08.03.2014 Views

Africa: - Islamic Finance News

Africa: - Islamic Finance News

Africa: - Islamic Finance News

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

August 2011<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>:<br />

The sleeping<br />

giant<br />

Features<br />

Reviving lost<br />

trade<br />

Asset<br />

management in<br />

South <strong>Africa</strong><br />

Banking on<br />

microfinance<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>n<br />

emergence


EDITOR’S NOTE<br />

Supplements<br />

Editor<br />

Associate Editor<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> Investor<br />

Editor<br />

Features Editor &<br />

Copy Editor<br />

Senior Publishing<br />

Manager<br />

Copy Editor<br />

Senior Reporter<br />

Journalists<br />

Production<br />

Manager<br />

Production<br />

Editors<br />

Senior Production<br />

Designers<br />

Business<br />

Development<br />

Managers<br />

Subscriptions<br />

Director<br />

Subscription<br />

Executive<br />

Subscriptions<br />

Sponsorship Sales<br />

Manager<br />

Nazneen Halim<br />

Nazneen.Halim@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Scott Weber<br />

Scott.Weber@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Raphael Wong<br />

Raphael.Wong@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Lauren Mcaughtry<br />

Lauren.Mcaughtry@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Sasikala Thiagaraja<br />

Sasikala@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Roshan Kaur Sandhu<br />

Roshan.Kaur@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Ellina Badri<br />

Ellina.Badri@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Lai Pei Yee<br />

Peiyee.Lai@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Siew Han Liang<br />

Han.Siew@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Hasnani Aspari<br />

Hasnani.Aspari@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Norzabidi Abdullah<br />

Zabidi.Abdullah@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Mohd Hanif Mat Nor<br />

Hanif.Nor@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Mohd Hair Kadir<br />

Hair.Kadir@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Mohamad Rozman Besiri<br />

Rozman.Besiri@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

June Abu Zaid<br />

June.Abuzaid@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 56<br />

Rizal Halim Dahlan<br />

Rizal.Dahlan@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 13<br />

Andrew Cheng<br />

Andrew.Cheng@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 55<br />

Musfaizal Mustafa<br />

Musfaizal.Mustafa@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 24<br />

Sivaranjani Sukumaran<br />

Sivaranjani .Sukumaran@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 41<br />

Logeswaran Kuladevan<br />

Logeswaran.Kuladevan@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Tel: +603 2162 7800 x 64<br />

The beast stirs<br />

It is impossible to describe the contrasts and complexities of the <strong>Africa</strong>n political,<br />

economic and social situation within the constraints of these pages. The<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>n continent has long remained an underachiever in terms of its economic<br />

potential, and years of constant fi ghting and perhaps to some degree neglect,<br />

has ravaged its people. However, as the world turns, so do peoples’ perception,<br />

and these days <strong>Africa</strong> is seen as a diamond in the rough, with growing optimism<br />

surrounding its fi scal and political future.<br />

Recent political upheavals, mostly in the North; affecting Egypt, Tunisia, Libya<br />

and Sudan, could work both ways in affecting international interest in the<br />

continent’s investment landscape, and for now economic pundits choose to be<br />

positive about its growth prospects. <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance players have also begun<br />

to turn their attention towards <strong>Africa</strong>, seeing the vast potential in areas such as<br />

microfi nance and trade fi nance.<br />

Long-term involvement and backing from ‘AAA’-rated fi nancial institutions<br />

such as the <strong>Islamic</strong> Development Bank (IDB) via the Special Program for the<br />

Development of <strong>Africa</strong> (SPDA), in which the IDB has committed US$4 billion,<br />

are expected to elevate the continent’s social and economic standing and are<br />

aimed at providing a platform to boost its growth.<br />

At the recent SPDA meeting, the IDB vice president of operations, Birama<br />

Boubacar Sidibe, highlighted the significant positive elements seen across<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>: including strong economic growth, rapid progress of the Millennium<br />

Development Goals leading to a drop in poverty across many <strong>Africa</strong>n countries,<br />

increased investments in the private sector, and a high return on investments;<br />

as well as providing a robust climate for market-oriented, pro-poor reforms<br />

which has led to prudent economic policies. “The IDB has acknowledged that<br />

the situation in <strong>Africa</strong> is not what we had envisioned, the urgent need to provide<br />

much needed resources and the participation of the member countries to help<br />

sustain and further develop the growth of the <strong>Africa</strong>n continent is a major factor<br />

for us and we are here to discuss ways to bolster our relationships and share<br />

knowledge and ideas,” he stated.<br />

In this issue of IFN Supplements, we traverse the vast continent of <strong>Africa</strong> and<br />

explore the opportunities that lie ahead for <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance in the region. From<br />

Takaful to investment prospects and regulatory updates, we endeavor to reveal<br />

industry perception towards the region. Indeed, many see <strong>Africa</strong> as the next<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance haven, considering the growing saturation of the GCC and<br />

Asian markets, and a general lackluster response in North America and Europe,<br />

excluding the UK. <strong>Africa</strong>, they suggest, is the sleeping giant which when awoken<br />

could allow the <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance industry to achieve its full potential.<br />

Financial<br />

Controller<br />

Faizah Hassan<br />

Faizah.Hassan@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Deputy Publisher<br />

& Director<br />

Managing Director<br />

Managing Director<br />

& Publisher<br />

Geraldine Chan<br />

Geraldine.Chan@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Andrew Tebbutt<br />

Andrew.Tebbutt@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Andrew Morgan<br />

Andrew.Morgan@REDmoneyGroup.com<br />

Nazneen Halim,<br />

Editor<br />

Published By:<br />

21/F, Menara Park, 12, Jalan Yap Kwan Seng<br />

50450 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia<br />

Tel: +603 2162 7800<br />

Fax: +603 2162 7810<br />

www.<strong>Islamic</strong><strong>Finance</strong><strong>News</strong>.com<br />

DISCLAIMER<br />

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, duplicated or copied<br />

by any means without the prior consent of the holder of the copyright, requests for which<br />

should be addressed to the publisher. While every care is taken in the preparation of this<br />

publication, no responsibility can be accepted for any errors, however caused.<br />

August 2011<br />

1


CONTENTS<br />

TS<br />

COVER STORY<br />

4 The sleeping giant<br />

Development, trade, labor movement, and an influx<br />

of investors are quickly boosting the resource-rich<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>n economy. How high is <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance on the<br />

agenda of banks and fi nancial institutions alike and<br />

what are the prospects for this sector?<br />

FEATURES<br />

8 Reviving lost trade<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>, a thriving trade destination for the Middle<br />

East, Europe, India and China up until the 19 th<br />

century, is once more on the brink of a trade fl urry<br />

after decades of dormancy.<br />

10 Banking on microfinance<br />

At present, over 410 million people in sub-Saharan<br />

<strong>Africa</strong> are living below the poverty line. Could<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance be the panacea for millions of<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>’s poor?<br />

11 Asset management in South <strong>Africa</strong><br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance has seen exponential growth in<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>, particularly in the North <strong>Africa</strong>n region, and<br />

of late to the west and east of <strong>Africa</strong> as well. <strong>Africa</strong><br />

is home to about 412 million Muslims with a high<br />

concentration focused in the regions mentioned<br />

above.<br />

13 <strong>Africa</strong>n emergence<br />

The <strong>Africa</strong>n Takaful market is gearing itself up as<br />

an important future market in the Takaful arena.<br />

SCOTT WEBER turns his gaze towards the latest<br />

incumbents in what is proving to be Takaful’s next<br />

frontier.<br />

We’re not just a weekly but also a daily news provider<br />

Register now for RSS feeds on<br />

www.islamicfinancenews.com<br />

2 August 2011


COVER STORY<br />

The sleeping giant<br />

Development, trade, labor movement, and an influx of investors are<br />

quickly boosting the resource-rich <strong>Africa</strong>n economy. How high is<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> finance on the agenda of banks and financial institutions alike<br />

and what are the prospects for this sector? NAZNEEN HALIM explores.<br />

The birthplace of modern man, <strong>Africa</strong> has long remained an<br />

exotic and untamed enigma. However these days, it is not<br />

adventurous explorers who are interested in mapping this<br />

rich and diverse continent; but investors, keen to explore the<br />

untapped fi scal potential of the resource-rich, second most<br />

populous continent in the world.<br />

Decades of civil unrest, tribal clashes, and political and economic<br />

turmoil has left <strong>Africa</strong> muddled in a morass of troubles. Despite<br />

being home to the world’s most desirable commodities and<br />

natural resources such as diamonds, iron, gold and of course<br />

oil, <strong>Africa</strong> has not been able to free itself from the shackles of<br />

poverty and remains stuck in the rut of economic stagnation.<br />

However, things are expected to turn around for this continent<br />

of 1 billion people. Economic pundits are ready to place their<br />

bets on this emerging market, and investors are ready to<br />

venture into uncharted territory.<br />

Over the last 10 years, trade between <strong>Africa</strong>n countries and<br />

the rest of the world has grown signifi cantly; charting a 170%<br />

increase in trade with the GCC, and 45% growth with China and<br />

India; the world’s fastest growing economies. Chinese investors<br />

have expressed much interest in <strong>Africa</strong>, and are already<br />

heavily invested in manufacturing and infrastructure projects in<br />

countries such as Sudan and Ghana. In places such as Ethiopia<br />

and Ghana, over 60% of Chinese investments in the countries<br />

constitute manufacturing. And the Chinese government is<br />

keen to see these numbers grow. China’s push for industrial<br />

restructuring domestically has created opportunities in <strong>Africa</strong>,<br />

and the government, seeing this opportunity, has created<br />

measures aimed at facilitating access to credit and simplifying<br />

procedures for Chinese fi rms looking to invest overseas.<br />

And with China keeping ahead of the global economic trend<br />

these days, other countries are likely to follow suit. This is also<br />

4 August 2011


COVER STORY<br />

expected of the GCC, who have had a trade history with <strong>Africa</strong>,<br />

which has recently been strengthened by the involvement of<br />

the Saudi-based <strong>Islamic</strong> Development Bank’s efforts to aid its<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>n member countries, and growing interest from Middle<br />

East investors looking to diversify their investments. Afaq<br />

Khan, CEO of Standard Chartered Saadiq, is confi dent of the<br />

resurrection of trade ties between the Middle East and <strong>Africa</strong>:<br />

“The Middle East already has historical trade links with <strong>Africa</strong><br />

due to geographical proximity. They have done business with<br />

each other for decades, so it is natural for them to go to <strong>Africa</strong>.<br />

It is a question of how easy and attractive it will be for foreign<br />

investors to do business there.”<br />

Strengthening trade ties with the GCC, a growing Muslim<br />

population, the need to fi nance large-scale infrastructure<br />

and manufacturing projects, as well as a large unbanked<br />

population, all provide a robust platform for the introduction of<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> banking to <strong>Africa</strong>.<br />

The Middle East has done<br />

business with <strong>Africa</strong> for<br />

decades, so it is natural for them<br />

to go there. It is a question of how<br />

easy and attractive it will be for<br />

foreign investors to do<br />

business<br />

Status Quo<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> banking has its roots in Egypt, one of <strong>Africa</strong>’s most<br />

affl uent Arab countries. Having pioneered modern <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

banking in the 1960s, Egypt’s <strong>Islamic</strong> banking sector has not<br />

had the chance to reach its fullest potential due to political<br />

intervention and a general air of scepticism surrounding the<br />

industry. Nevertheless, the country is already home to major<br />

players such as Faisal <strong>Islamic</strong> Bank and Al Baraka Egypt<br />

Bank, as well as Abu Dhabi <strong>Islamic</strong> Bank (ADIB), which took<br />

the acquisition route to gain a foothold in Egypt, via its 51%<br />

acquisition of the National Development Bank of Egypt (NBD).<br />

Despite the country’s relatively slow progress in the sector and<br />

an uncertain market sentiment due to recent political upheavals,<br />

the Egypt-based unit of ADIB reported positive growth for the<br />

first quarter of 2011 for its <strong>Islamic</strong> banking business; charting a<br />

growth rate of 13.72% amounting to EGP2.61 billion (US$439.18<br />

million). However, the bank saw a 14.9% decline in total assets at<br />

EGP10.21 billion (US$1.71 billion) as at March 2011. Despite its<br />

significant overall losses, the bank is optimistic about growing its<br />

retail customer base and high-end banking products to attract new<br />

consumer segments within the Egyptian market.<br />

Other North <strong>Africa</strong>n countries such as Sudan are also seasoned<br />

players in <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance, with the country’s major <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

banking players such as the <strong>Islamic</strong> Bank of Khartoum looking<br />

to expand its customer base to East <strong>Africa</strong> in the medium-term,<br />

beginning with Kenya. The <strong>Islamic</strong> Bank of Khartoum was<br />

privatized in 2002, and is now 60% owned by Dubai <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

Bank. However, on the Sukuk front, Sudan has not fared too<br />

well, with its recent Sukuk sale in February being severely<br />

undersubscribed at SDG600 million (US$224.5 million) despite<br />

being a SDG863 million (US$323.03 million) issue. The Sukuk,<br />

issued by the government of Sudan and backed by its stake in<br />

the Khartoum Refinery Company (a joint venture with China<br />

National Petroleum Corporation), saw a 12.5% buy in by<br />

overseas investors.<br />

However, determined to bounce back from last year’s Sukuk<br />

disappointment, the country is due to issue a total of SDG3.6<br />

billion (US$1.34 billion) in Sukuk this year, beginning with a<br />

SDG765 million (US$286.35 million) issuance in September.<br />

According to industry players, demand for Sukuk in Sudan has<br />

increased since its failure to launch in February this year and<br />

is primarily from fi rms and banks. The Sukuk are expected to<br />

yield a 15% return; 3-5% higher than traditionally afforded by<br />

GCC banks.<br />

The country, which recently saw a separation between the<br />

Muslim-majority north and Christian-dominated south, currently<br />

relies heavily on the domestic debt market after being snubbed<br />

by international markets due to US-imposed sanctions.<br />

However, the growing number of Arab Banks in North Sudan,<br />

such as Qatar National Bank and Faisal <strong>Islamic</strong> Bank, bodes<br />

well for its <strong>Islamic</strong> banking sector, and is expected to revive the<br />

country’s struggling economy.<br />

Morocco also began introducing <strong>Islamic</strong> banking products in<br />

2007 under the “Alternative Financial Products” banner. The<br />

move, which was initiated by the Moroccan Central Bank,<br />

allows certain types of <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nancial products, and is said to<br />

be in response to growing consumer demand.<br />

Non-Arab dominated countries in the sub-Saharan <strong>Africa</strong> are<br />

also beginning to see the flourishing of the <strong>Islamic</strong> banking and<br />

finance sector, with countries such as Kenya, Tanzania, Uganda<br />

and Nigeria ramping up their <strong>Islamic</strong> banking efforts with the<br />

introduction of interest-free banking laws in Nigeria, a significant<br />

growth in <strong>Islamic</strong> banking and Takaful institutions in Kenya, a<br />

growing consumer demand for Shariah compliant products<br />

in Tanzania, as well as Uganda’s recent pledge to set up its<br />

first <strong>Islamic</strong> bank. Amar Meher, a senior associate at law firm<br />

Vinson & Elkins, is optimistic on the growth of these jurisdictions:<br />

“Countries such as Kenya, Nigeria, Egypt and South <strong>Africa</strong> are<br />

visibly increasing their commitment to growing their respective<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> banking and investment space, and are starting to see<br />

an influx of investments from Asia including the Middle East.”<br />

Kenya began introducing <strong>Islamic</strong> banking in 2008 with the<br />

establishment of Kenya Commercial Bank’s Amana <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

arm. The subsequent establishment of Gulf <strong>Africa</strong>n Bank also<br />

proved successful, contributing 1% to the banking sector’s<br />

net assets. Since then, fi ve other conventional banks have<br />

begun introducing <strong>Islamic</strong> banking products in the country. The<br />

amendment to the Banking Act by the Central Bank of Kenya<br />

in May 2010 is expected to further boost the country’s <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

banking industry.<br />

August 2011 5


COVER STORY<br />

Khan is confi dent of the growth potential in sub-Saharan <strong>Africa</strong>:<br />

“I believe the potential is great, due to its large population,<br />

growing economies and improved regulations. The <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

banking industry is also looking for new markets, so everything<br />

is aligning well. Countries such as Nigeria and Tanzania have<br />

expressed much interest, with Nigeria recently incorporating<br />

the Non-interest Banking Law, and Uganda announcing plans<br />

to set up an <strong>Islamic</strong> bank. There are all these things happening<br />

across the board, so I think there is a good opportunity. <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

investors are looking for new growth markets, and as the<br />

regulations come in place I see great potential.”<br />

Amman Muhammad, the managing director of Absa <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

Bank in South <strong>Africa</strong>, believes that the sub-Saharan economies<br />

provide a perfect petri dish for the induction of <strong>Islamic</strong> banking,<br />

mainly due to the sheer volume of Muslims: “Countries in west<br />

<strong>Africa</strong> such as Gambia, Guinea, Mauritania, Niger and Senegal<br />

all have Muslim populations above 90%, and in East <strong>Africa</strong><br />

[countries] such as Comores, Djibouti and Somalia have similar<br />

numbers. The countries in <strong>Africa</strong> that will fare best are naturally<br />

those with the largest Muslim populations or those with the most<br />

affl uent Muslim populations. In all North <strong>Africa</strong>n countries the<br />

Muslim population is above 90%, with the exception of Sudan<br />

at 70%. In South <strong>Africa</strong>, although the Muslim population is only<br />

2%, the level of affl uence of this population makes <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

banking a viable proposition.<br />

“In 2010, the economic growth rates of the Central <strong>Africa</strong><br />

Republic, Botswana and Nigeria were well above 8%, with<br />

Zambia and Mozambique above 7%,” he added.<br />

South <strong>Africa</strong>, one of the most affl uent <strong>Africa</strong>n states, has<br />

a Muslim population of 1.3 million, making up 2.4% of the<br />

population. Despite this, the country remains a strong contender<br />

in the sector, and is keen on achieving hub status. Fifty eight<br />

percent of the country’s Muslim population currently subscribes<br />

to conventional banking, and the sector is ready to tap into this<br />

market via an increase in education and awareness to gain<br />

access to high net-worth accounts. Muhammad revealed: “Both<br />

South <strong>Africa</strong> and Nigeria are keen to become hubs for <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

banking on the continent and are fast-tracking amendments to<br />

conventional fi nancial legislation. The consistent high growth of<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> banking in South <strong>Africa</strong> is an indicator of the potential<br />

for <strong>Islamic</strong> banking growth on the continent.”<br />

Risky Business?<br />

“There is always a country risk that you have to take into<br />

consideration; and it is more substantial in that part of the<br />

world. However, it still depends on the governments in question<br />

and how they will play it. Political risk is defi nitely something<br />

you would have to take into consideration, but it may work<br />

both ways; could be for or against the industry in that area.<br />

For instance, what impact would the change in regime have in<br />

Egypt; would they be for or against it?” said Meher.<br />

He added: “This mainly depends on the demographic of the<br />

country in question. For example, would <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance have<br />

a higher success rate in a country like Zimbabwe instead of<br />

Nigeria? It would be natural to say that Nigeria would have<br />

a higher success rate, because they have a larger Muslim<br />

population and have always demonstrated an intention to<br />

introduce <strong>Islamic</strong> banking. Whereas Zimbabwe is obviously a<br />

Christian/Catholic-driven society, which may not necessarily<br />

entertain it as the Nigerians would. So the demographic there<br />

is different.”<br />

Sudan, for instance, has seen its economy suffer from political<br />

turmoil; with foreign investors shying away from the country’s<br />

economy despite its vast potential. Sukuk sales have previously<br />

been withdrawn, with issuers citing political uncertainty as one of<br />

the main reasons. A lack of ratings and investment grade papers<br />

have also created cause for scepticism within the international<br />

investment community. Prior to the separation, industry players<br />

expressed trepidation regarding the Sudanese economy due<br />

to its low level of transparency and diffi culty in gaining reliable<br />

and useful information to assess the macroeconomic, and the<br />

external and public debt situation.<br />

Moving Forward<br />

The sectors expected to thrive in <strong>Africa</strong>’s vast and diverse<br />

economy include <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nancing, trade and project<br />

fi nancing and capital market issuances as well as agricultural<br />

investments.<br />

“An estimated 45-50% of the <strong>Africa</strong>n population are Muslim,<br />

standing between 400 and 500 million people. As a faithbased<br />

offering, <strong>Islamic</strong> banking has the potential to appeal<br />

to those who are currently unbanked and to those who are<br />

under-banked, which is due to a variety of reasons. The key<br />

reason being an aversion to conventional banking and only in<br />

certain circumstances taking up conventional banking products<br />

because of the lack of suitable compliant alternatives. There<br />

are also many affl uent Muslim traders, which means that<br />

potential <strong>Islamic</strong> banking customers fall into low, middle and<br />

6 August 2011


COVER STORY<br />

high income bands. <strong>Islamic</strong> banking in <strong>Africa</strong> has enormous<br />

potential to increase the percentage of <strong>Africa</strong>ns participating in<br />

the formal banking system,” said Muhammad.<br />

“There is enormous potential in the areas of infrastructure<br />

development and in manufacturing. <strong>Africa</strong> has an estimated<br />

300 million hectares of arable land, only a fraction of which is<br />

currently being used for farming. Mineral resources continue<br />

to play an important economic role and some <strong>Africa</strong>n countries<br />

also have rich untapped oil resources. Our experience in<br />

Tanzania also shows us that Muslim customers respond well to<br />

an offering that speaks to their faith. There is generally a high<br />

demand for microfi nancing products so this would be a popular<br />

offering, provided that suitable Shariah compliant structures<br />

are utilized to deliver this type of funding,” he added.<br />

Meher concurs, stating: “The potential for microfi nance has<br />

a signifi cant role in <strong>Africa</strong> - particularly in <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance.<br />

Two big areas for me are sovereign Sukuk issuances and<br />

the development of more socially conscious investments;<br />

particularly microfi nance in <strong>Africa</strong>. I do not see much potential<br />

in lending with commodity Murabahah and Ijarah, but sovereign<br />

Sukuk issuances, microfi nance and trade fi nance are defi nitely<br />

a strong growth area in that part of the world.”<br />

The country, which recently<br />

saw a separation between<br />

the Muslim-majority north and<br />

Christian-dominated south,<br />

currently relies heavily on the<br />

domestic debt market after being<br />

snubbed by international<br />

markets<br />

Khan is also confi dent of the corporate banking prospects<br />

<strong>Africa</strong> has to offer: “I think it will start with corporate banking;<br />

driven by trade fi nance. Once there is critical mass and enough<br />

product education, the likes of Kenya, Tanzania, and Nigeria<br />

will look to the retail market. It will start traditionally; similar to<br />

Malaysia and Indonesia, and will follow the same pattern. First<br />

trade, then retail, then capital markets.<br />

“Some countries in <strong>Africa</strong> have pledged to issue Sukuk in<br />

the short to medium-term, but a sovereign Sukuk issuance is<br />

different to having a Sukuk market. The market will take time to<br />

develop, but a strong statement of support by any sovereign is<br />

a positive sign, and shows that the lawmakers and government<br />

are serious about <strong>Islamic</strong> banking. The local currency Sukuk<br />

market will develop based on the conventional local capital<br />

market. Without a local currency capital market, it is diffi cult<br />

to develop a local currency Sukuk market. You need capital<br />

market people and investors who can understand the risks, as<br />

well as proper systems put in place; all these elements have<br />

to exist.”<br />

In terms of regulatory and tax updates, <strong>Africa</strong>n countries seem<br />

to be on the right track with some nations such as Nigeria<br />

making serious commitments by incorporating non-interest<br />

banking into its fi nancial system. However, as demonstrated in<br />

many jurisdictions across the globe, desire itself is not suffi cient<br />

in guaranteeing the success of a country’s <strong>Islamic</strong> capital<br />

market. “Similar to other jurisdictions, these jurisdictions would<br />

have to consider the regulatory hurdles unique to the countries<br />

and whether or not [they are] willing to overcome those hurdles.<br />

So… if they have expressed an intention and desire, like<br />

most other countries, are they willing to make the necessary<br />

changes to facilitate the industry? And each of these will be<br />

bespoke to the country in question. From my understanding,<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>n countries all share similar legal systems, but they will<br />

defi nitely have to revisit those and see whether or not [<strong>Islamic</strong><br />

banking] works from their country’s perspective,” said Meher.<br />

Double-digit growth<br />

“Muslim customers in <strong>Africa</strong> have shown a strong preference<br />

for the <strong>Islamic</strong> brand, even paying a premium for the products<br />

offered by <strong>Islamic</strong> banks. The regional industry has shown<br />

double-digit growth rates although from a relatively low absolute<br />

base,” said Khalid Howladar, the head of <strong>Islamic</strong> Financial<br />

Institutions at Moody’s.<br />

Meher is excited about <strong>Africa</strong>’s potential contribution to the<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance industry as a whole: “<strong>Africa</strong> is a sleeping giant,<br />

in the sense that people have always looked to the GCC and<br />

Asia for development, and there was a period when people<br />

were looking at North America and Europe, but for some<br />

reason, people have overlooked <strong>Africa</strong> where the potential<br />

in the immediate-term is enormous. <strong>Africa</strong> has the right<br />

ingredients; <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance offers the right product areas, and<br />

it is just dependent on the countries in question whether or not<br />

they decide to develop the industry, which involves revisiting<br />

the legal and regulatory regimes and introducing <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

institutions. Hopefully <strong>Africa</strong> won’t be one to disappoint. We<br />

as market participants have been watching <strong>Africa</strong> very closely;<br />

particularly those based in the GCC, due to geographical<br />

proximity.”<br />

Khan also affi rmed that the <strong>Islamic</strong> banking community is keen<br />

on the continent: “<strong>Islamic</strong> investors are on the lookout for new<br />

markets, growth markets, diversifi cation, and good returns from<br />

capital investments. The <strong>Islamic</strong> industry generally prefers to<br />

make investments and understand the relationship and credit,<br />

as opposed to investing based on ratings. The primary focus<br />

of the bank is the business model and understanding the<br />

management team in order to do business.”<br />

With proper regulations, increased transparency, education,<br />

and an objective, non-political perspective of the Shariah<br />

compliant sector, <strong>Islamic</strong> banking in <strong>Africa</strong> has the potential<br />

to thrive. Increased interest from Gulf investors in terms of<br />

agricultural land acquisitions and the mergers and acquisitions<br />

of fi nancial institutions, as well as a growing Asian investor base,<br />

particularly in manufacturing and project fi nance, is expected to<br />

grow the <strong>Africa</strong>n economy signifi cantly. As it stands, <strong>Africa</strong> has<br />

everything to gain and nothing to lose by growing its <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

banking sector.<br />

August 2011 7


FEATURE<br />

Reviving lost trade<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>, a thriving trade destination for the Middle East, Europe, India<br />

and China up until the 19 th century, is once more on the brink of a<br />

trade flurry after decades of dormancy. NAZNEEN HALIM examines the<br />

prospects for <strong>Islamic</strong> trade and project financing in the continent, and<br />

the initiatives already in place.<br />

To date, the <strong>Islamic</strong> Development Bank (IDB) has provided up<br />

to US$6 billion in fi nancing to <strong>Africa</strong>; out of which US$4.3 billion<br />

was allocated to fi nance development projects and US$1.7<br />

billion to fund trade. The IDB has recently reiterated its pledge<br />

to aid in the development of the <strong>Africa</strong>n economy, in particular<br />

its member countries, and is actively encouraging trade and<br />

project fi nance activities, especially in the agricultural sector.<br />

Industry players are also optimistic about the future of these<br />

two sectors in <strong>Africa</strong>, considering positive growth patterns and<br />

a signifi cant increase in bilateral trade between <strong>Africa</strong> and<br />

emerging economies; particularly China and India. Between<br />

2000 and 2009 <strong>Africa</strong>’s trade with the GCC grew by 170%,<br />

whilst bilateral trade with China reached US$115 billion in 2010<br />

and trade with India saw a 45.5% increase to US$13.8 billion<br />

in 2009.<br />

Set against the cacophonous background of the <strong>Africa</strong>n<br />

socioeconomic landscape, <strong>Islamic</strong> trade and project fi nancing<br />

are expected to thrive; capitalizing on untapped opportunities<br />

in construction and infrastructure development including roads,<br />

highways, and power plants, as well as manufacturing. Backed<br />

by the IDB, trade fi nancing in <strong>Africa</strong> is also expected to kick off<br />

as trade between OIC member <strong>Africa</strong>n countries increases and<br />

more trade programs and corridors are developed.<br />

Amman Muhammad, the managing director of Absa <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

Bank in South <strong>Africa</strong>, believes that the growth opportunities in<br />

8 August 2011


FEATURE<br />

these sectors are promising: “Based on the attention that <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

project and trade fi nance are currently receiving the prospects<br />

are exciting, provided the appropriate vehicles are available<br />

to support this development. There is enormous potential in<br />

the areas of infrastructure development and in manufacturing.<br />

<strong>Africa</strong> has an estimated 300 million hectares of arable land,<br />

and only a fraction is currently being used for farming. Mineral<br />

resources continue to play an important economic role, and<br />

some <strong>Africa</strong>n countries also have rich untapped oil resources.<br />

The <strong>Islamic</strong> Development Bank also aims to make agriculture<br />

one of its main areas of focus in <strong>Africa</strong>, stating: “Considering<br />

that poverty in the majority of member countries is a rural<br />

phenomenon, investment in the agricultural sector, which the<br />

bulk of the population depends on for its livelihood, is an obvious<br />

target for any poverty reduction program. It is imperative that<br />

the Bank’s assistance in agriculture is targeted in high valueadded<br />

sub-sectors such as agro-processing, irrigation and<br />

crop development, marketing and storage facilities, as well as<br />

micro-credit schemes.<br />

The sheer size and volume<br />

of the continent affords<br />

abundant opportunities to<br />

investors<br />

Agro-processing is one area that has a high value-addition,<br />

especially in <strong>Africa</strong>, and therefore will have a greater impact on<br />

improving the living conditions of the most vulnerable groups<br />

in society.”<br />

Amar Meher, senior associate at Vinson & Elkins, also believes<br />

that the agricultural sector in <strong>Africa</strong> will grow as demand for<br />

arable land increases among GCC investors: “At the moment,<br />

GCC investors are most interested in acquiring agricultural<br />

land for growing fruits and vegetables to bring back to their<br />

respective home countries; mostly on a micro-level. GCC<br />

investors look to <strong>Africa</strong> with the view of managing infl ation<br />

through the acquisition of agricultural land. Crop prices have<br />

gone up, whilst supply has decreased, and it becomes quite<br />

hard to manage as a supplier, because your production costs<br />

have gone up. There is also the issue of managing the price<br />

caps that have been imposed by GCC countries during certain<br />

periods in a year. The acquisition of agricultural land in <strong>Africa</strong><br />

allows them to manage infl ation on a micro-level.”<br />

Affi liates of the IDB, such as the <strong>Islamic</strong> Corporation for the<br />

Development of the Private Sector (ICD), are also actively<br />

increasing their focus on <strong>Africa</strong>. Khaled Al-Aboodi, CEO of ICD,<br />

revealed: “At present our businesses are mainly in the Middle<br />

East and North <strong>Africa</strong> region. We want to move to sub-Saharan<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>, East Asia and Central Asia.” Among the ICD’s plans<br />

for sub-Saharan <strong>Africa</strong> are schemes to set up non-banking<br />

fi nancial institutions to fi nance projects as well as support the<br />

housing sector, and establish special economic zones. “We<br />

also want to prepare projects to be bankable,” he added. The<br />

ICD has spent more than US$1.6 billion on various projects<br />

and helped mobilize funds from other fi nanciers for projects<br />

worth US$5 billion.<br />

Tunisia, which has been elected as a representing board<br />

member of the IDB’s North <strong>Africa</strong> Group for the 2011-2014<br />

period, is also expected to gain from its affi liation with the IDB;<br />

having recently received two fi nancing facilities worth TND50<br />

million (US$36 million) and TND30 million (US$21.62 million)<br />

for the fi nancing of integrated agricultural development projects<br />

and to support the Tunisian Solidarity Bank’s micro-credit<br />

program.<br />

With the implementation of proper regulations and the creation<br />

of a level playing fi eld for tax, industry players are confi dent<br />

of the growth of the continent’s <strong>Islamic</strong> project and trade<br />

fi nancing sectors, as well as an infl ux of <strong>Islamic</strong> investors;<br />

particularly from the GCC. The sheer size and volume of the<br />

continent affords abundant opportunities to investors, whilst its<br />

people have much to gain from infrastructure and development<br />

projects.<br />

9 August 2011


FEATURE<br />

Banking on microfinance<br />

At present, over 410 million people in sub-Saharan <strong>Africa</strong> are living<br />

below the poverty line. Could <strong>Islamic</strong> microfinance be the panacea for<br />

millions of <strong>Africa</strong>’s poor? NAZNEEN HALIM explores.<br />

According to the Multidimensional Poverty Index, produced<br />

by the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) and the<br />

Oxford Poverty & Human Development Initiative, 24 out of the<br />

25 poorest countries in the world are located in <strong>Africa</strong>. The<br />

continent’s fragile socio-economic situation, despite seeing<br />

some improvement over the last decade, is still dire.<br />

High on the agenda of the <strong>Islamic</strong> Development Bank (IDB)<br />

and <strong>Islamic</strong> Financial Services Board’s Ten-year Framework<br />

for the development of the <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance industry is poverty<br />

alleviation through <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance, particularly among the<br />

IDB member countries; which at present rank among the lowest<br />

in the UNDP’s Human Development Index for 120 developing<br />

countries. What is needed to move the <strong>Africa</strong>n economy<br />

forward, according to economists, is a substantial increase in<br />

real per capita GDP and improved social conditions.<br />

Industry players believe that <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance could<br />

play a signifi cant role in growing and developing the sub-<br />

Saharan <strong>Africa</strong>n economies due to its low cost and ability<br />

to entice small entrepreneurs and the large unbanked<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>n population to fully participate in the economy. Based<br />

purely on volume, <strong>Africa</strong>’s <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance initiatives<br />

have incredible potential. Benjamin Nkungi, CEO of the<br />

Association of Microfi nance Institutions, stated: “The next big<br />

thing we are likely to see is the establishment of exclusive<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance institutions across sub-Saharan <strong>Africa</strong><br />

as a result of outstanding grassroots demand.” The impact<br />

across <strong>Africa</strong>, he says, is expected to be huge; creating a<br />

signifi cant supply of liquidity based on retail-based deposits<br />

and investments in Shariah compliant deposits and premiums<br />

among corporate and institutional investors.<br />

Power to the people<br />

Microfi nance is not an alien concept to <strong>Africa</strong>, with its main<br />

client base comprising of organized women groups. The most<br />

popular microfi nance model, according to the IDB report, is the<br />

Village Bank model; which involves an implementing agency<br />

that establishes a village bank with around fi fty members, and<br />

provides external capital for onward fi nancing to individual<br />

members. Individual loans are repaid at weekly intervals over<br />

four months, at which time the village bank returns the principal<br />

with interest and profi ts to the implementing agency.<br />

As a village bank accumulates suffi cient capital internally,<br />

it eventually becomes an autonomous and self-sustaining<br />

institution. However, unlike <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance, the interest<br />

rates for conventional microfi nance loans in <strong>Africa</strong> at present<br />

are sky-high; sometimes even touching 20%, and predatory<br />

lenders are plentiful.<br />

Recognizing the potential of microfi nance, the Central Bank of<br />

Sudan in 2010 called for a minimum allocation of 12% of every<br />

bank’s portfolio to microfi nance, and for the establishment<br />

of specialized units to develop the industry. Banks are also<br />

required to submit annual reports to the central bank on their<br />

microfi nance activities, and to create public awareness and<br />

education initiatives.<br />

Based purely on<br />

volume, <strong>Africa</strong>’s <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

microfinance initiatives<br />

have incredible potential<br />

Among the fi rst <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance institutions in sub-Saharan<br />

<strong>Africa</strong> was Azaouad <strong>Finance</strong>s, resulting from a development<br />

project by the German Technical Cooperation and German<br />

Financial Cooperation after the eruption of fi erce confl icts in the<br />

three poorest northern regions of Mali; spanning Timbuktu,Gao<br />

and Kidal, beginning in 1990 and ending in 1995. The aim of<br />

the project was to provide fi nancial services to all the tribes<br />

in Northern Mali, and based on general consensus, it was<br />

decided that an <strong>Islamic</strong> bank would be most appealing to the<br />

areas’ tribes.<br />

Since then, the <strong>Islamic</strong> microfi nance scene in <strong>Africa</strong> has been<br />

rather muted, but a revival is due very soon. Takaful companies<br />

such as Takaful Insurance of <strong>Africa</strong> have begun introducing<br />

microfi nance-linked products such as Takaful micro insurance,<br />

while Kenya’s Equity Bank recently introduced a Shariah<br />

compliant microfi nance lending product in the country. Other<br />

institutions such as Ghana <strong>Islamic</strong> Microfi nance (GIM) aim to<br />

capitalize on the growing demand for microfi nance products<br />

in <strong>Africa</strong>, and will offer Shariah compliant microfi nance<br />

transactions to Muslims and non-Muslims alike. According to<br />

the bank, GIM aims to provide an alternative avenue to loan<br />

seekers outside of the conventional sphere, allowing them to<br />

escape the web of predatory lending.<br />

At present, Shariah compliant microfi nancing products in <strong>Africa</strong><br />

are based on the Wadiah, Mudarabah and Ijarah contracts,<br />

while Bai Bithaman Ajil is a common feature among its debtbased<br />

products. The further development of <strong>Africa</strong>’s tax and<br />

regulatory environments is expected to spur the introduction<br />

of newer and more sophisticated forms of lending, as well as<br />

create a more diverse product range for its currently underserved<br />

poor population.<br />

10 August 2011


FEATURE<br />

Asset management in South <strong>Africa</strong><br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> finance has seen exponential growth in <strong>Africa</strong>, particularly in the<br />

North <strong>Africa</strong>n region, and of late to the west and east of <strong>Africa</strong> as well.<br />

<strong>Africa</strong> is home to about 412 million Muslims with a high concentration<br />

focused in the regions mentioned above. North <strong>Africa</strong> is an obvious<br />

choice for <strong>Islamic</strong> finance due in part to its close proximity to the Middle<br />

Whilst <strong>Islamic</strong> banking is seeing rapid growth in countries such<br />

as Nigeria, Kenya, Uganda and even Tanzania, where half the<br />

population is Muslim, South <strong>Africa</strong> has had two decades of<br />

experience, being one of the fi rst non-Muslim countries in <strong>Africa</strong><br />

to establish <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance.<br />

Constituting only 2% of its total population, South <strong>Africa</strong> has<br />

the smallest number of Muslims on the continent. This did not<br />

prevent Al Baraka Bank from establishing the only fully fl edged<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> bank in South <strong>Africa</strong> in 1989. Subsequently, four other<br />

banks opened <strong>Islamic</strong> windows alongside their conventional<br />

practices.<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> asset management<br />

On the investment front, there are a number of Shariah<br />

investment funds available in the market. Currently, 11<br />

asset management companies in South <strong>Africa</strong> offer Shariah<br />

compliant investment schemes or mutual funds as well as<br />

discretionary and multi-managed portfolios. That makes up a<br />

quarter of the total number of asset management companies<br />

registered under the country’s Financial Services Board (FSB).<br />

The company managing the largest number of <strong>Islamic</strong> funds<br />

is the Oasis Group’s Oasis Asset Management. It is reported<br />

that the Oasis family of funds currently manages 63 Shariah<br />

compliant domestic and offshore funds.<br />

The fi rst <strong>Islamic</strong> fund to be launched in South <strong>Africa</strong> was<br />

the Futuregrowth Albaraka Equity Fund which was initially<br />

managed by Element Investment Managers, formerly Frater<br />

Asset Management, from 2000 to 2005. It was then managed<br />

by Futuregrowth, which has since become a member of the Old<br />

Mutual Investment Group (OMIGSA).<br />

Mogammad Saliegh Salaam, an investment manager at Old<br />

Mutual Investment Group, says there is interest to expand<br />

Shariah compliant investment in South <strong>Africa</strong>, as can be seen<br />

by a number of new asset management companies that have<br />

come into the market to provide various products across the<br />

board.<br />

“Also the product offering has also started to cater for the asset<br />

allocation requirements of Muslim investors. There have been<br />

a number of banks that have come up with <strong>Islamic</strong> windows or<br />

products for high net worth individuals. We have seen one or<br />

two companies offer their products and services for high net<br />

worth individuals,” he says, adding that the majority of mutual<br />

Eurekahedge <strong>Islamic</strong> South <strong>Africa</strong> Fund Index<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

funds that dominate the Shariah landscape in South <strong>Africa</strong> are<br />

for the mass market.<br />

As with the world over, <strong>Islamic</strong> equity funds are also very<br />

popular in South <strong>Africa</strong>. However, Salaam notes that the South<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>n investor is evolving. “Not everybody wants to invest<br />

totally in equity. Even if the markets are not volatile, people<br />

have different profi les, tolerances and preferences.<br />

“It has been an equity-centric environment but as the market<br />

develops clients are becoming more sophisticated and have<br />

different requirements,” he elaborates, before briefl y mentioning<br />

that Old Mutual launched its <strong>Islamic</strong> balanced fund in the fourth<br />

quarter of last year.<br />

Less well known is that South <strong>Africa</strong> is also home to <strong>Africa</strong>’s fi rst<br />

Shariah compliant exchange traded fund (ETF), launched in<br />

2009 by NewFunds, a joint venture between Absa Capital and<br />

Vunani Capital. The Shariah Top 40 Exchange Traded Fund<br />

(ETF) includes Shariah compliant companies that are selected<br />

from the FTSE/JSE Top 40 index listed on the main board of<br />

the Johannesburg Stock Exchange, as measured by market<br />

capitalization.<br />

Reception of <strong>Islamic</strong> Funds<br />

The Eurekahedge <strong>Islamic</strong> South <strong>Africa</strong> Fund Index reveals that<br />

the value of funds has increased by 135.26% in May 2011, up<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

<br />

11 August 2011


FEATURE<br />

Performance of a sample of South <strong>Africa</strong> domiciled funds<br />

As of May 2011 Return<br />

Fund Name Date of inception Return since<br />

Inception<br />

Return since<br />

Mar 2010<br />

2011 Return<br />

YTD<br />

Element <strong>Islamic</strong> Equity Fund February 2006 65.33% 11.23% 1.62%<br />

Futuregrowth Albaraka Equity Fund June 1992 1215.60% 17.41% 2.32%<br />

Kagiso <strong>Islamic</strong> Equity Fund July 2009 52.20% 22.05% 3.46%<br />

Oasis Crescent Balanced High Equity Fund of Funds April 2010 10.99% 10.99% 2.94%<br />

Oasis Crescent Balanced Stable Fund of Funds April 2010 8.90% 8.90% 2.85%<br />

STANLIB Shari’ah Equity Fund A June 2007 -4.66% 10.85% 2.51%<br />

Symmetry <strong>Islamic</strong> Fund December 2005 75.77% 7.16% 2.53%<br />

Source: Eurekahedge<br />

19.47% from a year earlier. Despite the positive performance,<br />

Salaam laments the slow uptake of funds. “It has been a tough<br />

market generally to try to sell any product that has some other<br />

market linkage to it,” he explains.<br />

Institutional investors, he continues, are less receptive to<br />

Shariah compliant solutions. The only instance of the uptake<br />

is termed as ‘member level choice’ – the equivalent to the<br />

US’ 401 plan where employees of a company can choose to<br />

make contributions for their retirement plan. “In South <strong>Africa</strong>,<br />

a number of pension funds have allowed members of that<br />

platform to select Shariah compliant vehicles to invest their<br />

pension savings,” Salaam elucidates.<br />

Ongoing campaigns are being promoted by all the asset<br />

management companies to create further awareness of<br />

Shariah compliant investing, targeting not only Muslim but non-<br />

Muslim investors as well.<br />

has garnered almost no foreign investor interest either from the<br />

Middle East, Asia or Europe. The asset management industry<br />

is no exception with most mergers and acquisitions being<br />

completed only at the domestic level. With the exception of a<br />

small handful of funds that have been marketed globally, the<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> funds are catered to domestic investors.<br />

“We haven’t seen much foreign demand for Shariah compliant<br />

local products. It is conducive for foreign investors to invest but<br />

we just have not seen any major foreign interest.”<br />

As the excitement to develop <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance in the western<br />

and eastern regions of <strong>Africa</strong> continues to build, it would do<br />

South <strong>Africa</strong> some good to lure some of the attraction in its own<br />

direction. It is well positioned to promote the industry, with good<br />

structures in the areas of regulation, legislation, governance and<br />

compliance as well as a sturdy risk management framework.<br />

The other challenge faced by companies managing <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

funds is the lack of investment tools available. Salaam says:<br />

“We need a lot more products from the various investment<br />

banks. They need to provide us a lot more Shariah compliant<br />

products or avenues in which to deploy our cash. That is<br />

probably by far the biggest challenge.”<br />

Investment banks dealing with these asset management<br />

companies are normally faced with the issue of Shariah<br />

compliance. “The products that they come up with may not<br />

necessarily satisfy our Shariah board. We need to make sure<br />

that all the products satisfy our Shariah boards.”<br />

In its bid to promote and maintain a sound fi nancial investment<br />

environment in South <strong>Africa</strong>, the FSB has recently introduced<br />

several exemptions for <strong>Islamic</strong> funds. Notice 1503 of 2005,<br />

which was published in the terms of the Collective Investment<br />

Schemes Control Act of 2002, now allows managers of a<br />

Shariah compliant fund to invest up to 50% of the market value<br />

of total assets in a particular portfolio, from the previous 10%<br />

limitation.<br />

The exemption applied on the 1 st July 2011 until the 31 st May<br />

2013.<br />

Despite coming a long way with <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance, South <strong>Africa</strong><br />

12 August 2011


FEATURE<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>n emergence<br />

The <strong>Africa</strong>n Takaful market is gearing itself up as an important future<br />

market in the Takaful arena. SCOTT WEBER turns his gaze towards the<br />

latest incumbents in what is proving to be Takaful’s next frontier.<br />

<strong>Africa</strong> is a new market for Takaful operations, and many<br />

countries with Muslim majority populations and developed<br />

banking sectors are looking at the alternative industry to<br />

diversify their operations and hopefully attract a new, previously<br />

untapped customer base. This growth potential is clearly shown<br />

by the number of new Takaful operators and <strong>Islamic</strong> windows<br />

sprouting up across the continent.<br />

Larger reinsurance<br />

companies should take it as<br />

a responsibility to see the rapid<br />

growth of Takaful in third<br />

world countries<br />

Cross-continent rollout<br />

The emergence of Takaful has begun in earnest, with the<br />

Takaful industry looking to replicate its successes in Southeast<br />

Asia and the GCC. Hassan Bashir, CEO at Takaful Insurance of<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>, says that: “There are companies now operating Takaful<br />

models in the north, south, west and east of <strong>Africa</strong>. The <strong>Africa</strong>n<br />

continent offers signifi cant opportunities for the Takaful industry,<br />

particularly because the Takaful model fi ts very well with the<br />

traditional <strong>Africa</strong>n way of life that is fundamentally based on<br />

a self-help, group support social structure.” Bashir goes on to<br />

state that: “If presented well, the Takaful model is…at home<br />

in <strong>Africa</strong> and as a result there is an exciting prospect for the<br />

Takaful industry in <strong>Africa</strong>”.<br />

<strong>Africa</strong> does however remain a relatively isolated market. The<br />

continent as a whole is yet to fully connect with the world<br />

market. According to Bashir: “Markets in other regions must<br />

play a signifi cant role in the development of Takaful in <strong>Africa</strong>.<br />

The Takaful industry in <strong>Africa</strong> will rely on other regions such as<br />

Asia and Arabia for knowledge, training and capital.” However,<br />

as Bashir goes on to say: “Many markets in <strong>Africa</strong> will benefi t<br />

from such partnerships.” <strong>Africa</strong>n start-ups will benefi t from the<br />

expertise of mature fi rms entering from other regions but it is<br />

also heavily reliant on re-Takaful fi rms from other regions for<br />

support and protection.<br />

Issues raised<br />

Issues do continually present themselves in the <strong>Africa</strong>n<br />

market, according to Bashir, and there are numerous <strong>Africa</strong>-<br />

13 August 2011


FEATURE<br />

specifi c limitations to offering Takaful coverage: “First, <strong>Africa</strong>n<br />

markets are largely governed by conventional insurance acts<br />

that have little or no consideration for the needs of a Takaful<br />

model.” This presents challenges in the areas of governance<br />

and investment. Secondly, <strong>Africa</strong>n markets (with the exception<br />

of North <strong>Africa</strong>) lack any form of Shariah compliant capital<br />

market. “This presents signifi cant operational diffi culties in<br />

many markets where conventional insurance acts restrict<br />

investment in foreign markets,” according to Bashir, who<br />

faces this situation in Kenya. Third, is the limitation of Shariah<br />

scholars in corresponding their understanding of business,<br />

fi nance and risk management to the challenges that <strong>Africa</strong><br />

presents. Bashir’s fi nal point is that there still remains a lack<br />

of well-trained human capital and resources to support the fast<br />

emerging <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance sector in <strong>Africa</strong>.<br />

The conventional insurance market in <strong>Africa</strong> has been<br />

somewhat dominated by the larger international players and<br />

Bashir believes that this could happen with the Takaful market.<br />

“In the case of re-Takaful, we have already seen signs of this<br />

with foreign players showing equal interest as local reinsurers.”<br />

In Bashir’s view, Takaful can hardly exist without the <strong>Islamic</strong><br />

banking sector, and the key to this is “the development of a<br />

vibrant <strong>Islamic</strong> capital market.” Without this, “any Takaful<br />

operations will be fundamentally fl awed”.<br />

There are companies now<br />

operating Takaful models<br />

in the North, South, West<br />

and East of <strong>Africa</strong><br />

The Gambian example<br />

Gambia provides a good case study for the issues facing<br />

Takaful operators in the country. Gambia previously had<br />

11 conventional banks, one of which was <strong>Islamic</strong>, and 12<br />

registered insurance companies, none of which were <strong>Islamic</strong>.<br />

That all changed when a taskforce was set up to facilitate the<br />

passing of Takaful regulations in 2005; comprising of members<br />

from the international investment department (Gambia<br />

investment promotion), the chamber of commerce, the central<br />

bank, members of the justice department and fi nanciers.<br />

According to Momodou Joof, the managing director and CEO<br />

at Takaful Gambia: “It took many meetings with all invested<br />

parties explaining to them the economic benefi ts such an<br />

operation could provide,” as the Gambian Takaful regulations,<br />

based on those in Malaysia, would have been blocked by those<br />

in government with a vested interest in the conventional system<br />

as this would have proved a threat to their operations.<br />

Takaful operations in Gambia are still in their infancy having<br />

only been in operation for three years. The current focus is only<br />

on general insurance, but Takaful Gambia has plans to open a<br />

Family Takaful operation when their general insurance operation<br />

breaks even. Joof admits that he is missing a large segment of<br />

the market and that: “The society assistance models offered<br />

through Family Takaful offer a greater opportunity for poverty<br />

alleviation,” and the fl exibility of Family Takaful would offer the<br />

opportunity to come up with unique Shariah specifi c solutions<br />

allowing them to work with SMEs and small businesses.<br />

Joof is personally invested in this project and is looking to take<br />

the Gambian model into West <strong>Africa</strong>. Takaful Gambia is actively<br />

looking at creating a network of Takaful companies in a similar<br />

vein to the pan-<strong>Africa</strong>n Ecobank, which is proving successful in<br />

its own right. “Nothing is stopping Takaful from taking the lead<br />

and jumping into the countries around Gambia,” Joof adds.<br />

There is a signifi cant market in Sudan, which is solely <strong>Islamic</strong>,<br />

and considerable interest is being shown in both Nigeria and<br />

Senegal, who have appointed Egyptian consultants to review<br />

their legislation for the possibility of offering <strong>Islamic</strong> banking<br />

and Takaful and are working hard on supporting its adoption;<br />

having hosted several seminars on the issue and even inviting<br />

the IDB to open a regional <strong>Africa</strong>n offi ce in Dhaka.<br />

Challenges abound<br />

Bureaucracy remains the greatest challenge on the <strong>Africa</strong>n<br />

scene, with networking playing an important role in opening<br />

doors that could otherwise remain reluctant to such proposals.<br />

According to Joof, it will take “the governments to appreciate<br />

what is being achieved in Gambia and either replicating or<br />

consulting with more experienced nations to advise on the<br />

feasibility of gaining operational licenses to operate subsidiaries<br />

in their markets”.<br />

Other challenges that have emerged are in competition<br />

with the conventional market which according to Joof “are<br />

creating a price war, which is not sustainable”. Eventually<br />

the governments are going to have to step in and regulate as<br />

this trend is not benefi cial for the industry to allow unhealthy<br />

competition through pricing.<br />

14 August 2011


FEATURE<br />

Investment is still key to rolling out Takaful, proving that<br />

Takaful is a legitimate and profi table solution. According to<br />

Joof: “The larger reinsurance companies should take it as a<br />

responsibility to see the rapid growth of Takaful in third world<br />

countries and aid such institutions in their capacity building<br />

efforts.” Governmental support is one thing, but getting it right<br />

is important and this can only be achieved with support from<br />

reinsurance companies.<br />

The Takaful model fits very<br />

well with the traditional<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>n way of life that is<br />

fundamentally based on a selfhelp,<br />

group support social<br />

structure<br />

The floodgates open<br />

Numerous Takaful and conventional operators have sought<br />

entry into the lucrative Takaful sector, attracted by its capacity<br />

to open up previously untapped segments of the market.<br />

This is demonstrated by the recent announcement by Kenya<br />

Reinsurance corporation (Kenya Re)’s plan to begin operating<br />

a re-Takaful window to grow its current income and to tap into<br />

the expanding <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nance sector as part of the company’s<br />

fi ve year plan of product diversifi cation.<br />

“The intention is to have a department that fully complies with<br />

all… re-Takaful requirements so that Takaful fi rms are not shy<br />

to give us business,” according to Jadiah Mwarania, chief<br />

executive offi cer of Kenya Re.<br />

By expanding its product offerings to include re-Takaful, Kenya<br />

Re is responding to regional insurance market dynamics<br />

following this year’s launch of Takaful Insurance of <strong>Africa</strong>, a<br />

fully fl edged Shariah compliant insurance company that plans<br />

to expand its operations into Tanzania and Uganda.<br />

Kenya has continually shown its interest towards the<br />

alternative insurance industry with the launch of the fi rst Takaful<br />

company, GulfCap Takaful, followed a short time later by the<br />

establishment of two other new fi rms: FCB Takaful and Takaful<br />

Insurance Agency.<br />

Competitive market<br />

Last year, Kenya Re’s direct competitor <strong>Africa</strong> Re launched its<br />

own re-Takaful subsidiary, <strong>Africa</strong> re-Takaful, in order to tap into<br />

the burgeoning <strong>Africa</strong>n Takaful market. In September 2010,<br />

<strong>Africa</strong> Re launched a subsidiary company based in Egypt<br />

to offer exclusive re-Takaful services while Comesa-owned<br />

reinsurer ZEP-RE, where Kenya Re is also a shareholder, set<br />

up a Sudan-based re-Takaful subsidiary in September 2009.<br />

By entering into the competitive re-Takaful business, Kenya<br />

Re is responding to regional insurance market dynamics.<br />

Insurance companies are racing to launch Shariah compliant<br />

products across the <strong>Africa</strong>n continent in order to tap into the<br />

growing Muslim middle class.<br />

The shift towards re-Takaful will mean more business fl ows into<br />

the company from predominantly Muslim regions like Sudan<br />

and particularly North <strong>Africa</strong>, where Kenya Re is expanding its<br />

presence.<br />

But Kenya Re, like many other operators, will have to reinvest<br />

income from their re-Takaful department outside the country<br />

because Kenya does not currently have the necessary Shariah<br />

compliant capital market products for reinvestment.<br />

Kenya Re currently underwrites business for all 47 insurance<br />

companies in Kenya, which are by law required to cede 18%<br />

of their reinsurance to the company up to 2015. This valuable<br />

revenue stream currently accounts for 40% of Kenya Re’s<br />

gross premium income.<br />

Growth will also be driven by an expected tripling of mortgage<br />

lending, which shot from an annual KES100 million (US$1.1<br />

million) to KES300 million (US$3.3million) as of January 2011.<br />

Despite market prospects, Kenya’s only other Takaful<br />

underwriter, Takaful Insurance of <strong>Africa</strong>, has continually raised<br />

concerns over the inability of Kenya’s capital markets authority<br />

to license Shariah compliant products.<br />

Its re-Takaful focus will also enable Kenya Re to widen its<br />

business partnerships in the West <strong>Africa</strong>n market, where it has<br />

reopened its offi ces after the end of the civil war in Ivory Coast.<br />

There are many obstacles that continue to cause concern for<br />

the budding industry; for instance the lack of qualifi ed Takaful<br />

professionals in the region and the absence of the necessary<br />

Shariah compliant legal framework for investment and Shariah<br />

compliant instruments.<br />

Premium potential<br />

Morgan Stanley has previously stated that Kenyan Takaful<br />

premiums could potentially reach KES20 billion (US$221.73<br />

million) by 2014, or 31% of total insurance premiums.<br />

Barclays Bank was the fi rst fi nancial institution to test the<br />

market with a Shariah compliant product in December 2005,<br />

and since then <strong>Islamic</strong> fi nancial products have exploded with at<br />

least eight commercial banks tapping into the market.<br />

Two <strong>Islamic</strong>-driven banks with roots in the Middle East are Gulf<br />

<strong>Africa</strong>n and First Community. Both banks opened up shop in<br />

2007 and have since moved to the profi t zone, illustrating the<br />

vibrancy of the halal economy in the country.<br />

They are seeking to deepen penetration in a market where<br />

conventional insurance has suffered from consumer apathy<br />

and ignorance, with uptake remaining at below 3% over the<br />

decade.<br />

15 August 2011


Global industry<br />

One publication<br />

Established in 2004, <strong>Islamic</strong> <strong>Finance</strong> news covers all realms<br />

of <strong>Islamic</strong> finance, providing professionals around the globe<br />

with a vehicle to educate and understand the market, the<br />

players, the individuals and perhaps more importantly, the<br />

benefits over, and comparisons with the conventional<br />

banking system.<br />

Published every Wednesday, <strong>Islamic</strong> <strong>Finance</strong> news is the<br />

industry’s leading, e-newsletter providing over 20,000<br />

individuals with unrivaled editorial coverage of the global<br />

<strong>Islamic</strong> financing market.<br />

Request for a complimentary trial subscription by emailing<br />

subs@islamicfinancenews.com or simply call +603 2162 7800.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!