''Vladimir Nabokov's Comic Quest for Reality' - Nottingham eTheses

''Vladimir Nabokov's Comic Quest for Reality' - Nottingham eTheses ''Vladimir Nabokov's Comic Quest for Reality' - Nottingham eTheses

etheses.nottingham.ac.uk
from etheses.nottingham.ac.uk More from this publisher
28.02.2014 Views

- 86 - other's real personalities and natures but that they know only phantoms: images they create of each other and which they mistake for real persons. Once they have created an image of somebody they are reluctant to change it, and as their reactions are to that image and not to the real person, and as the image corre- sponds to only one (and in most cases the most super- ficial) aspect of that person (if there is any corre- spondence at all) there can be no real communication and contact between people and no mutual attachment and understanding. The end of The Eye suggests how lonely and unhappy anyone can get as a result. Pnin reveals the mechanism at work behind all this, and in Timofey Pnin shows the effects that are only implicitly indicated in The Eye. At one point Hagen makes a remark which both explains, and exposes the absurdity of, the general attitude of those who insist on treating Pnin as the comic person they see in him (their "phantom"), and which neatly sums up what is at the root of his loneliness: "The world wants a machine, not a Timofey" (161). The reader is not allowed to share the attitude of the Waindell people. He is certainly shown what they see and might be inclined to simply laugh as they do, if he were not at the same time made to appreciate Pnin's originality. 16 Also, Pnin's comic sides are presented in such an exaggerated form, which so obviously makes for effect, that by and by the laughter is stifled. The initial amusement is superseded by an almost protective attitude

- 87 - which induces the reader to sympathize with Pnin, to take sides with him and react rather scornfully against those who have so blindly made him their laughing stock. Bathos, too, is used to evoke sympathy rather than hilarity, such as when Joan Clements finds Pnin in a truly distressed state after Liza has left him, and is immediately confronted with an instance of his adventurous and comic English: He came out of [the pantry], darkly flushed, wild-eyed, and she was shocked to see that his face was a mess of unwiped tears. 'I search, John, for the viscous and sawdust, ' he said tragically (59). Most important, however, in determining the reader's attitude to Pnin is the insight he is given to the "inner Pnin" of whom the Waindell people know nothing. "Always in Nabokov, the most sensitive conscious- nesses are those made to bear enormous pain. "32 This is insinuated at first only in short and unobtrusive remarks which, moreover, stand in very comic contexts. In the middle of a description of Pnin almost collapsing over his own subtle jokes in class, there is the la- conic statement, added in brackets and as an after- thought, that the world of his youth had been "abol- ished by one blow of history" (12), and in the middle of his comically disastrous journey to Cremona, Pnin himself dismisses his fears about losing a travelling 4. bag by reminding himself that he has "lost, dumped, shed many more valuable things in his day" (19). "Such a comment", says Morton, "is easily passed over, but it opens a way through the trivial problems at the 33

-<br />

87<br />

-<br />

which induces the reader to sympathize with Pnin,<br />

to take sides with him and react rather scornfully<br />

against those who have so blindly made him their<br />

laughing<br />

stock.<br />

Bathos, too, is used to evoke sympathy rather than<br />

hilarity, such as when Joan Clements finds Pnin in a<br />

truly distressed state after Liza has left him, and<br />

is immediately confronted with an instance of his<br />

adventurous and comic English:<br />

He came out of<br />

[the pantry], darkly flushed,<br />

wild-eyed, and she was shocked to see that<br />

his face was a mess of unwiped tears.<br />

'I search, John, <strong>for</strong> the viscous and<br />

sawdust, ' he said tragically (59).<br />

Most important, however, in determining the reader's<br />

attitude to Pnin is the insight he is given to the<br />

"inner Pnin" of whom the Waindell people know nothing.<br />

"Always in Nabokov, the most sensitive conscious-<br />

nesses are those made to bear enormous pain. "32 This<br />

is insinuated at first only in short and unobtrusive<br />

remarks which, moreover, stand in very comic contexts.<br />

In the middle of a description of Pnin almost collapsing<br />

over his own subtle jokes in class, there is the la-<br />

conic statement, added in brackets and as an after-<br />

thought, that the world of his youth had been "abol-<br />

ished by one blow of history" (12), and in the middle<br />

of his comically disastrous journey to Cremona, Pnin<br />

himself dismisses his fears about losing a travelling<br />

4.<br />

bag by reminding himself that he has "lost, dumped,<br />

shed many more valuable things in his day" (19).<br />

"Such a comment", says Morton, "is easily passed over,<br />

but it opens a way through the trivial problems at the<br />

33

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!