Which Alice?

Which Alice? Which Alice?

logic.books.info
from logic.books.info More from this publisher
02.04.2014 Views

The White Knight Couldn't Quite Remember "Oh, good!" said Alice. "Which ones did lie and which ones did tell the truth?" "Alas, I have forgotten that by now!" replied the Knight. "Then I guess it's hopeless for me to solve the mystery," said Alice sadly. "That's very remarkable that you should have said that!" replied the Knight. "Because the same thing happened to me last week. I met Humpty Dumpty and told the case to him. I also told him that I had told the White King about the case a week earlier and that the White King was able to solve it after I told him which ones lied and which ones told the truth. Then Humpty Dumpty asked me which ones had lied and which ones had told the truth, but by then I had forgotten, so I couldn't answer Humpty Dumpty's question. Then Humpty Dumpty also said, 'Then I guess it is hopeless for me to solve it.'" 10

The White Knight Couldn't Quite Remember<br />

"Oh, good!" said <strong>Alice</strong>. "<strong>Which</strong> ones did lie and which ones did<br />

tell the truth?"<br />

"Alas, I have forgotten that by now!" replied the Knight.<br />

"Then I guess it's hopeless for me to solve the mystery," said <strong>Alice</strong><br />

sadly.<br />

"That's very remarkable that you should have said that!" replied<br />

the Knight. "Because the same thing happened to me last week. I<br />

met Humpty Dumpty and told the case to him. I also told him that I<br />

had told the White King about the case a week earlier and that the<br />

White King was able to solve it after I told him which ones lied and<br />

which ones told the truth. Then Humpty Dumpty asked me which<br />

ones had lied and which ones had told the truth, but by then I had<br />

forgotten, so I couldn't answer Humpty Dumpty's question. Then<br />

Humpty Dumpty also said, 'Then I guess it is hopeless for me to<br />

solve it.'" 10

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!