i Report Issue No. 3 2005 - Philippine Center for Investigative ...
i Report Issue No. 3 2005 - Philippine Center for Investigative ...
i Report Issue No. 3 2005 - Philippine Center for Investigative ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
T H E C A M P A I G N<br />
“CONSULTATIONS”<br />
WITH CASH<br />
Apparently more focused on<br />
their “tasks” were Garcillano and<br />
his cohorts. Indeed, Garcillano<br />
already seemed to know what he<br />
would be doing when he applied<br />
<strong>for</strong> the post of Comelec commissioner.<br />
In his <strong>No</strong>v. 11, 2003 letter<br />
to the president, Garcillano<br />
reminded Arroyo that he was<br />
among those approached by<br />
her husband when she ran and<br />
topped the 1995 senatorial polls.<br />
He also underlined his role in<br />
monitoring and protecting the<br />
votes of the Lakas senatorial candidates<br />
in 2001. Garcillano was<br />
<strong>for</strong>merly the Region 10 (<strong>No</strong>rthern<br />
Mindanao) Comelec director.<br />
Sen. Aquilino Pimentel called<br />
him a “dagdag bawas” (vote-padding<br />
and shaving) operator, but<br />
he was named elections commissioner<br />
anyway in February 2004.<br />
The burly Zuce says he was instrumental<br />
in bringing Garcillano<br />
to Rufino’s —and consequently<br />
the president’s––attention. In his<br />
sworn statement, Zuce says Garcillano,<br />
with Rufino’s blessings, in<br />
2002 organized three “consultation<br />
meetings” with Mindanaobased<br />
Comelec officials in Lanao<br />
del <strong>No</strong>rte and General Santos City<br />
during which he solicited their<br />
support <strong>for</strong> the president’s candidacy<br />
and gave out cash ranging<br />
from P5,000 to P20,000.<br />
A year later, says Zuce, Mindanao<br />
regional directors and procampaign<br />
<strong>for</strong> the president. Cabinet<br />
members, <strong>for</strong> example, were<br />
told to make a pitch <strong>for</strong> Arroyo<br />
when they distributed Philhealth<br />
cards. “We asked if we could<br />
campaign and they said we could<br />
legally because we were political<br />
appointees,” says Soliman.<br />
On election day onward,<br />
Cabinet members fanned out<br />
to the provinces to gather the<br />
provincial certificates of canvass<br />
and the accompanying statements<br />
of votes. This time they<br />
took their cues from then presidential<br />
legal counsel and now<br />
Defense Secretary Avelino Cruz,<br />
who had set up a quick-count<br />
center at the basement of the<br />
Olympia Towers in Makati.<br />
Cruz also headed a legal panel<br />
assembled <strong>for</strong> the president’s<br />
election bid. Operating out of Olympia<br />
Towers as well, the panel<br />
included <strong>for</strong>mer local governments<br />
undersecretary and now<br />
Government Corporate Counsel<br />
Agnes Devanadera, ex-Comelec<br />
Commissioner Manuel Gorospe,<br />
and election-law experts Romulo<br />
Makalintal and Al Agra.<br />
A BIG WINNING MARGIN<br />
Like any candidate, Arroyo<br />
wanted to win. That much was<br />
clear to all the president’s men<br />
and women. Actually, says<br />
an ex-Cabinet member, “she<br />
was obsessed with the idea of<br />
winning. She (couldn’t) stand<br />
a loss….(She) felt she had to<br />
redeem her father (the late president<br />
Diosdado Macapagal) who<br />
lost in his reelection (bid).”<br />
That the president should<br />
win by at least a million votes,<br />
however, was never made<br />
known to most members of her<br />
Cabinet. Yet it apparently was<br />
common knowledge among the<br />
other groups working <strong>for</strong> her.<br />
A handler of a K-4 senatorial<br />
candidate says that two weeks<br />
be<strong>for</strong>e the May 10, 2004 elections,<br />
a campaign operative had<br />
said the president would win by<br />
800,000 votes. “Plantsado na<br />
raw<br />
(It was already arranged),”<br />
the handler says. That statement<br />
would make sense to the handler<br />
only after the “Hello, Garci”<br />
tapes controversy broke out.<br />
More interestingly, however,<br />
is that other campaign insiders<br />
say First Gentleman Mike Arroyo,<br />
Kampi stalwart Ronaldo ‘Ronnie’<br />
Puno, and a top government official<br />
met regularly at the Wack Wack<br />
Country Club be<strong>for</strong>e the campaign<br />
to discuss ways to ensure not only<br />
the president’s victory, but also a<br />
huge winning margin.<br />
As campaign manager, presidential<br />
political adviser Gabriel<br />
Claudio was the K-4’s public face<br />
in last year’s elections. But those<br />
with the administration party say it<br />
was Mike Arroyo who was the de<br />
facto campaign manager, and that<br />
he got a lot of help from Puno.<br />
At the peak of the political<br />
crisis, the president herself told<br />
some Cabinet members that<br />
she had called in the Antipolo<br />
congressman to help. But during<br />
the campaign, he had no official<br />
role in the Arroyo camp. “He was<br />
never mentioned, he was never<br />
seen,” says Deles. “I would even<br />
deny his involvement in the president’s<br />
campaign. Even the First<br />
Gentleman was not visible.”<br />
Some Palace insiders, however,<br />
say Puno was working<br />
quietly behind the scenes with<br />
the First Gentleman and had recommended<br />
“unorthodox” means<br />
to clinch Arroyo’s huge winning<br />
margin over her opponent, actor<br />
Fernando Poe Jr.<br />
A campaign strategist who<br />
was part of the K-4 coalition<br />
also recalls a K-4 lawyer assuring<br />
them that they were certain to get<br />
help. “The same operations as<br />
Sulo Hotel and Byron Hotel,” the<br />
strategist was told, apparently in<br />
reference to Puno’s operations at<br />
Sulo Hotel in Quezon City when<br />
he helped Ramos’s 1992 presidential<br />
campaign and at Byron Hotel<br />
in Mandaluyong when he backed<br />
Joseph Estrada’s presidential bid.<br />
The strategist says, “DILG<br />
(the Department of Interior and<br />
Local Governments that Puno<br />
headed under the Estrada presidency)<br />
people in the provinces<br />
were used as listening posts.<br />
They even knew who drug and<br />
jueteng money were funding.”<br />
Both Claudio and Puno were<br />
with the Ramos campaign. In a<br />
2003 interview with PCIJ, Puno<br />
scoffed at allegations that he was<br />
the architect of Ramos’s supposed<br />
dirty-tricks department based at<br />
Sulo Hotel. He said he delivers<br />
because he has the science, citing<br />
his experience a campaign<br />
consultant <strong>for</strong> the U.S. lobbying<br />
firm Black, Mana<strong>for</strong>t, Stone, and<br />
Kelly, which has strong links to<br />
the Republican Party.<br />
In 2002, Puno supposedly set<br />
up camp again at Byron Hotel<br />
to build a comprehensive elections<br />
database <strong>for</strong> Arroyo. A K-4<br />
campaign strategist says Puno<br />
disbanded the group when President<br />
Arroyo announced on Rizal<br />
Day in 2002 she was not running.<br />
But he quickly got the group<br />
back together in April 2003, long<br />
be<strong>for</strong>e the president announced<br />
her candidacy. The strategy, this<br />
source says, was to use the database<br />
to pinpoint places where Arroyo<br />
was strong and employ “all<br />
means” to increase her votes.<br />
Malaya columnist and opposi-<br />
tion stalwart Lito Banayo, quoting<br />
Loren Legarda’s electoral recount<br />
consultants, says Byron Hotel was<br />
the “headquarters of choice in the<br />
2004 electoral experience of a<br />
coven of pre-fabricators of election<br />
returns” used to ensure the president’s<br />
landslide victory in Pampanga,<br />
Cebu, Iloilo, and Bohol.<br />
One member of the K-4 campaign<br />
says Puno oversaw the<br />
Mindanao canvassing after being<br />
proclaimed Antipolo City’s congressman.<br />
This source asserts that “Ronnie<br />
Puno played a big role,” although<br />
he was “distracted because he was<br />
running at the same time.”<br />
vincial election supervisors met<br />
at the Grand Boulevard Hotel on<br />
Roxas Boulevard to discuss the<br />
president’s candidacy. Envelopes<br />
containing P17,000 each were<br />
distributed to the participants.<br />
On Jan. 10, 2004, Garcillano,<br />
through Rufino’s office, organized<br />
yet another meeting with<br />
23 Mindanao election officials,<br />
again at the Grand Boulevard.<br />
This time, each Comelec official<br />
got P25,000, Zuce says.<br />
But Zuce’s most damning allegation<br />
so far is that President<br />
Arroyo hosted dinner <strong>for</strong> 27 Mindanao-based<br />
Comelec officials at her<br />
La Vista residence in Quezon City<br />
four months be<strong>for</strong>e the elections,<br />
and that envelopes containing<br />
P30,000 each were distributed by<br />
Lilia ‘Baby’ Pineda, wife of jueteng<br />
lord Rodolfo ‘Bong’ Pineda, to<br />
her guests in her presence. Zuce,<br />
who was invited to the dinner<br />
and got an envelope himself, says<br />
Garcillano and <strong>for</strong>mer Isabela Gov.<br />
Faustino Dy were also present.<br />
Zuce told the PCIJ as well as<br />
the Senate later that the president<br />
hosted another dinner that same<br />
month <strong>for</strong> about 20 Comelec officials<br />
from Luzon and the Visayas.<br />
Baby Pineda again distributed<br />
money to the officials be<strong>for</strong>e they<br />
left Arroyo’s home.<br />
Malacañang has issued no<br />
categorical denial about the dinners,<br />
although the president herself<br />
has said, “Ang masasabi ko<br />
walang nagbibigay ng suhol sa<br />
harap ko (All I can say is no one<br />
gives out bribes in front of me).”<br />
The now ailing Rufino’s own<br />
statement said, “I and my office<br />
have never been involved in influencing,<br />
much less bribing,<br />
Comelec officials to support Lakas-NUCD<br />
candidates including<br />
President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo.”<br />
Comelec officials led by<br />
Region 4 Director Juanito ‘Johnny’<br />
Icaro, who allegedly distributed<br />
the envelopes at La Vista, have<br />
PHILIPPINE CENTER FOR INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM<br />
I REPORT<br />
7