Which Alice?

Which Alice? Which Alice?

logic.books.info
from logic.books.info More from this publisher
02.04.2014 Views

The White Knight Couldn't Quite Remember "Who were the defendants?" repeated the White Knight. "Who were they? I can't quite remember just who they were, but I definitely remember there were three of them." "Well, what happened at the trial?" asked Alice. "What happened?" repeated the Knight. "Why, the defendants made statements!" "What statements did they make?" asked Alice, who was getting just a little impatient with the rather slow way the account was going. "What statements?" repeated the Knight. "What statements? I can't quite remember just what the statements were, but I do remember that they made statements." "Really now!" said Alice, who was getting quite exasperated. "Don't you remember anything about the statements?" "Oh, yes," replied the White Knight, "I remember something about them. The first defendant accused either the second defendant or the third defendant, but I don't remember which one." "What about the second defendant?" asked Alice. "Well, the second defendant was asked who was guilty, and to everyone's surprise he claimed to be the guilty one." "And the third defendant?" asked Alice. "Well, the third defendant was asked who was guilty, and either he accused himself or he accused the second defendant, but unfortunately I can't quite remember which." Alice tried to puzzle all this out, but could not make head or tail of what went on. "Tell me," said Alice, "did the innocent defendants both know who the guilty defendant was?" "Oh, yes," replied the Knight, "the defendants all knew who was guilty." "Then I guess some of the defendants lied, and maybe some told the truth. Is that it?" "That's right," replied the Knight. "Some of them lied and some of them told the truth." "Can you remember which ones lied and which ones told the truth?" asked Alice. "Well," replied the White Knight, "I remember that the guilty one lied. As for the innocent ones, I remember that either one of 103

The White Knight Couldn't Quite Remember<br />

"Who were the defendants?" repeated the White Knight. "Who<br />

were they? I can't quite remember just who they were, but I<br />

definitely remember there were three of them."<br />

"Well, what happened at the trial?" asked <strong>Alice</strong>.<br />

"What happened?" repeated the Knight. "Why, the defendants<br />

made statements!"<br />

"What statements did they make?" asked <strong>Alice</strong>, who was getting<br />

just a little impatient with the rather slow way the account was going.<br />

"What statements?" repeated the Knight. "What statements? I<br />

can't quite remember just what the statements were, but I do<br />

remember that they made statements."<br />

"Really now!" said <strong>Alice</strong>, who was getting quite exasperated.<br />

"Don't you remember anything about the statements?"<br />

"Oh, yes," replied the White Knight, "I remember something about<br />

them. The first defendant accused either the second defendant or<br />

the third defendant, but I don't remember which one."<br />

"What about the second defendant?" asked <strong>Alice</strong>.<br />

"Well, the second defendant was asked who was guilty, and to<br />

everyone's surprise he claimed to be the guilty one."<br />

"And the third defendant?" asked <strong>Alice</strong>.<br />

"Well, the third defendant was asked who was guilty, and either<br />

he accused himself or he accused the second defendant, but<br />

unfortunately I can't quite remember which."<br />

<strong>Alice</strong> tried to puzzle all this out, but could not make head or tail<br />

of what went on.<br />

"Tell me," said <strong>Alice</strong>, "did the innocent defendants both know<br />

who the guilty defendant was?"<br />

"Oh, yes," replied the Knight, "the defendants all knew who was<br />

guilty."<br />

"Then I guess some of the defendants lied, and maybe some told<br />

the truth. Is that it?"<br />

"That's right," replied the Knight. "Some of them lied and some<br />

of them told the truth."<br />

"Can you remember which ones lied and which ones told the<br />

truth?" asked <strong>Alice</strong>.<br />

"Well," replied the White Knight, "I remember that the guilty<br />

one lied. As for the innocent ones, I remember that either one of<br />

103

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!