What Is This Campaign About?

What Is This Campaign About? What Is This Campaign About?

peaceinst.org
from peaceinst.org More from this publisher
17.05.2014 Views

c) Structures created by the state in an ad hoc or planned manner. It is understood that an encroachment threatening an ecosystem is bad and is wrong irrespective of its origin, nature or legal status. Fortunately both the Supreme Court (SC) and the High Court of Delhi have been seized of this problem and have directed the state for taking action against encroachers from time to time ever since 1992 when an enlightened citizen of Delhi (Comdr Sureshwar D Sinha) first brought up the matter of the sad state of river Yamuna before the Hon SC. The worst irony and gross injustice happens when the lands which a re reportedly ‘recovered’ from During 2006 while JJ colonies in river flood plain between the Shahadara Bridge and the Nizamuddin Bridge were successfully relocated (under the supervision of the HC created Justice Usha Mehra Committee) similar encroachers both in Majnu Ka Tila and in areas south of DND managed to defy and remain. (one can see in this picture the Raj ghat Power plant in the back ground which itself is located in the flood plain) (Date of Photograph: 28 January 2007) Construction work going on (picture dated 28 January 2007) in the lands ‘freed’ from the Yamuna Pushta JJ colony ‘encroachers’ in 2004. The third kind of injustice happens when the state in its own wisdom decides to permit either an Akshardham or a power plant or a Secretariat or a Metro depot to come up in the same river bed and flood plain creating thereby the so called ‘authorized’ encroachments. the encroachers in the name of securing the river bed and reducing the pollution load from the river is later put to ‘developmental’ use/s by the same state. The other kind of injustice (as happened recently in 2006) happens when as a result of a drive against encroachment only few get up-rooted and rest who can ‘influence’ or ‘manage’ remain. Google picture, showing the under construction, Shastri Park Metro Station in the river bed The JJ colonies seen diagonally opposite the metro station (under construction) in the south of the old railway bridge were removed and relocated in 2006 2 What Is This Campaign About?

preventing the revival of river Yamuna. Even the judiciary while addressing the question of encroachments in the river has linked it only as a pollution issue rather than a issue about maintaining the integrity of the river ecosystem. While admittedly the rampant pollution of river Yamuna mainly in its 22 km stretch in Delhi is one of the major problems facing the river Yamuna it is firstly the question of the survival of the river as an ecosystem in its own right which should ideally take precedence over all other actions. If the river in its natural form is lost then clean water if ever available can as well flow in a channelised drain without the benefits accruing to the multitudes from a river system. Yamuna flood plain south of the ITO bridge under conversion for the Yamuna Depot of the Delhi Metro (Date of Photograph: 28 January 2007) Focussing on an encroacher only as an existing or potential polluter automatically targets the residents of either the JJ colonies or of the unauthorized colonies since these remaining outside the planned sewage management schemes of the state are assumed to be the key polluters. This approach presumes that the river is not getting polluted either by the power plants, or the metro stations or an Akhshardham or a games village. PENNY WISE AND POUND FOOLISH Signature Bridge or the Najafgarh Drain The Najafgarh drain that meets the river Yamuna just down stream of the Wazirabad Barrage (see picture) is reputedly the most polluting of all the 22 drains feeding the river in Delhi. (Date of Photograph: 28 January 200) There is a proposal to raise a games village for the 2010 Commonwealth Games in Delhi spread over 42.5 ha of the Yamuna flood plain next to the structure called Akshardham. THE ELEMENT OF ILLOGIC MISSING THE WOODS FOR THE TREES Treating an encroacher only as a polluter is missing the larger picture The state and most others concerned has it seems till date diagnosed only pollution as the key ill What Is This Campaign About? 3

preventing the revival of river Yamuna. Even the<br />

judiciary while addressing the question of<br />

encroachments in the river has linked it only as a<br />

pollution issue rather than a issue about maintaining<br />

the integrity of the river ecosystem.<br />

While admittedly the rampant pollution of river<br />

Yamuna mainly in its 22 km stretch in Delhi is one<br />

of the major problems facing the river Yamuna it is<br />

firstly the question of the survival of the river as an<br />

ecosystem in its own right which should ideally take<br />

precedence over all other actions. If the river in its<br />

natural form is lost then clean water if ever available<br />

can as well flow in a channelised drain without the<br />

benefits accruing to the multitudes from a river<br />

system.<br />

Yamuna flood plain south of the ITO bridge under conversion<br />

for the Yamuna Depot of the Delhi Metro (Date of Photograph:<br />

28 January 2007)<br />

Focussing on an encroacher only as an existing or<br />

potential polluter automatically targets the residents<br />

of either the JJ colonies or of the unauthorized<br />

colonies since these remaining outside the planned<br />

sewage management schemes of the state are<br />

assumed to be the key polluters. <strong>This</strong> approach<br />

presumes that the river is not getting polluted either<br />

by the power plants, or the metro stations or an<br />

Akhshardham or a games village.<br />

PENNY WISE AND POUND FOOLISH<br />

Signature Bridge or the Najafgarh Drain<br />

The Najafgarh drain that meets the river Yamuna<br />

just down stream of the Wazirabad Barrage (see<br />

picture) is reputedly the most polluting of all the 22<br />

drains feeding the river in Delhi. (Date of<br />

Photograph: 28 January 200)<br />

There is a proposal to raise a games village for the 2010<br />

Commonwealth Games in Delhi spread over 42.5 ha of the Yamuna<br />

flood plain next to the structure called Akshardham.<br />

THE ELEMENT OF ILLOGIC<br />

MISSING THE WOODS FOR THE TREES<br />

Treating an encroacher only as a polluter is<br />

missing the larger picture<br />

The state and most others concerned has it seems<br />

till date diagnosed only pollution as the key ill<br />

<strong>What</strong> <strong>Is</strong> <strong>This</strong> <strong>Campaign</strong> <strong>About</strong>?<br />

3

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!