Network News - Winter/Spring 2010 - Canadian Breast Cancer ...
Network News - Winter/Spring 2010 - Canadian Breast Cancer ...
Network News - Winter/Spring 2010 - Canadian Breast Cancer ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
A more recent case-control study<br />
looked at 472 postmenopausal BRCA1<br />
mutation carriers. 3 Women who<br />
developed breast cancer (cases) were<br />
compared with women who didn’t<br />
(controls) and researchers tried to<br />
determine whether prior HT use had<br />
influenced cancer risk. They found<br />
that use of HT was not a risk factor<br />
for developing breast cancer. In fact,<br />
women who used estrogen alone had<br />
a lower risk of breast cancer compared<br />
to women who did not use estrogen<br />
at all. It is not known whether results<br />
from this study also apply to BRCA2<br />
mutation carriers. BRCA1 cancers are<br />
commonly negative for estrogen and<br />
progesterone receptors, so they may be<br />
affected less by hormones.<br />
A model was designed to calculate<br />
life expectancy gains after rrBSO<br />
in BRCA 1 or 2 mutation carriers<br />
between 30 and 40 years of age. 4<br />
Data used to calculate risk of breast<br />
cancer associated with HT was from a<br />
general population of postmenopausal<br />
women, not BRCA mutation carriers<br />
or women who had undergone rrBSO.<br />
The analysis found that HT did not<br />
change life expectancy gains of rrBSO<br />
if women stopped taking the hormones<br />
by age 50. In this model, the gain in life<br />
expectancy with rrBSO ranged from<br />
3.34 to 4.65 years, depending on age<br />
at oophorectomy. The change in life<br />
expectancy with HT ranged from +0.17<br />
years to -0.34 years when HT was<br />
stopped at age 50.<br />
Bioidentical Hormone Therapy<br />
There are many HT products available<br />
in Canada. Hormone therapy must<br />
be individualized based on the effect<br />
it has on symptoms and any adverse<br />
effects that occur. Different products<br />
can have different effects and what<br />
works well for one woman doesn’t<br />
necessarily work as well for another.<br />
Many women have heard about<br />
“Bioidentical Hormone Therapy”<br />
(BHT). It may be promoted as a<br />
safer, more natural type of HT.<br />
The term “bioidentical” refers to a<br />
hormone that has the same chemical<br />
structure as one produced by the<br />
body. Examples include estradiol,<br />
estrone, estriol, progesterone and<br />
testosterone. Bioidentical hormones<br />
are commercially available in several<br />
well-tested Health Canada approved<br />
prescription products. BHT may also<br />
refer to custom compounded HT<br />
preparations that are mixed up at a<br />
compounding pharmacy. All BHT<br />
products, whether commercially<br />
manufactured or custom compounded,<br />
may help symptoms of surgical<br />
menopause. There is still no strong<br />
evidence that one type or brand of<br />
estrogen is safer than the others when<br />
it comes to breast cancer risk.<br />
Vaginal estrogen and testosterone<br />
Women with symptoms of vaginal<br />
dryness may use a vaginal estrogen<br />
product. Absorption into the body<br />
is minimal at recommended doses.<br />
Vaginal estrogen may be used along<br />
with systemic HT if necessary.<br />
Women may be interested in using<br />
testosterone for low sexual desire.<br />
Whether testosterone should be<br />
replaced after rrBSO is controversial.<br />
Many things affect sexual function<br />
in women, including relationship<br />
factors, stress, fatigue and overall<br />
health. Estrogen therapy may improve<br />
sexual desire and response by<br />
improving blood flow to the vagina<br />
and increasing lubrication. There<br />
are no commercially manufactured<br />
testosterone products available in<br />
Canada for women due to lack of longterm<br />
safety and efficacy data. Effect of<br />
testosterone on breast cancer risk is not<br />
known.<br />
An individual decision<br />
Many aspects of the effects of HT on<br />
breast cancer risk in BRCA mutation<br />
carriers are unknown. Caution is still<br />
advised. If HT is “bioidentical,” this<br />
does not guarantee that it is a safer HT<br />
without risks. Women should decide<br />
about short-term HT based on quality<br />
of life issues and consider stopping<br />
HT around the time when natural<br />
menopause would have occurred.<br />
Most importantly, the decision<br />
whether or not to use HT following<br />
rrBSO is an individual one. •<br />
References<br />
1. MacLennan et al. Cochrane Database<br />
Syst Rev. 2004;18(4)<br />
2. Rebbeck et al. J Clin Oncol. Nov<br />
2005;23(31):7804-10<br />
3. Eisen et al. J Natl <strong>Cancer</strong> Inst. Oct<br />
2008;100(19):1361-7<br />
4. Armstrong et al. J Clin Oncol. Mar<br />
2004;22(6):1045-54<br />
Jodi Wilkie, B.Sc.Pharm., is a pharmacist<br />
and North American Menopause Society<br />
credentialed Menopause Practitioner.<br />
She obtained her Bachelor of Science<br />
in Pharmacy with distinction from the<br />
University of Alberta and worked for<br />
many years as a community pharmacist<br />
with Safeway Pharmacy. This is where<br />
she developed an interest in women’s<br />
health and pursued this as a specialty. Jodi<br />
currently works in outpatient Women’s<br />
Health clinics, including Menopause and<br />
Obstetric Medicine clinics, at the Grey<br />
Nuns and Royal Alexandra hospitals in<br />
Edmonton.<br />
Subscribe to our<br />
e-letter, Outreach!<br />
Outreach is the <strong>Canadian</strong><br />
<strong>Breast</strong> <strong>Cancer</strong> <strong>Network</strong>’s free<br />
e-letter, which contains action<br />
alerts, info about our activities,<br />
programs and projects. You can<br />
find out about opportunities to<br />
join panels, do surveys, order<br />
reports, and much more! It is<br />
only available by e-mail. To<br />
subscribe, send an e-mail to<br />
cbcn@cbcn.ca or call Maureen<br />
at 1-800-685-8820 to sign up.<br />
16 <strong>Network</strong> <strong>News</strong> <strong>Winter</strong>/<strong>Spring</strong> <strong>2010</strong>