Which Alice?

Which Alice? Which Alice?

logic.books.info
from logic.books.info More from this publisher
02.04.2014 Views

The Twelfth Question "Yes, I realize that," said Alice, a bit nervously. "And being nervous won't help a bit!" added the Queen. "I realize that, too," replied Alice, even more nervously. "Now, child, here is the question—remember, everything depends on whether you answer it wrong or right!" "Yes, yes, I know!" cried Alice. "Well, the question is this: Will you pass this examination?" "How should I know?" replied Alice, surprised at her own boldness. "Tut, tut, child; that's no answer!" said the Red Queen. "You must give me a definite answer—yes or no. If you answer correctly, you will pass; if you don't you will fail—it's as simple as that!" The matter didn't seem quite that simple to Alice! Indeed, the more she thought it over, the more puzzling it became. Then she suddenly realized something very interesting! If she answered one way, then the Red Queen would have the option of either passing her or failing her as she pleased. If she should answer the other way, then it would be impossible for the Queen either to pass her or fail her without contradicting her own rules! Well, since Alice was more interested in not failing than in passing, she chose the second alternative, and answered in such a way as totally to confound the Queen. What answer did she give? 73

The Twelfth Question<br />

"Yes, I realize that," said <strong>Alice</strong>, a bit nervously.<br />

"And being nervous won't help a bit!" added the Queen.<br />

"I realize that, too," replied <strong>Alice</strong>, even more nervously.<br />

"Now, child, here is the question—remember, everything depends<br />

on whether you answer it wrong or right!"<br />

"Yes, yes, I know!" cried <strong>Alice</strong>.<br />

"Well, the question is this: Will you pass this examination?"<br />

"How should I know?" replied <strong>Alice</strong>, surprised at her own<br />

boldness.<br />

"Tut, tut, child; that's no answer!" said the Red Queen. "You<br />

must give me a definite answer—yes or no. If you answer correctly,<br />

you will pass; if you don't you will fail—it's as simple as that!"<br />

The matter didn't seem quite that simple to <strong>Alice</strong>! Indeed, the<br />

more she thought it over, the more puzzling it became. Then she<br />

suddenly realized something very interesting! If she answered one<br />

way, then the Red Queen would have the option of either passing<br />

her or failing her as she pleased. If she should answer the other<br />

way, then it would be impossible for the Queen either to pass her or<br />

fail her without contradicting her own rules! Well, since <strong>Alice</strong> was<br />

more interested in not failing than in passing, she chose the second<br />

alternative, and answered in such a way as totally to confound the<br />

Queen.<br />

What answer did she give?<br />

73

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!