23.06.2014 Views

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

The habitation or residence of a minor child is, by operation of law, determined and<br />

fixed by that of the parent legally entitled to the custody and control of the child<br />

unless the parent has voluntarily surrendered such right.<br />

The only way Eva could acquire a Kansas domicile is by becoming emancipated.<br />

The emancipation of a child by a parent may be proved by circumstantial evidence<br />

or may be implied from the conduct of the parties<br />

Wills v. Wills, 16 Neb. App. 559, 745 N.W.2d 924 (2008)<br />

Facts: 1992 New Mexico divorce. Dad to pay child support until children emancipate under<br />

NM law (age 18). Later both parents and the children move to NE, and Mom has NE court<br />

modify, and resets emancipation age to 19. Held: No can do! The court takes an extensive<br />

look into the various UIFSA amendments, and the official commentary accompanying those<br />

amendments, in reaching its decision.<br />

Section 42-746 states, in pertinent part:<br />

I Except as otherwise provided in section 42-747.03, a tribunal of this state<br />

shall not modify any aspect of a child support order that cannot be modified<br />

under the law of the issuing state, including the duration of the obligation<br />

of support. . . .<br />

(d) In a proceeding to modify a child support order, the law of the state that is<br />

determined to have issued the initial controlling order governs the duration of<br />

the obligation of support. The obligor’s fulfillment of the duty of support<br />

established by that order precludes imposition of a further obligation of support<br />

by a tribunal of this state.<br />

Despite a basic difference in the nature of the case, we rely upon the decision in<br />

Groseth v. Groseth, 257 Neb. 525, 600 N .W.2d 159 (1999), for guiding principles.<br />

… First, we properly look to the official comments contained in a model act on which<br />

a <strong>Nebraska</strong> statute or series of statutes was patterned for some guidance in an effort<br />

to ascertain the intent of the legislation. … Second, dicta in Groseth supports our<br />

interpretation. Third, a court must look to a statute’s purpose and give to the statute<br />

a reasonable construction which best achieves that purpose, rather than a<br />

construction which would defeat it.<br />

A comment to the 2001 UIFSA amendments…(states): The fact that the State of the<br />

new controlling order has a different duration of for [sic] child support is specifically<br />

declared to be irrelevant by UIFSA. … This comment refers to the 2001 amendment<br />

to UIFSA § 611 adding a new section (d), which was, in turn, adopted essentially<br />

verbatim by the <strong>Nebraska</strong> Legislature as the current § 42-746(d). Section 42-476I<br />

was also amended to expressly refer to the duration of the obligation of support as<br />

an aspect that cannot be modified under the law of the issuing state.<br />

[T]he duration of the support obligation remains fixed despite the subsequent<br />

residence of all parties in a new state with a different duration of child support.<br />

Wulff v. Wulff, 243 Neb. 616, 500 N.W.2d 845 (1993)<br />

Whether there has been an emancipation is a question of fact, but what is emancipation<br />

is a question of law.<br />

Emancipation is not necessarily a continuing status; even if once established, it<br />

may be terminated at any time during the child’s minority.<br />

A minor child giving birth may be one factor to be considered in the determination<br />

of whether a minor has achieved a new status or position inconsistent with parental<br />

control, but should not alone be dispositive.<br />

- 66 -

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!