cr ft m sonry - Onondaga and Oswego Masonic District Historical ...

208 years of
CR FT M SONRY
in Onondaga County
New York
Part II
1826 to 2001
by
R∴W∴ Gary L. Heinmiller
Chancery Press
Liverpool, New York
May 2007
1

Craft Masonry – Part II
in Onondaga County, New York
1826-2001
by R.’.W.’. Gary L. Heinmiller, Director OMDHS - May 2007
Preface
The main archives for a history of Freemasonry consist largely of some of, or a combination of, the following:
Minute Books of a Lodge
Lodge Registers of Members
Proceedings of the Grand Lodge
Correspondence of Lodges and Grand Lodge
Programs, Anniversary Books or Booklets
Archives of Concordant Orders
Photos, engravings, newspaper articles
Town or County Histories
Diaries, Journals, Genealogical records
Books, Magazines, Rosters and Trestle Boards
Lodge records contain little in the way of biographical information on the average Brother, most often in the older Registers
consisting of a line-entry, giving the Lodge No., Grand Lodge No., Name, Initiating, Passing and Raised Dates or Date of Affiliation,
Occupation, Birth Place, Date of Birth, Date of Death, and such other information if a Brother was Suspended, Reinstated or
Demitted. More current records may give Offices Held, Addresses, Phones Numbers and name of a Spouse or Lady.
The following pages were compiled from many different sources, not the least of which is the burgeoning files of the internet. Where
once it would have been prohibitive for a researcher to travel the ends of the State, the U.S. or abroad to compile a work of this
scope, in mere minutes a considerable amount of information may be found, transcribed and formatted. A considerable amount of
additional information could be added the present work with further travel and research, or may be so added at a future date, but the
present scope of the work is to present a sketch of the Lodges in such light and depth as to present its historical context in the frame
of its place and events in community and district in which the Brothers lived, met and worked.
The Grand Lodge of the State of New York undertook at one time to publish in its proceedings a history of many of the Lodges in the
State. This policy was later abandoned with a view that the greater part of such work would not be of sufficient interest to the
Brothers of the State to justify its continuance, at least not within the covers of the Grand Lodge Proceedings. On the other hand, to
publish a comprehensive history of each Lodge would produce considerably dry reading and appeal to a somewhat limited
readership. The present work has attempted to walk the line between too much . . . and too little of either.
Much of Masonic history has been lost to the vicissitudes of time. There have been fires, movings and closings of Lodges, auctions,
file ‘purgings’ and the inevitable case of Lodge and private Masonic records being maintained in the homes of Brothers, but a small
portion of which has remained for posterity or public perusal.
Hopefully the present work will meet with your approbation. If you have information that would enhance its content or appeal, please
feel free to contact the Onondaga and Oswego Masonic Districts Historical Societies (OMDHS) through its website at
www.omdhs.syracusemasons.com or the Grand Lodge of the State of New York at www.nymasons.org .
-----------
R.’.W.’. Gary L. Heinmiller
Area 11 Historian, GLNY; Director, OMDHS
Liverpool, New York
A very good, searchable discussion of what happened in the Craft in New York State between 1826 and 1844 is available on line in
the book of Peter Ross, A Standard History of Freemasonry in the State of New York: Including Lodge, Chapter, Council,
Commandery and Scottish Rite Bodies, The Lewis Publishing Company – 1899, at:
http://books.google.com/books?id=-
GciAAAAMAAJ&pg=PA274&lpg=PA274&dq=%22country+lodges%22+masonic&source=web&ots=UmqKyt67v1&sig=MHHX7yhrRB
Ln4x4c4uT6n3hLW0c#PPP11,M1
. . . regarding not only the Morgan incident but several schisms within the Grand Lodge of the State of New York. It is far too
detailed to be covered it the present work, but the book will be of interest to those seeking further information on this period.
The Morgan Affair
From the Short Talk Bulletin of the Masonic Service Association of the United States, Vol. 11, March 1933, No. 3
http://web.mit.edu/dryfoo/Masonry/Essays/msa-morgan.html
Perhaps the most romantic story of Freemasonry, the fuel which the alleged abduction and murder of William Morgan supplied to
the anti-Masonic hysteria of a hundred years ago, and the gradual emergence of the Ancient Craft from the cloud which threatened
to extinguish it, is a tale which all Freemasons may ponder to their enlightenment.
William Morgan, a brickmason, lived in Batavia, New York, from 1824 to 1826. Accounts of him differ widely, as they do of any
notorious person. Few are so wicked as to be without friends; few are so good they have not their detractors. From the estimates of
both enemies and friends, the years have brought an evaluation of Morgan which shows him as a shiftless rolling stone; uneducated
but shrewd; careless of financial obligations: often arrested for debt; idle and improvident; frequently the beneficiary of Masonic
charity.
2

That he was really a Mason is doubtful; no record of his raising or Lodge membership exists, but it is certain he received the Royal
Arch in Western Star Chapter R.A.M. No. 33 of LeRoy, New York. It is supposed that he was an "eavesdropper" and lied his way
into a Lodge in Rochester by imposing on a friend and employer, who was led to vouch for him in Wells Lodge No. 282 at Batavia.
Judge Ebenzer Mix, of Batavia, a Mason of unquestioned reputation, wrote of this alleged Masonic membership: "There must have
been a most reprehensible laxity among the Masons both of Rochester and LeRoy; for there was no evidence educed, then or
afterwards, that he ever received any Masonic degree save the Royal Arch, on May 31, 1825, at LeRoy." At any rate, he visited
Lodges, was willing to assist, made Masonic speeches, took part in degrees. When Companions of Batavia asked for a Royal Arch
Chapter, he was among those who signed the petition. But suspicion of his regularity began to grow, and his name was omitted as a
member when the Charter was granted. Just how much this incident inspired the enmity he developed for the Fraternity is only a
guess; doubtless it had much to do with it.
Enemy he became, and it became known that he had applied for a copyright on a book which was to "expose" Masonic ritual,
secrets and procedure. In spite of the deep resentment which this proposed expose created, Morgan entered into a contract on
March 13, 1826 with three men for the publication of this work. These were: David C. Miller, an Entered Apprentice of twenty years
standing, stopped from advancement for cause, who thus held a grudge against the Fraternity; John Davids, Morgan's landlord; and
Russel Dyer, of whom little is known. These three entered into a penal bond of half a million dollars to pay Morgan one fourth of the
profits of the book.
Morgan boasted in bars and on the street of his progress in writing this book. The more he bragged, the higher the feeling against
him ran, and the greater the determination engendered that the expose should never appear. Brethren were deeply angered, fearful
that were the "secrets" of Freemasonry "exposed", the Order would die out. Feeling ran high. Matters came to a head in September,
1826. Morgan was arrested for the theft of a shirt and tie. Of this he was acquitted, but immediately rearrested for failure to pay a
debt of $2.68, and jailed. After one day behind bars, someone paid the debt. When he was released he left in a coach with several
men, apparently not of his own free will. He was taken to Fort Niagara and there confined in an unused magazine. Then Morgan
disappeared!
What happened to William Morgan?
Enemies of the Craft said Freemasons had kidnapped and murdered him, to prevent the publication of his expose. Freemasons, of
course, indignantly denied the charge. As time went on and Morgan was not found, members of the Craft disavowed any approval of
any such act, if it had been committed. Governor DeWitt Clinton, Past Grand Master, issued proclamation after proclamation, the
last one offering two thousand dollars reward "that, if living, Morgan might be returned to his family; if murdered, that the
perpetrators might be brought to con dign punishment."
It was not too difficult to discover that Masons were concerned in Morgan's hundred and twenty five mile journey to Fort Niagara.
Three members of the Craft -- Chesebro, Lawson and Sawyer -- pleaded guilty to conspiracy to "seize and secrete" Morgan, and,
together with Eli Bruce, Sheriff, and one John Whitney, all served terms in prison for the offense. But murder could not be proved for
no body was found.
In October, 1827, a body was washed ashore forty miles below Ft. Niagara. Morgan's widow "identified" the body, although it was
dressed in other clothes than her husband had worn alive; was bearded, although Morgan was clean shaven; had a full head of hair,
although Morgan was bald! Thurlow Weed, Rochester Editor, was accused of having the corpse shaved and of adding long white
hairs to ears and nostrils, to simulate the appearance of Morgan. The first inquest decided that this was, indeed, the body of William
Morgan. Three inquests were held in all. The third decided, on the unimpeachable evidence of Mrs. Sara Monroe, who minutely
described the body, its marks, and the clothes it wore, that the corpse was not William Morgan, but Timothy Monroe, of Clark,
Canada, her husband. Commonplace and unexciting truth seldom catches up with scandalous, electrifying, remarkable falsehood!
William Morgan had disappeared. Freemasons had been convicted of abducting him. A body had been found and identified as
Morgan. That better evidence and a less excited jury had later reversed this identification was anti-climatic. The stories of Morgan's
"murder" persisted.
Thurlow Weed, whom history shows as an unscrupulous opportunist, no matter what the exact truth of his activities with the body
may have been, added fuel to the flames. Weed died in 1882. On his death bed he stated that in 1860 (twenty-two years before)
John Whitney, who had been convicted in the conspiracy charge, confessed to him the full details of the murder of Morgan.
According to this alleged confession, Whitney and four others carried the abducted Morgan in a boat to the center of the river, bound
him with chains, and dumped him overboard. Weed stated -- and here his memory failed him -- that Whitney had promised to dictate
and sign this confession, but died before he could do so. But Whitney died in 1869 nine years after!
Whitney did indeed tell a story -- not to Thurlow Weed, who was his accuser in the conspiracy case and whom he hated -- but to
Robert Morris. This story is both the most probable and the best attested of any we have, as to the true fate of William Morgan.
Whitney told Morris that he had consulted with Governor Clinton at Albany, relative to what could be done to prevent Morgan
executing his plans to print the expose. Clinton sternly forbade any illegal moves, but suggested the purchase of the Morgan
manuscript, for enough money to enable Morgan to move beyond the reach of the influence and probable enmity of his associates
in the publishing enterprise. From some source (Masons? Governor Clinton?) Whitney was assured of any amount needed, up to a
thousand dollars, which was a great sum in those days. In Batavia Whitney summoned Morgan to a conference in which the bribe
was temptingly held forth. On the one hand, the enmity of all, persecution, continual danger -- it is not improbable that threats were
mingled with the bribe! On the other hand, money, safety, freedom from a plan to publish which held much of danger.
If Morgan would take five hundred dollars, go to Canada, "disappear", his family would be provided for, and later sent to him!
Morgan agreed. He was to be arrested and "kidnapped", to make it easy to get away from Miller and his associates. Whitney feared
that without some such spectacular escape, Morgan might at the last moment decline to go through with the plan, fearing reprisals
from his friends in the publishing venture. Whitney told Morris that two Canadian Masons received Morgan from the hands of his
"kidnappers" at Fort Niagara, traveled with him a day and a night to a place near Hamilton, Ontario, where they paid him the five
hundred dollars, receiving his receipt and signed agreement never to return without permission of Captain William King, Sheriff
Bruce, or Whitney. Later there were two other "confessions" of complicity in the "murder" of Morgan -- neither consistent with the
facts. Doubtless they were of the same hysterical origin which leads so many notoriety seekers to confess crimes which by no
possibility they could have committed.
3

Did William Morgan choose the easier way, disappear with five hundred dollars from a dangerous situation, eliminating from his
responsibilities a wife and family suddenly burdensome, and, in a new freedom, ship on a vessel from Montreal and out into the
world, there to come to an unknown end? Or was he basely murdered by Masons who thought the crime less than the evil results to
follow on the publication of Morgan's Book. No man knows. No incontestable evidence can be adduced -- or was ever adduced --
definitely to prove either solution. All that is undoubted is that William Morgan was apparently kidnapped and did disappear.
It is difficult, a hundred years after, to understand the extent and power of the widespread excitement and passions this incident
created. For the fame and infamy of the Morgan affair spread over an immense territory. It was the beginning of an anti-Masonic
sentiment which grew and spread like wild fire. Meetings were held, the Order was denounced by press and pulpit. An anti-Masonic
paper was started -- with Thurlow Weed as Editor -- soon joined by the Anti-Masonic Review, in New York City. The many groups in
Pennsylvania, already opposed to any oath bound society (Quakers, Lutherans, Mennonites, Dunkards, Moravians,
Schwenkfelders, German Reformed Church) were aroused to a high pitch of feeling against the alleged "murderers" and
"kidnappers" -- the Freemasons. The anti-Masonic excitement spread -- and fast and far. Gould, in his History of Free-Masonry, thus
epitomizes the spirit of that time:
"This country has seen fierce and bitter political contests, but no other has approached the bitterness of this campaign against
the Masons. No society, civil, military or religious, escaped its influence. No relation of family or friends was a barrier to it. The
hatred of Masonry was carried everywhere, and there was no retreat so sacred that it did not enter. Not only were teachers and
pastors driven from their stations, but the children of Masons were excluded from the schools, and members from their
churches. The Sacrament was refused to Masons by formal vote of the Church, for no other offense than their Masonic
connection. Families were divided. Brother was arrayed against brother, father against son, and even wives against their
husbands. Desperate efforts were made to take away chartered rights from Masonic Corporations and to pass laws that would
prevent Masons from holding their meetings and performing their ceremonies."
Reverend Brother John C. Palmer, Grand Chaplain of the Grand Lodge of the District of Columbia, says in his little classic of the
Craft, Morgan and anti-Masonry (Volume 7 of The Little Masonic Library, published by The Masonic Service Association in 1925):
"The pressure was so strong that withdrawals by individuals and bodies were numerous. In 1827, 227 lodges were represented
in the Grand Lodge of New York. In 1835, the number had dwindled to forty-one.
Every Lodge in the State of Vermont surrendered its Charter or became dormant; and the Grand Lodge, for several years, ceased to
hold its sessions. As in Vermont, so also in Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Connecticut; and in lesser degrees in
several other states. The Masonic Temple was cleft in twain; its brotherhood scattered, its trestleboard without work; its working
tools shattered. Thus Masonry endured the penalty of the mistaken zeal of those fearful brethren who thought that the revealing of
the ritual to profane eyes would destroy the Order and who hoped to save it by removing the traitor within the camp."
Space here is not sufficient to retell the interesting, often exciting, and always varied story of the political campaigns which were
predicated on, and took much of their ammunition from, the anti-Masonic excitement which followed the Morgan affair.
It is not to be supposed that the abduction and alleged -- never proved -- murder of Morgan was the sole cause of this outburst, any
more than was the assassination in 1914 the sole cause of the World War. Both were triggers which set off guns which, in turn,
caused other explosions. Suffice it here that a wave of hysteria was seized upon by able politicians, fanned by demagogues,
increased by the righteous indignation of good men and true who saw not beneath the surface, helped onward by press and pulpit
with the best of intentions but little understanding, until the whole east flamed with passion and Freemasons were spit upon in the
streets, lodges threw away their charters, and Freemasonry bowed its head to a storm as unjust and undeserved as all religious
persecutions have always been.
Like any other hysteria, this passed. Passions wore themselves away. A few sturdy and brave men stood staunchly by, a few Grand
Lodges with high courage and the strength of the right never ceased to proclaim their allegiance to the principles of the Order. Little
by little, Freemasonry raised its head; one by one, lodges took heart; brother by brother, Craftsmen returned to their Altars.
After a period following almost twenty years of more or less complete eclipse, the sun of Freemasonry shone again, and the world
was treated to a spectacle that has been a heartening lesson to millions and will be to counted millions yet to be born anew at the
sacred Altar of Freemasonry -- the strange sight of an Order many had thought dead, suffering from uncounted thousands of stabs
to the heart, coming again to life to grow and thrive and attract to it then, as it had in the historic past, men of the highest character.
It is for this that the Craft of today can offer thanks to the Great Architect for the Morgan affair. Dreadful as it was to the men who
lived through it, terrible in its consequences to the brethren who suffered, it demonstrated again -- and it may be hoped and
believed, once for all -- that the underlying faith of Freemasonry, its Ancient Landmarks, its foundation upon Deity and the Great
Light, together are stronger than any evil, more lasting than any calumny, more enduring than any human passions.
---------------
This is a Working Draft. Lodge Masters & Secretaries please read and update
missing information, biographies and history beyond 1976.
4

In Part I of this work, covering the period 1799-1826, sketches for the early Craft Lodges were presented, as follows:
Craft Lodges in Onondaga County 1799-1826
Charter or
No. Name Village Warrant Ceased Labor
80 Village Marcellus 08 Jan 1799 1819 Dropped; no record of dissolution
93 Military (215) Manlius 02 Sep 1802 Charter returned by GL 26 Oct 1886; see history
98 Onondaga Onondaga Hollow 12 Jan 1803 7 Jun 1833; in archives of Onondaga Historical Association
156 Philanthropic Pompey 04 Mar 1807 5 Jun 1835; Forfeited
166 Farmers Delphi 02 Mar 1808 5 Jun 1834; Forfeited
219 Selected Friends Camillus 03 Jun 1813 5 Jun 1834; Forfeited
245 Mt. Moriah Otisco (Amber) 23 Jun 1815 5 Jun 1834; Forfeited
287 Franklin Fabius 05 Jun 1817 1831; Surrendered
290 Morning Star Marcellus 05 Jun 1817 5 Jun 1734; in archives of Morning Star Lodge 524; 1962
327 Salina Salina 02 Dec 1819 4 Jun 1834; Forfeited
330 Cicero Benevolent Cicero 09 Jun 1820 5 Jun 1835; Forfeited
341 Jamesville Manlius 05 Dec 1821 7 Jun 1833; Forfeited
354 Pleiades Baldwinsville 04 Dec 1822 7 Jun 1832; Forfeited; in archives of Seneca River Lodge 160
355 Corinthian Onondaga 04 Dec 1822 7 Jun 1833; Forfeited
379 Camillus Camillus 04 Jun 1824 5 Jun 1834; Forfeited
381 Leonidas Liverpool 04 Jun 1824 5 Jun 1834; Forfeited
444 Farmers Spafford 01 Jun 1825 1831; Surrendered
456 Village Skaneateles 10 Jun 1826 5 Jun 1834; “Dormant”
484 Syracuse Syracuse 09 Jun 1826 5 Jun 1835; Forfeited
In this present work will be sketched the Lodges from the period 1826 through 1976 that have ceased work or have merged or
consolidated with another Lodge in Onondaga County. There were no Lodges chartered in Onondaga County 1827-1843. The
shifting sands of time affect people, communities, states, countries and organizations. Freemasonry, too, shifts with these times.
The above Lodges all ceased work in the wake of an Anti-Masonic movement that took to wings of its own following the Morgan
incident. It is not the intent of the present work to elucidate on this incident; it has been ably discussed in many other works, other
than to note that, politically, the Anti-Masonic Party used the Morgan incident somewhat to its own purposes, as a study of its early
leaders will attest. When the furor had abated, those Lodges, or rather Brothers, who were dormant returned to work, some having
continued to work quietly during the period. The first to officially reemerge for this period was Syracuse Lodge No. 102 which
petitioned the Grand Lodge of the State of New York in May 1844 and was granted its Charter 23 July of that year.
Craft Lodges in Onondaga County 1826-2001
Many of the Lodges listed below have living members who were Raised in the Lodges recorded,
but are now members under a different Lodge number or style (name) and/or in a different village.
No. Name Village Warrant Merged, Consolidated or Split
102 Syracuse Syracuse 23 Jul 1844 23 Sep 1860; split: Syracuse Lodge 501 and Central City 305
215 Military Manlius see discussion in this present work
222 Corinthian Skaneateles see sketch 7 March 1855, last minutes; see sketch
305 Central City Syracuse 11 Jun 1853 Consolidated with Fayetteville Lodge No. 578
501 Syracuse Syracuse 05 Jul 1860 Consolidated with Liverpool Lodge No. 525
520 Salt Springs Syracuse 1861 Consolidated with to become Crossroads Lodge No. 520
525 Liverpool Liverpool 03 Jun 1863 Consolidated with Syracuse Lodge No. 502
578 Fayetteville Fayetteville 1865 Consolidated with Central City Lodge No. 305
648 Centerville North Syracuse 18 Jul 1867 Consolidated with Onondaga Lodge No. 802
768 Sapphire Camillus 13 Jun 1876 Merged with Morning Star Lodge No. 524
802 Onondaga East Syracuse 1892 Consolidated with Centerville Lodge No. 648
864 Mount Sinai Syracuse 01 Jan 1908 Merged with Philo Lodge No. 968, 1980
949 Uncas Syracuse 08 May 1918 Consolidated to become Crossroads Lodge No. 520
955 Salina Syracuse 19 May 1919 Consolidated to become Crossroads Lodge No. 520
957 Danforth Syracuse 19 May 1919 Merged with Liverpool Lodge No. 525
968 Philo Syracuse 18 May 1920 Merged with Mount Sinai Lodge No. 864, 1980
2-983 Sea and Field Syracuse May 1921 Merged with Centerville Lodge No. 648
1109 William S. Farmer Solvay Jun 1931 Consolidated to become Crossroads Lodge No 520
1168 Piety Hill Syracuse 1968 Merged with Centerville Lodge No. 648
* Indicates that this Lodge met originally in the village indicated, but elsewhere in its later history.
Syracuse Masonic Temple
To the above listing must be added the advent of the Syracuse Masonic Temple, dedicated 22 Feb 1917, which was noted in its
time as “distinctively marking the division between the old and new in the local history of Free Masonry in Syracuse . . .” A sketch of
this Temple is given in the body of the sketch for Central City Lodge No. 305 in the succeeding pages of this present work.
5

Initial Meeting Places of Lodges in Onondaga County.
Many of these Lodges, or their members, subsequently met in other places.
See further details in their respective sketches.
I-690 I-81
NYS Thruway
Wm. S. Farmer 1109 x
Centerville 648 x
x Liverpool 525
Syracuse 102
Onondaga 802 x
Central City 305
Syracuse 501 x
Salt Springs 520
Mount Sinai 864 x Sapphire 768 Rt. 5 - Genesee St. x Fayetteville 578
Uncas 949
Salina 955 Military 215 x
Danforth 957
Philo 968
Sea and Field 2-983
Piety Hill 1168
I-81
Onondaga County
Syracuse Lodge No. 102
Syracuse, New York
23 Jul 1844 - 5 Jul 1860; per Grand Lodge Communication of 1860
Petition: May 1844
Warrant: 23 Jul 1844
Dedicated: 18 Mar 1845
Suspended: 23 Feb 1859; last meeting
Petitioned: 24 Feb 1859; see below for details of this.
Dispensation: 4 Apr 1860
Number Change: 5 Jul 1860; at the Grand Lodge Communication of 1860, from No. 102 to No. 501
During the reverberations of the Morgan incident, the Light of Freemasonry remained diminished but not extinguished for the
Syracuse Lodge, and when times grew better for the reemergence of the Craft, 14 faithful Brothers petitioned for a dispensation to
form the keystone of Masonry in Onondaga County in May of 1844.
A Warrant was granted for Syracuse Lodge No. 102 on 23 July 1844, but the Lodge was not dedicated until 18 March 1845.
The Past Master of Syracuse Lodge No. 484, W.’. Henry Newton, now became the Senior Warden of the new Syracuse Lodge No.
102, and Hiram Judson, a past Senior Deacon and Senior Warden of the old Lodge, became the Junior Warden of the new one.
One of the (two?) Minute Books of Syracuse Lodge No. 102, covering the ten-year period of 22 Aug 1844 through 27 Dec 1854
remains in the archives of Liverpool-Syracuse Lodge No. 501. From its pages the following Masters of Syracuse Lodge No. 102 are
recorded:
Masters
1844-46 Tracy, Luther M. 1849-51 Cook, John W.
1847 Judson, Hiram 1852 Williams, George N.
1848 (No Minutes) 1853-55 Hall, William
During the period of the Minutes, the usual Officers of the Lodge are noted as being elected or installed, and additionally, a
"Physician" and an "Orator" were appointed. A listing of their Officers is at the Appendices for your review.
6

Syracuse Lodge No. 102 recorded 256 members in its 16 years of existence, of whom the present writer has been able to list about
245 of them from various sources [see Appendices].
Meeting Places:
In their 16 years, their meetings were held:
1. In the north end of what was the Empire Block on North Salina Street
2. 1849 In Frazee Hall, later called the Courier Building.
3. Jan 1850 In the Alvord Block on South Warren Street, site of the University Building.
4. Nov. 1852 In the Stanley Block which stood where the Snow Building later stood.
5. 1856 At 63 (later No. 317) South Salina Street, just south of the Rosenbloom Block.
These times of transition are reflected by some early entries in their minutes:
“Affiliation fee shall be $2.00. Degree fee shall be $12.00,”
“Visitors fee shall be one (1) shilling” (12½ cents in 1844).
19 Dec 1844: “Resolved that any member spitting on the carpet shall be fined 12 cents.”
There were two unaccounted for breaks in the Minutes of Syracuse Lodge No. 102. The first was from 17 Sep 1846 to 17 Dec of
that year; the second was from 2 Nov 1848 to 14 Mar 1850.
Around 1858 dissension crept in and the Brethren separated into factions.
February 23, 1859 - The last communication of Syracuse Lodge No. 102 records in its minutes of this date:
. . . "A communication was received and read by R.’.W.’. Clinton F. Paige 1 from the M.’.W.’. Grand Master, empowering him
to act as he may think proper, with regard to the welfare of our Lodge, which was the result of Bro. [George Judd] Gardner's [a
prominent Onondaga Masonic historian of the time] interview with the Grand Master.
"On motion of Bro. Barnum [Henry A.; a Major General during the Civil War] and vote of the Lodge, the following resolutions
were adopted:
"Resolved that all the members of Syracuse Lodge No. 102, in good and regular standing be, and hereby are invited to
petition to R.’.W.’. Clinton F. Paige, who has been duly empowered to act in the matter, that they be allowed to continue the
organization of said Lodge and we hereby pledge ourselves that we will cordially consent and agree to act in accordance with
his wishes.
"R.’.W.’. Clinton F. Paige then demanded the Charter of Syracuse Lodge No. 102 and suspended the Lodge until authorized
to restore it, or otherwise, by the Grand Master" . . . [who deemed it necessary to suspend the Charter until the Grand Lodge
meeting in June]
February 24, 1860 - The day after their Charter was demanded, 30 loyal Brothers petitioned the Grand Master, and become
Charter Members, as follows:
Syracuse, February 24, 1860
To the M.’.W.’. Grand Master, of Free and Accepted Masons in the State of New York:
The undersigned petitioners, being Ancient Free and Accepted Master Masons, having the prosperity of the fraternity at heart, and
willing to exert their best endeavors to promote and diffuse the genuine principles of Masonry, respectfully represent that they are
desirous of resuscitating Syracuse Lodge, No. 102, they therefore pray for the restoration of the Charter of said Lodge, to the
undersigned, to empower them to assemble as a Legal Lodge, to discharge the duties of Masonry in a regular and constitutional
manner, according to the original forms of the Order, and the regulations of the Grand Lodge. They have nominated and do
recommend Brother Lewis E. Joy to be their first Master, Brother John Frary to be their first Senior Warden, and Brother E. S.
Dawson, to be their first Junior Warden of said Lodge. If the prayer of the petition shall be granted, they promise a strict conformity
to the Constitution, laws and regulations of the Grand Lodge.
R.[iley] S. Eaton
B.[enjamin] F. Howland
D. Robert Snow Edward S. Dawson
T.[homas] S. Truair
A.[ugustus] N. Fairchild
Demster Moore, present Secretary I.[saac] D. Lawson
Ira Babcock
Lewis E. Joy, past S.W.
Sam'l Hurst
John Frary
O.[wen] Lavelle
James Fuller
F.[riend] A. Andrews
Austin B. Webber
Wm. C. [E.?] Williams
James Meldrum
John W. Cook, past Master John Newell, past Master
A.[lexander] B. Wells * D.[amon] Coats, PM R.[ichard] B. Claxton * W.[illiam] W. Parker *
Oney Sayles Richard J. Chillingworth *
Dudley W. Chase
Rhesa Griffin
B.[enjamin] F.[ranklin] Green A.[lonzo] B. Caldwell
* later to be petitioners and Charter members of Liverpool Lodge No. 525, March 3, 1862.
In reply to the foregoing petition, a Dispensation was issued by the Grand Master, and the first Communication thereunder was held
on April 4, 1860.
In the Proceedings of the Grand Lodge for 1860, it is noted regarding the action taken relating to Syracuse Lodge No. 102.
" . . . part of the [Grand Master's] Address was referred to the Committee on Warrants, who reported as follows: 'They also
recommend that the warrant of Syracuse Lodge No. 102, which was suspended on the request and complaint of the members
1 R∴W∴ Clinton F. Paige was raised in Syracuse Lodge No. 102, and later a member of Central City Lodge No. 305. He was Jr. Grand Warden in
1858-59, Sr. Grand Warden in 1860-61, Deputy Grand Master in 1862 and Grand Master in 1863-64.
7

of that Lodge by the Grand Master, within the last year, be declared forfeit. They also recommend that a warrant be granted for
a Lodge in Syracuse, Onondaga County, to be called Syracuse Lodge, No. 501.' "
In the above few words, Syracuse Lodge No. 102 became Syracuse Lodge No. 501, with only such break in service as was
occasioned by the suspension of 102.
The Brethren of No. 501 were permitted by the Grand Lodge to have the records and all of the property of No. 102, on condition
that they pay all indebtedness of the old Lodge. [One Minute Book, Vol. I, survives as of 2001.)
Roster of Syracuse Lodge No. 102 (241 of 256 Brothers)
Selected biographical sketches are appended for Brothers in Bold type.
Numbers in brackets give previous Lodge number affiliation.
Adams, Henry P.
Andrews, Friend A
Austin, Pardon
Avril, L. R. (Averill)
Babock, Ira
Bainbridge, Charles
Ball, Calvin Stowe Jr.
Barber, Joseph
Barrett, Michael
Barron, John
Barton, Joseph
Bauker,
Baum, Artemus
Baum, Isaac
Baum, John
Beebe, William
Bennett, George C.
Bernhard, Gustav
Bickford, Dearborn B. (93)
Bigelow, Joshua G.
Bogardis, Davis
Boynton, John F.
Briggs, Caleb
Bronner, Isaac H.
Brower, A. G.
Bulger, John (Bolger)
Burdick, Perry
Burditson, Jacob
Burns, Milton, C.
Butler, Eben
Caldwell, Alonzo Born
Carrier, Dudley
Chandler, James
Chapman, Cyrus Y.
Chase Van Buren
Chase, Dudley W.
Chase, Dudley Winthrop
Chase, Horace Hills
Chillingworth, Richard J.
Church, Hiram
Clark, J. M.
Claxton, Richard B.
Cleveland, Perry P.
Coates, Damon
Coates, William J.
Cogswell, Z. W.
Comstock, Levi Wilson
Cone, Marcus
Conroy, Patrick
Cook. John Watson
Courtney, Robert
Cronk, Warren
Dann, Walter B.
Davis, Guy
Dawson, Edward Seabred
Dean, Charles A.
Didama, H. D.
Drake, Edwin C.
Duncan, J. W.
Durnford, H. W.
Earl, J. D.
Eason, Thomas
Eason, William
Eaton, Riley S.
Edwards, Thomas C.
Elliott, Daniel
Elsner, Leopold
Everson, George
Fairchild, Augustus Newell
Feber, Charles L.
Fish, Gilbert B.
Fisher, Anson
Fitch, Charles C.
Franklin, J. B.
Frary, John
French, Benjamin (330)
Fuller, James
Gardner, Napoleon B.
Garson, Isaac
Gifford, James E.
Giles, Charles P.
Goodfellow, Adam W.
Goodfellow, William B.
Grant, Stephen
Gray, George W.
Green, Benjamin Franklin
Green, George
Green, Warren
Green, William W.
Griffin, Rhesa (Rasa)
Grumbach, Nicholas
Hall, James B.
Hall, William
Hallister, Clark
Hamilton, William T.
Hay, George (Hey?)
Helmer, William
Henocksburg, Aaron
Henocksburg, Moses
Higgins, Every J.
Higgins, George E.
Hirshman, Leopold
Hochstrasser, Osmond
Hodges, William
Howard, George
Howland, Benjamin F.
Hubbard, Caleb Dr.
Hurst, Samuel
Isaacs, Alfred A.
Isenning, Carl (Charles)
Jacobs, Joshua
Jacobs, Moses
Jacobus, J. S.
Jones, Henry
Joy, Lewis Everett
Judson, Hiram
Kinny, R. (King)
Kraft, Simon
Lamb, Joseph
Laslow, Charles (Latzlo)
Lavelle, Owen
Lawrence, Grove (379)
Lawson, Isaac D.
Leopold, Elsner
Levy, Sylvester
Lewis, George
Lewis, Isaac
Lewis, Jabez W.
Lewis, John
Linch, Benjamin
Litt, Jacob J.
Lovejoy, William J. Dr.
Lyon, McKennon
Lyon, Wakeman
Manheimer, Isaac
Marvin, Edgar
Matson, Alpheus
Matthews, James H.
McDonald, J. R.
Meldram, James
Mellen, Joseph B.
Miller, Joseph Y.
Monroe, S.
Moore, Dempster
Morehouse,
Morgan, John J.
Morgan, William E.
Newell, John
Newton, Henry (484)
Norgrove, Richard L.
Northrup, Darius
Olmsted, William B. (98?)
Ormsby, A. P.
Paige, Clinton Freeman
Palmer, William L.
Pardee, Stephen B.
Parker, Dr. Jared Husted
Parker, William W.
Pease, Roger, W.
Peck, Myron
Peck, Sanford C.
Penfield, Jerry
Perkins, B. (A)
Perry, H. W.
Phelps, Martin J.
Philips, Robert D.
Phillips, Ira E.
Phillips, John H.
Prall, William H. H.
Pratsman, F. W.
Quick, Peter
Raymond, Daniel
Reals, L. George
Remon, Lonnzo R.
Robie, John E.
Robinson, John C. Capt.
Rosenbeck, Samuel
Samson, Joseph
Samuels, Joseph M.
Sayles, Owney (Oney)
Schoen, Francis
Seldon, H.
Seldon, L. (H. R.)
Seymour, Joseph
Sherwood, John F.
Sixbury, Charles
Skinner, Charles L.
Slocum, Joseph
Slocum, WIlliam M.
Smith, Peter Jr.
Snow, Dillaye Robert
Stanton, Alexander
Stanton, Herman H.
Stanton, N. P.
Stanton, Sydney Sr.
Stern, Abraham
Still, Martin
Story, Amos
Stoutenger, Bennett
Summers, Moses
Thayer, Sanford (Thays)
Thompson, Alexander M.
Thompson, David W.
Tiffany, Henry
Tracy, Luther M.
Truair, Thomas Spencer
Tucker, (Jonathan) N. T.
Tuttle, James B.
VanVolkenburg, D. A.
VanZandt, Ulrich H.
Wales, Hatcher P
Walter, Adam
Walter, William
Warne, Henry Edward
Warren, Henry
Warson, Frederick
Webber, Austin B.
Welch, Eliphat
Wells, Alexander Brush
Wells, Charles H.
Welsh, Carl (Welch)
Wheadon, Phillip M.
(Weaton)
White, George H.
White, William H.
Whitehilll, Lewis
Whitmore, Charles
Wilcox, Asel (93)
Willard, James L.
Willcox, Samuel G.
Williams, George N.
Williams, William C.
Wilson, Elishu
Wilson, T. O
Wilson, W. Y.
Wilson, William A.
Wooley, Peter
Worden, Hiram H. (93)
Worden, James
Worden, John S.
Worley, John
Zinn, Simon
8

Selected Biographical or Historical Data
Paige, Clinton F.
Grand Master, 1863-1864. See Central City Lodge No. 305 for his biographical information
Isaac Baum , b. 1808, Montgomery Co., NY; m. Mary / Miriam Dockstader, 1831; b. 6 Dec 1814, Near Indian Castle, Herkimer, NY
Note: Isaac married Mary/Miriam Dockstader. Her nephew, James Dockstader was member no. 261 of Syracuse Lodge No. 501
(GL No. 112549, Initiated 18 Mar 1868, Passed 22 Apr 1868, Raised 29 Apr 1868. He was a carpenter:
Birth: 17 JUL 1843 in Hammond, St. Lawrence County, NY
Death: 18 JUN 1912 in 1507 Midland Ave., Syracuse, NY of chronic hepatitis and endocarditis
Military Service: 6 AUG 1862 Private, Co. D., 110 Regt., NY Volunteers; 28 AUG 1865 Discharged, Special Order #16
Medical Information: Light Complexion, Brown Hair, Gray Eyes, suffers from: One Rupture, Varicose Veins & Rheumatism, Sore
Eyes, Left Hand Minus Two Fingers [ http://awt.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db=dockstader&id=I06454 ]
Father: Henry G. Dockstader b: 22 OCT 1817 in Near Indian Castle, Herkimer County, NY
Mother: Eliza Joyce b: 29 JAN 1811 in Herkimer County, NY
Marriage 1 Izilda Adelaide Vowers b: ABT. 1850; no children listed.
Brother of: Daniel Baum, who married Abigail and were the parents of Artemus Baum, b. 1 Aug. 1824; d. 1 July 1887, buried in
the Cicero Cemetery. Artemus married Betsey Snow who was b. ca Feb 1828; died 10 May 1867, age 39-3-17. Artemus married
Betsy Snow and all of their children died. Betsy died giving birth to the last child, who lived one month. Artemus was so
grieved/upset that he never even named the child. Artemus died twenty years after Betsy, never remarried and the oldest daughter
Josephine, died three years after the death of her mother. It seems as though they all stopped taking care of themselves and
languished, so to speak. Atremus rented out rooms for a living, one of which was to Centerville Lodge No. 648 for their first
meetings. The yearly rent for that building was $17.50. He died at age 53 years.
John Baum, brother of Isaac and Daniel above. b. 12 May 1797; d. 20 Jun 1854; m. Magdalene ‘Lany” Elwood 13 Feb 1818,
Jonville [Johnville?],Montgomery Co., NY. He was the grandfather of Lyman Frank Baum, author of the “Wizard of Oz” books.
Baum Family
of Centreville and Mattydale
Philip Baum m. Catherine ____
b. ca 1738
George F. Dockstader
Henry G. Dockstader
Philip Baum
Catherine Barth
b. 12 Sep 1784 – d. 31 May 1848 b. bef 7 Mar 1772 – d. ca 1 Jan 1846 James Dockstader
Henry John P. Baum Daniel * b. 1801 Isaac Baum Jacob b. 1810
b. 1791 b. 12 May 1797 – d. 20 Jun 1854 Abraham b. 1803 b. 1808, Montgomery Co., NY Philip b. 1812
m. Magdalene Lany Elwood Mary b. 1806 m. Mary/Miriam Dockstader, 1831 Besse b. 1814
13 Feb 1818, Jonville [Johnville?] b. 6 Dec 1814, near Indian Castle, Barbara b. 1816
Montgomery Co., NY * (m. Abigail; had son, Herkimer Co., NY
Artemus1824-1887)
Benjamin Franklin Baum?
Cynthis Ann Stanton Benjamin Ward Baum Martha ca 1832 Isaac Baum **
b. 28 Oct 1820 b. 3 Jan 1821, MindenTwp m. Richard Fergerson ca 1850, prob. Cicero
New Woodstock, Madison, NY Montgomery Co., NY Sarah Ann ca 1834 res. 1868-69. P.O. Plank Road
d. 14 Feb 1886, Syracuse, NY Franklin ca 1837 Town of Clay, NY
Alonzo ca 1838 Agent for Lightning Rod Co.
Amenzo ca 1838 m. Mary Williams
Cynthia 1843 Lyman Frank Baum* Henry Clay 1859 Melville ca 1845
Oliver S. 1844 b. 15 May 1856, Chittenango NY George M. 1861 Granville * ca 1845
Harriet A. 1846 d. 06 May 1919, Ozcot, LA, CA (Postmaster) William Baum
Mary Louise 1848 m. Maud Gage, 9 Nov 1882 * L. Frank Baum Mary Augusta ca 1848 b. prob. Onondaga Co., NY
Benjamin W. 1850 b. 27 Mar 1861, Fayetteville, NY Author: Wizard of Oz Naomi ca 1854 m. Emma Wendling
Edwin C. 1853
Children: Frank, Robert, [ b. Syracuse ]; Harry, Kenneth [ b. SD ]
* Granville m. Mary E. Dockstader, b. 2 Jul 1850 in Herkimer
** Isaac: first Master of Centreville Lodge No. 648, 1867
Compilation and graphics by Gary L. Heinmiller, April 2005, May 2007
Names in blue were Freemasons.
9

-----------
Henry A. Barnum: Born 24 Sep 1833, Jamesville, NY; died 29 Jan 1892, New York, NY, age 58. He was a Member of Syracuse
Lodge No. 102, but apparently affiliated with Central City Lodge No. 305. He was also a Companion (# 103 in their Register) of
Syracuse Chapter No. 70, RAM, having been proposed 11 Mar 1859, MM 26 Apr, PM, 27 Apr, MEM 27 Apr and Exalted a RAM 29
Apr 1859.
He received a good education and was a teacher, lawyer, member of the bar and a local militia man. He joined the army and was
elected Captain of the 12th New York Infantry. Barnum’s company fought at First Manassas (21 Jul 1861), and he was promoted to
Major in Nov 1861. At Malvern Hill (1 Jul 1862), he was severely wounded and presumed dead. A body, believed to have been his,
was buried and a funeral was held for him at his home. He had been shot through his body by a rifle bullet. His wound was
continually annoying, and, interestingly, he placed a steel rod through his body for a photograph for his pension claim (photo copy
on file in the Archives of the OMDHS). His hip bone in on display at the National Health & Medicine Museum).
He was later captured and imprisoned at Libby Prison and eventually exchanged. At Gettysburg he was Colonel of the 149th New
York Infantry, which he had established. He fought with Brig. Gen. George Greene’s Brigade on Culp’s Hill. After Gettysburg he
fought at Lookout Mountain, where he was again wounded. He took part in the Atlanta Campaign and was brevetted Major General.
Following Atlanta, he commanded a brigade in the famous "March to the Sea." He was the first officer to enter Savannah in Dec
1864. Barnum was appointed full Brig. General on 31 May 1865. He also won "The Medal of Honor" for his action on Lookout
Mountain. He became, successively, the New York Inspector of Prisons, New York Harbormaster and Deputy Tax Commissioner.
[ref: Munn, Sheldon A., Freemasons at Gettysburg , Thomas Publications, Gettysburg, PA, 1993.]
See also Onondaga Historical Assn. Files for photo, from a 1962 bulletin, showing him returning the colors of the 149th Regiment of
the New York State Volunteers to Syracuse. Reproduced in the Herald American (Metro, pgs. B1 & B2) article of Sunday, 14 Jun
1998.
Calvin Stowe Ball, Jr.
Born in the Village of Pompey, County of Onondaga, and State of New York, on the 18th day of March 1832. Residence, Syracuse,
NY, Profession, Jeweler &c.
Initiated an Entered Apprentice Aug 2, 1855, in Syracuse Lodge No. 102, F&AM
Passed to the degree of Fellow Craft Aug 23, 1855 “ “
Raise to the Sublime degree of Master Mason Sept 8, 1855 “ “ [mbr 88}
And now a member of Central City Lodge No. 305, at Syracuse, NY - affiliated April 24, 1865, [mbr 309] - Demitted Jan 19, 1886.
Advanced to degree of Mark Master June 30, 1865 in Central City Chapter No. 70, RAM
Regularly passed the Chair June 30, 1865 “ “
Received and acknowledge as Most Ex-Master Oct 27, 1865 “ “
Exalted to Sub. Degree of Royal Arch Mason Nov 10, 1865 “ “ [mbr 143]
[n. b. in our archives we also have the Register of Salina Chapter No. 70, RAM]
Masonic Veterans Association (MVA) of Central New York, Registry No. 4; May 24, 1879, Charter Member.
In the OMDHS archives is his original, beautifully engraved, Membership Certificate.
He served as 2nd Vice President of the MVA in 1906 and was Elected 1st Vice President for 1907, resigning on Nov 5th, 1907. He
attended the MVA Annual Feast of Dec 26, 1906.
He died May 1st, 1926 in Syracuse, New York, and was interred at Oakwood Cemetery.
Attached to his Registry Page is the following news clipping of 9 Mar 1903:
HALF A CENTURY IN BUSINESS
Calvin S. Ball Tells about what he did in the City’s Early Days.
Calvin S. Ball, the oldest jewelry merchant in this city, will have been in that business 50 years to-morrow. When he first began
business here in 1848, the year that Syracuse was made a city, there were six jewelry stores, and now there are 40.
Mr. Ball, who began business for himself on March 10, 1853, was born at Pompey Hill in 1832, His father was a jeweler and
watchmaker at Pompey, and Mr. Ball naturally followed in his footsteps so far as his business occupation was concerned.
After three years of schooling, Mr. Ball, was then16 years old, came to this city to engage as an apprentice boy, with B. R. Norton &
Co., jewelers, whose store was located in the building which stood on the site of the present Gridley block. Mr. Ball’s salary was $25 a
year, and included board and medical attendance.
Before he reached his twenty-first birthday, in company with Seymour H. Stone [see his biographical sketch under Central City
Lodge No. 305 below] of this city, he bought out the business of his employers, and the new firm set up in business for themselves,
continuing in the same location for a period of four years. The store was then removed to the place now occupied by Becker & Lathrop,
where the business was conducted for 25 years. The firm dissolved in 1867. Since that time Mr. Ball had carried on the business
alone. His store has been located at different times in the Gridley block, in Becker & Lathrop’s store, the White Memorial building and
the old Syracuse House block. When Mr. Ball first engaged in business there were not more than 12 stores of all kinds in the city.
A first class jewelry store in Syracuse in those days, Mr. Ball says, kept in stock about two gold watches and a dozen silver watches,
which was stock enough for the town. The stock also included a few watch chains and clocks. The stores were kept open until 9
o’clock at night, and every storekeeper was compelled by the city ordinance to sweep half the street in front of his store every Friday
morning.
Merchant lighted their stores with whale oil, and later with a fluid known as camphene. Mr. Ball is active in business to-day as ever,
and is one of Syracuse’s leading citizens.
Ancestral notes for Calvin S. Ball, Jr.:
Ball, Fred A. M., Syracuse – Lebbeus Ball, Sr., was born in Granville, MA, in 1738, served seven years in the Revolutionary war, was
wounded, was honorably discharged at its close with the rank of major, and died in 1806. His son, Lebbeus Ball, Jr., also a native of
Granville, MA, born in 1775, settled as a farmer in Pompey, Onondaga Co., in 1799, and died there in 1802.
10

Alvin Munn Ball, son of Lebbeus, Jr., and the twin brother of Calvin S. Ball, Sr., whose son, Calvin S. [Jr.], has long been a prominent
jeweler in Syracuse, was born in Galway, Saratoga Co., in 1798, came to Pompey with his parents in 1799, followed the occupations
of farmer and carpenter, and died in 1872. His wife, Lucretia Vickery, was born Jan. 29, 1799, and died July 29, 1878, being the
mother of nine daughters and one son, Fred A. M. [most likely Alvin Munn], the youngest of the family.
Fred A. M. Ball was born in Pompey, May 27, 1843, was educated at the academies at Pompey and Manlius, and worked on the farm
summers and taught school winters for nine years. In Aug., 1864, he enlisted as a private in the Second New York (Harris Light)
Cavalry and served under General Custer, until the close of the war, receiving an honorary commission as lieutenant upon his
discharge for gallant and meritorious services in the field.
Returning home in June, 1865, he remained on the farm until 1873, when he came to Syracuse and entered the employ of J. & F. B.
Garrett. Two years later he returned to the farm, whence he again came to the city in 1882, taking his old position, but after two years
he became bookkeeper for Pierce, Butler & Pierce, where he remained four years, when he accepted his present position with A. C.
Powell & Son.
Mr. Ball has been active in both politics and Grand Army matters, being past commander of Root Post, and serving as alderman of the
Eleventh ward in 1891 and 1892. He is a member and was formerly president, secretary, etc., of the Syracuse Rifle Club, and was
charter member of the Indoor Shooting Club, of which he has also been president, etc.
Feb 22, 1866, he married Alice R., daughter of V. R. Taylor, of Pompey, and their children are Bertha (Mrs. G. W. Pulver), Irving
Custer (with C. S. Ball), and Leora A. and Mabel L. (at home), all residents of Syracuse.
-----------
Richard Jolly Chillingworth was born in Handsworth, Staffordshire, England, on November 30, 1833. His family moved to the United
States in 1835, living in New York City for about a year before moving to Cherry Valley, New York., in the spring of 1836. They next
moved to Fruit Valley, near Oswego, in 1838. He had a sister, Sarah, who was born in England on December 14, 1824. She married
Daniel Devine Miller of Liverpool.
Brother Chillingworth mined for gold in California where he was quite successful. With his "fortune" he came to Liverpool and
established a home and farm where the Myron Melvin farm stood on Route 57. He was a member of Syracuse Lodge No. 102, having
been Initiated February 24, 1859, Passed March 10th, and Raised March 17th of the same year. He became a Charter Member (No.
25) of Syracuse Lodge No. 501 on April 4, 1960, from which Lodge he demitted on August 26, 1862, the same date he was elected as
the first Master of Liverpool Lodge No. 525 at the age of 28. He also served as Master in 1863, 1864, 1866, 1867 and 1873.
There were five members of Liverpool Lodge No. 525 by the name of Chillingworth: Richard J., our first Master; Joseph, Master in
1881 and 1882; Frank (member no. 24), Edward L. (member no. 52), and Charles C. (member no. 149). W. . Richard J. Chillingworth
moved to Florida in 1892 where he assisted in the organization of Harmonia Lodge No. 135. He passed away in 1915 at the age of 82.
-----------
From Recollections of Early Syracuse by Ill.’.Richard Husted Parker, 33 o
For the full text, see: http://omdhs.syracusemasons.com/History/Parker,%20Richard%20-%20Recollections.pdf
Dr. Jared Husted Parker was born in Cherry Valley in 1795 . . . in the town of Paris, Oneida Co. & . . . thereto Jared H. [attended]
Alexander Hamilton College at Clinton afterward Fairfield Medical College where he graduated at 18 [January 1822 -Degree of Doctor
of Medicine, College of Physicians and Surgeons of the Western District of New York]. [He] Immediately located at Onondaga Hill then
the . . . where he commenced the practice of his profession. He married Mary Pease daughter of Samuel T. Cheney of Manlius
formerly of Rockingham VT – a manufacturer of silk lace [?]. Subsequently Syracuse & Salina being located on the canal had far
advanced in a business point beyond Onondaga. Consequently by a vote of the Co[unty] the Co. seat was removed to the two villages
[Salina and Syracuse] as a compromise and the Court House & Jail were built on North Salina at exactly on the dividing line of the two
village[s]. Across the street opposite west where Town Hall now stand[s] James R. Laurance had erected a large frame four story hotel
with extensive barn[s] open sheds &c & named it the Center House. My Father had now built a large and lucrative practice but on
account of ill health having contracted rheumatism by his long horse back rides in all kinds of weather through sparsely settled county
was obliged to give up his practice & seek other business.
1831 Jany 22 I was born. In that year father leased the Center House for a term of four years at the annual tent of 450 & took
possession Oct 1 with Charles Spafford as Manager. Therefore I was 8 months & 8 days old when I first made my appearance in the
Village of Syracuse then boasting of between four & five thousand inhabitants which was destined to become (possibly on account of
my advent) the great beautiful & prosperous city of to day.
[If my memory would serve me that I might recount the local events that I have been cognizant of the many interesting incidents that
have come within my notice I am sure it would make greater a book]
Page 2
My father had purchased salt block no. 1 located on the Oswego canal Willow & Pearl st & built a house on the latter st. At the
expiration of his lease of the Center House in 1835 moved into the same & engaged in the manufacture of salt afterwards built a house
on Willow st near the bridge an[d] . . . . . there until his death Feby 23 – 1864.
He was quite active in politics [was a whig until the organization of the Rep Party] was elected member of [New York State] Assembly
in 1830 again in 1833. He was Village Trustee, assessor, Sup of Co. Poor, was trustee of pub School No 5 for many years. He was a
Mason having been raised in Onondaga Valley Lodge [98] afterwards affiliated with Old Syracuse Lodge [102].
See Syracuse Lodge No. 501 below for a continuation of this sketch.
Military Lodge No. 215
Manlius, New York
6 Jun 1851 - 17 Jun 1867
See sketch of Military Lodge No. 93 in Part I of the present work; 2 Sep 1802; Last Meeting 25 Dec 1830
11

After a lapse of 21 years, a number of the brethren petitioned for dispensation recommending Bro. Illustrious Remington for WM, Lloyd
Remington, SW and Samuel G. Wilcox, which was granted. The Lodge commenced with the following Charter members as noted from
their Register.:
1. Illustrious Remington
2. Lloyd Remington
3. Robert Gilmore
4. Samuel G. Wilcox
6. Jabez Lewis
7. John W. Lewis
8. William Walter
10. William Taylor
11. Asel Wilcox
12. William M. Richardson
23. George Reals
The above gaps in numbering (nos. 5 and 9) includes two Brothers, Alfred Nims and Reuben A. Reals, who were Raised on 30 May
1852. I do not know why George Reals was counted among the Charter members as member number 23. The intervening numbers
are accounted for by Brothers Affiliated (5) or Raised in 1852 and 1853.
Members
Illustrious Remington was elected as first Master at the reopening of Military Lodge No. 215 in
1851, serving in all 12 years (1851-55, 59-60, 63-66, and 69). He was born at Warwick, Kent Co.,
RI, on 17 Oct 1791. In 1813 he was married to Eunice Dennison who was born 21 Jul 1791 in
Stonington, New London, CT. She was the daughter of Beebe Dennison and Prudence Holmes.
After their marriage he became a resident of Vernon, CT, and later removed to Cherry Valley, NY,
where he affiliated with the Masonic Lodge at that place*, having been made a Mason at Linn
[Lynn], CT, sometime previously. [There were two Lodge in Cherry
Valley, Otsego County, at about this time: Trinity Lodge No. 139,
warranted 19 Jun 1806, and Cherry Valley Lodge No. 276,
warranted 6 Feb 1817.]
In the spring of 1822 he removed to the village of Manlius where
he engaged in the cotton manufacturing business. While he is not
listed as a Member of Military Lodge 93 in Larkin’s book, he was
nonetheless a signatory to the famed ‘Barley Corn’ lease dated 1
Oct 1824. He was also interested in agricultural pursuits and
several years later he became interested in the manufacture of
paper, in which capacity he continued until his final from active business; he was also one of the
directors of Fayetteville National Bank.
He was the senior warden of Christ Episcopal Church at Manlius, which position was filled by him
until his death on 12 May 1883, aged 91 years.
The Remington Memorial Window >
Illustrious Remington was a warden and vestryman of the church for almost fifty years.
Four Remington Siblings, three brothers and a sister, all lived in Manlius.
All were active in the Church.
The Remington memorial window, ordered 1889, came from Munich, Germany.
The figures are in the early Renaissance style.
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~twigs2000/charities7.htm
In 1854 I. Remington & Sons, then operating a mill at Fayetteville, leased the long-idle Juhelville
cotton-mill from P. O’Dougherty, and fitted it up for papermaking, with four rag engines and an 84-
inch Fourdrinier machine. The mill was run entirely on news paper. It had a capacity of one ton per
day and was, in those days, considered a large mill. The firm was composed of Illustrious
Remington and his two sons, Hiram and Alfred D.
A. D. Remington removed to Watertown, and to his energy, business ability, and mechanical skill
much of the development of the paper-making industry in this section was due. In 1863 he became sole proprietor of the mill, and in
1865 organized the Remington Paper Co., which operated one of the most extensive plants in the country. On the expiration of the
O’Dougherty lease, in 1867, the mill was removed to Sewall’s Island, and in 1869, the first wood pulp machinery was introduced.
From that time there was an almost constant increase of facilities and capacity until the Remington Paper Co. operated two large
paper mills, three wood pulp-mills, and one sulphite fibre-mill, the daily output of paper being 30 tons, all made from spruce logs on its
own premises, no rags or other fibre being used.
In 1862 the mill later owned by the Watertown Paper Co. was built by A. D. Remington, at the island end of the upper dam, crossing
the south channel at Sewall’s Island. This mill was for many years operated by Hiram Remington and Charles R. Remington, a
third son of Illustrious Remington. After 1881 it was owned by H. Remington & Son.
WILLIAMS CHAPTER No. 72, RAM.- Organized 8 Feb 1854. First officers . Illustrious Remington, H. P.; Jabez Lewis, S.; Robert
Gilmore, K.
Lloyd Remington, elected Master 1856-57, was a brother of Illustrious Remington above, and also a native of Connecticut. Some
time after coming to Manlius he became interested, with Alvah Woodworth as a partner, in the manufacture of agricultural
implements and general machine work, an industry that was for many years considered among the first of its kink in Onondaga
County. He disposed of his interest in the business in 1861 and bought a farm on the hill east of Manlius, later occupied by George
Hale, where he resided for about three years. He then purchased the residence occupied by Alvah Woodworth, residing there about
the same length of time. He then sold out and purchased the Sylvanus Towsley residence, later owned by George J. Champlin,
where, after a brief illness, he died in 1869, aged 72 years. He was member of Christ Episcopal Church.
12

Robert Gilmore, elected Master 1827-1830, was an early settler in Manlius, having removed here from Albany previous to 1820, as
it was the year he became a member of Military Lodge (the Register notes he was Affiliated, giving his Raised date as 7 Mar 1816).
He was born in New York City.
For many years he was engaged in the stove and tin trade, occupying the brick building on the south side of Military Square, being
the same later used by Bro. C. W. H. Wood as a machine shop. He laid down his Working Tools on 1 Jun 1879, age 86 years and 5
months. He was also a member of Christ Episcopal Church.
Jabez Lewis, of Manlius Center, was elected to the 1857 New York State Assembly, serving until 1864. Tiny Manlius Center grew
in importance, not only because of its location on the Erie, but also through the efforts of Jabez Lewis, who came here in the 1830’s
to serve as New York Central’s freight agent. He became a large landowner here and would later serve the Town of Manlius as
Town Supervisor, 1852-53.
William Walter b. 18 May 1803 d. 9 Jan. 1883, bur. Jan. 10, 1883. Married Parmelia E. _____, Parmelia E. bur. 6 Jan 1874, ae. 66-
0-21,
William Taylor was born in Suffield, CT, on 12 Oct 1791, coming to Manlius in April 1811 where he completed his studies as a
physician under Dr. Bro. Hezekiah L. Granger. In 1812 he became Granger's business partner. In 1817 Taylor was surgeon's mate
in Col. John G. Forbes' 176th regiment. Soon after he became a member of Military Lodge (the archives record that he ‘Affiliated’
on 15 Feb 1821), and was also a Royal Arch Mason. In 1824 Taylor was senior warden of the Masonic Military Lodge. Also in 1824,
Lucy Taylor bought Dr. Bro. Hezekiah Granger's residence at 501 Pleasant Street. Their home, shown on the right, was later
purchased by Gen. Marsena Patrick. He was very successful in his practice and he was selected to represent the town as
Supervisor in 1839 and 1840.
He married Lucy Ward (1792, Shaftsbury, VT-1857), daughter of William
Ward and Susanna Doolittle of Dover, NH. According to historical records
for Onondaga County, William WARD settled on Lot No. 97 in Manlius ca
1793, was appointed a Justice of the Peace and erected the first grist mill
in town.
Bro. Taylor was elected as a Jacksonian to the 23rd and 24th Congresses
and reelected as a Democrat to the 25th Congress (4 Mar 1833 to 3 Mar
1839). He served as chairman of the Committee on Invalid Pensions (25th
Congress) and then resumed the practice of his chosen profession. He
served as member of the state assembly in 1841-42 and as delegate to
the state constitutional convention in 1846.
< The first stained glass window in Christ Church was the Taylor Memorial Window above the altar.
It was installed in the new chancel in February 1867. He died in Manlius, NY, 16 Sep 1865 and was
interred in Christ Church Cemetery. His epitaph reads: FULL OF YEARS, AND/IN THE BRIGHT
HOPE/OF A BLESSED/IMMORTALITY. Taylor's first wife, Hannah, died in 1813, aged 20. His
second wife, Lucy Ward, died 9 Nov 1857, aged 65.
A lengthy address, delivered before the brethren of
Military Lodge on 24 Jun 1822 by Bro. Taylor at the
celebration of the festival of St. John the Baptist, is
recorded on pages 80-91, where, in part, he said, “My
brethren, I have endeavored briefly to delineate some
of the leading principles and duties of Masons, and call
you attention to some of the beauties of our Masonic
edifice.”
In 1867 William Manlius Smith published a
‘Biographical Sketch of William Taylor, MD,’ 10 pages.
ref: http://www.christchurchmanlius.org/tour_1_-_19.htm
http://christchurchmanlius.org/windows3.htm#The%20Taylor%20Memorial%20Window
Asel Wilcox, Master 1816-17, was the son of Bro. Samuel Wilcox, also a Charter Member of Military Lodge No.215. He was reared
on the homestead farm at Lyndon, in the town of DeWitt, formerly a part of Manlius. The large portion of his lifetime was devoted to the
business of agriculture and gypsum or plaster manufacture, a business from which he acquired a large property. His name appears
among those mentioned in the lengthy lease executed by Azariah Smith to Military Lodge. Four generations of the Wilcox family
appear on the Register of Military Lodge.
http://www.rootsweb.com/~nyononda/FAMILY/samuelwilcox.html
Asahel (Asel) Wilcox (son of Samuel Wilcox and Lois Cogswell)
This son was born at Peru MA, 8 Apr 1784, and died at Manlius NY, 5 Jun 1867. On 25 Mar 1812, he married Hillenda Foster, born 13
Jun 1796, died 16 Mar 1867, daughter of Jonathan Bunnion Foster (brother of Bro. Libbeus Foster) and Thankful Messenger
(Wilcox family bible). Asahel and Hillenda are buried at Fayetteville.
Asahel was a landowner and businessman. A plaster bed was opened on the Wilcox homestead about 1812. He had flour, plaster,
cement, and saw mills at Highbridge, and also engaged in boating. He served in the War of 1812, mainly at Oswego and Lewiston,
and had a contract to furnish 2000 tons of plaster at $2.00 per ton (Bruce, 2:1021-22).
Children: (probably all born at Dewitt or Manlius NY)
i. Samuel. died 3 Feb 1816, age 7/12.
ii. Franklin, born 1817, died 13 Apr 1873, married Nancy Lidman or Snell; lived at Vernon, Oneida County.
13

iii. Lois C. married Joseph Bennett; lived at Maqoun, IL.
iv. Clinton. died 15 May 1821, age 16 days.
v. Asahel F(oster). born 16 Nov 1823.
vi. Hillenda (Helen). born 1826; died 28 July 1890, Dewitt; married Peter Lansing.
vii. S. Gilbert. died 21 Apr 1854, age 25.
viii. Lucy A. born 1833; married Simon Rice; lived at Manlius.
Children (above), i, ii, iv, vii buried at Fayetteville.
------------------
6 Jun 1851 New Charter granted under the No. 215
In Jan 1860 they reported 90 members. Of this number there were 14 who belonged to Military Lodge No. 93 in Dec 1829, viz.:
Bickford, Dearborn B.
Clapp, Carlton
Clement, Hiram
Clink, Michael
Edwards, Harry
Gilmore, Robert
Hibbard, Isaac V. V.
Loomis, Isaac N.
Moore, Henry B.
Story, Amos
Taylor, George L.
Taylor, William
Wilcox, Asa
Worden, Hiram H.
It may be further noted that Bros. Thomas Church, Jeremiah Gates, Asel Wilcox and David Williams signed the by-laws of Military
Lodge in 1814, and were also signers of the by-laws of 1851.
1867 06-08 84 The petition of Military Lodge, asking for the restoration of the original number (which was 93) has been
carefully considered, and your committee would recommend that the prayer of the petitioners by granted.
Minutes of Military Lodge referring to change in Lodge Number
5 May 1867 T. D. Hadley, D. D. Barnes, and A. Nims were appointed by Worshipful A. A. Wood as a committee to frame a
memorial to be presented to Grand Lodge to restore the old lodge No. 93.
20 May 1867 The above committee presented the above mentioned memorial which was adopted. The Worshipful Master A. A.
Wood was appointed to present the request to Grand Lodge.
17 Jun 1867 Number 215 was used for the last time.
1 Jul 1867 Number 93 was noted to the minutes for the first time since 25 Dec 1830.
There are no other minutes referring to this change, other than “It was moved and voted the thanks of this lodge be tendered to
Worshipful Master A. A. Wood for services rendered this lodge” on 21 Dec 1868.
Another factor facilitating the restoration of its original number may be cited. Number 93 had been reassigned to St. Joseph Valley
Lodge in Niles (Berrien County), Michigan by the Grand Lodge of New York on 10 Jun 1843. This lodge was one of the four
constituting the new Grand Lodge in Michigan in 1845. It was given the No. 4, and is still in good standing (2007). The number 93
thereafter was dormant until returned to Military Lodge in 1867. No other lodge in this county reactivated after the Morgan episode had
been successful in this respect.
It is interesting that whereas the original petition of Military Lodge No. 93 was endorsed by United Brethren Lodge No. 78, Cazenovia,
New York, the minutes of Military Lodge No. 215 of 21 May 1866 state that a petition from brethren in Cazenovia for a lodge was
presented and granted. (Cazenovia Lodge No. 616, chartered 11 Jun 1867.)
Corinthian Lodge No. 222
Skaneateles / Marcellus, New York
ca Mar 1852 – 7 Mar 1855
In the annals of Craft Masonry of Onondaga County, this Lodge is bit of an enigma. With this said the following quoted transcription is
given verbatim as to its existence and work in the county. The original for this transcription was written in July 1924 by William M.
Beauchamp, presumably the son the locally famed historian Rev. William Martin Beauchamp and uncle of F. J. Humphryes, who
compiled the ‘History of Masonry in Skaneateles’ in the 64 page booklet, “Souvenir of Skaneateles Masonic Fair and Carnival,” printed
for this event of 4-9 August 1924. The following appears on pages 19 and 21 of this booklet.
“At this date, July 1924, there seems to be no authentic history of the application for a Charter for this Lodge. I have in my possession
a copy of the By-Laws, adopted August 26th, 1851, and printed by H. B. Dodge, owner and publisher of the Skaneateles Democrat. I
presume at the request of the Lodge, also a Ledger under dates of 1854, 55 and 56 from which I copy the following names [which has
been alphabetized and placed into columns for easier reference – glh]:
Beauchamp, William M.
Brown, Jos.
Courtney, Robert
Dare, Robt.
Fuller, Bonville
Fuller, Samuel
Gillys, David
Hall, Daniel W.
Hessler, Oliver
Isom, John F.
Isom, Thomas
Mason, Richworth
Nye, John M.
Page, Gorham
Phillips, Ulysses F.
Thompson, Charles
Wheadon, Samuel C.
Williamson, Philander
14

Notes - glh: Oliver Hessler appears in South Onondaga, 1840, and again in 1952-53 in the Skaneateles Methodist Church
as a ‘pastoral minister.’ Samuel C. Wheadon is noted as a member of Village Lodge No. 80 above, and also a later member
of Morning Star Lodge No. 290 at Marcellus. The name Samuel Wheadon also appears as one of the first settlers of
Marcellus on South Hill, ca 1800; this may perhaps have been he or his father.
William M[illet]. Beauchamp [b. ca 1799] was a native of Somersetshire, England and came to America in 1929. He married
Mary, daughter of James Jay, and they had five children: Mary E., Mrs. Maria B. Humphryes, [Rev.] William M., John A.,
and Sarah A.. In 1831 Mr. Beauchamp moved to Skaneateles where he founded and published the Skaneateles Democrat
in 1840. He also engaged in the nursery business and was one of the first to experiment in the raising of teasels in New York
State. He died in 1867, aged 68 years. Ref: Dwight H. Bruce, Ed., Onondagas Centennial Gleanings of a Century. 1896,
Vol II, Family Sketches, page 99.
“The William M. Beauchamp, mentioned above, is the father of Rev. Wm. M. Beauchamp and grandfather of the [present] writer. From
Dr. Beauchamp’s history of Masonry in Skaneateles, I find the following:
‘Corinthian Lodge No. 222’ – What discussion of the matter there might have been I do not know, but in his diary of January
27th, 1851, my father wrote: ‘I went to Auburn with S. Fuller and Lewis Beardsley to attend the Lodge. Three initiated. Did
not get home until 12.’
“(Brother Wm. E. Taylor of St. Paul’s Lodge, Auburn, sends me the following from the records:
‘Wm M. Beauchamp, born in England, by occupation, horticulturalist. He was 51 years of age when initiated in St. Paul’s Lodge No.
124, on the 27th day of January, 1851, withdrew May, 1851. I have no doubt that it was for the purpose of joining Corinthian Lodge No.
222 that he withdrew from St. Paul’s Lodge. Samuel Fuller, born in England, occupation Farmer. He was 24 years old when he was
initiated January 27th, 1851, withdrew May 1851, withdrew probably for the same reason.” The writer).
March 22nd – Had a meeting in my room in regard to a Lodge. March 31st had a meeting of Masons.
July 9th, Brother Hooper came over to give us Masonic instructions.
July 10th, attended Lodge morning, afternoon and evening.
February 3rd, 1852, attended Lodge.
March 19th, Mr. Chase, G. V., paid us a visit (G. V. may mean Grand Visitor).
March 22nd, Mr. Chase left for Borodino.
The next line is definite. March 27th received dispensation form Grand Lodge last night.
Note - glh: There were several “Chases” in the Onondaga Masonic District at this period:
Dudley Winthrop Chase, Horace Hills Chase and Van Buren Chase, all of Syracuse Lodge No. 102
“The first book of records of Corinthian Lodge disappeared from the Secretary’s desk and never came to light. A small copy book
replaced it, all records being written by my father [Rev. Wm]. It begins December 27th, 1853, and abruptly ends March 7th, 1855. This
came into my hands of my nephew, F. J. Humphryes. The officers elected January 3rd, 1854, were:
Samuel Fuller
Master
Richworth Mason Senior Warden
Thomas Isaam [Isom], Sr. Junior Warden
William M. Beauchamp [Sr.] Secretary
Bonville Fuller
Treasurer
Robert Courtney Senior Deacon
Coral Humphrey
Junior Deacon”
Notes – glh: There exists a May 1936 newspaper article in the Skaneateles Press entitled "Notes from my Scrapbook" by F.
J. Humphryes, an article on old families in the area, a copy of which is available from the Onondaga Historical Association.
Corinthian Lodge No. 222 appears in the List of Lodges, page 158, Grand Lodge of New York Proceedings, 1853, and is
listed in 1855, page 160, but not in 1856, page 185.
Central City No. 305
Syracuse, New York
11 Jun 1853 - 1999
So endeth the tale of this enigmatic Lodge.
Petition:
Signatures:
Barnum, Isaac D.
Bigelow, Joshua G.
Devendorf, H. H.
Hamilton, Wm. T.
5 May 1853; to M.’.W.’. Reuben H. Walworth, Grand Master.
Leach, James S.
Marvin, Edgar
Mathews, James H.
Nye, James W.
Paige, Clinton F.
Phillips, John H.
Pratt, W. H. H.
Richardson, Robert M.
Seymour, Joseph
Thompson, D. W.
Williams, George N.
Endorsement: 5 May 1853; signed by: William Hall, Master; John W. Cook, Senior Warden; William L. Palmer, Junior Warden.
At a regular meeting of Syracuse Lodge No. 102 of Free and Accepted Masons, held at the hall in the city of Syracuse on the 5th
Day of May, A.D. 1853, A.L. 5853, a petition was presented in the Lodge which was directed to the Grand Lodge of the State of New
York, signed by Bros. Joseph Seymour, W.’. H. H. Pratt and others, for a warrant for a new Masonic Lodge to be located in
Syracuse, to be called Central City Lodge.
Warrant: 11 Jun 1854
15

It was early in the year of 1853 that a group of Masons, members of Syracuse Lodge No. 102, feeling there was a need for
expanded activities in the Masonic Fraternity in the City of Syracuse, made application to Grand Lodge of this State for a
dispensation to form a new Lodge to be known as Central City Lodge.
The outstanding and exemplary character of the petitioners, together with the favorable recommendation of Syracuse Lodge No.
102, resulted in a procedure most unusual in that the customary trial period under dispensation was waived, and the warrant for the
Lodge was promptly issued and its charter bears the date of 11 Jun 1854.
First Officers:
George N. Williams, Master Druggist. b/ ca 1819, Franklin, CT. Initiated in Mt. Morris Lodge No. 122, New York. Master in 1853,
attended Grand Lodge as representative in June 1854. Appointed to Committee on Grievances, June 1854.
Joshua G. Bigelow, SW Physician, b. ca 1822 in Oswego County. Initiated in Sylvan Lodge No. 44.
Robert M. Richardson, JW Attorney, by ca 1819.
Charter Members:
Barnum, Isaac D. Saddler.
Devendorf, H. H. Bank Teller, b. ca 1834.
Hamilton, William F. Merchant, b. ca 1830 in Onondaga, NY. Initiated in Syracuse Lodge No. 102.
Leach, James S. Attorney, b. ca 1809, resided in Syracuse. Initiated in Sylvan Lodge No. 44.
Marvin, Edgar Merchant, b. ca 1827. Initiated in Syracuse Lodge No. 102.
Mathews, James H. Bookkeeper, b. ca 1829 in Salina, Onondaga, NY. Initiated in Syracuse Lodge No. 102.
Nye, James W. Attorney, b. ca 1831.
Paige, Clinton F. Attorney, b. ca 1829 in Dryden, Tompkins County, New York. Initiated 11 Mar, Passed 17 Mar, Raised 24
Mar 1853 in Syracuse Lodge No. 102. Master 1855-60. Grand Master in 1863-64.
Phillips, John H. Bookkeeper, b. ca 1831 in Dryden, Tompkins County, New York.
Pratt, William H. H. Secretary IOOF, b. ca 1816 in Prattsville, NY. Initiated in Joppa Lodge, Brooklyn.
Seymour, Joseph Silversmith, b. ca 1824 in Schoharie, NY. Initiated in Syracuse Lodge No. 102
Thomson, David W. Tailor, b. ca 1819.
Meeting Places:
1. 1854. First displayed it three great lights in the Stanley Block, which later occupied the site of the Merchant National Bank
Building on S. Warren Street.
2. Building on S. Salina Street, which would be about number 317, however the buildings have so changed at this location that it
would be very difficult to determine the exact position of this meeting place.
3. In the year 1871 the Lodge moved to a location further south in the same block of S. Salina Street, into a building known as the
Crouse-Lyman-Gifford Estate Building. The entrance was located at what would be about 339 S. Salina Street. The Lodge remained
at this location for about 45 years. Those of our members who received their degrees in these old quarters would recall with
sentimental regard those old Lodge rooms, unique in many respects, but whose memories remind us of the happy days of our
Masonic careers. There one found Masonic brotherhood at its best.
It was at this location that quarters were fitted up for the use of other Masonic bodies known as Central City, which included:
Central City Chapter 70, RAM
Central City Council 13, Royal and Select Masters (Cryptic)
Central City Commandery No. 25, K.T., and
Central City Bodies, Ancient Accepted Scottish Rite (A.A.S.R.)
In Jan 1902 a most disastrous fire swept through these quarters with great loss to the various Masonic bodies, including the early
records, and thus was lost much data and valuable and intimate information regarding the early history of the Lodge.
4. It was at this time that Syracuse Lodge No. 501, with generous
hospitality, permitted Central City Lodge No. 305 to use their rooms,
and thus our Lodge was able to continue its work without interruption
in the Greyhound Building (photo), located at the northwest corner of
James and Warren Streets. The Lodge continued to meet there for
several months while its old quarters were being repaired.
---------
1000th to 2500th Members
On 20 Dec 1910 a Third Degree was conferred on a class of five, and
this marked the 1000th member of the Lodge, or 1000 members in 57
years, for an average of nearly 20 per year in “good” and well as
“bad” years. By 1917 the total had increased to 1217 Brothers. We
continued to grow to 2500 members, but due to deaths, demits and
members dropped for non-payment of dues, we started to go downward by 1957 with a total of 950 Brothers spread throughout the
United States and in many foreign lands.
---------
16

Syracuse Masonic Temple
5. In 1917 our Lodge joined with the other Masonic bodies in the City of Syracuse to occupy the new Masonic Temple located at
320 Montgomery Street, where it was one of the four owner Lodges, which were:
Central City Lodge No. 305
Syracuse Lodge No. 501
Salt Springs Lodge No. 520
Mount Sinai Lodge No. 864
The cornerstone of this building was laid on 4 Nov 1915 when Central City Lodge No. 305 joined the other Masonic bodies in the
city and with the officers of the Grand Lodge in the formal ceremony.
Herbert W. Greenland recorded the story of the Syracuse Masonic Temple’s conception and subsequent building in his booklet,
“Free Masonry in Syracuse and Vicinity, published by the Syracuse Journal at the Dedication of the Syracuse Masonic Temple,
February 22, 1917.”
The interesting account that he then gave is as follows:
1879 - The erection of a temple to hold all of the Masonic Bodies had long been an ardent desire of the Syracuse Masons. In 1879,
committees were appointed by the three lodges (Central City 305, Syracuse 501 and Salt Springs 520), and an organization
formed, who secured options on many sites at prices which we now realize were very low, but then the present only was considered
and the brethren were reluctant to mortgage the future, so the whole project was abandoned.
1891 - The Masons of the city again felt the time was ripe to build their temple. An organization of the three lodges was formed with
about 200 members. Brother Austin C. Wood was the president and Brother Benjamin F. Stevens, secretary. Up to 1894
subscriptions for bonds to the amount of $25,000 were received. Unfortunately at that time the great financial troubles of the country
set in and many of the subscribers found it impossible to meet their payments. A meeting was called and it was voted to pay back
the amount subscribed and again abandon the undertaking. During its existence the association held many entertainments and the
proceeds thereof enabled it to pay all of its expenses and also the interest on all subscriptions.
21 Jan 1909 - Syracuse Lodge was summoned to take action regarding the purchase for a
Masonic Building of the Jones property on the southwest corner of South Salina and Adams
Streets, upon which an option was secured for $30,000. There was a large attendance and a
special committee was appointed to consider the proposition. April 1 the committee reported
that only an unsatisfactory progress had been made and asked to be discharged, which was
done.
2 Feb 1912 - Central City Lodge No. 305 sent communications to the other lodges
announcing that a committee had been appointed to consider a plan for the erection of a
Masonic Temple and asked that like committees be appointed to co-operate therewith.
Several meetings of the committee were held and reports made to their respective lodges, but
on account of a difference of opinion among the members of the several lodges as to the
erection of a strictly “Fraternal” building, or of a “Commercial-Fraternal” building, there was no
union of effort and the committees were discharged. Central City Lodge, however, authorized
the purchase of the property 604 (620) South Salina Street with the intention of erecting
thereon a Temple for the Central City Bodies, but upon the agreement of the Masonic Bodies
of Syracuse upon the site of Montgomery Street, it abandoned the project and contracted to
convey the South Salina Street site to the Syracuse Temple Association for $33.500.
The history of the new temple, from the inception to completion is fully related in the
dedication program, so it will not be necessary to give it here.
22 Feb 1917 - distinctively marks the division between the old and new in the local history of Free Masonry in Syracuse and may be
compared to the entrance of the Chosen People of God into the promised land, after their wanderings for forty years in the
wilderness. For nearly a hundred years the craft, in its various lodges and other bodies, has held meetings in numerous localities,
wherever quarters were available, which were fitted up and maintained by great individual expense, only to be discarded after a time
to repeat the experiment in other places. What we and our predecessors have hoped for and dreamed of is now realized. We will
hereafter be under one roof, a united family where one may have any and all degrees of Masonry, as well as of the allied
organizations, conferred. Where no distinction can exist, “save that noble contention, or rather emulation, of who best can work and
best agree.”
---------
Here follows the tribute of the General Temple Committee:
Dream of Generation of Masons Fulfilled
The dream of a generation of Masons in Syracuse came to a full and happy realization. Too high a tribute cannot be paid to the
small, generous hand of our brothers, whose unceasing activity and unfailing perseverance have translated a glorious vision into a
still more glorious reality. Credit is due the Masons whose financial assistance made it possible to enter upon the project so happily
concluded. To all who have borne a hand in this project the consciousness of a work well done will be a proud memory in the years
to come.
Space does not permit an extended explanation of the history of our Temple. Its roots reach back into the years where dreamers in
Masonry foresaw in marble and stone a living example of the strength and vitality of our institution.
It immediate history began with a meeting in November 1914, with the following representatives:
Central City Lodge:
Edward E. Haun, George N. Crouse and William F. Canough
17

Syracuse Lodge:
Salt Springs Lodge:
Mount Sinai Lodge:
Louis J. Lynn, Selbert T. Friedrich and Hubert J. Wright
Lawrence Thompson, Caleb Joss and Oscar W. Palmer
Isaac Schwartz, Norwell L. Philllips and Sigmund Sugarman
< 320 Montgomery Street, ca 1880, residence and office of Dr. Henry H. Pease.
At that meeting Lawrence Thompson was chosen president and Edward F. Haun
secretary. The next step was the securing of an option on the land where the Masonic
Temple stood at 320 Montgomery Street, the option being taken in the names of Selbert
T. Friedrich, Oscar W. Palmer and William F. Canough. Shortly thereafter the committee
agreed unanimously authorizing the organization of a corporation under Benevolent
Orders Law. This action of the committee was ratified 28-31 Dec 1914, by the four
mentioned lodges and each and each of the lodges thereupon elected one trustee, as
follows:
Central City Lodge:
Syracuse Lodge:
Salt Springs Lodge:
Mount Sinai Lodge:
William F. Canough
Hubert J. Wright
George E. Derby
Isaac Schwartz
Corporation papers were filed on 8 Jan 1915, and the following day the organization of
the trustees was perfected; William F. Canough was elected president, George E. Derby,
vice president, Isaac Schwartz, secretary, and Hubert J. Wright, treasurer. The trustees
employed Messrs. Gaggin & Gaggin as architects and purchased the lot secured by
option. Messrs. Gaggin & Gaggin, were Edwin H. Gaggin and T. Walker Gaggin of
Syracuse, NY. Bro. Thomas Walker Gaggin was Raised in Central City Lodge No. 305
on 25 March 1913. His biographical sketch may be seen below.
Dr. Henry H. Pease
To digress for a moment, while on the subject of the Syracuse Masonic Temple’s origins, Dr. Henry Hale Pease, did indeed occupy
the address of 320 Montgomery Street prior to the demolition of his home for the building of the Temple. A Masonic membership
has not been found for Dr. Pease (b. 26 Apr 1860, Syracuse) at this writing, but it is quite possible that he could have belonged to
one of the several lodges in the City at the time. He was the son of Roger Williams Pease and Hannah (Fuller) Pease.
Roger W. Pease is listed as member no. 43, GL no. 55847, in the Register of Syracuse Lodge No. 501:
Initiated 28 Jun 1855; Passed 6 Sep 1855; Raised 11 Oct 1855; affiliated to Syracuse 501 from Syracuse Lodge No. 102 on 20
Mar 1861. Physician. Suspended 24 Apr 1867. He is the only Pease in the Syracuse 501 Register.
Brother Roger W. Pease was born 31 May 1828 in Conway, MA; d. 28 May 1886 in Syracuse, NY; m. Jan 26, 1858 in Syracuse,
Hannah Fuller. She was the daughter of James C. Fuller the noted Abolitionist of Skaneateles, NY. Roger Pease graduated
from the College of Medicine and Surgery in Geneva, NY, Jan 25, 1848, and practiced in Syracuse. During the Civil War, he was a
surgeon with the 12th New York Infantry, connected to the Army of the Potomac in May 1861. This Regiment was at the battle at
Blackburn’s Ford Jul 18, 1861.
After a brief retirement, Doctor Pease joined the 10th New York Cavalry as a Major Surgeon in Nov 1861, and spent the winter in
Gettysburg. In Apr 1862 he organized the 1200 bed Patterson Park US Hospital at Baltimore. The following year, he was at the
battle of Fredericksburg under Major General Burnside. On May 25, 1863, Surgeon Pease was made Medical Inspector of the
Cavalry Corps by General Stoneman, and organized a field hospital at Aquia Creek. In the expedition of General Philip H. Sheridan
towards the Virginia Central Railroad, Pease transported over 400 wounded soldiers nearly 200 miles to the White House using only
twelve ambulances, and any vehicle he could obtain. He also participated in the Battles of Richmond, Old Tavern and Cold Harbor.
The results of exposure in all of the battles impaired Surgeon Pease’s health, forcing him to resign from the field. He was placed in
command of the Newton US General Hospital, and later, the Charlestown, West Virginia Hospital. He was mustered out as a Brevet
Lieutenant Colonel, Oct 07, 1865. After the War, he resumed his practice in Syracuse.
ref: http://archiver.rootsweb.com/th/read/PEASE/2000-09/0969911460
Roger W. Pease, Tenth Cavalry, whose services were so highly appreciated that he was promoted to be Medical Director of the
Cavalry Corps of the Army of the Potomac . . . (from Honors of the Empire State in the War of the Rebellion, by Thomas Seaman
Townsend, 1889, page 49)
In the yearbook of Syracuse University, “The Onondagan,” of 1886, Roger W. Pease, is listed as: Professor of Operative and
Clinical Surgery, residing at 36 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, NY (pg. 21)
In 1872 the Geneva Medical College was transformed into the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Syracuse University; Roger
W. Pease served on the Committee which brought this transformation about. (pg. 57)
To resume to chronological account of the Syracuse Masonic Temple:
4 Nov 1915 - the cornerstone of the Syracuse Masonic Temple was laid with Masonic service, R.’.W.’. William S. Farmer acting as
Grand Master. Nearly 3,000 Masons participated in the parade. Despite the difficulty of securing materials and other unavoidable
delays, the building was been rapidly pushed to completion, so that it was ready for occupancy.
18

The following items are especially worth emphasizing:
• the building contained an elaborate ventilating system at a cost of $8,000. (about $125,803.43 in 2006 dollars)
• the Brass pillars at the entrance were donated H. B. Azadian of Salt Springs Lodge.
• the stucco Masonic emblems over the proscenium arch on the stage were made and donated by Frederick Schneider of
Central City Lodge.
• the building cost, with the lot, about $250,000, and was built within the sum appropriated. (about $3,931,357.25 in 2006)
• the first meetings in the new Temple were held by:
Central City Lodge 2 Jan 1917
Mount Sinai Lodge 3 Jan 1917
Syracuse Lodge 4 Jan 1917
Salt Springs Lodge 8 Jan 1917
• Merwin W. Lay was the first Master installed.
At the first meetings above mentioned all outstanding bonds were sold and the successful financing of the Temple completed. On 1
Jan 1917, Hubert J. Wright resigned and Frank T. Miller of Syracuse Lodge was elected in his place as treasurer.
The Masons of Syracuse could justly pride themselves on the fact that seldom was a building constructed with the celerity and with
the same efficiency as this Masonic Temple. Justly could they say to the Board of Trustees, “Well done, good and faithful servants.”
Tenants of the Temple ?
Temple closed in 1984
Parking; Seedy
Sell out, no plan, Money
Sold out from under CC 305
Furniture – Paul Fritsch – no agreement, $60,000 in furniture left behind.
Who was the Committee for the closing of the Temple?
The Syracuse Masonic Temple, as of 2007
http://development.downtownsyracuse.com/planned/detail.php?id=12
< Building exterior
Project Name:
Masonic Temple
Project Developer:
Masonic Lofts LLC
Project Address: 318 Montgomery St, Syracuse, NY 13202
District:
Heart of Downtown
Estimated Project Cost:
$5.76 million
Anticipated Start/Completion Date: Oct 1, 2006 / Jun 1, 2007
Project Description:
Monahan Development Corporation announced plans in April 2006 to transform the currently
vacant Masonic Temple, located at 320 Montgomery Street, into 35 live/work lofts and ground floor
commercial space. Built in 1917, the Masonic Temple was occupied by the Masons until 1985, when the Metropolitan School of the
Arts (MSOA) purchased the building for use as a center for arts-related programming. However, the MSOA’s plans for the reuse of
this historic property came to a halt during the early stages of renovation and the building has lay vacant since.
Jim Monahan, president of Monahan Development, and a partner in the LLC responsible for spearheading this redevelopment
project will transform this five story, 68,500 square foot structure into a home for artists, entrepreneurs, and those who operate their
own business. Each residential unit will have approximately 1,150 square feet of space to allow for both living space and studio or
business space. All but one unit will have 2 bedrooms. Monahan has used a combination of historic preservation tax credits, low
income housing tax credits, and tax free bond financing to complete this $5.76 million project. As a result of Monahan’s financing
structure, apartments can only be rented to “moderate” income residents – those making approximately $16 per hour.
Although Monahan’s project is not targeted specifically to artists, it is expected that the attractive rent rates, apartment design, and
location in downtown will attract artist residents as Montgomery Street has long been viewed as the cultural heart of downtown
Syracuse. Construction on this project is expected to start mid-October 2006 and be ready for tenant occupancy by June 2007.
Background on Development Team:
Monahan Development Corporation provides many services, from concept to planning, financing to development and project
management, sales and leasing to ongoing property management. Monahan Development's housing projects have included historic
rehabilitation for low income housing, such as the Dubois Street Historic Renovation, and for market rent tenants, such as the
Hanover Square Lofts. Other projects include the ongoing Peekskill ArtLofts and the ten year-old Low Income Housing Tax Credit
project in Eaton, NY.
Monahan Development is headquartered in downtown Syracuse.
See also, for interior pictures: http://syracusethenandnow.org/Dwntwn/MontgmrySt/MasonicTemple.htm
19

-----------------
The history of Central City Lodge through the years was one of progress and accomplishment. The Lodge drew to its membership
many of the professional and businessmen of the community with the result that many doctors, lawyers, and business executives
participated actively in the affairs of the Lodge.
The Lodge was known for the high quality of its ritualistic work, and for many years its exemplification of the Third Degree, with its
elaborate costuming and stage settings, attracted wide attention from all over New York State and other Masonic jurisdictions.
Credit for the development of a high standard of degree work is largely due to the outstanding efforts of R.’.W.’. Howard E. Plaisted
who served as Master of the Lodge for four years, and as its beloved secretary for 19 years. It was during his Mastership that he
ruled that all officers and Brethren participating in the work should wear formal evening clothes. As the first Lodge to do this, it
became known as the “Silk Stocking Lodge.” The sobriquet, however, came to mean leadership in the community. This was started
in the year 1893 when he was installed Master of Central City Lodge No. 305. The Lodge owed much of its success over the years
to the efforts of Brother Plaisted who was ever an inspiration to Masons, both young and old, who looked to him for Masonic
guidance.
Third Degree Team – ca 1928 – Central City Lodge No. 305
Biographies
http://wc.rootsweb.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db=gdtrowbridge&id=I14605
Mead Belden was born 14 Feb 1833 in Fabius, NY, the son of Royal Denison Belden born
17 Feb 1795 in Onondaga Co., NY; died 2 Jul 1868 in Fabius, Onondaga Co., NY, and Olive
Cadwell, born 25 Feb 1794 in East Hartford, CT; died 1 Feb 1856 in Geddes, NY. Bro. Mead
Belden m1. Elizabeth Hubbell; he m2 Amelian Gertrude Woolson 31 Mar 1864 who was born
ca 1837 in NY. Mead and Gertrude had four children:
i. Edward Mead Belden, b. 16 Apr 1865 ;
ii. Anna Louise Belden, b. 2nd week in Feb 1867 who m. 23 of April, 1895 Andrew Strong
White, b. 1st week of Feb 1866.
iii. Edith Belden, b. 24 Sep 1869 who m. 23 Apr 1896 John Wilkinson, b. 11 Feb 1868. Their
daughter, Helen, was born 5 Apr 1897.
iv. Olive Gertrude Belden, b. 5 Jan 1873 who m. 23 Apr 1895 Henry Wigglesworth. They had
a daughter, Silvia, b. 8 Jul 1897. Among Olive’s descendants are Howard Brush Dean III, b.
17 Nov 1948, Governor of Vermont elected to five two-year terms, serving as governor from
1991 to 2003, making him the second longest-serving Governor in Vermont history.
Masonic Career of Bro. Belden:
Mar 1860 Raised in Central City Lodge No. 305
1861 Received the Capitular Degrees
1862 Created a Knight Templar in Central City Commandery No. 25, KT
1865 Grand Warden of the Grand Commander of the State of New York
1868 Third Commander of Central City Commandery No. 25, KT
1873 Grand Commander of the Grand Commandery of the State of New York
He Received all the Grades of the A.A.S.R. in the Syracuse Valley
7 Feb 1872 Created a Sovereign Grand Inspector General, 33 o , Honorary Member of the Supreme Council, NMJ, by special
commission at Albany, NY.
Bro. Belden had for some years been a large contractor for earth works, and in the pursuit of his business contracted malarial
disorders which, for some year or more prior to his death, had rendered his health precarious. On 7 Jun 1876 in Syracuse, feeling
somewhat indispose, he retired early and in a few moments expired.
20

Edward Heywood Brown was born 15 Aug 1834 in Greenwich Village, now a part of the City
of New York. After the death of his father about 1842, Bro. Brown removed to Syracuse and
was brought up in the family of his uncle, John Flint. He was educated in the public schools of
Syracuse and graduated as a civil engineer from Rensselaer Institute of Technology at Troy.
Shortly after his graduation he became connected with the Syracuse Water Company, and
was its superintendent for many years until the water plant was taken over by the city. He
then went to California where he was engaged in railroad building and mining pursuits. His
health failed in 1898, and he was obliged to give up his business, returning to Syracuse
where he spent the remaining years of his life with the friends of his youth. Although confined
to the house for many years, and at times suffering a great deal of pain, he was at all times
uncomplaining; he never lost his bright and cheery disposition nor his interest in current
events, and appreciated to the full the attentions which he received from his Masonic
brethren.
Masonic Career:
1856 Raised in Roman Lodge No. 223 at Rome, NY
1858 Affiliated with Central City Lodge No. 305; Master in 1864, 1865 and 1872.
1869-1870 District Deputy of the 16th Masonic District
1875-1876 High Priest of Central City Chapter No. 70, RAM
1869 Thrice Illustrious Master of Central City Council No. 13, Royal and Select Masters
1879 Commander of Central City Commandery No. 25, KT.
1866 Received the degrees of the Ancient Accepted Scottish Rite, holding office in all of the bodies,
most of the time from 1866 to 1877 inclusive.
1868-1871 Thrice Potent Master of the Lodge of Perfection
1867 He was one of the officers of the New York Council of Deliberation at its first meeting,
after the Union of the Supreme Councils.
7 Feb 1872 He was crowned an Honorary Member of the Supreme Council, 33 o , at New York.
Being possessed of a fine voice and a splendid presence, Bro. Brown excelled as a ritualist. His rendition of the different degrees,
especially the Order of the Temple in the Commandery, in which he acted as Prelate for many years, and the beautiful degrees of
the Scottish Rite, was one of the traditions of Masonry in Syracuse.
After his return from California, he was prevented by illness from attending the meetings of any Masonic Body, although he was
present with them in spirit. His did appear at the meeting of the Council of Deliberation of New York in 1907, when he was carried in
and he and his colleagues, 33 o , were received and greeted as the only survivors of the first meeting of the body forty years previous.
Bro. Brown died at Syracuse on 10 Mar 1917 and was buried by Central City Lodge No. 305, from the Syracuse Masonic Temple,
with interment in Oakwood Cemetery.
Thomas Walker Gaggin was born 1 Jan 1871 in Erie, PA. He came to Syracuse to attend the University and remained to give the
City the benefit of a beautiful and successful life. In college he became a member of Delta Kappa Epsilon Fraternity and every
maintained an active interest as a “deke.”
Syracuse in the late 1880s.
http://archives.syr.edu/archives/buildings/goldstein_alumni.html
Goldstein Alumni and Faculty Center, Syracuse University, constructed as
Delta Kappa Epsilon Fraternity House: 1903. Designed by SU alumni Edwin
H. Gaggin, (1866-1955) Class of 1892, and T. Walker Gaggin, Class of 1895,
it is a modified federal style building of red Akron brick with trimmings, sill
courses, bay window, etc. of white Vermont marble. The foundation is of
Onondaga limestone. The interior boats a central hall wainscoted high in dark
oak, with oak beam ceiling. Located ay formerly Walnut Avenue until E. S.
Bird Library's construction cut off the end of Walnut; now 401 University
Place
On November 17, 1871 the Phi Gamma chapter of Delta Kappa Epsilon was
chartered, the first chapter of any fraternity located at Syracuse University.
Originally housed in lodge rooms in the Wieting Block downtown, the ‘Dekes’
flourished through myriad housing changes and became one of the first
fraternities to adopt the chapter house system when it was inaugurated at
As noted in the 1910 Catalogue of the Delta Kappa Epsilon Fraternity, “For many years it was the dearest wish of every brother to
have an ideal chapter house, located within easy reach of the University and possessing all the modern conveniences of a fraternity
house.” In 1898 the Central New York Association of Delta Kappa Epsilon, consisting of ‘Dekes’ of all chapters, was organized, and
at once started an active movement for a new chapter house. A financial canvass was started and at the commencement banquet of
June 1899, $8,000 was subscribed. This amount, with that previously secured, formed the nucleus of the building fund.”
Designed by SU alumni Edwin H. Gaggin, Class of 1892, and T. Walker Gaggin, Class of 1895, the new chapter house was
“situated at the corner of Walnut Avenue and University Place, without doubt the finest site near the campus for a building of this
kind. The house faces Walnut Park and has a side outlook upon the campus, a view which can never be cut off by future building in
any direction.” The house was opened for the first time by the annual banquet of the Central New York Association of Delta Kappa
Epsilon on the evening of June 9, 1903 and 155 brothers were present.
21

In 1974 Syracuse University bought the DKE fraternity house when the chapter moved to Comstock Avenue. After remodeling, the
new Faculty Center was opened on November 4, 1974 with accommodations for meetings,
lunch or informal relaxation.
Having completed the course in Architecture at Syracuse University, he took graduate work at
Columbia and attended L'École des Beaux Arts in Paris. As an architect he placed great
emphasis upon the study of classical works and deprecated the tendency to underestimate
the value of cultural study. Less than a week before he died he stated his intention to re-read
the works of the great classical writers and quoted at length from Latin and Greek authors.
Several of the public and commercial buildings of Syracuse
were designed and the erection supervised by Bro. Gaggin.
He planned the hospital in which he died. The Crouse Hinds
Building, the A. E. Nettleton Shoe Factory, Syracuse
Y.M.C.A Building, several hospital buildings and Winchell
Hall are but a few of the buildings which he supervised.
The Syracuse Masonic Temple was his product and for
many years he served as President of the Trustees of the
Temple.
Syracuse Masonic Temple >
Dedicated 22 Feb 1917
He designed the L. C. Smith Building in Seattle and made frequent trips to the coast during its
construction.
< Smith Tower construction, February 1913, Seattle, Washington. On 20 Oct 1910, the City of
Seattle issued a permit to build a 36-story steel frame and concrete office building at the northeast
corner of 2nd Avenue and Yesler Way. It was completed in 1914 as the Smith Tower, and was the
tallest building west of Ohio at the time.
Edwin H. Gaggin and T. Walker Gaggin of Syracuse, NY, were the architects,
and Lyman Cornelius Smith (1834-1910) was the owner.
It took four years to construct the building, which was dedicated on 4 Jul 1914. Smith died before the building was completed. He
was an inventor and industrialist. Although his family manufactured guns, they are not the 'Smith' from Smith and Wesson. They
founded Ithaca Gun Company.
Bro. Gaggin was a long time member of the First Methodist Church, serving faithfully in many capacities, and where his final
services were conducted by Rev. C. C. Noble and the Rose Service of the 33 o was given by the 33 o Club of the Valley of Syracuse.
Masonic Record:
25 Mar 1913 Raised in Central City Lodge No. 305; Master 1921. More than 100 Master Masons were Raised during his term.
He served as Chaplain of the Lodge in 1922 and from 1924 to 1942 inclusive.
13 Jun 1913 Received the Royal Arch Degree in Central City Chapter No. 70, RAM
He was a member of Central City Council No. 13, R&SM
5 Nov 1915 Received the Temple Degrees in Central City Commandery No. 25, KT
1915-16 Received the Degrees of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite, Valley of Syracuse.
1927-29 Most Wise Master of the Chapter of Rose Croix
1938-41 Commander-in-Chief of Central City Consistory
28 Sep 1938 Crowned an Honorary Member, 33 0 , of the Supreme Council, NMJ
Bro. T. Walker Gaggin laid down his Working Tools on 20 Oct 1945, at Syracuse, NY. He contributed abundantly to degree work
both in the Blue Lodge and the Rite. His Masonic character was not confined to the Lodge room, nor backstage in the dressing
room. His standing in the community was well expressed in the Syracuse Herald:
“Although T. Walker Gaggin’s life has closed and his body has been laid to rest, the work of this gifted Syracuse architect will live
on. Architecture . . . is frozen music. The rhythmic harmonies of Mr. Gaggin’s structures in this city will continue to speak to his skill
while their functional qualities play their part in civic life. Quiet in manner, of broad outlook, he had a busy and useful career.”
As noted above, among his other works were some of the following:
< Lyman C. Smith Hall, Syracuse University, 1902, Gaggin & Gaggin
Gifted by Lyman C. Smith, typewriter pioneer and president of L. C.
Smith & Brothers Typewriter Company.
22

Winchell Hall Dormitory for Women, Syracuse University - 1900 >
Architect: E. H. Gaggin, Syracuse University School of Architecture, located on the
Northeast corner of University Avenue and University Place; demolished Feb 1984.
This was the first dormitory to be built on the Syracuse University campus, and was
named for Alexander Winchell, first Chancellor of Syracuse University, 1872-74,
and Professor of Geology, Zoology, and Botany, 1873-78. The building opened in
the fall of 1900 and had thirty rooms housing female students. The dormitory later
housed 58 students and had offices, and in the mid 60’s housed classrooms, one of
which was used for students in Advertising Design (such as I). It was in the process
of being demolished to make room for the building of the Schine Student Center
when a fire swept through it in early Feb 1984 and hastened the venerable
structure's end.
Crouse Hinds Plant, built in 1911 at the corner of Wolf and 7th North
Streets in Syracuse, New York.
Howard Everett Plaisted was born in Syracuse on 21 May 1859. He was made a Mason in Central City Lodge No. 305 in
December 1887. Immediately appointed to office, he served continuously until he was elected Master in 1892, serving in that office
for four years and was the “Masonic Father” of many prominent Brothers. He was elected Secretary in 1909, which office he held
until his death. Bro. Plaisted was Representative of the Grand Lodge of Georgia near the Grand Lodge of New York 1912-1915, and
was member and active in all the Masonic bodies in Syracuse.
He received the degrees in the Scottish Rite in April 1897 and was Sovereign Prince, Central City Princes of Jerusalem in 1905;
Grand Hospitaler of the Council of Deliberation in 1906. He was made an Honorary member of the Supreme Council, 33 o on 18 Sep
1906 at Boston, serving as Secretary of the Central City 33 o Club from 1911 until the date of his death.
The offices filled by him and the honors conferred upon him form no record of his Masonic history. After he became Secretary of the
various Masonic bodies, he devoted his entire time and abilities to the Order. At the Temple, he was the fountainhead of information
and the confidant and advisor of the officers of all of the Masonic bodies. He knew no distinction between lodges or between Rites
of Freemasonry. He was prepared at any time to give and charge or take any office or station in any of the Blue Lodge work and
frequently he filled vacancies on a moment’s notice.
Ill.’. Bro. Howard E. Plaisted laid down his Working Tools at Manlius on 22 February 1927.
The place which he held in the community was quietly yet nonetheless positively shown by the cooperation in the funeral
arrangements rendered by the civil and police authorities of the City of Syracuse and the public at large. During the two days the
body of Bro. Plaisted lay in state in the Blue Room of the Masonic Temple with a Commandery Guard of Honor throughout every
hour of the day and night, and during that time traffic on a downtown street was entirely discontinued.
As seemed most fitting, the funeral services were held in those surrounding where he had labored so faithfully and which to him had
been like home. The largest Lodge room in the Temple was packed beyond the doors and hundreds were unable to obtain
admission. The religious rites of the Episcopal Church were read by Bro. Almon A. Jaynes, Archdeacon of the Diocese of Central
New York, followed by the impressive service of the 33 o , under the direction of Ill.’. Bro. Jerome L. Cheney, Active 33 o , and Deputy
for the State of New York. “Full many a head in sorrow drooped.” As the final words of the Blue Lodge ritual were spoken by the
Master of Central City Lodge.
The character of Bro. Plaisted has impressed itself upon the hearts of the Masons of Syracuse. No eulogy could be written which
would do him justice. No written record of his deeds and accomplishments can be made. No man can estimate the measure of his
work or the limit of his influence. The life he led is his eulogy.
Farewell, O friend! Long may the cheer
Thy presence gave yet linger here!
-------------
The memory of thy merit dwell
Like a light on distant seas! Farewell!
Two members of this Lodge served as Grand Masters of Masons in the State of New York:
M..W.. Clinton F. Paige, Grand Master 1863-1864
Clinton Freeman Paige was born at Dryden, Tompkins County, New York, on 10 Sep 1827. He was the eldest son of Dr. Daniel D.
and Lavina Paige’s three children. After the death of his parents in 1842 he lived with his maternal uncle, Horatio Ballard, in
Cortland. He was educated at Cortland Academy and thereafter read law with his uncle, passing his Bar examinations in 1848. He
then moved to Syracuse, becoming Secretary of the Syracuse and Binghamton Railroad Company until 1856, when he was elected
President, a post which he held until 1861.
23

Ill∴ Paige then moved to Binghamton and was associated with his father-in-law, Colonel Hazard Lewis, in lumbering, milling and
framing operations. He was general agent and adjuster for the Imperial Insurance Company of London for New York and
Pennsylvania from 1863 to 1896, being associated with Joseph B. Chaffee and John B. Babcock. He was a charter member and
served as the first president of the New York State Association of Supervisory and Adjusting Insurance Agents.
Masonic Record
BLUE LODGE:
24 Mar 1853 - Raised in Syracuse Lodge No. 102
7 Jun 1853 - Petitioner and Charter Member of Central City Lodge No. 305; Junior Deacon, 1853;
Senior Warden 1854; Master, 1855-1860.
1858 & 1859 Junior Grand Warden, Grand Lodge, F&AM, of the State of New York.
1860 & 1861 Senior Grand Warden, Grand Lodge, F&AM, of the State of New York.
1862 Deputy Grand Master, Grand Lodge, F&AM, of the State of New York.
1863 & 1864 Grand Master of Masons, Grand Lodge, F&AM, of the State of New York.
1864-1898 Grand Representative of the Grand Lodge to New Jersey.
CAPITULAR MASONRY:
Royal Arch:
18 May 1853 - Mark Master and Past Master, Syracuse Chapter No. 70, R.A.M.
01 Jun 1853 - Most Excellent Master, Syracuse Chapter No. 70, R.A.M.
17 Jun 1853 - Exalted, Royal Arch Mason, Syracuse Chapter No. 70, R.A.M.; Chapter Member No. 14.
1857 King, Syracuse Chapter No. 70, R.A.M.
03 Dec 1861 - Affiliated with Binghamton Chapter No. 139; High Priest, 1861-1871.
1875-76 Grand Captain of the Host, Grand Chapter, R.A.M.
1870-1902 - Grand Representative to the Grand Chapter of Maine.
Royal and Select Masters (Cryptic Council):
8 Jun 1858 - Greeted, Adelphic Council No. 7, R.& S.M., New York City.
7 Dec 1859 - Affiliated, Central City Council No. 13, R.& S.M., Syracuse, NY.
Commandery:
• 15 Dec 1853 - Knighted, Utica Encampment No. 3, K.T., Utica, NY.
• 8 Mar 1856 - A meeting of those eligible as petitioners was held at the office of Clinton F. Paige at 8:00 p.m. to take into
consideration the expediency of petitioning the Grand Encampment for a dispensation or charter for an Encampment of
Knights Templar to be located in Syracuse, styled Central City Encampment. Sir Knight Clinton F. Paige was elected chairman
and upon balloting, was elected to be the first Grand Commander. This petition was endorsed by Salem Town Encampment
No. 16 on 14 Mar 1856; a Dispensation was granted on 17 March.
• 6 Feb 1857 - Warrant issued at the Annual Conclave of the Grand Encampment in Albany, NY, for Central City Commandery
No. 25, K.T.; Clinton F. Paige, Charter Commander, which office he held from 1856 to 1860.
• Affiliated with Malta Commandery No. 21, K.T., Binghamton, NY; Commander, 1863 to 1871.
A.A.S.R., Otseningo Bodies, Binghamton, NY:
14 Jan 1862 - Sublime Prince of the Royal Secret, Hays Council.
Received the Fourth to Thirty-second Grades inclusive in Hays Council.
5 Jun 1862 Elevated to the 33º in Hays Council.
20 Oct 1864 Admitted to Active Membership in Hays Council.
1867 As an Active Member and Committee Member of Hays Council, he attended the Union of
all the Supreme Councils of the Northern Masonic Jurisdiction.
17 May 1867 to Oct 1873 - Grand Minister of State, Supreme Council, A.A.S.R, N.M.J.
Oct 1873 to 16 Sep 1902 -
1875-1902 Trustee, Supreme Council, A.A.S.R., N.M.J.
1874-1902 Chairman of the Committee on Returns.
1894-1897 Chairman of the Committee on Foreign Correspondence.
He was also a Committee Member of:
Jurisprudence 1867-1871
Ritual 1868-1870
Constitutions 1868-1873
Grand Secretary General, Supreme Council, A.A.S.R., N.M.J.
Foreign Correspondence 1874-1876
Rituals and Ritualistic Matters 1897-1900
He was also a Grand Representative of the Supreme Council 33º for England, Wales and New Granada,
and an Honorary Member of the Supreme Councils for Mexico and Canada.
1883-1887 Thrice Potent Master Otseningo Lodge of Perfection.
1883-1895 Sovereign Prince, Otseningo Council, Princes of Jerusalem.
1870-1895 Most Wise Master Otseningo Chapter of Rose Croix.
1867-1902 Commander-in-Chief Otseningo Consistory.
The strength of Freemasonry at that time and the impact of a great personality on the Brothers of his Fraternity can be gleaned
from the magnitude of the funeral service on the Passing of Ill∴ Clinton Freeman Paige, 33º, on 13 November 1902. At his request,
Masonic services were conducted by Central City Lodge No. 305. A special train carried the Syracuse delegation of 200 Masons
with an additional 50 boarding at Cortland and 25 at Marathon and other points, having left Syracuse at 11:30 a.m.
The entourage did not reach Binghamton until 2:00 p.m., due to a breakdown at Cortland. Inspiring Episcopal services were held
at his home. 49 members of the Supreme Council attended with additional services conducted by Ill∴ William Homan, 33º, Deputy
for the State of New York. The scene was one of solemnity and impressiveness as each Brother deposited a rose on the casket.
The march to the cemetery constituted one of the most soul-stirring corteges ever seen in Binghamton including 100 members of
the Malta Commandery No. 21, 300 Brothers from Binghamton Lodge No. 177 and Otseningo Lodge No. 433, and 300 Masons from
24

Central NY. Crowds lined the streets to the cemetery where two thousand others were waiting. The final majestic and moving
Masonic Rites were completed at the grave in the glow of lanterns.
References:
• Cathers, George B., “Historical Sketch of Central City Lodge No. 305, F.& A.M., at its Diamond Jubilee, June 11, 1928, Syracuse, NY.”
• Cummings, William L., “History of Central City Bodies, A.A.S.R., 1862-1937.”
• Peacher, William G., “100 Years of Scottish Rite Masonry in the Valley of Syracuse, 1862-1962.”
• Peacher, William G., “History, Central City Chapter No. 70, Royal Arch Masons, 1821-1962.”
• Peacher, William G., “History, Central City Commandery No. 25, Knights Templar, 1857-1966.”
• Vogt, George C., “Our Heritage: Centennial, Otseningo Bodies, 1867-1967.”
M..W.. William S. Farmer, Grand Master 1918-1919
William Sidney Farmer was born in Hailesborough, St. Lawrence, New York, on 18 Jul 1861, was the son of Seymour M. and
Alethea M. Farmer. His education was in the district schools and in Wesleyan Seminary at Gouveneur. Following graduation he
studied law in the office at the latter place of the late Jude Vasco P. Abbot, and in 1862 was admitted to the bar at the General Term
of the Supreme Court at Saratoga. Seven years later he located at Kimball, South Dakota, were he engaged in legal lines and also
served as vice president and managing director of a bank.
Returning to the east in 1891, he began practice of the law at Syracuse as senior member of the firm of W. S. and H. H. Farmer. In
1915 he was appointed Judge of the Municipal Court, a position which he occupied until his death. On 27 Feb 1889 he was married
to Ruth Adelia Selleck, daughter of William H. Selleck, and they had a daughter, Alethea Farmer.
Judge Farmer belonged to the Universalist faith and was a member of the Citizens Club, Masonic Club, Syracuse Escort, Mystique
Krewe, and Elks Club of Syracuse, and the Masonic Club of New York City.
BLUE LODGE:
20 Nov 1894 Initiated in Central City Lodge No. 305
1895 Junior Master of Ceremonies
1896 Senior Deacon
1897 & 1898 Junior Warden
1899 & 1900 Master
1902-1905 District Deputy Grand Master, 27th Masonic District
1908 Grand Lodge Commission of Appeals; Chief Commissioner, 1909
1910-1914 Junior Grand Warden
1914-1918 Senior Grand Warden
1918-1919 Grand Master of Masons in the State of New York
CAPITULAR MASONRY:
24 May 1895 Received in Central City Chapter No. 70, RAM, serving in various capacities
02 Jan 1901 Initiated in Central City Council No. 13, Royal and Select Masters
18 Apr 1898 Knighted in Central City Commandery No. 25, K.T.
A.A.S.R., Valley of Syracuse:
30 Mar and 2 Apr 1898 The degrees of the Scottish Rite were conferred upon him.
1906 Sovereign Prince of the Council
17 Sep 1918 Honorary Member 33 o , Supreme Council, A.A.S.R., NMJ
Judge Farmer was ever watchful for the true interests of the Masonic order. He was Grand Master during the hectic period of the
First World War when countless numbers turned their thoughts toward securing fraternal affiliation, and his thought in the particular
was expressed to the Lodges in the following from their Grand Master:
“We must have good material – men of courage, men of thought, men of conviction. We do not want, and must not elect to
membership, the unworthy, cowards, grafters, trimmers, weaklings, men lacking backbone, floaters with the popular tide no matter
whither they may tend. Direct your Lodge members in passing upon applications to do their full duty, manfully, bravely, without fear,
without favor. Direct them to scrutinize closely the character of those who seek to join. Direct them to make exception of no man,
howsoever great, howsoever wealthy, howsoever influential. Direct them to see to it that no person be admitted to the rites of
Freemasonry who does not measure up to the standard of a man, bearing in mind this axiom, that the end of man’s human destiny
is not to be counted as the best Frenchman, the best Englishman or the best American in any other sense than the he is the best
man that his physical, mental, and moral faculties can make of him.”
On the natal day of the Father of our Country in 1930, while returning from a meeting in Washington of the Directors of the George
Washington National Masonic Memorial Association, to which enterprise he had given ten years of earnest effort, Ill.’. William
Sidney Farmer, 33 o , was suddenly stricken in the city of New York, and passed to the Celestial Lodge Above. The fraternity in the
entire state was shocked and grieved by the new and general mourning ensued. The body was conveyed to his home city,
Syracuse, and there laid to rest on Thursday afternoon, 27 Feb 1930, duly honored by all branches of the fraternity and by the
citizenry in general.
-----------
George Judd Gardner, born 19 Jul 1818, in Boston, MA, was one of seven children of Thomas and Hannah (Anna) Judd Gardner.
About 1830 he became one of Syracuse’s first newsboys and an apprentice printer to his cousin, Lewis H. Redfield, Onondaga
County’s first printer (and member of Onondaga Lodge 98). He thereafter led an active and successful business and active public
life.
He was deeply interested in Masonry, serving with distinction in all Bodies:
25

Central City Lodge 305, Master 1866-67
District Deputy Grand Master, 1872-73
Central City Chapter 70, HP 1890-91
Central City Council 13, Recorder 1859-66
Central City Commandery, Recorder 1860-67
Central City Scottish Rite Bodies:
Lodge of Perfection, TPM 1862-65
Council Princes of Jerusalem, JW 1862-65
Chapter of Rose Croix, MWM 1866-71
Consistory, 1862-73, held offices.
Honorable Member Supreme Council, Jun 7, 1886
Bro. Gardner founded the Masonic Veterans’ Association of CNY in 1879, serving as its Secretary from 1879 to 1888,
and as its President in 1879.
He was the most prominent Masonic Historian of his day. The minutes of the Onondaga Masonic Bodies indicate that
he was a frequent lecturer on such historical subjects as:
“The Early History of Freemasonry in Onondaga County, 1797-1826.”
“Complete History of the Various Masonic Organizations Which Ever Existed within the Present Limits of the City
of Syracuse.”
“The History of Capitular Masonry in Onondaga County.” (an unpublished manuscript, which is in the Ill. William L.
Cummings Collection in Lexington, MA.)
A newspaper review by J. C. Spencer, dated Oct 22, 1851, calls attention to items from Bro. Gardner’s interesting and
valuable collection. His library was a veritable mine of historic lore, including:
All known directories ever published in the City of Syracuse.
Minutes of Syracuse and village
societies.
Autographs of all local mayors.
Patriotic envelopes (5,000).
Copies of all the earliest newspapers.
Ante-bellum (1861-65) bank notes, & etc.
26

It is unfortunate that none of these items have survived.
Other material which has survived includes newspaper clippings, obituaries, and a copy of the Twenty-fifth Anniversary Program of
Central City Commandery No. 25, which contains an historical address written by Bro. Gardner.
His heart began to fail in 1902, and while attempting to recuperate at Spring-Cliff, Jay, New York, he died on July 17th of that year.
His historical work set a precedent which was admirably emulated by Ill. Herbert W. Greenland.
Source: “100 Year of Scottish Rite Masonry 1862-1962” by William G. Peacher, M. D., pgs. 17 & 18, photo pg. 16.
See also, photo pg. 34 (facing), “History of the Central City Bodies, A.A.S.R. - Seventy-Five Years of Scottish Rite Masonry in the
Valley of Syracuse,” by Dr. William L. Cummings, 33 o , 1937.
Biography copied from Ars Collegium, Vol. 1, No. 1, journal of the Onondaga Masonic Districts Historical Society.
Judd
m. bef 1815
Thomas Gardner Hannah (Anna) Judd Col. Oliver Teall III Mary ‘Polly’ Judd (1767-1844)
d. ca 1826, Boston 1782-1840 1788-1857 m. Peleg Redfield of Manchester,
of Ontario County (1762-1852)
m. 1843
six other children George Judd Gardner Phoebe A. Teall Lewis H. Redfield, Printer
b. 19 Jul 1818 youngest daughter 1793-1882
Boston, Mass.
d. 2 Oct 1902, Syracuse, New York
Bur. Fayetteville, New York
George Judd Gardner residences & misc. time-line items:
(George?) Hariett E. Genevieve; m. Mr. Fuller
m. Mr. Stafford
(had son, George Gardner Stafford)
1818 b. Boston, Mass.
1826 ae 8 removed to New York City, following the death of his father.
1829/30 ae 11 lived in NYC 4 years; removed to Manchester, Ontario County; lived with his uncle, Peleg Redfield for 3 months.’
1829 ae 11 George removed to Syracuse to work as a ‘printer’s devil’ and newspaper carrier with his uncle,
Lewis H. Redfield, who had recently removed from Onondaga Hollow to the city.
Lewis was the publisher of the Onondaga Register and Syracuse Gazette.
1831 ae 13 Lewis retired from newspaper, ‘retaining his book store’ (on the present site of the Gridley Building),
in which George became a clerk.
1841 ae 23 George succeeded Lewis as proprietor of the book store.
1842 ae 24 Initiated into Oneida Lodge No. 70, I.O.O.F., Utica, New York; withdrew 1843 becoming a Charter Member of
Onondaga Lodge No. 79, serving sixty years, until his death.
1846 ae 28 George became teller of the Onondaga County bank.
1854 ae 36 He, with others, organized the Onondaga Bank, of which he became Cashier.
1856 ae 38 Raised in Central City Lodge No. 305, F&AM, 10 June; serving in many bodies and offices until his death.
Honorary Member, A.A.S.R., 33 o , 7 Jun 1866 (ae 48).
1860 ae 42 Resigned from the Onondaga Bank.
1861-1866 Appointed Assistant Postmaster, serving until the expiration of the appointment term.
1863 ae 45 Became a life member of the (Onondaga) Historical society (Association).
1866-1872 Secretary of the New York State Life insurance company, until its reorganization.
1872-1897 ‘for years afterward he acted as executor and administrator of estates and general accountant, and was Secretary
and Treasurer of the Genesee and Water Street Railroad company, which he assisted in organizing.’
1902 ae 84 died in the Adirondacks, at Spring-Criff (Cliff?), Jay, Essex County, while recuperating from ‘cardiovascular disease.’
Charles Elliot Ide, Jr. was born 31 May 1853 in Oaks Corners, Town of Phelps, Ontario, New
York. He lived in Phelps until 12 years old, when he removed with his widowed mother (Mary C.
Ide), and sister in Geneva. There he was educated in the Union school, graduating in 1871.
While continuing his education at Yale University he was a member of the varsity crew. On
returning to Syracuse, he entered the law office of Ruger, Wallace & Jenney. In 1873 he
became, upon his admission to the bar, managing clerk for Fuller & Vann, remaining there
three years. In 1876 he and John H. Costello opened law offices under the firm name of
Costello & Ide. The firm in 1884 became Costello, Ide & Hubbard, William H. Hubbard, Mr. Ide’s
brother-in-law, being the new junior member. In 1880 Mr. Ide formed a new firm of Ide &
Newell, James E. Newell being the junior member. Then Mr. Ide associated himself with
Charles G. Baldwin, the firm being first Baldwin & ide and later when Charles P. Ryan was
admitted, Baldwin , Ide & Ryan. Mr. Baldwin withdrew in 1894 and the firm became Ide & Ryan.
Bro. Ide became active in politics from the time that he became of age. He was a member of
the Republican county and city committee for years and was chairman of both the city
27

committee and Fifth judicial district committee for several years. He was a candidate for District Attorney in 1889, when he was
defeated in the convention by Theodore E. Hancock. He was appointed 23 Feb 1892 by Mayor William Cowle to succeed W. P.
Ganon as Corporation Counsel and this place he held through both of Mayor Amos’s terms. Mr. Ide was a candidate for Supreme
Court Justice at the Utica convention, but with drew when it became evident that W. S. Andrews had a majority of the Onondaga
delegation. Mr. Ide was, while Corporation Counsel, also counsel for all city boards. He had been active for the last year in the
organization of the Pacific Biscuit trust and other large business combinations.
He was a member of the Century, Syracuse, and Citizens Clubs of Syracuse; Albany Club, Whist Club (Rochester), and
Craftsmen’s Club (New York City). He married Miss Etta Cary, daughter of Wesley Cary of Webster City, Iowa, in 1885. There was
one child of this union. (possible son: New Haven, CT, 25 Mar 1907. - Charles Elliott Ide '08 was tonight elected captain of the
university crew. He rowed seven on last year's crew and was also a member of the freshman crew in 1905.)
1880 Census, Syracuse, Onondaga, New York
Mary C. IDE Self W 49 (widow; head of household; nee Mary Colburn?)
Charles E. IDE Son S 27 Lawyer
Willie IDE Son S 12 At School
S. James IDE Son S 20 Brakeman On R.R.
Genie HUBBARD Dau M 31
Wm. H. HUBBARD SonL M 31 Lawyer
Eva HUBBARD GDau S 7
Lydia COLBURN Mother W 85
He was best known for his prominence in Masonry.
Symbolic Masonry – Blue Lodge, Central City Lodge No. 305
14 May 1878 Initiated
18 Jun 1878 Passed
02 Jul 1878 Raised
1885 & 1886 Junior Warden
1887 & 1888 Senior Warden
1889 & 1890 Master
1893 & 1894 Junior Grand Warden, Grand Lodge of the State of New York
1895-1898 Senior Grand Warden, Grand Lodge of the State of New York
He did not appear to serve in junior Lodge chairs or as District Deputy Grand Master.
Capitular Masonry – Central City Chapter No. 70, RAM
14 May 1880 Mark Master
11 Jun 1880 Past Master
11 Jun 1880 Most Excellent Master (MEM)
25 Jun 1880 Royal Arch Mason
1893-1894 Master of the Third Veil
Cryptic Masonry – Central City Council No. 13, R&SM
21 May 1888 Royal Master
21 May 1888 Select Master
23 Jun 1892 Super-Excellent Master
Chivalric Orders – Central City Commander No. 25, KT
06 Apr 1881 Knight of Red Cross
15 Apr 1881 Knight Templar
20 Apr 1883 Knight of Malta
1882 Second Guard
1883 Junior Warden
1884-1885 Captain General
1886 Generalissimo
1887-1889 Commander
1899 Grand Commander of the Grand Commandery of the State of New York
Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite – Central City Bodies, Valley of Syracuse
24 May 1882 Lodge of Perfection
25 May 1882 Princes of Jerusalem
25 May 1882 Chapter of Rose Croix
25 May 1882 Consistory, S.P.R.S., NMJ
1886-1888 Thrice Potent Master, Lodge of Perfection
1889-1891 Most Wise Master, Chapter of Rose Croix
1892-1895 Commander in Chief, Central City Consistory
16 Dec 1890 Sovereign Grand Inspector General, 33 o , Honorary Member, NMJ
17 Sep 1895 Active Member of the Supreme Council, NMJ, being elected Deputy for the State of New York in the same session
and holding that office until his death.
28

Bro. Ide left for the south on 11 Nov 1899, remaining in New York closing up the organization of the Pacific Coast Biscuit trust, then
left for Asheville, NC, where he remained several days. He went thence to Waldo, FL, 150 miles south of Jacksonville, intending to
go to St. Augustine. In Jacksonville he was compelled to take to bed at the Rathbun House, and there with his wife (the former Miss
Carey) and his son of 13 years, Charles E. Ide, Jr., he died on the morning of 9 Dec 1899, at the age of 46. He had been ill (of
Bright’s disease) for a year, and for three months had known that he could not live long. He had gone south in the hope of
prolonging his life.
His Masonic services were “the most notable and impressive Masonic funeral in Syracuse since that of Orrin Welch, twenty years
ago.” There is a lengthy newspaper account of his services on file in the archives of the OMDHS, in the Registry of the Masonic
Veterans Association of Central New York, of which Bro. Ide was Registry No. 220 (11 Jul 1899).
The brethren of the Valley of Syracuse, sincerely mourning his death, felt they should perpetuate his memory, his acts and his
standing as a brother Mason, in a manner that would testify to his life and record when their generation had passed away.
Accordingly a Committee of fifteen members from the different Masonic bodies was appointed to procure and erect a suitable
monument to his memory. This Committee, under the Chairmanship of Ill. Edwin C. Hall, after much careful consideration decided
upon a design for this monument. It is a replica, in Barre granite, of the Altar of Central City Lodge No. 305, with appropriate
emblems of the various Masonic bodies on the four sides. It was dedicated on 9 Nov 1901 at Oakwood Cemetery, the address on
that occasion being delivered by Ill. Charles H. Armatage, who succeeded Ill. Bro. Ide as Grand Commander.
A memorial booklet was prepared and printed. Of this but few copies seem to have survived. As it was printed in November or
December of 1901, it is probable that the larger part of the edition was destroyed during the Masonic Temple fire in January 1902.
http://archiver.rootsweb.com/th/read/NYONONDA/1999-08/0934895145
Joseph E, Shackford was born ca 1850; died 23 Oct 1921 in St. Joseph's Hospital, Syracuse. He married Donna L. Evans. She
was born ca 1865. He was a Commercial Traveler and lived at 104 East Castle Street, Syracuse in 1892, was assistant to the
president at American Can Company. He well known in Syracuse Masonic circles and for 32 years a resident of the city, Bro.
Shackford was for 29 years with the National Lead Company, retiring from active business four years ago. He was a member of
Central City Lodge No. 305; Central City Chapter No. 80, RAM; Central City Council No. 13; Central City Commandery No. 25,
Knights Templar and of the Central City Scottish Rite Bodies. He was also a member of Ziyara Temple, Nobles of the Mystic Shrine,
Keder Khan Grotto, and the Citizen's Club of Syracuse. He was survived by four sons: Joseph E. Jr., of Baldwinsville: Thomas L. of
St. Augustine Fla.: Arthur E. of Syracuse, and William H. of Troy, and by a daughter. Mrs. William J. Brown of New York City.
Seymour Henry Stone was born 27 Jul 1831 at Homer, NY, to Mr. and Mrs. Jacob Stone,
descendants of sturdy Revolutionary stock from New England. At the age of 14 he removed to
Syracuse where he spent the remainder of his life and attained a high place in the estimation of his
fellow citizens. He died on New Year’s day, 1920, survived by two brothers and a sister. He served as
vestryman for about 40 years in St. Paul’s Episcopal Church in Syracuse.
Masonic Service:
Oct 1855 Raised in Central City Lodge No. 305; Master 1868-69
1869 District Deputy Grand Master
1872-1873 Grand Standard Bearer, Grand Lodge of the State of New York
10 May 1854 Exalted a Royal Arch Mason in Central City Chapter No. 70; High Priest 1861-1865
1862 Grand Captain of the Host, Grand Chapter of the State of New York, serving in
different offices until 1867
1867-1868 Grand High Priest, Grand Chapter of the State of New York
1859 Received the Cryptic Degree in Adelphic Council No. 7 of New York
Charter Member of Central City Council No. 13, R&SM; Master of the Council in 1859 and 1861.
1860-1861 Deputy Grand Master, Grand Council of the State of New York
5 Sep 1856 Central City Commandery No. 25, Knights Templar; created and dubbed a Knights Templar and Knight of Malta in
due form. Being the first to be Knighted in the Encampment, as it was then called. He therein held numerous offices.
He was also active in Scottish Rite Masonry, having been on of the organizers and charter members of the Central City Bodies of
the Rite in the Valley of Syracuse in 1862, and held many offices in the different Bodies.
7 Jun 1866 Crowned 33 o Honorary in the Supreme Council, NMJ, A.A.S.R. and for many years before his death was the Dean
of the Honorary Thirty-Thirds in the Northern Masonic Jurisdiction. He was a member of the first Council of Deliberation of the State
of New York, after the Union of 1867, and was the last surviving member of that body. For many years he was active in the
exemplification of the degrees of the Rite, and his portrayal of the characters he assumed was an example to those who followed
him in the work. His more than 60 years of service in the Craft was an inspiration to whose with whom he served.
Seymour H. Stone’s entry in a SAR yearbook states, “Retired. Born, Homer, N.Y., July 27, 1831. Lieutenant in Co. A, 51st Regt.
N.G.N.Y., over 30 years ago. Member of all Masonic bodies, York and Scottish rites; Society of Mayflower Descendants and the
Onondaga County Historical Society. Son of Jacob Thompson Stone and Mary Bennett; grandson of Thomas Stone, Jr., and Mary
Webb, and of Asa Bennett, Jr., and Chloe Grow; great-grandson of Thomas Stone, Sr., and Rachel Marsh, and of Darius Webb and
Deborah Palmer; gt-gt-grandson of Ebenezer Webb and Ruth Crane.”
SEYMOUR HENRY STONE, Syracuse, N. Y. (10638).
Son of Jacob Thompson and Mary (Bennett) Stone; grandson of Thomas and Mary (Webb) Stone;
great-grandson of Thomas Stone, Sr., private Mass. Continentals;
grandson of Asa Bennett, Jr., Sergeant Rhode Island troops;
great-grandson of Darius and Deborah (Palmer) Webb:
great'-grandson of Ebenezer Webb, private Third Conn. Militia.
29

A National Register of the Society, Sons of the American Revolution, by Sons of the American Revolution, page 827
It appears that his sister, Mrs. Amelia Stone Quinton & Mr. S. H. Stone were confused about the service of their great-great
grandfather, Ebenezer Webb Sr. of Windham, and obviously unaware of the service of his great grandfather, Darius Webb. They
claimed that Ebenezer Webb Sr. of Windham served in Captain Obadiah Johnson’s Company, Colonel Israel Putnam’s 3rd
Regiment Connecticut Troops during Lexington Alarm. It was further claimed (by some descendants) that he was at Bunker Hill, but
absolutely no evidence has come forth to support this claim (but it was convincing enough to have gained him entry to the Syracuse
Chapter of the SAR). http://www.webbdeiss.org/webb/ebenezerwebb.html
http://www.exonumia.com/sale11/alla.htm
Seymour H. Stone and Calvin S. Ball sold silverware and jewelry, and repaired clocks and
watches. They were partners from 1853 to 1869. See extensive
write-up in Brunk. "Stone & Ball"/"Syracuse/N.Y." apparently the
first line is one mark, and the other two another, as they are not
centered. Bold VF/XF marks on Fine+ 1853 arrows & rays Seated
Liberty Quarter. $125.00-150.00+. See Syracuse Lodge No. 102
above for a biographical sketch of Calvin S. Ball, Jr.
< One of the very few known countermarks on a gold coin! Brunk
quotes the 1897 Syracuse Herald interview with Calvin Ball.
Issued in 1853 and 1854. "Stone & Ball" single line punch, bold
VF mark, variety with part of the last letter missing because the stamp broke (see Brunk); on
choice XF 1854 US GOLD Quarter Eagle, $2.50. Only known specimen on gold coin! A rare
opportunity to acquire a unique GOLD countermark! $4500.00-5000.00+
Orrin Welch was born on 7 Jan 1828 at New Berlin, Chenango, NY. He
attended school in Cortland two years, living with his sister, Mrs. Hubbard,
on his father’s death in 1836. The next ten years were spent with his
oldest brother, Orson, in Moravia, and one additional year with his sister
in Auburn.
In 1846 he moved to Syracuse, becoming a printer’s apprentice at the
Star Newspaper office where he served as a foreman of the Job
Department until he became a bookkeeper in the Canal Collector’s Office
in 1849 remaining one year. His next position was accountant at the
Syracuse and Binghamton Railroad Company until his promotion to
paymaster and secretary in 1854. Concomitantly he served in 1871 as
Treasurer of the Morris Run Coal Company and as Secretary and
Treasurer of the Excelsior Dairy Salt Company.
< Song Oh Id be a Soger Boy, dedicated to Captain Orrin Welch,
Syracuse Citizens Corps, pictured on the left of the cover illustration.
1862.
Bro. Welch served the community in several important offices including
School Commissioner and Chairman of the Board of Education, and was
elected to the Board of Police Commissioners in 1876 on which he
continued until he death at the age of fifty one on 21 March 1878.
A beautifully bound memorial volume of 178 pages outlining the career of
this distinguished brother was posthumously published. There are two
copies of this in the collections of the OMDHS. An address on his life and
Masonic character was given by Samuel E. Thomason at the DeMolay
Mounted Commandery No. 4, Washington, DC, on 23 Jun 1878.
Numerous newspaper articles were written in tribute of the genius and virtue of this
remarkably gifted and talented man.
There is a very fine Templar style monument at his grave in Oakwood Cemetery, as
short distance up the hill from the old west gate, near the Chapel. A perpetual care
agreement was signed for its upkeep by Syracuse Lodge No. 501 and Central City
Lodge No. 305, a copy of which is also in the archives of the OMDHS. The Trustees
of Central City Commandery also “set aside (the equivalent of about $500 in 2006
dollars) for perpetual care of monument and lot of R. E. Orrin Welch at Oakwood
Cemetery.” Likewise, a fine, large framed oil painting of him is in the archives. His
equally fine gold Grand Commander of Commandery sword is on display in the
Greenland Collection at the Utica Branch of The Chancellor Robert R Livingston
Masonic Library.
There are few today who could equal the Masonic record of Bro. Welch. He is the
only one of the charter members who could qualify for the Knight of the York Cross of
Honor (K.Y.C.H. – service as head of all the York Rite bodies being a prerequisite).
SYMBOLIC LODGE - A workman that needed not to be ashamed
Central City Lodge No. 305, Syracuse, New York which had been Warranted 11 Jun
1853 from Syracuse Lodge No. 102.
30

21 Nov 1853 Initiated Entered Apprentice
28 Nov 1853 Passed Fellow Craft
19 Dec 1853 Raised Master Mason
26 Dec 1853 Secretary
23 Dec 1856 Senior Warden
Dec 1860 Master
Jun 1863, 64, 65 & 66 Grand Marshal, Grand Lodge, F&AM, State of NY
Jun 1867, 68 District Deputy Grand Master, 16th Masonic District (Cayuga, Cortland, Onondaga and Oswego Counties)
CAPITULAR DEGREES -
the Overseers Squares.
He worked faithfully in our quarries, and his work ever stood the test of
CHIVALRIC ORDERS - A Valiant Knight, worthy of our Steel.
10 May 1854 Mark Master Mason
10 May 1854 Past Master , “Regularly Passed the Chair”
10 May 1854 Most Excellent Master, Companion No. 27
10 May 1854 Royal Arch Mason, Syracuse Chapter No. 70, RAM
20 Dec 1854 Captain of the Host
19 Dec 1855 Ex. King
17 Dec 1856-61 M. Ex. High Priest
1857 Order of High Priesthood
CRYPTIC DEGREES - Ever active in searching for hidden treasures.
1858 Royal and Select and Super-Excellent Master Adelphic Council No. 7, NY City
1859 Petitioner for Central City Council No. 13, R & SM, became Master of this Council.
1856 Order of Red Cross and Knight Templar Salem Town Encampment No. 16, Auburn, New York
8 Mar 1856 Petitioner for Central City Encampment, U.D. & First S.W.
14 Jul 1856 Prelate
Elected under Warrant of Central City Commandery No. 25, KT, 6 Feb 1857 :
19 Mar 1858 Senior Warden
15 Apr 1859 Generalissimo
16 Mar 1860 Em. Commander, serving for 16 years.
12 Sep 1860 Em. Grand Generalissimo, Grand Commandery, State of NY
Sep 1861 V.E. Deputy Grand Commander, re-elected in 1862.
Sep 1863 R. E. Grand Commander, re-elected in 1864.
1870 Grand Representative of Grand Commandery of MN near the Grand Commandery of NY until his death in 1878.
Sir Orrin Welch was the author of Knights Templar Tactics and Drills for the Use of Commanderies and the Burial Service of the
Orders of the Masonic Knighthood, Masonic Publishing Co; New York, 1862. This was adopted by the Grand Commandery of the
State of New York as well as many other Grand Bodies. The Knights Templar’s badge or jewel which presently and proudly adorns
the tunics of the Templars was designed and created especially for Central City Commandery No. 25 at Syracuse by Sir Welch in
1878.
ANCIENT AND ACCEPTED SCOTTISH RITE - Faithful and efficient in every official position.
16 Feb 1862 4th to 16th Degrees ; Lodge of Perfection and Council of Princes of Jerusalem and soon after the remaining
Degrees of Chapter of Rose Croix and Consistory of S∴P∴R∴S∴
1862 Commander-in-Chief, Central City Consistory S∴P∴R∴S∴
8 Jan 1863 Crowned 33 o , Honorary Member, Sov∴ Grand Inspector-General
16 May 1867 Active Member, Supreme Council of S∴G∴I∴G∴
17 May 1867 Deputy of the Supreme Council of S∴G∴I∴G∴ for the State of New York, holding this office until his death in 1878.
< The Gavel used by Ill: Orrin Welch, 33 o , was made of Oak from Commander Perry’s flagship, the Lawrence.
"We have met the enemy and they are ours—two ships, two brigs, one schooner and a sloop." With this simple
victory message to General William Henry Harrison, commander of the U.S. forces in the Northwest Territory,
Commodore Oliver Hazard Perry announced his defeat of the British fleet at the Battle of Lake Erie. This battle,
one of the most unusual in American naval history, ensured American control of the Great Lakes during the War
of 1812 and secured the country's tenuous hold on the Northwest.
Commodore Perry's victory was quickly enshrined as one of the heroic military events of the early American
Republic. The famous engagement on September 10, 1813, was initiated by Perry's flagship Lawrence, named
after James Lawrence, the commander of the recently captured Chesapeake. Lawrence's dying words,
"Don't give up the ship," inspired the nation and Perry. Those words were stitched onto Perry's battle flag,
which flew over the Lawrence. As the battle began, Perry placed the Lawrence at the head of his fleet. The
Caledonia and the Niagara, as well as six other ships of various sizes, fell in behind. For reasons that have never
been determined, the faster Niagara remained behind the slower Caledonia, and the Lawrence sailed into the
battle virtually unsupported. Perry was then forced to fight the entire British fleet with only the Lawrence.
31

After an intense bombardment of two and a half hours, the Lawrence fought the British fleet to a standstill, though the ship itself
was severely damaged and four-fifths of its crew were killed or wounded. In a daring move, Commodore Perry abandoned his
shattered ship and climbed into a rowboat with four crewmen. He took with him his battle flag, which he draped over his shoulders.
The boat set out for the brig Niagara, braving heavy gunfire. Perry boarded the ship, took command, and turned the Niagara directly
toward the British ships. The encounter was confusing and bloody, but brief. The damaged British flagship Detroit attempted to
swing around, and its rigging became entangled with that of the Queen Charlotte, rendering both ships helpless against the
onslaught from the Niagara. In short order, the smaller British ships also succumbed, and a mere 15 minutes after boarding, Perry
had achieved an extraordinary victory. With it the British supply line to the Western frontier was severed, and within the month the
British and their Indian allies were decisively defeated.
He was the brother of Commodore Matthew Calbraith Perry (April 10, 1794 – March 4, 1858) who compelled the opening of Japan
to the West with the Convention of Kanagawa in 1854.
According to 10,000 Famous Freemasons, Commodore Matthew C. Perry was a brother of Holland Lodge in New York City; Oliver,
while often thought to be a Mason, was not one.
http://www.phoenixmasonry.org/10,000_famous_freemasons/Volume_3_K_to_P.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pogo
"We have met the enemy . . ."
Pogo strip from Earth Day, 1971. Copyright 1971, 2005 OGPI
Probably the most famous Pogo quotation is "we have met the enemy and
he is us." More than any other words written by Kelly, it perfectly sums up
his attitude towards the foibles of mankind and the nature of the human
condition.
The quote, a rephrasing of a message sent in 1813 from U.S. Navy
Commodore Oliver Hazard Perry to Army General William Henry Harrison
after The Battle of Lake Erie stating "We have met the enemy, and they are
ours," first appeared in a lengthier form in A Word To The Fore, the
foreword of the book The Pogo Papers. Since the strips reprinted in Papers
included the first appearances of Mole and Simple J. Malarkey, beginning
Kelly's attacks on McCarthyism, Kelly used the foreword to defend his
actions:
"Specializations and markings of individuals everywhere abound in such
profusion that major idiosyncrasies can be properly ascribed to the mass.
Traces of nobility, gentleness and courage persist in all people, do what we
will to stamp out the trend. So, too, do those characteristics which are ugly.
It is just unfortunate that in the clumsy hands of a cartoonist all traits
become ridiculous, leading to a certain amount of self-conscious
expostulation and the desire to join battle.
"There is no need to sally forth, for it remains true that those things which make us human are, curiously enough, always close at
hand. Resolve then, that on this very ground, with small flags waving and tinny blast on tiny trumpets, we shall meet the enemy, and
not only may he be ours, he may be us.
"Forward!"
32

Marching Songs dedicated to Captain Orrin Welch, ca 1862
http://levysheetmusic.mse.jhu.edu/cgi-bin/display.pl?record=089.086.000&pages=4
33

Oh I’d be a Soger Boy
Composer, Lyricist, Arranger: T.H. Hinton. Published by Henry Tolman Company, Boston. 1862
Dedicated to Capt. Orrin Welch, pictured on the left below.
http://levysheetmusic.mse.jhu.edu/cgi-bin/condisp.pl?/Box_089/089.068.html
-----------------
34

Also among the distinguished Brothers of Central City Lodge No. 305 are others who have served in the Concordant Orders:
Grand High Priests of the Grand Chapter of the State of New York:
Seymour H. Stone 1867-1868
Richard H. Parker 1889
Jay B. Kline 1910
Jerome L. Cheney 1920
Charles J. Wells 1940
Illustrious Grand Master of the Grand Council of Royal and Select Masters of the State of New York:
Jerome L. Cheney 1930
Chester D. Crowell 1941
Most Excellent Grand Commanders of the Grand Commandery Knights Templar of the State of New York:
Orrin Welch 1863-1865
Mead Belden 1873
Austin C. Wood 1888
Charles E. Ide 1899
Thrice Potent Masters, Central City Lodge of Perfection:
Frank Rupp 1931-1934
George W. C. Braithwaite 1950-1951
Henry C. Kogler 1953-1954
Eugene B. C. Bloom 1956-1957
Harry J. Green 1957-1958
Edward M. Benham 1969-1970
Sovereign Princes, Central City Council, Princes of Jerusalem:
Edwin G. Nichols 1922-1923
Chester L. Lane 1935-1936
Harry J. Hawkins 1936-1937
Charles W. Mason 1953-1954
Thomas M. Miller 1956-1957
John S. Walker 1958-1959
Marcy Bower 1961-1962
Most Wise Masters, Central City Chapter, Rose Croix:
Chester L. Lane 1954-1959
Philip R. Adams 1957-1959
Uri M. Harris 1959-1960
Commanders-in-Chief, Central City Consistory, SPRS:
Jerome L. Cheney 1949-1950
Gustav Schneider 1956-1959
Harty J. Hawkins 1961-1963
Stanley M. Dibble 1963-1964
Ray Hevner 1967-1968
Richard W. Scott 1974-1975
Philip R. Adams 1963-1965
Eugene Bloom 1971-1973
Forty six Brothers went on to have been honored by election as 33 o Honorary Members, A.A.S.R., six of whom were Active
members of the Supreme Council.
Central City Lodge 305 Oakwood Cemetery Plots:
About 1860 a burial plot (lot no. 107-10) was purchased in Oakwood Cemetery for use of their Lodge Brothers. It is doubtful that
many members of the Fraternity have ever visited this plot of ground on which there has been erected a monument – a replica of the
altar in their Lodge room, a symbol indeed of their fraternal love.
On the subject of burial plots, there is a quiet interesting one also at Oakwood Cemetery for Ill.’. Orrin Welch. It is within sight, just
up the hill from the old west entrance, and is distinguished the Templar motif and considerable Masonic detailing of the monument
erected thereon. There was executed by Central City Lodge 305 and Syracuse Lodge No. 501 a perpetual care certificate for this
plot and monument. At last visit (2005), it was in need some repair and cleaning.
Syracuse Lodge No. 501
Syracuse, New York
5 Jul 1860 - 2 May 1994
3249 Members 1860-1994
Syracuse Lodge No. 501 refers to its 100th Anniversary history as consisting of three Periods: the Pioneer Period (1860-1885), the
Transitional Period (1886-1930) and the Modern Period (1931-1960).
As noted previously, Syracuse Lodge sprang from its predecessors, Syracuse Lodge No. 484 and Syracuse Lodge No. 102, which
sketches you are invited to read.
Pioneer Period: Petition, 24 Feb 1860
On 24 Feb a petition, signed by thirty brethren who had been members of Syracuse Lodge No. 102, was forwarded to the Grand
Master stating that they were “desirous of resuscitating Syracuse Lodge No. 102, and praying for the restoration of the Charter.”
Much to the regret of the petitioners, this was not possible, but the Grand Master permitted the records and all of the property of No.
102 to pass into the possession of No. 501, on the condition that the new lodge pay all the indebtedness of its predecessor.
35

A dispensation was granted to the petitioners and they held their first meeting on 4 Apr 1860, as Syracuse Lodge, U.D. in the rooms
at 63 (now 317) South Salina Street, which they leased from Central City Lodge. They were subsequently granted a charter bearing
the number 501 on 5 Jul 1860.
The first candidate for Initiation on 11 Apr 1860 was E. F. Rice, who was Passed 25 Apr and Raised on 25 Apr 1860.
The first brother to join the Lodge by affiliation was Bro. H. H. Chase, on 12 Jul 1860.
The cost at that time for all three degrees was $20 (about $500 in 2006 dollars); $5 ($125 today) on presenting the petition and the
balance of $15 before receiving the Entered Apprentice Degree. Affiliation was $3 ($75 today); the annual dues were $2 ($50
today).
The initial expenses of organizing Syracuse 501, including the indebtedness of No. 102, was $107.30 ($2683 today); and by the
year 1882 forty-two of the members of Syracuse Lodge No. 102 had affiliated with the new Syracuse Lodge No. 501. Many
prominent citizens became members of Syracuse Lodge, both by initiation and affiliation, among the latter being M.’.W.’. Finley M.
King, the Grand Master, a member of Port Byron Lodge No. 130 and publisher and editor of the “Masonic Union*,” who affiliated
with Syracuse Lodge on 16 Oct 1861 and remained a member until his death on 3 Feb 1868.
[* The last number of the “Masonic Union” was June 1854, and in September of the same year it reappeared in connection with the
Masonic Register, published by J.F. Adams at 343 Broadway, New York City, the combined monthly being called the Masonic
Register and Union.]
http://home.earthlink.net/~dahoude/from_the_archives.htm
WAR MEETING YESTERDAY. The meeting yesterday was largely attended in Hanover square. Finlay M. King, Massachusetts
Dunbar, and Hon. Thos. G. Alvord, addressed the meeting. Dunbar sang a sort of negro medley, with but poor success. Dunbar
should drop the darkey, and confine himself to patriotism. It is a great pity to see him waste his pantomimic efforts on the colored
gammon. If he desires to enter the ranks of a minstrel troupe, room must be made for him and a few others who train with him.
(Syracuse Daily Courier and Union 27 Aug 1862)
The early members of the lodge made every known effort to have the old number of 102 restored, but this was denied by Grand
Lodge. It was not until 1910 that the members were able to obtain possession of the charter of the late Syracuse Lodge No. 102 as
a relic. The present whereabouts of this charter is unknown, but may possibly be in the Greenland Collection at the Utica Branch of
the Grand Lodge Library.
5 Mar 1862 The Master of Syracuse Lodge received a petition form eleven members requesting to right to form a lodge at
Liverpool, New York. Their request was honored, and as a result, Liverpool Lodge No 525 was chartered on 3 Jun 1863.
< The first Bastable Block aka Shakespeare Hall ca 1870-80; destroyed by
fire ca 1893. Among its other tenants was the Second National Bank,
established in 1862 by Benjamin Ward Baum, owner of the Carbon Oil
Company. Baum was a successful businessman, but is mainly remembered
today as the father of L. Frank Baum, author of the Wizard of Oz.
Summer 1867: The Lodge changed its meeting place to rooms in the
Bastable Block where the State Tower Building is now located. These rooms
were elaborately fitted and equipped, the cost of which was largely offset by
individual subscriptions of the members in the amounts of $3 to $25, for a
total of $1,129.00.
The Lodge continued to prosper, and its 1873 its membership had increased
until these rooms were inadequate. Larger rooms were secured on the
fourth floor of the Whitlock Block at 217 South Clinton Street. At that time
the Lodge met on Wednesday evenings, and the weary journey of climbing three long, narrow flights of stairs was not considered a
hardship.
There were 640 Masons in the Pioneer Years of Syracuse Lodge; 30 charter members, 501 initiated and 108 affiliated.
Transitional Period: 1886-1930
The financial panic of 1873, a part of the secondary depression which followed the Civil War, hit the fraternal world hard. There was
only a 74% net increase in the membership of the Lodge between 1873-1888, but the spotlight of Masonry was soon to shine upon
the Syracuse Lodge again and a result of the devotion to the craft by R.’.W.’. Herbert William Greenland.
Past Masters
Joy, Lewis Everett 1860-61 Miller, Frank T. 1908-09 Jowett, Arthur 1960
Chase, Horace Hills 1862 Stone, Horace G. 1910-11 Holland, Richard W. 1961
Babcock, Ira 1863 Friedrich, Sebert T. 1912-13 Chacona, Pano S. 1962
Goff, Charles Sterling 1864-65 Dewald, Charles B. 1914-15 Larkins, Franklin D. 1963
Haywood, Waterman Henry 1866 Hancock, George K. 1916-17 Middleton, Lloyd A. 1964
Barnes, John William 1867-68 Shaw, C. Arthur 1920-21 Ryan, C. Wilson 1965
Brodhead, Fred Augustus 1869-70 Ireland, Lewis E. 1924-25 Sherman, Charles N. 1966
Blodgett, Rufus Barton 1871-72 Babcock, Joseph E. 1926-27 Cameron, Chandler J. 1967
Seeley, Obadiah 1873-74 Friedrich, Sebert H. 1930-31 Ace, Carle H., Jr. 1968
Phelps, William H. 1875-76 Thomasmeyer, Raymond H. 1934-35 DeHaven, William C. 1969
Barber, Theo. Milton 1877 Miller, O. Lacy 1938-39 Kanton, Peter J.* 1970
36

Latterner, Nicholas 1878-79 Crenan, Claude J. 1940-41 Kociuba, Frank 1971
Jeffrey, Charles J. 1880-81 Kogler, Henry C. 1944-45 McCann, Thomas I. 1972
Raymond, Frank 1882-83 Holland, Wilson E. 1948 Beckendorf, Charles N. III 1973-74
Worden, Stewart 1884-85 Cummings, Walter H. 1949 Edwards, Sylvester E. 1975
Norton, Clark H. 1886-87 Plaister, Hiram L. 1950 Bishop, Carlton E. 1976
Fix, Frederick W. 1888-89 Lees, B. Kenneth 1951 Heller, Wayne B. 1977
Greenland, Herbert W. 1890-91 Fulford, Robert D. 1952 Gray, Charles A. 1978-79
Phillips, A. Richard 1892-93 Rear, Harold 1953 Reed, George F. 1980-81
Soule, Albert D. 1894-95 Owen, William M. 1954 Wilson, Harold F. 1982
White, Samuel L. 1896-97 Davis, Paul J. 1955 Hartman, Gary S. 1983-84
Hall, Edwin C. 1998-99 Brill, George A. 1956 Pacini, Patrick E. 1985-86
Lynn, Louis J. 1900-01 Raaflaub, William I. 1957 Lees, Benjamin G. 1987
Reussow, Charles H. 1902-03 Zorn, Theodore E. 1958 Eustace, Robert J. Jr. 1988-89
Listman, John P. 1904-05 Sopp, Charles P. 1959 Hartman, Gary S. 1990
Lees, Benjamin G. 1991-94
* Peter J. Canton also served as Master of Military Lodge No. 93 in 1984.
-------------
The danger of fire was an ever-present menace, and in 1886 the lodge again changed its place of meeting, this time to the Y.M.C.A.
building on South Warren Street. These rooms, too, were soon outgrown, and in 1896 much larger accommodations were obtained
in the Greyhound Building at the corner of James and North Warren Streets. These rooms were dedicated on 4 Apr 1897 by M.’.W.’.
William A. Sutherland, then Grand Master. The elevator service at this new building made access much more convenient. On the
night of the dedication of the rooms in the Greyhound Building, Syracuse Lodge celebrated the reception of its 501st member. The
ceremonies of that evening were most impressive and concluded with a reception and banquet in Empire Hall.
Empire House, in which was the Empire Hall;
presently the site of the Herald Building on Clinton Square.
9 Jun 1910 the Lodge celebrated its 50th Anniversary with a banquet at the New York State Armory. Some 700 Masons were in
attendance. Fifty children from the Masonic Home at Utica were present and took part in the ceremonies.
The Lodge continued to beet in the Greyhound Building until the completion of the Syracuse Masonic Temple on Montgomery
Street; its first meeting there was on 4 Jan 1917.
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/ackerman.html
Daniel Ackerman Lodge No. 424; Grand Lodge No. 174893; Raised 21 Jul 1875, was born on 4 Dec
1851 in Frankenstein in the Rheinpfalz (Rhenish Bavaria). In October 1855 he emigrated with his parents to
America, coming directly to Syracuse. Educated in the public schools until the age of 13, he then received
business training in accounting--bookkeeping, etc.--and became the accountant for the wholesale grocery
firm of C. E. Crouse & Company. Working continually for this current employer from 1871 to 1884, he was
then made a partner in the business, which ranked among the most important in our city and whose
blossoming is owed primarily to his untiring efforts. In addition, Mr. Ackerman was one of the directors of
Bartels' Brewery and was married to Bertha C. Soldan, daughter of the deceased Pastor Soldan; they had
two children, of which one was a daughter. He resided at 206 Park Avenue and died on 8 Aug 1905.
Theodore Milton Barber Lieutenant-Colonels
GUSTAVUS SNIPER, from September 23, 1864, to February 3, 1865. (who was promoted to Colonel) Photograph
See more about Bro. Gustavus Sniper below under Salt Springs Lodge No. 520.
THEODORE M. BARBER, from February 4 to May 30, 1865. Photograph
185th New York Volunteer Infantry
"Sixth Onondaga County Regiment; Onondaga and Cortland Regiment; Otsego Regiment"
History and Campaigns
This regiment, Col. Edwin S. Jenney, was organized under State orders, dated 26 Aug, 1864, at Syracuse,
and there mustered in the service of the United States for one year; Companies A, B, C, D, E, G, H, and I
19 Sep 1864; Company F 25 Sep 1864; and K 21 Sep 1864. The few three years' men in the regiment
were, 30 May 1865, transferred to the 5th Veteran Infantry.
37

The companies were recruited principally: A at Lysander and Syracuse; B at Syracuse and Salina; C at Syracuse; D at Syracuse,
Salina, Otisco, Clay and Geddes; E at Homer, Cortlandville, Syracuse, Truxton and Taylor; F at Cortland, Syracuse, Virgil and
Taylor; G at Marathon, Freetown, Willet and Cincinnatus; H at Syracuse, Spafford and Baldwinsville; I at Fabius, Syracuse and
Baldwinsville; and K at Skaneateles and Syracuse.
The regiment left the State 27 Sep 1864; it served in the 1st Brigade, 1st Division, 5th Corps, and, commanded by Col. Gustavus
Sniper, it was honorably discharged and mustered out 30 May 1865, near Washington, D.C.
During its service the regiment lost by death, killed in action, 2 officers, 36 enlisted men; of wounds received in action, 1 officer, 23
enlisted men; of disease and other causes, 3 officers, 33 enlisted men; total, 6 officers, 92 enlisted men; aggregate, 98; and it took
part in the following engagements, etc.:
• Before Petersburg, Va. 1 Oct 1864 – 2 Apr 1865--1 enlisted man killed; 1 enlisted man wounded but recovered.
• Burgess Farm, Va. 27-28 Oct 1864--5 enlisted men wounded but recovered; 1 enlisted man missing.
• Hicksford Raid, Va. 6-11 Dec 1864--6 enlisted men missing.
• Hatcher's Run, Va. 5-7 Feb 1865--2 enlisted men killed; 1 officer and 9 enlisted men wounded but recovered; 1 officer and
3 enlisted men missing.
• Watkin's Farm, Va. 25 Mar 1865--no loss.
• Appomattox Campaign, Va. 28 Mar – 9 Apr 1865
o Quaker Road, 29 Mar 1865--1 officer and 31 enlisted men killed; 1 officer and 22 enlisted men mortally
wounded; 8 officers and 140 enlisted men wounded but recovered.
o Gravelly Run, 31 Mar 1865--6 enlisted men wounded but recovered.
o Five Forks, 1 Apr 1865--2 enlisted men killed; 1 enlisted man mortally wounded; 1 officer and 14 enlisted men
wounded but recovered.
o Fall of Petersburg, 2 Apr 1865--1 enlisted man wounded but recovered.
o Appomattox Court House, 9 Apr 1865--1 officer killed.
• Surrender of Lee and his army.
• March to Washington, DC, May 1-12.
• Grand Review May 23.
• Mustered out at or near Washington, DC, 30 May 1865.
• Veterans and recruits transferred to 5th New York Veteran Infantry.
Bro. Barber served with the 185th as follows:
Enlisted as a Lieutenant 1st Class on 5 Sep 1864 at the age of 31
Commission in Company D, 185th Infantry Regiment New York on 12 Dec 1864.
Transferred on 9 Jan 1865 from company D to company C
Promoted to Full Captain on 9 Jan 1865 (As of Co. C)
Transferred on 4 Feb 1865 from company C to company S
Promoted to Full Lieutenant Colonel on 4 Feb 1865
(Raised in Syracuse Lodge No. 501 on 1 Mar 1865)
Mustered out Company D, 185th Infantry Regiment New York on 30 May 1865 in Washington, DC
Masonically, Bro. Barber served as:
(He has two entries in the Registry of Syracuse Lodge No. 501):
Lodge No. 138, GL No. 85381, Raised 1 Mar 1865, Silver Plater, b. 22 Jul 1833, Auburn, NY; d. 2 Jul 1911; Demitted 10 Jan 1866.
Lodge No. 211, GL No. 107634, Affiliated 17 (restored) Apr 1867 from Syracuse 501; Elected a Life Member 20 May 1909.
1869-1870 Senior Deacon, Syracuse Lodge No. 501
1871-1872 Junior Warden, Syracuse Lodge No. 501
1875-1876 Senior Warden, Syracuse Lodge No. 501
1877 Master, Syracuse Lodge No. 501
1884-1885 Commander, Central City Commander No. 25, KT; served 25 years as Drill Master.
1889-1904 Illustrious Master, Central City Council No. 13, Cryptic Council (R&SM)
1893-1894 High Priest, Central City Chapter 70, RAM
16 Sep 1902 Supreme Council, A.A.S.R., NMJ, Honorary 33 o , at Providence, RI
1902-1904 Sovereign Prince, Council of Princes of Jerusalem, A.A.S.R.
1905-1908 Past Commander-in-Chief, A.A.S.R.
William Henry Chilton, Member No. 1494; GL No. 421072, Raised 29 Dec 1909, he was born 21
May 1885 in Johnstown, PA, the son of William and Emily Chilton. Moving to Syracuse at the age of
one, he attended Bassett and Madison Elementary Schools and Central High School. Chilton was
employed by the Syracuse Transit Company for 49 years starting as a street car conductor 14 Oct
1905; rising successively to instructor of conductors 11 Nov 1911; Division Superintendant 8 May
1917, Superintendant of Transportation 30 Jan 1930; General Superintendant 6 Dec 1943; and
finally to Vice President in Charge of Transportation 24 Dec 1944.
Masonic Record:
29 Dec 1909 Raised in Syracuse Lodge No. 501
27 Oct 1911 Exalted in Central City Chapter No. 70, RAM
13 Mar 1912 Greeted in Central City Council No. 13, R&SM
18 Oct 1912 Knighted in Central City Commandery No. 25, KT; Commander in 1941
Grand Representative to the State of Illinois, 1943-46
Member of the Finance and Budget Committee, 1941-47
Grand Captain General, 1953-54
38

1954 Master of Ceremonies, Council of Princes of Jerusalem, AASR, Valley of Syracuse
Concordant Bodies:
Red Cross of Constantine, St. Leo’s Conclave
Royal Order of Scotland
Tigris Temple, A.A.O.N.M.S.
Bro. Chilton married Ethel Claire Grover on 23 Mar 1904. One son, William Lawrence, and one daughter Mrs. Esther Margaret
Bottnsack, were born of that union. He died suddenly of coronary thrombosis at 1:30 am on 5 Apr 1954.
A man of many virtues, “Bill” Chilton particularly personified true fraternalism. Form and ceremony never held him for him the
attraction that did association with friends and brothers. Surely in the Book of the Angel his name is recorded as “one who loves his
fellowman.”
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/dopffeljr.html
William (Wilhelm) Dopffel, Jr., Member No. 764; Grand Lodge No. 270113, Raised 12 Mar 1891,
he was widely and broadly renowned and most a prominent insurance and real estate property
agent, and longtime Supervisor of the 12th Ward. He was born on 20 Jun 1853 in the City of New
York. His father was the well-known and respected Wilhelm Dopffel, Sr., who died in 1878. In the
year 1855 the family moved to Syracuse, where Mr. Dopffel lived. After completing his schooling he
was at first a telegraphist, then operated his own gentlemen's apparel business, then assumed
following the death of his father the insurance business he had created. In addition he was a partner
in the Syracuse Pottery Company along with Mr. Breitschwerth, the Supervisor of the 16th Ward.
Bro. Dopffel had an affable nature and in social circles was remarkably popular. But it is in the
political realm where he was a particular favorite. The voters entrusted him four times (1894-1897)
with the office of Supervisor, each time with so overpowering a majority as to express therein the
unlimited confidence of his fellow citizens. He was an enthusiastic friend of all organizations and
belonged to many, including the Turnverein, the Liederkranz, Knights of Pythias, the Order of the
Harugari, the German Life Insurance Association, the A. O. U. W., the Order of the Elks, the
Freemasons, and others. Mr. Dopffel was married to the former Johanna Wittneben and had four
children. He lived at 401 North Salina Street and died on 6 Aug 1934.
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/dopffelsr.html
Wilhelm Dopffel, Sr., father of the above Wilhelm Jr., was born 17 Dec 1828 in Brackenheim, Württemberg,
where he also received his education. In the year 1852 he emigrated to America. After a short stay in New
York he decided to go to Florida in search of employment and a climate beneficial to his health. During his
stay there he once came close to mortal danger while bathing in a river, when an alligator seized him by
the head and pulled him under the water. By desperate exertions and with the help of his friends, he
succeeded in being rescued, though he was seriously injured. The memory of this danger and the nearmiracle
of his escape stayed with him until his death. When he had recovered his health he returned to
New York where he married Miss Carolina Mühlig. In 1857 he came to Syracuse where, through diligence,
perseverance and thrift, he acquired a fortune. In the last years of his life he entered the insurance
business which he developed into full bloom. At all times he had a lively interest in matters concerning the
local Germans. His health, however, was always less than could be wished, and he died in the bloom of
his years on 19 Jan 1878 at the age of 49. During his lifetime he was an outstanding and untiringly active
member of the Lincoln-Loge. He served as supervisor of the old Fourth Ward and was appointed by Mayor
(Judge) Wallace to the position of Tax Commissioner.
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/gilcher.html
Jacob Gilcher, Lodge No. 617; Grand Lodge No. 236011; Raised 26 Jun 1884, was born on 28 Aug
1843 in Hachenbach in the Rhein-Pfalz, attended the local community-school in his youth and then
learned the butcher business. During the Franco-Prussian
war he was a member of the Third Bavarian cavalry,
Regiment "Königin Mutter," of the Third Army Corps. After
the war was over he decided to emigrate to America and
then in 1871 came to Syracuse, where he has since resided
and operated a very successful butcher business in the
Gilcher Block.
The Gilcher Block (1324 Lodi) >
at the corner of Butternut and Lodi Streets, Syracuse, New York.
A big four-story building with a main entrance door at the corner surmounted by a tower
of bay windows overlooking the intersection.
The top story might have been residential; the two middle stories look like offices; the
ground floor is filled with shops and storefronts.
This building was built by Jacob Gilcher.
Bro. Gilcher was one of the founders and most prominent supporters of German singing societies in this city. He was one of the
organizers of the Central New York Saengerbund, and besides being honorary president of the Liederkranz, a life office, he was
president of the Central New York Saengerfest held here in 1904. When he came to this city from Germany in 1871 he brought with
him a love of music and Teutonic folk-song which he lost no time in spreading among those of his countrymen who had already
come from the Fatherland to make their homes in Syracuse.
Mr. Gilcher was a member of Lincoln Encampment, No. 104, I. O. O. F.; Freie Breuder lodge, No. 458, of the Harugari; the Gneiger
Verein [sic], an organization of the veterans of the Prussian wars; the Arion Quartet club, the "Liederkranz" [German singing society]
as well as of the Sportsmen's Club, the Harmonia-Loge, and Lincoln-Loge. He has won the justly-placed confidence of his fellow
39

citizens as proved by his elections as a delegate to county, city, and ward conventions. In the year 1875 he married the former
Katherine Loos and had four children, to include Julius O., Louise, and Mathilde Gilcher. He resided at 1324 Lodi Street, Syracuse,
and died 10 Apr 1906 after an illness of three weeks, caused by blood poisoning. This resulted from a sliver in his left hand while
moving furniture in Gilcher hall preparatory to the rehearsal of the Syracuse Liederkranz of which he was the honorary president. He
was survived four brothers, Adolph, Julius and Peter of this city and Carl Gilcher of Germany; four sisters, Mrs. A. O. Zischang and
Mrs. Carl Schneider, both of this city and Mrs. Jacob Keller and Mrs. Carl Troninger of Germany. Burial was at Woodlawn cemetery
Herbert W. Greenland was a native of Weymouth, Dorset, England, where he was born on 28 May
1853. He came to this country one year later and from then on spent most of his years in Syracuse.
Following his studies in the public schools here, he engaged in the business of silversmith and
harness maker. In 1876, following his marriage, he went into the harness business for himself at
Fayetteville, later coming to Syracuse to go with the firm of Frazier & Jones.
Later he embarked in the insurance business, the firm being Stevens and Greenland. Upon the
death of his partner, Benjamin Franklin Stevens (Raised 24 May 1861 in Syracuse Lodge No. 501)
he continued the business alone until the firm became White & Greenland, and later Greenland,
Durston, Yackel & Rupp, Inc. The offices were in the White Memorial Building.
Few men of the day had wider connections in Freemasonry than Bro. Greenland. He was a Founder,
Founding Member or Charter Member of many Masonic Bodies in Central New York and other
areas. He was far more than a ‘joiner’ or card-carrying member; he was very active in the Bodies
which were privileged to have him among them. His Masonic career began at the age of 21, ending
with a glorious record of 53 years of service in 1927 at the age of 74.
SYMBOLIC MASONRY - BLUE LODGE:
His affiliations begun in this area broadened until they reached far across the seas. His Blue Lodge was Syracuse Lodge No. 501,
F&AM, (Lodge No. 405, GL No. 182164) where he was:
Initiated 7 Oct 1874 Passed 11 Nov 1874
and Raised to the Sublime Degree of Master Mason on 2 Dec 1874.
Going through the chairs he became:
1886 Senior Deacon 1888-89 Senior Warden
1887 Junior Warden 1890-91 Master
He was elected Secretary in 1894 and continued in that capacity until 1919. He was elected a Life Member on 15 Jan 1920; served
as Trustee from 1920 until 1924, becoming Lodge Historian during the latter year.
Bro. Greenland was appointed District Deputy Grand Master, of the then 19th District, in 1892 and served on the Grand Lodge
Committee on Antiquities in 1909.
CAPITULAR MASONRY - HOLY ROYAL ARCH:
In 1883 he became a Companion of Central City Chapter No. 70, Royal Arch Masons, and served as:
1884 Master of the 1st Veil 1887-88 Captain of the Host
1885 Master of the 2nd Veil 1889 Scribe
1886 Master of the 3rd Veil 1890-91 King
1892 High Priest.
He was Representative of the Grand Chapter of Nebraska from 1893 to 1902 and served as Assistant Grand Lecturer from 1903 to
1914.
CRYPTIC MASONRY - ROYAL AND SELECT MASTERS:
Seven years later he became affiliated with Central City Council No. 13, Royal and Select Masters, serving as:
1900-01 Captain of the Guard
1902 Principal Conductor of the Work
1903-04 Deputy Master
1905-06 Thrice Illustrious Master
He was Recorder in 1914-16. He became Grand Steward, 1906-07; Grand Marshal, 1907-08; and Most Illustrious Master of the
Grand Council of the State of New York in 1912 and was Representative of the Grand Council of England and Wales from 1915 until
his death.
Honorary Member of King Hiram Council No. 18, Auburn, NY, 10 Feb 1913.
CHIVALIC ORDERS - COMMANDERY:
In 1884 that Bro. Greenland became affiliated with Central City Commandery No. 25, K.T., and was
20 Jun 1884 Received and Constituted a Knight of Red Cross
18 Jul 1884 Created and Dubbed a Knight Templar
06 Nov 1885 Received the Order of Knight of Malta
holding offices in the Commandery as:
1885 Third Guard 1888-89 Senior Warden
1886 Sword Bearer 1890-91 Captain General
1887 Junior Warden 1892 Generalissimo
1893-94 Eminent Commander.
He was Representative of the Grand Commandery of California from 1918 to 1921.
ANCIENT ACCEPTED SCOTTISH RITE:
He joined Central City Lodge of Perfection, AASR, in 1887, receiving the Grades:
40

27 Jun 1887 Lodge of Perfection, 4th to 14th Grades
14 Nov 1887 Council of Princes of Jerusalem, 15th and 16th Grades
19 Dec 1887 Chapter of Rose Croix, 17th and 18th Grades
29 Dec 1887 Consistory of S.P.R.S, 19th to 32 Grades.
serving as:
Lodge of Perfection 14 o :
Captain of the Guard 1888
Junior Warden 1893-1895
Senior Warden 1896-1897
Deputy Grand Master 1898-1899
Thrice Potent Gr. Master 1900-1901.
He was a member of Central City Council, Princes of Jerusalem 16 o , from 14 Nov 1887,
and of Central City Chapter, Rose Croix 18 o , 19 Dec 1887, of which he was:
Master or Ceremonies 1893-1896
Junior Warden 1897
Senior Warden 1898-1901
Most Wise Master 1902-1903.
He was a member of Central City Consistory, S.P.R.S. 29 Dec 1887 and was Historian from 1917 on, and a member of NY Council
of Deliberation where he was Grand Master of Ceremonies in 1904 and Grand Hospitaler in 1905.
16 Sep 1919 - He was Crowned with the Thirty-Third Honorary Degree at Philadelphia by the Supreme Council, Northern Masonic
Jurisdiction, AASR.
MASONIC VETERANS ASSOCIATION OF CENTRAL NEW YORK:
5 Dec 1895 - He joined the Masonic Veterans Association of Central New York as Registry No. 161, from which much of this
Masonic Biography is obtained, serving as:
1897-98 Second Vice-President
1898-99 First Vice-President
and 1899-00 President.
From 1902 to 1910 he was named Senior Past President and Venerable Chief in 1920.
From 1901 to 1919 he was Secretary of this Association. As with his Secretary Reports for Syracuse Lodge No. 501, they are
meticulously typed and carefully preserved in a leather bound volume in the Archives of the OMDHS at the Liverpool Temple.
Bro. Greenland was an Honorary Member of the Masonic Veterans Associations in
29 Jun 1905 - Glasgow, Scotland;
26 Jun 1909 - Brooklyn,
31 May 1910 - New York City,
23 Jan 1911 - District of Columbia,
31 Mar 1911 - Pennsylvania,
03 Apr 1911 - Yonkers, NY,
16 Jan 1912 - Minnesota,
27 Feb 1913 - London,
15 Mar 1913 - Newark, NJ,
and Troy. He was Patriarch member of the State of Illinois.
7 Mar 1908 - Most Venerable Greenland visited with the M.V.A of Newburgh, NY. On 7 Mar 1911 he, with a delegation, went to
Philadelphia, PA to the M.V.A. Reunion to organize the Masonic Veterans Federation of the World.
24 Jan 1906 - Becoming a member of Keder Khan Grotto 12, MOVPER, he was Orator from 1907 to 1909.
SHRINE - A.A.O.N.M.S.:
1908 - He became a Noble in Ziyara Temple, AAONMS, Utica, and served as Illustrious Potentate in 1920. He was that year made
an Honorary member of Damascus Temple, Rochester. He was an Honorary member of Tigris Temple, Syracuse, and was
Representative to the Imperial Council in 1916, 1917, 1919 and 1920. See the 1921 Syracuse Herald article following the
Bibliography of this paper, titled “Shriners Happy at Creation of Tigris Temple.”
26 Oct 1910 - He further founded the Past Masters Association of the Twenty-Seventh Masonic District, serving as its first
President, and its Secretary from 1914 to the time of his death.
ORDER OF THE EASTERN STAR:
11 Dec 1888 - Becoming a Charter Member of Syracuse Chapter No. 70, O.E.S., he served as:
1893 Worthy Patron
1903-6 Representative to the Grand Chapter of Scotland
1906-07 Grand Lecturer
On the Founding level he was also very active with the:
21 Feb 1891 - Masonic Hall Association; Secretary, 1894-1902
20 Jan 1902 - Masonic Temple Club; Charter Member; Secretary 1902+
He was also affiliated with:
Grand Commandery of the State of New York, K. T.
Grand Chapter of the State of New York, Royal Arch Masons
Grand Council of the United States, Royal and Select Masters.
41

Since Feb 1892 he had been one of the Fraternal Union of Appointed High Priests, State of New York
and since 11 Jun 1908 of the Templar Knights Commanders of New York.
Other memberships included:
Masonic History Society of New York, 20 Sep 1905.
Quatuor Coronati Lodge No. 2076, London, England, Correspondence Circle, 4 Mar 1910.
Royal Order of Scotland.
St. Paul’s Conclave No. 12, Red Cross of Constantine, New York.
Salina Lodge No. 520, F&AM.
Syracuse Chapter, Acacia Fraternity, to which a bequest was later given by his widow.
King Hiram Council No. 718, R&SM, Auburn.
Honorary President of the Trowel Club of Syracuse Lodge No. 501, F&AM.
24 Feb 1908 he was made a Charter Member of Syracuse Court No. 35, Order of Amaranth, and was Trustee from 1909 to 1912.
As an author he wrote ‘interestingly’ of Masonic affairs. He was the author of:
“The History of Freemasonry in Syracuse and Vicinity”
“Centennial History of Central City Chapter, Royal Arch Masons”
“History of the Ancient Accepted Scottish Rite, Valley of Syracuse”
and “Centennial History of the Grand Council, Royal and Select Masters, State of New York.”
Other organizations claiming Bro. Greenland as a member were:
Independent Order of Odd Fellows, Americus Lodge No. 607;
Cynosure Encampment No. 14;
Twilight Lodge No. 285, Rebeccas.
Knights of the Golden Spur
Order of St. George
Rotary Club
New York State Association if Local Insurance Agents
and Insurance Federation of the State of New York.
From 1904 to 1907 he was a member of the Syracuse Board of Education and was Secretary of Woodlawn Cemetery since 1912.
He was stricken with apoplexy while on a visit with his wife at Batavia and later suffered an attack of pneumonia. Herbert W.
Greenland, 74, Thirty-Third Degree Mason and known to the fraternity in two hemispheres, died shortly after 1 o’clock on October
27th, 1927, at his home, 2332 South Salina Street. Private services were held at his home on Sunday morning, then the body was
taken to the Masonic Temple at Montgomery Street where it was viewed by various Bodies of the Masonic Fraternity and where
Masonic Ceremonies were conducted. He was interred at Woodlawn Cemetery and survived by his wife, one son, Edward H.
Greenland, and a daughter, Mrs. Arthur Langdon.
Around 1925 Ill. Herbert W. Greenland succeeded in completing sets of proceedings of the various Grand Bodies of New York State
and of the Supreme Council for the Northern Masonic Jurisdiction. These were bound and placed in some cases which happened to
be available.
After the death of Ill. and R∴W∴ Brother Greenland, Mrs. Greenland presented to the Scottish Rite Bodies his Masonic books and
papers, with the understanding that they were to form part of a collection to be known as the Herbert W. Greenland Memorial Library
and Museum. In addition to some Masonic books and pamphlets of much interest and value this included a large number of
manuscript copies of Masonic records covering all the Lodges and other Masonic bodies that have ever existed in Onondaga
County, together with considerable data pertaining to the organization of the Scottish Rite bodies which had been preserved by the
late Ill. Brother George Judd Gardner. Thus the indefatigable efforts of Bro. Greenland, continued over a long period of years, has
preserved to us a large amount of most valuable information that would otherwise have been hopelessly lost. Much of this Collection
continues to exist and is currently housed at the Chancellor Robert R Livingston Masonic Library at Utica, New York, where it was
transferred largely through the supreme efforts of Ill. and R∴W∴ Walter H. Cummings and his wife, Ethel, and by R∴W∴ Charles
J. Haskin of Utica, following the closing of the Montgomery Street Masonic Temple.
In keeping with his high regard for the tenets of the Fraternity, he bequeathed a sum of money to Syracuse Lodge No. 501 which is
still held as the “Greenland Memorial Fund,” which is used to cover the dues of Brothers who would otherwise have to be dropped
from the rolls, and for similar beneficent purposes.
Additionally, the archives of Liverpool Syracuse Lodge No. 501 are happily replete with the meticulous records compiled and kept
by Bro. Greenland during his tenure as Secretary of Syracuse Lodge No. 501. The two typed and bound volumes of Secretary
Reports commence with the last meeting of Syracuse Lodge No. 102 in 1860 and end with reports by his successor.
References:
• Cummings, William L., Seventy-Five Years of Scottish Rite Masonry in the Valley of Syracuse, Syracuse, NY. 1937. pg 44,
“The Library and Museum.”
• Syracuse Journal, “Body of Noted Mason Will Lie in State at Temple on Sunday,” Thusday, October 27, 1927, page 8.
• Grand Council, Royal and Select Masters of the State of New York, Address of Most Illustrious Herbert W. Greenland, Grand
Master, Poughkeepsie, NY. 25-26 August 1913.
• Greenland, Herbert W. “Personal Scrapbooks” in the Collection of the Onondaga Masonic Districts Historical Society Library,
Liverpool Temple, Liverpool, NY
• Lane, Chester L., “A History of the Masonic Veterans Associations,” 1965, corrected and updated through 1975. This is a spiral
bound, 108 page handwritten manuscript, with a Table of Contents and assorted memorabilia inserted.
• Registers of the Masonic Veterans Association of Central New York [MVA]:
42

Vol 1 - the work of George J. Gardner. See Registry No. 161, 5 Dec 1895, for “The Masonic Record of Brother Herbert Wm.
Greenland.”
Vol 1a - Compiled by Herbert W. Greenland. See page (Registry No. 161), “Masonic Record of Herbert William Greenland.”
Bro. Greenland evidently copied Gardner’s Registry into the ‘Greenland’ Registry.
Article from Syracuse Herald, 17 Jun 1921
From the Scrapbook of Herbert W. Greenland,
on file in the Onondaga Masonic Districts Historical Society’s Library
SHRINERS HAPPY
AT CREATION OF TIGRIS TEMPLE
----------------
Syracuse Nobles to Celebrate at Me(e)ting at K(e)ith’s
Saturday Afternoon.
-----------------
FANCHER IS POTENTATE
-----------------
Will Lead Caravan to Welcome Back Delegates to Imperial Council
----------------
There wasn’t a Shriner among the 1,200 in Syracuse and vicinity who wasn’t as tickled Thursday afternoon as a little boy with his
first pair of pants. And since the Nobles are anxious to try ‘em on, as it were, Illustrious Potentate William A. Fancher has called the
first meeting of Tigris Temple, Ancient Arabic Order Nobles of the Mystic Shrine, at Keith’s Theater Saturday afternoon at 5:30
o’clock, or thereabouts.
The 1,200 Nobles will assemble at the Masonic Temple at Montgomery Street at 4 o’clock to form a Caravan which will meet the
4:57 train from the West. The Syracuse delegates to the Imperial Council, which granted Tigris its charter as this week’s session in
Des Moines, Ia, will be on the train.
The first attempt of the Syracuse Shriners to obtain a Shrine, all of their very own, was undertaken about 10 years ago. It wasn’t
until about a year ago, however, that anything like real business was started.
Greenland Upset Program.
Bygones are bygones, but it will do no harm to recall just for a moment that a little more than a year ago, when Herbert W.
Greenland of this Valley of Onondaga was about due to be elevated to the position of Illustrious Potentate of Ziyara Temple, the
Nobles of the Valley of the Mohawk let it be known that they didn’t propose such things to happen.
Ziyara Temple, to which most of the Shriners in Syracuse have been owing allegiance, has its headquarters in Utica. For years a
Mohawk Valley man had been occupying the seat at the head of the Divan.
Gets Purple and Everything.
Syracuse heard the report from the East. No such thing had ever before been suggested with reference to Herbert W. Greenland.
As a matter of fact, when Herbert W. wants anything from Syracuse Shriners he gets it. He got the purple and all the rest of the doodads
that go with the Illustrious Potentate’s job. Moreover, Syracuse took all the rest of the offices, just by way of showing the folks
down East what they might expect if they got to monkeying with a buzz-saw.
A little later, another petition to obtain a new Temple charter in this city was prepared. This was presented to the Imperial Council
session in Portland, Ore., in 1920. Mr. Greenland, then Illustrious Potentate of Ziyara Temple, and a delegation of Syracuse
Shriners went to Portland to help put the thing across.
Herbert W. was ill in bed when the train blew the signal for the start. This didn’t hinder him a particle. He ordered a wheel chair
and took that train. While he was sleeping the sleep of the just in the wilds of Canada someone put him off the train at Calgary, and
he awoke in a hospital.
Petition Lost in Shuffle.
He allowed he couldn’t Potentate around there, so he fired the entire hospital staff and caught the next train for Portland. He
arrived in time to attend a session or two of the big conclave, but the petition for a new Shrine in Syracuse got lost in the shuffle.
Time will heal all things. A year went by. Came another election of officers officers in Ziyara Temple. Utica wanted to know what
part it would be permitted to play in the proceedings. It found out after the ballots had been counted that the Syracuse Shriners had
handed back the Temple with about 800 more members than it had before it left town.
Likewise the Syracuse bunch had shown the folks from Mohawk Valley how to do some things. The new officers put on the Spring
Ceremonial recently and hauled better than 400 more members across the hot sands.
Utica Nobles Boost for Tigris.
Everybody began to agree that Ziyara Temple was getting too big. Accordingly, Utica and the Nobles of Mohawk Valley “plugged”
for Tigris when the petition came up in the Imperial Council this week. Charles E. Northrup, Will R. Olds, Harvey D. Burrill and
Robert D. Rooney comprised the Syracuse Committee.
The parade scheduled for Saturday afternoon is for the purpose of welcoming the committee back home and showing its members
how Syracuse Shriners appreciate what was done. With $40,000 in the bank and $150,000 more pledged toward the new combined
Scottish Rite Cathedral and Shriners Temple, it is expected that construction work will begin in the near future, probably on the site
of the old Onondaga Orphans home in East Genesee Street.
Transcribed 1997 - R∴W∴Gary L. Heinmiller, Area 11 Historian.
43

The R∴W∴ Herbert W. Greenland, 33º, Memorial Library and Museum
housed in The Chancellor Robert R Livingston Library of Grand Lodge
at the Masonic Home, Utica, New York
Bro. Greenland was intensely interested in local Masonic records and history. He compiled a leather notebook in which he recorded
in small, legible script all the members of the early Lodges in Syracuse, including:
Salina Lodge no. 327, Central City Lodge No. 305, and
Syracuse Lodge No. 484, 102 and 501, Salt Springs Lodge No. 520.
He kept a similar record as his contribution to the Central City 33º Club.
The above records have not been seen by this writer as of July 1997, although a similar computerized listing has been compiled by
this writer for the Pre-Morgan Onondaga County Lodges, R.A.M. Chapters and Syracuse Lodge No. 102, from extant Returns at
Grand Lodge, Registers, and Minute Books.
Around 1925 Ill∴ Greenland succeeded in completing sets of Proceedings of the various Grand Bodies of NY State and of the
Supreme Council, N.M.J. These were bound and placed in some cases; the work of collecting continued and was complete to date,
as of 1937.
After the death [27 Oct 1927] of Ill. and R∴W∴ Brother Greenland, Mrs. Greenland presented to the Scottish Rite Bodies [28 Nov
1927] his Masonic books and papers, with the understanding that they were to form part of a collection to be known as the Herbert
W. Greenland Memorial Library and Museum. In addition to some Masonic books and pamphlets of much interest and value this
included a large number of manuscript copies of Masonic records covering all the Lodges and other Masonic bodies that have ever
existed in Onondaga County, together with considerable data pertaining to the organization of the Scottish Rite bodies which had
been preserved by the late Ill. Brother George Judd Gardner. Thus the indefatigable efforts of Bro. Greenland, continued over a long
period of years, has preserved to us a large amount of most valuable information that would otherwise have been hopelessly lost.
Early in 1933 such books as remained of the collection bought in 1915 were removed to the Syracuse Masonic Temple.
Much of this Collection continues to exist and is currently housed at The Chancellor Robert R Livingston Masonic Library at Utica,
NY, where it was transferred largely through the supreme efforts of Ill. and R∴W∴ Walter H. Cummings and his wife, Ethel,
following the closing of the Montgomery St. Masonic Temple.
This Collection consisted of, in addition to that listed above:
Collection Named for: Donated by: Included:
Cheney Ill∴ Jerome L. Cheney Jerome K. Cheney, son Books, Certificates, Magazines, Jewels
Cook Ill∴ Abel G. Cook, 33º Mrs. Walter M. Cheney Certificates, Jewels
Farmer Ill∴ and M∴W∴ Mrs. Farmer
Books, Membership Certificates, Trowels, Gavels
William S. Farmer, 33º
Gardner Ill∴ George Judd Gardner The earlier records amassed by our first Historian and one of the
founders of our local Scottish Rite Bodies, formed the nucleus of
the Greenland Collection, some (or most) of which were mingled
with the William L. Cummings Library, which see.
Goodwin Bro. Charles B. Goodwin Mrs. Detor, dau. More than 300 Badges and Medals in a specially built cabinet.
Other acquisitions were added ‘in the intervening years,’ some of which are recorded in the:
Central City Scottish Rite Bulletin:
Vol. 1 No. 2 1931
Vol. 2 No. 1 1931; No. 2 1932
Vol. 3 No. 1; 1933 No. 2 1933.
Sources:
• Peacher, William G., “100 Years of Scottish Rite Masonry in the Valley of Syracuse, 1862-1962,” page 48.
• Cummings, William L., “History of the Central City Bodies, A.A.S.R., 1862-1937.” See also pages 44-46, ‘The Library and
Museum.’
------------
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/haberle.html
Benedict Haberle Lodge No. 397; Grand Lodge No. 160955; Raisde 25 Feb 1867 in Salt Springs
Lodge No. 520; Affiliated to Syracuse Lodge No. 501 11 March 1874.
For now, the following biographical information will have to suffice until a translation may be
obtained:
He was the founder and owner of the Haberle Brewing Company of Syracuse, NY, which operated
under the names of Benedict Haberle (Butternut & McBride Streets, southwest Corner, 1865-1875)
and B. Haberle & Sons from 1875 until his death in 1881. He was born 19 Mar 1824 in Rulfingen in
Fürstenthum Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen.
Nach beendigter Schulzeit, bereitete er sich weiter auf den Lehrerberuf vor und war bis zum Jahre
1850 im Lehrfach thätig. Im letztgenannten Jahre entschloss er sich zur Auswanderung nach
Amerika, und als er im September ankam, liess er sich zuerst in Brooklyn, N. Y., nieder. Kurze Zeit
darauf zog er westwärts und kam nach Cincinnati, Ohio. Ungefähr um das Jahr 1853 siedelte er
nach Syracuse über, wo er bis zu seinem Lebensende wohnen blieb. Während der ersten zwei
Jahre seines hiesigen Aufenthalts arbeitete er als Holzschnitzer. Bis dahin gab es noch keine richtige Lagerbier-Brauerei hier,
obwohl verschiedene kleine Anfänge bereits gemacht worden waren. Als intelligenter Mann erkannte er bald mit dem sicheren
44

Scharfblick eines geborenen Geschäftsmanns, dass diese Industrie hier eine grosse Zukunft haben müsse. Er errichtete (1855) die
erste Lagerbier-Brauerei, im grösseren Massstabe [sic], an der Ecke von McBride und Butternutstrasse, wo sich jetzt Ryan’s Ale-
Brauerei befindet. Das Unternehmen war von Anfang an erfolgreich und unter seiner geschäftskundigen Leitung nahm die Brauerei
einen grossartigen Aufschwung. Im Jahre 1865 errichtete er dann die jetzige nach ihm benannte grossartige Brauerei auf der
gegenüberliegenden Seite der Strasse. Gleich nach seiner Ankunft in Amerika verheirathete er sich mit Caroline Oswald, die am 11.
Okt. 1829 in Benzingen (Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen) geboren war und noch heute lebt. Herr Häberle wurde bald eine leitende
Persönlichkeit unter den hiesigen Deutschen, sowohl in geschäftlicher Hinsicht, wie auch mit Bezug auf Charakter und Ansehen
unter seinen Landsleuten. Was immer unter den Deutschen vorgenommen wurde, fand seinerseits bereitwillige Unterstützung durch
Rath und That. Er starb in seinen besten Jahren, am 22. September 1881 mit Hinterlassung seiner Gattin und 6 Kindern, die noch
alle leben. Diese sind: Frau Olive Biehler, Frank B. Häberle, William H. Häberle, Charles Häberle, Frau Louise Schwarz und
Fräulein Julia Häberle. Der blühende Zustand des von ihm gegründeten Geschäfts legt Zeugniss ab von seinem
Unternehmungsgeist und beweist, dass er einen guten Grund dazu gelegt hatte. [page 268]. He died 21 Sep 1881.
It is probable that the Charles Haberle, noted as a son of his above, was the same Charles in the Register of Syracuse Lodge No.
501, Member No. 972, Grand Lodge No. 307694, Raised 8 Jul 1897, born 10 Aug 1860, died 27 Oct 1910. Occupation: Brewer.
Edwin Cyrus Hall Member No. 692; Grand Lodge No. 253258; Raised 12 Jul 1888; Accountant,
was born 25 May 1857 at Tully, NY. He was educated in the public schools of his native village, and
in early life took up the study of telegraphy, and at age 17 was telegraph agent of the Delaware,
Lackawanna and Western Railrod at Tully. Remaining in the position about fur years he removed to
Syracuse to enter the employment of his uncle who managed the W. L. Ross and Company,
wholesale liquor dealers on West Fayette Street. From there he went to the Crystal Brewing
Company on its incorporation in 1877 as Secretary.
Upon the consolidation of the Haberle and Crystal Spring Breweries, Bro. Hall was the unanimous
selection to assume the post of General Manager in addition to continuing as Secretary and
Treasurer. He mastered every aspect of the concern and knew all the employees by name with
whom he was a great favorite. Business men knew him as a leading force in commercial affairs,
and he was equally active and interested in civic matter. He was a member of the Citizens Club,
Century Club, Knights of Pythias and the Odd Fellows, I.O.O.F.
Masonic Record:
12 Jul 1888 Raised in Syracuse Lodge No. 501; Master in 1898 and 1899; Trustee 1902-16
1888 Exalted in Central City Chapter No. 70, RAM
1889 Greeted in Central City Council No. 13, R&SM
1889 Knighted in Central City Commandery No. 25, KT; Commander in 1899-1900
1909-10 Grand Commander, Grand Commandery of the State of New York
1911 Chairman of the Commandery Finance Committee
1896-97 Thrice Potent Master, Central City Bodies, AASR, Lodge of Perfection
1890-91 Junior Grand Warden, Council of Princes of Jerusalem
1892-95 Senior Grand Warden, Council of Princes of Jerusalem
1890-92 Senior Warden, Chapter of Rose Croix
1893-95 Most Wise Master, Chapter of Rose Croix
1890-1905 Consistory, S.P.R.S., 32 o , serving as Commander-in-Chief in 1905
1894 Second Lieutenant Commander, New York Council of Deliberation
17 Sep 1895 Crowned and Honorary Member, 33 o , Supreme Council, NMJ, at Buffalo, NY
Bro. Hall had been in failing health for at least a month before his death on 29 Nov 1916. He had spent several weeks recuperating
at the Clifton Springs Sanitorium but was transferred to the Syracuse University Hospital on 17 Nov where he later succumbed. His
wife, Mrs. Florence Clark Hall, and his sister, Miss Esther Hall of Tully, were with him when he died. His body rested in state at the
Syracuse Lodge No. 501 Lodge rooms in the Greyhound Building at James and North Warren Streets where members of the
Commandery acted as Guard of Honor. He was laid to rest in the full Templar regalia of Grand Commander after religious services
were observed at the Chapel in Oakwood Cemetery.
Finlay M. King Member No. 56; Grand Lodge No. 52048; Raised 15 Mar 1848 in Port Byron Lodge No. 130; Affiliated with
Syracuse Lodge No. 501 on 16 Oct 1961. Born 1820, Died 3 Feb 1868. Grand Master of Masons of the State of New York 1861-62.
Ref. "A Standard History of Freemasonry in the State of New York" by Peter Ross,
The Lewis Publishing Company, 1899. Volume I, pages 494-500. et al. Photo, page 495
Finlay M. King succeeded to the Grand Mastership in June 1861, and entered upon his duties with all the preparation which a
thorough knowledge of Grand Lodge could afford him. He had served as:
Junior Grand Warden 1853
Senior Grand Warden 1854 to 1859
Deputy Grand Master 1860, under M\W\ John W. Simons.
As Editor of the "Masonic Union," a small monthly periodical which he conducted mainly from his office at Port Byron from 1850 to
1854, and which was merged afterward into the "Masonic Register," he rendered good service to the fraternity and discussed
Masonic matters, especially those relating to his own State, with a sincere desire to promote harmony, and to close up the scattered
ranks without at the same time yielding up in the slightest degree any of the dignity or asserted rights of the Grand Lodge. His
reports as Chairman of the Committee on Foreign Correspondence made him known as a Masonic writer and jurist throughout the
craft universal, and much of his best literary work - from a Masonic point of view - lies entombed in these efforts. He was a true
and faithful brother, and although he delighted in controversy and was an unyielding supporter of any cause he adopted, any cause
45

he deemed to be right or which appealed to his sympathy, he never permitted his pen to give vent to malice or indulge in
personalities.
In private life Brother King seemed pursued by misfortunes. He was a good lawyer, brighter, it is said by those who knew him,
than the average, yet he never seemed able to command a sufficiently wide circle of clients to make life any better than a struggle
for subsistence. It is considered that perhaps he worked in the legal profession mainly as a means of obtaining income so that he
could then write or go out on the road with his Masonic lecture circuit, for which he was noted as a knowledgeable but somewhat
'dull' speaker. He tried for years to build up a practice at Port Byron, but failed, and in 1854 he removed to New York City,
establishing the firm of King, Smith & Co., at No. 9 Nassau Street, with no better success.
As a specimen of Grand Master King's clear and logical discussion of matters of Masonic moment, the following selection is
quoted on the subject of the use of the ballot in the administration of candidates, and in their advancement:
“The question often arises in Lodges as to the right of a single member to oppose the admission of an applicant. The
general rule in the United States is that of entire unanimity - that one negative ballot will reject a candidate, and it is the
safest and best rule that can be adopted. European Grand Lodges have, in some instances, provided by constitutional
regulations that subordinate Lodges may themselves determine the number of negative ballots which shall be necessary to
reject a candidate, provided the number does not exceed three, and there are individual Lodges in this country which have
adopted a similar practice. We believe, the practice, however is wrong. It contravenes a principle which is necessary to the
preservation of the harmony of the fraternity. No person should be admitted a member of a Lodge whose presence would
disturb its peace and harmony, and these features -- the prominent characteristics of our Order, cannot be preserved
without a rigid adherence to the rule of unanimity in the acceptance of petitioners.”
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/knappj.html
Jacob Knapp, Member No. 490; Grand Lodge No. 186050; Raised 5 Dec 1877, known by
everyone as “Captain” or “Major” Knapp, was born 28 Nov 1837 in Wadril, in the district of Trier, in
Prussia. He attended elementary school in his home town and came at the age of 14 years, on 8
Jul 1852, to Syracuse. He learned to make cigars, and when the Civil War broke out, he enlisted in
Co. B of the 149th NY Volunteer Regiment and participated in all their battles and marches that
are described elsewhere here, except for the Battle of Gettysburg. He was captured and had the
chance for six long weeks to learn from his own bitter experience the frights and miseries of the
notorious Libby Prison. Mr. Knapp has every right to pride himself upon his military career. After
serving for a long time as an army courier, he was promoted to 2nd Lieutenant, then to 1st
Lieutenant, then Captain, then finally Major. After returning home from the war, he went into
business with his half-brother, Mr. Nicholas Peters Sr., from 1865 until 1884, when he retired to
private life. Mr. Knapp is one of the most prominent figures among the local German populace, and
has been repeatedly entrusted by them with public offices. So it was that in 1872 he became City
Councilman from the Second Ward, served as Police Commissioner from 1875 to 1882, and was Street Commissioner in 1884.
He was married to the former Miss Lisetta Elisabetha Egelhoff, had one child, and lived at 422 Kirkpatrick Street. (see also
Nicholas Grumbach biography, of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, above for more about Bro. Knapp)
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/rupp.html
Frank J. Rupp, Doctor of Medicine, Member No. 961; Grand Lodge No. 307683; Raised 25 Mar 1897;
Born 11 Jul 1869, Syracuse, died 16 Feb 1832. Again, apologies, until a translation of the following
may be obtained:
Dr. Med. Frank J. Rupp geboren am 11. Juli 1869 in hiesiger Stadt, besuchte in seiner Jugend zuerst
die öffentlichen Schulen und studirte dann auf dem berühmten Hartwick Seminary. Hierauf war er 2
Jahre als Buchhalter thätig und wandte sich dann dem Studium der medizinischen Wissenschaft zu.
Nachdem er von der medizinischen Fakultät der hiesigen Universität graduirt hatte, machte er noch
einen Kursus in der New York Post Graduate Medical School durch. Nach beendigtem Studium
etablirte er sich hier als practischer Arzt und Chirurg und hat als solcher seine Office No. 717
Catherinestrasse. Dr. Rupp stammt mütterlicherseits von den frühen deutschen Pionieren dieser Stadt.
In seiner Profession ist er sehr erfolgreich gewesen und erfreut sich einer ausgedehnten Praxis. Im
Besitz einer umfassenden allgemeinen und fachwissenschaftlichen Bildung und einfach und
gemessen im Umgang, geniesst er grosses Vertrauen in deutschen Kreisen. In den Jahren 1895-96
war er City and County Ward Physician. Am 14. Juni 1894 verheirathete er sich mit Fräulein Helene C. Achilles und wohnt No. 1300
Lodistrasse. [page 291]
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/saxerldr.html
Leonard Alexander Saxer, Member No. 742; Grand Lodge No. 264246; Raised 10 Apr 1890; Doctor
of Medicine, president of the local School Board, and a physician of expansive practice and widespread
demand, was born in Lockport, NY, 30 Oct 1856. One year after his birth, his parents moved from
Lockport back to Syracuse, where they had previously resided. Here he attended the public schools
and later graduated from the medical school of the local University ([SU?] class of 1882). Since then he
has enjoyed here a large and successful practice. In 1893 he did
specialized studies in the hospitals of Vienna, Austria. He held several
different honorary positions in medical organizations and belongs to
several societies. Since 1891 he served as School Commissioner for the
16th Ward and since 1896 was President of the School Board. On 2 Apr
1884 he married Miss Nettie B. Worth of Constantia. His residence was at
305 James Street. He died 3 May 1933.
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/simon.html
Charles (Karl) Simon Member No. 118; Grand Lodge No. 80013
One of the most outstanding local German pioneers and businessmen, Carl Simon was born near the
Rhine, on 24 Feb 1837 in Argenschwanz, Prussia, and came with his parents in 1846 to America,
where the family established itself in Liverpool. When they left Germany, the family possessed about
46

$1,000, but lost everything because of an accident to the ship. Nothing could be saved, and they had to completely start over.
His father died in 1849 and Mr. Simon had to support the family. He learned the shoemaker handicraft and could already make a
pair of boots by himself when he was 15 years old. He has been in business since 1849, starting his own shoe store in 1853, which
he brought from small beginnings to the present large business.
He served 14 years in the 51st militia regiment and Captain of Co. B. He was furthermore one of the founders and vice-president of
the Woodlawn-Kirchhofs. From 1868-74 he was City Assessor and was elected in the autumn of 1874 as a representative of the 3rd
Assembly district of the State Legislature. He was the first Democrat elected in many years in this district.
In 1891 the German pioneer association was created by his efforts, he becoming the 1st Vice-president. Now he has for several
years been the president of the same. He was Raised 30 Mar 1864 in Syracuse Lodge No. 501, F&AM; member of Central City
Chapter No. 70, RAM; and Central City Commandery No. 25, KT.
He was furthermore one of the founders of the Germania Brewing Co., whose first president he was. He made a journey to
Germany and after his return helped to organize the Crystal Brewing Co., at which time he became its president for 3 years.
In 1856 he married Ms. Katharine Poehlmann, from which marriage 10 children issued, of whom 2 died prematurely. He lived at No.
715 Danforth Street and lay beneath the Acacia on 5 Jun 1914.
Edward Zahm, Member No. 1045; Grand Lodge No. 320805; Raised 6 Jul 1899; Brewer, was born 28
May 1874 in Toledo, Ohio, besuchte die oeffentliche und Hochschule, erlernte das Braugeschaeft und
absolvirte die Brauerakademie, darauf studirte er die praktische Braukunst in verscniedenen [sic;
verschiedenen] groesseren Brauereien des Landes und wurde
Braumeister fuer die Crystal Spring Brewing Co. Am 14. Februar 1897
verheirathete er sich mit Fraeulein Margarethe Guenther, eine Tochter
von Henry Guenther, Superintendent der John Kress Brewing Co. in New
York City. Herr Zahm wohnt bei seinem Vater. [page 299] He died 15 Feb
1949.
George Zahm, Member No. 1123; Grand Lodge No. 337084; Raised 12
Mar 1902; Lawyer, was born 27 Feb 1876 in Toeldo, Ohio, juengster Sohn des Herrn Anton Zahm,
besuchte die oeffentliche und Hochschule, absolvirte ein Business College, erlernte Stenographie und
Typewriting und wurde Buchhalter fuer die Haberle und Crystal Spring Brewing Co. Seine Neigung
geht jedoch nach dem Studium und er gedenkt die Yale-College zu beziehen, um die
Rechtswissenschaft zu studiren. [page 299]
Salt Springs Lodge No. 520
Syracuse, New York
10 Jun 1862 -
PREFACE
The history of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, F. & A. M., is a digest of the work or an organization dedicated to the study and
advancement of the principles of ancient craft masonry. The highest standards of loyalty to these landmarks have been maintained
throughout the century.
Our principal objective in writing this history has been to carefully preserve the accomplishments and traditions of the past 100
years. So often written records are lost, destroyed by water or fire, deteriorate through neglect, discarded involuntarily or for needed
space. Then, too, living memories fade, become distorted in succeeding generations, and are ultimately claimed by the great architect
of the universe. To avoid irreparable loss of our heritage, these notes have been set down for posterity.
In an undertaking of this type, useful material is obtained from so many sources and individuals that a complete listing is quite
beyond the space available. For the 1\ame reason, many transactions of our lodge have been excluded although the main
substance has been preserved. The minutes, when quoted, have been edited for the most part for greater clarity.
Where possible, older lodge members were interviewed and out-of-town members were contacted. William Crabtree, Max Klein, and
Andrew Stohrer have been particularly helpful. Our Secretary, Vernon Tapper, has made available all information in his possession.
My sincere thanks for his kindness and extreme patience. Without the photographic skill and enthusiasm of Kenneth Tisdell, the
history would have lacked much of its attractiveness. Mr. and Mrs. Richard Wright at the Onondaga Historical Association need
particular mention for their assistance in locating pertinent material and for placing their complete files at our disposal. Countless
others have furnished data, important clues as to sources, by-laws, programs, newspaper clippings, and other crucial knowledge.
The standard published-histories of Syracuse and Onondaga County including those specifically within, during, and following the
War of the Rebellion; and early newspapers in bound volumes or on microfilm found. in the Public Library and Onondaga Historical
Association were diligently searched for leads on our members and lodge activities. It would be almost impossible to separate
Masonry' from the growth of the area, hence significant historical events have necessarily been included for continuity.
The archives of the Syracuse Masonic Temple, including the Herbert Greenland Memorial' Collection and the William L. Cummings
Thirty-Third Degree Library, all furnished additional helpful records.
It is my earnest hope that this commemorative volume will give the members of this lodge as much pleasure as its research and
preparation have given the author. May its perusal awaken tender memories, inspire hope, and lead to zealous efforts to eclipse the
past with a brilliant future.
47

CONTENTS
Preface
List of Photographs
I. Organization of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, F&AM. Charter Members
II. War of the Rebellion
III. Spanish-American War. Boxer Rebellion. World Wars I and II. Korean War
IV. Anniversary Celebrations
V. Historical Events
VI. Historical Lectures
VII. Charitable Activities
VIII. Gifts. Purchases. Portraits of Past Masters
IX. Masonic Funeral Services
X. Masonic Home, Utica, New York. Religious Services
XI. Music. Refreshments . Entertainment
XII. By-Laws. Dues and Fees. Meeting Places. Meetings. Attendance. Minute Books
XIII. Fraternal Visitations and Degree Work. Visitations to other Lodges. Petitions from sister Lodges
XIV. Membership
XV. Oldest Living Master, William Crabtree. The Crabtree Class
XVI. Honors
XVII. Masters of Salt Springs Lodge
Index
LIST OF PHOTOGRAPHS
Photostatic Copy of Charter, Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, F. & A. M.
First Page of Register, Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, F. & A. M.
Copy of Seal of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, F&AM
Minutes of First Meeting of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, F. & A. M., U. S. September 14, 1862. Page 1
Minutes of First Meeting of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, F. & A. M., U. S. September 14, 1862. Page 2
Dr. Henry D. Didama, Early Lodge Member
Mending the Flag: Battle Scene of the 149th Regiment at Gettysburg
Monument Erected at Culp's Hill, Gettysburg, to 149th Regiment
Moses Summers, Charter Member
Nicholas Grumbach, Charter Member
Philip Eckel
Memorial Tablet to the 12th Army Corps (149th Regiment), Lookout Mountain, Tennessee
Rare Photograph of General Gustavus Sniper (Center) and His Staff Officers of the 185th Regiment
Max Klein, Sixty-Year Member: Taken at the Time of the Boxer Rebellion
Centennial Anniversary of Dispensation, September 17, 1961: M.W. Carl W. Peterson Addressing the Lodge
Sword used by Colonel Nicholas Grumbach during the War Between the States
Ash Tray Memento of Celebration May 24, 1909
Louis Wittneben , Tyler, 1881-1947
First Page of By-Laws of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, F. & A. M.
Visitation from St. Andrews Lodge No. 560, A. F. & A. M., Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, May 5, 19 62
W. William Crabtree, Our Oldest Living Master (1912-1913)
-------------
Fraternally yours,
WILLIAM G. PEACHER, M.D.
Fayetteville, New York, 21 May 1962
Chapter I. Organization of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, F &AM. Charter Members Freemasonry in Syracuse in 1862
Petition to Grand Lodge for Dispensation. The original is on file in the office of the Grand Secretary, New York.
To the Most Worshipful Grand Lodge of the State of New York: The undersigned petitioners being Ancient Free and Accepted
Masons, having the prosperity of the fraternity at heart, and willing to exert their best endeavors to promote and diffuse the genuine
principles of Masonry, respectfully represent that they are desirous of forming a new Lodge in the First Ward of the City of Syracuse,
to be named Salt Springs Lodge. They therefore pray for letters of dispensation or a warrant of Constitution to empower them to
assemble as a legal Lodge, to discharge the duties of Masonry in a regular and constitutional manner according to the original forms
of the Order and the regulations of the Grand Lodge. They have nominated and do recommend Brother Jno. F. Sherwood to be the
first Master, Henry F. Greene to be the first Senior Warden, and Peter Smith, Jr., to be the first Junior Warden of said Lodge. !f the
prayer of the petition shall be granted, they promise a strict conformity 'to the constitution, laws, and regulations of the Grand Lodge.
Dated Salina, Monday evening, 29 Jul 1861
Allis, Aug. G. S.
Avery, A. **
Bainbridge, Charles *
Butler, Eben *
Chase, V. B. *
Childs, O. C. **
Didama, Dr. Henry D. *
Edwards, Thomas C. *
Fisher, Anson *
Fitch, Charles E. *
Franklin, J. B. *
Gifford, Harry **
Grant, Stephen *
Green, Benjamin Franklin *
Green, George *
Greene, H. F.
Grumbach, Nicholas *
Hodgeman, Henry **
Howard, George *
Lewis, George *
Lilly, William C. **
Loomis, I. O.
Miller, Joseph Y. *
Peter Smith, Peter Jr. *
48

Sherwood, John F. *
Sixbury, Charles *
Smith, Alfred
Stoutenger, B. *
Summers, Moses *
Tremain, Richard
Van Volkenberg, D. A. *
Wheeler, Park
Willard, James L. *
* Originally member of Syracuse Lodge No. 102.
** Originally member of Central City Lodge N o. 305.
Biographies, for the names in Bold are given below.
The following endorsement was forwarded with the above petition. Endorsed
At a regular meeting of Central City Lodge No. 305, held at Masonic Hall in Syracuse Tuesday evening, 20 Aug 1861, the following
resolution was unanimously adopted:
Resolved, That the petition presented by B. F. Green and others for the recommendation of this Lodge to the Grand Master for
the formation of a Lodge to be located in the First Ward of the City of Syracuse, be granted on condition that such lodge shall be
permanently located in the said first ward of this city. Edgar S. Mathews, Sec. pro tem; Orrin Welch, WM
EARLY STATISTICS
Petition: 19 Jul 1861
Endorsement: from Central City Lodge No. 305 to Grand Master: 20Aug 1861
Dispensation: granted and first meeting U.D, 17 Sep 1861
Charter: 10 Jun 1862
First meeting: under charter, 16 Jun 1862
OFFICERS OF THE LODGE ON 17 SEP 1861
Master:
Senior Warden:
Junior Warden:
Treasurer:
Secretary:
John F. Sherwood
Henry F. Green
Peter Smith, Jr.
Benjamin F. Green
Thomas C. Edwards
Senior Deacon: George Green
Junior Deacon: O. C. Childs
Senior Master of Ceremonies: Harry Gifford
Junior Master of Ceremonies: Park Wheeler
Tyler:
Nicholas Grumbach
CHARTER MEMBERS
Name Lodge Age Nativity Occupation Deceased
Charles Bainbridge 102 36 Bedfordshire, Eng. Gardener 19 May 1893
Thomas C. Edwards 102 37 Fayetteville, NY Merchant -
Benjamin F. Green 102 44 Cheshire, MA Engineer 17 Oct 1863
327
George Green 102 33 Herkimer, NY Engineer
Henry F. Green - - - Surveyor
Nicholas Grumbach 102 26 Detroit, MI Tobacconist 05 Jul 1912
John F. Sherwood 102 23 - Saddler -
Peter Smith, Jr. 102 39 Warren, NY Fruit dealer 06 Mar 1893
Moses Summers 102 41 Wexford, Ireland Editor 15 Jun 1882
Richard Tremain - 27 - Machinist 11 Jun 1892
CHARLES BAINBRIDGE was born in Bedfordshire, England, and migrated to Syracuse when he was nine years old. He resided in
the First Ward throughout his 'life, being employed as a gardener. As one of the first members of Plymouth Congregational Church,
he worked industriously and enthusiastically. He was raised in Syracuse Lodge No. 102 in 1853, then a charter member of our
lodge, demitting on 1 Sep 1862, and finally affiliating with Syracuse Lodge No. 501 on 16 Oct 1867. He retained active membership
until his death at 68 on 19 May 1893.
DR. HENRY D. DIDAMA appeared on various committees, and he served as Chaplain in 1864.
THOMAS C. EDWARDS transferred his membership from Syracuse Lodge No. 102 to become a charter member of our lodge in
1861. The minutes written during the years of his secretaryship in 1861, 1862, and 1867 were executed in a very clear and concise
manner, truly a delight and privilege to read during these days of penmanship debauchery. Edwards also served as Master from
1864 through 1866 and again in 1868. Service as a trustee occupied his years in the lodge from 1862 through 1866 and 1868 and
1869. The minutes then indicated he was dropped on 28 April 1873. The signatures on the constitution and by-laws of Syracuse
Chapter No. 70 (previously Salina and later Central City), revived on 1849, included Thomas C. Edwards. He served as Scribe of
this chapter in 1851 and was one of the chapter representatives to Grand Chapter at the Annual Convocations held in Albany on 5
Feb 5, 1850, and 1 Feb 1851.
BENJAMIN FRANKLIN GREEN, one of the oldest settlers in the First Ward, was universally respected for his active social and
political participation in the community. He was a civil engineer by profession and served as City Surveyor for many years (1848,
1851 through 1853, 1856, and 1862) before his death on 17 Oct 1863, in his 64th year. Masonically, he had held membership in
Salina Lodge No. 327 and in Syracuse Lodge No. 102 prior to becoming one of our charter members. He was Trustee in 1861 and
Treasurer in 1861 and 1862. In the higher Masonic bodies he was one of those who signed a petition dated 6 Feb 1849, from Salina
Chapter No. 70 praying that the chapter be revived by the name of Syracuse (now Central City) Chapter No. 70, which he then
served as King. Bro. Green was also a member of Central City Commandery No. 25.
GEORGE GREEN. Diligent search has disclosed few items in Bro. Green's life. He served as JW in 1861 and was appointed on the
Committee of Instruction on January 4, 1864, before being dropped on May 16, 1864. Green had been exalted in Syracuse (now
Central City) Chapter No. 70 on August 5, 1859, and was suspended on May 14, 1869. He was also on the roster of Central City
Commandery No. 25.
49

HENRY F. GREEN served as SW 1861 through 1863 and demitted on 3 Apr 1865. Nothing is known of his life other than he worked
as a surveyor. The charges he brought against Peter Smith, Jr., on 27 Oct 1862, and 17 Nov 1862, were discussed elsewhere. Also
on 21 Nov 1864, the minutes indicate that all were in favor of moving the lodge from the First Ward to the Central portion of the city
except Green.
JOHN F. SHERWOOD was raised in Syracuse Lodge No. 102 on 5 Jun 1856, prior to becoming one of our charter members. He
served as Master from 1861-1863 and demitted on 23 May 1870. He was also exalted in Salina (now Central City) Chapter No. 70,
RAM, on 5 Aug 1859 and suspended on 24 Nov 1871. He was greeted in Central City Council No. 13, R&AM, on 5 Dec 1859.
PETER SMITH, JR. was born in Warren, NY, and spent his life in Syracuse working as a fruit dealer. He served as our first JW, both
under dispensation (U.D.) and charter, and as SD in 1863. The following paragraphs appearing in the minutes are self-explanatory,
but other details are not given:
27 Oct 1862. SW Brother Henry F. Green preferred charges against Brother Peter Smith, Jr., JW, for unmasonic conduct. The
WM appointed the following brothers as a commission on the trial: PM Thomas C. Edwards, H. D. Didama, John Barney, A. S.
Allis, and Eben Butler.
17 Nov 1862. The Commission on the charges advanced by Brother Henry F. Green, SW, against Brother Peter Smith, JW,
presented their report with the following resolution: Resolved: That Brother Peter Smith, Jr., JW, be hereby declared
suspended from membership in Salt Springs Lodge No. 520 for the space of six months from 17 Nov 1862, A.L. 5862. The
report of this resolution was then unanimously adopted by the lodge.
Bro. Smith’s name then reappears in the minutes of 28 Sep, 5 Oct and 28 Dec 1862; he is listed as JW on 21 Dec 1863, SW on 4
Jan 1864, and member of the Committee on Instructions. He was made an honorary member on 15 Oct 1889 and died in Syracuse
at age 70 on 3 Mar 1893. He was exalted on 14 Jan 1859, afterwards demitting 25 Dec 1863, as a member of Central City Chapter
No. 70, RAM, and he was greeted in Central City Council No. 13, R&SM, on 4 Nov 1859.
Only one other event in his life is known, and this is in connection with the Greenway Barbeque. Bro. Smith was one of the fifty
most prominent Syracusans selected as a waiter for this memorable occasion, which is recorded in further detail below.
RICHARD TREMAIN served as Junior Deacon in 1863 and was dropped from membership 20 Dec 1886. He was well-known in
railroad and political circles. Employment by the New York Central Railroad and West Shore Company as a master mechanic
occupied the majority of his working years. In 1881 and 1882 he was Alderman of the Fifth Ward in the Common Council, and in
1889 was Assistant Superintendent of Streets. The family moved to New York City in 1890 after his government appointment as
Inspector of Boilers in New York Harbor, where he died on 11 Jun 1892 of cardiovascular disease.
Biographical sketches of the remaining two charter members, Nicholas Grumbach and Moses Summers, are included in the section
on “The War of the Rebellion.”
Greenway Barbeque
Above it is noted that Bro. Peter Smith, Jr., was a waiter at the Greenway Barbeque. In Dr. Peacher’s “Centennial History of Salt
Springs Lodge No. 520,” he devotes page 21 to recording a sketch of this interesting event. What he does not record is that John
Greenway was a member of Syracuse Lodge No. 501, but I will record this story here, as Dr. Peacher did, with some added material
on Bro. Greenway and this event:
JOHN GREENWAY was born 6 Jan 1821 in Brailes, Warwickshire, England, died 28 May 1887 in Syracuse.
He was Raised in Syracuse Lodge No. 501 on 15 May 1871 as member number 347.
John Greenway Presents his Compliments with many a Happy New
Year and requests The pleasure of your Company At the Grand
Barbecue, New Years Day 1870
The barbeque was a revival of an ancient English custom by Bro.
Greenway, who had migrated here with his parents in 1837 at age
sixteen in a destitute condition and ultimately amassed a fortune in the
manufacture of beer. The affair was held on 1 Jan 1870 at Clinton
Square for the sole purpose of feeding the poor. Half of the city’s
population of 43,000 thronged to the area, the largest crowd ever to
congregate for an individual enterprise there.
Five thousand loaves of bread were pyramided on a twenty-foot square
raised on the north bank of the Erie canal. The combined weight was
sufficient to compress the bottom layer to the thickness of one inch. Two
old-fashioned Dutch roasting ovens were constructed of sheet steel
flanked with piles of hardwood maple logs. The latter were placed on
iron grates with two monstrous beeves mounted on spits consisting of
heavy rods fourteen feet long. It was in one of the huge pans twelve feet
long placed underneath to catch the drippings that one of the carvers,
George Hancock, fell in, white chef uniform and all, to enliven the
occasion. Fortunately, he was quickly saved by his companion carvers,
obviating “Hancock au jus” being served to the hungry Syracusans
waiting behind the fenced-in area to protect the workers. No serious illness in the populace was reported from the use of this broth,
sanitation not being highly regarded in these days. (There is a George C. Hancock on the register of Syracuse Lodge No. 501, born
14 Jun 1835, Barnstable, England; died 6 Jan 1890, a cigar maker, who was raised on 9 Dec 1963, member no. 108).
50

Everyone received a wooden tray with a delicious roast beef sandwich drenched with tasty drippings. Twelve steaming plum
puddings weighing 200 pounds each, made at the nearby brewery, were served for dessert. They were dramatically delivered on
one of Greenway’s sleighs by twelve gaily caparisoned percherons, each with a uniformed attendant. The event took from 10:30
a.m. until 2:00 p.m., with the remains being distributed to local charitable institutions and to the needy unable to attend.
“The Syracuse Sunday Times” of 9 Feb 1896 recounted this event in a lengthy article which is appended to this present work.
Greenway Barbeque at Clinton Plaza – New Years Day 1870
in front of the Empire House
Dr. Henry Darwin Didama was born in Perryville, Madison Co., NY, on 17 Jun 1823. His father,
Dr. John Didama, and his grandfather, Dr. Simon Didama, were natives of Holland. His mother,
Lucinda Gaylord Didama, was born in Connecticut.
With the highest respect for other and less favored people, Dr. Didama regarded the commingling
of Holland Dutch and Connecticut Yankee blood as constituting the best stock which had been or
was likely to be invented. Dr. Didama inherited that excellent legacy, a sound constitution and a
trend towards longevity; his parents each reaching the advanced are of 83 years. He was
fortunate though to have a District School education at a time when more attention was paid to
such fundamental branches as spelling, writing, grammar and arithmetic, than to chemistry,
music, philosophy and German in four weeks.
Dr. Didama’s academic training was obtained during three years’ attendance at Cazenovia
Seminary. He entered in 1842 the office of the accomplished scholar, Dr. David A. Moore, whose
unwavering friendship he enjoyed for many years. Dr. Didama continued his medical studies
under the esteemed Dr. Nelson C. Powers, graduating, after one course of lectures at Geneva,
and two courses at Albany, in 1846. He continued medical practice in Romulus, Seneca County,
where he remained for five years.
In 1848 he married Miss Sarah Miller, of Danby, Tompkins County. He attributed not a little of his success to her industry, prudence
and common sense. He removed to Syracuse in 1851 where, for more than 20 years he practiced in the first ward and then to the
sixth ward in 1874. He found time, usually in the early morning, to consult his books and to keep abreast with the rapid progress of
medical science. He took part in the organization of the Medical College of Syracuse University, and was chosen Professor of the
Principles and Practice of Medicine. He was a somewhat prominent advocate of a graded system of medical education, having
made earnest appeals in this direction in addresses before two State Medical Societies. This system was the one adopted by the
Syracuse Medical College. He received many honors from friends in the profession and out of it, to include:
President, Syracuse Medical Association
President, Onondaga Medical Society
First President, NY Central Medical Association
President, New York State Medical Society
First President, New York State Medical Association
First President, Boerhaarean Medical Society
President. Young Mens’ Christian Association (YMCA)
Vice-President, British Medical Association
Chairman, Medical Section, American Medical Association
Chapter II War of the Rebellion
Philip Eckel (aka Phillip, or Philipp Eckle)
First Lieutenant in Company B of the 149th Regiment; on 4 Oct 1862.
Bro. Philip was born 11 Aug 1827 in St. Julian, Rheinbaiern (in the region of Kusel in today's Rhineland-
Pfalz, Germany), the son of Peter and Elisabeth (Schneider) Eckel, and emigrated with his family in the
summer of 1840. He was proprietor of a restaurant a short time and then became a constable. He joint
51

the Volunteer Fire Department as member of “Empire” Engine Company No. 4 in 1847 with its fire house on Division Street. It was
he who suggested, when the Civil War broke out, that the Syracuse Germans form a military company of volunteers to be led by
fellow immigrant Nicholas Grumbach, and he distinguished himself under Captain Grumbach in the Civil War. In this war he
received a gunshot wound in the arm and was taken prisoner at Chancellorville on 3 May 1863. He was thereafter paroled and sent
to a hospital and received a disability discharge on 21 Dec 1863. He was later brevetted a captain. Following his discharge he
served as Chief of the Syracuse Fire Department from 1864 to 1877, Assistant Chief 1877 to 1881, and again Chief in Oct 1891
when Ira Wood resigned.
It was on 1 Jun 1886, while riding on the side of Central City Hook and Ladder No. 1 enroute to a fire on Chestnut Street (South
Crouse Avenue) that Bro. Eckel was fatally injured. The Standard of 2 Jun 1886 vividly described this accident in a conversation
between C. Albert Sherff and the driver. “My God, Al, there’s the train,” as the wagon bore down the steep descent in Chestnut
Street at a terrific burst of speed onto the New York Central Railroad tracks on East Washington Street. There was only one thing to
do; the driver lashed his horses and the truck crossed the tracks just ahead of the train. Unfortunately, the wagon bounced as it
struck the rails, causing Eckel to either jump or be thrown from the vehicle. He was caught between the wheels of the wagon, but
escaped the train. Eckel was still conscious and bystanders carried him into a nearby barbershop
and summoned a doctor. From there, Eckel was transported by ambulance to his home where
lived only five hours. The fire bell then tolled 58 times, the years of his life. A few days later Eckel’s
body was laid to rest in Woodlawn Cemetery. Thousands of mourners lined the route; over 1,000
firemen comprised the cortege.
Masonic funeral services were held at the grave in Woodlawn Cemetery. The newspapers at that
time state that in the number of organizations and bodies, in the extent and value of floral gifts, it
was the largest and most imposing funeral held in this city. He was eulogized at the church by the
Reverend Jeremiah Zimmerman as representing two heroic characters – that of a fireman and
soldier. Further tribute to the family was given in German by Reverend Dr. Oberlander. He was
married in 1864 to Barbara Eckel (11 May 1837 - 7 Oct 1909). A large monument in his memory
was erected on North Salina Street in 1900.
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/eckel-p-mon.html
This monument was designed by Carrick Brothers, a Vermont-based firm that opened a branch
office in Syracuse in the 1890's. Carved from granite in Vermont, this memorial was funded by
contributions raised by Syracuse firefighters and policemen.
Old photos show this monument in a different location. At its 22 Aug 1900 dedication it was installed at the corner of North Salina,
Butternut, and State Streets, in the midst of Syracuse's north side German community. Later it was moved to the intersection of
North Salina and Pearl Streets. Construction of Interstate 81 forced its final move downtown. The monument was moved to its
present location in Fayette Park at the same time the park was renamed Fayette Firefighters Memorial Park, on 2 May 1979. In the
last few years all of the monuments in this park and the park itself have been restored to a pristine condition that does Syracuse
proud. Fayette Firefighters Memorial Park also contains the 1905 Hamilton White Monument, the Collins Block Fireman's Memorial,
dedicated in 1939, a bell tower (1979) and a restored antique cast-iron fence. The park, a public green area since 1839, is bordered
by Townsend, Fayette, State and Genesee Streets in the city.
http://home.earthlink.net/~dahoude/from_the_archives.htm
PRESENTATION TO LIEUT. ECKLE. The members of Empire Fire Co. No. 4, of which Lieut. Eckle, of Co. B, 149 th regiment, has
been the foreman for many years, have presented their esteemed chief with a sword, sash, belt and other military insignia. The
presentation took place at Camp White, yesterday afternoon, and was attended by Empire Fire Company in full numbers, who
marched to the camp headed by Samsel’s Band, and also by Capt. Grumbach’s full company. The presentation address was made
by L. W. Hall, Esq., in neat and appropriate terms, to which R. H. Gardner, Esq., in behalf of Lieut. Eckle, made a fitting response.
The affair was witnessed by a large gathering of citizens. The compliment to Lieut. Eckle is richly deserved. (SYRACUSE DAILY
JOURNAL 9 Sep 1862)
Nicholas Grumbach, Jr.
Captain of Company B; Major and Lt. Col. of the 149th Regiment
http://www.149th-nysv.org/Roster/Field/grumbach_nicholas_.htm
Nicholas Grumback, Jr., was born 30 Jan 1835 in Detroit, Michigan. His father, Nicholas Grumbach, was
a native of Alsace who came to Syracuse in 1828. His mother, Mrs. Elisabeth Grumbach, and her father,
Christian Rupprecht, also from Alsace, came with other families to America in the year 1831. During their
journey to Buffalo on the Erie Canal the boat froze and a small group decided to remain and live in
Syracuse. In 1831 or 1832 Nicholas Grumbach married Miss Rupprecht and they subsequently moved to
Detroit where Colonel Grumbach was born. Besides him, they had six other children, of whom, however,
three died. Their other children were Mrs. Brucker of Deerfield, Colonel Nicholas Grumbach, George, and
Johann P. Grumbach, all of Syracuse.
It may interest some to know what Syracuse looked like around that time. Most of the buildings were in close proximity to the canals.
From Lodi Street a brook came down known as "Yellow Brook," which water-way went up to Lemon Street then turned south and
southwest into the area of today’s Harrison Street where it turned north, crossing then in the neighborhood of the Farmer-Blocks at
Warren Street and flowed diagonally by Jefferson Street at Salina Street and along the south of Fayette Street into Onondaga
Creek. Only in the year 1838 was this brook completely filled in.
Between Chestnut Street and Fayette Park there were neither houses nor improvements nor arable country. North of the (Genesee)
turnpike, the trees had been felled to provide firewood for the salt-settlers, but the stumps still stood. On the south side of the great
swamps, trees and brush yet remained as a great wilderness. The swamp was still not passable by wagon. On the west side of
52

Salina Street, south of the "Yellow Brook," there were no buildings, and on the east side was the last of the only four plots south of
Fayette Street. Where the "Yellow Brook" crossed Salina Street was a deep ravine, and in 1824 Salina Street was still about six feet
higher than now, and very uneven and hilly.
The area which today Onondaga Street cuts through was at that time a swampy cedar forest. The area between Salina,
Washington, Warren, and Fayette Streets was in 1824 still completely empty, excepting some trees. In 1825 the Presbyterians
erected a church where stood McCarthy’s building. Where the Onondaga County Savings Bank building stands now was at that time
the location of the later "Syracuse House," and in the place of the Wieting Block there was a two-story building. Between Salina,
East Fayette, Warren, and Jefferson Streets stood a few shacks. The main part of the village lay between Washington, Montgomery,
Fayette, and Warren Streets. North of the canal up to the village of Salina was uninhabited and usually wooded.
Nicholas moved back to Syracuse with his parents on 15 May 1838. His education was obtained in the public schools and as a boy
he engaged in various pursuits. Sperry and Hier employed him as a cigar maker from 1854 until 1856. At that time he formed a
partnership with Gustavus Sniper (Grumbach and Sniper), engaging in the manufacture of cigars. Grumbach also became a
member of the old Syracuse Grays in 1856 and was later Captain of Company F, Monroe Cadets, New York State Militia. He was
serving in his second term as supervisor of the Second Ward when he was mustered into the United States Service on 18 Sep 1862
at Syracuse, N.Y., September 18, 1862, at the age of 27 under a commission as Captain of Company B dated 4 Oct 1862, rank 2
Sep 1862. The 150 men of his company were personally recruited by their commanding Officer. He was mustered as Major of the
regiment 23 Aug 1964, under a commission dated 2 Aug 1864, rank 3 Jul 1864, and mustered as Lieutenant Colonel of the regiment
at Bladensburg, Maryland, about 11 May 1865, under a commission dated and rank that day. He also received a commission as
Colonel dated 7 Jun 1865 with rank the same day, but was not mustered.
He was married on 14 September 1862 to Miss Emilie Steiger of Syracuse and had four children. (Geschichte der Deutschen in
Syracuse und Onondaga County Nebst Kurzen Biographien von Beamten und Hervorragenden Buergern – 1897; History of the
German People in Syracuse and Onondaga County with short biographies of officials and prominent citizens. Author: Syracuse
Union, published at Syracuse, NY, 1897; 304 pages, paperback, illustrations).
At that time Colonel Nicholas Grumbach was Supervisor of the Second Ward, member of the city’s war committee, and captain of
the Monroe Cadets. The war situation was discussed among all classes of the population at that time, especially the so-called
"drafts" which here and there (but not in Syracuse) were necessary to fulfill the required numbers of troops. So too among the
Germans this question prompted lively discussion, and everywhere loud voices proclaimed themselves ready to enter into the
service if they only had a leader. On the evening of 27 August 1862 a large number of such men were gathered at the Centre House
and Philip Eckel, the fire chief, made the motion that a German company be formed and that Nicholas Grumbach be captain of it.
This suggestion was taken up with jubilation and next Philip Eckel and Jakob Knapp (of Syracuse Lodge No. 501, see biography
below) were chosen as first and second lieutenants. Hereupon they all proceeded to Jakob Kohl’s shop and when Grumbach came
in soon after, he was hailed on all sides as "Captain." When someone told him what was going on, he explained that he could not go
in on that, because he had promised his business partner (General Sniper) to take care of the business while Sniper was in the field.
Besides, he was afraid that those in the throes of their first enthusiasm who had declared themselves ready for soldiering would
regret their decisions by the next morning, however provisionally he consented to wanting to be their captain. When he left that
evening Mr. Grumbach expected that nothing would come of it by the next morning. He was surprised, therefore, to find a large tent
ready in the open lot at Salina Street and Prospect Avenue and a crowd of volunteers ready to make good on their promises. The
matter became serious and the recruitment began. The senate war committee gave its consent and by midday on 28 Aug 1862 40
men were already enlisted. At the empty corner of Ash, Salina and Prospect Avenue a grandstand was set up where, in the evening,
speeches were to be given. The evening came; Samsel’s Band played patriotic tunes and Georg Saul delivered an inspirational
address. Then volunteers were asked to step forward and report. If a pause occurred, the chairman continued, one of the many
German women offered the next volunteer so many pairs of socks, or another ten dollars, and so on. Over four days 115 men were
registered, mostly from the second and fourth wards. But all of them did not end up going, as some of them had parents who
protested; others were married and their wives vetoed the deal. As noted above, Captain Grumbach was married on 14 Sep 1862
and went to Watertown on his honeymoon but returned immediately upon hearing that three of his recruits would evaporate. On 18
Sep 1862 this German Company B, with about 100 men including the officers, was mustered into Union service and posted at Camp
White until 23 September when the regiment went to Washington.
During the war they took part in the following battles: Chancellorsville, Gettysburg, Wauhatchie, Lookout Mountain, Ringgold,
Resaca, New Hope Church, Lost Mountain, Pine Knob, Kennesaw Mountain, Peach Tree Creek and the siege of Savannah; and
they were present at the battles of Missionary Ridge, Rocky Face Ridge, Averasboro, Bentonville and The Carolinas. In total they
lost 133 dead and 353 wounded.
Col. Grumbach, while captain, was for a long time acting field officer of the regiment, and as such was on several occasions in
temporary command of the regiment; notably at the battle of Gettysburg after Col. Randall was wounded. Col. Barnum (Henry A.
Barnum of Central City Lodge No. 305) being called to the command of the brigade by the death of Col. Ireland on 10 Sep 1864, at
Atlanta, GA, Col. Grumbach as Major assumed command of the regiment on that day, and so continued until after the arrival of the
regiment at Savannah, GA. Before the regiment left Savanna, he received a leave of absence and went home. He rejoined the
regiment at Goldsboro, NC about 1 Apr 1864 and from thence continued command of until the regiment was disbanded at Syracuse.
http://209.85.165.104/search?q=cache:RoTpivzDv7cJ:www.navarrocollege.edu/library/civilwar/abstracts/e_h.htm+%22gustavu
s+sniper%22&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=20&gl=us
Grumbach (Nicholas) Papers, 1864
This Union army officer describes how his men are the first to enter Savannah, posting flags throughout the city so that the
remainder of the Union forces could see them as they entered the city. Grumbach, a colonel of the 149th New York Volunteer
Infantry, writes a four page letter, quarto, dated December 25th, 1864 from "Corner west road and Zulbey, Savannah, Ga." He
writes the letter to Colonel Gustavus Sniper of the 185th New York Infantry.
The regiment was mustered out on 12 Jun 1865, and the welcome accorded it on its return to Syracuse was overwhelming. The
entire populace turned out “en masse” to demonstrate and voice their joy in the return of their loved ones. Amidst round after round
53

of cheers, the constant fluttering of handkerchiefs, and the repeated tolling of the City Hall bell, the men paraded through South
Salina, James and East Genesee Streets under the command of Colonel Grumbach. Every soldier was garlanded with flowers and
each rifle decorated with a bouquet in its muzzle. The stirring scene of the infantry striding forward to the playing of “When Johnny
Comes Marching Home” by Gehm’s band, alternating with the rolling cadence of Martin’s Drum Corps with the regimental and
captured rebel standards waving in the breeze was long to be remembered.
At the close of the war Col. Grumbach received a Brevet commission as Colonel of U.S. Volunteers, dated 22 Mar 1866, rank 13
Mar 1865 for "faithful and meritorious services since September 1862, and particularly during the campaigns of Atlanta and
Georgia."
In the post-bellum period, Grumback engaged in the manufacture of glue with Paul Birchmier until their business burned out two
years later. He then became United States Cigar Stamper until the office was abolished five months thereafter. Real estate,
insurance, and the restaurant business then became his chief livelihood. He was and active Republican and served as Alderman of
the Fourth Ward, 1868-1869; Excise Commissioner, Janitor of the United States Government Building, and Court Crier.
His fraternal relations included:
Syracuse Lodge No. 102; Petitioner and Charter Member Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, F&AM, 1861.
International Order of Odd Fellows (I.O.O.F.)
Ancient Order of United Workmen (A.O.U.W.); see for more on them, including a Masonic-like ritual, at:
http://www.phoenixmasonry.org/masonicmuseum/fraternalism/aouw.htm
County Treasurer, Onondaga County in 1896
He was the organizer and first quartermaster of Lilly Post, G.A.R.
He lived a long and useful life as a citizen, soldier, politician and business man. At his death on 5 Jul 1912 he was the last living
charter member of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520. He resided at 1210 Lodi Avenue, Syracuse
http://home.earthlink.net/~dahoude/from_the_archives.htm
A PATRIOTIC FIRE COMPANY. A meeting of Empire Company No. IV, from the Second Ward, was held last evening at their
Engine House, to consider measures for the promotion of a company from that Ward under the Recruiting Officers, Nicholas
Grumbach, Phillip Eckel, and Jacob Knapp. On motion of a member, Resolved, That the Empire Company No. IV give one
hundred dollars to the above officers for extra bounty to volunteers. Resolved, That the Secretary shall write an order for the above
amount. Resolved, That these proceedings be published in all our city daily papers. MICHAEL SPRISSER, JOHN A. ECKEL,
JACOB BLIND, - Committee. (Syracuse Daily Courier and Union 30 Aug 1862)
THE 2D WARD COMPANY COMPLETE. THE BEST WORK YET. The German Company of the 2d ward, under Capt. Grumbach
and Lieuts. Eckle and Knapp, is far above the maximum number. On Saturday evening the company numbered fifty-one men. Fiftyfour
men were enlisted yesterday, being, we believe, the best day’s recruiting for one company ever done in this State. The people
of the second ward yesterday did nothing but recruit. They entered into the business with a real German enthusiasm - the women,
wives, mothers and daughters urging and encouraging enlistments, and the result is this glorious success, the first full company for
the Fourth regiment. The company marched in a body this morning to the office of Justice Hurst, where the oath was administered
to those not already sworn in. A few of them are now in the surgeon’s hands. The company will muster in as soon as possible,
probably to-day. - Standard. (Syracuse Daily Courier and Union 2 Sep 1862)
PRESENTATION TO CAPT. GRUMBACH
http://home.earthlink.net/~dahoude/archives_page_2.htm
On Saturday evening Capt. Nicholas Grumbach was made the recipient of a sword, sash and belt, a
present from his fellow members of the Board of Supervisors. The presentation took place at the Mayor’s
room in the City Hall, and was attended by the members of the Board residing in the city, a number of
Capt. Grumbach’s company and several citizens. Jason S. Hoyt, Esq. was called to preside, and after a
few remarks introduced Peter Burns, Esq. who in behalf of the Supervisors presented Capt. Grumbach
with the above named articles, in a neat and appropriate speech. He regretted the necessity which called
for such an occasion, and thought the conduct of Capt. Grumbach, who at no inconsiderable sacrifice had
enlisted in the service of his country, was worthy of all praise. He referred to the high esteem in which the
Captain was held by his associates in the Board, and expressed a wish that he might return from the war
in safety and with honor. Capt. Grumbach replied feelingly, and thanked the Supervisors for the
testimonial they had conferred upon him. His associations with the members of the Board of Supervisors
were of the most friendly character, but he had had no expectation of being so kindly remembered. He
would look back on this occasion as one of the proudest in his life, and should ever cherish as sacred the
gifts with which he was presented. Short addresses were made by P. Corbett, Wm. Baumgras and
James Bonner, Esqs.- The party then adjourned to the Plymouth Rock, where the very pleasant meeting
was concluded with refreshments. (Syracuse Daily Courier and Union, 22 Sep 1862)
PRESENTS TO OFFICERS - The officers of no regiment were ever better provided with serviceable testimonials of the esteem and
regard of their friends, than are those of the 149th. Nearly all the field, staff and line officers, and many of the non-commissioned
officers, have been the recipients of presents of weapons or other useful gifts. On Saturday evening, Lieutenant-Colonel Strong was
presented with a fine horse, valued at $200, by his friends in Onondaga,- the ceremony taking place at Col. Eaton’s hotel at
Onondaga Hill; P.H. Gardner, Esq., making the address in behalf of the donors, and the Lieutenant Colonel responding. These
addresses were both good, and several other gentlemen also made pertinent remarks. Quartermaster Summers (see below) was
this forenoon presented with a fine horse, valued at $170, by some of his personal friends. The ceremony was brief and interesting.
Mr. Samuel Rooney made the presentation, and Lieut. Summers responded. Capt. James Lynch has been presented with a sword
by Mr. M.E. Lynch, and Lieut. E.D. Murray with a sword by Judge Pratt. Capt. Grumbach has received a sword from members of
the Board of Supervisors. A splendid sword is to be given to Col. Barnum, and Major Cook has already received one. The late
54

employees of Capt. Wilkinson, on the Syracuse and Utica section of the Central road, have had prepared an elaborately finished
sword, which will be formally presented to him before he joins the regiment. (SYRACUSE DAILY JOURNAL 22 Sep 1862)
William C. Lilly
149th Regiment, New York State Volunteers
Relief from the monument to the 149th New York on Culp's Hill.
This relief memorializes the actions of the 149th's Color Sergeant William C. Lilly
who, under enemy fire, took the time to repair the broken flag staff of their regimental colors.
Gettysburg National Military Park, Pennsylvania
Color Sergeant William C. Lilly on the Soldiers & Sailors Monument at Clinton
Square, Syracuse, Post-Standard c. December 18, 1978
Not a Medal of Honor recipient, but a hero nonetheless, was Color Sergeant William
C. Lilly. Sgt. Lilly's image and act of bravery are forever captured on the bronze relief
sculpture affixed to the monument to the 149th New York on Culp's Hill at Gettysburg
National Military Park. The image depicts Sgt. Lilly mending the broken flag staff of the
regimental colors with leather from his knapsack and wood slats from a cracker box.
This he done after climbing over the breastworks exposing himself to a torrent of
enemy fire to retrieve the broken staff and colors after a bullet hit the staff and
effectively cut it in two. This heroic event was also immortalized in a bronze sculpture
on the Soldiers & Sailors Monument at Clinton Square in Downtown Syracuse. The colors would receive eighty or more holes during
that battle at Gettysburg at Culp's Hill on July 2nd, 1863. Sergeant Lilly survived the battle at Gettysburg, but would be mortally
wounded later at Wauhatchie in Tennessee. Sergeant Lilly is buried in the Civil war section of Woodlawn Cemetery in Syracuse,
New York. Sergeant Lilly was posthumously awarded New York State's highest honor, the Conspicuous Service Cross
Different view of the above photo
55

This statute is located at the Lilly Post GAR section of the Woodlawn Cemetery in Syracuse, New York.
It is the final resting place of Sergeant William C. Lilly, as well as other members of the 149th NYSV.
http://home.earthlink.net/~dahoude/woodlawn.htm
William C. Lilly
Color Sergeant, Co. D
http://www.149th-nysv.org/Roster/Co_D/lilly_william.htm
William Lilly enlisted August 21, 1862 at the age of 33. Promoted from corporal
to sergeant March 18, 1863. He was wounded slightly at Chancellorsville, VA.,
3 May 1863, and in the shoulder slightly at Gettysburg, PA., 3 Jul 1863. He
was wounded severely in the thigh at Wauhatchie, TN., 28 Oct 1863, and died
of wounds at Bridgeport, Alabama, November 1, 1863.
As an example of the courage of Sgt. Lilly and his valor on the field of battle,
reference is made to the picture of Forbes, in the Gettysburg chapter, where he
is depicted in the act of mending the flag under fire after the staff had been cut
in twain by Confederate bullet, and it is fitting that such an incident should be
cast in bronze, which has been done, and placed on the memorial monument at Culp's Hill where the
incident occurred. On 3 Jul 88 bullets pieced their National Color, and the staff was finally severed.
William C. Lilly climbed over the ramparts notwithstanding the deadly gunshot and shell fire, retrieved the flag, then knelt and
repaired the wooden shaft with splints from a cracker box and straps from a knapsack. Lilly was a member of Central City Lodge No.
305, was Raised 6 Nov 1858, and was one of the original petitioners to the Grand Lodge of the State of New York for the
dispensation for Salt Springs Lodge No. 520 on 28 Jul 1861. The Freemasons of Syracuse generously contributed the necessary
funds for Colonel Henry A. Barnum (a member of Central City Lodge No. 305) to arrange for his remains to be returned to
Syracuse. He was accompanied by the regimental standard which he loved so well and faithfully carried during his period of service.
It is apparent that Lilly’s army service ending in death obliviated his return to civilian life and continuing Masonic career in Salt
Springs Lodge. Post No. 77, Grand Army of the Republic was named in his honor. The National Colors and the Regimental Banner
of both the 149th and !85th Regiments are on display in the County Clerk’s Office at the Onondaga County Court House.
But that the pre-eminent goodness of the man may be known, as well as his great courage and valor, the following, contributed by
Major O. L. F. Browne, an eye-witness of the incident, is related:
Just after the battle of Wauhatchie, where Lilly was mortally wounded, he was transferred, in a cold driving rain-storm, from an open
field hospital to an ambulance for transportation to the rear. In the same vehicle was a desperately wounded Confederate soldier,
half naked and shivering cold. Poor Lilly, although suffering from pain and chilled from loss of blood, observed his fellow traveler,
and being moved with compassion, remarked, "My friend, I guess I will have to share my blanket with you," and suiting the action to
the word, withdrew a part of the covering his friend had tenderly placed about him and wrapped it around his pristine foe.
Mending the Flag
Edwin Forbes (1839-1895), a well-known artist during the Civil War period, executed in oil a battle scene of the 149th Regiment at
Culp’s Hill including Lilly’s heroic deed, for reproduction on a bronze tablet. This was placed on the memorial to the 149th Regiment
which was erected in 1891 and now reposes on Culp’s Hill in Gettysburg, PA. This same painting may also be observed in bronze
on the Soldier’s Monument at Clinton Square. Beneath it appears the words: “This Memorial erected by the grateful people of
Onondaga, in appreciation of the glorious achievements of the men who volunteered their services in defense of the flag and for the
preservation of the Nation, 1861-1865. May their example speak to coming generations.”
Many other engraving of Edwin Forbes may be viewed at: http://www.pddoc.com/reflets/forbes_image_index_01.htm
56

William Lilly Day - 2 May 1999
The Onondaga County Civil War Round Table organized Sgt. William C. Lilly Day. They discovered that when the members of the
GAR post named for Sgt. Lilly moved his body from where it was buried in Oakwood Cemetery to the area of Woodlawn Cemetery
dedicated for the use of their post, none of his comrades or family were present. This oversight was caused when Nicholas
Grumbach, responsible for the notification of the members, was taken quite ill.
Wanting to put this right, the OCCWRT planned an event that did much more than that. They had present a Brigadier General, the
current Commander of the New York Air National Guard, a state assemblyman, and an assistant to the head of New York Veteran
Affairs. Together, they present Sgt. Lilly and five other servicemen from World War II and Korea (three of whom were there) with the
Conspicuous Service Cross, the highest military award from the state. Sgt. Lilly was the first Civil War veteran to receive this award.
There was a fife and drum corps there in Civil War uniform, a Civil War Honor Guard to give a 21 Gun Salute, and a bugler from the
Army to top it all off by playing taps.
The LILLY POST Monument
Civil War memorial erected in 1887 by the Lilly Post of the G.A.R. (Grand Army of the Republic)
Woodlawn Cemetery, Syracuse, New York
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/lillypost-mon.html
Photos by M. Stone 2004
Atop a hill in Woodlawn Cemetery the memorial erected to Civil War veterans by the Lilly Post No. 66, G.A.R. was erected in 1887.
There are veterans' grave markers on this hill surrounding the monument in concentric circles.
Moses Summers
Quartermaster
http://www.149th-nysv.org/Roster/Field/summers_moses.htm
Moses Summers was born in Wexford, Ireland, on 1 Jan 1820, migrating to New York State with his
parents in infancy. His father worked as a stone mason during the construction of the Erie Canal, the
family residing variously at Utica, Rochester, Lockport, and Buffalo. Following completion of the canal, the
Summers settled in Oswego where Moses received his preliminary education. After the death of his father
from cholera in 1832, he became an apprentice printer to Richard Oliphant, publisher of the “Free Press.”
He concluded his services as a journeyman printer with John Carpenter, who published the Oswego
“Palladium.” Bro. Summers then moved to Syracuse in 1841, entering the office of he Onondaga Standard
with A. L. Smith and Marcellus Farmer, later becoming foreman. He was present at the gunpowder
explosion in Syracuse on 20 Aug 1841, and was a member of the rescue squad.
Summers bought Smith’s interest in the newspaper in 1848 and formed a partnership, Agan and Summers, with the editor, Patrick
H. Agan, a fearless and independent writer. The Standard had absorbed the Syracuse Reveille in 1850. In the ante-bellum period,
Summers had been an active abolitionist and was one of the prime instigators of the widely publicized “Jerry Rescue” slave case in
Syracuse on 3 Oct 1851. He was prosecuted with other participants by the United States authorities for the alleged offense, but the
case was abandoned after several years of litigation:
http://docsouth.unc.edu/neh/loguen/loguen.html
“Instead of taking Jerry out of the city, the rescuers took him to the densest part of it, and set him down at the front door of the
Syracuse House, in Salina Street, where the Judges of the Supreme Court and its officers, surrounded by fastidious politicians,
were huddled together to look at him. Though it is impossible to name all the persons who took part in carrying Jerry in this
imperial procession, special notice is due one of them.
When Jerry came down the steps, his head and one of his shoulders were delivered to Moses Summers, one of the
editors of the Daily Standard, then the democratic organ of the city. Mr. Summers did not quit that position, but as after stated,
until Jerry entered the carriage that took him off. As the procession was passing the Townsend Block, it was assaulted by B. L.
Higgins, one of the democratic Aldermen of the city, at the point where Summers was engaged. Summers instantly quit his
hold, and laid the officious Alderman in the gutter, and again took his position. Higgins got up out of the dirt, and followed by
57

the side of the procession, and again stepped in front of it and commanded the liberators to lay Jerry down and obey the laws.
Full of the spirit of the occasion, Summers gave his place to Peter Reed, a colored man, and turned upon the meddling
Alderman and knocked him down. This quieted the officious Alderman, and Summers returned to his place again.”
--------
“From the door of the Syracuse House Jerry was taken and deposited at the Rail Road Depot -- but the mass was so dense
that the carriages to take him off could not come to him -- and still the tumult was so great that but few knew where Jerry was.
When in prison, it was an object to collect the people--now it was important to disperse them, that he might find a place,
unknown to his enemies, where his chains could be broken, and he could refresh his bruised and broken body with food,
medicine and slumber. Several rescuers now ran in opposite directions through the crowd, crying "Fire! fire! Fire!" This was a
successful ruse de guerre. The masses, wild with excitement, ran every way, crying "Fire! fire! fire!" -- some, doubtless,
scenting the stratagem, and others falling into it.
In a short time Jerry was left alone with James Davis, Jason S. Hoyt, Moses Summers, and a few other brave and stalwart
men, who lifted him, groaning with pain into a carriage, and he was taken, by a circuitous route, to a colored man's house in the
eastern part of the city. A proposition to call at Doct. Hoyt's office. and have his wounds dressed, was overruled in regard to
prudence. As the carriage rolled away, the Liberators sent up a "Hurrah!" at the top of their voices, which drew up the
sympathizing voices of thousands in all directions, and the heavens vibrated with delight.
Without delay, Jason S. Hoyt brought his cutting bar -- a powerful instrument -- and cut Jerry's shackles apart, leaving
each of his limbs free, but bruised and bleeding, and encumbered by the dissevered irons. Not daring to leave Jerry with the
colored man, he was disguised in female attire, and led from house to house among the colored people, who were willing to
receive him, but who, nevertheless, those who had him in charge, to wit, Jason S. Hoyt, James Davis, &c., feared to trust,
because of a possible lack of prudence or discretion. Therefore they led him to the house of Caleb Davis, on Genesee Street --
a man whose heart was big with the love of liberty, and whose mind they knew to be charged with qualities fitting their
purpose. * ”
-----------
Quartermaster Moses Summers was mustered into service at Albany, NY on 28 Aug 1862, under a commission as Quartermaster
dated 18 Apr 1862, rank 28 Aug 1862. He enlisted in the 149th Regiment, New York State Volunteers, in Aug 1862, and began
active duty 18 Sep 1862 as Lieutenant and Quartermaster under Colonel Henry A. Barnum. He was detached for duty as A. A. Q.
M. on the staff of Colonel Ireland, command the 3rd Brigade at Stevenson, Alabama, 22 Apr 1864. He was subsequently
discharged 1 Jul 1864 to accept a commission as Captain and A. A. Q. M. of US Volunteers in the same staff. Captain Summers,
from the time of his appointment on the staff of Colonel Ireland, continued to serve at Brigade H.Q. until the close of the war. He
also acted as scribe throughout the various fortunes of the regiment until it was mustered out of service 12 Jun 1865. He reported
regularly to his newspaper, “The Standard,” under the caption, “The Sword and the Pen.” Following his pithy messages, the notes
were signed: “Yours for the Union, and against secession,” or “Yours for the Union and against traitors wherever they are,” etc.
Many interesting and amusing anecdotes have survived, such as speaking of the first night in Virginia he said, “That was the
dreariest night I ever experienced, and I never or expect to see another.” The old saying, “misery loves company” was certainly true
the same night on bivouac. Lieutenant Collins was purloined of his valise by itinerant nocturnal predators. Lieutenant Summers,
Wheeler, Westcott, and Stevens were simultaneously relieved by the visiting Washington “gentlemen.” But all things have their
compensation. “Thing of those new boots, what pain and suffering they were saved by their loss.”
He was an intelligent and efficient officer, and performed the duties assigned to him in a creditable manner.
Bro. Sommers fought with the men at Lookout Mountain, 14 Nov 1863; Missionary Ridge, 25 Nov 1863; and Ringgold, 27 Nov 1863.
During Sherman’s Campaign in Georgia, 2 May to 13 Dec 1864, he was commissioned a Captain, his unit being attached to the 2nd
Brigade of the 20th Corps. Summers was among the first of the troops of Sherman’s Corps on its famous “March to the Sea” to
enter Savannah. By order of Major-General John W. Geary, he seized all the printing equipment of the city and collected it in one
office. The first issue of the new publication, “The Loyal Georgian,” appeared the next day, much to the surprise of all. Summers
continued his editorship for several months, the newspapers attracting wide attention. He was also the author of the articles
appearing from time to time in the Syracuse Daily Standard entitled "The Sword and Pen".
He then continued with his command to Raleigh, where the rebellion ended with the surrender of Johnston. The unit participated in
the post-war Grand Review at Washington, where he was brevetted a Major. He returned home overland with a number of animals
and property purchased from the government. He later held a commission of Lieutenant Colonel and Quartermaster in the Sixth
Division of the New York State National Guard on the staff of Major-General D. P. Wood.
Moses Summers returned home in 1865 and continued at the head of the paper until May 9, 1866, when Charles E. Fitch, a gifted
writer, acquired an interest in the establishment. On July 23 of the same year the firm of Summers & Company was formed,
consisting of the Summers Brothers, Charles E. Fitch and Henry A. Barnum, with whom he served in the 149th Regiment. Mr. Fitch,
Moses Summers, and F. A. Marsh (the later acting as city editor) acted as editors of the paper, while William Summers was
business manager. A more vigorous and aggressive policy was adopted, the paper was made a nine-column sheet and it soon
advanced to a leading position among the journals of the State.
Summers was elected Alderman of the Sixth Ward in 1861, serving on the Board of Supervisors for two years, and was Treasurer in
1866. His main interest was in the political field, and in 1869 he was elected Member of Assembly from Onondaga County’s Second
District and was the recipient of political preferment on several occasions, but never received the full recognition due him for his
merits and great services rendered in behalf of the country, owing to partisan jealousies engendered against him as on the leaders
of the party in the county of Onondaga.
As an officer he was meritorious and efficient, as a citizen and as a friend he was faithful and loya. He retired from the profession in
1875 and was made Warden of the Port of New York, and his untimely death on 15 Jun 1882, caused by an accident while serving
in that capacity, in the full vigor of his manhood, was universally regretted.
58

At the close of the war he received the brevetted rank of Major
Obituary of Moses Summers
from The N.Y. Times, June 16, 1882, p. 5
http://web.cortland.edu/woosterk/genweb/summers_obit.html
Col. Moses Summers, of No. 21 Delancey Street, New York, the Port Warden, while walking on the
beams fell into the hold of the bark Prince Albert, at the foot of Amity street, Brooklyn, on Saturday,
June 3, died at the Long Island College Hospital last evening.
His spine was both dislocated and fractured by the fall. Col. Summers was born in Wexford County,
Ireland, on the 1st of January, 1819, and was brought to this country by his parents when only 1 year
old. They settled in Oswego, and here young Summers learned the trade of printer. In 1841 he went to
Syracuse, and was employed as journeyman printer on the Syracuse Standard. That year, when Jerry,
the escaped negro slave from Missouri, was arrested and brought into court in Syracuse, Col.
Summers was one of the party that rescued the fugitive. He was indicted for the offense, but his trial
never came off. He worked as a printer on the Standard until 1848, when he purchased a half interest
in that paper and assumed editorial management. He was a great friend of Gen. Henry A. Barnum, and
when that gentleman took the One Hundred and Forty-ninth Regiment into the field he appointed Col.
Summers Quartermaster. Col. Summers at once left his position, abandoned his property and marched
out to defend the Union.
This was in 1862. He served with the regiment in the Army of the Potomac until after the battles of
Gettysburg, when the command was transferred to the Department of the Cumberland in the West. In
the early part of 1864, upon the recommendation of the Hon. Thomas T. Davis, then member of
Congress from Onondaga District, President Lincoln appointed Summers Captain and Assistant
Quartermaster in the Army, and he was assigned to duty in the brigade commanded by Gen. Barnum
in the Twentieth Army Corps. He served in this position until the close of the war, being present at the
battles of Wauhatchie, Lookout Mountain, and Chattanooga, and making the campaigns with Sherman
of Atlanta, Savannah, and the Carolinas, and his large property accounts with the Government were
found to be absolutely correct, and were promptly settled. For his efficient services in the field he was
brevetted Lieutenant-Colonel of Volunteers.
After the war he was appointed Quartermaster on the staff of the Major-General commanding the Sixth Division of the National
Guard of this State, and held this position until his death. He resumed editorial charge of the Syracuse Standard in 1865. Two years
ago he was appointed Port Warden in the City, and one year ago he resigned the editorial management of his paper. He was an
enthusiastic Republican, and was regarded as a man of keen judgment and great foresight in political affairs, and his advice was
often sought by the leaders of the party.
http://home.earthlink.net/~dahoude/from_the_archives.htm
4TH REGIMENT. - Quartermaster Summers arrived home from New York on Sunday morning. The supplies of clothing, &c., were
very scarce, owing to the rapidity which regiments are coming in. He succeeded in procuring the blankets, and it is expected the
uniforms will be shipped before many days. (Syracuse Daily Courier and Union 2 Sep 1862)
CLOTHING FOR THE NEW REGIMENT. We learn that a full supply of army blankets, of good quality, has been received by
Quartermaster Summers, for the Fourth Onondaga Regiment, and they will be served out to the men as fast as they are ready to
take up quarters in Camp. It is impossible at the present time to obtain uniforms and other necessary articles of clothing, but they
will be forthcoming at an early day. Since the appointment of our “local” friend Moses, of the Standard, to the position of Quarter-
Master of the new, or Fourth Onondaga Regiment, he has been very active in seeing to the wants of the men, and has displayed the
same agility and untiring perseverance which has at all times characterized his connection with the press, as an able and
industrious local editor. We are not apprised as to who will be his successor in the local Chair, but whoever he may be, with all due
deference to whatever talent he may bring to his aid, we are quite sure that the readers of the Standard will miss the pungent pen of
our former cotemporary, while we shall be relieved from many a sharp poke in the ribs. But notwithstanding all this, which to his
readere, like the fable of the boy and the frogs was “fun to them but death to us,” we, too, shall miss his genial, every day
association, and the frank, generous and courteous manner in which he has always treated us, personally. Ever willing to impart any
information to us within his knowledge, which might be of service to us, we found him accommodating and communicative to an
extent that perhaps we had no right to expect. But what his former readers will loose through his absence as local editor, they will
gain it in the service of interesting letters that he will be able to send his paper from time to time, from the seat of war. As Quarter-
Master of the regiment, the gallant boys will find in our old friend Moses, one ever alive to their best interests, and who will be
constantly on the alert to supply their every want in time of need. In taking leave of him as one of our most genial and clever city
cotemporaries, our regards shall follow him upon the tented field, coupled with hopes for his personal safety and future prosperity
and when, at the end of the war he shall return home, conscious of having performed his whole duty to our common country, none
will be more rejoiced at the opportunity of extending to him a warm greeting and the right hand of editorial fellowship than his
humble servant the “local” of the Courier and Union. (Syracuse Daily Courier and Union 3 Sep 1862)
CONSOLIDATION OF THE FOURTH ONONDAGA REGIMENT. This regiment was consolidated on Wednesday under the
designation of the One Hundred and Forty-ninth (149th) Regiment, when all the Captains and most of the Lieutenants were
appointed. We like the number designating the regiment. It sounds strong, and looks invincible. Quarter-Master Summers furnishes
his paper with some items of interest in regard to camp matters, which we subjoin :
59

The Camp of the 4th Regiment has been named Camp White in honor of Ald. White, the well known and popular commander of Co.
D, of the 51st regiment. Major Cook is in command of the camp, and strict military discipline is enforced. Captain Townsend and
some fifty men went into camp this morning before breakfast, and took possession of one of the barracks. There are now five
companies Capts. Light, Lynch, Townsend, Graves and the Pompey company, in camp, and others will go there to-day and tomorrow.
The Manlius Company, Captain Graves marched to town this morning, and went into camp. The march of eight miles must
have been a tiresome one, but the boys bore the fatigue like heroes. Capt. Lindsay and his company will be in camp this afternoon.
It is understood that 950 men have enlisted in the Regiment, but probably all will not pass muster. However, it is safe to say that the
Regiment will soon be filled to the maximum. (Syracuse Daily Courier and Union 5 Sep 1862)
http://home.earthlink.net/~dahoude/archives_page_2.htm
LAST CALL. All persons having claims against the 149 th Regiment must present their bills this forenoon to the Quartermaster or his
Sergeant. The regiment will march immediately, and the bills require the approval of the Colonel and Quartermaster to make them
valid. MOSES SUMMERS, QUARTERMASTER. (Syracuse Daily Courier and Union 22 Sep 1862)
DEPARTURE OF THE FOURTH ONONDAGA REGIMENT. The 149th regiment has received positive orders to leave Camp White
today for the seat of war. The exact time for its departure has not come to our knowledge, but preparations were being made
yesterday for the breaking up of camp at an early hour this morning. Nearly all the men were out on furlough yesterday, making a
last visit to their friends, and enjoying themselves as they pleased. The regiment will go to Washington via Elmira, by the New York
and Erie road. Noncommissioned officers were detailed to gather in the stragglers yesterday, and a large number were picked up in
various parts of the city. The livery stables reaped a rich harvest, as everything in the shape of horse flesh was engaged by the
soldiers at high prices. The soldiers having received their bounty monies were quite flush, and it changed hands rapidly. The
Daguerrean artists got their share of it, while the boys exchanged daguerreotypes with their lady-loves. Groups of soldiers could be
seen upon the corners of the streets, exhibiting to each other the likenesses of dear friends, wives, sweethearts, sisters and
brothers. We have not seen the streets so crowded in a long while as they were on Saturday, caused by an influx to the city of the
friends and relatives of the soldiers, whom they were anxious to spend a few more hours with before their departure, many of them,
perhaps, never to return. Trying scenes will be enacted today when the regiment takes its departure, of such a mournful character
that we should prefer not to witness. P.S. Since the above was put in type, we have later intelligence in regard to the movement of
the regiment.
Quarter-Master Summers returned from New York at 4 A.M. yesterday, bringing with him a full supply of haversacks, canteens,
and every other needful article, which were distributed to the men at Camp White yesterday. He has been quite active and untiring
in his exertions to provide the men of his regiment with a complete outfit, and this he has finally accomplished at the expense of
much hard labor and considerable outlay upon his part, to the entire satisfaction of the members of the regiment. “Moses” looks
“ripe peaches” in his uniform, and will make a “bully” officer. Col. Barnum is expected home early this morning, to direct the
movements of his regiment. (Syracuse Daily Courier and Union 22 Sep 1862)
LAST DAY OF THE 149TH REGIMENT. The announcement made in the daily papers that the regiment would leave for Washington
yesterday, drew a large concourse of the friends and relatives to the city, who loitered about the depot for many hours, expecting to
see the regiment off and bid the boys “God speed.” They were much disappointed at the delay, particularly upon learning that the
regiment would not leave until 7 o’clock this morning. They expected to see them off at 6 o’clock last evening, but their departure
was postponed until 7 A.M., today. The route is by Geneva and Seneca Lake to Elmira, and thence via Harrisburg and Baltimore to
Washington. The National Colors ordered by the Salt Company, was presented to the regiment at 4 o’clock yesterday afternoon at
the camp grounds. The Citizens Corps acted as an escort, and Col. Barnum received the flag in behalf of his regiment, which was
drawn up in line. The stand of regimental colors being prepared by the Israelite ladies of the Seventh Ward, are not yet ready, and
will be formally presented the regiment through the Mayor, who will follow them on Friday next. Lieut. Savage, of Capt. Lynch’s
company, was presented with a sword and pistol on the camp ground Sunday afternoon, by a party of his friends. The presentation
address was made by John Molloy, Esq., in his usual felicitous style, and responded to by Robt. F. Trowbridge, Esq., on the part of
Lieut. Savage. Matthew J. Dolphin was called upon, and in response made a very effective speech. Capt. Lynch, himself, was the
recipient of an elegant and costly sword, a tribute of respect from Lieut. F. D. Murray, and M. E. Lynch, Esq. This was an informal
presentation and done so quietly that we had no opportunity to notice it heretofore.
A handsome sword, sash and belt were presented to Capt. Grumbach by the Board of Supervisors on Saturday. Col. Barnum is to
receive a valuable sword before the regiment leaves, and we understand it was to be presented yesterday afternoon, at the same
time with the flag presentation. A number of the friends of Quartermaster Summers presented him with a horse and equipments at
the camp ground yesterday morning, at nine o’clock. The presentation was made by Mr. Samuel Rooney, to which “Moses”
responded in his usual “gilt edged” style. Alexander McKinstry, ex-Inspector, now orderly Sergeant of Co. E, 149th, was on
Saturday evening made the recipient of an ivory-handled, silver-mounted Colt’s Revolver and a sash, by his recent co-laborers in
the Canal office. Lieut. Col. John M. Strong received the gift of a valuable war charger, on Saturday last, from his friends in
Onondaga. The horse was purchased by Sanford D. Evans and Earl B. Alvord, who were appointed a committee for that purpose by
a meeting of citizens, at a cost of $200. The ceremony took place at Col. Eaton’s new hotel at Onondaga Hill, when R. H. Gardner,
Esq., of this city, made a neat presentation speech in behalf of the donors, to which the Lieut. Col. responded in an able and
patriotic manner. Speeches were also made by Jas. Johnson and H. Case, Esq., and the occasion passed off with great eclat. Capt.
J. Forman Wilkinson is to be complimented with a splendid sword, elaborately finished and appropriately engraved, before he takes
his departure with the regiment. It will be the gift of his former railroad employees, which is sufficient to guarantee that it will be a
costly and elegant affair. A number of the friends of Lieut. Ahio. L. Palmer, Co. H, 149th regiment, presented him with a splendid
sword and sash, on Saturday evening last. The affair came off in the parlor of the Sherman House, and everything connected with it
passed off in the most happy manner. Lieut. Palmer leaves with the regiment this morning, and carries with him the best wishes of
all our citizens. (Syracuse Daily Courier and Union 23 Sep 1862)
THE QUARTERMASTER OF THE 149TH REGIMENT. Editor Courier. There are some points made in the letters published by you
on Monday morning from the 149th regiment, which justice demands that attention should be called to, as there are utterly
groundless causes of complaint against the Quartermaster, however much somebody higher in authority and beyond his regiment
may be at fault. 1st. The Quartermaster must issue the kind or quality of food that is issued to him by the Brigade Quartermaster,
60

with the privilege however of having spoiled food condemned by Board of Survey and returned - drawing other rations in its stead.
The lack of vegetables and the kind and quality of rations is therefore no fault of the Quartermaster, unless in the latter case he
refuses to have them condemned and returned. 2d. That "thinking more of his pocket than of the good of his men" has any bearing,
I cannot see, as no opportunity occurs for him to convert the rations into money, and the Sergeant drawing the company rations
ought to be sharp enough to know whether he gets his weight and measure or not. 3d. The lack of full or any rations is at times
entirely beyond the control of the Quartermaster, and is only one of the many "sufferings" incident to a soldier's life. Particularly is
this true when troops are moving from place to place, which it seems has been the chief occupation of the 149th since its departure
from home. I make these remarks for the benefit of the men who complain to their friends at home as well as that of the
Quartermaster. A new regiment, with officers who have not seen service has much rough usage which experience will enable them
to avoid, and the most experienced officers, serving as Quartermaster, cannot fail at times to be censured for errors not his own,
though it is sometimes difficult to make those who suffer to believe that the fault can exist beyond the officers of their own regiment.
I ask you to publish these comments with the hope that they may allay some of the fears of the friends of both the Quartermaster
and the complaining men. Respectfully yours. H. A. BARNUM. (Syracuse Daily Courier and Union 22 Oct 1862)
John F. Wheeler
The first Tyler of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520, John F. Wheeler was the brother of Park Wheeler and one of three of the Wheeler
family who served through the War of the Secession, enlisting at Syracuse as a Sergeant in Company D on 21 Aug 1862 at the age
of twenty-two.
The 149th was transferred to General Sherman’s army in Sep 1863, taking part in the battle of Lookout Mountain and then the
Atlanta Campaign, during which the regiment was under fire 100 consecutive days and nights. Wheeler was promoted to Second
Lieutenant 7 May 1864. Although his outfit participated in some of the bloodiest encounters of the war, he was never wounded.
However, during hostilities at Peach Tree Creek on 20 Jul 1864, he was taken prisoner while in command of his company. He then
spent nine months at the notorious rebel Georgia prisoner of war camp, “Andersonville,” popularized in a Pulitzer Prize novel by
MacKinlay Kantor in 1955. It was there that 50,000 Union soldiers suffered and nearly 14,000 died. When it was learned that
Wheeler was an officer, her was transferred to Charlestown and then to a prison camp at Charlotte when he finally escaped and
worked his way back to the Union lines. He rejoined his company at Alexandria, VA, 1 Jun 1865 and was promoted to First
Lieutenant 7 Jun 1865, and later brevetted a Captain.
Following the war, Bro. Wheeler formed a partnership with Augustus G. S. Allis (one of Salt Springs Lodge’s original petitioners) and
James A. Allis in a coffee and spice mill at 34 Wolf Street, serving as a salesman for their products, driving through Central New
York with a horse and buggy. He worked (1871) for the New York Central Railroad as a car coupler in the East Syracuse yards until
his retirement as seventy in 1909. He served the lodge faithfully for 60 years, dying at age ninety-two on 23 Nov 1931.
Park Wheeler
Bro. Park Wheeler entered the armed forces of the Union as a First Lieutenant in Company D on 17 Sep 1862 at the age of thirty.
He had been Junior Master of Ceremonies and a Trustee of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520 in 1861. Promotion to Captain was effected
on 20 Dec 1862 when Captain Wilkinson resigned. Wheeler was placed on detached service a short time at Ellis’ Ford in the
summer of 1863 and received a gunshot wound in the thigh at Lookout Mountain, TN, on 24 Nov 1863. A bronze tablet was placed
on a monument to the New York Brigade, 2nd Division, 12th Army Corps, of which the 149th Regiment was a part at Lookout
Mountain. The plaque indicated that eight enlisted men were killed and seven officers wounded, Park Wheeler’s name being
included on the latter list.
The winters of 1863 and 1864 were spent in charge of the Soldier’s Home at Stevenson, Alabama, where he resigned on 7 Aug
1864, having been brevetted a Major. After his discharge he practiced law a Syracuse and served as County Treasurer in 1866. It is
unfortunate that he thereafter became addicted to alcoholism, which led to forgery. He was indicted by the Grand Jury and brought
before Judge Reigel, who sentenced him to Auburn Prison for 15 years. Thus ended what should have been a brilliant and illustrious
career in law and Masonry.
Gustavus Sniper
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.com/~mstone/sniper-g.html
General Gustavus Sniper was born 11 June 1836 near Frieberg in Baden, Germany, and
to Syracuse when he was three. He attended the public schools and also night school. In
1850 he learned cigar-making in George Hier’s firm. In 1856 he formed a partnership with
Nicholas Grumbach (Grumbach and Sniper), engaging in the manufacture of cigars at
North Salina and Union Streets, which was continued for a time after the cessation of
hostilities. In 1854 he joined the ranks of the Syracuse Light Guards and later also joined
the Syracuse Grays and the Davis Light Guards. In 1859-1860 he organized a company,
the Monroe Cadets, and served as their captain until the war broke out. Grumbach,
coincidentally had presented his petition for the degrees in Masonry on 3 Oct 1861, with
Bro. Sniper being Raised on 2 Jan 1862.
Through his study of military texts and his preparation in the militia service, he was
qualified to perform extraordinary services during the war, namely in the 101st and the
185th Regiments. Following the was, he was Commander of the Civil War Veterans
Association. He also played an outstanding role in politics. In 1870 he was elected to the
State Legislature and served three terms there. In 1876 he was appointed Deputy County
Clerk and rose to County Clerk in 1882 where he served for nine years, and then became
a Deputy Collector of Internal Revenue. He married in 1863 the former Miss Katharina Miller. His later years were occupied in
insurance, with an office in the Wieting Block, and he remained active in the affairs on the North Side until his death on 29 March
1894, survived by his widow and two children, Lavina C. E. Sniper and Gustav Sniper.
61

Bro. Sniper was perhaps our most distinguished brother serving in the War of the Rebellion. When the 185th Regiment was
mustered into service on 23 Sep 1864, he was appointed Lieutenant Colonel. Their principal movements were:
Sep 1864 Petersburg
Oct 1864 South Side Railroad
7-11 Dec 1864 Weldon Railroad
5-7 Feb 1865 Hatcher’s Run
29 Mar 1865 Quaker Road
9 Apr 1865 Pursuit of Lee to Appomattox
3 Jun 1865 Return to Syracuse
http://www.historicalartprints.com/hap/collection/viewitem.jsp?id=54
Union Officer's Smoking Caps
These beautifully embroidered smoking caps were
presented to Colonel Gustavus Sniper of the 185th New
York Volunteers by one of his officers. Caps like this were
popular undress wear while in quarters. Sniper was
brevetted 31 Mar 1865 Brigadier General for gallantry at
Quaker Road and White Oak Rd, VA.
The engagement at Quaker Road is worth recounting.
with great loss to our intrepid regiment.
Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain’s brigade was ordered to make that charge to
force back the Rebel line and move toward the key road junction of the Boydton
Plank and White Oak Roads for a final push to the South Side Railroad. Little did
they know they would face over 6000 Confederate veterans from Virginia and
North Carolina; they were outnumbered three to one. Charge and countercharge
surged back and forth during an hour of continuous rifle firing and hand to hand
combat. Rebel sharpshooters in the trees took their toll. The 185th under the
brave and dynamic leadership of Colonel Gustavus Sniper was slowly forced back
until the unit was parallel to the Quaker Road. They held. They bent, but they did
not break---they bent, but they did not run!
< Rare Photograph of General Gustavus Sniper (center) and his Staff Officers of
the 185th Regiment
A fierce encounter ensued, with the Union forces being repulsed. The second
division was retreating in great disorder, when General Chamberlain, in command
of the First Brigade, rode up to the Colonel of the 185th, saying, “For God’s sake,
Colonel Sniper, can you save the day with you regiment?” The Colonel replied,
“General, I can try.” He immediately formed his men in line of battle. They were
ordered to charge the enemy, the attack being made with great spirit over and
eminence where they met the advancing column of the Rebels in pursuit of the
retreating Union forces. Making a desperate assault, they hurled back the foe, but
This encounter lasted scarcely more than half and hour, but it was one of the most desperate and important in its results of any
during the war. The aim of the Confederates seemed to be to shoot down our colors. The Color Bearer, Sergeant B. H. Wilson, was
twice wounded. The Sergeant of the Color Company, William H. Tyler, in whose hands the colors were then placed, was killed.
Herman Reiss, on of the Color Guard, then seized the standard but received a cranial injury. Captain D. N. Lathrop of Company D
next grasped the flag, but was severely wounded in the foot.
At this juncture, Colonel Sniper, being dismounted in the thick of the charge, seeing the colors drop, rushed ahead, seized them
and, whirling them above his head shouted, “Men of the 185th, forward.” A wild yell was sent up from the ranks and, rapidly
advancing with their heroic leader, the day was won.
After the hostilities, the General Officers complimented Colonel Sniper in unison upon the gallantry and valor of his regiment in the
terrible charge and said that it had saved the day. In the short period of this engagement, the regiment lost a least 25 per cent of its
available material with 30 killed, and 180 wounded, about ten per cent of the latter mortally. Survivors look back at this sudden sharp
“Fight of the saw-dust pile,” as it was popularly described, as a horrible dream.
Frank Leslie’s Magazine dated 29 Mar 1865 published an illustration showing the general in the act of picking up the fallen colors
that afterward made his name a household topic in every soldier’s home in the Union. He was brevetted Brigadier General on 31
Mar for gallantry at Quaker Road and White Oak Road, VA.
http://web.cortland.edu/woosterk/genweb/sniper.html
Summary of his service as it appears on page 4066, volume V, of Phisterer's New York in the War of the Rebellion:
SNIPER, GUSTAVUS, late Lieutenant-Colonel, 101st Infantry; mustered in as Lieutenant-Colonel, this regiment [185th], September
23, 1864; promoted Colonel, February 3, 1865; mustered in as such, March 10, 1865; mustered out with regiment, May 30, 1865,
near Washington, D.C.; Brigadier-General, U.S. Volunteers, by brevet, from March 13, 1865; commissioned Lieutenant-Colonel,
November 29, 1864, with rank from September 17, 1864, original; Colonel, February 14, 1865, with rank from February 3, 1865, vice
E. S. Jenney, discharged.
62

Muster-In Roll of Col. Gustavus Sniper
may be viewed more clearly by enlarging screen to 150% or more
http://web.cortland.edu/woosterk/genweb/sniper.html
Bro. Sniper lived at 504 Prospect Avenue, not far from Schlosser Park, 400 Block of North Salina Street where his memorial was
raised in 1906, twelve years after his death:
Sniper Camp 66, Sons of Union Veterans, spontaneously organized a
movement to raise a memorial to him. With the help of the Grand Army
of the Republic, the Women’s Relief Corps, and many friends, the
equestrian statue (the only one of its type in Syracuse) of the General
and his horse, “Bill,” reviewing the troops was dedicated on Memorial
Day 1905. Following a parade, the monument (completed by the
German Company of New York City) was unveiled with civic ceremonies
before a crowd estimated at 10,000 people.
The General’s home at 504 Prospect Avenue had been purchased by
Dr. Serafino F. Chiarulli in 1912. Most items of historical interest were
reportedly given to the Onondaga Historical Society at that time.
However, this was later discussed with Mr. Richard Wright, Director,
who stated that no acquisition of this type was on record. Dr. Chiarulli
died in 1932, but his son, Eugene, also a physician, continued to use
the home as his office, having extensively remodeled the first floor in
1956. He recalled seeing a plaster bust of General Sniper in the attic
and kindly allowed Dr. Peacher to see it on 15 Mar 1962. It was a good
likeness of the general in uniform, although portions of the bus had
broken off. In addition, there was a heavy metal base with a figure of
Sniper in bas-relief which was used to hold a large plant in front of the
house. There were also about 100 books strewn over the floor beneath
the front windows of assorted Reports, Transcriptions, Manuals, &c.
63

Gordon Warren Stevens was Born 2 Jun 1879 at Athens, Ontario, Canada. He married 27
Nov 1901 to Alice Esther Williams at the First English Lutheran Church in Syracuse,
Onondaga, New York, and died 4 Dec 1981 at the Masonic Home in Utica, NY. His father was
a blacksmith, and had a shop in Athens for many years.
Abel Stevens with sons Wilson, David Arden, and Gordon Warren Stevens.
From "THE RECORDER AND TIMES" dated Saturday,
April 22, 1933, "Old Farmersville Seen as a New World"
by Harry D. Blanchard reads: "...on that memorable
second day in Old Farmersville...came two of the
nicest-looking small boys we had ever seen. They
seemed interested in 'the new boy in the Liddie Sheldon
house', but they were shy and he was shy. We
gradually edged our way to the sleigh-tracks mid-street
and they twain likewise. The older boy shyly asked our
name and we told him. He then asked how old we were,
where we came from, how many brothers and sisters
we had, and a long list of other questions. These two boys were 'Ardie' and 'Gordie' Stevens,
younger sons of Abel Stevens and his wife, who was a member of the well known Warren
family. Abel ran a blacksmith's shop and carriage-works on Elgin Street, at the northwest
corner beyond our new home. Their residence was immediately north of the shop and there
was then a well on the street in front of the house, close to the fence. Ardie and Gordie had an
older brother, Will, who, like his father, was very fond of racehorses and often 'jockeyed' them
at the Farmersville Driving Park, which was located on the property now occupied by the
House of Industry. Gordie, or Gordon, is now the father of Warren Stevens, former flying wing
and quarter-back, the most talked of football player of the year 1931, now the well known
coach for the teams at Toronto University. Warren, it will be noted, gets his Christian name from the maiden name of his
grandmother, Mrs. Abel Stevens, who, before her marriage was Elizabeth Warren of Elgin, Ont. On his grandfather's side of the
house the descent from Deacon Abel Stevens, the Canadian U.E. Loyalist pioneer, is Warren, son of Gordon, son of Abel, son of S.
K. Stevens, son of Rev. Abel Stevens, son of Abel Stevens, U.E.L. Rev. Abel Stevens, son of the original Abel, was educated and
ordained in the State of Vermont and came to Canada with his parents, rather than take the oath of allegiance to the United States
government.
On an old map located by our faithful correspondent, Curzon Lamb, Upper Beverly Lake is given the alternative name 'Abel Lake'
after the pioneer, Elder Abel Stevens....
Well, on that second day, at the hour of high noon, we sealed our friendship with Gordie and Ardie Stevens and many a happy hour
we spent playing with them during the year following, until we moved to our new home on Main street east, this friendship being
continued for many years by our later chum, Cliff, now Dr. C. C. Nash of Kingston, as recalled to us by Cliff himself when we last
saw him. The dear mother of Gordie and Ardie Stevens was awfully good to us always; she was kindness personified and we have
many happy memories of the good times spent in her home, when it was too inclement for us boys to play out-of-doors and of the
visits of Gordie and Ardie to our own home...."
Elizabeth Warren died when my grandfather was just eight years old. It is said that she "died of a broken heart". Family lore is that
her husband had been unfaithful. Shortly thereafter, Abel Stevens moved to Syracuse, NY, following his cousin, Peter Bresee to the
Syracuse area where he had a string of race horses. The boys, Wilson, "Ardie" and Gordon stayed for a while in Athens. When their
father sent for them they arrived at the train station in Syracuse, one boy carrying the picture of his mother, and another the frame
for the picture carried around his neck. They waited some time at station until their father arrived. At first they resided in the
Syracuse suburb of Baldwinsville, later moving into downtown Syracuse.
Abel Stevens continued his profession with horses, riding, showing, shoeing and caring for horses. Regardless of how fashionably
he was dressed, he always smelled like horses, reminisces his granddaughter [my mother]. He lived in a succession of boarding
houses with his three sons. My grandfather, Gordon, only had a third grade education, obtained at the old school in Athens before
his departure for the U.S. At age 12 he worked in the Smith Corona typewriter factory in Syracuse. His father was an avid pool and
billard player, and my grandfather often found his father in the pool halls late at night.
Gordon met his future wife, Alice Esther Williams, at a church picnic. His Sunday School teacher, as well as his future in-laws, took
a liking to this shy, quiet boy whose mother had died so young, and who was left to fend for himself amid a less than normal home
life. Gordon was a self-educated man. He loved sports, and surely, if he had had the opportunity, he might have been a sports star
himself. Although small in stature, as was his son, Warren, he spent every free moment either attending sports events or listening
on the radio the football, basketball, baseball or hockey games.
Early in his married life, he and Alice lived on the north side, her parents living with them. For a while he worked on the New York
Central Railroad until his foot slipped while crossing between cars, and his foot and leg were caught in the coupling of the train. After
that near disaster, he left the railroad. Gordon's brother, "Ardie" went into the milk business, pasteurizing milk in the barn behind his
home on Hartson Street. At one or two o'clock in the morning, the milk would be delivered to the barn behind Gordon's home on
Bellevue Avenue, from which he delivered milk in a horse and wagon on Syracuse's southwest side. I remember 'Gramp' telling
about the very icy day when, as he was out of the wagon delivering to a customer, the wagon began to slip down a steep hill. The
horse bolted, and the wagon came loose and slid down the hill on its side. The horse disappeared. When 'Gramp' walked home,
there was the horse, 'Joe', in his stall in the barn. The horse knew the route so well that he found his way home alone.
64

Because of his schedule, Gordon was rarely around the family. He would leave the house at two o'clock in the morning so the milk
would be in the customer's milk boxes before they arose. After his route was done for the day, he came home and was in bed and
asleep by early evening.
After the advent of motor cars, 'Gramp's' horse and buggy milk route was abandoned. For a short time, during the depression years,
he became involved with a friend of his in the house-building business. They built two houses on Winkworth Parkway, off Bellevue
Avenue, in Syracuse.
The Stevens family purchased a home at 1707 Bellevue Avenue, later moving to a home at 1826 Bellevue Avenue. In the early
1930's 'Gramp' built a home at 206 Carleton Road, also on the city's southwest side. They lost this home during those years
immediately following the depression. My mother, Dorothy Elizabeth Stevens, was married at the Carleton Road home in
September, 1934. I still have the blueprints for the home--a gracious Dutch colonial.
Sometime around this time, and perhaps leading to the loss of the Carleton Road home, my grandfather and a friend invested in a
Florida land deal. They purchased what they believed to be land in Winter Haven, Florida. During that era, land sales in Florida was
a big business, and unscrupulous people are always attracted to investment deals such as this. After purchasing the land, 'Gramp'
and his friend took a cruise to Florida to check out their investment. When they arrived, they found the land under water. After a six
months' stay in Florida they returned to Syracuse empty handed.
Gordon went to work for Yackel & Rupp, insurance agents, as a premium collector. He was given an automobile, and crisscrossed
the city of Syracuse to collect premium payments from folks who notoriously paid late. He worked there for many, many years,
retiring at the age of 85.
Gordon and Alice Stevens then moved to 111 Cherry Road in the suburb of Westvale where
they rented for 15 years. After that, a one-year lease at 401 Avery Avenue, and another oneyear
at 411 Hopper Road discouraged them from renting individual homes where one-year
leases ended with another move. Their later years were spent at 219 Village Drive, in the
Eastwood area of Syracuse, where they rented a one-bedroom apartment for many years.
< Alice (Williams) & Gordon W. Stevens (50th Wedding Anniversary)
Gordon Stevens was a Mason at the Salt Springs Lodge No. 520; 32nd Degree in the
Scottish Rite, Valley of Syracuse. He was also a member of the Citizens' Club on James
Street in Syracuse. For his entire life he played billiards. I have several newspaper articles
and photos of him playing billiards at these two clubs. He was a crack shot, and regularly
beat opponents of all ages. After his retirement from the insurance business, he would take
the bus from Grant Village to downtown Syracuse to play billiards at the clubs.
At age 96, and six years after the death of his wife, he went to live at the Masonic Home on
Bleeker Street in Utica. Although active and vital up to that stage, he became increasingly
resigned to his age and lost vitality. He was living at the Masonic Home when he died at age
102.
Written by Jill Sibson Holmes Russell
http://www.eclipse.net/~sholmes/gwstevens.html
Chapter III Spanish-American War, Boxer Rebellion, World Wars I and II, Koran War
Spanish American War
3 Oct 1898. A communication was received from the Grand Master requesting the secretary to forward a list of all members
participating in the War with Spain. This roster could then be presented to Grand Lodge On 7 Jun 1899. This report was published in
the Grand Lodge Proceedings of 1900, pages 321-329, by R.’.W.’. Peter Ross, Grand Historian. Salt Springs Lodge is not included
in the list, however, W.’. William Crabtree indicated that two brothers participated in this conflict: his brother-in-law, John Shackleton,
and Melvin Estes.
Boxer Rebellion
Max Klein was born in Orgave, Russia, was a 60-year member of Salt Springs Lodge and oldest living veteran (1962), who
participated in the Boxer Rebellion. His experiences are worth recording.
Bro. Klein enlisted in the U.S. Army on 4 Jun 1898, and was assigned to Company D of the 9th U.S. Infantry Regiment, then fighting
in Cuba. On reaching Tampa, Florida, hostilities had ceased, so further service was spent at Fort McPherson, Georgia, and
Sackett’s Harbor, New York. He was discharged on 29 Jan 1899 but reenlisted the following day for three years. The regiment was
sent to the Philippines where it was involved in a series of engagements against the insurgents on Luzon in the post-war period.
Two incidents in which he brushed eternity occurred. The men had arrived at Angeles, a small town north of Manila, at dusk and had
retired when they were attacked. As the first shot was fired, Klein jumped up and as he did a bullet struck the pillow where his head
had rested seconds before. The next close call occurred while riding with a squad of men in a wagon when lightning struck, killing
three soldiers and the mules, the wagon being completely demolished.
The outfit was then ordered to China during the Boxer Rebellion to relieve our Legation and missionaries who were surrounded by
the Chinese. They arrived at the Port of Taku in late afternoon on 12 Jul 1900, proceeding on flat cars to Tiensten, twenty miles up
the Pan River.
The eight companies, with those of other allies, were assigned to the recently vacated quarters of the Chinese. Any thought of rest
were interrupted by severe bombardment, beginning during the night. An emergency council held be General Chaffee decided upon
a frontal assault at 6:00 a.m. with the 800 Americans being held in reserve of the 5,000 French troops in the front lines. Flank fire
65

from the Boxers routed the French, the attack being made from behind a well fortified wall 40 x 30 feet. The fighting was intense
during the entire day with 554 casualties in their own outfit.
With ammunition running desperately short, Colonel (Emerson H.) Liscomb (aka Liscumb) called for volunteers to secure the
necessary shells from the dead and wounded. Klein was on of the four men who crawled forward through the deadly enfilade to
within 150 feet of the enemy’s entrenched position to secure seven cartridge belts. In distributing the ammunition to members of the
command, he had to cross a dyke of water about 30 feet wide. He became exhausted and all would have been lost had not a fellow
soldier pushed his gun toward his near prostrate hand and pulled him out. This act kindled the spark and the whole line of assailants
surged forward and carried the crest of the Chinese position. Colonel Liscomb’s last words before dying from wounds received in
this conflict were to recommend that the men who had volunteered should be decorated. Klein was a member of the Home Guard
that accompanied the Colonel’s remains to the port where he was placed aboard a gunboat for the United States. Klein thereafter
received the Distinguished Service Cross and was admitted to membership in the Legion of Valor on 5 Dec 1936.
http://www.homeofheroes.com/valor/1_Citations/00_dsc-prewwi/dsc_03china.html
Also awarded Distinguished Service Crosses for the 13 Jul action at Tientsin were:
ABBOTT, GEORGE F., Corporal, U.S. Army, Company G, 9th Infantry, for distinguished gallantry in action. Home: Worcester, MA
DAVIS, ALBERT, Sergeant, U.S. Army, Company B, 9th Infantry, for distinguished service in the battle. Home Town: Whitehall, MI
FRAZIER, JOSEPH, First Lieutenant, U. S. Army, 9th Infantry, for extraordinary heroism in action. Lieutenant Frazier displayed
conspicuous gallantry and absolute disregard of personal safety in rescuing, under a terrific enemy fire, the colonel (Emerson H.
Liscomb) of his regiment, who had fallen mortally wounded. Home Town: Grand Center, MO
WALDRON, WILLIAM H., Second Lieutenant, U.S. Army, 9th Infantry, for extraordinary heroism in action, in rescuing while under a
heavy fire three of his men from drowning, all of whom fully accoutered had fallen into a deep ditch, when Lieutenant Waldron also fully
accoutered, jumped in and saved them. Home Town: Welch, WV.
After Peking fell on 4 Aug 1900 to foreign powers, the 9th Regiment was assigned to the island of Samar in the Philippines. Klein
again brushed death while swimming on a sand bar at Catabolong in the changing tide. His personal life is studded with similar
close disasters – nearly drowning in the Erie Canal at the age of twelve; in a coma ten days with a fractured skull following a bicycle
fall; six major operation, including a spinal cord tumor; encephalitis and pneumonia following influenza in 1922 for a period of ten
weeks.
With all of this, Bro. Klein outlived his three doctor and celebrated his eighty-eighth birthday on 7 Apr 1962, and his fifty-eighth
wedding anniversary in the same year.
1917:
World War I
28 May Purchase of a $1000 Liberty Bond.
01 Oct A committee was appointed to communicate with members serving in the armed forces.
Gold Masonic rings and traveling certificates were presented to our members attached to the 4th Ambulance Company: Arthur T.
Gwynn, Glenn R. Benson, A. S. Perry, I. B. Hale, I. C. Blint, D. S. Earll, J. Miller, and F. W. Swift.
Union Company No. 1919, K. of C. stated they were willing to be of assistance to any member of the Masonic Fraternity at any time,
have been officially designated by the War Department to work in conjunction with the Y.M.C.A.
25 Oct Communication was received from Grand Lodge requesting all lodges to aid in the contribution of $1,000.000 to the War
and Relief Fund. A committee was appointed.
12 Nov Syracuse Masonic lodges voted to purchase a suitable service flag on which stars were to be added.
28 Feb War Relief Fund $1000.
30 Mar Harold J. Reck was raised to Master Mason in short form by special dispensation due to his being called for immediate
action in the U. S. war service.
A list of honored members of this lodge who served with distinction in World War I was made. This included 67 brethren and their
branches of service in most instances. All were presented with engraved rings and traveling certificate.
1918:
01 Apr Carl C. Hayward was Passed and Raised in short form by special dispensation, being called to active duty.
20 May $75 in thrift stamps and $25 in War Savings were purchase.
27 May K. M. Prehn was presented with a Masonic ring and traveling certificate.
10 Jun A letter was forwarded from William H. Miers, Secretary of the Fraternal Society for new Jersey, stating that James Swift
was ill at the Base Hospital, Camp Dix, NJ.
15 Jun The First and Second Degrees were conferred on William H. Goetell in short form.
17 Jun Special Communication was held to confer the Master Mason Degree on William H. Goetell in short form.
01 Jul War Relief Fund: $1000. There is a list that was in existence naming the 444 members of Salt Springs Lodge who
contributed $5 to $25 to the Grand Lodge War Relief Fund.
22 Jul W. H. Kittel was called to service and passed to the Degree of Fellowcraft in short form. E. Klein, J. R. Price, and W. H.
Kittel then received the Third Degree.
12 Aug E. H. Hymes was given all the Degrees in short form.
12 Sep A letter was read from H. D. Snyder indicating he had reached France without mishap.
16 Sep Word was sent from A. C. Burchard announcing his safe arrival in France. Fred E. Samuels was appointed to correspond
with him.
23 Sep R. W. C. Joss reported he had seen Brother D. M. Prehn, U.S.N., and he was doing well.
07 Oct $1,000 donated to the Fourth Liberty Loan.
04 Nov H. D. Snyder wrote from France requesting letters.
Dispensation received from the Grand Master permitting acting upon application of C. G. Grieb, USA enlisted, age twenty, Company
A, S.A.T.C. stationed at Syracuse University. This was later cancelled (25 Nov 1918), following the armistice.
66

25 Nov War Savings Stamps, $500.
World War II
Salt Springs Lodge had a total of 55 members in the armed services, all without casualty.
1942 Series G Defense Bonds, $5,000.
1943 Series G Defense Bonds, $5,000; 1944, $6,000.
1945 Victory Bond, $1,000.
431 Brothers contributed $774.50 to the Masonic War Chest in 1943; 366 in 1944 for a total of $820 ($99.25 to local Service
Center). 1945, 370 donated a total of $1,173.75.
Grand Lodge Service Center, Syracuse. Salt Springs was host during the weeks of 9 Aug 1943, 20 Mar and 17 Sep 1944, and 4
Mar 1945.
20 Aug 1944 Sponsored several Sunday breakfasts for 210 service men at the Y.M.C.A.
Thirty to thirty-five visitors were often present throughout the war years, particularly on a Third Degree. A record number of 48
attended 14 Feb 1942.
Christmas cards were mailed to all brothers on military duty.
Dues were remitted of all members in the armed services for the duration.
Dispensations were presented by Grand Lodge to confer degrees on more that five candidates at one meeting.
Numerous letters were received from brethren in the theatres of war throughout the world.
The Masonic War Chest Program sponsored by Grand Lodge during World War II included:
First Phase:
1. Establishment of Service Centers and recreation rooms throughout the state.
2. Seventy-five bed dormitory at Masonic Hall.
3. Sponsorship of 1,176 men on 42 Navy landing craft ships.
4. Ambulance and mobile units to American Red Cross.
5. $10,000 worth of radios, musical instruments, phonographs, and records to U.S. Navy in Pacific Theatre.
6. Games and recreation material for U.S.S. Bennington.
7. Contributions to Masonic Service Center and related services.
Second Phase: Rehabilitation of service men in general.
1. Furnishing 20 sun rooms at Rhoades General Hospital (USA) and St. Albans Hospital (USN); recreation room: Mason
General Hospital. Patio at Halleran General Hospital and day room in its annex.
2. 2,000 kits for wounded service men.
3. 200 strapped mirrors for disabled service men.
4. Sound system for hospital and post, Fort Hamilton.
5. Games and recreation material for men at Sampson Naval Hospital.
6. Miscellaneous equipment for A.A.F. at Pawling.
7. Books and cigarettes at various military and naval hospitals throughout the state.
Third Phase: Individual rehabilitation for our brethren in service.
Korean War
The following communication is the only reference to the Korean War found in the minutes of Salt Springs Lodge.
14 Jan 1952. G.M. Richard A. Rowlands: Short form closing ordered in event of national emergency: riot, air raid, blackout,
etc., to preserve community civilian protection as well as protection for the brethren and their friends:
W.M. (call up lodge . . .) “Brother S.D. attend at the altar and close the great light in Masonry” (done).
W.M. “By order of the G. M., I declare this lodge closed.”
Chapter IV Anniversary Celebrations
.Annual reunions had been the hallmark of Salt Springs Lodge since its founding.
27 Nov 1886 Committee appointed by the Master to make arrangements to celebrate the 25th Anniversary. The three principal
officers were appointed, with all Past Masters on the Advisory Committee.
16 May 1892 Their 30th Anniversary was observed with a social gathering at the lodge rooms. R.’.W.’. George Judd Gardner
presented an historical address followed by literary and musical entertainment under the direction of Brother G. Pabst.
10 Jun 1907 The highlight of our 45th Anniversary was the presentation of a chair to our only living charter member, Nicholas
Grumbach, by Brother Wenhurst on our behalf.
24 Jun 1917 The Bicentennial Anniversary of the Grand Lodge of England was celebrated on St. John’s Day on the annual
official pilgrimage of M.’.W.’. Thomas Penney to the Masonic Home at Utica. Members of Salt Springs Lodge were in attendance at
this communication.
21 Sep 1936 The 76th Anniversary dinner was held on 14 Sep 1936 at the Masonic Temple. $1000 had been appropriated for
this festivity, which was attended without cost by 400 Brethren out of a total membership of 769. Grand Lodge Fifty-year Medals
were awarded to Brothers Gates Wiseman, Charles Listman, and George Dunn. Wiseman, who was raised on 30 Sep 1872, our
oldest member with 64 years of service, the first of which were consecutive, gave a most inspiring talk. Our youngest member, Roy
Stone, raised on 15 Jun 1936, was then introduced. Other speakers included M.’.W.’. Harold J. Richardson, R.’.W.’. Fay C. Parsons,
and R.’.W.’. Henry G. Meacham. The program prepared at that time included an historical sketch by Vernon Tapper.
67

26 Apr 1937 180 Brethren attended the celebration of the Bicentennial Anniversary of Masonry in New York State in conjunction
with Salina Lodge No. 955. R.’.W.’. William Braithwaite, Grand Chaplain, was the speaker for the evening.
In more recent years it has been customary to have an annual reunion sauerbraten dinner at the time of a regular stated
communication as well as a supper dance on Saturday; both in the fall.
Centennial Celebration of our First Meeting U.D.
to be continued
Liverpool Lodge No. 525
Liverpool, New York
5 Jun 1863 – 2 May 1994
On March 3, 1862, a petition for a Lodge to be erected in Liverpool by the name of Palestine Lodge was submitted to the Grand
Lodge of New York with the endorsement of Salt Springs Lodge No. 520 of Syracuse.
The 10 petitioners and charter members for this lodge were:
*Charles S. Wells
Franklin Dickson
Richard Platt
*Alexander B. Wells
*Wm. W. Parker
25 Mechanic
26 Farmer
30 Farmer
51 Mechanic
50 Boatman
James O'Neil 26 Boatman
*Tho B. Anderson 50 Merchant
*Richard B. Claxton 48 Boat Builder
*Thomas Drum(m) 35 Boatman
Richard J. Chillingworth 28 Farmer
* also members of Gilboa Lodge No. 259, I. O. O. F., and all of them were members of Syracuse Lodge No. 501, F&AM,
except Bro. Anderson, at the time of submitting the petition.
A letter of endorsement was received and a Dispensation was granted by Grand Lodge. The first regular meeting under
Dispensation was held on August 26, 1862, in the former facilities of the I. O. O. F. in the Smith Building.
The first petitioner U.D. for the Degrees in Masonry was David A. Brown, who was born in Vermont (and also a member of
Gilboa Lodge No. 259, I. O. O. F.). Brother Brown was Initiated September 11, 1862, Passed October 10th and Raised October
30th. He passed away on December 26, 1881.
The first Brother Raised U.D. was Charles S. Sterling, a physician, born in Connecticut and married to Armenia Hasbrouck. His
sister, Ellice, was married to Philander Hasbrouck. He was Initiated September 4, 1862, Passed September 16th and Raised
October 2nd (and was also a member of Gilboa Lodge No. 259, I. O. O. F.). Dr. Sterling, a Whig and a Republican, was a prominent
man in the affairs of Liverpool. A man of fine education, he took great interest in educational matters and was a long time Trustee of
the Village School. He taught singing school "without money and without price He was a magnificent looking man and had one of
the sweetest voices that I have ever heard (Mrs. Lydia Adams Mason Ross - 1894). He passed away September 12, 1884, at the
age of 82.
Other early brothers Raised in Liverpool Lodge U.D. were as follows:
Lodge No.
15 2nd Michael Sommers Shoemaker October 2, 1862 *
12 3rd Orson C. Gleason Farmer October 4 *
13 4th David Wetsel Carpenter October 4 *
03 5th Charles S. Wells Mechanic October 16 * (Charter Member)
06 6th Franklin Dickson Farmer October 16 (Charter Member)
14 7th Byron R. Chafee Carpenter October 16
18 8th Thomas Hand Innkeeper October 16
16 9th David A. Brown Grocer October 30 *
17 10th Wm. H. Seymour Carpenter October 30 *
21 11th Jared Bassett Salt Mfr November 13 *
23 12th Hiram L. Hawley Salt Mfr. November 20
20 13th William Manly Farmer December 4 *
22 14th John L. Hawley Salt Mfr. December 11
19 15th John S. Heath Boatman December 9 *
* Also members of Gilboa Lodge No. 259, I. O. O. F.
The Charter for Liverpool Lodge No. 525 is dated June 3, 1863, the text of which is as follows:
We, The Grand Lodge of the Most Ancient and Honorable Fraternity of Free and Accepted Masons, of
the State of NEW YORK, in Ample Term assembled, according to the Old Constitutions, regularly and solemnly established under
the Auspices of PRINCE EDWIN, at the City of York in Great Britain, in the year of Masonry 4926, viz:
THE MOST WORSHIPFUL Clinton F. Paige Grand Master.
THE RIGHT WORSHIPFUL J. B. Yates Sommers Deputy Grand Master.
THE RIGHT WORSHIPFUL Stephen H. Johnson Senior Grand Warden.
68

Do, by these Presents appoint, authorize, and empower our worth Brother Richard J. Chillingworth to be the Master; our worthy
Brother William W. Parker to be the Senior Warden; and our worthy Brother Charles S. Wells to be the Junior Warden, of a Lodge of
Free and Accepted Masons, to be, by virtue hereof, constituted, formed and held in LIVERPOOL, ONONDAGA COUNTY.
which Lodge shall be distinguished by the Name and Style of LIVERPOOL LODGE NUMBER 525 and the said Master and
Wardens, and their successors in Office, are hereby respectively authorized and directed by and with the Consent and Assistance of
a Majority of the Members of the said Lodge, duly to be Summoned and present upon such Occasions, to Elect and Install the
Officers of the Said Lodge as Vacancies happen, in manner and form as is, or may be, prescribed by the Constitution of this
Grand Lodge.
And Further, the said Lodge is hereby invested with full Power and Authority to assemble upon proper and lawful
Occasions, to MAKE MASONS, and to ADMIT MEMBERS, as also to do and perform all and every such acts and Things
appertaining to the CRAFT as have been, and ought to be done, for the Honor and Advantage thereof; conforming in all their
Proceedings to the Constitution of this GRAND LODGE, otherwise this WARRANT and the powers thereby granted, to cease and
be of no further effect.
THE RIGHT WORSHIPFUL James Gibson
Junior Grand Warden.
Registered in the Book of the
Grand Lodge - Page 108
Given under our Hands and the Seal of our Grand Lodge, at the City
of New York, in the United States of America, this THIRD day of JUNE, in
the Year of our Lord One Thousand Eight Hundred and Sixty Three and
in the Year of Masonry Five Thousand Eight Hundred and Sixty Three.
James M. Austin Grand Secretary.
W.. Richard Jolly Chillingworth
Charter Master of Liverpool Lodge No. 525
Richard J. Chillingworth was born in Handsworth, Staffordshire, England, on 30 Nov 1833. His family
moved to the United States in 1835, living in New York City for about a year before moving to Cherry
Valley, New York., in the spring of 1836. They next moved to Fruit Valley, near Oswego, in 1838. He had a
sister, Sarah, who was born in England on 14 Dec 1824. She married Daniel Devine Miller of Liverpool.
< Brother Chillingworth mined for gold in California where he was quite successful. With his "fortune" he
came to Liverpool and established a home and farm where the Myron Melvin farm stood on Route 57. He
was a member of Syracuse Lodge No. 102, having been Initiated 24 Feb 1859, Passed March 10th, and
Raised March 17th of the same year. He became a Charter Member (No. 25) of Syracuse Lodge No. 501
on 4 Apr 1960, from which Lodge he demitted on August 26, 1862, the same date he was elected as the
first Master of Liverpool Lodge No. 525 at the age of 28. He also served as Master in 1863, 1864, 1866,
1867 and 1873.
There were five members of Liverpool Lodge No. 525 by the name of Chillingworth: Richard J., our first
Master; Joseph, Master in 1881 and 1882; Frank (mbr no. 24), Edward L. (mbr no. 52), and Charles C. (mbr no. 149). W.’. Richard
J. Chillingworth moved to Florida in 1892 where he assisted in the organization of Harmonia Lodge No. 135. He passed away in
1915 at the age of 82.
Masonic Temples used by Liverpool Lodge No. 525
1. 26 Aug 1862 to 1866: The first communications of the Lodge were held in the Odd
Fellows Hall on the third floor of the Smith Block (building owned by R & J Smith) which
stands on the northwest corner of Vine and First Streets, now minus the third floor (the
Nichols Liquors Store as of 1995). The original furnishings were purchased from the
Odd Fellows (Gilboa Lodge No. 259) following the surrender of their Charter.
2. 1866 to 1878: In 1866 the Smith's lease was broken to occupy space in the newly
erected Manly Building on the northwest corner of Tulip and First Streets, presently
number 401 and occupied by The Olde Liverpool Shoppes. The lease, dated April 1,
1866, is in the archives of the Lodge and reads as follows:
This Article of Agreement between [Bro.] William Manly of the Village of Liverpool of the first
part, and [Bro.] Hiram L. Hawley and [Bro.] John S. Heath of said Village of Liverpool of the
second part - Witnesseth, that the said William Manly agrees to let - or rent - to the said
Hiram L. Hawley and John S. Heath or their assigns the third story of his brick building (now
in progress of construction) together with the right of entrance through the first and second
stories to the said third story; the same to be used as a Masonic Hall or Lodge Room - Said
Manly reserves the right of entrance through the said third story to the roof of the building - In
consideration of the payment - of fifty six dollars per year to be paid quarterly by the
occupants, this agreement is to remain in force for the term of ten or more years.
Signed and sealed this first day [of] April at Liverpool Onondaga Co. New York Eighteen hundred and sixty six -
Wm. Manly
J. S. Heath
69

The minutes of the Lodge record the regular payment of rent on the Manly Lodge Room until November of 1875, when some
trouble developed in paradise, culminating in an entry in the minutes on 25 Dec 1876, when "a committee of three was appointed to
confer with [Bro.] M[oses] Latimore in relation to Renting his room."
3. 11 Mar 1878 to Late 1889: "Lodge met in the Manly Block and adjourned to the Latimore
Block." The rental amount for the new Lodge room was $50 per year. On 1 Feb 1886, Past
Master Chillingworth moved that "two weeks from tonight the Lodge take a vote as to whether we
remain in our present quarters or not. Carried. The Trustees, meanwhile, to confer with M.
Latimore and Bro. Hand in regard to their respective Halls." The 'Latimore Block' or Building was
later the Crowe Letter Service Building on First Street, minus the third floor, and is presently
owned by the LaVallee’s Karate Sudio.
4. Late 1889 to Late 1907: The Masonic Hall was returned to the Manly Building, except that it
was now owned by Br. Thomas Hand (and later by Mrs. Gertrude Gale). The minutes of 9 Sep
1889, reflect that the motion to move was carried and a draft for $20 rent was drawn.
5. ca 20 Aug 1906 to Sep 1918: On June 4th the Lodge received a
communication from Mrs. Gale raising the rent from July 1st to $75 [per year].
After a procedural error, the then Master, W.’. Luther L. Weller, found it
necessary on July 30th to write a lengthy letter to the Brethren, to be spread
upon the Minutes, which reads in small part . . . "This Lodge at its last regular
communication, the members having been summoned therefore, voted to
remove its place of meeting from the building owned by Mrs. Gertrude Gale [the
Manly or Hand Block], a part of which this Lodge had occupied for a number of
years, to the building owned by William Gleason and the Gleason estate (later
by the Orths). This meeting was the last one to be held in the Gale building
prior to the expiration of the tenancy, and it was necessary that the next regular
communication of the Lodge, August 20th, should be held in the new Lodge
rooms. Notwithstanding this fact the Lodge closed its meeting without any
provisions being made for affecting the transfer of the Lodge from one building
to the other. . . . Who had the power and authority to make the transfer?" . . .
This building is located at the southeast corner of Tulip and First Streets, where once
stood Bro. Gleason’s store.
6. 7 Sep 1918 to present 1995: The present Liverpool Temple lot, at 608 Oswego Street,
was purchased on 16 Dec 1916, for $800. The financing of the new Temple was
accomplished by the sale of stock. The cornerstone was laid on 11 Nov 1917 and was
dedicated on 6 Aug 1918, by M.’.W.’. William S. Farmer, Grand Master. In more recent
times it has seen renovations in the kitchen, the main Lodge room and foyer and most
recently in the Fellowcraft room, with new lighting, chairs and pool table, round tables, a
VCR and a new television. The O.E.S. has assisted financially throughout the Temple's
history, most recently with a beautiful new set of Stickley furniture and a display case for
the upstairs foyer area.
Masters of Liverpool Lodge No. 525
Chillingworth, Richard J. 1862-64 Chetwin, Charles 1916-17 Lyons, James D. 1955
Parker, William W. 1865 Pease, Oliver S. 1918 Leisner, Howard F. 1956
Chillingworth, Richard J. 1866-67 Manzer, Louis 1919 Gell, Thomas 1957
Parker, William W. 1868 Rogers, J.P. 1920 Johnson, Donald 1958
Gleason, Orson C. 1869-71 Timmins, W.H. 1921 Smith, Sawdon S. 1959
Baxter, George 1872 Stevens, G.H. 1922 Nigro, Alfred D. 1960
Chillingworth, Richard J. 1873 Rhodes, Neil S. 1923 Krause, Robert 1961
Parker, William W. 1874 Smith, Herbert A. 1924 Vine, Earl 1962
Gleason, Orson C. 1875 Kentner, Cliff L. 1925 Bahn, Willard R. 1963
Fargo, Curtis A. 1876 Allen, Frank H. 1926 Meloling Jr., Henry 1965
Gleason, Orson C. 1877 Van Antwerp, Nate 1927 Anthony, Barent V. 1966
Beebe, William G. 1878 McNight, Frank H. 1928 Davis, Carl 1967
Lyke, Andrew 1879-80 Meloling, Henry J. 1929 Wyker, Frederick H. 1968
Chillingworth, Joseph 1881-82 Thomas, Richard F. 1930 Busse, Leonard C. 1969
Sharp, Milo C. 1883-84 Lutzy, Fred D. 1931 Carr, Oliver J. 1970
Alvord, Charles 1885 Traister, Fred 1932 Nelson, Robert 1971
Aiken, A.Willis 1886-87 Duerr, George 1933 Maurer, John P. 1972
Buescher, Frank 1888 Damon, Earnest A. 1934 Chester, Harold L. 1973
Russell, George H. 1889 Kenrick, Leslie J. 1935 Hoffman, Clayton 1974
Randall, Albert B. 1890 Duck, Orman H. 1936 Cox, Dwayne E. 1975
Whitney, Royal A. 1891 Beacham, Raymond A. 1937 Westcott, Richard F. 1976
Bardes, Jacob 1892-93 Loveless, Earl W. 1938 Ward, Richard J. 1977
Whitney, Royal A. 1894 Pease, Warren S. 1939 Lyon, David J. 1978
King, Charles J. 1895 Kinne, Prentice L. 1940 Raymond Jr., Joseph 1979
70

Smith, Peter J. B. 1896-98 Hurst, Howard H. 1941 Rockdashil, Robert 1980
Whitney, Royal A. 1899 Hamlin, Herbert A. 1942 Lowell, Chris 1981
Woener, David C. 1900-01 Cox, Maurice E. 1943 Proper, Floyd A. 1982
Green, Manford D. 1902 Beahan, Charles J. 1944 Russell, Douglas G. 1983
Warner, Fred E. 1903-04 Huntley, Brainard H. 1945 Rockdashil, Robert 1984
Bretzer, Charles J. 1905 Parshall, Richard C. 1946 Melfi, Richard C. 1985
Weller, Luther L. 1906-07 Church, Howard K. 1947 Barber, Carl R. 1986
Orth, Ezra J. 1908-09 Chapman, Othmer H. 1948 Fields, David W. 1987
Duell, James T. 1910 Andersen, Henry E. 1949 Vassily, William G. 1988
Aiken, Edwin V. 1911 Hole, Stanley 1950 Rogers, Clark E. Sr. 1989
Rogers, James T. 1912 Moak, John O. 1951 Tyrrell, Robert 1990
Orth, George W. 1913 Pare, W. Carl 1952 Barber, Carl R. 1991
Bittel, Clarence W. 1914 Lunn, Edward G. 1953 Poltenson, Charles A. 1992
Naumann, William 1915 Hawks, E. Allison 1954 Williams, Monty L. 1993
Note: Lodge Consolidated 2 May 1994 To become Liverpool Syracuse No. 501
Secretaries
Treasurers
Anderson, Thomas B. 1862 Gleason, Orson Columbus 1863
Basset, Jared 1863-64 Hand, Thomas 1864
Sterling, Charles S. 1865-70 Hawley, Hiram L. 1865-66
Baxter, George 1871 Bassett, Jared 1867
Parker, Truman 1872-73 Claxton, Richard B. 1868-71
Sterling, Charles S. 1874-75 Miller, James G. 1872-73
Smith, Millard F. 1876 Latimore, Moses 1874-86
Fargo, Curtis A. 1877-84 Gleason, Orson C. 1887-03
Randall, Albert B. 1885-87 Randall, Albert B. 1904-22
Tyler, Lorenzo D. 1888 Miller, Frank F. 1923-54
Alvord, Charles G. 1889-90 Church, Howard K. 1955-75
Lyon, Charles T. F. 1891-1904 Hawks, E. Allison 1976-86
Green, Manford D. 1905-38 Chester, Harold L.* 1987-98
Kenrick, Leslie J. 1939-68 Lees, Benjamin G. 1998-00
Moore, James L. 1969-85 Melfi, Richard C. 2000-02
Funck, Frederick 1986 Forbes, Leroy J. 2002-03
Proper, Floyd A. 1987-88 Lees, Benjamin G. 2003-05
Rogers, Clark E. Sr.* 1989-96 Wiggins, Lee 2005-
Heinmiller, Gary L. (Asst) 1996-97
Melfi, Richard C. 1997-99
Heinmiller, Gary L. 1999-02
Melfi, Richard C. 6/02-2/03
Heinmiller, Gary L. (Acting) 3/03-6/03
Heinmiller, Gary L. 2003-
Past Master Photos
R. J. Chillingworth Andrew Lyke Peter J.B. Smith Geo. H. Russell Frank Beuscher
David C. Woerner M. D. Green Fred E. Warner Chas J. Bretzer E. J. Orth
71

E. V. Aiken G. W. Orth C. W. Bittle Chas Chetwin O. S. Pease
Louis Manzer W. H. Timmins N.S. Rhodes H. A. Smith C. L. Ketner
F. H. Allen N. VanAntwerp H. J. Meloling Sr. R. F. Thomas F. D. Lutzy
Fred Traister Geo. Duerr E. A. Daman L. J. Kenrick R. A. Beacham
E. W. Loveless W. S. Pease P. L. Kinne H. H. Hurst H. A. Hamlin
M. E. Cox C. J. Beahan B. H. Huntley R. C. Parshall H. K. Church
72

O. H. Chapman H. E. Anderson S. Hole John Moak W. K. Pare
E. G. Lunn E. A. Hawks J. D. Lyon H. F. Leisner Thos. E. Gell
D. L. Johnson S. S. Smith A. D. Nigro R. P. Kraus Earl Vine
Willard R. Bahn Henry J. Meloling Jr. Barent V. Anthony Carl E. Davis Frederick H. Wyker
Leonard C. Busse Oliver J. Carr Robert C. Nelson John P. Mauer Harold L. Chester
Clayton D. Hoffman Dwayne E. Cox Richard F. Westcott Richard J. Ward David J. Lyon
73

Joseph Raymond Jr. Robert E. Rockdashil Chris R. Lowell Floyd A. Proper Douglas G. Russell
Richard C. Melfi David W. Fields William G. Vassily Clark E. Rogers Sr. Robert M. Tyrrell
Carl R. Barber Charles A. Poltenson Monty L. Williams Lewis T. Paradise Jr. Willard G. Jones
Charles E. Blood William J. Hanna III Gary L. Heinmiller Robert T. Locastro William C. Schuetz
Leonard J. Jensen Robert D. Bowles Dennis E. Lagoe, Sr.
Grand Lodge Elections & Appointments
(S) = Syracuse 501; (D) = Danforth
M∴W∴ Findlay M. King (S) Grand Master 1861
Gr. Rep. Peru & Arkansas 1867
M∴W∴Clinton F. Paige (S102) Grand Master 1863-64
R∴W∴Nicholas Latterner (S) DDGM 1883
R∴W∴Herbert W. Greenland (S) DDGM 1892
R∴W∴Frank Raymond (S) Jr. Grand Deacon 1893
R∴W∴Hubert J. Wright (S) Grand Steward 1903 [08?]
R∴W∴ David L. Edwards (S) DDGM Wayne District 1905
R∴W∴Horace G. Stone (S) Grand Sword Bearer 1911
R∴W∴Frank T. Miller (S) DDGM 1912
R∴W∴Sebert T. Friedrich (S) DDGM 1913
R∴W∴Jeremiah Zimmerman (S) Grand Chaplain 1913, 15-19
R∴W∴ John P. Listman (S) DDGM 1918
74

R∴W∴ George G. Hancock (S) Jr. Grand Deacon 1918
R∴W∴ Charles B. Dewald (S) Grand Sword Bearer 1919
R∴W∴ Almon A. Jaynes (S) Grand Chaplain 1919
R∴W∴ Russell S. Carroll (S) Grand Steward 1921
R∴W∴ G. Arthur Shaw (S) Grand Steward 1923
R∴W∴ William A. Drinkwine (S) Grand Dir. Ceremonies 1925
R. .W. . Frank H. Allen DDGM 1930-31
R∴W∴ Louis J. Lynn (S) Grand Dir. Ceremonies 1932
R∴W∴ George H. Ballantyne (S) DDGM 1935
R∴W∴ Earle W. Wilson (S) Grand Sword Bearer 1940
R. .W. . Warren S. Pease DDGM 1941-42
R∴W∴ George MacCall (S) DDGM 1948
R. .W. . Maurice E. Cox DDGM 1949-50
R∴W∴ Henry C. Kogler DDGM 1952
R∴W∴ Walter H. Cummings (S) DDGM 1958
R. .W. . Leslie J. Kenrick Grand Steward 1963-64
R∴W∴Robert Cox (D) DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1965-66
R. .W. . Willard R. Bahn DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1967-68
R. .W. . Milton T. Jefferson Grand Chaplain 1970-72
R. .W. . Frederick H. Wyker Grand Sword Bearer 1972-73
Grand Standard Bearer 1985-86
R∴W∴Charles N. Beckendorf III (S) DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1975-76
R. .W. . Harold L. Chester DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1977-78
R. .W. . Richard F. Westcott Gr. Dir. of Ceremonies 1979-80
R. .W. . Dwayne E. Cox DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1982-83
R∴W∴Charles A. Gray (S) Grand Sword Bearer 1982-83
R. .W. . Joseph D. Mazza Gr. Rep. to the Tazmania 1982-84
R∴W∴George A. Anderson, III (S) DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1984-85
R∴W∴Gary S. Hartman (S) DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1986-87
R∴W∴Paul R. Byrns (D) Grand Steward 1988
R∴W∴Charles O. Jamieson (D) Grand Sword Bearer 1989
R∴W∴Patrick E. Pacini (S) DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1990-92
R. .W. . William G. Vassily DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1992-94
R. .W. . Clark E. Rogers, Sr. DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1994-96
R∴W∴Alan J. Morgan (LS - Afil) DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 1996-98
R∴W∴Gary L. Heinmiller Trustee, The Robert R 1996-02
Livingston Library of Grand Lodge
R∴W∴ Richard C. Melfi* Grand Sword Bearer 2000-02
R∴W∴ Richard W. Holland (S) GRep Santa Catarina Brazil 2000-02
R∴W∴ Carl R. Barber GRep Bolivia 2002-04
R∴W∴ Richard D. Melfi* DDGM, 2nd Onondaga 2002-04
R∴W∴ Alan J. Morgan (LS-Afil) Senior Grand Warden, GL 2002-04
R∴W∴ William G. Vassily Custodian of the Work 2001-
R∴W∴Walter H. Cummings (S) Trustee, The Robert R 19
Livingston Library of Grand Lodge
(Emeritus) 19
R∴W∴Robert J. Eustace, Jr. Gr. Dir. of Ceremonies 2002-04
* ex. 15 Jan 04
33rd Degree Honorary Members, A.A.S.R.
Ill∴ Clinton F. Paige (S102) (Active - 1868) 1862
Ill∴ Theodore M. Barber (S) 1902
Ill∴ Herbert W. Greenland (S) 1919
Ill∴ Frank H. Allen (L444) 1956
Ill∴ Edward T. Coupal ( 1964
Ill∴ Robert B. Cox (D) 1974
Ill∴ Charles K. Peck (D) 1976
Ill∴ Walter H. Cummings (S) 1964
Ill∴ Charles A. Gray (S) 1999
Ill∴ Gary S. Hartman (S) 2003
Past Commanders, K.T.
Central City Commandery No. 25
Clinton F. Paige (S102) 1856-60;
Theodore M. Barber (S) 1884-85
Herbert W. Greenland (S) 1893-94
Edwin C. Hall (S) 1899-1900; Grand Commander, 1909-10
William H. Chilton 1941; Grand Captain General, 1953-54
Clinton F. Paige (S102) Binghamton Chapter 139 1861-71
Theodore M. Barber (S) Central City Chapter 70 1893-94
Past High Priests, R.A.M.
75

Herbert W. Greenland (S) Central City Chapter 70 1892
Raymond A. Beacham Central City Chapter 70 1945
Alan J. Morgan (Afil) Riverside Chapter 260 19xx; Grand High Priest 20xx
William G. Vassily Riverside Chapter 260 1997
Lewis T. Paradise, Jr. (L) Riverside Chapter 260 20
Past Illustrious Masters, Cryptic Council (R&SM)
Central City Council No. 13
Theodore M. Barber (S) 1889-1904
Herbert W. Greenland (S) 1905-06
(Grand Master, R&SM) 1912
William G. Vassily 1991-92
(Grand Lecturer, CC) 1996-98
(Grand Lecturer Emeritus, CC) 1998
Richard C. Melfi 1999
Leonard J. Jensen 2003-04
Past Thrice Potent Masters, A.A.S.R.
Central City Lodge of Perfection
Clinton F. Paige (S102) Otseningo Bodies 1883-87
Herbert W. Greenland (S) 1900-01
Charles N. Beckendorf (S) 1976-77
Gary S. Hartman (S) 1998-99
Patrick E. Pacini (S) 2001-02
Robert M. Tyrrell (L) 2002-03
Robert J. Locastro (L) 2000-05
Past Sovereign Princes, A.A.S.R.
Council of Princes of Jerusalem
Clinton F. Paige (S102) Otseningo Bodies 1883-95
Theodore M. Barber (S) 1902-04
C. Arthur Shaw (S) 1925-26
Raymond A. Beacham (L) 1948-49
Willard R. Bahn (L) 1978-79
Alan J. Morgan (SR160, Afil 501) 1993-95
Past Most Wise Masters, A.A.S.R.
Central City Chapter of Rose Croix
Clinton F. Paige (S102) Otseningo Bodies 1870-95
Herbert W. Greenland (S) 1902-03
Walter H. Cummings (S)
Gary S. Hartman (S) 1988-89
George A. Anderson III (D) 1989-90
Robert M. Tyrrell (L) 2004-05
Past Commanders-in-Chief, A.A.S.R.
Consistory
Clinton F. Paige (S102) Otseningo Bodies 1867-1902
Theodore M. Barber (S) 1905-08
Walter H. Cummings (S) 1955-56
Gary S. Hartman (S) 2004-05
Past Patrons, Order of the Eastern Star
Chapter No. 219, Liverpool
Green, Manfred D. 1901-07 Moore, Weston V. 1951 Irwin, Kenneth 1981
Petit, Irving 1908-09 Avery, Austin F. 1952 Vine, Earl E. 1982
Price, Frank 1910 Anderson, Henry E. 1953 Proctor, Ivan 1983
Schaeffer, Joseph 1911-14 Hinchcliffe, Robert 1954 Irwin, Kenneth 1984
Sargent, C. J., Rev. 1915-19 Gell, Thomas P. 1955 Proper, Floyd A. 1985
Hardy, M. 1920 Anderson, Henry E. 1956 Rosa, Frank 1986
Sargent, C. J., Rev. 1921 Vine, Earl E. 1957 Altenburg, Paul 1987
Tucker, Irvin L. 1922-23 Nigro, Alfred 1958-59 Rogers, Clark E., Sr. 1988
Manzer, Lewis 1924-25 Vine, Earl E. 1960 Sutton, David K. 1989
Tucker, Irvin L. 1926-28 Nigro, Alfred 1961 Rosa, Frank 1990
Manzer, Lewis 1929-30 Duerr, Wayne E. 1962 Rogers, Clark E., Sr. 1991
Grimshaw, Ralph 1931 Barbery, James W. 1963 Chester, Harold L. 1992
Greenleaf, Ned P. 1932 Wild, Robert S. 1964 Harrison, Roger B. 1993
Manzer, Lewis 1933 Hiepler, Frederick 1965 Rosa, Frank 1994
Tucker, Irvin L. 1934 Wyker, Frederick H. 1966 Jamieson, Charles O. 1995
Kenrick, Leslie J. 1935 Hiepler, Frederick 1967 Barber, Carl R. 1996
Robinson, Kenneth W. 1936-37 Chester, Harold L. 1968 Sutton, David K. 1997
Thomas, Richard T. 1938 Ward, Richard J. 1969 Rosa, Frank 1998
Duck, Orman D. 1939 Bloss, Cole 1970 1999
Robinson, Kenneth W. 1940 Tomeny, Raymond S. 1971 2000
Thomas, Richard T. 1941 Stone, Richard J. 1972 2001
Anderson, Henry E. 1942 Merrill, E. John 1973 2002
Beahan, Charles J. 1943 Chester, Harold L. 1974 2003
Anderson, Henry E. 1944-45 Lee, Alfred E. 1975 2004
Rogers, John P. 1946 Hunt, Francis 1976 2005
Tucker, Irvin L. 1947 Tomeny, Raymond S. 1977 2006
Anderson, Henry E. 1948 Camerson, Chandler 1978 2007
76

Pare, W. Karl 1949 Merrill, E. John 1979 2008
Rogers, John P. 1950 Lyon, David 1980 2009
Liverpool Chapter No. 219 became Liverpool-Baldwinsville Chapter No. 219
Past Potentates of Tigris Shrine, A.A.O.N.M.S.
Herbert W. Greenland (Ziyara Temple, Utica) - 1920
Fred Mylcrest
Harold Roderick
Alfred V. Valkenberg
Carlton E. Swanker (Honorary)
Frank Mazzye - (Afil 1999)
Paul J. Altenberg - 1997
William Cianciolla, Jr. (Afil 1998) - 1998
Roger B. Harrison - 1999
Arthur Hook - (Afil 1999) – 2000
Frank Rosa - 2007
Dedicated Service Awards
1975 Jarrett, Chester L. 501 1986 Hawks, Alllison E. 525
1977 Vine, Earl L. 525 1986 Middleton, Lloyd A. 501
1978 Forkhamer, Edw. A. 957 1988 Knight, Arthur E. 525
1979 Lucas, John P. 957 1990 Rockdashil, Willard J. 525
1979 Raaflaub, William I. 501 1991 Edwards, Sylvester E. 501
1980 Mazza, Joseph D. 525 1992 Tomeny, Raymond S. 525
1983 Smith, Sawdon S. 525 1994 Reed, George F. 501
1984 Frederick, Walter M. 957 1996 Munson, Gerald E. 525
1985 Zorn, Theodore 501 Barber, Carl R. 525
Gray, Charles A. (S) 1977
Bahn, Willard R. (L) 1980
Anderson, George A. (S) 2000
Tyrrell, Robert M. (L) 2004
Gray, Charles A. (S) 1982
Hartman, Gary S. (S) 1990
Bahn, Willard R. (L) 1992
Dedicated Service Awards - A.A.S.R.
Meritorious Service Awards A.A.S.R.
Honorary Members
Stanton, F. H. Jul 6, 1868 Chaplain
Chase, Nathan Dec 25, 1876
Chapin, William A. Dr. Feb 25, 1878
Wood, G. C. Rev. Dec 29, 1879 Chaplain
Rooney, D. M. Dec 15, 1884 Chaplain, Affil fm Boonville 165
Swanker, Carlton E.
Potentate, Tigris Shrine
Blank, Sheldon K. May 18, 1992 Grand Master 1992-93
Henningsen, Gary A. Sep 11/19, 1994 Grand Master 1993-94
Minutes
The Minutes of Liverpool Lodge No. 525, F&AM, are intact from its inception, including the last Minute Book of Gilboa Lodge No.
259, I.O.O.F. The minutes are noteworthy for their ‘lack of interest’ up to Oct 13, 1864, other than some items of historical interest.
For the most part they record Lodge business and do not mention or allude to local, state or national events. A few entries of some
of the early minutes are extracted following:
Aug 26, 1862 - (The First Regular Communication of Liverpool Lodge U.D.)
Six Petitions were presented and committees appointed.
" . . . On motion of A. B. Wells, Resolved that this Lodge adopt the Bye Laws of Syracuse Lodge 501 F&AM for the government of
this Lodge untill further ordered. Except the time shall be Thursday evening."
Sep 4, 1862 - Twelve visiting Brethren from Syracuse Lodge 501 included:
W. .M. . H. H. Chase W. H. Haywood
C. S. Goff James Golding
Rhesa Griffin
R. E. Ellis
James Meldram R. C. Hall
J. Walin Past W. .M. . Lewis E. Joy
E. A. Hudson O. Lyon
(Syracuse Lodge 501 visited on other occasion in this period, sitting in the Chairs and assisting with the conferring of degrees
for the new Lodge and Brothers.)
77

Apr 16, 1863 - "On motion of Bro. J. S. Heath an order of $333.49, $180.00 and $20.00 was made on the Treasury in favor of T. B.
Anderson to reimburse him for expenditures made by him in fitting up the Lodge Room and procuring the Furniture for the same,
including the amount paid the Odd Fellows Lodge for property purchased of them."
Dec 11, 1866 - "The Treasurer reported about $86.00 in the Treasury."
Feb 11, 1867 - "Br. Joseph Palmer presented a request to this € for consent to form a new Lodge at Centreville which was voted by
the € without dissent."
Oct 12, 1868 - "The committee on Territorial Jurisdiction reported that in confirmation with Centreville committee they have agreed
to a line between the two Lodges as follows - Beginning at the creek south of the tollgate on the Brewerton plank [road] kept by
Isaac Patten thence direct to a point between Dunhams & the Joshua Smith's place thence to the Rial Woodward place which is
within the Centreville district thence to the Judge Saul Jones, the Simon Eaton place being in the Liverpool District."
May 10, 1869 - "Br. Baxter presented a bill of $38.00 for 3 chairs for East, West and South."
Lodge Jurisdiction Note
In 1928 Grand Lodge was petitioned by William S. Farmer Lodge for a Masonic Lodge to be organized in the Village of Solvay. The
Charter was granted and this move reduced the potential membership of Liverpool Lodge nearly fifty percent. Consequently
Liverpool Lodge grew slowly but, nevertheless steadily, becoming on of the larger Lodges in the District.
The Grand Lodge directive on jurisdiction relative to William S. Farmer Lodge is quoted herewith:
“Any Lodge now existing or hereafter created in the territorial limits of the Village of Solvay, in the County of Onondaga, shall have
exclusive jurisdiction over all candidates residing within the territorial limits of said village and shall have no jurisdiction whatsoever
over any candidate residing outside such village limits as they now exist.”
This jurisdictional directive during the year 1958 was changed to read as follows:
“Any Lodge now existing or hereafter created in the territorial limits of the Village of Solvay in the County of Onondaga shall have
exclusive jurisdiction over all candidates residing within the territorial limits of said Village, and shall have no jurisdiction whatsoever
over any candidates residing outside such Village limits as they now exist, except that William S. Farmer Lodge No. 1109, Solvay,
New York, shall have concurrent jurisdiction with Liverpool Lodge No. 525, Liverpool, New York, over all candidates in the portion of
the area now under the jurisdiction of Liverpool Lodge No. 525, Liverpool, New York, which is west of the east town line on the Town
of Geddes, Onondaga County, and south of the New York State Thruway.”
This was the only instance in Onondaga District where a concurrent jurisdiction existed except in the City of Syracuse.
The Royal Canadian Mounted Police
On 29 Apr 1939, 6000 Master Masons gathered at the New York State Fair
Coliseum to witness an exemplification of the Third Degree. The Royal
Canadian Mounted Police Degree Team in full dress uniform gave an amazing
performance.
Syracuse Lodges invited this team, but the Fair Grounds being in the Liverpool
Lodge’s jurisdiction at that time, the Liverpool Lodge Officers, under W.’.
Warren S. Pease, held a Special Communication and opened the meeting in
due form. A large number of high ranking dignitaries from Canada were
present. W.’. Sgt. J. Delmar Graham of Builders Lodge No. 177, Ottawa,
Canada, was in charge of this degree team. Brother Graham paid a visit to
Liverpool Lodge on 2 Dec 1940. For more on the Mounties and Freemasonry
see: http://www.canadianpolicedegreeteam.com/team.html .
Biographies
Ward Wellington Ward - Lodge No. 379, Raised 3 Mar 1919, age 41 (b. ca 1878; died 6 Aug 1932, at age 54, per the Register of
Liverpool Lodge No. 525.)
http://syracusethenandnow.org/Architects/WWWard/WWWard.htm
A young architect, Ward Wellington Ward, moved from New York City to Syracuse, New York, in
1908 to practice architecture. During the next eighteen years, he designed over 200 private
residences in upstate New York. Most of these works stand today as eloquent testimony to Ward's
talent and show him to be a figure of historical importance within the Arts and Crafts movement in
America.
Ward was born in Chicago in 1875 (ca 1878), son of William D. and Emma Hart Ward who were
natives of England. Ward grew up in Detroit where he attended public schools. From 1894 to 1897
he studied architecture at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology but did not receive a
degree. During these years he met his future wife, Maude Moyer, of Syracuse, who was a student
at the Boston Conservatory of Music. The Wards married in 1900 and moved to New York City
where he practiced architecture. His only known design from these years was a residence and
78

stables for Mrs. H. G. Curry, built at Magnolia, Massachusetts in 1905 and destroyed by fire in recent years.
An early H. A. Moyer Carriage >
The couple finally settled in Maude Ward's hometown, Syracuse, in 1908. Her father,
Harvey A. Moyer, the manufacturer of carriages and the Moyer automobile, was a prominent
businessman and social figure whose influence probably helped Ward obtain his earliest
commissions. Soon, however, Ward was flourishing on his own. In 1914, after designing
residences for more than ninety clients, Ward built his home and studio, Lemoyne Manor, on
land across from his father-in-law's estate, Moyerdale (now home to Breese Chevrolet), in
Liverpool, a suburb of Syracuse. There the Wards lived, worked, and raised their only child,
Peggy. Remnants of Ward's Lemoyne Manor can still be seen near the entrance of the large
motel-restaurant complex of the same name constructed around the original building after
World War II.
Two-thirds of Ward's houses are in the City of Syracuse, most of them on scattered sites, but some concentrated in certain areas
developed in the 1920's, notably those of the Scottholm, Sedgwick Farms, Berkeley Park, and Onondaga Park. Occasionally Ward
designed a house in such other upstate towns as Ilion, Watertown, Gouverneur, Baldwinsville, Liverpool, and Manlius. In 1912, he
was called upon by three Oneida Community Ltd. executives to design their new residences in Sherrill. Ward presented his ideas to
his clients in very attractive pen and watercolor sketches. These architectural renderings and perspectives are drawn with great skill
and command attention in their own right as works of art. Ward had a virtuoso talent for producing these studies quickly and in great
numbers.
Though Ward mainly designed private residences, he occasionally worked in other genres. In Syracuse, he designed an addition to
the Henry Schmeer Box Factory in 1911 (since demolished) and "Sherbrook," an apartment building for George Wilson on Walnut
Avenue in 1914. He also extensively remodeled several historic houses and their interiors in Syracuse, most notably a Greek revival
house of the 1830's at Salt Springs Road and East Genesee Street for Harry Burhans in 1916, and an Italianate house on Highland
Avenue for Donald Dey in 1919. In 1916, he remodeled the Romanesque St. Paul's Paris House, built in Oswego in 1871
(demolished in 1978). Ward's last known design, dated 1926, was for Dr. F. K. Holzworth in Rochester. In that year his career
ended abruptly. He became ill and was hospitalized for six years before he died.
Fayetteville Lodge No. 578
Fayetteville, New York
24 Jun 1865 –
Dispensation: 28 Mar 1865, under dispensation from the Grand Lodge of the State of New York, dated 1 Mar 1865, a group of
Master Masons held a meeting in the George C. Gilson rooms. Meetings were held every Tuesday evening at 7 pm for twelve
months a year. The initiation fee was $20 and the dues were $2 per year, paid quarterly. If a Brother was one year in arrears, he
was dropped from the rolls. No member was permitted to speak by twice upon the same subject. As a Masonic duty, every member
was to report all unmasonic conduct of other members “especially the vices of intemperance and profanity.” These rules were
contained in the first by-laws of the Lodge.
Some of the Brothers who signed the by-laws in 1865 were probably relatives of the natives of Fayetteville and Manlius:
Barney, George
Baton, L. H.
Beard, Huntington
Bostwick, J. Weston
Burham, Albert
Crocker, E. J.
Darling, Francis A.
Charter:
Eaton, James D.
Eberling, Fred
Gage, Henry
Hale, Charles E.
Knapp, H. A.
Nichols, H. A.
Nichols, Thomas D.
Pratt, Henry S.
Reals, Fred
Reals, George
Taylor, I. A.
Terwilliger, John
Tibbetts, Frank M.
24 Jun 1865: Hiram Wood, Master; Henry S. Pratt, Senior Warden and Dr. Frank M. Byington, Junior Warden.
Meeting Places: The Lodge held meetings in rooms rented from George Gilson until 18 May 1866, when it was decided to
procure Brother (Dr.) Frank M. Byington’s rooms in connection with the Good Templars, and “that a tax of $3.00 be ordered upon
each member for the purpose of paying expenses of the same.” On 2 Oct 1866 Bro. Byington reported that $500 was pledged to
secure and furnish rooms above his store to be used as the Lodge rooms. On 15 Jan 1867 it was decided to refuse the Good
Templars request to use the Lodge rooms for another year. No details were given as to why this action was taken.
The Lodge later removed it meetings to rented quarters in the Howard Block in Limestone Plaza.
8 Mar 1826 – The building committee reported favorably on the Emma Beard Homestead at 116 East Genesee Street, and the
property was purchased for $15,000. With a down payment of $1,500, a committee was appointed to raise funds to finance the
purchase. The first meeting in the new quarters was held on 7 Sep 1926. This red brick mansion served well for 41 years and also
as the meeting place of Fayetteville Chapter No. 107, Order of the Eastern Star, and Military Court No. 114, Order of the Amaranth.
On 9 Dec 1950 that mortgage was paid off and the mortgage “burned” at the annual meeting of Fayetteville Lodge No. 578. With the
passage of time, the Lodge grew in membership and prospered. The Beard Mansion was reaching a point where it could no longer
be economically maintained. In 1967 a progressive and farsighted membership began work on planning for a new Masonic Temple
on the same site. The Beard Mansion was demolished and construction of the present Temple began.
This new Temple was dedicated on 20 Apr 1968, with larger, more modern facilities. Additional tenet organizations included Mount
Sinai Lodge No. 864 and Syracuse Assembly No. 2, Order of the Rainbow for Girls. A dinner was held on 15 Jun 1975 to “burn” the
mortgage of this new Temple and to celebrate the 110th anniversary of the Lodge.
79

Extracts from the Minutes
16 Oct 1866 Resolutions on the death of a Brother were published in the Fayetteville Record. These resolutions were quite
lengthy and almost impossible to miss when reading the paper.
At this meeting it was resolved to change the meeting nights from Tuesday to the first and third Tuesdays of each month.
21 May 1867 A committee was appointed to “call on Brother [Charles] Baker and demand the Lodge money in his possession.”
Nothing is noted as to what led up to this action.
4 Jun 1867 “On motion resolved that Fayetteville Lodge objected to Military Lodge conferring the degrees on Charles Tremain.”
18 Jun 1867 “Report of the committee appointed to see Brother Baker reports that he intends to hand in the Lodge money at the
first opportunity.”
2 Jul 1867 Military Lodge asked permission to confer the degree on Charles Tremain. “On motion resolved that we will not
consent.”
16 Jul 1867 “For the information of the Lodge I now state that Brother Doc. Baker has handed me the Lodge money that was in
his possession.” S. Taylor, Secretary.
17 Apr 1868 “Brother Sines was raised to the sublime degree of Master Mason.”
7 May 1868 “Brother Sines applied for a dimit which was granted him.”
7 Jul 1868 Seventeen brothers were stricken from the rolls for non-payment of dues.
During the years 1868 and 1869, twenty four candidates were rejected from joining this Lodge. Three candidates were rejected on
one night – 7 Jul 1868.
6 Oct 1868 The same motion on which 17 brothers were stricken from the rolls on 7 July was again brought up, and this time
the motion was defeated. (If only the old minute books could talk!)
16 Mar 1869 A committee was appointed to settle the dispute between Brothers Gage and Worden.
20 Jan 1874 The word “watches” was first noted at this meeting. The meaning of this word was that if a Brother was sick and
needed constant attention, one or tow members, as the need may have been, would sit up all night with the ailing Brother. This was
intended to relieve the family of watching the patient 24 hours a day. For this “watch” service the Lodge paid the “watcher” $2.00 per
night. In some cases this procedure was rather costly. A bill of $60 was rendered to the Lodge for watching a Brother.
7 Mar 1876 A period of hard times are noted in the tone of the minutes. The trend of the Lodge was downhill, both financially
and in membership. The entire year of 1876 revealed a low ebb in Masonic interest. On some meeting nights, there were not
enough present to open Lodge. The Tyler’s salary was cut from $1 to 50 cents. The minutes are nil.
From the minutes – “It was moved and seconded that the W.’.M.’. communicate with the District Deputy Grand Master and state
condition of the Lodge and see if the Grand Lodge will refund the dues for this year. It was moved and seconded that the trustees be
authorized to borrow $100 for a few months.”
2 May 1876 The M.’.W.’. appointed a committee to receive contributions to defray the expenses of the funeral of W. M. Bishop.
2 Jan 1877 Initiation fee dropped from $25 to $20 . . . Sometime between 1876 and 1879 the Byington Block came into the
hands of Charles Baker. At least the rent was paid to Bro. Baker with no mention being made of ever changing their Lodge rooms.
During the greater part of 1879, one meeting per month was held.
In 1880, jurisdictional disputes began to crop up between East Syracuse and Fayetteville. Committees from the two Lodges met but
the result of their findings do not appear in the minutes.
17 Apr 1883 39 members were notified that they had been unaffiliated for non-payment of dues.
In 1888 Fayetteville Lodge had weathered the depression and was on the upgrade both in members and money.
It must be noted here that two books containing the minutes of the meetings from 1889 to 1900 cannot be found. These may have
been lost while moving from the old Temple to the present one.
1910-1917 Jurisdiction line were more or less disregarded in accepting applications. The Lodge would accept a candidate,
initiate, pass and raise him, and then think about whether or not he was in their jurisdiction; only if another Lodge brought it to their
attention. The result: lengthy correspondence, bad feelings, paying the initiation fees from one Lodge to another and sometimes
Grand Lodge had to step into the dispute (21 Jun 1910).
Ca 1910 the Lodge rooms were used by the Forester, G.A.R., Grangers, Good Templars and Eastern Star. All but the Star paid rent
to the Lodge.
17 Nov 1914 A petition was received containing the names of several Brothers residing in Minoa asking permission to form a new
Lodge in that village. On the following meeting the petition was rejected.
16 Jan 1917 Jurisdictional disputes still continued. So much so that an Isaac Swartz was paid $15 for surveying jurisdictional line
between Fayetteville and East Syracuse. 17 Apr 1917 our representative to the Grand Lodge Convention was instructed to notify the
Grand Lodge of our difficultly with Onondaga County.
During WWI the Lodge purchased Liberty Bonds, War Savings Stamps, contributed to various relief organizations and remitted the
dues of our Brothers serving in the Military Forces.
80

6 Dec 1921 “A communication was received from duly qualified Master Masons living in Minoa or thereabouts petitioning
Fayetteville Lodge for a letter of dispensation, to empower them to assemble as a regular Lodge.” At the following meeting is was
noted to grant their request with this provision: “that said Brothers shall pay into the treasury of Fayetteville Lodge the sum of $4
each for their assessment of the next four years to the Soldiers and Sailors Hospital Fund, pledged by the Lodge.”
During the years of WWII comparatively few petitions were received, but immediately after the was, degree work was the order of
business at almost every meeting. During 1946 28 joined our Lodge, and in 1947 14 more were initiated. In 1946 a special
dispensation was obtained to initiate a class of ten candidates at one time. The Fellow Craft Degree was exemplified by the Shrine
Field Ban in the Municipal Hall on 2 Nov 1946.
Fayetteville Lodge No. 579, 1865 to 1950
compiled by Arvin H. Almquist, PM; edited by Bro. David U. Wells, Jan 1992.
Fayetteville Lodge is proud of its past Grand Lodge appointments:
R.’.W.’. George Parkhust, Grand Sword Bearer
R.’.W.’. Albert Saunders, District Deputy Grand Master
R.’.W.’. Roger Prehn, Grand Director of Ceremonies
W.’. William Fraser received the 33rd Degree in 1970 from the Supreme Council, AASR, NMJ.
Centerville Lodge No. 648
North Syracuse, New York
18 Jul 1867 – May 9, 2002 the first meeting of Memorial Lodge No. 648 F&AM took place.
Petition Date:
Petitioners:
Baker, Hiram Salt Springs Lodge No. 520
Baum, Artemus Fort Brewerton Lodge No. 256
Baum, Isaac Syracuse Lodge No. 102
Carpenter, Charles Enterprise Lodge No. 48 (NJ?)
Conway, John Salt Springs Lodge No. 520
Hicks, Russell Phoenix Lodge (Callimachus No. 369?)
Lillie, Stephen Fort Brewerton Lodge No. 256
Mosher, John Salt Springs Lodge No. 520
Palmer, Joseph Fort Brewerton Lodge No. 256
Russell, Lewis Scriba Lodge No. 414
Dispensation Date: Feb 1867
Charter Date: 18 Jul 1867
Charter Officers:
Charter Members: ???
Meeting Places:
1. The first meetings were held in a building owned by Artemus Baum at a rent of $17.50 per year.
2. In April 1870 the Lodge moved to the upper room of the school house on South Main Street, where they continued to meet until a
new Lodge room was completed and dedicated 7 Dec 1872.
3. Bro. Isaac Baum constructed the basement and first floor of a building on the corner of South Main and Church Streets. The
Lodge erected the second floor and the roof at a total cost of $1074. In 1910 the Lodge bought the lower part of the building, and on
1 Jul 1911 voted to sell the building and purchase the lot on which they erected a new Masonic Temple.
4. The first meeting in the new Temple at 137 Church Street was held on 3 Jan 1913; the cornerstone was set and the building
dedicated on 9 Oct 1914. The Village of North Syracuse demolished the old Temple, ca 2003:
NORTH SYRACUSE COMMITTEE SAYS MASONIC BUILDING SHOULD FALL;
TEARING DOWN LANDMARK FOR A PARKING LOT WOULD BE CHEAPEST OF FIVE OPTIONS. (Neighbors Northeast)
From: The Post-Standard (Syracuse, NY), 3 Jan 2002.
At the Dec. 27 village board meeting, North Syracuse trustees were presented with options on what the village should do about the
old Masonic building on 137 Church St. The building, formerly known as Centerville Lodge No. 648, was built by local Masons in
1912. The village bought the property in 1997 with plans to either renovate it and use it for village offices or use it in other ways.
The "137 Church Street Committee" was formed in September, with the goal of looking into the most cost-effective way of using the
property adjacent . . .
VILLAGE TAKES A LOOK AT SALE OF VACANT LOT;
MASONIC TEMPLE BUILDING IS TORN DOWN, VILLAGE EXAMINES ITS OPTIONS. (Neighbors Northeast)
From: The Post-Standard (Syracuse, NY), 29 Jan 2004
The village of North Syracuse is waiting to find out how much the vacant lot at 137 Church St. is worth now that the old Masonic
Temple is gone. The three-floor brick building was built in 1912 and has been vacant since January 1997. In the past, the village
board discussed moving a teen center into the building, but eventually voted to demolish it. "I would like us to put it in real estate
hands," said Trustee Gary Rainbow. Rainbow suggested the village board sell the property . . .
5. In 1997 the new Masonic Memorial Center was erected at 648 Centerville Place, adjacent to the old Temple, and dedicated,
where they were joined, as tenants, by the Central City Bodies, Valley of Syracuse, A.A.S.R.
81

Baum, Isaac 1867
Palmer, Joseph 1868
Russell, Lewis 1869
Collins, W. Harvey 1870
Baker, Hiram 1871-74
Stephens, George 1875
Baker, Hiram 1876
Brown, L. Harris 1877-80
Sadler, Russell Z. 1881-82
Baker, Hiram 1883
Sadler, Russell Z. 1884-85
Brown, L. Harris 1886-88
Reese, Burton J. 1889-90
Sampson, Ernest S. 1891-92
Sotherden, Thomas C. 1893-94
Smiley, Fred L. 1895-96
Shepard, J. Wesley 1897-00
Conway, Ernest 1901-03
McKinley, Irving 1904-06
Stearns, Charles 1907
Shepard, Frank 1908-09
Tripp, Allen G. M.D. 1910-11
Conner, George W. 1912
Sotherden, Frank 1913-14
Melvin, Myron S. 1915-16
Sotherden, Alvin J. 1917-18
Thayer, Fred 1919
Strever, Alfred J. 1920-21
Smith, Dwight R. 1922-23
Curtis, Elisha H. 1924
Edwards, Harry A. 1925
Stokes, Fred 1926-27
Asselstine, Earl L. 1928
Dence, Clarence J. 1929
Down, W. LeClare 1930
McHuron, Ernest L. 1931
Past Masters
Hazard, Charles L. 1932
McPhee, Clyde H. 1933
Viel, Frank 1934
Blankman, Harold J. 1935
Pearson, F. Allen 1936
Manchester, Irving W. 1937
Harvey, Arthur L. 1938
Viel, Willard 1939
Sears, Fred R. 1940
Talmadge, Ernest C. 1941
Harris, Paul T. 1942
Down, George L. 1943
Sotherden, Donald V. 1944
Groves, Floyd 1945
Lewis, Clane 1946
Molesky, Leo 1947
Hicks, Alfred J. 1948
Baylis, Douglas 1949
Thayer, Orrin J. 1950
Watrous, Ira 1951
Bunto, Hiram 1952
Smith, Earl 1953
Harvey, Donald 1954
Shavalier, Fred 1955
Sheely, Donald 1956
Gerhardt, Herbert N. 1957
Cook, Paul H. 1958
Belanger, Malcolm 1959
Schneider, Karl 1960
Milback, Lee 1961
Kelsey, Harry 1962
Gilbert, Donald 1963
Pattat, Harlow 1964
Wilson, Milford 1965
Jaquay, Robert 1966
LeClair, Harold B. 1967
Grand Lodge Officers
1968
1969
1970
1971
1972
Walker, Charles J. 1973
1974
1975
Marsh, Stewart H. 1976
Warwick, Billy E. 1977
1978
Tomb, Clark E. 1979
Herrick, Robert A. 1980
Greene, Frederick D. 1981
Carr, Harold H. 1982
Gibbs, Gerald L. 1983
Christo, Chris 1984
Shirk, Raymond 1985
Naumann, H. Bruce 1986
1987
Deischer, Paul E. 1988
Arthur, Richard J. 1989
Simonds, Howard F. Jr. 1990
1991
1992
Parker, Karl D. 1993-94
Mantia, Robert T. 1994-95
Fergerson, Alfred 1995-96
1996-97
1997-98
1999-00
2000-01
2001-02
see Memorial Lodge No. 648
Ernest F. Conway District Deputy Grand Master 1924-25
Fred R. Sears Assistant Grand Lecturer 1941-42; District Deputy Grand Master 1942-43
Junior Grand Warden 1958-60 Grand Representative. to Vermont 1962
A. Theodore Haines District Deputy Grand Master 1943-44
Samuel G. McKnight District Deputy Grand Master 1944-45
Alfred J. Hicks Assistant Grand Lecturer 1950-51; District Deputy Grand Master 1951-52
Paul H. Cook Assistant Grand Lecturer 1961-63; District Deputy Grand Master 1965-66
Gordon W. Knapp Grand Chaplain 1968-70
Sheldon R. Bishop Assistant Grand Lecturer 1972-73; District Deputy Grand Master 1973-74
Edward J. Sinay Assistant Grand Lecturer 1977-78; District Deputy Grand Master 1979-80
Frederick D. Greene District Deputy Grand Master 1984-85
Raymond A. Shirk Grand Director of Ceremonies 1987-88
Floyd F. Mason Grand Rep. to Philippines 1987-88
Richard J. Arthur Grand Sword Bearer 1992-94
Ronald H. LeClair Assistant Grand Lecturer 1996-98
Carl D. Parker District Deputy Grand Master 1998-00
Gary A. Kall Assistant Grand Lecturer 2002-04; District Deputy Grand Master 2004-06
Kevin Parker Assistant Grand Lecturer 2006-07
A. Theodore Haines Alfred J. Hicks Paul H. Cook Ernest F. Conway Fred R. Sears
82

Sapphire Lodge No. 768
Camillus, New York
13 Jun 1876 –
CAMILLUS was originally Township Number Five of the Military Tract. At the organization of the county it was included in the town
of Marcellus, from which it was formed into a separate town March 8, 1799. A part of Onondaga was annexed to it in 1834.
This village is situated in a picturesque spot in the valley of Nine-Mile Creek. It is on the "Old Road," or Auburn branch of the New
York Central Railroad, distant nine miles from the city of Syracuse. A "side cut" or "feeder" of the Erie Canal extends to the village,
and the Nine-Mile Creek supplies an excellent water-power, which attracted settlers and began to be utilized for mill purposes at an
early period. In 1806 the first mills of importance were erected in the village.
http://history.rays-place.com//ny/onon-camillus.htm
During the summer and fall of 1875, a few brethren of the Masonic Order interested themselves in the formation of a Lodge of Free
and Accepted Masons in this village. After the usual formalities, a dispensation was granted by Grand Master, Elwood E. Thorne,
which was delivered on December 31, 1875; a charter was granted by the Grand Lodge on the 13th of June, 1876, and Sapphire
Lodge No. 768 was formed with twenty-one charter members, as follows:
Bucklin, William B.
Burdick, H. D.
Burdick, Lafayette
Cook, S. H. Sr.,
Fish, T. A.
Glynn, E. R.
Hinsdale, A. L.
Petition Date:
Petitioners:
Dispensation: 31 Dec 1875
Charter: 13 Jun 1876
Hopkins, A. R.
Hopkins, S. L.
Larkin, E. D.
Lyboult, J. Harvey
Owens, T. V.
Paddock, J. H.
Paddock, J.
Safford, Clarence S.
Sherwood, E. D.
Shoens, Thomas H.
Skinner, E. C.
Skinner, Merril
Slocum, J. O.
Sweet, Cyrus
Charter Officers: Thomas H. Shoens, Master; married Agnes I. Fish, 5 Feb 1873. She was born 14 Feb 1842, died 8 Aug
1896, the daughter of George B. Fish, b. 13 Nov 1813, Marcellus, Onondaga Co., d. 10 Mar 1885, Amboy, NY, and Orvilla Isham, b.
bef 1830 ( http://www.zodiacal.com/barbarowa/trees/getperson.php?personID=I119700&tree=Brainard )
First officers: T. H. Shoens, W. M.; J. H. Lyboult, S. W.; T. A. Fish, J. W.; E. D. Sherwood, Treasurer; C. S. Safford, Secretary; C. E.
White, S. D.; W. B. Bucklin, J. D.; H. D. Corwin, Tiler.
Meetings were held once a week until the start of the war years.
The Lodge had nicely furnished rooms in the third story of the Harmon Block, fitted up at an expense of nearly $1,000, the
membership having increased from twenty-one in 1876, to forty-five in 1878.
Officers for 1878: J. Harvey Lyboult, W. M.; C. E. White, S. W.; C. W. Darling, J. W.; E. E. Veeder, Treasurer; C. S. Safford,
Secretary; W. B. Bucklin, I. D.; H. Abrams, J. D.; G. T. Downer, S. M. C.; L. Richmond, Jr., J. M. C.; H. T. Corwin, Tiler. Trustees: M.
L. Hay, E. D. Sherwood, J. 0. Slocum.
30 Dec 1892 First public installation of officers was conducted.
8 Jun 1900 Sapphire Lodge placed a cornerstone in the Northeast corner of the Town Building, in memory of Brother Hiram D.
Corium.
5 Mar 1908 The decision was made to purchase the Munro lot on Main Street, Camillus, for the purpose of building a Masonic
Temple. On 12 Mar 1908 the incorporation papers were signed.
26 Nov 1908 Lodge voted unanimously to permit the Order of the Eastern Star to use the Lodge rooms.
18 Dec 1915 The cornerstone was laid for the new Masonic Temple and a dedication ceremony was held.
20 Dec 1923 Worshipful Stephen Breed reported on his trip to Washington, DC, where he attended the laying of the cornerstone
of the Washington Memorial.
7 Jul 1927 The Lodge voted to build an addition to the Temple. On 7 Feb 1828 a social evening was held for the dedication of
the new addition.
5 Mar 1942 Contributions began for the New York State Masonic War Chest and aid to the nearby air field were made.
21 Oct 1943 Lodge presented plaques to members of the Lodge who had sons in the armed services.
Jul 1945 Arthur H. Pneuman received his three degrees by special dispensation in three consecutive weeks. Bro. Pneuman
was home on leave after being a POW in Germany.
83

6 May 1976 W.’. Harry Stone, Secretary, received the Dedicated Service Award for his outstanding and untiring service.
15 Jun 1976 By proclamation of the Town of Camillus, 26 Jun 1976 was Sapphire Lodge Masonic Day in Camillus.
26 Jun 1976 The Lodge celebrated its 100th Anniversary, presenting the Grand Master, M.’.W.’. Albert W. Schneider, with an
Honorary Membership in the Lodge.
Past Masters:
Shoens, Thomas H. 1876-77
Lyboult, J. Harvey 1878-79
Larkin, Edwin D. 1880
Darling, Charles D. 1881-82
Veeder, Ekiakim E. 1883-84
Kellog, Ovand J. 1885-88
Bucklin, William B. 1889
Safford, Clarence S. 1890
Ellis, Earl E. 1891-92
Darling, Edgar E. 1893-94
Kelsey, George A. 1895
Sebring, Edwin 1896-97
Sanders, Charles H. 1898-99
Kelsey, George A. 1901
Darling, Edgar S. 1902
Ellis, Earl E. 1903
Sebring, Edwin 1904
Kasson, Vernon D. 1905-07
Forward, Hervey D. 1908
Taylor, George D. 1909
Sanders, Charles H. 1910
Stanton, Maurice A. 1911
Horringan, George I. 1912
Gorham, William B. 1913
Peck, W. Leroy 1914
Richards, Charles O. 1915
Smith, Ernest O. 1916
Vedder, Edwin L. 1917
Button, Albert S. 1918
Crossley, Morris R. 1919
Sanders, Stephen D. 1920
Timmins, William D. 1921
Moore, Ernest D. 1922
Breed, Stephen D. 1923
Hardy, John C. 1924
Lovell, Earl P. 1925
Lovell, Gilbert 1926
Williams, Burdette 1927
Crossley, Morris R. 1928
Merriam, Leroy F. 1929
Crossley, Morris R. 1930
McLeod, John 1931
Blainey, Herbert F. 1932
Ashby, Frank H. 1933
Palgrove, Joseph 1934
Shadd, Edward 1935
Kinney, Willard F. 1936
Case, J. Glenn, Sr. * 1937
Cross, Lewis B. 1938
Smith, Walter B. * 1939
Lovell, Earl P. 1940
Paddock, Herbert K. 1941
Hinman, Ellis O. 1942
Van Alstine, Abram J. 1943
Breed, Stephen D. 1944
Loffts, William H. 1945
Williams, Burdette 1946
Smith, Walter B. * 1947
Brunton, Perry M. 1948
Lippert, Frederick P. 1949
Hinman, Ellis O. 1950
Upcraft, Milton J. 1951
Raymond, Melbourne L. 1952
Case, J. Glen, Jr. 1953
Pietsen, Albert J. * 1954
Steele, Lloyd 1955
Sewell, William 1956
Brown, Theodore K. 1957
St. Denny, George 1958
Wolcott, Hubert E. 1959
Joslin, Harry, Jr. 1960
O’Tier, John J. 1961
Stone, Harry W. * 1962
Van Alstine, Elston A. * 1963
Wenham, Raymond J. 1964
Sipes, Robert F. 1965
Pagano, Anthony J. 1966
Kleeman, Emil 1967
Morrison, David 1968
Teegarden, Klare * 1969
Sherwood, Donald W. 1970
Merritt, Edward D. 1971
Highbrown, Charles W. 1972
Slater, Douglas 1973
Dodge, Paul C. 1974
Sherwood, Keith 1975
Weiss, William C. 1976
* Served additionally as follows:
R.’.W.’. J. Glenn Case, Sr. Grand Sword Bearer
R.’.W.’. Albert J. Pietsen District Deputy Grand Master
R.’.W.’. Walter B. Smith Grand Director of Ceremony
R.’.W.’. Klare Teegarden Grand Steward
R.’.W.’. Elston Van Alstine District Deputy Grand Master
W.’. Harry Stone Dedicated Service Award, 1976
Edited and reformatted from 100th Anniversary, Sapphire Lodge No. 768 1876-1976
written by W.. Paul Hurst
Charles D. Darling was born 23 Mar 1845 in Camillus, New York, and was a resident of Auburn for 22 years. He was a member of
St. Paul’s Lodge No 124 and a Past Master of Sapphire Lodge No. 768. He had two children, Mrs. Edward F. MacEwen of
Cleveland, Ohio, and Fred J. Darling of Buffalo . . . and two grandchildren, Miss Olive MacEwen of Cleveland, and Clyde Darling of
Kent, New York. He died ca 24 Jan 1921 (Saturday morning) at his home on East Genesee Street, Auburn, after a three months
illness and with interment at Soule Cemetery with Masonic Honors.
Eliakim E. Veeder, 1859-'61, President of the Village Board.
Onondaga Lodge No. 802
East Syracuse, New York
1892 –
Gathered in the hay loft of the old Livery Stable of Fred Sterling’s place on Manlius Street, some Brothers were circled around a box
by the light of a lantern, discussing the requirements and possibilities of forming a Masonic Lodge. Included in this meeting were
Brothers:
Albro, S. L.
Bennett, A. W.
Chapman, F. E.
Cole, L. A.
Demon, J. H.
Estes, L. H.
Marshall, Fred A.
Odell, Walter
Parker, James A.
Sarr, M. E.
Smith, S. McK.
Sterling, F. O.
84

Thus was the beginning of Onondaga Lodge No. 802.
The first date we have of any minutes being kept was on 27 Oct 1890 when the above named Brothers met to discuss the
establishing of a Lodge in East Syracuse. It also appeared probable that the hall in the Ball Block, known as the Conductor’s Hall,
could be had at the cost of about $40 per year. On 31 Oct 1890 it was decided to contact the Syracuse Lodges as well as
Fayetteville Lodge No. 578 to get their consent for the forming of a new Lodge.
On 20 Nov 1890 a meeting was called for the purpose of electing officers for the proposed Lodge. There were 22 votes cast with the
following results: S. McK. Smith, Master (who was principal of East Syracuse Schools); F. O. Sterling, Senior Warden; West Bartlett,
Junior Warden. These were the only officers elected at that time.
The question of a name for the Lodge was next in order and the following names were proposed: East Syracuse, DeWitt Clinton,
Onondaga, and Rising Sun. After considerable discussion, it was voted to call the Lodge “East Syracuse Lodge.”
A request for dispensation was asked, but because it was not made before 15 Feb 1891, and not being in at least three months
before Grand Lodge met, the request was not granted at that time. The request, however, was granted on 25 Nov 1891, but only
after the Lodge changed its name, at the request of Grand Lodge. It was then decided the Lodge would be known as Onondaga
Lodge, after our county, and also bringing back to life the name of a former Masonic Lodge by the name of Onondaga No. 98, which
had be organized at Onondaga Valley in 1803, but had ceased to work some years later. It may also be noted that the number was
Onondaga Lodge No. 800 for a little time, but apparently was renumbered shortly after to 802.
About this time a meeting was called to elect a Master, as Bro. Smith had transferred out of town. After the ballots had been
counted, Bro. I. W. Allen was elected Master.
Petition Date: ???
Petitioners:
Dispensation: 25 Nov 1891
Charter Date: ???
Charter Members:
Allen, I. W.
Ames, C. H.
Albro, S. L.
Binning, John
Bartlett, L. M.
Cole, Lewis A.
Cole, Lincoln H.
Cady, Harry
Curtis, I. J.
Chapman, Fred E.
Conway, W. J.
Damon, J. H.
Estes, L. H.
Easterly, Charles A.
Foote, John W.
Hindsdale, A .G.
Kellogg, George A.
Legg, Homer M.
Marshall, Fred A.
Orr, George H.
Orchard, Frank E.
Price, George B.
Richmond, Loren
Rice, A. Smith
Robinson, Virgil
Stryker, Daniel
Sarr, M. E.
Schweiter, Henry
Sterling, F. O.
Strong, William
Tiffany, Henry
Van Alstine, O. A.
Van Alstine, L. M.
Watson, Joseph M.
Charter Officers:
Consecrated:
Relics: ???
21 Jul 1892 by R.’.W.’. Herbert W. Greenland, DDGM of the 19th District.
Consolidated with Centerville Lodge No. 648 to become Memorial Lodge No. 802.
Allen, I. W. 1891-94
Stryker, Daniel 1895
Allen, I. W. 1896
Price, George B. 1897-88
Lehman, D. D. 1899-00
Robinson, Arthur J. 1901-03
Baker, T. R. 1904-05
Bush, W. W. 1906
Marcy, Leon * 1907-08
Martin, Harry 1909-10
Smith, Ray C. 1911
Marsh, A. W. 1912
Peck, Henry C. 1913-14
Studer, A. K. 1915-16
Hodge, R. L. 1917-18
Marsh, H. A. 1919
Studer, F. P. 1920
Buchholz, L. O. 1921
Fay, William W. * 1922-23
Chamberlain, Don G. 1924
Stroup, Harry M. 1925
Van Alstine, Walter 1926
Bedwell, William J. 1927
Past Masters
Cauraugh, Fred 1928-29
Robinson, C. F. 1930
Groat, Roamaine 1931
Adcook, Harold S. 1932
Generous, E. L. 1933
Quonce, George S. 1934
Coon, Lawrence R. * 1935
Pearson, Paul E. 1936
Asquith, A. S. 1937
Nelson, Charles J. 1938
Pell, Herman 1939
Lansing, Walter E. 1940
Bragg, Roy C. 1941
Davis, John R. 1942
Lansing, Willis E. 1943
Peet, Donald S. 1944
Egy, J. Edgar 1945
Pindle, E. Lee 1946
Sharp, Maurice * 1947
Price, Clifton 1948
Egy, William 1949
Irving, Welsey 1950
Becht, Edgar 1951
Shanklin, Robert 1952
Popp, Floyd * 1953
Hale, Duard * 1954
Rhoades, Robert 1955
Knudsen, Robert 1956
Backenstross, Roland 1957
Benjamin, Kenneth 1958
Hyde, Olin 1959
Schneider, Frederick W. 1960
Myers, James A. 1961
Solberg, Richard C. 1962
Sauer, Norman J. 1963
Marsh, James E. 1964
Van Dorpe, Raymond 1965
Rockwood, Willard A. 1966
Trendell, Albert T. 1967
Hawley, Donald R. 1968
Fisher, Thomas D. 1969
Robinson, Ronald W. 1970
Ackerman, Bruce H. * 1971
Yeates, James 1972
Wagner, Donald 1973
Naylor, H. James 1974
85

Mitchell, Robert 1975
Brown, Dana S. 1976
Greabell, Robert * 1977
Walter, Gilbert * 1978
Eggleston, Robert * 1979
Kogler, Robert 1980
Past Secretaries:
Damon, J. H. 1890-98
Bush, W.’. W. W. 1898-01
Richardson, H. E. 1901-07
Greabell, M. J. 1907-10
Dedicated Service Awards
Irving, W.’. Wesley 17 Mar 1977
Counselman, John 03 Apr 1980
Smith, Robert 02 May 1981
DuPree, William * 1981
Cooper, John J. * 1982
Greabell, Robert * 1983
Machell, Charles 1984
Eggleston, Robert * 1985
LaQuay, Richard * 1986-87
Conklin, Dana 1910-14
Notteley, W. J. 1914-19
Marcy, W.’. L. H. 1 to 6 1920
Studer, W.’. A. K. 1920-47
Walter, Webster 19 Apr 1984
Laws, George Sr. 18 May 1988
Smart, Ray May 1989
Fairbank, Ronald 1988
Schneider, Frederick W. 1989
Fairbank, Ronald 1990
DuPree, William * 1991
Brown, Dana S. 1992
Cooper, John (Dep WM)1992
Coon, R.’.W.’. L. R. 1947-53
Sharp, R.’.W.’. M. H. 1953-75
Ackerman, W.’. Bruce H. 1976-86
Eggleston, W.’. Robert 1987-
Mount Sinai Lodge No. 864
Fayetteville, New York
7 May 1908 –
Petition Date:
Petitioners:
Fenner, Dr. Frederick
Freeman, George
Kepelowich, Samuel
Levy, Dr. I. H.
Marquisee, Solomon
Meyer, Dr. Gustave M.
Rubenstein, Moses J.
Samuels, Max
Sauber, Robert
Schwartz, Isaac
Solomon, Dr. Joel
Solomon, Samuel D.
Sugarman, Sigmond
Van Gorder, Winfred H.
Dispensation: 2 Jan 1908; Dispensation Surrendered 15 Apr 1908
Officers:
Chartered: 7 May 1908
Samuel D. Solomon, Master; Frederick Fenner, SW; Isaac Schwartz, JW.
Charter Master: Samuel D. Solomon was installed 28 May 1908 by R.’.W.’. William S. Farmer, and the Lodge was duly Constituted
and Consecrated at this time.
Meeting Places:
Mount Sinai Lodge was instituted under dispensation by M.’.W.’. Townsend Scudder on 22 Jan 1908 at the Syracuse Lodge No. 501
Lodge Room in the Greyhound Block, by R.’.W.’. Jay B. Kline, DDGM.
The first meeting was held in a small hall at 238½ West Fayette Street, which was found to be totally inadequate. The following
meeting of the Lodge was held in the Pythian Hall in the Bastable Block on Thursday nights. On 13 Feb, Burton Michael was
appointed musical director.
On 8 May 1909 the meeting place was changed to the I.O.O.F. Temple.
7 May 1912 the Lodge had their first meeting in their new room at Pythian Hall in the University Block.
Harry S. Bronson was the first Master of the Lodge who was Raised in the Lodge, and he was the first Master elected and installed,
on 2 Jan 1918, in the new Montgomery Street Masonic Hall.
Solomon, Samuel D. 1908-09
Fenner, Dr. Frederick 1910
Schwart, Isaac 1911-13
Van Gorder, Winfred H. 1914-15
Sugarman, Sigmond 1916-17
Bronson, Harry S. 1918-19
Shapiro, Louis 1920-21
Ferrer, A. M. 1922
Morrell, William G. 1923
Ullman, Adolph 1924
Rudolph, B. G. 1925
Jacobson, William A. 1926
Wolfson, Harry 1927
Cohan, Dr. Mortimer 1928
Masters
Klein, Sim B. 1929-30
Merwitz, Milton R. 1931
(records for next 30 years ‘misplaced’)
Joselit, David 1932
Markham, Wolfe 1933
Maxon, Benedict 1934
Schwartz, Abraham B. 1935
Solomon,Harris A. 1936-37
Berman, Leonard M. 1938-39
Rothschild, Gustave 1940
Saul, Alexander L. 1941
Altfield, David S. 1942
Weltmann, Norman 1943
Zausmer, Abraham A. 1944
Birnbaum, Harold L. 1945
Zurett, Irving 1946
Levy, A. Edward 1947
Fisher, Donald M. 1948
Naselli, Joseph B. 1949
Devorsetz, Harold 1950
Brodsky, Jerome 1951
Aronson, Irving 1952
Reiss, Joseph 1953
Goldstein, Louis 1954
Ruberstein, Maurice 1955
Sweedler, Alex 1956
Herr, Jacob 1957
Weiss, Jerome 1958
86

Lessinger, Charles 1959
Weingarten, Philip 1960
Small, Sam 1961
Blumberg, Gabreal 1962
Crown, Lawrence 1963
Reiser, Eugene 1964
Bennett, Lawrence J. 1965
Schwartz, Harry 1966
Birnbaum, Martin 1967
Pine, Harris 1968
Osso, Robert 1969
Freeman, Herbert 1970
Rosenfeld, Elroy 1971
Levy, Ronald 1972
Snyder, Irving 1973
Levine, Arthur 1974
Levy, Ronald 1975
Ziegler, Milton 1976
Wheelock, Avery D. 1977
1978
Hart, Earl L. 1979
Merged with Philo 968 1980
1908 4 Jun Bro. Dr. Meyer removed from the city and Bro. Frank Dellow, Jr., was appointed Secretary.
W.’. Solomon was appointed a member of the Board of Relief to represent the Lodge. The initiation fee was raised to $40. At the
close of the first year there were 55 members.
1909 27 May the first anniversary was celebrated with a reception. SW Fenner presented the Lodge with the original corn,
wine and oil used at its consecration, which was artistically mounted and framed for permanent preservation.
21 Oct Bro. Joseph Rhein removed from the city and Bro. Leo Karp was appointed Tyler in his place.
1910 On 10 Jan Frederick Fenner was installed as Master. An oil painting of W.’. Solomon was ordered in April. The By-Laws
were amended to change the meeting night from Thursday to Wednesday at 8:00 p.m. On 26 May there was a reception and dance
in celebration of the 2nd Anniversary.
1911 4 Jan Isaac Schwartz was installed as Master. In April B. Michael resigned as organist and Prof. H. Vibbard was
appointed in his place. In May the Lodge took a trip to the Masonic Home in Utica by special car. The Lodge ordered an oil painting
of W.’. Fenner.
1912 George E. Pabst was appointed organist. W.’. Schwartz organized a Fellowcraft Club to promote new interest in the
Lodge, with B. G. Rudolph as Chairman. The new club entertained the officers of the Lodge, held an outing at Long Branch Park
and formed a Fellowcraft Team for the Third Degree. The original officers of the Lodge worked the First Degree on 31 Jan. W.’.
Solomon, W.’. Schwartz and N. J. Phillips were appointed a committee pertaining to the new Syracuse Masonic Temple, then being
planned to be built. For a more complete account of the Syracuse Masonic Temple, see further details under Central City Lodge No.
305 above. On 25 Sep the initiation fee was raised to $50. The Lodge purchased costumes for the Third Degree drama.
1915 W.’. Schwartz was elected Secretary. In October the Master appointed a committee for Laying the Cornerstone of the
new Masonic Temple: W.’.s Solomon and Gorder, and Bros. Sugarman, Bronson and Phillips. The Masonic Club held an open
house in celebration of this on 3 Nov 1915. On 16 Dec Charter Member Bro. Samuel Kopelowich passed to the Celestial Lodge
Above.
1916 The Lodge ordered a quartette for all degrees. The new Temple was opened for inspection on 30 May. The original
officers conferred the Third Degree on 7 Jun and Bro. Walter H. Scammel of Tully Lodge was made on Honorary Member of Mount
Sinai Lodge. On 3 Jul and emergent communication was called to attend the funeral of W.’. Fenner, a Charter Member and Past
Master of the Lodge. At the request of W.’. Fenner, the Past Master’s Jewel presented to him was presented to the Lodge and was
placed in a frame.
1917 The United States had entered the First World War and the Lodge bought Liberty Bonds. In September the Grand
Lodge convened; honor was ordered for War Service of all Masons. Mount Sinai Lodge passed a motion to present Masonic rings to
each Brother who joined the service. SW, Robert Sauber, died in Dunkirk, NY on 2 December. Bros. Sugarman, Bronson and
Shapiro went to Buffalo for the Masonic funeral; Perseverance Lodge acted with the Lodge and also furnished cars. On 25 and 28
Dec a special dispensation was given to confer the three Degrees in one night on soldiers.
1918 In January the Lodge issued its first bulletin and Bro. Timmons gave a very interesting program on the American Flag.
The first Masonic Ball was held on Washington’s birthday. 13, 20 and 27 Mar special dispensation again obtained to confer three
degrees on soldiers. 14 Apr there was an emergent communication to attend the funeral of W.’. Swartz, one of the largest ever held
at the Masonic Temple; standing room only. On 22 May W.’. Wm. H. H. Chamberlain gave the Masters a dinner at the Onondaga
Hotel to plan War Relief work. .M.’.W.’. Wm. S. Farmer was present. Mt. Sinai Lodge gave $1320 to the Fund - $360 over their
quota. The Lodge celebrated its 10th Anniversary on 27 May, with M.’.W.’. Wm. S. Farmer in attendance. W.’. Bronson presented
W.’. Solomon a Masonic ring in token of high regard and Brotherly love as founder and first Master of the Lodge. On 8 Jun the
Grand Master entertained the Grand Lodge officers and the Masters of the City Lodges at Bellevue Country Club. In the evening a
banquet was held at the Onondaga Hotel in honor of the Grand Master. The Grand Master appointed W.’. Solomon a member of the
Charity Committee of Grand Lodge; the Lodge made M.’.W.’. Farmer an honorary member.
During the Summer the Lodge worked degrees on soldiers several times. In the Fall they gave their consent for Danforth and
Salina Lodges to receive dispensations.
From the History of Philetus Lodge No. 1023, F&AM, Binghamton, New York.
http://www.stmarksphiletus.org/history.html
The history of Philetus Lodge No. 1023, F&AM began early in 1922, when a petition was submitted to Grand Lodge with the aid of
its Mother Lodge, Philo Lodge No. 968 of Syracuse, NY, to establish a fourth Masonic Lodge in Binghamton. On 11 Jul 1923, in the
Masonic Temple at 83 State Street, Miles M. Smith, DDGM of the Broome-Chenango District, formally instituted the Lodge as
Philetus Lodge U.D., F&AM. Attending this important occasion was Isadore Rothchild, Philo Lodge No. 968 (Master 1920-21; Grand
Director of Ceremonies, 1922-23). Among the Masters and Past Masters also in attendance: Warren Winkelstein (Master, 1923),
Philo Lodge No. 968 and Sigmund Sugarman (Master 1916-17), Mt. Sinai Lodge No. 864.
In 1977, negotiations and required procedures began to merge Philetus Lodge No. 1023 with St. Mark’s Lodge No. 1001,
culminating on 1 Jul 1978 with a new charter for St. Mark’s-Philetus Lodge No. 1001.
87

St.Marks-Philetus Lodge, desiring to move to a different location requested a dispensation from Grand Lodge for permission to
move to Vestal-Otseningo Lodge 108 Lincoln Drive, Vestal, NY (Vestal Masonic Temple). On 3 Dec 2003, word was received from
Grand Lodge that this request for a dispensation had been granted. secretary@masonsonline.net
Uncas Lodge No. 949
8 May 1918 -
Syracuse, New York
–
Joel Frank Troutman, PM Uncas Lodge No. 949, b. 16 Oct 1871, Seneca Falls, NY - d. 3 Dec 1935 (Tuesday)
http://archiver.rootsweb.com/th/read/NYSENECA/2006-11/1162752098
>From Herald Newspaper, Syracuse, NY, July 30, 1929 - These people were born in Seneca Falls, NY
Frank S. TROUTMAN died yesterday at his home at 728 Tallman Street. He was born in Seneca Falls Jun 6, 1849, and resided
there until 1909, when he came to Syracuse. Surviving him are his wife, Mrs. Cornelia M. TROUTMAN, three sons, Joel F.
TROUTMAN of 167 Beverly road, Oliver W. TROUTMAN, of Mount Pleasant, Mich., and J. Louis TROUTMAN of 106 Upland Road;
a daughter, Miss Marie A. TROUTMAN, 728 Tallman Street, and four grandhildren. Private prayer service will be held at 11 o`clock
Thursday morning at the home with funeral services at Sanderson`s undertaking rooms, Seneca Falls at 2:30. Burial will be made in
Seneca Falls Cemetery.
(Frank S. TROUTMAN is the son of Joel TROUTMAN and Louisa OSMAN); he was the father of the below Joel F. Troutman.
************************************************************************************************************
Obituary from original article with photo, handwritten date Dec 3, 1935:
Joel F. TROUTMAN Rites Will Be Conducted on Thursday. Joel Frank TROUTMAN, 62, of 162 Beverly Road, president of the
Conduit Electric Supply Company of West Jefferson Street, died in the Syracuse General Hospital Tuesday morning following an
operation for hernia.
Mr. TROUTMAN was well known in Masonic circles. He was a member of Uncas Lodge and had served as master of the lodge from
1921 to 1923. He was born in Seneca Falls Oct. 16, 1872, the son of the late Frank and Cornelia TROUTMAN, and came to
Syracuse in 1906. He was employed by the Franklin Motor Company before entering the electric business.
Funeral services will be conducted from the home Thursday afternoon at 1 o`clock by the Rev. Claude H. Leyfield, rector of the
Trinity Episcopal Church. Masonic rites will be conducted by members of the Uncas Lodge. Burial will be in Restvale Cemetery,
Seneca Falls.
Surviving are two daughters, Mrs. Frank LAZERUS of Montclair, N. J., and Miss Minerva A. TROUTMAN; a sister Miss Marie
TROUTMAN, a brother, Louis TROUTMAN; a nephew, Frank G. TROUTMAN, and a niece, Miss Doris M. TROUTMAN, all of
Syracuse.
---------
Mrs. TROUTMAN
Obituary transcribed from original article with handwritten date Mar 19, 1935:
Mrs. Mildred Frances (Walter) TROUTMAN, 59, wife of Joel F. TROUTMAN, died yesterday at her home, 167 Beverly Road. She
had been ill only a few days with pneumonia.
Mrs. Troutman was born in Seneca Falls, May 18, 1875, a daughter of William and Elizabeth WALTER, and had lived in Syracuse
nearly 30 years. She was a member of Trinity Episcopal church.
Surviving besides her husband are two daughters, Mrs. Frank W. LAZARUS of Montclair, N. J., and Miss Minerva TROUTMAN of
Syracuse. She was interred at Restvale Cemetery, Seneca Falls, NY.
Joel F. Troutman (Mildred R.) pres. Condult Electric Supply Corp. at 244 W. Jefferson, home at 167 BeverlyRoad.
http://archiver.rootsweb.com/th/read/NYONONDA/2003-12/1072670972
1910 and 1920 census in Syracuse, Onondaga Co., NY.
Frank S. TROUTMAN, Born: June 1849, New York; Died: btn. 1920 - 1930
Parents: Joel TROUTMAN and Louisa OSMAN*
Between 1900 and 1910 Frank & his family moved from Seneca Falls, Seneca Co., NY.
Marr: Cornelia (maiden name Unknown) TROUTMAN, Born: June 1852, NY; Died: after 1930, probably Syracuse where she
lived
Known children: (all living in Syracuse, except Oliver)
Joel TROUTMAN, b. Oct 1873 marr. Mildred
Marie/Mary A. TROUTMAN b. Nov 1877 w/mother in 1930
Oliver W. TROUTMAN b. Aug 1880 (probably in Michigan 1930)
Louis TROUTMAN b. Sep 1883 marr. Edith
88

Frank Weedon
http://www.phoenixmasonry.org/the_builder_1920_december.htm
SYNOPSIS OF THE FINAL REPORT OF THE MASONIC OVERSEAS MISSION
BY BRO. TOWNSEND SCUDDER, P.G.M., NEW YORK
To the Masonic Grand Jurisdictions of the United States participating in the efforts to secure governmental permission for the Masonic
Overseas Mission to engage in War Relief service overseas:
THE MISSION which you dispatched in January, 1919, to Freemasons in the United States Forces Overseas begs leave to submit the
following report:
On May 29th, Wor. Brother C. D. Brooks, of Uncas Lodge, No. 949, Syracuse, who had been engaged in the educational activities of
the Y.M.C.A., and had planned to take part in the educational work of the A. E. F. University at Beaune, was buried with Masonic
services in the Suresnes Cemetery outside Paris, conducted by Brother Lay.
http://www.newzjunky.com/obits/0424peckobit.htm
Charles P. Peck
April 24, 2007 SAND BAY, NY - Charles P. Peck, 84, of Syracuse, and a summer resident of Gates Trailer Park, Sand Bay
(Clayton), died early Saturday morning at Loretto Nursing Home, Syracuse, where he had been a patient since March 14.
Born Feb. 21, 1923, in Syracuse, the son of Charles S. and Edith Miller Peck, he graduated from Vocational High School in
Syracuse and served in the United States Army from 1943 to1945.
He married Bernice Gates on Dec. 28, 1943. She died in June of 1995.
After serving in the Army, Charlie became service foreman for NY Telephone in Syracuse, retiring in 1983. He was a Mason for
many years and served as Worthy Master for the Uncas Lodge, Syracuse, in 1966. He enjoyed the St. Lawrence River.
He is survived by two sons and their wives, David (Patti), Marcellus, NY; Daniel (Gail), Silver Springs, MD; a daughter, Mrs. Jeffrey
(Wendy) Oliver, Crossville, TN; four grandchildren; three great-grandchildren; a brother, Donald (Carol) Peck, Gettysburg, PA; and a
sister, Alta Quigley, Endicott, NY. A daughter, Karen Peck Albers, died in February 1978, and two brothers, Louis Peck and Arthur
Peck, also died before him.
A memorial service will be held at a time to be announced this summer at Sand Bay, NY.
Memorial contributions may be sent to the Food Bank of Central New York, 6970 Schuyler Rd., East Syracuse, NY 13057-9791 or
made online at www.foodbankcny.org.
Information provided by: Costello Funeral Service and Newzjunky.com, Watertown, N.Y
http://archiver.rootsweb.com/th/read/NY-CENTRA/2006-07/1153065674
MOSHER -- Suddenly at Phoenix, N. Y., March 13 (1931 written in pencil), Hiram S. Mosher. Survived by his wife, Bessie Lush
Mosher; two brothers, Robert S. Mosher and N. R. Streeter. Funeral services at First Baptist Church Monday afternoon at 2 o'clock.
Friends are invited. Armory Lodge, 895, I.O.O.F., will conduct services at the church. Uncas lodge, F. and A. M., will conduct
services at Jacksonville cemetery. Friends wishing, may call at the home of Cornell, Clement & Greenleaf, Inc., 503 W. Onondaga
st. Sunday afternoon from 2 to 5 and evening from 7 to 9.
Salina Lodge No. 955
Syracuse, New York
19 May 1919 –
Dispensation 28 Oct 1918 to 15 Apr 1919
In the Spring of 1918 it was proposed to form a new Masonic Lodge in Syracuse, and on 13 May Brothers Grant Sheldon, Eugene
A. Beach, Wilton Olds, O. D. Burhans and W. C. Hinman met with R.’.W.’. Frank C. Miller to discuss the matter.
Per the Register of Syracuse Lodge No. 501, the following 43 Brothers demitted on 19 May 1919 to Salina Lodge No. 957 (sic):
Name Lodge No. GL No. Raised Occupation Born Birthplace
Andrews, William Duffany 1529 430833 15 Dec 1910 Merchant 27 Jan 1858 Cicero, NY
Ayling, Bruce Gill 1764 474940 17 Dec 1914 Confectioner 20 Oct 1881 Syracuse, NY
Ball, Irving Custar (Gustav) 1619 451817 24 Oct 1912 Electrician 01 Jan 1872 Pompey, NY
Beach, Eugene Augustus 1489 421068 23 Dec 1909 Insurance Agt 18 Aug 1873 Weedsport, NY
Buechner, Richard Frederick 1314 389660 26 Apr 1906 Salesman 21 Feb 1881 Syracuse, NY
Burhans, Orbo Daniel 1323 389669 14 Jun 1906 Merchant 13 Apr 1869 Fayetteville, NY
89

Clark, William Charles 1655 463207 17 Apr 1913 Engraver 28 May 1874 Syracuse, NY
Dunning, James Walter 1867 408794 21 Jan 1909* Salesman 07 Feb 1878 Duanesburg, NY
Dyer, Frederick Ernest 1148 347065 19 Jun 1902 Clothing Cutter 12 Feb 1877 Morristown, NY
Easton, Frederick Edward, 1784 485883 15 Apr 1915 Physician 18 Dec 1861 Cedarville, NY
Esler, John Richard 1999 510318 05 Dec 1917 Time Keeper 10 Nov 1885 Long Lake, MN
Gaylord, Henry Jay 1547 441254 11 May 1911 Mail Orders 01 May 1872 Syracuse, NY
Gaylord, Willis Edmund 1623 451821 19 Dec 1912 Manufacturer 29 Jun 1864 Syracuse, NY
Gettman, Glenn Charles 1270 370044 22 Jun 1905 Grocery Clerk 09 Feb 1883 Liverpool, NY
Hammond, Frederick Star 1873 497597 15 Jun 1916 Builder 19 Aug 1858 Cheshire Co., NH
Hinman, William Curtis 1662 463214 29 May 1913 Monument Dlr 10 May 1869 Moravia, NY
Hodges, Frank Beers 1575 451778 16 May 1912 Lawyer 29 Sep 1864 Pompey, NY
Hopton, Walter Edwin 1566 441272 21 Dec 1911 Purchasing 11 Jun 1865 Bridgeport, CT
Housekneeht, Chester Arthur, 1795 485894 17 Jun 1915 Toolmaker 09 Jul 1883 Muncy, PA
Howlett, Lewis Parker 1022 320787 09 Feb 1899 Law Clerk 25 Dec 1875 Camillus, NY
Jay, Yoder Harry 1728 474905 21 May 1914 Purchasing Agt 17 May 1886 Auburn, NY
Jones, James Erwin 1330 389676 27 Nov 1906 Druggist 09 May 1868 Syracuse, NY
Keller, Edward Levi 1898 497633 25 Apr 1911** Clergyman 12 Nov 1884 Salona, PA
Klein, Louis Carl 1603 451803 13 Jun 1912 Landscaper 25 Jul 1882 Syracuse, NY
Klock, Newton Earle 2008 510327 05 Dec 1917 Buyer 25 Jun 1899 Canastota, NY
Law, William Frederick, 1782 485881 15 Apr 1915 Physician 18 Jan 1871 Vernon, NY
Meneilly, Walter Jr. 1601 451801 20 Jun 1912 Citizen’s Club 22 Nov 1871 Bangor, Ireland
Nhare, George Englehart 1742 474918 25 Jun 1914 Carpenter 20 Jan 1886 Syracuse, NY
Nhare, John Allen Jr. 1428 411282 18 Jun 1908 Pharmacist 23 Oct 1881 Syracuse, NY
Noble, Ray Clifford 1497 430805 10 Feb 1910 Foreman 27 Dec 1885 Syracuse, NY
Olds, Wilton Ralph 1468 421049 13 May 1909 Salesman 17 Apr 1875 Morristown, NY
Orr, William Shaw 0847 276250 31 May 1894 Merchant 03 Jan 1862 Syracuse, NY
Richard, Howe Clarence 1725 474902 21 May 1914 Builder 28 Aug 1886 Near Memphis, NY
Robinson, Frank Kelsey 1488 421067 23 Dec 1909 Broker 23 Dec 1868 Nunda, NY
Sheldon, Howard Grant, 1791 485890 10 Jun 1915 Civil Engineer 31 Oct 1889 Syracuse, NY
Sheldon, Lansing Grant 1783 485882 15 Apr 1915 Manager 19 Oct 1863 Borodino, NY
Sheldon, Ralph Ainslie 1998 510317 28 Jun 1917 Storekeeper 16 May 1896 Syracuse, NY
Sheridan, William Edmund 1847 497576 31 Mar 1916 Office Manager 01 Mar 1879 Fulton, NY
Smith, Charles Allen 1168 357795 12 Feb 1903 Journalist 20 Sep 1866 Nelson, NY
Spencer, Frank Josiah 1827 497557 16 Mar 1916 Foreman 28 Jan 1886 Whitney Point, NY
Summers, William David 1394 401111 27 Jun 1907 Comml Traveler 28 Sep 1868 Oswego, NY
Wiggins, Alton Vergne 1596 451797 13 Jun 1912 Machinist 31 Aug 1887 Sutton, VT
Windholz, Charles Anglesea 1195 357819 17 Dec 1903 Secy & Treas 25 May 1881 Syracuse, NY
* Affiliated to Syr 501 on 20 Apr 1916 from Oneida Lodge No. 270, Oneida, NY
** Affiliated to Syr 501 on 09 Nov 1916 from Cambria Lodge No. 278, Johnstown, PA
There were 72 original petitioners whose names appeared on the dispensation. When the charter was granted there were 108
charter members, nine having affiliated and 27 having been raised under dispensation. On 31 Dec 1919 the records show a
membership of 137 and total assets of $3,530.13 with no liabilities.
Past Masters
Sheldon, L. Grant 1919
Beach, Eugene A. 1920
Windholz, Charles A. 1921
Sheridan, William E. 1922
Nhare, John A. 1923
Newell, Wilber D. 1924
Olds, Wilton R. 1925
Sheldon, Ralph A. 1926
LeFevre, Joseph S. 1927
Dunning, James W. 1928
Alexander, Wellington 1929
Berney, Dean J. 1930
Hayden, Daniel E. 1931
Morenus, Charles C. 1932
Schupp, Floyd J. 1933
Wells, Raymond B. 1934
Barney, Mason A. 1935
Greenleaf, Harold H. 1936
Wood, Harold R. 1937
Busch, Carl E. 1938
Bloss, Jacob H. 1939
Seymour, Willard H. 1940
Gunning, C. Harry 1941
Jones, Charles H. 1942
Young, Robert A. 1943
Schupp, Floyd J. 1944
Lawrence, Vernon 1945
Jakes, William E. 1946
Russell, Melvin B. 1947
Patten, George A. 1948
Hay, W. Chester 1949
Newell, Wilber W. 1950
O’Hara, Alton C. 1951
Leigh, Lawrence V. 1952
Landers, John D. 1953
Jones, Stanford W. 1954
Young, George D. 1955
Hudson, Arthur 1956
Ives, Arthur G. 1957
Paetznick, Luther A. 1958
Workman, Floyd E. 1959
Conklin, Evan N. 1960
Wells, Millard R. 1961
Gilbert, Robert B. 1962
Brown, Maurice L. 1963
Youngs, George J. 1964
Armstrong, Herbert G. 1965
Moore, James E. 1966
Reichenbach, David 1967
Thompson, Robert L. 1968
Barth, Warren F. 1969
Howlett, Donald B. 1970
Hemstreet, Wellington 1971
Newell, Wilbur W. 1972
Storey, Douglas H. 1973
Van Marter, Robert E. 1974
Ridall, J. LaVerne 1975
Van Marter, Daniel B. 1976
Biographies
Eugene A. Beach, b. 18 Aug 1873, Weedsport, NY; d. 7 Apr 1939, bur. Weedsport Cemetery, Brutus, Cayuga Co., NY. He was
vice-president of the Beach Family Association for New York State in the late 1920's. For a biography and photograph see Beach
Family Magazine, Vol. III, No. 3, p. 292. He m. Florence R. SINCERBEAUX (1870 - 1935). He was the son of Charles Jacob
BEACH b. 18 Apr 1840, d. 28 Feb 1908), who was a minister and served as pastor of the Cayuga and Forestville Methodist Church,
Cayuga County, NY, from 1878 to 1880, and Eliza J. THOMPSON (1845 - 1910).
See also: http://www.beachfamilyjournal.com/gedcom/html/fam02940.htm for further family ancestry.
90

Newton Earl Klock, life resident of the Canastota area and a machinist in Syracuse for many years died ca Tuesday, 24 Apr 1942
at a convalescent home in Syracuse at 538 Delaware St. after a three month illness. He was a son of the late Erwin and Lucy Swan
Klock of Whitelaw.
Surviving were two sisters, Mrs William Stockle of Whitelaw and Mrs. William Beardsley of Syracuse.
John Allen Nhare, b. 23 OCT 1881 son of John Allen Nhare who m. Polly Ann Farmer, 24 AUG 1878 South Onondaga, Onondaga,
NY. John, b. 20 JAN 1885/86, was the brother of John Allen Jr. Other siblings of this family were:
Gussie Winifred Nhare b. 28 JUN 1879, d. 25 DEC 1880
Fred Coates Nhare b. 23 OCT 1883
Ethel Lydia Nhare b. 26 AUG 1888
L. Grant Sheldon
http://www.townononhist.org/text_files/1880Part1.txt
1880 Federal Census for the Town of Onondaga, NY Part1
Census Place: Onondaga, Onondaga, New York
Source: FHL Film 1254906 National Archives Film T9-0906 Page 98C
Relation Marr Age Birthplace
Lansing SHELDON Self M 51 NY Occ: Farmer
Emily C. SHELDON Wife M 49 NY Occ: Keeping House Fa: VT Mo: VT
Hattie L. SHELDON Dau S 20 NY
L. Grant SHELDON Son S 16 NY Occ: Farm Laborer
Catharine SHELDON Sister S 52 NY
Wilton R. Olds, probably married Clara Brinkerhoff, b. 29 Jan 1879, Marcellus, NY, daughter of Abraham L. Brinkerhoff, b. 22 Jan
1822 in Fishkill, NY, d. 20 Jun 1909 in Marcellus, NY.
For more on this family ancestry see: http://www.conovergenealogy.com/conover-p/p361.htm#i284511
Danforth Lodge No. 957
Syracuse and Liverpool, New York
19 May 1919 – 15 May 1985
56 Charter Members - 19 May 1919 (39 from Salt Springs Lodge No. 520)
Name Raised From Occupation DOB DOD
Marriot, Samuel R. W. 26 Jun 1910 520 Salt Springs Mechanical Supt 26 Jan 1875 26 Jan 1940
Boyle, James E. 18 Nov 1907 520 Salt Springs Machinist,
21 Jan 1878 1954? Dim 1931?
Lehman, George 30 Jun 1902 520 Salt Springs Bookkeeper Foreman
16 Apr 1880 3 Sep 1940
Schilly, Otto Augustus 27 Mar 1916 520 Salt Springs Bookkeeper 4 Sep 1875 5 Dec 1954
Kuntz, Howard Jacob 7 Mar 1916 520 Salt Springs Draughtsman 26 Mar 1894 Susp 1 Apr 1925
Gordan, Rea Milton 19 Jun 1908 158 Carthage Mech. Engineer 26 May 1881 31 Jan 1942
Smith George G. 23 Mar 1914 520 Salt Springs Accountant 30 Aug 1881 4 Apr 1959
Hoffman, William F. 18 May 1903 520 Salt Springs Tool Maker 19 Oct 1873 2 Jan 1954
Maurer, Oscar Theobald 3 Mar 1902 520 Salt Springs Insurance 19 Dec 1880 17 Mar 1945
Bender, Charles Henry 1 Jul 1912 520 Salt Springs Electrician 8 Oct 1884 2 Feb 1970
Russell, Miles Julian 8 Nov 1909 520 Salt Springs Contractor 26 Aug 1877 25 Nov 1958
Jutton, Edward J. 27 May 1915 768 Sapphire Machinist 4 Jan 1869 Dimit 1931
Perry, Andrew Jackson 10 Apr 1911 520 Salt Springs Machinist 17 Apr 1859 18 Jan 1940
Lohman, William F. 12 Feb 1917 520 Salt Springs Machinist 17 Jul 1884 23 Jul 1965
Kilian, Frederick Karl 22 Sep 1916 124 St Pauls Aub Manufacturer 9 Jan 1893 2 Jun 1981
McGee, James L. 21 Apr 1914 305 Central City Accountant 16 Dec 1882 Dim 12 Nov 1952
Hoffman, John Daniel 30 Oct 1916 520 Salt Springs Carpenter 12 Aug 1892 25 Sep 1939
Bock, August 15 Dec 1913 520 Salt Springs Hardware 12 Aug 1879 21 Oct 1930
Russell, Frank H. 26 Feb 1917 520 Salt Springs Susp 26 Dec 1928
Roney, William B. 25 Apr 1910 520 Salt Springs Hardware 28 Feb 1854 10 Jul 1938
Potter, Orla S. 520 Salt Springs Inspector 7 Nov 1854 23 May 1930
Cady, Percy Luther 21 Feb 1916 520 Salt Springs Salesman 22 Jul 1893 8 Apr 1970
DeHaven, William Charles 27 May 1912 520 Salt Springs Sales Manager 21 Jun 1884 19 Jan 1939
Richards, Arthur Leon 11 Dec 1911 520 Salt Springs Machinist Foreman 10 Mar 1883 7 Feb 1966
Light, Jesse 11 Dec 1911 520 Salt Springs Stock Clerk 17 Sep 1878 4 Jul 1950
Stilbert, Thomas John 21 Dec 1914 520 Salt Springs Foreman 8 Aug 1887 23 Dec 1985
Newson, Raymond Charles 13 Dec 1915 520 Salt Springs Inspector 27 May 1886 28 Jul 1971
Strathdee, John C. 29 Oct 1917 520 Salt Springs 16 Apr 1935
Luff, George William 22 May 1911 520 Salt Springs Meat Dealer 24 Aug 1876 5 Sep 1932
91

Haas, Herbert John 26 Jun 1911 520 Salt Springs Merchant 10 Jan 1886 14 Jan 1949
Hinckleman, Earle Ludwig 12 Feb 1917 520 Salt Springs Machinist 26 Sep 1888 12 Apr 1964
Kennedy, William 18 Feb 1918 520 Salt Springs Machinist 3 Feb 1864 1930
Azadian, Harutun Bab 31 Oct 1910 520 Salt Springs Gauge Mfg. 11 Aug 1876 19 Dec 1965
Kalebdjian, Setrak K. 12 Feb 1912 520 Salt Springs Meat Market 28 Mar 1886 29 Mar 1972
Babcock, Frank Albert 1 May 1914 520 Salt Springs Production Clerk 20 Feb 1882 24 Sep 1944
Wadsworth, Ray D. 14 Dec 1914 520 Salt Springs Machinist 28 Jun 1886 18 Sep 1974
Young, Ira Edward 22 Apr 1918 520 Salt Springs Foreman 8 Jan 1893 4 Feb 1957
Storms, Frank Ed. 26 Jun 1916 520 Salt Springs 28 Jul 1872 6 Nov 1950
Norgren, Albert Frederick 28 Feb 1910 520 Salt Springs Salesman 4 Dec 1873 21 Jun 1948
Perry, Charles W. 22 Oct 1917 520 Salt Springs Gear Cutter 21 Oct 1895 12 Sep 1976
Ellison, Morgan Curtis 10 Apr 1916 520 Salt Springs Machinist 23 Dec 1872 1930
Smith, Robert Francis 25 Jan 1915 520 Salt Springs Salesman 7 Feb 1886 Susp 1 Jun 1932
Eccles, Leon Leroy 10 Dec 1917 520 Salt Springs Salesman 17 Apr 1894 27 Mar 1947
Whiteside, Isaac Vance 12 Mar 1896 520 Salt Springs Foreman 14 Apr 1873 30 Aug 1954
Smith, Arthur Edward 4 Jun 1908 768 Sapphire Accountant 16 Oct 1886 10 Dec 1947
Lawton, George H. 7 Mar 1907 768 Sapphire ? 27 Mar 1865 1920
Wheeler, Frederick D. 7 Mar 1907 768 Sapphire Clerk 25 Mar 1885 11 Apr 1966
Kincaid, Stanley L. 31 May 1917 768 Sapphire Clerk 1 Jan 1881 Susp 1931
Noble, Ray Clifford 10 Feb 1910 501 Syracuse Foreman 27 Dec 1885 24 Dec 1963
Cunningham, William W. 28 Nov 1916 305 Central City Foreman 20 Jul 1886 Susp 27 Dec 1922
Patterson, James Clifford 4 Jun 1908 768 Sapphire Superintendent 23 Dec 1876 Susp 21 Jun 1933
Norris, Walter Whitcomb 8 Apr 1918 901 Ilion Clerk 19 Dec 1865 27 Aug 1946
Conklin, Raymond Burton 11 Nov 1914 406 Humanity Salesman 20 Apr 1890 9 Feb 1978
Hutchinson, Loomis 11 Mar 1898 262 Ann Arbor Electrician 19 Apr 1875 1941
Wilson, Henry E. 20 Jun 1889 438 Marathon Lawyer ? 17 Nov 1929
Lowes, Robert Telford ? ? ? 5 May 1941
Past Masters
Marriott, S. R. W. 1919-20 Howe, Price W. 1943 Marble, Robert H. 1965
Boyle, James E. 1921 Blume, John H. 1944 Withers, Stanley C. 1966
Lohman, George 1922 Bretzer, Ralph F. 1945 Alheid, Harry J. 1967
Maurer, Oscar T. 1923 Lohman, William F. 1946 Wright, J. Clayton 1968
Smith, George G. 1924-25 Howe, Arthur W. 1947 Krebs, Gordon 1969
Bender, Charles H. 1926 Axe, Donald H. 1948 Fredenburg, Carlton J. 1970
Noble, Elbert A. 1927 Chenault, C. Theo. 1949 Cox, George F. 1971
Hartman, Fred G. 1928 Campbell, J. James 1950 Byrns, Paul R. 1972
Gifford, Bert H. 1929 Faust, A. Ray 1951 Anderson, George A. III 1973
Hamm, Arthur W. 1930 Page, George N. 1952 Wright, J. Clayton 1974
Hoffman, John D. 1931 Frederick, Walter M. 1953 Watson, Mahlon H. 1975
Daw, Lawrence 1932 Tracy, William K. 1954 Parker, Charles P. 1976
Price, J. Frank 1933 Dorn, Robert W. 1955 Byrns, Paul R. 1977
Roderick, Harold R. 1934 Anderson, George A. 1956 Parsnow, Victor G. 1978
Johns, Irvin H. 1935 Winkworth, David A. 1957 Byrns, Paul R. 1979
Donegan, Edward H. 1936 Rall, Roy R. 1958 Allen, K. David 1980
Sorenson, Anders 1937 Mager, Raymond W. 1959 Foster, J. Kenneth 1981
Arbogast, Lester F. 1938 Marcellus, Clyde D. 1960 Jamieson, Charles O. 1982
Merkle, William J. 1939 Cox, Robert B. 1961 Robbins, Ronald A. 1983
Schenkenberger, Carl M. 1940 Grier, John P. 1962 Robbins, Ronald A. 1984
McKeegan, Harold M. 1941 Bushorr, Harold W. 1963 Robbins, Ronald A. 1985
Rapp, George E. 1942 Valentine, Emmett M. 1964
Sea and Field Lodge No. 2-983
Syracuse, New York
May 1921 –
Sea & Field No. 1 assimilated all the members in numbers 2, 3, 4 & 5, and recorded them as members and met in regular session
on 5 Apr 1920 with Janksheer No. 865 Yonkers and worked the 2 nd section of the 3 rd Degree. Up to that time 225 members had
been demitted to membership in other Lodges. 204 remained on the rolls exclusive of the personnel of No. 1’s membership.
The Judge Advocate’s Committee reports those involving discretion action arising out of or war conditions not likely to recur. [No
petition can be received from a candidate under 21 years of age, and such petition, or action had thereon, shall be ineffective for
any purpose.]
92

The overseas mission asked for passports dated 31 December 1918. Then came the chance to affiliate with the AEF-YMCA as a
Masonic unit, partly on suggestion of the President and Raymond B. Fresdick that we ally ourselves “with a recognized relief
agency” so that arrangements and passports were obtained through the YMCA. After going to Washington, passports were issued
on 21 Jan 1919. First was to find a ship to sail which was the Aquatania from Halifax on 1 Feb. This was a troop ship still in the
service of the British Admirality but carrying passengers. They left NYC on 30 Jan 1919 for Halifax via Boston by rail. Each had
hand luggage and one small trunk and they carried a typewriter & stationery. In Boston one of the party accompanied the trunks
crosstown and saw them on the B&W Line. They thought sure the trunks would arrive when they did – but on arrival in Halifax after
midnight of 1 Feb they found only two of the six trunks were on the train.
The ship was due to sail at 0900 and the train was due at this same hour. Those whose trunks had not arrived stayed ashore and
waited for the train. The ship was delayed 1-1/2 hours in departure but they all sailed together as a group. They was the ship was
very dark and musty, partitions had been removed along with much of the furniture. The portholes still blackened to prevent the light
from shining out while at sea, but were fairly comfortable under the circumstances. They had expected to land at Liverpool but
landed in Glascow instead. They arrived in London on 8 Feb in the a.m. and found comfortable lodgings doing without heat, hot
water and warm baths.
Sea & Field 2-983 was Instituted 3 Apr 1919 at 42 Rue Rochechonart, Paris, France . . . .
The YMCA Secretaries had a Triangle Club called the Trowel and Triangle. The members of this club were throughout the areas
wherever YMCA’s had been established for troops. Through these club members they had a connecting line with the Y and the
mission and almost immediate contact with all the Masonic activities in the YMCA.
From hereon the activities of R..W.. Lay, Bros. Moore and Goodrich would read like a cooks tour, visiting clubs in different camps,
meeting in Y huts, Jewish welfare huts, &c. Sometimes the camp Commandant would set aside a hut where they could hold a
meeting. It was in the Jewish hut where R..W.. Lay met Bro. Charles Huntley, who with Bro. Porter, originated the SOI, a very
popular so-called side degree. Some of the boys who received it overseas have promised to receive it and put it on for the Lodge,
but up to date it has never been done [as of 1976].
At Marseilles, the American Triangle Club and Heathes Hill Triangle Club met in a macaroni factory; 74 clubs were functioning.
Sea & Field 2-983 was Instituted 3 Apr 1919 at 42 Rue Rochechonart, Paris, France . . . .
The said Lodge is hereby invested with full power and authority to assemble on all proper and lawful occasions to elect and confer
the three degrees, or either of them, of ancient Craft Masonry without the usual formal ties and requirements of chartered Lodges
upon candidates; who have actually enlisted, or been drafted, or commissioned officers in the US forces in the present great war
[WWI]; and who apply therefore in writing and satisfy the Master Masons; so they be over the age of 18 years; and upon payment of
$20; as also to perform and do all & every such acts and things appertaining to the Craft as have been, and ought to be done for the
honor and advantage thereof.
Membership or Officership in said Lodge shall in no wise impair or affect existing membership or Officership in a regular chartered
or warranted Lodge. To be the JD or a Sea & Filed Lodge of F&AM, to be, but virtue thereof, constituted, formed and held at the city
of New York; and elsewhere and overseas; as may be convenient and necessary; which Lodge shall be distinguished and known by
the name or style of Sea & Field Lodge #2; and the said Master is hereby authorized to appoint subordinate officers of said Lodge;
and said Lodge is authorized to adopt all such By-Laws; regulations for the governance of its proceedings, subject to my approval
as it may see fit.
Said Lodge shall have a seal and shall have and keep all books required to be kept by regular Lodges in the State of New York, the
same and all records to be surrendered to the Grand Lodge on the termination of this warrant. This warrant shall terminate at the
pleasure of the Grand Master.
Given under my hand and private seal at the city of New York in the US of A, this day of . . . in the year of our Lord 1918 and in the
Year of Masonry 5918 G.M. [sic].
The Lodges had their seal and kept books the same as any regular Lodge and surrendered it records and warrant at the pleasure of
the G.M.
Officers
WM Townsend Scudder
SW Thomas Channing Moore
JW Merwin W. Lay
Sec Willian L. Prine
SD George L. Goodrich
JD B. D. Norman
Tiler G. B. Blackwell
Appointive Officers
Acker PGM of Texas
Eddy next year GM of Michigan
Davis Rhode Island
Collins Rhode Island
Keely Nebraska
Lee Oklahoma Branch, WVa
This Lodge worked 9 times in 99 days, the last being 10 July when M..W.. William S. Farmer was present and took part in the
ceremonies when 66 were Raised in one day. Total of 282 Raised and 25 of whom received their 1 st and 2 nd Degrees. For foreign
jurisdictions, “We have one apron presented to us several years later.”
This Lodge was warranted by M.’.W.’. William S. Farmer, Grand Master of Masons in the State of New York for work and instruction
overseas in the American Expeditionary Forces during World War I and degrees were conferred upon candidates in Paris and
elsewhere in France. This Lodge was reorganized by R.’.W.’. William H. Hall and was chartered for work and instruction in
93

Syracuse, New York, at the annual communication of the Grand Lodge, May 1921, A.L. 5921. Affixed were the signatures of the
original signers of the petition to the Grand Lodge for dispensation and 2 Honorary Members:
Burlidger, C. B.
Bushnell, Carl E.
Choler, Frederick W.
Clarke, Harry E.
Egloff, William J.
Elliott, George E.
Farmer, William S. [GM 1918]
Furrier, Harry H.
Hall, William W.
Hersburgh, Walter N.
Hooker, George W.
Hurst, Oscar J.
Jaynes, Almon H.
Kimmey, Harold I.
Kincaid, R. L.
King, Russell J.
Krause, William H.
Lear, Fred R.
Mintel, Walter K.
Mott, John
Pierce, James E.
Smith, Harry N.
Williams, R. R.
This reorganized Lodge, as of 1976 had 583 Initiations / Affiliations and a ‘present membership of 140.’ As of 1976 its W.’.M.’. was
Andrew P. Storher, Jr. The Onondaga Masonic Districts Historical Society (OMDHS) is fortunate to have a large collection of Bro.
Storher’s photo collection, some of his personal Masonic Aprons & artifacts, and the Records which he held in trust for another
Lodge in which he was active, Peity Hill Lodge 1168, of which he was the Senior Deacon in 1976.
Past Masters of Sea & Field Lodge 2-983 are as follows:
1921-22
1923
1924
1925
1926
1927
1928
1929
1930
1931
1932
1933
1934
1935
1936
1937
1938
1939
1940
1941
1942
Jaynes, Almon H.
Farmer, Harry H.
Horsburgh, Walter N.
Elliot, George E.
Clark, Harry E.
Dudley, Lewis A.
Lear, Fred R.
Van Wormer, Richard
Schneider, Jacob S.
Fisk, J. Dwight
Estey, Stephen M.
Searle, Dana A.
Farnham, Carl N.
Kimmey, Harold I.
Rowland, Judd L.
Hopkins, Albert E.
Milazzo, Francis
Stafford, Louis E.
Smith, Harvey N.
Dennis, William
Armstrong, James
1943
1944
1945
1946
1947
1948
1949
1950
1951
1952
1953
1954
1955
1956
1957
1958
1959
1960
1961
1962
1963
Baker, Earl R.
Clark, Howard A.
Powell, Almeron L.
Farrington, Earl E.
Smith, Raymond V.
Park, Orrin S.
Dernier, Arthur C. Sr.
Geiger, Charles L. Sr.
White, Lloyd C.
Davies, Wheeler A.
Stewart, Kenneth M.
Burton, Darrell E.
Raaflaub, George F.
Edmunds, Harry L.
Lenning, Bertram E.
Van Luven, Carlton E.
Crawford, Earl W.
Halliday, Harry B.
Quinn, William J.
Paice, Delbert J.
HIckok, Wallace C.
1964
1965
1966
1967
1968
1969
1970
1971
1972
1973
1974
1975
1976
1977
1978
1979
1980
1981
1981
1983
1984
Nordheim, Erich R. Jr.
Mahoney, Arthur J.
Salisbury, Richard W.
Dunlop, Norman J.
Kennedy, David K.
White, Lawrence B.
Stohrer, Andrew P. Jr.
Stevens, Charles G.
Abell, Carl W.
Black, Alexander A.
Sinay, Edward J.
Abell, Carl W.
Stohrer, Andrew P. Jr.
Grand Lodge Officers of this Lodge were:
District Deputy Grand Masters:
Grand Lodge Committee for Public Relations:
Grand Director of Ceremonies:
R∴W∴s James Armstrong and Charles I. Geiger
R∴W∴ Charles I. Geiger
R∴W∴ Arthur J. Mahoney
The above notes are transcribed verbatim from the
“Masonic History of Onondaga County Commemorating the Bicentennial,” Sep 1976, pg. 20.
Sea & Field 2-983 merged with Centerville Lodge 648 [now Memorial Lodge No. 648] when the downtown Syracuse Temple closed.
The Minutes of Sea & Field, to my understanding, are presently in the archives of Memorial Lodge No. 648, North Syracuse, NY.
-------------
American Army Lodges in the World War
Sea and Field Lodge No. 2 of New York Stationed in Paris
by CHARLES F. IRWIN, Associate Editor
The Builder Magazine
http://www.phoenixmasonry.org/the_builder_1929_march.htm
TO approach the problem of recounting the history of the several Army Lodges established in France by the Grand Lodge of New
York it is necessary to make a brief survey of the efforts of the American Craft to carry aid and comradeship to the Masons who
went across the seas in the service of our government during the war.
The war, as everyone knows, was officially declared in April of 1917. By midsummer troops began to cross the Atlantic as an
advance guard of the later movement. As early as August of that summer a group of Engineers and others, aboard the Cunarder
"Saxonia", met in one of the Ward Rooms for a delightful evening of Fellowship, and formed, for that occasion, an informal
association to which they attached the name "Saxonia Lodge, Somewhere at Sea." The story of that evening will be told later in this
series.
94

In the old Coast Defense a Club had been organized, known as the "Fellowcraft Club." And when this branch was reorganized into
the Coast Artillery and broken up into a number of regiments, the parent Club was likewise separated into a group of Clubs. And
among these, several went across and took root, first at Bordeaux, and later, scattered throughout France wherever the former units
of the Coast Guard (now the C. A. C.) were stationed.
Meanwhile the Masonic bodies at home were busy forming various kinds of organizations, every one of which had the welfare and
comfort of Craftsmen and their families at heart. Out in Missouri the Grand Lodge created an "Overseas Commission", and
appointed a number of their members as a Committee to proceed to Europe and survey the situation, with a view to relief, not only
to Americans, but also to all the Allied countries. The Chairman of the Committee was W. Bro. George S. McLanahan.
In the Grand Lodge of Ohio, William Melish, known and loved throughout the United States, had fathered and started an
organization called the "Masonic War Relief Association of the U.S.A." This organization eventually spread beyond the confines of
this Grand Lodge.
The Southern Jurisdiction Scottish Rite very early in 1917 took practical steps to survey the situation and sent to Paris Judge
George F. Moore, Sovereign Grand Commander, with several of their prominent members. The stories of all these movements will
find a place later in this series.
In the Grand Lodge of New York, in the reconvened Annual Communication of 1917, a Resolution was introduced looking toward
active work for the relief of American Masons within our forces and candidates for the degrees in the same. Their efforts culminated
in the formation of Sea and Field Lodge, No. 1, the story of which was told last month. At the same time this Grand Lodge organized
an "Overseas Masonic Mission" with powers to proceed to France and survey the Field, and, if it was deemed necessary and
advisable, to issue dispensations for Sea and Field Lodges. The Chairman of this Mission was Chief Justice Townsend Scudder of
the Highest Court within the State of New York. Associated with Justice Scudder were a number of the finest type of professional
and business men, all leaders in the Masonic Fraternity. The story of this Mission will be made a matter of a special paper a little
later.
But the story of this Mission is so intertwined in the history of the four Sea and Field Lodges of France that it is necessary for me to
go somewhat into their preliminary history here. Many Craftsmen wondered during the year 1918, and in the winter months of 1918-
19, why it was that the home Lodges seemed to have forgotten their very existence. It is due to these Masonic bodies to speak very
frankly in this paper. And I want to say that the Masonic Fraternity was not negligent nor static during those months. Anyone who will
take the trouble to secure a copy of the "Report of the Masonic Overseas Mission", issued on Dec. 31, 1918, by the Grand Lodge of
New York, will find, after reading the 129 pages of this report, which is signed by every member of the Committee, why Masonry
was unable to follow its members across the seas until after the Armistice. A reading of this report would be very healthy food for
those Masons who still hold fond fancies as to the general friendliness that is supposed to exist toward the Fraternity throughout the
United States.
Suffice it to say here that passports which were first assured to this Mission in the summer of 1918 were refused by the Government
for almost a year; statements were issued that General Pershing was opposed to the entrance of the Fraternity into France in 1918,
which statements he has, I am informed, since denied, comparatively recently in fact. After the heaviest pressure was placed upon
the former Secretary of War, and even the President, the only way the representatives of the forty-nine Grand Lodges of America
could get to France was in the garb of the Y.M.C.A., designated as Secretaries of the same.
However, the New York Mission finally landed in France, and reached Paris in February, 1919, and proceeded immediately to obtain
information as to the state of affairs in regard to Masonry. They found Judge Moore already there and assisted in opening the Paris
Overseas Club. The formal housewarming of this headquarters was on the twenty-second of the same month. The Masons working
at the Headquarters of the Y. M. C. A. at Paris had already formed the Trowel and Triangle Club, the membership of which was
composed of Y. M. C. A. Secretaries scattered throughout France. The story of this Club will have to come later.
Judge Moore soon after returned home. The Overseas Mission fitted themselves into the scheme of things as they found them and
proceeded to organize, the Y. M. C. A. authorities giving them such assistance as lay in their power. The Mission found a home at
10 Victor Emmanuel, and made this the center of their work.
As soon as practicable, members of the Mission visited all parts of the country to see what was to be done. Their experiences are
being prepared now by former members of the Mission and will find a place later on in the series.
It was apparent to Justice Scudder and his companions that the establishment of a Sea and Field Lodge at Paris would be very
valuable, and so under the authority of the Grand Master of the Grand Lodge of New York the dispensation issued to Bro.
Townsend Scudder was put into effect, and with Bro. Scudder as Worshipful Master, Thomas Channing Moore as Senior Warden,
and Merwin W. Lay as Junior Warden, Sea and Field Lodge, No. 2, Paris, France, was instituted.
Associated with these brethren were William C. Prime, as Secretary; George S. Goodrich, as Senior Deacon; B. D. Norman, as
Junior Deacon; and C. B. Blackwell as Junior Deacon.
The story of this Lodge was reported to the Grand Lodge in 1920 by Bro. Scudder and published in the Proceedings of the Grand
Lodge for 1920. I am here largely reproducing this report, because being told so soon after the events happened, and by the Master
of the Lodge himself, the story is not only official but undoubtedly comprehensive and accurate.
Justice Scudder said:
When you appointed me Chairman of the Mission to Freemasons in the United States Forces Overseas, you also commissioned me
as your plenipotentiary in territory outside the United States, with all power and authority possessed by yourself as Grand Master, in
respect of Freemasons without the United States, owing obedience to the Grand Lodge of New York in respect of the relations of
95

the Grand Lodge of New York with Masonic Grand Jurisdictions overseas, and you committed to my care four Warrants for
Overseas Sea and Field Lodges exclusively military in their character, which Warrants were signed by you Dec. 24, 1918. You
instructed me to complete the same by inserting the names of the seven principal officers of each at my discretion, and in case I
should determine that the welfare of the members of the Fraternity from New York, with the A. E. F., required it, or would be
promoted thereby, to institute said Lodges, or any thereof, as regular Naval or Military Masonic Lodges, in such places without the
United States as I should see fit, for service to and with the men enlisted, drafted or commissioned in the United States Forces in
the Great War, or regular members of the A. E. F. - Y.M.C.A. or American Red Cross ministering to our men.
You will discover in this paragraph that most extraordinary powers were granted by Grand Master W. S. Farmer to his Committee.
How statesmanlike was his masterly foresight, and his confidence in the ability of his committee to proceed on wise and sound lines,
even if far away from New York! So utterly different from many other Grand Masters who displayed such timidity and fear as to the
Masons who went with the Army, lest they might not know how to proceed nor be able to control their zeal, should they be given
powers to act as Masons when abroad ! Particularly noticeable is the absence of any "strings," of fettering provisos and exceptions,
to the commission granted to Justice Scudder. The soundness of his procedure, and the type of men he chose for the responsible
places in the four Overseas Lodges justified this carte blanches and is in strong contrast to the hesitating and the non possums
attitude, found elsewhere. Of course, these other rulers of the Craft may have been justified concerning their own members.
Regarding this they were perhaps the best judges, though my own observation does not incline me to agree with them.
Bro. Scudder in his report gives the blank dispensations used by all four of Field Lodges:
SIT LUX ET LUX FUIT William S. Farmer, Grand Master
I, William S. Farmer, Grand Master of Masons in the State of New York, do, by these presents, appoint, authorize and
empower our
Worthy Brother to be Master, our
Worthy Brother to be Senior Warden, our
Worthy Brother to be Junior Warden, our
Worthy Brother to be the Treasurer, our
Worthy Brother to be the Secretary, our
Worthy Brother to be the Senior Deacon, our
Worthy Brother to be the Junior Deacon
of a Sea and Field Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons, to be, by virtue hereof, constituted, formed and held at the City
of New York, and elsewhere and Overseas, as may be convenient and necessary, which Lodge shall be distinguished
and known by the name or style of Sea and Field Lodge, No. 2, and the said Master is hereby authorized to appoint
subordinate officers of said Lodge; and said Lodge is authorized to adopt all such by-laws and regulations for the
governance of its proceedings and labor, subject to my approval as it may see fit.
And, further, the said Lodge is hereby invested with full power and authority to assemble on all proper and lawful
occasions and to elect and confer the three degrees, or either of them, of Ancient Craft Masonry, without the usual
formalities and requirements of chartered Lodges upon Candidates, who have actually enlisted, or been drafted, or
commissioned officers in the United States forces in the present great War, and who apply therefore in writing and satisfy
the Master and Wardens of said Lodge that they are qualified, and in case they be sons of Master Masons, so they be
over the age of eighteen years; and on payment of twenty dollars; as also to do and perform all and every such acts and
things appertaining to the Craft as have been, and ought to be, done for the honor and advantage thereof.
Membership or officership in said Lodge shall in no wise impair or affect existing membership or officership in a regular
chartered or warranted Lodge.
Said Lodge shall have a seal and shall have and keep all books required to be kept by regular Lodges in the State of New
York, the same and all records to be surrendered to the Grand Lodge on the termination of this warrant.
This warrant shall terminate at the pleasure of the Grand Master.
Given under my hand and Private Seal, at the City of New York, in the United States of America, this ..... day of .... in the
year of our Lord, One thousand nine hundred and eighteen.
Carrying with him these warrants in blank form, Bro. Scudder and his Mission set sail, and he relates what occurred as follows:
I left New York Jan. 30, 1919, and arrived in London, via Glasgow, Feb. 8, remaining seven days, which were devoted to examining
into the welfare of our numerous sailors at several Naval Bases, in the United Kingdom, and many soldiers and sailors on leave in
Condone or at the several rest camps. Inquiry of the proper authority of the United Grand Lodge of England led me to believe that
objection would not be made to a Sea and Field Lodge at some place in that Jurisdiction if I should decide that the welfare of our
men would be promoted thereby. I also studied war service and activity of the United Grand Lodge of England to the end that we
might profit by the experience of our mother Grand Lodge.
I proceeded to Paris, arriving Feb. 15. We had mailed to France, in anticipation of our arrival, some fifty letters addressed to wellknown
Brethren with the Forces announcing our coming and giving them our address in Paris, and soliciting their advice as to the
paramount needs of men in the service and particularly of our Brethren. Answers to these inquiries soon began to come in, and in
addition an active correspondence commenced with Masonic Clubs which we located by various means, including advertisement in
the Daily Mail, the Paris Herald and the Stars and Stripes. Through the Trowel and Triangle Club, an organization of Freemasons,
who were Secretaries of the A. E. F.-Y. M. C. A., through personal interviews with officers and men, members of the Fraternity who
96

came to us in Paris, and through a thorough canvas of the whole of France by the several members of the Mission, I endeavored to
sense the situation and determine the needs of our men.
I was greatly enlightened on conditions in the occupied territory by interviews with Major W. S. Solomon, 417 Telegraph Battalion,
Signal Corps, a prominent and zealous member of the Fraternity from Rhode Island, who was stationed at Coblentz and who had,
as President, undertaken the reorganization of the Third Army Masonic Club in the occupied territory of Germany, assisted by M.W.
Wendell Davis, Past Grand Master, and by R. W. James S. Collins, then Deputy Grand Master, now Grand Master of Rhode Island,
both secretaries of the A. E. F.-Y. M. C. A. These Brethren, who had been with the forces for months, in conflict, and behind the
lines, and who had been in Germany for some time since the Armistice, not only recognized the need of the Masonic Club referred
to, but had cabled the Grand Master of Rhode Island, requesting a Warrant for an Overseas Lodge with the Army of Occupation,
and in due time were assured that there request had been granted and a Warrant dispatched. I offered these Brethren, whatever I
might decide as respects Lodge activities in France, to hold for them one of the Warrants which I carried, until their own should
arrive, or until they should be assured it had not been lost in transit. Their Warrant, a replica as to authority of those entrusted to me,
arrived in due course, and Overseas Rhode Island Lodge, with Bro. Davis as W. Master, did valiant service for the A. E. F. in the
Occupied Territory and I am informed has been preserved as a living instrumentality for such service as may be required of it, at
home. By virtue of the authority invested in me, I exchanged plenary waivers, over all material in France and in Germany,
respectively, with Overseas Rhode Island Lodge and referred to it all requests for courtesy service coming to me, affecting men
stationed in the Occupied Territory.
The story of this Rhode Island Lodge was given in the January number of THE BUILDER. This mention by Bro. Scudder calls
attention to the perfect harmony that prevailed among the several Masonic bodies representing various groups of Masons at home.
The kindly and courteous fellowship did much to deepen the loyalty of the rank and file to the Institution.
The next thing dealt with in the report is the baffling and perplexing problem of French Masonry. Bro. Scudder said in regard to this:
At the Conference of Grand Masters, held at New York May 9, 1918, the possibility of Overseas Lodge activity under New York
auspices, was intimated to certain of the representatives of Grand Jurisdictions there assembled, and by some, plenary authority
was granted me, to accommodate their material applying to me in France, without reference to headquarters.
Though the Grand Lodge of New York was not, and is not, in fraternal relation with any French Grand Jurisdiction, I bore letters to
the Conseil Federal of the Grand Orient, and to the Grande Loge de France, and also to the Supreme Conseil of the Rite Ecossais
Ancien et Accepte; also to Brother Edmond Heiseh, Senior Grand Warden of the Grand Loge National et Regulaire pour la France,
and soon presented them and established most amicable and friendly personal relations with them all. With each of these
Obediences the possibility of Lodge activity in France, under authority of the Grand Master of Masons in the State of New York, for
the benefit of the A. E. F. was discussed, and from each cordial acquiescence was received, and offers of use of all facilities and
premises belonging to them, without change, were graciously made. It would be difficult to imagine a more perfect courtesy than that
shown me, and all American Freemasons with whom I came in contact, by the Masonic Authorities and brethren of France.
In this statement I am sure the host of American Masons in the A. E. F. who came to know the French brethren will agree. I had a
wide contact with French Freemasons throughout France and found them invariably courteous, generous, willing to exhaust
themselves to care for our Masonic needs. I also found them to constitute the highest mentality in that nation and believe that within
the ranks of Freemasonry in France is to be found the great underlying stable force that keeps France poised and sound.
But returning to the story as told by Bro. Scudder:
As graphically descriptive of the condition of our men when I arrived in France, let me quote the following from an article by
Katherine Mayo in the Outlook for March 3, 1920. Referring to Le Mans, she wrote:
"In order to appreciate, however, anything of what it really meant, one should be able to realize, as perhaps only an eyewitness can
do, the utter depression, the weight of melancholy the general low morale of the whole body of troops held waiting in the
Embarkation Center Area.
"The great machine that had been throwing men across the ocean into France was now to be reversed. All the big, nervous effort
that had preceded the Armistice had stopped short. The excitement was over. A dull, long pause had ensued. Men had begun to fret
and fear about their jobs at home- to ponder at leisure the possible personal cost of their war period. Mail service had been
exceedingly defective. For many months, in many eases, home news had been entirely shut off. Meantime, in America, the
influenza had Slain its thousands, and every man who had failed to hear from his family dreaded the possible truth.
"Under conditions as anxious as these, with little but time killing labor to occupy attention and with sailing orders still delayed, a
vicious circle of thought ground on."
I saw these same conditions. Each member of the Mission saw them in every part of France where our men were. The sad story
was brought to me by Masons in numbers, and by others, competent observers.
I became convinced that valuable as was the influence of the Masonic Club, it was not sufficient. The existence of Masonic life, to
vary the tedium of existence, was necessary. Once established it came to the knowledge of innumerable non-Masons buddies of
our brethren in the service, and they were keen to acquire the same privilege. The need for more genuine Masonic life than the Club
could afford was conspicuous. If we were justified in our effort to serve in the activity of our Sea and Field Lodge, No. 1, in New
York, and in our regularly chartered lodges, men about to be sent out of the country, surely in their sorry plight, if we could, it was
our duty to serve them "over there."
I decided to institute Sea and Field Lodge! No. 2, in Paris, and arranged with the officers of the Grande Loge National, to rent
quarters for that lodge at 42 rue Rochechouart, Paris, in the headquarters in France of that Grand Jurisdiction, and equipped our
97

premises there with such furnishings as were needed. You had designated the personnel of this lodge in the Warrant which you had
signed, and it was supplemented by Brothers Davis and Collins of Rhode Island, Kelly of Nebraska Lee of Oklahoma, Crouch of
West Virginia, Eddy, now Grand Master of Michigan, Acker, Past Grand Master of Texas, and many other keenly interested and
devoted brethren, hailing from all over the United States.
It sat first on April 3, 1919, and nine times thereafter, its last session being July 10, 1919, at which you were present and took part,
and it conferred the degrees of Craft Masonry on 278 candidates, which included 40 candidates accommodated by courtesy for
other lodges.
The full personnel, and the roster, are appended to this report together with the same information respecting the other Sea and Field
Lodges temporarily located in France in the A. E. F.
Thus we have a clear and, to my mind, a very true picture of the conditions under which this Mission operated, and of the causes
that led to the formation of Sea and Field Lodge, No. 2, and its companion lodges. What they meant to the Craft can never be
overstated. The tonic they injected into the demoralized conditions during the period of waiting; the progress of activity which they
provided; the outlet for the pent up emotions. As I sat in the East at the closing communication of the Lodge in Paris, in July, and
watched the eager faces of the brethren and candidates, I was confirmed in my profound conviction that the Military Lodge is just as
justifiable, and just as rational, as any civilian lodge ever was. Only those who have passed through the field conditions of war can
appreciate the tremendous import of the close association afforded by the Masonic Lodge to men whose whole nature is strung
almost to the breaking point.
The tabulation of statistics referred to by Justice Scudder is as follows. It covers the entire life and service of the lodge. A close
study of this chart yields much valuable information.
Communications 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Totals
Dates (1919) 4 4 4 5 5 5 6 6 6 7
3 8 18 2 15 29 5 19 26 10
S & F Material 5 1 9 1 11 28 21 50 50 63 239
New York Lodges 2 1 3 6
Other Jurisdiction 5 5 1 10 6 4 1 2 3 37
Totals 12 1 15 2 24 34 25 51 52 66 282
Dimitted: (1919) 31, (1920) 39 70
New York Lodges 1 1
Other Jurisdiction
1st Degree 1 1 2
2nd Degree 1 1 2 2 3 1 1 3 14
3rd Degree 2 1 2 1 1 7
Going into these statistics a little in detail we discover that the courtesy work covered candidates from Missouri, Ohio, Oregon,
Texas, Washington, Indiana, Kentucky, Ontario, Georgia, Illinois, Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska, South Dakota, California, Kansas,
New Jersey, Montana, Tennessee, England, France, South Carolina.
This Mission carried with it the following authorization from a number of the Grand Lodges which had assembled at Cedar Rapids,
Iowa, to discuss the Masonic situation both at home and abroad in 1918:
CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORITY OF BROTHER TOWNSEND SCUDDER GRAND LODGE OF IOWA, A. F. & A. M. Geo. L.
Schoonover Grand Master of Masons of Iowa Anamosa, Iowa.
This is to certify that at a conference of Grand Masters of Masons in the United States, held November 26, 27 and 28, 1918, at
Cedar Rapids, Iowa, the following resolution was duly adopted:
Be it resolved, That Brother Townsend Scudder, Past Grand Master of New York, and the Chairman of the Commissioners
appointed by the Grand Master of New York. to undertake the Overseas work among the soldiers and sailors of the American
Expeditionary Force, be and he is hereby, appointed and designated as the agent and Commissioner of this Conference and the
Grand Jurisdictions here represented, and those which may hereafter adopt the Constitution of the Masonic Service Association of
the United States, to take charge of the overseas work contemplated and embodied in the Constitution this day adopted.
GEORGE L. SCHOONOVER, Chairman of the Conference.
Attest:
NEWTON R. PARVIN, Secretary of the Conference. December 1, 1918.
From this document it is to be seen that the Mission Overseas was acting not only for New York, but also for a group of Grand
Lodges who had subscribed to the Constitution of the newly organized Masonic Service Association.
With the winding up of the work of Sea and Field Lodge, No. 2, of Paris overseas, the records of this and the other New York
Lodges were returned by the Mission to New York, and deposited in the archives of the Grand Lodge of New York.
98

The roster of No. 2 was consolidated with that of No. 1, and provision was made to dimit all material on the No. 2 roster to the
various lodges within whose jurisdiction the membership of No. 2 resided when at home. This dimitted membership was not turned
adrift without further knowledge and information to the Grand Lodges involved, but full information was transmitted by Sea and Field
Lodge, No. 1, to the Grand Officers of the Grand Lodges, within whose bounds the dimitted brethren resided, so that a check up
could be maintained.
In spite of all this care there were wartime candidates, made overseas, who did not take up their dimits, and in these cases the
brothers have been carried on the roster of Sea and Field Lodge, No. 1, of New York City.
In a letter which I received some time ago from my friend and brother Merwin W. Lay, one of the Overseas Mission. I find this
paragraph:
Sea and Field Lodge, No. 2 (the Paris Lodge), has been perpetuated by a dispensation from our Grand Master to veterans of the
war, and I am glad it is located in Syracuse.
Thus the brethren of New York have proceeded to do what those of Rhode Island did; they have perpetuated the names and the
activities of these overseas Army Lodges. It was a wise provision, and as the years stretch out their course, more and more will
these names gather to themselves memories and traditions of inestimable value to their membership and to the Craft at large.
Too much praise to the members of the Overseas Mission cannot be given. And alongside this praise must ever be added the
praise for the foresightedness of those Grand Lodges which made possible the formation of the Masonic Service Association in the
time of War to meet the stringent requirements laid upon the Craft by the Government, when great need arose for universal Masonic
aid to the Craft under arms.
That the reader may once more be reminded of the brothers who carried on the labors of this Army Lodge, I offer the tableau of their
Lodge:
W. M. Townsend Scudder, New York City.
S. W. Thomas Channing Moore, New York City.
J. W. Mermin W. Lay, Syracuse, N. Y.
Secy. William C. Prime, Yonkers, N. Y.
Treas. ..........
S. D. George S. Goodrich, Bronxville, N. Y.
J. D. B. D. Norman.
Tyl. C. B. Blackwell.
I cannot close my story of this Lodge without revealing a personal contact I had with Sea and Field, No. 2, in Paris. It is my first and
only opportunity to get back at dear Bro. Goodrich, who caused me to have a rather embarrassing interview with my good wife upon
my return home. I had received a very distressing letter from my home parish, from a widowed and crippled aged mother, asking me
to try to locate the grave of her son. I obtained leave and went to Paris, from which city I planned to re-visit the battle front and
attempt to find the boy's resting place. In Paris I ran in to the headquarters of the Overseas Mission, as I was wont to do every time I
went there. Having heard of the fund of money they had at their command I resolved to try them out in order that I might testify upon
return to America to the actual working of their financial scheme. I had more than sufficient money in my money belt to cover all my
expenses. Nevertheless I remarked to Bro. Goodrich, who presided over the office at this time, "How about a little loan for a few
weeks ?" "Help yourself," replied George. Opening a drawer in his desk he displayed enough French paper money to paper the four
walls of an office. I closed my eyes, stretched my fingers to utmost capacity, and reached in. I drew out my hand holding a bundle of
the money. Saying good-bye I left the office and went down to the street. Then I retraced my steps and looked into the office once
more and said, "Goodrich, you never asked me for a receipt." "Get along with you," replied he, "you have sufficient credentials
already. You are a Mason, a Chaplain, and officer of the U. S. Army." I wrote out an I. O. U. after this manner: "This is to
acknowledge the receipt of a loan of ..... francs from the Overseas Mission, Paris." I signed my name and went out. I had assured
Bro. Goodrich I would send him a French Postal Order as soon as I returned to my station. He was to send to me the I. O. U. After
some time on the old battle line I returned to my station and sent the Postal Order to Paris. But Goodrich never sent the I. O. U.
back to camp. After months in the service I landed in my home town in the late summer of 1919, and a few days later my wife came
to me with a very serious face, and handing me a slip of paper inquired, "What does this mean? Why were you in Paris, without any
money?" Goodrich had sent the I. O. U. to my American address. And to this day my wife has a reminiscent gleam in her eye every
time Paris is mentioned in conversation. Thus in my earnest desire to test the generosity of the Masons at home, I created a
situation that almost severed my relations with "friend" wife. I have long wanted to get back at Bro. Goodrich, and now after almost
ten years I have accomplished it.
William S. Farmer Lodge No. 1109
780 Woods Road, Solvay, New York
Jun 1931 –
Petition Date: 1 Jul 1930. The petition was accompanied by twelve Certificates of
Consent from the various Lodges affected and Certificates showing dues of 42
petitioners paid.
Under Dispensation: 11 Aug 1930 to 13 Apr 1931
Constituted: 1 Jun 1931
99

Charter Members (63):
Adams, Cedric S.
Atwood, Clinton H.
Barber, Samuel J.
Berger, Fred L. Jr.
Berger, Martin C.
Blair, Gerald L.
Blair, Ronald
Boyle, James E.
Briggs, Louis
Bryers, John J.
Callan, Lawrence
Coseo, William R.
Cottrell, Oliver J.
Craig, Frank
Craig, John
Cunningham, Leo G.
Darrow, Fred J.
Darrow, Marcus
Deutsche, Zola
Dorchester, Earl
DuVall, Claude A.
Forth, Arthur J.
Fulmer, I. H.
Glenn, Charles S.
Glisson, Frank
Gorman, Louis N.
Grant, Frederick L.
Grant, Theodore H.
Greene, Clayton
Greene, Kenneth
Hadley, H. Earl
Hall, Charles R.
Hall, Edwin M.
Hand, Horner
Hardy, John C.
Hodge, Elvin L.
Horrigan, G. Ivan
Hurst, Oscar J.
Johnson, Howard H.
Kanar, Orson
Kasso, R. M.
Lawrence, George
Lawton, Earl A.
Luchsinger, Fred J.
Mathers, Edwin
McKaig, Lloyd
Mitchell, Roy B.
Morris, Earl W.
Page, Willis C.
Parks, Frank
Patchin, William
Patrick, David L.
Preston, Francis
Rarick, George T.
Robinson, Frank
Salisbury, Clyde N.
Stanton, Harry
Voorhees, Herman
Wall, Francis E.
Walters, Frank
Weyant, Walter B.
Wiley, T. Harold
Williamson, Stanley
No history of William S. Farmer Lodge would be complete without some mention of the Solvay Masonic Club and those men whose
foresight, ability and courage made possible the Solvay Masonic Temple and who later overcame difficulties and obtained a
dispensation and charter for the Lodge.
The background date, relating to William S. Farmer Lodge No. 1109 of Solvay, is somewhat unique. The airline Masonic jurisdiction
rules divided the Village of Solvay and nearby area into several different districts. Most Masons residing in the area were members
of Liverpool, Camillus and Syracuse Lodges. There was much interest in having a Masonic organization in Solvay. The creation of a
Lodge in the area seemed quite remote, so, the creation of the Solvay Masonic Club came about in March of 1923, due mainly to
the efforts of Brothers Frederick Luchsinger, Howard Johnson and Clinton Atwood. There was great interest and the Club was well
supported by the Masons of the community who met in rented halls. In early 1924 the Club obtained use of a third floor with kitchen
facilities where they met twice a month for $36 a year plus $1 each time the kitchen was used. They later paid 25 cents per month
extra to reimburse the occupant on the second floor for gas used, since it ran through his meter.
On 23 May 1924 a building fund was started and on 19 Jun 1924 the Club took the necessary steps to incorporate. The legal work
was done by Truman Preston, and through the efforts of Charles Glenn and John Bryers, a deed was acquired from the Solvay
Process Company for the sum of $1 for the property on Woods Road where the building now stands.
In March 1926 the necessary motions were passed to acquire the money to start construction and it appeared that they were on the
way to having a Masonic Temple even though they had no Masonic Lodge – and unusual situation. Melvin King, a prominent
Syracuse architect, offered to be the architect and fees would be his actual costs. The plans for the building were similar to ones
erected in Phoenix and Liverpool, NY, by his firm.
The building was erected through the supervision of John Craig, a Club member and local contractor. His interest and skills gave
them a beautiful building and he was voted a life membership after the building was completed. The cornerstone was laid by M.’.W.’.
Judge William S. Farmer on 25 Sep 1926. Much of the work was done by the members. They laid flooring, did carpentry, wiring,
steamfitting, plumbing, and carried bricks and mortar. Interest, enthusiasm and cooperation was wonderful. They had a purpose
which was to benefit their community and to provide a place of much enjoyment for the members and their families.
Soon after the completion of the Solvay Masonic Temple, the need for a Solvay Masonic Lodge became apparent. Those Masons
who worked so hard in the planning and construction of the Temple came from many different Lodges and a closer bond of
fellowship would result if a Lodge could be chartered in the Village of Solvay. This proved to a long and difficult thing to do. First, it
would be necessary to obtain an amendment to the Grand Lodge Constitution and, second, it would be necessary to obtain the
permission and good will of the twelve Masonic Lodges in the district that would be affected.
Much of the credit for final success must go to Brothers Charles Glenn and Fred Luchsinger who, among other things, visited each
of the Lodges in the district and explained the reasons and need for a Solvay Lodge.
During Grand Lodge in 1929, with the help of R.’.W.’. Grant Goodelle, then District Deputy, and other outstanding Masons in the city
of Syracuse, a resolution was offered proposing that a section be added to Grand Lodge Constitutions authorizing the organization
of a Masonic Lodge in the Village of Solvay with jurisdiction confined to the boundaries of the Village as they then existed. In 1930
the resolution was ratified and became a part of the Grand Lodge Constitution.
On 1 Jul 1930 a petition was sent to Grand Lodge for a letter of dispensation to establish a Lodge in the Village of Solvay. It was
accompanied by 12 certificates of consent from the Lodges affected and certificates showing dues of 42 petitioners paid. As a result,
a Dispensation was granted and presented to W.’. John C. Hardy, the Lodge’s first Master, and his officers. The Lodge operated
under this dispensation from Aug 1930 to Apr 1931, during which time 8 candidates were raised and 16 became members by
affiliation.
At the 1931 session of Grand Lodge, the Lodge was chartered as William S. Farmer Lodge No. 1109, F&AM, and on 1 Jun 1931 the
Lodge was formally constituted by M.’.W.’. Charles H. Johnson. This was perhaps one of the few times in history that Grand Lodge
officers established a new Lodge in a Masonic Temple already erected.
In 1953, through the efforts of Bro. Frank Darrow, a move was started to obtain concurrent jurisdiction in the Town of Geddes, with
all of the Lodges affected. When it became evident that his plan had too much opposition, the matter was dropped. However, in
1956, a change was made in the Grand Lodge Constitution giving the Lodge concurrent jurisdiction with Liverpool Lodge on that
part of the Town of Geddes lying generally north of the Village of Solvay.
In April 1955 Anchor Assembly, Order of Rainbow for Girls was formed and in 1956 they received their Charter, sponsored by the
Lodge, and soon thereafter the Iroquois Chapter of DeMolay for Boys was also sponsored. Both of these organizations were very
successful and active.
100

Biographical
M..W.. William S. Farmer was a man who lived by the teachings of Masonry and worked incessantly to promote the Craft in this
State. He was born 18 Jul 1861 at Hailesborough, St. Lawrence, NY; he studied law and was admitted to the Bar in 1882. In 1889
he moved to Kimball, South Dakota, where he was both lawyer and banker. He returned to Syracuse in 1891 to become a partner in
a law firm with his brother, H. H. Farmer. He was appointed Judge of the Municipal Court in 1915 where he served until his death.
Raised in Central City Lodge No. 305 on 20 Nov 1894, he became Master of his Lodge in 1899-1900. He served as District Deputy
for the 27th District of Onondaga, Cortland and Madison Counties 1902-1904. In 1908 he was appointed to the Grand Lodge
Commission of Appeals, and was elected Grand Junior Warden in 1910, Grand Senior Warden in 1914, and served as Grand
Master 1918 and 1919. M.’.W.’. Farmer was later appointed to head the committee on the George Washington Memorial at
Alexandria, Virginia, and had just returned from a meeting at Washington when he died on 22 Feb 1930.
Past Masters
Hardy, John C. 1931
Hardy, John C. 1932
Barber, Samuel J. 1933
Morris, Earl W. 1934
Horrigan, G. Ivan 1935
Hurst, Oscar J. 1936
Grant, Fred L. 1937
Coseo, William R. 1938
Cohen, Asher S. 1939
Patrick, David L. 1940
Horrigan, James D. 1941
Cohen, Solly S. 1942
Hardy, J. Edwin 1943
Johnson, Peter Jr. 1944
Weyant, Walter B. 1945
Walsh, James E. 1946
Gorbutt, Albert P. 1947
Donahue, Arthur C. 1948
MacKaig, Lloyd F. 1949
Hummell, Charles B. 1950
Pierson, Robert L. Sr. 1951
Hendrickson, A. Elroy 1952
Darrow, Frank S. 1953
Darrow, Fred M. 1954
Raaflaub, Fred E. 1955
Forhth, Harold J. 1956
Johnson, Alan 1957
Burritt, Clayton M. 1958
Roberts, Charles C. 1959
Cunningham, L. Herman1960
Wall, William E. 1961
Tindall, Albert W. 1962
Their, David J. 1963
Bell, Craig 1964
Neufand, Robert F. 1965
Tolhurst, George R. 1966
Carrodeguas, Leon 1967
Jerome, Van 1968
Christopher, John 1969
Dearden, Abbott 1970
Sniffen, Robert 1971
Conger, George F. 1972
Conger, Jason H. 1973
Menke, Hector H. 1974
Jones, Garfield 1975
Anderson, Robert E. 1976
Barlow, Walter 1977
Hoornany, Nicholas 1978
Green, Albert E. 1979
Metcalf, Richard 1980
Metcalf, Richard 1981
Piety Hill Lodge No. 1168
Syracuse, New York
1969 –
Dispensation 1967
Chartered 1968
Met at the Masonic Temple, 320 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, NY
In 1966 M.’.W.’. Frank Staples, GM, proposed a new concept for Masonic Lodges in the State of New York. It was to charter a lodge
at a university to attract younger members and at a reduced initiation fee. M.’.W.’. Staples had joined such a lodge in Massachusetts
when he was a student at M.I.T. He conveyed this information to R.’.W.’. Frederick Sears, PGW, who was instrumental in executing
the designs which were on the Grand Master’s Trestle Board and who became a founding member of the new lodge. This idea was
well received by the local Masonic leadership and gained unanimous support from the local Masons.
A name was chosen for the new lodge from the area of Syracuse where the Syracuse University and Upstate Medical Center are
located. The people call the area Piety Hill, because a religious college had been located there in the past.
Piety Hill Lodge was granted Dispensation in 1967 and R.’.W.’. Dr. William Harris was its first Master. He was subsequently honored
in being appointed DDGM of the 1 st Onondaga District.
Piety Hill was chartered in 1968 in an impressive ceremony with M.’.W.’. Charles Gosnell, GM, presiding. Its first elected officers in
1969 were:
Master W.’. Dr. Kendrick Sears
SW Harold Sanderson
JW Terrell V. Norris
Treas W.’. William Hartwell
Secy Gordon Lovell
Piety Hill drew its membership from the faculty, staff, students and alumni of Syracuse University and the Upstate Medical Center,
including many brothers from Acacia Fraternity. It was the second youngest lodge in the State of New York and had the distinction
of always reaching its goal in the Brotherhood Fund Drive. Piety Hill Lodge fulfilled its purpose as a University oriented lodge
annually bringing many young men into Masonry and also providing a home away from home for sojourning Masons at Syracuse
University and the Upstate Medical Center.
Ref: ‘Masonic History of Onondaga County, Commemorating the Bicentennial,’ the Word, Sep 1976, pg. 21.
101