19.05.2014 Views

Karnataka - People's watch

Karnataka - People's watch

Karnataka - People's watch

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

II<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

1. Custodial Death 34<br />

32<br />

2. False Charge 36<br />

3. Police Acquiescence 39<br />

5. Police Intimidation 62<br />

6. Police Torture – No Death 72<br />

7. Police Violence 104<br />

8. Extra Judicial Killing 135<br />

9. Police Rape (Violence Against Women) 137<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Annual Report on Torture<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

33<br />

01-Custodial Death<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-49/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Markandappa; 2) (Late) Srinivas<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Lakshmi Devamma 2) Police<br />

Location : Vemgal Road<br />

Date of incident : 25/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Markandappa, aged 60 is a resident of Madera Halli village under Kolar Taluk. The victim is<br />

working as a coolie. His son Srinivas was in love with the daughter of Lakshmi Devamma and often<br />

went to her house. Now Srinivas belongs to the Vokkaliga caste and the girl belongs to the Kuruba caste.<br />

On 24 April 2008 there was a clash between Lakshmi Devamma and Srinivas that the latter returned<br />

home and hid in the cattle shed. In the meantime Lakshmi lodged a complaint with Kolar Rural Police<br />

Station alleging Srinivas of harassing her daughter. Accordingly the victim was arrested from his house<br />

and taken to the station. Markandappa went to the station with food but his son wasn’t there. Srinivas was<br />

admitted in SNP Hospital with stomach ache. At the hospital the victim couldn’t be found anywhere and<br />

a policeman stated that he could have escaped. After some time another policeman who was in civilian<br />

attire informed Marandappa that Srinivas was found dead on Vemgal Road. The victim suspects this<br />

could be a murder. Owing to his penury Markandappa is not able to go to the court.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

34<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-04/08<br />

Victim(s) : (Late) Nandan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Forest Officials<br />

Location : Mysore Medical College<br />

Date of incident : 03/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Nandan, aged 40 was a resident of Sasimala under Wyanad district, of Kerala state. His place of<br />

residence was adjacent to the <strong>Karnataka</strong> Forest Region. Nandan used to collect twigs for firewood from<br />

the forest area for many years. On 3 January 2008 the victim went into the forest and never returned.<br />

Santha, W/o Nandan assumed that her husband would have been taken into custody for interrogation in<br />

connection with a case related to their neighbours or he would have been delegated to do some work in<br />

the forest. Santha was hence not much worried about his absence. But on 24 January 2008 a police<br />

official from Pulpally Police Station informed the wife of the victim that Nandan had expired in Mysore<br />

Medical College. He also informed that the victim was in Mysore Jail in relation with a forest case.<br />

Santha suspects that her husband would have died because of custodial torture. She urges necessary<br />

inquiry into the case and appropriate action against the officials responsible for her husband’s death.<br />

Santha also requests the post mortem to be performed in the presence of higher ranked police officials.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Annual Report on Torture<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

35<br />

02-False Charge<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-33/08<br />

Victim(s) : Chandh Pasha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Ramamurthi, PI, CCB PS; 2) Venkatesappa, SI, CCB PS;<br />

3) Omprakash, PC, CCB PS<br />

Location : CCB PS<br />

Date of incident : 01/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Chandh Pasha was a resident of Mandi Mohalla and was working as a mechanic. On 1<br />

March, 2008 the CCB police have gone to the victim’s house and have taken him to the police station for<br />

inquiry. But Chandh Pasha has not returned home after a day. When the victim’s parents have gone to<br />

the police station, the police have abused them and sent them back. But the victim Chandh Pasha was<br />

not released for four days. So his parents have again gone to the police station. Then the police have told<br />

them that Chandh Pasha had accepted that he had killed a jewel merchant. The police have illegally<br />

detained Chandh Pasha at the police station for four days and have tortured him severely. Later the<br />

police have fabricated a case against him and have sent him to jail. When the victim’s parents have met<br />

him at the police station, they were shocked to see injuries on his left shoulder, right thighs and right knee<br />

due to police assault.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M64/08<br />

Victim(s) : Samshu Khan (a) Basha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Shiva, PC, Andersonpet PS<br />

Location : Andersonpet PS<br />

Date of incident : 15/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Samshu Khan (a) Basha was a resident of Muskam village. He had a piece of land in the<br />

village. There was a land dispute between the victim Samshu Khan (a) Basha and Devan Naidu. The<br />

case was at the Court. Meantime, Devan had bribed the police Inspector. On 15 June, 2008, a police<br />

constable had gone to the victim’s house and had called him to the police station. When the victim had<br />

refused, the police had abused him with filthy words. Then the police had dragged him to the police<br />

station and threatened to include his name in the criminal list. Then the police have given him a slate<br />

mentioning something and have taken photo. After the incident the victim Samshu Khan (a) Basha felt<br />

humiliated to face the people of his community. He suffered due to mental agony.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-35/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kemparaju<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Sundararajan, PI, Hunsoor PS;<br />

2) Mahadevappa, SI, Hunsoor PS; 3) Narayan, PC, Hunsoor PS<br />

Location : Hunsoor PS<br />

Date of incident : 15/03/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

36<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Case Details:<br />

The victim Kemparaju was a resident of Aswalu village. His sister Bhagyamma was married to Nagaraju.<br />

Due to intolerable dowry harassment, she has committed suicide on 25 th August, 2008 by jumping into<br />

the river with her two children. So the father of the victim has filed a complaint against Nagaraju at<br />

Hunsoor Police Station. The police have received bribe from the accused and mentioned that they were<br />

missing. Later the accused Nagaraju has bribed the police and has come out on bail. He had persuaded<br />

the police and has filed a complaint against the victim Kemparaju that he had stolen valuables from his<br />

house. On 15 th March, 2008 the police have gone to the victim Kemparaju’s house. The police had<br />

informed him that he will not be arrested if he withdrew the dowry death case, which he filed against his<br />

brother-in-law.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-28/08<br />

Victim(s) : Mohammed Ali Phver<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) SI; 2) Gurumattur PS<br />

Location : Gurumattur PS<br />

Date of incident : 10/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Mohammed Ali Phver was a resident of Savannur village. On 10 April, 2008 he had gone to<br />

his friend’s coconut thicket. Then the victim Mohammed Ali Phver and his friends have taken rest at the<br />

thicket. All on a sudden a police jeep had stopped by the thicket. The victim and his friends have not paid<br />

attention to the police. Few policemen have got down from the jeep and have entered into the coconut<br />

thicket. The police have questioned them for not paying attention to the police and have beaten them<br />

fiercely. The police alleged that they have played gambling and have abused them offensively. Later the<br />

police have filed a false case against the victim Mohammed Ali Phver and his friends and harassed<br />

them physically and mentally.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-27/08<br />

Victim(s) : Vancheera K. AjayKumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Ganesh, ASI, Murunadu Police outpost<br />

Location : Murunadu Police outpost<br />

Date of incident : 07/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Vancheera K. AjayKumar is the coordinator of the Hoddur natives and Civil Welfare Committee.<br />

The coordinator of Dalitha Sangarsha has lodged a false complaint against the victim that he had tried to<br />

kill him. Though the case was proved to a false allegation, the victim still lives under threat. The police did<br />

not respond properly. So it has caused great psychological in convenience to the victim Vancheera K.<br />

AjayKumar<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

37<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Annual Report on Torture<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

04-Police Acquiescence<br />

38<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-10/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ananda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Dasappa; 2) Police<br />

Location : Kushalnagar PS, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 30/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Ananda, aged 58 is a resident of Thorenoo village under Somwarpete Taluk. The victim belongs<br />

to the gowda clan and he is an illiterate person. Ananda’s wife Rangamma, daughter Kavita and son<br />

Ravi are all coolies. On 30 January 2008 the victim’s brother Dasappa filed a complaint at Kushalnagar<br />

Police Station alleging Ananda to have threatened to kill him with regard to a property issue. There was<br />

a property clash between the victim and his brother and the court order was in favor of Ananda. But<br />

Dasappa acquired the help of the police and tried to evict Ananda from the property. When the victim went<br />

to the police station to file a counter complaint he was abused and driven away from the police station.<br />

Ananda desires stringent action against the indifferent police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-24/08<br />

Victim(s) : Bhavani Shankar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Manjunath, SI, Bhagamandala PS<br />

Location : Bhagamandala PS<br />

Date of incident : 29/10/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Bhavani Shankar was a resident of Bhagamandala and he was a forest guard by profession.<br />

On 15 October, 2007, he had heard some noise and had gone to trace that. But he was attacked by a<br />

local smuggler named Dubai Suresh. The victim sustained grievous injuries on his neck and chest and<br />

he had become unconscious. He was hospitalized for nearly a month and had undergone a surgery on<br />

30 January, 2008.Then he had given a complaint to the police. The police Sub-Inspector had refused to<br />

take proper measures against the accused, though the victim Bhavani Shankar had given him a<br />

personal statement. The police have procured a wrong statement from a doctor mentioning that the<br />

victim had inflicted injuries by himself. The police have remained inactive after receiving bribe from the<br />

accused.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-23/08<br />

Victim(s) : Chandrashekar B.L<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Ramesh 2) Poonachcha 3) Ganesh, ASI<br />

Location : Hoddur village, Kodagu<br />

Date of incident : 02/20/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Chandrashekar B.L is a resident of Murunadu village under Kodagu district. The victim practices<br />

agriculture to sustain his livelihood. On 2 February 2008 Chandrashekar was involved in protesting<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

39<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


against the encroachment of forest land in Hoddur village. The activists of Dalitha Sangharsha Samiti<br />

(DSS) were also involved in this protest. At that time two resident of that village namely Ramesh and<br />

Poonachcha warned the victim not to participate in the protest. In his fury Poonachcha shot Chandrashekar.<br />

A case was filed in Murunadu Out-Post Police Station regarding this but ASI Ganesh so far hasn’t taken<br />

any action in respect to the complaint. Though the DSS members held protests it yielded no fruit. The<br />

victim has suffered severe injuries because of the bullet.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-22/08<br />

Victim(s) : Chapala Gangappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Kambalapalli village, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 11/02/2008, 13/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Chapala Gangappa, aged 60 is a resident of Mini Kambalapalli village under Chintamani Taluk.<br />

The victim is an eyewitness of the Kambalapalli incident where 7 Dalits for burnt alive. From then<br />

Chapala Gangappa has been regularly threatened by the Reddy community. After the session court<br />

judgment the court recommended to give protection to the witness. But the police gave protection only for<br />

a week, but later unknown people were found roaming around the victim’s house. The village people<br />

and leaders of DSS (A) movement complained against the tense atmosphere created by those people<br />

to Chintamani Police Station but in vain. Kambalapalli village is 36 kilometers away from Chintamani<br />

town. This arrangement was made by the government so as to avoid clash between the Dalits and the<br />

Reddy’s. But the victims are facing continuous threats from the upper caste, and leading a life of fear. On<br />

11 February 2008 and 13 February 2008 again few strangers were roaming around Chapala Gangappa’s<br />

house but the police never turned out to render protection, rebuking that the villagers were not Chief<br />

Ministers or VIP’s to be given protection.<br />

FF Code : KAR/CHN/PT/M-04/08<br />

Victim(s) : Chikkamallige<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Satyabama, AC; 2) Narasimhamurthy, SI<br />

Location : Kollegal<br />

Date of incident : 18/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Chikkamallige, aged 28 is a resident of Bheemanagar under Kollegal Town. The victim is<br />

working as a reporter in the ‘Kahale’ Fortnight Magazine. In the January section of his magazine<br />

Chikkamallege wrote an article on AC Satyabama exposing the fact that she misused Government<br />

money. After this the AC offered some money to the SI of Kollegal Town Police Station and got a criminal<br />

case registered against the victim. The police came to his house searching for the victim but having<br />

gained news of this earlier, Chikkamallege fled from Kollegal. In his absence the police began to abuse<br />

his father. They even entered the house and searched it. Chikkamallege states that the case against him<br />

is unwarranted and false. The AC should have filed a Defamation case against him and not a criminal<br />

case he states. Though Chikkamallege appealed for bail in Kollegal Court, the judge rejected it. He has<br />

also appealed to the High Court but no reply has turned out. Now Chikkamallege is leading a life of fear.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

40<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-52/08<br />

Victim(s) : (Late) Prathapa Reddy<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Manjunath Reddy 2) Manjunath Selty, SI<br />

Location : Chinthamani<br />

Date of incident : 16/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Choudappa is a resident of Batlahalli village under Chintamani Taluk. He got his daughter Padvathamma<br />

married to Manjunath Reddy. Now this Manjunath tried to kill his elder mother while she was taking bath.<br />

She was admitted in Bangalore Hospital under a serious condition. This incident was witnessed by his<br />

son Prathapa Reddy, who in turn told the matter to the other family members. Manjunath over heard this<br />

and crushed Prathapa with a wooden log on his head while he was sleeping. This happened on 16 May<br />

2008. The victim died on the way to the hospital itself. The matter was informed to Chintamani Police<br />

Station but the police didn’t take any action. So the relatives of the decease compassed the police station<br />

by bringing the body to the station. But SI Manjunath Selty didn’t react to the incident. The villagers were<br />

agitated and threw bricks at the police station. Dy.S.P Ganesh arrived at the place and assured to take<br />

action, following which the mob dispersed, and the body was sent for post mortem. But till date no action<br />

has followed. Though there are valid proofs the police refuse to arrest the accused for they are bribed.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-22/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kusumavathi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Svami Gowda; 2) Radha; 3) Police;3) D.B. Dharmappa<br />

Location : Shanivarasanthe PS<br />

Date of Incident : 06/07/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Dharmappa aged 35 resides at Doddalli Village, in Somvarapete Taluk. He is a coolie. On 06 July 2008<br />

his wife named Kusumavathi went to Doddalli village to meet Svami Gowda to request him to provide<br />

her some work. Svami Gowda and his wife Radha had assaulted Kusumavathi. Kusumavathi went to<br />

the Shanivarasanthe Police Station to file a complaint but the SI refused to act positively Instead, he<br />

verbally abused her and chased her away. The head of the village D.B.Dharmappa tried to induce<br />

Kusumavathi’s son to accept Rs. 500 and demanded that the matter should be suppressed without<br />

taking it to the notice of police or concerned authorities .<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-09/08<br />

Victim(s) : Dinesh S.K<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Chennamallappa; 2) Prakash Gowda, SI; 3) Mallesh, PC<br />

Location : Somwarpete PS, Kodagu<br />

Date of incident : 22/01/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

41<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Case Details:<br />

Victim Dinesh, aged 32 is a resident of Sampigedalu village under Somwarpete Taluk. The victim<br />

belongs to the Scheduled Caste community. There was a small argument between Dinesh and<br />

Chennamallappa, a retired army man of the same village. The latter always demanded work from the<br />

victim alleging Dinesh of owing him some money. When Dinesh refused to work for him he was abused<br />

in return. This Chennamallappa had assaulted few of the boys in the village belonging to Dinesh’s caste.<br />

On 22 January 2008 Dinesh was threatened by this person, that he was greatly afraid and filed a<br />

complaint at Somwarpete Police Station the very next day. The SI and Constable who first accepted the<br />

complaint then began to chide Dinesh once they knew that the perpetrator was an army man. The victim<br />

was also forced to withdraw the complaint. Now Dinesh feels psychologically depressed after this<br />

incident.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M08/08<br />

Victim(s) : Amanulla Khan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Ramappa, SI, Robertson pet PS<br />

Location : Robertson pet PS<br />

Date of incident : 27/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Amanulla Khan was a resident of Bangarpet. He got his elder daughter Anjum Khan married<br />

to Norulla Khan in 2006. Amanulla Khan had given her 15 sovereigns of gold as dowry. In 2007, Norulla<br />

had again demanded dowry and had sent Anjum to her father’s house. The victim Amanulla Khan had<br />

given her Rs 30,000 and sent her back to her husband’s house. In this circumstance, Anjum had given<br />

birth to a female kid. Norulla had again tortured her to get money. On 27 January, 2008 the victim<br />

Amanulla Khan had received a phone call that his daughter Anjum was not well and he has gone to<br />

Norulla’s house. He was shocked to see his daughter unconscious. They rushed to the hospital, but<br />

Anjum had died on the way. The victim Amanulla Khan had gone to the police station to file a complaint.<br />

But the police refused to accept the case and they were in a dilemma whether it was a murder or a<br />

suicide. Later due to pressure from DHRM, the police have filed the FIR, stating that his daughter was<br />

murdered.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-73/08<br />

Victim(s) : Hulibele Suresh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Venkatesh, CI, Bangarpet PS<br />

Location : Bangarpet PS<br />

Date of incident : 17/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Hulibele Suresh was a social worker. On 17 June, 2008, an auto driver, Rajappa had expired<br />

after consuming liquor. The victim Hulibele Suresh along with others had complained at Bangarpet<br />

Police Station. But the Excise police were negligent and did not take measures against the complaint.<br />

The police have received bribe from the liquor sellers and have not taken measures against them. The<br />

people have picketed in the road and the Deputy Superintendent of Police had assured to take measures.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

42<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-71/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishnappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Chandrappa, SI,Gownipalli Town PS<br />

Location : Gownipalli Town PS<br />

Date of incident : 09/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Krishnappa was a resident of Gownipalli village and he belonged to Madiga caste. The<br />

village consisted of the dominant Reddy caste and Dalit people. There was a clash between the Reddys<br />

and the Dalit, Madigas. The Reddy caste men have assaulted the Madigas. The police received bribe<br />

from the dominant castes and supported them. The police have also filed false case against 14 Madigas,<br />

including the victim Krishnappa. The people of the Madiga Organization have organized a Dharna<br />

against the Reddys. The police insulted their organization and involved in caste discrimination.<br />

FF Code : KAR/CHN/M-10/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Shriva Swamy, SI, East PS, Ramasamundora<br />

Location : East PS, Ramasamundora<br />

Date of incident : 16/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Kumar was a college student. The father of the victim had a land dispute with one Muddaiah<br />

of the same village. The victim’s father had approached the Court and the Court verdict was in favour of<br />

him. After few days, when the victim’s brother had gone to the field, the accused Muddaiah have<br />

threatened him and chased him out. On 16 February, 2008 the victim’s father had gone to East Police<br />

Station to give a complaint. In spite of producing the Court order, the Si had supported the accused and<br />

trees from his field were cut down. When the victim had questioned the police, he was taken to the<br />

outskirts of the town and beaten brutally.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-67/08<br />

Victim(s) : Anjappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Kariyappa, CI, Bangarpet PS<br />

Location : Bangarpet PS<br />

Date of incident : 21/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Anjappa was a resident of Murugal village and was a Dalit. On 21.01.2008 the victim’s<br />

daughter who was 16 years old had gone to fetch drinking water. Then three forest officers have<br />

knocked her unconscious and have raped her. She had reported it to her parents. Then the victim and<br />

his daughter have gone to Bangarpet Police Station to lodge a complaint. The Circle Inspector had<br />

refused to file the case after receiving bribe from the accused. Taking advantage, the accused have<br />

threatened to burn the victim’s daughter. Later the victim Anjappa and his daughter have approached the<br />

SP. In presence of the SP, the CI had got her complaint.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

43<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOD/PT/M-08/08<br />

Victim(s) : Subbegowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Gowtham 2) FO<br />

Location : Arepalya village, Kollegal<br />

Date of incident : 20/12/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Subbegowda, aged 50 is a resident of Arepalya village under Kollegal Taluk. The victim is<br />

married and has two children. Subbegowda is a tenant in the agricultural land owned by Umesh Babu.<br />

On 20 December 2007 an elephant was found dead in the village and the forest authorities being bribed<br />

by the wealthy land owner Gowtham failed to investigate the matter. Instead they registered a case<br />

against the owners of the nearing plots including Subbegowda. The victim gained news of this from the<br />

local papers. He applied for bail from the local court but was rejected. He appealed to the High Court and<br />

is waiting for the order. Till then Subbegowda is living in hiding in fear of the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-35/08<br />

Victim(s) : Fakeeravva<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Ramesh Hoogar, PSI, Guthala PS<br />

Location : Guthala PS<br />

Date of incident : 12/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Fakeeravva was a resident of Srirahalli Taluk. On 28 March, 2008, she had gone to<br />

purchase clothes at a store with her daughter. Then her two year daughter who had gone out was found<br />

missing. The victim had searched for daughter everywhere, but she was able to locate her. Later she<br />

had given a complaint at Guthala Police Station. The police were negligent and after 15 days, the victim<br />

had gone to the police station to know if they have found any clues. But the police blamed her for loosing<br />

the child and chased her out.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/PT/M-48/07<br />

Victim(s) : Gavi Rangaiah<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Sidappa; 2) Police<br />

Location : Bellur Village, Mandya<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Gavi Rangaiah, aged 41 is a farmer residing in Bellur village under Nagamangala Taluk. The<br />

victim is educated up to PUC is practices seasonal agriculture. He is married to Ratnamma and has two<br />

sons and a daughter, all of whom are studying in 7 th Standard, 2 nd Standard and 5 th Standard respectively.<br />

Gavi Rangaiah belongs to the Scheduled Caste community. There was a land dispute between the<br />

victim and Sidappa of Thavareker belonging to Vokkaliga community. In Mandya district the atrocity on<br />

the SC/ST community is more. The upper caste people prevail over the SC/ST by creating a division<br />

among them. The police also neglect taking proper action upon the complaints of these people. In the<br />

case of Gavi, Sidappa was frequently disturbing the victim not allowing him to cultivate his own land. Gavi<br />

approached Bellur Cross Police Station but his pleas went unanswered despite frequent requisitions.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

44<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-25/08<br />

Victim(s) : Giridavva<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Ramesh Kamble, PSI, Halageri PS<br />

Location : Halageri PS<br />

Date of incident : 09/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Giridavva was a resident of Ranebennur. On 9 March, 2008 when she was sleeping alone<br />

in her house, her neighbour Suresh had entered into her violently. He had snatched her sari and raped<br />

her. But Suresh had announced the villagers that the victim herself had invited him to her house and she<br />

had snatched Rs 8000 from him. Later the victim had informed the village heads but it was in vain. The<br />

next day, she had given a complaint to the police. But the police have remained inactive. The culprit had<br />

absconded due to negligence of the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-17/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Glory; 2 )Anandam<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Rangama Naidu; 2) Police<br />

Location : Telugu School Out House, Marikuppam<br />

Date of incident : 27/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Glory (40), W/o Anandam is a resident of Telugu School Out-House under Marikuppam. The<br />

victim belongs to the Madiga community and is working as the attendant in the school. Glory resides in<br />

the house allotted by BGML Company, to which belongs the school. She has been residing here for the<br />

past twenty years. Since three years Rangama Naidu, the Head Master of the school began to disturb<br />

the family of the victim, demanding of them to vacate the house, for he considered Glory and her family<br />

as a disturbance to his illegal contact with cook Vasanthi. On 15 February 2008 he organized a dharna<br />

in front of the victim’s house with the help of the students demanding to vacate the house. Again on 27<br />

February 2008 when everybody were away from the house the head master set Glory’s house on fire.<br />

Though the matter was immediately informed to the police they asked to submit a written complaint and<br />

put the matter under rest. Still the head master and the cook are found roaming about freely. The victim<br />

is not interested to lodge complaints against the indifferent attitude of the police for she feels that her family<br />

needs their help.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-44/08<br />

Victim(s) : Hanumanthappa Pujara<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police, Ranebennur Rural PS<br />

Location : Ranebennur Rural PS<br />

Date of incident : 10/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Hanumanthappa Pujara was a resident of Ranebenur. The Gram Panchayat had sanctioned<br />

her permission to construct a house under ASHRAYA scheme. Accordingly, on 10 April, 2008, when<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

45<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


the victim Hanumanthappa Pujara had gone to the land to construct the house, his relatives stopped him.<br />

The relatives of the victim have abused him and sent him away. Previously, the case of the site was at<br />

the Court and the verdict was in favour of the victim. The victim Hanumanthappa Pujara had gone to the<br />

Ranebennur Rural Police Station to lodge a complaint. The police have abused him abruptly and<br />

refused to get his complaint. Later the victim had got a letter from the Thasildar with the help of DHRM and<br />

then his case was registered.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-12/08<br />

Victim(s) : Jagadish<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Krishna Reddy; 2) Narasimhamurthy, HC<br />

Location : Kambalapalli, Chinthamani<br />

Date of incident : 11/02/2008, 13/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Jagadish is a resident of Mini Kambalapalli, and belongs to the Adi Dravidar community. The<br />

victim is a Dalit activist, who engaged himself in strengthening the Dalit people with regard to Kambalapalli<br />

Incident, along with activists of DSS and CPI. The case in the session’s court favoured the Reddy<br />

community, owing to which Jagadish was actively involved in fighting against the injustice. The Reddy<br />

community was somehow trying to suppress the victim. Krishna Reddy, an accused in this case and<br />

many other accused were trying to abduct and murder Jagadish. On 11 February 2008 and 13<br />

February 2008 few strange people were found roaming around the house of the victim. Jagadish<br />

informed the matter to the police and HC Narasimhamurthy was send to the place for security purpose.<br />

But the HC began to abuse the victim and his mother. He addressed Jagadish’s mother as a bastard.<br />

Thereafter the police also joined hands with the real culprits and threatened the victim not to involve in the<br />

case. Now Jagadish is left helpless without police protection.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

46<br />

FF Code : KAR/ KOL/M-66/08<br />

Victim(s) : Jayakanth<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Ramesh, SI, BEML Nagar PS<br />

Location : BEML Nagar PS<br />

Date of incident : 12/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Jayakanth was the wife of Devendra. In 2005, few thieves have entered into her house in<br />

absence of her husband. They have struck on her head and she had become unconscious. The next<br />

day, she had given a compliant at Robertson Police Station. But the police have not taken any measures.<br />

Again on 12 June, 2008 few thieves have entered into her house and have taken the utensils and other<br />

articles. The next day, she had again given a complaint at BEML Nagar Police Station. But the police<br />

have not taken any measures.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-32/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kanchanamma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Mani 2) SI<br />

Location : Champion Reef PS, KGF<br />

Date of incident : 16/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Kanchanamma, aged 61 is a resident of Oorgaum. The victim is a widow and has no sons. Her<br />

elder daughter is married to Mani, who owns a vulcanizing shop in front of KGF Court. Kanchanamma<br />

is working as a peon in Seventh Day Adventist School at Robertson Pet. This Mani cheated the victim<br />

by getting her signature in her husband’s death certificate and thereafter began to sell her deceased<br />

husband’s property. Having gained knowledge of the illegal activity of her son-in-law Kanchanamma<br />

filed a case at Chennai with the help of the school principal wherein she was working. Mani began to<br />

harass the victim to withdraw the complaint under the threat of torturing her daughter. On 16 th March<br />

2008 Kanchanamma again lodged a complaint at Champion Reef Police Station. But the police were<br />

convincing the victim to settle the issue at the family level. Following this the Principal spoke with the SI,<br />

and after the intervention of a human rights organization the SI filed the FIR and handed it over to the<br />

victim.<br />

FF Code<br />

Victim(s)<br />

Perpetrator(s)<br />

Location<br />

Case Details:<br />

: KAR/KOL/M-05/08<br />

: Kodanda Pani<br />

: SI<br />

: Oorgaum PS, KGF<br />

Victim Kodanda Pani, aged 53 is a social worker and an Ambedkarist residing in Oriental line under<br />

KGF. The victim belongs to the Scheduled Caste community. Kodanda released audio cassettes and<br />

CDs to propagate Dr. Ambedkar’s Ideology, and the function was inaugurated by ADGP Subhas<br />

Bharani, IPS. The victim also runs a general stores department and a STD Booth. Many BGML<br />

employees had credit account in the store. One such customer refused to pay any credit and threatened<br />

Kodanda with the help of a local rowdy. The victim approached Oorgaum Police Station but the police<br />

refused to register the complaint and began to abuse him if he was a VIP. Kodanda then requested the<br />

IPS, who in turn spoke with the SI of Oorgaum Police Station to consider the case but in vain, for the local<br />

rowdy had political influence. Instead the SI filed 107 cases against Kodanda and his family members<br />

including the children. Later on Kodanda received bail from the court. But the victim states that the police<br />

caused him and his family lot of mental pressure, and he is unable to eat and sleep, thereby leading a<br />

life of fear each and every day. Even in this condition Kodanda is not ready to pursue case against the<br />

police for he fears they might spoil his sons education.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

47<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-01/08<br />

Victim(s) : Sowmya<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Mulbagal Road<br />

Date of incident : 02/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Krishnappa, aged 40 is a DSS Convener residing in Srinivas Pura. On 2 April 2008 he received a<br />

phone call from his friend Narasimha, asking him to come to the bus stand. Krishnappa went accordingly<br />

and there he found a girl named Sowmya. She was a student of Srinivas Pura Government High<br />

School. The head master enticed the victim to come with him assuring to give her the SSLC Mathematics<br />

Examination Question Paper to be held the next day. Sowmya too went with him in his motor bike. But<br />

the head master took her to a forest in Mulbagal Road and tried to rape her. The girl managed to escape<br />

and fell in the hands of Narasimha, who in turn brought her to Krishnappa. Now both the friends and the<br />

victim went to the police station but the officer on duty asked the parents of the girl to lodge complaint, and<br />

refused to file the same. Then Krishnappa informed the matter to the press, following which he went to the<br />

girl’s parents. But they were not interested in pursuing the case thinking it would spoil their daughter’s<br />

reputation.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

48<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-11/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) (Late) Rajanna; 2) Kubedrappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Anitha Ramamurthy; 2) Police<br />

Location : Chinthamani Rural PS<br />

Date of incident : 05/10/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Kubendrappa, aged 35 is a resident of Madaba Halli village under Chinthamani Taluk. On 5<br />

October 2007, Rajanna, the brother of the victim was murdered by Anitha Ramamurthy. This Anitha had<br />

illegal contacts with Rajanna. He died after having food in Anitha’s house and his body was found near<br />

the house. She added poison in his food and killed him. The same day Kubedrappa lodged complaints<br />

against Anitha at Chinthamani Rural Police Station but the police didn’t take any action. The post mortem<br />

report also affirmed that Rajanna was poisoned to death. Following this the victim and many other people<br />

organized a dharna in front of the Dy.S.P Office. The APMC members, the Ex-Panchayat President<br />

and many others participated in the dharna. The Dy.S.P received the memorandum and assured that<br />

the accused would be arrested but so far no action has followed. So the victim and his associates are<br />

demanding the case to be referred to the CID. This is a common thing in this Taluk states the victim, for<br />

many such cases have gone un-answered.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-48/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Kumaran; 2) (Late) Geetha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Doctors; 2) Police<br />

Location : Ganesh Maternity Hospital, Robertson Pet<br />

Date of incident : 04/11/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Kumaran, aged 36 is a resident of Marikuppam and works as a daily wage labourer at a<br />

company in Bangalore. On 04.11.2007 Geetha, W/o Kumaran was admitted in Ganesh Maternity<br />

Hospital at Robertson Pet for her first delivery. Dr. Loganayagie assured that it would be normal delivery<br />

but the doctors conducted cesarean, and she delivered a baby boy. When applying oxygen it was noted<br />

that the cylinder was empty. The victim and the doctor rushed to a nearest hospital and brought another<br />

cylinder. In the meantime Geetha passed away. The doctor said she would compensate for her death,<br />

and requested not to create any agitation in the hospital. Kumaran approached Vimochana Woman’s<br />

Association but they referred him to the branch at Kolar. The matter was also reported to Robertson Pet<br />

PS and the D.S.P, but they took no action. The news was published in the local newspaper too.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-65/08<br />

Victim(s) : Madivanan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Gangamma Playa, Bangarpet<br />

Date of incident : 20/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Madivanan, aged 50 is a resident of Gangamma Playa village under Bangarpet Taluk. The<br />

victim is a social worker and also a convener of DSS Ambedkar Wada. Most of the villagers are<br />

coolies, the result of which the sale of illicit liquor is more in this area. The police also allow it as they get<br />

bribe from the sellers. On 20 May 2008 two persons died after consuming poisonous arrack. The<br />

bodies were buried in a hurry. Initially the police denied accepting that the deaths were due to liquor<br />

consumption from unauthorized sellers. Madivanan and his associates organized a dharna and protested<br />

against the police. Finally SP Shiva Kumar and DySP Kudichi came and declared that the deaths were<br />

due to the consumption of illicit liquor. The victim states if they had kept silent about the incident the police<br />

would have registered it as a natural death. Thereafter the deaths of Gowramma, Pusaraj, MGR and<br />

Gandhi were also registered as deaths due consumption of illicit liquor.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-65/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Madivanan; 2) Rajanna<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Vivekanand, CI, Bangarpet PS<br />

Location : Bangarpet PS<br />

Date of incident : 20/05/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

49<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Case Details:<br />

The victims Madivanan and Rajana were residents of Gangamma Palya and they were social workers.<br />

The sale of illicit liquor was active in their area. Though the people have given several complaints to the<br />

police, the police remained inactive after receiving bribe from the sellers. On 20 th May, 2008, two men<br />

have expired on consumption of liquor. The victims Madivanan and Rajana along with the people of that<br />

area have organized a protest against police inaction over the deaths. Later the SP has visited the spot<br />

and has registered a case mentioning that the deaths have occurred due to consumption of illicit liquor.<br />

FF Code : KAR/CHN/M-19/08<br />

Victim(s) : Raju<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Mahesh<br />

Location : Bheemanabedy Vilage, Chamarajanagara<br />

Date of incident : 04/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Mahadevamma, is the w/o late Raju residing at Bheemanabedy Vilage, located in, Chamarajanagara<br />

District. She was married to Raju 9 years ago. Her husband Raju was not in good terms with his<br />

neighbor named Mahesh. Mahesh used to criticize and tease Mahadevamma . She had taken this to<br />

the notice of her husband. Later the matter was solved by the panchayat. However Mahesh continued<br />

to disturb Mahadevamma On 04 May 2008 one Muddashetty took Raju to the field. Later Raju never<br />

turned up. Mahadevamma discovered that her husband was murdered by Mahesh near National<br />

Highway at Gundlupete. Mahadevamma had informed the incident to the police. Later Mahadevamma<br />

filed a complaint against the perpetrators to the police. Mahesh and the other abettors were arrested but<br />

they were released without proper investigation. Mahadevamma and her relatives approached the<br />

D.S.P. The D.S.P directed them to the SP. The SP had ordered to take appropriate action but in vain.<br />

The culprits were disturbing and threatening mahadevamma and her relatives for having lodged complaint<br />

against them. The police had never taken steps either to ensure their safety or to arrest the culprits.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-47/08<br />

Victim(s) : Maheswari<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Selvaraj 2) Police<br />

Location : Robertson Pet<br />

Date of incident : 10/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Maheswari, aged 33 is a resident of Oorgaum Pet. The victim had been living in her aunt’s<br />

house, where she fell in love with Selvaraj, who dwelled in the opposite house. Both got married without<br />

the knowledge of Maheswari’s guardian on 7 May 1998. In 2001 they were blessed with a baby boy and<br />

named him Solomonraj. Later Maheswari’s parents gave her money and gold ornaments. After few<br />

days Selvaraj went Mysore and returned only after a week or ten days. The victim then came to know<br />

that he was a popular thud and was already married. Despite this fact Maheswari compromised to stay<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

50<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


with him and begat a girl baby too. But Selvaraj would go to Mysore and come only after a month. Till<br />

then the victim was left to starve. He also began to suspect Maheswari and tortured her. On 10 March<br />

2008, he assaulted the victim severely that she managed to escape from his clutches. Finally Maheswari<br />

lodged complaints at Robertson Pet Police Station but the case was referred to the Police Woman<br />

Helpline. The lady police summoned the couple for investigation. Selvaraj was under the influence of<br />

alcohol and the police asked them to solve the case among themselves. Maheswari states that the<br />

police are bribed by her husband and hence they are negligent in taking action.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-59 /08<br />

Victim(s) : Muni Raj<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Excise Officials 2) Police<br />

Location : Bile Narasapura, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : May 2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Muni Raj, aged 48 is a DSS activist residing in Bile Narasapura village under Kolar Taluk. After<br />

knowing that 19 people died due to the consumption of illicit liquor the victim and other activists picketed<br />

on NH4.The activists also carried the dead bodies in tractors to organize a dharna against the excise<br />

department and the police.The people who had expired belonged to the Scheduled Caste community<br />

and worked as coolies.All of them had the habit of drinking.But the police and the excise department took<br />

no step to curb the preparation of illicit liquor.The police received bribe from the makers and allowed<br />

them to continue their business.The deaths took place due to the negligence of the police and the excise<br />

department.Protest is only way that such innocent deaths can be avoided is the statement of Muni Raj.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

51<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-54/08<br />

Victim(s) : Devikunte Srinivas<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Amar; 2) Arjun; 3) Krishna Reddy; 4) Rama Linga Reddy;<br />

5) Raja Reddy; 6) Police<br />

Location : China Kayala Palli, Bage Palli<br />

Date of incident : 11/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Devikunte Srinivas is a resident of Chinna Kayala Palli village falling under the jurisdiction of<br />

Bagepalli Police Station. The above mentioned perpetrators threatened the victim with regard to a land<br />

dispute. On 11 May 2008 they assaulted Srinivas, owing to which the victim approached Munivenkatappa,<br />

who was a SFI activist and also a member of the CPI. On 20 May 2008 Srinivas and the Ex. Zilla<br />

Panchayat member organized a dharna under the leadership of Munivenkatappa in front of Bagepalli<br />

Police Station. Even after the dharna the police have not taken any action against the accused. It is<br />

alleged that the police are bribed by the perpetrators not to take any action against them.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-19/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ravi P.M<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Darshan; 2) Papanna; 3) Ravi; 4) Police<br />

Location : Karkalli, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 03/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Ravi P.M, aged 18 is a resident of Karkalli under Somwarpete Taluk. The victim has studied upto<br />

7 th Standard and is working as a coolie. On 3 rd February 2008 Ravi was <strong>watch</strong>ing cricket match at<br />

home. Suddenly Darshan, Papanna and Ravi barged into the house of the victim and assaulted him with<br />

a coconut on his back and stomach; and pulled him out of the house. By then Ravi’s brother returned<br />

from a marriage he had attended and tried to protect his brother, but he too was beaten up. The<br />

perpetrators inquired the victim about one Venkappa and when Ravi denied knowledge of the same they<br />

left the place. The victim states that those persons had assaulted him owing to some previous grudge.<br />

Ravi then got admitted at Somwarpete Hospital and later police came and took his statement. But till date<br />

they have not taken any action against the accused. Moreover the police have helped the perpetrators<br />

to avail bail. Ravi states that the police have denied him justice all because of BJP Politics, the result of<br />

which the accused are threatening the victim.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

52<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-18/08<br />

Victim(s) : Parameshwara<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Harish, Mandappa<br />

Location : Madikeri<br />

Date of incident : 16/07/2008<br />

Case details:<br />

Parameshwara aged 66 resides at Kattemadu paisari located in Madikeri taluk. On 16 July 2008<br />

around 7 o’clock in the morning few strangers fired at Parameshwara while he was on his way to the<br />

temple. Parameshwara sustained severe injuries in his abdomen and fell to the ground. The strangers<br />

who shot him were Harish and Mandappa. They had shot him by accident while aiming to shoot a dog.<br />

Harish and Mandappa rushed Parameshwara to a hospital at Mangalore the doctor refused to give<br />

treatment. Later he was taken to Madikeri hospital. The doctor struggled to take out the bullets that<br />

pierced through Parameshwar’s abdomen. Harish and Mandappa bore the medical expenses of<br />

Parameshwar. Parameshwar’s daughther and son in law went to the police station to lodge a complaint<br />

against Harish and Mandappa but the police refused to take the complaint under the pretext that the<br />

perpetrators had agreed to bear the medical expenses of Parameshwara.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-26/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Priya; 2) (Late) Selvam (a) Naryana<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Kumaresh; 2) Vivekanand, CI<br />

Location : Oorgaum, KGF<br />

Date of incident : 08/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Priya (25), W/o (Late) Selvam is a resident of Oorgaum. The victim belongs to the Adi Dravidar<br />

community. Her husband is an auto driver. On 8 March 2008 Selvam came home along with his friends<br />

for coffee and left within few minutes. After few hours Priya received news that her husband was lying<br />

injured at a marriage hall. She went to the place and found him dead. There was a deep injury on the<br />

back of his head. Immediately Priya lodged a complaint at Oorgaum Police Station and gave the name<br />

of the persons who had accompanied him as suspects. Thereafter Kumaresh, one of the friends was<br />

traced at Thirupathi and it came to light that he had assaulted Selvam on his head during a scuffle using<br />

a stone. Kumaresh was arrested but released the very next day. It is alleged that CI Vivekanand<br />

received bribe from the accused and released him. Following this the family of the deceased protested<br />

on Ambedkar Road, placing the dead body. Inspector Puttamadaiah came to the spot and assured to<br />

take action. In the meantime Kumaresh surrendered before the JM Court and KGF Police took him into<br />

custody. The police knew all the real facts regarding the murder of Selvam but released the real culprit<br />

having received bribe. So the protest was widely published throughout the city and owing to the wide<br />

propaganda the CI and the politicians had planned to surrender the accused in the court.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-36/08<br />

Victim(s) : R.A.Belavatti<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Hanagal, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 30/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Belavatti, aged 25 is a resident of Hanagal under Haveri district. The victim is the president of<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong> Rakshana Vedike in his area. On 30 March 2008 Belavatti had a fight with his uncles over a<br />

property issue. When the victim approached the police they just registered the case and closed it as a<br />

case of B value, meaning there are no sufficient evidences to take action. Belavatti also approached<br />

Hanumantha Bandi, District President of <strong>Karnataka</strong> Rakshana Vedike and awaits justice in this matter<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-07/08<br />

Victim(s) : Raju<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Anil; 2) Shivaram; 3) Shankar; 4) SI<br />

Location : Shivalli, Mandya<br />

Date of incident : 15/01/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

53<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Case Details:<br />

Victim Raju, aged 45 is a resident of Shivalli under Mandya Taluk. The victim is married to Sunita and<br />

has a son and a daughter. He is a coolie and at times sold milk to manage his family needs. Due to<br />

uninterrupted worked Raju couldn’t shift the cow dung in front of his house, over which his neighbours<br />

often fought. On a particular day Anil, the son of Raju’s neighbour and his cousins Shivaram and<br />

Shankar assaulted the victim with a wooden stick. When Raju went to the police station the officials didn’t<br />

bother to take action. The SI was in favour of the culprits. The matter was then taken to the panchayat,<br />

where also the victim didn’t get justice. On 15 January 2008 Raju was again assaulted by the perpetrators.<br />

He once again went to the police station but he was driven away by the SI and threatened to be arrested.<br />

Raju has lost all his hopes on the police, but he desires justice in this matter.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-39/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ramu<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Somanna<br />

Location : Manjamara, Virajapete Taluk<br />

Date of incident : 27/04/2008<br />

Case Details<br />

Ramu aged 35 resides at Manjamara in Virajapete Tq with his wife Lakshmi and son Raju. He is a<br />

collie. On 27 April 2008 while he was resting, a person by name Somanna shot Ramu on his leg and<br />

abused him verbally. He called him by filthy words and abused his caste. Later Ramu was taken to the<br />

hospital. The doctors refused to give proper treatment. When Ramu took the matter to the police they<br />

failed to act positively instead abused him verbally.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/PT/M-38/08<br />

Victim(s) : Rashmi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Vinoth<br />

Location : TN Pura taluk, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 15/02/2008<br />

Case Details<br />

Rashmi, aged 18 resides at Dodda Mulagudu Grama, TN Pura taluk in Mysore district. A year back<br />

she was induced by a man named Vinodh and became pregnant. He promised to marry her. But later<br />

he failed to marry her. She filed a complaint against Vinoth with the T. Narasipura police station on 15<br />

February 2008. But the police have not taken any legal action against the accused. The police have a<br />

cordial relationship with the relatives of the accused and making all attempts to close the case. The police<br />

failed to take action under the pretext that he was absconding.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

54<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-14/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ravi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Dasappa 2) Police<br />

Location : Thorenoo village, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 30/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Ravi, aged 21 resides in Thorenoo village under Somwarpete Taluk along with his parents. On<br />

30 January 2008 Dasappa, the victim’s uncle filed a complaint at Kushalnagar Police Station against<br />

Ravi and his father stating that they threatened to murder him. There was a property clash between the<br />

family of the victim and his uncle, and the court order fell in favour of Ravi. Dasappa planned a plot against<br />

Ravi and his family with the help of the police so as to acquire the property. Dasappa also abused the<br />

victims with filthy words and threatened to murder them. When Ravi went to lodge complaints regarding<br />

this he was driven away. The victim availed an anticipatory bail on 23 February 2008, and seeks justice<br />

in this case.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-15/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) (Late) Sandeep; 2) Lakshman<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Murali; 2) Dinesh; 3) Police; 4) Purushottam<br />

Location : Kambi Bane village, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 22/07/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Lakshman is a resident of Kambi Bane village under Somwarpete Taluk. The victim’s son<br />

Sandeep had a small brawl with Dinesh, S/o Murali on 22 July 2007. The latter and his father beat up<br />

Sandeep severely. Sandeep was found missing after this incident and when Lakshman searched for<br />

him he was found dead. When the victim filed a complaint at the station the police made no efforts to trace<br />

the real culprit and instead harassed Lakshman and his wife, accusing them of killing their own son.<br />

Though the victim gave names of few suspects the police took no step to arrest them. Therefore on 7<br />

September 2007 a protest was organized in front of the DC’s Office with the help of <strong>Karnataka</strong> Raita<br />

Sangha and few other organizations. A memorandum was also submitted before the SP of Kodagu and<br />

a deadline of 15 days was given to trace the real culprits, but so far they received no support from the<br />

police. The second day after the death of Sandeep, a man named Purushottam came to Lakshman and<br />

warned him not to lodge complaints with the police. The victim therefore urges stringent action against the<br />

police for harassing them, and also punish Murali and his son Dinesh for murdering his son.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-07/08<br />

Victim(s) : V. Satisha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Byadagi<br />

Date of Incident : 12/02/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

55<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Case Details:<br />

Victim V. Satisha, aged 38 is working as KSRTC Depot Manager for the past six years in Byadagi. The<br />

troubles from the private vehicle operators are common in the bus depot. Very often the private operators<br />

break the glass of government buses and assault the staff of NWKSRTC buses. Complaining to the<br />

police yielded no result, for they received heavy bribe from the accused. Satisha also suffered in the<br />

hands of the miscreants who assaulted him brutally. Despite intimations to the police they took no action.<br />

For the past one year 23 cases have been reported to the police but they have not taken any action. The<br />

KSRTC staffs are worried about the activities of the miscreants and the indifferent attitude of the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-44/08<br />

Victim(s) : Seetha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Robertson Pet, Oorgaum<br />

Date of incident : 07/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Seetha, aged 18 is a resident of 2 nd Block KGF under Robertson Pet. The victim was in love with<br />

Rajesh, a resident of the same village. Both of them eloped on 25 March 2008 and got married in a<br />

temple at Oorgaum Pet the next day. They stayed in a friend’s house at Bangalore and returned to KGF<br />

on 6 April 2008. The next day Seetha and Rajesh went to the latter’s house but Rajesh’s family<br />

members didn’t accept them. On 7 April 2008 Seetha lodged complaints against the family members of<br />

Rajesh at Robertson Pet Police Station but the police refused to file an FIR. So the victim organized a<br />

dharna in front of Rajesh’s house with the help of her well-wishers criticizing the police inaction. The next<br />

day Rajesh’s parents produced their son in the police station. CI Puttamadiah called the panchayat<br />

members and convinced his parents. After this the bride and groom were entrusted in the hands of the<br />

panchayat, and they were married again in the presence of the panchayat. Due to this action of the police<br />

Seetha is not interested in pursuing action against them.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-37/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shivanna<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Security Guard; 2) DC<br />

Location : DC Office, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 26/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Shivanna is a physically challenged person residing in Angavikalara Vokkuta under Kolar<br />

district. The victim is a convener in Angavikalara Vokkuta Organization. The victim and other handicapped<br />

people were facing a number of problems every day regarding which they approached the DC Office so<br />

as to submit their demands. But the Security Guard never allowed them to meet the Official. The<br />

politicians who came in cars were allowed to go inside the gate. Thus on 26 March 2008 these people<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

56<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


organized a dharna in front of the DC Office against the guard. This dharna was supported by the<br />

people’s movements and handicapped association, claiming equal, valuable and useful training for the<br />

handicapped by the government. A number of handicapped women who couldn’t walk also participated<br />

in the dharna. They demanded that the security should allow them inside or the DC should come<br />

outside. When their pleas went un-answered the victims forced themselves inside but the huge gate was<br />

closed. Finally the DC came out and inquired in a harsh tone. He just received the petition for the sake<br />

of getting it.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-05/08<br />

Victim(s) : Siddlingamma Angadi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) DC 2) MLA<br />

Location : Sangur, Hanagal<br />

Date of incident : 18/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Siddlingamma Angadi, aged 40 is a resident of Sangur. The victim’s husband is an employee in<br />

a sugar factory where all the workers received no payment for the past 20 months. Last year all the male<br />

workers made a strike but in vain, and complaints were also lodged against them. Later on the women<br />

from Sree Shakti Committee started to protest and they crossed 70 odd days in protest. Nobody cared<br />

to look at the victim and his associates while they were admitted in the hospital during the strike. All the<br />

workers and women made a protest at the DC’s Office. Though they were on a hunger strike the DC<br />

never bothered and ordered the SP to arrest all the 300 women participants. A police constable laid<br />

hands on Siddlingamma but she resisted. The influence of the MLA was strong in this case, and that’s<br />

the reason for the negligence of the police. But the victim and her associates strongly state that they will<br />

continue fighting till their husbands get the PF, and net salary due to them. Sree Shakti Group had<br />

planned a protest before the Rajabhavan in Bangalore and Siddlingamma Angadi seeks the help of<br />

human rights organization in this endeavor.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-45/2008<br />

Victim(s) : Somanna<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Bill collector<br />

Location : Doddebagilu Grama, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 11/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Somanna aged 40 resides at Doddebagilu grama in the district of Mysore. He is a farmer. He had paid<br />

water bill for getting water connection for his house. On 11-04-08 he had gone to the bill collector asking<br />

for the receipt of his payment. The bill collector abused him verbally and filed a fake complaint at the<br />

police station. Somanan went to the police station to file a complaint against the perpetrator but the police<br />

refused to take his complaint instead Somanna was abused and threatened by the police.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

57<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-35/08<br />

Victim(s) : Somesha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) George; 2) Siddapura Narasimha; 3) Police<br />

Location : Gowribidanure<br />

Date of incident : 07/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Somesha (22), S/o Aswathappa is a resident of Gowribidanure. The victim belongs to the<br />

Scheduled Caste community. Somesha’s father is a lorry driver, who worked under George. On 2<br />

February 2008 Aswathappa took the Zinger Road to Hubli. While returning he had loaded potatoes from<br />

Hyderabad to Chikkabalapur. This matter was informed to the family members by cleaner Siddapura<br />

Narasimha. But Aswathappa never returned home. Somesha inquired with the owner who stated that<br />

his father had received the salary on 7 February 2008 and left. Narasimha too said the same thing. Then<br />

Somesha gave an oral complaint at Gowribidanure Police Station on 18 February 2008 requesting the<br />

police to inquire the lorry driver and the cleaner but the police remained silent for they had been bribed<br />

by the accused. Even after Somesha submitted a written complaint the police didn’t take any action.<br />

When they were repeatedly pestered the police stated that Aswathappa might have been heavily drunk<br />

and roaming somewhere. They also insulted and threatened Somesha, and drove him away. Finally on<br />

10 March 2008 the victim met some media personnel and got this eviction published.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-43/2008<br />

Victim(s) : Sudha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Hosavaranalli Village, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : January 2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Sudha aged 28 resided at Hosavaranalli located at Hunsur Tq, in the district of Mysore. She was given<br />

in marriage to Kumar in 2007. Sudha was found missing and later it was found that she had died.<br />

Sudha’s husband had filed a complaint in the police station and the post mortem report revealed that she<br />

was raped and murdered. 3 months had elapsed since the complainant filed the complaint but the police<br />

are reluctant in taking appropriate action. It is suspected that incidents of this sort were common in<br />

Hosavaranchi village and the perpetrators involved were people having strong political background and<br />

they were protected by the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-22/08<br />

Victim(s) : T.C. Dharmappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Erappa; 2) Police<br />

Location : Tholuru village, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 13/02/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

58<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Case Details:<br />

Victim T.C. Dharmappa, aged 42 is a resident of Tholuru village under Somwarpete Taluk. The victim<br />

is an illiterate, belonging to the Scheduled Caste community; and works as a coolie. On 13 th February<br />

2008 when Dharmappa was at home, a villager named Erappa barged into his house and began<br />

abusing him. He also demanded money from Dharmappa showing a notice from Aiyappa Swamy<br />

Trust of Hassan district. The victim is a physically handicapped person and fears of being assaulted by<br />

this Erappa. Hence he lodged a complaint at the police station, but the police were negligent and didn’t<br />

take any action. Dharmappa feels insecure without police protection and in course of time he has<br />

developed a sense of fear and depression.<br />

FF Code : KAR/CHA/PT/M-06/08<br />

Victim(s) : Umesh Babu<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Goutham; 2) FO<br />

Location : Kollegal<br />

Date of incident : 20/12/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Umesh Babu, aged 37 is a resident of Kollegal under Chamrajnagar district. The victim is<br />

married and has two children. Umesh is a businessman by profession. On 20 December 2007 two<br />

elephants died under suspicious circumstances in the Arepalya area, where the field of the victim is<br />

located. The forest officials, without making a proper inquiry registered a false case against Umesh and<br />

many others. The victim gained news of this from the local newspaper, for his name appeared in the<br />

accused list. The neighbouring plot next to that of Umesh’s belongs to that of Goutham, a wealthy man<br />

in the locality. He had put up electric fencing around his field to keep away wild animals. He had acquired<br />

some government ponds which he had refilled with water and added salt. A lot of wild animals were<br />

attracted by the taste and came to these ponds. There are also suspicions among villagers that Goutham<br />

smuggles Deer meat to Bangalore and that the forest officials are also involved. That’s the reason the<br />

officials ignored his name in the list of accusers. The bail application of Umesh was rejected by the local<br />

court; hence he is living in hiding. Appealing at the High Court is very expensive and is a financial burden<br />

to the victim.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-18/08<br />

Victim(s) : Elangovan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Aravindan; 2) Lokesh; 3) Vijay; 4) Basha, SI<br />

Location : Coromandal, KGF<br />

Date of incident : 23/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Elangovan (16), S/o Dhanapal (a) Kuppaswamy – Vasagi is a resident of Coromandel Post<br />

under KGF city. The victim belongs to the Scheduled Caste community. On 23 February 2008, Elangovan<br />

was playing cricket in the ground. At that time Aravindan, Lokesh and Vijay came to the victim. These<br />

boys were the sons of Elangovan’s neighbour, who had come from Chennai. They assaulted the victim<br />

using the cricket bat on his head causing severe bleeding. They had done this on a previous grudge,<br />

stating that the same day the previous year the victim and his father had assaulted them. The same boys<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

59<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


informed the matter to Elangovan’s parents and they rushed him to the hospital. Though complaints<br />

were lodged at Oorgaum Police Station, SI Basha denied taking action for the father of the accused was<br />

a politically influential person. He forced the family of the victim to compromise the case.<br />

FF Code : KAR/ KOL/M-69/08<br />

Victim(s) : Venkataramaih Shetty<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Ramesh, CI, Malure Town PS<br />

Location : Malure<br />

Date of incident<br />

Case Details:<br />

: 26/06/2008<br />

The victim Venkataramaih Shetty was a resident of Malure Town. He was a retail merchant. The area<br />

consisted of large number of tractor repairing workshops and spare part shops. There were frequent<br />

theft of the spare parts and machines in that area. Though the people have reported to the police, the<br />

police have remained inactive. The police have received bribe from the criminals and have neglected<br />

the complaints of the merchants. On 26.06.2008 the people of that locale have organized a protest<br />

against the inaction of police. The Deputy Superintendent had visited the spot and has assured to deploy<br />

patrol duty police to avoid theft.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-20/08<br />

Victim(s) : Venkatesh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Erappa, PC; 2) Shankaralingappa, PC; 3) Policemen<br />

Location : Barla Gadde Village, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 26/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Venkatesh, aged 36 resides in Barla Gadde village under Somwarpete Taluk. The victim belongs<br />

to the Dalit community. On 26.02.2008 an influential upper caste person of the village assaulted Venkatesh<br />

abusing him with his caste name. The victim was severely injured and thereafter admitted in Somwarpete<br />

GH. Later Venkatesh filed a complaint at the police station but the police ignored the complaint of the victim<br />

considering him as a Dalit and also abused him using his caste name. The above mentioned police<br />

constables abused him and supported the accused. Venkatesh states that he will surely protest against<br />

the police if they don’t render him protection and justice.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-26/08<br />

Victim(s) : Vinodhkumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police, Saraswathipuram PS<br />

Location : Saraswathipuram PS<br />

Date of incident : 21/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Vinodhkumar was a working as a sales manager at Cheverlet General Motors. On 21.02.2008<br />

his friends Sippin and Nanayya have assaulted him in drunken state. The victim Vinodhkumar had<br />

reported the incident to the Saraswathipuram police. As he had some urgent work, he had left to<br />

Bangalore. After three days, the victim had returned home. But the police have not taken any measures<br />

against the accused. Further, the accused have harassed him. So the victim Vinodhkumar has given<br />

a complaint to the Commissioner about the negligence of the police.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

60<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Annual Report on Torture<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

05-Police Intimidation<br />

61<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-15/08<br />

Victim(s) : Bhaskara<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Sudhakar Reddy, SI, Kalpet PS<br />

Location : Kalpet PS<br />

Date of incident : 04/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

On 4 February 2008, the victim Bhaskara had gone in his two-wheeler with his two friends, Paramesh<br />

and Manjunath. Then they were stopped by the Sub-Inspector of Kalpet Police Station. The police officer<br />

had abused all three of them with vulgar words. He had asked them for the documents and helmets. The<br />

victim Bhaskara had questioned him for abusing them instead of imposing a penalty. The Sub-Inspector<br />

was aggravated and he had slapped the victim. Soon people have gathered in the road. The victim<br />

Bhaskara was humiliated, as he was beaten in presence of his friends and public. Later the police had<br />

imposed a penalty of Rs 100 for violating traffic rules. The victim had paid the money and then he had left<br />

the spot.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-70/08<br />

Victim(s) : Devaraj<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Sampath Kumar, CI, Sidlaghatta PS<br />

Location : Sidlaghatta PS<br />

Date of incident : 03/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Devaraj was a resident of Devarapali village and he was a social worker. The landless and<br />

homeless people of Devarapalli have constructed huts at Gomala land and they have resided there for<br />

a long time. The Circle Inspector had gone there and had destroyed their huts. He had dragged the<br />

women out of the house in absence of the men. The Circle Inspector had also destroyed the board<br />

which contained the photo of the national leader, Dr. Ambedkar.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-61/08<br />

Victim(s) : Johnson<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Sivappa, Crime Police, Andersonpet PS<br />

Location : Andersonpet PS<br />

Date of incident : 12/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Johnson was a resident of Andersonpet and he was a coolie. Previously he was associated<br />

with ADMK Party and had committed many crimes. He has been to jail several times. Later he had<br />

reformed himself and had led a peaceful life with his family. But the police have included his name in the<br />

rowdies list and have tried to catch him under Preventive Detention Act in the elections. The victim had<br />

concealed himself to escape, from being arrested. The victim Johnson fears that he might again slip into<br />

the past life and become a rowdy again.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

62<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-74/08<br />

Victim(s) : Prasad<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Chandrappa, SI, Gownipalli Town PS<br />

Location : Gownipalli Town PS<br />

Date of incident : 07/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Prasad was Congress Party leader at Gownipalli Town. The SI of Gownipalli has acted as<br />

the agent of Janathadal Party and he did not respect the Congress men. On 7 June, 2008 the victim<br />

Prasad has gone to the police station, with reference to a cow theft. On seeing them, the Sub-Inspector<br />

had asked the constables to remove the chairs. The Sub-Inspector had made the victim and others to<br />

stand in front of him. At that time, the JDS officers had gone to the police station. The police officer had<br />

immediately arranged chairs for them. The victim and others were humiliated by the ill treatment of the<br />

Sub-Inspector.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-72/08<br />

Victim(s) : Raghunath Reddy<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Sampath Kumar, CI, Sitlakata PS<br />

Location : Sitlakata PS<br />

Date of incident : 18/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Raghunath Reddy was a resident of Devaramallure village. The Zilla Panchayat President<br />

and Secretary have looted the government property. The villagers have reported it to the police several<br />

times. But The Circle Inspector, Sampath Kumar had not taken any measures. So the victim had taken<br />

part in the protest along with the villagers. Instead of taking measures against the accused, the Circle<br />

Inspector has filed false complaint against the victim Raghunath Reddy and few others. Further one<br />

Venkatesh and his wife were assaulted by the Congress Party men and a complaint was made for the<br />

same. But the police have not taken any measures. The police have threatened the innocent villagers<br />

to file them under false cases.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-10/08<br />

Victim(s) : Peddanna<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Srinisvamurthy, CI, Mulbagal PS<br />

Location : Mulbagal PS<br />

Date of incident : 21/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Peddanna was a resident of Mulbagal Hobli and he was working as a coolie in the field of<br />

Chengalarayappa. The victim Peddanna had a daughter named Lakshmakka. The land owner’s son<br />

K.C. Narayana had illicit relationship with Lakshmakka and she had become pregnant. Then Lakshmakka<br />

had met Narayana to discuss about her pregnancy, but she was murdered for caste based reasons.<br />

According to the statement of the victim Peddanna, his daughter had fallen into the well accidentally. But<br />

the police have recorded that as a murder case.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

63<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/CHM/M-12/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shivakumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Somanna, ASI, Chamrajnagar Town PS<br />

Location : Chamrajnagar Town PS<br />

Date of incident : 15/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Shivakumar was a resident of Ramasamudra and he was worked in a granite company. He<br />

had driven TATA Sumo, eight times a day to buy materials for his company. On 15 February, 2008, the<br />

victim had driven his vehicle to the company. Two policemen have signaled him to stop. The road was<br />

busy and the victim was driving at high speed and so he could not stop. He had moved his vehicle to a<br />

little distance and then he had stopped. The two policemen were drunk and they have abused him with<br />

filthy words. The police have also beaten him and a crowd had gathered. The public gathered, have<br />

stopped the policemen from beating the victim. The victim Shivakumar had given a complaint against<br />

the concerned policemen. The next day, the two policemen have gone to the victim’s house and asked<br />

him sorry for beating him the previous day.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-13/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Fairoz Khan; 2) (Late) Fateh Khan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Mandya Sub Jail<br />

Date of incident : 24/01/2008, 10/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Fairoz Khan (30), S/o Fateh Khan is a resident of Guthalu under Mandya district. He is one<br />

among the eight children in the family. The victim’s father was arrested on 24 January 2008 by SI<br />

Deepak Kumar under suspicion of transporting sandal wood. Fateh Khan was kept in the police station<br />

for a whole day and later on remanded to judicial custody. Fairoz Khan met his father at Mandya Sub<br />

Jail, where he stated that he was arrested on a false allegation. On 10 February 2008 while the victim<br />

was in Mysore his father passed away at Mandya GH. This incident appeared in the local newspapers<br />

too. Fairoz admits that his father already had an attack. The jail authorities state that Fateh had a minor<br />

chest pain on 10 February 2008 and was immediately taken to the hospital, where he passed away.<br />

Fairoz feels that his father would have survived if he hadn’t been arrested on false grounds. Now the<br />

victim feels that he has to take up the family burden, having lost their bread winner.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-25/08<br />

Victim(s) : Honnamma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Lakshmangowda, PC, Illavala PS<br />

Location : Illavala PS<br />

Date of incident : 03/02/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

64<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Case Details:<br />

The victim Honnamma was a resident of Kamarangalli village. She and few other women in the village<br />

have started a chit fund to save the money and utilize it in difficult situations. One of the women named<br />

Sarojamma, suspected the business and she had demanded her money back. The victim Honnamma<br />

has requested her to cooperate with them, but she had refused. On 3 February 2008 a meeting was held<br />

in the village. Sarojamma had gone to the meeting with her relative Lakshmanegowda, a police constable.<br />

At the meeting it was decided that Rs 2300 should be deducted from Sarojamma’s savings. But she<br />

refused to agree with them. The police constable has abused the victim Honnamma with filthy words and<br />

had threatened to beat her in presence of the villagers. Later the victim has reported to the Circle<br />

Inspector. He has made the constable apologize her.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-16/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Jayaram; 2) Hemanth Kishore<br />

Perpetrator(s) : CI<br />

Location : Bethamangala, Bangerpet<br />

Date of incident : 18/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Jayaram, aged 62 is a resident of Bethamangala Road under Bangerpet Taluk. The victim’s son<br />

is working in CRPF in Delhi. Jayaram visited Delhi during the month of January and considering the cold<br />

environment he brought his seven year old grandson Hemanth Kishore to Bangerpet. Hemanth was<br />

admitted in BGML (KGF) Central School. On 18 February 2008 Hemanth was crossing the road<br />

having got down from the school bus. Bangerpet CI’s jeep hit the boy and immediately the CI took the<br />

boy to a private hospital. This incident was witnessed by Nagamma, the servant maid of Jayaram. The<br />

boy was shifted to Manipal Hospital at Bangalore. Nagamma lodged a complaint against the CI at<br />

Oorgaum Police Station, but the CI gave Rs.2000 to Jayaram’s wife for taking care of the boy. Hence the<br />

victim has denied help from any source regarding this case.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-22/08<br />

Victim(s) : Rajegowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Lakshmangowda, PC, Illavala PS<br />

Location : Illavala PS<br />

Date of incident : 03/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Rajegowda has resided at Kamaragalli village with his family. His wife, Honnamma along<br />

with few other women of the village has saved money in chit fund to utilize it in emergency situations. A<br />

woman named Sarojamma, suspected the business and has demanded her money from the savings.<br />

The victim Honnamma has asked her to cooperate but she was stubborn. On 3 February 2008, a<br />

meeting was held in the village. The women in the group decided to deduct Rs 2300, which she had<br />

already borrowed. But Sarojamma did not agree with them. Sarojamma had taken her relative<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

65<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Lakshmangowda, a police constable with her. He had abused the victim with filthy words and tried to<br />

snatch her wedding chain. Thereafter, he had pushed the victim Honnamma down and has beaten her<br />

on her shoulder, hands and legs with the baton. The next day, the victim had reported the incident to the<br />

Circle Inspector. The police had made the constable apologize and pay Rs 1000 as compensation. The<br />

victim’s wife was mentally disturbed by the act of the police constable.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-35/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kamalamma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police, Kodlipete PS<br />

Location : Kodlipete PS<br />

Date of incident : 25/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Kamalamma was the wife of Basavarajappa. She was a resident of Kullooru village. On 25<br />

May 2008, the victim’s husband has quarreled with her for not tying the cow. Then her relative Nanjappa<br />

and his son have entered into her house and have assaulted her husband. The victim Kamalamma’s<br />

husband sustained injuries on his head and he had collapsed on the ground. Later the victim’s husband<br />

was taken to Kiodipete Police Station. The police Inspector had asked them to go to Somavarpet Police<br />

Station. There, the police have refused to take measures and have beaten the victim’s husband. The<br />

victim’s husband who was already injured had fallen down in the ground. The victim Kamalamma has<br />

hospitalized her husband and had taken him home after treatment. The accused have again attacked<br />

the victim and her husband. So the victim had gone to the police station the next day to lodge a complaint,<br />

but the police have threatened her to compromise the case.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

66<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-27/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishnegowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Rajana, CI, Saraswathipuram PS<br />

Location : Saraswathipuram PS<br />

Date of incident : 21/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Krishnegowda was a resident of K.G. Koppal and he was an advocate by profession. On 17<br />

September, 2006 he had gone to Saraswathipuram Police Station to meet one of his client. The Circle<br />

Inspector, Rajanna had previous enmity against the victim and he had abused him with filthy words.<br />

Then he had asked the constables to beat him and file a case that he had disturbed them in their duty.<br />

Based on that, the police constables have beaten him on his chest and back and dragged him out of the<br />

police station. The victim Krishnegowda was mentally depressed and has filed a case in the Court<br />

against the concerned police officers. The police officers have absconded for the first two summons and<br />

then they have appeared in the Court on 21 February, 2008.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-37/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kushala<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police, Shanthalli Out Post<br />

Location : Shanthalli Out Post<br />

Date of incident : 09/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Kushala was a resident of Shanthalla village. On 25 May, 2008 the victim Kushala and his<br />

relatives have chatted. They have spoken in aloud voice. The people near by have misunderstood<br />

them and have given a complaint at the Out Post. The police from out post have gone to the victim’s<br />

house. The victim Kushala and his friends have tried to escape on seeing the police. The police have<br />

caught the victim and have beaten him. The victim Kushala had sustained internal injuries and was<br />

mentally depressed due to the act of police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-30/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Lakshmi; 2) (Late) Srinivas<br />

Perpetrator(s) : (Late) Ashok, PC<br />

Location : Giligana Kallu, Kodagu<br />

Date of incident : 15/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Srinivas was working as a painter at the house of a politician named Sanjay Vijaya. On 15<br />

February 2008 while Srinivas was waiting for a bus to go home a police jeep stopped by. Constable<br />

Ashok told all the workers to get into the jeep. Since the policeman was a forceful man all the men got into<br />

the jeep out of fear. Near Giligana Kallu the jeep collided with a KSRTC Bus commuting between<br />

Bangalore and Madikeri. All five of them including Ashok died in that accident. Victim Lakshmi, wife of<br />

deceased Srinivas alleges that the accident has occurred due to the careless driving of Ashok. Now she<br />

has lost her only company and admits that it is difficult for her to survive without him.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-26/08<br />

Victim(s) : Manjula Kohlgi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Ramesh Kamble, SI, Halageri PS<br />

Location : Halageri PS<br />

Date of incident : 13/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Manjula Kohlgi was a resident of Ranebenur. On 13 March 2008, when she at her house,<br />

her neighbour Sumangala had cleaned the corns. The dust from the corn had entered into the victim’s<br />

house. The dust had spread in the drinking water which the victim had stored. The victim had informed<br />

her neighbour not to clean the corns further. The neighbour Sumangala was annoyed and she had had<br />

scuffled with the victim. Then Sumangala and her children have torn their clothes by themselves and<br />

then they have given a compliant against the victim. Based on that, the police have taken the victim to the<br />

police station and have detained her for the whole night without investigation.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

67<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-41/08<br />

Victim(s) : Raghu<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Mostaque Basha, SI<br />

Location : Ashok Nagar, KGF<br />

Date of incident : 02/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Raghu, aged 39 is a resident of Robertson Pet. The victim is working in a private company at<br />

Bangalore, and his father works in the PWD. On 2 March 2008 Raghu decided to go to Kammasandra<br />

to worship his deity. On the way two motor bikes crashed and fell on the two wheeler of Raghu, thereby<br />

causing a little damage. The victim stopped to help out the injured persons. One of the injured was a<br />

politically influential person. Hence SI Mostaque Basha filed a case against Raghu at Oorgaum Police<br />

Station, mentioning his vehicle number. The case has been settled at the court. But the Animal Rescue<br />

Organisation is anxious to lodge complaints against the SI and informed the matter to a human rights<br />

forum. The victim on the other hand is not interested to pursue case, for he states that the matter is settled<br />

and he is afraid of the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-37/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ramu<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Shanthalli Out Post<br />

Location : Shanthalli<br />

Date of incident<br />

Case Details:<br />

: 09/05/2008<br />

The victim Ramu has resided with his wife and a 15 day old kid at Shanthalli. On 09.05.2008, the victim<br />

had gone to his relative Kushala’s house. In the night, he has chatted with his relatives in a loud voice.<br />

Then the people of the village have misunderstood them and have complained at the Out Post. The Out<br />

Post police have gone to the spot and have beaten the victim and his relatives with the baton. The victim<br />

Ramu sustained internal injuries due to police torture and was mentally depressed.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/—/08<br />

Victim(s) : S.K.Puttamma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police, Somavarapete PS<br />

Location : Somavarapete PS<br />

Date of incident : 01/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim S.K.Puttamma was a resident of Shanthalli village. On 01.04.2008 she had walked to her<br />

house with her dog. Then a retired ASI, Changappa had shot her dog with his gun. When the victim<br />

S.K.Puttamma had asked him the reason, the ASI had threatened to shoot her too. With reference to<br />

this, she had filed a case at Somavarapete PS. The police have gone to her house and have seen her<br />

dog. Then the police have again called the victim to the police station on 02.04.2008. When the victim has<br />

gone to the police station, the police have forced her to sign in a statement mentioning that her dog was<br />

not shot by the retired ASI. Later she has given a complaint to the SP. But no measures were taken on<br />

the concerned person as he was a police.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

68<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-38/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shivanna<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police, Shanthalli Out Post<br />

Location : Shanthalli village<br />

Date of incident : 09/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Shivanna was a resident of Shanthalli village. On 9 May 2008, his relative Ramu, Kushala<br />

have gone to his house. They have consumed liquor and have spoken in a loud voice. The villagers<br />

have misunderstood them. They have given a complaint at the Out Post stating that the victim Shivana<br />

and his relatives were fighting with each other. Based on the complaint, the police have gone to the spot<br />

and started beating them with batons. The victim and his relatives who tried to escape from the police<br />

were also beaten. The victim Shivappa had sustained injuries on his hands and legs. He had suffered<br />

physically and mentally due to the police assault.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-24/08<br />

Victim(s) : Siddamma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Lakshmengowda, PC, Illavala PS<br />

Location : Kamaragalli<br />

Date of incident : 03/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Siddamma was a resident of Kamaragalli village. She along with few other women has<br />

started chit fund business to save money and utilize it during emergency situations. One of the members<br />

named Sarojamma had demanded her money back. A meeting was conducted in the village on 3<br />

February, 2008 in which Sarojamma had taken her relative named Lakeshmengowda, who was a<br />

police constable. At the meeting, it was decided that a sum of Rs 2300 should be deducted from<br />

Sarojamma. But Sarojamma did not agree with them. She demanded the whole amount. Thereafter<br />

Lakshmengowda abused the victim Siddamma and others with filthy words. Then he had assaulted her<br />

on her hands and shoulders and pushed her to the ground.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-21/08<br />

Victim(s) : Sivaraj<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Trafic Police, Haveri<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 12/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Sivaraj was a resident of Nagandar Mutt and he was an auto-driver. On 12 March 2008, a<br />

woman had stopped his auto. So the victim had stopped his auto and when the woman was about to get<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

69<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


into the auto, a traffic police had gone there. The policeman had abused him with vulgar words and has<br />

beaten him abruptly with a baton without hearing any explanation. Prior to the incident the same policeman<br />

had asked the victim to pick-up his wife from the railway station. The victim had done that and when he<br />

had asked the policeman for money, the policeman had abused him with filthy words for asking money<br />

from the police and had threatened him<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-01/08<br />

Victim(s) : (Late) Sudha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : (Late) Lokesh<br />

Location : Jyothi Nagar, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : January 2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Sudha, W/o Lokesh was a resident of DAR Police Quarters in Jyothi Nagar under Mysore<br />

district. Her husband was a police in DAR. In his twenty years of service Lokesh had no black mark. On<br />

a particular day Lokesh reported to duty in the morning. He was assigned the duty of VIP Security and<br />

given stain gun. He went back to the house for breakfast and sent his daughter to get milk. In the<br />

meantime Lokesh locked the house from inside and started firing on his wife Sudha. Later he set himself<br />

on fire to commit suicide. His mother who was resting rushed to rescue but she too suffered injuries.<br />

Mahesh, the brother of Lokesh heard his niece shouting and rushed for help. With the help of few men<br />

he took the injured family members to JSS and Apollo Hospital in the police ambulance. Sudha was in<br />

a pool of blood as she had suffered injuries on her chest due to the bullet firing. Lokesh had suffered 80%<br />

burns. As a death statement Lokesh revealed the fact the he had fired upon his wife for she didn’t agree<br />

to take care of his sickly mother. He also stated that if the gun worked properly he would have killed his<br />

mother also. Now Tejaswi, the 11 year old daughter of the deceased victim is an orphan and Mahesh<br />

had taken responsibility over her.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

70<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Annual Report on Torture<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

71<br />

06 -Police Torture-No Death<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-20/08<br />

Victim(s) : Appaji<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Chandrasekhar CI; 2) Policemen, Kunigal PS<br />

Location : Kunigal PS<br />

Date of incident : 13/08/2008- 15/08/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim, Appaji, aged about 39 years, a resident of Mandya district was called to the Kunigal PS on<br />

13 August 2008. Appaji went to the Kunigal PS where C.I Chandrasekhar and five other police men<br />

forced him to confess the murder of his sister in law. And when he refused he was tortured brutally for<br />

2 days. The police men striped Appaji off his clothes, bound his legs together and beat him brutally.<br />

Appaji was later hospitalized and is unable to walk as a result of the assault.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/PT/M-54/08<br />

Victim(s) : Akbar and Ifzal<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1)Subin; 2) Alwin; 3) Manju; 4) Soma<br />

Location : Mysore City Central Jail<br />

Date of incident : 08/05/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

72<br />

Case Details:<br />

Akbar aged 30 S/o Kalim Mulla resides at Honasur taluk in Mysore. He is a prisoner at the Mysore<br />

City central Jail. On 8 May 2008 around 12.30 p.m Akabar was talking to his friend Ifzal in the premises<br />

of the prison. Subin, Alwin, Manju and Soma were lifetime prisoners and they were selling ganja<br />

(drugs). They forced Akbar to consume drugs and said that they would pay him Rs, 1,000, every<br />

month if they join them. When Akbar and his friend refused the offer they stared assaulting them and tried<br />

to injure them with knives. Later the police officials arrived and dragged Akbar and ifzal to their cells. They<br />

denied hearing Akbar’s and Ifzal’s words. The police assaulted Akbar and Ifzal stating that they were the<br />

cause for the commotion. The police did not take action against the perpetrators. Later Akbar and Ifzal<br />

were admitted in the hospital for treatment.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-40/2008; KAR/MYS/M-41/2008KAR/MYS/M-42/2008<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Althaf; 2) Iqbal; 3) Suresh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : ARK function hall, N.R.Mohalla, Shivaji Road, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 01/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Althaf aged 30 resides at Siddique nagar in Mysore. Iqbal aged 37 resides at N.R. Mohalla, Shivaji<br />

Road in Mysore. Both of them are politicians. On 1 April 2008 Althaf and Iqbal participated in a function<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


organized at ARK function hall at N.R.Mohalla, Shivaji Road in Mysore. The function commenced around 6 pm.<br />

The followers of a politician named tanveer Sait were bursting crackers and rejoicing his arrival. All of a sudden<br />

a commotion erupted and the people started throwing chairs on each other. Under the leadership of S.I Poovaih<br />

the police abused and attacked Althaf, Iqbal, Suresh and others. Althaf , Iqbal and Suresh sustained severe<br />

injuries on their hips, back, legs, thighs and hands.<br />

FF Code : KAR/CHN/PT/M-18/2008<br />

Victim(s) : Annadorai<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Forest Officials<br />

Location : Kollegal, Chamrajnagar<br />

Date of incident : 18/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Annadorai, aged 37 is a resident of Gopinathan village under Kollegal Taluk. The victim is married<br />

and has two children. He is a farmer. Gopinatham is a small village in the <strong>Karnataka</strong>- Tamilnadu border.<br />

Since this area was previously one of forest brigand Veerappan’s haunts, the number of residents has<br />

reduced. For the past ten years many elephants have been killed in this area. On 10 April 2005 two<br />

elephants were electrocuted to death in Puduru forest area. The forest officials suspected the victim and<br />

his brother in this. Both were arrested and got bail after a period of six months. From then the forest<br />

officials regularly threatened Annadorai and his brother in this regard. They were frequently arrested and<br />

inquired about the persons responsible for the elephant deaths. When Annadorai denied knowledge of<br />

the same he would be beaten up. On 18 January 2008 once again the victim was suspected in an<br />

elephant murder case. The forest officials came to him inquiring about the details. Now Annadorai is<br />

leading a life of fear, for he is often subjected to threats and torture. The officials beat him with lathis and the<br />

butt of guns.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-07/08<br />

Victim(s) : Appanna<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Lokesh; 2) Jeevan Kumar, SI<br />

Location : Doddanerale, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 27/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Appanna, aged 54 is a resident of Doddanerale village under P. Patna Taluk. The victim is a<br />

teacher. Appanna got his daughter married to Lokesh who was a winebibber. Due to this reason there<br />

was a persistent quarrel in the family. Appanna remained silent for the sake of his daughter’s future. On<br />

27 January 2008 while the victim was waiting for a bus near a tea shop his son-in-law came and started<br />

assaulting him. The people separated them and in the meanwhile SI Jeevan Kumar arrived at the place.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

73<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


He took both of them to the police station and assaulted Appanna on his hands, legs and other parts of<br />

the body using a lathi. He was also abused with filthy words. Thereafter the SI filed a false case against<br />

Appanna and sent him to judicial custody. This incident led to a break of relationship between the victim<br />

and his daughter’s family. It had also caused Appanna a damage of his social reputation.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-13/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ashoka<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Cheluvaraju, PC; 2) Ganesh, PC<br />

Location : Shanivara Shante PS, Kodagu<br />

Date of incident : 07/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Ashoka, aged 24 is a resident of Mulluru village under Shanivaarasanthe Post. The victim<br />

belongs to the Scheduled Caste community. On 7 February 2008 the victim was walking towards<br />

Guddugalle Fair Grounds. Accidentally his shoulder touched that of Cheluvaraju, Constable of Shanivara<br />

Shante Police Station. In his fury the constable started beating Ashoka along with another Constable<br />

Ganesh by name. The victim had consumed alcohol. The policemen hit on his legs, hands, back, and<br />

shoulders with a lathi. He was taken to the police station and further beaten there. The policemen stopped<br />

beating Ashoka once he told them that he was the son of a village panchayat member. Ashoka’s bike<br />

keys were held with Head Constable Jayappa. At midnight he was taken to a doctor and forced to write<br />

a certificate saying the victim was drunk. The injuries on Ashoka started swelling but he was not taken<br />

to the hospital. Early in the morning he was sent back home. On 8 February 2008 the victim was<br />

administered treatment in the presence of an advocate and a human rights monitor. Ashoka is unable to<br />

walk because of the brutal torture meted to him. He had lost his peace of mind and feels humiliated after<br />

this incident.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-05/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ayisha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Ashoka Road, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 29/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Ayisha (38), W/o Nazeer Ahmed is a resident of Ashoka Road in Mysore. The victim has been<br />

assisting her husband in their own jewelry shop for the past ten years. On 29 January 2008, few<br />

policemen came to the shop of Ayisha’s husband in civilian attire, revealing themselves as police from<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

74<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Bangalore Kalasi Palyam Police station. Ayisha was not in the shop at that time. The policemen<br />

forcefully took him away alleging him in a false robbery case. Ayisha went to Mandi Police Station the<br />

next day along with few neighbours. The police didn’t respond to her questions. As crowd gathered in the<br />

place and started protesting ACP Ganesh told her that Nazeer was arrested by Chick Pete Polcie from<br />

Bangalore on charges of robbery. He allowed Ayisha to speak with her husband over phone, and he<br />

informed her about the overnight tortured meted to him without providing any food. Ayisha feels that it was<br />

illegal on the part of the police to arrest at night. She also desires her husband to be released and the<br />

police who had tortured her husband be punished.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-14/08<br />

Victim(s) : Basavaraju<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Ravindra, SI; 2) PC<br />

Location : Devaraju Urs Circle, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 09/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Basavaraju, aged 48 is an LIC agent residing in Kuvempunagar. The victim’s son is an<br />

engineering student in Tumkur. On 9 February 2008 Basavaraju picked up his son from KSRTC Bus<br />

Stand, Mysore and was returning home in a van. As the van passed by D. Devaraju Urs Circle a bike<br />

overtook the van and fell down having collided. Ravindra, Traffic SI and another Constable took the<br />

person aside and whispered something in his ears. After that the SI started abusing the victim and his<br />

son. He held their collar and assaulted them. The Constable slapped Basavaraju’s son. Many people<br />

gathered in the place and calmed the police. The SI seized the van key and took the victims to the police<br />

station. They were charged under a false case of preventing the police from performing their duty and<br />

assaulting them, and thereafter sent to judicial custody. Later Basavaraju and his son came out on bail.<br />

But they feel upset about the violent nature of the police.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

75<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/ PT/M-55/08<br />

Victim(s) : Bhagyamma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Hulimavu Village, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 10/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Bhagyamma aged 35 resides at Hulimavu village in Mysore. On 10 May 2008 she had gone to a<br />

school in Hulimavu village to cast her vote. During that time a political party was trying to canvass the<br />

people who had come to cast their votes. People started agitating against this and it broke into a rival. The<br />

police men present in the school premises advanced towards Bhagyamma and manhandled her. They<br />

tried to strip off her sari and hit her hard on her thighs. This incident had physically and mentally impacted<br />

Bhagyamma<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/CHN/M-01/08<br />

Victim(s) : Venkataramu<br />

Perpetrator(s) : B.T.Sridhar, PI, Bellur PS<br />

Location : Bellue PS<br />

Date of incident : 07/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Venkataramu was a resident of Chamrajnagar. He earned his living by renting tents and<br />

speakers for functions. Prior to the incident there was a theft at Nagamangala temple, in which idol of<br />

gods were stolen. With reference to this, the Bellur police have taken the victim Venkataramu to the<br />

police station on 7 January, 2008. The police have forced him into the jeep alleging that he was involved<br />

in the theft case. The police have questioned him about the stolen idols. When the victim had pleaded his<br />

innocence, they have beaten him brutally with the batons. At the police station, his hands and legs were<br />

fastened and he was hung inversely. The police have beaten him brutally and the victims Venkataramu<br />

had become unconscious. The victim sustained injuries on his legs and he was not able to walk. After<br />

eight days of brutal torture, he was released.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

76<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-53/08<br />

Victim(s) : Chandre Gowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Mangala; 2) Srikanth, SI<br />

Location : Vemgal, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 21/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Chandra Gowda, aged 42 is a resident of Kadagatture Vemgal falling under Kolar Taluk. The<br />

victim is married to Mangala and has two children. Mangala was working as a Coordinator in an NGO<br />

named ‘Vimochana’ under Shanthamma. She actively participated in many issues and slowly developed<br />

police contacts. She also had an illegal contact with HC Venu Prasad. Chandre gained knowledge of this<br />

and with the help of Shanthamma he made Mangala confess in front of the village panchayat and<br />

thereby come away from Venu. Then Mangala left ‘Vimochana’ and joined Mamtha Reddy’s ‘Mahila<br />

Jagruthi Vedike’. She shifted her residence from Vemgal to Kolar KHP. Now Mangala developed<br />

contacts with SI Srikanth. With the help of the latter she kidnapped Chandre and forced him to sign in a<br />

blank paper, and thereby gain possession of his property. The police poured water mixed with chilly<br />

powder on his face and forced him to oblige. The SI kicked and slapped the victim and forced him to<br />

sign. Somehow Chandre managed to escape from the place. This incident took place on 21 may 2008.<br />

Thus the victim was tortured by his wife with the help of the police. And now Chandre seeks protection<br />

for his life.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-13/08<br />

Victim(s) : Cheluvaiah<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Cheluvaraju, Dy.S.P 2) Police 3) Boregowda<br />

Location : Ilavala PS, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : February 2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Cheluvaiah, aged 21 is a resident of Ilavala Hobli under Mysore district. The victim developed a<br />

love affair with his neigbour Laxmi, D/o Boregowda, and wished to marry her as she attains 18 years<br />

of age. But the matter was known to her father, who in turn fought with Cheluvaiah. Boregowda left Laxmi<br />

in a relative’s house and filed a complaint before the Dy.S.P stating that the victim tried to abduct his<br />

minor daughter. Accordingly Cheluvaiah was arrested by Ilavala Police who subjected the victim to<br />

torture, beating on his face and head. The news spread to the village and Mavinnahalli Siddegowda, the<br />

JDS Leader led a protest demanding the Dy.S.P to make Laxmi tell the truth in public. Laxmi boldly<br />

confessed the truth thereby bringing shame upon the Dy.S.P, who then agreed to release Cheluvaiah<br />

soon after the case is closed. Siddegowda again met the Dy.S.P and got the victim released.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

77<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-27/08<br />

Victim(s) : Chetan Lal<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Jeevan Bhima PS, Bangalore<br />

Date of incident : 03/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Chetan Lal, aged 50 owns a jewelry shop at Dodda Pet Kolar under the name ‘Sai Jewelers’. On<br />

3 March 2008 four policemen came to the shop of the victim and inquired about stolen jewels. When<br />

Chetan denied all allegations he was forced to get into the TATA Sumo and taken to Jeevan Bhima Police<br />

Station at Bangalore. The policemen didn’t allow him to inform his family members. At the station he was<br />

treated like a criminal and not provided even water. Chetan was abused with filthy words and threatened.<br />

The Merchants Association organized a bandh demanding the release of Chetan, and informed the<br />

Dy.S.P regarding the illegal activities of Jeevan Bhima Police, following which the victim was released<br />

immediately.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-07/08<br />

Victim(s) : Natesh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Prakash Gowda, SI; 2) Police<br />

Location : Mulur village, Kodagu<br />

Date of incident : 17/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Natesh, aged 31 is a resident of Jagenhalli village under Somwarpet Taluk. The victim is working<br />

as a coolie. On 17 January 2008 Natesh was waiting for a bus to Jagenhalli from Banavara. His friend<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Naveen came in a van and offered him a lift. While they were near Mulur village the van collided with a<br />

bike, and thereby police arrived at the spot. The police began to accuse the victim and Naveen of<br />

smuggling spirit in the van. In the meantime Naveen escaped from the place. Natesh and his brother<br />

Suresh were arrested and taken to the police station. They were beaten with lathis and kicked with shod<br />

legs and forced to accept all the charges against them. They were detained in the lock up and the next<br />

day produced before the Magistrate. SI Prakash Gowda threatened Natesh not to disclose about the<br />

torture and illegal detention. Thus Natesh states that he had lost his self respect and reputation after this<br />

incident.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/PT/M-51/08<br />

Victim(s) : Devegowda and family<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Koppal Nagar in Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 27/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Devegowda aged 30 is the, S/O Kullappa. He resides at kestur koppal Nagar in Mysore . On 27April<br />

2008 five policemen of KR Nagar police station knocked Devegowda’s house in the midnight. As<br />

everyone was asleep the police tried to break open the house of Devegowda but in vain. The police then<br />

entered the house of Devegowda through the roof. The act of the police astonished Devegowda and his<br />

family. The police said that they entered his house on receiving information that the murderers who had<br />

connection with the murder of one Mr. Manju were hiding in Devegowda’s house. The police threatened<br />

Devegowda and his family and extorted a golden necklace, 2 gold bangles and cash worth Rs 20,000.<br />

Next day when Devegowda complained of the incident to the KR Nagar police the policemen abused<br />

him and refused to take his complaint.<br />

FF Code : KAR/CN/M15/08<br />

Victim(s) : Vasudevan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Narasimhamurithy, SI, Kollegal Town PS<br />

Location : Kollegal Town PS<br />

Date of incident : 10/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Vasudevan was the editor of the magazine, ’Kahale’. He had written an article that the AC,<br />

Mrs. Sathyabama had misused the Government money. So the AC has filed a criminal case against<br />

the victim using her power. Based on the complaint, the policemen under the leadership of the SI had<br />

gone to the victim Vasudevan’s house. The police have grabbed him and have beaten him. Then the<br />

police have forced into the jeep with his night dress and taken him to the police station. At the police<br />

station, the police have beaten him brutally on his hands and legs with the baton and produced him<br />

before the Court. Instead of booking a defamation case against the victim, the AC has booked him<br />

under criminal case. The victim was sent to Jail and later he had come out on bail.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

78<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-18/08<br />

Victim(s) : Firoz<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Ganesh; 2) Jail Authorities;<br />

3) Veerabhadraiah, Jail Superintendent<br />

Location : Mysore Jail<br />

Date of incident : 01/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Firoz, aged 32 was working as an auto welder, and dwelled in Shantinagar of Mysore district. The<br />

victim was arrested by the police under charges of creating tension during the procession organized by<br />

MLA Tanweer Sait. Firoz was remanded to judicial custody and put in Mysore Jail. The jail authorities<br />

encouraged a convict named Ganesh to attack the victim. On 1 February 2008 while Firoz was praying<br />

along with his friend in the jail prayer hall, this Ganesh disturbed him and abused the victim’s religion.<br />

This paved way for a scuffle and Firoz was attacked by Ganesh and his henchmen namely Shivaramu<br />

and Machchu Suresh. The prisoners who were outside started pelting stones and suddenly the jail<br />

siren blew. The Jail Superintendent and his battalion chased all of them away to the barracks. Later the<br />

Superintendent came to the victim’s cell and brutally assaulted him. Firoz suffered injuries on his hands,<br />

hips and left shoulder with blood clots. He was also abused with filthy words. The police have tortured the<br />

victim and he wishes to bring the notice of the organization.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-03/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishna<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Mallesh, HC 2) Praveen, HC<br />

3) Annegowda, PC 4) Vedamurthi<br />

Location : Police Station<br />

Date of incident : 20/01/2008 – 22/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Krishna resides in Gangavara village along with his mother, wife and daughter. The victim works<br />

as a coolie. On 21 st January 2008 Krishna had gone to the police station to meet his neighbour<br />

Maraiah, who had been arrested on the charge of stealing coffee bags from an estate. But the above<br />

mentioned police officials arrested the victim also alleging of his involvement in the case. On 21 st<br />

January 2008 Vedamurthi of Kaisaravalli village met the police and bribed them to torture Krishna.<br />

Accordingly the policemen abused the victim using his caste name for he belonged to the Scheduled<br />

Caste community. PC Annegowda kicked him with shod legs and the others pressed a ruler stick on<br />

Krishna’s legs. They struck his chest, stomach and legs with the butt of their guns. As Krishna fell<br />

unconscious they pulled him to the corner of the lock up. He was provided neither food nor water. HC<br />

Mallesh gave petrol and asked him to apply it on the wounds. On 22 nd January 2008 his finger prints<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

79<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


and leg prints were registered, following which the policemen stamped all over his legs and hands,<br />

thereby causing grievous injuries. Krishna was then produced before the court and sent to jail at<br />

Madikeri as per the court order. Krishna states that even though he was working as a coolie he had<br />

gained a good respect in the village, which has now come down. Therefore the victim seeks necessary<br />

action against these police who tortured him.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-13/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ganesh (a) Mysore Ganesh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Khaleel; 2) Veerabhadraiah, Jail Superintendent<br />

Location : Mysore Jail<br />

Date of incident : 01/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Ganesh (a) Mysore Ganesh, aged 30 was running a diary shop in Nazarabad. The victim was<br />

arrested by Nazarabad Police under the allegation of creating tension during the procession organized<br />

by MLA Tanweer Sait. Ganesh was remanded to judicial custody and imprisoned in Mysore Jail. At the<br />

jail few convicts targeted the victim and waited for an opportunity to attack him. On 1 February 2008,<br />

Khaleel, a convict tried to create chaos by alleging Ganesh of disturbing his prayer. Thus he made an<br />

attempt to assault the victim along with his henchmen who pelted stones at Ganesh. Suddenly the jail<br />

siren blew and Superintendent Veerabhadraiah and his battalion chased all of them to the barracks.<br />

Later the Superintendent came to the victim’s cell with four policemen and brutally assaulted Ganesh.<br />

The victim suffered injuries on his hands, fingers, hips and left shoulder with blood clots. Later in the<br />

evening the jail doctor was called and the victims were given injection and other treatments. Ganesh<br />

states that the pain was severe for two days but later it was cured.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/ PT/M-64/08<br />

Victim(s) : Gayathiri<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Mahadevappa, CI; 2) Mahadevaiah, ASI; 3) Mallikarjun, PC;<br />

4) Anusuyamma, PC; 5) Mahadev; 6) Ramesh<br />

Location : Bairaweshwara Nagar, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 18/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Gayathri aged 35 is the wife of Sreenivas a resident of Manchegowdanakoppalu town in Mysore . She<br />

has a property near Bairaweshwara nagar. After the death of Gayathiri’s mother, Rajabai, son of<br />

Shantarao, a resident of vivekanandanagar, tried to acquire the property of Gayathiri through illegal<br />

means. In this regard Gayathiri went to the police station to file a complaint against the perpetrator. The<br />

circle inspector Mahadevappa and Mahadevaiah, ASI denied to accept her complaint instead they<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

80<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


supported, Rajabai. With the support of the police, Rajabai had constructed a wall in Gayathiri’s property<br />

by demolishing her house. On 18 March 2008 Gayathiri went to the police station to file a complaint<br />

against Rajabai but in vain. The police constables namely Mallikarjun, Anusuyamma, Mahadev and<br />

Ramesh, abused her in filthy words and dragged her out of the police station brutally. Gayathiri incurred<br />

severe pain in her shoulders.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-15/08<br />

Victim(s) : Govinda Raju<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Suresh, PC; 2) Guru, PC; 3) Jayaram, PC; 4) PSI<br />

Location : Maddur<br />

Date of incident : 14/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Govinda Raju, aged 32 is a carpenter residing in Udavana halli along with his family. The victim<br />

is a carpenter and owns a shop at Maddur road. He receives many orders and makes tables, cots and<br />

chairs. A police named Suresh asked Govinda to make a cot for him and paid an advance of Rs. 500.<br />

He assured to pay the balance of Rs.1000 at the completion of the work. Accordingly the victim took the<br />

cot to the police station on 14 February 2008. But the official paid only Rs. 500 and denied paying the<br />

remaining amount. Govinda grew angry and returned giving back that amount. He also talked back<br />

stating that he’ll get the money only if it paid fully. As the victim was returning few policemen pulled him<br />

back to the station and started beating him. In the meantime the PSI came and asked them to leave<br />

Govinda. He also told his subordinates to get a doctor certificate stating he was drunk and register a<br />

complaint of making nuisance at the police station. Later on Govinda was hospitalized by his friends.<br />

They gave a complaint to the Inspector. The Dy.S.P and the CI met the victim and requested him to<br />

withdraw the complaint and assured to provide all the expense incurred for the cot and the hospital<br />

charges. Govinda accepted it, but he also states that he has suffered injuries at the hands of the police.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

81<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-16/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Shekar H.C; 2) Prakash<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Sulochana; 2) Vijay Kumar, PC; 3) Madevappa, PC<br />

Location : Koppa PS<br />

Date of incident : 04/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Shekar H.C, aged 35 resides with his family in a portion of house shared by his brothers. On 4<br />

March 2008 there was a fight between his brother Prakash and his wife Sulochana, who lived next<br />

door. Shekar and Krishnegowda rushed outside to find their brother Prakash injured and bleeding. The<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


victim and Krishnegowda rushed Prakash to the hospital despite Sulochana’s rejection. She in turn<br />

lodged a complaint at Koppa Police Station stating that the brothers of her husband had stolen gold<br />

ornaments from her house and assaulted her in public. Accordingly Shekar and Krishnegowda were<br />

arrested and beaten by the constables. The police ignored the statement of Prakash’s son, who was<br />

repeatedly saying that his mother was lying and had assaulted her own husband. The police paid no<br />

heed and forced the victims to sign on a blank paper. Subsequently the victims’ brothers gathered<br />

people of <strong>Karnataka</strong> Rakshana Vedike and Raita Sangha and many others in protest against the police.<br />

The Dy.S.P arrived after and long time and assured to resolve the issue. But the agitation continued,<br />

following which the ASP arrived at the place and assured to take action within three days.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/31/08<br />

Victim(s) : Harish K.R<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Mahadevaiah, SI; 2) Policemen<br />

Location : Bandikeri, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 02/02/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

82<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Harish K.R, aged 25 is a resident of Bandikeri under Mysore district. The victim is working as a<br />

beeda vendor. On 2 February 2008 few persons belonging to Bandikeri assaulted three persons<br />

namely Gururaj, Ningappa and Golla at Chamundi Bar near Agrahara Circle. Under suspicion SI<br />

Mahadevaiah and four policemen came to the victim’s shop in search of those men. The SI forcefully<br />

took Harish to the police station and subjected him to severe assault. The victim was forced to accept the<br />

offense. He was pushed into the cell for another inquiry at night. But the people of Bandikeri protested<br />

before the station in support of Harish and later MLA Somashekar requested the SI to release him,<br />

following which Harish was released. The victim desires stringent measures against the police who had<br />

tortured an innocent person.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-45/08<br />

Victim(s) : H.T Ganesh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Mangaladevinagara Town, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 12/05/2008<br />

Case Details<br />

H.T Ganesh aged 35 belong to scheduled caste. He resides at Mangaladevinagara town in Mysore.<br />

On 12 May 2008 he was waiting for the bus to go to madikeri, near sampaji check post. Two policemen<br />

were standing near the Sampaji check post gate taking bribe from the lorry drivers entering the gate.<br />

Ganesh questioned the policemen on taking bribe from the lorry drivers. The policemen were annoyed<br />

with Ganesh and they assaulted him with lathi. The policemen abused him in filthy words and hit him<br />

hard on his legs and hands. Later Ganesh went to the hospital to get him treated.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MYS/PT/M-52/08<br />

Victim(s) : Iftiaz Ahmed<br />

Perpetrator(s) : ACP Ganesh<br />

Location : Banni mantap, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 25/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Iftiaz Ahmed is the S/o Siddiqahmed. He resides at Banni mantap in Mysore district. On 25th, of April<br />

2008 he was on the way to jambu bazaar. A bus driver was trying to park the bus near a depot. The<br />

driver was annoyed at the passengers standing near the depot he started shouting at them. Iftiaz Ahmed<br />

was reprimanded by the bus driver. Iftiaz Ahmed’s friends started criticizing the driver, which caused<br />

commotion in the place. ACP Ganesh and jay Kumar along with three policemen arrived to the place.<br />

ACP Ganesh advanced towards Iftiaz Ahmed and held him by his collar, pushed him down to the floor,<br />

hit him hard on his knees and back with lathi and abused him in filthy words. Iftiaz Ahmed sustained<br />

severe injuries.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

83<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-08/08<br />

Victim(s) : Jayaram<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Suguna; 2) SI; 3) PCs<br />

Location : Bagamanadala PS, Kodagu<br />

Date of incident : 18/12/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Jayaram, aged 32 resides in Kottur village under Bagamanadala Taluk. The victim belongs to the<br />

marati family, and works in an estate for sustaining his livelihood. On 18 December 2007 Jayaram had<br />

been to Cherambane and few of his villagers Suguna, Kunjhalu and Raghu were also there. Jayaram<br />

was drunk and accidentally fell upon Suguna. He along with his friends assaulted Jayaram on his chest,<br />

cheek and hands. They pushed him down that his head fell on a stone causing a severe injury. Then the<br />

victim was taken to Bagamanadala Police Station and Suguna lodged a complaint stating that Jayaram<br />

fought with them. Accordingly the SI pushed the victim inside the cell. A constable took him to the hospital,<br />

and brought him back to the station. He got Jayaram signed in a sheet of paper. From then on the victim<br />

was assaulted on his hands, legs and chest. There were five policemen who tortured and abused him.<br />

Later on Rukmini, the wife of the victim pleaded with the police and got him released. The couple had to<br />

walk all the way home at night for there wasn’t any bus facility. On 19 December 2007 Rukmini took<br />

Jayaram to the hospital but the doctor refused to admit him. Finally after repeated pressure he was<br />

admitted. A complaint was lodged before the SP the same day. On 20 December 2007 the SI came to<br />

the hospital and threatened the victim not to disclose their names. Jayaram alleges that this incident has<br />

caused him a loss of self respect, and he also urges action against the police who had tortured him.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-14/08<br />

Victim(s) : Justin<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) SI; 2) PCs<br />

Location : Oorgaum PS, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 15/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Justin, aged 27 is a resident of Champion Reef Block in KGF. The victim belongs to the Christian<br />

Adi Dravidar community. On 15 February 2008 there was a theft in the mines in relation to which the<br />

victim was arrested by Oorgaum Police. Bharat Gold Mines Limited (BGML) is a world recognized<br />

company which was closed down in March 2001. After the closure about 30 groups were involved in<br />

stealing valuable material from the company with the help of the police. But innocent Justin was arrested<br />

with regard to this, and subjected to brutal torture. The SI and Constables beat him with lathis and kicked<br />

with shod legs for nearly two hours. They also filed a number of theft cases under Justin. The victim is<br />

hence not interested to pursue case against the police, and he believes his uncle would help him out of<br />

this, for the latter has good contacts with politicians as well as police.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

84<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-14/08<br />

Victim(s) : Justin<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) SI; 2) PCs<br />

Location : Oorgaum PS, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 15/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Justin, aged 27 is a resident of Champion Reef Block in KGF. The victim belongs to the Christian<br />

Adi Dravidar community. On 15 February 2008 there was a theft in the mines in relation to which the<br />

victim was arrested by Oorgaum Police. Bharat Gold Mines Limited (BGML) is a world recognized<br />

company which was closed down in March 2001. After the closure about 30 groups were involved in<br />

stealing valuable material from the company with the help of the police. But innocent Justin was arrested<br />

with regard to this, and subjected to brutal torture. The SI and Constables beat him with lathis and kicked<br />

with shod legs for nearly two hours. They also filed a number of theft cases under Justin. The victim is<br />

hence not interested to pursue case against the police, and he believes his uncle would help him out of<br />

this, for the latter has good contacts with politicians as well as police.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-17/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Kariyajah; 2) Sannatayamma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Rajaiah; 2) Ratnesh; 3) Nanjiah; 4) Shiva Kumar, PSI<br />

Location : Bappanahalli PS<br />

Date of incident : 27/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Kariyajah, aged 48 is a resident of Kattaragatta village near K.R. Pete. The victim is married to<br />

Sannatayamma and has three children. He is illiterate and hence practices farming in the small piece of<br />

land giving him by his father. Kariyajah’s father divided his land among five children. But the victim’s<br />

sister and her family assaulted him several times, trying to encroach the land. On 27 February 2008<br />

when Kariyajah was away from home Rajaiah, Ratnesh and Nanjaiah peddled his house with stones<br />

and Sannatayamma sustained grievous blood injuries. After the victim returned she was hospitalized<br />

and a complaint was filed against the perpetrators at Bappanahalli Police Station. But there was no<br />

positive response from the police. Kariyajah approached the SP, who directed him to the Dy.S.P, who<br />

also in turn send the victim back to the SI of Bappanahalli Police Station. The SI behaved inhumanly with<br />

the victim. He kicked Kariyajah on his hips, thighs and stomach. All the efforts of intimating the MLA and<br />

the Speaker were in vain. The victim was left to starve and thirst at the police station. Finally after the<br />

instruction of the MLA, Kariyajah was released but the SI caused him and his son to stand behind the<br />

bars and took photographs of them. Their names were added to the local rowdy list. The victim is<br />

mentally disturbed about the future of his son, and seeks justice in this matter.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

85<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/PT/M-62/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kariya<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Kote Taluk, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 24/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Kariya aged 34 resides at metikuppe, located in Kote taluk in the district of Mysore. He is a coolie. On<br />

24 June 2008, at 6 O’ Clock in the morning, Rayappa of hosahalli village sought the aid of Kariya to slit<br />

a tree nearby the woods. Rayappa promised to pay Kariya Rs 400 for his services. Kariya agreed to his<br />

proposal. When Kariya went to the woods he found 15 other men in the woods. All of a sudden few police<br />

officials surrounded the spot and stated firing at the strangers present in the woods. Kariya tried to flee<br />

from the firing of the police but unfortunately he fell prey to the bullets of the gun. Kariya started to bleed<br />

heavily. The bullet had pierced the right thigh of Kariya. He was rushed to the nearest police station.<br />

Kariya says that he has not recovered from the injury and he finds it difficult to work and make his earning<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-16/08<br />

Victim(s) : Khaleel<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Veerabhadraiah , Jail Superintendent; 2) Jail Authorities<br />

Location : Mysore Jail<br />

Date of incident : 01/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Khaleel, aged 27 was a resident of Mandi Mohalla village under Mysore district. The victim was<br />

working as a mechanic. Khaleel was arrested for creating tension in connection to the procession<br />

organized by MLA Tanweer Sait. The victim was remanded to Mysore Jail under judicial custody. At the<br />

jail, the authorities encouraged a convict by the name Ganesh to attack Khaleel and take control over<br />

him. On 1February 2008, this Ganesh disturbed Khaleel while he was performing his prayers in the jail<br />

prayer hall along with his friend. As other prisoners gathered around, Ganesh assaulted Khaleel along<br />

with his henchmen. In the meantime the prisoners who were outside began to pelt stones. Suddenly the<br />

jail siren blew and Superintendent Veerabhadraiah and his battalion chased all of them into the barracks.<br />

Later the Superintendent came to Khaleel’s cell and beat him up severely. The victim was injured on his<br />

hands, hips and left shoulder with blood clots. He was also subjected to abuses.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-30/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishnamurthy<br />

Perpetrator(s) : HC<br />

Location : Vemkal PS, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 02/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Krishnamurthy, aged 50 is a farmer residing in Hosapura village under Kolar district. On 2<br />

March 2008 the victim’s buffalo was missing. Krishnamurthy searched it in many places but couldn’t<br />

find anywhere. Finally the victim went to Vemkal Police Station but the HC refused to take up the case<br />

without being bribed. The Constable grew angry when Krishnamurthy refused to bribe and stated that it<br />

was his duty to protect public property. The policeman began to abuse the victim and beat him with an<br />

iron rod on his leg. Though Krishnamurthy’s mother and wife tried to prevent him they were also<br />

subjected to abuses. The constable tightened a towel around the neck of the victim. Later Krishnamurthy<br />

was admitted in the hospital. He has lodged complaints to the Dy.S.P requesting action against such<br />

corrupt police officials.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-31/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) M.M. Siddaiah; 2) Madhu<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Jayalakshmi; 2) Punit; 3) Police<br />

Location : Shanivara Santhe PS, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 28/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim M.M. Siddaiah, aged 54 resides in Shanivara Santhe under Somwarpete Taluk. The victim is<br />

working as a coolie and belongs to the Scheduled Caste community. He is an illiterate person and his<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

86<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


wife and sons are also coolies. On 28 March 2008 Siddaiah went to Shanivara Santhe Police Station to<br />

lodge complaint against the Hassan Police for they had lodged a false complaint against his elder son<br />

Madhu along with a DSS Coordinator named Sannaiah. But Siddaiah was abused and caused to sit in<br />

Shanivara Santhe Police Station, for daring to lodge complaints against the police. Madhu, S/o Siddaiah<br />

had been filed under a false case alleging him of being the cause for the death of his sister-in-law. In fact<br />

the victim’s daughter-in-law set herself on fire owing to the torture meted to her by her step mother<br />

Jayalakshmi and her son Punit. Before dying she also gave her death statement stating the above<br />

mentioned are the cause for her death. But the police on the other hand demanded Rs.5000 from<br />

Siddaiah for not taking any action against his son. On 14 April 2008 Siddaiah and Madhu were again<br />

arrested and produced before the court. Later Jayalakshmi and Punit filed a false case at Somwarpete<br />

CI Office and SP Office, in response to which Madhu was detained in the police lock up from 28 March<br />

2008 to 1 April 2008 and subjected to torture.<br />

FF Code : KAR/CHN/PT/M-19/08<br />

Victim(s) : Madesh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : FO<br />

Location : Kollegal<br />

Date of incident : 18/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Madesh, aged 45 is a resident of Gopinatham village under Kollegal Taluk. The victim is married<br />

and had two children. Madesh belongs to the Hindu Padiyachi Gownder Caste. Gopinatham is a small<br />

village in the <strong>Karnataka</strong>- Tamilnadu border. Since this area was previously one of the haunts of forest<br />

brigand Veerappan, a number of resident have gone away. For the past ten years many elephants have<br />

been killed in this area. On 10 April 2005 two elephants were electrocuted to death in the Puduru forest<br />

area. The forest officials suspected Madesh and his brother, and arrested them. They produced false<br />

documents against the victims and sent them to jail. Madesh and his brother came out after six months<br />

having got bail. After this incident, the victims were frequently threatened and tortured whenever there<br />

was an elephant death. On 18 January 2008 once again Madesh was suspected in an elephant<br />

murder case. Forest Officers, namely Chinnaswamy, Veerappa, Rajendra and Kumbegowda came to<br />

the house of the victim and inquired him about the murder. Madesh was already handicapped. The<br />

officials often came to his house and beat him with lathis and the butt of their guns.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-30/08<br />

Victim(s) : Madhu<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Mahadevaiah, SI; 2) Policemen<br />

Location : Bandikeri, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 02/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Madhu, aged 23 is a milk vendor residing in Bandikeri under Mysore district. On 2 February<br />

2008 few people from Bandikeri assaulted Gururaj, Ningappa and Golla at Chamundi Bar near Agrahara<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

87<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Circle. Under suspicion SI Mahadevaiah and four policemen came to Madhu’s shop and forcefully took<br />

him to the station. He was tortured to accept the offense and list the names of people involved in the<br />

scuffle. Though Madhu shouted confessing his innocence the SI paid no heed and put him inside the cell<br />

for further inquiry in the night. In the meantime MLA Somashekar intervened and requested the release<br />

of Madhu, following which he was released. The victim desires stringent punishment against the police<br />

official who had tortured him for no cause.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-33/08<br />

Victim(s) : Madhu M.D<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Jayalakshmi; 2) Punit; 2) Police<br />

Location : Hassan PS, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 27/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Madhu M.D, aged 27 is a resident of Mylapura village under Somwarpete Taluk. The victim has<br />

studied upto 8 th Standard and works as a coolie. On 27 March 2008 Madhu was arrested by Hassan<br />

Police from his house under the allegation of killing his sister-in-law by setting her on fire. Though the<br />

victim confessed his innocence he was assaulted by the police, who beat him with lathis on his hands,<br />

and legs. Madhu was also abused using his caste name for he belonged to the Scheduled Caste<br />

community. The victim was assaulted the whole night and sent home the next day. In fact Madhu’s<br />

sister-in-law had given her death statement alleging her step mother Jayalakshmi and her son Punit<br />

responsible for her death. But the police were trying to protect the real perpetrators and subjected<br />

innocent Madhu to torture.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-06/08<br />

Victim(s) : Mahadevanna<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Ranganayaka; 2) Harivardhan, SI<br />

Location : Kempaiana Hundi village, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 03/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Mahadevanna, aged 50 is a resident of Kempaiana Hundi village under Mysore district. The<br />

victim served as the Panchayat President of the village during 2005. At that time Mahadevanna<br />

purchased a land near the gate of the village. While the victim was carrying out fencing work Ranganayaka<br />

raized objection and filed a complaint at the police station. The case is pending before the High Court of<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong>. Despite this SI Harivardhan has taken a fresh complaint from Ranganayaka on 3 rd January<br />

2008 about this land issue. As Mahadevanna sought justification from the SI he misbehaved with the<br />

victim and caused mental torture. Mahadevanna also states that the SI has been bribed by Rahganayaka<br />

to dig up the issue. The SI on the other hand desired to take revenge on the victim for the latter had<br />

formerly led a protest against the SI’s involvement in illegal sand supply.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

88<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-06/08<br />

Victim(s) : Mahesh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Prakash Gowda, SI<br />

Location : Shanivara Santhe PS, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 18/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Mahesh, aged 28 resides in Gopala Pura village under the jurisdiction of Shanivara Santhe<br />

Police Station. The victim has studied upto 10 th Standard and is a driver by profession. He belongs to<br />

the Scheduled Caste community. On 18 January 2008 Mahesh went to Shanivara Santhe Police<br />

Station to inquire about his brother Dinesh’s arrest. It was the engagement day for the victim and he was<br />

about to leave for the girl’s house for the ceremony. As he rushed to the police station the SI accused the<br />

victim and his brother of supplying illicit spirit in their van. Mahesh admitted that the van belonged to<br />

Naveen, and requested the SI to check with the driver. The SI allowed them to attend the engagement<br />

ceremony under the condition of returning to the station in the evening. After Mahesh and his brother<br />

came back to the police station they were beaten with lathis and abused with filthy words. The victim<br />

states that they were arrested under a false charge and this incident has caused damage to his social<br />

reputation.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-06/08<br />

Victim(s) : Mahesh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Kirugavalu<br />

Date of incident : 14/01/2008, 15/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Mahesh, aged 40 is a resident of Kirugavalu under Mandya district. The victim works as a<br />

coolie at a garment in Bangalore. Mahesh’s wife also works in the same garment unit. They belong to<br />

the Scheduled Caste community. The percentage of Vokkaliga caste people is high in the village and<br />

hence the rate of violence on the down caste people is also high. In the past Mahesh had involved in the<br />

protest against the violence of upper caste people on Dalits, the result of which the latter were seeking<br />

an opportunity to take revenge. On 14 January 2008 the victim had come to the village on the occasion<br />

of a festival. The next day, while Mahesh was rearing cattle in his ground, few people came to him. They<br />

enticed him and took him to the police station, where he was subjected to brutal torture. A false complaint<br />

was registered against Mahesh stating that he has stolen the TV from the village school. The victim was<br />

also abused with filthy words. Thus Mahesh was tortured from morning till night without food or water.<br />

The brother of the victim was also arrested. The PSI belonged to the upper caste and acted in favour<br />

of the upper caste people in the village. Mahesh was produced before the Magistrate and put inside the<br />

prison for three days. The victim has lost his social reputation and is mentally upset after the incident.<br />

Hence Mahesh seeks justice in this matter.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

89<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-19/08<br />

Victim(s) : Mahiuddin<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Shiggav<br />

Date of incident : 05/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Mahiuddin, aged 35 is a resident of Shiggav. For the past many years the victim is engaged in<br />

the business of cinema projection in his town. The police usually come to <strong>watch</strong> movies and at the<br />

weekend to gather their collection. If the collection is regular they don’t even mind if one shows blue<br />

movies, but if the collection is due they will file case even if the movies are <strong>watch</strong>able. On 5 March 2008<br />

few policemen came to Mahiuddin while he was standing outside the theater. They wanted to raid the<br />

theater and when the victim defended him, he was assaulted with a lathi and taken to the police station.<br />

The police filed a case against Mahiuddin stating that he was exhibiting porn movies. Thereafter the<br />

victim was subjected to severe assault at the police station. Mahiuddin desires necessary action<br />

against the police who had tortured him.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-37/2008<br />

Victim(s) : Manja<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Jail authorities, Central Jail, Mysore<br />

Location : Central Jail, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 23/03/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

90<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Manja was a convict in prison for the past three months. On 23 Match, 2008 the inmates<br />

were allowed to take a walk inside the prison. Then the victim Manja and his friends have sat near the<br />

temple chatting. Then a rowdy named Shivanna had tried to beat the victim and his friends. So the victim<br />

Manja had scuffled with the rowdy Shivanna. Shivanna sustained injuries on his forehead and was<br />

shifted to the hospital. Then the jail authorities have taken the victim Manja and his friends to the police<br />

station and assaulted them brutally. The victim Manja was beaten continuously for 15 minutes and<br />

locked in a cell without water. The next day, the police have threatened him not to disclose the mater to<br />

anyone.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-28/08<br />

Victim(s) : Manju H.P<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Rajesh, Writer; 2) Police<br />

Location : Napoklu PS, Kodagu<br />

Date of incident : 23/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Manju H.P, aged 20 resides in Karugunda village under Madikari Taluk. The victim is working as<br />

a coolie and stays along with his parents. On 23 March 2008 Manju was arrested by Napoklu Police<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


under the accusation of stealing coffee. At the station the victim was stripped naked and his hands were<br />

fastened with chains, following which the police assaulted on his thighs, hips and legs. Manju was<br />

provided neither food nor water. On 24 th March 2008 the complainant Pemmaiah came to the station<br />

and inquired the victim about the number of bags stolen. Manju admitted that he had taken bags which<br />

were given him by Writer Rajesh. But the Writer himself came to the station and accused Manju of<br />

stealing 33 bags of coffee. Again some police assaulted the victim and inquired about his father. On 25<br />

March 2008 Manju was taken to the police rest house and locked up inside a room. On 27 March 2008<br />

Manju was taken by a policeman named Pawan to Virajapete and shown a movie in a theater for half an<br />

hour, and again brought back to the police station. Later the police took the victim to a shop and<br />

recovered four bags of coffee. His finger prints were then registered and he was produced before the<br />

Magistrate. The police had threatened Manju not to disclose about the illegal detention and torture. The<br />

victim alleges that the real culprit in this case was Rajesh but he was spared by the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-01/08<br />

Victim(s) : Manjunath<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Mallesh, PC<br />

Location : Shanivara Santhe PS, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 03/01/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

91<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Manjunath, aged 21 resides in Honnavalli village under Somwarpete Taluk along with his mother<br />

Venkatamma. They both do coolie work and manage the family. For the past eight months the victim<br />

was in love with Bhavya, D/O Nagaiah of Mylapura. On 3 January 2008 while Manjunath was waiting<br />

for a bus to Shanivara Santhe village, the brother of Bhavya suddenly pulled him and took the victim to<br />

the police station. Bhavya and her mother also came to the station. Constable Mallesh assaulted<br />

Manjunath with a lathi on his hands, legs and abused him with filthy words. The victim was caused to sit<br />

in the station till evening and thereafter taken to a temple nearby. Constable Mallesh forced Manjunath to<br />

tie a mangalya (sacred thread worn around neck so as to unite in marriage) to Bhagya. Inspite of the<br />

victim and his mother’s request they forced him to do this, for Manjunath had not attained 21 years of<br />

age. The constable threatened Venkatamma to be arrested if she didn’t accept this marriage. On the<br />

advice of the police constable the married couple was kept in the house of Bhagya’s uncle. Later<br />

Venkatamma brought a search warrant from the court and traced him. Subsequently Manjunath was<br />

produced before the Magistrate and entrusted in the hands of his mother. The victim states that this<br />

incident has caused him lot of mental pressure, and wishes that the constable is punished.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-02/08<br />

Victim(s) : Maraiah<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Vedamurthi; 2) Mallesh, PC; 3) Praveen, PC;<br />

4) Annegowda, PC<br />

Location : Shanivara Santhe PS, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 19/01/2008 – 22/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Maraiah, aged 46 is a resident of Gangavara village under Somwarpete Taluk. The victim works<br />

as a coolie. On 19 January 2008 Maraiah approached his sister for some money. His sister gave him<br />

three bags of coffee and asked him to sell it and keep the money. Accordingly Maraiah went to the shop<br />

but the shopkeepers informed the police under suspicion. Subsequently the victim was arrested by<br />

Shanivara Santhe Police, alleging him of stealing those coffee bags from the estate of Vedamurthi. On 21<br />

January 2008 Vedamurthi of Kaisaravalli village came to the station and bribed the police to torture the<br />

victim. Accordingly Maraiah was beaten and abused by the above mentioned policemen. Annegowda<br />

kicked the victim with shod legs and the other policemen pressed a ruler upon his legs. Constable<br />

Mallesh gave petrol to rub upon his wounds. On 22 January 2008 Maraiah’s finger prints and leg prints<br />

were registered, following which the policemen stamped all over his hands and hands, thereby causing<br />

grievous injuries. The same day he was produced before the Magistrate and remanded to Madikeri<br />

Jail. The victim was shifted to Mysore Jail owing to his severe chest pain, and thereafter treated at JSS<br />

Hospital. Maraiah states that though he was a coolie he had gained a good reputation in the village, which<br />

has now been spoiled.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

92<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-39/08<br />

Victim(s) : Mohammad Ghouse<br />

Perpetrator(s) : CCB Police<br />

Location : CCB PS<br />

Date of incident : 27/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Mohammad Ghouse, aged 23 is a resident of Lashkar Mohalla village under Mysore district.<br />

The victim is a wood cutter. Kamran and Deepika, residents of the same village had a love affair and in<br />

course of time they ran away. The Mandi Police under the false impression that Mohammad Ghouse<br />

was the friend of Kamran took him to the Police Station. But they set him free seeing that he was ignorant<br />

about the matter. On 27 March 2008 CCB Police summoned Mohammad Ghouse to the police station<br />

for inquiring about the same matter. Accordingly the victim went to the police station along with his mother.<br />

The policemen pushed his mother out. Mohammad Ghouse was taken into the station and stripped<br />

naked. His hands and legs were tied upwards. Three wire clips were then connected to his privy parts<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


and he was given electric shock. Mohammad started screaming in unbearable pain, but the officials<br />

abused him with vulgar words. He was also whipped with belts and the victim fell down. Later the same<br />

treatment was meted to him once again. Unable to tolerate the pain Mohammad stated that the boy and<br />

girl who had eloped were in Chamrajnagar. Later on, a friend of a policeman took his home, following<br />

which Mohammad was hospitalized. Initially the staff in the hospital refused to admit him but after his<br />

mother and friend protested he was admitted. The victim states that the police who subjected him to<br />

torture were in civilian attire. On 28 March 2008, Basavaraj, a policeman of Mandi Police Station came<br />

to the hospital and threatened to withdraw the case giving money. The Commissioner expressed his<br />

apology about the incident and stated that the four CCB Officials namely Shashikant, Mudhukesh,<br />

Prakash and Shivakumar were immediately suspended.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/PT/M-57/08<br />

Victim(s) : Muniswamy Gowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Hebbal Extension, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 16/05/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

93<br />

Case Details:<br />

Muniswamy Gowda aged 40 is the S/O Shambu Gowda residing at Hebbal Extension, Mysore. He is<br />

a bus conductor in The Mysore city road Transport Corporation. On 16 May 2008 around 9 am a<br />

policeman boarded the bus. When Muniswamy asked him the money for the ticket the policeman very<br />

arrogantly yelled at him and refused to pay money for his ticket. He showed Muniswamy his ID card<br />

and scolded him in filthy words. Later he called up the police control room and complaint against<br />

Muniswamy The policeman abused Muniswamy verbally. The passengers were annoyed with his<br />

behavior and they slapped him. Later a police vehicle arrived; the people started complaining against<br />

the policeman to the officials. The policeman was taken to the Vontikoppal police station. Muniswamy<br />

also went along to file a complaint against the policeman but the officials refused to file a complaint instead<br />

they asked the policemen to apologize for his misbehavior.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-03/08<br />

Victim(s) : Narayana<br />

Perpetrator(s) : SI<br />

Location : Kirugavalu PS, Mandya<br />

Date of incident : 02/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Narayana is a resident of Bendaravadi village under Mandya district. The victim is a post<br />

graduate student, and now working as a clerk at the Mandya Zilla Cooperative Bank. Narayana belongs<br />

to the Scheduled Caste community. He was in love with Bhagya, who too belonged to the same caste.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Both got married and shifted to Bangalore owing to various threats and agitation from their families and<br />

the village people. But their marital life didn’t go well and they often landed up quarreling. As the situation<br />

grew worse the couple returned to the village. The matter was brought to the panchayat. But the family<br />

members of Bhagya lodged a false complaint against Narayana and his family at Kirugavalu Police<br />

Station. The victim and his brother were arrested on charges of dowry harassment. The SI of the station<br />

beat Narayana and his brother on their hands and legs using lathis, and also slapped them. They were<br />

neither provided food nor water. The victim has undergone mental distress because of this incident and<br />

desires justice.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-30/08<br />

Victim(s) : Poova H.N<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Pemmaiah; 2) Police; 3) Rajesh, Writer<br />

Location : Madikeri<br />

Date of incident : 23/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Poova H.N, aged 46 is a resident of Karugunda village under Madikeri Taluk. The victim is a<br />

coolie, and also takes up offers of beating the drum during times of village weddings or other occasions.<br />

Few people in the village never paid him the result of which he took orders from outside the village. One<br />

day Pemmaiah called Poova to beat the drum for a feast which the victim refused. Holding grudge in<br />

mind this Pemmaiah caused Poova’s son Manju to be arrested by the police on 23 March 2008<br />

accusing him of stealing coffee. The police assaulted Poova also and accused him of the same. Manju<br />

was asked to sell 33 Kilograms of coffee by Writer Rajesh of an estate by giving commission. Poova<br />

states that his son never stole that coffee. Later the police searched the house of the victim, but Poova<br />

kept himself in hiding owing to fear of police torture. The victim applied for bail and got it on 9 April 2008.<br />

Poova states that the real culprit was Rajesh but the police have spared him and tortured innocent<br />

victims in accordance to Pemmaiah’s grudge.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-15/08<br />

Victim(s) : M.B. Prasad<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Ravindra, Traffic SI<br />

Location : D. Devaraju Urs Circle, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 09/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim M.B.Prasad, aged 23 is a resident of Kuvempunagar under Mysore district. The victim is an<br />

engineering student in Tumkur. On 9 February 2008 Prasad’s father picked him up from Mysore<br />

KSRTC Bus Stand in their van. While returning a person in a two-wheeler overtook them and fell down<br />

near D.Devaraju Urs Circle having collided with the van. Ravindra, Traffic SI and another Constable<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

94<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


immediately came and whispered something into the ears of the other person by taking him aside. Later<br />

the SI began abusing the victim and his father. He held their collar and slapped them, threatening to put<br />

them behind the bars. In the meantime many people gathered in the place and pacified the policemen.<br />

The police took the van key and took Prasad and his father to the police station. The SI charged them<br />

of Preventing the police from performing their duty and demanded Rs.50,000 to compromise the case.<br />

The victims were sent to judicial custody and later they came out on bail. Prasad feels hopeless<br />

because this kind of allegations will not win in the court of law as it does not have any proof.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-10/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ramesha Shekara Gowda Huliyappa Gowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Vidyanagara PS, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 02/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Ramesha Shekara Gowda Huliyappa Gowda, aged 17 is a resident of Bevina Halli village under<br />

Haveri district. The victim’s family hails from a poor background. Ramesha worked at Kumar Photo<br />

Studio at Hubli to manage the family, consisting of his parents and an un-married sister. On 2 February<br />

2008 a camera was missing from the studio. The owner took the victim to Vidyanagara Police Station<br />

and asked the police to make an inquiry. The police tied his hands, hit him with iron rods and kicked him<br />

with shod feet. They also stamped on both his hands. Early in the morning Ramesha was stripped<br />

naked and assaulted till night. Due to unbearable pain the victim accepted all the charges against him.<br />

Later two policemen who were in civilian attire assaulted the victim inside the cell. Then the police called<br />

for Ramesha’s uncle and demanded Rs.30,000 for his release. The victim was released based on the<br />

assurance given by his uncle. Now Ramesha is scared of the police, fearing what might happen to him<br />

and his family.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/PT/M-61/08<br />

Victim(s) : Sanjay Kumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Shivakumar, PSI; 2) Veerendra Prasad, SI<br />

Location : Krishnarajpet, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 07/06/2008<br />

Case Details<br />

Sanjay kumar aged 36 is an advocate by profession. He resides at Krishnarajpet, in Mysore district.<br />

Kumar, a resident of Koliguppa village near K.R. Pet, had contacts with Harish from Hasan district, in<br />

matters concerning a construction. Kumar and Harish developed misunderstanding in matters concerned<br />

with the construction. Kumar filed a complaint against Harish and it was represented by Sanjay Kumar.<br />

On 7 June 2008 Sanjay kumar went to the police station in connection to the complaint given by Kumar.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

95<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


There was an exchange of hot words between Sanjay Kumar and PSI Shivakumar. Following that<br />

Shivakumar snatched the mobile of Sanjay kumar and slapped him hard on his cheek. He yelled at<br />

Sanjay kumar in filthy words and pushed him down to the floor. Sanjay kumar went to the city police<br />

station, and met SI Veerendra Prasad, he narrated the incident and gave a complaint against Shivakumar<br />

but the police refused to take his complaint<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/PT/M-58/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shankar @ Siddaraju<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Shantinagar, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 17/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Shankar alias Siddaraju aged 35 is a resident of shantinagar in Mysore. He is a dalith. He is a driver.<br />

On 17 May 2008 he was returning home after his friend’s marriage. Few policemen hindered his way<br />

and took him to the police station for an enquiry relating to missing of a girl. He was physically assaulted.<br />

The police hit him hard on his head and legs. He was verbally abused. He was taken to the marriage hall<br />

and the police enquired others about the number of days of Shankar’s presence in the marriage hall. It<br />

was found that he had been in the marriage hall for four days (14.5.2008 – 17.5.2008). Later the police<br />

detained him till 19 May 2008. The girl who was said to be kidnapped was found and she was forced by<br />

the police to give a complaint against Shankar. On 20 May 2008 the police registered a case against him<br />

and produced him before the police. The girl’s mother deposed in favor of Shankar and finally he was<br />

released by the court.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

96<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/—/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shivamurthy<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) CI; 2) SI<br />

Location : Davanagere Village, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 09/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Shivamurthy, aged 19 is a resident of Davanagare village under Somwarpete Taluk. On 9May<br />

2008 while the victim was coming with his colleagues in his goods vehicle near Somwarpete, a police<br />

jeep came from the opposite side. Since the road was curvy Shivamurthy’s vehicle came close almost<br />

to wallop with each other. But his colleague managed to avoid colliding and stopped the vehicle a little<br />

farther. The CI came down and abused Shivamurthy with filthy words, and assaulted him with a lathi on<br />

his chest and shoulders. The police also slapped him and took the victim to the police station along with<br />

his colleague and charged a fine of Rs.300. The SI asked Shivamurthy to reveal the name of the lady<br />

with whom he was talking, and when Shivamurthy told that she was a DHRM he kept silent. The victim<br />

states that this incident has bought him humiliation and the public misunderstood him as a liquor supplier<br />

for election campaign.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-20/2008<br />

Victim(s) : Shivaramu<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Verabhadraiah, Jail Superintendent, Central Prison, Mysore<br />

Location : Central Prison, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 01/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Shivaramu was a convict at Central Prison. Few inmates had waited for a target to attack him.<br />

On 1 February, 2008 there was a prayer conducted. Then an inmate named Khaleel alleged that the<br />

victim Shivaramu had disturbed him in his prayer. So he had called his men for support. A group of men<br />

have surrounded the victim Shivaramu and have pelted stones on him. Suddenly the siren was blown<br />

and the Jail Superintendent had chased all of them. The Jail Superintendent along with other policemen<br />

has assaulted the victim. The victim Shivaramu sustained injuries on his hands, legs and shoulder.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

97<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-19/08<br />

Victim(s) : Subhan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Ganesh; 2) Shivaramu; 3) Machchu Suresh;<br />

4) Veerabhadraiah, Jail Superintendent<br />

Location : Mysore Jail<br />

Date of incident : 01/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Subhan, aged 30 was a wood polisher residing in Mandi Mohalla village under Mysore district.<br />

Two months back the victim was arrested in connection to a procession organized by MLA Tanweer<br />

Sait, alleging him of creating tension. Thereafter he was remanded to Mysore Jail under judicial custody.<br />

The jail authorities encouraged a convict by the name Ganesh to attack the victim and take control over<br />

him. Accordingly on 1 February 2008 while Subhan was praying with his friend in the jail prayer hall this<br />

Ganesh disturbed the victim and began abusing his religion. This paved way for a scuffle and Ganesh<br />

assaulted Subhan with the help of his henchmen. In the meantime the prisoners who were outside<br />

began pelting stones. Suddenly the jail siren blew and Veerabhadraiah, Jail Superintendent and his<br />

battalion chased all of them into the barracks. Later the Superintendent came to Subhan’s cell and<br />

subjected him to brutal assault, thereby causing injuries on his hands, hips and left shoulder with blood<br />

clots. Though the victim begged it turned to deaf ears.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/CHM/M-13/08<br />

Victim(s) : Sundar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : 3rd Cross, Devangapete, Kollegala Tq, Chamarajanaga<br />

Date of incident : 16/02/2008<br />

Case Details<br />

Sundar aged 35 residing at 3rd Cross, Devangapete, Kollegala Tq, in Chamarajanaga District is a<br />

businessman. On 16 February 2008 there was a clash at A.C’s office. The clash emerged out as the<br />

election results were announced. The followers of the candidate that won the election were celebrating<br />

their victory that annoyed the opponents. Finally it broke into a clash. In order to control the mob the<br />

police charged the people with lathi. .Sundar was found in the premises of the place of commotion and<br />

the police charged him on grounds of suspicion. Sundar incurred severe injuries on his shoulders, legs<br />

and back.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-20/08<br />

Victim(s) : Suresh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Mushtak Basha, SI<br />

Location : Oorgaum Pet PS<br />

Date of incident : 01/12/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Suresh, aged 37 is a resident of North Tank Block under KGF. The victim belongs to the<br />

Scheduled Caste community. Suresh is working in a private company at Bangalore and daily traveled<br />

up and down. The Oorgaum Pet Police took the victim into custody so as to inquire about the clash that<br />

took place between youth groups in his area. On 2 December 2007 Suresh was subjected to brutal<br />

torture by SI Mushtak Basha. He was locked up the whole night and produced before the court the next<br />

day. The victim’s family arranged for his bail and Suresh was released from police custody. Now the<br />

victim is receiving treatment from a private hospital. Since Suresh hasn’t any political support he is not<br />

willing to complaint against the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-30/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishne Gowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Mandya District<br />

Date of incident : 10/03/2008<br />

Case Details<br />

Krishne Gowda T.L, aged 40 resides at Talagavadi village, located in Mandya District. On 10 March<br />

2008 Krishne Gowda had phone call stating that a youth named Raghu had died as a lorry ran over<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

98<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


him. Krishne Gowda rushed to the spot and found that the police officials had not arrived to the spot. The<br />

police were negligent to perform their duty hence Krishne gowda and others staged a protest. The police<br />

arrived to the spot and charged the people with lathi. Krishne Gowda sustained severe injuries all over<br />

his body.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-12/08<br />

Victim(s) : Thimegowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Naveen, SI; 2) Prasad, PC; 3) Antony, PC<br />

Location : Srirangapatina, Mandya<br />

Date of incident : 04/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Thimegowda is a resident of Mallena Halli Koppalu. The victim is a farmer and also an active<br />

member of Raitasangha. Thimegowda’s wife and his mother often fought with each other. On 4 February<br />

2008 there was a serious clash between the two in the absence of Thimegowda. The mother of the<br />

victim lodged a complaint against her son and daughter-in-law at Arekere Police Station. Thimegowda<br />

was summoned to the police station. He went along with the panchayat members and returned home<br />

having gained permission to settle the issue at the panchayat level. But during midnight police barged<br />

into the house of Thimegowda and took him to the station. His wife was pushed aside when she tried to<br />

resist them. SI Naveen gave orders to his subordinates to beat Thimegowda with lathis. The victim was<br />

beaten on his thighs, hands, back and hips. Thimegowda’s wife gathered the people and came to the<br />

station. The next day 50-60 people protested in front of the station. The people also gathered in front of<br />

Arekere Police Station under the leadership of Nanjundegowda, following which the CI came and<br />

apologized on behalf of the SI. Thimegowda suspects that the SI took this opportunity to take revenge<br />

with regard to the murder case of Ninge Gowda, in which the victim managed to come out of the jail after<br />

six months. Thimegowda was severely assaulted in the police station. Constable Antony beat on his<br />

neck and chest to the extent that he still has the pain in both the shoulders.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/PT/M-60/08<br />

Victim(s) : Vanjakshi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Haradhanahalli Village Hobli, Nanjanagudu Taluk, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 26/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Vanjakshi, aged 35 years is the wife of mariswamy. She resides at Haradhanahalli Village Hobli located<br />

in Nanjanagudu Taluk in Mysore district. She runs a shop. One day, a police official of Halloli police<br />

station came to her shop and forced her to pay Rs. 50. But Vanjakshi refused to give policeman the<br />

money. On 26 of April 2008 the policeman without the knowledge of Vanjakshi placed some liquor bottles<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

99<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


in her shop. Later the policeman came with a few officials demanding to search her shop. When they<br />

found the liquor bottles they started abusing her in filthy words and took her to the station. She was<br />

threatened by the police saying that they would detain her in the station and break her legs. Later she was<br />

detained in police custody. Vanjakshi’s husband went to the police station to give a complaint against the<br />

policemen but the police failed to accept his complaint and was driven away by the police. With the help<br />

of some higher officials Vanjakshi was able to get bail.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-42/08<br />

Victim(s) : Venkataramu<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Mandya West PS<br />

Date of incident : 07/01/2008, 08/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Venkataramu, aged 50 is a businessman residing in Santhemaralli Circle Taluk. The victim is<br />

married and has two sons and a daughter. Few days back there was a theft of a god’s statue at<br />

Nagamalgala village. Bellur Police received an anonymous letter stating that Venkataramu was also<br />

involved in the theft. Accordingly the victim was arrested by the police in civilian attire and taken to<br />

Mandya West Police Station on 7 January 2008. There were ten policemen in the jeep wherein the<br />

victim was taken and they spoke harshly to him and didn’t tell the reason of arrest. At the police station<br />

Venkataramu was shown the letter and subjected to torture. He was hung upside down all night and<br />

beaten up brutally. The victim lost his consciousness and when he regained the same he found both his<br />

limbs bleeding. The victim could hardly walk. On 8 January 2008 the same torture was meted to him.<br />

Venkataramu was released at night and his family members took him Seetaranga Hospital. Still the<br />

victim is undergoing treatment and is afraid of lodging complaints against the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-36/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Venkatesh; 2) Channegowda; 3) Rajesh; 4) Thimmegowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Mandya district<br />

Date of incident : 10/03/2008<br />

Case details:<br />

Venkatesh aged 35 resides at Alabhiyanahalli Maddur,Tq in Mandya district. He is a coolie. On 10<br />

March 2008 Venkatesh went out with his friends to <strong>watch</strong> a movie. An accident had occurred near the<br />

theatre and people were staging a protest demanding the police to take immediate action. The police<br />

arrived to the spot and started charging the crowd with lathis. Venkatesh and his friends namely<br />

Channegowda, Rajesh and Thimmegowda sustained severe injuries. Venkatesh incurred severe<br />

incurred injuries on his legs, chest, hands, thighs and back.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

100<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-42/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) (Late) Erappa; 2) Venkatram<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Nagesh, SI<br />

Location : Marikuppam, KGF<br />

Date of incident : 30/05/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Venkatram, aged 52 is a resident of Belagana Halli village falling under the jurisdiction of Marikuppam<br />

Police Station. On 30 May 2007 Erappa, the brother of Venkatram was walking towards to the village.<br />

He was drunk. On the way the SI of Marikuppam Police Station caught Erappa and kicked him down.<br />

The victim was beaten with lathi so brutally that he lay on the road unconscious. Few villagers spotted<br />

him and admitted him in the hospital. Before the doctor could book the MLC the SI came and discussed<br />

something with him, following which the victim was directed to Puttur stating that there was a simple<br />

fracture in his legs. But Erappa didn’t recover even after 15 days of treatment and passed away. When<br />

the matter was informed to the SI he refused to acknowledge it. Many villagers went to the police station<br />

but they were all driven away. Complaints were then lodged before the SP who in turn called up the SI.<br />

The latter convinced the SP and filed a false case against Venkatram. But the victim came out on bail.<br />

Even now Venkatram’s family is facing threats from SI Nagesh, stating that if he persists in lodging<br />

complaints he would be booked under another non-bailable false case. But Venkatram is determined to<br />

fight against the SI.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

101<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-25/08<br />

Victim(s) : Polanda Vinu Pemmaiah<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Santhosh Kumar, SI; 2) Vasantha, PC;<br />

3) Srinivasa, PC; 4) Ganapathi<br />

Location : Siddapura PS, Kodagu<br />

Date of incident : 05/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Polanda Vinu Pemmaiah, aged 30 is an advocate residing in Arameri village under Siddapura<br />

Taluk. On 5 March 2008 the victim was summoned to Siddapura Police Station by SI Santhosh Kumar<br />

for a compromise meeting with regard to a case of Kadumanda Ganapathi. Pemmaiah appeared for the<br />

case and the court had ordered a temporary stay. Accordingly the victim went to the police station. But<br />

the SI abused the victim and the whole lawyers’ association. He pressed his lathi on the neck of<br />

Pemmaiah and threatened to kill him if he didn’t withdraw the petition filed against Ganapathi. The SI<br />

warned Pemmaiah to return all the documents related to the said petition, and assaulted the victim on his<br />

chest, stomach, jaws and toes using a lathi. He also forced Pemmaiah to fall at the feet of Ganapathi.<br />

Later the victim was assaulted by Constables Vasantha and Srinivasa, who kicked him brutally. Again<br />

the SI pressed his lathi upon the neck of Pemmaiah and kicked on his genitals. The victim states that this<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


incident is the consequence of the case filed against SI Santhosh Kumar by advocate D.C. Dhruva. The<br />

SI used Pemmaiah as a scapegoat to humiliate the whole lawyers’ community. After this incident the<br />

victim feels humiliated and depressed; and he urges immediate action against the SI and the two<br />

Constables.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-58/2008<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Yallappa Basavannappa Thamboli;<br />

2) Veerabhadra Gowda; 3) Kannappa Gaddappa Bajjihalli<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 10/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Yallappa basavannappa thamboli , aged 50 years residing at varadhi, taluk hanagal district Haveri is a<br />

farmer. He belongs to Panchamasali (Lingayath) community. On 10/06/08 he visited Haveri to purchase<br />

seeds and manure. Around 1.30 p.m the agriculture office was closed and the farmers were refused of<br />

seeds and manure. The farmers agitated against this. The police rushed to calm the situation. The police<br />

had charged the farmers with lathi. Yallappa Basavannappa Thamboli was shot by police on his right<br />

knee, left foot and right thigh. Later he fell unconscious to the ground. Veerabhadra Gowda is another<br />

farmer residing at Nelogal taluk in Haveri district who had incurred severe injuries on his forehead<br />

resulting from the lathi charge of the police. Another victim named Kannappa Gaddappa Bajjihalli, aged<br />

35 hailing from Kalibyala taluk in Haveri district incurred severe injuries on his hand.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

102<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


07 -Police Violence<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

103<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FFCODE : KAR/HAV/M-46/08<br />

Victim(s) : Abdul Rasak Modinsab<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police Men, Haveri<br />

Location : Near the Taluk office ,Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 10/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Abdul Rasak aged 38, belonging to Lingayat caste, resides at Shilavantha Aaladhakatti,<br />

Haveri Dist and is a cart driver. On June 10 2008, the police men of Haveri started golibar on innocent<br />

villagers. In the golibar, Abdul Razak was also hit by a bullet and got injured on his right chest and fell<br />

unconscious. Abdul Rasak also lost his bullock and amount of Rs 3000 and was hospitalized and is<br />

suffering mentally and physically.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-54/08<br />

Victim(s) : Mahalingappa Thalaveerappa Badige,<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Policemen, Haveri<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 10/06/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

104<br />

Case Details:<br />

Mahalingappa Thalaveerappa Badige, aged 42, belonging to Lingayat caste resides at Hosanagara<br />

road, Haveri and is a carpenter. On 10 June 2008, the police men of Haveri started golibar on innocent<br />

villagers. In the golibar Mahalingappa who was coming back home from his work also got hit by a bullet<br />

in his right leg. Mahalingappa fell unconscious and was hospitalized and suffered both mentally and<br />

physically.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-61/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kusuma Sidligappa Churi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Policemen, Haveri<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 10/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Kusuma Sidligappa Churi, aged 26 belonging to Lingayat caste, resides at Haveri district and is a<br />

house wife. On 10 June 2006, the police men of Haveri started Golibar on innocent villagers. In the<br />

golibar Kusuma’s husband Sidligappa died due to the bullet of the police.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-54/08<br />

Victim(s) : Chandravva Nagappa Angadi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Policemen, Haveri<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 10/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Chandravva Nagappa Angadi, aged 60 years, belonging to Linagyat caste, resides at Kalyala, Haveri<br />

Dist and is a house wife. On 10 June 2008, the policemen of Haveri started golibar on innocent villagers.<br />

In the golibar, Chandravva’s son Puttappa who was coming from work was hit by Lathi and was<br />

severely injured on his head and has stopped speaking. Due to this Chandravva is suffering both<br />

mentally and physically.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-40/08<br />

Victim(s) : Malathesha Bheemappa Bhajantri<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Policemen, Haveri<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 24/05/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

105<br />

Case Details:<br />

Malathesha Bheemappa Bhajantri aged 45; belonging to Lingayat caste resides at Gejjehalli, Hangal,<br />

Haveri and is an agriculturist. On 24 May 2008, the police men of Haveri started beating the innocent<br />

people who were in the queue for voting. Malathesha who was also there in the queue got injured in the<br />

left thigh due to beating. Complaint was given to the Tahsildar.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-67/08<br />

Victim(s) : Mallappa Siddappa Banakara<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Policemen, Haveri<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 10/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Mallappa Siddappa Banakara, aged 40 belonging to Lingayat caste resides at Kummur, Byadagi Tlk.,<br />

Haveri Dist and is a coolie. On 10 June 2008, the police men of Haveri started golibar on innocent<br />

villagers.In the golibar Mallappa who was going home, was hit in his right arm by a bullet and he fell<br />

unconscious. Mallappa was later hospitalized and is suffering both mentally and physically.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-55/08<br />

Victim(s) : Prabu Siddappa Makri<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Policemen, Haveri<br />

Location : P.B Road, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 04/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Prabu Siddappa Makri, aged 45 years, resides at Sannagubbi, Hirekerur Taluk, Haveri District and is<br />

an agriculturist. On 4 June 2008 , Prabu was protesting against the fertilizer shortage along with other<br />

farmers near the shop of Kempanna, P.B. Road. The police men of Haveri started Lathi charge on<br />

Prabu and other villagers and in that Lathi charge, Prabu got a fracture on his right leg and was later<br />

hospitalized. Prabu is suffering both mentally and physically.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-48/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ramanagowda Yallappa Malammanar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Policemen, Haveri<br />

Location : Bus stand ,Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 11/06/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

106<br />

Case Details:<br />

Ramanagowda Yallappa malammanar ,aged 56 belonging to Kuruba caste, resides at Kanakapura,<br />

Haveri and is an agriculturist. On 11 June 2008, the police men of Haveri started golibar on innocent<br />

villagers. In the golibar, Ramana who was on his way back home from his sister’s house was beaten all<br />

over the body. The police men also abused Ramana in filthy language. Later Ramana was hospitalized<br />

and is suffering severe pain on his left leg and stomach.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-47/08<br />

Victim(s) : Puttappa Honnathi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Policemen, Haveri<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 10/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Puttappa Honnathi resided at Nelogal, Haveri.On 10 June 2008, the police men of Haveri<br />

started golibar on innocent villagers. In the golibar, Puttappa was shot by the police bullets. Due to that,<br />

Puttappa was in the ICU in a coma state and was later dead<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-69/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shanthappa Mahadevappa Halerithi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Policemen, Haveri<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 10/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Shanthappa Mahadevappa Halerithi, aged 35 years, belonging to Lingayat caste resides at Yalaguch,<br />

Haveri Dist and is an agriculturist. On 10 June 2008, the police men of Haveri started golibar on innocent<br />

villagers. In the golibar, Shantappa who was returning to his village was hit by tear gas shell on his right<br />

shoulder which caused irritation to his mouth and eyes. Shantappa was later hospitalized as there was<br />

severe ache in his stomach and his mouth was filled with poisonous gas.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-51/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shantappa Mallappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Policeme, Haveri<br />

Location : Bus stand, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 10/06/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

107<br />

Case Details:<br />

Shantappa Mallappa, aged 30, belonging to Lingayat caste resides at Shilavantha Aaladhakatti, Haveri<br />

Dist and is a coolie. On 10 June 2008, the police men of Haveri started golibar on innocent villagers.<br />

Shantappa who was coming from a movie was hit by a bullet on his right hip which passed through his<br />

thigh and he fell unconscious.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYSM-36/08<br />

Victim(s) : Alwyn Dsouza<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Jail authorities, Central Jail, Mysore<br />

Location : Central Jail, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 13/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Alwyn Dsouza was a convict in an attempt case and was serving in jail for a year. On 13<br />

March, 2008 the inmates of the prison were allowed to take a walk inside the campus. When the victim<br />

was chatting with his friends, a rowdy named Shivaram had demanded money. He had also tried to<br />

assault the victim Alwyn Dsouza.<br />

The friends of the victim have rescued him from the rowdy. In the scuffle, the rowdy Shivaram was<br />

injured and he was rushed to the hospital. The policemen have assaulted the victim Alwyn Dsouza and<br />

his friends without any reason. The victim was assaulted for more than 15 minutes and he sustained<br />

injuries on his back and thighs. He was locked in the cell the whole day without water. The next day, the<br />

police have threatened him with dire consequences and then provided first aid.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-29/08<br />

Victim(s) : Aruna M.C<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Ramesh, PC, Vijayanagara PS<br />

Location : Rani Bahadur Hall<br />

Date of incident : 28/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Aruna M.C was a MBA student at Mysore University. On 28 January, 2008 he had gone to<br />

get reading materials from Rani Bahaddur Seminal Hall. At that time, there was a book release at that<br />

hall by the former Minister, K. H. Viswanath. All on a sudden an argument had taken place between the<br />

dignitaries and the Congress Party workers. The victim Aruna had witnessed the incident, standing<br />

inside the hall. The people were vandalizing the articles. The Vijayanagara Police started lathi charge on<br />

the innocent people. The victim Aruna who was standing at the corner was beaten by a police constable.<br />

The victim had come to know the name of the constable was Ramesh, from the badge he had. The<br />

victim had pleaded that he was a student, but the constable continued beating him. The victim Aruna<br />

sustained severe injuries on his left. Later one of the college assistant had taken him to the hospital.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-36/08<br />

Victim(s) : Polaiah<br />

Perpetrator(s) : K.N. Ramesh, CI<br />

Location : Chinthamani Bus Stand, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 05/03/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

108<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Polaiah, aged 55 is a beggar at Chintamani Bus Stand. On 5 March 2008 K.N. Ramesh, the CI<br />

was chasing away all the beggars from the bus stand. Badri, another beggar who was along with<br />

Polaiah managed to escape but the victim fell in the hands of the police and was subjected to brutal<br />

torture. Both his knees started bleeding at the severe assault using a lathi. Later Badri admitted Polaiah<br />

at Chintamani GH. At that time a constable came to the hospital and called both of them to the station.<br />

Thereafter the CI stopped a civil bus and ordered the conductor to drop Polaiah at Bangalore. From then<br />

there is no news of the victim. The police on the other hand state that no such incident happened but the<br />

witness statements and that of the police do not match, because the Secretary of Janavadi Mahila<br />

Sanga had witnessed Polaiah lying bleeding at the GH.<br />

FF Code : KAR/CHN/M /08<br />

Victim(s) : Bangarashetty<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Satyanarayan, FO<br />

Location : Satyamangal road<br />

Date of incident : 01/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Bangarashetty, aged 45 is an agriculturist residing in Doddamole village under Chamrajnagar<br />

Taluk. The victim is married and the father of two children. On 1 February 2008 Bangarashetty along<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


with his fellow villagers transported timber in a bullock cart on Satyamangal road. Suddenly Forest<br />

Officer Satyanarayan asked them for their license. Bangarashetty and his fellowmen didn’t know that he<br />

was forest officer and they tried to neglect him. So the officer seized the vehicle. The victim and his fellow<br />

men were also caused to sit in the office. As the matter was taken to the Human Rights Organization the<br />

Forest Officer avoided registering a case but kept Bangarashetty in the office all night without food. The<br />

next morning the victim was set free after getting him signed in an apology letter.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-34/08<br />

Victim(s) : Basha (a) Samsu Kahan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Anand; 2) SI<br />

Location : Maskam, Anderson Pet<br />

Date of incident : 19/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Basha (a) Samsu Kahan, aged 51 is a resident of Maskam falling under the jurisdiction of<br />

Anderson Pet Police Station. The victim owns a plot next to his house, which his neighbour Anand, a<br />

TCL worker at BEML desired to take possession. Basha immediately filed a civil suit in the court and<br />

the order came in favour of him. On 19 March 2008 when the victim was fencing the plot, Anand came<br />

to the place along with the SI of Anderson pet Police Station. The SI threatened Basha to come to an<br />

understanding with Anand regarding the plot but the victim refused. The SI in turn sternly threatened to<br />

face the consequences for not giving heed to his command. Since then Basha is living in fear.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

109<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-34/08<br />

Victim(s) : Bhoganandish<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Kambli, DySP, Mysore<br />

Location : Saraswathipuram<br />

Date of incident : 20/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Bhoganandish was a resident of Saraswathipuram and was engaged in electrical work.<br />

Since his school days, the victim had taken part in a number of progressive movements. In recent<br />

times, there was a huge opposition to the government power project at Chamalapura. A team had visited<br />

the victim’s village to get the opinion of the people, under the leadership of K.P. Pande. Few VIPS have<br />

also gone to the village at the same time to get the opinion of the people. Then the victim Bhoganandish<br />

along with few other protesters have sat in front of the car, of the KERC team and demanded justice. All<br />

on a sudden, the police have assaulted the victim on his head. The victim Bhoganandish sustained<br />

heavy bleeding injury on his forehead and was rushed to the hospital.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-50/08<br />

Victim(s) : C.D. Ramachandra<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Rajesh; 2) Syed Basha; 3) Srikanth, SI<br />

Location : Rughupati Agrahara village, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : -<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim C.D. Ramachandra, aged 60 is a resident of Rughupati Agrahara village under Kolar Taluk. Theft<br />

of pump sets, cables and pipes is very common in this rural area. Though the matter was reported to the<br />

police they took least interest in the issue. So the villagers themselves set an ambush and caught a thief<br />

named Rajesh red handed. The villagers inquired him and he revealed the name of Syed Basha as<br />

their agent to whom they handed the stolen items. The villagers caught Syed also and handed him over<br />

to the police. But SI Srikanth immediately produced Syed before the court from where he managed to<br />

get bail. This action of the SI enraged the villagers and they organized a dharna and picketed. But the<br />

police on the other hand charged them with lathis so as to disperse them. The victim states that the SI<br />

had received bribe from Syed and helped him get bail easily.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

110<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-12/08<br />

Victim(s) : Chenna Basava Deshi Kendra Swamy<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Virajpete<br />

Date of incident : 30/12/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Chenna Basava Deshi Kendra Swamy is a purohit (priest) residing in Virajpete. On 30 December<br />

2007 the victim had been to the house of Chaurira family, which was a property of the congregation.<br />

There was no one in the house and hence Chenna Swamy slept there for a while. Suddenly police<br />

knocked the door and asked the victim to come to the police station. The members of Chaurira family<br />

were also present with the police. When Chenna resisted he was forcefully taken to the station. The<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong> Rakshna Vedike members protested against the victim’s arrest and in course of time the<br />

protesters were also arrested. The police seized the flags, lorry, and other materials belonging to the<br />

KRV. Legally this property belongs to the victim’s Kannada Congregation. Chenna has pledged that if the<br />

Chaurira family doesn’t vacate the house they will resort to severe protest.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-08/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Mallanna, PC<br />

Location : Najarbad, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 03/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Kumar, aged 27 is a resident of Kesare under Mysore district. The victim is working as a<br />

cashier at Apoorva Bar in Najarbad for the past six years. On 3 January 2008 Mallanna, Constable of<br />

Najarbad Police Station created disturbance in the bar. He demanded bribe from the cashier. This was<br />

the custom of most of the police officials who visit the bar. The constable took Kumar aside and began<br />

abusing him, and threatened to take revenge. In the meantime few of the customers started assaulting<br />

the constable, but the owner of the bar prevented them and called for the police. They came and took<br />

Mallanna away. After this incident Kumar has lost his self confidence and developed fear and an irritable<br />

character.<br />

FF Code : KAR/CHN/M-18/08<br />

Victim(s) : Raju<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Gundlupet taluk<br />

Date of incident : 14/12/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Raju S/o Javaregowda aged 30 resides at Kumbarageri located at Gundlupet town, in Chamarajanagar<br />

district. He is a Real Estate agent. He purchased a Qualis vehicle from Sampath raiker for 2.70 Lakhs<br />

Rs in exchage for his car worth 1.50 lakhs. Raju issued a cheque amounting to Rs 95,000 on 8 th<br />

December2008 to settle the total amount for the vehicle. On 14th December 2007 he visited sampath<br />

raiker to take the vehicle. But Sampath raiker taking the aid of three persons including town station Sub<br />

inspector Govindaraju blackmailed him on vague grounds. Thereafter Sub inspector arrested him and<br />

registered a case under section 420 of IPC and sent him to jail. Later he was released on 18 th December<br />

2007 on bail.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-23/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shantappa Mahadevappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Hirehalli<br />

Date of incident : -<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Shantappa Mahadevappa is a farmer residing in Yalaguch. The victim is married and has two<br />

children. On a particular day when Shantappa was returning home from Hirehalli having purchased<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

111<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


some things a tear gas shell hit his shoulder. This resulted in a bad swelling and within a few minutes the<br />

victim was covered by smoke, resulting in lot of inhalation of poisonous gas. At that moment Shantappa<br />

couldn’t see anything and fell down feeling dizzy. He returned home leaving behind the bag. Due to<br />

inhalation of poisonous gas his health went for a toss and he suffered a bad stomach ache. Shantappa<br />

went to the hospital but after much pleading he was admitted.<br />

FF Code : KAR/ MAN/M-01/08<br />

Victim(s) : Chetan Kumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : T. Gururaj, SI<br />

Location : Belakavadi PS, Malavalli<br />

Date of incident : 06/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Chetan Kumar is a resident of Belakavalli village under Malavalli Taluk. The victim is a second<br />

year PUC student at Sri Shivakumar Swamy College. Since the classes were very boring Chetan and<br />

his friends cut the history class on 6 January 2008 and were sitting near the ITI block. Few policemen<br />

arrested the boys and took them to Belakavalli Police Station. SI Gururaj beat Chetan and his friends on<br />

their hands and legs. They were warned not to commit any offense and released. After coming to the<br />

college the victims came to know that the Principal had given a complaint against them stating that they<br />

were creating tension in the campus by playing cards and teasing the girls. When the parents of the<br />

victims questioned him he denied all charges. Due to this incident Chetan has lost all his self respect and<br />

he states that this is a painful moment in his life.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-46/08<br />

Victim(s) : Erappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Traffic Police Shive Gowda<br />

Location : Not specified<br />

Date of incident : 19/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Erappa aged 40 is a bus driver. On 17 May 2008 around 9.30 in the morning he accidentally hit a traffic<br />

police named Shive Gowda. The traffic police became furious. He got into the bus and verbally abused<br />

Erappa and assaulted him. In fact the traffic police did not incur any injuries. Later Erappa got admitted<br />

in the hospital. Later the matter was solved by the intervention of the D.S.P and the traffic officer Krishna<br />

Gowda<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

112<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-75/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Javanth Raj; 2) Suresh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Robertsonpet PS<br />

Location : Robertsonpet<br />

Date of incident : 18/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victims Javanth Raj and Suresh owned jewellery shop at Robertsonpet. A thief named Mani had<br />

stolen in their shops several times. The victim’s have reported to the police and Mani was imprisoned<br />

several times. Once when Mani tried to steal a shop in Bangalore, he was caught by the police. Due to<br />

enmity, he had given wrong information to the police.<br />

Based on that, the police have raided the shop of the victims Javanth Rai and Suresh. The victim’s<br />

experienced a heavy loss in business due to police raid. The police created mental disturbance to the<br />

victims. To condemn the act of police, the people of Robertsonpet have protested in front of Robertsonpet<br />

Police Station. The MLA of the locale had assured the protestors that he would negotiate with the Deputy<br />

Commissioner and terminate the unnecessary raids. Thereafter the people have dispersed.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-71/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishnan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police, Banasavadi PS<br />

Location : Banasavadi PS<br />

Date of incident : 15/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Krishnan was a supporter of the Republican Party of India. On 15 June, 2008 the police of<br />

Banasavadi had gone to his house in a white TATA Sumo and have taken him to the police station for<br />

inquiry. The police alleged that he was involved with a false currency case.<br />

The victim Krishnan had told the police that he was working in the BPL Company. But the police were not<br />

convinced by that. They have detained him at the police station for two days and tortured him brutally.<br />

Then the police have confirmed that he was not involved in the theft and they have released him. The<br />

victim Krishnan has sustained severe injuries all over his body due to the police torture.<br />

FF Code : KAR/CHN/M-07/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shivaiah<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Kumar Aradys, SI, Simaralli PS<br />

Location : Simaralli PS<br />

Date of incident : 26/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Shivaiah was a resident of Tellahar village and earned his livelihood from agriculture. The<br />

village consisted of 300 families and most of them belonged to Schedule Caste. On 26 January, 2008<br />

there was a land dispute between the victim Shivaiah and Siddaiah.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

113<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Later that evening, two policemen have taken the victim Shivaiah to the police station The Inspector had<br />

spoken to the victim roughly. When the victim had questioned the police, he had beaten him on his hands<br />

and legs brutally with the baton. Later two more constables have joined together and have beaten the<br />

victim with fists. Then the police had threatened him not to disclose the matter to anyone and released<br />

him.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-17/08<br />

Victim(s) : Hanumantappa Shivappa Malagunda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Rathod, PC; 2) Poojar, PC<br />

Location : Hanagal, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 22/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Hanumantappa Shivappa Malagunda is a resident of Hanagal of Haveri district. The victim is<br />

working as a <strong>watch</strong>man at Janatha Shikshana Samsthe. On 22 February 2008 while Hanumantappa<br />

was on duty at a school he had stomach upset and went to the toilet. In the meantime the above<br />

mentioned perpetrators were shouting in the school premises and tore the bed of the victim.<br />

Hanumantappa rushed out to see, and was consequently assaulted by these policemen. When the<br />

principal of the college came to his rescue and questioned the policemen they went away throwing the<br />

college keys. Hanumantha Prasad, a staff of the college filed a complaint against these officials with the<br />

SI but the case was registered as one of B value, which means there isn’t sufficient evidence to take<br />

action. Now Hanumantappa Shivappa Malagunda desires justice in this case, for he has lost his hope<br />

on the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-12/08<br />

Victim(s) : Badri<br />

Perpetrator(s) : K.N. Ramesh, CI<br />

Location : Chintamani Bus Stand<br />

Date of incident : 05/03/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

114<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Badri, aged 55 is a beggar at Chinthamani Bus Stand. There is another beggar along with the<br />

victim named Polaiah. On 5 March 2008 K.N. Ramesh, Chinthamani CI came and chased Badri and<br />

Polaiah. The latter was grievously injured at the thrashings and thereafter admitted in the hospital. In the<br />

meantime, a policeman came to the hospital and summoned Badri and Polaiah to the station. The CI<br />

stopped a civil bus and ordered the conductor to drop Polaiah at Bangalore. From then there is no news<br />

of him.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-24/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ibrahim Kamadolli<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Savanur<br />

Date of incident : 21/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Ibrahim Kamadolli is a businessman residing in Savanur. There is a persistent conflict regarding<br />

the market for the past 40 years in the area. Some of the vendors wanted the market in the play ground<br />

and some objected it. The town municipality decided to have the market at Sri Renukacharya Mata.<br />

However some communal forces gave ignited violence in this issue, thereby leading to police lathi<br />

charge on innocent people on 21 March 2008. The victim had visited the place to assess the situation<br />

but was brutally beaten up by the police. Ibrahim Kamadolli suffered grievous injuries and was admitted<br />

in the GH for three days. The victim urges the concerned authorities to take necessary action on the<br />

police for their atrocious act.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

115<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-12/08<br />

Victim(s) : Jagadish<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Vinay Kumar, DCF; 2) Mahadevaiah, Dy.S.P;<br />

3) Sundar Raj, CPI; 4) Prasanna Kumar, ACF<br />

Location : Shindenahalli Village, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 02/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Jagadish, aged 24 is a resident of Shindenahalli village under Mysore district. The victim is a<br />

bachelor and stays with his parents. Six months back Jagadish and his family worked for the forest<br />

department under the scheme of food for coolie. The family worked for Rs.6000-8000, and when asked<br />

for the payment they were given some wooden logs in compensation. Jagadish brought the logs and<br />

kept it in his house. On 2 February 2008 few policemen and forest officials visited the house of the victim<br />

in the name of raid. They abused Jagadish’s family as thieves. This word hurt the victim badly that he<br />

attempted suicide by taking poison but the Dy.S.P rescued him and sent him to the hospital in the police<br />

van. Jagadish urges necessary action against the police for taking away his agricultural equipments by<br />

blindly following the words of some people. Jagadish also stated that the above mentioned perpetrators<br />

had caused him all the trouble.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-57/08<br />

Victim(s) : Jaya Prakash<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Varthure Prakash; 2) Police<br />

Location : Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 08/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Jaya Prakash, aged 45 is a resident of Keel Kote under Kolar Taluk. The victim is a Congress<br />

party activist. On 8 May 2008 Jaya Prakash accompanied Srinivas Gowda, who was contesting in the<br />

Assembly Election for a door to door campaign. At the same time Varthure Prakash, the leader of the<br />

opposite party and his followers entered the same area. A clash broke out between both parties and<br />

subsequently police entered the scene. They began to charge everybody with lathis. A number of<br />

people were injured including the victim but none of them were taken to the hospital. Jaya Prakash<br />

sustained severe injuries on his left leg. The victim is not interested in pursuing case against the police<br />

for he states that this kind of treatment is very common during election times.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-24/08<br />

Victim(s) : Jaylanisab Chamansab Shiggavi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Savanur<br />

Date of incident : 21/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Jaylanisab Chamansab Shiggavi, aged 38 is a cloth merchant residing in Savanur. On 21<br />

March 2008 while the victim was at his shop, suddenly violence erupted at Indira circle and lathi charge<br />

was under force. Jaylanisab decided to close the shop and while doing so, two of his boys were<br />

assaulted by the police. The victim and his sons were then chased to the terrace and subjected to brutal<br />

torture. They were not even allowed to go to the hospital. Later Jaylanisab and his sons had to receive<br />

treatment in private clinics. Even now the victim is not able to walk properly. He feels afraid of the police<br />

and doesn’t want to pursue case against the police fearing that he might be assaulted at any time and his<br />

family might fall into trouble.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-33/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kiran Basappa Malenahalli<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Byadegi, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 26/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Kiran Basappa Malenahalli, aged 35 is a businessman residing in Byadegi under Haveri district.<br />

On 26 March 2008 while the victim was returning home on his bike a police jeep stopped before him.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

116<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Kiran was subjected to severe assault. Some women gathered in the place and rescued him from their<br />

hands. Kiran suffered injuries on his legs, hands and face. He fainted on the spot, following which he was<br />

hospitalized. The villagers protested against the police and broke the windows of the hospital in their fury.<br />

However the police justified their action stating that according to section 144 they can beat anybody and<br />

do anything. All the people became violent at this reply. On 31 March 2008 the villagers held a peace<br />

meet to settle the issue of dismantling of a goddess statue and as per their direction the victim did not<br />

proceed with the case.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-17/08KAR/KOD/M-16/08<br />

Victim(s) : Naveen and Kiran<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Cheluvaraju, PC<br />

Location : Mulluru Post, Somvarapete Taluk<br />

Date of incident : 22/11/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

Case Details:<br />

Kiran aged 12 resides at Mulluru Post in Somvarapete Taluk with his grandmother Lakshmi and<br />

brother Naveen. He is studying in 6 th standard and his brother Naveen in 8 th standard. After the death of<br />

his father, Kiran and Naveen refused to stay with their mother as many strangers frequented their house<br />

to meet their mother. On 22 November 2008 a Head constable of Shanivarasanthe Police station<br />

named Cheluvaraju visited Kiran’s house with his mother. He assaulted Kiran and Naveen besides<br />

verbally abused them. He threatened them to stay with their mother.<br />

117<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-40/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kodhandappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) P. Shiva Kumar, CI; 2) Police<br />

Location : Beda Setty Halli, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 20/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Kodhandappa, aged 50 is an agricultural labourer residing in Beda Setty Halli village under Kolar<br />

district. On 20 March 2008 a bullock race was about to commence in the village on the occasion of<br />

Sankranthi festival. Many villagers used to participate in the race along with their bullocks. But CI Shiva<br />

Kumar entered the village and stated that the bullock race cannot be allowed because the court doesn’t<br />

permit this. The villagers discussed with the police and the latter allowed the village to conduct the race<br />

but not for the outsiders. This paved way for an argument and since it reached the peak the policemen<br />

resorted to lathi charge, and also used tear gas. The local people hid themselves inside their house but<br />

the outsiders were beaten up severely. Kodhandappa also suffered injuries on his back bone and the<br />

fingers in his hands. They were swollen and started bleeding. The victim is not interested to pursue case<br />

against the police for the panchayat has settled the issue.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-08/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishna Kumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Harohalli<br />

Date of incident : 28/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Krishna Kumar is a resident of Harohalli village. The victim is married and has two children.<br />

Krishna owns a tea shop, with the income of which he manages the family. The shop is situated at the<br />

juncture of Pandavapura and Harohalli villages and the business is good at times and the vice versa.<br />

There was a group clash between both the villages over a ‘kabaddi’ match on 28 February 2008. A<br />

team of police arrived at the place and began to charge the people with lathis. Krishna was also injured<br />

on his hands and legs, and his shop was closed, owing to which suffered loss. It is also alleged that the<br />

police have filed false cases against few.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-04/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishna Prasad<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Mandya<br />

Date of incident : -<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

118<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Krishna Prasad, aged 42 is an LIC agent, social worker and also an active partisan of farmer’s<br />

association. He is married to Renuga and has a son named Keerthi Prakash. In the initial years of his<br />

career Krishna was working as the first divisional clerk at Mandya Zilla Parishad. But the farmer’s<br />

movement influenced him and he spend 50% of his LIC Commission for the farmer’s movement. The<br />

victim was actively involved in sensitizing the public against the corrupt politicians. During a movement<br />

organized by many organization including <strong>Karnataka</strong> Rakshana Vedike, Raita Sangha, Slum Dwellers<br />

Association and many others, thousands of farmers of the district gathered to protest against the<br />

government policies. Having gained news of this the police blocked the Bangalore- Mysore Highway<br />

and seized all the food materials arranged for the farmers. They also enforced lathi charge and arrested<br />

all the leaders. Many farmers suffered grievous injuries. All the leaders were released in the night and<br />

Krishna feels that it was clear cut act of police goondaism. The victim’s associates organized a bandh<br />

and it was a successful one. Krishna feels that this kind of police lathi charge has lead to the increase in<br />

the farmer’s suicide in the district.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-11/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishne Shetty<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Harohalli village, Mandya<br />

Date of incident : 28/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Krishne Shetty, aged 48 is a resident of Harohalli village under Mandya district. He is married to<br />

Putta Lakshmamma and has five children. On 28 February 2008 the victim was walking on the village<br />

road and suddenly a police assaulted him with his lathi and pulled him down. The victim was alleged of<br />

being involved in the assault that occurred in the village, in connection to a kabaddi match. The police<br />

had simply assaulted the villagers also, who were in the panchayat office without sparing the aged<br />

people. Krishne was trying to move away from the place but the police compassed him and subjected<br />

him to severe assault. Thus they created a scene of terror at the village. Krishne seeks justice against<br />

such acts of the police.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

119<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-10/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishne Gowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) KSRP Force; 2) Police<br />

Location : Harohalli village, Mandya<br />

Date of incident : 28/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Krishne Gowda, aged 46 is a resident of Harohalli village under Mandya district. The victim is<br />

married to Mangala and has two children. On 28 February 2008 many villagers had gathered in the<br />

panchayat to discuss on the issue of assault on a village boy named Shivakumar. There were nearly<br />

400 people gathered there including Krishne Gowda. Suddenly police arrived at the place including the<br />

KSRP Force. They threatened the villagers to vacate the place and began charging with lathis. They<br />

didn’t spare the aged persons either. As Krishne Gowda was trying to escape he was surrounded and<br />

severely beaten up. The police also threw smoke bombs, which fell on the electric transformer and the<br />

power supply went off in the village. Thus the police assaulted everyone in the village as it was very<br />

dark. They pulled out some people from their houses and took them to the police station. Krishne was<br />

injured all over his body particularly hips, thighs and hands. He couldn’t walk properly even after 15<br />

days. None of the villagers dared to go to the hospital in fear of the police who were patrolling around the<br />

village. The police on the other hand state that they were trying to curb the disturbance created by the<br />

people of Hiremarali village who were disturbing a wedding function.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-18/08<br />

Victim(s) : Lajkkappa Lamani<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Nidnegilu village, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 19/06/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Lajkkappa Lamani, aged 45 is a resident of Nidnegilu under Haveri district. The excise officials<br />

and police barged into the house of the victim, accusing him of producing hooch. They assaulted all the<br />

family members and misbehaved with the women. The police threw all the articles in the name of<br />

searching the house for evidences. All the villagers protested against the illegal activities of the police,<br />

owing to which they left the place temporarily. The next day police came and disturbed the people of the<br />

village. Lajkkappa Lamani states that on one hand the policemen have made this a custom to harass<br />

innocent poor people and on the other hand they close their eyes to the liquor barons who produce liquor<br />

without license.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/PT/M-60/08<br />

Victim(s) : Gopalaswamy<br />

Perpetrator(s) : A. Srikantaiah, Shanthi<br />

Location : Chatra Village, Nanjanagud Taluk<br />

Date of incident : 05/05/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

120<br />

Case Details:<br />

M. Gopalaswamy aged 40 resides at Immavu Grama Chikkayana Chatra village located in nanjanagud<br />

taluk. He is a librarian in the <strong>Karnataka</strong> Open University. His mother Devamma, owns a piece of land.<br />

A.Srikantaiah, the resident of Vishweshwara Nagara and Ms Shanthi the resident of JP nagar had<br />

agreed to pay 28 lakhs for the taking sand from their land. But they failed to pay the agreed sum of<br />

money. Srikanthaiah and Shanthi filed a false complaint against Gopalaswamy stating that he had<br />

cheated them and breached the agreement. Gopalaswamy was called to the police station for an<br />

enquiry by Inspector Dharmesh on 5 May 2008. He was forced to sign on a cheque amounting to Rs<br />

10.5 Lakhs. Later he was detained in the police station. The police called him by filthy words and<br />

threatened that he has to pay the perpetrators Rs.18 Lakhs. Later the police had extorted Rs 6 lakhs<br />

from Gopalaswamy.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-09/08<br />

Victim(s) : Madashetty<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Satyanarayan, FO<br />

Location : Satyamangal Road<br />

Date of incident : 01/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Madashetty is a farmer residing in Doddamole village under Chamrajnagar Taluk. The victim is<br />

married and has two children. On 1 February 2008 Madashetty and his fellow villagers were transporting<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


timber in a bullock cart on Satyamangal Road. At Sultan Shareef Circle they encountered FO<br />

Satyanarayan, who asked for their license. Ignorant of the fact that the person inquiring them was a FO<br />

the victims tried to neglect him. Ultimately their cart was seized and the victims were caused to wait at the<br />

forest office the whole night without food. After the intervention of a Human Rights Organization the FO<br />

released Madashetty and his fellowmen the next morning, without registering a case. But the FO<br />

caused them to sign in an apology letter.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-03/08<br />

Victim(s) : Mahesh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Harivardhan, SI<br />

Location : T. Narasipura, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 19/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Mahesh, aged 32 is an auto driver residing in Shambu Linganapura village under Mysore<br />

district. The victim runs his auto between his village and T. Narasipura. The new SI, Harivardhan often<br />

harassed the auto drivers for the monthly minimum bribe of Rs.300. Some of the drivers including<br />

Mahesh opposed this movement. The SI sought for an opportunity to take revenge. On 19 January<br />

2008 while Mahesh was near a temple at T. Narasipura the SI stopped him and stated abusing him with<br />

filthy words. The SI slapped Mahesh in public and broke the glass of the auto rickshaw. Immediately the<br />

victim informed the matter to the Auto Owners Association and staged a protest in front of the police<br />

station. Later Inspector Kumar Swamy promised of taking necessary action. Mahesh states that he has<br />

been targeted by the police and this incident has affected his social reputation, and henceforth seeks<br />

justice and strict action against the SI for his revengeful act.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

121<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-21/2008<br />

Victim(s) : Manamohan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Mahadevaiah, ASI, Devaraja PS<br />

Location : Devaraja PS<br />

Date of incident : 26/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Manamohan was a BBM student. On 26 February, 2008 when he was riding in his twowheeler;<br />

the Sub-Inspector and a traffic constable have stopped him for not wearing helmet. The victim<br />

Manamohan had told them that he had an injury in his head and so he could not wear the helmet. The<br />

police had asked him to pay Rs 100. The victim had told the police that he did not have money and<br />

asked his permission to get money from his friends. When the victim was about to get in his bike, the<br />

ASI had pushed him down.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


The victim sustained injuries on his knee. Then the ASI had abused him vulgarly and demanded Rs 300<br />

or threatened to seize his bike. The public, who were <strong>watch</strong>ing this incident, have protested against the<br />

police. The next day, the victim was called to the police station and Circle Inspector had asked sorry for<br />

the misbehavior of the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-10/08<br />

Victim(s) : Manchegowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Police; 2) Forest Officials<br />

Location : Siddenahalli village, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 02/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Manchegowda, aged 46 is a resident of Siddenahalli village under Mysore district. The victim<br />

lives along with his parents, and the family has been depending on the forest products for firewood and<br />

survival as they live in the outskirts of the forest. This is the practice of the family for many generations.<br />

However on 2 February 2008 some policemen and forest officials made a sudden visit to the village and<br />

took away some wooden agricultural equipment from Manchegowda’s house in the name of raid. As<br />

the victim resisted the police pushed him down, thereby causing injuries on his hand and back.<br />

Manchegowda urges necessary action against the police for taking away his instruments by blindly<br />

following the words of some envious people. According to the victim DCF Vinay Kumar, Dy.S.P<br />

Mahadevaiah, CPI Sundar Raj and ACF Prasanna Kumar were the officials who caused all the trouble.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

122<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-29/08<br />

Victim(s) : Manjunath<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Srikanth, SI<br />

Location : Vemgal, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : -<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Manjunath, aged 33 is a resident of Vemgal town. The victim is working as a school master.<br />

Manjunath fell in love with Geetha and both got married on 7 March 2008. Geetha’s family was against<br />

the registered marriage and bribed the SI to separate the couple. They also brain washed Geetha.<br />

When Manjunath opposed the SI the latter threatened the victim that he would be proven an alcoholic<br />

with the help of a medical practitioner. After this Manjunath approached Geetha’s family along with the<br />

panchayat members and well wishers. They agreed to get the victim and Geetha re-married as per<br />

their customs. Hence Manjunath is not interested in pursuing the case as the wedding is going to be held<br />

soon in a devasthana.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-09/08<br />

Victim(s) : Marigowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Police; 2) Forest Officials<br />

Location : Siddenahalli village, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 02/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Marigowda, aged 48 resides in Siddenahalli village along with his family. The age old practice of<br />

the family is to collect forest products for firewood and survival as they were living in the outskirts of the<br />

forest. However on 2 February 2008 few policemen and forest officials made a sudden visit to the village<br />

and took away some wooden equipment from the house of the victim which were used for agriculture.<br />

As Marigowda resisted the police pushed him down thereby causing injuries on his hands and back.<br />

The victim thus urges necessary action against the police for taking away his instruments by blindly<br />

following the words of few envious people. Marigowda states that DCF Vinay Kumar, Dy.S.P<br />

Mahadevaiah, CPI Sundar Raj and ACF Prasanna Kumar were the officials who caused him all the<br />

trouble.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

123<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-44/2008<br />

Victim(s) : Mohan<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 11/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Mohan S aged 24 resides at Kempalapura, piriyapatna located at Mysore. He is a Businessman. On<br />

11 April 2008 he visited Mysore for a buisiness purpose. While he was standing near a shop a woman<br />

called him. Mohan was confused as to why she called her. Later he realized that she was a harlot. Two<br />

policemen noticed him and took him to the police station for an enquiry. They demanded Rs 30,000<br />

from him for his release and took Rs 12,000 from him which he had it for his business purpose. Later<br />

they took his phone number saying that he will have to frequent the police station when called for.<br />

FF Code<br />

Victim(s)<br />

Perpetrator(s)<br />

Location<br />

: KAR/HAV/M-34/08<br />

: Nagappa Thirukappa Matada<br />

: 1) CRPF Officials; 2) Police<br />

: Islampura, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 26/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Nagappa Thirukappa Matada is a resident of Islampura under Haveri district. On 26 March 2008<br />

there was a clash between two castes on the issue of business. The struggle became severe and<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Nagappa decided to vacate his work place. As he was climbing the ladder to water the new building near<br />

his work place, a police official hit on his head from behind. The victim was then pushed down and<br />

subjected to brutal assault. Nagappa ran to the hospital holding his head. There was nobody to help him.<br />

Four sutures were applied on his head. Two weeks from thence Nagappa couldn’t go for work, and he<br />

is a sole bread winner of the family. On 31 March 2008 a peace meeting was organized but nobody<br />

thought of the injured people. The victim has spent more than Rs.4,000 for the hospital expenses and<br />

none of the leaders had come forward to help him. The police on the other hand state that they had come<br />

to the place in order to curb the clash between Hindus and Muslims in connection to the dismantling of<br />

the statue of a goddess. On the day of the incident some miscreants had set fire to some Muslim shops<br />

and to prevent it they had charged the people with lathis.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-47/2008<br />

Victim(s) : Nargesh Kumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Mohan Kumar, Inspector; 2) Harish, SI; 3) PCs<br />

Location : Tonachikoppalu Layout, Kuvempu Nagara, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 16/04/2008<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

124<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Nagesh kumar aged 40 resides at Tonachikoppalu layout, Kuvempu Nagara in Mysore with<br />

his family. The victim is a businessman and a politician belonging to B.J.P party. On 16 April 2008<br />

around 3pm Inspector Mohan Kumar and SI Harish with 2 constables raided his house. The victim was<br />

not at home and as his wife and son questioned the police about the raid. The police replied that they got<br />

information stating that Nagesh Kumar had hoarded money and liquor in his house. Mrs. Nagesh<br />

Kumar requested the police to pursue their search after the arrival of her husband. But the policemen did<br />

not heed their request instead they damaged the things at home. Later they called the superior official and<br />

said that they did not find anything at Nargesh Kumar’s house. Mrs. Nargesh Kumar and her son were<br />

shocked at the attitude of the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-55/08<br />

Victim(s) : Narayan Kumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Salim Nathar, SI; 2) Anand, PC<br />

Location : Malure Town PS<br />

Date of incident : 20/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Narayan Kumar, aged 38 is an advocate residing in Someswara Nagar falling under the jurisdiction<br />

of Malure Police Station. The victim went to Malure Town Police Station on 20 May 2008 so as to collect<br />

some information regarding a case. SI Salim Nathar was on probation at that time. Another Advocate<br />

named Saraswathamma was ill treated by the police the previous month. The Bar Association organized<br />

a dharna against the police and after that the latter are in enmity towards the lawyers. In this circumstance<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Narayan went to the police station. As expected the SI didn’t respect the victim and answered in single<br />

words. He began to kick the chair and table. The constable also behaved in an indifferent manner.<br />

Narayan states that if this was the treatment meted to a lawyer then how would they behave with a<br />

common man. Thereafter the lawyers took a procession to the town and submitted a memorandum to<br />

the CI of Malure demanding the dismissal of Salim Nathar, under the condition of resorting to a hunger<br />

strike.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-19/08<br />

Victim(s) : Nelson<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : KGF City<br />

Date of incident : 22/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Nelson, aged 35 is a resident of Marikuppam under KGF. On 22 February 2008 the Municipal<br />

Council President Elections were about to take place. At that time two dharnas were organized by the<br />

CPM and the Congress Party respectively, in front of the Municipal Office demanding their kidnapped<br />

Councilors to be produced. Nelson was standing at the side of the road observing the struggle. Suddenly<br />

police arrived at the scene and began to charge everybody with lathis. They also opened charge on the<br />

onlookers including the victim. Nelson was injured and he fled to the park, where also he was thrice<br />

struck by another lathi charge. He left the place immediately and received treatment in a hospital. The<br />

same day police announced that the elections were postponed to 1 March 2008. The victim is not<br />

interested to pursue case against the police considering this as a silly matter.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

125<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-42/08<br />

Victim(s) : Pradeep<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Vasanth, PC<br />

Location : KGF<br />

Date of incident : 28/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Pradeep, aged 22 is a student of KGF First Grade College. After the classes were over the victim<br />

and his friends used to gather at a place and chatted for a while. Their girl friends also accompanied<br />

them once in a while. During such times police constables would come and threaten the students. They<br />

would also carry away the mobile. This was going on for a long time. On 28 March 2008 when Pradeep<br />

was discussing with his girl friend regarding the class lessons a constable named Vasanth inquired<br />

them alleging them of being lovers. He took away Pradeep’s mobile and asked him to arrange for<br />

Rs.500 under the threat of informing their parents. Finally the constable threatened to book Pradeep<br />

under a false case if he failed to give the money. The victim doesn’t want to spoil his girl friend’s<br />

reputation and hence he is hiding the matter and negotiating with the constable.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-56/08<br />

Victim(s) : Rama Krishna<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Traffic Police<br />

Location : Chinthamani<br />

Date of incident : 24/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Rama Krishna, aged 50 is a conductor with Balaji Bus Service from Chinthamani to Bangalore.<br />

There are timings fixed for the departure of buses. But few buses fail to abide by the time constraints. This<br />

led to a quarrel along the drivers and conductors but it was often resolved. But the same problem arose<br />

repeatedly and having gained knowledge of this the traffic police involved in the matter and charged the<br />

drivers and conductors with lathis. Though the police and the RTO are aware of this situation they never<br />

took the issue seriously. On 24 February 2008 there was an argument with the driver and conductor of<br />

Annapoorna Bus. The argument developed into a clash and ultimately paved way for police lathi<br />

charge. Rama Krishna was injured on his neck and thereafter taken to the hospital. The victim is not<br />

interested in lodging complaints against the police, for he states that he has to abide with them or he might<br />

lose the job.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-31/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ramu<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Rajanna, SI<br />

Location : Anderson Pet, KGF City<br />

Date of incident : 11/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Ramu (35), S/o Pushpam is a resident of Anderson Pet. The victim belongs to the Adi Dravidar<br />

community. Ramu’s father was a famous contractor and he had bought a plot near Frank and Co. Few<br />

people fought over this land and often caused trouble. The case was taken to the court and the judgment<br />

fell in favour of the victim. But on 11 March 2008 when Ramu went to the site he noticed his opponent<br />

entering the site with the help of SI Rajanna of Champion Reef Police Station. The SI forced the victim to<br />

come to and understanding with his opponents and from then he began to torture Ramu mentally. The<br />

victim has once again approached the court.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-06/08<br />

Victim(s) : Ruplappa Nanappa Lamani<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Police; 2) Excise Officials<br />

Location : Channali, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 26/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Ruplappa Nanappa Lamani, aged 55 is a resident of Channali under Hirekerur Taluk. On 26<br />

January 2008 few police and women excise officials barged into the house of the victim accusing him<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

126<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


of producing hooch. The police assaulted the family members, and threw all the articles in the name of<br />

searching. They also misbehaved with the women. As Ruplappa was tired after work he had kept two<br />

liters of liquor at home to take it in night but the police accused him of preparing hooch. Thus the police<br />

have made it mandatory to raid the houses of poor people and torture them. On the contrary they close<br />

their eyes to the liquor barons who produce liquor without license. Therefore Ruplappa seeks justice<br />

against the activities of the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-11/08<br />

Victim(s) : Savitramma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Police; 2) Forest Officials<br />

Location : Shindenahalli, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 02/20/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Savitramma, aged 38 is a resident of Shindenahalli under Mysore district. Six months back the<br />

family of the victim worked for the forest department under the scheme ‘food for work’. Savitramma and<br />

her family worked for nearly Rs.80, 000. When asked for the payment the forest officials gave some teak<br />

wood in compensation. However on 2 February 2008 some policemen and forest officials made a<br />

sudden visit to their village and took away some wooden equipment from Savitramma’s house. As the<br />

victim resisted this she was pushed down, thereby causing injuries on her hand and back. Savitramma<br />

urges action against the officials who carried away her instruments by blindly following the words of few<br />

jealous people. The victim states that DCF Vinay Kumar, Dy.S.P Mahadevaiah, CPI Sundar Raj and<br />

ACF Prasanna Kumar were the officials who caused her all the trouble.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

127<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-23/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shantappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Byadagi<br />

Date of incident : 12/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Shantappa is a farmer residing in Binnihalli village under Byadagi Taluk. On 12 March 2008 the<br />

victim missed the last bus from Byadagi Bus Stand to his village. Therefore he slept in the bus stand<br />

itself. A police constable asked Shantappa the reason for lying there. Though the victim explained the<br />

truth the police put his hand into the shirt pocket of Shantappa and tried to snatch the money. When the<br />

victim resisted he was forced to come to the station. However Shantappa agreed to come to the station<br />

for which he was severely assaulted with a lathi. The victim sought the help of a shop owner, from whom<br />

the police demanded Rs.500. Finally after he was bribed with Rs.100 Shantappa was set free from his<br />

clutches.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-09/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shivakumar<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Harohalli village, Mandya<br />

Date of incident : 28/02/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Shivakumar, aged 29 is a resident of Harohalli village under Mandya district. The victim is a<br />

bachelor and one among three brothers in his house. Shiva practices agriculture with the income of<br />

which he manages his expenses. On 28 February 2008 while the victim was returning home riding his<br />

cycle from Pandavapura, he was assaulted by few men. Shiva sustained grievous injuries. The matter<br />

was brought to the panchayat, and nearly 400 people gathered to discuss on this issue. Suddenly a<br />

team of police men arrived at the scene and assaulted all the people including the aged. The ASP and<br />

KSRP Force were active in doing this. They charged the people including the victim with lathis. Shiva<br />

was further injured and somehow escaped from the place. The police on the other hand state that they<br />

had come to the area in connection to the scuffle that took place during the kabaddi match and also added<br />

that the group of 400 people pelted stones at them, for which they had resorted to lathi charge.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

128<br />

FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-02/08<br />

Victim(s) : Srinivasa Poojari<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Srirangapatina, Mandya<br />

Date of incident : 06/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Srinivasa Poojari is a gold smith residing in Srirangapatina under Mandya district. The victim<br />

also owns agricultural land which he cultivates depending on the rainfall. Srinivasa’s father is also a<br />

goldsmith and all the people in the village consult him before purchasing any gold ornament. On 6<br />

January 2008 the victim’s father had been to Srirangapatina. On his return in his friend’s bike he met with<br />

an accident and died on the spot. Many people gathered around and began talking about the<br />

compensation. In the meantime Srinivasa too arrived at the spot. The police also came soon and<br />

requested the body to be taken for post mortem. The victim and the mob protested demanding spot<br />

compensation. The police on the other hand resorted to lathi charge. Many people got injured. By then<br />

Inspector Jayaram came there and accepted to give immediate compensation.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-28/2008<br />

Victim(s) : Shyamsunder<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Ramesh, PC, Vijayanagar PS<br />

Location : Rani Bahaddur Hall<br />

Date of incident : 28/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Shyamsunder was a MBA student at Mysore University. On 28 January, 2008 he had gone<br />

to Rani Bahaddur Seminar Hall to collect reading materials. Meantime there was a book release<br />

function at the hall, which was presided by the former Minister K.H. Vishwanath. There was an argument<br />

between the dignitaries and Congress Party men. The victim Shyamsunder was witnessing the incident<br />

from the corner.<br />

The people have started vandalizing the articles. The Vijayanagara police started lathi charge on the<br />

mob. The victim Shymasunder was beaten by a police constable. He had pleaded that he was a college<br />

student, but the police were least bothered. The victim Shyamsunder sustained heavy injury on his left<br />

thigh due to lathi charge. Later one of the college staffs had taken him to the hospital.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

129<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/M-02/08<br />

Victim(s) : Siddartha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : CCB Police<br />

Location : Ashoka Road, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 14/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Siddartha (23), S/o Sumati Lal Jain assists his father in jewelry, and pawn business. They have<br />

the official license to do pawn brokerage business. On 14 January 2008 while Siddartha’s father was<br />

away from the city, few policemen came to the shop and inquired the victim about some stolen jewel.<br />

Siddartha denied knowledge about the same, and requested the policemen to come after his father<br />

arrives. One of the police scolded Siddartha and another police caught hold of his collar trying to push<br />

him into the police van. The neighbouring shop owners chased the van and stopped it neat the toll gate.<br />

The police inside the van revealed that they were from the Crime Branch of Bangalore. Due to pressure<br />

from the public Siddartha was taken to the Crime Branch at Mysore. The ACP of Mysore CCB<br />

requested for a compromise with the Jewelry Association, and as for now the issue had been closed.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-22/08<br />

Victim(s) : Sivappa<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Sheela Daaradkar, Excise Inspector, Hirekerur<br />

Location : Kannalli Thanda<br />

Date of incident : 12/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

The victim Sivappa was a resident of Kannalli Thanda. On 12 March, 2008 when the victim was<br />

washing his face, the police and the excise officer had gone to his house. They have beaten him<br />

indiscriminately and have claimed that he had concealed liquor illegally. Though the victim had told them<br />

that he did not have any connection with the illegal liquor, the police have arrested him. The police have<br />

often entered into that area and have harassed the people. The people of Kannalli Thanda were poor<br />

and remained calm due to fear of police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-39/08<br />

Victim(s) : Srinivas<br />

Perpetrator(s) : P. Shiva Kumar, CI<br />

Location : Malure village, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 20/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Srinivas, aged 42 is a resident of Beda Setty Halli village under Malure Taluk. 20 March 2008<br />

was celebrated as Sakranti festival in the village, on occasion of which there used to be a bullock race,<br />

wherein people from other villages participated. But on the day CI Shiva Kumar came and banned the<br />

race stating that it was a Supreme Court judgment. Since many outsiders had come, there was a heated<br />

argument regarding this, which led to a severe lathi charge. The police also used tear gas and fired in<br />

the air. The local villagers managed to hide inside their houses but the outsiders were grievously injured<br />

including the victim. Srinivas was injured on his shoulder and he took treatment at home itself. The victim<br />

is not interested in pursuing case against the police.<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-01/08<br />

Victim(s) : Uday Shetty<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 31/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Uday Shetty, aged 23 is a resident of Haveri, and runs a bar attached with a non-vegetarian hotel.<br />

On 31 January 2008 few police officials came to the victim’s bar and drank. They also ate from the<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

130<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


attached non-vegetarian hotel. As the supplier finally gave the bill to the police they didn’t agree to pay on<br />

the reason that they were police. Uday asked them politely to pay the bill but the police began abusing<br />

him and assaulted him in the presence of other customers. Suddenly a man from the press helped the<br />

victim to get away from the hands of the police. Uday sternly told the policemen not to come to the bar<br />

again without paying the bill. This enraged the policemen that they assaulted him again and tore his shirt.<br />

The victim lodged a complaint to ASP Manjunath who advised him to file a complaint at the City Police<br />

Station. Lately Uday came to know that the police officials who had assaulted him were suspended from<br />

duty.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-40/08<br />

Victim(s) : Umesh<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) CI; 2) SI<br />

Location : Davanagare, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 09/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Umesh, aged 32 is a resident of Davanagare under Somwarpete Taluk. The victim is working as<br />

a driver. On 9 th May 2008 Umesh was coming with his colleagues in a goods vehicle. The road was<br />

curvy and the van was about to collide with a police jeep coming in the opposite direction near Somwarpete.<br />

Umesh managed to avoid colliding and stopped the vehicle a little farther. The CI came and slapped the<br />

victim. He abused Umesh and assaulted him with a lathi on his chest and shoulders. The victim and his<br />

colleagues were taken to the police station and charged a fine of Rs.300. Umesh states that this incident<br />

had caused him great humiliation and the public misunderstood him as a liquor supplier for the election<br />

campaign.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

131<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-04/08<br />

Victim(s) : Vasanth<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Mallanna, PC<br />

Location : Shanivara Santhe, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : 07/12/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Vasanth, aged 45 is a resident of Muluve village under Kodagu district. The victim belongs to the<br />

Achari caste and earns his livelihood by working as a coolie. On 7 December 2007 Vasanth was<br />

having a word with his cousin and advised him not to take his wife to police officials, particularly to<br />

Constable Mallanna. The cousin grew angry and beat up Vasanth. The victim was injured on his lips<br />

and he went to the hospital the next day; but doctor Naveen didn’t administer good treatment. A constable<br />

from the police station came and took his statement. Vasanth was then summoned to the police station<br />

in the absence of the SI, and filed under a false attempt to murder case. Later when the victim approached<br />

the SI he suggested him to take bail. In the meantime Constable Mallanna threatened Vasanth not to<br />

interfere in his matter or he would be subjected to severe torture.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-03/08<br />

Victim(s) : Veerabhadrappa Hosalli<br />

Perpetrator(s) : M.M. Nadhaf, SI<br />

Location : Haveri<br />

Date of incident : January 2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Veerabhadrappa Hosalli, aged 38 is a resident of Mageda under Haveri district. The victim works<br />

as a clerk in a Lorry Transport Company for the past fifteen years. Veerabhadrappa states that police<br />

regularly collected bribe from the lorry drivers every month. It was a kind of adjustment between the<br />

drivers and the police though the act was an illegal one. However the present the SI started a practice of<br />

standing in the outskirts of the city and collecting fee from every vehicle. If anybody didn’t pay that vehicle<br />

will be charged penalty, and the driver will be abused with filthy words. He also used to visit some poor<br />

colonies at midnight and disturbed the people, and particularly if there were only women he used to<br />

abuse them. The members of Lorry Association represented before the SP and lodged complaints<br />

against the SI. Following the complaints lodged by the victims the SI was suspended from duty having<br />

found him guilty of taking bribe from mines lorry.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

132<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-26/08<br />

Victim(s) : Vinay Manjaiah Gunduru Mata<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Savanur, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 21/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Vinay Manjaiah Gunduru Mata, aged 16 is a resident of Savanur under Haveri district. The<br />

victim is working as a salesperson in a textile. On 21 March 2008 while Vinay was in his work place<br />

there was a sudden clash between some people. The victim’s owner instructed all the workers to close<br />

the shop and go home. Accordingly the shop was closed and all were about to leave. Suddenly police<br />

chased them and charged them with lathis. Vinay was severely injured on his hands and legs. Later on<br />

he was hospitalized and now he feels better. Vinay also states that poor people like him are not treated<br />

well in the GH, for the doctors listen to influential persons only. After this incident the victim and his family<br />

members are leading a life of fear because of the police.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-27/08<br />

Victim(s) : Yankanagowda Ninganagowda Patila<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Savanur, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 21/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Yankanagowda Ninganagowda Patila, aged 40 is a resident of Savanur under Haveri district.<br />

The victim is working as a salesperson in a textile. On 21 March 2008 there was a clash between two<br />

caste groups with regard to business. The issue became severe and all the shop keepers began to<br />

shut down their shops. Yankanagowda also closed the shop and sat in the terrace. Suddenly police<br />

barged into the shop and assaulted the victim in the terrace. Yankanagowda was beaten with lathis and<br />

kicked with shod legs. He states that the assault was so severe and he still can’t walk properly, and is<br />

under medication. Yankanagowda feels that such problems arise due to the influence of politicians, and<br />

the police also aid them in such activities. Now the victim is frightened about what the police might do at<br />

any time.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

133<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Annual Report on Torture<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

134<br />

08 -Extrajudicial Killing<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/MAN/M-10/08<br />

Victim(s) : Krishne Gowda<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Ningaiah; 2) Police<br />

Location : Kalikamba temple, Mandya<br />

Date of incident : January 2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Krishne Gowda resides behind the Kalikamba temple. He rears cattle with the income of which he<br />

manages his life. On a particular day when Krishne Gowda was walking near his house he witnessed<br />

a boy being beaten up by a security guard named Ningaiah. Krishne prevented the man taking the help<br />

of his friends. Later on the same boy was chased by a lorry driver and late at night on the same day the<br />

duty police of that area assaulted the boy tying him to a coconut tree. This too was witnessed by Krishne<br />

Gowda. The next day he received news of the boy’s death, and that the body was lying in the temple<br />

premises. The body of the deceased has many injuries on the stomach. The body was also swollen<br />

and blood was coming out of the mouth. The corpse was then shifted to the GH. At the hospital Krishne<br />

Gowda looked at the police and said that they were responsible for this, but the Inspector signaled him<br />

to keep silent. All the police were behaving indifferently at the hospital. Krishne Gowda desires stringent<br />

action against the police.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

135<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


Annual Report on Torture<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

09. Police Rape (Violence against Women)<br />

136<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-58/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Badrunissa; 2) Mahamadi Salma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Amzad; 2) Suhel; 3) Fazal; 4) Zeelan; 5) Muni Krishnappa, SI<br />

Location : Sidlagatta PS, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 28/09/2007<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Badrunissa, aged 48 resides in Mehaboob Nagar under Sidlagatta Taluk. The victim is a daily<br />

wage worker in a local silk factory and has a daughter named Mahamadi Salma and a son named<br />

Syed Mohammad Pasha. Salma, aged 17 was studying 9 Standard in a Government Junior College.<br />

The above mentioned perpetrators often teased her while she went to school. The husband of Badrunissa<br />

deserted her long back and hence the mother and daughter didn’t make this matter an issue for they<br />

were lonely. On 28 September 2007 Salma never returned from school and Badrunissa went to lodge<br />

a complaint at Sidlagatta Police Station. But the SI drove her away stating that her daughter might have<br />

eloped with someone. Finally the victim approached a Councilor who in turn took her to Chintamani<br />

Police Station. The SI of this station talked with the SI of Sidlagatta Police Station asking him to register<br />

the complaint. SI Muni Krishnappa was enraged at this, and when Badrunissa went to Sidlagatta Police<br />

Station he assaulted her along with Amzad and Zeelan. They told her that Salma was in Mumbai and<br />

warned her not to disclose it to anybody if she wanted to see her. Salma was allowed to be with her<br />

mother for three days and on 26 October 2007 she was again taken back to Mumbai. Once again<br />

Badrunissa filed a complaint but no action was taken upon it. She also gave an interview in ‘Udaya TV<br />

along with a press release but all in vain. As of now Badrunissa is residing in an Ashram. She requests<br />

that her only daughter comes back.<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-24/08<br />

Victim(s) : DK. Saraswathamma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Heera Mut, SI; 2) Shiva Kumar, CI<br />

Location : Malure PS, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 04/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim DK Saraswathamma, aged 40 is a civil advocate. The victim had taken up a land dispute case,<br />

and she took the order of the court regarding the case to Malure Police Station. Saraswathamma<br />

requested SI Heera Mut to provide protection for her client but he didn’t respond properly. The victim<br />

then met CI Shiva Kumar, who too reacted in the same manner. The SI then kicked Saraswathamma<br />

out of the police station with the help of a lady constable. It was a very shameful moment for the victim<br />

and her profession. Later Saraswathamma approached the Lawyers’ Association and submitted a<br />

memorandum to the DC and the SP. All the advocates boycotted the court and organized a dharna in<br />

front of the DC Office. SP Yellappa received the memorandum and assured to take action, following<br />

which the dharna was withdrawn.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

137<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-03/08<br />

Victim(s) : Geetha<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Eswar; 2) Police<br />

Location : Sanjaygandhi Nagar, Robertsganj<br />

Date of incident : 02/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Geetha (30), W/o Eswar is a resident of Sanjaygandhi Nagar under Robertsganj. The victim’s<br />

husband is an auto driver. She has four children and carrying an 8 month babe. Geetha gained<br />

knowledge of her husband’s illegal relationship and questioned him regarding this, for he often came<br />

home late. Eswar would get angry at this and beat her up including the children. On 2 January 2008<br />

there was a serious clash between Geetha and Eswar that the latter threatened of pouring acid on her<br />

face. Geetha managed to escape but the bottle tilted and fell on Eswar’s face and other parts of the body.<br />

He was then hospitalized by their neighbours. The police came for inquiry and Eswar alleged Geetha<br />

of deliberately pouring acid on him. The President of Auto Drivers’ Association spoke with the victim’s<br />

husband for a compromise but he refused. Finally Geetha was arrested the same night, for the police<br />

didn’t believe her statement. She is presently under judicial custody, and there is nobody to support her<br />

in availing bail.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

138<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-07/08<br />

Victim(s) : Glory<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Shanthappa, SI<br />

Location : Marikuppam<br />

Date of incident : 04/05/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Glory, aged 45 is a resident of Marikuppam Telugu Line. The victim’s father is a BGML Employee<br />

and the family has been residing in the company quarters since three generations. There is a company<br />

school wherein the victim’s son studies. The head master of the school had illegal contacts with the<br />

cooks which Glory’s son witnessed. So the head master bribed the police to arrest the boy. After this<br />

happening the head master began to harass the victim’s family. He also burned down their house. Glory<br />

lodged an FIR regarding this but the head master managed to come out on bail. On 4 May 2008 SI<br />

Shanthappa asked the victim to report at the police station. When she went there the SI told her that the<br />

head master had received a letter from the BEO to have the victim vacated from her house. Then Glory<br />

approached BGML Housing Concern Officer and Dy.S.P Shiva Kumar. He assured that the SI will no<br />

more interfere in the case. But the SI began harassing the victim having received bribe from the hands<br />

of the head master.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-25/08<br />

Victim(s) : 1) Jagadishwari; 2) Muniyamma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : K.N. Ramesh<br />

Location : Chinthamani Bus stand<br />

Date of incident : 04/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Jagadishwari, aged 30 is the Zilla President of Janavadi Mahila Sanga. The victim belongs to the<br />

Scheduled Caste community. Jagadishwari’s mother Muniyamma is a fruit vendor, selling at Chinthamani<br />

Bus Stand using a push cart. On 4 March 2008 CI Ramesh began to chase away the vendors using<br />

his lathi. He also assaulted Maniyamma causing her immense pain. When she questioned him the CI<br />

grew ferocious and began to beat her brutally. He even distributed the fruits to the people around. When<br />

Jagadishwari prevented him from beating her mother the CI assaulted her also and broke her bangles,<br />

causing severe bleeding. Though the victim cried that she was the president of a woman’s organization<br />

the CI paid no heed and tortured even more. When Jagadishwari tried calling the convener the CI<br />

snatched the mobile off her hands and started beating on her back. As the victim fell down he kicked her<br />

with shod legs and beat with a lathi. Thus the CI assaulted Jagadishwari and her mother alternatively. At<br />

present Muniyamma is in judicial custody.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

139<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-26/08<br />

Victim(s) : Jayanthi N.M<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Medhappa; 2) Chandrakala; 3) Bhagirathi; 4) Police<br />

Location : Siddapura PS, Kodagu<br />

Date of incident : March 2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Jayanthi N.M, aged 43 is a resident of Nellihudikere/ The victim belongs to Kodava community.<br />

She has done M.A and currently taking care of her estate. Now Jayanthi is an orphan and is leading a<br />

life as a spinster. She has a brother named Medhappa, sister-in-law Chandrakala and another widowed<br />

sister-in-law Bhagirathi, all of whom are putting threat to her life in relation to the property issue. The<br />

fencing which was made around Jayanthi’s estate under the protection of the police had been removed<br />

by her family members thereby causing her a loss of Rs.5000. When Jayanthi went to file a complaint<br />

at Siddapura Police Station the brother-in-law of Kumar, who is a constable filed a counter complaint<br />

against the victim thereby denying her justice. The victim alleges that though the above mentioned<br />

perpetrators are the real culprits the police have filed a complaint against her. She desires protection<br />

from the police but is denied of the same.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-07/08<br />

Victim(s) : Kamali Bai Lakakappa Lamani<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Dharwad Jail, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 26/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Kamali Bai Lakakappa Lamani, aged 45 is a resident of Chanalui under Hirekerur Taluk. The<br />

victim manages her family by rearing cattle. On 26 January 2008, police barged into the house of<br />

Kamali, alleging her of producing hooch. They demanded her to go with them to the jail. When the victim<br />

defended she was assaulted by a lady police and taken to Dharwad Jail, where Kamali was detained for<br />

a day. Though the victim was set free the next day she underwent mental harassment and has lost her<br />

social reputation. The small children in her house were also frightened at the sight of the police and are<br />

living in fear. Kamali is very depressed for this is the first time her family has stepped into the police<br />

station.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

140<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOD/M-05/08<br />

Victim(s) : Manjula<br />

Perpetrator(s) : SI<br />

Location : Shanivara Santhe PS, Somwarpete<br />

Date of incident : January 2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Manjula (35), W/o (Late) Ananda is a resident of Chaudanahalli village falling under the jurisdiction<br />

of Shanivara Santhe Police Station. The victim has two sons namely Abhishek and Avinash. On 5 th<br />

July 2007 Manjula’s husband passed away in a natural calamity and thereby the government released<br />

a sum of Rs.50,000 to her as relief package but the victim’s mother-in-law and sister-in-law took away<br />

the amount by making false records and signatures. Manjula’s mother-in-law often harassed her that<br />

she lived separately, owing to which the latter was spreading false information about her daughter-inlaw.<br />

Even though Manjula lodged complaints at Shanivara Santhe Police Station it was in vain, because<br />

the SI stood in favour of her opponents. After a week when the victim went to the police station regarding<br />

the follow up the SI forcibly caused her to sign on a paper, demanding her to accept Rs.5,000 each in<br />

her two children’s name. This entire incident took place in front of her mother-in-law, sister-in-law,<br />

lawyer Jayendra and Nirvanappa, a Community Party leader. Manjula states that the police have not<br />

taken any step in favour of her. The SI has not helped her for he has been bribed by politicians to work<br />

in favour of the perpetrators. Therefore Manjula seeks stringent action against the SI and justice for her<br />

in this case.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-23/08<br />

Victim(s) : Muniyamma<br />

Perpetrator(s) : K.N. Ramesh, CI<br />

Location : Chinthamani<br />

Date of incident : 04/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Muniyamma, aged 62 is a resident of Boombazar under Chinthamani Taluk. The victim has<br />

three children. Her second daughter Jagadishwari is the President of Janavadi Mahila Sanga (a<br />

woman’s organization). Muniyamma is a fruit vendor. On 4 March 2008 while the victim was selling<br />

she was driven out by CI K.N. Ramesh, who also distributed the fruits to the passersby without permission.<br />

When Muniyamma questioned him she was beaten up severely. The CI caught hold of her hair and<br />

assaulted on her back. When Jagadishwari tried to prevent him she was also beaten up. The CI broke<br />

her bangles causing severe bleeding. Meanwhile the public gathered, following which the victims were<br />

taken to Chinthamani Police Station. Thereafter Muniyamma was taken to Sidlagatta Judicial Magistrate,<br />

and sent to judicial custody. After two days she came out on bail.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

141<br />

FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-51/08<br />

Victim(s) : Rehamathulla<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Prasad, HC<br />

Location : Sidlagatta, Kolar<br />

Date of incident : 03/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Rehamathulla, aged 42 is a resident of Mehaboob nagar under Sidlagatta town. The victim has<br />

two daughters. On 3 March 2008, when Rehamathulla was supplying water on her vehicle HC Prasad<br />

came near her and questioned about the tanker, as to why it was placed on the road. The victim<br />

understood that he had come to collect bribe and replied rudely. He grew angry and started beating<br />

Rehamathulla and her daughter who was nearby. All the people from Elahi Nagar gathered and questioned<br />

the HC. They became angry and picketed in front of the Travelers’ Bungalow and many others<br />

organized a dharna in front of the Town Police Station. The Jamati leader also joined the dharna. Then<br />

SI Ramappa Guttar of Rural Police Station arrived at the place and tried to convince, but the protesters<br />

stood adamant to get the HC dismissed. CI Sampath Kumar called up and assured that action would be<br />

taken, following which the dharna was withdrawn. But till date no action has followed.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-38/08<br />

Victim(s) : Sabina Begaum<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Police Driver 2) K.N. Ramesh, CI<br />

Location : Chinthamani PS<br />

Date of incident : 07/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Sabina Begaum (42), W/o Mushtaq is a resident of Gajana Circle Muslim Colony under<br />

Chinthamani town. The victim’s husband is a daily wage labourer and Sabina prepares ‘agarbathis’ at<br />

home. She normally dries the agarbathis in front of her house. On a particular day a police jeep entered<br />

the village and drove upon the bathis smashing all of them. Sabina questioned the driver angrily that CI<br />

K.N. Ramesh got off the jeep and caught hold of the victim’s hair, and dragged her to the jeep. He abused<br />

Sabina with vulgar words and took her to Chinthamani Police Station. At the station the victim was<br />

caused to sit on the floor. Then the youth of the area came to the police station and negotiated with the CI,<br />

following which Sabina was sent off. The Janavadi Mahila Santayana also came and discussed about<br />

the incident. Hence Sabina is not interested to lodge complaints against the police since the matter is<br />

settled.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

142<br />

FF Code : KAR/MYS/ PT/M-49/08<br />

Victim(s) : Saraswathi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Rajagopal<br />

Location : Yadavagiri railway quarters, Mysore<br />

Date of incident : 21/04/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Saraswathi, aged 38 is the W/o Bopaiah. She resides at yadavagiri railway quarters in Mysore district.<br />

She worked as a house maid at Rajagopal’s house who is a traffic inspector. On 21 April 2008<br />

Saraswati was packing up Rajagopal’s clothes in his suitcase. Rajagopal offered her cool drinks.<br />

Saraswathi fainted after taking the cool drink. Later she espied that Rajagopal had physically abused her.<br />

Later that evening Saraswathi’s son came in search of his mother and found her lying nude. He took the<br />

help of the neighbors and admitted her in the hospital. The next day Saraswathi went to the police station<br />

to give a complaint against Rajagopal but the police had not taken any action against the perpetrator<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007


FF Code : KAR/KOL/M-28/08<br />

Victim(s) : Shanthi<br />

Perpetrator(s) : 1) Mariyamma; 2) Adiappa, ASI<br />

Location : Oorgaum, KGF<br />

Date of incident : 13/03/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Shanthi, aged 46 is a resident of Kennedy’s Telugu Line under Oorgaum. The victim belongs to<br />

Adi Andra (SC) community. On 13 March 2008 Shanthi was discussing with her neighbour Mariyamma<br />

regarding a quarrel. At the same time the daughter of the latter threw stones at the victim’s house and<br />

broke the AC Sheet. In the meantime few other women in the locality lodged complaints at Oorgaum<br />

Police Station in favour of Mariyamma. Accordingly ASI Adiappa came and arrested Shanthi and her<br />

son. At the station the ASI abused them with filthy words, thereby causing them shame. A petty case was<br />

filed against the victims, and they were produced before the court. The ASI states that there were more<br />

witnesses on the side of Mariyamma and that the reason he had arrested Shanthi and her son.<br />

<strong>Karnataka</strong><br />

143<br />

FF Code : KAR/HAV/M-04/08<br />

Victim(s) : Sumangala Ramappa Madiwalara<br />

Perpetrator(s) : Police<br />

Location : Hanagal, Haveri<br />

Date of incident : 13/01/2008<br />

Case Details:<br />

Victim Sumangala Ramappa Madiwalara, aged 40 is a resident of Shiraguppan under Haveri district.<br />

The victim’s husband is the Secretary at Grama Panchayat. Sumangala was often tortured and harassed<br />

by her husband and in-laws over issues of work. She was never allowed to sit, and forced to go to the<br />

field or do another work. Several times her nose bled at their assault and while having meal they used<br />

to snatch the plate from her. Sumangala’s husband had illegal sexual affair with Lalitha, the President of<br />

Grama Panchayat. He always accused the victim for one reason or the other and abused her. Though<br />

Sumangala filed a complaint at the police station no action was taken in respect of that. One day the<br />

victim’s husband, Lalitha and her husband joined hands to assault Sumangala and filed a false complaint<br />

against her. Accordingly the victim was arrested and tortured at the station. Both men and lady police<br />

assaulted her and took away the mobile. Finally Sumangala was helped by a lawyer who took her out<br />

on bail. At present the victim is residing in her mother’s house. Her son too stood in support of his father<br />

and often harassed her. Sumangala thought of committing suicide many a times but desiring justice she<br />

managed to live till date. The victim alleges that her husband tried to kill her many times and also has the<br />

good support of the police.<br />

Annual Report on Torture<br />

2007

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!