04.06.2014 Views

Kristine L. Engel, RN, MSN, CRRN - Paralyzed Veterans of America

Kristine L. Engel, RN, MSN, CRRN - Paralyzed Veterans of America

Kristine L. Engel, RN, MSN, CRRN - Paralyzed Veterans of America

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

A Transdisciplinary Education Model<br />

for Advancing Sexual Health in<br />

Adults with Spinal Cord Injury<br />

Presented by<br />

Michelle Wesline, <strong>RN</strong><br />

Kim Burie, MSW, APSW


Disclosures<br />

This continuing education activity is managed and accredited<br />

by Pr<strong>of</strong>essional Education Service Group. The material<br />

presented in this activity represents the opinion <strong>of</strong> the<br />

faculty. Neither PESG, nor any accrediting organization<br />

endorses any commercial products displayed in<br />

conjunction with this activity.<br />

Commercial Support was not received for this activity.<br />

Kim Burie, MSW, APSW and Michelle Wesline, <strong>RN</strong> have no<br />

financial interest or relationships to disclose.


Obtaining CME/CE Credit<br />

If you would like to receive continuing education<br />

credit for this activity, please visit:<br />

http://pva.cds.pesgce.com/


Froedtert Hospital:<br />

Spinal Cord Injury Center


Learning Objectives<br />

• Review the significance <strong>of</strong> sexuality and<br />

reproductive health as a concerning and under<br />

addressed topic for individuals with Spinal Cord<br />

Injury (SCI)<br />

• Discuss the healthcare providers’ role in providing<br />

sexual health education to individuals with SCI<br />

and their partners<br />

• Describe the journey one organization took to<br />

implement best practice guidelines regarding<br />

sexual health education for staff caring for<br />

individuals with SCI


Sexuality<br />

• Complex<br />

• Unique<br />

• Evolves over a lifetime


Best Practice Guidelines<br />

The Consortium <strong>of</strong> Spinal<br />

Cord Medicine<br />

published “Sexuality<br />

and Reproductive<br />

Health in Adults with<br />

Spinal Cord Injury”, an<br />

evidence-based clinical<br />

practice guideline, in<br />

January 2010


“…many pr<strong>of</strong>essionals are<br />

uncomfortable providing information<br />

about sexuality within the context <strong>of</strong><br />

rehabilitation after spinal cord<br />

injury.”<br />

Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine. Sexuality and Reproductive<br />

Health in Adults with Spinal Cord Injury: A Clinical Practice<br />

Guideline for Health-Care Pr<strong>of</strong>essionals. <strong>Paralyzed</strong> <strong>Veterans</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>America</strong> (PVA); 2010.


What We Know<br />

• Addressing sexuality & fertility issues<br />

during hospitalization was controversial &<br />

seldom done<br />

• Myths & misconceptions existed<br />

• People with SCI & their families were<br />

poorly informed <strong>of</strong> resources surrounding<br />

sexuality & reproductive health


What We Know<br />

• Sexuality & fertility are consistently identified<br />

as priority topics for people with SCI<br />

• Education surrounding sexuality & reproductive<br />

health becomes increasingly more important<br />

the months & years following injury<br />

• Although providing education is a key role,<br />

many clinicians are uncomfortable discussing<br />

this topic with patients & families


“…it is our role to ensure that they<br />

[patients] have accurate information<br />

about sexuality and the emotional<br />

support to make that decision.”<br />

Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine. Sexuality and Reproductive<br />

Health in Adults with Spinal Cord Injury: A Clinical Practice<br />

Guideline for Health-Care Pr<strong>of</strong>essionals. <strong>Paralyzed</strong> <strong>Veterans</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>America</strong> (PVA); 2010.


SCI Education Team for Sexuality<br />

& Reproductive Health<br />

• A interdisciplinary team convened to<br />

implement sexuality & fertility education<br />

based on best practice guidelines<br />

• Team members were selected to include<br />

representatives from the entire continuum<br />

<strong>of</strong> care program


Project Goals<br />

• Increase awareness that providing<br />

comprehensive education is a key role &<br />

responsibility for clinicians<br />

• Improve quality <strong>of</strong> care through education based<br />

on best practice evidence<br />

• Improve documentation surrounding education<br />

provided to patients and their partners<br />

• Establish a method for providing continuing<br />

education for existing staff & new hires to the<br />

department


“…we realize that life does not end<br />

after a spinal cord injury nor does<br />

the ability to have fulfilling intimate<br />

relationships and a satisfying<br />

sexual life.”<br />

Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine. Sexuality and Reproductive<br />

Health in Adults with Spinal Cord Injury: A Clinical Practice<br />

Guideline for Health-Care Pr<strong>of</strong>essionals. <strong>Paralyzed</strong> <strong>Veterans</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>America</strong> (PVA); 2010.


Project Development: Method<br />

The PLISSIT Model for sexual health<br />

education & counseling served as the<br />

framework to guide the project<br />

Permission<br />

Limited Information<br />

Specific Suggestion<br />

Intensive Therapy


Permission<br />

• Create an open atmosphere to discuss<br />

sexuality and sexual functioning<br />

• Discuss the fact that many people have<br />

questions/concerns about sexuality<br />

• Provide private time for the patient and<br />

their partner


Limited Information<br />

• Relates to an individual's readiness to receive<br />

information/education<br />

• Varies from one individual to another and<br />

may change over time<br />

• General and basic education<br />

• Know your own limitations in knowledge and<br />

comfort<br />

• Collaborate with team members and use<br />

resources as necessary


Specific Suggestions<br />

• Requires advanced knowledge and clinical<br />

skill<br />

• Involves obtaining a sexual history,<br />

identifying specific problems and setting<br />

goals<br />

• Addresses an individual’s specific issues


Intensive Therapy<br />

Requires formal training and documented<br />

competence in sex therapy, sexuality<br />

counseling, or psychotherapy.


Our Journey


Local Sexual Health Center<br />

• Education for the implementation<br />

committee: Sexuality and Disability<br />

• We explored and learned


“… we realized that sexuality is a<br />

complex integration <strong>of</strong> biological,<br />

cultural, spiritual, social, relational,<br />

and psychological factors. Sexual<br />

expression is not only what occurs<br />

in the privacy <strong>of</strong> one’s own home,<br />

but goes to the core <strong>of</strong> how we<br />

relate to other people and how we<br />

feel about ourselves.”<br />

Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine. Sexuality and Reproductive<br />

Health in Adults with Spinal Cord Injury: A Clinical Practice<br />

Guideline for Health-Care Pr<strong>of</strong>essionals. <strong>Paralyzed</strong> <strong>Veterans</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

<strong>America</strong> (PVA); 2010.


Circles <strong>of</strong> Sexuality<br />

Sensuality<br />

Sexualization<br />

Intimacy<br />

Sexual Health<br />

and<br />

Reproduction<br />

Sexual<br />

Identity


“In this culture, people with<br />

disabilities are expected to be<br />

perpetual children, which means<br />

that sexual expression would not be<br />

appropriate and may be considered<br />

perverted.”<br />

Doress-Worters PB, King L, Lennett J, Norsignian J, Sanford WC (ed),<br />

Yanco J. Our Bodies, Ourselves: For the New Century. New York,<br />

NY: Boston Women’s Health Book Collective; 1998:248.


Sexuality & Disability<br />

Sensuality<br />

Sexualization<br />

Intimacy<br />

Sexual Health<br />

and<br />

Reproduction<br />

Sexual<br />

Identity


Values and Beliefs<br />

Formed by personal<br />

histories and<br />

experiences, society,<br />

culture, religion,<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>essional<br />

knowledge and<br />

experiences<br />

Values and beliefs <strong>of</strong>ten lead to biases, both<br />

positive and negative


Biases<br />

• Information should be medically accurate<br />

and factual<br />

• Pr<strong>of</strong>essionals should address sexuality in<br />

a nonjudgmental manner<br />

• Follow standardized guidelines<br />

• Acknowledge your own biases, especially<br />

if they lead to discomfort


Implementation: 3 Phases<br />

1<br />

2<br />

3<br />

Phase<br />

Phase<br />

Phase<br />

Survey to measure knowledge & comfort<br />

to providing sexual health education<br />

& gain staff “buy-in”<br />

Program Meeting (1 st <strong>of</strong> 2)<br />

Development <strong>of</strong> 3 unique education<br />

requirements<br />

2 online modules<br />

Program Meeting (2 nd <strong>of</strong> 2)<br />

Implementation <strong>of</strong> the education<br />

Program Evaluation


Phase 1


Staff Assessment<br />

Knowledge, Comfort, Approach and<br />

Attitude towards Sexuality Scale<br />

(KCAASS)


Section 1: Knowledge<br />

On a scale <strong>of</strong> 1-4, please indicate your current level <strong>of</strong> knowledge in dealing with the following topics as<br />

they relate to people with spinal cord injury.


Section 2: Comfort<br />

Please rate the following items on a scale from 1 (nil discomfort), to 4 (high discomfort) on the amount <strong>of</strong><br />

discomfort you would feel in these situations.


Section 3: Approach<br />

Please rate the following items on a scale from 1 (nil discomfort), to 4 (high discomfort) on the amount <strong>of</strong><br />

discomfort you would feel in these situations.


Section 4: Attitude<br />

Read the following statements and indicate by circling the appropriate number whether you disagree or<br />

agree from 1 (disagree strongly) to 4 (agree strongly).


Additional Questions<br />

Please answer the following questions.


Pre-Education Results


Requested Education Topics<br />

• Sexual function in SCI: sensation <strong>of</strong> orgasms/erections in<br />

men & women with SCI<br />

• Care <strong>of</strong> bowel & bladder during sex<br />

• Fertility options/methods/costs & childbearing<br />

information<br />

• Sex positions & assistive devices, including medications<br />

• Scripting: how to handle difficulties in approach <strong>of</strong><br />

sexuality topic<br />

• LGBT information


Gaining Staff “Buy-In”<br />

• Promotional Flyers “Bringin’ Sexy Back”<br />

• 2011 Spring Program Meeting “Kick-<strong>of</strong>f”<br />

We’re Bringin’ Sexy Back………..<br />

You Ready?


SCIC Program Meeting 2011<br />

• Program goals for sexuality &<br />

reproductive health education shared<br />

• Pre-education data examined –<br />

KCAASS results<br />

• Guest speaker facilitated discussions<br />

& activities


SCIC Program Meeting 2011<br />

• Active discussion defining sexuality<br />

• Examined personal biases<br />

regarding sexuality & disabilities<br />

• Activities to increase comfort level<br />

around sexuality concerns


Feedback<br />

Very mixed responses<br />

• Some enjoyed the work out sessions<br />

• Some did not see the relevance<br />

• Some did not think it was “appropriate” material


Phase 2


Online Educational Module 1<br />

Content<br />

• Sexuality following<br />

spinal cord injury<br />

• PLISSIT Model<br />

• Staff’s role in<br />

education<br />

• Sexual function post<br />

SCI<br />

Method<br />

• Interactive online<br />

module<br />

• Interactive with built<br />

in activities & quiz


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Module 1 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000037/player.html


Online Educational Module 2<br />

Content<br />

• Components <strong>of</strong> a<br />

sexual H&P<br />

• Practical, physical &<br />

emotional<br />

considerations<br />

• Intensive treatment<br />

for sexual dysfunction<br />

& infertility<br />

Method<br />

• Interactive style<br />

maintained & content<br />

built upon the first<br />

module


Module 2 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000040/player.html


Module 2 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000040/player.html


Module 2 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000040/player.html


Module 2 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000040/player.html


Module 2 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000040/player.html


Module 2 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000040/player.html


Module 2 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000040/player.html


Module 2 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000040/player.html


Module 2 Demonstration<br />

https://ecs.fmlh.edu/courseware/Dept/5SE/5SE000040/player.html


Happy 25 th Anniversary, SCIC!!<br />

Gary Karp<br />

• Author<br />

• Motivational speaker


Implementation <strong>of</strong> Education<br />

• Allow staff completion <strong>of</strong> both modules<br />

• Devise learning plan for new hires<br />

• Team developed agenda for Spring SCIC<br />

Program Meeting 2012 final piece <strong>of</strong><br />

education series


Trip to The Tool Shed<br />

• Visited and toured the erotic<br />

boutique, The Tool Shed<br />

(www.toolshedtoys.com)<br />

• Staff provided education<br />

• Staff open to learning about disability,<br />

specifically the needs <strong>of</strong> the SCI population<br />

• “Hands on” experience<br />

• Purchased devices for education<br />

• Guest speaker at SCIC Program Meeting


SCIC Program Meeting 2012<br />

Team developed an agenda for the<br />

meeting<br />

• Guest speaker from The Tool Shed<br />

• Interactive booth displays<br />

– Medical management<br />

– Assistive devices<br />

– Role play<br />

– Resources


SCIC Program Meeting 2012<br />

Guest Speaker<br />

Laura Stewart<br />

Educator and Erotic Boutique Owner


SCIC Program Meeting 2012<br />

Medical Management<br />

Farhad Sepahpanah, MD<br />

Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation<br />

Spinal Cord Injury Medicine<br />

Clement J. Zablocki VA Medical Center in Milwaukee, WI


SCIC Program Meeting 2012<br />

Assistive Devices<br />

Laura Stewart and her partner, Hudson<br />

The Tool Shed in Milwaukee, WI<br />

Sandi Kaszkowski, COTA<br />

Spinal Cord Injury Center<br />

Froedtert Hospital in Milwaukee, WI


SCIC Program Meeting 2012<br />

Role Play<br />

Kathryn Zao, PhD<br />

Psychologist, Spinal Cord Injury Center<br />

Froedtert Hospital in Milwaukee, WI


SCIC Program Meeting 2012<br />

Resources<br />

Donna Johnson, <strong>RN</strong>, BSN<br />

Coordinator <strong>of</strong> the Spinal Cord Injury Program<br />

Froedtert Hospital in Milwaukee, WI<br />

Danielle Siclovan, <strong>RN</strong>***<br />

Neurosciences Director <strong>of</strong> Nursing<br />

Froedtert Hospital in Milwaukee, WI


3<br />

Phase


Sexuality Program Evaluation<br />

Administer the KCAASS to staff<br />

• Post education<br />

• Evaluate the results <strong>of</strong> the 3 phase<br />

education program


Pre & Post Education: Knowledge<br />

• 47% improvement: sexual positioning<br />

• 35% improvement:<br />

– Pr<strong>of</strong>essional issues in dealing with sexuality<br />

rehabilitation<br />

– Changes in people’s perception <strong>of</strong> their sexual<br />

identity following SCI<br />

– Care <strong>of</strong> bladder and bowel during sexual activity<br />

– Assistive devices and medications for achieving<br />

erections<br />

– Communication in relationships<br />

– Courtship and dating


Pre & Post Education: Comfort<br />

• 20% improvement:<br />

– Patient says, “I can’t feel anything<br />

anymore, so what’s the point?”<br />

– Male patient asks, “Will I ever be able to<br />

have children?”<br />

• 17% improvement:<br />

– Female patient asks, “I like to be on top but<br />

my legs don’t hold me”<br />

– Female patient asks, “Why am I so dry<br />

during sex?”


Pre & Post Education: Approach<br />

• 26% improvement: You walk into a room and<br />

find a patient masturbating<br />

• 15% improvement: You walk into a room and<br />

find a patient and his/her partner engaged in<br />

sexual foreplay<br />

• 11% improvement: Patients asks you for a<br />

date


Pre & Post Education: Attitude<br />

• 19% improvement: People with a spinal cord<br />

injury would find it hard to get a partner


Pre & Post Education:<br />

Additional Questions<br />

• 43% improvement: In the last month, how<br />

many times have you responded to a<br />

patient’s questions about sex?<br />

• 40% improvement: In the last month, how<br />

many times has a patient brought up the topic<br />

<strong>of</strong> sexuality?<br />

• 31% improvement: In the last month, how<br />

many times have you initiated conversation<br />

about sexuality with a patient?


Pre & Post Education: Barriers<br />

• 49% improvement: I don’t know enough<br />

about it<br />

• 5% improvement:<br />

– I’m not comfortable<br />

– It’s not my role<br />

• 10% regression:<br />

– There was no appropriate time<br />

– The patient is inappropriate regarding this<br />

topic


Program Evaluation: Strengths<br />

“It definitely made people aware <strong>of</strong> how awkward<br />

a sexual conversation can be for some people”<br />

“Stations were good”<br />

“Knowledge base was very good”<br />

“Ease at which a sensitive subject was<br />

presented”<br />

“Very informative – hands on booths very good<br />

“Presenters not embarrassed or uncomfortable”


Program Evaluation:<br />

Recommended Improvements<br />

“Reflection was uncomfortable”<br />

“It wasn’t really about spinal cord patients”<br />

“More tips on what we could actually talk to our<br />

patients about”<br />

“Anyone can look at a sex toy magazine and find<br />

ideas, but I wish we could have had ideas for<br />

addressing the issues our patients may bring up”<br />

“I was very uncomfortable throughout the entire<br />

session”


Bottom Line<br />

• Seems like more people are talking<br />

about it<br />

• Patients are inquiring<br />

• Currently discussing if need to<br />

teach more <strong>of</strong> A&P, due to<br />

feedback


Implementation Committee Members<br />

• <strong>Kristine</strong> L. <strong>Engel</strong> <strong>RN</strong>,<br />

<strong>MSN</strong>, CR<strong>RN</strong><br />

• Sharon Feldmann PT,<br />

MS, OCS<br />

• Donna Johnson <strong>RN</strong>, BSN<br />

• Patricia Meurer <strong>RN</strong>, BSN<br />

• Nicole Rosin, <strong>RN</strong>, APNP<br />

• Cathy Sandmayr <strong>RN</strong>,<br />

<strong>MSN</strong><br />

• Mary Voegeli <strong>RN</strong>,<br />

<strong>MSN</strong>, CR<strong>RN</strong>, APNP<br />

• William Waring MD<br />

• Michelle Wesline <strong>RN</strong><br />

• Kathryn Zao PhD


Special Acknowledgment<br />

Special thanks to the Froedtert Hospital<br />

Foundation. Their generous support funded<br />

the purchase <strong>of</strong> adaptive equipment and<br />

educational materials as well as payment for<br />

guest speakers and <strong>of</strong>f-site education.


What questions<br />

do you have?<br />

?<br />

Michelle Wesline, <strong>RN</strong> mwesline@froedterthealth.org<br />

Kim Burie, MSW, APSW kburie@froedterthealth.org


References<br />

1. Burns SP, Hammond MC, eds. Yes, You Can! A Guide to Self-Care for Persons with Spinal Cord<br />

Injury. Washington DC: <strong>Paralyzed</strong> <strong>Veterans</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>America</strong> (PVA); 2009.<br />

2. Consortium for Spinal Cord Medicine. Sexuality and Reproductive Health in Adults with Spinal Cord<br />

Injury: A Clinical Practice Guideline for Health-Care Pr<strong>of</strong>essionals. <strong>Paralyzed</strong> <strong>Veterans</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>America</strong><br />

(PVA); 2010.<br />

3. Doress-Worters PB, King L, Lennett J, Norsignian J, Sanford WC (ed), Yanco J. Our Bodies,<br />

Ourselves: For the New Century. New York, NY: Boston Women’s Health Book Collective; 1998:248.<br />

4. Everaert K, deWaard WIQ, Van Ho<strong>of</strong> T, Kiekens C, Mulliez T, D’herde C. Neuroanatomy and<br />

neurophysiology related to sexual dysfunction in male neurogenic patients with lesions to the spinal<br />

cord or peripheral nerves. Spinal Cord. 2010;48:182-191.<br />

5. Fronek P, Booth S, Kendall M, Miller D, Geraght T. The effectiveness <strong>of</strong> a sexuality training program<br />

for the interdisciplinary spinal cord injury rehabilitation team. Sex Disabil. 2005;23:51-63.<br />

6. Health Info & Services page. Planned Parenthood. http://www.plannedparenthood.org/. 2012.<br />

Accessed August 14, 2012.<br />

7. Kendall M, Booth S, Fronek P, Miller D, Geraghty T. The development <strong>of</strong> a scale to assess the<br />

training needs <strong>of</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essionals in providing sexuality rehabilitation following spinal cord injury. Sex<br />

Disabil. 2003;21:49-64.<br />

8. Preventing pain during sex page. <strong>America</strong>n Cancer Society.<br />

http://www.cancer.org/Treatment/TreatmentandSideEffects/PhysicalSideEffects.htm. April 25, 2011.<br />

Accessed August 14, 2012.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!