Dissertation_Paula Aleksandrowicz_12 ... - Jacobs University

Dissertation_Paula Aleksandrowicz_12 ... - Jacobs University Dissertation_Paula Aleksandrowicz_12 ... - Jacobs University

jacobs.university.de
from jacobs.university.de More from this publisher
11.03.2014 Views

entry into retirement, the old-age pension for the severely handicapped and the disability pension were taken into focus which had for a long time invited evasive strategies of persons trying to avoid permanent benefit reductions. For the receipt of the old-age pension for severely handicapped persons between the age of 60 and 63, permanent deductions were introduced. With regard to disability pensions, the delineation between the disability pension for persons with general incapacity to work (Erwerbsunfähigkeitsrente) and the disability pension for persons incapable to work in their profession (Berufsunfähigkeitsrente) was replaced with the full or partial work incapacity pension (Erwerbsminderungsrente). However, due to objections of trade unions and Social Democrats, the newly elected Red-Green government postponed the restrictions in disability pensions and old-age pensions for the severely handicapped to the year 2000 and introduced transitory periods. The controversial elements were passed at last in 2001, and ATZ was closed for new entrants from 2010. In 2007, a law raising the retirement age to 67 (Rentenversicherungs- Altersgrenzenanpassungsgesetz) was legislated despite fierce opposition from unions and counterarguments from scholars who claimed that the reform will undermine the adequacy of pension income (Nürnberger 2007, Bäcker 2006, Brussig/Knuth 2007). The proponents saw the reform as a step in the direction of an increase of the factual retirement age and as solution for the financial strain on the German pension system (Reimann 2007; Köhler 2007; BDA 2007). The higher retirement age will be phased in for persons born between 1947 and 1963 in two paces: by one month per year of birth till 2023, and by two months from 2024 till 2029. The presented reform elements introduced several pathways of early exit in the German old-age pension and disability pension system. A ´pathway of early exit´ can be understood as “an institutional arrangement or – in most cases – a combination of different institutional arrangements that are sequentially linked to manage the process of transition to retirement, that is, the period between exit from work and entry into the normal old-age pension system” (Jacobs et al. 1991: 198). Jacobs et al. distinguish between the ´unemployment pathway´, ´the pre-retirement pathway´ and the ´health pathway´, hereby counting early retirement pensions as located within ´the normal old-age pension system´. Ebbinghaus, in turn, recognises six pathways (2002: 134ff), as the utilisation of the early retirement pension is linked to a different motivation and employment history than the standard retirement pension – the early pension 47

pathway, the flexible and partial pension pathway, the special pre-retirement pathway, the unemployment pathway, and the disability pathway. The standard old-age pension is available at the retirement age of 65 years and after a minimum contribution period of five years. Persons who have been insured for 35 years can claim the seniority pension (´flexible retirement age´) which is available at the age of 63, albeit with permanent deductions of 0.3 per cent for every month of earlier take-up. 15 Women born before 1952 are entitled to the old-age pension for women available at the age of 60 after a contribution period of 15 years (with permanent deductions). This pension was introduced in 1957 in order to allow couples to retire together (Jacobs et al. 1991: 190). The raising of the pensionable age set into practice with the pension reform of 1992 was a response to European Court of Justice rulings on equal treatment in public and private pensions (Ebbinghaus 2002: 248). Persons who are severely handicapped can apply for the old-age pension at the age of 60 after a qualifying period of 35 years. The standard retirement age for that pension is 63 years, so their benefit is reduced for every month of earlier take-up, with the exception of transitory periods for persons born before 1944. The old-age pension after unemployment was introduced in 1957. The motive behind it was supporting older workers who were especially affected by long-term unemployment and faced difficulties with return to work (Jacobs et al. 1991: 202). Persons born before 1946 can apply for that pension after completion of their 60 th year. For persons born between 1946-1952, the pensionable age was raised stepwise from the age of 60 to 63. Table 3 depicts the currently valid retirement pathways and pensionable ages within the public pension scheme. A disability pathway is constituted by the subsequent use of sickness benefit (provided by the firm for the first six weeks of an illness or after an accident and by the health fund for up to one year and a half) and of the disability pension (Jacobs et al. 1991: 199). Since the reform of 2001, disability pensions are granted for three years, after which a re-assessment of the health status is undertaken. The new system distinguishes between the full disability pension granted when the applicant is able to work less than three hours daily, and the partial disability pension, if the applicant is able to work less than six hours daily. As a disincentive to early retirement via the disability pension, deductions of 0.3% per month are 15 Those bonus/malus rules are actuarially neutral in the sense that they cover the loss or rise in the income of DRV due to earlier or deferred retirement (Hoffmann 2007: 300). However, for those rules to be neutral with regard to the incentives or disincentives to continued work they may pose (anreizneutral), the current amount of 3.6 per cent per year should rise by half (Hinrichs 1998: 19). 48

pathway, the flexible and partial pension pathway, the special pre-retirement pathway, the<br />

unemployment pathway, and the disability pathway.<br />

The standard old-age pension is available at the retirement age of 65 years and after a<br />

minimum contribution period of five years. Persons who have been insured for 35 years can<br />

claim the seniority pension (´flexible retirement age´) which is available at the age of 63,<br />

albeit with permanent deductions of 0.3 per cent for every month of earlier take-up. 15<br />

Women born before 1952 are entitled to the old-age pension for women available at the age<br />

of 60 after a contribution period of 15 years (with permanent deductions). This pension was<br />

introduced in 1957 in order to allow couples to retire together (<strong>Jacobs</strong> et al. 1991: 190). The<br />

raising of the pensionable age set into practice with the pension reform of 1992 was a<br />

response to European Court of Justice rulings on equal treatment in public and private<br />

pensions (Ebbinghaus 2002: 248). Persons who are severely handicapped can apply for the<br />

old-age pension at the age of 60 after a qualifying period of 35 years. The standard<br />

retirement age for that pension is 63 years, so their benefit is reduced for every month of<br />

earlier take-up, with the exception of transitory periods for persons born before 1944. The<br />

old-age pension after unemployment was introduced in 1957. The motive behind it was<br />

supporting older workers who were especially affected by long-term unemployment and<br />

faced difficulties with return to work (<strong>Jacobs</strong> et al. 1991: 202). Persons born before 1946<br />

can apply for that pension after completion of their 60 th year. For persons born between<br />

1946-1952, the pensionable age was raised stepwise from the age of 60 to 63. Table 3<br />

depicts the currently valid retirement pathways and pensionable ages within the public<br />

pension scheme.<br />

A disability pathway is constituted by the subsequent use of sickness benefit (provided<br />

by the firm for the first six weeks of an illness or after an accident and by the health fund for<br />

up to one year and a half) and of the disability pension (<strong>Jacobs</strong> et al. 1991: 199). Since the<br />

reform of 2001, disability pensions are granted for three years, after which a re-assessment<br />

of the health status is undertaken. The new system distinguishes between the full disability<br />

pension granted when the applicant is able to work less than three hours daily, and the<br />

partial disability pension, if the applicant is able to work less than six hours daily. As a<br />

disincentive to early retirement via the disability pension, deductions of 0.3% per month are<br />

15 Those bonus/malus rules are actuarially neutral in the sense that they cover the loss or rise in the income of<br />

DRV due to earlier or deferred retirement (Hoffmann 2007: 300). However, for those rules to be neutral with<br />

regard to the incentives or disincentives to continued work they may pose (anreizneutral), the current amount<br />

of 3.6 per cent per year should rise by half (Hinrichs 1998: 19).<br />

48

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!