28.02.2014 Views

23_237-252.pdf

23_237-252.pdf

23_237-252.pdf

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Lichenologist <strong>23</strong>(3): <strong>23</strong>7-252 (1991)<br />

MICROCLIMATIC INFLUENCES ON LICHEN<br />

DISTRIBUTION AND COMMUNITY<br />

DEVELOPMENT<br />

K. J. CANTERS*, H. SCHOLLERJ, S. OTT§ and H. M. JAHNS§<br />

Abstract: The distribution of cryptogams and phanerogams and the microclimate<br />

of different habitats have been studied. It is shown that a forest community of<br />

phanerogams includes an assemblage of different microhabitats inhabited by different<br />

lichens and mosses. The distribution of lichens and mosses is governed by factors<br />

that are often of little importance to higher plants.<br />

Introduction<br />

Plant communities dominated by lichens and mosses are less well known than<br />

those consisting mainly of phanerogams. The question whether cryptogams<br />

should be treated together with higher plants in the same associations has often<br />

been discussed. Arguments for a separate classification of cryptogamic<br />

communities are the widely differing minimum areas for mosses, lichens,<br />

herbs, shrub and trees and the entirely different microclimatic conditions for<br />

diese layers of the vegetation (Barkman 1990). However, the whole vegetation<br />

is connected in an ecological respect, which argues for a whole phytocoenosis<br />

system. There is no simple solution to these problems but in this paper an<br />

attempt is made to give some examples of the difficulties encountered in this<br />

area of research. The observations described here will be published in much<br />

more detail in other papers. They are used in this context for a broad and<br />

general discussion of some interesting problems.<br />

Methods<br />

Methods for microclimatic measurements have been described in several papers (Schuster et al.<br />

1982; Jahns & Ott 1983; Jahns & Fritzler 1982; Ott 1989). The details of mapping procedure etc.<br />

will be given in other papers together with a more detailed account of the experiments and results.<br />

For cluster analysis the' Tabord ' programme, developed by van der Maarel et al. (1979) was used.<br />

Results<br />

Plant distribution in a heterogenous forest area<br />

The research area investigated was situated in the valley of the Wisper, a<br />

tributary of the Rhine in the Taunus mountains. This tree-covered rocky spur<br />

of the mountain has one side exposed to the north-east and covered by beech<br />

forest and the other side faces south-west and is covered by open oak forest.<br />

*Centrum voor Milieukunde, Rijksuniversiteit Leiden, Garenmarkt lb, <strong>23</strong>11 PG Leiden, The<br />

Netherlands.<br />

JBotanisches Institut, Universitat Frankfurt, Siesmayerstr. 70, D-6000 Frankfurt, Germany.<br />

§Botanisches Institut, Univeristat Diisseldorf, Universitatsstr. 1, D-4000 Diisseldorf, Germany.<br />

0024-2829/91/030<strong>23</strong>7+ 16 $03.00/0 © 1991 The British Lichen Society


<strong>23</strong>8 THE LICHENOLOGIST Vol. <strong>23</strong><br />

FIG. 1. Vegetation on a tree-covered spur of a mountain with a north-east facing slope (left part) and<br />

a south-west facing slope (right part). Distribution of cluster-groups.<br />

The vegetation was studied by cluster analysis and by principal component<br />

analysis (PCA). Good correlations between the vegetation and the distribution<br />

of abiotic factors such as light and pH were observed.<br />

A cluster analysis of the complete research area showed several groupings<br />

(Fig. 1, A-F) each representing homogeneous vegetation according to the rules<br />

of plant sociology. The principal species in each group, higher plants as well as<br />

lichens and mosses, and their abundance are given in Fig. 2. No lichens were<br />

present (epiphytic lichens were excluded) in the cluster groups A and B from<br />

the north-east facing slope. In group C the first species of Cladonia appear, but<br />

only C.furcata is found with large numbers of thalli. The main occurrence of<br />

Cladonia is in the cluster groups E and F, with a marked increase in Parmelia<br />

conspersa and Polytrichum piliferum in cluster group F. This means that on the<br />

southern-facing slope lichens and mosses could be used together with the<br />

higher plants for the definition of the cluster groups.<br />

A PCA of both slopes together included the cryptogams and resulted in a<br />

clear picture. Only the occurrence of the plants and not their abundance was<br />

used. The resulting scatter showed a gradient that could be separated into 10<br />

parts (Fig. 3). The gradient shows a continuous change starting from the lower<br />

part of the northern slope, passing upwards to the transition zone between the<br />

two slopes and ending in three open areas at the margin of the south slope. A<br />

comparison between PCA and cluster analysis shows a high degree of conformity.<br />

The distribution of abiotic factors was also investigated by PCA and a<br />

high degree of conformity between the distribution of vegetation and the light<br />

intensity (Fig. 4), the pH and the ground cover by dead leaves was found.


1991 Microclimate influences on lichens—Canters et al. <strong>23</strong>9<br />

Oxolis acetosella<br />

IW.VJ<br />

H * » * »1<br />

Cardamine pratensis I.V.'.'.I<br />

Mercurialis perennis<br />

Anemone nemoroso<br />

Lamiastrum galeobdolon<br />

Dryopteris filix-mos<br />

Festuca altissima r<br />

Luzula luzuloides [•:•<br />

Polypodium vulgare<br />

I<br />

Polytrichum formosum<br />

Hypnum cupress i for me<br />

Dicronum scopar/um<br />

Avenella flexuosa<br />

Clodonia furcato<br />

Pleurozium schreberi<br />

Fagus sylvatica (seedling)<br />

Hierocium lacnenalii and H. glaucinum<br />

Clodonia coniocraea<br />

Cladonia orbusculo<br />

Quercuspetraea (seedling)<br />

Clodonia ciliota<br />

Cladonia squamoso<br />

Cladonio rangiferina<br />

Dicronun spunurn<br />

Calluna vulgarls<br />

Hieracium umbellatum<br />

Polytrichum piliferum<br />

Genista pilosa<br />

Parmelia conspersa<br />

X-Uv<br />

II<br />

LZZJL<br />

E<strong>23</strong>L<br />

•:-:ii<br />

II<br />

:VMK-:-:-:-II<br />

X-ires^k-:<br />

\mm\<br />

tv<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

II<br />

II<br />

II<br />

II 1<br />

II<br />

X-ll 1<br />

II 1<br />

M^FXy^<br />

•XU-:-<br />

iK-x '•il.' :-:->HF>:-:-H<br />

it-:-'.-XJ N<br />

\[yy.<br />

ICv/<br />

II<br />

1<br />

'.*. W.V.I lA A A A A 1<br />

'.V.V.V.i 1 * A A A J<br />

s?i:-ga C-:-:*:-.M<br />

:•:•:•:•! Pv>:-:1<br />

Ml WKMMMM<br />

If: •.vHEv.v]<br />

A A A A '!J t*i*i%*i"»%"»1 r<br />

A A A A AI CVXVXVH 1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

1<br />

It-:<br />

JI±<br />

It-:<br />

II<br />

II<br />

y-iwmm<br />

'»]•••<br />

1 tvX-M<br />

lf#?SSSi|<br />

| I


240 THE LICHENOLOGIST Vol. <strong>23</strong><br />

4 * 4 5<br />

1 33<br />

'• X #<br />

. -a 1<br />

2<br />

,»< '<br />

FIG. 3. PCA of the occurrence of phanerogams and cryptogams on the mountain spur. The gradient<br />

is divided into 10 parts and starts from the lower part of the northern slope and ends at the upper<br />

margin of the south slope.<br />

A separate PCA was made for the south-west exposed slope, which alone is of<br />

interest for the cryptogams. Not only the distribution of clusters along the first<br />

axis, but also the arrangement of individual species showed the same interesting<br />

pattern. For example, Polypodium vulgare was found at one end of the axis and<br />

Calluna vulgaris at the opposite end. Festuca cinerea occurs mainly in the<br />

middle part of the axis. This corresponds with a light gradient from dark<br />

{Polypodium) to light {Calluna). Of the cryptogams Polytrichum piliferum is<br />

found at the end of the axis together with Calluna. For Cladonia a characteristic<br />

distribution exists along the axis: all species occur in the middle part of the axis<br />

and not at the extremes but C.furcata and C. squamosa are found nearer to the<br />

darker part of the gradient and C. arbuscula and C. rangiferina in the lighter<br />

areas.<br />

This summary of the experiments shows that cryptogams can be included<br />

with phanerogams in both cluster analysis and PCA, and that they contribute to<br />

the study of the whole phytocoenosis. To summarize the results: Cladonia<br />

(sect. Cladina) species are absent in the shady beech forest and in the open<br />

sunny areas of the oak forest but dominate the rest of the oak forest. The<br />

open oak forest contains an undergrowth of certain cryptogams, which can be<br />

included in the sociological characteristics of the Quercetalia roboris-petraeae.<br />

This statement does not answer the question whether, for lichens and mosses,<br />

the open forest is a homogeneous area or an accumulation of completely<br />

different microhabitats. Probably only the sum of these habitats together gives


1991 Microclimate influences on lichens—Canters et al. 241<br />

-ss-<br />

-50 SO too<br />

180<br />

X »0" a<br />

FIG. 4. PCA of the light intensity (largest dots = highest intensity). The gradient shows the same<br />

pattern as the PCA of the vegetation (see Fig. 3).<br />

the impression of homogeneity. In this case the separated associations of<br />

cryptogams are obscured by their inclusion into the description of the forest<br />

community. To answer this question the scale of research must be reduced.<br />

Lichen distribution in microhabitats in the forest<br />

The tree-crowns of the open forest are responsible for variations in the light<br />

intensity at ground level. Small 2 x 2 m plots were marked out at the border of<br />

shadow areas in such a way that in summer there was a gradient from light,<br />

warm and dry conditions at the lower left corner to dark, humid and cold<br />

conditions at the upper right corner. The result should be a gradient of those<br />

microclimatic factors that are most important to cryptogams. In winter, when<br />

the trees are bare, the microclimate is more homogeneous. Therefore the differentiation<br />

in the distribution of species must occur in the other months of the<br />

year. The spatial distribution of microclimatic data was recorded for every hour<br />

of the day; an example is given in Fig. 5. The microclimatic measurements were<br />

combined in a gradient, which is shown in Fig. 6 for three plots.<br />

The distribution of the plants was recorded in each quadrat including some<br />

higher plants and the dominant lichens and mosses. For mapping, the 2 x 2 m<br />

plots were divided into 400 small 10x10 cm quadrats. Figures 7 & 8 show the<br />

distribution in two plots. The upper row contains the frequently occurring<br />

plants common to all plots. The second row shows the distribution of frequently<br />

occurring plants found only in one or two quadrats. The last row


242 THE LICHENOLOGIST Vol. <strong>23</strong><br />

LOT<br />

•<br />

rel E 84 %<br />

=100 = 68250 Lux<br />

gOO<br />

o°°<br />

* ;<br />

1• =100=7000 Lux<br />

K<br />

7"<br />

• = 100 = 84000 Li<br />

A1 = 100=17250 Lu<br />

(V<br />

4 = 100=14000 Lux<br />

4 = 100= 55250 Lu<br />

8"<br />

• =100 = 45000 Lux rel. F4I %<br />

12°"<br />

41 = 100=14500 Lux<br />

el. F 45 %<br />

• = 100=7000 Lux rel F 45%<br />

13"<br />

= 100 = 35750 Lu><br />

*<br />

"So<br />

rel. F 39 %<br />

L \<br />

=IOO = l7OOLux rel FT 53%<br />

14"<br />

S "\><br />

• =100=50500 Lux<br />

rel.E35%<br />

FIG. 5. Distribution of microclimatic factors in the 2 x 2 m plots during the day. 1 = relative light<br />

intensity (percentage of lightest spot), 2 = temperature (°C), 3 = vapour pressure deficit (mm Hg),<br />

(*light intensity at lightest spot; rel.F. =rel. humidity).<br />

contains the rare species. Species with a concentration in the lower left (light)<br />

corner are placed in the left part of the figures, species with a preference for the<br />

darker corner are situated to the right and plants without obvious preference in<br />

the middle. Figure 7 shows that many species are concentrated in corners or at<br />

one side of a quadrat. Examples are Polytrichum piliferum and P. formosum,


1991 Microclimate influences on lichens—Canters etal. 243<br />

13<br />

— —<br />

9 \<br />

I<br />

•<br />

I<br />

J<br />

I<br />

1<br />

14<br />

10<br />

1<br />

1<br />

l5<br />

I<br />

I „<br />

1 ^r*<br />

2 3<br />

' / /<br />

1 L/,e<br />

1 r^6<br />

1/<br />

5<br />

V<br />

n<br />

y.<br />

i<br />

A<br />

\ /Pi<br />

1 *.<br />

1<br />

J<br />

1 ^<br />

1<br />

FIG. 6. Microclimatic gradients for direct gradient analysis in the 2 x 2 m plots, divided into 16<br />

quadrats for mapping of vegetation. The quadrats are projected onto the gradients.<br />

which occur in opposite corners. The same is more or less true for Cladonia<br />

arbuscula and Dicranum scoparium. Avenella flexuosa seems to show a certain<br />

preference for the right upper corner of the area. In Fig. 8 the quadrat shows a<br />

concentration of P. piliferum and D. spurium in the left part and of P. formosum<br />

in the upper part of the area. Among the rare species, Genista pilosa prefers the<br />

left lower corner, Festuca cinerea the lower part and Luzula luzuloides the right<br />

upper corner.<br />

Of the total of 25 species, 12 occurred in all quadrats examined. A comparison<br />

of these 12 species shows that:<br />

(1) Some species (e.g. P. piliferum, C. portentosa) occurred in the left or the<br />

left lower part (with more light).<br />

(2) Some species (e.g. C.furcata, A. flexuosa, H. cupressiforme, D. scoparium,<br />

P. formosum) were distributed in the right part or the upper right corner (darker<br />

area).<br />

(3) Some species (e.g. C. rangiferina, C. arbuscula, Pleurozium schreberi, C.<br />

ciliata) showed no clear preferences.<br />

The results were also examined by direct gradient analysis. The 2 x 2 m plots<br />

were divided into 16 quadrats of 25 x 25 cm and the occurrence and abundance<br />

of species were recorded. The quadrats were projected onto the microclimatic


Polytrichum<br />

piliferum<br />

Dicranum<br />

spurium<br />

Cladonia<br />

portentosa<br />

Cladonia<br />

Pleurozium Melampyrum Cladonia<br />

Dicranum Hypnum<br />

arbuscu/a schreberi pratense ciliata scoporium cupressiforme<br />

Cladonia<br />

furcata<br />

m<br />

• "<br />

• ' 3<br />

Parmelia<br />

conspersa<br />

Hieraciun<br />

pilosella<br />

Hypogymnia<br />

physodes<br />

Calluna Quercus<br />

vulgaris petraea<br />

m Teucrium<br />

scorodonic<br />

Hieracium<br />

um be IIa turn cf. Hieracium<br />

lachenalii<br />

Cladonia<br />

cornuto<br />

Cladonia<br />

coccifera<br />

Cladonia<br />

pyxidata<br />

Cladonia<br />

sguamosa<br />

Cladonia<br />

g/auca<br />

•<br />

•<br />

m<br />

• 1<br />

• i<br />

1<br />

Genista<br />

pilosa<br />

Festuca<br />

cinerea<br />

C/adonia<br />

verticillata<br />

Fagus<br />

sylvatica<br />

m m<br />

Galeopsis<br />

tetrahit<br />

Cladonia<br />

macilenta<br />

Cladonia<br />

gracilis<br />

Cladonia Luzula<br />

floerfteano luzuloides<br />

m<br />

•<br />

FIG. 7.<br />

Polytrichum<br />

piliferum<br />

Dicranum<br />

spurium<br />

Cladonia Cladonia Cladonia Pleurozium Melampyrum Cladonia Polytrichum Dicranum Hypnum Avenella Cladonia<br />

portentosa rangiferina arbuscula<br />

m<br />

schreberi pratense ciliata scoparium cupressiforme flexuosa furcata<br />

m<br />

Hierocium<br />

pilosella<br />

Hypogymnia Caliuna Quercus Teucrium Hieracium Hieracium C/adonia C/adonia Cladonia Ciadonio Clodonia<br />

physodes vulgaris petraea scorodonia umbellatum cf lachenalii cornuto coccifera pyxidata squamosa gtouco<br />

i"'<br />

Genista<br />

pilosa<br />

m<br />

• •<br />

m<br />

a<br />

Festuca Cladonia Fagus Galeopsis C/adonia Clodonia Cladonia Luzula<br />

cinerea verticillatc sylvatica tetrahit macilenta gracilis fioerkeana luzuloides<br />

•<br />

7.* • \<br />

FIG. 8.<br />

FIGS 7 & 8. Distribution of species in two 2 x 2 m plots divided into 400 quadrats. Upper rows = frequently occurring species; middle rows = species frequent<br />

but c ilv found in r fe 1 r r=<br />

quadrats; Jo' x ro"<br />

r 8 = r'<br />

r<br />

^ «•" "'is., -


1991 Microclimate influences on lichens—Canters et al.<br />

Polytrichum pil/ferum<br />

Cladonia ciliata<br />

245<br />

I 2 5 9 6 131014 3 7 II 15 4 8 12 16 I 2 5 9 6 13 10 143 7 II 15 4 8 12 14<br />

FIG 9<br />

FIGS 9—11. Abundance of species in quadrats 1—16 in the direct gradient analysis for three 2 x 2 m<br />

plots. Warm and dry conditions to the left, dark and wet conditions to the right of every diagram.<br />

gradients described above (Fig. 6), in order to compare the distribution of<br />

species along the gradient. Figures 9-11 demonstrate the preference of certain<br />

species for the light, warm end of the gradient while others prefer the darker<br />

end. A third group seems to react indifferently. Among these is C. furcata, a<br />

species that will be discussed separately (see below).<br />

It is concluded that the distribution of lichens and mosses show characteristic<br />

patterns on a very small scale. The same is apparently true for some<br />

phanerogams.<br />

Lichen distribution in microhabitats in an open area<br />

In the open forest area the tree crowns are responsible for a distinct pattern of<br />

light patches and a resulting microclimatic variation. For comparison an open


246 THE LICHENOLOGIST<br />

Polytrichum piliferum<br />

Cladonia ci/iata<br />

Vol. <strong>23</strong><br />

Cladonia portentosa<br />

Cladonia furcata<br />

60 - ^^<br />

I 5 2 9 6 3 10 13 7 4 14 II 8 12 15 16<br />

FIG. 10.<br />

20<br />

I I I I I I i i<br />

5 2 9 6 3 10 13 7 4 14 II 8 12 15 16<br />

area at the border of the forest was examined. This area was only 10x3 metres<br />

but the distribution of cryptogams showed distinct patterns. A microclimatic<br />

gradient from the trees to the open parts could be observed along which the<br />

lichens showed distinct preferences. From the forest outwards the vegetation<br />

was dominated by Polytrichum formosum, Cladonia arbuscula and C. rangiferina.<br />

Towards the open parts followed in sequence C. portentosa, P. piliferum,<br />

C. macilenta and C. floerkeana,and finally Baeomyces roseus and Pycnothelia<br />

papillaria. Cladonia furcata again showed no clear preferences. The details of<br />

these patterns and the behaviour of other species together with microclimatic<br />

correlations will be discussed elsewhere.<br />

The distribution patterns exist not only for species but also for groups<br />

of species. It is possible to distinguish (Fig. 12) a Polytrichum formosum-<br />

Cladina zone (1), a P. piliferum zone (2), a C. portentosa zone (3), a


1991 Microclimate influences on lichens—Canters et al.<br />

247<br />

Polytrichum piliferum<br />

Cladonia ciliata<br />

g, Cladonia rangiferina<br />

5 2 9 6 3 10 13 7 4 14 II 8 12 15 16 I 5 2 9 6 3 10 13 7 4 14 II 8 12 15 16<br />

FIG. 11.<br />

C. portentosa-Baeomyces transition zone (4), a Baeomyces zone (5), a Grimmia<br />

pulvinata zone (6), and other transition zones (7).<br />

Microclimatic influences on lichen distribution and community<br />

development<br />

The last section again showed a separation of cryptogam vegetation into units<br />

on a scale much too small for phanerogams. A joint treatment of both groups<br />

would only serve to obscure the existing differences. If the distribution of<br />

cryptogams is characterized by small areas, the influence of abiotic factors must<br />

also be effective on a corresponding scale. In the first instance this means<br />

microclimatic influences. Some of the decisive factors are also relevant to<br />

ecological investigations of higher plants. However, often the distribution of


248 THE LICHENOLOGIST Vol.<strong>23</strong><br />

FIG. 12. Distribution pattern of species groups in an open area 1, Polytrichum formosum-Cladonia<br />

(Sect. Cladina) zone; 2, P. piliferum zone; 3, C. portentosa zone; 4, C. portentosa-Baeomyces<br />

transition zone; 5, Baeomyces zone; 6, Grimmia pulvinata zone; 7, other transition zones.<br />

lichens can only be explained by factors that are irrelevant to higher plants or at<br />

least different in their way of influencing the higher and lower vegetation.<br />

The influence of many factors such as light, water relations and insolation<br />

have been discussed in many papers. Some of these factors have already been<br />

mentioned together with the examination of the forest area (see above). Here,<br />

only some aspects will be reported that are often omitted.<br />

The influence of dead leaves<br />

The examination of small areas in the forest showed an influence of light and<br />

temperature on the distribution of cryptogams. The occurrence of many<br />

lichens showed a correlation with these factors and the real distribution<br />

patterns of these species could only be explained by work on this microscale.<br />

However, some species such as C.furcata seemed to be indifferent to light and<br />

temperature. The climatic conditions on the lichen-free, north-east facing slope<br />

should also be suitable for the species, but it does not occur there. This could be<br />

due to the influence of dead leaves, which gather on this slope in a thick layer. To<br />

test this hypothesis some transplantation experiments were carried out.<br />

Thalli of several species of Cladonia were transplanted from the south slope<br />

to the north slope. Each species was exposed on two 1 m 2 plots. One plot was<br />

regularly cleared of all dead leaves (plot B) while from the other only sufficient<br />

leaves were removed to prevent the lichens from being completely covered (plot<br />

A). The condition of the lichens and their disintegration was classified with a<br />

simple system. The development of the transplants is shown in Table 1.


1991 Microclimate influences on lichens—Canters etal. 249<br />

TABLE 1. Condition of several transplanted Cladonia species<br />

Date<br />

16 September 1976<br />

6 October 1976<br />

22 November 1976<br />

17 February 1977<br />

31 March 1977<br />

13 May 1977<br />

6 July 1977<br />

8 September 1977<br />

13 December 1977<br />

1 March 1978<br />

C. rangiferina<br />

A* B<br />

_ +<br />

—<br />

—<br />

-<br />

—<br />

—<br />

-<br />

0<br />

0<br />

C. arbuscula<br />

A B<br />

+<br />

+ —<br />

+ — —<br />

+ -<br />

+ —<br />

+<br />

+-_0<br />

+ —<br />

__<br />

0<br />

0 0<br />

C. squamosa<br />

A B<br />

+<br />

+<br />

—<br />

-<br />

—<br />

- 0<br />

0<br />

0<br />

0<br />

+<br />

+<br />

+<br />

+<br />

—<br />

-<br />

--0<br />

0<br />

C.furcata<br />

A B<br />

+ +<br />

+ +<br />

+ +<br />

+ +<br />

+ +<br />

+ +<br />

+ +<br />

+ + +<br />

+ + +<br />

+ ++§<br />

•Plot A with only a few leaves removed. Plot B regularly cleared of all dead leaves.<br />

X + +, Very good (thallus upright without any disintegration); +, good (some small discoloured<br />

parts); +, intermediate (discoloured parts and some spots with disintegration beginning; —, bad<br />

(thallus partly dead and disappearing, some parts still left alive); , very bad (only some parts of<br />

the thallus left, discoloured, broken down); 0, disappeared.<br />

§Fertile thallus with apothecia.<br />

The transplant experiment showed that for three of the four species the<br />

microclimate of the north slope is unsuitable and the thalli degenerate. The<br />

remaining dead leaves in plot A have an additional negative influence. On the<br />

other hand C. furcata can, as expected, survive under these microclimatic<br />

conditions only if the dead leaves are removed. In the completely leaf-free plot<br />

B even apothecia were formed.<br />

Dead leaves are therefore an extremely important factor for lichens in forest<br />

communities. On the south slopes most leaves are blown away by the wind. The<br />

remaining leaves do not lie on the cushions of Cladonia sect. Cladina species;<br />

they slide down and gather between the cushions. The growth form of these<br />

lichens therefore enhances their chances for survival in wooded areas.<br />

The combined influence of wind and rain<br />

The importance of some climatic factors can be understood only when they<br />

are observed together. During research on the microclimate of lichen habitats<br />

on an island in the North Sea the distribution of Physcia tenella on Sambucus<br />

was recorded. It could be shown that the development depended on the water<br />

relations, but that there existed no simple correlation with precipitation. The<br />

really important influence was the wind from the sea, which in open locations<br />

could direct the rain through the foliage to the trunk. In the lee of the dunes this<br />

did not happen. The combination of exposure to wind with the rainfall was a<br />

decisive factor for lichen occurrence.<br />

Dewfall and 'dry nights '<br />

Another example of an environmental influence often omitted is dewfall,<br />

which is always important to lichens. In the course of a project, a transect


1991 Microclimate influences on lichens—Canters et al. 251<br />

LI Lh Tl T2 L2Pr HR Ra Hu Wm Me Hs Wl Mb Hz Sa G2 Go W2 W4 NA HT la<br />

FIG. 15. Key: H, Parmelia caperata; 0, Ochrolechia androgyna; •, Graphis scripta.<br />

;<br />

nz<br />

i<br />

n<br />

i<br />

n n n<br />

M<br />

n<br />

i<br />

i i i i 10<br />

11Hi 6 H n c<br />

' fa<br />

J;<br />

i<br />

y Lin<br />

Ml:<br />

:j H H<br />

• : w, ', ', ', ; > • •<br />

LI Lh Tl T2 L2 Pr HR Ra Hu WmMe Hs Wl Mb Hz Sa G2 Go W2 W4 NA HT 2a<br />

FIG. 16. Key: fS,Pseudeverniafurfuracea; 0, Platismatiaglauca; U,Cetrariachlorophylla.<br />

through the valley of the Wisper from the Rhine valley to the Taunus mountains<br />

was examined. The results of this study will be published in more detail<br />

elsewhere (Scholler unpublished data). The Rhine valley is characterized by<br />

warm, subcontinental summers and mild, sub-oceanic winters. The Wisper<br />

valley is colder and the hills of the Taunus have a submontane climate. The<br />

climate can be characterized by diagrams including factors such as rainfall and<br />

humidity but in the usual form both are of little relevance to lichen vegetation.


252 THE LICHENOLOGIST Vol.<strong>23</strong><br />

It is better to count the number of nights without dewfall. In the narrow Wisper<br />

valley dew accounts for one-tenth of the precipitation. Figure 13 shows along<br />

the transect the number of dry nights during a 2-year period. It can be seen that<br />

in the middle part of the valley hardly any night without dewfall occurred,<br />

and this was the only part with an exceptionally rich lichen vegetation. The<br />

parameter of dry nights and the distribution of lichen vegetation show a high<br />

degree of conformity.<br />

The study of an open oak forest showed the advantage of studying lichen<br />

distribution on a microscale as opposed to the variations in higher plants on a<br />

much larger scale. The distribution along the transect in the valley of the<br />

Wisper deals with both groups of organisms on the same scale, but here again<br />

the lichens give a much more detailed separation of vegetation zones. Naturally<br />

not all lichen species react in the same way. Figure 14 shows that some species<br />

occur in the lower part of the valley, whereas others (Fig. 15) grow in the middle<br />

part and a third group are found in the upper hills (Fig. 16). Sometimes a lichen<br />

species may be replaced by a closely related species along the transect. An<br />

example of such a lichen pair with different microclimatic requirements is<br />

Parmelia conspersa and P. somloensis. The picture is further complicated by the<br />

fact that certain species seem to change their microclimatic requirements along<br />

the transect. Cladonia arbuscula occurs in open localities in the middle part of<br />

the valley and particularly in shady places in the warmer, lower parts. This is<br />

the well-known law of relative habitat constancy. For lichens this law applies to<br />

smaller areas than for higher plants.<br />

Conclusions<br />

The distribution of lichens is governed by microclimatic factors that influence<br />

higher plants in different ways or not at all. The microclimate causes a separation<br />

of much smaller units in cryptogams than in phanerogams. A joint treatment<br />

of both types of plants in ecological investigations can sometimes obscure<br />

the existing differences. On the other hand the description of a phytocoenosis<br />

including cryptogams together with the higher plants may be of advantage in<br />

some cases. However, it must be remembered that the lichens and mosses<br />

inhabit special microhabitats and niches within the phytocoenosis. There<br />

probably exists no general solution for these problems and the selection of a<br />

suitable method must be governed by the nature of the problem.<br />

REFERENCES<br />

Barkman, J. J. (1990) Controversies and perspectives in plant ecology and vegetation science.<br />

Phytocoenologia 18: 565-589.<br />

Jahns, H. M. & Fritzler, E. (1982) Flechtenstandorte auf einer Blockhalde. Herzogia 6: 243-270.<br />

Jahns, H. M. & Ott, S. (1983) Das Mikroklima dicht benachbarter Flechtenstandorte. Flora 173:<br />

183-222.<br />

Maarel, E. van der, Jansen, J. G. M. & Louppen, J. M. W. (1979) TABORD, a program for<br />

structuring phytosociological tables. VegetatioiS: 143-156.<br />

Ott, S. (1989) Standorte epiphytischer Flechten in einem Diinengebiet. Herzogia 8: 149-175.<br />

Schuster, G., Herold, K. & Jahns, H. M. (1982) Mikroklimatische Messungen an Flechtenstandorten.<br />

Neue Messapparaturen. Herzogia 6: 183-200.<br />

Accepted for publication 27 April 1991

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!