong>CIE</strong> 191 Msopic<br />

Photometry in Outdoor <strong>lighting</strong>.<br />

18 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

9


Photopic and scotopic vision<br />

If the visual adaptation field is broader than the road,<br />

the road surrounding also influeces mesopic<br />

<strong>photometry</strong>!<br />

19 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

Conclusions<br />

Thank you very much <strong>for</strong><br />

your attention!<br />

20 Halonen, Bizjak: <strong>CIE</strong> mesopic <strong>photometry</strong> – <strong>implementation</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>outdoor</strong> <strong>lighting</strong><br />

10

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!