06.05.2014 Views

GORDON KEENE VELLA. - On Point News

GORDON KEENE VELLA. - On Point News

GORDON KEENE VELLA. - On Point News

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Psychological Association approved training program, and zero relevant research<br />

experience in the relevant field. (Barden Decl. 31.)<br />

o Dr. Brown claimed that the inclusion of “dissociative amnesia” in the DSM-IV<br />

provided evidence that the hypothesis of dissociative amnesia was generally<br />

accepted in the relevant scientific community. However, he failed to note that the<br />

DSM-IV lists dissociative amnesia as a “pseudoneurological symptom” or<br />

conversion system – symptoms that have no genuine neurological or medical<br />

basis. Moreover, Dr. Brown wholly failed to inform the Court that “pseudoseizures”<br />

– a condition attributed to Plaintiff by Brown – is contained in the very<br />

same list of pseudonueorlogical symptoms. (Pope Decl. 47-58.)<br />

o Dr. Brown failed to disclose the number of times he has been disqualified to<br />

testify as an expert witness on the topic of dissociative amnesia. Prior to his<br />

testimony in the Vella case, Dr. Brown is known to have been excluded from<br />

testifying as an expert witness on the hypothesis of dissociative amnesia in State<br />

of New Hampshire v. Hungerford and State of New Hampshire v. Walters, 698<br />

A.2d 1244 (N.H. 1997); State of New Hampshire vs. Phillip Bourgelais, Case No.<br />

02-S-2834, Judge Tina Nadeau, April 4, 2005. See State of Rhode Island v.<br />

Quattrocchi, C.A. No. P92-3759 (R.I. 1999). (Barden Decl. 26.)<br />

o Dr. Brown failed to apprise the Court of the history of the movement associated<br />

with dissociative amnesia, including theories concerning international satanic<br />

cults and CIA mind control experiments. (Barden Decl. 35-40.)<br />

CONCLUSION<br />

Dr. Brown’s numerous and varied misrepresentations, taken together, demonstrate either<br />

an intentional attempt to mislead this Court on the issue of dissociative amnesia, or demonstrate<br />

a truly reckless presentation of the facts concerning the hypothesis. Dr. Brown engaged in wordsmithing<br />

to suggest an error rate, where none is recognized by the relevant scientific community.<br />

Dr. Brown inexplicably cited to numerous publications as supportive of dissociative amnesia,<br />

- 24 -

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!