Helensburgh Tunnel REF - Transport for NSW - NSW Government
Helensburgh Tunnel REF - Transport for NSW - NSW Government
Helensburgh Tunnel REF - Transport for NSW - NSW Government
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Digital Train Radio System<br />
<strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Site<br />
Review of Environmental Factors<br />
May 2013<br />
Released<br />
By: JM<br />
UGL<br />
Date: 21/05/2013 Reviewers: JM,JM,JM,JM<br />
Page 1 of 78
Table of Contents<br />
Executive Summary .................................................................................................................... 4<br />
1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 7<br />
1.1 Background to the Project ........................................................................................ 7<br />
1.2 Background to the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> site ............................................................ 8<br />
1.3 Location and Land Use ............................................................................................. 8<br />
1.4 Consultation ............................................................................................................ 12<br />
2 Statutory Position and Requirements ........................................................................... 14<br />
2.1 Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 ............................................... 14<br />
2.2 State Environmental Planning Policy (Infrastructure) 2007 .................................... 15<br />
2.3 Confirmation of Statutory Position .......................................................................... 15<br />
2.4 Other Relevant Environmental Planning Instruments ............................................. 16<br />
2.5 Other <strong>NSW</strong> Legislation ........................................................................................... 17<br />
2.6 Commonwealth Legislation ..................................................................................... 19<br />
2.7 Ecologically Sustainable Development ................................................................... 20<br />
2.8 Other Guidelines ..................................................................................................... 22<br />
2.9 Licences and Approvals .......................................................................................... 22<br />
3 Description of the Proposal ........................................................................................... 23<br />
3.1 Scope of Proposed Works ...................................................................................... 23<br />
3.2 Construction Methodology ...................................................................................... 26<br />
3.3 Timing and Costing ................................................................................................. 27<br />
3.4 Alternatives to the DTRS ........................................................................................ 28<br />
3.5 Alternatives to the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> site ........................................................... 29<br />
3.6 Justification of the Preferred Option ....................................................................... 31<br />
4 Environmental Impact and Risks .................................................................................. 32<br />
4.1 Land<strong>for</strong>ms, Geology and Soils ................................................................................ 32<br />
4.2 Water Quality and Hydrology .................................................................................. 33<br />
4.3 Air Quality ............................................................................................................... 35<br />
4.4 Biodiversity .............................................................................................................. 36<br />
4.5 Noise and Vibration ................................................................................................. 38<br />
4.6 Heritage .................................................................................................................. 43<br />
4.7 Waste ...................................................................................................................... 44<br />
4.8 Contaminated Land ................................................................................................. 45<br />
4.9 Hazardous Materials ............................................................................................... 46<br />
4.10 Visual Aesthetics and Urban Design ...................................................................... 47<br />
4.11 Land Use ................................................................................................................. 51<br />
4.12 Socio-Economic Effects .......................................................................................... 51<br />
Page 2 of 78
4.13 Electromagnetic Energy (EME) .............................................................................. 52<br />
4.14 Traffic and Access .................................................................................................. 53<br />
4.15 Utilities and Services ............................................................................................... 54<br />
4.16 Light spill ................................................................................................................. 54<br />
4.17 Demand on Resources ........................................................................................... 55<br />
4.18 Cumulative Environmental Effects .......................................................................... 55<br />
4.19 Consideration of Clause 228 of EP&A Regulations and EPBC Act ....................... 56<br />
4.20 Summary of Control Measures ............................................................................... 60<br />
4.21 Implementation Process ......................................................................................... 67<br />
5 References ....................................................................................................................... 68<br />
Appendix 1: Principles from the Telecommunications Facilities Guidelines ..................... 69<br />
Appendix 2: Design Plans ........................................................................................................ 76<br />
Appendix 3: Database Searches .............................................................................................. 77<br />
Appendix 4: Electro- Magnetic Energy (EME) Reports.......................................................... 78<br />
Page 3 of 78
Executive Summary<br />
Need <strong>for</strong> the Proposal<br />
<strong>Transport</strong> <strong>for</strong> New South Wales (Tf<strong>NSW</strong>) currently operates an analogue train radio system<br />
known as MetroNet <strong>for</strong> operational communications between signallers and train drivers. This<br />
system has reached the end of its serviceable life and requires replacement. The New South<br />
Wales <strong>Government</strong> and Tf<strong>NSW</strong> have begun work on the implementation of a Digital Train Radio<br />
System (DTRS) which will replace this analogue system and address a number of<br />
recommendations from the Waterfall Special Commission of Inquiry. The DTRS will be a secure<br />
digital train radio system designed to provide reliable voice and data communications on a<br />
Global Systems Mobile – Railway (GSM-R) plat<strong>for</strong>m.<br />
The DTRS will provide 100% radio coverage across the 1455 kilometre electrified rail network.<br />
The DTRS has an expected design life of at least 15 years. UGL Infrastructure has been<br />
contracted to design, construct, commission and maintain the DTRS.<br />
Proposal Description<br />
The <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> distributed base station (DBS) comprises three sites (Outdoor<br />
Locations 1 – 3 inclusive, hereafter referred to as Outdoor Location 1, Outdoor Location 2, and<br />
Outdoor Location 3) that will be installed on relatively level ground in cleared, grassy areas<br />
within the rail corridor of the South Coast Line. <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Station is about 670 metres<br />
southwest of the proposed Outdoor Location 1 site.<br />
The proposed work will involve the elements listed below.<br />
• A new 20 metre tall steel monopole with a bored pile foundation at Outdoor Location 1. The<br />
pole will have a 1500 millimetre lightning rod installed at the top and be hinged about 1200-<br />
1400 millimetres from the base to assist in erection but, once established, the hinge will be<br />
bolted in order to fix the monopole in place.<br />
• A new 10 metre tall mast at both Outdoor Location 2 and Outdoor Location 3.<br />
• Two Argus panel antennas mounted onto the monopole at Outdoor Location 1, situated at<br />
a height of 19 metres. Two Yagi antennas mounted on to the mast at Outdoor Location 2<br />
and one Yagi antenna mounted to the mast at Outdoor Location 3, both situated at a height<br />
of 9.5 metres. The antennas will be mounted while the pole and masts are on the ground.<br />
• One aboveground DBS cabinet installed at each Outdoor Locations, which will contain all<br />
necessary radio frequency equipment (about 880 millimetres wide, 1000 millimetres long<br />
and 1700 millimetres tall) and one power equipment. Cabinets will be installed on a<br />
concrete slab close to the monopole and mast locations.<br />
• Conduit feeder cables to connect to the power and fibre supply, installed into new trenches<br />
or new and existing galvanized steel trough (GST).<br />
Page 4 of 78
• Leaky feeder installation along the length of the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong>.<br />
• Other associated and necessary activities to ensure the proper functioning of the radio<br />
communications facility including earthing, safe access, signage and bollards <strong>for</strong> vehicle<br />
protection.<br />
Approval Process<br />
The proposal is being assessed under Part 5 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment<br />
Act 1979 (EP&A Act) which requires Tf<strong>NSW</strong> to consider the environmental impacts of the<br />
proposal.<br />
This Review of Environmental Factors (<strong>REF</strong>) has been prepared to address the requirements of<br />
the EP&A Act. It assesses the potential environmental impacts of the proposal within the<br />
context of Clause 228 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2000 (EP&A<br />
Regulation) and the Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995 (TSC Act). The requirements<br />
of the Commonwealth Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (EPBC<br />
Act) are also considered.<br />
Environmental Impact Assessment<br />
The benefits of the proposal cannot be achieved without some degree of environmental impact.<br />
The impacts resulting from construction and operation of the facility have been assessed in this<br />
<strong>REF</strong>. This <strong>REF</strong> identifies that, subject to the implementation of mitigation measures, potential<br />
environmental impacts can be controlled and reduced to acceptable levels and would not<br />
significantly affect the environment.<br />
The main environmental issues relate to construction impacts such as erosion and<br />
sedimentation risks as well as short-term traffic, air quality and noise issues <strong>for</strong> nearby<br />
receivers. Such impacts will be managed through the implementation of a program wide<br />
Construction Environmental Management Plan (CEMP) and site specific Environmental Control<br />
Map (ECM).<br />
In the long term, a new monopole and masts will be introduced into the visual landscape. The<br />
monopole and its antennas will not be bulky and will be screened by vegetation along the rail<br />
corridor. Electromagnetic energy (EME) impacts have also been considered and the EME levels<br />
<strong>for</strong> the proposal will be well within the limits set by the Australian Radiation Protection and<br />
Nuclear Safety Agency (ARPANSA).<br />
Page 5 of 78
Environmental Management<br />
Following determination of the project, construction works will be undertaken in accordance with<br />
the program wide CEMP and site specific ECM. The CEMP and ECM will further detail <strong>REF</strong><br />
mitigation measures and will be prepared in accordance with the following:<br />
Guideline <strong>for</strong> the Preparation of Environmental Management Plans (Department of<br />
Infrastructure, Planning and Natural Resources, 2004)<br />
The Environmental Management Plan <strong>for</strong> DTRS (UGL Infrastructure, 2010)<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong> Guide to Environmental Control Map (2012).<br />
The following sub-plans are proposed in the <strong>REF</strong> and will be prepared concurrently with the<br />
CEMP and/or ECM as appropriate:<br />
Erosion and Sediment Control Plan<br />
Water Management Plan<br />
Waste Management Plan<br />
Traffic Management Plan<br />
The program wide CEMP has been approved by Tf<strong>NSW</strong>. The site specific ECM will be<br />
reviewed and approved by Tf<strong>NSW</strong> prior to the commencement of construction.<br />
Page 6 of 78
1 Introduction<br />
1.1 Background to the Project<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong> currently operates an analogue train radio system known as MetroNet <strong>for</strong> operational<br />
communications between signallers and train drivers. This system has reached the end of its<br />
serviceable life and requires replacement. The New South Wales <strong>Government</strong> and Tf<strong>NSW</strong> have<br />
begun work on the implementation of a Digital Train Radio System (DTRS) which will replace<br />
this analogue system and address a number of recommendations from the Waterfall Special<br />
Commission of Inquiry regarding communications in <strong>NSW</strong> rail operations and within RailCorp.<br />
Following the establishment of Tf<strong>NSW</strong>, RailCorp became an operating agency within Tf<strong>NSW</strong>.<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong> is now the proponent <strong>for</strong> the DTRS.<br />
The primary objectives of the DTRS project are to:<br />
Provide continuous radio coverage across the entire electrified rail network<br />
Replace and improve on the current MetroNet communications system<br />
Provide a technology plat<strong>for</strong>m <strong>for</strong> future development of the Automatic Train Protection<br />
system<br />
Adopt best management and administrative practices while complying with the principles of<br />
ecologically sustainable development.<br />
The DTRS will provide secure and reliable voice and data communications via a Global<br />
Systems Mobile – Railway (GSM-R) plat<strong>for</strong>m. It will be used by train controllers, train drivers,<br />
train guards and signallers. The system is designed to allow <strong>for</strong> growth in both the size of the<br />
network and the number of services using it. It will be compatible with communications systems<br />
used by other users of the network, e.g. freight operators.<br />
The DTRS will provide 100% radio coverage along approximately 1455 kilometres of the<br />
electrified rail network, including along approximately 70 kilometres of tunnel, and has an<br />
expected design life of at least 15 years.<br />
The DTRS will include:<br />
A main switching centre at a CBD location<br />
A geographically separated back-up switching centre at Homebush<br />
On-train equipment in approximately 675 train cabs<br />
About 250 base transceiver stations (BTS) as well as other base stations in tunnels<br />
Approximately 65 dispatcher terminal units<br />
Capability to provide staff with handheld terminals.<br />
Page 7 of 78
The DTRS will provide continuous radio coverage across the entire electrified rail network <strong>for</strong><br />
on-train radios and permit at least 14 simultaneous voice calls from each base station.<br />
DTRS systems are now widely used as a standard by major rail operators in Europe and Asia.<br />
In Australia, GSM-R is being installed on the Melbourne train network by the Victorian<br />
<strong>Government</strong>.<br />
1.2 Background to the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> site<br />
The proposed distributed base station (DBS) at <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> is part of the DTRS that is<br />
being developed across the electrified rail network. The proposal at <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> is <strong>for</strong> a<br />
new DBS comprising three locations, Outdoor Location 1, Location 2, and Location 3, which will<br />
provide coverage along a section of track between the adjacent <strong>Helensburgh</strong> BTS site and the<br />
Metropolitan DBS site on the South Coast Line, including coverage through the <strong>Helensburgh</strong><br />
<strong>Tunnel</strong>.<br />
The <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> site is one of about 250 radio facilities which will provide an enhanced,<br />
efficient and reliable communication system <strong>for</strong> the electrified railway network.<br />
1.3 Location and Land Use<br />
Site Name<br />
<strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong><br />
Street Address In the rail corridor, <strong>Helensburgh</strong>, <strong>NSW</strong> 2508<br />
Property Description<br />
South Coast Line<br />
Railway Line<br />
South Coast Line<br />
Chainage Outdoor Location 1<br />
Near SW47+180<br />
Outdoor Location 2<br />
Near SW47+575<br />
Outdoor Location 3<br />
Near SW48+160<br />
Site Co-ordinates<br />
Reference system: GDA94<br />
Outdoor Location 1<br />
Latitude: -34.17282<br />
Longitude: 151.00128<br />
Page 8 of 78
Outdoor Location 2<br />
Latitude: -34.174102<br />
Longitude: 151.004980<br />
Outdoor Location 3<br />
Latitude: -34.177860<br />
Longitude: 151.009003<br />
Local <strong>Government</strong> Area<br />
Wollongong<br />
<strong>NSW</strong> State Electorate<br />
Heathcote<br />
Catchment<br />
Small unnamed tributary, <strong>for</strong>ms part of the Hacking River<br />
Catchment<br />
Nearest Railway Station<br />
<strong>Helensburgh</strong><br />
Outdoor Location 1 will be located on the southern side of the rail corridor about 670 metres<br />
north-east of <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Station (refer to Figure 1 and Figure 2). The site is on generally level<br />
ground in a cleared, grass and gravel area approximately seven metres from the railway line.<br />
Outdoor Location 2 will be located on the southwest side of the rail corridor about 910 metres<br />
east northeast of <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Station (refer to Figure 1 and Figure 2). The site is on generally<br />
level ground in a cleared, grass and gravel area approximately six metres from the railway line.<br />
Outdoor Location 3 will be located on the eastern side of the rail corridor about 1.25 kilometres<br />
east of <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Station (refer to Figure 1 and Figure 2). The site is on generally level<br />
ground in a cleared, grass and gravel area approximately eight metres from the railway line.<br />
The sites are within the Wollongong Local <strong>Government</strong> Area (LGA) and the proposed works will<br />
be undertaken on land in Zone SP2 – Infrastructure.<br />
The section of rail corridor at the proposed <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> DBS sites are surrounded by<br />
the Royal National Park situated northeast and east of the predominantly residential township of<br />
<strong>Helensburgh</strong>. Notable features surrounding the proposed sites are listed below.<br />
• The Royal National Park, approximately 25 metres away, borders the rail corridor to the<br />
north, east and west of Outdoor Location 1, to the north and east of Outdoor Location 2<br />
and to the north, east and south of Outdoor Location 3.<br />
• <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Waste Disposal Depot is located further to the south, southwest and west of<br />
Outdoor Location 1, Location 2, and Location 3, respectively.<br />
Page 9 of 78
• Residential properties are located beyond the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Waste Disposal Depot with the<br />
nearest residential receiver located on Gardiner Place 500 metres southwest from Outdoor<br />
Location 1.<br />
• There are no child care centres, aged care facilities, schools or hospitals within 500 metres<br />
of the proposed sites.<br />
There is adequate vehicle and plant access to Outdoor Location 1 and Outdoor Location 2 via<br />
existing railway gates and a sealed road off Gardiner Place. Access to Outdoor Location 3 will<br />
be via an unsealed track off Nixon Place and is suitable <strong>for</strong> construction vehicle access.<br />
The Royal National Park is listed as registered on the National Heritage List and Garawarra<br />
State Conservation Area is listed as an indicative place on the Register of National Estate.<br />
There are no restrictions <strong>for</strong> the Register of the National Estate places, as the register is now a<br />
non-statutory archive.<br />
The Royal National Park borders the rail corridor within close proximity to all three proposed<br />
Outdoor Locations. <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Railway Station Group is a state listed heritage item and is<br />
also on the Wollongong LEP heritage schedule and RailCorp s.170 heritage register. There are<br />
eight indigenous places in <strong>Helensburgh</strong> included on the Register of National Estate, however,<br />
details relating to the nature and locations of these items are not available through the<br />
Australian Heritage Database.<br />
Dense bushland comprising mature trees and undergrowth lines both sides of the rail corridor at<br />
all three locations. RailCorp Biodiversity Mapping indicates that the sites are within an area of<br />
remnant vegetation. The site also contains weeds such as Crofton weed, mint bush, Lantana,<br />
Fleabane, and Rhodes grass and Bidens.<br />
A review of the RailCorp Sensitive Site Register identified native vegetation of the Royal<br />
National Park as a sensitive area proximal to all three locations. The sensitive native vegetation<br />
of the Royal National Park is adjacent to the rail corridor from Waterfall to Ot<strong>for</strong>d (chainage<br />
SW39+500 to SW52+000) which includes all three of the proposed Outdoor Locations of the<br />
<strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> DBS.<br />
The closest waterway is a small unnamed drainage line located approximately 80 metres to the<br />
north-west of Outdoor Location 1 and is a tributary of the Hacking River catchment.<br />
Page 10 of 78
Figure 1<br />
Proposed sites and surrounds<br />
© 2011 Google – Image © 2011 Sinclair Knight Merz © 2011 Whereis® Sensis Pty Ltd<br />
Outdoor Location 1<br />
Outdoor Location 2<br />
Outdoor Location 3<br />
Figure 2<br />
Outdoor Locations Map<br />
Map section reproduced with permission of UBD. Copyright Universal Publishers Pty Ltd DD 06/11<br />
Page 11 of 78
1.4 Consultation<br />
The consultation activities <strong>for</strong> the proposed work are outlined below. These measures are<br />
designed to assist in in<strong>for</strong>ming stakeholders of the proposal. These activities also assist Tf<strong>NSW</strong><br />
in meeting its obligations under the State Environmental Planning Policy (Infrastructure) 2007<br />
(ISEPP). Consultation activities and work practices will be undertaken in accordance with<br />
community relation protocols and requirements as per Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s Communications Management<br />
Plan.<br />
Three main consultation activities will take place.<br />
1) Communication with local councils and other regulatory authorities<br />
Consultation with the local council and other regulatory authorities is required by the ISEPP.<br />
Council and any relevant government authorities will be contacted and a link to this document<br />
provided.<br />
2) Communication with residents and businesses within a 500 metre radius of works<br />
Consultation with nearby residents is required. A number of consultation activities will be<br />
undertaken and are outlined below.<br />
• A letter will be sent to all properties within a 500 metre radius detailing the DTRS project<br />
and the scope of works proposed <strong>for</strong> the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> DBS site. The letter will also<br />
provide advice on where copies of the <strong>REF</strong> can be viewed.<br />
This <strong>REF</strong> will be on public exhibition <strong>for</strong> 21 days. The <strong>REF</strong> will be accessible via<br />
www.transport.nsw.gov.au/projects.<br />
• Face to face consultation will be undertaken with nearby residents. Residents will be<br />
advised of the proposal and provided with in<strong>for</strong>mation about where they can obtain the<br />
<strong>REF</strong> and the mechanisms through which they can provide feedback.<br />
• A project in<strong>for</strong>mation line will be established <strong>for</strong> the community to obtain further in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
during business hours.<br />
Community relations <strong>for</strong> the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> DBS proposal will specifically be targeted at:<br />
• Residents along a section of Gardiner Place.<br />
• <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Waste Disposal Depot, owned and operated by Wollongong City Council, as<br />
the proposed access road to Outdoor Location 3 is Nixon Road which will be co-utilised<br />
with users of this facility.<br />
3) Notification and community relations prior to construction, during construction and<br />
during commissioning works with Council and nearby community.<br />
Subject to planning approval, the nearby community and Wollongong City Council will be<br />
advised of the determination.<br />
Page 12 of 78
The nearby community and Wollongong City Council will also be provided with notification at<br />
least five days be<strong>for</strong>e any construction work/site establishment work begins. This in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
will include specific detail regarding activities, works hours, traffic control measures and<br />
compound/assembly location.<br />
Further consultation with the community during this phase of project may also include face-toface<br />
communication with nearby community members.<br />
Summary<br />
Feedback received during pre-construction consultation will be taken into consideration and<br />
included in the project determination report. This report, along with the <strong>REF</strong>, will be used to<br />
determine whether the development should process and what, if any, changes need to be<br />
made.<br />
Page 13 of 78
2 Statutory Position and Requirements<br />
The description of the proposed works and the associated environmental impacts has been<br />
undertaken in the context of Clause 228 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment<br />
Regulation 2000 (EP&A Regulation), the Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995 (TSC<br />
Act), and the (Commonwealth) Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999<br />
(EPBC Act). In doing so, this <strong>REF</strong> helps fulfil the requirements of Section 111 of the<br />
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (EP&A Act), that Tf<strong>NSW</strong> must examine and<br />
take into account, to the fullest extent possible, all matters affecting or likely to affect the<br />
environment by reason of the activity. The legislative framework relevant to the proposed works<br />
and associated approvals is set out in the following sections.<br />
2.1 Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979<br />
The proposal comprises an ‘activity’ <strong>for</strong> the purposes of Part 5 of the EP&A Act. As the<br />
determining authority <strong>for</strong> the purposes of Part 5 of the EP&A Act, Tf<strong>NSW</strong> must examine and<br />
take into account to the fullest extent possible all matters affecting or likely to affect the<br />
environment by reason of that activity, in accordance with section 111 of the EP&A Act.<br />
To document Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s considerations under Part 5 of the EP&A Act, Tf<strong>NSW</strong> is required to<br />
prepare a Review of Environmental Factors (<strong>REF</strong>), which includes mitigation measures to<br />
manage and minimise impacts on the environment. The <strong>REF</strong> document will be exhibited and<br />
made publicly available. During the exhibition period, the community are encouraged to make<br />
submissions to Tf<strong>NSW</strong> on the proposal and any potential environmental impacts.<br />
Prior to determining whether or not to proceed with the project, Tf<strong>NSW</strong> will consider issues<br />
raised in submissions and respond to community feedback. Tf<strong>NSW</strong> may propose changes to<br />
the proposal and detail these in the determination report. The determination report will be made<br />
available to the public on the Tf<strong>NSW</strong> website (www.transport.nsw.gov.au/projects).<br />
Should Tf<strong>NSW</strong> determine to proceed, the proposal will be constructed and operated in<br />
accordance with the mitigation measures proposed in the <strong>REF</strong>, determination report and any<br />
conditions of approval.<br />
Page 14 of 78
2.2 State Environmental Planning Policy (Infrastructure) 2007<br />
The State Environmental Planning Policy (Infrastructure) 2007 (ISEPP) provides a consistent<br />
planning regime <strong>for</strong> infrastructure and the provision of services across <strong>NSW</strong>, along with<br />
providing <strong>for</strong> consultation with relevant public authorities during the assessment process.<br />
The ISEPP provides <strong>for</strong> the development of certain activities <strong>for</strong> a range of infrastructure types.<br />
The ISEPP indicates whether an activity is permissible with or without consent, and on what<br />
land the activity is permissible.<br />
Section 76 of the EP&A Act states that “if an environmental planning instrument provides that<br />
specified development may be carried out without the need <strong>for</strong> development consent, a person<br />
may carry the development out, in accordance with the instrument, on land to which the<br />
provision applies.” However environmental assessment of the development may nevertheless<br />
be required under Part 5 of the EP&A Act.<br />
2.3 Confirmation of Statutory Position<br />
Clause 79(1) of the ISEPP provides:<br />
“Development <strong>for</strong> the purpose of a railway or rail infrastructure facilities may be<br />
carried out by or on behalf of a public authority without consent on any land.”<br />
The proposal is <strong>for</strong> the installation of a new distributed base station (new monopole, masts,<br />
antennas and power cabinets), which is consistent with the definition of a rail infrastructure<br />
facility under Clause 78, which includes “signalling, train control, communication and security<br />
systems”.<br />
In addition Clause 114(1) provides:<br />
“Development <strong>for</strong> the purposes of telecommunications facilities (including radio<br />
facilities) may be carried out by a public authority without consent on land.”<br />
The proposal also meets the definition of a telecommunication facility under Clause 113 of the<br />
ISEPP. Tf<strong>NSW</strong> is classified as a public authority under Section 4 of the EP&A Act.<br />
Accordingly, this proposal (construction of new DBS at <strong>Helensburgh</strong>) is being assessed under<br />
Part 5 of the EP&A Act. Tf<strong>NSW</strong> is the proponent and determining authority as per the provisions<br />
of Section 110 of the EP&A Act.<br />
Page 15 of 78
2.4 Other Relevant Environmental Planning Instruments<br />
State Environmental Planning Policy No. 14 Coastal Wetlands<br />
The proposed site is not located within an area covered by the SEPP and there<strong>for</strong>e no further<br />
consideration of SEPP 14 is necessary.<br />
State Environmental Planning Policy No. 19 Bushland in Urban Areas<br />
This SEPP protects and preserves bushland within certain urban areas in the Sydney<br />
Metropolitan Area, as part of the natural heritage or <strong>for</strong> recreational, educational and scientific<br />
purposes. Wollongong LGA is not listed in Schedule 1 as an area where bushland is preserved<br />
under the SEPP, there<strong>for</strong>e no further consideration of this SEPP is required.<br />
State Environmental Planning Policy No. 26 Littoral Rain<strong>for</strong>ests<br />
The proposed site is not located within an area covered by the SEPP and there<strong>for</strong>e no further<br />
consideration of SEPP 26 is required.<br />
State Environmental Planning Policy No. 44 – Koala Habitat Protection<br />
The Wollongong LGA is an area nominated/classified by this SEPP as an area containing<br />
habitat <strong>for</strong> koalas. However, the proposed sites are in previously cleared areas within the rail<br />
corridor, adjacent to the railway track, and the proposed works will not require the removal of<br />
any native vegetation; there<strong>for</strong>e no further consideration of this SEPP is required.<br />
State Environmental Planning Policy No. 55 – Remediation of Land<br />
SEPP 55 provides <strong>for</strong> a consistent state-wide planning approach to the remediation of<br />
contaminated land. The policy states that land must not be developed if it is unsuitable <strong>for</strong> a<br />
proposed use because it is contaminated. If the land is unsuitable, remediation must take place<br />
be<strong>for</strong>e the land is developed. The presence of contamination will be determined during<br />
excavation works and a suitable remediation plan will be developed, if required.<br />
State Environmental Planning Policy No. 71 – Coastal Protection<br />
The proposed site is not located within an area covered by this SEPP and there<strong>for</strong>e no further<br />
consideration of SEPP 71 is required.<br />
State Environmental Planning Policy (Major Development) 2005<br />
This SEPP identifies certain developments which are deemed major projects. The proposal is<br />
not listed in this SEPP.<br />
State Environmental Planning Policy (State and Regional Development) 2011<br />
The proposal is not listed in the SEPP and has not been declared as State Significant<br />
Infrastructure or State Significant Development under the SEPP.<br />
State Environmental Planning Policy (Sydney Drinking Water Catchment) 2011<br />
Page 16 of 78
The proposal is in the Hacking River catchment and is not part of a drinking water catchment.<br />
This SEPP does not apply to the proposal.<br />
Wollongong City Council Local Environmental Plan 2009<br />
The proposed sites are in the Wollongong LGA and are subject to the Wollongong City Council<br />
Local Environmental Plan 2009 (Wollongong City Council LEP). The proposed works will be<br />
undertaken in land Zoned SP2 – Infrastructure.<br />
Development <strong>for</strong> the purposes of railways is permissible in Zone SP2 – Infrastructure with<br />
consent, as specified in the Land Use Table - SP2, Infrastructure, within the Wollongong City<br />
Council LEP. As the ISEPP overrides the development consent requirements of any LEP, the<br />
proposal can proceed without development consent (refer Section 0 and 2.3 <strong>for</strong> more detail).<br />
2.5 Other <strong>NSW</strong> Legislation<br />
Crown Lands Act 1989<br />
The proposed work will not be undertaken on crown land and the provisions of this act are not<br />
applicable to the proposal.<br />
Electricity Supply Act 1995<br />
The Electricity Supply Act 1995 and Electricity Supply (General) Regulation 2001 set out certain<br />
notification and procedural requirements in relation to excavation.<br />
Section 63Z provides:<br />
(1) A person must not commence to carry out excavation work to which this section<br />
applies, or authorise such excavation work to be commenced, unless the person has<br />
first:<br />
(a) contacted the designated in<strong>for</strong>mation provider and requested in<strong>for</strong>mation as to the<br />
location and type of any underground electricity power lines in the vicinity of the<br />
proposed work, and<br />
(b) complied with any reasonable procedures of the designated in<strong>for</strong>mation provider as<br />
to the manner of contacting the designated in<strong>for</strong>mation provider and the in<strong>for</strong>mation to<br />
be provided by the person in connection with the person’s request <strong>for</strong> in<strong>for</strong>mation, and<br />
(c) allowed a reasonable period <strong>for</strong> the requested in<strong>for</strong>mation to be provided.<br />
Clause 104B of the Electricity Supply (General) Regulation 2001 provides:<br />
(1) Work of the following kind that is carried out within the distribution district of a<br />
distribution network service provider is excavation work to which section 63Z of the Act<br />
applies…<br />
(b) excavation that is, or is carried out in connection with, an activity within the meaning<br />
of Part 5 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979.<br />
Page 17 of 78
Consultation with the relevant service provider will occur in accordance with these provisions.<br />
Heritage Act 1977<br />
Section 57(1) of the Heritage Act 1977 lists the types of activities/works that require approval<br />
from the Heritage Council when working on/in an item/place listed on the State Heritage<br />
Register. An application <strong>for</strong> an exemption can also be made under some circumstances.<br />
Approval from the Heritage Council is also required under Section 139 of the Heritage Act 1977<br />
prior to the disturbance or excavation of land if a project will, or is likely to result in, a relic being<br />
discovered, exposed, moved, damaged or destroyed.<br />
The proposed work is to be undertaken close to the Royal National Park which is a nationally<br />
listed heritage item. However, the sites are not within its heritage boundary. The proposed work<br />
will not directly affect any heritage items and approval under the Heritage Act is not required.<br />
More in<strong>for</strong>mation about heritage is included in Section 4.6.<br />
National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974<br />
The excavating, moving or exhibiting of Aboriginal objects requires a permit under Section 87 of<br />
the National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974 (NPW Act). The harming or desecrating of Aboriginal<br />
objects or places is an offence under Section 86 of the NPW Act. Under Section 90, an<br />
Aboriginal heritage impact permit may be issued in relation to a specified Aboriginal object,<br />
Aboriginal place, land, activity or person or specified types or classes of Aboriginal objects,<br />
Aboriginal places, land, activities or people.<br />
There are Aboriginal objects or places known to occur within 200 metres of Outdoor Location 2,<br />
and none <strong>for</strong> location 1 and location 3, however when the search was narrowed to 50 metres,<br />
there were none identified. No known items or places will be affected by the proposed work.<br />
Due to the location of the site within proximal distance to dense, undisturbed bushland, the<br />
likelihood of uncovering Aboriginal heritage items is considered moderate (refer Section 4.6).<br />
Safeguards have been proposed to address circumstances if an unexpected find occurs.<br />
All native birds, reptiles, amphibians and mammals, except the dingo, are protected in <strong>NSW</strong><br />
under the NPW Act. The harming of protected fauna is prohibited under the NPW Act, but an<br />
exemption applies in relation to things that are essential to the carrying out of an activity to<br />
which Part 5 of the EP&A Act applies and where the determining authority has complied with<br />
the provisions of that part. Potential impacts to fauna are considered in Section 4.4.<br />
Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997<br />
The Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997 (POEO Act) provides a licensing<br />
framework <strong>for</strong> certain activities as defined in Schedule 1 of the POEO Act. The proposal is not<br />
considered to fall within the definition of Section 33 ‘Railway systems activities’ of Schedule 1.<br />
As such, the proposal does not require an environment protection licence (EPL) under the<br />
POEO Act.<br />
Page 18 of 78
Roads Act 1993<br />
Under Section 138 of the Roads Act 1993, a person must not “erect a structure or carry out a<br />
work in, on or over a public road, or dig up or disturb the surface of a public road...” other than<br />
with the consent of the appropriate roads authority. However, clause 5(1) in Schedule 2 of the<br />
Act states that public authorities do not require consent <strong>for</strong> works on unclassified roads.<br />
Gardiner Place and Nixon Place will be used to access the proposed sites, both of which are<br />
not classified roads under the meaning of the Roads Act. There<strong>for</strong>e, approval from Roads and<br />
Maritime Services will not be required.<br />
Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995<br />
The Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995 (TSC Act) is directed at conserving threatened<br />
species, populations and ecological communities of animals and plants. Although there is<br />
habitat considered suitable beyond the boundaries of the rail corridor, the proposed sites are<br />
situated in previously cleared areas within the rail corridor and are utilised as Tf<strong>NSW</strong> land. As<br />
such, threatened species, populations, or endangered ecological communities are unlikely to<br />
occur within the immediate vicinities of the sites and there<strong>for</strong>e further consideration under the<br />
Act is not required.<br />
Native Vegetation Act 2003<br />
The Native Vegetation Act 2003 (NV Act) manages the clearing of native vegetation in <strong>NSW</strong>.<br />
Section 25(g) of the NV Act provides that any clearing that is part of an activity that is<br />
permissible without consent does not require approval under the Act.<br />
RailCorp’s guideline <strong>for</strong> the vegetation management in rail corridors provides a framework <strong>for</strong><br />
compliance with this Act.<br />
No native vegetation would be affected as part of the proposed works.<br />
2.6 Commonwealth Legislation<br />
Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999<br />
The primary legislation at the Commonwealth level is the Environment Protection and<br />
Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (EPBC Act). Part 3 of the EPBC Act requires approval from<br />
the Commonwealth Minister <strong>for</strong> Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and<br />
Communities if a development is likely to have, or will have, a significant effect on a matter of<br />
National Environmental Significance (NES).<br />
For the purposes of the EPBC Act, matters of NES are defined as:<br />
• world heritage properties;<br />
• national heritage places;<br />
• Ramsar wetlands;<br />
Page 19 of 78
• nationally threatened species and ecological communities;<br />
• migratory species;<br />
• commonwealth marine areas; and<br />
• nuclear actions.<br />
The proposed work is to be undertaken close to the Royal National Park which is a nationally<br />
listed heritage item. However all proposed works are inside the rail corridor, there<strong>for</strong>e it will not<br />
affect matters of national environmental significance. Commonwealth land will not be affected,<br />
either directly or indirectly, as a result of this proposal. Consideration of the EPBC Act factors is<br />
included in Table 4 in Section 4.19.<br />
Commonwealth Telecommunications Act<br />
To operate the DTRS, Tf<strong>NSW</strong> will have a Telecommunication Licence and so will have certain<br />
rights under the relevant Commonwealth Legislation. In particular, Tf<strong>NSW</strong> will be able to install<br />
low impact facilities without reference to local or state approvals processes.<br />
However, the Telecommunications (Low-impact Facilities) Determination 1997 defines a low<br />
impact facility as:<br />
Panel, Yagi or other like antenna:<br />
(a)<br />
Not more than 2.8 metres long; and<br />
(b) If the antenna is attached to a structure — protruding from the structure by not<br />
more than three metres.<br />
Since this DTRS site includes the installation of a pole and masts greater than three metres, it is<br />
not a low impact facility and so will be assessed under Part 5 of the EP&A Act.<br />
2.7 Ecologically Sustainable Development<br />
Ecologically sustainable development (ESD) entails using, conserving and enhancing the<br />
community’s environmental resources in a manner that sustains and improves ecological<br />
processes and, hence, the quality of life <strong>for</strong> present and future generations. The basis <strong>for</strong><br />
achieving ecologically sustainable development involves the application of four principles:<br />
the precautionary principle;<br />
intra- and inter-generational equity;<br />
conservation of biological diversity and ecological integrity; and<br />
improved valuation and pricing of environmental resources.<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong> is committed to ensuring its projects are consistent with the principles of ESD and these<br />
have been considered <strong>for</strong> this proposal (refer Table 1).<br />
Page 20 of 78
Table 1<br />
Consideration of ESD <strong>for</strong> the proposal<br />
ESD Principle<br />
Application to the proposal<br />
Precautionary principle<br />
The site selection and design process aims to avoid areas where<br />
there will be a significant environmental impact or impacts that are<br />
irreversible. The site selected is within a previously disturbed area<br />
in the rail corridor. In addition, some of the potential impacts are<br />
reversible as the monopole and cabinets can be removed if no<br />
longer required.<br />
Any adverse impacts associated with the site and construction will<br />
be minor and measures to reduce impacts identified within this<br />
<strong>REF</strong> will be implemented during construction, as far as practicable.<br />
Intergenerational equity<br />
This proposal and the overarching DTRS project will contribute<br />
towards Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s strategic benefits <strong>for</strong> current and future<br />
generations, including safer public transport, by improving on the<br />
current communications system, providing coverage and reliable<br />
communications services to all parts of the electrified rail corridor<br />
and acting as the basis <strong>for</strong> the introduction of an Automatic Train<br />
Protection System.<br />
The economic, social and safety considerations of the DTRS have<br />
been integrated with the consideration and assessment of<br />
potential environmental impacts regarding the development and<br />
operation of the DTRS.<br />
Conservation of<br />
biological diversity and<br />
ecological integrity<br />
The proposed site is on disturbed land that has been previously<br />
cleared. Major clearing or other disturbance to the biodiversity or<br />
items of ecological significance of the area is not required. The<br />
proposed activity is not expected to result in loss of biodiversity or<br />
ecological integrity.<br />
Improved valuation and<br />
pricing of environmental<br />
resources<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong> recognises the value of environmental sustainability and<br />
will minimise the impact of its activities by ensuring appropriate<br />
mitigation measures are implemented <strong>for</strong> all aspects of the DTRS<br />
project. The potential environmental costs of the proposal have<br />
been considered in conjunction with the costs of design,<br />
construction and operation.<br />
Page 21 of 78
2.8 Other Guidelines<br />
Consideration of the <strong>NSW</strong> Telecommunication Facilities Guideline including Broadband <strong>NSW</strong><br />
(DoP 2010) is a requirement when Clause 114 or Clause 115 (development of a<br />
telecommunications facility) of the ISEPP is applied. The requirements of the guidelines have<br />
been considered and are included in Appendix 1.<br />
2.9 Licences and Approvals<br />
Responsible Authority<br />
Approval/Licence/Permit<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong><br />
Determination under Part 5 of the Environmental Planning<br />
and Assessment Act 1979<br />
Page 22 of 78
3 Description of the Proposal<br />
3.1 Scope of Proposed Works<br />
3.1.1 Summary<br />
The DBS at <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> will consist of the following components:<br />
Outdoor Location 1<br />
A 20 metre high monopole;<br />
A 1500 millimetre high lightning rod at the top;<br />
Two Argus panel antennas mounted on the monopole;<br />
A DBS cabinet on a slab two metres from the monopole; and<br />
Power and fibre connections<br />
Outdoor Location 2<br />
A ten metre mast;<br />
Two Yagi antennas mounted on the tilt mast;<br />
A DBS cabinet on a slab five metres from the tilt mast; and<br />
Power and fibre connections.<br />
Outdoor Location 3<br />
A ten metre mast;<br />
One Yagi antenna mounted on the tilt mast;<br />
A DBS cabinet on a slab two metres from the tilt mast; and<br />
Power and fibre connections.<br />
These components are described in the sections below. Plan drawings are provided in<br />
Appendix 2. All aspects of the proposal will be earthed in line with all relevant standards.<br />
3.1.2 DBS Sites<br />
DBS Systems<br />
The DBS systems consists of a base band unit (BBU) unit and multiple remote radio unit (RRU)<br />
subsystems and is a distributed fibre fed base transceiver station. The BBU and RRU are<br />
interconnected by dark fibre, one BBU being able to control up to 12 RRU Radio Frequency<br />
(RF) units (i.e. six RRU pairs) each fed by separate fibres.<br />
The DBS cabinets will be placed on a concrete slab adjacent to the monopole and masts. The<br />
cabinets will be approximately 1700 millimetres high by 1000 millimetres long by 880 millimetres<br />
Page 23 of 78
wide, and will be placed on a steel plinth with a minimum height of 200 millimetres to allow <strong>for</strong><br />
the management of cables entering the cabinet.<br />
The DBS cabinets will include the following equipment:<br />
DBS equipment (transceiver modules, transmission equipment, controller etc.);<br />
Direct Current (DC) distribution (including electromagnetic interference filter and surge<br />
protection);<br />
Transmission interface (Huawei PTN910);<br />
Fibre optic distribution frame;<br />
Monitoring and reporting capability of power cabinet conditions; and<br />
Field monitoring device <strong>for</strong> radio frequency coverage. This requires a 12V DC input so is<br />
installed with a 48V to 12V DC power converter.<br />
The cabinets will also include power equipment including the following:<br />
Alternating Current (AC) and earth terminations;<br />
Transfer switch (mains and generator positions);<br />
Surge protection;<br />
General purpose outlet;<br />
Low voltage disconnect;<br />
Rectifier modules;<br />
Controller/supervisory module;<br />
DC distribution rack; and<br />
Batteries (with the capability of providing a minimum of four hours’ back-up).<br />
Monopole<br />
A 20 metre monopole will be erected approximately two metres to the east of the DBS cabinet<br />
in the rail corridor approximately seven metres from the eastern side of the track at Outdoor<br />
Location 1. Two Argus antennas will be mounted 19 metres above the ground with azimuths of<br />
80° and 240° to provide coverage along the rail corridor to <strong>Helensburgh</strong> as well as coverage<br />
towards the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> tunnel. The antennas will be installed to have a zero degree tilt, but<br />
will be able to be remotely adjusted to different degrees of tilt, without the need to climb the<br />
monopole <strong>for</strong> such adjustments.<br />
Page 24 of 78
Masts<br />
10 metre high tilted masts will be erected at Outdoor Location 2 and Location 3 at approximate<br />
distances of five metres northwest and two metres southeast from the DBS cabinet respectively.<br />
Two Yagi antennas will be mounted on the mast at Outdoor Location 2 with azimuths of 120°<br />
and 310° to provide coverage overlap between Outdoor Location 1. One Yagi antenna will be<br />
mounted on the mast at Outdoor Location 3 with azimuth of 200° to provide coverage along the<br />
rail corridor towards the adjacent Metropolitan site.<br />
3.1.3 Power Supply<br />
Power supply is yet to be determined.<br />
3.1.4 Fibre Optics<br />
The DBS require fibre connectivity between the RRU and the BBU. The <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong><br />
design will be external, loose tube construction, with glass armouring, rodent protection and a<br />
halogen free and flame retardant outer sheath.<br />
Leaky feeder cables are required to provide coverage within the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> tunnel and will be<br />
secured to the tunnel wall by 80mm round base and clic clamps.<br />
The cable runs <strong>for</strong> the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> DBS sites will be:<br />
At Outdoor Location 1, new fibre optics route will involve installation of single mode optical fibre<br />
(SMOF) cable between the DBS cabinet and a new pit adjacent to the site. From the pit, fibre<br />
will run via a combination of existing and new galvanised steel trenching (GST) to Outdoor<br />
Location 2 (near the tunnel portal) and along tunnel portal via cable ladder. Trenching distance<br />
at Outdoor Location 1 and Outdoor Location 2 will be approximately five metres and four metres<br />
respectively. No native vegetation will be removed, only some grass will be cleared.<br />
The fibre route <strong>for</strong> Outdoor Location 3 will comprise the installation of SMOF cable between the<br />
DBS cabinet and a new pit adjacent to the site. Fibre will then run via existing GST to the tunnel<br />
portal and along tunnel portal via cable ladder. Trenching distance at Outdoor Location 3 will be<br />
approximately 5 metres. No native vegetation will be removed, only some grass will be cleared.<br />
A leaky feeder cable will connect from Outdoor Location 2 to Outdoor Location 3 via the length<br />
of the <strong>Tunnel</strong>.<br />
3.1.5 Earthing<br />
The earthing installation will comprise six earth stakes at a pre-determined distance apart. Once<br />
these earth stakes have been installed, the system will be tested and modified if needed. The<br />
initial extent of the trenching <strong>for</strong> earthing grid will be around 20 metres. However, it can be<br />
extended up to five metres if the results show that the earthing arrangement is insufficient.<br />
Page 25 of 78
3.2 Construction Methodology<br />
Construction of the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> DBS sites can be split into two distinct methods, On<br />
Track Works and Off Track Works. Each method uses specific plant and construction<br />
techniques.<br />
On Track Work consists of work require to be per<strong>for</strong>med whilst on or around track. In this case<br />
this works consists of installation of leaky feeder cables fixed to the tunnel wall and optic fibre<br />
through an existing cable route.<br />
To undertake these works, a track possession will be required. These are already scheduled as<br />
per the Tf<strong>NSW</strong> possession calendar and weekend possession schedule as issued by Tf<strong>NSW</strong>.<br />
As part of the application process to gain access to these possessions, UGL will coordinate with<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong> and other contractors <strong>for</strong> access to specific locations.<br />
The plant used <strong>for</strong> these works will be:<br />
Hi Rail vehicle (a vehicle which can operate both on rail tracks and a conventional road);<br />
Hi Rail plat<strong>for</strong>m truck of varying sizes;<br />
Hi Rail Crane truck;<br />
Hi Rail EWP or Scissor trucks;<br />
Hi Rail Manitou’s or non-slewing cranes with man buckets;<br />
Hand tools such as battery powered hammer drills; and<br />
Cable drum stands and brakes.<br />
Materials used to fit out the tunnels are typically:<br />
Leaky feeder cable and bracket assemblies;<br />
GST and associated brackets assemblies;<br />
Chemical Adhesive such as Hilti;<br />
Antenna’s and brackets; and<br />
Any waste is stored on the Hi Rail vehicles until the end of the shift, when the waste is<br />
removed back to UGL’s Milperra site and disposed of.<br />
Off Track works consist of the installation of radio equipment and power supplies, 20 metre<br />
monopole mast and foundations, 10 metre tilt masts and foundations, Panel and Yagi antenna<br />
systems mounted to the monopole and masts, earthing, cable routes (buried and above ground)<br />
and installation of cabling (power and optic Fibre cable). These works will follow the following<br />
methodology:<br />
Service location and verification – using cable locators and vacuum excavations;<br />
Page 26 of 78
Site establishment;<br />
Excavation <strong>for</strong> mast and equipment foundations using excavators with auger attachment;<br />
Installation of earth grid, using excavator;<br />
Installation of foundations, requiring steel re-en<strong>for</strong>cement, concrete and <strong>for</strong>mwork;<br />
Installation of underground cable routes – using excavators;<br />
Installation of above ground cable routes such as GST, using hand augers, excavators with<br />
auger attachment or Dingo;<br />
Installation of monopole and masts will be via the use of crane trucks to deliver and stand<br />
the poles onto the foundation;<br />
Installation of radio and power supply equipment. This may be installed onto foundations<br />
already constructed;<br />
Installation of cables through new and existing routes; and<br />
Most deliveries will be using a heavy rigid or medium rigid crane truck and concrete Aggi,<br />
other vehicles movements will be <strong>for</strong> the floating of plant, typically using a tilt tray and light<br />
vehicles will be used <strong>for</strong> daily movements.<br />
The area of ground disturbance at each outdoor DBS site is likely to be in the vicinity of 15<br />
square metres. The monopole and mast foundations will require an excavation approximately<br />
five metres deep with a diameter of one metre. This will result in approximately 15 cubic metres<br />
of excavated material at each location which may include rock.<br />
Installation of the fibre optic cables will require excavation of trenches approximately 14 metres<br />
long, approximately 500 millimetres deep and 1000 millimetres wide. This will result in<br />
approximately 7 cubic metres of excavated materials <strong>for</strong> trenches. Excavated material will be<br />
stockpiled and reused <strong>for</strong> backfilling.<br />
3.3 Timing and Costing<br />
Construction is planned to begin in late 2013 and involves non-possession and scheduled track<br />
possession. Construction activities will require four to six weeks and work may require to be<br />
undertaken in non-consecutive work days.<br />
Proposed construction timing:<br />
Standard working hours<br />
Monday to Friday 7.00am to 6.00pm<br />
Saturday 8:00am to 1:00pm<br />
Evening/weekends/out of hours:<br />
Out of hours work from 6:00am Saturday 6 July<br />
2013 to 6:00 pm Sunday 7July 2013<br />
Page 27 of 78
The DTRS project has an overarching value of $225 million. This includes the design, supply,<br />
and installation of the DTRS on Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s electrified network plus a five-year life support<br />
component.<br />
3.4 Alternatives to the DTRS<br />
A number of alternatives already used by the state government or available commercially were<br />
investigated. The government alternatives were the existing MetroNet system or the<br />
<strong>Government</strong> Radio Network (GRN).<br />
The existing MetroNet communication system was not deemed a feasible solution <strong>for</strong> the<br />
reasons listed below.<br />
It uses out-dated technology and cannot be expanded due to its limited capacity.<br />
It does not have the ability to support the requirements of Automatic Train Protection.<br />
It only has one main supplier and this, combined with obsolete technology, means the cost<br />
of using and maintaining the MetroNet system is increasing at a substantial rate.<br />
It cannot facilitate a communications plat<strong>for</strong>m that can be used by all necessary Tf<strong>NSW</strong><br />
personnel.<br />
It could not meet interoperability requirements.<br />
The Department of Commerce’s <strong>Government</strong> Radio Network (GRN) was not deemed a feasible<br />
solution <strong>for</strong> the reasons listed below.<br />
It has to be shared with other <strong>NSW</strong> <strong>Government</strong> agencies.<br />
Priority is given to emergency services which could result in a failure of 100% rail network<br />
coverage.<br />
The network is both inside and outside the rail corridor.<br />
GRN would require a substantial upgrade, including new base stations, to ensure 100%<br />
network coverage of the rail corridor.<br />
The cost of this upgrade is comparable to the development of an entire new network.<br />
The radio communications marketplace responded with three systems: APCO-25, Terrestrial<br />
Trunked Radio (TETRA) and GSM-R.<br />
APCO-25 is a proven standard <strong>for</strong> emergency services but was rejected <strong>for</strong> the reasons listed<br />
below.<br />
It has no proven history of usage in a rail environment.<br />
It does not support a functional addressing system that maps train run numbers to mobile<br />
subscribers’ numbers, which is a key requirement.<br />
It does not meet the interoperability requirements.<br />
Page 28 of 78
It relies on a dispatch terminal <strong>for</strong> functionality, which does not meet Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s reliability<br />
requirements.<br />
It is not scalable in regard to the future growth of the rail network.<br />
TETRA is also a proven emergency services communications system and is deployed in a<br />
number metropolitan rail networks. However, it was rejected <strong>for</strong> the reasons listed below.<br />
This application is confined primarily to underground metro networks that are not<br />
comparable to Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s network.<br />
It relies on a dispatch terminal <strong>for</strong> functionality, which does not meet the Tf<strong>NSW</strong> reliability<br />
requirements.<br />
It does not meet the interoperability requirements.<br />
There is no commercialised Automatic Train Protection (ATP) solution available.<br />
GSM-R was deemed the plat<strong>for</strong>m most suitable <strong>for</strong> Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s train network and system<br />
requirements <strong>for</strong> the reasons listed below.<br />
It is the only rail-specific communications standard and has the highest levels of safety and<br />
reliability in its design.<br />
It is an open standard with a large number of equipment suppliers.<br />
It achieved a higher level of compliance with the Tf<strong>NSW</strong> functional requirements when<br />
compared to the other systems.<br />
It is deployed by major rail operators in Europe and Asia, some with networks comparable<br />
in size and complexity to Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s network.<br />
It operates on a spectrum of 1800 MHz which was available <strong>for</strong> purchase by Tf<strong>NSW</strong>. The<br />
other options would have required the leasing of a radio spectrum from a<br />
telecommunications licence holder.<br />
It is a scalable network that can grow in step with Tf<strong>NSW</strong> operations and network.<br />
It is compatible with the Australian Rail Track Corporation’s communication system.<br />
It provides a plat<strong>for</strong>m <strong>for</strong> future enhancements and increased operational safety, including a<br />
Level 2 Automatic Train Protection (ATP) System, as per the recommendations of the<br />
Waterfall inquiry.<br />
It will deliver the best value <strong>for</strong> money solution with the least risk.<br />
3.5 Alternatives to the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> site<br />
The following options were considered <strong>for</strong> the development of the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> site:<br />
• To do nothing;<br />
Page 29 of 78
• Install the proposed equipment in different locations along the rail corridor; or<br />
• Use of alternate antenna technologies or configurations.<br />
The do nothing option was rejected <strong>for</strong> the reasons listed below.<br />
• The inability to meet the requirement of 100% network coverage.<br />
• A ‘black spot’ in the DTRS network, resulting in a significant safety issue in the event of an<br />
emergency call or a train incident.<br />
• The increasing maintenance costs of the MetroNet facility and the limited reliability <strong>for</strong><br />
adequate operation <strong>for</strong> the next 10 – 15 years.<br />
Moving equipment to different locations was rejected <strong>for</strong> the reasons listed below.<br />
• The radio frequency modelling indicated that any alternative DTRS site configuration would<br />
not provide coverage to 100% of the rail corridor and tunnel without additional antennas.<br />
• The additional of extra antennas to ensure 100% network coverage, particularly in regard<br />
to the tunnel would incur additional costs and, potentially, increase the risk of<br />
environmental impacts of the proposal.<br />
• Location of BBU and RRU equipment is generally restricted to portals because of lack of<br />
space and access in the tunnel.<br />
Other infrastructure options were considered, but were not feasible <strong>for</strong> the proposal.<br />
• The proposed monopole at Outdoor Location 1 is less obtrusive, requires less space and<br />
will be cheaper to maintain than a lattice tower or guyed mast. A monopole also uses a<br />
foundation design that is better suited given the spatial limitations within the rail corridor.<br />
The monopole is thinner at the top and less obtrusive than a lattice tower, helping to<br />
minimise the visual impacts of the proposal.<br />
• The monopole can be installed using a hinge mechanism, which removes the need <strong>for</strong><br />
large cranes.<br />
• Yagi antennas cannot be mounted onto the tunnel portals due to on-going maintenance<br />
issues; and<br />
• Inward facing Yagi antennas were not used within the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> because of the<br />
length and the curvature of the tunnel. As a result, Leaky feeder cables are proposed <strong>for</strong><br />
signals within this tunnel.<br />
• The installation of a walk-in equipment hut would use more space and be more expensive.<br />
The use of outdoor cabinets was the most suitable solution given the limited space, cost<br />
and minimisation of environmental impacts.<br />
Page 30 of 78
Alternative sites towards <strong>Helensburgh</strong> and towards Wollongong were examined <strong>for</strong> Outdoor<br />
Location 1 but were rejected due to the following reasons:<br />
• Towards <strong>Helensburgh</strong>: As the rail path curves through a cutting the most efficient location<br />
with regards to RF coverage would be at the apex of the curve. Positioning the site at the<br />
apex will ensure that losses in RF signal strength due to the cutting are kept to a minimum.<br />
The site is located as close to the apex as possible. It is not advantageous to move the site<br />
further towards <strong>Helensburgh</strong> as this will further shift the site away from the apex and will<br />
lead to a coverage hole between the site and the tunnel portal.<br />
• Towards Wollongong: There are no suitable sites available down track as there are<br />
cuttings on both sides of the rail corridor. It is not recommended to move the site beyond<br />
the cutting as this will lead to an RF coverage hole between the site and the adjacent<br />
<strong>Helensburgh</strong> sites.<br />
3.6 Justification of the Preferred Option<br />
It was decided to construct DBS sites at <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> using GSM-R technology because<br />
it will enable the site to be consistent with the whole Tf<strong>NSW</strong> DTRS network. Consistent<br />
technology choice will enable Tf<strong>NSW</strong> to improve its existing quality of service, reliability and<br />
emergency responsiveness.<br />
The <strong>Helensburgh</strong> outdoor locations have been selected due to their ability to cover the section<br />
of track between <strong>Helensburgh</strong> and the adjacent Metropolitan site, including tunnel coverage.<br />
The proposed antenna height of 19 metres at Outdoor Location 1 is the minimum height<br />
required to provide optimum RF coverage <strong>for</strong> the section of track between <strong>Helensburgh</strong> and<br />
Outdoor Location 2.<br />
Outdoor Location 2 and Location 3 were selected <strong>for</strong> proximity to the respective tunnel portals<br />
so that continuous coverage could be maintained between the tunnel and Outdoor Location 1<br />
and handover coverage could be maintained between the tunnel and the adjacent Metropolitan<br />
site. As such no other alternative locations were examined. The proposed antenna heights of<br />
nine metres at Outdoor Location 2 and Location 3 are the minimum height required to provide<br />
optimum RF coverage <strong>for</strong> these sections of track.<br />
The proposed outdoor locations are also close to existing fibre supply and have good<br />
construction and maintenance access. However, due to the requirement <strong>for</strong> tunnel equipment<br />
installation, track possession could not be avoided. In addition, the proposed work will not<br />
require the removal of native vegetation.<br />
It was decided that the preferred option would offer the least impact on the local environment<br />
while still meeting operational requirements.<br />
Page 31 of 78
4 Environmental Impact and Risks<br />
4.1 Land<strong>for</strong>ms, Geology and Soils<br />
Existing Situation<br />
The Proposal is located within the railway corridor. All three sites are on relatively level ground<br />
in cleared and grassy areas. The geology of the area has been predicted to comprise fine to<br />
medium-grained quartz-lithic sandstone with lenticular shale interbeds of the Clifton subgroup.<br />
The soil landscape in which Outdoor Location 1 and Outdoor Location 3 will be situated is<br />
described as Hawkesbury Group with extreme soil erosion hazard, mass movement (rock fall)<br />
hazard, steep slopes, and very low soil fertility. The soil landscape in which Outdoor Location 2<br />
will be situated is described as Lucas Heights Group which is described as hard setting Yellow<br />
Podzolic soil and Yellow Soloths on ridges and plateau surfaces with low soil fertility.<br />
<strong>NSW</strong> Acid Sulphate Soils (ASS) risk mapping provided by the <strong>NSW</strong> Office of Environment and<br />
Heritage (OEH) indicates the proposed site is in an area of no known occurrence.<br />
A desktop geological review was undertaken <strong>for</strong> these sites. This review did not anticipate the<br />
presence of ASS or contaminated material and found the site was suitable <strong>for</strong> the proposed<br />
use. Since no contaminants are expected, the standard control measures described below are<br />
deemed adequate <strong>for</strong> these sites. Prior to construction UGL will confirm ground conditions by:<br />
On-site inspections during pre-construction site reviews to confirm desk-top study<br />
predictions; and<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
Approximately a total of 45 square metres will be disturbed during construction of the proposal.<br />
Excavated soil and rock will be stockpiled and removed from the site if it cannot be used<br />
elsewhere on the site. The foundation <strong>for</strong> the monopole, masts and trenches <strong>for</strong> the cables will<br />
each result in approximately 22 cubic metres of spoil. The trenches <strong>for</strong> the cables will be<br />
backfilled upon completion.<br />
Excavation and trenching activities may result in erosion if appropriate mitigation measures are<br />
not in place. Soil erosion has the potential to destabilise land<strong>for</strong>ms and deposit sediments in<br />
drainage systems and waterways. Sediment deposition and fine particles in suspension within<br />
waterways have direct impact on water quality and aquatic life.<br />
Given the site characteristics and the scope and size of the proposed work, it is anticipated that<br />
erosion and sediment risks are minimal and can be effectively managed through the<br />
implementation of standard measures as outlined in the Landcom/Department of Housing<br />
Managing Urban Stormwater, Soils and Construction Guidelines (the Blue Book) (Landcom<br />
2004).<br />
No operational impacts are expected.<br />
Page 32 of 78
Control Measures<br />
Site specific Erosion and Sediment Control measures will be identified as part of ECM. The<br />
proposed measures will be in accordance with the ‘Blue Book’ (Managing Urban Stormwater:<br />
Soils and Construction 4 th Edition (Landcom, 2004), and will be implemented during the<br />
construction phase. The measures will include, but not be limited to, those outlined below.<br />
All spoil will be transferred directly to skip bins or stockpiled appropriately.<br />
Appropriate stockpiling of materials will take place away from drainage lines, waterways<br />
and drains.<br />
Any soil that may be contaminated or weed infested will be stockpiled separately be<strong>for</strong>e<br />
being removed from the site.<br />
Sediment fences and bunds will be installed and inspected regularly.<br />
The tracking of soils on public roads will be prevented by using appropriate shaker<br />
grids/ballast pads.<br />
Soil will be removed from public roads and other paved areas using dry street sweepers or<br />
other measures.<br />
Disturbed areas will be reinstated, if required.<br />
During maintenance activities, any spills will be attended to and treated in an appropriate<br />
and timely fashion in accordance with Tf<strong>NSW</strong> procedures.<br />
4.2 Water Quality and Hydrology<br />
Existing Situation<br />
The nearest waterway, a small unnamed tributary, is about 80 metres north-west of the Outdoor<br />
Location 1 and <strong>for</strong>ms part of the Hacking River catchment. While the suburban stormwater<br />
system is located at a large distance from the site however, there is a dish drain located within<br />
approximately five metres of Outdoor Location 1. Runoff from the site drains south-west towards<br />
Wilsons Creek. Based on a search of registered groundwater bores within the <strong>Helensburgh</strong><br />
area, the local groundwater resources are estimated to be about 10 metres below the surface<br />
(Registered Groundwater Bore reference: GW100275).<br />
Flood mapping <strong>for</strong> the proposed site location is not provided by Wollongong City Council.<br />
However, given the locations and topography of the area, flooding is not considered to present<br />
a substantial risk.<br />
Possible Risks<br />
There is a risk that the local underground water table may be reached and groundwater may be<br />
encountered during pile boring activities. While this is not expected to occur at this site, it<br />
Page 33 of 78
emains a risk in respect of water quality and hydrology. The CEMP, ECM and Water<br />
Management Plan will contain procedures to manage this risk if it eventuates.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
In addition to sediment rich runoff, the following wastewater types can be generated by<br />
construction activities:<br />
Liquid waste from non-destructive excavation<br />
Water from spills<br />
Sewage from the site facilities<br />
Water collected in trenches and the pit<br />
Without appropriate safeguards, contaminants such as fuel and oil spills may reach nearby<br />
drains and discharge into local waterways. These contaminants may have the potential to harm<br />
aquatic life and affect the quality of water downstream. However, the risk of such occurrence<br />
would be minimised through implementation of measures provided in control measures<br />
provided below.<br />
Rain or groundwater may enter the excavations. If inappropriately managed, sediment-laden<br />
water could be discharged into local water bodies and/or the nearby stormwater system.<br />
No operational impacts are expected. The works will not affect the land<strong>for</strong>m or the flow of water<br />
in the area.<br />
Control Measures<br />
During construction water quality impacts will be minimised through a range of control measures<br />
in addition to the erosion and sedimentation controls included in Section 4.1. The water quality<br />
measures will include, but will not be limited to those outlined below.<br />
A Water Management Plan will be prepared be<strong>for</strong>e construction begins to determine the<br />
most appropriate method <strong>for</strong> water disposal should groundwater be encountered during pile<br />
boring activities.<br />
A geological engineer will be present during the boring of the pile and work will cease<br />
immediately if groundwater is encountered. The water will be tested according to industry<br />
standards to determine the presence of contaminants or other materials. This will determine<br />
the most appropriate method of water disposal. If water is encountered, special construction<br />
methodologies will be adopted to prevent a continuing flow of groundwater to the surface.<br />
Ensure construction materials are not left in the vicinity of stormwater drains.<br />
Trenches and excavations will be covered to prevent rainwater entering.<br />
Plant and equipment will be checked regularly <strong>for</strong> oil leaks.<br />
Plant and equipment will not be refuelled on site.<br />
Page 34 of 78
Wash down areas will be off site.<br />
Liquid waste generated during non-destructive excavation will be removed from the-site <strong>for</strong><br />
treatment and disposal.<br />
4.3 Air Quality<br />
Existing Situation<br />
Wollongong City Council’s State of the Environment Report 2009-2010 reported that the<br />
regional air quality in Wollongong City Council was largely ‘good’. Local air quality is influenced<br />
by domestic and industrial emissions.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
Local and regional air quality can be affected during construction by dust, construction vehicle<br />
emissions and odour. Dust may be generated from the disturbance of soils or poorly maintained<br />
stockpile areas, which can affect human health or property. Poorly maintained vehicles can<br />
produce excess emissions.<br />
The works will require energy to power vehicles (e.g. construction, delivery and staff vehicles)<br />
and construction plant. The energy requirements will primarily be in the <strong>for</strong>m of fuel (petrol and<br />
diesel). Fuel use will emit greenhouse gases with about 2.3 to 2.7 kilograms of carbon dioxide<br />
equivalent (CO 2 -e) emitted per litre of fuel consumed (DEWHA 2008). In addition, indirect and<br />
third party emissions will be generated as a result of energy used to produce materials (<strong>for</strong><br />
example steel and concrete) – which is known as ‘embodied energy’.<br />
During operation, electricity will be required to power the facility, but the energy use will <strong>for</strong>m<br />
only a small contribution to Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s overall greenhouse gas emissions.<br />
Control Measures<br />
Air quality impacts throughout construction will be minimised through a range of control<br />
measures which will include, but will not be limited to, those outlined below.<br />
Plant and equipment will be maintained in accordance with manufacturers’ specifications.<br />
Regular inspection of plant and equipment will be undertaken to ascertain that fitted<br />
emission controls are operating efficiently.<br />
Plant or machinery will not be left idling.<br />
Stockpiles will be maintained and contained appropriately, which could include covering or<br />
regular watering to minimise dust.<br />
Minimal work will be undertaken during high wind periods.<br />
Trucks transporting spoil and other waste materials from site will be covered appropriately.<br />
Disturbed areas will be rehabilitated as soon as practicable.<br />
Page 35 of 78
4.4 Biodiversity<br />
Existing Situation<br />
Based on a search within a one kilometre buffer of the proposed sites, there are 19 species of<br />
fauna, 10 species of flora and 12 migratory bird species listed as threatened under the<br />
Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (EPBC Act). These species or<br />
their habitat may occur in the search area (refer Appendix 3). In addition, there is one<br />
Endangered Ecological Community (EEC) of Upland Basalt Eucalypt Forests of the Sydney<br />
Basin Bioregion identified within the search area.<br />
Based on a search within a 10 kilometre buffer of the proposed sites, there are recordings of<br />
105 threatened fauna species, 54 threatened flora species and one EEC listed under the<br />
Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995 (TSC Act) within the search area (refer Appendix<br />
3).<br />
The three sites are located in cleared or grassy areas within the corridor that have been cleared<br />
previously. Dense bushland surround the expanse of the rail corridor in this area. RailCorp<br />
Biodiversity Mapping <strong>for</strong> the Illawarra, Map 2 (42.3kilometre – 49.15kilometre) does not identify<br />
any flora or fauna within a 100 metre buffer along this area of rail corridor that requires specific<br />
protection.<br />
A review of the RailCorp Sensitive Site Register identified native vegetation of the Royal<br />
National Park as a sensitive area proximal to all three Outdoor Locations. The sensitive native<br />
vegetation of the Royal National Park is adjacent to the rail corridor from Waterfall to Ot<strong>for</strong>d<br />
(chainage SW39+500 to SW52+000) which incorporates all three of the proposed locations of<br />
the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> DBS.<br />
There are 90 species of noxious weeds identified in the Wollongong LGA. Weed control is<br />
en<strong>for</strong>ceable by Wollongong City Council, as the local control authority under the Noxious<br />
Weeds Act 1993. RailCorp vegetation mapping also indicates that the sites are in a section of<br />
rail corridor where there is remnant vegetation and weeds including Crofton weed, mint bush,<br />
Lantana, Fleabane, and Rhodes grass and Bidens are present.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
While there are threatened species known to be present in the searched area and some are<br />
likely to be present within the dense bushland of the Royal National Park that borders the rail<br />
corridor. Outdoor Location 1 and 2 are separated from the Royal National Park by the rail line.<br />
All three sites are within previously cleared and disturbed areas within the rail corridor.<br />
Following on consultation and inspection with a Tf<strong>NSW</strong> Environmental Officer it was confirmed<br />
Royal National Park would not be impacted by the proposed work.<br />
The works are not expected to impact on listed threatened species or EECs. Given the absence<br />
of suitable habitat in the immediate vicinity of the sites, it is unlikely that threatened fauna<br />
Page 36 of 78
species will be present in the immediate area. The proposed work is not expected to remove<br />
any native vegetation. No impacts to native vegetation are expected.<br />
As such, the proposed works will not affect, threaten or have a significant impact on ecological<br />
communities, plants or animals listed under the EPBC Act and/or TSC Act. Referral to the<br />
Commonwealth Minister <strong>for</strong> Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities<br />
<strong>for</strong> further consideration or approval in relation to potential flora and fauna impacts associated<br />
with the works is not considered necessary. Similarly, the preparation of a Species Impact<br />
Statement under <strong>NSW</strong> legislation to further consider the impacts of the proposal on threatened<br />
plants or animals is not considered necessary.<br />
Once soil has been disturbed there is the potential <strong>for</strong> the spread of weeds. Noxious weeds are<br />
known to occur in the Wollongong area.<br />
With regard to fauna, the work will not remove native vegetation or other features considered as<br />
potential habitat <strong>for</strong> fauna (threatened or otherwise). Animals could potentially fall into an open<br />
trench and become trapped or injured. Trapped animals could be accidentally entombed during<br />
the backfilling of trenches.<br />
No operational impacts are expected.<br />
Control Measures<br />
Impacts on flora and fauna throughout construction will be minimised through a range of control<br />
measures which will include, but will not be limited to, those outlined below.<br />
If threatened flora or fauna species are identified on site, work will stop immediately. A<br />
spotter/catcher or botanist will be engaged to survey the site, in conjunction with Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s<br />
Environmental Officer, and advise on species management.<br />
No native vegetation will be removed.<br />
Root cutting will be avoided.<br />
Care will be taken to minimise the spread of weeds. Appropriate management and disposal<br />
of noxious weeds will be undertaken in consultation with Wollongong City Council, if<br />
required.<br />
The work site will be inspected <strong>for</strong> trapped or injured fauna at the start of each day.<br />
Trenches/excavations will be covered at the end of each day and inspected be<strong>for</strong>e they are<br />
backfilled to ensure that no fauna species are harmed.<br />
Ensure sediment runoff is controlled near creeks and gullies.<br />
Ensure spoil is collected as soon as work is finished.<br />
Page 37 of 78
4.5 Noise and Vibration<br />
Existing Situation<br />
The adjacent railway line and traffic are the major sources of noise in the area.<br />
The closest receivers to the site are residents on Gardiner Place about 500 metres to the<br />
southwest of Outdoor Location 1. There are no other sensitive receivers including schools, child<br />
care centres or aged care facilities within 500 metres of the proposed sites.<br />
Construction Noise<br />
The Interim Construction Noise Guideline (ICNG) (DECC 2009) defines noise management<br />
levels (measured in decibels) <strong>for</strong> residential receivers and other types of receivers including<br />
commercial and industrial premises, places of worship and schools.<br />
The ICNG states:<br />
Where the predicted or measured L Aeq, 15 min is greater than the noise affected level, the<br />
proponent should apply all feasible and reasonable work practices to meet the noise<br />
affected level<br />
The proponent should also in<strong>for</strong>m all potentially affected residents of the nature of works to<br />
be carried out, the expected noise levels and duration and contact details<br />
For works above the highly affected noise criteria, respite periods may be required, and <strong>for</strong><br />
works outside standard hours there needs to be a strong justification and negotiation with<br />
the community (DECC 2009).<br />
Noise associated with the proposal is likely to be generated by construction trucks, machinery<br />
and, in particular, boring activities required to establish the foundations <strong>for</strong> the monopole. These<br />
activities will be of a short duration.<br />
Construction is expected to take six weeks and all work is expected to be undertaken during<br />
standard working hours. The key noise-generating activity, the pile boring, is expected to be<br />
undertaken during one day.<br />
Given the nearest receiver is approximately 500 metres away, background noise monitoring and<br />
the establishment of noise management levels <strong>for</strong> residential receivers is not proposed.<br />
Nevertheless, a qualitative construction noise assessment has been undertaken (refer Table 2).<br />
In addition, the ICNG prescribes a highly noise affected criteria of 75 dBA L Aeq, 15min, which is the<br />
point at which there may be strong community reaction to noise. Given the offset distance, it is<br />
unlikely that sensitive receivers will experience a noise level above the highly affected level of<br />
75 dBA L Aeq, 15min during the noisiest works)<br />
Page 38 of 78
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Table 2<br />
Qualitative Construction Noise Assessment<br />
Distance to nearest<br />
sensitive receiver<br />
Approx. construction noise level<br />
at 7m, dB(A)<br />
Noise screening or barriers<br />
Ambient noise<br />
environment at receiver<br />
Timing of construction work<br />
Duration of construction work<br />
Distance<br />
(m)<br />
Category (refer AS2436<br />
and Note 2)<br />
Description<br />
Description<br />
Category<br />
Duration<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Distance to nearest<br />
sensitive receiver<br />
Approx. construction noise level<br />
at 7m, dB(A)<br />
Noise screening or barriers<br />
Ambient noise<br />
environment at receiver<br />
Timing of construction work<br />
Duration of construction work<br />
Distance<br />
(m)<br />
Category (refer AS2436<br />
and Note 2)<br />
Description<br />
Description<br />
Category<br />
Duration<br />
>1000 -46<br />
For pile boring activities undertaken within one construction day<br />
500m -40 ≥100dB(A) (e.g. bored<br />
100 Receivers screened<br />
-10 Quiet, rural, or<br />
-35 Day (7am – 6pm<br />
0
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Rating<br />
Distance to nearest<br />
sensitive receiver<br />
Approx. construction noise level<br />
at 7m, dB(A)<br />
Noise screening or barriers<br />
Ambient noise<br />
environment at receiver<br />
Timing of construction work<br />
Duration of construction work<br />
Distance<br />
(m)<br />
Category (refer AS2436<br />
and Note 2)<br />
Description<br />
Description<br />
Category<br />
Duration<br />
pneumatic drill)<br />
Score 25 Impact / risk level ranges<br />
Low: 50 requires specialist noise study / advice)<br />
Note: the qualitative noise assessment has been based on a total six week construction period. It is noted that the level of impact identified above is likely to<br />
occur on one day only (i.e. during pile boring activities). All other noise generated during the construction process will be well within the low range.<br />
Page 41 of 78
Construction Vibration<br />
Vibration effects from the operation of heavy machinery, such as vibratory rollers or large earth<br />
moving equipment have the potential to cause structural disturbance or discom<strong>for</strong>t. The<br />
proposed work will not require the use of vibration-causing heavy machinery.<br />
Discom<strong>for</strong>t effects are not expected given the types of machinery required <strong>for</strong> construction<br />
works. Similarly, structural damage to buildings is not expected as the nearest buildings are<br />
adjacent to the railway and already experience vibration from trains on a regular basis.<br />
Operational Noise and Vibration<br />
No operational impacts are expected.<br />
Control Measures<br />
Construction works will adopt Best Management Practice (BMP) and Best Available Technology<br />
Economically Achievable (BATEA) practices as described in the Interim Construction Noise<br />
Guideline (ICNG) (DECC 2009) and be carried out in accordance with Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s Construction<br />
Noise Strategy.<br />
Control measures to minimise noise and vibration impacts will include, but will not be limited to,<br />
those outlined below.<br />
Maximise the offset distance between noise plant items and sensitive receivers<br />
Orient plant and equipment away from sensitive receivers<br />
Avoid the simultaneous operation of two or more noise plant items in close vicinity and<br />
adjacent to sensitive receivers<br />
Carry out loading and unloading away from sensitive receivers<br />
Where necessary, use structures to shield sensitive receivers from noise sources<br />
Provide periods of respite if high noise generating activities occur <strong>for</strong> extended periods.<br />
In addition, the community will be notified of the works and their duration and provided with<br />
contact details be<strong>for</strong>e work begins. Any noise complaints received will be addressed by the<br />
Project Manager as soon as possible.<br />
Page 42 of 78
4.6 Heritage<br />
Existing Situation<br />
A search <strong>for</strong> non-Aboriginal heritage items was completed by consulting the following<br />
databases: Wollongong LEP, State Heritage Register, State Heritage Inventory, Australian<br />
Heritage Database, (including Commonwealth Register of the National Estate), world heritage<br />
sites and RailCorp’s Section 170 Heritage and Conservation Register. Full details of the<br />
searches are provided in Appendix 3.<br />
The following heritage items are located in the vicinity of the proposal:<br />
The Royal National Park (approximately 25 metres away from Outdoor Location 1 and<br />
2) and Garawarra State Conservation Area (approximately 15 metres away from<br />
Outdoor Location 3) is a nationally listed heritage item which borders the rail corridor<br />
within close proximity to all three proposed sites<br />
<strong>Helensburgh</strong> Station, approximately 670 metres south-west from Outdoor Location 1 is<br />
listed under RailCorp’s Section 170 Heritage and Conservation Register.<br />
There are eight indigenous places in <strong>Helensburgh</strong> included on the Register of National<br />
Estate, however, details relating to the nature and locations of these items are not<br />
available in the Australian Heritage Database. There are no restrictions <strong>for</strong> the Register<br />
of the National Estate places, as the register is now a non-statutory archive.<br />
A search <strong>for</strong> known items of Aboriginal heritage value was undertaken <strong>for</strong> the proposed site,<br />
(with a 200 metre buffer) using OEH’s Aboriginal Heritage In<strong>for</strong>mation Management System<br />
(AHIMS). Four Aboriginal sites have been identified within 200 metres of Outdoor Location 2;<br />
however none were recorded within 50 metres from the site. In addition there are no Aboriginal<br />
sites located around Outdoor Location 1 and 3.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
All work will be undertaken outside the boundaries of heritage items. With the implementation of<br />
control measures included in a CEMP <strong>for</strong> the sites, the works are unlikely to have an impact on<br />
known items or places of non-Aboriginal heritage value. No permits or approvals are required.<br />
RailCorp Biodiversity mapping identifies numerous aboriginal art sites within close proximity to<br />
Outdoor Location 2. However a search using OEH’s AHIMS identifies these Aboriginal sites to<br />
be outside of the 50 metres buffer of Outdoor Location 2. There are no Aboriginal sites close to<br />
Location 1 and 3.<br />
There are no known Aboriginal objects or places known to occur within 50 metres of any<br />
Outdoor Locations. Although the sites are located in areas that have been disturbed and<br />
cleared previously, due to the proximity of the site to known Aboriginal objects or places, the<br />
potential to uncover unidentified Aboriginal heritage items is considered moderate. Safeguards<br />
have been proposed to address circumstances if an unexpected find occurs.<br />
Page 43 of 78
Control Measures<br />
Impact on heritage throughout construction will be minimised through a range of control<br />
measures, which will include, but will not be limited to, those outlined below.<br />
If a non-Aboriginal historical relic is discovered, all work likely to affect it will cease and the<br />
Project Manager will be contacted. Tf<strong>NSW</strong> heritage staff and the Heritage Branch (<strong>for</strong>merly<br />
Heritage Office), <strong>NSW</strong> OEH will be notified as required. An investigation will be undertaken<br />
by a suitably qualified archaeologist to identify suitable measures to reduce the impact on<br />
the relic discovered be<strong>for</strong>e work resumes.<br />
Should Aboriginal heritage items be uncovered, all work in the vicinity will cease and the<br />
Project Manager and Tf<strong>NSW</strong> heritage staff will be notified immediately. The Manager of the<br />
Planning and Aboriginal Heritage Section, Metropolitan Branch, Environment Protection and<br />
Regulation Division, OEH will be notified in accordance with Section 89A of the National<br />
Parks and Wildlife Act 1974. The local Aboriginal Land Council will be notified and an<br />
assessment by an archaeologist will be arranged to determine the significance of the<br />
objects and other requirements be<strong>for</strong>e work resumes.<br />
4.7 Waste<br />
Overview<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong> is required to manage waste in accordance with the Waste Avoidance and Resource<br />
Recovery Act 2001 (WARR Act). The waste hierarchy (Avoid, Reuse, Recycle, Energy<br />
Recovery and Disposal) should be followed <strong>for</strong> all projects.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
The main waste streams that may be generated during construction include:<br />
spoil from excavation<br />
concrete<br />
asphalt<br />
vegetation<br />
packaging<br />
general litter including glass, plastic, metal and paper waste<br />
wiring<br />
wastewater from non-destructive excavation.<br />
No operational impacts are expected.<br />
Page 44 of 78
Control Measures<br />
A waste management plan will be prepared as part of CEMP to detail waste types and<br />
quantities as well as methods <strong>for</strong> segregation, handling, storing and disposal. Furthermore,<br />
waste impacts will be minimised through a range of control measures, (consistent with the<br />
WARR Act) which will include, but not be limited to, those outlined below.<br />
All waste will be classified in accordance with the Waste Classification Guidelines (DECC<br />
2009) and transported to a place that can lawfully accept the waste.<br />
Any material that may be classified as a hazardous waste will be dealt appropriately and in<br />
accordance with Tf<strong>NSW</strong> procedures.<br />
Packaging will be minimised, where possible and where the safety and delivery of services<br />
is not compromised.<br />
Wherever possible, suitable excavated spoil will be reused on site <strong>for</strong> backfilling,<br />
landscaping and other purposes.<br />
Any spoil or waste material tracked onto roads will be swept up immediately.<br />
Adequate numbers of bins and waste containers will be placed at the site. The site manager<br />
will ensure bins are not overflowing and are appropriately covered.<br />
Wastewater generated by non-destructive excavation will be taken off site <strong>for</strong> treatment and<br />
disposal.<br />
All waste will be removed from the site when work is completed.<br />
4.8 Contaminated Land<br />
Existing Situation<br />
The subject site has been initially investigated <strong>for</strong> potential land contamination. The<br />
investigation included:<br />
A site walk over and visual inspection <strong>for</strong> potential signs of land contamination<br />
Search of OEH register of contaminated sites<br />
Search of RailCorp records<br />
Review of all materials that will be used at the subject site to establish their potential <strong>for</strong><br />
land contamination.<br />
Due to the historical and ongoing use of the site as part of the rail corridor, the following<br />
potential sources of contamination may be present in the vicinity of the site:<br />
Fuel and oil spills and engine emissions<br />
Rail corridor maintenance activities, such as application of pesticides and herbicides<br />
Page 45 of 78
Brake linings<br />
Historical cables / pipework ducting and <strong>for</strong>mer site structures, with potential asbestos<br />
containing materials<br />
Fabric of old rolling stock<br />
Imported fill.<br />
The initial investigation did not find any signs of potential land contamination. There were no<br />
visible and/or obvious signs of contamination in the vicinity of the site. No waste dumping, soil<br />
discoloration, odours and/or similar were noticed.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
Although contamination is not identified as part of the initial investigation, the limited<br />
investigation cannot exclude potential contamination as the result of unknown past activities,<br />
either on the site or in the vicinity. There is a risk that contaminants may be encountered during<br />
the proposed work. If encountered, contaminants may pose a risk to health of workers and the<br />
environment in general.<br />
Control Measures<br />
The risk of encountering unknown contaminants during excavation shall be managed in<br />
accordance with Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s procedures, the CEMP, ECM and land contamination legislation.<br />
Control measures to manage contamination risks will include, but not be limited to, those<br />
outlined below.<br />
During excavation, site workers will look <strong>for</strong> signs of potential contamination such as:<br />
presence of waste and/or other imported materials, odours, soil colouring, floating layer in<br />
groundwater etc.<br />
If any contamination is encountered, or suspected, the work will be immediately stoped and<br />
the site fenced off. The site will be investigated and validated and work will only resume<br />
after approval from the Health, Safety and Environment Manager is obtained.<br />
Contaminated soil will be segregated in a special container; prior to classification and<br />
ultimate disposal.<br />
4.9 Hazardous Materials<br />
Existing Situation<br />
Construction, operation and maintenance of the proposed facilities will not require the use of<br />
hazardous chemicals and/or materials. However, if required <strong>for</strong> un<strong>for</strong>eseen reason, a hazardous<br />
waste management plan will have to be prepared. The plan will detail terms applying to the<br />
purchase, storage, use, handling and disposal of such materials.<br />
Page 46 of 78
Potential Impact<br />
If not properly used, chemicals may present a risk to the safety of workers and the environment<br />
in general.<br />
Safe use of hazardous chemicals is regulated and subject to numerous standards, including a<br />
need <strong>for</strong> a dangerous goods licence.<br />
Control Measures<br />
The impact of hazardous materials will be minimised through a range of control measures<br />
including, but not limited to, those outlined below.<br />
Hazardous materials will be properly classified and managed in accordance with<br />
requirements <strong>for</strong> their particular class.<br />
An evaluation of alternative materials will be undertaken be<strong>for</strong>e use of chemicals is<br />
approved.<br />
Hazardous materials will be transported, stored and used in accordance with the<br />
corresponding material safety data sheets which will be available on the site.<br />
Hazardous materials will be stored in a locked and bundled area at the site; incompatible<br />
chemicals will not be stored together.<br />
No fuels will be stored on site. Refuelling will be undertaken at off-site facilities.<br />
Adequate spill prevention, containment and response measures (e.g. drip trays) will be<br />
provided on site if needed.<br />
Construction personnel will be trained in spill containment and response procedures.<br />
All storage and handling equipment on site will be maintained properly.<br />
4.10 Visual Aesthetics and Urban Design<br />
Existing Situation<br />
The visual landscape surrounding the proposed sites includes the South Coast Line, associated<br />
overhead power lines and the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong>. There is dense vegetation lining both sides<br />
of the rail corridor.<br />
Residential dwellings are about 500 metres away from Outdoor Location 1 on Gardiner Place.<br />
This is the closest sensitive receiver to the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> DBS sites. No residents will<br />
have direct views of any of the DBS sites. There are no other sensitive receivers close to the<br />
proposed sites.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
During construction the visual environment will be temporarily altered through the presence of<br />
temporary work buildings, plant and equipment.<br />
Page 47 of 78
While the site is operational, a new 20 metre high monopole and two new 10 metre high masts<br />
will be introduced into the visual environment. The monopole will be accompanied by 1.7 metre<br />
high cabinets. The cabinets will be of little visual significance.<br />
Visually sensitive receivers in the vicinity of the site include residences located approximately<br />
500 metres south-west from Outdoor Location 1. Hikers on the Burgh Track may be able to view<br />
the 10 metre mast of Outdoor Location 2. The Burgh Track is approximately 200 metres away<br />
from Outdoor Location 2. It is expected that there will be no visual impacts from Outdoor<br />
Location 2 due to the large separation distance between the site and the Burgh Track.<br />
Additionally, the smaller 10 metre mast will be screened by mature vegetation.<br />
The new monopole will be 20 metres in height and there are two additional 10 metre high<br />
masts. A photomontage of the new monopole and masts are provided in Figure 3, Figure 4 and<br />
Figure 5. Due to dense bushland screening the rail corridor, residents are unlikely to have direct<br />
views of the DBS sites.<br />
The potential visual impact of the proposal is considered to be low.<br />
Figure 3<br />
View of Outdoor Location 1 looking south-west<br />
Page 48 of 78
Figure 4<br />
View of Outdoor Location 2 looking north-west<br />
Page 49 of 78
Figure 5<br />
View of Outdoor Location 3 looking south<br />
Control Measures<br />
Visual impact during construction will be minimised through a range of control measures which<br />
will include, but will not be limited to, those outlined below.<br />
The work area shall be maintained in an orderly manner<br />
All temporary signage associated with the works must be appropriately displayed<br />
Page 50 of 78
All work equipment and materials will be contained within the designated boundaries of the<br />
work site<br />
All waste generated during the course of the works will be removed from the work areas as<br />
soon as practicable or at the end of each work day and disposed of in accordance with the<br />
measures identified <strong>for</strong> ‘Waste’<br />
On completion of work, all vehicles, materials and refuse relating to the works will be<br />
removed and the site reinstated to the pre-work condition if not better.<br />
4.11 Land Use<br />
Existing Situation<br />
The proposed sites are on land owned by Tf<strong>NSW</strong> and zoned <strong>for</strong> the purposes of a railway under<br />
the Wollongong LEP. The land where the new monopole, masts and cabinets are to be situated<br />
and where trenching is required is not actively used <strong>for</strong> Tf<strong>NSW</strong> activities (i.e. an access route or<br />
storage area). The immediate neighbouring land uses are mainly bushland and residential.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
The proposal will not affect or alter the current use of the site or the immediate surrounding area<br />
as a rail corridor. It will not have effects on the use of the neighbouring properties.<br />
Control Measures<br />
No specific control measures are required.<br />
4.12 Socio-Economic Effects<br />
Existing Situation<br />
The proposed sites are in the Wollongong LGA, which in the 2011 census had a population of<br />
around 192,418. <strong>Helensburgh</strong> is mostly a residential suburb with small commercial areas<br />
scattered around the suburb and surrounded by dense bushland.<br />
The railway line at the DBS sites runs through dense bushland northeast and east of the<br />
predominantly residential township of <strong>Helensburgh</strong>. The closest residential receivers are<br />
situated approximately 500 metres from Outdoor Location 1. There are no other sensitive<br />
receivers within close proximity to the proposed sites.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
Social and economic considerations typically focus on the effect on the local community as a<br />
whole, and on local businesses. Amenity issues such as noise, visual impacts and traffic are<br />
some of the key areas that can affect the community and are discussed in detail in sections 4.5,<br />
4.10 and 4.14.<br />
Page 51 of 78
Construction is unlikely to have any adverse effect on businesses or residents in the<br />
<strong>Helensburgh</strong> area, as work will be within the rail corridor. Potential noise impacts will be<br />
temporary (less than six weeks). There will be no traffic or access changes <strong>for</strong> businesses or<br />
residents.<br />
As some work may be undertaken during scheduled track work, some activity may occur on<br />
weekends to minimise interruptions to train services as a result of the work.<br />
The sites will be appropriately fenced off during construction. In operation, the facilities will be<br />
fenced off and pose only a minimal risk to public safety.<br />
There will be positive long term effects resulting from the proposal, as the new DTRS will<br />
provide a more effective communication service and improve the safety of the rail network.<br />
There may be minor short-term positive impacts <strong>for</strong> the surrounding area as a result of the need<br />
<strong>for</strong> materials, transport, food, services and accommodation.<br />
The DTRS project has a capital value of approximately $225 million and will generate over 100<br />
jobs over the life of the project.<br />
Control Measures<br />
In addition to the control measures proposed in the noise, traffic and visual sections, other<br />
control measures are outlined below.<br />
Nearby residents and businesses will be in<strong>for</strong>med about the nature and timing of works.<br />
Signage will notify the public about the works.<br />
Appropriate fencing around the site will help maintain public safety during construction and<br />
operation.<br />
4.13 Electromagnetic Energy (EME)<br />
Overview<br />
Electromagnetic energy (EME) is the energy stored in an electromagnetic field. Radiofrequency<br />
EME refers to the EME generated by radio waves. EME is a factor of everyday life and is<br />
emitted by natural sources such as the sun and earth, and by man-made sources operating on<br />
radio waves (e.g. TV and radio broadcasts), baby monitors, model planes, mobile phone base<br />
stations and radio communications facilities.<br />
The Australian Radiation Protection and Nuclear Safety Agency (ARPANSA) have established a<br />
radiation protection standard specifying limits <strong>for</strong> continuous exposure of the general public and<br />
occupational workers to radio frequency emissions.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
EME levels emitted by the new DBS sites have been estimated at 1.5 metres above ground<br />
level at various distances from the proposed antennas. It should be noted that the actual EME<br />
Page 52 of 78
levels will be significantly less than predicted due to path losses and the fact that the DBS<br />
automatically minimises transmitter power to serve only established phone calls. The maximum<br />
cumulative EME level at 1.5 metres above the ground is estimated to be 0.031%, 0.032% and<br />
0.028% of the ARPANSA exposure limits at Outdoor Locations 1, 2 and 3 respectively. EME<br />
impacts are unlikely when the facility is operational. The ARPANSA report is included at<br />
Appendix 4.<br />
Control Measures<br />
The various elements will be located in areas that are not accessible by the public. However,<br />
the following control measures will also minimise health and safety risks.<br />
Appropriate signage will be placed around the site to warn people of the potential hazards.<br />
All people required to work around occupationally hazardous radio frequencies will<br />
undergo RadHaz training.<br />
4.14 Traffic and Access<br />
Existing Situation<br />
Access to the proposed Outdoor Location 1 and 2 will be via existing railway gates and sealed<br />
road off Gardiner Place whilst access to Outdoor Location 3 will via an unsealed track off Nixon<br />
Place which is co-utilised by users and employees of the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Waste Disposal Depot.<br />
The unsealed track will only be used to access the site and no construction work will occur on<br />
the unsealed track.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
During construction, there will be an increased number of vehicles using the local streets;<br />
however, the anticipated volume of traffic is relatively small (about four to six truck movements<br />
per day).<br />
As works are to take place in the rail corridor, access changes to local roads or access to<br />
driveways are not expected. There may be temporary inconveniences such as additional traffic<br />
and delays to motorists on Nixon Place and employees of the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Waste Disposal<br />
Depot as the road will be used to access the site, however impacts are expected to be minor as<br />
the works would be of short term duration. In addition measures would be implemented to<br />
minimise any potential impacts.<br />
Vehicular traffic in the rail corridor will be limited to concrete and delivery trucks <strong>for</strong> the cabinets<br />
and the monopole sections and trucks with pile boring or trenching equipment. These trucks are<br />
not large enough to prevent access via the gate.<br />
There will be some traffic movement associated with vehicles that will need to access the site<br />
<strong>for</strong> maintenance requirements. However, the volume of traffic will be very small and will not<br />
adversely impact on the surrounding road network. It is proposed that the monopole and<br />
Page 53 of 78
antennas be accessed via an elevated work plat<strong>for</strong>m, or through the use of a ladder and dual<br />
lanyard system.<br />
Control Measures<br />
Impacts associated with traffic and access will be minimised through a range of control<br />
measures, which will include, but will not be limited to those outlined below.<br />
A Traffic Management Plan will be developed <strong>for</strong> the site.<br />
A dilapidation survey will be completed prior to construction commencing.<br />
All pavement or road surfaces damaged during construction will be restored when work is<br />
finished.<br />
The Traffic Management Plan will ensure compliance with Australian Standard AS1742.3-<br />
2002 Manual of uni<strong>for</strong>m traffic control devices – traffic control devices on roads.<br />
Consultation with the Wollongong City Council will be undertaken regarding potential issues<br />
relating to the co-utilisation of Nixon Place with users of the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Waste Disposal<br />
Depot <strong>for</strong> access to Outdoor Location 3.<br />
4.15 Utilities and Services<br />
Existing Situation<br />
There is existing services such as fibre close to the proposed sites.<br />
Potential Impacts<br />
The facilities will be connected to the fibre network and do not require connections to water or<br />
gas.<br />
There are no public utilities near the sites and there is the potential <strong>for</strong> some known or unknown<br />
services to be impacted during excavation or relocation/connections. Depending on the service,<br />
outages or interruptions could affect nearby properties or the rail network.<br />
Control Measures<br />
• Ensure that a Dial Be<strong>for</strong>e You Dig call and a services search are undertaken to identify<br />
services prior to construction commencing<br />
• Consult with public utility providers to minimise impacts during any utility relocations or<br />
readjustments.<br />
4.16 Light spill<br />
There may be some light spill impacts during the proposed works. However, there is no new<br />
permanent lighting proposed. Light sources will not be directed to residential properties and<br />
there is dense vegetation screening surrounding the sites.<br />
Page 54 of 78
4.17 Demand on Resources<br />
Construction materials are readily available and will be sourced from local contractors where<br />
possible.<br />
4.18 Cumulative Environmental Effects<br />
Cumulative impacts often result when several different construction projects are scheduled <strong>for</strong><br />
similar times and locations.<br />
A search of the Department of Planning and Infrastructure’s Major Projects register, Wollongong<br />
City Council’s development application register and the Tf<strong>NSW</strong> projects website were<br />
undertaken on April 2013 and no major projects were identified in the vicinity of the proposed<br />
site.<br />
There is also a risk of cumulative impacts if unscheduled work, e.g. emergency work by other<br />
utilities or developers, is required. Such situations will be monitored and addressed by the<br />
Project Manager.<br />
The proposed DBS is part of a large number of radio communications facilities being installed<br />
across the electrified network as part of the DTRS project. In terms of localised cumulative<br />
construction impacts, the nearest construction <strong>for</strong> the DTRS project will be at the Metropolitan<br />
DBS site, which is approximately 300 metres south-west of Outdoor Location 3. <strong>Helensburgh</strong><br />
BTS site is located approximately 900 metres north-east of Location 1 and <strong>Helensburgh</strong> 2 BTS<br />
site is located approximately 420 metres north-west of Location 1.Even if all the mentioned<br />
facilities were constructed simultaneously, it is not likely cumulative noise or local traffic impacts<br />
will result.<br />
Overall this work, as part of the DTRS project, will result in significant benefits by providing a<br />
more effective communications systems <strong>for</strong> the Tf<strong>NSW</strong> network. The GSM-R system is in use<br />
around the world and allows <strong>for</strong> continuous communications coverage, the capacity to make<br />
simultaneous calls and greatly improved emergency calling capabilities. Once active, the DTRS<br />
will provide a more effective communications system that will assist in the safe and efficient<br />
operation of Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s electrified rail network.<br />
Control Measures<br />
• Any other major development or works planned in the vicinity of the sites will be<br />
investigated be<strong>for</strong>e construction begins.<br />
• Consultation with Wollongong City Council and other relevant stakeholders regarding other<br />
developments will be undertaken on an ongoing basis.<br />
Page 55 of 78
4.19 Consideration of Clause 228 of EP&A Regulations and<br />
EPBC Act<br />
Clause 228 Factors<br />
Clause 228(2) of the EP&A Regulation 2000 details those factors that must be taken into<br />
account when consideration is being given to the likely impact of an activity on the environment.<br />
Table 3 provides a summary of how each of these factors has been considered.<br />
Table 3<br />
Consideration of Clause 228 Factors<br />
Clause 228 Factor Impacts Comments<br />
(a) Environmental impact on a<br />
community?<br />
-ve short-term<br />
+ve long term<br />
There will be a short-term minor negative<br />
impact during the construction phase as<br />
there may be noise, air quality, traffic<br />
and visual impacts <strong>for</strong> nearby residents<br />
and community facilities.<br />
The proposal, as part of the broader<br />
DTRS, will provide a more effective<br />
communication service and improve the<br />
safety of the rail network.<br />
(b) Trans<strong>for</strong>mation of a locality?<br />
-ve short-term<br />
-ve long-term<br />
Overall the locality would not be<br />
significantly trans<strong>for</strong>med from the current<br />
environment, as it will continue to be<br />
used <strong>for</strong> rail infrastructure.<br />
Minor short-term changes during<br />
construction phase given the presence of<br />
machinery and noise.<br />
In the long term, there will be the<br />
addition of new infrastructure to the<br />
visual landscape (monopole and masts).<br />
Visual impacts have been assessed as<br />
low.<br />
(c) Environmental impact on the<br />
ecosystems of the locality?<br />
nil<br />
With the implementation of the proposed<br />
control measures, the proposed works<br />
are not anticipated to impact on the<br />
ecosystem of the locality.<br />
Page 56 of 78
Clause 228 Factor Impacts Comments<br />
(d) Reduction of the aesthetic,<br />
recreational, scientific or other<br />
environmental quality or value<br />
of a locality?<br />
-ve short-term<br />
-ve long-term<br />
There will be a minor reduction in the<br />
aesthetic values of the neighbourhood<br />
due to the anticipated noise, air quality,<br />
traffic and visual impacts resulting during<br />
construction.<br />
In the long term, there will be the<br />
addition of new infrastructure to the<br />
visual landscape. Visual impacts have<br />
been assessed as low.<br />
(e) Effect on a locality, place or<br />
building having aesthetic,<br />
anthropological,<br />
archaeological, architectural,<br />
cultural, historical, scientific or<br />
social significance or other<br />
special value <strong>for</strong> present or<br />
future generations?<br />
nil<br />
Works will be undertaken close to Royal<br />
National Park and identified Aboriginal<br />
sites. Consultation will be undertaken<br />
with Tf<strong>NSW</strong> Environmental Officer to<br />
ensure significant places will not be<br />
affected during construction or operation.<br />
(f)<br />
Impact on the habitat of<br />
nil<br />
No habitat on which protected or<br />
protected fauna (within the<br />
endangered species would be reliant on<br />
meaning of the National Parks<br />
is anticipated to be impacted by the<br />
and Wildlife Act 1974)?<br />
proposed works.<br />
(g) Endangering of species of<br />
animal, plant or other <strong>for</strong>m of<br />
life, whether living on land, in<br />
water or in the air?<br />
nil<br />
No protected or endangered species are<br />
anticipated to be impacted by the<br />
proposed works.<br />
(h) Long-term effects on the<br />
environment?<br />
nil<br />
The proposed activities are not<br />
anticipated to pose environmental risks<br />
in the long term.<br />
(i)<br />
Degradation of the quality of<br />
nil<br />
The proposed work is not expected to<br />
the environment?<br />
have significant adverse impacts on the<br />
quality of the environment.<br />
(j) Risk to the safety of the -ve short-term During construction there is a risk to the<br />
Page 57 of 78
Clause 228 Factor Impacts Comments<br />
environment?<br />
environment due to accidental spills and<br />
sedimentation. These risks will be<br />
minimised through the implementation of<br />
the proposed control measures.<br />
(k) Reduction in the range of<br />
beneficial uses of the<br />
environment?<br />
nil<br />
Works are to take place within the<br />
existing rail corridor and would not<br />
reduce the beneficial uses of the<br />
environment. Some work may be done<br />
during scheduled track work.<br />
(l) Pollution of the environment? -ve short term During construction there is a risk of<br />
noise, water and air pollution. These<br />
risks will be minimised through the<br />
implementation of the proposed control<br />
measures.<br />
(m) Environmental problems<br />
associated with the disposal of<br />
waste?<br />
-ve<br />
short-term<br />
During construction it is possible <strong>for</strong> spoil<br />
to be contaminated and an appropriate<br />
remediation plan and/or waste disposal<br />
method will be required.<br />
(n) Increased demands on<br />
resources, natural or otherwise<br />
which are, or are likely to<br />
become in short supply?<br />
nil<br />
Construction materials are readily<br />
available and will be sourced from local<br />
contractors where possible.<br />
(o) Cumulative environmental<br />
effect with other existing or<br />
likely future activities?<br />
nil short-term<br />
+ve long-term<br />
There are no other projects proposed or<br />
ongoing in the vicinity that may result in<br />
cumulative environmental impacts.<br />
The distance between the different<br />
DTRS sites is such that cumulative<br />
noise, air quality and traffic impacts are<br />
not expected.<br />
Overall this site, as part of the DTRS<br />
project, will have significant benefits in<br />
providing a more effective<br />
communications systems <strong>for</strong> the Tf<strong>NSW</strong><br />
Page 58 of 78
Clause 228 Factor Impacts Comments<br />
network. Once active, the new DTRS will<br />
provide a safer and more efficient rail<br />
network.<br />
(p) Impact on coastal processes<br />
and coastal hazards, including<br />
those under projected climate<br />
change conditions?<br />
nil<br />
The proposed sites are not on the<br />
coastline and have not been identified as<br />
within an area that is subject to<br />
increased sea level rise.<br />
Key: -ve = Negative Impact, nil = No Impact, +ve = Positive Impact<br />
EPBC Act 1999 Factors<br />
Matters of national environmental significance must also be considered as required by the<br />
EPBC Act. These are considered in Table 4.<br />
Table 4<br />
Consideration of EPBC factors<br />
Factor (Commonwealth Legislation) Impacts Comments<br />
(a) Environmental impact on a World<br />
Heritage property?<br />
(b) Impact on the National Heritage<br />
values of a National Heritage<br />
Place?<br />
(c) Environmental impact on wetlands<br />
of international importance?<br />
No<br />
No<br />
No<br />
There are no World Heritage<br />
properties in the vicinity the sites.<br />
The Royal National Park which is<br />
listed on the National Heritage<br />
List is located proximal to the<br />
sites. However, given the nature<br />
and scale of the works as<br />
construction works will not take<br />
place within the Royal National<br />
Park, impacts to the national park<br />
are not expected.<br />
There are no wetlands of<br />
international importance in the<br />
vicinity of the sites.<br />
Page 59 of 78
Factor (Commonwealth Legislation) Impacts Comments<br />
(d) Environmental impact on<br />
Commonwealth listed threatened<br />
species or ecological<br />
communities?<br />
(e) Environmental impact on<br />
Commonwealth listed migratory<br />
species?<br />
No<br />
No<br />
The nature, scale and location of<br />
the works are such that impacts<br />
on Commonwealth listed<br />
threatened species or ecological<br />
communities or their habitats are<br />
not expected. Indirect impacts are<br />
also not expected.<br />
The nature, scale and location of<br />
the works are such that impacts<br />
on Commonwealth listed<br />
threatened species or ecological<br />
communities or their habitats are<br />
not expected. Indirect impacts are<br />
also not expected.<br />
(f)<br />
Does part of the proposal involve<br />
No<br />
The proposal does not involve<br />
a nuclear action?<br />
nuclear actions.<br />
(g) Environmental impact on a<br />
Commonwealth marine area?<br />
(h) Direct or indirect effect on<br />
Commonwealth land?<br />
No<br />
No<br />
The sites are not in the vicinity of<br />
Commonwealth marine areas.<br />
The sites are not on or close to<br />
Commonwealth land.<br />
4.20 Summary of Control Measures<br />
Land<strong>for</strong>ms, Geology and Soils<br />
All spoil will be transferred directly to skip bins or stockpiled appropriately.<br />
Appropriate stockpiling of materials will take place away from drainage lines,<br />
waterways and drains.<br />
Any soil that may be contaminated or weed infested will be stockpiled separately<br />
be<strong>for</strong>e being removed from the site.<br />
Sediment fences and bunds will be installed and inspected regularly.<br />
The tracking of soils on public roads will be prevented by using appropriate shaker<br />
grids/ballast pads.<br />
Page 60 of 78
Soil will be removed from public roads and other paved areas using dry street<br />
sweepers or other measures.<br />
Disturbed areas will be reinstated, if required.<br />
During maintenance activities, any spills will be attended to and treated in an<br />
appropriate and timely fashion in accordance with Tf<strong>NSW</strong> procedures.<br />
Water Quality and Hydrology<br />
A Water Management Plan will be prepared be<strong>for</strong>e construction begins to determine<br />
the most appropriate method <strong>for</strong> water disposal should groundwater be encountered<br />
during pile boring activities.<br />
A geological engineer will be present during the boring of the pile and work will cease<br />
immediately if groundwater is encountered. The water will be tested according to<br />
industry standards to determine the presence of contaminants or other materials. This<br />
will determine the most appropriate method of water disposal. If water is encountered,<br />
special construction methodologies will be adopted to prevent a continuing flow of<br />
groundwater to the surface.<br />
Ensure construction materials are not left in the vicinity of stormwater drains.<br />
Trenches and excavations will be covered to prevent rainwater entering.<br />
Plant and equipment will be checked regularly <strong>for</strong> oil leaks.<br />
Plant and equipment will not be refuelled on site.<br />
Wash down areas will be off site.<br />
Liquid waste generated during non-destructive excavation will be removed from thesite<br />
<strong>for</strong> treatment and disposal.<br />
Air Quality<br />
Plant and equipment will be maintained in accordance with manufacturers’<br />
specifications.<br />
Regular inspection of plant and equipment will be undertaken to ascertain that fitted<br />
emission controls are operating efficiently.<br />
Plant or machinery will not be left idling.<br />
Stockpiles will be maintained and contained appropriately, which could include<br />
covering or regular watering to minimise dust.<br />
Page 61 of 78
Minimal work will be undertaken during high wind periods.<br />
Trucks transporting spoil and other waste materials from site will be covered<br />
appropriately.<br />
Disturbed areas will be rehabilitated as soon as practicable.<br />
Biodiversity<br />
If threatened flora or fauna species are identified on site, work will stop immediately. A<br />
spotter/catcher or botanist will be engaged to survey the site, in conjunction with<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong>’s Environmental Officer, and advise on species management.<br />
No native vegetation will be removed.<br />
Root cutting will be avoided.<br />
Care will be taken to minimise the spread of weeds. Appropriate management and<br />
disposal of noxious weeds will be undertaken in consultation with Wollongong City<br />
Council, if required.<br />
The work site will be inspected <strong>for</strong> trapped or injured fauna at the start of each day.<br />
Trenches/excavations will be covered at the end of each day and inspected be<strong>for</strong>e<br />
they are backfilled to ensure that no fauna species are harmed.<br />
Ensure sediment runoff is controlled near creeks and gullies.<br />
Ensure spoil is collected as soon as work is finished.<br />
Noise and Vibration<br />
Maximise the offset distance between noise plant items and sensitive receivers<br />
Orient plant and equipment away from sensitive receivers<br />
Avoid the simultaneous operation of two or more noise plant items in close vicinity and<br />
adjacent to sensitive receivers<br />
Carry out loading and unloading away from sensitive receivers<br />
Where necessary, use structures to shield sensitive receivers from noise sources<br />
Provide periods of respite if high noise generating activities occur <strong>for</strong> extended<br />
periods.<br />
Heritage<br />
Page 62 of 78
If a non-Aboriginal historical relic is discovered, all work likely to affect it will cease and<br />
the Project Manager will be contacted. Tf<strong>NSW</strong> heritage staff and the Heritage Branch<br />
(<strong>for</strong>merly Heritage Office), <strong>NSW</strong> OEH will be notified as required. An investigation will<br />
be undertaken by a suitably qualified archaeologist to identify suitable measures to<br />
reduce the impact on the relic discovered be<strong>for</strong>e work resumes.<br />
Should Aboriginal heritage items be uncovered, all work in the vicinity will cease and<br />
the Project Manager and Tf<strong>NSW</strong> heritage staff will be notified immediately. The<br />
Manager of the Planning and Aboriginal Heritage Section, Metropolitan Branch,<br />
Environment Protection and Regulation Division, OEH will be notified in accordance<br />
with Section 89A of the National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974. The local Aboriginal<br />
Land Council will be notified and an assessment by an archaeologist will be arranged<br />
to determine the significance of the objects and other requirements be<strong>for</strong>e work<br />
resumes.<br />
Waste<br />
All waste will be classified in accordance with the Waste Classification Guidelines<br />
(DECC 2009) and transported to a place that can lawfully accept the waste.<br />
Any material that may be classified as a hazardous waste will be dealt appropriately<br />
and in accordance with Tf<strong>NSW</strong> procedures.<br />
Packaging will be minimised, where possible and where the safety and delivery of<br />
services is not compromised.<br />
Wherever possible, suitable excavated spoil will be reused on site <strong>for</strong> backfilling,<br />
landscaping and other purposes.<br />
Any spoil or waste material tracked onto roads will be swept up immediately.<br />
Adequate numbers of bins and waste containers will be placed at the site. The site<br />
manager will ensure bins are not overflowing and are appropriately covered.<br />
Wastewater generated by non-destructive excavation will be taken off site <strong>for</strong><br />
treatment and disposal.<br />
All waste will be removed from the site when work is completed.<br />
Page 63 of 78
Contaminated Land<br />
During excavation, site workers will look <strong>for</strong> signs of potential contamination such as:<br />
presence of waste and/or other imported materials, odours, soil colouring, floating<br />
layer in groundwater etc.<br />
If any contamination is encountered, or suspected, the work will be immediately stoped<br />
and the site fenced off. The site will be investigated and validated and work will only<br />
resume after approval from the Health, Safety and Environment Manager is obtained.<br />
Contaminated soil will be segregated in a special container; prior to classification and<br />
ultimate disposal.<br />
Hazardous Materials<br />
Hazardous materials will be properly classified and managed in accordance with<br />
requirements <strong>for</strong> their particular class.<br />
An evaluation of alternative materials will be undertaken be<strong>for</strong>e use of chemicals is<br />
approved.<br />
Hazardous materials will be transported, stored and used in accordance with the<br />
corresponding material safety data sheets which will be available on the site.<br />
Hazardous materials will be stored in a locked and bundled area at the site;<br />
incompatible chemicals will not be stored together.<br />
No fuels will be stored on site. Refuelling will be undertaken at off-site facilities.<br />
Adequate spill prevention, containment and response measures (e.g. drip trays) will be<br />
provided on site if needed.<br />
Construction personnel will be trained in spill containment and response procedures.<br />
All storage and handling equipment on site will be maintained properly.<br />
Visual Aesthetics and Urban Design<br />
The work area shall be maintained in an orderly manner<br />
All temporary signage associated with the works must be appropriately displayed<br />
All work equipment and materials will be contained within the designated boundaries<br />
of the work site<br />
Page 64 of 78
All waste generated during the course of the works will be removed from the work<br />
areas as soon as practicable or at the end of each work day and disposed of in<br />
accordance with the measures identified <strong>for</strong> ‘Waste’<br />
On completion of work, all vehicles, materials and refuse relating to the works will be<br />
removed and the site reinstated to the pre-work condition if not better.<br />
Land Use<br />
No specific control measures are required.<br />
Socio-Economic Effects<br />
Nearby residents and businesses will be in<strong>for</strong>med about the nature and timing of<br />
works.<br />
Signage will notify the public about the works.<br />
Appropriate fencing around the site will help maintain public safety during construction<br />
and operation.<br />
Electromagnetic Energy (EME)<br />
Appropriate signage will be placed around the site to warn people of the potential<br />
hazards.<br />
All people required to work around occupationally hazardous radio frequencies will<br />
undergo RadHaz training.<br />
Traffic and Access<br />
A Traffic Management Plan will be developed <strong>for</strong> the site.<br />
A dilapidation survey will be completed prior to construction commencing.<br />
All pavement or road surfaces damaged during construction will be restored when<br />
work is finished.<br />
The Traffic Management Plan will ensure compliance with Australian Standard<br />
AS1742.3-2002 Manual of uni<strong>for</strong>m traffic control devices – traffic control devices on<br />
roads.<br />
Consultation with the Wollongong City Council will be undertaken regarding potential<br />
issues relating to the co-utilisation of Nixon Place with users of the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> Waste<br />
Page 65 of 78
Disposal Depot <strong>for</strong> access to Outdoor Location 3.<br />
Utilities and Services<br />
Ensure that a Dial Be<strong>for</strong>e You Dig call and a services search are undertaken to identify<br />
services prior to construction commencing<br />
Consult with public utility providers to minimise impacts during any utility relocations or<br />
readjustments.<br />
Light Spill<br />
No specific control measures are required.<br />
Demand on Resources<br />
No specific control measures are required.<br />
Cumulative Environmental Effects<br />
Any other major development or works planned in the vicinity of the site will be<br />
investigated be<strong>for</strong>e construction begins.<br />
Consultation with Wollongong City Council and other relevant stakeholders regarding<br />
other developments will be undertaken on an ongoing basis.<br />
Page 66 of 78
4.21 Implementation Process<br />
The construction contractor will incorporate the mitigation and control measures in this <strong>REF</strong> into<br />
the program wide CEMP (if not already included), and the site specific ECM as appropriate. The<br />
CEMP and ECM will be the key environmental management documents followed by the Project<br />
Manager during construction and commissioning to ensure appropriate environmental<br />
management practices are implemented.<br />
A copy of this <strong>REF</strong>, the program wide CEMP and the ECM are to be retained on site and<br />
produced upon request. The CEMP and/or ECM will include:<br />
• details of environmental controls to be implemented including location and timing<br />
• details of statutory requirements including those of any approvals and licences<br />
• assignment of responsibility <strong>for</strong> implementation and monitoring of environmental controls<br />
• reporting and emergency procedures<br />
• contact details <strong>for</strong> all site personnel and agency contacts<br />
• corrective action requirements and their verification.<br />
Page 67 of 78
5 References<br />
• DECC (2009) Interim Construction Noise Guideline. Prepared by the Department of<br />
Environment and Climate Change, Sydney.<br />
• DECC (2009) Waste Classification Guidelines. Prepared by the Department of<br />
Environment, Climate Change and Water, Sydney.<br />
• DIPNR (2004) Guideline <strong>for</strong> the Preparation of Environmental Management Plans.<br />
Prepared by the Department of Infrastructure, Planning and Natural Resources, Sydney.<br />
• DoP (2010) <strong>NSW</strong> Telecommunication Facilities Guideline including Broadband. Prepared<br />
by Department of Planning, Sydney.<br />
• Landcom (2004) Managing Urban Stormwater, Soils and Construction Guidelines 4 th<br />
Edition (the Blue Book). Prepared by Landcom/Department of Housing, Sydney.<br />
• RailCorp (2012): Contaminated Land Management Procedure (EMS-09-PR-0004).<br />
• Wollongong City Council (2010) State of the Environment Report 2009/2010. Prepared by<br />
Wollongong City Council, Sydney.<br />
Page 68 of 78
Appendix 1: Principles from the Telecommunications<br />
Facilities Guidelines<br />
Principle 1: A telecommunications facility is to be designed and sited to minimise visual<br />
impact.<br />
Principle<br />
(a) As far as practical, a telecommunications<br />
facility that is to be mounted on an existing<br />
building or structure should be integrated with<br />
the design and appearance of the building or<br />
structure.<br />
(b) The visual impact of telecommunications<br />
facilities should be minimised, visual clutter is<br />
to be reduced particularly on tops of buildings,<br />
and their physical dimensions (including<br />
support mounts) should be sympathetic to the<br />
scale and height of the building to which it is to<br />
be attached, and sympathetic to adjacent<br />
buildings.<br />
(c) Where telecommunications facilities<br />
protrude from a building or structure and are<br />
predominantly backgrounded against the sky,<br />
the facility and their support mounts should be<br />
either the same as the prevailing colour of the<br />
host building or structure, or a neutral colour<br />
such as grey should be used.<br />
(d) Ancillary facilities associated with the<br />
telecommunications facility should be<br />
screened or housed, using the same colour as<br />
the prevailing background to reduce its<br />
visibility, including the use of existing<br />
vegetation where available, or new<br />
landscaping where possible and practical.<br />
Proposal<br />
The proposed work does not involve mounting<br />
antennas to an existing building or structure.<br />
The design and site selection process aimed<br />
to minimise visual impact. This has been<br />
achieved by selecting a location inside the rail<br />
corridor where there is already a level of<br />
disturbance, the presence of vertical<br />
structures as well as trees along the edge of<br />
the rail corridor. The selection of a monopole,<br />
masts and antenna mounting system that are<br />
unobtrusive with minimal visual bulk will also<br />
minimise visual impact.<br />
The proposal does not involve mounting<br />
antennas to an existing building or structure.<br />
The outdoor cabinets will be adjacent to the<br />
base of the monopole and masts. The<br />
cabinets will be less than two metres high.<br />
Page 69 of 78
Principle<br />
(e) A telecommunications facility should be<br />
located and designed to respond appropriately<br />
to its rural landscape setting.<br />
(f) A telecommunications facility located on, or<br />
adjacent to, a State or local heritage item or<br />
within a heritage conservation area, should be<br />
sited and designed with external colours,<br />
finishes and scale sympathetic to those of the<br />
heritage item or conservation area.<br />
(g) A telecommunications facility should be<br />
located so as to minimise or avoid the<br />
obstruction of a significant view of a heritage<br />
item or place, a landmark, a streetscape, vista<br />
or a panorama, whether viewed from public or<br />
private land.<br />
(h) The relevant local government authority<br />
must be consulted where the pruning, lopping,<br />
or removal of tree or other vegetation would<br />
contravene a Tree Preservation Order<br />
applying to the land or where a permit or<br />
development consent is required.<br />
(i) A telecommunications facility that is no<br />
longer required is to be removed and the site<br />
restored, to a condition that is similar to its<br />
condition be<strong>for</strong>e the facility was constructed.<br />
(j) The siting and design of<br />
telecommunications facilities should be in<br />
accordance with relevant Industry Design<br />
Guides.<br />
Proposal<br />
The proposed facilities are within a rural area<br />
but are located within areas of dense<br />
vegetation and are considered to be of low<br />
visual impact given their size.<br />
The visual elements of the proposal are not on<br />
or within a heritage item.<br />
The proposed facility will not block or<br />
significantly obstruct views of heritage items or<br />
other landmarks of state significance.<br />
The proposed monopole and masts is less<br />
than 500 millimetres wide at the top and will<br />
not have a headframe supporting the<br />
antennas. The monopole and masts will not<br />
represent dominant structures in the view lines<br />
of people occupying the residential properties<br />
in the surrounding area.<br />
No native vegetation will be removed.<br />
Should the facilities ever become redundant;<br />
the various elements will be decommissioned<br />
and removed. Following removal, the land will<br />
be restored as close as practicable to its<br />
condition be<strong>for</strong>e work began.<br />
The proposed design has been completed<br />
using “best industry practice” and complies<br />
with the relevant standards regarding<br />
structural engineering, EME and construction<br />
Page 70 of 78
Principle<br />
Proposal<br />
procedures.<br />
Principle 2: Telecommunications facilities should be co-located wherever practical.<br />
Principle<br />
(a) Telecommunications lines are to be<br />
located, as far as practical, underground or<br />
within an existing underground conduit or<br />
duct.<br />
(b) Overhead lines, antennas and ancillary<br />
telecommunications facilities should, where<br />
practical, be co-located or attached to existing<br />
structures such as buildings, public utility<br />
structures, poles, towers or other radio<br />
communications equipment to minimise the<br />
proliferation of telecommunication facilities<br />
and unnecessary clutter.<br />
(c) Towers may be extended <strong>for</strong> the purposes<br />
of co-location.<br />
(d) The extension of an existing tower must<br />
be considered as a practical co-location<br />
solution prior to building new towers.<br />
(e) If a facility is proposed not to be colocated<br />
the proponent must demonstrate that<br />
co-location is not practicable.<br />
(f) If the development is <strong>for</strong> a co-location<br />
purpose, then new telecommunications facility<br />
must be designed, installed and operated so<br />
that the resultant cumulative levels of radio<br />
frequency emissions of the co-located<br />
telecommunications facilities are within the<br />
Proposal<br />
The fibre connections <strong>for</strong> the DTRS network<br />
will be in existing conduits or in new<br />
underground conduits wherever feasible or<br />
possible.<br />
Co-location on other communications towers<br />
has been considered. No other towers were<br />
deemed appropriate or in a location to<br />
provide sufficient network coverage, as such<br />
a new monopole and masts are proposed.<br />
The proposal does not involve the use of an<br />
existing tower. The extension of existing<br />
towers in the area was considered and<br />
deemed unsuitable.<br />
The proposal does not involve the use of an<br />
existing tower; however the extension of<br />
existing towers in the area was considered<br />
and deemed unsuitable.<br />
There are no suitable communications<br />
towers in the target coverage area that would<br />
satisfy the coverage objectives as well as the<br />
network requirements of the DTRS project.<br />
Co-location is not proposed.<br />
Page 71 of 78
Principle<br />
Proposal<br />
maximum human exposure levels set out in<br />
the Radiation Protection Standard.<br />
Principle 3: Health standards <strong>for</strong> exposure to radio emissions will be met.<br />
Principle<br />
(a) A telecommunications facility must be<br />
designed, installed and operated so that the<br />
maximum human exposure levels to<br />
radiofrequency emissions comply with<br />
Radiation Protection Standard.<br />
(b) An EME Environmental Report shall be<br />
produced by the proponent of development<br />
to which the Mobile Phone Network Code<br />
applies in terms of design, siting of facilities<br />
and notifications.<br />
The Report is to be in the <strong>for</strong>mat required by<br />
the Australian Radiation Protection Nuclear<br />
Safety Agency (ARPANSA). It is to show the<br />
predicted levels of electromagnetic energy<br />
surrounding the development comply with<br />
the safety limits imposed by the Australian<br />
Communications and Media Authority and<br />
the Electromagnetic Radiation Standard, and<br />
demonstrate compliance with the Mobile<br />
Phone Networks Code.<br />
Proposal<br />
The proposed facilities will comply with the<br />
ARPANSA standard in relation to human<br />
exposure to EME. An EME report has been<br />
completed and is found at Appendix 4.<br />
This report demonstrates compliance with the<br />
ARPANSA standard <strong>for</strong> the operation of a<br />
radio communications facility in Australia.<br />
The proposal is not <strong>for</strong> a mobile phone<br />
network and is not subject to the Code <strong>for</strong> the<br />
Development of Mobile Phone Network<br />
Infrastructure commonly known as the ACIF<br />
Code.<br />
An EME report has been completed and is<br />
found at Appendix 4.<br />
Principle 4: Minimise disturbance and risk, and maximise compliance<br />
Principle<br />
(a) The siting and height of<br />
telecommunications facility must comply with<br />
relevant site and height requirements specified<br />
by the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 and the<br />
Airports (Protection of Airspace) Regulations<br />
Proposal<br />
The provisions of the Civil Aviation<br />
Regulations 1988 and the Airports (Protection<br />
of Airspace) Regulations 1996 were<br />
considered during the design and siting<br />
process. There is no need <strong>for</strong> the installation<br />
Page 72 of 78
Principle<br />
1996 of the Commonwealth. It must not<br />
penetrate obstacle limitation surface shown on<br />
relevant Obstacle Limitation Surface Plan that<br />
has been prepared by the operator of an<br />
aerodrome or airport operating within 30<br />
kilometres of the proposed development and<br />
reported to the Civil Aviation Safety Authority<br />
Australia.<br />
(b) The telecommunications facility is not to<br />
cause adverse radio frequency interference<br />
with airport, port or Commonwealth Defence<br />
navigational or communications equipment,<br />
including the Morundah Communication<br />
Facility, Riverina.<br />
(c) The telecommunications facility and<br />
ancillary facilities are to be carried out in<br />
accordance with the applicable specifications<br />
of the manufacturers <strong>for</strong> the installation of<br />
such equipment.<br />
(d) The telecommunications facility is not to<br />
affect the structural integrity of building on<br />
which it is erected.<br />
(e) The telecommunications facility is to be<br />
erected wholly within the boundaries of a<br />
property where the landowner has agreed to<br />
the facility being located on the land.<br />
(f) The carrying out of construction of the<br />
telecommunications facilities must be in<br />
accordance with all relevant regulations of the<br />
Blue Book – ‘Managing Urban Storm water:<br />
Soils and Construction’ (DECC 2008), or its<br />
replacement.<br />
(g) Obstruction or risks to pedestrians or<br />
vehicles caused by the location of the facility,<br />
construction activity or materials used in<br />
Proposal<br />
of a warning light or aircraft navigation light, as<br />
the proposal does not penetrate the Obstacle<br />
Limitation Surface.<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong> will operate the radio facilities with its<br />
own spectrum and the facilities will not cause<br />
interference with other networks. All radio<br />
transmitters will use the frequency assigned to<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong> <strong>for</strong> the exclusive use of Tf<strong>NSW</strong>.<br />
The installation and operation of the radio<br />
equipment and antennas will be carried out in<br />
accordance with the manufacturers’<br />
specifications.<br />
The proposed facilities will not be connected<br />
to existing buildings.<br />
The proposed facilities will be inside the rail<br />
corridor that is owned and used by Tf<strong>NSW</strong>.<br />
Tf<strong>NSW</strong> is the proponent of the network and<br />
agrees to the use of the land <strong>for</strong> the proposed<br />
radio equipment.<br />
The activities associated with construction and<br />
installation will be done in accordance with<br />
sediment controls, erosion controls,<br />
stormwater controls and other controls<br />
outlined in the Blue Book (refer Section 4.1).<br />
Construction activities will take place in the rail<br />
corridor and changes to traffic and access are<br />
Page 73 of 78
Principle<br />
construction are to be mitigated.<br />
Proposal<br />
not expected.<br />
Traffic changes will be implemented in<br />
accordance with an approved Traffic<br />
Management Plan.<br />
There will be no risks to traffic or pedestrians<br />
during the operation of the proposal.<br />
(h) Where practical, work is to be carried out<br />
during times that cause minimum disruption to<br />
adjoining properties and public access. Hours<br />
of work are to be restricted to between 7:00am<br />
to 6:00pm, Mondays to Fridays, 8:00am to<br />
1:00pm Saturdays, with no work on Sundays<br />
and public holidays.<br />
Work associated with the development and<br />
installation of the DBS site will occur between<br />
7:00am to 6:00pm, Mondays to Fridays and<br />
8:00am to 1:00pm Saturdays, with no work on<br />
Sundays and public holidays. Additionally,<br />
scheduled track possession will be undertaken<br />
from 6am Saturday 6 July 2013 to 6pm<br />
Sunday 7 July 2013 <strong>for</strong> the installation of the<br />
Leaky feeder cables to provide coverage<br />
within the <strong>Helensburgh</strong> tunnel.<br />
(i) Traffic control measures are to be taken<br />
during construction in accordance with<br />
Australian Standard AS1742.3-2002 Manual of<br />
uni<strong>for</strong>m traffic control devices – Traffic control<br />
devices on roads.<br />
(j) Open trenching should be guarded in<br />
accordance with Australian Standard Section<br />
93.080 – Road Engineering AS1165 – 1982 –<br />
Traffic hazard warning lamps.<br />
(k) Disturbance to flora and fauna should be<br />
minimised and the land is to be restored to a<br />
condition that is similar to its condition be<strong>for</strong>e<br />
the work was carried out.<br />
(l) The likelihood of impacting on threatened<br />
species and communities should be identified<br />
A Traffic Management Plan will be developed<br />
and implemented during construction and<br />
installation activities. The procedures and<br />
mitigation measures in the plan will ensure<br />
compliance with Australian Standard<br />
AS1742.3-2002 Manual of uni<strong>for</strong>m traffic<br />
control devices – Traffic control devices on<br />
roads (Refer Section 4.14).<br />
There will be no open trenches outside the rail<br />
corridor and all trenches will be covered or<br />
filled so that they are not open overnight.<br />
No native vegetation will be removed. The<br />
land will be reinstated to its original condition<br />
prior to construction.<br />
The proposed activities do not require the<br />
removal of native vegetation. A search of<br />
Page 74 of 78
Principle<br />
in consultation with relevant state or local<br />
government authorities and disturbance to<br />
identified species and communities avoided<br />
wherever possible.<br />
(m) The likelihood of harming an Aboriginal<br />
Place and / or Aboriginal object should be<br />
identified. Approvals from the Office of<br />
Environment & Heritage (OEH) must be<br />
obtained where impact is likely, or Aboriginal<br />
objects are found.<br />
Proposal<br />
threatened species has been completed (refer<br />
Appendix 3) and there is not expected to be<br />
significant impact on threatened species.<br />
A search of the AHIMS has been completed<br />
and has identified items or places of<br />
archaeological significance within 200 metres<br />
of Outdoor Site 2 (refer Appendix 3) however<br />
impacts to these items are not expected as<br />
they are located in excess of 50 metres away.<br />
If suspicious items or objects are found during<br />
excavation, work will cease immediately and<br />
the OEH will be consulted and works will not<br />
re-commence until OEH have granted their<br />
consent.<br />
(n) Street furniture, paving or other existing<br />
facilities removed or damaged during<br />
construction should be reinstated (at the<br />
telecommunications carrier’s expense) to at<br />
least the same condition as that which existed<br />
prior to the telecommunications facility being<br />
installed.<br />
All street furniture, paving and walkways will<br />
be reinstated at the end of construction to at<br />
least the same condition they were in be<strong>for</strong>e<br />
work began.<br />
Page 75 of 78
Appendix 2: Design Plans<br />
DTRS-D-033-BS-0003: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Outdoor Design – Rail Corridor Site Layout<br />
Plan Location 1<br />
DTRS-D-033-BS-0007: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Outdoor Design – Rail Corridor Site Layout<br />
Plan Location 2<br />
DTRS-D-033-BS-0011: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Outdoor Design – Rail Corridor Site Layout<br />
Plan Location 3DTRS-D-033-BS-0004: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Outdoor Design – Rail Corridor<br />
Set out Design Location 1<br />
DTRS-D-033-BS-0008: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Outdoor Design – Rail Corridor Set out<br />
Design Location 2<br />
DTRS-D-033-BS-0012: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Outdoor Design – Rail Corridor Set out<br />
Design Location 3<br />
DTRS-D-033-BS-0005: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Outdoor Design – Rail Corridor DBS Elevation<br />
and Antenna Table<br />
DTRS-D-033-BS-0005: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Outdoor Design – Rail Corridor DBS Elevation<br />
and Antenna Table Location 1<br />
DTRS-D-033-BS-0009: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Outdoor Design – Rail Corridor DBS Elevation<br />
and Antenna Table Location 2<br />
DTRS-D-033-BS-0013: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Outdoor Design – Rail Corridor DBS Elevation<br />
and Antenna Table Location 3<br />
DTRS-D-033-TR-0001: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Transmission Diagram<br />
DTRS-D-033-BS-0036: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Earthing Diagram.<br />
Page 76 of 78
Appendix 3: Database Searches<br />
Extracts from the <strong>NSW</strong> Wildlife Atlas<br />
Flora<br />
Fauna<br />
Section 170: RailCorp Heritage Register – Items in <strong>Helensburgh</strong><br />
<strong>NSW</strong> Heritage Register<br />
Australian Heritage Database<br />
EPBC Act 1999 Protected Matters Report<br />
Page 77 of 78
Appendix 4: Electro- Magnetic Energy (EME) Reports<br />
Refer to attached:<br />
DTRS-R-033-EM-0001: <strong>Helensburgh</strong> <strong>Tunnel</strong> Electro-Magnetic Energy Report<br />
(APRANSA REPORT)<br />
Page 78 of 78