24.03.2014 Views

Table of contents

Table of contents

Table of contents

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

<strong>Table</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>contents</strong><br />

1.1 Rules and regulations 1<br />

1.2 Scope and hand-in formats 1<br />

1.3 Evaluation criteria 1<br />

2 3 September 2011, Carlsberg Group Headquarters, Valby 2<br />

3 Carlsberg’s History and Heritage 4<br />

4 Boulder: The re-launch <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg Group’s flagship brand 5<br />

5 Carlsberg Group’s Stand 7<br />

6 Carlsberg Group’s Winning Behaviours put into action 9<br />

7 The Strategy Wheel 10<br />

8 Local idea with global scope - the beer list 11<br />

9 The GloCal approach 12<br />

10 The scrutiny <strong>of</strong> beer: Dark markets 13<br />

11 Thirst for Beer 14<br />

12 Carlsberg Group’s consumer segments: The right occasion and the right brand 16<br />

13 Carlsberg Group: One <strong>of</strong> the world’s largest FMCG companies 18<br />

14 Summing up 19<br />

15 Perspectives on the case – Communication challenges 20<br />

The Corporate Brand Perspective 20<br />

The Financial Perspective 20<br />

The Intercultural Perspective 20<br />

The CSR Perspective 21<br />

16 Instructions 22<br />

17 Overview <strong>of</strong> handed-out material 23<br />

Carlberg Breweries A/S (Director <strong>of</strong> Corporate Communications Iben Johannesen and Communications Coordinator<br />

Maria Tejada Ljungbeck) prepared this case for ComCaseCompetition 2012 with assistance from Copenhagen<br />

Business School (Associate Pr<strong>of</strong>essor Karl-Heinz Pogner, Department <strong>of</strong> Intercultural Communication<br />

and Management).


1.1 Rules and regulations<br />

The competition stretches from Wednesday January 25th to Wednesday January 26th.<br />

The participants have to hand in no more than 7 Power Point- slides, and an executive summary <strong>of</strong> no more<br />

than 2500 Standard Typographic Units (STU) by 12.30 n January 26th.<br />

1.2 Scope and hand in formats<br />

The participants (groups <strong>of</strong> 4- 5 students) should prepare a problem-based and solution-oriented presentation<br />

(7 slides) and a short executive summary (2500 STU) <strong>of</strong> their findings and recommendations about their<br />

chosen research question and their chosen perspective/s concerning the case.<br />

The 3 best presentation drafts and executive summaries will go to the final, where the finalists present their<br />

findings and recommendations in a 15 minutes pitch for the jury, who will ask questions and discuss the solutions<br />

for 10 minutes. The groups decide themselves how to do the presentation.<br />

1.3 Evaluation criteria<br />

The evaluation <strong>of</strong> the groups’ presentations will be based on the following evaluation criteria:<br />

The participants should demonstrate that they are able to<br />

Identify, analyze and solve a key problem<br />

Apply theories, models and key concepts to the practical communication in a solution oriented manner<br />

Design pr<strong>of</strong>essional, innovative and creative – but realistic - communication strategies that are embedded in<br />

the organizational context<br />

Reflect upon how preconditions, chosen key concepts, methods and theories have an impact on strengths,<br />

limitations and weaknesses <strong>of</strong> the problem solution<br />

Communicate the results in an adequate, correct language in a coherent, convincing presentation and discussion<br />

that fulfills rhetorical, academic and pr<strong>of</strong>essional standards.<br />

NOTES


1. 3 September 2011, Carlsberg Group Headquarters, Valby<br />

The elevator doors slowly opened onto the 20th floor exposing dark mahogany floors. Mr. Jørgen Buhl Rasmussen<br />

glanced at the Carlsberg memorabilia hanging impeccably on the walls. It was late. The sun had given<br />

way to the moon hours ago, and there were probably still a few Carlsberg employees and their families milling<br />

around the Carlsberg district, sipping on beers and listening to the last verses <strong>of</strong> D.A.D. It would have been<br />

hard to be in Copenhagen today without noticing that Carlsberg was celebrating its founder, J.C. Jacobsen’s<br />

200th birthday.<br />

Mr. Buhl Rasmussen thought back to the speech he made in TAP1, the overwhelming cheer and positive energy<br />

his Danish and international employees exhibited had awed him. He made his way to the window. Standing<br />

high above the rest <strong>of</strong> Copenhagen, CEO <strong>of</strong> the Carlsberg Group, the 4th largest brewery in the world, with<br />

over 40,000 employees on three continents, Jørgen Buhl Rasmussen’s thoughts brought him back to today’s<br />

event.<br />

There had been several incentives for creating such a celebration out <strong>of</strong> the 200th anniversary. Foremost it<br />

was to honour J.C. Jacobsen, Carlsberg’s founder. Moreover 3 September was an important part <strong>of</strong> the transformation<br />

journey that the Carlsberg Group as a global brand was on; the celebration was meant to illustrate<br />

how Carlsberg had made a strategic decision to use the company’s heritage to look to the future and ultimately<br />

inspire people today.<br />

Since his promotion from Executive Vice President to President and CEO in 2007 up until quite recently, things<br />

had been looking promising for the Carlsberg Group. Carlsberg’s transformation journey took <strong>of</strong>f long before<br />

Mr. Buhl Rasmussen had joined the corporation. Back in 1999, Carlsberg was primarily a regional brewer in<br />

Scandinavia and the UK. By 2007 the Carlsberg Group saw itself as the market leader in Northern Europe and<br />

parts <strong>of</strong> Eastern Europe and Asia.<br />

In April 2008 the Carlsberg Group made the biggest acquisition ever made in Denmark by acquiring Scottish &<br />

Newcastle. This had proven very beneficial for the company, not only acquiring S&N’s shares <strong>of</strong> French, Greek,<br />

Chinese and Vietnamese operations, the Carlsberg Group had also gained sole ownership <strong>of</strong> Baltika Breweries,<br />

the biggest FMCG (Fast Moving Consumer Goods) company and the biggest brewer in Russia. In 2008 the<br />

media had declared Carlsberg Group as having entered the super league and the venture with Baltika Breweries<br />

had strengthened Carlsberg’s position on the global beer market considerably.<br />

Things continued to look increasingly promising as the newly acquired local markets and brands were integrated<br />

into Carlsberg, creating what was now the Carlsberg Group – 140 markets and 500 brands under one ro<strong>of</strong>.<br />

The Carlsberg Group controlled 43% <strong>of</strong> total volume in Northern and Western Europe, 41% <strong>of</strong> total volume in<br />

Eastern Europe, and 16% in Asia with projections to improve competitiveness and earnings, ensure pr<strong>of</strong>itable<br />

growth, and build growth platforms respectively.<br />

As the Carlsberg Group had grown to include diverse brewers and brands from around the world, Mr. Buhl<br />

Rasmussen and his team became increasingly aware <strong>of</strong> the importance to acknowledge that each <strong>of</strong> these<br />

companies represented its own corporate culture, regional personality and point <strong>of</strong> market differentiation<br />

NOTES


and it was becoming crucial to unify these companies as the Carlsberg Group. Among employees there still<br />

seemed to exist a divide between countries, markets and cultures, and with projections for more growth, as<br />

well as further expansions and acquisitions it was becoming imperative for the Carlsberg Group to communicate<br />

an authentic and inspiring Group story, while still maintaining a “GloCal” (Global and Local) approach,<br />

and retaining regional and local brand value. Carlsberg Group faced the challenge <strong>of</strong> what seemed to be a lack<br />

<strong>of</strong> cultural communication and understanding between the various markets in which the global brewery exists.<br />

This included cultural challenges among old, mature markets and new emerging beer markets, as well as<br />

perhaps a deficiency in clear communication regarding how things are done in different parts <strong>of</strong> the world. Beyond<br />

this many long-established breweries that had been bought up by Carlsberg Group such as Baltika and<br />

Brasseries Kronenbourg possessed traditions and a certain pride that could contest some <strong>of</strong> the procedures<br />

implemented by the Carlsberg Group on a whole. This said, it would be a lot easier said than done to execute<br />

the actual implementation <strong>of</strong> the GloCal approach.<br />

Overlooking the old brewery district in Valby, Jørgen Buhl Rasmussen thought back to the current trouble in<br />

Russia. The Russian beer market was negatively impacted by significant duty increase in 2010 and a challenging<br />

macroeconomic environment, and it had only been a few weeks since the Carlsberg Group’s 2011 Quarter<br />

2 (Q2) results had been released on 17 August. Q2 had not reaped the results that the company had expected;<br />

Eastern Europe came in below expectations, with a disappointing Russian market performance and although<br />

the Northern and Western Europe regions and Asia had shown positive performance with pr<strong>of</strong>it improvements<br />

and market growth, the decline in Russia was continuing to impact the Carlsberg Group negatively. Despite the<br />

improved macroeconomic conditions in Russia, local consumers had not yet adjusted to substantial price increases<br />

and the weather conditions in Q2 had also been unusually poor. Baltika Breweries, Carlsberg’s Russian<br />

conglomerate that stood behind the best selling beer in Europe - Baltika, had simply not been able to match<br />

its own recognized name and Carlsberg Group<br />

Sitting down slowly, Mr. Buhl Rasmussen was once again reminded <strong>of</strong> J.C. Jacobsen’s birthday today. The<br />

sun had beat down on the Carlsberg district. Children and adults alike had enjoyed the warm temperatures<br />

that are unusual to Copenhagen in September. The area buzzed with activity, over 40,000 people had been<br />

expected to show up to celebrate J.C. Jacobsen’s birthday. The celebration had been the perfect example <strong>of</strong><br />

the Carlsberg Group drawing from its history and heritage, and ultimately inspiring employees and consumers<br />

alike.<br />

Mr. Buhl Rasmussen and his team would have to use today as a trampoline; the energy that had been so<br />

clearly reflected in the Carlsberg employees and the spirit that could be felt all around the Carlsberg district<br />

was the exact message the Carlsberg Group needed to relay across all 140 markets.<br />

NOTES


2. Carlsberg’s History and Heritage<br />

Carlsberg’s rich heritage in scientific discoveries dates back to 1845 when a young J.C. Jacobsen (J.C.) made his<br />

way back from Munich to Copenhagen in a horse drawn stagecoach. Gently nestled on his knee lay a hatbox<br />

that contained something that has since revolutionized the brewing industry; a special yeast from a brewery in<br />

Germany. The living yeast survived the journey, and it was not long before J.C. was ready to produce 300 barrels<br />

<strong>of</strong> Bavarian lager beer which quickly proved very popular. Perched on a hill in Valby J.C. Jacobsen founded<br />

his brewery in 1847, calling it Carlsberg in honour <strong>of</strong> his only son Carl and the “mountain” (“bjerg” in Danish) on<br />

which the brewery lay.<br />

J.C. was not one to keep innovations to himself and it did not take long for Carlsberg’s founder to realize the<br />

important connection between natural science and industrial innovation. A man that demanded quality, J.C.<br />

founded the Carlsberg Laboratory in 1875 as an independent institution. Nowadays the Carlsberg Laboratory<br />

still makes outstanding scientific discoveries which continue to benefit and transform the beverage industry. In<br />

1883 Scientist Emil Christian Hansen developed a method for propagating pure yeast, named Saccharomyces<br />

Carlsbergensis. Before that impurities in yeast meant that beer would <strong>of</strong>ten turn sour during production or<br />

transportation.<br />

The clean yeast was given freely to the world, and is still used in every mass-produced lager beer today. J.C.’s<br />

inventions in the art <strong>of</strong> beer production and his disposition for sharing his and his colleagues’ scientific discoveries<br />

with the world have laid the cornerstone <strong>of</strong> the modern brewing industry.<br />

J.C.’s son Carl Jacobsen would go on to be just as talented a brewer as his father. A patron <strong>of</strong> art, Carl<br />

amassed a huge art collection as well as building two museums to house the paintings. One <strong>of</strong> the museums,<br />

the Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek in Copenhagen is still open to the public today. Much like his father, Carl was<br />

also armed with a deep passion and interest in the art <strong>of</strong> beer making. In 1903 Carlsberg and Tuborg’s United<br />

Breweries signed a formal agreement <strong>of</strong> cooperation that was to last 100 years, the “1903-agreement” would<br />

ensure that although the breweries were still to run independently and in competition, it was agreed that they<br />

would share all pr<strong>of</strong>its and losses, and participate equally in each other’s investments in new installations.<br />

In 1882 J.C. Jacobsen carved the ‘golden words’ into the stonework <strong>of</strong> the original Carlsberg brewery in 1882.<br />

The mision and vision <strong>of</strong> those days:<br />

“In working the brewery it should be a constant purpose, regardless <strong>of</strong> immediate gain, to develop the art <strong>of</strong><br />

making beer to the greatest possible degree <strong>of</strong> perfection so that this brewery as well as its products may ever<br />

stand out as a model, and through their example, assist in keeping beer brewing in this country at a high and<br />

honourable level.” J.C. Jacobsen, Carlsberg’s Founder.<br />

NOTES


3. Boulder: The re-launch <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg Group’s flagship brand<br />

5 April 2011. A day 40,000 employees in over 150 countries across the globe had been anticipating for months.<br />

Today the Carlsberg Group was launching a new brand proposition for its flagship beer Carlsberg, rolled out<br />

across all markets simultaneously in what was the company’s largest international makeover to date. This<br />

was no small feat; a global re-launch <strong>of</strong> the iconic Carlsberg brand would not only see the removal <strong>of</strong> the<br />

company’s globally recognized tagline “Probably the best beer in the world” replaced with the new, modernized<br />

proposition, “That calls for a Carlsberg”, but the international transformation would be unveiling a package<br />

that would bring changes to both the brand proposition and Carlsberg’s visual identity.<br />

Standing on the stage <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg’s TAP2, Khalil Younes, Senior Vice President <strong>of</strong> Group Sales, Marketing and<br />

Innovation (GSMI) welcomed Carlsberg’s employees to what was internally referred to as C-Day: “Carlsberg<br />

is a fantastic brand, but the brand has even more potential that can be cultivated. Now, we also want to add<br />

essence to our brand. It is time we take Carlsberg to the next level,” Mr. Younes paused before revealing to<br />

thousands <strong>of</strong> employees Carlsberg’s largest global re-launch in the history <strong>of</strong> the company.<br />

“That calls for a Carlsberg”<br />

Consumers will no longer have to wonder if Carlsberg is probably the best. From now on a new tagline will be<br />

on the tip <strong>of</strong> beer drinkers’ tongues. “That calls for a Carlsberg” is Carlsberg’s modernized tagline, a proposition<br />

that aims to celebrate Carlsberg’s heritage and values, while connecting with today’s generation <strong>of</strong> active beer<br />

drinkers. The new positioning encourages consumers to ‘step up and do the right thing’, subsequently gratifying<br />

themselves with a Carlsberg for their good deeds.<br />

The transformation <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg’s classic tagline falls closely in line with the revolution <strong>of</strong> consumers today.<br />

Consumer behaviour is significantly moulded by information, technology, travel and social media, all available<br />

with the swipe <strong>of</strong> a finger. Young, independent adults today do not wait for things to happen, they go out and<br />

make them happen. They are prepared to take risks, to explore and accept new opportunities and challenges,<br />

while maintaining courage and integrity in the way they lead their lives. They are prepared to step up and do<br />

the right thing.<br />

NOTES


4. Carlsberg Group’s Stand<br />

In 2010 the Carlsberg Group adopted a new global vision that attempts to capture the essence <strong>of</strong> the Group,<br />

the unique identity, personality and diversity <strong>of</strong> the Group across cultures. Opposite to the product brands,<br />

Carlsberg created “The Stand” – something the Group has chosen to use as a definition for what the global<br />

brewer stands for. The Stand, a dictum which unites employees across markets, regions and cultures, is so to<br />

speak an updated version <strong>of</strong> the ‘golden words’ that J.C. Jacobsen had carved into the stonework <strong>of</strong> the original<br />

Carlsberg brewery in 1882, and the motto aims to take the essence <strong>of</strong> the Carlsberg Group’s identity and<br />

render it into 91 words.<br />

The Stand touches upon three topics:<br />

• The always burning passion, thirsting for better<br />

• Strength in unity. We brand as many, but stand as one<br />

• The ambition and courage to raise the bar<br />

According to Michael Kreutzfeldt, Company Branding Manager, the establishment <strong>of</strong> The Stand came from<br />

employees lacking a clear message <strong>of</strong> what unites the Group on a global level. He realized that no matter<br />

which region or department he and his team asked for input from, the same basic traits kept popping up. In<br />

order to express and reflect the people behind the Carlsberg Group, The Stand was formed.<br />

Carlsberg has defined The Stand as a vision that is increasingly relevant to the Carlsberg Group today and<br />

shows that ‘we never settle, but always thirst for better’. Input has been used from various long-established<br />

brands around the world so that every Carlsberg employee, regardless <strong>of</strong> where they come from or where they<br />

work, can recognize a little <strong>of</strong> their company’s past and present in Carlsberg Group’s Stand. Beyond connecting<br />

Carlsberg employees across the globe, The Stand also aims to show what the Carlsberg Group aspires for; a<br />

guide to target setting, making decisions and people development.<br />

“Our stakeholders are increasingly looking at what a company stands for when they make decisions,” explains<br />

Anne-Marie Skov, Senior Vice President, Communications & CSR. “We want an association with Carlsberg<br />

Group to add extra value to the products we sell and the companies we are. The Stand gives us a common<br />

way to express our identity whether we want to influence consumers’ perceptions, convince employees that we<br />

are best place to work for or make new deals with customers and partners.”<br />

NOTES


NOTES


5. Carlsberg Group’s Winning Behaviours put into action<br />

The Stand tells what the Carlsberg Group stand for as a company. As a supplement - you can call it the values<br />

- the Carlsberg Group has the five Winning Behaviours; a set <strong>of</strong> action-oriented principles <strong>of</strong> best behaviours<br />

that provides employees across the Group guidance on how to work with colleagues and customer and drive a<br />

performance culture.<br />

The Winning Behaviours pull the Carlsberg Group as a company together across national borders and functions<br />

as well as promoting commitment and engagement. All companies within the Group have implemented<br />

the Winning Behaviours as guiding principles. The five iconic characters hang in the production hall in<br />

Carlsberg Kazakhstan; Carlsberg Malaysia has rolled out a full package <strong>of</strong> workshops, T-shirts and celebrations;<br />

and around the brewery in Latvia you find the icons sprayed as graffiti on the wall.<br />

The five Behaviours are the same on all three continents where Carlsberg is present, but as markets sometimes<br />

differ significantly the approach and actual way <strong>of</strong> implementing them may be adjusted locally.<br />

What sets us apart from our competitors is that we strive to find the right balance between working closely<br />

together at a global level whilst allowing local brands and initiatives to flourish.<br />

The Carlsberg Group Winning Behaviours<br />

Together we are stronger.<br />

We want to win.<br />

Our consumers and customers are at the heart <strong>of</strong> every decision we make.<br />

We are each empowered to make a difference.<br />

We are engaged with society.<br />

NOTES


6. The Strategy Wheel<br />

The Carlsberg Group’s Strategy Wheel was developed after the formulation <strong>of</strong> the Stand and the Winning<br />

Behaviours. Five core levers form the wheel, <strong>of</strong> which the core concepts are cascaded down to all companies<br />

within the Group. The levers must support the Carlsberg Group’s ambition <strong>of</strong> being the fastest growing global<br />

beer company - measured in terms <strong>of</strong> average organic growth in net sales and growth in operating pr<strong>of</strong>it over<br />

a three year period.<br />

In total the Strategy Wheel, The Stand and the Winning Behaviours are the mission, vision and values <strong>of</strong> the<br />

company and the strategy for how to drive the business forward:<br />

• The Stand tells you what the company stands for<br />

• The Winning Behaviours: how the employees must act in relation to colleagues, customers and society<br />

• The Ambition: what the company aspires to be<br />

• The Strategy is the approach and priorities on how to run the business<br />

See the full strategy wheel at http://www.carlsberggroup.com/Company/Strategy/Pages/Strategy.aspx<br />

7. Local idea with global scope – the beer list<br />

Carlsberg Group has marketed a beer list to increase beer sales in bars and restaurants, an idea that was originally<br />

developed by Carlsberg in the UK, Denmark, Finland and Switzerland respectively. The idea was adopted<br />

by GSMI (Group Sales, Marketing and Innovation), adapted and improved based on best practice from other<br />

markets so that the beer list could ultimately be used by the entire Carlsberg Group. The beer list enables<br />

consumers to choose exactly what to drink with their meal and gives them a chance to try something different.<br />

The beer list is a prime example <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg Group’s Winning Behaviours being put into action, with GSMI<br />

adapting best practices from four different countries.<br />

Carlsberg Group is a collection <strong>of</strong> recipes, with one common ingredient: the passion for great.<br />

2 September 2011. The morning sun glinted through the glass windows <strong>of</strong> the Winter Garden, inside ‘The<br />

Academy’, an Italian inspired villa that had once been the home <strong>of</strong> J.C. Jacobsen. Vita Clausen, Brand PR<br />

Manager paced nervously back and forth, she had been eagerly anticipating this day for months. Journalists<br />

from across the globe had been arriving to Copenhagen in streams over the past couple <strong>of</strong> days to take part in<br />

Carlsberg’s biggest celebration <strong>of</strong> the company’s heritage to date - J.C. Jacobsen’s 200th birthday.<br />

After a walk around the Carlsberg grounds, where J.C. Jacobsen’s home, garden, and the Jutland dray horses<br />

would be displayed, lunch was to be served at the Carlsberg Museum. This would be no ordinary meal, and<br />

Vita smiled at the thought <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg Brewmaster Morten Ibsen’s enthusiasm at today’s arrangement.<br />

Morten had arranged for the journalists to be served a traditional Danish lunch, under which he would share<br />

the secrets <strong>of</strong> pairing ales and pilsners with a gourmet meal, ensuring the curious writers learned how to<br />

NOTES


match food with the perfect beer flavour.<br />

Morten commenced the meal by inviting the journalists to test Carlsberg’s international flagship brand, the<br />

Carlsberg Pilsner. After the Pilsner, clearly a favourite <strong>of</strong> most <strong>of</strong> the male journalists, Morten introduced the<br />

reporters to Velvet Ale, which reminds much more <strong>of</strong> champagne than beer.<br />

“To appropriately pair beer with a meal the ingredients in the food must be harmonized with the richness <strong>of</strong><br />

the ale,” the Brewmaster explained. The journalists nodded their heads appreciatively, all the while oohing and<br />

aahing at the new found knowledge that beer really was an appropriate accompaniment to a meal, just as<br />

wine has been for centuries.<br />

Morten’s beer and food pairing was another example <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg Group’s Winning Behaviours being put into<br />

action; putting consumers and customers at the heart <strong>of</strong> every decision Carlsberg Group makes.<br />

8. The GloCal Approach<br />

Being a diverse company that operates in more than 150 countries makes it imperative for the Carlsberg Group<br />

to recognize that each company is confronted with different challenges that are individually based on the<br />

countries, societies and cultures in which they operate. Carlsberg Group has chosen to take a ‘GloCal’ approach<br />

in order to come to terms with the cultural differences that plague a worldwide corporation and to communicate<br />

an authentic and inspiring Group story while finding the right balance between working closely together<br />

on a GLObal level and allowing loCAL brands and initiatives to flourish.<br />

‘We work together on a global level to develop our strategic approach but acknowledge the local diversity<br />

within our operations’.<br />

The GloCal approach seeks to engage employees across all markets and functions while aligning and inspiring<br />

stakeholders. Finding the right GloCal balance in a matrix structure is the key to Carlsberg’s success in activating<br />

and developing local markets while still increasing the flagship Carlsberg brand’s presence on the global<br />

market.<br />

Carlsberg Group expects that the re-branding <strong>of</strong> the flagship Carlsberg beer brand will help distinguish between<br />

the Company Brand and the Product Brand, which at times can be indistinguishable for the company’s<br />

stakeholders and many employees today. The distinction may seem unimportant in Denmark, but the Danish<br />

market only contributes to about 3% <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg’s total volume earnings. With more than 40% <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg<br />

Group’s volumes based on beer sales in Eastern Europe (particularly Russia), where the Baltika brand is far<br />

more recognized than Carlsberg, both the relevance <strong>of</strong> the flagship Carlsberg product and its heritage are less<br />

evident to consumers and Carlsberg Group employees.<br />

NOTES


9. The scrutiny <strong>of</strong> beer – dark markets<br />

We are back in Valby, the CEO Jørgen Buhl Rasmussen is still sitting at his desk and his thoughts have now<br />

fallen on the Carlsberg Group’s long range <strong>of</strong> alcoholic products which have been subject to rough scrutiny<br />

lately. Stricter legislations on the sales and marketing <strong>of</strong> alcoholic drinks, consumers’ rising demands for transparency<br />

and healthier products, more efficient and innovative competitors, an ever-watching media and the<br />

nature <strong>of</strong> the financial market are all factors contributing to the Carlsberg Group’s need to seriously reassess<br />

the external message that the brewery sends to customers and consumers.<br />

As a worldwide brewer and beer producer, the Carlsberg Group faces the challenge <strong>of</strong> increasing dark markets<br />

within the regions where the company operates. Dark markets are countries and districts where it is partly or<br />

completely forbidden to promote alcoholic drinks in the media. In many Nordic countries there are restrictions<br />

and prohibitions on alcohol advertisements while some countries only allow alcoholic commercials in allocated<br />

time slots. Beyond advertising the Carlsberg Group is also increasingly experiencing a rise in restrictions on<br />

sales <strong>of</strong> alcohol within some <strong>of</strong> its largest and most important markets, such as Russia.<br />

The role <strong>of</strong> social media on dark markets<br />

The revolution <strong>of</strong> social media is something that the Carlsberg Group will increasingly place focus on as it<br />

becomes more and more important to reach consumers through the channels they use the most (such as<br />

Facebook, YouTube and Twitter). In the dark markets where Carlsberg Group is present social media is one <strong>of</strong><br />

the only ways to reach consumers (especially younger generations) without <strong>of</strong>ficial advertising. In order for<br />

Carlsberg Group to expand and reach the consumers the company chooses to target, social media channels<br />

which <strong>of</strong>ten contain much user-generated content are vital. By creating viral commercials such the most recent<br />

‘Carlsberg stunt with bikers in a cinema’ released by Carlsberg Belgium, a scenario which depicts several couples<br />

entering a movie theatre to be greeted by a room filled with not-so friendly gentlemen bikers has taken<br />

the internet by storm. If the couples dare to mosey through the bikers and take their seats the whole theatre<br />

celebrates with a Carlsberg beer and the slogan ‘That calls for a Carlsberg’. The video has generated an audience<br />

<strong>of</strong> almost 10 million viewers to date since its release on 29 September 2011.<br />

10. Thirst for Beer<br />

The Carlsberg Group’s ‘Thirst for Beer’ strategy is one <strong>of</strong> the ways Carlsberg hopes to improve the image and<br />

value <strong>of</strong> beer, something that is increasingly important for the company today. Carlsberg has defined the<br />

‘Thirst for Beer’ as a cross-border team effort with three major practice areas: markets and consumer behaviour,<br />

policies and fair excise taxes along with commercial freedom, and people as ambassadors for beer. The<br />

strategy simultaneously supports category growth and pr<strong>of</strong>itability while safe-guarding the Group’s license to<br />

operate. The approach is executed by supporting the external image <strong>of</strong> beer while placing emphasis on beer’s<br />

refreshing and social character, the natural and healthy qualities <strong>of</strong> the beverage and its cultural heritage.<br />

NOTES


Responsible drinking<br />

Responsible drinking policies are part <strong>of</strong> the Group’s world-wide Corporate Social Responsibility program. An<br />

initiative to ensure conscientious drinking and consumer awareness is launched by Carlsberg’s Group Communications,<br />

and it focuses on 4 areas that are vital to the beer and drinking industry:<br />

• Drunk driving<br />

• Under-age drinking<br />

• Binge drinking<br />

• Moderate consumption<br />

Campaigns can be seen from across Carlsberg Group’s regions. In 2007 Finnish Sinebrych<strong>of</strong>f took part in an<br />

award winning advertising campaign targeted at the binge drinking culture and underage drinking in Finland.<br />

Using blunt, straight forward language and arresting imagery, the campaign highlighted the problems <strong>of</strong> binge<br />

and under-age drinking in a society where it is accepted to binge drink as part <strong>of</strong> the youth culture.<br />

“We are proud that millions <strong>of</strong> consumers enjoy our products. To help them make sensible choices on alcohol<br />

consumption we develop local responsible drinking campaigns and ensure we market our products in a<br />

responsible way.” Khalil Younes, Senior Vice President, Group Sales, Marketing and Innovations<br />

Corporate Social Responsibility<br />

Beyond promoting responsible drinking Carlsberg Group is integrating CSR throughout the company’s value<br />

chain by placing focus on developing new kinds <strong>of</strong> barley that are more resistant to climate change and<br />

finding innovative brewing methods to reduce energy and water consumption in breweries around the Group.<br />

The Carlsberg Group has defined its intentions to bring CSR aspects that are relevant to the company and its<br />

stakeholders closer to business plans and decisions. Integrating CSR into the company’s operations will help<br />

Carlsberg reduce costs, manage risks, minimise environmental impact, attract and retain employees, as well as<br />

strengthen the brand and business overall. Carlsberg Group believes that CSR is the compass that will ensure<br />

the company continues to grow in a responsible way, and new targets have therefore been set for 2013 in each<br />

<strong>of</strong> the CSR areas that Carlsberg Group has chosen to focus on.<br />

Carlsberg Group is a diverse global brewer that operates in more than 150 countries and each local company is<br />

faced with different challenges and issues based on the countries and societies in which they operate. In terms<br />

<strong>of</strong> CSR the Carlsberg Group has chosen to take a GloCal approach and work together on a global level to develop<br />

a strategic approach while still acknowledging local diversity within the company’s operations. Local CSR<br />

champions ensure that Carlsberg Group’s strategy is suited to local circumstances.<br />

“Our strategy to implement CSR reflects our GloCal way <strong>of</strong> thinking. We work together globally to identify our<br />

direction and priorities and integrate our strategy in our local business activities to ensure we grow in a responsible<br />

way.” Anne-Marie Skov, Senior Vice-President, Communications & CSR<br />

NOTES


11. Carlsberg Group’s consumer segments – The right occasion and the right<br />

brand<br />

Carlsberg Group’s brand portfolio strives to maximize the value <strong>of</strong> each brand by having products that fulfil<br />

a variety <strong>of</strong> consumer needs and occasions. The dynamics <strong>of</strong> beer consumption vary significantly across the<br />

world; in mature Western European markets volumes are generally stable or modestly declining while less<br />

mature or emerging beer markets such as Asia and Eastern Europe have seen stable growth over the past<br />

years, with some countries showing rapid growth rates. Beer trends play an imperative role in the Carlsberg<br />

Group’s continuous growth, and it is evident that on emerging and growth markets developments point towards<br />

an increase in the substitution <strong>of</strong> traditional local spirits with beer, a tendency that is driven by rising<br />

incomes and increasing responsiveness towards brands and marketing. Younger generations’ demographic<br />

shifts towards urbanization and increasing westernization have also supported the shift towards beer.<br />

Focus on female consumers<br />

The Carlsberg Group has to rise to the challenge <strong>of</strong> meeting a constantly rising number and category <strong>of</strong> consumers<br />

and while the Group’s main consumer group has for a long time focused on men, which is reflected in<br />

the many sponsorships related to European football. Over the past couple <strong>of</strong> years it has become increasingly<br />

important to focus on the female consumer market.<br />

In 2010 the Carlsberg Group’s Investor magazine ‘News’ wrote that women buy or influence the purchase <strong>of</strong><br />

80% <strong>of</strong> all consumer goods as well as accounting for more than 37% <strong>of</strong> alcohol consumption. Surveys have<br />

also shown that Danish women aged 18-24 consume just as much beer as males but then switch to wine as<br />

they get older.<br />

2009 saw Jeanette Elgaard Carlsson join Carlsberg’s Group Innovation department as Innovation Platform<br />

Director, and as her first assignment she was told to focus on this previously underserved segment <strong>of</strong> women.<br />

Beer has <strong>of</strong>ten been regarded by women as unglamorous and unappealing, and although the Carlsberg<br />

Group’s main products and primary innovation efforts will continue to be within the beer category, in the future<br />

the Carlsberg Group will increasingly place emphasis on women. Jeanette Elgaard Carlsson explains why:<br />

“Women are a big untapped opportunity for Carlsberg. Today, 80 percent <strong>of</strong> our global volume is consumed<br />

by men. Yet half <strong>of</strong> the population is women. And we know that women are becoming increasingly independent<br />

around the world. They are working more and having families later. Many <strong>of</strong> them are spending more time<br />

enjoying themselves with friends in cafes, bars and restaurants, but Carlsberg hasn’t really focused on women<br />

before now. In fact, we didn’t really have any products that met the needs <strong>of</strong> women until we got Eve.”<br />

The release <strong>of</strong> Copen*hagen was one <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg Group’s bids at meeting female consumers’ demands, and a<br />

new beer marketed at the modern woman aged between 23 and 35 years was met with mass media coverage<br />

and rising sales. Carlsberg continuously looks to expand beyond existing brands and consumer groups, looking<br />

for pr<strong>of</strong>itable opportunities to strengthen the portfolio both within beer and adjacent beverage segments.<br />

NOTES


The successful launch <strong>of</strong> Somersby Cider in Norway and Denmark is another example <strong>of</strong> a premium product<br />

development outside the beer category aimed at women. Another illustration is Eve, a malt-based premium<br />

drink that bridges brewing technology and consumer insights, delivering a refreshing drink with a taste and<br />

look that is a far cry from beer.<br />

12. Carlsberg Group: One <strong>of</strong> the world’s largest FMCG companies<br />

Carlsberg Group is one <strong>of</strong> the globe’s fastest growing FMCG (fast moving consumer goods) companies with a<br />

large portfolio <strong>of</strong> beer and s<strong>of</strong>t drinks brands, including the flagship Carlsberg- one <strong>of</strong> the world’s best known<br />

international beers. While Carlsberg Group’s core products are beer, the corporation also produces and distributes<br />

mineral water, s<strong>of</strong>t drinks and other non-alcoholic drinks. Consumers are at the forefront <strong>of</strong> every decision<br />

Carlsberg Group makes, and the company aims to iconize Carlsberg’s corporate brand and grow through a<br />

varied portfolio <strong>of</strong> discount, mainstream, international premium and strong local brands.<br />

Business Standardisation Programme<br />

Breweries naturally experience an increase in production volumes due to FMCG goods’ short shelf life. Supplying<br />

FMCG products requires an extensive distribution network and room for high stock turnover, in turn making<br />

logistics and supporting processes <strong>of</strong> the value chain extremely crucial to the ultimate success <strong>of</strong> the company.<br />

Carlsberg has an ambition to be the fastest growing global beer company in the world, and the company’s<br />

main business priority is based on two central drivers: increasing earnings by reducing costs and winning local<br />

market shares.<br />

In 2005 the Carlsberg Group launched the Business Standardisation Programme (BSP), a key lever for standardizing<br />

business processes, which will ultimately make employees’ work across the group faster, smarter and<br />

leaner. Faster because successes will be optimized; smarter because best practice can be shared across countries<br />

and leaner because focus can be placed on value adding activities and reducing costs through economies<br />

<strong>of</strong> scale. BSP was a logical and necessary step for Carlsberg and today it is one <strong>of</strong> the largest transformation<br />

programmes ever launched in the Group.<br />

As the reaches <strong>of</strong> such a global business need to be consolidated and uniformed, the plan captures value<br />

from the benefits <strong>of</strong> standardization, while at the same time enabling local businesses to respond to local<br />

markets as well as spend more time and resources on innovation and business development. The implementation<br />

<strong>of</strong> BSP has to be driven locally to succeed, ultimately requiring a high degree <strong>of</strong> local involvement and<br />

ownership. BSP is built around Carlsberg’s core supporting and enabling process and it focuses on increasing<br />

Carlsberg’s earnings by reducing costs while becoming more efficient and winning market shares through constant<br />

engagement with consumers and customers.<br />

NOTES


13. Summing up<br />

Mr. Jørgen Buhl Rasmussen looked back at his desk, jerked back from his thoughts by the ring <strong>of</strong> his <strong>of</strong>fice<br />

phone. Ignoring the buzzing, he could not help but smile; so much power, so much passion was embedded in<br />

the spirit <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg. The stories and heritage rooted in the buildings below him were second to none in a<br />

way many companies would envy. Many challenges lay ahead, but if the company got the fundamental roots<br />

right and could unite around that, the short term obstacles could be dealt with.<br />

Rising slowly, Mr. Buhl Rasmussen decided it was time to rest his mind and go home. Today’s celebration had<br />

given him the confidence he and the Corporate Communications team needed, and the CEO was positive that<br />

this was just one <strong>of</strong> many milestones that would lay the brickwork for the Carlsberg Group’s future.<br />

14. Perspectives on the case – Balancing one corporate brand with multiple<br />

product brands<br />

An analysis <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg Group’s situation and the challenges that the company faces can be looked at from<br />

several standpoints. The following describes a variety <strong>of</strong> perspectives and questions which have been prepared<br />

to give you ideas and inspiration to discover, formulate and investigate your own research question.<br />

The Corporate Brand Perspective<br />

The Carlsberg Group’s subsidiaries exist across a variety <strong>of</strong> countries and regions; all with strong traditions and<br />

cultures and many with hundreds <strong>of</strong> years <strong>of</strong> history behind them. Brasseries Kronenbourg in France dates<br />

back to 1664, Finnish Sinebrych<strong>of</strong>f is the oldest brewery in Scandinavia and Baltika Breweries, the biggest<br />

FMCG company in Russia, just turned 20 years.<br />

The Carlsberg Group and the Carlsberg beer carry the same name and logo and are therefore hard to separate.<br />

In 2011 the Carlsberg beer, was re-launched to fit the modern, global world, and the link and leverage between<br />

the two must be clarified.<br />

• How should the top executives from Carlsberg Group Headquarters and Group Communications balance<br />

the need for a coherent global corporate brand and local or regional needs for a relevant corporate<br />

position tailored for the local market? What stakeholders should be prioritised and what messages will<br />

support the chosen balance?<br />

• What role should the Carlsberg beer play in the corporate story, taken into account that the importance <strong>of</strong><br />

the Carlsberg beer varies from market to market. Where should the product brand and the corporate brand<br />

align and where should they part? What role should local power brands play?<br />

NOTES


The Financial Perspective<br />

Carlsberg Group is the undisputed market leader in Northern Europe, and also holds the number one position in Eastern<br />

Europe. In 2010 Eastern Europe accounted for 45% <strong>of</strong> operating pr<strong>of</strong>it, but 2011 has seen a decline in the Carlsberg<br />

Group’s pr<strong>of</strong>it margins, especially within Russia and Eastern Europe in Q2 and Q3.<br />

• In times <strong>of</strong> economic uncertainty, such as the one Carlsberg Group is currently facing in Russia, how can communication<br />

help restore the Group’s reputation in the financial community? How can communication help turn Carlsberg<br />

Group’s financial struggles into a benefit?<br />

• Financial communication is serious and must be highly trustworthy. Hence social media is not a channel used<br />

much. In what way can that be changed and what risks should be taken into consideration?<br />

The Intercultural Perspective<br />

Over 40,000 people on three continents work for the Carlsberg Group. They speak Chinese, Russian, Vietnamese,<br />

French, German and some speak English. Obviously a company <strong>of</strong> the size <strong>of</strong> the Carlsberg Group faces the dilemma <strong>of</strong><br />

a complex and diverse organisation.<br />

Being a global FMCG (Fast Moving Consumer Goods) company one needs to standardise processes and systems and<br />

one must be able to work together across borders. That has to correspond to employees taking pride in working for the<br />

company, going that extra mile to improve company performance.<br />

• Should corporate brand elements vary in different parts <strong>of</strong> the world to account for cultural differences? What are<br />

the benefits and risks <strong>of</strong> having one global uniform corporate brand versus differentiated corporate brands on local<br />

or regional level? What direction should the Carlsberg Group choose?<br />

• What should the role <strong>of</strong> the CEO play when it comes to bridging cultural differences? How, what and where should<br />

the CEO communicate?<br />

• “What are you proud <strong>of</strong> when telling about your workplace?” What elements <strong>of</strong> the company and the corporate<br />

story can employees at all levels, across the globe associate with? How can Group Communications in Headquarters<br />

support this pride, and how do you take the different cultural elements into perspective?<br />

The CSR Perspective<br />

CSR is an integrated part <strong>of</strong> the way the Carlsberg Group does business. Consumers expect the company behind their<br />

favourite beer to take a social and environmental stand, employees want to work for a company they can be proud <strong>of</strong><br />

and legislators want responsible advertising. How can you survive without a stand on CSR?<br />

• The CSR story can be told as part <strong>of</strong> the corporate story and/or be communicated by the individual product brands.<br />

How can CSR leverage the corporate and the product brands, what stories should be told by whom and what are<br />

the benefits and risks?<br />

• Th e beer category faces dark markets and restrictions, and the health risk <strong>of</strong> alcohol abuse is indisputable. Responsible<br />

Drinking campaigns have been part <strong>of</strong> advertising for many years. How do you re-think the way Responsible<br />

Drinking is used by the corporate brand?<br />

15. Instructions<br />

Choose a perspective, either from the list above or your own perspective on the case.<br />

• Choose a specific Research Question within the topic area <strong>of</strong> Carlsberg’s Corporate Branding and balancing the<br />

Global and the Local according to your own perspectives.<br />

• Prepare a problem-based and solution-oriented presentation and a short executive summary (cf. Rules and regulations;<br />

Scope and hand in formats, and Evaluation criteria).

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!