Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Volume 14, Number 2-<strong>Febru</strong>ary 2009<br />
©<br />
www.parkingtoday.com<br />
“High Cost” of<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> on a<br />
Great Street...<br />
Donald Shoup<br />
Sets the Price…<br />
Page 22
See our other ad on Page 48
PARKING TODAY<br />
P.O. Box 66515<br />
Los Angeles, CA 90066<br />
DELIVERIES<br />
12228 Venice Boulevard, #541<br />
Los Angeles, CA 90066<br />
PHONE<br />
310.390.5277<br />
FAX<br />
310.390.4777<br />
EDITOR & PUBLISHER<br />
JOHN VAN HORN<br />
extension 2<br />
jvh@parkingtoday.com<br />
PARKING TODAY<br />
volume 14 number 2<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 FEATURES<br />
16 Tough Times Call for Smart Technologies<br />
22 The Price of <strong>Parking</strong> on a Great Street<br />
24 Remaining “Service-Focused” in Tough<br />
Economic Times<br />
SALES MANAGER<br />
MARCY SPARROW<br />
extension 3<br />
marcy@parkingtoday.com<br />
CLASSIFIED SALES<br />
NIKI BISESI<br />
extension 8<br />
niki@parkingtoday.com<br />
ART DIRECTOR<br />
SHELLY BROWN<br />
extension 5<br />
sbrown@bricepac.com<br />
GRAPHIC DESIGN<br />
RADUNTY HERMIDA<br />
rad@bricepac.com<br />
28 Henry Hudson Paid to Park; His Legacy<br />
Survives <strong>Today</strong><br />
30 Why Multi-Space <strong>Parking</strong> Meters?<br />
32 Replacement for Coins, or More?<br />
34 Woolworths, ITS and Rushmoor<br />
40 Amateur Parker: I Want My Free <strong>Parking</strong><br />
REGULAR FEATURES<br />
Pay-by-Cell . . . . . . . . . .Page 16<br />
On the Cover: Donald Shoup<br />
pays for his parking on a Great<br />
Street in Pasadena, California.<br />
See Page 22.<br />
CIRCULATION<br />
PAT RESTIVO<br />
extension 0<br />
pat@parkingtoday.com<br />
MARKETING AND<br />
QUALITY ASSURANCE<br />
SANDRA WATSON<br />
extension 4<br />
sandra@parkingtoday.com<br />
RESEARCH ASSISTANT<br />
JOYCE NEWMAN<br />
extension 7<br />
joyce@bricepac.com<br />
ACCOUNTING<br />
SUE RESTIVO<br />
extension 6<br />
sue@parkingtoday.com<br />
DIRECTOR OF<br />
OPERATIONS, BRICEPAC<br />
ANDY VAN HORN<br />
extension 1<br />
andy@bricepac.com<br />
www.parkingtoday.com<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> <strong>Today</strong> is a<br />
Bricepac company<br />
Point of View ..................................................................................................6<br />
People in <strong>Parking</strong> ............................................................................................8<br />
PT Blog ........................................................................................................20<br />
Product Focus Ads........................................................................................36<br />
PT the Auditor ..............................................................................................38<br />
Death by <strong>Parking</strong> ..........................................................................................44<br />
Advertisers Index ........................................................................................49<br />
Marketplace ..................................................................................................50<br />
Dealers, Installers & Suppliers ....................................................................52<br />
Upcoming Events ........................................................................................54<br />
PARKING TODAY is circulated free of charge to those who have an<br />
interest in the parking industry. In order to facilitate delivery,<br />
readers outside North America are charged $60. Post Office receipt<br />
available upon request. Single copy price $15.<br />
Manuscripts, articles, photographs, artwork, product releases and<br />
all contributed materials are welcomed by PARKING TODAY;<br />
however submissions are subject to editing. Advertisers and<br />
advertising agencies assume liability for all content (including<br />
text, representations and illustrations of advertisements printed<br />
and also any and all claims made against the publisher.<br />
Publisher’s sole responsibility for error in advertising content<br />
extends to correction in the succeeding issue.<br />
PARKING TODAY (ISSN: 10955062) is published monthly by Bricepac,<br />
Inc., 12228 Venice Boulevard, #541, Los Angeles, California<br />
90066. Periodicals postage paid at Los Angeles, CA and additional<br />
mailing offices.<br />
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to PARKING TODAY, P.O. Box<br />
66515, Los Angeles, CA 90066 In Canada to Station A, PO Box 54,<br />
Windsor, ON N9A 6J5. Publications Agreement Number 40826055.<br />
©2009, Bricepac, Inc.
POINT OF VIEW<br />
SF, NYC, Jackson and<br />
‘Three Little Words’<br />
PBY JOHN VAN HORN<br />
ERIODICALLY, ON MY PARKING<br />
<strong>Today</strong> blog, I give a Baghdad by the<br />
Bay award to the organization that<br />
makes the most boneheaded parking<br />
decisions. Last month, it went to its<br />
namesake’s doppelganger, that city on the Hudson,<br />
New York, NY.<br />
Get this. If you get a parking ticket in one of the Big Apple’s<br />
five boroughs, you simply have to contest it, either online, by<br />
mail or in person, and the city will reduce your fine about a third.<br />
Period.<br />
No, that’s it. Just contest it, then plead guilty, and don’t ask<br />
for a hearing. Bribery? Well, of course. But there is another interesting<br />
tidbit. The city of Broadway, the Empire State Building<br />
and Wall Street hasn’t<br />
told anyone about the<br />
program. To find out,<br />
you have to go contest a<br />
ticket.<br />
That bastion of<br />
truth and justice, The<br />
New York Times, got<br />
wind of this and broke<br />
the story. The stalwart<br />
reporters of the Old Gray Lady, while looking for work, did ask<br />
the city about the fact that no one knows about this program. The<br />
answer:<br />
“Since this is offered to everyone universally, it was not as<br />
necessary” to publicize it, said Owen Stone, a spokesman for the<br />
city’s Department of Finance, which runs all parking ticket adjudication<br />
programs.<br />
Let’s see if I can parse this for you. You get a parking ticket<br />
in NYC, whether you were wronged by the citation writer or not,<br />
you simply appeal through the “secret” program and get a onethird<br />
reduction in your parking ticket fee, automatically. Yep!<br />
Oh, and you’ll love the photo that went with the story. It’s a<br />
picture of a car with a bunch of tickets on it and two flat tires. It<br />
must have been sitting there for weeks, collecting tickets.<br />
Is the city nuts? Why leave the car there? After the second<br />
ticket, it would seem to me to be abandoned and therefore could<br />
be towed. There are towing services that would pay the city $50<br />
to come and pick up the car. After all, if no one calls for it in a<br />
month, they can legally sell it. But not in NYC. It just sits there<br />
and parking enforcement officers sidle up and write another ticket.<br />
There had to be half a dozen on that car.<br />
To add even more gold-leaf clusters on their award, there is a<br />
quote from a woman who has gotten “hundreds” of tickets since<br />
she has lived in the city. What’s this all about? A person can get<br />
“hundreds” of tickets. Doesn’t it reach a point where this<br />
becomes at least a felony? This person has single-handedly<br />
turned the NYC parking department into a monthly parking operation.<br />
It’s just that the fee varies each month, depending on how<br />
often she is caught. Well, I guess this is to be expected from a city<br />
that is outlawing and taxing fat in food.<br />
Look out, San Francisco, NYC is catching up on being the<br />
capital of parking idiocy …<br />
Check out the “Big Apple and Baghdad by the Bay” posting<br />
(Jan. 2) at the PT blog at www.parkingtoday.com. The history<br />
of this coveted award is there, plus links to the article about this<br />
winner.<br />
***<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> assessments – these are charges the city levies<br />
against businesses to cover the costs of providing parking in<br />
downtown areas. The city justifies the charges because of the<br />
expense of paving,<br />
marking, policing, snow<br />
removal and the like.<br />
The city of Jackson, MI,<br />
is in a tizzy over these<br />
little fees.<br />
Merchants in a<br />
midtown area want customers.<br />
They feel that<br />
charging for parking onstreet<br />
causes those customers to go elsewhere, so they lobby the<br />
city to provide free parking for their customers.<br />
The city says, “Sure, we’ll provide ‘free’ parking, but someone<br />
has to pay.” So rather than charge everyone in the city, they<br />
charge the merchants an assessment to cover the costs.<br />
The merchants then pass this assessment along to their customers<br />
as a higher cost for their goods and services, and suddenly<br />
the midtown merchants aren’t as competitive as those in the<br />
malls outside town.<br />
Of course, everyone pays for the cost of parking, not just<br />
those who drive. Those who walk, take the bus or ride with someone<br />
else also pay for the parking assessment.<br />
Plus, there’s another problem. There is no way, with “free”<br />
parking and a parking assessment, to regulate who parks where.<br />
With “free” parking, the folks who work in stores and<br />
shops in the area simply park where they like, taking the best<br />
spaces. The visitors must “cruise” looking for parking and<br />
causing congestion.<br />
The “free” parking causes traffic problems, angry customers<br />
and, frankly, decisions to shop elsewhere. Few make the decision<br />
to shop at the mall at the edge of town based on free parking.<br />
They go there because of good prices, selection and the “scene.”<br />
All of these could be available midtown.<br />
Those Jackson merchants are asking the city to review the<br />
“Since this is offered to everyone<br />
universally, it was not as necessary”<br />
to publicize it.<br />
Continued on Page 8<br />
6<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
Dynamic software to<br />
manage your parking<br />
revenue accurately,<br />
consistently, and<br />
automatically<br />
GENEVA<br />
“Converting to<br />
Integrapark’s<br />
integrated<br />
PARIS and GENEVA software<br />
enabled our company to reduce<br />
processing time and improve<br />
the accuracy of the financial<br />
information to our clients while<br />
reducing staff involvement by<br />
three full time employees.”<br />
Brian Dusenberry, CPA<br />
Allpro <strong>Parking</strong> LLC<br />
For more information contact:<br />
ruth.beaman@IntegraPark.com or call: 888.852.9993<br />
GENEVA is enterprisewide<br />
revenue<br />
management software<br />
that parking professionals rely<br />
on. GENEVA easily—<br />
• Replaces spreadsheets used<br />
for ticket tracking, analysis,<br />
budgeting, and rate projections<br />
• Gives you instant insight<br />
into operational details<br />
• Posts revenue<br />
information, plus your<br />
bank deposits, directly<br />
to your general ledger<br />
• Ensures accuracy and<br />
ready availability of<br />
historical data<br />
• Uses tickets-issued data,<br />
cashier reports, and statistical<br />
information to automatically<br />
produce reports<br />
•Provides parking rate<br />
projection analysis<br />
•Standardizes reporting for all<br />
of your locations<br />
•GENEVA delivers what it<br />
promises. And more.<br />
Manage your parking revenue with the GENEVA advantage<br />
IntegraPark.com
PEOPLE IN PARKING<br />
Standard <strong>Parking</strong> announced that Roamy R. Valera<br />
has joined the Company as Director of Business Development<br />
and Municipal Services. In this capacity, Mr. Valera<br />
will be responsible for supporting the growth and development<br />
of Standard <strong>Parking</strong>'s municipal and government services,<br />
and overseeing new business and marketing initiatives<br />
as they pertain to the Company's Florida operations. Most<br />
recently, Valera served as Vice President of Timothy Haahs<br />
& Associates, Inc., an architectural and engineering firm<br />
specializing in parking design, planning and engineering.<br />
Valera also served as Deputy Executive Director with the<br />
Miami <strong>Parking</strong> Authority and Associate Director of Professional<br />
Development for the International <strong>Parking</strong> Institute.<br />
Insta<strong>Parking</strong> has begun operations servicing parking<br />
customers at the Buffalo Niagara International Airport.<br />
The facility has more than 1,000 parking spots for valet and<br />
self-park executive customers. Insta<strong>Parking</strong> also has the<br />
ability to expand to 2,000 parking spots, making it the<br />
largest off-airport parking facility servicing the airport.<br />
Alan Cruickshank, President of Alan J. Cruickshank<br />
and Associates, is now working in the LA office of<br />
LTK Engineering Services. The firms are located in the<br />
Fine Arts Building in Los Angeles.<br />
Tracy Little is the new Director of National Accounts at<br />
AMAG Technology. He will manage its national account<br />
customers and develop sales initiatives to increase its market<br />
share. Little reports to Matt Barnette, Vice President of Sales<br />
and Marketing. Also, Mike Taylor has been promoted to<br />
Continued on Page 10<br />
POINT OF VIEW<br />
from Page 6<br />
parking assessment, some claiming that it is a “tax” (of<br />
course, it is) and therefore illegal. The city is saying they will<br />
review it, but the program needs to be funded, and the “fee”<br />
must stay in place.<br />
There is an alternative – charge for parking and have the<br />
money generated go back into the neighborhoods whence it<br />
came. Charge enough so that there is one empty space always<br />
available on each block face. Tell people that the parking<br />
charges are there for clean streets, better parks, new sidewalks<br />
and the like.<br />
All would be right with the world.<br />
(Be sure to check out our Resident Cynic, Melissa, in her<br />
“Amateur Parker” on Page 40 this month. She has a few<br />
choice words for parking charges, and her editor, moi.)<br />
***<br />
Three Little Words – no, not those three little words.<br />
With all the doom and gloom we are hearing constantly<br />
about everything from the weather to Wall Street Ponzi<br />
schemes, how about a little perspective.<br />
Correspondent Mark sent me this<br />
quote from Robert Frost, the great<br />
American poet: “In three words, I can<br />
sum up everything I’ve learned about<br />
life: It goes on.”<br />
PT
Introducing the World’s Most<br />
Advanced Single Space <strong>Parking</strong><br />
Meter with Credit Card capability<br />
The revolutionary Single Space Meter from IPS can be retrofitted into existing<br />
on street parking meter housings within 15 seconds without any additional<br />
installation costs.<br />
See it for yourself: www.ipsgroupinc.com/installvideo<br />
The IPS Single Space Meter<br />
features:<br />
• Patented Flexi-Pay mechanism<br />
accepts payment by coin, credit card,<br />
debit card and smart card.<br />
• Meters are wirelessly networked and<br />
connected to a web-based Management<br />
System.<br />
• Solar powered with rechargeable<br />
battery pack guaranteed for 3 years.<br />
• Full credit card and cash collection<br />
auditing capabilities.<br />
• Uses existing poles, housings, cash<br />
containers and collection techniques.<br />
• Operating costs are lower than Payand-Display<br />
or Pay-by-Space systems.<br />
Are you ready to experience<br />
first-hand the simplicity and<br />
performance of this<br />
revolutionary product?<br />
Contact us at IPS to arrange an<br />
on-site demonstration.<br />
Ask how you can receive a<br />
FREE 90 day Field Trial<br />
Telephone: 1-858-764-4225<br />
Email:<br />
dave@ipsgroupinc.com<br />
denis@ipsgroupinc.com<br />
Website: www.ipsgroupinc.com<br />
IPS Group Inc is a global engineering and manufacturing company, with offices in 6 countries.<br />
For 15 years, we have been delivering world-class solutions to the telecommunications and parking industries.<br />
Africa | Australia | Europe | New Zealand | United Kingdom & Ireland | United States<br />
© Copyright 2007 IPS Group Inc.All rights reserved. | Corporate Web Site: www.IPSGroupInc.com<br />
IPS Group Inc. | 12526 High Bluff Dr., Suite 165 | San Diego, CA 92130
PEOPLE IN PARKING<br />
from Page 8<br />
Director of Sales at AMAG. He will be<br />
responsible for the day-to-day operations<br />
of its Regional Sales Managers and Sales<br />
Engineers. Taylor also reports to Barnette.<br />
Also, Mike Noe has joined AMAG<br />
as Northeast Regional Sales Engineer.<br />
He is responsible for providing pre-sales<br />
technical and consultative support to the<br />
Northeast Regional Sales Manager<br />
On- and Off-Street Meters<br />
PCI Compliant Data Security<br />
Advanced Power Management<br />
Enforcement System Integration<br />
See how the fourth largest city in North<br />
America has benefited from implementing<br />
solutions from Digital Payment Technologies.<br />
www.digitalpaytech.com/casestudy.pdf<br />
888.687.6822 | digitalpaytech.com<br />
regarding new sales opportunities.<br />
Michael Johnson has joined Carl<br />
Walker Inc. in its Dallas office as a Senior<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Manager. Before joining the<br />
company, he had headed the <strong>Parking</strong><br />
Services Group for Walter P. Moore.<br />
Before that, he spent several years with<br />
International <strong>Parking</strong> Design in California.<br />
Johnson is an active member of the<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Consultants Council of the<br />
National <strong>Parking</strong> Association, the<br />
International <strong>Parking</strong> Institute and<br />
other industry-related associations.<br />
McMahon Associates has promoted<br />
Jennifer Walsh, P.E., to Senior<br />
Project Manager and Brian DiBiase,<br />
P.E., PTOE, to Project Manager.<br />
Walsh has been an important contributor<br />
to McMahon’s traffic department<br />
for more than six years. She has<br />
helped build McMahon’s data collection<br />
efforts in the Mid-Atlantic region,<br />
and has managed projects from smaller<br />
traffic-impact studies to larger corridor<br />
and point-of-access studies.<br />
DiBiase has been with the firm for<br />
eight years.<br />
Akçelik &Associates has received<br />
the 2008 Governor of Victoria (Australia)<br />
Export Awards Commendation,<br />
Small Business Award. Its director,<br />
Rahmi Akçelik, received the Contribution<br />
to the Transportation Profession<br />
Award for the ITE Australia & New<br />
Zealand Section.<br />
KSW Microtec, one of the world’s<br />
leading suppliers of RFID components,<br />
said it had a remarkable year that saw<br />
the release of a host of innovative<br />
RFID-based products, including the<br />
optimized RFID-based VarioSens label,<br />
the industry’s first flexible temperature<br />
data logger; the eGO dual-frequency<br />
(HF/UHF) contactless transponder for<br />
merging long-distance applications<br />
with proximity access and security; and<br />
the Thinlam, the exceptionally thin<br />
prelaminate for contactless ID card and<br />
government applications, which the<br />
company says sets new standards for<br />
card manufacturing.<br />
The Portland Cement Association<br />
(PCA) Board of Directors elected<br />
Enrique Escalante as Chairman during<br />
the association’s fall board meeting<br />
in Dallas. He will serve a two-year<br />
term as PCA chairman, succeeding<br />
Charlie Sunderland of Ash Grove<br />
Cement Co. Escalante is President of<br />
GCC of America in Denver. He<br />
joined GCC in 1999 as President of its<br />
Mexican division, moving to his current<br />
position in 2000. Before joining<br />
GCC, Escalante had more than 20<br />
years’ experience in management and<br />
sales positions in heavy-industry and<br />
construction materials.<br />
Bill Osborne has joined Digital<br />
Monitoring Products (DMP) as Mid-<br />
Atlantic Regional Sales Manager. He<br />
will be responsible for developing new<br />
sales and providing on-going service to<br />
DMP-authorized dealers in Kentucky,<br />
10<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
Send information for this section to: Editor@parkingtoday.com<br />
North Carolina, Virginia, West Virginia and Tennessee. “Bill has<br />
enormous experience in the industry and has been interacting<br />
with clients for many years as sales manager for other organizations,”<br />
said Jeff McAleer, DMP Vice President of Sales.<br />
Timothy Haahs & Associates has been awarded a significant<br />
expansion project for the Tampa Port Authority. The<br />
company joined the Manhattan Construction and HKS<br />
Architects team to design this crucial infrastructure project.<br />
The TPA’s Channelside Garage expansion is a complex designbuild<br />
project consisting of a five-tier horizontal expansion to<br />
an existing garage for about 720 additional spaces. The expansion<br />
will serve the growing number of cruise travelers and<br />
associated traffic at the port and the Channelside District. The<br />
ground level features daytime parking for buses and limousines,<br />
and nighttime valet parking. The upper tiers will be used<br />
for public and valet parking at the owner’s option.<br />
The Town of Bay Harbor Islands, FL, is building a<br />
long-awaited four-story parking garage at 95th Street<br />
between Bay Harbor Terrace and West Bay Harbor Drive.<br />
The project was celebrated with a groundbreaking ceremony<br />
Dec. 9 to commemorate the start of construction. TimHaahs<br />
is serving as the prime designer, providing full architectural<br />
and parking design services for this new facility.<br />
In continued efforts to be a resource to concrete design<br />
and construction professionals, the American Concrete Institute<br />
(ACI) has announced several goals, programs and initiatives<br />
to provide knowledge on the sustainable properties of<br />
concrete to its members and the concrete industry as a whole.<br />
ACI agrees with a common definition (Brundtland Commission,<br />
1987) of sustainable development: “Development that<br />
meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability<br />
of future generations to meet their own needs.”<br />
Skidata distributor Sentry Control Systems installed<br />
LEED-compatible parking systems at the Molasky Corporate<br />
Center project recently completed in Las Vegas, The<br />
six-level, 1,450-space parking garage features 150 photovoltaic<br />
panels on its roof, which generate a portion of the<br />
building’s electricity. Sentry’s Tim Flanagan said, “We take<br />
pride in delivering parking solutions that help reduce total<br />
carbon emissions. Our equipment is made of durable, abuseresistant<br />
materials that help reduce maintenance calls and<br />
costs. Systems can be configured as paperless operations<br />
and provide remote monitoring and control.” Equipment<br />
installed by Sentry included Skidata entry/exit columns and<br />
classic automatic pay stations, with Tagmaster LR6 Readers<br />
and real-time credit card authorization.<br />
Corey Gase, with nine years of experience as a technical<br />
engineer, brings a wide range of valuable training to his<br />
position for Skidata-St. Louis. Gase, who serves the St.<br />
Louis Trading Area, is responsible for all service-related<br />
issues, maintenance and upkeep of existing Skidata equipment<br />
and software, as well as customer service.<br />
Grace Construction Products (GCP), a worldwide leader<br />
in products and services for the construction industry, has promoted<br />
Michael D. Ragan to Vice President, Global Ready-Mix<br />
and was appointed to the GCP Leadership Team effective Jan. 1.<br />
Walker <strong>Parking</strong> Consultants has been awarded a project<br />
to provide parking design services for the proposed 1,500-<br />
space parking deck at the James A. Haley Veterans Hospital<br />
in Tampa. The structure will serve the parking needs of<br />
patients, employees and visitors to the hospital. Walker’s respon-<br />
Continued on Page 12<br />
AIMS<br />
AIMS <strong>Parking</strong> Management<br />
Solutions<br />
www.edc-aim.com<br />
University, Municipal, Hospital,<br />
Airport and Private <strong>Parking</strong><br />
Professionals throughout North America<br />
manage their parking operation with AIMS.<br />
AIMS Ticket Management streamlines parking enforcement<br />
through automated billings, payments, voids, appeals,<br />
letter generation, and reporting.<br />
Choose from one of our AIMS Ticketer Ensembles for<br />
on-street ticket issuance and electronic tire chalking with<br />
automated ticket upload to AIMS or your in-house parking<br />
management software.<br />
AIMS Permit Management simplifies permit issuance,<br />
payments, and invoicing. AIMS maintains lot and permit<br />
inventories, multiple waiting lists, generates custom<br />
correspondence, and provides detailed reports.<br />
AIMS Web+ is your complete solution for online permit<br />
registration, ticket appeals and payments with complete<br />
parking account review. Our e-commerce solution is<br />
designed to enhance your customer service while reducing<br />
office traffic.<br />
AIMS is available for use with Oracle or MS SQL databases<br />
and integrates with your R/O lookup agency, DMV, collection<br />
agency, gate arm software, SCT Banner, PeopleSoft, custom<br />
finance packages, print shops, and cashiering software.<br />
Customer Service and User-Friendly products drive<br />
University – Municipal – Hospital – Airport –<br />
Private Operators to AIMS.<br />
Visit www.edc-aim.com for more information.<br />
Contact us at sales@edc-aim.com or 800.886.6316 to<br />
book a product tour.<br />
EDC Corporation<br />
ELECTRONIC DATA COLLECTION CORP.<br />
EAST COAST<br />
WEST COAST<br />
13 Dwight Park Drive 42196 Roanoke Street<br />
Syracuse, New York 13209 Temecula, California 92591<br />
800-886-6316 | Fax (315) 706-0330 877-277-6771<br />
CANADA<br />
www.edc-aim.com<br />
70 Wakelin Terrace sales@edc-aim.com<br />
St. Catharines, Ontario L2M 4K9<br />
(905) 931-4085 | Fax: (905) 931-4086<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com 11
PEOPLE IN PARKING<br />
from Page 11<br />
sibilities for the project will include functional, structural and<br />
mechanical design. Architectural, civil and landscape design services<br />
will be provided by HDR Inc. Walker also was awarded a<br />
project to provide design services for the VA hospital campus in<br />
Gainesville, FL. Walker will work in conjunction with AKEA Inc.<br />
to provide it with a new 650-space stand-alone parking structure.<br />
Kimley-Horn andAssociates, an engineering, planning and<br />
environmental consulting firm, has hired Forrest Hibbard, P.E.,<br />
as Senior <strong>Parking</strong> Planner in its Atlanta Midtown office. With<br />
more than 30 years of civil engineering experience, Hibbard specializes<br />
in parking planning and design, including programming<br />
for phased mixed-use parking and master planning for campus<br />
environments. Before joining the firm, he worked for Walker<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Consultants and Carl Walker Inc.<br />
Kenneth Elbert Zimmerman<br />
Kenneth Elbert Zimmerman, P.E., died Dec. 17 in Houston.<br />
He was 95. The 1934 graduate of Texas A&M University was a<br />
consulting engineer with the firm of Walter P. Moore and Associates<br />
from 1946 to his retirement in 1982. During his tenure, Zimmerman<br />
was the structural engineer-of-record for the Houston<br />
Astrodome, the Jesse H. Jones Hall for the Performing Arts, Rice<br />
Stadium, The Warwick Hotel and many more sites in Houston. He<br />
was a registered engineer and architect in Texas and a registered<br />
engineer in Indiana, Virginia and South Carolina.<br />
PT<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Attendant<br />
Impersonators<br />
Milwaukee has a bit of a problem. It has some vacant cityowned<br />
lots near major attractions (the symphony hall, arts center,<br />
etc.) and it doesn’t want anyone parking on them.<br />
Local “entrepreneurs” are setting up business on the lots,<br />
using legit-looking uniforms and even “traffic direction” flashlights<br />
to direct folks into the lots. They collect $10 a head and<br />
then leave when the lot is full.<br />
The city then comes by and tickets the cars in the lots since<br />
they are parking illegally. Makes perfect sense, doesn’t it? OK,<br />
city officials voided the tickets after they found out about the<br />
scam.<br />
PT Editor comments:<br />
1. Where were the police, and why didn’t they question the<br />
practice?<br />
2. <strong>Parking</strong> enforcement folks ticketed a group of cars at 3<br />
p.m. (matinee concert) and a second group at 8 p.m. (evening<br />
concert). Didn’t anyone realize there was a problem here?<br />
3. Why not simply lease out the lots for periods of time that<br />
the spaces are needed (during concerts, etc.) and let the practice<br />
proceed?<br />
4. If private (though illegal) enterprise can make parking<br />
work in the area, why can’t the city?<br />
5. They voided 135 tickets on that day – that’s $1,350 that<br />
the group collected. Seems like that’s a business the city would<br />
want a piece of.<br />
RELIABLE<br />
exceed expectations. consistently.<br />
Our clients entrust us with their operations. It’s a responsibility we don’t<br />
take lightly. Because you rely on us, it’s critical that we deliver—day in, day out.<br />
Consistently achieving results. Performing beyond expectations.<br />
Nationally and internationally, ACS works hand-in-hand with its clients, combining<br />
operational expertise with cutting-edge technology to create comprehensive,<br />
customized parking programs. Solutions you can rely on. People you trust.<br />
Contact us at 1-800-368-2003 or parking.usa@acs-inc.com.<br />
www.acs-inc.com<br />
Copyright 2008 ACS.
Houston <strong>Parking</strong> Teamwork<br />
Leads to Recognition, Promotion<br />
Have a parking question in Houston? There was a time when<br />
you had to determine whether to contact the police, public works,<br />
finance and administration, or municipal courts. Once a fractured<br />
division, Houston’s <strong>Parking</strong> Management Division has made significant<br />
strides in the past three years.<br />
The country’s largest deployment of pay-and-display meters<br />
has led to unprecedented revenue growth and national recognition.<br />
The contribution of individual team members, under the<br />
leadership of Liliana Rambo, CAPP, has been recognized with<br />
recent promotions.<br />
Carlos Medel began working with collections in municipal<br />
courts in 2002 and transferred to <strong>Parking</strong> Management’s customer<br />
service. He draws on that experience to serve as the supervisor<br />
of the newly established permitting section.<br />
As liaison for Houston’s Public <strong>Parking</strong> Commission, Melonie<br />
Curry has gained knowledge of the many facets of the parking<br />
industry and stakeholder involvement. As the division’s new<br />
administrative specialist, she will facilitate customer service<br />
requests, coordinate petitions for Residential Permit <strong>Parking</strong><br />
areas and continue to support the activities of the <strong>Parking</strong> Commission.<br />
James Connolly has utilized his Las Vegas security experience<br />
to become the evening enforcement supervisor. Kevia<br />
Stroder’s seven years of experience as a New Orleans senior parking<br />
control officer has lead to her promotion as enforcement<br />
leader for the evening shift. Earline Jones was added to provide<br />
administrative support for enforcement.<br />
With eight years of project management for revenue control<br />
installations including the Houston Airport System, Jerry Keeth<br />
led the successful deployment of pay-and-display meters. Keeth<br />
has now earned the title of Administrative Manager for Meter<br />
Operations. The experience that Nicole Chinea gained in Florida<br />
in code enforcement and permitting, storage lots, and parking<br />
enforcement led to her ability to provide the coordination<br />
required for the meter project. She now serves as the assistant<br />
superintendent for Meter Operations.<br />
As new Financial Analyst, Catherine Brown adds her experience<br />
in strategic purchasing for the state of Texas.<br />
Marketplace Ads in PT are Placed<br />
Immediately On our Web Site<br />
www.parkingtoday.com<br />
Increase <strong>Parking</strong> Revenue<br />
300 %<br />
275 %<br />
250 %<br />
225 %<br />
200 %<br />
175 %<br />
150 %<br />
125 %<br />
Get Results<br />
with AutoVu<br />
The AutoVu LPR solution by<br />
Genetec allows you to<br />
significantly increase parking<br />
revenues.With the most<br />
accurate license plate<br />
recognition technology,<br />
AutoVu automatically<br />
identifies vehicles at entries<br />
and exits, eliminating client<br />
and employee fraud at your<br />
parking facility. Find out how<br />
Genetec’s AutoVu solutions<br />
can dramatically facilitate the<br />
management of your parking<br />
facility at www.genetec.com<br />
100 %<br />
14<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
POWER<br />
The computer ‘ON’ button. With it you have access to a<br />
portfolio of information management tools critical in today’s<br />
business climate. That portfolio just welcomed its newest<br />
member.<br />
Introducing entervo by Scheidt & Bachmann. It will become<br />
the benchmark by which <strong>Parking</strong> and Access Management<br />
will be measured for years to come.<br />
Sounds incredible?<br />
It is. And we can prove it.<br />
By just pushing the ‘ON’ button.<br />
SOFTWARE. HARDWARE. EVERYWHERE.
Tough Times Call for<br />
Smart Technologies<br />
BY NEIL PODMORE<br />
THE PAST FEW YEARS<br />
have seen the evolution of<br />
pay-by-cell technology<br />
from small-scale trials to<br />
cost-effective revenue control<br />
solution deployed in major cities<br />
around the world. It is estimated that more<br />
than 25 million on-street parking sessions<br />
were paid by phone in 2008, worth an<br />
approximate $55 million, with more than<br />
half of these transactions originating from<br />
Europe but with rapid growth in North<br />
America.<br />
Major U.S. cities such as Miami, San Francisco<br />
have either fully deployed or are in trials with<br />
pay-by-cell technology. It is interesting that tough<br />
economic times led to the last significant change in<br />
on-street revenue control; the introduction of the<br />
coin-operated parking meter in 1935, and that the<br />
current economic climate will spur similar demand<br />
for cost-effective solutions to on-street revenue<br />
control.<br />
Some verifiable results that illustrate the economic<br />
benefits of pay-by-cell phone can be<br />
observed in these major deployments:<br />
• Westminster, London, UK – Net revenue<br />
increase of $12 million per year from eliminating<br />
coin losses and lower operating and capital expenses.<br />
80% parking payments by cell phone.<br />
• Vancouver, BC, Canada – Some 4,000 daily<br />
transactions paid by cell phone across 8,000 coinonly<br />
meters. Average payment by cell is 44% higher<br />
than coin payment ($2.60 vs. $1.80).<br />
• Miami –Citywide deployment across 12,000<br />
on-street parking spaces without significant capital<br />
investment or changes to current meter installations.<br />
In common with many new technologies, early pay-by-cell<br />
service providers competed to establish different operating platforms<br />
and systems. There are still some significant variations,<br />
but the differences are narrowing as the industry settles around<br />
the successful and practical methodologies. However, the commonly<br />
accepted approach to pay-by-cell service is now:<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> and payment is activated by using a cell phone to<br />
send a short message service (SMS), call an automated voice system<br />
(AVS) or by mobile web browser. Research has shown that<br />
more than 90% of drivers in major cities carry cell phones.<br />
The service is usually deployed as an alternative that can<br />
lead to a phased reduction of current systems, allowing drivers to<br />
make the transition when they choose to.<br />
There is no need to upgrade or integrate with the current<br />
meters. The cell phone system does not update the meter with<br />
payment information, since this would be costly and incur ongoing<br />
connectivity costs for every meter.<br />
Payment status is determined by issuing staff with webenabled<br />
cell phones or PDAs or by using existing ticket-writers.<br />
Officers can list paid license plates space numbers for a particular<br />
zone or by individual vehicle/space.<br />
There are of course variations; some systems issue drivers a<br />
bar code or RFID tag that is queried, rather than tracking by<br />
vehicle plate or space. Some modern multi-space/pay-anddisplay<br />
back-office systems have the ability to integrate with<br />
Continued on Page 18<br />
16<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
Tough Times Call for Smart<br />
Technologies<br />
from Page 16<br />
pay-by-cell systems so that transaction information can be<br />
shared across both systems. However, there is an obvious complexity<br />
and cost to these variations; the “standard” service<br />
requires no integration or supply of devices to the driver.<br />
The increasing expansion of pay-by-cell usage by both<br />
municipalities and private parking operators has been driven by<br />
a number of key factors:<br />
1. Capital Budget Savings: Typically pay-by-cell services<br />
require no capital budget. Revenue for the pay-by-cell operator<br />
is generated on a per transaction basis, paid by either the driver<br />
as part of a value-added service or the municipality from higher<br />
revenues and lower costs.<br />
2. Operational Savings: Reducing or eliminating the use of<br />
coins lowers collection and maintenance costs, and losses from<br />
coin theft.<br />
3. Revenue Increase: Many cities have seen the average payby-cell<br />
payments 30% higher than the average coin payment.<br />
This statistic is shared with many industry studies that show a<br />
card payment option creates higher dollar-value payments. Make<br />
it easy and drivers pay more.<br />
4. Flexible Tariffs: A growing aspect of pay-by-cell technology<br />
is the ability to set different tariffs for different drivers. Since<br />
every user on a pay-by-cell system has a unique profile, they<br />
also can have unique payment profiles based, for example, on<br />
whether they are residents or businesses from a specific area. In<br />
some cities, drivers of low-emission vehicles can pay lower<br />
parking tariffs. It is not just tariffs that can be tweaked; by-laws<br />
can vary for different users such as disabled or elderly drivers.<br />
The ability to generate meaningful information is a powerful<br />
benefit of modern parking revenue control systems. Analysis<br />
of street-level parking activity on a transaction by transaction<br />
basis is a core component of any pay-by-cell system that can be<br />
used to guide the informed decision making needed for framing<br />
and updating parking policies.<br />
The features of pay-by-cell systems vary more widely than<br />
the operating methodology or benefits that are largely common<br />
to all. Apart from the obvious aspects of reliability, reputation<br />
and value, the feature-set is an area that municipalities should<br />
look at closely to see which best meets their requirements. At a<br />
minimum, these features should be part of the overall service<br />
platform:<br />
• Remind drivers by SMS text message before parking time<br />
expires and enable parking time to be added without returning to<br />
the car, subject to stay restrictions. It’s an open argument as to<br />
whether reminding drivers before parking expires reduces the<br />
number of parking infractions. But making it easier for drivers<br />
to follow and comply with the parking and transport policies is<br />
undoubtedly key to allowing the effects of the policy to be realized.<br />
Excessive parking infractions are typically a sign of a policy<br />
that has failed, unless it was specifically designed to maximize<br />
the number of infractions (and I hope that we have moved<br />
beyond that approach).<br />
• By-law and rate support: The system needs to support the<br />
rate structure and by-laws, such as maximum stays and restricted<br />
parking hours, so that payment by cell phone is subject to the<br />
same limits in place for metered transactions. In many ways,<br />
compliance is improved. For example a pay-by-cell service<br />
should block a driver from adding more time by phone once the<br />
maximum stay period has expired or purchasing time into a<br />
commuter lane restriction time period.<br />
• Real-time enforcement data: The payment data must be<br />
available in real time for enforcement officers.<br />
• Back-office systems: Typically, accounting and operational<br />
reports, rates and by-law administration and customer-service<br />
interfaces are available via a secure web browser interface<br />
so the only IT requirement is to have Internet access, there is no<br />
need to install software or servers in the local offices.<br />
• The future looks promising for pay-by-cell and electronic<br />
parking payments in general, and it is now feasible to envisage,<br />
as some cites have done, the elimination of the parking meter.<br />
The advent of drivers and vehicles that can “connect” easily<br />
and reliably to a remote payment system is clearly the end of the<br />
traditional parking meter system, just as surely as the Internet<br />
has eroded the concept of the retail travel agent. “What do you<br />
mean I have to walk down the street to book my flight?” is a<br />
short step from “What do you mean I have to walk down the<br />
street to pay for my parking?”<br />
The parallels are stronger by the day. It’s even possible to<br />
envisage that if the street is half empty, you will get a better<br />
price; and the opposite: if there is only one space left, expect to<br />
pay a bit more. It’s partly about yield management, but for<br />
municipalities, it’s also about using smart pricing to influence<br />
parking behavior.<br />
Neil Podmore is a Vice President with Verrus Mobile Technologies<br />
and can be reached at npodmore@verrus.com.<br />
PT<br />
18<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
PT BLOG<br />
JVH comments on <strong>Parking</strong> News every day at PT Blog –<br />
log on at www.parkingtoday.com. Each month, there are<br />
at least 40 other comments like these, posted daily.<br />
‘Unfair hospital car parking charges were in<br />
effect a tax on ill-health’<br />
That headline is a quote from Nicola Sturgeon, health secretary<br />
in the Scottish government. She is saying that if you charge<br />
people to park, you are then in essence “taxing” them for being<br />
sick.<br />
I suppose then that it’s also true that if a person has a<br />
headache, then charging them for an aspirin is “taxing” them for<br />
being sick. So it would follow that all over-the-counter meds<br />
should be free, because we don’t want to “tax” someone who has<br />
stubbed their toe, or has a hangover, or a hangnail.<br />
The UK has “free” health care. Well, what they really have<br />
is a government-run insurance program that forces you to pay for<br />
the insurance and then use the doctors and hospitals that they tell<br />
you. The insurance is paid through your income taxes, some of<br />
the highest anywhere, and if you would prefer to buy private<br />
insurance, you are on your own. You have to pay for the governments<br />
insurance first, and then buy private insurance out of<br />
what’s left. But I digress.<br />
It’s little wonder that parking has now become a “right” and<br />
that it is up to the medical insurance system to pay for those who<br />
elect to drive to the hospital. Let’s see if I get this right. Everyone<br />
pays the same amount (as a percentage of income) for their<br />
health care. However, those who take a cab or bus or walk, pay<br />
for the parking for those who drive. How is that fair?<br />
I’m sure that Nicola hasn’t considered the issues of “free”<br />
parking, not only some paying for others, but the fact that it isn’t<br />
“green,” the fact that it causes congestion, and the fact that what<br />
started all this charging for parking half a decade ago was the<br />
fact that there wasn’t any parking space at the hospitals, since<br />
locals were parking “free” in the hospital lots and garages and<br />
taking all the space needed for ambulances, doctors and, dare I<br />
say it, patients.<br />
I guarantee that the hue and cry will be very loud the first<br />
time someone who needs emergency medical care can’t find a<br />
place to park. Stay tuned.<br />
JVH<br />
Can’t Happen in Plattsburgh<br />
I took a stroll around the neighborhood with my neighbor<br />
this mid-December morning. He’s in some kind of financial business.<br />
Of course, the conversation got around to the economy.<br />
The world it seems is awash with cash. It all came out of the<br />
markets and is in banks, pillowcases, government bonds, etc. No<br />
one wants to invest because they are afraid.<br />
Yes, fear is driving the recession, nothing else.<br />
Continued on Page 46<br />
v<br />
DESMAN<br />
T R A N S P O R T A T I O N<br />
TRAFFIC ENGINEERS • TRANSPORTATION PLANNERS<br />
PARKING CONSULTANTS<br />
• TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDIES<br />
• SITE ACCESS & CIRCULATION ANALYSIS<br />
• PARKING STUDIES<br />
• MICRO-SIMULATION MODELING<br />
• CORRIDOR STUDIES<br />
• MASTER TRANSPORTATION PLANS<br />
• ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ANALYSIS<br />
New York<br />
212.686.5360<br />
Cleveland<br />
216.736.7110<br />
Chicago<br />
312.263.8400<br />
Boston<br />
617.778.9882<br />
Denver<br />
303.740.1700<br />
Hartford<br />
860.563.1117<br />
W W W . D E S M A N . C O M<br />
WashingtonDC<br />
703.448.1190<br />
Las Vegas<br />
877.337.6260<br />
20<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
Single Space Meter Solutions<br />
AutoCITE X3 Handheld for<br />
Issuance and Maintenance<br />
>> METERS<br />
>> HANDHELDS<br />
>> PROCESSING<br />
>> COLLECTIONS<br />
I N T E G R A T E D S O L U T I O N S for<br />
Duncan Solutions is a premier provider<br />
Secure<br />
Citation Processing<br />
Delinquent<br />
Debt Collections<br />
of integrated, end-to-end solutions for<br />
on-street parking programs. From single<br />
and multi-space meters and meter management<br />
solutions through full lifecycle<br />
citation management—issuance, processing,<br />
and collections—Duncan leads the<br />
industry for advanced technology, durability,<br />
security, and low environmental impact.<br />
For solutions that generate enhanced<br />
O N - S T R E E T P A R K I N G<br />
program revenues year after year, Duncan<br />
Solutions is your strategic partner of choice.<br />
Pay-by-Space and<br />
Pay-and-Display<br />
Multi-Space Meters<br />
888.993.8622<br />
www.duncansolutions.com
The Price of Parkin<br />
BY DONALD SHOUP<br />
H<br />
OW CAN CURB PARKING CONtribute<br />
to making a street great? A<br />
city can (1) charge performancebased<br />
prices for curb parking and<br />
(2) return the revenue to the metered<br />
districts to pay for added public services. With these<br />
two policies, curb parking will help to create great<br />
streets, improve transportation, and increase the economic<br />
vitality of cities.<br />
Performance <strong>Parking</strong> Prices<br />
Performance-based prices can balance the varying demand<br />
for parking with the fixed supply of curb spaces. We can call this<br />
balance between demand and supply the “Goldilocks principle”<br />
of parking prices: the price is too high if many spaces are vacant,<br />
and too low if no spaces are vacant. When a few vacant spaces<br />
are available everywhere, the prices are just right. After the city<br />
adjusts prices to yield one or two vacant spaces in every block<br />
(about 85 percent occupancy), everyone will see that curb parking<br />
is readily available. In addition, no one can say that performance<br />
parking prices will drive customers away if almost all curb<br />
spaces are occupied.<br />
Prices that produce an occupancy rate of about 85 percent<br />
can be called “performance-based” for three reasons. First, curb<br />
parking will perform efficiently. The spaces will be well used but<br />
readily available. Second, the transportation system will perform<br />
efficiently. Cruising for underpriced curb parking will not congest<br />
traffic, waste fuel, and pollute the air. Third, the economy<br />
will perform efficiently. The price of parking will be higher when<br />
demand is higher, and this higher price will encourage rapid<br />
parking turnover. Drivers will park, buy something, and leave<br />
quickly so that other drivers can use the spaces. Cities can<br />
achieve all these goals by setting curb parking prices to yield<br />
about an 85 percent occupancy rate.<br />
Local Revenue Return<br />
Performance prices for curb parking can yield ample public<br />
revenue. If the city returns this revenue to pay for added public<br />
spending on the metered streets, citizens are more likely to support<br />
the performance prices. The added funds can pay to clean<br />
and maintain the sidewalks, plant trees, improve lighting, bury<br />
overhead utility wires, remove graffiti, and provide other public<br />
improvements.<br />
Put yourself in the shoes of a merchant in an older business<br />
district where curb parking is free and customers complain about<br />
a parking shortage. Suppose the city installs meters and begins to<br />
charge prices that produce a few vacancies. Everyone who wants<br />
to shop in the district can park quickly, and the city spends the<br />
meter money to clean the sidewalks and provide security. These<br />
added public services make the business district a place where<br />
people want to be, rather than merely a place where anyone can<br />
park free if they can find a space. Returning the meter revenue<br />
generated by the district to the district for the district’s own use<br />
can help to convince merchants and property owners to support<br />
performance prices for curb parking.<br />
Suppose also that curb parking remains free in other business<br />
districts. Everyone complains about the shortage of parking,<br />
and drivers congest traffic and pollute the air while they search<br />
for curb parking. The city has no meter revenue to clean the sidewalks<br />
and provide other amenities. In which district would you<br />
want to have a business?<br />
Performance prices will improve curb parking by creating a<br />
few vacancies, the added meter revenue will pay to improve public<br />
services, and these added public services will create political<br />
support for performance prices.<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Increment Finance<br />
Most cities put their parking meter revenue into the city’s<br />
general fund. How can a city return meter revenue to business<br />
districts without shortchanging the general fund? The city can<br />
return only the subsequent increment in meter revenue–the<br />
amount above and beyond the existing meter revenue–that arises<br />
after the city begins to charge performance prices. We can call<br />
this arrangement parking increment finance.<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> increment finance closely resembles tax increment<br />
finance, a popular way to pay for public investment in districts in<br />
need of revitalization. Local redevelopment agencies receive the<br />
increment in property tax revenue that results from the increased<br />
property values in the redevelopment districts. Similarly, business<br />
districts can receive the increment in parking meter revenue<br />
that results from performance parking prices.<br />
More meters, higher rates, and longer hours of operation<br />
will provide money to pay for added public services. These<br />
22<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
g on a Great Street<br />
added public services will promote business activity in the district,<br />
and the increased demand for parking will further increase<br />
meter revenue.<br />
Performance <strong>Parking</strong> Prices in Practice<br />
Some cities have begun to charge performance prices for<br />
curb parking and return the meter revenue to its source. Redwood<br />
City, California, sets meter rates<br />
to achieve an 85 percent occupancy<br />
rate for curb parking<br />
downtown; the rates differ both<br />
by location and time of day,<br />
depending on demand. The city<br />
returns the revenue to the<br />
metered district to pay for public<br />
parking structures, police protection,<br />
and cleaner sidewalks.<br />
Merchants and property<br />
owners all supported the new policy when they learned the meter<br />
revenue would pay for added public services in the downtown<br />
business district, and the city council adopted it unanimously.<br />
Performance prices create a few curb vacancies so visitors can<br />
easily find a space, the added meter revenue pays to improve public<br />
services, and these added public services create political support<br />
for the performance prices.<br />
Redwood City’s<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Ordinance<br />
To accomplish the goal of managing the supply<br />
of parking and to make it reasonably available<br />
when and where needed, a target occupancy rate<br />
of eighty-five percent (85%) is hereby established.<br />
The <strong>Parking</strong> Manager shall survey the average<br />
occupancy for each parking area in the Downtown<br />
Meter Zone that has parking meters. Based<br />
on the survey results, the <strong>Parking</strong> Manager shall<br />
adjust the rates up or down in twenty-five cent<br />
($0.25) intervals to seek to achieve the target<br />
occupancy rate.<br />
Revenues generated from on-street and off-street<br />
parking within the Downtown Meter Zone<br />
boundaries shall be accounted for separately<br />
from other City funds and may be used only<br />
within or for the benefit of the Downtown Core<br />
Meter Zone.<br />
Sections 20.120 and 20.121 of the Redwood City<br />
Municipal Code<br />
We can call the balance<br />
between demand and supply<br />
the “Goldilocks principle”<br />
of parking prices.<br />
Most cities keep their meter rates constant throughout the<br />
day and let occupancy rates vary in response to demand. Instead,<br />
cities can vary their meter prices to keep occupancy constant at<br />
about 85 percent. The goal is to balance supply and demand<br />
everywhere, all the time. Most cities also limit the length of stay<br />
at meters so long-term parkers won’t monopolize the underpriced<br />
curb spaces. But after Redwood City adjusted meter rates to guarantee<br />
the availability of curb<br />
spaces, it removed the time limits<br />
at meters.<br />
This unlimited-time policy<br />
has turned out to be popular<br />
with drivers who can now park<br />
for as long as they are willing to<br />
pay. The demand-determined<br />
meter rates create turnover at<br />
the most convenient curb<br />
spaces, and long-term parkers<br />
tend to choose the cheaper spaces in off-street lots.<br />
Other cities have also begun to adjust their meter rates to<br />
ensure the availability of curb parking. The U.S. Department of<br />
Transportation has awarded grants to Chicago, Los Angeles, and<br />
San Francisco to test performance prices for curb parking, and<br />
Washington, D.C., has already started them. Pasadena and San<br />
Diego return meter revenues to enhance public services in the<br />
metered districts.<br />
Any city can use a pilot program to test Goldilocks parking<br />
prices for curb parking. All the city has to do is allow any business<br />
district that requests a pilot program to have one. It won’t<br />
cost the city anything, because the meters pay for themselves.<br />
Dirty and unsafe streets will never be great, so the city can initially<br />
use the meter revenue to pay for clean-and-safe programs.<br />
Many communities may value clean and safe sidewalks<br />
more highly than free but overcrowded curb parking. After the<br />
community is clean and safe, the parking revenue can pay for<br />
urban amenities such as street trees, underground utilities, and<br />
public transit improvements. <strong>Parking</strong> on a great street may not be<br />
free, but it will be convenient and worth the price.<br />
For additional reading on this topic log on to<br />
www.parkingtoday.com click on “magazine”, search articles,<br />
and enter “Shoup”. You will find this article in our archives.<br />
Numerous links and references are listed.<br />
Donald Shoup, FAICP, is professor of urban planning at the<br />
University of California, Los Angeles. He has written many books<br />
and articles on parking, including The High Cost of Free <strong>Parking</strong><br />
(Planners Press, 2005), which explains the theory and practice of<br />
parking management. He can be reached at shoup@ucla.edu<br />
This article was adapted from a chapter in Planetizen<br />
Contemporary Debates in Urban Planning, edited by Abhijeet<br />
Chavan, Christian Peralta, and Christopher Steins. Washington, DC:<br />
Island Press, 2007, pp. 52–56.<br />
PT<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com 23
Remaining “Service-Focused”<br />
in Tough Economic Times<br />
BY JOE SCIULLI<br />
The phone rings: “How much more can you give me from the parking program?”<br />
comes the voice from the other end. “Nothing, Mr. Mayor,” says the parking director.<br />
Five minutes later, it rings again. “How much more can you give me from the<br />
parking program?” asks the mayor of the new parking director!<br />
IN THE CURRENT ECONOMY, WITH<br />
pressures mounting to raise public revenue<br />
and cut services, the municipal on-street<br />
parking program is fair game – and hunting<br />
season has been declared!<br />
Meanwhile, there is the city’s parking director – supposedly<br />
the advocate for parking equity, availability and customer service.<br />
He or she may have some tough decisions to make, especially<br />
when the phone rings and it’s the mayor calling. “Justify”<br />
meter-rate and ticket-fine increases? Cut staff? Reduce or defray<br />
planned maintenance?<br />
To be sure, a parking program is always in the cross-hairs,<br />
and some city officials might see only the dollars and cents –<br />
rather than the parking management sense – of asking for more<br />
revenue from increased fines, meter rates, “more tickets” or<br />
staffing cuts.<br />
But the opinion here is that the parking leader must above all<br />
protect the program’s integrity and be proactive to resist pressure<br />
from those who might see the program only as a cash-cow to be<br />
milked dry during tough economic times, or at anytime when<br />
parking conditions on the street do not warrant pricing and policy<br />
changes.<br />
So how can a parking leader resist the temptation to make<br />
unwarranted changes to policies or operations?<br />
The short answer is that it requires a strong-willed leader<br />
who has paved the way with all parking stakeholders through<br />
education and action; one who can make the most persuasive<br />
argument from a position of facts as to whether changes in parking<br />
prices, policies, operations and budgets are warranted.<br />
As to the longer answer, here are eight proven approaches,<br />
from what literally could be hundreds, to help the parking leader<br />
make wise decisions in tough economic times.<br />
1. Routinely collect and analyze your on-street parking<br />
activity indicators and maintain these statistics over time.<br />
This is step one. As a great parking director once said, “You can’t<br />
manage what you don’t measure.” Occupancy and violation rates<br />
provide feedback on the appropriateness of meter rates, regulated<br />
parking limits and enforcement activities. This knowledge creates<br />
a climate for continual improvement. The violation capture<br />
rate, as a measure of enforcement efficiency and when analyzed<br />
in concert with other indicators, can indicate how well enforcement<br />
beats are designed, patrolled and supervised.<br />
2. Compare your program’s indicators with its own history<br />
(if available), and with selected norms for on-street parking<br />
activity indicators. Developing these benchmarks lays the<br />
foundation for internal management improvements; also, having<br />
trend data may help you win approval for programmatic changes<br />
that may be needed in the future. These norms can be found in<br />
Chapter 4: <strong>Parking</strong> Surveys and Studies in the IPI publication<br />
“<strong>Parking</strong> 101: A <strong>Parking</strong> Primer.” Suggested norms also have<br />
been provided in the <strong>Parking</strong> Industry Exhibition’s On-Street<br />
Boot Camp sessions (materials available through <strong>Parking</strong> <strong>Today</strong><br />
or by contacting the author). If your program’s indicators are generally<br />
within these norms, chances are your program is working<br />
toward its potential. If not, an offering of potential causes and<br />
remedies are indicated in the norms matrix.<br />
Continued on Page 26<br />
24<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
transform<br />
chaos<br />
parking<br />
control<br />
into<br />
Main Street, USA:<br />
The StreetSmart Portal provides a<br />
powerful view of the city’s entire onstreet<br />
parking operation... intelligently<br />
monitoring, enforcing and maintaining<br />
the meters 24/7.<br />
A Revolutionary New System<br />
Transforms Municipal On-Street <strong>Parking</strong><br />
With StreetSmart Technology, every city parking meter can be monitored, enforced,<br />
repaired and collected...through an intelligent wireless network that revolutionizes<br />
on-street parking management. StreetSmart Automated <strong>Parking</strong> Solutions is the first<br />
system that gives parking managers the tools to transform their operation.<br />
Imagine your on-street parking operation with:<br />
Dramatically increased revenue and turnover<br />
Reduced congestion and emissions<br />
Labor savings from work orders sent wirelessly to<br />
enforcement, maintenance and collection staff<br />
A web-enabled portal showing city-wide meter<br />
status laid over a geo-map<br />
wirelessly connected meters<br />
exchange data with the<br />
StreetSmart Portal<br />
Visit the website to view animated<br />
movies showing StreetSmart<br />
Technology in action.<br />
For more information contact:<br />
StreetSmart Technology LLC<br />
Phone: (203) 222-0203<br />
Email: sales@streetsmarttechnology.com<br />
http://streetsmarttechnology.com<br />
TRANSFORM CHAOS INTO CONTROL. GET STREETSMART.
Remaining “Service-Focused” in Tough Economic Times<br />
from Page 24<br />
3. Remember that having a history<br />
of improvements or degradations in<br />
parking indicators is the best justification<br />
for pricing, policy and other management<br />
decisions. So you want to raise<br />
the meter rate because the city<br />
has a budget shortfall? Bad<br />
manager! But if your data<br />
trends show that parking<br />
availability and turnover have<br />
suffered as off-street prices<br />
have increased while meter<br />
rates and ticket fines have<br />
stagnated, your odds of success<br />
and acceptance of the<br />
remedies will be much improved.<br />
4. Never confuse the enforcement<br />
officer’s daily productivity average as a<br />
measure of program efficiency or effectiveness.<br />
Historically, some programs have<br />
achieved averages of 100 tickets per officer<br />
per day, but their parking and traffic<br />
situations were none the better for it. Collectively,<br />
the percent of optimum turnover<br />
rate, and the safety violation and parking<br />
occupancy rates, are more representative<br />
of how well the parking program is fulfilling<br />
its mission.<br />
5. Maintain regular contact with<br />
your constituencies. Make sure program<br />
managers, supervisors, analysts<br />
The temptation for some to<br />
abuse their jobs and the public<br />
may be hard to resist over time.<br />
and you (as the leader) participate in<br />
merchant and neighborhood association<br />
meetings; meet with advocacy groups<br />
for persons with disabilities; and maintain<br />
contacts with elected officials and<br />
peers. Listen to their feedback and<br />
address their needs as appropriate.<br />
When it comes to the public contacts,<br />
don’t be discouraged by initial attempts<br />
that may degenerate into grievance sessions.<br />
It may take repeated efforts to<br />
gain acceptance and trust that could<br />
translate to support during the tough<br />
times.<br />
6. Fight to maintain funding for<br />
parking analyst positions.These positions<br />
can generate their salaries<br />
many times over in cost savings and<br />
optimized revenues. More important,<br />
the contribution to program quality<br />
from them can’t be overestimated. For<br />
the relatively smaller parking programs,<br />
at least one individual who is focused<br />
solely on collecting, tracking and providing<br />
quantitative feedback to supervisors<br />
and managers on parking activity<br />
indicators is essential to program quality,<br />
efficiency and effectiveness. Largecity<br />
programs may require several analysts<br />
per operating branch. Their functional<br />
and geographical assignments<br />
and performance expectations should<br />
be clearly defined to realize the most<br />
value from their efforts and optimize<br />
program efficiency.<br />
7. Emphasize and promote the<br />
qualitative aspects of the parking<br />
management program to external<br />
and internal stakeholders alike. Does<br />
your parking program distribute an<br />
annual report to elected officials, other<br />
municipal managers, and the constituencies<br />
mentioned above? If so,<br />
does it highlight the program’s positive<br />
effects on transit timeliness, public<br />
safety, and parking access improvements<br />
in commercial and residential<br />
areas? And is this report circulated to<br />
your most important constituents – your<br />
employees? And what of the report’s<br />
underlying message? Does<br />
it focus solely on tickets<br />
issued and revenues collected?<br />
Not that these indicators<br />
aren’t important measures<br />
of program efficiency,<br />
but parking revenue must<br />
be viewed for what it really<br />
is: a by-product, not the<br />
objective, of a parking management<br />
program.<br />
8. Invest the time and money in<br />
employee customer service, communication,<br />
leadership and refresher<br />
technical training. Yes, you’ll have to<br />
take your enforcement officers and others<br />
“off the street” for awhile.Your ticket<br />
count will be less on those days –<br />
accept it as a down-payment on future<br />
improvements in product quality and<br />
customer service. But your frontline<br />
employees make or break the public’s<br />
image of your parking program. To the<br />
extent that enforcement officers and<br />
others believe their only purpose is to<br />
“make money” for the mayor, the temptation<br />
for some to abuse their jobs and<br />
the public may be hard to resist over<br />
time.<br />
Obviously, the above items are just<br />
starting points to help your parking program<br />
avoid unwise, knee-jerk decisions<br />
in this unsettled economy. We haven’t<br />
even discussed meter security, operational<br />
efficiency, and ticket processing<br />
and collection strategies that also<br />
should be pursued.<br />
But in the end, knowing your parking<br />
program’s numbers and maintaining<br />
contact with its stakeholders are two of<br />
the best ways of ensuring its mission<br />
remains service-focused, as opposed to<br />
revenue-driven.<br />
Joe Sciulli is Vice President and Senior<br />
Operations Consultant of CHANCE<br />
Management Advisors<br />
(www.chancemanagement.com).<br />
PT<br />
26<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
“Check’s in the mail”, IL:<br />
$18,721.33<br />
in unpaid citations.<br />
“That’s a lot of moo-la”, TX:<br />
$32,724.56<br />
in unpaid citations.<br />
C i t a t i o n C o l l e c t i o n S e r v i c e s<br />
“Tall order”, NE:<br />
$514,618.25<br />
in unpaid citations.<br />
“Way short on funds”, MN:<br />
$73,901.14<br />
in unpaid citations.<br />
“Forget about it”, NY:<br />
$1,532,321.92<br />
in unpaid citations.<br />
Get paid.<br />
Think technology. Think solutions. Think T2.<br />
That’s what Citation Collection Services (CCS) from T2 is all about. Getting<br />
your money. T2 can help you increase collections through technologybased<br />
services, while you maintain complete control and access to all of<br />
your data—in real time. And because it’s built on T2 Flex (the industry’s first<br />
unified parking management system), CCS is completely customizable to<br />
meet your needs. It’s time to think T2, and get paid.<br />
www.T2systems.com
Henry Hudson Paid to Park;<br />
His Legacy Survives <strong>Today</strong><br />
BY MICHAEL KLEIN<br />
THIS YEAR, ALBANY, NY, WILL<br />
celebrate the 400th anniversary of<br />
being founded by Capt. Henry Hudson<br />
as he sailed up what would become his<br />
namesake river in the Dutch East India<br />
Co. ship, the Half Moon.<br />
Rumor has it that Hudson was charged to park his ship on<br />
the riverside while trading furs with the Native Americans.<br />
This way, the slips were<br />
maintained at 90% occupancy,<br />
and time and trouble<br />
looking for a place to tie up<br />
were kept to a minimum.<br />
Naturally, a portion of this<br />
revenue went to support the<br />
development of Fort<br />
Orange; otherwise, local<br />
merchants would be unhappy<br />
with the parking charges.<br />
A few hundred years later, the automobile was invented, and<br />
this brought us Park-O-Meter (POM), PARCS, robotic parking<br />
and even our own TV show, “<strong>Parking</strong> Wars.”<br />
Sure, a lot has changed during the four centuries that separate<br />
these eras, but the river remains an important part of Albany<br />
Mayor Gerald Jennings’ vision of waterfront development. And<br />
the mayor is fortunate to have a well-run independent parking<br />
authority to collect fees that facilitate access for people to live,<br />
work, shop and enjoy vibrant downtown Albany. This separation<br />
of the parking function from the city administration makes for a<br />
positive relationship between a parking authority and a city<br />
administration.<br />
Having an independent parking<br />
authority (provides) a financial<br />
framework that takes parking<br />
off the city ledger.<br />
In general, there are six areas of opportunity for an authority<br />
to provide parking services, rather than having a city or private<br />
entity do so. These relate to finance, business efficiency, tax<br />
exposure, procurement, service delivery, and the tradeoff<br />
between business and “political” decisions.<br />
One important benefit of having an independent parking<br />
authority is to provide a financial framework that takes parking<br />
off the city ledger, as this eliminates the city’s need to take on<br />
debt service to invest in parking infrastructure. Also, this allows<br />
the city to use its debt service for other purposes and avoids<br />
potential pitfalls associated<br />
with parking having a negative<br />
impact on a city’s bond<br />
rating.<br />
This would be particularly<br />
true if a city subsidized<br />
parking at below-market<br />
rates, a not uncommon practice<br />
when parking falls under<br />
the city banner. In Albany’s<br />
case, Standard & Poor’s<br />
November 2008 rating on its general obligation debt was raised to<br />
AA- from A, reflecting the city’s stable economy and strong<br />
financial position.<br />
The city’s overall debt burden, including county and school<br />
debt, is moderate at $2,484 per capita and 4.5% of market value.<br />
The city’s moderate capital needs and debt profile further stabilize<br />
the credit. If parking debt were on this ledger, it would add<br />
about 10% to the debt burden.<br />
When the business of parking is properly managed by an<br />
authority, it is reasonable to achieve investment-grade ratings by<br />
S&P or other rating agencies. <strong>Parking</strong> authorities at small cities<br />
28<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
such as Albany (with a population of about 100,000) may have<br />
ratings of BBB+ and larger-city authorities may move one or two<br />
notches higher than that.<br />
When achieving investment-grade ratings, the cost of debt<br />
service may result in savings of about 150 to 200 basis points as<br />
compared with what would be charged to private developers. On<br />
top of this is the same tax-exempt status as a city (as long as the<br />
parking is offered to the public in a non-exclusionary way), provided<br />
savings for both capital and operating costs.<br />
With a minimum of red tape, an authority can buy goods and<br />
services either under state contracts or in the private marketplace,<br />
whichever is more favorable. This yields a lower cost of business,<br />
which allows savings to be passed on to the customer. Ultimately,<br />
parking infrastructure is created and operated efficiently to support<br />
parking demand.<br />
It is often helpful for city officials to be distanced from parking<br />
issues. When people complain about parking costs or availability,<br />
this can create adversarial relationships between elected<br />
officials and the citizens they serve. It is a benefit to be distanced<br />
from the old parking bugaboo, and be able to direct inquiries to a<br />
parking professional at the helm of an independent authority.<br />
At the same time, it is typical to have the authority staff<br />
report to a board of directors that is made up of community volunteers<br />
selected and approved by elected leaders. This just-closeenough<br />
but not-too-close relationship between elected leaders<br />
and the administration of a parking program ensures that the<br />
parking authority will function in the best interests of the citizenry<br />
and elected officials, while avoiding becoming embroiled in<br />
political issues that may interfere with effective and efficient<br />
service delivery.<br />
City departments are tasked with myriad responsibilities in<br />
order to provide a good quality of life to the people, and when<br />
independent authorities take on tasks such as parking, transportation,<br />
water and housing, these operations no longer place a burden<br />
on city services. Then the city government may focus on its<br />
raison d’etre and be streamlined and have a reduced tax burden<br />
on the people.<br />
We’ve all read about the “high cost of free parking.” Under<br />
the authority framework, market prices support effective and efficient<br />
parking systems, and supply and demand set price. When<br />
this occurs, if an authority is less than optimally managed, private<br />
business may compete effectively, and when private parking<br />
organizations flourish in a competitive environment, this better<br />
addresses parking capacity needs.<br />
Similarly, when the authority is well-run, this provides a<br />
brake against excessive pricing by private business. This kind of<br />
system automatically maintains a level of equilibrium, and this<br />
self-regulation is yet another reason that such a good relationship<br />
is maintained between city officials and authority staff.<br />
So come on up to Albany via the Hudson River (the oldfashioned<br />
way), or travel to the city in a more modern mode by<br />
plane, train or automobile. It’s a wonderful city, and good parking<br />
is available and priced right.<br />
Michael Klein is the Executive Director of the Albany <strong>Parking</strong><br />
Authority. He can be reached at mklein@parkalbany.com.<br />
PT<br />
An<br />
Affinity Partner<br />
Alliant, the specialty insurance leader.<br />
Every day your customers depend on you.<br />
They leave their cars in your parking garage<br />
or with your valet and assume everything will<br />
be fine. But things can go wrong. Vehicles<br />
disappear from parking garages. Valets crash cars.<br />
Pedestrians trip on potholes. And customers file claims.<br />
So who can you depend on? For more than<br />
25 years, Alliant Insurance Services has been offering<br />
complete insurance solutions for all types of parking<br />
operations. We can help you prevent and manage<br />
risks while making sure you have the most appropriate<br />
coverage for your business. Contact us today.<br />
Customers depend on you. Who can you depend on?<br />
(866) 805-7275, Ext. 775<br />
www.alliantinsurance.com/parking<br />
kphillips@alliantinsurance.com<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com 29
Why Multi-Space<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Meters?<br />
BY DAN KUPFERMAN<br />
OKLAHOMA CITY HAD AN<br />
unusual problem back in 1935.<br />
Employees were taking up all the<br />
downtown parking spaces. Some<br />
things never change.<br />
“My invention relates to meters for measuring the time of<br />
occupancy or use of parking or other space, for the use of which<br />
it is desirous an incidental charge be made<br />
upon a time basis.” So begins Carl C.<br />
Magee’s patent request on May 13, 1935,<br />
for the first coin-controlled parking meter.<br />
<strong>Today</strong>, in the United States alone,<br />
about five million parking meters are collecting<br />
those “incidental charges.” If we<br />
estimate a conservative average of $1 per<br />
day being deposited in each of those<br />
meters six days per week (no Sundays),<br />
we’re talking about $1.565 billion per year.<br />
That’s a lot of quarters!<br />
I don’t know about you, but if that’s<br />
my money, I want to make sure of a few<br />
things:<br />
1) I want all my customers to pay.<br />
2) I want all my meters to work.<br />
3) I want all my money to find its way<br />
to my bank account.<br />
Guess what? With conventional<br />
meters, all my customers are not paying. A<br />
lot of them don’t have any quarters on<br />
them; they’d pay if they could. And though<br />
I have enforcement people writing tickets,<br />
let’s face it, they can’t be everywhere. I<br />
can’t afford to have enforcement on every<br />
street!<br />
To make matters worse, a lot of my<br />
meters are out of service. They jam easily<br />
and are easily put out of service by some<br />
of my less scrupulous customers. Sometimes<br />
the meters are out of service for days,<br />
or even weeks before they’re discovered,<br />
reported and repaired.<br />
Wait – there’s more. Ask me how<br />
much money I have in each of my meters. I<br />
have no idea! I have to wait until my collectors<br />
come back, and my counters add up<br />
all those quarters. I hope they get it right,<br />
because I can’t even conduct an audit.<br />
There has to be “a better way.”<br />
Well, this is the last straw – the downtown business association<br />
is now complaining about the way the meters look!You have<br />
to be kidding! What’s a few bent poles here and there? What do<br />
you mean they’re an eyesore? When did “streetscape” even<br />
become a word?<br />
But wait a minute – this isn’t 1935; it’s 2008! There have<br />
been technological advances! We’re not stuck with the old conventional<br />
single-space meters anymore! <strong>Today</strong>’s multi-space<br />
30<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
parking meters out-perform conventional parking meters in<br />
virtually every way:<br />
• Multi-space meters give customers more ways to pay.<br />
Multi-space meters can accept coins, bills, credit and debit<br />
cards, smart cards, and even cellphone payments. When you<br />
give people more ways to pay, they’ll pay! An added benefit is<br />
that absolutely everyone pays. Multi-space meters do not<br />
show unused time on their display screens, so customers no<br />
longer get to park for free by piggybacking on the time of the<br />
person who parked before them.<br />
• Multi-space meters are extremely vandal-resistant. The<br />
best ones have a shutter at the coin slot that will not open for<br />
paper or cardboard, and will let paper clips and slugs pass<br />
through without incident. Bill acceptors allow for four-way<br />
insertion – it’s idiot-proof! In the unlikely event the machine<br />
does malfunction, an alarm is automatically sent to you wirelessly,<br />
which advises you of the condition, so you can fix it;<br />
downtime is minimized. In the meantime, customers can simply<br />
pay via another form of payment (coin/bill/card, etc.), or<br />
they can walk to the next multi-space meter to pay, so there is<br />
no loss of revenue.<br />
• Multi-space meters count and report revenue as it’s<br />
deposited into the machine. This means I’ll know if any money<br />
is missing. My employees will know that I know, too. The<br />
reports are real-time and online. I’ll even know when my<br />
employees are at the meter – I’ll get an alarm and a report<br />
advising me that the door is open, a collection is in process,<br />
how much was collected, etc.<br />
• Multi-space pay meters provide remarkably accurate<br />
and detailed financial reports and statistics. Since every transaction<br />
is reported and recorded, I’m able to sort revenue and<br />
volume by machine, location, time of day, amount paid, type<br />
of payment, etc. The entire city can be networked together<br />
and/or divided into neighborhoods, zones, streets, etc. These<br />
statistical data lead to effective analysis and planning.<br />
• How many coins does a conventional meter hold? Thirty<br />
to fifty dollars in quarters? Multi-space meters can hold<br />
$700 in quarters, and $500 in bills. Fewer meters are required,<br />
and fewer collections are required. With credit card and bill<br />
payments, collections are faster and easier – far fewer coins to<br />
transport, count, roll and deposit.<br />
• Multi-space meters are environmentally friendly<br />
machines – 100% solar-powered, with no need to dig up<br />
streets running power lines or cables and no electric bill! Also,<br />
their rechargeable batteries are recyclable as are the units<br />
themselves at the end of their on-street lives.<br />
• Multi-space meters improve the streetscape. I think<br />
most of them are better looking than pole-mounted conventional<br />
meters, but you may disagree. One thing’s for sure;<br />
there will be far fewer of them on each street since one multispace<br />
meter can manage a full block.<br />
• Multi-space meter display screens can be programmed<br />
to communicate in multiple languages. Customers can push<br />
a button to select their language. Magnifico! Magnifique!<br />
Ausgezeichnet!<br />
In summary, why choose multi-space parking meters?<br />
Because we can! Technology has made our lives better in so<br />
many ways. It’s time to take advantage of all the advances<br />
since 1935 and start using the technology of today!<br />
Dan Kupferman spent 16 years as a parking operator before<br />
joining Parkeon as a Business Development Manager.<br />
Contact him at dkupferman@parkeon.com.<br />
PT<br />
Complete Systems Integration<br />
for <strong>Parking</strong>...and Beyond.<br />
Contact your local PARC Group integrator today:<br />
Northeast:<br />
Ber-National Automation<br />
Rochester and Western NY<br />
585-482-8525<br />
www.bernational.com<br />
Ber-National Controls, Inc.<br />
Central NY and Syracuse<br />
315-432-1818<br />
www.bernationalcontrols.com<br />
Entry Guard Systems<br />
Virginia<br />
804-423-6523<br />
800-488-3519<br />
www.entryguardsystems.com<br />
Richard N. Best Associates, Inc.<br />
PA, NJ, DE, MD<br />
215-945-9240<br />
www.rnbest.com<br />
Wescor <strong>Parking</strong> Controls Inc.<br />
MA, CT, RI, NH, VT, ME<br />
508-832-6305<br />
www.wescorparking.com<br />
Northwest:<br />
Entrance Controls<br />
WA, OR, ID, MT, WY, AK<br />
206-622-0452<br />
www.eci-nw.com<br />
Midwest:<br />
Hanen Electric<br />
Indiana, Kentucky<br />
812-948-1493<br />
800-377-PARK<br />
www.hanenelectric.com<br />
Light & Breuning, Inc.<br />
Indiana, Michigan<br />
260-422-6456<br />
www.lbpark.com<br />
Signature Control Systems<br />
Ohio<br />
614-864-2222<br />
www.signaturecontrols.com<br />
TAPCO<br />
Wisconsin, Illinois<br />
262-814-7000<br />
800-236-0112<br />
www.tapconet.com<br />
www.parcgroup.com<br />
» The Leading Network of Access<br />
Control Systems Integrators<br />
» Your One-Stop Resource for Design,<br />
Contract, Installation and Service<br />
» Unique Depth of Knowledge and<br />
Services Beyond Your Expectation<br />
Southwest:<br />
ProTech Access<br />
Texas<br />
713-776-8324<br />
www.protechaccess.com<br />
Southeast:<br />
Access Control Systems LLC<br />
TN, KY, MS, AL<br />
615-255-4466<br />
www.acs-llc.com<br />
Florida Door Control<br />
Florida<br />
321-254-8011<br />
www.fdc.com<br />
ITR of Georgia<br />
Georgia, Alabama<br />
770-496-0366 Ext 214<br />
www.itrofgeorgia.com<br />
JL Roberts & Associates<br />
Louisiana, Mississippi<br />
504-831-8113<br />
Southern Time Equipment Co.<br />
The Carolinas, 5 locations<br />
800-849-5654<br />
www.southerntime.com<br />
Canada:<br />
Ontario <strong>Parking</strong> Systems Ltd.<br />
London, Ontario, Canada<br />
519-667-1482<br />
www.ontarioparking.com<br />
PARC Automation Inc.<br />
Toronto, Ontario, Canada<br />
866-225-7272<br />
www.parcautomation.com<br />
Stinson Equipment<br />
Montreal, Quebec, Canada<br />
514-766-3567<br />
Mexico/Puerto Rico:<br />
Automatic Control Technology<br />
San Juan, Puerto Rico<br />
787-782-6006<br />
www.automatic-pr.com<br />
Automatizacion y Trafico Alto<br />
Mexico<br />
52-55-5580-0992<br />
www.alto.com.mx
SMART CARDS<br />
Replacement for Coins, or More?<br />
BY JOHN REGAN<br />
FOR YEARS, THE PARKING INDUStry<br />
has offered smart cards as an alternative<br />
to feeding meters. But these programs<br />
haven’t done very well, because of<br />
the premise that smart cards are nothing<br />
more than a replacement for coins.<br />
For smart cards to have wide adoption, they must be truly<br />
smart: They need to be a credit mechanism, not just debit, and<br />
need to include a high level of security, effective distribution<br />
channels and marketing strategies to entice customers. The technology<br />
to achieve all that is ready for prime time and should be<br />
activated.<br />
Most municipal governments haven’t been in the business<br />
of operating large consumer product initiatives. But in today’s<br />
recession, governments are responsible for stimulating the<br />
economy. Leveraging card payment solutions is an extremely<br />
cost-effective way to build revenue and encourage consumer<br />
spending. It is good local economic development without a<br />
price tag.<br />
The act of consumer spending starts with parking the car.<br />
That’s the trigger point of sale: If a shopping district is easy to<br />
park in, consumers will be enticed. So this point of sale is where<br />
the strategy and technological feature-set must come into play.<br />
To deploy a robust consumer spending initiative, municipalities<br />
need to understand the features and potential of existing card<br />
technologies, including memory, e-Purse, bank-issued credit and<br />
debit, and contactless card solutions – all in the context of parking<br />
technology.<br />
Memory cards provide rudimentary, challenge-based security<br />
features. In a parking application, this typically means an<br />
amount of “parking time value” remaining on the card. Memory<br />
cards are technologically limited in terms of utility and weak<br />
cryptography, which doesn’t meet the increasingly rigorous banking<br />
standards for payment. There also are distribution and marketing<br />
problems. Even if the card can<br />
be used in different proprietary<br />
meters, it can’t be used in a parking<br />
garage or in neighboring towns, and<br />
there’s no convenient way for consumers<br />
to obtain and reload a card.<br />
The whole system discourages user<br />
adoption.<br />
E-Purses, designed to meet banking<br />
standards for payment, are far<br />
more secure and flexible than memory cards. The catch is that<br />
they require purchasing more expensive multiprocessor-basedcards,<br />
and a secure access module (SAM) to be installed in the<br />
payment device. The SAM contains security keys to ensure the<br />
authenticity, integrity and security of every transaction in an e-<br />
Purse payment system.<br />
Despite some initial investment, e-Purses have limitless<br />
use potential. The return on investment occurs quickly, because<br />
there’s very low operating overhead. Also, e-Purses are<br />
designed for general payments regardless of location or items<br />
being purchased.<br />
For smart cards to have<br />
wide adoption, they<br />
must be truly smart.<br />
A merchant returns a customer’s “Electronic Purse,” one of the many payment<br />
options discussed in this article.<br />
Additionally, 3DES e-Purse systems have not been<br />
hacked. Symantec research documents millions of accounts<br />
being compromised in 2008 in a continuously shifting threat<br />
landscape; however, not one e-Purse using 3DES security has<br />
been compromised. The trade-off is that municipalities must<br />
be prepared to incorporate a check-and-balance system with e-<br />
Purses, which requires a trusted<br />
third-party administrator.<br />
An estimated 75% percent of the<br />
U.S. population carries a credit or<br />
debit card, according to www.creditcards.com.<br />
Without question, credit and debit<br />
cards have increased the value of a<br />
transaction at parking meters and are<br />
clearly convenient to consumers.<br />
Many cities cite increases of 30% to 35% in their card-based<br />
transactions. Although similar increases have been documented<br />
with prepaid stored-value programs, there is no additional cost to<br />
the operator to market or distribute credit or debit cards. And as<br />
on-street parking costs increase, these cards are ideally suited to<br />
purchases over $5.<br />
Many cities adopting credit/debit are surprised to discover<br />
that most of their meters capture only about 50% of their transactions<br />
on cards. Payment research suggests that it’s the identity<br />
theft issue. Consumers are increasingly concerned about using<br />
cards at unattended devices. Despite Payment Card Industry<br />
32<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
(PCI) success, both credit and debit cards are still prone to having<br />
their data skimmed at unattended devices. The crooks simply use<br />
a secondary card reader that the consumer is unaware of to gain<br />
access. The PCI does not address this issue.<br />
When accepting credit and debit, the operator also must dedicate<br />
resources to the management of the program. Accounting,<br />
rate structure and dispute issues must be managed. The required<br />
communications infrastructure can be costly. Interchange fees<br />
must be paid to the card-issuing bank, plus a margin to the merchant<br />
acquirer or originating processor of the transactions. These<br />
costs can be relatively high for small-dollar transactions,<br />
although they become more and more marginal as the average<br />
ticket rises above $5.<br />
Payment disputes, or charge-backs, also must be managed,<br />
which can cost the operator as much as $25 per dispute. And<br />
finally, Visa and MasterCard place liability squarely on the<br />
merchant, which in this case is the municipal government.<br />
Despite these new costs to a city for adopting credit and<br />
debit, the technology does, and will continue to, play an important<br />
role in on-street parking revenue generation.<br />
Contactless cards were originally designed for rapid-transit<br />
systems; their “tap-and-go” capability serves the quick<br />
throughput requirement of this market. The most well-known<br />
examples are the Hong Kong Octopus and London Oyster<br />
cards. Fare-payment transactions are required to work in one to<br />
three milliseconds. Both the Hong Kong and London cards<br />
have been compromised by hackers, despite their success in<br />
meeting their primary mission – rapid transit.<br />
About 45,000 merchants accept contactless cards out of a<br />
U.S. pool of three million plus. The jury is still out on this<br />
product, because the push-and-pull marketing game between<br />
the card issuers promoting the technology and the merchant<br />
acquirers has barely begun. Why should merchants pay for this<br />
new technology when, from their perspective, there is no real<br />
benefit?<br />
The challenge for the on-street parking industry is similar.<br />
Do contactless cards provide any more value to the parking operator,<br />
the cardholder or the municipal government? Since parkers<br />
still must get out of their cars and tell the meter how much time<br />
they need, tap-and-go convenience and speed do not seem to<br />
apply. Furthermore, why should meter vendors and parking operators<br />
invest in a technology when the bank issuers and their<br />
brands are still not ready to replace their current plastic in the<br />
U.S. market?<br />
Given the pros and cons, there certainly is a market for both<br />
bank-issued cards as well as regional e-Purse solutions. Notwithstanding<br />
the emergence of other wireless payment products, it is<br />
clear that these technologies will continue to be significant players<br />
in this market.<br />
The memory card never established the foothold its early<br />
promise suggested, and it’s a product clearly being overtaken by<br />
more capable technology. It also is unclear whether the U.S. will<br />
leapfrog contact-based card solutions in favor of contactless, and<br />
will likely remain unclear for many years to come.<br />
John Regan is President and CEO of Parcxmart Technologies. He<br />
can be reached at jregan@parcxmart.com.<br />
PT<br />
WHAT HAPPENS TO YOUR PARKING SYSTEMS<br />
WHEN THE POWER GOES OUT?<br />
When the power goes out, parking gate controls, revenue systems and security systems are all<br />
compromised. Ensure your systems continue to operate during power fluctuations or power outages<br />
by using Alpha indoor and outdoor backup power solutions.<br />
Alpha - Power when there isn’t power.<br />
www.alpha.com/parking Toll free: 800.667.8743 Direct: 604.430.1476
NOTES FROM BIG BEN …<br />
Woolworths, ITS and Rushm<br />
BY PETER GUEST<br />
IT’S THE BEGINNING OF<br />
a new year and traditionally<br />
a time for reflecting on the<br />
old year.<br />
Nothing to do with parking, but for<br />
many people of my age (almost dead), one<br />
sad memory will be the disappearance of<br />
F.W. Woolworths from our streets. I<br />
believe that “Woolies” stopped trading in<br />
the U.S. many years ago, but for more than<br />
90 years, every high street in every UK<br />
town seemed to have a magic place called<br />
Woolworths, where you could buy just<br />
about anything.<br />
It was said that the difference<br />
between a town and a village was whether<br />
or not they had a Woolworths. There was<br />
something about Woolworths; in my childhood,<br />
being a “Woolworths Girl” was in<br />
some way one-up on being a mere shop<br />
assistant. Sadly, the realities of the credit<br />
crisis, plus the Internet, finally caught up<br />
with the business, and just short of 100<br />
years, the company has gone bust, with the<br />
last few UK stores closing within days.<br />
Nostalgia aside, this was one of the<br />
USA’s better exports, and we shall be sorry<br />
to see them go.<br />
Intelligent Transport Systems (ITS)<br />
are the saviour of mankind, according to<br />
those that sell ‘em. To me they are, and<br />
always have been, a solution looking for<br />
a problem.<br />
The government has spent enough<br />
money on information signing on the<br />
national motorway network to cancel<br />
the national debt. I believe that each<br />
ITS sign cost about half a million dollars,<br />
and they are totally useless!<br />
Every time I see those signs, they<br />
are either switched off or tell me completely<br />
pointless information, such as it<br />
will take me X minutes to travel Y<br />
miles. Well, since it’s a motorway travelling<br />
at 70 mph – I can work that out.<br />
Just after Christmas, we took a<br />
friend back to Leicester, which is a journey<br />
of about 150 miles. All the way<br />
there, we drove slowly because the<br />
roads were busy and congested. The billion<br />
dollars worth of ITS contributions<br />
to helping me ease my journey was to<br />
tell me that I shouldn’t drink and drive,<br />
and occasionally that the road was congested<br />
just in case we hadn’t noticed.<br />
The true value of ITS became clear<br />
on the return trip. As soon as we joined<br />
the motorway, we were given warning<br />
that the road ahead was congested and<br />
we would experience 20 minutes extra<br />
delay about 15 miles ahead. Option A,<br />
divert; Option B, carry on and accept<br />
the delay.<br />
I have no faith in the informationsigning<br />
system and duly drove through<br />
the “congested” area at 65 mph with no<br />
delay. As we approached London, the<br />
ITS signs told us that the M25 London<br />
Orbital Motorway faced “Severe<br />
Delays” from where we joined it to well<br />
past the junction where we would leave<br />
to head off back to the country, probably<br />
about 25 miles.<br />
We slowed down for about three<br />
miles and drove the rest at the speed<br />
limit. Finally, we reached the jewel in<br />
the crown: the variable speed limit at<br />
Heathrow. The ITS supposedly measure<br />
the speed and volume of traffic, and if<br />
congestion starts to build up, they slow<br />
people approaching the back of the<br />
queue and thus smooth the flow and<br />
reduce total delay.<br />
That’s the theory. We drove<br />
through at the signed 40 mph with one<br />
lane empty and about 100 yards<br />
between cars. It’s total rubbish.<br />
Oh yes, this is supposed to be<br />
about parking, so before JVH bursts a<br />
blood vessel, here are some local<br />
headlines:<br />
Surrey Heath is just about the<br />
richest borough in the UK. The Council<br />
caught a cold in the 1980s when they<br />
bought up about half the town centre to<br />
redevelop just as the property market<br />
took a nose-dive. For the next 20-odd<br />
years, they operated what was probably<br />
one of the most expensive surface car<br />
parks in the world. This has now been<br />
redeveloped as a shopping mall with a<br />
brand-new shiny parking garage.<br />
I used it just after Christmas, and<br />
they have a novel way of welcoming<br />
customers. As we queued on the ramp<br />
(it’s the January sales), I smelt and then<br />
saw that the building’s gas central heating<br />
system vents onto the enclosed car<br />
park ramp. They say that your car park<br />
is the gateway to your town; spraying<br />
34<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
oor (no, not the Mount)...<br />
people with toxic fumes doesn’t seem<br />
the ideal welcome to me.<br />
Rushmoor, is there anything you<br />
can get right?<br />
The law changed here to allow<br />
councils to prosecute drivers who block<br />
crossovers where landowners access<br />
ITS – they are totally useless!<br />
their property by car. It’s always been an<br />
offence but dealt with by the police; now<br />
it’s done by councils.<br />
There are a few problems, not least<br />
of which are that people often park<br />
across their own driveways, rather than<br />
put the car off-street. However, my borough<br />
– never one to miss an opportunity<br />
to make a problem worse – has gone one<br />
step further. They have put formal, legal<br />
(as in right to park) parking bays across<br />
some crossovers. This means that I have<br />
a right to park there but commit an<br />
offence if I do.<br />
Bring back the stocks!<br />
Southampton is a big city, and<br />
their parking manager, Stuart Chivers, is<br />
a really, really nice<br />
man who seems to be<br />
poorly advised at<br />
present. Credit card<br />
rules say that if you<br />
pay for something by<br />
card, the transaction must be processed<br />
within 90 days; after that, the transaction<br />
is void.<br />
Unfortunately, the city’s bankers<br />
screwed up and processed 900 charges<br />
incurred on Nov. 29, 2007, a full year<br />
after the event. Although Southampton<br />
City Council has admitted the mistake,<br />
which was put down to the authority’s<br />
foreign-based merchant bank (which<br />
should therefore be responsible for fixing<br />
it), they say drivers will get a refund<br />
only if they ask for their money back.<br />
Wrong!<br />
The city can take the money only if<br />
they are entitled to it. If they make a mistake<br />
and take money they are not entitled<br />
to, they are obliged to repay it. The onus<br />
is on the city, not the driver.<br />
Taking money that you are not entitled<br />
to and keeping it is called theft, and<br />
you can go to jail. There also are Local<br />
Government Finance Laws that make it<br />
an offence. So, Stuart, get some better<br />
legal advice pronto.<br />
Peter Guest, past President of the British<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Association, is a parking consultant<br />
and PT’s reporter on the scene in<br />
Europe and the Middle East. He can be<br />
reached at peterguestparking@<br />
hotmail.co.uk.<br />
PT<br />
1-949-458-6400 Ext. 316 or 237<br />
Fax 1-949-458-0708<br />
suppliesinfo@oneilsupplies.com<br />
www.oneilsupplies.com<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com 35
Product Focus<br />
Even before this car’s owner<br />
sees the ticket, his account will<br />
see the fine.<br />
Real-time integration. That’s what sets BOSSCARS apart<br />
from all other campus parking enforcement systems. It<br />
integrates directly with your campus’s Oracle ® -based<br />
system in real-time, which makes BOSSCARS the leader<br />
on campuses across the country.<br />
This direct integration allows campus safety officers to immediately<br />
identify scofflaws and VIPs, and it gives them dependable, accurate<br />
data on the spot.<br />
On top of that, BOSSCARS makes it possible for parking fines or fees<br />
to go to customers’ accounts automatically without time-consuming<br />
tasks like batch processing, flat file feeds, uploads or downloads.<br />
As the only truly modular parking system in the industry, BOSSCARS<br />
is totally customizable, available exactly the way you want it. You buy<br />
only what you need and nothing you don’t. Adding on features a year<br />
or two down the road is never a problem.<br />
That’s the kind of attention to detail you’d expect from a company<br />
that specializes exclusively in the needs of college and university<br />
campuses, not in places like airports or hospitals.<br />
Feel free to call us at 877-498-7745 with any questions.<br />
Once you get to know and use BOSSCARS you’ll understand why<br />
BOSS Software is An Authority in Campus Software Solutions.<br />
INTEGRAPARK <br />
IntegraPark offers PARIS, the<br />
premier billing and<br />
receivables system for<br />
monthly parkers. PARIS may<br />
be integrated with many<br />
popular card access systems.<br />
PARIS automates collections<br />
with credit card charges and<br />
bank drafts, ensures<br />
compliance with complex<br />
lease terms, and more.<br />
IntegraPark’s Geneva<br />
application uses data from<br />
your revenue control system<br />
to track and analyze your<br />
operations, then posts the<br />
financial results to your<br />
General Ledger system.<br />
For more information, contact IntegraPark, LLC<br />
tel: 888-852-9993; fax: 281-656-4466<br />
email: ruth.beaman@integrapark.com<br />
www.integrapark.com<br />
METRIC PARKING <br />
Metric <strong>Parking</strong> has been<br />
producing multi-space<br />
parking equipment for over<br />
30 years. We are the proven<br />
choice with over 50,000<br />
Pay-By-Space and Pay and<br />
Display units installed. Our<br />
solar powered equipment<br />
accepts multiple payment<br />
options including coins,<br />
cards, bills, & on-line credit<br />
card payment. The central<br />
server provides reports &<br />
space information in real<br />
time. Our wireless space<br />
management system allows<br />
enforcement personnel to<br />
view the status in real time<br />
of all parking spaces, paid or unpaid via handheld unit.<br />
For more information, contact Metric <strong>Parking</strong><br />
tel: 609-395-8570; fax: 609-395-8541<br />
e-mail: sales@metricparking.com<br />
web: www.metricparking.com<br />
10375 Park Meadows Drive, Suite 250 | Lone Tree, Colorado 80124<br />
720.284.3893 | 877.498.7745 Toll-Free | 720.284.3897 Fax<br />
BossSoftware.com
CASIO<br />
Public Safety<br />
Solutions<br />
Casio’s Industrial Handheld<br />
Division offers a variety of<br />
mobile solutions to quickly meet<br />
the immediate and future application<br />
needs of your agency.<br />
IT-3100<br />
Integrated Thermal Printer,<br />
CMOS Imaging Barcode Scanner,<br />
Magnetic Card Reader,<br />
GPRS and WLAN<br />
DT-X30<br />
Integrated Color Digital Camera,<br />
CMOS Imaging Barcode Scanner,<br />
GPRS and GPS<br />
Phone: 1-866-812-2746<br />
www.casio4business.com<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> <strong>Today</strong> Presents<br />
PIE Webinar<br />
<strong>Febru</strong>ary 3, 2009<br />
“<strong>Parking</strong> and Income Generation<br />
in Challenging Times”<br />
Dr. Barbara Chance of<br />
Chance Management Advisors.<br />
April – Marketing your <strong>Parking</strong> Resources<br />
Now is the time to fill empty space and maximize your income.<br />
Clyde Wilson of The <strong>Parking</strong> Network<br />
—<br />
June – Protect Your <strong>Parking</strong> Assets<br />
Keep your insurance costs in check<br />
Kathy Phillips of Alliant Insurance<br />
—<br />
Complete Information and sign up (Free) at www.parkingtoday.com<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com 37
PT THE AUDITOR<br />
The Ultimate Punishment –<br />
MY JOB IS LIKE COP AND<br />
court rolled into one. I<br />
discover the problem;<br />
then I’m involved in<br />
the fix. The second<br />
part can be harder than the first.<br />
Consider this. I do an audit and find that a garage<br />
manager has been less than forthright with the numbers.<br />
This is a case of malfeasance,<br />
not simple incompetence. I<br />
have him dead to rights.<br />
He has cooked the books and<br />
taken his customer’s money.<br />
Remember: This manager works<br />
for a private operator. The operator<br />
has been hired by the owner.<br />
So the relationship passes from the owner, through the operator to<br />
their employee, the manager.<br />
Whose responsibility is it? The operator? The manager? The<br />
owner?<br />
I can make a case for each.<br />
First, the operator. The company has sold the owner on the concept<br />
that it is a manager of garages. It knows its business. It signed<br />
Now do they pay the ultimate<br />
price – termination?<br />
a contract to take fiduciary responsibility for<br />
the owner’s garage, his money, his service –<br />
the whole enchilada. The operator tells the<br />
owner that it is all-knowing about parking<br />
garages, that its employees are the besttrained<br />
and best-managed.<br />
The operator allowed malfeasance to<br />
go on under its very nose. In this particular<br />
case, the operator didn’t even notice that the<br />
manager had employees on duty in the garage<br />
that didn’t exist, that he was<br />
turning in their time cards<br />
and cashing their paychecks.<br />
The manager was<br />
caught when one of the<br />
ghost employees called to<br />
enquire about a lot more on<br />
her W-2 for last year than she worked. A simple audit caught<br />
him. However, in reality, it didn’t. It took an outside query.<br />
Obviously, the operator is the one at fault.<br />
But just a minute. Certainly there is culpability. But the<br />
operator instantly began an investigation on its own. They<br />
audited the garage, found the problem, fired the manager, and<br />
reported to the owner with a check in hand for the entire<br />
amount lost due to the ghost employees, and it wasn’t a small<br />
number. The operator was honest, quick to act, and cleared up<br />
the problem when it was discovered.<br />
So the fault was the manager’s. Of course, he is a thief.<br />
But in the parking industry, we put low-paid staff in very<br />
tempting positions. The main way we keep them honest is<br />
through very close supervision and training.<br />
The fact that this manager stole stunned the operator.<br />
He was very good at covering his tracks. It wasn’t an obvious<br />
problem. He was a long-time employee and very trusted.<br />
He had a very good act. The average city or branch manager,<br />
overworked and underpaid, could very easily have missed<br />
the problem.<br />
So we get to the owner. How can they possibly be held to<br />
account? They hired and trusted a company to do a job and<br />
they didn’t do it. But then …They also hired the low bidder.<br />
They hammered and hammered and got the lowest possible<br />
price.<br />
When the operator wanted to raise the manager’s salary,<br />
the owner said no. When the operator wanted to install a new<br />
accounting and revenue system, they said no. When the operator<br />
recommended a refurbishment of the parking office, new<br />
lighting in the garage, they said no.<br />
The operator asked for the tools it needed to run the<br />
garage properly; the owner said no. Perhaps it did the best it<br />
could with what resources it had.<br />
Certainly the operator is honorable. They didn’t cover up<br />
the problem. When they discovered it, they reported it instantly<br />
to the owner. They didn’t have to. They could have very easily<br />
fired the manager and let it go. They did the right thing.<br />
Now do they pay the ultimate price – termination?<br />
If that’s what is done, where is the motivation of operators<br />
to come clean? Why should they even try to keep their acts in<br />
order?<br />
38<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
Termination<br />
In some societies, they kill the messenger when bad news<br />
arrives. When that happens in business, we are all less for it. Terminating<br />
an operator when they report and fix problems is the wrong<br />
approach.<br />
You might say, “Well, if there was this issue, how do I know<br />
there aren’t others?” I concur that when a problem such as the one<br />
described above takes place, a close look at the operation is in<br />
order.<br />
But if the company acts honorably, perhaps you should let it<br />
go at that. For now.<br />
Set up a schedule with your operator and have outside audits<br />
done regularly. Look for ways that you as an owner can help the<br />
operator run your operation more efficiently. Ask the operator for<br />
their ideas and take them.<br />
Like a well-run university I know in the mid-Atlantic region,<br />
or an excellent airport parking operation in the Midwest, make the<br />
operator an extension of your internal staff.<br />
Hold regular meetings including the garage managers and<br />
supervisors. Put someone on your payroll in the parking office<br />
once a month. Let them work with the operator in solving problems.<br />
Don’t expect perfection if you are not involved in the process.<br />
WOOF!<br />
PT<br />
TranspoQuip Latin<br />
America Set for November<br />
TranspoQuip Latin America 2009, the exhibition and conference<br />
for transportation infrastructure, will be held Nov. 17-<br />
19 for the second consecutive year at Expo Center Norte in São<br />
Paulo, Brazil. The event brings together decision-makers and<br />
solutions for roads, rails, ports and airports.<br />
TranspoQuip focuses on three main themes in these sectors:<br />
management and operations, safety and security, and user<br />
comfort.<br />
An extensive parallel program includes conferences, meetings<br />
and technical tours. This year’s conference subjects are<br />
based on key issues relevant to the advance of infrastructure in<br />
Brazil.<br />
The parking seminar portion this year, planned and organized<br />
by <strong>Parking</strong> World magazine, will include sessions on stadium<br />
parking, revenue control and parking technology.<br />
TranspoQuip’s organizer, Real Alliance, expects a substantial<br />
growth in exhibitor and visitor numbers this year. For more<br />
information, go to www.transpoquip.com.<br />
Expo Estádio, a trade show and conference related to stadiums<br />
and sports venues in Brazil will take place in conjunction<br />
with TranspoQuip.<br />
For more information, go to www.expo-estadio.com.<br />
You See <strong>Parking</strong> Tickets.<br />
We See An Award Winning<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Ticket<br />
Management Solution!<br />
Our state-of-the-art technology combined with<br />
unparalleled service and support – that’s the Complus<br />
difference. Our <strong>Parking</strong> Ticket Management Solution<br />
includes customized software and handheld ticket<br />
writers, nationwide DMV lookups, delinquent noticing,<br />
web-based payments, along with 24/7 customer<br />
support, all at no up-front cost.<br />
TM<br />
Our proprietary FastTrack TM software program sets the<br />
industry standard for efficiency and ease of use.<br />
800.331.8802 • www.complusdata.com<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com 39
THE AMATEUR PARKER …<br />
I Want My Free <strong>Parking</strong><br />
BY MELISSA BEAN STERZICK<br />
IF I AM MORE THAN AN<br />
amateur in any specific parking<br />
area, it is in on-street parking.<br />
That’s because it’s the<br />
option offered to me most frequently<br />
to date, and the option I choose<br />
most frequently – when it’s free.<br />
So I might be something of an expert when<br />
it comes to on-street parking, and there are probably<br />
many drivers out there who could say the<br />
same thing. On-street parking is such a no-brainer<br />
that when it occurs without cost or episode or<br />
effort, it barely registers as a parking experience.<br />
In my day-to-day life, I park on the street less and less anymore.<br />
Now that I have joined the ranks of the property-owning<br />
public, I am entitled to two always-reserved private parking<br />
spaces in my very own driveway. And if I get rid of three bicycles,<br />
a tricycle and a wagon, various Costco-sized bulk food and<br />
paper product packages, and my husband’s tool bench, I have<br />
another two parking spots in my very own garage – all for the<br />
bargain price of a Southern California mortgage.<br />
But since there will be no scraping of snow<br />
or frozen brake lines in my ZIP code, unless the<br />
Apocalypse is upon us, my garage will continue<br />
to be dedicated to miscellaneous storage.<br />
However, in my former days as a beach-city<br />
renter, I parked on the street every day. With my<br />
little tag on the rearview mirror, I was entitled to<br />
any spot I could squeeze into along the two<br />
blocks nearest my apartment. I paid a very affordable<br />
$20 a year to scavenge for a decent spot.<br />
But it wasn’t the price of the parking that<br />
made my life miserable; it was the terms of the<br />
parking. If I forgot to hang my tag or move my<br />
car on street-cleaning day, I got a $35 ticket.<br />
If I had dinner guests, they were invited with<br />
strict instructions to park on the street parallel or depart at 8 p.m.<br />
sharp to avoid the same penalty. Needless to say, entertaining was<br />
not a simple procedure – there’s nothing like a deadline to pump<br />
up a party.<br />
If I had overnight company, I had to accommodate their<br />
vehicles by borrowing a neighbor’s extra permit. If I had a large<br />
item to unload, I parked in the red zone and looked over my<br />
shoulder nervously.<br />
40<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
I still park on the street when I go to the beach. If I can find<br />
free on-street parking, I take it; if not, I pay the meter and check<br />
my watch compulsively for the next few hours. Most of my local<br />
grocers, doctors, churches, etc. offer free parking in their lots, so<br />
I am spared the search.<br />
Overall, I’d say my life as a parker has improved dramatically<br />
since I became a homeowner.<br />
Still, a threat to my days of carefree parking looms darkly in<br />
the form of this magazine’s illustrious and opinionated publisher,<br />
John Van Horn. Hardly a month passes that he is not advocating<br />
paid on-street parking on every residential and commercial street<br />
in the country.<br />
I understand the theory that a fee to park in front of my own<br />
house would prevent me (or my neighbors) from leaving a rotting<br />
old El Camino in my driveway indefinitely. Paid residential parking<br />
would put an end to overstuffed garages and five-car families,<br />
rusted boats in carports, and an irritation I have recently<br />
noticed: the parking of my neighbor’s jalopy in front of my house.<br />
But what JVH must not realize is that his proposal, if carried<br />
out, would have a negative effect on the quality of life of every<br />
parker involved. Paying for on-street parking in residential areas<br />
adds a constant stress to the lives of residents.<br />
Permits mean tickets or the defacement of bumpers. Permits<br />
mean annual registration and payment that comes around<br />
whether you’re ready or not. Permits mean parking enforcement<br />
officers trolling your street every day waiting for you to<br />
screw up.<br />
Sure, I’d like to drive down my street with nary a car in sight,<br />
but what about the days and nights I have guests? Have you ever<br />
driven your own father to the impound lot after his car has been<br />
towed on your street? Have you ever had to dash out the front<br />
door in your robe, run down the street and move your car for the<br />
street cleaner?<br />
I’d much rather put up with the inconveniences of free onstreet<br />
parking than live with the un-American interference that<br />
comes with paid on-street parking. Sure, my neighbors don’t<br />
always park on the street the way I want them to. But my cynicism<br />
has not reached the level where I would rather limit their<br />
options to park than allow them the ability to choose what is best<br />
for them, and hopefully, for our neighborhood.<br />
Hey, Melissa –<br />
Mind if this “un-American” “darkly looming”<br />
editor responds?<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> isn’t free. Someone pays for it. The question<br />
is who. Should the property owners pay for<br />
it, the renters in an apartment building, business<br />
owners, the “city” – or should the people who<br />
own and drive the cars pay for it?<br />
As much as I understand, appreciate and<br />
embrace your libertarian approach (and hear<br />
your frustration), if nothing else, it simply isn’t<br />
fair. Some guy owns five cars and parks them in<br />
front of my house and moves them once a week<br />
so he can stay ahead of the street sweeper. I own<br />
two cars and put them in my garage. Why<br />
should I pay for the space on the street so this<br />
guy can park his fleet?<br />
All the Shoupista folderol aside – and I do<br />
think paying your own way is the “American<br />
Way” – it simply isn’t right to tax a young couple<br />
with a couple of kids who are trying to pay<br />
that LA mortgage so the rest of us can park our<br />
cars. Hell, if I’m going to help pay for his parking,<br />
why not his gas, oil and insurance while<br />
I’m at it?<br />
JVH<br />
PS – There are very easy ways to handle permits<br />
that don’t require annual renewals and allow for<br />
visitors. Check with a number of our advertisers<br />
and their “automated” on-street permit system.<br />
Melissa Bean Sterzick is PT’s amateur parker and proofreader.<br />
She can be reached at Melissa@parkingtoday.com.<br />
PT<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com 41
“WHEN<br />
“High Cost” of<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> on a<br />
Great Street...<br />
PARKING TODAY<br />
HITS THE<br />
STREETS…<br />
Donald Shoup<br />
Sets the Price…<br />
Page 22<br />
MY PHONE<br />
STARTS TO RING*”<br />
PARKING TODAY<br />
Driving the industry<br />
*Ruth Beaman, Principal, IntegraPark
DEATH BY PARKING – Episode 4 – Stack <strong>Parking</strong><br />
BY JVH<br />
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR PAUL MANNING FOUND A DEAD WOMAN<br />
in the trunk of a car blocking his in the stack parking lot at the Hollywood<br />
Bowl. His business card was in there, too. Once back home, Paul found an<br />
envelope with a picture of the person in the trunk, very much alive, and a note<br />
saying they wanted $1 million. The woman turned out to be his sister-in-law’s<br />
best friend, Sarah, who had left an estranged father and been widowed for about six months. But none of this made<br />
sense. Why would they kill Sarah if they were going to ransom her? How did they know not only where the Mannings<br />
would be tonight, but where Paul would be parking? And how was it that he had parked in virtually the only<br />
spot at the Bowl that could be blocked by a single car behind him? Paul returned to his office after talking to the<br />
operator who ran the Bowl’s parking and getting the names of the attendants who were probably involved. A big<br />
man came in. He had a dark suit, white shirt, navy tie, a bulge on his hip, and an attitude. “Manning? I’m FBI Special<br />
Agent in Charge Leon Peyton. We need to talk.” Paul’s phone rang at that moment; LAPD Capt. Bill Vose, his<br />
best friend, said, “Paul, the Feds are in on this. You are going to get a visitor.”<br />
Bill’s timing was better than this.<br />
He usually called before the fact, not<br />
after. What did a murder in Hollywood<br />
have to do with the FBI? I bet I would<br />
soon find out.<br />
The big man who had come into my<br />
office said, “We need to talk. What do<br />
you know about the Delacroix murder?”<br />
What We Saw Was Impossible<br />
Now that was a curve. Delacroix? I<br />
knew no Delacroix and I told him that.<br />
“Come on, Manning: Sarah<br />
Delacroix, Hollywood Bowl, your sisterin-law’s<br />
friend, your business card next<br />
to the body, a body you found.”<br />
Ahhhh, Delacroix was Sarah’s married<br />
name. But the FBI? I told him<br />
everything I knew right up to the vintage<br />
of the wine we drank celebrating Paulo’s<br />
engagement. The look on Peyton’s face<br />
told me he wasn’t satisfied.<br />
“Come on, Manning. Her father,<br />
William Smythe-Jones, who by the way<br />
is flying in this afternoon on his G5<br />
from New Jersey, specifically asked to<br />
44<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
meet with you. You are in this up to<br />
your PI neck.<br />
I was clueless and told him so. I<br />
didn’t know Smythe-Jones, had never<br />
met him, had never spoken to him.<br />
“Well, he knows you and wants you<br />
at the airport at 8 tonight when he<br />
arrives. I’ll meet you at Santa Monica at<br />
7, and we’ll continue this discussion.”<br />
Peyton left.<br />
I called Paulo to join me, and we<br />
went to the bar in Culver City where we<br />
had planned to meet Bill Vose. Perhaps<br />
between the three of us and some alcohol<br />
we could make some sense of this.<br />
I like Ford’s – a tony spot near the<br />
Sony Studios. They have a great selection<br />
of single malts. Plus, the view from the<br />
bar, out to the dining room, was great.<br />
Studios hire only beautiful women, and<br />
they like Ford’s. Probably many were<br />
there trying to spot the owner’s father, a<br />
Ford with the first name of Harrison.<br />
Sightings of movie stars are a hobby<br />
of many who live on Los Angeles’<br />
West Side. The other day I literally ran<br />
into Donald Sutherland at a Ralphs<br />
supermarket. We collided rounding an<br />
egg display. He apologized before I had<br />
a chance to, and then struck up a conversation<br />
with a woman about the advisability<br />
of free-range over regular eggs.<br />
But I digress.<br />
Bill was at the bar when we walked<br />
in. There was a glass of whiskey in front<br />
of him, and a glass of amber liquid on<br />
the bar next to him. It was 15-year-old<br />
Laphroaig. I could almost see the smoke<br />
rising out of the glass. Bill’s a good man.<br />
Paulo ordered a beer.<br />
We rehashed the case. Obviously,<br />
Smythe-Jones had some pull if the Feds<br />
were delivering his messages. His<br />
estranged daughter is kidnapped and<br />
killed, probably accidentally. I was to be<br />
the go-between. But why me?<br />
We held it to one drink, as we wanted<br />
to be clear-headed when the “meeting”<br />
took place.<br />
We left Ford’s at 6:30 and headed<br />
for the Santa Monica airport. The airport<br />
was a favorite for the rich and<br />
famous. It’s about 15 minutes from the<br />
wealthy enclaves of Bel Air, Beverly<br />
Hills and Century City. However, their<br />
private jets upset the airport’s neighbors<br />
to no end. I guess knowing that Madonna<br />
was in the jet rattling your fillings as<br />
it took off didn’t help.<br />
Peyton was there. We met in a<br />
conference room and then spent an<br />
hour looking at each other. There really<br />
wasn’t much to say.<br />
The G5 touched down at exactly 8<br />
p.m. It taxied right up to the executive<br />
terminal. The door opened, and the<br />
pilot came down the stairs. He turned<br />
and offered his hand to a man who<br />
needed a bit of help. He carried a cane<br />
and his shoulders were bent. He<br />
reached the tarmac and turned and<br />
looked back up the stairs.<br />
A woman dressed in a full-length<br />
fur coat stepped out of the plane. She<br />
paused on the top step and then<br />
descended, much like royalty entered a<br />
room. Slowly and with great dignity.<br />
It was dusk and I couldn’t see her<br />
features, but her walk seemed familiar.<br />
She took Smythe-Jones’ arm and they<br />
walked slowly toward the building.<br />
Some floods created circles of light,<br />
and I could see her clearly when they<br />
walked into one.<br />
I felt Paulo stiffen next to me;<br />
Bill’s mouth fell open. We were looking<br />
at a woman who had died 18<br />
months ago. She had been shot by her<br />
partner in crime. I absolutely knew it<br />
happened that way. I was sitting next to<br />
her at the time.<br />
To be continued ...<br />
Super Fast &<br />
Built to Last<br />
Combination<br />
Jack/Dollies<br />
Pneumatic Jacks<br />
PT<br />
American Made<br />
Quality<br />
800-446-5257<br />
www.gojaks.net
PT BLOG<br />
from Page 20<br />
I asked him if he had personally witnessed any problems. We<br />
ticked off the list.<br />
Houses are selling in our neighborhood – it takes a bit<br />
longer and you don’t get quite as much; however, they are selling.<br />
People are buying. Virtually everyone I talk to these days says<br />
they are having a year as good as last year.<br />
I went to a concert last night; the place was full. I had to look<br />
at 10 restaurants before I found one that could give me a reservation<br />
for two. This morning, the donut shop where we stopped for<br />
coffee was packed with people. Costco was jammed over the<br />
weekend.<br />
The auto companies are frankly in exactly the same shape<br />
they were in last year at this time, except that no one will lend<br />
them operating cash as they did before. The bad business decisions<br />
the auto companies have made over the past decade have<br />
caught up with them. It also is a fact that most of the loans (subprime)<br />
are working and not in foreclosure.<br />
So what has changed? Fear. People are afraid because they<br />
are told to be afraid. People who make their living bringing doom<br />
and gloom are saying, “I told you so,” and since they have a<br />
bunch of capital letters after their names, they are believed.<br />
Don’t get me wrong: Fear is a great driving force. But let’s<br />
not be fooled here. We are not going to be living in the streets. The<br />
electricity and gas are going to keep coming. Food will be in the<br />
supermarkets, and the systems that provide those will continue to<br />
work. No one has lost a cent in a bank collapse. (There were<br />
probably too many banks anyway.) I hear at least a dozen commercials<br />
a day on the radio for companies that want to lend you<br />
money on your house.<br />
What has happened is that we simply were living beyond our<br />
means and now it’s time for a reset. This has been going on for<br />
nearly 30 years – the longest period of boom times in history. So<br />
we need a bit of a rethink. However, it too will pass, and much<br />
sooner than you think. I wouldn’t be surprised if we see, in April,<br />
that the first quarter of 2009 actually showed a positive growth<br />
rate – small but there.<br />
There’s simply too much money out there and people want to<br />
use it. And they will. They will just be a bit smarter. Loans are<br />
funding right now. For instance, a garage in Chicago was just<br />
approved and moving ahead. Of course, it’s a blue chip project,<br />
but then maybe we need a few more of those.<br />
Just saying ...<br />
JVH<br />
You could have read these entries when they were originally posted<br />
at <strong>Parking</strong> <strong>Today</strong>’s Blog – and commented, if you liked – by<br />
logging on to www.parkingtoday.com and clicking on “blog.” JVH<br />
updates the blog almost every day.<br />
PT<br />
46<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
See our other ad on Page 3
ADVERTISERS INDEX<br />
ADVERTISER PAGE ADVERTISER PAGE ADVERTISER PAGE<br />
Acre Solutions, LLC 18<br />
ACS, Inc. 12<br />
AIMS(EDC) 11<br />
Alliant Insurance Services, Inc. 29<br />
Alpha Industries, Inc. 45<br />
Alpha Technologies, LTD. 33<br />
Atlantic Business Credit 38<br />
Boss Consulting Services, Inc. 36<br />
Casio 37<br />
Complus Data Innovations 39<br />
Consulting Engineers Group, Inc. 50<br />
DESMAN Associates - Transportation 20<br />
Desman Associates 51<br />
Digital Payment Technologies 10<br />
Digital Printing Systems 44<br />
Duncan Solutions, Inc. 21<br />
ElDorado National 17<br />
End2End 49<br />
EZ Tag Corporation 46<br />
Federal APD 2<br />
Genetec 14<br />
Hayes Software Systems 37<br />
Hectronic 53<br />
IntegraPark 7<br />
Intertraffic 43<br />
IPS Group, Inc. 9<br />
Login Lock 46<br />
Magnetic Automation 13<br />
Metric <strong>Parking</strong> 41<br />
Next <strong>Parking</strong>, LLC 40<br />
O'Neil Printer Supplies 35<br />
PARC Distributor Group 31<br />
Parcxmart 19<br />
Parkex/Traffex 47<br />
POM Incorporated 20<br />
Scheidt & Bachmann USA, Inc. 15<br />
SKIDATA, INC. 5<br />
Southland Printing Co. 3<br />
Southland Printing Co. 48<br />
Street Smart Technologies 25<br />
T2 Systems, Inc. 27<br />
Talk-A-Phone 8<br />
The <strong>Parking</strong> Network 51<br />
Toledo Ticket Co. 56<br />
Walker <strong>Parking</strong> Consultants 34<br />
Weldon, Williams & Lick, Inc. 26<br />
Zeag USA 55<br />
Zendex Tool Corp 45<br />
FOCUS ADS<br />
IntegraPark 36<br />
Metric <strong>Parking</strong> 36<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com 49
MARKETPLACE<br />
See More Ads and Post Ads NOW at www.parkingtoday.com<br />
BATTERIES<br />
BATTERIES<br />
FOR PARKING METERS<br />
Lithium and Alkaline 6 & 9 volts.<br />
Call Us For Your Best Price!<br />
Battery Clinic, Inc.<br />
800-786-1511<br />
BOOTS AND IMMOBILIZERS<br />
FAST AND TOUGH<br />
email Van Baehr • vanbaehr@gmail.com<br />
CALL: 800-982-6575<br />
NEW from Universal Boot Inc.<br />
The Most Complete Wheel Immobilizer Web Store<br />
www.wheelimmobilizers.com<br />
1-888-354-5699<br />
BOOTHS AND SHELTERS<br />
Need a well built Cashier Booth or Guard<br />
Shelter? Contact: Par-Kut (800)-394-6599<br />
www.parkut.com<br />
CONSULTANTS<br />
LARRY DONOGHUE<br />
ASSOCIATES, INC.<br />
Operational Audits . Manual Preparation<br />
Expert Witness Services<br />
1550 N Northwest Hwy., Ste 334<br />
Park Ridge IL 60068<br />
Tel: 847-297-1180; Fax: 847-297-1103<br />
Email: ldonogh@aol.com<br />
GATES<br />
ENGINEERED PARKING SYSTEMS<br />
<strong>Parking</strong>/Barrier gates. Rated for high<br />
traffic applications. EPS barrier gates<br />
are known for the dependability and<br />
durability. ETL Listed<br />
800-377-4636<br />
visit us at www.epsinfo.com<br />
ENGINEER, TECHNICAL<br />
FastPark is one of the national leaders in<br />
the airport parking services. We are currently<br />
seeking an experienced Engineer to<br />
manage and service our Revenue Control<br />
Systems (SKIDATA) at 19 facilities in 12<br />
markets throughout the US. Candidate<br />
should be based out of Cincinnati, Ohio or<br />
be willing to relocate to Cincinnati, Ohio.<br />
Individual selected for position will receive<br />
training at Ski Data US headquarters and<br />
be required to pass a certification test at<br />
Ski Data headquarters every other year.<br />
Responsibilities<br />
• Troubleshooting and installation of<br />
Skidata equipment for expansions and<br />
new sites.<br />
• Troubleshooting and servicing existing<br />
installation hardware/software –<br />
includes service visits to all 19 facilities<br />
at least twice per year.<br />
• Providing technical support and training<br />
to facility managers.<br />
• Testing of new equipment and<br />
software.<br />
• Equipment purchasing.<br />
• Managing 1 – 2 part-time service<br />
back-up personnel.<br />
Qualifications<br />
• Experience in microprocessor based<br />
hardware and software including:<br />
HELP WANTED<br />
• PC controlled electromechanical<br />
equipment<br />
• Knowledge of hardware activities (i.e.<br />
Client Server, LAN, WLAN)<br />
• Knowledge of software access<br />
(Microsoft, SQL/Database, Oracle)<br />
• Excellent interpersonal skills<br />
• Excellent verbal and written<br />
communication skills<br />
• Moderate - Extensive travel within the<br />
US<br />
• Engineering-related technology degree<br />
helpful (Electrical or Mechanical)<br />
• Network Administration or Cisco<br />
experience a plus<br />
• Networking background and troubleshooting<br />
experience<br />
We offer highly competitive compensation<br />
and benefits.<br />
For immediate consideration, please<br />
forward your resume with earnings<br />
history in confidence to:<br />
FastPark<br />
ATTN: IT – Ski Data Engineer<br />
250 West Court Street, Suite 200 E<br />
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202<br />
Fax 513.241.0497<br />
Resumes@fastparkandrelax.com<br />
Equal Opportunity Employer<br />
HELP WANTED<br />
DIRECTOR OF SALES AND MARKETING<br />
WASHINGTON, D.C.<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Management Inc. (PMI) has an exciting career opportunity for a confident<br />
and seasoned Sales and Marketing professional to identify and develop new parking<br />
business. This significant position will implement and facilitate sales and marketing<br />
programs to achieve company financial and strategic objectives, including<br />
increasing corporate visibility. Position will develop business models and assist<br />
with ROI analysis related to new business. Responsibilities require strong marketing<br />
and corporate management skills and the ability to negotiate effectively.<br />
Minimum qualifications include five years experience in sales and marketing,<br />
which must include experience in the parking or real estate industry. The ideal<br />
candidate will possess superior leadership abilities, excellent communication<br />
skills, community affiliations and personal savvy. Position is based in the<br />
Washington, D.C. Metropolitan area.<br />
PMI is not a “revolving door” company. We are privately held and focus our attention<br />
on satisfying our customers and our employees. If you are in search of a long-term<br />
career opportunity and are interested in increasing PMI’s market share based on<br />
delivering quality services to clients and customers, we encourage you to apply. We<br />
offer an attractive compensation package and benefits plan. Resumes without salary<br />
requirements will not be considered.<br />
Please reply in confidence to: Director of Human Resources<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Management, Inc.<br />
1725 DeSales Street, N.W., Suite 201, Washington, DC 20036<br />
FAX: 202-303-3676 • Email: hr@pmi-parking.com<br />
Please include job code SM2008. PMI is an equal opportunity employer.<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> <strong>Today</strong><br />
reaches over 25,000 <strong>Parking</strong><br />
Professionals Each Month.<br />
50<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
and click on “Marketplace” or call 310 390 5277 ext 4<br />
MARKETPLACE<br />
HELP WANTED REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES<br />
MANAGER<br />
ATLANTA, DALLAS, NEW YORK<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Company of America Airports, LLC<br />
seeking a success-driven Manager for its<br />
locations in Dallas, Atlanta and NYC.<br />
Primary role is to maximize performance<br />
with an emphasis on marketing and sales,<br />
providing excellent customer service and<br />
improving efficiencies. Must be hands-on<br />
with great people skills, problem solving<br />
skills, and experience with Microsoft<br />
Office applications. Two years management/supervisory<br />
experience in travel,<br />
transportation, hotel or car rental industry.<br />
Email resumes with salary requirements<br />
to: lsosa@parkingcompany.com.<br />
PCAA is an Equal Opportunity Employer.<br />
You can order<br />
a Marketplace ad<br />
on line at<br />
www.parkingtoday.com<br />
click on<br />
“Marketplace”<br />
PARKING STRUCTURES CASHIERING EQUIPMENT<br />
CONTRACT #7-09(PK)<br />
CITY OF BIRMINGHAM, MICHIGAN<br />
Sealed proposals endorsed “<strong>Parking</strong><br />
Structures Cashiering Equipment,<br />
Contract #7-09(PK)” will be received from<br />
contractors by the City of Birmingham, at<br />
the office of the City Clerk, located at 151<br />
Martin Street, Birmingham, Michigan, until<br />
2:00 p.m., on Monday, <strong>Febru</strong>ary 16, 2009.<br />
The proposals will be publicly read aloud<br />
at that time.<br />
The work will involve upgrading and supplying<br />
new equipment as specified to provide<br />
credit/debit and cash payment<br />
machines at five existing parking structures,<br />
as well as the removal of existing<br />
cashier booths. All equipment will be<br />
required to function using existing<br />
Amano/McGann hardware and software.<br />
Specifications for the project may be<br />
obtained from the City’s Engineering<br />
Department, (248) 530-1837, located on<br />
the second floor of City Hall, beginning<br />
Monday, <strong>Febru</strong>ary 2, 2009, for a nonrefundable<br />
fee of $25.00 if picked up<br />
directly, or $35.00 if mailed. Plans and<br />
specifications may also be sent in pdf format<br />
by email or mailed on disc for $10.00.<br />
Payment shall be in the form of a check<br />
made payable to the City of Birmingham,<br />
which must be received prior to mailing of<br />
plans and specifications. Overnight deliv-<br />
ery will be accommodated provided<br />
arrangements are made for the shipping<br />
cost to be paid through the purchaser’s<br />
account.<br />
The successful bidder shall be required to<br />
post bonds, and to comply with the contract<br />
requirements of the City Charter.<br />
Bids are firm, and no bid may be withdrawn<br />
for a period of sixty (60) days after<br />
opening of bids.<br />
The City reserves the right to reject any<br />
and all bid proposals, to waive any irregularity<br />
in any of the bid proposals submitted,<br />
and to accept any proposal which it<br />
shall deem to be the most favorable to the<br />
interest of the City.<br />
A certified check or bid bond in the<br />
amount of five percent (5%) of the base<br />
bid must accompany each bid proposal.<br />
NANCY WEISS<br />
CITY CLERK<br />
Published in:<br />
Birmingham Observer & Eccentric<br />
Newspaper – <strong>Febru</strong>ary 1, 2009<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> <strong>Today</strong><br />
PRESTIGE PARKING<br />
Partner wanted for New Jersey based<br />
Valet Company.<br />
Serious inquiries only, please contact me<br />
at the following number 732-859-7346<br />
FOR SALE<br />
EQUIPMENT FOR SALE<br />
Texas Medical Center has a variety of previously<br />
installed Amano McGann parking<br />
hardware available for purchase. Items<br />
include pay on foot machines, ticket dispensers,<br />
lag time readers, and<br />
ExpressPark machines. Equipment in<br />
working condition at the time of replacement.<br />
Contact Troy Froboese at<br />
tfroboese@texasmedicalcenter.org or<br />
713-791-6148 for specific details.<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> <strong>Today</strong>’s<br />
“Classifieds”<br />
Is now called<br />
“Marketplace”<br />
DESMAN<br />
A S S O C I A T E S<br />
ARCHITECTS • ENGINEERS • PLANNERS<br />
NATIONAL PARKING SPECIALISTS<br />
FACILITY PLANNING & DESIGN<br />
FUNCTIONAL DESIGN<br />
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING<br />
RESTORATION<br />
DEMAND FEASIBILITY<br />
DESIGN / BUILD<br />
PARKING CONSULTANTS • RESTORATION ENGINEERS<br />
New York<br />
212.686.5360<br />
Cleveland<br />
216.736.7110<br />
Chicago<br />
312.263.8400<br />
Washington, DC<br />
703.448.1190<br />
Denver<br />
303.740.1700<br />
Hartford<br />
860.563.1117<br />
www.desman.com<br />
Boston<br />
617.778.9882<br />
Las Vegas<br />
877.337.6260<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com 51
DEALERS, INSTALLERS AND SUPPLIERS<br />
Nationwide<br />
DAKTRONICS, INC.<br />
117 Prince Dr., PO Box 5120<br />
Brookings, SD 57006-5128<br />
Tel 888 325-8726<br />
Fax 605-697-4700<br />
parking@daktronics.com<br />
www.daktronics.com<br />
ENGINEERED PARKING SYSTEMS<br />
25010 Avenue Tibbitts,<br />
Valencia, CA 91355<br />
Tel 800-377-4636<br />
Fax 661-294-0674<br />
sales@epsinfo.com<br />
www.epsinfo.com<br />
ISIGNS<br />
7625 Birkmire Drive,<br />
Fairview PA 16415<br />
Tel 866-437-3040<br />
Fax 814-835-7057<br />
www.isignled.com<br />
Northeast<br />
ACCESS TECHNOLOGY<br />
INTEGRATION, INC.<br />
461 Main Avenue,<br />
Wynantskill, NY 12198<br />
Tel 518-237-8510<br />
Fax 518-237-8606<br />
sales@atiaccesscontrol.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
2740 Matheson Blvd. E. Unit 4,<br />
Mississauga, ON L4W4X3<br />
Canada<br />
Tel 905-624-4085<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
300 A Street,<br />
Boston, MA 02210<br />
Tel 617-224-5700<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
Highland Industrial Center<br />
1484 Highland Avenue, Unit 5,<br />
Cheshire, CT 06410<br />
Tel 203-272-2214<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
CINCINNATI TIME OF MAINE<br />
219 Anderson Street, Suite 1<br />
Portland, Maine 04101<br />
Tel 207-774-2336; 800-640-8463<br />
Fax 800-744-3681<br />
dick@netimetrack.com<br />
www.ctrmaine.com<br />
PSX INC.<br />
Factory Authorized<br />
Amano McGann Dealer<br />
708 Terminal Way,<br />
Kennett Square, PA 19348<br />
Tel 800-562-3268<br />
Fax 610-444-9646<br />
www.psxgroup.com<br />
PSX INC.<br />
Factory Authorized<br />
Amano McGann Dealer<br />
2826 Penn Avenue,<br />
Pittsburgh, PA 15222<br />
Tel 412-338-4345<br />
Fax 412-338-4347<br />
www.psxgroup.com<br />
RICHARD N. BEST ASSOCIATES, INC.<br />
15 Trail Road,<br />
Levittown, PA 19056<br />
Tel 215-945-9240<br />
Fax 215-945-9277<br />
sales@rnbest.com<br />
SYRACUSE TIME & ALARM CO., INC.<br />
2201 Burnet Avenue,<br />
Syracuse, NY 13206<br />
Tel 315-433-1234<br />
Fax 315-463-5006<br />
sales@syrtime.com<br />
www.syrtime.com<br />
TCS INTERNATIONAL, INC.<br />
55 Union Avenue,<br />
Sudbury, MA 01776<br />
Tel 978-443-2527<br />
Fax 978-579-9545<br />
sales@tcsintl.com<br />
www.tcsintl.com<br />
TRANSPORTATION TECHNOLOGIES<br />
4395 Iroquois Avenue,<br />
Erie, PA 16511<br />
Tel 888-811-7010<br />
Fax 814-836-8401<br />
brianv@transportation-tech.com<br />
www.transportation-tech.com<br />
TIME & PARKING CONTROLS<br />
7716 West Chester Pike,<br />
Upper Darby, PA 19082<br />
Tel 610-466-5400<br />
Fax 610-449-0680<br />
kelsesser@timeparking.com<br />
www.timeparking.com<br />
WESCOR PARKING CONTROLS, INC.<br />
16 Technology Drive,<br />
Auburn, MA 01501<br />
Tel 508-832-6305<br />
Fax 508-832-6195<br />
www.wescorparking.com<br />
Mid Atlantic<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
102 Railroad Avenue,<br />
Hackensack, NJ 07601<br />
Tel 201-457-0075<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
ENTRY GUARD SYSTEMS<br />
465 Southlake Blvd.,<br />
Richmond VA 23236<br />
Tel 804-423-6523<br />
Fax 804-423-6526<br />
www.entryguardsystems.com<br />
NEW BEGINNINGS PARKING & ACCESS<br />
CONTROLS, LLC<br />
204 Parkway Ct.,<br />
Virginia Beach, VA 23452<br />
Tel 757-965-6226<br />
Fax 757-340-0814<br />
cplatt@newbeginningsparking.com<br />
www.newbeginningsparking.com<br />
SECOM INTERNATIONAL<br />
325 Dalziel Road,<br />
Linden, NJ 07036<br />
Tel 201-792-6112<br />
SENTRY CONTROL SYSTEMS<br />
2116 N Monroe Street, Ste 41,<br />
Arlington, VA 22207<br />
Tel 800-246-6662<br />
Fax 703-842-8435<br />
www.sentrycontrol.com<br />
SMART PARCS, INC.<br />
Authorized Amano Dealer<br />
3835 Holland Blvd., Ste A,<br />
Chesapeake, VA 23323<br />
Tel 757-485-5527<br />
Fax 757-485-5529<br />
david@smartparcs.net<br />
WHITAKER BROTHERS PARKING<br />
SYSTEMS<br />
Authorized Rep for Amano - McGann - Sirit<br />
12410 Washington Ave.,<br />
Rockville, MD 20852<br />
Tel 800-243-9226<br />
Fax 301-230-0187<br />
parking@whitakerbrothers.com<br />
www.whitakerparkingsystems.com<br />
Southeast<br />
ACCESS CONTROL SYSTEMS, LLC<br />
2617 Grissom Drive,<br />
Nashville, TN 37204<br />
Tel 615-255-4466<br />
Fax 615-242-5202<br />
srhaley@acs-llc.com<br />
www.acs-llc.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
3901 SW 47TH Ave., Suite 413,<br />
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33314<br />
Tel 954-316-1004<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
5835 Peachtree Corners East<br />
Building 4, Suite D,<br />
Norcross, GA 30092<br />
Tel 770-447-8620<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
7648 Southland Blvd., Suite 109,<br />
Orlando, FL 32809<br />
Tel 407-826-5766<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
820 Fesslers Parkway, Suite 315,<br />
Nashville, TN 37210<br />
Tel 615-742-9100<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AUTOMATED CONTROL<br />
TECHNOLOGY CORP.<br />
Calle 3 SW # 1020<br />
San Juan, PR 00921-2518<br />
Puerto Rico<br />
Tel 787-782-6006<br />
Fax 787-728-1999<br />
ggrundler@automatic-pr.com<br />
www.automatic-pr.com<br />
ASSOCIATED TIME & PARKING<br />
CONTROLS<br />
1447 West Lindberg Drive, Suite 204,<br />
Slidell, LA 70458<br />
Tel 985-781-3929<br />
Fax 985-781-3950<br />
cweaver@associatedtime.com<br />
www.associatedtime.com<br />
CAROLINA TIME EQUIPMENT CO., INC.<br />
1801 Norland Road,<br />
Charlotte, NC 28205,<br />
Tel 704-536-2700<br />
Fax 704-536-9455<br />
CINCINNATI SYSTEMS<br />
107 Legrand Blvd.,<br />
Greenville, SC 29607<br />
Tel 864-232-6475<br />
Fax 864-232-3535<br />
CONSOLIDATED PARKING EQUIPMENT<br />
FEDERAL APD DISTRIBUTOR<br />
80 NE 29th Street, Suite B,<br />
Miami Fl. 33127<br />
Tel 305-461-2770<br />
loliva@consolidatedparking.com<br />
J. L. ROBERTS & ASSOCIATES, INC.<br />
1005 Harimaw Ct. W. STE 103,<br />
Metairie, LA 70001<br />
Tel 504-831-8113; 225-753-3216<br />
Fax 504- 831-8114<br />
www.jlrpark.com<br />
ITR OF GEORGIA, INC.<br />
3346 Montreal Station, Tucker, GA 30084<br />
Tel 678-775-6214; 800-367-6177 Ext. 214<br />
Fax 770-939-6962<br />
mgivens@itrofgeorgia.com<br />
www.itrofgeorgia.com<br />
INNOVATIVE PARKING CONCEPTS, LLC<br />
Distributor for Skidata, Zippark & Commend<br />
1008 Churchill Court, Woodstock, GA 30188<br />
Tel 877-340-3642<br />
Fax 770-321-1911<br />
sales@ipcusa.com<br />
www.ipcusa.com<br />
PSX INC.<br />
Factory Authorized Amano McGann Dealer<br />
5940 Benjamin Road, Tampa, FL 33634<br />
Tel 813-880-8600<br />
Fax 813-880-8655<br />
www.psxgroup.com<br />
SOUTHERN TIME EQUIPMENT CO., INC.<br />
North and South Carolina<br />
2920 Horace Watson Road<br />
Wilson, NC 27893<br />
Tel 800-849-5654<br />
info@southerntime.com<br />
www.southerntime.com<br />
TIME & PARKING CONTROLS<br />
816-B Post Street,<br />
Greensboro, NC 27405<br />
Tel 336-275-7700<br />
Fax. 336-274-7560<br />
Midwest<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
2008 NW South Outer Loop Road,<br />
Kansas City, MO 64015<br />
Tel 816-229-0056<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
8312 Page Avenue,<br />
St. Louis, MO 63130<br />
Tel 314-426-7727<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
405 North Racine Street,<br />
Chicago, IL 60622<br />
Tel 312-491-8325<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
700 West Michigan Street, Suite 150,<br />
Milwaukee, WI 53233<br />
Tel 414-355-2020<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
651 Taft Street NE,<br />
Minneapolis, MN 55413<br />
Tel 612-331-2020<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
601 South High St.<br />
Columbus, OH 43215<br />
Tel 614-222-0741<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC<br />
157 Meta Drive,<br />
Cincinnati, OH 45237<br />
Tel 513 683-2906<br />
Fax 513 683-4480<br />
michelle.copas@amanomcgann.com<br />
AUTOMATED PARKING TECH.<br />
500 W. 18th Street, Suite 301<br />
Chicago, IL 60616<br />
Tel 312-942-9570<br />
Fax 312-942-9572<br />
ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS, INC.<br />
1252 Allanson Road,<br />
Mundelein, IL 60060<br />
Tel 312-949-0134; 847-949-0134<br />
www.eci-illinois.com<br />
EVENS TIME<br />
1345 Brookville Way, Suite I,<br />
Indianapolis, IN 46239<br />
Tel 317-358-1000; 800-895-1959<br />
Fax 317-308-6608<br />
www.evenstime.com<br />
LIGHT & BREUNING, INC.<br />
912 Lawrence Drive,<br />
Fort Wayne, IN 46804<br />
Tel 800-947-4064<br />
Fax 260-422-6457<br />
sales@lbpark.com<br />
PSX INC.<br />
Factory Authorized Amano McGann Dealer<br />
2340 Hamilton Avenue,<br />
Cleveland, OH 44114<br />
Tel 216-622-2920<br />
Fax 216-622-2921<br />
www.psxgroup.com<br />
SAUNDERS PARKING SYSTEMS<br />
3538 South Old State Rd.,<br />
Delaware, OH 43015<br />
Tel 614-267-1945<br />
saundersparkingsystem@att.net<br />
SIGNATURE CONTROL SYSTEMS, LLC<br />
405 N. Brice Rd.,<br />
Blacklick, OH 43004<br />
Tel 614-864-2222<br />
Fax 614-864-2153<br />
www.signaturecontrols.com<br />
SIGNATURE CONTROL SYSTEMS-<br />
CLEVELAND<br />
FEDERAL APD<br />
35595-F Curtis Blvd.,<br />
Eastlake, OH 44095<br />
Tel 216-244-7047<br />
Fax 440-269-8244<br />
www.signaturecontrols.com<br />
SIGNATURE CONTROL SYSTEMS-<br />
CINCINNATI/DAYTON<br />
FEDERAL APD<br />
131 Broadway St., Loveland, OH 45140<br />
Tel 513-504-4506<br />
Fax 513-707-1809<br />
www.signaturecontrols.com<br />
TAPCO<br />
800 Wall Street,<br />
Elm Grove, WI 53122<br />
Tel 800-236-0112<br />
Fax 262-814-7017<br />
mark@tapconet.com<br />
www.tapconet.com<br />
TAPCO<br />
5356 S. Archer Drive,<br />
Chicago, IL 60638<br />
Tel 800-236-0112<br />
Fax 800-444-0331<br />
mark@tapconet.com<br />
www.tapconet.com<br />
TRAFFIC & SAFETY CONTROL<br />
SYSTEMS, INC.<br />
“Authorized Amano Dealer”<br />
48584 Downing, Wixom, MI 48393<br />
Tel 248-348-0570<br />
Fax 248-348-6505<br />
www.trafficandsafety.com<br />
ZEAG USA, INC.<br />
203 North LaSalle Street, Ste M5,<br />
Chicago, IL 60601<br />
Tel 312-252-4872<br />
Fax 312-252-4875<br />
sales@zeagusa.com<br />
www.zeagusa.com<br />
Southwest<br />
ACCUTRONICS, INC.<br />
1429 W. Hildebrand,<br />
San Antonio, TX 78201<br />
Tel 800-730-8463 or 210-736-5300<br />
Fax 210-734-8463<br />
toneal@accutronicsinc.com<br />
www.accutronicsinc.com<br />
ASSOCIATED TIME & PARKING<br />
CONTROLS<br />
9104 Diplomacy Row,<br />
Dallas, TX 75247<br />
Tel 214-637-2763<br />
Fax 214-688-0411<br />
carcher@associatedtime.com<br />
www.associatedtime.com<br />
52<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
DEALERS, INSTALLERS AND SUPPLIERS<br />
List your Company here. Contact Joyce at 310 390 5277 Ext. 7<br />
ASSOCIATED TIME & PARKING<br />
CONTROLS<br />
1217 West Loop North, Suite 190,<br />
Houston, TX 77055<br />
Tel 713-263-1366<br />
Fax 713-263-8154<br />
grodriguez@associatedtime.com<br />
www.associatedtime.com<br />
BP EQUIPMENT COMPANY<br />
Magnetic and Federal Dealer<br />
805 Clear Creek Ave, League City, TX 77573<br />
Tel 281-332-0288; Fax 281-332-0431<br />
San Antonio, TX<br />
Tel 210-559-1307<br />
bob@bpequipment.com<br />
www.bpequipment.com<br />
BP EQUIPMENT COMPANY<br />
Federal APD Dealer<br />
1611 N. Interstate 35 East, Suite 116<br />
Carrollton, TX 75008<br />
Tel 972-446-7275 (PARK)<br />
Fax 972-446-7274<br />
Gene@bpequipment.com<br />
www.bpequipment.com<br />
CENTRAL TIME RECORDER<br />
4001 East Lancaster<br />
Fort Worth, TX 76103<br />
Tel 817-534-0206<br />
Fax 817-534-4485<br />
centraltime@sbcglobal.net<br />
www.mitchell-time-parking.com<br />
MITCHELL TIME & PARKING<br />
4806 North IH 35, Austin, TX 78751<br />
Tel 512-371-7773; Fax 512-371-7181<br />
San Antonio, TX<br />
Tel 866-371-7773<br />
mtparking@sbcglobal.net<br />
www.mitchell-time-parking.com<br />
PROTECH ACCESS<br />
4401 S. Pinemont # 204, Houston, TX 77041<br />
Tel 713-PROTECH (776-8324)<br />
Fax 713-895-8499;<br />
john@protechaccess.com<br />
www.protechaccess.com<br />
Mountain<br />
ACCESS & TIME AUTOMATION, INC.<br />
1147 South Huron Street,<br />
Denver, CO 80223<br />
Tel 303-698-0065;<br />
Fax 303-698-0873<br />
cwgillen@gmail.com<br />
MOUNTAIN PARKING EQUIPMENT<br />
2009 S. Cherokee St., Denver, CO 80223<br />
Tel 720-259-4880;<br />
Fax 720-904-5296<br />
scottsouder@mtnpark.com<br />
www.mtnpark.com<br />
PROTECTIONTECH<br />
47 South Orange St, D#3<br />
Salt Lake City, UT 84116<br />
Tel 801-256-0214<br />
www.protectiontech.com<br />
Northwest<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
3837 13th Avenue West,<br />
Suite 208<br />
Seattle, WA 98119<br />
Tel 206-575-1980<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
DGM CONTROLS<br />
1426 Elliott Ave. West,<br />
Seattle, WA 98119<br />
Tel 206-284-6919<br />
Fax 206-284-5243<br />
biff@dgmcontrols.com<br />
ENTRANCE CONTROLS, INC.<br />
664 Industry Drive,<br />
Tukwila, WA 98188<br />
Tel 206-622-0452<br />
Fax 206-575-9755<br />
stevemenrath@eci-nw.com<br />
NORTHWEST PARKING EQUIP. CO.<br />
15029 Bothell Way, NE, #200<br />
Seattle, WA 98155<br />
Tel 206-363-5265<br />
Fax 206-367-6578<br />
PACIFIC CASCADE/DGM SYSTEMS<br />
14208 N.W. 3rd Court suite 200<br />
Vancouver, WA 98685<br />
Tel 800-292-7275<br />
Fax 360-574-9325<br />
markc@parkingzone.com<br />
www.parkingzone.com<br />
PROTECTIONTECH<br />
2891 152nd Ave NE<br />
Redmond, WA 98052<br />
Tel 425-869-7778<br />
Fax 425-869-7717<br />
Spokane Office 509-747-6231<br />
www.protectiontech.com<br />
Far West<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
900 Doolittle Drive, Suite 8A<br />
San Leandro, CA 94577<br />
Tel 510-568-6484<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
8220 Belvedere Avenue, Suite B<br />
Sacramento, CA 95826<br />
Tel 916-456-1065<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
AMANO MCGANN, INC.<br />
22619 Old Canal Road<br />
Yorba Linda, CA 92887<br />
Tel 714-282-3500<br />
www.amanomcgann.com<br />
CONSTRUCTION ACCESS<br />
3802 Rosecrans Street Ste #232<br />
San Diego, CA 92110<br />
Tel 619-749-1494<br />
Fax 619-749-1498<br />
info.constructionaccess@cox.net<br />
GMG SYSTEMS, INC.<br />
129 Encinitas Ave., Suite C<br />
Monrovia, CA 91016<br />
Tel 888-464-7978 ext 701<br />
Fax 888-464-7978<br />
sales@gmgsys.com<br />
www.gmgsys.com<br />
GMG SYSTEMS, INC.<br />
14439 Catalina Street, San Leandro, CA 94577<br />
Tel 888-464-7978 ext 701<br />
Fax 888-464-7978<br />
sales@gmgsys.com<br />
www.gmgsys.com<br />
PACIFIC ACCESS CONTROLS, INC.<br />
7733 Densmore Ave., Unit 1<br />
Van Nuys, CA 91406<br />
Tel 323-285-5236<br />
Fax 323-285-5631<br />
kevinm@pac-ca.com<br />
PARKING TECHNICAL SERVICES, INC.<br />
14140 E. Alondra Blvd., Ste A<br />
Santa Fe Springs, CA 90670<br />
Tel: 888-282-4506<br />
Fax 562-404-9179<br />
www.parkingtechservices.com<br />
SAS ACCESS SYSTEMS<br />
7292 Opportunity Rd., Suite B<br />
San Diego, CA 92111<br />
Tel 858-541-7896; Fax 858-541-7889<br />
www.sas-access.com<br />
SECOM INTERNATIONAL<br />
9610 Bellanca Ave.,<br />
Los Angeles, CA 90045<br />
Tel 310-641-1290<br />
SENTRY CONTROL SYSTEMS<br />
9842 Glenoaks Blvd., Sun Valley, CA 91352<br />
Tel 800-246-6662<br />
Fax 818-252-0400<br />
www.sentrycontrol.com<br />
UNITED CALIFORNIA GLASS & DOOR<br />
745 Cesar Chavez, San Francisco, CA 94124<br />
Tel 415 824-8500<br />
Fax 415 648-3838<br />
al@ucgd.com<br />
ZEAG USA, INC.<br />
Los Angeles, CA<br />
Contact: Don Graham<br />
Tel 773-954-1502<br />
don.graham@zeagusa.com<br />
www.zeagusa.com<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com 53
UPCOMING EVENTS<br />
2009<br />
March 3 - 4, 2009<br />
7th Annual Urban Transportation &<br />
Transit Summit<br />
Location: Toronto, CA<br />
Contact: Emily Davies<br />
866-298-9343 x 275<br />
Email: emilydavies@strategyinstitute.com<br />
March 18 - 20, 2009<br />
Intertraffic China<br />
Location: Shanghai Exhibition Center<br />
Contact: Albert de Soet<br />
+31 (0)20 549 12 12<br />
Email: intertraffic@rai.nl<br />
March 30 - April 2, 2009<br />
Texas <strong>Parking</strong> Association Annual<br />
Conference<br />
Location: AT&T Executive Education &<br />
Conference Center - Univ of Texas<br />
at Austin<br />
Email: info@texasparking.org<br />
April 2 - 3, 2009<br />
New England <strong>Parking</strong> Council's 18th<br />
Annual <strong>Parking</strong> & Transportation<br />
Conference<br />
Location: Boston, MA<br />
Contact: Dan Kupferman<br />
800-732-6868 x 324<br />
Email: dkupferman@parkeon.com<br />
April 21 - 23, 2009<br />
Traffex 2009<br />
Location: NEC Birmingham, England<br />
Contact: Hemming Group Ltd<br />
+44020 7973 6401<br />
April 22 - 24, 2009<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Association of Georgia<br />
Annual Meeting<br />
Location: Savannah, GA<br />
Contact: Michael Givens<br />
770-452-3649<br />
Email: info@thepag.org<br />
April 27 - 29, 2009<br />
Sweden: Svenska<br />
Parkeringsforegingen<br />
Annual Conference & Exhibition<br />
Location: Gavle, Sweden<br />
Contact: Sten Hakansson<br />
+46 (0)40 34 21 00<br />
Email: kansli@svepark.se<br />
May 3 - 5, 2009<br />
Big 10 Midwestern Transportation<br />
and <strong>Parking</strong> Conference<br />
Location: University of Illinois,<br />
Champaign<br />
Contact: Michelle Winters<br />
Email: wintersm@illinois.edu<br />
May 17 - 20, 2009<br />
IPI Annual Conference and Expo<br />
Location: Denver Convention Center,<br />
Denver, CO<br />
Contact: Lauri Chudoba<br />
540-371-7535<br />
Email: ipi@parking.org<br />
May 21 - 22, 2009<br />
BOSSCARS Annual User Group<br />
Conference<br />
Location: Warwick Denver Hotel<br />
Contact: Shannon Beckerich<br />
910-352-8413<br />
Email:<br />
shannon@boss-consulting-inc.com<br />
May 27 - 29, 2009<br />
Intertraffic Istanbul<br />
Location: Istanbul, Turkey<br />
Contact: Albert de Soet<br />
+31 20 549 2216<br />
Email: a.d.soet@rai.nl<br />
June 1 - 2, 2009<br />
Ohio <strong>Parking</strong> Association<br />
60th Annual Convention<br />
Location: Columbus Hyatt Regency<br />
(Convention Center)<br />
Contact: Jake Carleton<br />
Email: jcarleton@cuyahogacounty.us<br />
June 17 - 18, 2009<br />
Parken 2009<br />
Location: Frankfurt, Germany<br />
Contact: Annette Holtmann<br />
+49 (0)611 9 51 6656<br />
Email:<br />
annette.holtmann@mfa.messefrankfurt.com<br />
June 17 - 18, 2009<br />
Parkopolis France<br />
Location: Paris France<br />
Contact: Stephane Gontier<br />
Email:<br />
stephane.gontier@groupemoniteur.fr<br />
June 25 - 26, 2009<br />
BOMA Medical Office Buildings &<br />
Healthcare Facilities Seminar<br />
Location: Marriott Philadelphia<br />
Downtown - PA<br />
Contact: Vicki Cummins<br />
888-777-6956<br />
Email: vcummins@showmgmt.com<br />
June 28 - 30, 2009<br />
BOMA Annual Conference and Office<br />
Building Show<br />
Location: Pennsylvania Convention<br />
Center - Philadelphia, PA<br />
Contact: Vicki Cummins<br />
888-777-6965<br />
Email: vcummins@showmgnt.com<br />
June 28 - July 1, 2009<br />
World <strong>Parking</strong> Symposium VII<br />
Location: Breda, The Netherlands<br />
Contact: Doreen Ostrowski<br />
Email: doreen.canacn@sympatico.ca<br />
July 16 - 17, 2009<br />
Meeting of the <strong>Parking</strong> and<br />
Transportation Industry Minds<br />
Location: University of Rochester,<br />
Rochester, NY<br />
Contact: Glen Secard<br />
585-273-2149<br />
Email: gsicard<br />
@facilities.rochester.edu<br />
July 26 - 28, 2009<br />
4th Annual PIPTA - Pacific<br />
Intermountain <strong>Parking</strong> &<br />
Transportation Association<br />
Location: Tacoma, WA<br />
Contact: Linda Kildew<br />
Email: lkildew@wsu.edu<br />
September 23 - 25, 2009<br />
14th European <strong>Parking</strong> Association<br />
Congress<br />
Location: Vienna Austria<br />
Contact: Gerhard Trost-Heutmekers<br />
+49 (0)221 257 10 1<br />
Email: epa@europeanparking.eu<br />
September 26 - 30, 2009<br />
Canadian <strong>Parking</strong> Association<br />
Annual Conference<br />
Location: Quebec, QC<br />
Contact: Mathieu Blake<br />
613-727-0700<br />
Email: mathieu@canadianparking.ca<br />
September 28 - October 2, 2009<br />
Southwest <strong>Parking</strong> Association<br />
Location: Reno, NV<br />
Contact: Michelle Horton<br />
Email: mhorton@unr.edu<br />
October 12 - 15, 2009<br />
National <strong>Parking</strong> Association<br />
Annual Convention<br />
Location: Washington, DC<br />
Contact: Patricia Langfeld<br />
Email: plangfeld@npapark.org<br />
October 27 - 30, 2009<br />
TRAFIC - International Road Safey<br />
and Equipment Exhibition<br />
Location: Madrid, Spain<br />
Contact: Marta Peraza<br />
1-305-371-7767<br />
Email:<br />
miamioffice@madridinternational.com<br />
October 30 - 31, 2009<br />
International Philippine <strong>Parking</strong><br />
Expo & Conference<br />
Location: SMX Convention Center<br />
Manila, Philippines<br />
Contact: TBD<br />
November 9 - 11, 2009<br />
Middle East <strong>Parking</strong> Symposium<br />
Location: Abu Dhabi, UAE<br />
Contact: Davyd Farrell<br />
+971 50 565 2519<br />
Email: davyd.farrell<br />
@islandmedia-me.com<br />
November 17 - 19, 2009<br />
TranspoQuip Latin America 2009<br />
Location: Sao Paulo, Brazil<br />
Contact: Sebas van den Ende<br />
+55 21 3717 4719<br />
Email: sebas@real-alliance.com<br />
November 18 - 20, 2009<br />
New Jersey <strong>Parking</strong> Institute<br />
Annual Conference<br />
Location: Trump Marina,<br />
Atlantic City, NJ<br />
Contact: Donna Gentile<br />
Email: ltbdonna@optonline.net<br />
2010<br />
<strong>Febru</strong>ary 13 - 17, 2010<br />
NPA Winter Board Meeting<br />
Location: San Jose del Cabo, Mexico<br />
Contact: Patricia Langfeld<br />
Email: plangfeld@npapark.org<br />
March 7 - 10, 2010<br />
<strong>Parking</strong> Industry Exhibition<br />
Location: Chicago, IL<br />
Contact: Andy Van Horn<br />
310-390-5277 Ext 1<br />
Email: andy@parkingtoday.com<br />
March 23 - 25, 2010<br />
Intertraffic 2010<br />
Location: The Rai, Amsterdam<br />
Contact: Erik Dijkshoorn<br />
Email: intertraffic@rai.nl<br />
October 2 - 6, 2010<br />
Canadian <strong>Parking</strong> Association Annual<br />
Conference and Trade Show<br />
Location: Whistler, BC<br />
Contact: Mathieu Blake<br />
613-727-0700<br />
Email: mathieu@canadianparking.ca<br />
HAVE YOUR EVENT<br />
LISTED HERE –<br />
LOG ON TO:<br />
www.parkingtoday.com<br />
AND CLICK ON<br />
“CALENDAR”<br />
54<br />
FEBRUARY 2009 • PARKING TODAY • www.parkingtoday.com
Occupancy based Pricing -<br />
Totally Dynamic<br />
Occupancy based pricing for parking allows<br />
prices to rise with demand and is extremely<br />
suitable for competitive environments like<br />
shopping centers, airports and venues who<br />
wish to compete for customers, increase<br />
revenue or increased parking utilization.<br />
The feature is designed to optimize parking<br />
efficiency due to the flexibility it provides<br />
operators in attracting business.<br />
The solution has been made possible by new<br />
technology from Zeag. The system cleverly<br />
works out the occupancy from the entry and<br />
exit barrier statistics and sets the fee charged<br />
according to the occupancy. The fee charged<br />
increases as parking occupancy increases -<br />
Totally Dynamic.<br />
Zeag USA Inc.<br />
9555 James Avenue South<br />
Suite 260<br />
Bloomington, MN 55431<br />
Ph: 952-277-1821<br />
Fx: 952-277-3607<br />
sales@zeagusa.com<br />
www.zeag.com<br />
Dynamic Rates -<br />
from ZEAG