Considering a Cadre Augmented Army - RAND Corporation

Considering a Cadre Augmented Army - RAND Corporation Considering a Cadre Augmented Army - RAND Corporation

07.06.2014 Views

-320- A Historical Analysis of Cadre reliance of the country was to be placed forthrightly upon citizen soldiers.” 170 Recognizing that these forces alone would not be large enough to fight another World War, the NDA of 1920 created another force called the Organized Reserves. The NDA of 1920 called for Organized Reserve units that would be manned in peacetime with officers from the Officers’ Reserve Corps (ORC) and enlisted personnel from the Enlisted Reserve Corps (ERC). Officers in the ORC were commissioned through either the Reserve Officers Training Corps (ROTC) or the Citizens Military Training Camps (CMTCs). 171 The ERC was a federal reserve of enlisted personnel established by the NDA of 1920. 172 The NDA of 1920 divided the nation into nine corps areas as shown in Figure 5.1. Figure 5.1—Nine Corps Areas Outlined in National Defense Act of 1920 173 Each Corps Area was to contain one Regular Army division, two infantry divisions of the National Guard, and three infantry divisions of the Organized Reserves. 174 The Organized ____________ 170 Weigley (1984), p. 399 171 The CMTCs “had grown out of the pre-World War I ‘Plattsburg idea’ promoted by Army Chief of Staff Leonard Wood” where men volunteered to attend military training camps in the summertime in exchange for commissions.” [Crossland and Currie (1984), p. 39] 172 Crossland and Currie (1984), p. 35 173 Kreidberg and Henry (1955), p. 386

-321- A Historical Analysis of Cadre Reserves contained the largest number of units but were the least expensive force to maintain. The Organized Reserves were inexpensive for two reasons. First, the officers in the ORC did not train regularly and were not paid for inactive duty drills. 175 Second, the ERC was non-existent. Weigley writes that the “Enlisted Reserve Corps … was practically nonexistent because there were no means of recruiting it.” 176 In 1920, the ORC ended the year with 68,232 officers while the number of enlisted personnel in the ERC was significantly less than 10,000. 177 Though Congress envisioned the Organized Reserves as a reserve of non-training units with a full complement of officers and enlisted personnel, what they got instead was a cadre force with a large number of reserve officers and very few enlisted personnel. This cadre force was different from those proposed in the past. Instead of an all-cadre force as proposed by Calhoun and Upton, the Organized Reserves were a component of a cadre augmented force with a mobilization order of: (1) Regular Army, (2) National Guard, and (3) Organized Reserves. 5.2—A CADRE REGULAR ARMY Weigley argues that soon after passing the National Defense Act of 1920 “the goals … broke down because Congress and the executive gave them lip service but little practical 174 Palmer (1941), p. 175 175 “Members of the ORC could not count on two weeks of active duty each year, as could members of the National Guard, and there was no pay at all for inactive duty drills… The ‘average’ reservists had a 1 in 4 chance of getting active duty training in a given year.” [Crossland and Currie (1984), p. 45] 176 Weigley (1984), p. 401. In their history of the Army Reserve, Crossland and Currie do not discuss the Enlisted Reserve Corps because of its small size. They wrote: “Because of the small inter-war size of the Enlisted Reserve Corps, this chapter (on the interwar period) is restricted almost totally to the Officer’s Reserve Corps.” [Crossland and Currie (1984), p. 34].] 177 “The Enlisted Reserve Corps, created by the National Defense Act of 1920, was of very minor importance between World Wars I and II. It consisted of only 6000 men in 1928, and by 1936 its ranks numbered less than 4000.” [Crossland and Currie (1984), p. 35-36]

-320- A Historical Analysis of <strong>Cadre</strong><br />

reliance of the country was to be placed forthrightly upon citizen soldiers.” 170 Recognizing<br />

that these forces alone would not be large enough to fight another World War, the NDA of<br />

1920 created another force called the Organized Reserves.<br />

The NDA of 1920 called for Organized Reserve units that would be manned in<br />

peacetime with officers from the Officers’ Reserve Corps (ORC) and enlisted personnel<br />

from the Enlisted Reserve Corps (ERC). Officers in the ORC were commissioned through<br />

either the Reserve Officers Training Corps (ROTC) or the Citizens Military Training Camps<br />

(CMTCs). 171 The ERC was a federal reserve of enlisted personnel established by the NDA<br />

of 1920. 172<br />

The NDA of 1920 divided the nation into nine corps areas as shown in Figure 5.1.<br />

Figure 5.1—Nine Corps Areas Outlined in National Defense Act of 1920 173<br />

Each Corps Area was to contain one Regular <strong>Army</strong> division, two infantry divisions of the<br />

National Guard, and three infantry divisions of the Organized Reserves. 174 The Organized<br />

____________<br />

170 Weigley (1984), p. 399<br />

171 The CMTCs “had grown out of the pre-World War I ‘Plattsburg idea’ promoted by <strong>Army</strong> Chief of Staff<br />

Leonard Wood” where men volunteered to attend military training camps in the summertime in exchange for<br />

commissions.” [Crossland and Currie (1984), p. 39]<br />

172 Crossland and Currie (1984), p. 35<br />

173 Kreidberg and Henry (1955), p. 386

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!