PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES - United Kingdom Parliament
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES - United Kingdom Parliament PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES - United Kingdom Parliament
1575 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 2013 Easter Adjournment 1576 [Mr Stewart Jackson] dear to my heart is the Sue Ryder hospice at Thorpe Hall. A grade I listed building which was the home of Oliver St John—Oliver Cromwell’s money man—it is no longer fit for purpose as a hospice. The fundraising committee, of which I was a member for five years, is raising money for a purpose-built £6 million 22-bedroom hospice on the site. We desperately need the funds for that and good work is being done. So my city is generous and it is raising money for good causes. May I end by wishing all hon. Members, you, Mr Deputy Speaker, the Speaker, the Chairman of Ways and Means and all staff a happy, peaceful and restful Easter recess? 6.24 pm Fiona O’Donnell (East Lothian) (Lab): May I begin by apologising to you, Mr Deputy Speaker, the House and the Deputy Leader of the House for that fact that I will not be able to stay for the duration of the debate? I congratulate the hon. Member for Peterborough (Mr Jackson) on his contribution, as he took the opportunity to raise a kaleidoscope of issues. I also congratulate you, Mr Deputy Speaker, and the Backbench Business Committee on this excellent initiative that I am taking advantage of for the first time. Although I do not agree with the hon. Gentleman on tax breaks for married couples, I hope that he would extend them to same-sex couples who choose to marry. Such great issues of human rights have been raised by the hon. Gentleman and by the hon. Member for Bradford West (George Galloway), who discussed child poverty, a shameful and deepening scar on this country. However, I wish to be a little more parochial and concentrate on issues closer to home. This may feel like groundhog day to you, Mr Deputy Speaker, as I spoke about the future of Cockenzie power station in yesterday’s Budget debate, but it is an issue of real importance to my constituency. Cockenzie’s coal-fired power station closed on Friday 15 March, after 45 years of electricity generation which powered approximately 1 million homes every year during the station’s lifetime. Some 10,000 people have been employed there during its lifetime, through construction and generation. In some cases, three generations of families have been involved in the plant. It was a sad and emotional day when we saw those grown men in their hard hats having soft hearts about the closure of such an important part of East Lothian’s history, which has made such a great contribution to its economy. For many, including me, as I frequently fly into Edinburgh airport, its twin chimney stacks are the place that marks home. I wish to praise ScottishPower, which has a good record in managing such closures. I praise the way in which it has worked with the trade unions in the workplace and with individual employees to ensure that there have been no compulsory redundancies. Many employees are moving to other stations, while others have opted for retirement or severance voluntarily. Having said that, this was still a tough day for East Lothian, as Cockenzie now lies like a sleeping giant, waiting for a decision from this Government. There has been uncertainty about the future of Cockenzie for some time, and I do not lay this all at the door of this Government; the previous administration in East Lothian council, a Scottish National party-Lib Dem coalition, opposed planning permission for the plant’s conversion to gas. Fortunately, that decision was overturned by Scottish Ministers, who are also from the SNP— indecision is not limited to those on the Government Benches. Thankfully, we have a new administration in East Lothian council, a Labour-Conservative coalition— that is how democracy can be at times. It results from the single transferable vote, and I do not think it is a coalition we will ever see replicated in this place. ScottishPower is calling for clarity on a capacity mechanism for thermal generation in the Energy Bill. Speaking at the annual meeting of the shareholders of Iberdrola—the Spanish owner of ScottishPower—its chief executive officer, Mr Galan, said that ScottishPower would increase its planned UK spend of £10 billion by £3 billion to build new gas-fired power stations, but uncertainty caused by market conditions and a lack of clarity from the UK Government was holding back that further investment. Some of that money could be used to refurbish the station at Cockenzie, creating 1,000 construction jobs in my constituency in the process and with further knock-on benefits to the local economy. When completed, it would be a welcome source of skilled jobs and apprenticeships for young people in my constituency. I urge the Deputy Leader of the House to take that message back to the Department of Energy and Climate Change. This is an opportunity for investment in the UK and in my constituency to create jobs and to keep the lights on. 6.29 pm Richard Graham (Gloucester) (Con): Not long ago, a Slovak national, Mr Peter Pavlisin, badly beat up his pregnant Gloucester girlfriend, Natasha Motala, threatened her with death and had to be subdued by several policemen. He was sentenced to four years in prison in the Gloucester Crown court and the judge revealed during sentencing that during Mr Pavlisin’s four years in the UK he had been convicted of 14 offences from 21 charges. When I read that in our local paper, The Citizen, my immediate reaction was relief for my constituent Natasha, who had given birth safely, and for my other constituents, as the criminal would be off the streets of Gloucester. There was something missing, however. Where was the instruction to the courts to deport the prisoner at the end of his sentence? I rang the judge and he explained that judges have the authority to deport non-EU nationals but not EU nationals. That can only be decided by the Home Secretary. I did more research, and I discovered that if an EU national is sentenced to more than two years, or 12 months for certain crimes, the National Offender Management Service is supposed to make recommendations to the Home Secretary on deportation some months before that sentence is over. That system is unsatisfactory in several ways. First, the victims, the court, the media and the community are unaware of it. No one in Gloucester knows that Mr Pavlisin should be deported in due course. As the judge is silent on the issue—indeed, judges have to be—the implication is that he will not be deported and will emerge with a strong likelihood of extending his frequent appearances in our courts. Secondly, there is no clear responsibility for action, no audit trail and no measurement of the Ministry of Justice’s ability to ensure that dangerous EU nationals
1577 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 2013 Easter Adjournment 1578 are deported at the end of their sentences. Thirdly, as the law allows for deportation but the process does not highlight it, my constituents and everyone else’s are unlikely to have confidence in the system. That gap in the process could, I believe, be fixed relatively simply through an amendment to the UK Borders Act 2007 and a memorandum of conviction that would require judges to say when the sentence for any EU national is of a length or severity that obliges NOMS to consider recommending deportation to the Home Secretary well ahead of the completion of the sentence. That would spell out to everyone, including EU nationals, an important likely consequence of serious crime in our country. It would remind everyone that we decide who is deported and who is not, wherever they come from, and give us all more confidence in the process of law. Let me be clear: this is not about bashing the EU or stoking xenophobic paranoia. Immigrants to Gloucester, from Roman legionaries to Norman monks, Jamaican nurses, Asian engineers, Polish makers of shirts and many others besides, including some great European rugby players, have contributed hugely to our city. We have thrived on immigration but not on foreign criminals. This is about the safety of my constituents and justice for all our constituents and it is a plea for more certainty and rigour in the process of justice. I am sure that Ministers in both the Ministry of Justice and the Home Department share my concerns and I hope that they will act to ensure that justice is done and is seen to be done and that all foreign criminals will be deported when they deserve to be. Let me take this opportunity to wish you, Mr Deputy Speaker, and everyone in this House a happy Easter. Several hon. Members rose— Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Lindsay Hoyle): On her birthday, I call Barbara Keeley. 6.33 pm Barbara Keeley (Worsley and Eccles South) (Lab): Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker. I want to take this opportunity to talk about sport and fitness for women and girls. I spoke about it during the debate on international women’s day last year and from that debate we managed to get cross-party agreement to support the development of a new all-party group on women’s sport and fitness. We launched it, it is supported by the Women’s Sport and Fitness Foundation and we have had some great meetings. Our first meeting was with the presenter and sports commentator Clare Balding and the Olympic rowing gold medallist Kath Grainger, and most recently we have had a meeting with the Paralympian Martine Wright, who survived the 7/7 bombings and went on to compete in the Paralympics, and Claire Lomas, who was the first paraplegic to complete the London marathon, doing so in 17 days walking in a robotic suit. It was great to listen to those inspirational women from those different sports. It is needed, because women’s sport faces a crisis in media coverage and lack of sponsorship. Outside Olympic years, women’s sport receives less than 5% of the total sport print coverage, and even then, unsurprisingly, women’s sport receives only 0.5% of the total sponsorship income. There was the recent case of the England women’s football team being offered a salary increase from £16,000 to £18,000 a year. They eventually settled on a contract of £20,000 a year. In the same week, the Arsenal football player Theo Walcott signed for £100,000 a week. I know that we have some talented girls and young women playing football now, and the difference in reward levels for women’s football must be offputting for those talented enough to seek a professional career. Appropriately enough for a debate at this time of year, it is a case of the chicken and the egg. More media coverage is needed to provide girls and young women with positive role models in sport, and that would encourage participation and future achievement, but media coverage is elusive and without it we do not get the sponsorship and salaries remain low. Let me turn quickly to school sport, because we currently have a crisis of activity levels among children, especially girls, with just 16% of girls and young women reaching the recommended levels of activity by the time they leave primary school, compared with 29% of boys, and only 12% of 14-year-olds are active enough to benefit their health. In fact, girls leave school only half as likely to meet the recommended activity levels of boys, and nearly a third of 16-year-olds do no physical activity at all. In that context, the Government’s announcement of £150 million for primary school sport is welcome, but I have some questions about the funding. How will Ministers ensure that the investment helps to close the gender gap in activity levels in primary schools? Do they have any plans to provide similar, much needed support in secondary schools, where sport among girls really drops away? How do Ministers plan to measure the success of the investment, given that there is no comprehensive annual measurement of children’s activity levels in sport? The status quo is that 51% of girls say that school sport and physical education actually puts them off being active, and they are only half as likely as boys to meet the recommended activity levels. I commend the Rugby Football Union for its All Schools programme. At a recent event in the House, I met three young women who had taken up playing rugby at school and at a local club. The RFU has done a great job in enthusing teachers and coaches, who in turn enthuse and inspire young women, such as the three I met. I also congratulate FC United of Manchester on commemorating international women’s day by holding events to celebrate women in football, including an event called “A woman’s place is at the match”. Its women’s team was awarded Manchester Football Association’s “Team of the Month” award. They also won a recent semi-final to win through to the league cup final against Manchester City’s women’s team. I commend them and all women and girls working to break down barriers in women’s sport. Finally, I would like to give the customary thanks to all staff of the House. I particularly want to thank Noeleen and the staff of the Tea Room, who I think do a wonderful job, the Hansard reporters, to whom I think we should all be very grateful, and you, Mr Deputy Speaker. I wish all a happy Easter. I will end by wishing a happy birthday to my hon. Friends the Members for Bristol East (Kerry McCarthy) and for Nottingham South (Lilian Greenwood) and my right hon. Friend the
- Page 15 and 16: 1473 Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundati
- Page 17 and 18: 1477 Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundati
- Page 19 and 20: 1481 Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundati
- Page 22 and 23: 1487 26 MARCH 2013 Rail Franchising
- Page 24 and 25: 1491 Rail Franchising 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 26 and 27: 1495 Rail Franchising 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 28 and 29: 1499 Rail Franchising 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 30 and 31: 1503 UK Border Agency 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 32 and 33: 1507 UK Border Agency 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 34 and 35: 1511 26 MARCH 2013 Points of Order
- Page 36 and 37: 1515 UK Elected Representatives 26
- Page 38 and 39: 1519 Business without Debate 26 MAR
- Page 40 and 41: 1523 Flood Insurance 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 42 and 43: 1527 Flood Insurance 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 44 and 45: 1531 Flood Insurance 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 46 and 47: 1535 Flood Insurance 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 48 and 49: 1539 Flood Insurance 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 50 and 51: 1543 Flood Insurance 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 52 and 53: 1547 Flood Insurance 26 MARCH 2013
- Page 54 and 55: 1551 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 56 and 57: 1555 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 58 and 59: 1559 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 60 and 61: 1563 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 62 and 63: 1567 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 64 and 65: 1571 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 68 and 69: 1579 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 70 and 71: 1583 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 72 and 73: 1587 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 74 and 75: 1591 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 76 and 77: 1595 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 78 and 79: 1599 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 80 and 81: 1603 Easter Adjournment 26 MARCH 20
- Page 82 and 83: 1607 Energy Infrastructure (UK Supp
- Page 84 and 85: 1611 Energy Infrastructure (UK Supp
- Page 86 and 87: 419WH Munitions Workers 26 MARCH 20
- Page 88 and 89: 423WH Munitions Workers 26 MARCH 20
- Page 90 and 91: 427WH Munitions Workers 26 MARCH 20
- Page 92 and 93: 431WH Munitions Workers 26 MARCH 20
- Page 94 and 95: 435WH Munitions Workers 26 MARCH 20
- Page 96 and 97: 439WH Fetal Anti-convulsant Syndrom
- Page 98 and 99: 443WH Fetal Anti-convulsant Syndrom
- Page 100 and 101: 447WH 26 MARCH 2013 HMRC Closures 4
- Page 102 and 103: 451WH HMRC Closures 26 MARCH 2013 H
- Page 104 and 105: 455WH HMRC Closures 26 MARCH 2013 H
- Page 106 and 107: 459WH HMRC Closures 26 MARCH 2013 4
- Page 108 and 109: 463WH Bee Health 26 MARCH 2013 Bee
- Page 110 and 111: 467WH Bee Health 26 MARCH 2013 468W
- Page 112 and 113: 471WH [Steve Webb] Under-Occupancy
- Page 114 and 115: 475WH [Steve Webb] Under-Occupancy
1577 Easter Adjournment<br />
26 MARCH 2013 Easter Adjournment<br />
1578<br />
are deported at the end of their sentences. Thirdly, as<br />
the law allows for deportation but the process does not<br />
highlight it, my constituents and everyone else’s are<br />
unlikely to have confidence in the system.<br />
That gap in the process could, I believe, be fixed<br />
relatively simply through an amendment to the UK<br />
Borders Act 2007 and a memorandum of conviction<br />
that would require judges to say when the sentence for<br />
any EU national is of a length or severity that obliges<br />
NOMS to consider recommending deportation to the<br />
Home Secretary well ahead of the completion of the<br />
sentence. That would spell out to everyone, including<br />
EU nationals, an important likely consequence of serious<br />
crime in our country. It would remind everyone that we<br />
decide who is deported and who is not, wherever they<br />
come from, and give us all more confidence in the<br />
process of law.<br />
Let me be clear: this is not about bashing the EU or<br />
stoking xenophobic paranoia. Immigrants to Gloucester,<br />
from Roman legionaries to Norman monks, Jamaican<br />
nurses, Asian engineers, Polish makers of shirts and<br />
many others besides, including some great European<br />
rugby players, have contributed hugely to our city. We<br />
have thrived on immigration but not on foreign criminals.<br />
This is about the safety of my constituents and justice<br />
for all our constituents and it is a plea for more certainty<br />
and rigour in the process of justice. I am sure that<br />
Ministers in both the Ministry of Justice and the Home<br />
Department share my concerns and I hope that they<br />
will act to ensure that justice is done and is seen to be<br />
done and that all foreign criminals will be deported<br />
when they deserve to be.<br />
Let me take this opportunity to wish you, Mr Deputy<br />
Speaker, and everyone in this House a happy Easter.<br />
Several hon. Members rose—<br />
Mr Deputy Speaker (Mr Lindsay Hoyle): On her<br />
birthday, I call Barbara Keeley.<br />
6.33 pm<br />
Barbara Keeley (Worsley and Eccles South) (Lab):<br />
Thank you, Mr Deputy Speaker.<br />
I want to take this opportunity to talk about sport<br />
and fitness for women and girls. I spoke about it during<br />
the debate on international women’s day last year and<br />
from that debate we managed to get cross-party agreement<br />
to support the development of a new all-party group on<br />
women’s sport and fitness. We launched it, it is supported<br />
by the Women’s Sport and Fitness Foundation and we<br />
have had some great meetings. Our first meeting was<br />
with the presenter and sports commentator Clare Balding<br />
and the Olympic rowing gold medallist Kath Grainger,<br />
and most recently we have had a meeting with<br />
the Paralympian Martine Wright, who survived the<br />
7/7 bombings and went on to compete in the Paralympics,<br />
and Claire Lomas, who was the first paraplegic to<br />
complete the London marathon, doing so in 17 days<br />
walking in a robotic suit.<br />
It was great to listen to those inspirational women<br />
from those different sports. It is needed, because women’s<br />
sport faces a crisis in media coverage and lack of<br />
sponsorship. Outside Olympic years, women’s sport receives<br />
less than 5% of the total sport print coverage, and even<br />
then, unsurprisingly, women’s sport receives only 0.5%<br />
of the total sponsorship income. There was the recent<br />
case of the England women’s football team being offered<br />
a salary increase from £16,000 to £18,000 a year. They<br />
eventually settled on a contract of £20,000 a year. In the<br />
same week, the Arsenal football player Theo Walcott<br />
signed for £100,000 a week. I know that we have some<br />
talented girls and young women playing football now,<br />
and the difference in reward levels for women’s football<br />
must be offputting for those talented enough to seek a<br />
professional career.<br />
Appropriately enough for a debate at this time of<br />
year, it is a case of the chicken and the egg. More media<br />
coverage is needed to provide girls and young women<br />
with positive role models in sport, and that would<br />
encourage participation and future achievement, but<br />
media coverage is elusive and without it we do not get<br />
the sponsorship and salaries remain low.<br />
Let me turn quickly to school sport, because we<br />
currently have a crisis of activity levels among children,<br />
especially girls, with just 16% of girls and young women<br />
reaching the recommended levels of activity by the time<br />
they leave primary school, compared with 29% of boys,<br />
and only 12% of 14-year-olds are active enough to<br />
benefit their health. In fact, girls leave school only half<br />
as likely to meet the recommended activity levels of<br />
boys, and nearly a third of 16-year-olds do no physical<br />
activity at all.<br />
In that context, the Government’s announcement of<br />
£150 million for primary school sport is welcome, but I<br />
have some questions about the funding. How will Ministers<br />
ensure that the investment helps to close the gender gap<br />
in activity levels in primary schools? Do they have any<br />
plans to provide similar, much needed support in secondary<br />
schools, where sport among girls really drops away?<br />
How do Ministers plan to measure the success of the<br />
investment, given that there is no comprehensive annual<br />
measurement of children’s activity levels in sport? The<br />
status quo is that 51% of girls say that school sport and<br />
physical education actually puts them off being active,<br />
and they are only half as likely as boys to meet the<br />
recommended activity levels.<br />
I commend the Rugby Football Union for its All<br />
Schools programme. At a recent event in the House, I<br />
met three young women who had taken up playing<br />
rugby at school and at a local club. The RFU has done<br />
a great job in enthusing teachers and coaches, who in<br />
turn enthuse and inspire young women, such as the<br />
three I met. I also congratulate FC <strong>United</strong> of Manchester<br />
on commemorating international women’s day by<br />
holding events to celebrate women in football, including<br />
an event called “A woman’s place is at the match”. Its<br />
women’s team was awarded Manchester Football<br />
Association’s “Team of the Month” award. They also<br />
won a recent semi-final to win through to the league cup<br />
final against Manchester City’s women’s team. I commend<br />
them and all women and girls working to break down<br />
barriers in women’s sport.<br />
Finally, I would like to give the customary thanks to<br />
all staff of the House. I particularly want to thank<br />
Noeleen and the staff of the Tea Room, who I think do<br />
a wonderful job, the Hansard reporters, to whom I<br />
think we should all be very grateful, and you, Mr Deputy<br />
Speaker. I wish all a happy Easter. I will end by<br />
wishing a happy birthday to my hon. Friends the Members<br />
for Bristol East (Kerry McCarthy) and for Nottingham<br />
South (Lilian Greenwood) and my right hon. Friend the