You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
August 2011<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>:<br />
The sleeping<br />
giant<br />
Features<br />
Reviving lost<br />
trade<br />
Asset<br />
management in<br />
South <strong>Africa</strong><br />
Banking on<br />
microfinance<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>n<br />
emergence
EDITOR’S NOTE<br />
Supplements<br />
Editor<br />
Associate Editor<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> Investor<br />
Editor<br />
Features Editor &<br />
Copy Editor<br />
Senior Publishing<br />
Manager<br />
Copy Editor<br />
Senior Reporter<br />
Journalists<br />
Production<br />
Manager<br />
Production<br />
Editors<br />
Senior Production<br />
Designers<br />
Business<br />
Development<br />
Managers<br />
Subscriptions<br />
Director<br />
Subscription<br />
Executive<br />
Subscriptions<br />
Sponsorship Sales<br />
Manager<br />
Nazneen Halim<br />
Nazneen.Halim@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Scott Weber<br />
Scott.Weber@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Raphael Wong<br />
Raphael.Wong@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Lauren Mcaughtry<br />
Lauren.Mcaughtry@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Sasikala Thiagaraja<br />
Sasikala@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Roshan Kaur Sandhu<br />
Roshan.Kaur@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Ellina Badri<br />
Ellina.Badri@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Lai Pei Yee<br />
Peiyee.Lai@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Siew Han Liang<br />
Han.Siew@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Hasnani Aspari<br />
Hasnani.Aspari@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Norzabidi Abdullah<br />
Zabidi.Abdullah@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Mohd Hanif Mat Nor<br />
Hanif.Nor@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Mohd Hair Kadir<br />
Hair.Kadir@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Mohamad Rozman Besiri<br />
Rozman.Besiri@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
June Abu Zaid<br />
June.Abuzaid@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 56<br />
Rizal Halim Dahlan<br />
Rizal.Dahlan@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 13<br />
Andrew Cheng<br />
Andrew.Cheng@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 55<br />
Musfaizal Mustafa<br />
Musfaizal.Mustafa@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 24<br />
Sivaranjani Sukumaran<br />
Sivaranjani .Sukumaran@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 41<br />
Logeswaran Kuladevan<br />
Logeswaran.Kuladevan@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 64<br />
The beast stirs<br />
It is impossible to describe the contrasts and complexities of the <strong>Africa</strong>n political,<br />
economic and social situation within the constraints of these pages. The<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>n continent has long remained an underachiever in terms of its economic<br />
potential, and years of constant fi ghting and perhaps to some degree neglect,<br />
has ravaged its people. However, as the world turns, so do peoples’ perception,<br />
and these days <strong>Africa</strong> is seen as a diamond in the rough, with growing optimism<br />
surrounding its fi scal and political future.<br />
Recent political upheavals, mostly in the North; affecting Egypt, Tunisia, Libya<br />
and Sudan, could work both ways in affecting international interest in the<br />
continent’s investment landscape, and for now economic pundits choose to be<br />
positive about its growth prospects. <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance players have also begun<br />
to turn their attention towards <strong>Africa</strong>, seeing the vast potential in areas such as<br />
microfi nance and trade fi nance.<br />
Long-term involvement and backing from ‘AAA’-rated fi nancial institutions<br />
such as the <strong>Islamic</strong> Development Bank (IDB) via the Special Program for the<br />
Development of <strong>Africa</strong> (SPDA), in which the IDB has committed US$4 billion,<br />
are expected to elevate the continent’s social and economic standing and are<br />
aimed at providing a platform to boost its growth.<br />
At the recent SPDA meeting, the IDB vice president of operations, Birama<br />
Boubacar Sidibe, highlighted the significant positive elements seen across<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>: including strong economic growth, rapid progress of the Millennium<br />
Development Goals leading to a drop in poverty across many <strong>Africa</strong>n countries,<br />
increased investments in the private sector, and a high return on investments;<br />
as well as providing a robust climate for market-oriented, pro-poor reforms<br />
which has led to prudent economic policies. “The IDB has acknowledged that<br />
the situation in <strong>Africa</strong> is not what we had envisioned, the urgent need to provide<br />
much needed resources and the participation of the member countries to help<br />
sustain and further develop the growth of the <strong>Africa</strong>n continent is a major factor<br />
for us and we are here to discuss ways to bolster our relationships and share<br />
knowledge and ideas,” he stated.<br />
In this issue of IFN Supplements, we traverse the vast continent of <strong>Africa</strong> and<br />
explore the opportunities that lie ahead for <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance in the region. From<br />
Takaful to investment prospects and regulatory updates, we endeavor to reveal<br />
industry perception towards the region. Indeed, many see <strong>Africa</strong> as the next<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance haven, considering the growing saturation of the GCC and<br />
Asian markets, and a general lackluster response in North America and Europe,<br />
excluding the UK. <strong>Africa</strong>, they suggest, is the sleeping giant which when awoken<br />
could allow the <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance industry to achieve its full potential.<br />
Financial<br />
Controller<br />
Faizah Hassan<br />
Faizah.Hassan@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Deputy Publisher<br />
& Director<br />
Managing Director<br />
Managing Director<br />
& Publisher<br />
Geraldine Chan<br />
Geraldine.Chan@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Andrew Tebbutt<br />
Andrew.Tebbutt@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Andrew Morgan<br />
Andrew.Morgan@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />
Nazneen Halim,<br />
Editor<br />
Published By:<br />
21/F, Menara Park, 12, Jalan Yap Kwan Seng<br />
50450 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia<br />
Tel: +603 2162 7800<br />
Fax: +603 2162 7810<br />
www.<strong>Islamic</strong><strong>Finance</strong><strong>News</strong>.com<br />
DISCLAIMER<br />
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, duplicated or copied<br />
by any means without the prior consent of the holder of the copyright, requests for which<br />
should be addressed to the publisher. While every care is taken in the preparation of this<br />
publication, no responsibility can be accepted for any errors, however caused.<br />
August 2011<br />
1
CONTENTS<br />
TS<br />
COVER STORY<br />
4 The sleeping giant<br />
Development, trade, labor movement, and an influx<br />
of investors are quickly boosting the resource-rich<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>n economy. How high is <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance on the<br />
agenda of banks and fi nancial institutions alike and<br />
what are the prospects for this sector?<br />
FEATURES<br />
8 Reviving lost trade<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>, a thriving trade destination for the Middle<br />
East, Europe, India and China up until the 19 th<br />
century, is once more on the brink of a trade fl urry<br />
after decades of dormancy.<br />
10 Banking on microfinance<br />
At present, over 410 million people in sub-Saharan<br />
<strong>Africa</strong> are living below the poverty line. Could<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance be the panacea for millions of<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>’s poor?<br />
11 Asset management in South <strong>Africa</strong><br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance has seen exponential growth in<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>, particularly in the North <strong>Africa</strong>n region, and<br />
of late to the west and east of <strong>Africa</strong> as well. <strong>Africa</strong><br />
is home to about 412 million Muslims with a high<br />
concentration focused in the regions mentioned<br />
above.<br />
13 <strong>Africa</strong>n emergence<br />
The <strong>Africa</strong>n Takaful market is gearing itself up as<br />
an important future market in the Takaful arena.<br />
SCOTT WEBER turns his gaze towards the latest<br />
incumbents in what is proving to be Takaful’s next<br />
frontier.<br />
We’re not just a weekly but also a daily news provider<br />
Register now for RSS feeds on<br />
www.islamicfinancenews.com<br />
2 August 2011
COVER STORY<br />
The sleeping giant<br />
Development, trade, labor movement, and an influx of investors are<br />
quickly boosting the resource-rich <strong>Africa</strong>n economy. How high is<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> finance on the agenda of banks and financial institutions alike<br />
and what are the prospects for this sector? NAZNEEN HALIM explores.<br />
The birthplace of modern man, <strong>Africa</strong> has long remained an<br />
exotic and untamed enigma. However these days, it is not<br />
adventurous explorers who are interested in mapping this<br />
rich and diverse continent; but investors, keen to explore the<br />
untapped fi scal potential of the resource-rich, second most<br />
populous continent in the world.<br />
Decades of civil unrest, tribal clashes, and political and economic<br />
turmoil has left <strong>Africa</strong> muddled in a morass of troubles. Despite<br />
being home to the world’s most desirable commodities and<br />
natural resources such as diamonds, iron, gold and of course<br />
oil, <strong>Africa</strong> has not been able to free itself from the shackles of<br />
poverty and remains stuck in the rut of economic stagnation.<br />
However, things are expected to turn around for this continent<br />
of 1 billion people. Economic pundits are ready to place their<br />
bets on this emerging market, and investors are ready to<br />
venture into uncharted territory.<br />
Over the last 10 years, trade between <strong>Africa</strong>n countries and<br />
the rest of the world has grown signifi cantly; charting a 170%<br />
increase in trade with the GCC, and 45% growth with China and<br />
India; the world’s fastest growing economies. Chinese investors<br />
have expressed much interest in <strong>Africa</strong>, and are already<br />
heavily invested in manufacturing and infrastructure projects in<br />
countries such as Sudan and Ghana. In places such as Ethiopia<br />
and Ghana, over 60% of Chinese investments in the countries<br />
constitute manufacturing. And the Chinese government is<br />
keen to see these numbers grow. China’s push for industrial<br />
restructuring domestically has created opportunities in <strong>Africa</strong>,<br />
and the government, seeing this opportunity, has created<br />
measures aimed at facilitating access to credit and simplifying<br />
procedures for Chinese fi rms looking to invest overseas.<br />
And with China keeping ahead of the global economic trend<br />
these days, other countries are likely to follow suit. This is also<br />
4 August 2011
COVER STORY<br />
expected of the GCC, who have had a trade history with <strong>Africa</strong>,<br />
which has recently been strengthened by the involvement of<br />
the Saudi-based <strong>Islamic</strong> Development Bank’s efforts to aid its<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>n member countries, and growing interest from Middle<br />
East investors looking to diversify their investments. Afaq<br />
Khan, CEO of Standard Chartered Saadiq, is confi dent of the<br />
resurrection of trade ties between the Middle East and <strong>Africa</strong>:<br />
“The Middle East already has historical trade links with <strong>Africa</strong><br />
due to geographical proximity. They have done business with<br />
each other for decades, so it is natural for them to go to <strong>Africa</strong>.<br />
It is a question of how easy and attractive it will be for foreign<br />
investors to do business there.”<br />
Strengthening trade ties with the GCC, a growing Muslim<br />
population, the need to fi nance large-scale infrastructure<br />
and manufacturing projects, as well as a large unbanked<br />
population, all provide a robust platform for the introduction of<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> banking to <strong>Africa</strong>.<br />
The Middle East has done<br />
business with <strong>Africa</strong> for<br />
decades, so it is natural for them<br />
to go there. It is a question of how<br />
easy and attractive it will be for<br />
foreign investors to do<br />
business<br />
Status Quo<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> banking has its roots in Egypt, one of <strong>Africa</strong>’s most<br />
affl uent Arab countries. Having pioneered modern <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
banking in the 1960s, Egypt’s <strong>Islamic</strong> banking sector has not<br />
had the chance to reach its fullest potential due to political<br />
intervention and a general air of scepticism surrounding the<br />
industry. Nevertheless, the country is already home to major<br />
players such as Faisal <strong>Islamic</strong> Bank and Al Baraka Egypt<br />
Bank, as well as Abu Dhabi <strong>Islamic</strong> Bank (ADIB), which took<br />
the acquisition route to gain a foothold in Egypt, via its 51%<br />
acquisition of the National Development Bank of Egypt (NBD).<br />
Despite the country’s relatively slow progress in the sector and<br />
an uncertain market sentiment due to recent political upheavals,<br />
the Egypt-based unit of ADIB reported positive growth for the<br />
first quarter of 2011 for its <strong>Islamic</strong> banking business; charting a<br />
growth rate of 13.72% amounting to EGP2.61 billion (US$439.18<br />
million). However, the bank saw a 14.9% decline in total assets at<br />
EGP10.21 billion (US$1.71 billion) as at March 2011. Despite its<br />
significant overall losses, the bank is optimistic about growing its<br />
retail customer base and high-end banking products to attract new<br />
consumer segments within the Egyptian market.<br />
Other North <strong>Africa</strong>n countries such as Sudan are also seasoned<br />
players in <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance, with the country’s major <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
banking players such as the <strong>Islamic</strong> Bank of Khartoum looking<br />
to expand its customer base to East <strong>Africa</strong> in the medium-term,<br />
beginning with Kenya. The <strong>Islamic</strong> Bank of Khartoum was<br />
privatized in 2002, and is now 60% owned by Dubai <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
Bank. However, on the Sukuk front, Sudan has not fared too<br />
well, with its recent Sukuk sale in February being severely<br />
undersubscribed at SDG600 million (US$224.5 million) despite<br />
being a SDG863 million (US$323.03 million) issue. The Sukuk,<br />
issued by the government of Sudan and backed by its stake in<br />
the Khartoum Refinery Company (a joint venture with China<br />
National Petroleum Corporation), saw a 12.5% buy in by<br />
overseas investors.<br />
However, determined to bounce back from last year’s Sukuk<br />
disappointment, the country is due to issue a total of SDG3.6<br />
billion (US$1.34 billion) in Sukuk this year, beginning with a<br />
SDG765 million (US$286.35 million) issuance in September.<br />
According to industry players, demand for Sukuk in Sudan has<br />
increased since its failure to launch in February this year and<br />
is primarily from fi rms and banks. The Sukuk are expected to<br />
yield a 15% return; 3-5% higher than traditionally afforded by<br />
GCC banks.<br />
The country, which recently saw a separation between the<br />
Muslim-majority north and Christian-dominated south, currently<br />
relies heavily on the domestic debt market after being snubbed<br />
by international markets due to US-imposed sanctions.<br />
However, the growing number of Arab Banks in North Sudan,<br />
such as Qatar National Bank and Faisal <strong>Islamic</strong> Bank, bodes<br />
well for its <strong>Islamic</strong> banking sector, and is expected to revive the<br />
country’s struggling economy.<br />
Morocco also began introducing <strong>Islamic</strong> banking products in<br />
2007 under the “Alternative Financial Products” banner. The<br />
move, which was initiated by the Moroccan Central Bank,<br />
allows certain types of <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nancial products, and is said to<br />
be in response to growing consumer demand.<br />
Non-Arab dominated countries in the sub-Saharan <strong>Africa</strong> are<br />
also beginning to see the flourishing of the <strong>Islamic</strong> banking and<br />
finance sector, with countries such as Kenya, Tanzania, Uganda<br />
and Nigeria ramping up their <strong>Islamic</strong> banking efforts with the<br />
introduction of interest-free banking laws in Nigeria, a significant<br />
growth in <strong>Islamic</strong> banking and Takaful institutions in Kenya, a<br />
growing consumer demand for Shariah compliant products<br />
in Tanzania, as well as Uganda’s recent pledge to set up its<br />
first <strong>Islamic</strong> bank. Amar Meher, a senior associate at law firm<br />
Vinson & Elkins, is optimistic on the growth of these jurisdictions:<br />
“Countries such as Kenya, Nigeria, Egypt and South <strong>Africa</strong> are<br />
visibly increasing their commitment to growing their respective<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> banking and investment space, and are starting to see<br />
an influx of investments from Asia including the Middle East.”<br />
Kenya began introducing <strong>Islamic</strong> banking in 2008 with the<br />
establishment of Kenya Commercial Bank’s Amana <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
arm. The subsequent establishment of Gulf <strong>Africa</strong>n Bank also<br />
proved successful, contributing 1% to the banking sector’s<br />
net assets. Since then, fi ve other conventional banks have<br />
begun introducing <strong>Islamic</strong> banking products in the country. The<br />
amendment to the Banking Act by the Central Bank of Kenya<br />
in May 2010 is expected to further boost the country’s <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
banking industry.<br />
August 2011 5
COVER STORY<br />
Khan is confi dent of the growth potential in sub-Saharan <strong>Africa</strong>:<br />
“I believe the potential is great, due to its large population,<br />
growing economies and improved regulations. The <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
banking industry is also looking for new markets, so everything<br />
is aligning well. Countries such as Nigeria and Tanzania have<br />
expressed much interest, with Nigeria recently incorporating<br />
the Non-interest Banking Law, and Uganda announcing plans<br />
to set up an <strong>Islamic</strong> bank. There are all these things happening<br />
across the board, so I think there is a good opportunity. <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
investors are looking for new growth markets, and as the<br />
regulations come in place I see great potential.”<br />
Amman Muhammad, the managing director of Absa <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
Bank in South <strong>Africa</strong>, believes that the sub-Saharan economies<br />
provide a perfect petri dish for the induction of <strong>Islamic</strong> banking,<br />
mainly due to the sheer volume of Muslims: “Countries in west<br />
<strong>Africa</strong> such as Gambia, Guinea, Mauritania, Niger and Senegal<br />
all have Muslim populations above 90%, and in East <strong>Africa</strong><br />
[countries] such as Comores, Djibouti and Somalia have similar<br />
numbers. The countries in <strong>Africa</strong> that will fare best are naturally<br />
those with the largest Muslim populations or those with the most<br />
affl uent Muslim populations. In all North <strong>Africa</strong>n countries the<br />
Muslim population is above 90%, with the exception of Sudan<br />
at 70%. In South <strong>Africa</strong>, although the Muslim population is only<br />
2%, the level of affl uence of this population makes <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
banking a viable proposition.<br />
“In 2010, the economic growth rates of the Central <strong>Africa</strong><br />
Republic, Botswana and Nigeria were well above 8%, with<br />
Zambia and Mozambique above 7%,” he added.<br />
South <strong>Africa</strong>, one of the most affl uent <strong>Africa</strong>n states, has<br />
a Muslim population of 1.3 million, making up 2.4% of the<br />
population. Despite this, the country remains a strong contender<br />
in the sector, and is keen on achieving hub status. Fifty eight<br />
percent of the country’s Muslim population currently subscribes<br />
to conventional banking, and the sector is ready to tap into this<br />
market via an increase in education and awareness to gain<br />
access to high net-worth accounts. Muhammad revealed: “Both<br />
South <strong>Africa</strong> and Nigeria are keen to become hubs for <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
banking on the continent and are fast-tracking amendments to<br />
conventional fi nancial legislation. The consistent high growth of<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> banking in South <strong>Africa</strong> is an indicator of the potential<br />
for <strong>Islamic</strong> banking growth on the continent.”<br />
Risky Business?<br />
“There is always a country risk that you have to take into<br />
consideration; and it is more substantial in that part of the<br />
world. However, it still depends on the governments in question<br />
and how they will play it. Political risk is defi nitely something<br />
you would have to take into consideration, but it may work<br />
both ways; could be for or against the industry in that area.<br />
For instance, what impact would the change in regime have in<br />
Egypt; would they be for or against it?” said Meher.<br />
He added: “This mainly depends on the demographic of the<br />
country in question. For example, would <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance have<br />
a higher success rate in a country like Zimbabwe instead of<br />
Nigeria? It would be natural to say that Nigeria would have<br />
a higher success rate, because they have a larger Muslim<br />
population and have always demonstrated an intention to<br />
introduce <strong>Islamic</strong> banking. Whereas Zimbabwe is obviously a<br />
Christian/Catholic-driven society, which may not necessarily<br />
entertain it as the Nigerians would. So the demographic there<br />
is different.”<br />
Sudan, for instance, has seen its economy suffer from political<br />
turmoil; with foreign investors shying away from the country’s<br />
economy despite its vast potential. Sukuk sales have previously<br />
been withdrawn, with issuers citing political uncertainty as one of<br />
the main reasons. A lack of ratings and investment grade papers<br />
have also created cause for scepticism within the international<br />
investment community. Prior to the separation, industry players<br />
expressed trepidation regarding the Sudanese economy due<br />
to its low level of transparency and diffi culty in gaining reliable<br />
and useful information to assess the macroeconomic, and the<br />
external and public debt situation.<br />
Moving Forward<br />
The sectors expected to thrive in <strong>Africa</strong>’s vast and diverse<br />
economy include <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nancing, trade and project<br />
fi nancing and capital market issuances as well as agricultural<br />
investments.<br />
“An estimated 45-50% of the <strong>Africa</strong>n population are Muslim,<br />
standing between 400 and 500 million people. As a faithbased<br />
offering, <strong>Islamic</strong> banking has the potential to appeal<br />
to those who are currently unbanked and to those who are<br />
under-banked, which is due to a variety of reasons. The key<br />
reason being an aversion to conventional banking and only in<br />
certain circumstances taking up conventional banking products<br />
because of the lack of suitable compliant alternatives. There<br />
are also many affl uent Muslim traders, which means that<br />
potential <strong>Islamic</strong> banking customers fall into low, middle and<br />
6 August 2011
COVER STORY<br />
high income bands. <strong>Islamic</strong> banking in <strong>Africa</strong> has enormous<br />
potential to increase the percentage of <strong>Africa</strong>ns participating in<br />
the formal banking system,” said Muhammad.<br />
“There is enormous potential in the areas of infrastructure<br />
development and in manufacturing. <strong>Africa</strong> has an estimated<br />
300 million hectares of arable land, only a fraction of which is<br />
currently being used for farming. Mineral resources continue<br />
to play an important economic role and some <strong>Africa</strong>n countries<br />
also have rich untapped oil resources. Our experience in<br />
Tanzania also shows us that Muslim customers respond well to<br />
an offering that speaks to their faith. There is generally a high<br />
demand for microfi nancing products so this would be a popular<br />
offering, provided that suitable Shariah compliant structures<br />
are utilized to deliver this type of funding,” he added.<br />
Meher concurs, stating: “The potential for microfi nance has<br />
a signifi cant role in <strong>Africa</strong> - particularly in <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance.<br />
Two big areas for me are sovereign Sukuk issuances and<br />
the development of more socially conscious investments;<br />
particularly microfi nance in <strong>Africa</strong>. I do not see much potential<br />
in lending with commodity Murabahah and Ijarah, but sovereign<br />
Sukuk issuances, microfi nance and trade fi nance are defi nitely<br />
a strong growth area in that part of the world.”<br />
The country, which recently<br />
saw a separation between<br />
the Muslim-majority north and<br />
Christian-dominated south,<br />
currently relies heavily on the<br />
domestic debt market after being<br />
snubbed by international<br />
markets<br />
Khan is also confi dent of the corporate banking prospects<br />
<strong>Africa</strong> has to offer: “I think it will start with corporate banking;<br />
driven by trade fi nance. Once there is critical mass and enough<br />
product education, the likes of Kenya, Tanzania, and Nigeria<br />
will look to the retail market. It will start traditionally; similar to<br />
Malaysia and Indonesia, and will follow the same pattern. First<br />
trade, then retail, then capital markets.<br />
“Some countries in <strong>Africa</strong> have pledged to issue Sukuk in<br />
the short to medium-term, but a sovereign Sukuk issuance is<br />
different to having a Sukuk market. The market will take time to<br />
develop, but a strong statement of support by any sovereign is<br />
a positive sign, and shows that the lawmakers and government<br />
are serious about <strong>Islamic</strong> banking. The local currency Sukuk<br />
market will develop based on the conventional local capital<br />
market. Without a local currency capital market, it is diffi cult<br />
to develop a local currency Sukuk market. You need capital<br />
market people and investors who can understand the risks, as<br />
well as proper systems put in place; all these elements have<br />
to exist.”<br />
In terms of regulatory and tax updates, <strong>Africa</strong>n countries seem<br />
to be on the right track with some nations such as Nigeria<br />
making serious commitments by incorporating non-interest<br />
banking into its fi nancial system. However, as demonstrated in<br />
many jurisdictions across the globe, desire itself is not suffi cient<br />
in guaranteeing the success of a country’s <strong>Islamic</strong> capital<br />
market. “Similar to other jurisdictions, these jurisdictions would<br />
have to consider the regulatory hurdles unique to the countries<br />
and whether or not [they are] willing to overcome those hurdles.<br />
So… if they have expressed an intention and desire, like<br />
most other countries, are they willing to make the necessary<br />
changes to facilitate the industry? And each of these will be<br />
bespoke to the country in question. From my understanding,<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>n countries all share similar legal systems, but they will<br />
defi nitely have to revisit those and see whether or not [<strong>Islamic</strong><br />
banking] works from their country’s perspective,” said Meher.<br />
Double-digit growth<br />
“Muslim customers in <strong>Africa</strong> have shown a strong preference<br />
for the <strong>Islamic</strong> brand, even paying a premium for the products<br />
offered by <strong>Islamic</strong> banks. The regional industry has shown<br />
double-digit growth rates although from a relatively low absolute<br />
base,” said Khalid Howladar, the head of <strong>Islamic</strong> Financial<br />
Institutions at Moody’s.<br />
Meher is excited about <strong>Africa</strong>’s potential contribution to the<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance industry as a whole: “<strong>Africa</strong> is a sleeping giant,<br />
in the sense that people have always looked to the GCC and<br />
Asia for development, and there was a period when people<br />
were looking at North America and Europe, but for some<br />
reason, people have overlooked <strong>Africa</strong> where the potential<br />
in the immediate-term is enormous. <strong>Africa</strong> has the right<br />
ingredients; <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance offers the right product areas, and<br />
it is just dependent on the countries in question whether or not<br />
they decide to develop the industry, which involves revisiting<br />
the legal and regulatory regimes and introducing <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
institutions. Hopefully <strong>Africa</strong> won’t be one to disappoint. We<br />
as market participants have been watching <strong>Africa</strong> very closely;<br />
particularly those based in the GCC, due to geographical<br />
proximity.”<br />
Khan also affi rmed that the <strong>Islamic</strong> banking community is keen<br />
on the continent: “<strong>Islamic</strong> investors are on the lookout for new<br />
markets, growth markets, diversifi cation, and good returns from<br />
capital investments. The <strong>Islamic</strong> industry generally prefers to<br />
make investments and understand the relationship and credit,<br />
as opposed to investing based on ratings. The primary focus<br />
of the bank is the business model and understanding the<br />
management team in order to do business.”<br />
With proper regulations, increased transparency, education,<br />
and an objective, non-political perspective of the Shariah<br />
compliant sector, <strong>Islamic</strong> banking in <strong>Africa</strong> has the potential<br />
to thrive. Increased interest from Gulf investors in terms of<br />
agricultural land acquisitions and the mergers and acquisitions<br />
of fi nancial institutions, as well as a growing Asian investor base,<br />
particularly in manufacturing and project fi nance, is expected to<br />
grow the <strong>Africa</strong>n economy signifi cantly. As it stands, <strong>Africa</strong> has<br />
everything to gain and nothing to lose by growing its <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
banking sector.<br />
August 2011 7
FEATURE<br />
Reviving lost trade<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>, a thriving trade destination for the Middle East, Europe, India<br />
and China up until the 19 th century, is once more on the brink of a<br />
trade flurry after decades of dormancy. NAZNEEN HALIM examines the<br />
prospects for <strong>Islamic</strong> trade and project financing in the continent, and<br />
the initiatives already in place.<br />
To date, the <strong>Islamic</strong> Development Bank (IDB) has provided up<br />
to US$6 billion in fi nancing to <strong>Africa</strong>; out of which US$4.3 billion<br />
was allocated to fi nance development projects and US$1.7<br />
billion to fund trade. The IDB has recently reiterated its pledge<br />
to aid in the development of the <strong>Africa</strong>n economy, in particular<br />
its member countries, and is actively encouraging trade and<br />
project fi nance activities, especially in the agricultural sector.<br />
Industry players are also optimistic about the future of these<br />
two sectors in <strong>Africa</strong>, considering positive growth patterns and<br />
a signifi cant increase in bilateral trade between <strong>Africa</strong> and<br />
emerging economies; particularly China and India. Between<br />
2000 and 2009 <strong>Africa</strong>’s trade with the GCC grew by 170%,<br />
whilst bilateral trade with China reached US$115 billion in 2010<br />
and trade with India saw a 45.5% increase to US$13.8 billion<br />
in 2009.<br />
Set against the cacophonous background of the <strong>Africa</strong>n<br />
socioeconomic landscape, <strong>Islamic</strong> trade and project fi nancing<br />
are expected to thrive; capitalizing on untapped opportunities<br />
in construction and infrastructure development including roads,<br />
highways, and power plants, as well as manufacturing. Backed<br />
by the IDB, trade fi nancing in <strong>Africa</strong> is also expected to kick off<br />
as trade between OIC member <strong>Africa</strong>n countries increases and<br />
more trade programs and corridors are developed.<br />
Amman Muhammad, the managing director of Absa <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
Bank in South <strong>Africa</strong>, believes that the growth opportunities in<br />
8 August 2011
FEATURE<br />
these sectors are promising: “Based on the attention that <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
project and trade fi nance are currently receiving the prospects<br />
are exciting, provided the appropriate vehicles are available<br />
to support this development. There is enormous potential in<br />
the areas of infrastructure development and in manufacturing.<br />
<strong>Africa</strong> has an estimated 300 million hectares of arable land,<br />
and only a fraction is currently being used for farming. Mineral<br />
resources continue to play an important economic role, and<br />
some <strong>Africa</strong>n countries also have rich untapped oil resources.<br />
The <strong>Islamic</strong> Development Bank also aims to make agriculture<br />
one of its main areas of focus in <strong>Africa</strong>, stating: “Considering<br />
that poverty in the majority of member countries is a rural<br />
phenomenon, investment in the agricultural sector, which the<br />
bulk of the population depends on for its livelihood, is an obvious<br />
target for any poverty reduction program. It is imperative that<br />
the Bank’s assistance in agriculture is targeted in high valueadded<br />
sub-sectors such as agro-processing, irrigation and<br />
crop development, marketing and storage facilities, as well as<br />
micro-credit schemes.<br />
The sheer size and volume<br />
of the continent affords<br />
abundant opportunities to<br />
investors<br />
Agro-processing is one area that has a high value-addition,<br />
especially in <strong>Africa</strong>, and therefore will have a greater impact on<br />
improving the living conditions of the most vulnerable groups<br />
in society.”<br />
Amar Meher, senior associate at Vinson & Elkins, also believes<br />
that the agricultural sector in <strong>Africa</strong> will grow as demand for<br />
arable land increases among GCC investors: “At the moment,<br />
GCC investors are most interested in acquiring agricultural<br />
land for growing fruits and vegetables to bring back to their<br />
respective home countries; mostly on a micro-level. GCC<br />
investors look to <strong>Africa</strong> with the view of managing infl ation<br />
through the acquisition of agricultural land. Crop prices have<br />
gone up, whilst supply has decreased, and it becomes quite<br />
hard to manage as a supplier, because your production costs<br />
have gone up. There is also the issue of managing the price<br />
caps that have been imposed by GCC countries during certain<br />
periods in a year. The acquisition of agricultural land in <strong>Africa</strong><br />
allows them to manage infl ation on a micro-level.”<br />
Affi liates of the IDB, such as the <strong>Islamic</strong> Corporation for the<br />
Development of the Private Sector (ICD), are also actively<br />
increasing their focus on <strong>Africa</strong>. Khaled Al-Aboodi, CEO of ICD,<br />
revealed: “At present our businesses are mainly in the Middle<br />
East and North <strong>Africa</strong> region. We want to move to sub-Saharan<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>, East Asia and Central Asia.” Among the ICD’s plans<br />
for sub-Saharan <strong>Africa</strong> are schemes to set up non-banking<br />
fi nancial institutions to fi nance projects as well as support the<br />
housing sector, and establish special economic zones. “We<br />
also want to prepare projects to be bankable,” he added. The<br />
ICD has spent more than US$1.6 billion on various projects<br />
and helped mobilize funds from other fi nanciers for projects<br />
worth US$5 billion.<br />
Tunisia, which has been elected as a representing board<br />
member of the IDB’s North <strong>Africa</strong> Group for the 2011-2014<br />
period, is also expected to gain from its affi liation with the IDB;<br />
having recently received two fi nancing facilities worth TND50<br />
million (US$36 million) and TND30 million (US$21.62 million)<br />
for the fi nancing of integrated agricultural development projects<br />
and to support the Tunisian Solidarity Bank’s micro-credit<br />
program.<br />
With the implementation of proper regulations and the creation<br />
of a level playing fi eld for tax, industry players are confi dent<br />
of the growth of the continent’s <strong>Islamic</strong> project and trade<br />
fi nancing sectors, as well as an infl ux of <strong>Islamic</strong> investors;<br />
particularly from the GCC. The sheer size and volume of the<br />
continent affords abundant opportunities to investors, whilst its<br />
people have much to gain from infrastructure and development<br />
projects.<br />
9 August 2011
FEATURE<br />
Banking on microfinance<br />
At present, over 410 million people in sub-Saharan <strong>Africa</strong> are living<br />
below the poverty line. Could <strong>Islamic</strong> microfinance be the panacea for<br />
millions of <strong>Africa</strong>’s poor? NAZNEEN HALIM explores.<br />
According to the Multidimensional Poverty Index, produced<br />
by the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) and the<br />
Oxford Poverty & Human Development Initiative, 24 out of the<br />
25 poorest countries in the world are located in <strong>Africa</strong>. The<br />
continent’s fragile socio-economic situation, despite seeing<br />
some improvement over the last decade, is still dire.<br />
High on the agenda of the <strong>Islamic</strong> Development Bank (IDB)<br />
and <strong>Islamic</strong> Financial Services Board’s Ten-year Framework<br />
for the development of the <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance industry is poverty<br />
alleviation through <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance, particularly among the<br />
IDB member countries; which at present rank among the lowest<br />
in the UNDP’s Human Development Index for 120 developing<br />
countries. What is needed to move the <strong>Africa</strong>n economy<br />
forward, according to economists, is a substantial increase in<br />
real per capita GDP and improved social conditions.<br />
Industry players believe that <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance could<br />
play a signifi cant role in growing and developing the sub-<br />
Saharan <strong>Africa</strong>n economies due to its low cost and ability<br />
to entice small entrepreneurs and the large unbanked<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>n population to fully participate in the economy. Based<br />
purely on volume, <strong>Africa</strong>’s <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance initiatives<br />
have incredible potential. Benjamin Nkungi, CEO of the<br />
Association of Microfi nance Institutions, stated: “The next big<br />
thing we are likely to see is the establishment of exclusive<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance institutions across sub-Saharan <strong>Africa</strong><br />
as a result of outstanding grassroots demand.” The impact<br />
across <strong>Africa</strong>, he says, is expected to be huge; creating a<br />
signifi cant supply of liquidity based on retail-based deposits<br />
and investments in Shariah compliant deposits and premiums<br />
among corporate and institutional investors.<br />
Power to the people<br />
Microfi nance is not an alien concept to <strong>Africa</strong>, with its main<br />
client base comprising of organized women groups. The most<br />
popular microfi nance model, according to the IDB report, is the<br />
Village Bank model; which involves an implementing agency<br />
that establishes a village bank with around fi fty members, and<br />
provides external capital for onward fi nancing to individual<br />
members. Individual loans are repaid at weekly intervals over<br />
four months, at which time the village bank returns the principal<br />
with interest and profi ts to the implementing agency.<br />
As a village bank accumulates suffi cient capital internally,<br />
it eventually becomes an autonomous and self-sustaining<br />
institution. However, unlike <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance, the interest<br />
rates for conventional microfi nance loans in <strong>Africa</strong> at present<br />
are sky-high; sometimes even touching 20%, and predatory<br />
lenders are plentiful.<br />
Recognizing the potential of microfi nance, the Central Bank of<br />
Sudan in 2010 called for a minimum allocation of 12% of every<br />
bank’s portfolio to microfi nance, and for the establishment<br />
of specialized units to develop the industry. Banks are also<br />
required to submit annual reports to the central bank on their<br />
microfi nance activities, and to create public awareness and<br />
education initiatives.<br />
Based purely on<br />
volume, <strong>Africa</strong>’s <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
microfinance initiatives<br />
have incredible potential<br />
Among the fi rst <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance institutions in sub-Saharan<br />
<strong>Africa</strong> was Azaouad <strong>Finance</strong>s, resulting from a development<br />
project by the German Technical Cooperation and German<br />
Financial Cooperation after the eruption of fi erce confl icts in the<br />
three poorest northern regions of Mali; spanning Timbuktu,Gao<br />
and Kidal, beginning in 1990 and ending in 1995. The aim of<br />
the project was to provide fi nancial services to all the tribes<br />
in Northern Mali, and based on general consensus, it was<br />
decided that an <strong>Islamic</strong> bank would be most appealing to the<br />
areas’ tribes.<br />
Since then, the <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance scene in <strong>Africa</strong> has been<br />
rather muted, but a revival is due very soon. Takaful companies<br />
such as Takaful Insurance of <strong>Africa</strong> have begun introducing<br />
microfi nance-linked products such as Takaful micro insurance,<br />
while Kenya’s Equity Bank recently introduced a Shariah<br />
compliant microfi nance lending product in the country. Other<br />
institutions such as Ghana <strong>Islamic</strong> Microfi nance (GIM) aim to<br />
capitalize on the growing demand for microfi nance products<br />
in <strong>Africa</strong>, and will offer Shariah compliant microfi nance<br />
transactions to Muslims and non-Muslims alike. According to<br />
the bank, GIM aims to provide an alternative avenue to loan<br />
seekers outside of the conventional sphere, allowing them to<br />
escape the web of predatory lending.<br />
At present, Shariah compliant microfi nancing products in <strong>Africa</strong><br />
are based on the Wadiah, Mudarabah and Ijarah contracts,<br />
while Bai Bithaman Ajil is a common feature among its debtbased<br />
products. The further development of <strong>Africa</strong>’s tax and<br />
regulatory environments is expected to spur the introduction<br />
of newer and more sophisticated forms of lending, as well as<br />
create a more diverse product range for its currently underserved<br />
poor population.<br />
10 August 2011
FEATURE<br />
Asset management in South <strong>Africa</strong><br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> finance has seen exponential growth in <strong>Africa</strong>, particularly in the<br />
North <strong>Africa</strong>n region, and of late to the west and east of <strong>Africa</strong> as well.<br />
<strong>Africa</strong> is home to about 412 million Muslims with a high concentration<br />
focused in the regions mentioned above. North <strong>Africa</strong> is an obvious<br />
choice for <strong>Islamic</strong> finance due in part to its close proximity to the Middle<br />
Whilst <strong>Islamic</strong> banking is seeing rapid growth in countries such<br />
as Nigeria, Kenya, Uganda and even Tanzania, where half the<br />
population is Muslim, South <strong>Africa</strong> has had two decades of<br />
experience, being one of the fi rst non-Muslim countries in <strong>Africa</strong><br />
to establish <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance.<br />
Constituting only 2% of its total population, South <strong>Africa</strong> has<br />
the smallest number of Muslims on the continent. This did not<br />
prevent Al Baraka Bank from establishing the only fully fl edged<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> bank in South <strong>Africa</strong> in 1989. Subsequently, four other<br />
banks opened <strong>Islamic</strong> windows alongside their conventional<br />
practices.<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> asset management<br />
On the investment front, there are a number of Shariah<br />
investment funds available in the market. Currently, 11<br />
asset management companies in South <strong>Africa</strong> offer Shariah<br />
compliant investment schemes or mutual funds as well as<br />
discretionary and multi-managed portfolios. That makes up a<br />
quarter of the total number of asset management companies<br />
registered under the country’s Financial Services Board (FSB).<br />
The company managing the largest number of <strong>Islamic</strong> funds<br />
is the Oasis Group’s Oasis Asset Management. It is reported<br />
that the Oasis family of funds currently manages 63 Shariah<br />
compliant domestic and offshore funds.<br />
The fi rst <strong>Islamic</strong> fund to be launched in South <strong>Africa</strong> was<br />
the Futuregrowth Albaraka Equity Fund which was initially<br />
managed by Element Investment Managers, formerly Frater<br />
Asset Management, from 2000 to 2005. It was then managed<br />
by Futuregrowth, which has since become a member of the Old<br />
Mutual Investment Group (OMIGSA).<br />
Mogammad Saliegh Salaam, an investment manager at Old<br />
Mutual Investment Group, says there is interest to expand<br />
Shariah compliant investment in South <strong>Africa</strong>, as can be seen<br />
by a number of new asset management companies that have<br />
come into the market to provide various products across the<br />
board.<br />
“Also the product offering has also started to cater for the asset<br />
allocation requirements of Muslim investors. There have been<br />
a number of banks that have come up with <strong>Islamic</strong> windows or<br />
products for high net worth individuals. We have seen one or<br />
two companies offer their products and services for high net<br />
worth individuals,” he says, adding that the majority of mutual<br />
Eurekahedge <strong>Islamic</strong> South <strong>Africa</strong> Fund Index<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
funds that dominate the Shariah landscape in South <strong>Africa</strong> are<br />
for the mass market.<br />
As with the world over, <strong>Islamic</strong> equity funds are also very<br />
popular in South <strong>Africa</strong>. However, Salaam notes that the South<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>n investor is evolving. “Not everybody wants to invest<br />
totally in equity. Even if the markets are not volatile, people<br />
have different profi les, tolerances and preferences.<br />
“It has been an equity-centric environment but as the market<br />
develops clients are becoming more sophisticated and have<br />
different requirements,” he elaborates, before briefl y mentioning<br />
that Old Mutual launched its <strong>Islamic</strong> balanced fund in the fourth<br />
quarter of last year.<br />
Less well known is that South <strong>Africa</strong> is also home to <strong>Africa</strong>’s fi rst<br />
Shariah compliant exchange traded fund (ETF), launched in<br />
2009 by NewFunds, a joint venture between Absa Capital and<br />
Vunani Capital. The Shariah Top 40 Exchange Traded Fund<br />
(ETF) includes Shariah compliant companies that are selected<br />
from the FTSE/JSE Top 40 index listed on the main board of<br />
the Johannesburg Stock Exchange, as measured by market<br />
capitalization.<br />
Reception of <strong>Islamic</strong> Funds<br />
The Eurekahedge <strong>Islamic</strong> South <strong>Africa</strong> Fund Index reveals that<br />
the value of funds has increased by 135.26% in May 2011, up<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
11 August 2011
FEATURE<br />
Performance of a sample of South <strong>Africa</strong> domiciled funds<br />
As of May 2011 Return<br />
Fund Name Date of inception Return since<br />
Inception<br />
Return since<br />
Mar 2010<br />
2011 Return<br />
YTD<br />
Element <strong>Islamic</strong> Equity Fund February 2006 65.33% 11.23% 1.62%<br />
Futuregrowth Albaraka Equity Fund June 1992 1215.60% 17.41% 2.32%<br />
Kagiso <strong>Islamic</strong> Equity Fund July 2009 52.20% 22.05% 3.46%<br />
Oasis Crescent Balanced High Equity Fund of Funds April 2010 10.99% 10.99% 2.94%<br />
Oasis Crescent Balanced Stable Fund of Funds April 2010 8.90% 8.90% 2.85%<br />
STANLIB Shari’ah Equity Fund A June 2007 -4.66% 10.85% 2.51%<br />
Symmetry <strong>Islamic</strong> Fund December 2005 75.77% 7.16% 2.53%<br />
Source: Eurekahedge<br />
19.47% from a year earlier. Despite the positive performance,<br />
Salaam laments the slow uptake of funds. “It has been a tough<br />
market generally to try to sell any product that has some other<br />
market linkage to it,” he explains.<br />
Institutional investors, he continues, are less receptive to<br />
Shariah compliant solutions. The only instance of the uptake<br />
is termed as ‘member level choice’ – the equivalent to the<br />
US’ 401 plan where employees of a company can choose to<br />
make contributions for their retirement plan. “In South <strong>Africa</strong>,<br />
a number of pension funds have allowed members of that<br />
platform to select Shariah compliant vehicles to invest their<br />
pension savings,” Salaam elucidates.<br />
Ongoing campaigns are being promoted by all the asset<br />
management companies to create further awareness of<br />
Shariah compliant investing, targeting not only Muslim but non-<br />
Muslim investors as well.<br />
has garnered almost no foreign investor interest either from the<br />
Middle East, Asia or Europe. The asset management industry<br />
is no exception with most mergers and acquisitions being<br />
completed only at the domestic level. With the exception of a<br />
small handful of funds that have been marketed globally, the<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> funds are catered to domestic investors.<br />
“We haven’t seen much foreign demand for Shariah compliant<br />
local products. It is conducive for foreign investors to invest but<br />
we just have not seen any major foreign interest.”<br />
As the excitement to develop <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance in the western<br />
and eastern regions of <strong>Africa</strong> continues to build, it would do<br />
South <strong>Africa</strong> some good to lure some of the attraction in its own<br />
direction. It is well positioned to promote the industry, with good<br />
structures in the areas of regulation, legislation, governance and<br />
compliance as well as a sturdy risk management framework.<br />
The other challenge faced by companies managing <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
funds is the lack of investment tools available. Salaam says:<br />
“We need a lot more products from the various investment<br />
banks. They need to provide us a lot more Shariah compliant<br />
products or avenues in which to deploy our cash. That is<br />
probably by far the biggest challenge.”<br />
Investment banks dealing with these asset management<br />
companies are normally faced with the issue of Shariah<br />
compliance. “The products that they come up with may not<br />
necessarily satisfy our Shariah board. We need to make sure<br />
that all the products satisfy our Shariah boards.”<br />
In its bid to promote and maintain a sound fi nancial investment<br />
environment in South <strong>Africa</strong>, the FSB has recently introduced<br />
several exemptions for <strong>Islamic</strong> funds. Notice 1503 of 2005,<br />
which was published in the terms of the Collective Investment<br />
Schemes Control Act of 2002, now allows managers of a<br />
Shariah compliant fund to invest up to 50% of the market value<br />
of total assets in a particular portfolio, from the previous 10%<br />
limitation.<br />
The exemption applied on the 1 st July 2011 until the 31 st May<br />
2013.<br />
Despite coming a long way with <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance, South <strong>Africa</strong><br />
12 August 2011
FEATURE<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>n emergence<br />
The <strong>Africa</strong>n Takaful market is gearing itself up as an important future<br />
market in the Takaful arena. SCOTT WEBER turns his gaze towards the<br />
latest incumbents in what is proving to be Takaful’s next frontier.<br />
<strong>Africa</strong> is a new market for Takaful operations, and many<br />
countries with Muslim majority populations and developed<br />
banking sectors are looking at the alternative industry to<br />
diversify their operations and hopefully attract a new, previously<br />
untapped customer base. This growth potential is clearly shown<br />
by the number of new Takaful operators and <strong>Islamic</strong> windows<br />
sprouting up across the continent.<br />
Larger reinsurance<br />
companies should take it as<br />
a responsibility to see the rapid<br />
growth of Takaful in third<br />
world countries<br />
Cross-continent rollout<br />
The emergence of Takaful has begun in earnest, with the<br />
Takaful industry looking to replicate its successes in Southeast<br />
Asia and the GCC. Hassan Bashir, CEO at Takaful Insurance of<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>, says that: “There are companies now operating Takaful<br />
models in the north, south, west and east of <strong>Africa</strong>. The <strong>Africa</strong>n<br />
continent offers signifi cant opportunities for the Takaful industry,<br />
particularly because the Takaful model fi ts very well with the<br />
traditional <strong>Africa</strong>n way of life that is fundamentally based on<br />
a self-help, group support social structure.” Bashir goes on to<br />
state that: “If presented well, the Takaful model is…at home<br />
in <strong>Africa</strong> and as a result there is an exciting prospect for the<br />
Takaful industry in <strong>Africa</strong>”.<br />
<strong>Africa</strong> does however remain a relatively isolated market. The<br />
continent as a whole is yet to fully connect with the world<br />
market. According to Bashir: “Markets in other regions must<br />
play a signifi cant role in the development of Takaful in <strong>Africa</strong>.<br />
The Takaful industry in <strong>Africa</strong> will rely on other regions such as<br />
Asia and Arabia for knowledge, training and capital.” However,<br />
as Bashir goes on to say: “Many markets in <strong>Africa</strong> will benefi t<br />
from such partnerships.” <strong>Africa</strong>n start-ups will benefi t from the<br />
expertise of mature fi rms entering from other regions but it is<br />
also heavily reliant on re-Takaful fi rms from other regions for<br />
support and protection.<br />
Issues raised<br />
Issues do continually present themselves in the <strong>Africa</strong>n<br />
market, according to Bashir, and there are numerous <strong>Africa</strong>-<br />
13 August 2011
FEATURE<br />
specifi c limitations to offering Takaful coverage: “First, <strong>Africa</strong>n<br />
markets are largely governed by conventional insurance acts<br />
that have little or no consideration for the needs of a Takaful<br />
model.” This presents challenges in the areas of governance<br />
and investment. Secondly, <strong>Africa</strong>n markets (with the exception<br />
of North <strong>Africa</strong>) lack any form of Shariah compliant capital<br />
market. “This presents signifi cant operational diffi culties in<br />
many markets where conventional insurance acts restrict<br />
investment in foreign markets,” according to Bashir, who<br />
faces this situation in Kenya. Third, is the limitation of Shariah<br />
scholars in corresponding their understanding of business,<br />
fi nance and risk management to the challenges that <strong>Africa</strong><br />
presents. Bashir’s fi nal point is that there still remains a lack<br />
of well-trained human capital and resources to support the fast<br />
emerging <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance sector in <strong>Africa</strong>.<br />
The conventional insurance market in <strong>Africa</strong> has been<br />
somewhat dominated by the larger international players and<br />
Bashir believes that this could happen with the Takaful market.<br />
“In the case of re-Takaful, we have already seen signs of this<br />
with foreign players showing equal interest as local reinsurers.”<br />
In Bashir’s view, Takaful can hardly exist without the <strong>Islamic</strong><br />
banking sector, and the key to this is “the development of a<br />
vibrant <strong>Islamic</strong> capital market.” Without this, “any Takaful<br />
operations will be fundamentally fl awed”.<br />
There are companies now<br />
operating Takaful models<br />
in the North, South, West<br />
and East of <strong>Africa</strong><br />
The Gambian example<br />
Gambia provides a good case study for the issues facing<br />
Takaful operators in the country. Gambia previously had<br />
11 conventional banks, one of which was <strong>Islamic</strong>, and 12<br />
registered insurance companies, none of which were <strong>Islamic</strong>.<br />
That all changed when a taskforce was set up to facilitate the<br />
passing of Takaful regulations in 2005; comprising of members<br />
from the international investment department (Gambia<br />
investment promotion), the chamber of commerce, the central<br />
bank, members of the justice department and fi nanciers.<br />
According to Momodou Joof, the managing director and CEO<br />
at Takaful Gambia: “It took many meetings with all invested<br />
parties explaining to them the economic benefi ts such an<br />
operation could provide,” as the Gambian Takaful regulations,<br />
based on those in Malaysia, would have been blocked by those<br />
in government with a vested interest in the conventional system<br />
as this would have proved a threat to their operations.<br />
Takaful operations in Gambia are still in their infancy having<br />
only been in operation for three years. The current focus is only<br />
on general insurance, but Takaful Gambia has plans to open a<br />
Family Takaful operation when their general insurance operation<br />
breaks even. Joof admits that he is missing a large segment of<br />
the market and that: “The society assistance models offered<br />
through Family Takaful offer a greater opportunity for poverty<br />
alleviation,” and the fl exibility of Family Takaful would offer the<br />
opportunity to come up with unique Shariah specifi c solutions<br />
allowing them to work with SMEs and small businesses.<br />
Joof is personally invested in this project and is looking to take<br />
the Gambian model into West <strong>Africa</strong>. Takaful Gambia is actively<br />
looking at creating a network of Takaful companies in a similar<br />
vein to the pan-<strong>Africa</strong>n Ecobank, which is proving successful in<br />
its own right. “Nothing is stopping Takaful from taking the lead<br />
and jumping into the countries around Gambia,” Joof adds.<br />
There is a signifi cant market in Sudan, which is solely <strong>Islamic</strong>,<br />
and considerable interest is being shown in both Nigeria and<br />
Senegal, who have appointed Egyptian consultants to review<br />
their legislation for the possibility of offering <strong>Islamic</strong> banking<br />
and Takaful and are working hard on supporting its adoption;<br />
having hosted several seminars on the issue and even inviting<br />
the IDB to open a regional <strong>Africa</strong>n offi ce in Dhaka.<br />
Challenges abound<br />
Bureaucracy remains the greatest challenge on the <strong>Africa</strong>n<br />
scene, with networking playing an important role in opening<br />
doors that could otherwise remain reluctant to such proposals.<br />
According to Joof, it will take “the governments to appreciate<br />
what is being achieved in Gambia and either replicating or<br />
consulting with more experienced nations to advise on the<br />
feasibility of gaining operational licenses to operate subsidiaries<br />
in their markets”.<br />
Other challenges that have emerged are in competition<br />
with the conventional market which according to Joof “are<br />
creating a price war, which is not sustainable”. Eventually<br />
the governments are going to have to step in and regulate as<br />
this trend is not benefi cial for the industry to allow unhealthy<br />
competition through pricing.<br />
14 August 2011
FEATURE<br />
Investment is still key to rolling out Takaful, proving that<br />
Takaful is a legitimate and profi table solution. According to<br />
Joof: “The larger reinsurance companies should take it as a<br />
responsibility to see the rapid growth of Takaful in third world<br />
countries and aid such institutions in their capacity building<br />
efforts.” Governmental support is one thing, but getting it right<br />
is important and this can only be achieved with support from<br />
reinsurance companies.<br />
The Takaful model fits very<br />
well with the traditional<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>n way of life that is<br />
fundamentally based on a selfhelp,<br />
group support social<br />
structure<br />
The floodgates open<br />
Numerous Takaful and conventional operators have sought<br />
entry into the lucrative Takaful sector, attracted by its capacity<br />
to open up previously untapped segments of the market.<br />
This is demonstrated by the recent announcement by Kenya<br />
Reinsurance corporation (Kenya Re)’s plan to begin operating<br />
a re-Takaful window to grow its current income and to tap into<br />
the expanding <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance sector as part of the company’s<br />
fi ve year plan of product diversifi cation.<br />
“The intention is to have a department that fully complies with<br />
all… re-Takaful requirements so that Takaful fi rms are not shy<br />
to give us business,” according to Jadiah Mwarania, chief<br />
executive offi cer of Kenya Re.<br />
By expanding its product offerings to include re-Takaful, Kenya<br />
Re is responding to regional insurance market dynamics<br />
following this year’s launch of Takaful Insurance of <strong>Africa</strong>, a<br />
fully fl edged Shariah compliant insurance company that plans<br />
to expand its operations into Tanzania and Uganda.<br />
Kenya has continually shown its interest towards the<br />
alternative insurance industry with the launch of the fi rst Takaful<br />
company, GulfCap Takaful, followed a short time later by the<br />
establishment of two other new fi rms: FCB Takaful and Takaful<br />
Insurance Agency.<br />
Competitive market<br />
Last year, Kenya Re’s direct competitor <strong>Africa</strong> Re launched its<br />
own re-Takaful subsidiary, <strong>Africa</strong> re-Takaful, in order to tap into<br />
the burgeoning <strong>Africa</strong>n Takaful market. In September 2010,<br />
<strong>Africa</strong> Re launched a subsidiary company based in Egypt<br />
to offer exclusive re-Takaful services while Comesa-owned<br />
reinsurer ZEP-RE, where Kenya Re is also a shareholder, set<br />
up a Sudan-based re-Takaful subsidiary in September 2009.<br />
By entering into the competitive re-Takaful business, Kenya<br />
Re is responding to regional insurance market dynamics.<br />
Insurance companies are racing to launch Shariah compliant<br />
products across the <strong>Africa</strong>n continent in order to tap into the<br />
growing Muslim middle class.<br />
The shift towards re-Takaful will mean more business fl ows into<br />
the company from predominantly Muslim regions like Sudan<br />
and particularly North <strong>Africa</strong>, where Kenya Re is expanding its<br />
presence.<br />
But Kenya Re, like many other operators, will have to reinvest<br />
income from their re-Takaful department outside the country<br />
because Kenya does not currently have the necessary Shariah<br />
compliant capital market products for reinvestment.<br />
Kenya Re currently underwrites business for all 47 insurance<br />
companies in Kenya, which are by law required to cede 18%<br />
of their reinsurance to the company up to 2015. This valuable<br />
revenue stream currently accounts for 40% of Kenya Re’s<br />
gross premium income.<br />
Growth will also be driven by an expected tripling of mortgage<br />
lending, which shot from an annual KES100 million (US$1.1<br />
million) to KES300 million (US$3.3million) as of January 2011.<br />
Despite market prospects, Kenya’s only other Takaful<br />
underwriter, Takaful Insurance of <strong>Africa</strong>, has continually raised<br />
concerns over the inability of Kenya’s capital markets authority<br />
to license Shariah compliant products.<br />
Its re-Takaful focus will also enable Kenya Re to widen its<br />
business partnerships in the West <strong>Africa</strong>n market, where it has<br />
reopened its offi ces after the end of the civil war in Ivory Coast.<br />
There are many obstacles that continue to cause concern for<br />
the budding industry; for instance the lack of qualifi ed Takaful<br />
professionals in the region and the absence of the necessary<br />
Shariah compliant legal framework for investment and Shariah<br />
compliant instruments.<br />
Premium potential<br />
Morgan Stanley has previously stated that Kenyan Takaful<br />
premiums could potentially reach KES20 billion (US$221.73<br />
million) by 2014, or 31% of total insurance premiums.<br />
Barclays Bank was the fi rst fi nancial institution to test the<br />
market with a Shariah compliant product in December 2005,<br />
and since then <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nancial products have exploded with at<br />
least eight commercial banks tapping into the market.<br />
Two <strong>Islamic</strong>-driven banks with roots in the Middle East are Gulf<br />
<strong>Africa</strong>n and First Community. Both banks opened up shop in<br />
2007 and have since moved to the profi t zone, illustrating the<br />
vibrancy of the halal economy in the country.<br />
They are seeking to deepen penetration in a market where<br />
conventional insurance has suffered from consumer apathy<br />
and ignorance, with uptake remaining at below 3% over the<br />
decade.<br />
15 August 2011
Global industry<br />
One publication<br />
Established in 2004, <strong>Islamic</strong> <strong>Finance</strong> news covers all realms<br />
of <strong>Islamic</strong> finance, providing professionals around the globe<br />
with a vehicle to educate and understand the market, the<br />
players, the individuals and perhaps more importantly, the<br />
benefits over, and comparisons with the conventional<br />
banking system.<br />
Published every Wednesday, <strong>Islamic</strong> <strong>Finance</strong> news is the<br />
industry’s leading, e-newsletter providing over 20,000<br />
individuals with unrivaled editorial coverage of the global<br />
<strong>Islamic</strong> financing market.<br />
Request for a complimentary trial subscription by emailing<br />
subs@islamicfinancenews.com or simply call +603 2162 7800.