Which Alice?

ALICE IN PUZZLE-LAND
he responded by drawing a circle, then he means yes by a circle and
no by a square, so he doesn't have the prize.
In summary, if he draws a square, he has the prize; if he draws a
circle, then the other one has the prize.
Chapter 9
In all the solutions for this chapter we shall let A be the first
defendant, B the second defendant, and C the third defendant.
WHICH ONE WAS GUILTY? We are given that the guilty one
lied. If B were guilty, he would have told the truth when he accused
himself; therefore, B cannot be guilty. If A were guilty, then all
three of them would have lied (because A would have accused
either B or C, both of whom were innocent; B would have accused
himself, who was innocent; and C would have accused either C, who
was innocent, or A, who is innocent). But we are given that not all of
them lied, so A can't be guilty either. So C was guilty.
THE SECOND ACCOUNT What could the White King have
been told which enabled him to know who the guilty one was? If he
had been told that all three of them lied, he could never have
known who was guilty, because it could be that A was guilty and
accused B, and B and C accused each other (so all of them lied); or
it could be that B was guilty and accused C, and A and C accused
each other (again all of them lied); or again it could be C was guilty
and accused A, and A and B accused each other. So the White King
was not told that all of them lied.
Could the King have solved the case if he had been told that
exactly two of them lied, and which two they were? No: Suppose,
174