1904 - 1913 - Parliament of New South Wales

1
,
- ~X-xyfii 'INDEX.
I AssRMBLY JOINT
REVERENCES TO THE VOTES AND PROCEZI)INGS, VOL. 1-22ND PARLIAMENT-SESSION 1911-1 .912 .
. ; -
VOLUMES . VOLUMES .
I
I
I
VOL.
PAGE .
SPEAKER (con,
Tur, HoNoi
Motion ( .
of or(
Writ issu
Pleas, &c
DisSENT IPR(
Decision I
Gove
That he c
That the
MoVe
to all
the 0
That a Qt
to Ila
and i
That the
prov ;
That it
ThcHoi
of his
The refusi
That a 11101
,to alIj
of free'
negat
That lie ca
with 1-1
That the cl
;altlioul
(111r . ,
Dissm,111 FRO
Removal 0~1
!ruled ~
Rumxcs or :
That when
House
That a mill
'Rulinj
Thata mot
Willis
entere
That the it
.
had bt
That the n
the co
tor diE
That a mo
order,
That the
was it
That inoti
out o
That it w
LE TIENRY WlLLI-, :-
'r . Levy), with reference to Aaec6mciit between the Government and, ruled out
r, 12 .
I against, by the '.Honorable John Perry, 15 .
in case Perry v.,*219 . . . .
. . . . . . .
I RULING
leave the Chair, without Quesfion put, after returning from hearing the Lieutenantor's
Speoch delivered, and negativod (Mr. Cohf.-u), 9 .
i oil h.is own authority postpone .a private Member's - motion duly set down oil the
ss Paper, and negatived (Alr . Cohen), 13 .
otion of urgency which the Honorable Member for T)arlinghursbwas proceeding to
n reference to Notice of 116tion No . 32 oil the Notice Paper far thatday, in reieterice .
greerrient between tho'Government and the Honorable IlenrY Willis in reference to
cc of Speaker, was out of order, and negatived (jlfr . Levy), 17 .
stion asked by the Hon,)rablc Afember for Darlinghurst, that certain remarks alleged
heen inade :it Lithgow, its reported in the newspapers of that (lay, was out of order,
c the Ronorable Ncleniber would not vouch for the correctness of the said reports,
gati ved (31r. Levy), 20 .
otion " That the Spealter's words accusing the Honorable Alember for Gordon of
cation be taken down,"-was out of order, and negatived (Dr . Arthur), 27 .
its not in order to discuss i. motion dealing with the conduct of the Speaker," and
red (Hr. 11'ood), 48 .
Drable Nleml)cr is very much outof order in interrupting the Preirder in the delivery
pooch ; he must not continue to do so," and negatived (Mr . Brivsley Hall), 58 .
to place on Busin~3 .% Paper, of 28th September, it notice of motion of dissent front
duly given b.~ the Honorable Member for Darlinghurst, oil 27th September, and
negazi" ~ed (i)[r . Levy), 59-60 .
ion moved as it matter of Privilege, referring to the action of Mr. Speaker in refusing
v the Honorable Alember for Bega to address the House, depriving him of his right
specch, wits out of order, not .being it matter of Privilege, but one of order, and
,,ed ( .117% 11'ood), 60 .
i post-pone it question of Privilege and allow other business to intervene in accordance
tanding Order No . 159-afid ;House counted out (Mr. Price), 61 .
,bate oil the motion of Mr. Lovien thould terminate by calling Mr . Levien in reply,
,h Honorable Aletubers rose and wished to address the House, and negatived
I'ade), 225 .
a AMON :
'ithe 11morable e ons'e, Member (13h% for Darling Harbour from the Chamber when in the act of
-addre
Wood) Point q.f
Order, -That the motion proposed to dissent
~froni i ,n action not a ruling, Further Point qj 07-der,-That the conduct of 3\1r . Speaker
Autd r~ contly been under review, and that-his action'could not be again discussed,-
gainst, motion negatived, 0 231 .
there was no Standing Order,
.
resort . was had to the Custom and Proceedings of the
of CommoDs, 8, 13 . 1
I
;er of Privilege should take procedenne over the notice for Dissent from Speaker's
, 8, 13 .
on to discuss the agreenient between the Government and The Honorable Henry
,in reference to the offica of Speaker, was out of order as no agreement bad been
I into, 12 .
otion given notice of by the 11onorable Alember for Darliighurst (Mr . Levy), which
cii ruled out of order, was still out of order, fo~ the reasons previously given, 17 .
)tice of motion of the Honorable Member for Bega (Mr. lFood), which referred to
itinued infraction of the law of Parliament . was out of order ; a course wasprovided
ienting front the rulings of Mr . Speaker, 17 .
ion " That the Speaker's words be taken down " was obsolete, and therefore out of
19 .
fouse liad no cognisarice of what appeared in the Press, and therefore it motion
Ang certain statement- by Mr. Speaker respecting the Honorable Member for Gordon
t one of Privilpge, and was out of order, 19.
n (Mr . Levy) in reference tD expunging notices ot motions from Business Paper was
order, 29.
3 not in orier to discuss a motion dealing with the conduct of the Speaker, and
i was therefore out of order, 41 .
Thata ion tinder Privilege referring to the action ofNlr. Speaker in refusing the Honorable
3r for 13e(la ( All% I Praod) the. right to address the House oil a motion then before
,the H ~usc, depriving him of his right of free speech, was oU of order, not being a matter
of Pri rilege, 47-9 .
That the 'I otalizator Bill di& not,constitute a tax on tile revenue, and therefore did note require
. .a , .1A] es cage from the Governor, and was in order, S3.
.T .11at it 1110 lion which iappeared oil tho Bus'incss Paper, and had lapsed, could not be moved on
Ithe s, ~uie
N\7ayS
day as all amendment oil the reading of Order of the Day 'for Committee of
1,and A-leans, as it bad been dealt with, 121 .
That it wii 4 for the House to~determine whether aparagraph ~whiclr appeared in thePressshould
'be Pea
Thd , 1, 123.
t if til ~'Honori.tble Member 'for, Grq'rdow'(-NT r . 'W.ade)'had denied the statement made in the
,Daily Telegraph,'headed"I Air. -Speaker's Ruling-,\Ar 'Wade's 'Comolaint,"Ithe editor of
j~might then have .been summoned, but the .-Honor~ble Member had 'own6d up t~
; used'the words an'a ;wasvm*akiii-g,.i~is,de~fence; .~1-24.
55
-'-JL