RANS SCAN - Western Australian Planning Commission - The ...
RANS SCAN - Western Australian Planning Commission - The ...
RANS SCAN - Western Australian Planning Commission - The ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
T<strong>RANS</strong> <strong>SCAN</strong><br />
TA global scan of emerging trends in mobility and the built environment<br />
Volume 11 Number 1 September 2010<br />
<strong>RANS</strong> <strong>SCAN</strong><br />
Cover illustration by Wind Power Ltd<br />
Could machines like this reshape<br />
what happens on the roads?<br />
IF transport is switched to electricity for its main<br />
source of power then machines like this could be<br />
the generators. <strong>The</strong> artist’s impression shows the<br />
latest advance in offshore wind turbines - the Aerogenerator<br />
X. It has been developed over the last 18<br />
months by a consortium of UK research organizations<br />
with backing by Rolls Royce, the Arup engineering<br />
group and major oil companies. Its main proponent,<br />
Wind Power Ltd*, is hoping to have the first 10MW<br />
prototype in operation by 2013. An earlier version<br />
was shown in TransScan in April 2008 but as the new<br />
picture shows, the Aerogenerator has undergone a radical<br />
makeover - particularly in the shape of its muchsimplified<br />
blades. <strong>The</strong> idea is not to present a sleeker<br />
looking turbine. <strong>The</strong> main purpose of the horizontal<br />
axis is overcome both high cost and fatigue problems<br />
of operating conventional upright turbines in a rigorous<br />
deep-sea environment.<br />
Read more about trends in mobility on pages 16 to 19<br />
* <br />
<strong>The</strong> big shift to ‘green’ building is not only environmental: Pages 3-9<br />
Department of <strong>Planning</strong><br />
Main Roads <strong>Western</strong> Australia,<br />
and Department of Transport<br />
T<strong>RANS</strong> <strong>SCAN</strong> is prepared quarterly<br />
by Strategic Scan and two agencies<br />
of the <strong>Western</strong> <strong>Australian</strong> Government
Volume 11 • Number 1 • September 2010<br />
ISSN 1440 - 8996<br />
T <strong>RANS</strong> <strong>SCAN</strong><br />
A global scan of emerging trends in mobility<br />
and the built environment<br />
Website: <br />
TransScan is an initiative of the<br />
Department of <strong>Planning</strong>, Main Roads WA<br />
and Department of Transport<br />
and is produced by<br />
Strategic Scan<br />
PO Box 1484<br />
Victoria Park East<br />
Perth, <strong>Western</strong> Australia 6981<br />
Tel/Fax: (08) 9362 6248<br />
Email: scanasia@highway1.com.au<br />
For information about distribution, please contact:<br />
<br />
TransScan is available in alternative formats to assist people<br />
who are unable to read this version.Initial<br />
requests should be made to<br />
Strategic Scan (Tel: 08 9362 6248)<br />
Editorial Committee:<br />
Chairman<br />
John Chortis, Department of <strong>Planning</strong><br />
Tel: 9264 7777<br />
<br />
Members<br />
Dr Fiona McKenzie,<br />
Housing and Urban Research Institute WA<br />
Tel: 9266 1087<br />
<br />
Dr Joseph Patroni, Department of Commerce<br />
Tel: 9222 3333<br />
<br />
Kathryn Martin, Main Roads WA<br />
Tel: 9323 4246<br />
<br />
George Brown, Department of <strong>Planning</strong><br />
Tel: 9216 8486<br />
<br />
Des Lock, Main Roads WA<br />
Tel: 9323 4185<br />
<br />
Peter Terry, Strategic Scan<br />
Tel: 9362 6248 <br />
Disclaimer<br />
Strategic Scan takes all reasonable care in the preparation of this<br />
document which represents the results of scanning and analysis<br />
over the past three months from sources listed within, but accepts<br />
no responsibility for any loss which may be sustained by any person<br />
or organisation that relies on information in this document.<br />
Contents<br />
TransScan reports a variety of views. None are<br />
necessarily those of the publishers.<br />
Overview:<br />
• An offshore machine that could reshape<br />
what happens on the roads 1<br />
Trends in green construction 3-9<br />
• Nolonger just ‘dumb designs and<br />
smart gadgets’ 3-9<br />
• How Perth plans to set new green standards 4<br />
• Power - with a mythical touch of Narnia 5<br />
• Is Australia home to the world’s greenest<br />
office building? 7<br />
Safety & health 10-12<br />
• Glasses that decide if you are fit to drive 10<br />
• Britain ‘experiments’ with a<br />
speed camera turn-off 10<br />
• Can technology eliminate ‘physical’<br />
road barriers? 11<br />
• Resilience & recovery 12-15<br />
• Finding better ways to manage disaster 12-15<br />
• Victoria’s bushfire report 13-14<br />
• No-go development zones? 14<br />
EVENTS up-date 15<br />
Trends in mobility 16-19<br />
• Is LNG the awy to keep freight moving? 16-17<br />
• Germany developing a new green transit 17<br />
T<strong>RANS</strong>Net - Internet update 19<br />
Advances in remote sensing 20<br />
• How radar imigery is offering<br />
new ways to track events 20<br />
About TransScan<br />
TransScan monitors change world-wide and is based<br />
on analysis of information scanned by staff of the<br />
Department of <strong>Planning</strong>, Main Roads WA, the Department<br />
of Transport, the Department of Commerce<br />
and the research organisation, Strategic Scan. <strong>The</strong><br />
aim is to stimulate the informed discussion necessary<br />
for the agencies to operate more effectively in a<br />
period of rapid change. <strong>The</strong> subject matter will often challenge<br />
assumptions. At the same time it seeks to familiarise<br />
readers with an ever-changing environment. It is not<br />
possible to predict tomorrow, but it is possible to make<br />
calculated assessments about the future. Fundamental to<br />
this approach is the recognition that the future is here now.<br />
When decisions are made on what is thought the future will<br />
bring, those decisions help shape that future. Information<br />
which appears in TransScan does not represent definitive<br />
research. <strong>The</strong> contents are the result of a scan made in<br />
the past few months. On an ongoing basis, such scans will<br />
expose ever more new and emerging themes.
Heat in the city<br />
TransScan 3<br />
Infrared image by Fraunhofer IMS<br />
Trends in green construction<br />
THE decision to build a new $2.6 billion urban precinct on Perth’s<br />
river foreshore will introduce to the city an unprecedented level of<br />
“green” office and “green” housing design. (See page 4) Here in the<br />
first of a two-part series*, guest writer Oenone Rooksby reviews the<br />
broader trends in going green - and finds the benefits are more than<br />
environmental.<br />
Nolonger just ‘dumb designs<br />
and smart gadgets’<br />
THE building sector is an<br />
extraordinary consumer<br />
of resources. According<br />
to the Green Building Council<br />
of Australia, it uses 40% of the<br />
world’s energy, 32% of its resources,<br />
generates 40% of landfill<br />
and emits 40% of all greenhouse<br />
gases. But change is happening<br />
- and rapidly. Internationally, the<br />
* <strong>The</strong> next edition of TransScan<br />
will look at ways architects are<br />
going beyond “saving energy”<br />
to make buildings greener.<br />
green building market is expected<br />
to expand from $US12 billion in<br />
2008 to $US60 billion in 2010(1)<br />
and close to 30% of the new<br />
buildings in the Asia Pacific are<br />
expected to be green by 2015.(2)<br />
One of the “greenest” ever built<br />
is already in operation in Australia<br />
(see page 7) and is helping to<br />
demonstrate that such commercial<br />
buildings are a significant<br />
and cost effective way to achieve<br />
greenhouse gas reductions using<br />
existing technologies.(3)<br />
In <strong>Western</strong> Australia,<br />
Continued next page<br />
A full-colour<br />
look at city<br />
temperature<br />
NEW ways of seeing<br />
what makes cities<br />
hot - through the<br />
lens of a new infrared camera<br />
developed in Germany.<br />
Until now such cameras<br />
were primarily for military<br />
use but the Fraunhofer<br />
Institute for Microelectronic<br />
Circuits and Systems in Duisburg*<br />
has just developed<br />
one that could open up a<br />
range of civilian applications.<br />
Initially the aim was<br />
to use it to improve motorists’<br />
night vision. But in refining<br />
the technology, other<br />
uses are emerging - like<br />
pinpointing hot spots in fires<br />
and helping find fire victims.<br />
As the image above shows,<br />
it can also identify hotspots<br />
in the streetscape.<br />
*
4<br />
TransScan<br />
Trends in green construction<br />
Above and below artist’s impressions of “Waterbank” courtesy of EPRA.<br />
How Perth plans to set<br />
new green standards<br />
A<br />
SERIES of major regeneration projects planned for Perth<br />
will not just transform the city’s appearance but place it at<br />
the forefront of green design. All the projects require high<br />
environmental standards and developers bidding for the latest section<br />
of regeneration, “Waterbank” pictured above and below, will<br />
have to meet either 5 or 6 Star standards on the Green Star rating<br />
table. <strong>The</strong> Green Building Council of Australia (a) which administers<br />
the rating system describes 6 Star as signifying “world leadership”<br />
in environmentally sustainable design and/or construction”.<br />
Tony Morgan, CEO of the East Perth Redevelopment Authority (b),<br />
the government agency administering the projects told TransScan<br />
that the authority adopted a green building design policy in 2009 and<br />
green designs were now needed for all EPRA redevelopment areas.<br />
“A minimum 6 Green Star rating is required for Waterbank’s landmark<br />
30-storey building, which is likely to include both residential<br />
and commercial developments,” he said. “A minimum 5 Green Star<br />
rating is required for the remaining buildings which are also mixed<br />
use and range from 3-20 stories.” Currently EPRA has more than 53<br />
hectares of regeneration projects in preparation within Perth’s inner<br />
city area and most are designed for a minimum 5 Star Green rating.<br />
“When completed they will significantly boost the stock of environmentally<br />
sustainable buildings in WA,” Mr Morgan said.<br />
(a) Green Building Council of Australia <br />
(b) EPRA <br />
Continued from previous page<br />
the new foreshore development<br />
planned for East Perth will also<br />
place new focus on the benefits of<br />
green design. (See story left.)<br />
Around the world, the last<br />
few years has seen all sections of<br />
the green building industry refine<br />
products and add innovation to<br />
the design process. Many of the<br />
trends relate to one of two overarching<br />
themes. Firstly, there is<br />
the increasingly common catch<br />
cry of the “low hanging fruit”,<br />
which many argue has been overlooked<br />
and is potentially going<br />
to waste, rotting on the vine so<br />
to say. Secondly, there is a sense<br />
that many in the industry are upping<br />
the ante, questioning the<br />
very concept of what constitutes<br />
green building, both in relation to<br />
standards and scope.<br />
Cheaper technologies<br />
In the case of “low hanging<br />
fruit” much of the focus has<br />
been on encouraging and enabling<br />
stakeholders to make use of<br />
existing and cheaper techniques,<br />
resources and technologies.<br />
Firstly there appears to<br />
have been a backlash against<br />
what one architect, Lance Hosey<br />
describes as “dumb design with<br />
smart gadgets”. His article “Sustainable<br />
design is more than bells<br />
and whistles”(4), is one of many<br />
that argues for getting back to<br />
basics and employ passive techniques<br />
to their full potential before<br />
turning to technology.(5)<br />
More retrofits<br />
Secondly, there has been<br />
a greater focus on green retrofits<br />
and renovations over new green<br />
construction. A recent report predicts<br />
that the retrofit market will<br />
account for 20 to 30% of all commercial<br />
projects by 2014.(6) In<br />
Australia, this year’s RMIT Green<br />
Building and Design Conference<br />
is entitled “Greening the existing<br />
building stock”(7), while the City<br />
of Melbourne has announced it<br />
intends to retrofit two thirds of its<br />
Continued page 6
TransScan 5<br />
Trends in green construction<br />
Illustration by Heatherwick Studio<br />
SOON to dominate the old industrial banks of England’s River Tees, a power station shapped like a mystical castle.<br />
Power - with a mythical touch of Narnia<br />
POWER stations don’t<br />
have to be ugly. <strong>The</strong> one<br />
pictured here - just given<br />
planning approval by the town of<br />
Stockton-on-Tees in England’s<br />
northeast - is described by <strong>The</strong><br />
Independent’s architecture correspondent<br />
Jay Merrick as “taking<br />
British power stations into the<br />
Bilbao Guggenheim league of<br />
architectural icons”. (a)<br />
When operational in<br />
2013, the new 49 MW sustainable<br />
biomass themal power generator<br />
could become an icon for<br />
clean energy too. (b) Its proponents,<br />
Bio Energy Investments<br />
Ltd, say it will produce enough<br />
electricity to power more than<br />
50,000 homes and do so with carbon<br />
emissions at 80% less than a<br />
conventional coal-fired station.<br />
Nonetheless, the chosen<br />
fuel will have a long way to<br />
travel. It is being shipped from<br />
Malaysia - thousands of tonnes of<br />
pine kernel shells left over from<br />
palm oil production. <strong>The</strong> shells<br />
will be carried up the River Tees<br />
directly by ship to what is today a<br />
flat, overgrown, brownfields site.<br />
According to BEI the visual appearance<br />
of the power station has<br />
been the driving force in the design.<br />
<strong>The</strong> company says it wants<br />
to create a “truly modern and<br />
exemplar building, which will<br />
challenge the way that power stations<br />
are currently designed and<br />
built when viewed from an urban<br />
area.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> architects, Heatherwick<br />
Studio (c), is the same<br />
company that design the UK<br />
Pavilion for the Shanghai Expo<br />
and London’s remarkable “Rolling<br />
Bridge” - an award-winning<br />
footbridge that with the help of<br />
an hydraulic jack, curls into an<br />
octagonal to let canal craft go by.<br />
At Teeside, Heatherwick has designed<br />
the new power station so<br />
that all its operating<br />
equipment is enclosed<br />
behind an earth mound<br />
stretching up to 12<br />
metres high. (See diagram<br />
right) <strong>The</strong> effect<br />
is not unlike a castle<br />
of Narnia - minus the<br />
odd mountain. But<br />
rather than provide<br />
an instant filmset, the<br />
benefit is to keep noise<br />
to a minimum - and<br />
create a green iconic<br />
landmark. <strong>The</strong> power<br />
station will occupy<br />
Illustration by<br />
Heatherwick Studio<br />
just a third of the four hectare site.<br />
<strong>The</strong> plan is to cover the remainder<br />
with grassland and eventually<br />
the flora and fauna that used to be<br />
there before industry arrived.<br />
(a) “Station to station: the new power<br />
generation” by Jay Merrick <strong>The</strong> Independent<br />
5 Aug 2010 <br />
(b) “Innovative design for a new age in<br />
power” briefing paper by Bio Energy<br />
Investments Ltd (BEI) March 2010<br />
<br />
(c) Heatherwick Studio website
6<br />
TransScan<br />
Trends in green<br />
construction<br />
Continued from page 4<br />
Photo by BWTC<br />
WIND turbines straddle the<br />
50-floor twin towers of the<br />
Bahrain World Trade<br />
Center.* When built in 2008,<br />
the skyscraper was the first in<br />
the world to integrate wind<br />
turbines into its design. On an<br />
average day, the three turbines<br />
operate for about 12 hours<br />
generating enough power to<br />
meet up to 15% of the building’s<br />
annual electricity needs.<br />
* <br />
existing building stock in a large<br />
scale sustainability initiative.(8)<br />
For the most part green<br />
retrofitting involves fairly mundane<br />
alterations. Commonly<br />
these include installing more efficient<br />
lighting and water fixtures,<br />
updating HVAC (Heating, Ventilating,<br />
and Air Conditioning)<br />
systems, increasing insulation<br />
and adding external sun shading<br />
devices.<br />
In many ways the retrofitting<br />
trend is borne of necessity.<br />
<strong>The</strong> global financial crisis forced<br />
many property developers to defer<br />
or cancel new projects and<br />
turn instead to retrofits that cost<br />
significantly less and have much<br />
shorter payback periods.<br />
But the benefits can be<br />
considerable. For example, many<br />
argue that because of the embodied<br />
energy within existing structures,<br />
such retrofits on average<br />
reduce energy consumption by<br />
30% and can easily reduce it by<br />
more than 50%. Consequently,<br />
the potentially positive environmental<br />
impact of green retrofitting<br />
far outweighs that of new<br />
green construction.(9)<br />
New focus on operation<br />
This increased focus on<br />
the existing building stock has<br />
brought with it a concern for the<br />
efficiency of the building in operation,<br />
as opposed to its efficiency<br />
as designed or as constructed.<br />
From November this<br />
year, all commercial offices in<br />
Australia over 2000sqm will have<br />
to disclose a National <strong>Australian</strong><br />
Built Environment Rating System<br />
(NABERS)(10) report upon<br />
sale or lease.(11) <strong>The</strong>se regulations<br />
are designed to encourage<br />
not only green retrofitting, but<br />
also the more regular recommissioning<br />
of the wider building<br />
stock.<br />
Last year New York<br />
passed a new bill that every ten<br />
years requires owners of largescale<br />
properties to conduct energy<br />
efficiency audits and have their<br />
buildings retro-commissioned<br />
and recalibrated to as-designed<br />
performance levels.<br />
More and more building<br />
operators are avoiding the need<br />
for such isolated but large scale<br />
commissioning by employing<br />
increasingly advanced Building<br />
Management Systems (BMS)<br />
that combine hard and soft ware<br />
technology to monitor and adjust<br />
their facilities’ operations and<br />
services. (12)<br />
Programs such as the<br />
Mediator by Cisco Systems and<br />
BuildingIQ Energy Management<br />
System by CSIRO use sensors<br />
and meters to illustrate operations<br />
in real time, integrate numerous<br />
service platforms and interact<br />
with and respond to the demands<br />
of facility managers and even everyday<br />
occupants. As such, they<br />
can not only pinpoint and alert<br />
building managers to potential<br />
technological problems as they<br />
occur, they can also record, display,<br />
analyse and respond to resource<br />
consumption levels in relation<br />
to season, occupancy rates<br />
and declared levels of comfort,<br />
business productivity and output,<br />
and floors or even tenancies. According<br />
to recent research, water<br />
and energy consumption can be<br />
reduced by 30-40% once usage<br />
patterns are understood.(13)<br />
Such systems are meant<br />
to ensure that not only does the<br />
building operate as intended but<br />
also that the occupant uses the<br />
building as it was intended.<br />
Differences in practice<br />
Recently, a report by the<br />
US Green Building Council (US-<br />
GBC) found a difference of more<br />
than 100% between what architects<br />
and engineers had originally<br />
calculated would be the energy<br />
consumption of a building and<br />
its actual post-occupancy energy<br />
usage one year after construction.<br />
(14)<br />
Many explain the discrepancy<br />
as being due to the unpredictable<br />
and inefficient behaviour<br />
of the building’s occupant.<br />
As a result, greater focus is now<br />
being given to understanding and<br />
integrating the needs, desires,<br />
idiosyncrasies and weaknesses of<br />
building users.<br />
Other organisations like<br />
the Green Building Council of<br />
Australia (GBCA) believe that<br />
the emphasis should be on education<br />
and behaviour modification<br />
rather than automation. It wants to<br />
see the use of real time, itemised<br />
and public display of consump-<br />
Continued next page
TransScan 7<br />
Continued from previous page<br />
tion levels in relation to targets<br />
and the performance of others as<br />
a tool for education and the instigation<br />
of cultural change.(15)<br />
Such thinking informs<br />
the University of Adelaide’s new<br />
development, Innova 21. It is the<br />
first educational building to be<br />
awarded 6 stars and the designers<br />
have deliberately made all its<br />
BMS data available to students<br />
and the public so that it provides<br />
an ongoing onsite educational<br />
example of environmental practices.(16)<br />
All this indicates that the<br />
computer simulated modelling of<br />
buildings, via cross platform software<br />
like Autodesk’s Revit, has<br />
not yet fully integrated occupant<br />
related data, such as visual and<br />
thermal “comfortmetrics”, into its<br />
environmental assessments. Nevertheless,<br />
such software is enabling<br />
a more integrated, holistic<br />
approach to building design, construction<br />
and maintenance. Better<br />
and earlier communication and<br />
coordination between the various<br />
“teams” involved in a building<br />
over its lifetime, design, service,<br />
structural, construction, facility<br />
management etc. was found by a<br />
recent study to be essential to a<br />
successful green outcome.<br />
No more oversizing?<br />
One common example of<br />
this is the avoidance of the types<br />
of “rule-of thumb” assumptions<br />
that encourage oversizing, which<br />
has led to the creation of HVAC<br />
equipment that is 15-25% larger<br />
than needed in over 70% of building<br />
stock. This is enabled by cross<br />
platform communication between<br />
not only the design, services and<br />
structural teams, but also by facility<br />
managers, who can provide<br />
essential data on a building’s energy<br />
usage patterns.(17)<br />
This is altering the contractual<br />
arrangements of the industry.<br />
<strong>The</strong> design build model<br />
is becoming increasingly popular<br />
Continued next page<br />
Trends in green construction<br />
<strong>The</strong> Pixel building - photo by Grocon <br />
Is Australia home to the world’s<br />
greenest office building?<br />
EVERSINCE Melbourne’s Pixel building opened in July, a<br />
steady stream of government and property representatives<br />
have been visiting to find out how it works. “For us its an<br />
exemplar,” says Jane Wilson of property developer, Grocon. “It<br />
could be scaled up into a much bigger building and achieve similar<br />
results.”<br />
In the next few months it will be known for certain whether the<br />
extraordinary carbon neutral office building on Swanston Street is<br />
the “greenest” of its type in the world. It has already collected a 6<br />
Green Star rating with the highest score ever awarded by the Green<br />
Building Council of Australia and by the end of the year it will have<br />
been assessed under similar US and UK rating systems to see if it<br />
can exceed the highest scores yet given internationally. (a)<br />
Under the <strong>Australian</strong> 6 Star rating, Pixel actually achieved<br />
an unprecedented perfect score of 100 point - five of them being<br />
for innovation and equating to “world leadership”. Pixel is now<br />
the project office for Grocon’s $1 billion redevelopment of the old<br />
Carlton Brewery site. <strong>The</strong> architects were Studio 505 who worked<br />
with sustainability consultants, Umow Lai* who advised on the engineering<br />
and energy saving systems. <strong>The</strong> four-storey building cost<br />
$6 million and any carbon emissions it produces are offset by the<br />
clean energy generated by the photovoltaic panels and wind turbines<br />
installed on the roof.<br />
* Interestingly Umow Lai has just fitted out its own office interior to a 6 Star<br />
level and has reported a big improvement in staff productivity. <strong>The</strong> company had<br />
the improvement measured by independent assessors who calculated productivity<br />
had risen by 13%. <br />
(a) “Pixel Gains Highest Green Star Score Ever” Grocon media statement 20 July<br />
2010
8<br />
TransScan<br />
Trends in green construction<br />
Continued from previous page<br />
and is being even taken further<br />
with the increasingly cooperative<br />
stance of the insurance, finance,<br />
development and real estate sectors<br />
towards the green building<br />
industry, a development no doubt<br />
encouraged by the reassurance of<br />
a green outcome given by BIM.<br />
A recent example of<br />
this integration is “<strong>The</strong> Gauge”<br />
in Melbourne. According to the<br />
Green Building Council of Australia,<br />
this project by Lend Lease<br />
has effectively utilised its “cross<br />
business synergies”, to not only<br />
create a six star design, but also<br />
to prove the financial case for<br />
green building.(18)<br />
Integration within the<br />
green building industry is also occurring<br />
on a larger scale, amongst<br />
NGOs and between them and regulatory<br />
bodies. <strong>The</strong> advent of the<br />
World Green Building Council<br />
(WGBC) and the development of<br />
regional committees such as that<br />
of the Asia Pacific(19) indicate<br />
an increasingly global approach<br />
to green building, encouraging<br />
the sharing of information and<br />
resources especially between developing<br />
and developed nations.<br />
Similarly although the<br />
world’s major rating systems<br />
- Britain’s BREEAM (Building<br />
Research Establishment Environmental<br />
Assessment Method) and<br />
the US LEED (Leadership in Energy<br />
& Environmental Design)<br />
- all have different standards and<br />
definitions for green buildings<br />
they have recently signed a MOU<br />
to create a common carbon metric.(20)<br />
Perhaps it is such cooperation<br />
that is giving advocates the<br />
courage and resources to raise the<br />
bar for the industry.<br />
Defining ‘green’<br />
Today there is also increased<br />
scrutiny on what really<br />
constitutes green building. <strong>The</strong>re<br />
has been a move away from the<br />
current model of “doing less<br />
harm” particularly in energy use<br />
and towards a model of “neutrality”<br />
that strives for net zero emissions<br />
and consumption.<br />
Pixel, in Melbourne is<br />
an example of this model.(21)<br />
(see page 3) More radically has<br />
been the move towards a “regenerative”<br />
model of green design.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se are called “Living Buildings”<br />
and such structures are not<br />
only designed to “do no harm”<br />
but they also actively and positively<br />
contribute to their environment.(22)<br />
<strong>The</strong> Oregon Sustainability<br />
Center is considered one of<br />
the first of this type of “living”<br />
office buildings.<br />
Energy has always been<br />
a primary concern of green designs<br />
and in co- and tri-generation<br />
systems increasing use is being<br />
made of “wasted” energy to<br />
provide power for both heating<br />
and cooling, and operating at efficiencies<br />
of up to 90%.(23)<br />
But as mentioned, there<br />
is also a focus on creating energy<br />
rather than reducing it. Renewable<br />
sources are increasingly popular<br />
and solar power continues to<br />
dominate the market.<br />
Largely because of nanotechnology,<br />
photovoltaics are<br />
becoming ever more efficient and<br />
flexible. Products such as Solar-<br />
Continued next page<br />
A solution to ‘instant greening’ is out of the bag<br />
RETROFITTING existing buildings<br />
with roof gardens could do much to<br />
reduce the “heat dome” effect of cities.<br />
In London, for example, there is no less<br />
than 24,000 ha of roofs ripe for greening<br />
- which is where “Pocket Habitat”* comes<br />
in. <strong>The</strong> new product (left) is especially designed<br />
for a roof retrofit.<br />
<strong>The</strong> makers describe their “pockets”<br />
as “stand-alone units made from environmentally<br />
friendly material and containing<br />
recycled substrates and wildflower seeds”.<br />
But customers can specify what plants they<br />
would prefer and can even turn their roofs<br />
into vegetable patches. <strong>The</strong> UK marketers<br />
- Arup and Sky-Gardens - say the size and<br />
weight of the “pockets” allows installation<br />
without cranes or specialist equipment.<br />
Photo by Arup<br />
*
Continued from previous page<br />
Ivy are even turning photovoltaics<br />
into architectural features<br />
to be displayed on walls rather<br />
than hidden on roofs.(24) <strong>The</strong>y<br />
are also being further integrated<br />
into the construction process<br />
with photovoltaics emerging as<br />
roof shingles, tiles and windowpanes.<br />
<strong>The</strong> international market<br />
for wind power grew 10% last<br />
year despite the hard economic<br />
TransScan 9<br />
Trends in green construction<br />
climate.(25) Micro turbines for<br />
individual buildings were especially<br />
popular, due to advances<br />
that have made them smaller,<br />
lighter, quieter and more efficient<br />
in lower winds.<br />
Nonetheless, aesthetics<br />
as well as the practical limitations<br />
of micro turbines has inhibited<br />
their market share. This may<br />
change with renowned designers<br />
like Philippe Starke entering the<br />
industry with his “Revolutionair<br />
WT”, a sleek vertical micro<br />
turbine that is virtually invisible<br />
once on the roof. Others like the<br />
Bahrain wind towers (see photo<br />
page 6.) are making turbines an<br />
architectural feature.<br />
Perhaps the most important<br />
development in the sector<br />
is the realisation that there is no<br />
silver bullet and that the various<br />
forms of energy generation<br />
should be combined for optimal<br />
efficiency.<br />
References:<br />
(1)“Environmentally Sustainable Buildings: Challenges and Policies. Executive Summary” <strong>The</strong> OECD Environment Programme<br />
2003 <br />
(2)“Green Buildings - A Strategic Analysis of the Asia Pacific Markets”, Frost and Sullivan October 2009 <br />
(3)“<strong>The</strong> Second Plank. Building a Low Carbon Economy with Energy Efficient Buildings” by <strong>Australian</strong> Built Environment<br />
Council September 2008 <br />
(4)“Gizmo Green. Sustainable Design Deserves More than Bells and Whistles” by Lance Hosey Architect January 2010 <br />
(5)“<strong>The</strong> Pragmatic Approach To Green Design. Achieving LEED Certification from an Architect’s Perspective” by Lucy Williams<br />
in the Journal of Green Building Winter 2010 <br />
(6) “SmartMarket Report: Green Building Retrofit & Renovation” by McGraw Hill Construction October 2009 <br />
(7)Green Building and Design Conference 2010. Greening <strong>The</strong> Existing Building Stock <br />
(8)1200 Buildings <br />
(9)“Energy Efficiency Retrofits for Commercial and Public Buildings” Pike Research 2010<br />
<br />
(10)NABERS <br />
(11)“Building Energy Disclosure Bill 2010. Explanatory Memorandum” June 2010<br />
<br />
(12)“Building <strong>Commission</strong>ing. A Golden Opportunity for Reducing Energy Costs and Greenhouse-Gas Emissions” by Evan<br />
Mills for Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory July 2009 <br />
(13)“Energy and Water Monitoring for Existing Buildings” by Robin Archibald in Ecolibrium July 2009 <br />
(14) “Regional Green Building Case Study Project. A post-occupancy study of LEED projects in Illinois”, US Green Building<br />
Council (USGBC) Chicago Chapter Fall 2009 <br />
(15)“Evolution 2010” Green Building Council of Australia (GBCA) March 2010 <br />
(16)Design Inc <br />
(17)“Innovating For Better Buildings Report. An Opportunity Disguised as a Meltdown” by Brian Walsh for <strong>The</strong> Nth Power<br />
October 2009 <br />
(18)“<strong>The</strong> Gauge Achieves a 6 Star Green Star Rating” Green Building Council of Australia (GBCA), May 2008<br />
<br />
(19)World Green Building Council Asia Pacific Network <br />
(20)“Common Carbon Metric” World Green Building Council 2010 <br />
(21)“PIXEL gains highest Green Star score ever” Green Building Council of Australia (GBCA) July 2010<br />
<br />
(22)International Living Building Institute <br />
(23)Trigeneration Research Group Brunel University West London <br />
(24)“‘Solar Ivy’ Photovoltaic Leaves Climb to New Heights” by Bridgette Meinhold for Inhabitat July 2009<br />
<br />
(25)“AWEA Mid Year 2010 Market Report American Wind Energy Association July 2010
10<br />
TransScan<br />
Safety & health<br />
Glasses that decide if you are fit to drive...<br />
THESE are no ordinary pair of dark glasses. (right) <strong>Australian</strong><br />
company Optalert* developed them as a new safety device to<br />
warn truck drivers if they show signs of fatigue. <strong>The</strong> device<br />
itself comprises the driving glasses and a connected in-cab processor.<br />
According to the company, the glasses use pulses of invisible light to<br />
constantly measure driver drowsiness by detecting changes in eye and<br />
eyelid movements. Every minute a score of between zero and ten is<br />
displayed on a dash-mounted screen - with a higher score indicating<br />
a higher level of drowsiness. For extra safety, the device emits a loud<br />
beep and voice message if drowsiness is evident. According to Optalert,<br />
the system has just been installed by Rockhampton-base Emerald<br />
Carrying Company whose road tankers are contracted to transport<br />
liquid fuel. <strong>The</strong> tankers are operating around Queensland’s Mackay<br />
district where in the last year 12 people died in eight crashes attributed<br />
to driver fatigue.<br />
* <br />
Photo by Optalert<br />
Smart growth’s billion dollar side benefits<br />
PLANNING cities for “smart<br />
growth”* usually means<br />
that infrastructure will be<br />
cheaper, energy demand will be<br />
less, vehicles will travel fewer<br />
kilometres and that overall greenhouse<br />
gas emission will drop. But<br />
now researchers in California<br />
have reworked local data to show<br />
that the health benefits of smart<br />
growth can be worth hundreds of<br />
millions of dollars too.<br />
For their basic data, the<br />
researchers have taken figures<br />
prepared for California’s new<br />
strategic planning strategy (a)<br />
and investigated the health benefits<br />
that could be gained from<br />
living in the type of cleaner environment<br />
that smart growth should<br />
bring.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y have calculated that<br />
if the new strategy is followed,<br />
then by 2035 smart growth should<br />
* Footnote: “Smart growth” can<br />
be defined as a theory of urban and<br />
transport planning that focuses population<br />
growth on central areas and<br />
avoids sprawl.<br />
have cut California’s air pollution<br />
by more than 132,000 tonnes annually,<br />
reduced avoidable premature<br />
deaths by 140, caused<br />
105,000 fewer asthma and respiratory<br />
problems, and save 16,550<br />
working days that would normally<br />
have been lost to sickness.<br />
<strong>The</strong> combined savings<br />
to the community could top<br />
$US1.66 billion. (b)<br />
California’s new strategic<br />
plan did not evaluate what<br />
benefits might be had by creating<br />
urban areas that encouraged walking,<br />
cycling and easier access to<br />
public transport. Instead the strategy’s<br />
proponents emphasised the<br />
benefits that smart growth would<br />
have in cutting infrastructure expenditure<br />
and lower living costs.<br />
(<strong>The</strong> strategy report suggests average<br />
household costs could fall<br />
by $US6500 a year just because<br />
people would need to make less<br />
use of their cars.)<br />
But the American Lung<br />
Association, which investigated<br />
the health impacts of the strategy,<br />
said smart growth would offer<br />
significant benefits over any business-as-usual<br />
model.<br />
It said air pollution would<br />
be reduced so much that by 2035<br />
Californians could expect 110-<br />
260 fewer heart attacks, up to 115<br />
fewer admissions to hospital.<br />
(a) “Vision California - Charting<br />
our future” http://www.visioncalifornia.org/reports.php<br />
(b) American Lung Association media<br />
statement 16 Sept 2010 <br />
AIR POLLUTION<br />
Remote sensing<br />
While Californians have been<br />
investigating the cash benefits of<br />
cleaner city life (see previous article)<br />
scientists in Spain have been<br />
working on a new remote device<br />
that can accurately measure traffic<br />
pollution. (c) Moreover, if the<br />
device proves successful, the developers<br />
are hoping it will be use-<br />
Continued next page
Continued from previous page<br />
ful in measuring pollution levels<br />
in places where it might be dangerous<br />
to send technicians. For<br />
example, if it works well enough<br />
on roads, it could be used to provide<br />
instant feedback on bushfire<br />
emissions, greenhouse gases rising<br />
from waste dumps - and even<br />
toxic gases pouring out of volcanoes.<br />
According to Professor<br />
Antonio de Castro who is leading<br />
the research at Madrid’s Universidad<br />
Carlos III, the device (pictured<br />
below) uses infrared remote<br />
sensing technology to analyse all<br />
types of pollutants being created<br />
by vehicles. “With this technique<br />
all of the gases that have absorption<br />
bands in the infrared can be<br />
measured simultaneously,” Prof<br />
de Castro said. “That means we<br />
can look at almost all the gases<br />
that are of environmental interest<br />
- carbon monoxide, carbon<br />
dioxide, nitrogen oxides, ozone,<br />
methane, hydrocarbons, sulfur dioxide,<br />
chlorhydric acid, etc.” He<br />
said the object was to determine<br />
the concentration of the chief gas<br />
pollutants associated with motor<br />
vehicle traffic. Currently the tests<br />
are being conducted at road sites<br />
in the towns of Villaviciosa de<br />
Odón and Leganés.<br />
(c) “New method for infrared remote<br />
sensing to analyse traffic pollution”<br />
Universidad Carlos III media statement<br />
8 Sept 2010 <br />
ABOVE: Spain’s new road pollution<br />
measuring device. Photo by Universidad<br />
Carlos III de Madrid.<br />
TransScan 11<br />
Safety & health<br />
Can technology eliminate<br />
‘physical’ road barriers?<br />
WOULD a simulated,<br />
“virtual road barrier”<br />
work as effectively as<br />
the real thing? For example, if<br />
your car started to “graze” the<br />
unseen virtual barrier, your steering<br />
wheel would start to vibrate.<br />
If you continued to drive into the<br />
virtual barrier, your car’s steering<br />
would bounce you off. It may<br />
sound science fiction, but the<br />
concept is already being tested in<br />
Norway. (1)<br />
<strong>The</strong> idea started as an<br />
electronic version of the “rumble<br />
strip” - the corrugated road marking<br />
strips used by some <strong>Australian</strong><br />
road authorities. <strong>The</strong> Norwegians<br />
were seeking to develop a<br />
safety product that would alert a<br />
motorist if their vehicle started to<br />
“drift” out of a driving lane. Some<br />
luxury cars are already fitted with<br />
video cameras to track lane markings<br />
and sound alerts if “drifting”<br />
occurs - but the cameras do not<br />
work if the roads are unmarked or<br />
say covered by snow.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Norwegians were<br />
looking for an alternative to the<br />
camera - and came up with the<br />
concept of an antenna installed<br />
in the side of a car which picks<br />
up radio signals broadcast from<br />
transponders buried in a road’s<br />
top layer of asphalt. During recent<br />
tests using driving simulators,<br />
researchers found that of all<br />
possible warning signals, motorists<br />
much preferred “vibrating”<br />
steering wheels - and that got the<br />
researchers thinking. Could such<br />
technology replace some physical<br />
road barriers?<br />
Terje Moen, research<br />
manager of SINTEF, Scandinavia’s<br />
independent research organization,<br />
thinks they can. “What is<br />
interesting about this product is<br />
that it can be developed to com-<br />
Photo by SINTEF<br />
A test vehicle fitted with a WayPilot<br />
antennae to pick up signals from the<br />
invisible barrier.<br />
pete with highway dividers,” Mr<br />
Moen says. “If it is linked to the<br />
steering wheel, a sort of electronic<br />
barricade that actually<br />
simulates a divider can be built<br />
into the highway, and the system<br />
can be retrofitted to existing vehicles.”<br />
Meanwhile the Norwegian<br />
Public Roads Administration is<br />
joining SINTEF and the product’s<br />
developers, Arendal, to begin<br />
road testing.<br />
T<strong>RANS</strong>IT PLANNING<br />
Health dividends<br />
Leaving the car behind and using<br />
public transport might be good<br />
for health - but it is usually hard<br />
to measure. Now a detailed study<br />
of obesity among travellers using<br />
light rail in Charlotte, North Carolina<br />
suggests people really can<br />
shed weight with public transport.<br />
(2) Researchers found daily users<br />
of light rail services were better<br />
able to control their weight and if<br />
Continued next page
12 TransScan<br />
Resilience & recovery<br />
AN inundated village<br />
in Pakistan’s Punjab<br />
Province. Just one<br />
of 4600 settlements<br />
flooded by the record<br />
monsoon. When<br />
this photo was taken<br />
in mid-August, floodwaters<br />
still covered<br />
a fifth of the country.<br />
More than 2000 people<br />
had lost their lives and<br />
millions were injured or<br />
suffering from disease<br />
and deprivations that<br />
followed.<br />
Finding better ways to manage disaster<br />
EVENTS like the Pakistan<br />
flood disaster naturally<br />
focus most of the world’s<br />
attention on the immediate needs<br />
for survival. Nonetheless, the<br />
growing litany of natural catastrophes<br />
is also producing examples<br />
of where governments and<br />
NGOs have been able to turn<br />
seemingly hopeless situations<br />
into “exemplars for recovery”.<br />
For example the aftermath<br />
of eight events - including<br />
Mexico City’s 1985 earthquake<br />
and the Bangladesh flood<br />
of 1998 - have been identified by<br />
researchers from the US thinktank,<br />
the RAND Corporation, as<br />
demonstrating successful recovery<br />
and redevelopment practices<br />
that could be usefully copied both<br />
by the US and other countries. (1)<br />
<strong>The</strong>ir findings have just been published<br />
by the US-based “Journal<br />
of Homeland Security and Emergency<br />
Management”.<br />
RAND’s researchers<br />
found no examples of successful<br />
UN Photo/Evan Schneider<br />
recovery policies within the US<br />
itself and said that until recently<br />
“disaster management” had been<br />
a neglected priority area in America.<br />
(See too “Remembering Katrina”<br />
below.)<br />
(Disaster management is<br />
also an area where other governments<br />
need to hone their skills.<br />
Last year’s report by the international<br />
Economics of Climate Adaptation<br />
Working Group said by<br />
Continued next page<br />
Continued from previous page<br />
they were walking a mile a day to<br />
catch their train then their weight<br />
probably dropped by an average<br />
of 6.45lbs (about 3 kilograms).<br />
<strong>The</strong> researchers found that increasing<br />
access to LRT services<br />
may also overcome individual<br />
barriers to engaging in “daily<br />
utilitarian exercise.” As a result,<br />
the researchers recommend that<br />
governments factor in “increases<br />
in physical activity” when calculating<br />
the cost-benefıts of new<br />
transit systems.<br />
AIR POLLUTION<br />
Disrupted sleep<br />
A link has been discovered between<br />
air pollution and a known<br />
cause of cardiovascular disease<br />
- sleep-disordered breathing<br />
(SDB). (3) A group of US researchers<br />
identified the problem<br />
after analysing the health of more<br />
than 6000 people and the air pollution<br />
levels in their home cities.<br />
According to Dr Antonella Zanobetti<br />
who led the investigation,<br />
novel evidence was found for pollution<br />
and temperature effects on<br />
sleep-disordered breathing. “Increases<br />
in apnea or hypopnea…<br />
were associated with increases<br />
in short-term temperature over<br />
all seasons, and with increases<br />
in particle pollution levels in the<br />
summer months,” she said. In<br />
the US about 17% of adults have<br />
problems with SDB.<br />
References:<br />
(1) “An extra driver behind the wheel” SINTEF media statement 3 June 2010<br />
<br />
(2) “<strong>The</strong> Effect of Light Rail Transit on Body Mass Index and Physical Activity”<br />
John MacDonald et al American Journal of Preventive Medicine Aug 2010<br />
<br />
(3) “New Link between Pollution, Temperature and Sleep-Disordered Breathing”<br />
American Thoracic Society media statement 14 June 2010
Continued from previous page<br />
2030 the world could be spending<br />
up to $US 135 billion annually<br />
to address the impacts of<br />
climate change - unless more was<br />
done now to improve resilience. *<br />
(2))<br />
Where there has been<br />
success RAND found it correlated<br />
to three basic approaches:<br />
• Local empowerment - take<br />
actions that minimise the affected<br />
community’s loss of income<br />
and social routine. This means<br />
directly employing local people<br />
in recovery work.<br />
• Organization and leadership<br />
- in practice this means government<br />
agencies have to cut red<br />
tape to restore infrastructure and<br />
livelihoods more quickly; and<br />
• Smart rebuilding - ensure that<br />
redeveloped housing and infrastructure<br />
is not only sustainable,<br />
but improves community resilience<br />
and reduces or eliminates<br />
previous vulnerabilities.<br />
* Footnote: <strong>The</strong> report calculated<br />
that actions taken now to improve<br />
resilience could cut the resulting<br />
damages bill by up to 68% - and<br />
that included such infrastructure improvements<br />
as strengthening buildings<br />
and constructing reservoirs to<br />
combat drought.<br />
AMREEN is her<br />
name and the<br />
eight-year-old was<br />
washing dishes in<br />
rainwater when the<br />
UNICEF photographer<br />
passed by.<br />
Behind her is what<br />
is left of the Khwas<br />
Koorona Village in<br />
Pakistan’s northwestern<br />
Khyber-<br />
Pakhtunkhwa<br />
province. An estimated<br />
2.5 million of<br />
the province’s<br />
3.5 million residents<br />
have been affected<br />
by the floods.<br />
Photo by<br />
UNICEF/ZAK<br />
Mexico City’s 1985<br />
earthquake devastated the city.<br />
More than 9500 people died,<br />
100,000 lost their homes and<br />
economic losses topped $US 4<br />
billion. According to RAND the<br />
Mexican Government responded<br />
by establishing an autonomous<br />
recovery agency with a timesensitive<br />
mandate. In other words,<br />
the agency was given two years<br />
to complete the job. It quickly<br />
transferred necessary staff, like<br />
planners and engineers, from<br />
other departments and used the<br />
time-sensitivity to set performance<br />
gaols.<br />
Says RAND: “<strong>The</strong> effectiveness<br />
of this policy is evidenced<br />
by the rapid completion<br />
of more than 45,000 homes within<br />
the agency’s two year mandate<br />
– an average of 3,220 dwellings<br />
per month – and contracts with<br />
1,200 private companies and the<br />
creation of 175,000 jobs.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> Bangladesh flood<br />
of 1998 saw 68% of the country<br />
covered by water for ten weeks,<br />
918 deaths and 31 million people<br />
in urgent need of help. RAND<br />
says the key to recovery was<br />
the actions of the Bangladesh<br />
Rural Advancement Committee<br />
(BRAC), an NGO that was normally<br />
focused on long-term development<br />
projects but had staff<br />
and resources spread across the<br />
country.<br />
BRAC diverted its people<br />
into the more immediate task<br />
of flood recovery, which meant<br />
returning flood victims to their<br />
TransScan 13<br />
Resilience & recovery<br />
homes and income-generating<br />
activities as quickly as possible.<br />
In some cases this meant donating<br />
seeds to local farmers so<br />
that grains and vegetables could<br />
be grown quickly. According to<br />
RAND, such actions also prevented<br />
large numbers of people<br />
sinking into long-term poverty.<br />
VICTORIA’S BUSHFIRES<br />
Final report and aftermath<br />
Less than a month after the Victorian<br />
Bushfires Royal <strong>Commission</strong><br />
published its final report (3)<br />
the Victorian Government issued<br />
its considered reply accepting in<br />
full or part 66 of the 67 recommendations.<br />
(4) <strong>The</strong> only recommendation<br />
rejected outright was<br />
a voluntary property buy-back<br />
scheme for residents in high-risk<br />
areas. (5) <strong>The</strong> State Government<br />
Continued next page
14 TransScan<br />
Resilience & recovery<br />
Continued from previous page<br />
believed such a policy would increase<br />
the fire risk for the residents<br />
who wished to remain. <strong>The</strong><br />
devastating fire that swept across<br />
Victoria in early 2009 (See special<br />
TransScan reports June 2009<br />
and October 2009 ) killed 173 people<br />
and destroyed 2133 homes.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Royal <strong>Commission</strong>’s final<br />
No-go development zones?<br />
report found that the potential<br />
risk of bushfires was rising with<br />
growing numbers of people living<br />
in the rural-urban interface<br />
and the “probable effects” of<br />
climate change. That being the<br />
case, the recommendations were<br />
largely concerned with reducing<br />
exposure to fire, making homes<br />
more defendable, reducing the<br />
intensity and spread of fire, and<br />
helping people recover from the<br />
IN theory by 2030 climate change<br />
will have so intensified hurricane<br />
and storm damage around the Caribbean<br />
that countries in the region<br />
will be spending up to 9% of their<br />
annual GDP on repairs and no investor<br />
will be prepared to risk money on<br />
local development.<br />
It is a grim prospect - so what<br />
is the solution? It looks like being<br />
a mixture of far tougher building<br />
codes and greater spending on<br />
insurance. At least those are the<br />
basic conclusions of a report, “Economics<br />
of Climate Adaptation” just completed by<br />
the Caribbean Catastrophe Risk Insurance Facility. * (a)<br />
At present Caribbean countries spend around 6% of GDP<br />
annually recovering from natural catastrophes and the report predicts<br />
the figure could rise by a further 3% in 20 years. But the<br />
report showed there were many “affordable” adaptation measures<br />
that could be taken. For example in the Cayman Islands the report<br />
suggests 90% of the country’s expected losses could be eliminated<br />
by constructing sea walls and enforcing building codes.<br />
But the solution is not so easy for Dominica. <strong>The</strong> report said<br />
studies indicated that only 2% of the country’s calculated loss could<br />
be averted by the cost-effective use of risk mitigation measures. As<br />
an alternative, the report recommended buying more insurance.<br />
* CCRIF is a unique international body. It was originally seed funded<br />
by the Japanese Government and draws membership from 16 Caribbean<br />
governments. Members use it as a risk pooling facility to provide<br />
quick short-term liquidity if their countries are is hit by a catastrophic<br />
event. Initial capital was raised internationally through the European<br />
Union, World Bank and certain individual governments. CCRIF website:<br />
<br />
(a) “Economics of Climate Adaptation” CCRIF 18 Aug 2010 <br />
impact of fire. Beyond Victoria<br />
the commission recommended<br />
State and federal governments<br />
invest more in research. It found<br />
the existing Melbourne-based<br />
and largely Victorian-orientated<br />
Bushfire Cooperative Research<br />
Centre (6) was not meeting all<br />
necessary research needs. In response,<br />
Australia’s fire services<br />
have collectively agreed to support<br />
the CRC’s transition into<br />
the “Australasian Fire Research<br />
Institute”. (7) Meanwhile, the<br />
Victorian Government is expecting<br />
that the actions it will take<br />
in response to the commission’s<br />
recommendations - including a<br />
“massive” increase in reduction<br />
burning, jobs for hundreds of<br />
new fire fighters and a new early<br />
warning system - will cost the<br />
State $867.3 million.<br />
REMEMBERING KATRINA<br />
Lessons in disaster<br />
Having been hit by a hurricane,<br />
global recession, and the oily<br />
outpourings of BP’s ill-fated rig<br />
Deepwater Horizon, New Orleans<br />
has become something of a test<br />
laboratory for coastal city disaster<br />
recovery. Five years after Hurricane<br />
Katrina struck, the Brookings<br />
Institute has just published a<br />
series of research papers on how<br />
that recovery is progressing - and<br />
it finds decidedly mixed results.<br />
(8) <strong>The</strong> hurricane and subsequent<br />
floods left 80% of the city underwater<br />
and destroyed more than<br />
182,000 homes. <strong>The</strong> aftermath<br />
exposed serious weaknesses in<br />
America’s preparedness to handle<br />
natural disasters and even<br />
after $US42 billion in federal<br />
spending, New Orleans today has<br />
got back only 78% of its pre-Katrina<br />
population. Reconstruction<br />
appears to have done little to end<br />
social disparities and Brookings<br />
finds African-Americans are still<br />
the lowest paid and struggle to afford<br />
the new, and comparatively<br />
Continued next page
TransScan 15<br />
Resilience & recovery<br />
Continued from previous page<br />
expensive housing. Meanwhile<br />
the local economy is hampered<br />
by what in the local New Orleans’<br />
context are “stagnant and declining<br />
industries” - like tourism, oil<br />
and gas, and shipping. So what is<br />
the solution? Brookings suggests<br />
New Orleans takes advantage of<br />
the US recession and the oil spill<br />
and use both to focus extra attention<br />
to the regional economy and<br />
coastline. Brookings sees the recession<br />
as “enormous opportunity”<br />
to “strengthen and diversify”<br />
local industry while the oil spill<br />
reinforces the need underlined<br />
by Katrina to invest in healthier<br />
coastal wetlands and so advance<br />
the city toward a culture of one<br />
“living with water.”<br />
DISASTER INSURANCE<br />
Covering the tax base<br />
Across the State border from<br />
New Orleans, the Alabama Government<br />
has just become the<br />
first in the world representing a<br />
developed economy to sign up for<br />
parametric insurance* to cover<br />
natural disasters. (9) Among other<br />
things, the insurance allows for<br />
immediate payments to cover the<br />
cost of an emergency response -<br />
and funds to replace any loss in<br />
tax revenue the disaster might<br />
cause. In effect the arrangement<br />
transfers from government to the<br />
private sector a slice of the financial<br />
exposure to natural disasters.<br />
Insurer Swiss Re negotiated the<br />
three-year deal and according to<br />
Alabama’s finance department,<br />
the transaction is a milestone in<br />
identifying and managing the<br />
State’s risks. “Based simply on<br />
the wind speed of a hurricane, we<br />
can now receive funds rapidly to<br />
cover our immediate costs,” said<br />
Alabama’s risks manager, Ben<br />
Spillers.<br />
* Footnote: With parametric insurance<br />
the insurer agrees beforehand<br />
that a certain sum will be paid out<br />
if a particular catastrophic event<br />
occurs.<br />
References:<br />
(1) “Enhancing Disaster Recovery: Lessons from Exemplary International<br />
Disaster Management Practices” by Jeffrey Garnett and Melinda<br />
Moore (RAND Corporation) Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency<br />
Management, Vol 7 2010 <br />
(2) “Shaping Climate-Resilient Development” Economics of Climate<br />
Adaptation Working Group 14 Sep 2009 <br />
(3) Victorian Bushfires Royal <strong>Commission</strong> 31 July 2010 <br />
(4) “Government takes action on major bushfire reforms” Victorian<br />
Government media statement 27 Aug 2010 <br />
(5) “Victoria unveils response to Black Saturday report” ABC News 27<br />
Aug 2010 <br />
(6) Bushfire Cooperative Research Centre website <br />
(7) “Establishment of bushfire research institute” Bushfire CRC media<br />
statement 31 July 2010 <br />
(8) “<strong>The</strong> New Orleans Index at Five Collection” Brookings Institution<br />
Aug 2010<br />
<br />
(9) “Alabama State Insurance Fund transaction marks first insurance<br />
solution on behalf of US state government” Swiss Re media statement<br />
27 Aug 2010<br />
<br />
Events<br />
up-date<br />
World Conference on Disaster<br />
Management<br />
11-12 Oct, 2010<br />
Sydney, NSW<br />
<br />
2nd International Sprayed<br />
Sealing Conference<br />
11-12 Oct<br />
Melbourne, Vic<br />
<br />
13th International<br />
Riversymposium<br />
11-14 Oct 2010<br />
Perth, WA<br />
<br />
24th ARRB Conference<br />
12-15 Oct 2010<br />
Melbourne, Vic<br />
<br />
National Local Roads and<br />
Transport Congress<br />
13-15 Oct 2010<br />
Bunbury WA<br />
<br />
SEGRA 2010 (Sustainable<br />
Economic Growth for Regional<br />
Australia)<br />
19-21 Oct 2010<br />
Townsville, Qld<br />
<br />
Cities and their Regions:<br />
Catalysts for Change<br />
1-4 Nov 2010<br />
Adelaide, SA<br />
<br />
Disclaimer: <strong>The</strong> inclusion of items<br />
in this column does not represent<br />
endorsement by the publishers.
16 TransScan<br />
Trends in mobility<br />
Is LNG the way to keep freight moving?<br />
By Catherine Madden<br />
LATEST assessments of<br />
LNG as a fuel for heavy<br />
duty trucks suggest its use<br />
will produce 25% less greenhouse<br />
emissions than diesel and<br />
since WA opened a $137 million<br />
production facility last year* increasing<br />
numbers of transport<br />
companies have been making<br />
the switch. But the arguments<br />
* Wesfarmers’ Evol LNG plant<br />
<br />
for using LNG extend beyond<br />
straight environmental considerations.<br />
Australia’s reliance on<br />
imported oil is growing and the<br />
fact that road freight could treble<br />
in size by 2050 (1) gives locally<br />
produced LNG great strategic<br />
importance. Now for all the same<br />
reasons, an independent US energy<br />
think-tank is advocating a<br />
similar conversion for America’s<br />
heavy-duty truck fleet.<br />
<strong>The</strong> National Energy Policy<br />
Unit, base at the University<br />
of Tulsa is proposing the switch<br />
as the single most significant option<br />
open to government both to<br />
curb oil consumption and make<br />
significant inroads into reducing<br />
carbon dioxide emissions.<br />
From an international<br />
perspective, such a move by the<br />
US would also have significant<br />
impacts on the world market for<br />
Continued next page<br />
WA gas know-how for Indian buses<br />
A<br />
NATURAL gas fuel<br />
enriched with hydrogen<br />
could help to alleviate<br />
the pollution from India’s notoriously<br />
choked roads. Perth-based<br />
clean power company Eden<br />
Energy* has begun the world’s<br />
first commercial trial of buses<br />
fuelled by Hythane, a blend of<br />
compressed natural gas enriched<br />
with 15 to 20 per cent hydrogen.<br />
In a country that is heavily reliant<br />
on public transport, the Hythane<br />
buses are part of India’s push<br />
towards a hydrogen economy,<br />
which could see a million of the<br />
country’s vehicles powered by<br />
hydrogen within a decade.<br />
Up to 70 of the buses,<br />
using the newly tested six-litre<br />
Photo by Eden Energy<br />
H06B CNG engines, will be on<br />
the streets of Mumbai by the end<br />
of 2010.<br />
Eden Energy says<br />
Hythane reduces harmful emissions<br />
and greenhouse gases from<br />
gas-powered vehicles by up to<br />
50 per cent while increasing their<br />
efficiency by up to 15 per cent.<br />
Although many bus<br />
fleets in India’s larger cities have<br />
switched to natural gas in the<br />
past five years, noxious gases<br />
and smog are still a problem.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> use of Hythane fuel<br />
in the nation’s municipal buses<br />
will make a significant reduction<br />
in these pollutants, without any<br />
power or performance penalties,<br />
and without expensive engine or<br />
vehicle add-on equipment,” said<br />
Justin Fulton, the director of engine<br />
and fuel systems for Eden’s<br />
US subsidiary, Hythane.<br />
Each bus is expected to<br />
save about seven tonnes of CO 2 -<br />
equivalent greenhouse gas annually.<br />
* “<strong>Australian</strong> company heralds successful<br />
tests in development of India’s<br />
first production Hythane engine for bus<br />
fleet” ASX announcement 28 May 2010<br />
TransScan 17<br />
Continued from previous page<br />
oil. According to the policy unit,<br />
it would effectively cut US oil<br />
imports by 36% and that in itself<br />
would reduce the world’s projected<br />
oil usage by a whopping<br />
50%. As a result, the world’s oil<br />
consumption over the next 20<br />
years would flatten.<br />
<strong>The</strong> policy unit’s findings<br />
and recommendations are<br />
contained in a new report “Toward<br />
a New National Energy<br />
Policy”. (2) It proposes a rapid<br />
start to the switch with 10% of<br />
America’s heavy-duty truck fleet<br />
being converted to LNG in 2011.<br />
It suggests the figure then rise<br />
by an additional 10% each year<br />
until 2020 when all new American<br />
trucks would be fuelled by<br />
LNG.<br />
Allowing for the older<br />
diesel trucks that would still be<br />
in operation, this would mean<br />
that by 2030 70% of America’s<br />
heavy-duty fleet would be running<br />
on LNG.<br />
<strong>The</strong> study says that although<br />
the vehicles would be<br />
more expensive to manufacture,<br />
the conversion scheme would<br />
lead to “significant reductions”<br />
in oil use and reduce carbon<br />
emissions by 1821 million metric<br />
tons between 2011 and 2030.<br />
<strong>The</strong> report says the greatest<br />
roadblock to the plan is the<br />
lack of an LNG refuelling infrastructure<br />
but the authors believe<br />
this would improve over time<br />
as the trucking industry turned<br />
increasingly to a system of centralised<br />
“hubs” for pick-ups and<br />
drop-offs rather than relying<br />
on the individual long distance<br />
truckers for all-points distribution.<br />
Like the US, Australia’s<br />
bill for oil imports is ratcheting<br />
up alarmingly (3). But while our<br />
production of crude oil last year<br />
dropped to its lowest level in four<br />
decades, the natural gas industry<br />
grew strongly (4). Industry analysts<br />
EnergyQuest estimates that<br />
Continued next page<br />
Trends in mobility<br />
Photo by Fraunhofer Institute<br />
Germany developing a new<br />
concept in green transit<br />
SO why does light rail need rails, or even a driver for that<br />
matter? As this photo of Germany’s new prototype “Auto-<br />
Tram”* shows, city transit vehicles of the future may well<br />
operate without either. <strong>The</strong> designers described it as being “as long<br />
as a streetcar and as agile as a bus with the combined benefits of<br />
both”.<br />
<strong>The</strong> vehicle reaches its destination simply by following,<br />
automatically, lines painted on the road. (Although to overcome the<br />
problems of winter snow covering up the lines, it may be necessary<br />
for the Germans to adopt Dutch ideas for burying transponders below<br />
the road. See “Could physical road barriers be eliminated?”<br />
page 11.)<br />
But for the moment researchers at the Fraunhofer Institute are<br />
concentrating on developing the AutoTram’s power source. It will<br />
be electricity - but it will not be delivered to the vehicle in the same<br />
way as overhead power lines used to deliver energy to previous<br />
generations of trams.<br />
What the Germans have in mind is a system of electricity<br />
recharging points along the AutoTram route. Rather than having<br />
large batteries installed that can take hours to recharge, the Auto-<br />
Tram will draw its electricity from docking stations positioned at<br />
say every third or forth stop along its route. In place of batteries,<br />
the researchers are in the process of developing “super capacitors”<br />
that will be able to recharge the tram in under 60 seconds. (But unlike<br />
batteries, capacitors can hold a large electric charge - but not<br />
for long.)<br />
<strong>The</strong> German Government is funding the research for another<br />
two years, by which time Fraunhofer hopes to present a new pollution-free<br />
transit vehicle to the world’s public transport authorities.<br />
*
18 TransScan<br />
Trends in mobility<br />
Continued from previous page<br />
<strong>Australian</strong> natural gas production<br />
increased by 10.1% in the<br />
year to December 2009, reaching<br />
a record 1897 petajolues (PJ.<br />
ELECTRIC TRUCKS<br />
<strong>The</strong> long-term solution?<br />
Converting trucks, or even investing<br />
in the latest LNG-powered<br />
vehicles, will not, in the<br />
long-term, fix the carbon conundrum<br />
- at least not if Australia is<br />
to reach “zero carbon emissions”<br />
as some believe necessary. But<br />
how would such a “sustainable”<br />
future ever be achieved? A team<br />
of more than 50 researchers have<br />
been investigating the idea and<br />
their results have just been published<br />
by Melbourne University’s<br />
Energy Research Institute in a report:<br />
the “Zero Carbon Australia<br />
Stationary Energy Plan”. (5)<br />
Remarkably the report finds that<br />
Australia could make the switch<br />
to 100% renewable energy in a<br />
decade, and have cars and trucks<br />
feeding off the all-electric system<br />
within the same period. <strong>The</strong> new<br />
electric grid would draw power<br />
from mainly large-scale solar<br />
power stations plus thousands of<br />
wind turbines. Interestingly the<br />
report does not suggest just a simple<br />
switch from petrol, diesel and<br />
LNG vehicles to electric and biofuelled<br />
ones. It envisages people<br />
making far greater use of a greatly<br />
expanded network of electric<br />
passenger trains and passenger<br />
trams. Freight would be largely<br />
shipped in freight trains and “cargo<br />
trams”. Although there would<br />
still be private cars - either electric<br />
or biofuelled - they would<br />
be used far less use than they are<br />
today. Instead services would be<br />
more localised and people would<br />
need to travel less. “<strong>The</strong> modal<br />
shift from private passenger vehicles<br />
to shared rail vehicles has<br />
the capacity to reduce the private<br />
car fleet by around 50%,” the<br />
Photo by Tecnalia<br />
Makeover for ‘wheelchairs’<br />
ANY belief that electric vehicles are merely motorised<br />
wheelchairs has finally been dismissed with the development<br />
of a sleek Spanish EV that reaches 140km in 10<br />
seconds. <strong>The</strong> Tecnalia Technological Corporation’s Dynacar is a<br />
two-seater with a single-shell, high-rigidity lightweight chassis<br />
of steel and aluminium alloy. It can run on a battery or a small<br />
internal combustion engine that will enable the battery to be supplied<br />
with energy in a supplementary mode. <strong>The</strong> vehicle has a<br />
peak power of 100 kW provided by a permanent magnet synchronous<br />
electric motor and an energy storage capacity of 15 kWh.<br />
Tecnalia says the car can be driven on the open road, but<br />
its main purpose is as a research platform for new electric vehicle<br />
technologies. Watch the video at .<br />
“Tecnalia presents electric vehicle that reaches<br />
140 km/hour in 10 seconds” 31 May 2010<br />
<br />
report claims. “<strong>The</strong> average car<br />
will travel 8000km p.a. instead of<br />
the15,000km travelled today,” it<br />
says.<br />
EV TECHNOLOGY 1<br />
Charging ahead 1<br />
<strong>The</strong> City of Perth is boosting its<br />
eco-credentials with the opening<br />
of the city’s first car park with<br />
recharging bays for electric cars<br />
(6). <strong>The</strong> $33.5 million Elder<br />
Street car park offers 12 hardwired<br />
bays powered by energy<br />
from solar panels on the roof.<br />
Among other green features are<br />
sensor-controlled lighting and<br />
soak wells that will return rainwater<br />
to the water table.<br />
EV TECHNOLOGY 2<br />
Charging ahead 2<br />
New York has finally joined the<br />
low emissions push by installing<br />
its first electric recharging bay<br />
in a city car park (7). <strong>The</strong> city is<br />
the fourth in America – behind<br />
San Francisco, Austin, and Detroit<br />
– to install public recharge<br />
points and with Ford, Chevrolet,<br />
Continued next page
Continued from previous page<br />
Nissan, and Daimler developing<br />
mass-produced electric vehicles,<br />
they could be in hot demand. Recharge<br />
points are also being built<br />
in garages under apartments.<br />
TRAINS MAKE TRACKS<br />
Riding the rails<br />
Americans are catching the train<br />
the work in greater numbers. <strong>The</strong><br />
State of Metropolitan America<br />
report (8) found that although<br />
driving to work is still by far the<br />
most popular way to commute,<br />
the share of Americans going by<br />
train or subway has increased<br />
for the first time in 40 years. Increases<br />
were seen in big cities<br />
with vast rail networks but also in<br />
places that had opened up a light<br />
rail service or expanded routes.<br />
ELECTRIC BUSES<br />
Running on sun power<br />
Already a familiar sight in<br />
Shanghai, the ultracapacitor bus<br />
has been launched in Arlington,<br />
Virginia (9). <strong>The</strong> zero-carbon bus<br />
Trends in mobility<br />
is powered by solar panels on the<br />
roof and capable of recharging in<br />
minutes. It has been developed<br />
by Sinautec Automobile Technologies,<br />
the American University<br />
and research partner, Shanghai<br />
Aowei Technology Development<br />
Company. Unlike battery-powered<br />
vehicles, ultracapacitor vehicles<br />
can be charged within minutes<br />
but lack storage and need<br />
frequent recharging. Watch the<br />
video at (See too<br />
Germany’s new bus, page 17)<br />
CYCLING<br />
Paris pedals<br />
Paris has embraced cycling culture<br />
with demand often outstripping<br />
supply for the 20,000 bikes<br />
available for hire throughout the<br />
city (10). Researchers estimate<br />
that 2.16 million car trips in Paris<br />
are foregone each year due to<br />
the city’s bike sharing system.<br />
A University of California study<br />
has found 101 public bike programs<br />
now operate in 125 cities<br />
- up from 60 in 2008.<br />
References<br />
(1)“Meeting the 2050 Freight Challenge” PriceWaterhouseCoopers, commissioned<br />
by Infrastructure Partnerships Australia, 21 Jan 2010 <br />
(2) “Toward a New National Energy Policy: Assessing the Options” National<br />
Energy Institute and Resources for the Future, June 2010 <br />
(3) “Australia’s Renewable Energy Future” <strong>Australian</strong> Academy of Sciences<br />
Feb 2010 <br />
(4) “<strong>Australian</strong> oil production in 2009 falls to lowest level in 40 years: major<br />
industry report” EnergyQuest 5 Mar 2010 <br />
(5) “Zero Carbon Australia Stationary Energy Plan” University of Melbourne’s<br />
Energy Institute and Beyond Zero Emissions 14 July 2010 <br />
(6) “Lord Mayor opens ‘greener’ Elder Street Car Park” Media statement 12<br />
July 2010 <br />
(7) “Will new charging stations spark electric car sales?” 14 July 2010 <br />
(8) “On the Map: America’s Shifting Commuting Choices” 1 July 2010 <br />
(9) “Sinautec to showcase zero carbon ultracapacitor minibus at American<br />
University” 22 Sept 2009 Media statement “Next Stop: Ultracapacitor Buses” 19 October 2009 <br />
(10) “Power to the pedals” Worldwatch Institute <br />
TransScan 19<br />
TRAN S<br />
Net<br />
A regular review of Internet sites<br />
covering mobility and the built<br />
environment<br />
NORMALLY when Royal <strong>Commission</strong>s<br />
publish their reports<br />
they do so as a series of weighty<br />
tomes - but not the Final Report<br />
of Victoria’s Bushfires Royal<br />
<strong>Commission</strong>. One volume -<br />
Volume IV - only comes as an<br />
online document. It contain not<br />
only witness statements but also<br />
photos and video footage of<br />
the events. “<strong>The</strong> quantity and<br />
nature of the material meant<br />
a printed version is impractical,”<br />
the commission explains.<br />
<br />
AS flood-torn Pakistan struggles<br />
with rebuilding, another<br />
country has been examining the<br />
lessons of its own past era of<br />
reconstruction - Germany. As<br />
well as publishing a fascinating<br />
portfolio of illustrations,<br />
Spiegel Online, also has an<br />
interview with Albert Speer<br />
- one of Germany’s top urban<br />
planners and son of the<br />
infamous Nazi architect of<br />
the same name. <br />
SOMEONE on ABC Radio mentioned<br />
the other day that the<br />
glamour had gone out of train<br />
spotting… But what if you could<br />
see all the trains moving all at<br />
the same time in real time? In<br />
the UK you can - thanks to the<br />
work of a retired public servant,<br />
Matthew Somerville. See the<br />
results on <br />
Disclaimer: <strong>The</strong> inclusion of these sites<br />
does not mean endorsement by the<br />
publishers. <strong>The</strong>y have been selected<br />
for interest value only.
20 TransScan<br />
Advances in remote sensing<br />
Images supplied by<br />
Infoterra GmbH the<br />
satellite operators.<br />
<br />
Fremantle as seen by TerraSAR-X - one of the new twin radar satellites shown left.<br />
How radar imagery is offering<br />
new ways to track events<br />
FREMANTLE and the<br />
Swan River (above) appear<br />
in stark contrast through<br />
the radar “eyes” of TerraSAR-<br />
X - one of two almost identical<br />
German satellites now orbiting in<br />
close formation 514 kilometres<br />
above the Earth. <strong>The</strong> image was<br />
taken exclusively for TransScan<br />
by Infoterra GmbH while the satellites<br />
were being manoeuvred and<br />
tested to operate in tandem.<br />
<strong>The</strong>ir radar “eyes” enable<br />
them to take Digital Elevation<br />
Measurements - or highly<br />
accurate three-dimensional images<br />
without having to worry<br />
about cloud cover or poor visibility.<br />
In fact so accurate are the images,<br />
that the twin satellites will<br />
be able to identify movements on<br />
the Earth’s surface - such as shifts<br />
caused by earthquakes or much<br />
more subtle geological movements<br />
like those that occur just<br />
before underground mining or gas<br />
extraction unexpectedly causes a<br />
nearby road, building or bridge<br />
to collapse. Radar<br />
imagery is<br />
also good for<br />
tracking oil<br />
pollution at sea<br />
and the German<br />
satellites<br />
have been used<br />
in the Mexican<br />
Gulf oil disaster.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> reflection<br />
of the radar<br />
beam by the<br />
smooth surface<br />
of the oil slick<br />
on the water is<br />
different from the reflection of<br />
the beam by the surrounding<br />
water,” explained a spokesman.<br />
In recent weeks they<br />
have provided data for rescue<br />
teams in the Pakistan floods.<br />
<strong>The</strong> ability of the satellites to cut<br />
through cloud cover means they<br />
can also provide highly accurate<br />
information on the damage being<br />
caused during a cyclone.<br />
REMOVE the billowing smoke and steam and this is<br />
what the mouth of a volcano really looks like, albeit in<br />
artificial colour. <strong>The</strong> image is made up of two taken by<br />
TerraSAR-X to show changes around Iceland’s<br />
Eyjafjallajoekull volcano and offers a good example of<br />
the 3-D effect that can be obtained using radar.<br />
Printed on <strong>Australian</strong> recycled paper