thank you! - Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Association of America
thank you! - Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Association of America
thank you! - Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Association of America
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Volume 20, Issue 3<br />
R e f l e x S y m p a t h e t i c D y s t r o p h y S y n d r o m e A s s o c i a t i o n<br />
in this issue:<br />
1 Thank <strong>you</strong>! Thank <strong>you</strong>!<br />
2 News from the Patient<br />
Representative<br />
3 Thanksgiving<br />
4 RSDSA News<br />
6 Mailbag<br />
9 When RSD Hits<br />
a New Phase<br />
10 Cognitive Behavioral<br />
Therapy for CRPS<br />
Participants gather at the Mall <strong>of</strong> <strong>America</strong> in Minneapolis to raise awareness <strong>of</strong> RSD.<br />
Thank <strong>you</strong>! Thank <strong>you</strong>!<br />
By James W. Broatch, MSW, Executive Director<br />
12 The Use <strong>of</strong> Opiods in<br />
CRPS-related Pain<br />
14 Opiods for CRPS?<br />
Think again.<br />
16 How to Avoid Firing<br />
Your Lawyer<br />
18 Donations<br />
This newsletter is not intended<br />
to provide advice on personal<br />
medical matters, or to substitute<br />
for consultation with a physician.<br />
On behalf <strong>of</strong> the Board <strong>of</strong><br />
Directors <strong>of</strong> the <strong>Reflex</strong><br />
<strong>Sympathetic</strong> <strong>Dystrophy</strong><br />
Syndrome <strong>Association</strong> and staff, I want to<br />
<strong>thank</strong> everyone who donated to help fund<br />
our educational program for occupational<br />
and physical therapists. Together we<br />
raised more than $50,000! We are in<br />
the process <strong>of</strong> signing a contract for the<br />
production <strong>of</strong> the DVD this month.<br />
We asked our membership to consider<br />
making at least a $5 gift: 557<br />
individuals responded (more than 9<br />
percent <strong>of</strong> our membership). Donations<br />
ranged from $1 to $10,000. Bernie<br />
Ackerman <strong>of</strong> Bethlehem raised $5,000<br />
by running a ½ Marathon <strong>of</strong> Hope on<br />
behalf <strong>of</strong> his 15-year-old daughter Liz,<br />
who developed CRPS while playing<br />
baseball for her high school.<br />
Jeanie Moser from Missouri wrote<br />
“Having had RSD twice now, in<br />
both <strong>of</strong> my hands, I am so grateful<br />
for my OT therapist. I literally would<br />
not be able to use my left hand if he<br />
had not worked with me. He did his<br />
own research. It was a painful time,<br />
but it worked.”<br />
(Continued on page 3)
Board <strong>of</strong> Directors<br />
James E. Tyrrell, Jr. Esq.<br />
Chairman <strong>of</strong> the Board<br />
Paul Charlesworth, CPCU<br />
President<br />
Mary Beth Kenny Ludington<br />
Patient Representative/Secretary<br />
Donald F. McKee<br />
Treasurer<br />
Rebecca C. Amoroso<br />
Bradley S. Galer, MD<br />
Wilson H. Hulley<br />
Disability Advocate<br />
Linda Lang<br />
Pierre LeRoy, MD<br />
Donald C. Manning, MD, PhD<br />
Betty Maul<br />
Peter A. Moskovitz, MD<br />
Idamarie Scimeca Duffy<br />
James W. Broatch, MSW<br />
Executive Director and Newsletter Editor<br />
Tel: (203) 877-3790<br />
Toll free: (877) 662-7737<br />
Email: info@ rsds.org<br />
RSDSA website<br />
www.rsds.org<br />
Newsletter Managing Editor:<br />
Debra Nelson-Hogan<br />
Email: Newsletter@rsds.org<br />
Editorial Assistant:<br />
Katie L. Aker<br />
RSD has been assigned the code<br />
number 337.2. It has been classified<br />
into four categories:<br />
(1) 337.20 – unspecified site<br />
(2) 337.29 – other specified site<br />
(3) 337.21 – upper extremity<br />
(4) 337 – lower extremity<br />
How to give to RSDSA through the United Way<br />
RSDSA is a partner in the combined<br />
Federal campaign. Our designation<br />
number is #11045.<br />
Working to raise awareness <strong>of</strong> reflex<br />
sympathetic dystrophy syndrome<br />
(RSD) and complex regional pain<br />
syndrome (CRPS) since 1984.<br />
As many <strong>of</strong> <strong>you</strong> know, November is<br />
CRPS Awareness month, and this year<br />
has been particularly jam-packed with<br />
events. On November 6, I went to Somerset<br />
Medical Center in New Jersey<br />
to attend a meeting <strong>of</strong> the wonderful<br />
support group Living with RSDS. Their<br />
president, Sharon Weiner, had arranged<br />
for a special guest speaker to address<br />
the group. The speaker was Mike<br />
Roman, a former surgical assistant,<br />
who at 27 had knee surgery following<br />
a basketball injury. Unfortunately, he<br />
developed MRSA, the devastating staph<br />
infection that has recently been in the<br />
news. Despite multiple surgeries to remove<br />
the infection, Mike was forced to<br />
undergo an above-the-knee amputation.<br />
After surgery, he developed phantom<br />
limb pain, with many <strong>of</strong> his symptoms<br />
similar to those <strong>of</strong> CRPS.<br />
Mike spoke quite movingly about his<br />
long journey <strong>of</strong> debilitating pain, depression,<br />
financial difficulties and withdrawal<br />
from family and friends. Feeling that<br />
he had become a burden to his family,<br />
he briefly considered suicide. His wife’s<br />
support remained constant, and he fortunately<br />
ended up at a pain specialist who<br />
urged him to try a new type <strong>of</strong> spinal<br />
cord stimulator. This decision proved to<br />
be the turning point for him. A devoted<br />
husband and father, he is now pursuing<br />
his dream <strong>of</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essional racecar driving,<br />
and is aiming for the Indy 500. His<br />
courage and indomitable spirit were an<br />
inspiration to all <strong>of</strong> us, and <strong>you</strong> can read<br />
his story at raceagainstpain.com.<br />
News From<br />
the Patient<br />
Representative<br />
By Mary Beth Kenny Ludington<br />
The next big event was the Bounty <strong>of</strong><br />
Hope on November 14. Always a fun<br />
evening, it is also an important one, as<br />
it raises both money and awareness.<br />
Proceeds from the dinner and silent<br />
auction fund many <strong>of</strong> RSDSA’s awareness<br />
projects. This year’s honoree was<br />
Dr. Joshua Prager, who utilized a PowerPoint<br />
® presentation to graphically<br />
depict the symptoms <strong>of</strong> CRPS to the<br />
audience. He also described the success<br />
<strong>of</strong> the comprehensive multidisciplinary<br />
treatment program he directs at the<br />
Center for the Rehabilitation <strong>of</strong> Pain<br />
Syndromes at UCLA.<br />
The month ended with Jim Broatch<br />
and board member Dr. Peter Moskovitz<br />
accepting an invitation from the Korean<br />
Pain Society and the Korean CRPS<br />
<strong>Association</strong> to speak at their conference.<br />
They also visited with some <strong>of</strong><br />
the foremost CRPS experts in Europe<br />
at the Neuropathic Pain Consortium<br />
in the Netherlands. Their visit enabled<br />
them to examine the state <strong>of</strong> emerging<br />
research across the globe, to explore the<br />
possibility <strong>of</strong> collaboration on a study<br />
<strong>of</strong> the long-term effects <strong>of</strong> CRPS and to<br />
forge important relationships with leaders<br />
in the field in other countries. I was<br />
tremendously impressed by the fact that<br />
they accepted the invitation knowing<br />
that they would have to miss Thanksgiving<br />
with their families. That level <strong>of</strong><br />
dedication and commitment gives us<br />
ALL something to be grateful for this<br />
holiday season! n<br />
2 RSDSA Review: Vol. 20, Issue 3
(Continued from page 1)<br />
The Puerto Rico Occupational Therapy<br />
<strong>Association</strong> sent $50. Your kind notes<br />
and words <strong>of</strong> encouragement were very<br />
heart warming. Together, we are making<br />
a difference.<br />
In October, the MN RSDS/CRPS Coalition<br />
sponsored its second walk-a-thon to raise<br />
money for CRPS research. More than 40<br />
individuals from Minnesota, Wisconsin, and<br />
as far away as Connecticut, participated and<br />
thus far, we have raised more than $10,000!<br />
I want to <strong>thank</strong> Bonnie Scherer, Linda<br />
Loudermill, Barbara VanKeuren, and the<br />
MN RSDS/CRPS Coalition for their hard<br />
work and dedication.<br />
In three major walks (two <strong>of</strong> the walks<br />
were cosponsored with the Achilles Track<br />
Club), RSDSA raised $40,000, a little<br />
more than in 2006. We know that the CRPS<br />
community has the potential for promoting<br />
much greater public awareness and research<br />
dollars. In 2008, we hope to raise more than<br />
$100,000 for CRPS research. With <strong>you</strong>r<br />
help, we will succeed. n<br />
Thanksgiving<br />
By Paul R. Charlesworth<br />
President, RSDSA Board <strong>of</strong> Directors<br />
During this season <strong>of</strong> Thanksgiving and joy it is easy<br />
to forget those who suffer in silence from CRPS. So<br />
many go undiagnosed, untreated, undertreated,<br />
can’t afford treatment, can’t resolve conflicts, don’t<br />
get understanding or support from friends or family,<br />
don’t get insurance reimbursement, get despondent<br />
and try suicide. I want <strong>you</strong> to know how much Jim<br />
Broatch ,our executive director, Gayle Bonavita our<br />
administrative assistant, our entire board, and our<br />
many volunteers around the country want to help.<br />
Call us if <strong>you</strong> need help or if <strong>you</strong> know someone<br />
else who does…help us with that first step <strong>of</strong><br />
communication.<br />
We are a small organization, but we have grown and<br />
we are very determined to continue with our mission<br />
<strong>of</strong> support, information, and search for effective<br />
treatments and a cure as soon as possible. Most<br />
who interact with RSDSA have little sense <strong>of</strong> the<br />
board <strong>of</strong> directors or our two wonderful full-time<br />
employees. Their <strong>thank</strong>s is in what they accomplish<br />
for <strong>you</strong> and the organization. During this season, I<br />
would like to <strong>thank</strong> them and urge all <strong>of</strong> <strong>you</strong> who read<br />
this to <strong>thank</strong> them in any way <strong>you</strong> find appropriate<br />
as well. All <strong>of</strong> our Board members serve as day-today<br />
workers for RSDSA, not just members <strong>of</strong> the<br />
governing body. Most <strong>of</strong> all I would like <strong>you</strong> to know<br />
how very motivated they are to succeed and help find<br />
a cure. Take hope in their work and the work <strong>of</strong> the<br />
many researchers who now work in the field <strong>of</strong> CRPS.<br />
Last, I would like <strong>you</strong> to know that we are going in<br />
some new directions to help. Rather than simply<br />
reviewing research proposals submitted to us, we are<br />
now funding a long-term research proposal with the<br />
help <strong>of</strong> a very generous benefactor family and we are<br />
raising money to fund conferences to help establish<br />
the best data about incidents <strong>of</strong> CRPS and best<br />
treatment approaches. As we expand our mission<br />
we need <strong>you</strong>r financial support and <strong>you</strong>r volunteer<br />
support more than ever. Please help us provide more<br />
help and research…talk it up with people <strong>you</strong> know,<br />
especially friends and family. Please accept our best<br />
wishes for a jo<strong>you</strong>s holiday season. n<br />
Join RSDSA<br />
People who join RSDSA are not content<br />
to be victims, but take an active role in our goals <strong>of</strong><br />
education, awareness, and research. Our members<br />
are people like <strong>you</strong>-patients, family and friends,<br />
healthcare pr<strong>of</strong>essionals, attorneys, and business<br />
people who understand the devastating effects <strong>of</strong><br />
CRPS and want to make a difference. Your RSDSA<br />
membership is important. There is power in numbers<br />
and we would like to see our membership, currently<br />
more than 7,000, double so that when we talk to<br />
the legislature, the pharmaceutical companies,<br />
and medical associations, our voice is strong and<br />
our message is clear.<br />
As a member, <strong>you</strong> have a forum to communicate <strong>you</strong>r<br />
concerns, share <strong>you</strong>r experiences, and learn about<br />
the most recent advances in treatment and research.<br />
Fill our the membership application and join today!<br />
Yes! I would like to be a member<br />
and support RSDSA<br />
❑ Patient (US) $15 ❑ Patient (outside US) $25<br />
❑ Can’t afford membership<br />
Name<br />
Address<br />
❑ Additional donation<br />
City State Zip<br />
Phone<br />
email<br />
❑ Please send me information on starting a support group.<br />
For credit card orders, please complete:<br />
❑ Visa ❑ MasterCard ❑ <strong>America</strong>n Express<br />
Card Number<br />
exp. Date<br />
Signature<br />
Please make check or money order in $US payable to<br />
RSDSA. Mail <strong>you</strong>r check with this form to:<br />
RSDSA, 99 Cherry Street, PO Box 502, Milford, CT, 06460<br />
3
RSDSANEWSRSDSANEWSRSDSANEWS<br />
Minneapolis Walk for<br />
a Cure<br />
On October 29th, approximately 50<br />
people met at 7:00 am in the Macy’s<br />
Court at the famous Mall <strong>of</strong> <strong>America</strong> in<br />
Minneapolis for the 2007 RSD Awareness<br />
Walk for a Cure. Linda Loudermill,<br />
Barbara Van Keuren, and Bonnie Scherer<br />
organized the walk, which raised more<br />
than $10,000.<br />
Brian Hicks with his wife Teresa and his sons Joel (on the left), and Justin during the New York Marathon<br />
in November.<br />
RSDer Member <strong>of</strong> the<br />
New York Marathon<br />
Freedom Team<br />
Brian Hicks, who has suffered with<br />
CRPS for nearly 10 years, was invited<br />
to be a member <strong>of</strong> the Freedom Team <strong>of</strong><br />
Wounded Veterans and participate using<br />
a hand cycle in the New York Marathon<br />
on November 4th. Veterans were flown<br />
to New York from all over the country<br />
to participate in the marathon with the<br />
Freedom Team. Brian finished the<br />
marathon in 2 hours and 26 minutes.<br />
The Freedom Team is a part <strong>of</strong> Achilles,<br />
an organization that supports athletes with<br />
disabilities. Brian learned about the Freedom<br />
Team through the RSDSA website’s<br />
information on the Achilles Walks. In fact,<br />
he was a medalist at the Achilles Walk in<br />
Atlanta last June.<br />
The Freedom Team consists <strong>of</strong> veterans<br />
who range from those who were injured<br />
in Iraq just a few months ago to those<br />
wounded in Vietnam.<br />
Brian was diagnosed with CRPS several<br />
years ago, but it had gone into remission.<br />
It returned with a vengeance after he was<br />
involved in a HumVee accident in Iraq.<br />
He was ultimately discharged and is<br />
currently on disability.<br />
Brian said the New York event was wonderful<br />
and as an added bonus, Achilles<br />
gave him the hand cycle he used for “as<br />
long as he wants it.” He plans to participate<br />
in the Miami Marathon at the end <strong>of</strong><br />
January and will surely be taking part in<br />
the Atlanta Achilles Run in 2008.<br />
Dr. Peter Moskovitz presents Chan Kim, MD, PhD,<br />
President <strong>of</strong> the Korean Pain Society with a copy<br />
<strong>of</strong> “Living With RSDS”, which he co-authored<br />
with Linda Lang.<br />
People who participated in the Minneapolis Walk<br />
for a Cure and Awareness raised more than<br />
$10,000 for research.<br />
RSDSA Honored by Korean<br />
CRPS Patients <strong>Association</strong><br />
In late November, Jim Broatch, RSDSA<br />
executive director and Peter Moskovitz,<br />
MD, a member <strong>of</strong> the RSDSA Board<br />
<strong>of</strong> Directors, were the guests <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Korean CRPS Patients <strong>Association</strong> at<br />
the annual meeting <strong>of</strong> the Korean Pain<br />
Society in Seoul. Both gentlemen gave<br />
presentations to the Pain Society. In<br />
addition, they met with a group <strong>of</strong> pain<br />
practitioners and principal organizers<br />
<strong>of</strong> the Pain Society as well as representatives<br />
<strong>of</strong> various pharmaceutical and<br />
medical device companies.<br />
4 RSDSA Review: Vol. 20, Issue 3
RSDSANEWSRSDSANEWSRSDSANEWS<br />
Rock Out To Knock Out RSD<br />
“Imagine a day, an hour, or even a minute<br />
without pain; that is what we are fighting<br />
so hard for...”<br />
This statement is true for CRPS sufferers<br />
everywhere, but Ashley Goodall has taken<br />
her fight into another direction. In 2006,<br />
Ashley founded ‘Rock Out To Knock Out<br />
RSDS, Inc.,’ a non-pr<strong>of</strong>it organization<br />
meant to raise awareness and money for<br />
CRPS research through concerts with<br />
local bands, drawings, and donations.<br />
Dr. Joshua Prager receives the Clinical Excellence Award from Jim Broatch.<br />
2007 Bounty <strong>of</strong> Hope<br />
On November 14th, a little more than<br />
200 people gathered at the Union League<br />
Club in New York City for the 9th Annual<br />
Bounty <strong>of</strong> Hope Silent Auction and<br />
Fundraising Dinner. Joshua Prager,<br />
MD, MS, the director <strong>of</strong> the Center for<br />
Rehabilitation <strong>of</strong> Pain Syndromes (CRPS)<br />
at UCLA Medical Plaza, was the keynote<br />
speaker and recipient <strong>of</strong> a Clinical<br />
Excellence Award. Next year’s dinner is<br />
scheduled for November 12, 2008.<br />
Guests at the 2007 Bounty <strong>of</strong> Hope check out the silent auction items. Daria and Paul Charlesworth<br />
chat with Barbara Schaffer during the auction.<br />
The 16-year-old high school student from<br />
Bakersfield, California was diagnosed<br />
with CRPS when she was 8. Before<br />
Ashley was diagnosed, she spent 7 years<br />
visiting over 10 doctors, and almost had<br />
her arm amputated due to a misdiagnosis.<br />
At one point, the pain was so excruciating<br />
that she stopped going to school. Some<br />
people even started to think she was<br />
making up her syndrome, increasing the<br />
frustration <strong>of</strong> Ashley’s loved ones.<br />
Although the idea had been several years in<br />
the making, Ashley raised $5000 at the first<br />
Rock Out concert last October. This year<br />
she raised $3000 even before the concert<br />
in San Luis Obispo, from people who just<br />
wanted to help Ashley and her cause. Half<br />
<strong>of</strong> the proceeds go towards future concerts,<br />
such as the next one in Los Angeles.<br />
Money raised by Rock Out in the past has<br />
gone towards a RSDSA walk, medical<br />
equipment for a CRPS patient, research<br />
for the Pediatric Pain Program at the<br />
University <strong>of</strong> California Los Angeles<br />
Mattel Children’s Hospital, and raising<br />
awareness. For more information on<br />
Rock Out To Knock Out RSDS, Inc.,<br />
visit www.tkorsds.org. n<br />
5
Mailbag<br />
October 14, 2007<br />
I am an RSD patient who, after failing all<br />
protocols that I tried in the United States,<br />
sought treatment through Traditional<br />
Chinese Medicine in China in March<br />
<strong>of</strong> 2007. By July 2007, I was pain free.<br />
The enclosed story tells <strong>of</strong> my journey<br />
to China and my amazing recovery from<br />
the pain <strong>of</strong> RSD. I am currently pain free<br />
and working full-time in the hospital<br />
where I was treated. I am currently<br />
working and living in China, but travel<br />
to the United States several times a year<br />
to visit my family. I will be in North<br />
Carolina again this spring. The dates for<br />
my spring trip are not yet set.<br />
I am interested in working with U.S.<br />
and international RSD patients, RSD<br />
associations, and other organizations that<br />
want to know <strong>of</strong> the pr<strong>of</strong>ound changes<br />
resulting from my treatment. I believe this<br />
treatment will work for others who suffer<br />
from the agonizing pain <strong>of</strong> this disease.<br />
I have included my story with this letter.<br />
Thank <strong>you</strong> for <strong>you</strong>r consideration.<br />
Sincerely,<br />
John Lauritzen<br />
JOHN’S STORY<br />
My RSD developed after a lisfranc fracture<br />
<strong>of</strong> the left foot. Foot surgery was<br />
required and I had no problems postsurgery.<br />
Three weeks following surgery<br />
I developed severe, unrelenting pain and<br />
was sent to the Arnold Pain Management<br />
Center at Beth Israel Hospital in Boston.<br />
Doctors there diagnosed me with RSD and<br />
were hopeful, since the disease was in the<br />
early stages, that the pain management<br />
team could relieve my pain. Over the next<br />
six months I had sympathetic blocks, epidural<br />
steroid injections, epidural infusions,<br />
a spinal cord stimulation trial, narcotic<br />
trials. None <strong>of</strong> the procedures gave me<br />
permanent pain relief. Relief from some<br />
<strong>of</strong> these procedures lasted hours, others,<br />
days. Before I developed RSD, I lived independently<br />
in an apartment in the Boston<br />
area. The apartment was just a three-block<br />
walk from the train. Now that I had RSD,<br />
I could see the train from my apartment<br />
window, hear it, but was no longer able to<br />
use it. I went from being an independent<br />
adult to wheelchair-bound. Shopping for<br />
groceries, getting a haircut, even doing<br />
laundry, required assistance.<br />
Following one last procedure, my doctors<br />
advised me to return to live near my family<br />
where I could receive assistance and<br />
seek help from Duke Medical Center in<br />
Raleigh, North Carolina.<br />
I returned to Asheville to live with my<br />
mother and stepfather, and began seeing<br />
doctors at Duke and several pain centers<br />
in Asheville. By now I was using narcotics<br />
to manage my pain. Nothing else gave<br />
me relief. I took pain pills all day long and<br />
kept increasing the amount <strong>of</strong> medication<br />
just to get the same effect. Along with pain<br />
meds, sleep meds were prescribed so that<br />
I could sleep three hours at a stretch each<br />
night. My foot became so sensitive that I<br />
couldn’t tolerate the weight <strong>of</strong> a sheet on<br />
it. I took pain meds in order to tolerate the<br />
discomfort <strong>of</strong> putting on my shoes.<br />
All these medications had side effects.<br />
They made me unsteady on my feet the<br />
days I wasn’t in a wheelchair or using<br />
a cane. I fell repeatedly. The falls led to<br />
further anxiety about reinjuring my foot.<br />
I was deconditioned from being in a<br />
wheelchair and tired easily. Doctors’ appointments<br />
filled my life. I saw a neurologist,<br />
internist, psychotherapist, psychiatrist,<br />
physical therapist and pain management<br />
doctor. Riding in a car, albeit one<br />
with excellent suspension, felt as if road<br />
vibrations drove stabbing pain through<br />
my foot. My mother and stepfather put<br />
8,000 miles on their cars from November<br />
until March driving me to and from medical<br />
appointments. Occasionally, I could<br />
work in alternative medicine appointment<br />
in between other medical appointments.<br />
I tried acupuncture, Reikki and meditation.<br />
I went to a local acupuncturist and<br />
the treatments he gave helped at first, and<br />
then failed to touch my pain.<br />
The following spring, I made a desperate<br />
attempt to live on my own again. I hated<br />
being dependent and wanted have my own<br />
life. I moved into an apartment one halfhour<br />
away from my family and attempted<br />
to use the city disability van services to<br />
transport me to my appointments. I signed<br />
up for online for college courses, hoping to<br />
get back to school. Several months later, I<br />
was back at my mother’s house. I couldn’t<br />
manage on my own. I met with the pain<br />
management team at Duke and a pain<br />
management neurosurgeon. Duke doctors<br />
told me that they could not help me as my<br />
other neurological conditions could inter-<br />
6 RSDSA Review: Vol. 20, Issue 3
fere with any further treatments. No one<br />
seemed to know what to do for RSD.<br />
It was all I could do now to dress myself<br />
or focus long enough to listen to a book on<br />
tape. I no longer had the ability to concentrate<br />
well enough to read. My foot became<br />
frozen in place. I had limited mobility, despite<br />
physical therapy from skilled therapists<br />
with knowledge <strong>of</strong> RSD. My doctors<br />
told me I’d gotten back all the function I<br />
was going to get. My weight skyrocketed<br />
from multiple medications and lack <strong>of</strong><br />
mobility. I felt isolated with RSD. I spent<br />
more and more time in my bedroom when<br />
I wasn’t seeing doctors or going to physical<br />
therapy, feeling hopeless and stuck.<br />
My depression increased.<br />
The acupuncturist who had treated me<br />
called me and told me about an article he’d<br />
read in Stroke Survivor Magazine. It was<br />
about a program called China Connection<br />
and he urged me to try it. I was afraid to<br />
leave what was familiar: my doctors who,<br />
even though they weren’t finding solutions<br />
for me, were compassionate. I’d never<br />
been so far away tram everything familiar.<br />
I was fearful <strong>of</strong> what <strong>of</strong> what the cabin<br />
pressure in an airplane would do to increase<br />
my foot pain. Traveling by air from<br />
Boston to Asheville, a two and a half hour<br />
trip, had been horribly painful. How would<br />
I manage a thirteen hour plane trip?<br />
My family encouraged me to consider<br />
trying Traditional Chinese Medicine that<br />
was <strong>of</strong>fered at Tianjin Regional Medical<br />
Center in China. Even though I’d been to<br />
the best pain management centers in the<br />
country it was clear I wasn’t improving.<br />
My doctors didn’t say no to my going,<br />
but they were concerned about whether<br />
I could receive a guarantee <strong>of</strong> recovery;<br />
I could not. When I was accepted in the<br />
program the doctors told me they would<br />
do all they could to help me. Faced with<br />
the last option in the US, placement <strong>of</strong> a<br />
morphine pump in my body, I decided to<br />
go to China. I was willing to try anything<br />
to get rid <strong>of</strong> the agonizing pain. If the<br />
doctors had told me to jump five feet in<br />
the air I think I would have tried.<br />
I traveled to China in March 2007. At<br />
first the staff at Tianjin Medical Center<br />
was perplexed. They’d never seen RSD before,<br />
but had great success with movement<br />
disorders from stroke and other neurological<br />
disorders. I began an intensive program<br />
<strong>of</strong> acupuncture, herbal soaks, vigorous<br />
massage called tuina, exercise therapy,<br />
and herbs six hours a day six days a week.<br />
It was slow medicine. When I spoke to<br />
my family in the US, I joked with them<br />
that the two words I heard most from the<br />
Chinese doctors were “rest” and “later”. I<br />
lived in a hospital setting with <strong>America</strong>n<br />
and international patients, all <strong>of</strong> whom<br />
were experiencing this same challenging<br />
program. Three weeks after I arrived I<br />
emailed my family to tell them <strong>of</strong> the first<br />
miracle, I had regained full mobility <strong>of</strong> my<br />
frozen foot. I gave up my cane. Over the<br />
next months I saw other changes: I began<br />
to sleep through the night, I lost weight, I<br />
had days when my pain was manageable.<br />
I went on several outings and began to<br />
socialize again. Soon, I was going to the<br />
gym six days a week walking on a treadmill,<br />
riding an exercise bike. I rediscovered<br />
laughter. Before I left the hospital in<br />
June I took a six hour bus trip to the Great<br />
Wall and climbed the hundred steps with<br />
the other stroke survivors on that trip.<br />
“I’m grateful I took the risk to<br />
find an answer to this cruel<br />
and perplexing disease, RSD.”<br />
By the time I left the hospital I was able<br />
to sleep through the night. I’d stopped all<br />
pain medications. I’d lost forty pounds.<br />
My depression diminished. I began working<br />
in the community room at the hospital,<br />
opening and closing the room for the<br />
<strong>America</strong>n staff and providing programs for<br />
international patients there several nights<br />
a week. It was exhilarating to be <strong>of</strong> use to<br />
others, to be productive again.<br />
Today I am pain free most days, although<br />
weather changes can cause my foot to<br />
ache. I’m continuing to lose weight and<br />
I’m working in the hospital where I was<br />
a patient. I enjoy a good night’s sleep,<br />
regular exercise, and regained my prized<br />
independence. I’m grateful I took the risk<br />
to find an answer to this cruel and perplexing<br />
disease, RSD.<br />
7
Mailbag<br />
Dear Jim,<br />
Thanks for the story from John. He<br />
obviously made an impressive recovery<br />
and this is a story <strong>of</strong> hope.<br />
From the medical science point <strong>of</strong> view<br />
there are many pieces <strong>of</strong> info missing so<br />
this is at best an anecdotal case. But in<br />
reality, the experience <strong>of</strong> one person just<br />
confirms what we knew all along: that<br />
the best treatment for any chronic pain<br />
patient, including RSD sufferers, is a<br />
multidisciplinary comprehensive approach<br />
which is clearly outlined in John’s story.<br />
Another fact that is apparent here is that<br />
even though the physicians in China did<br />
not understand RSD, they treated the<br />
patient based on their best judgments and<br />
upon generally accepted principles. They<br />
key here is “intense therapy,” which is too<br />
<strong>of</strong>ten the missing link here in the US.<br />
How many times have we seen our enthusiastic<br />
approach to treating the condition<br />
frustrated by insurance and other third<br />
party restrictions?<br />
Notwithstanding the above, I think the<br />
program at the Tianjing Regional Medical<br />
Center deserves a second look, to see if<br />
they have other similar cases <strong>of</strong> success.<br />
There is definitely something we can<br />
learn from in this case.<br />
Best,<br />
Jeffrey Ngeow, MD<br />
Clinical Associate Pr<strong>of</strong>essor <strong>of</strong><br />
Anesthesiology, Weill Medical College<br />
<strong>of</strong> Cornell University<br />
Dear Jim:<br />
I hope this letter finds <strong>you</strong> well. Your<br />
commitment to this organization is astounding.<br />
There was no RSDSA when I<br />
was first diagnosed in May 1988. There<br />
were, but a few minuscule gripe groups.<br />
We were a haphazard bunch back in<br />
those days, who were just lucky to find<br />
each other and an ear to chew. You have<br />
diligently pulled us together, and instead<br />
<strong>of</strong> allowing us to weep and wallow in our<br />
despair, <strong>you</strong> have formed a loud, progressive<br />
and reverberating organization. You<br />
have put us on the medical and political<br />
maps. Thank <strong>you</strong>.<br />
A few days ago I received the latest<br />
edition <strong>of</strong> the RSDSA Review (Volume<br />
20, Issue 2). The Clinical Q and A with<br />
Dr. Prager hit an emotional button, and<br />
I felt I needed to share my own experience<br />
with pregnancy and RSD.<br />
In February 1992, after years <strong>of</strong> surgeries,<br />
oral and intravenous medications,<br />
psychologists, psychiatrists, occupational<br />
and physical therapies, experimental treatments…<br />
and on the advice <strong>of</strong> Dr. Robert<br />
Schwartzman (2 years earlier) I went<br />
ahead and had a morphine pump implanted.<br />
Needless to say, the morphine pump<br />
was in its infancy for RSD back then, but<br />
I also knew that my various oral medications,<br />
including a patch, were not allowing<br />
me to lead a life and be a participant <strong>of</strong><br />
any sort in my communities. The pump,<br />
which has not always been a smooth and<br />
reliable partner in life, later allowed me to<br />
marry and in 1994 become pregnant. Today<br />
I have a beautiful, sometimes arrogant<br />
and sassy preteen daughter, who would not<br />
be here without my morphine pump.<br />
I think Dr. Prager <strong>of</strong>fers some terrific<br />
advice, but did not discuss the possibility<br />
<strong>of</strong> the morphine pump. Do not think the<br />
pump let us imagine we were out <strong>of</strong> trouble.<br />
We spent tremendous time discussing<br />
our venture with Dr. Schwartzman, Dr.<br />
Howard Rosner, and various neonatal<br />
specialists as well as psychologists and<br />
high-risk OB-GYNs. We knew this would<br />
be considered a high risk pregnancy (I<br />
was 36 at the time, <strong>you</strong> do the math now),<br />
and had a birth plan in place as a cesarean<br />
would be necessary if I could not deliver<br />
naturally. I couldn’t take the chance<br />
<strong>of</strong> an epidural with my catheter. There<br />
was far greater concern for me than the<br />
baby, though he/she would be medically<br />
scrutinized. You should know, there was<br />
no information available at the time concerning<br />
RSD and pregnancy/delivery. I<br />
always did like the idea <strong>of</strong> being a leader.<br />
I have to assume that almost 13 years<br />
later we have more knowledge and experience<br />
to <strong>of</strong>fer women and couples who<br />
are considering pregnancy. The bigger<br />
concern is not only the effects <strong>of</strong> opiates<br />
on the fetus, but the effect <strong>of</strong> fertility in<br />
general. And as Dr. Prager points out,<br />
when deliberating parenthood, <strong>you</strong> must<br />
take into consideration <strong>you</strong>r health and<br />
pain management support system.<br />
No plan is perfect and life throws us sour<br />
cherries, but ultimately only the person<br />
can sort out the questions; the answers<br />
are never clear.<br />
Again, wishing <strong>you</strong> the best and hope to<br />
see <strong>you</strong> in the near future. n<br />
Regards,<br />
Laurie<br />
8 RSDSA Review: Vol. 20, Issue 3
My relationship with RSD has changed<br />
over time. Before I was diagnosed and<br />
was going from doctor to doctor, I was<br />
terribly frightened. I was experiencing<br />
intense pain and symptoms that made<br />
no sense either to me or to the doctors I<br />
was seeing. Finally after several years,<br />
I was given a diagnosis. I had a disease<br />
that some doctors knew about, that others<br />
were suffering from, and for which there<br />
were treatments available. Despite my<br />
suffering, I was hopeful.<br />
Just when I thought things couldn’t get<br />
any worse, I developed an autoimmune<br />
disease. The first obvious symptom was<br />
the pain from my RSD was the worst pain<br />
I could feel, but this was much worse. I<br />
have had many operations to clear away<br />
the gangrene, but unfortunately, the affected<br />
areas covering the initial site <strong>of</strong><br />
RSD will not heal, and I will need skin<br />
grafts. To my many RSD medications, I<br />
have now added prednisone and methotrexate;<br />
the methotrexate is an immunosuppressant<br />
drug used for cancer. It<br />
supresses the immune system and leaves<br />
<strong>you</strong> open to all kinds <strong>of</strong> infections.<br />
Armed with a diagnosis, I visited the web<br />
and found RSDSA. I went to a symposium<br />
in Atlantic City—it seems like eons<br />
ago—where I met others like myself,<br />
heard doctors speak about RSD, and connected<br />
to some very special people. My<br />
life was really beginning to look up, and<br />
for the first time I felt that I would find a<br />
doctor with a treatment plan to help me.<br />
When I finally found a doctor knowledgeable<br />
in RSD, I was amazed at how<br />
many treatment options were available.<br />
I read as much as I could. The RSDSA<br />
newsletter and website were invaluable.<br />
There were so many stories <strong>of</strong> others with<br />
RSD who, while not cured, were able to<br />
resume their former activities with much<br />
lower pain levels. If they could beat this<br />
thing, then so could I.<br />
As the years went by, I tried every treatment<br />
I could find, short <strong>of</strong> ketamine. Some<br />
would help for a day or so, and some not<br />
at all. Instead <strong>of</strong> getting better, things got<br />
worse. One day I woke up and realized<br />
that I was no longer 45, but somehow was<br />
now in my 60s. I was battling arthritis,<br />
severe osteoporosis and breaking bones.<br />
I spent long stretches in a wheel chair,<br />
although most <strong>of</strong> the time I used a walker.<br />
The RSD had spread to both legs and<br />
with the added years, having the energy to<br />
wheel myself around was getting harder.<br />
There were no longer new treatments to<br />
try, so maintaining an optimistic outlook<br />
became more and more difficult.<br />
When RSD Hits<br />
a New Phase<br />
By Linda Lang<br />
“My life was<br />
really beginning<br />
to look up, and<br />
for the first time<br />
I felt that I would<br />
find a doctor<br />
with a treatment<br />
plan to help me.”<br />
when I developed vasculitis on my legs.<br />
My body was attacking my own skin,<br />
becoming gangrenous and exposing the<br />
nerves in large areas where there was no<br />
longer skin to protect them. I had thought<br />
I now spend a lot <strong>of</strong> time in bed because<br />
walking is so difficult. My lungs have also<br />
become involved and dealing with both<br />
diseases can be overwhelming. I have only<br />
spoken to one other person who is dealing<br />
with the same issues I am. Not much data<br />
has been collected about what is happening<br />
to those who have long-standing RSD,<br />
and who are now into our 60s or older. I’m<br />
sure that there are others out there like me<br />
and I would sure love to hear from <strong>you</strong>.<br />
RSDSA has done a wonderful job supporting<br />
those who are newly diagnosed or<br />
have suffered for a few years. We can now<br />
gather information from those who have<br />
had RSD for over 10 years and have not<br />
found relief, and are experiencing the normal<br />
problems <strong>of</strong> aging, or developed other<br />
serious diseases. We can begin to have the<br />
same support for this segment <strong>of</strong> RSDer’s<br />
as well. We can share information on how<br />
each <strong>of</strong> us manages to cope (or not) with<br />
this new phase <strong>of</strong> RSD, which might go<br />
a long way to ease our suffering. It also<br />
can give doctors new information about<br />
the directions RSD takes to help us better.<br />
Please help us to help <strong>you</strong>. E-mail <strong>you</strong>r<br />
stories. Remember how <strong>you</strong> felt when <strong>you</strong><br />
were first diagnosed and got to meet or<br />
hear about others who were experiencing<br />
the same things as <strong>you</strong>. I know for me it<br />
eased the feeling <strong>of</strong> being alone in this<br />
battle, and gave me so much comfort and<br />
hope. With <strong>you</strong>r help, we could do the<br />
same thing again for those who are finding<br />
it so much harder to be hopeful! n<br />
9
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy<br />
for CRPS<br />
By Stephen Bruehl, PhD<br />
Patients with CRPS <strong>of</strong>ten are<br />
told by their physician that they<br />
might benefit from seeing a pain<br />
psychologist. Yet patients may wonder<br />
how seeing a psychologist could help<br />
them with their pain given that CRPS is<br />
clearly a physical problem.<br />
There are several targets for psychological<br />
intervention with CRPS, the most<br />
obvious <strong>of</strong> which is helping patients<br />
deal more effectively with the physical<br />
and emotional impact <strong>of</strong> CRPS in their<br />
lives. However, another key target <strong>of</strong><br />
treatment is learning to control the pain<br />
without drugs. Many patients initially<br />
have trouble believing this is even possible;<br />
nevertheless, research has clearly<br />
documented that for the majority <strong>of</strong><br />
chronic pain patients, emotional distress<br />
frequently intensifies the severity <strong>of</strong><br />
pain. This does not imply that the pain<br />
is psychological, but rather reflects the<br />
interconnections between the parts <strong>of</strong><br />
the brain that underlie emotions and<br />
the stress response, and the parts <strong>of</strong> the<br />
brain that regulate pain.<br />
These pain-exacerbating effects <strong>of</strong> distress<br />
are particularly important in CRPS,<br />
because the physiological mechanisms<br />
believed to contribute to the pain, color<br />
changes, and temperature changes all<br />
can, in theory, be directly affected by<br />
certain hormones (adrenalin) released<br />
during stress and emotional distress.<br />
While patients cannot control whether<br />
they have CRPS, they can learn techniques<br />
to control their stress responses,<br />
which in turn can reduce pain intensity.<br />
The most common approach to psychological<br />
treatment for chronic pain is<br />
Reframing helps<br />
patients learn<br />
to take the<br />
“glass half full”<br />
attitude towards<br />
their pain rather<br />
than the<br />
(more natural)<br />
“glass half empty”<br />
attitude..<br />
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT).<br />
Psychologists and other mental health<br />
practitioners who employ CBT typically<br />
use a variety <strong>of</strong> specific techniques. The<br />
goal <strong>of</strong> reducing pain intensity <strong>of</strong>ten<br />
can be achieved by learning relaxation<br />
techniques that reduce emotional<br />
distress and control the stress response.<br />
These may include breathing relaxation<br />
(slow patterned breathing), progressive<br />
muscle relaxation, and imagery<br />
(ie, creating a detailed mental image <strong>of</strong><br />
a relaxing place). The effectiveness <strong>of</strong><br />
these techniques <strong>of</strong>ten can be increased<br />
by combining them with bi<strong>of</strong>eedback, in<br />
which moment-by-moment changes in<br />
the body’s stress response (reflected in<br />
muscle tension or finger temperature),<br />
can be observed on a computer screen to<br />
help “fine tune” the relaxation response.<br />
The “cognitive” part <strong>of</strong> CBT refers to<br />
the fact that our emotional reactions to<br />
a given life situation are determined by<br />
what we think (“cognitions” is another<br />
term for thoughts). For example, consider<br />
two individuals asked to speak in<br />
front <strong>of</strong> a large audience. The first, with<br />
a fear <strong>of</strong> public speaking, immediately<br />
starts thinking, “If I mess this up, I’ll<br />
look like a fool!” and begins feeling<br />
very nervous. The second person is an<br />
actress, who thinks, “Great! An opportunity<br />
to perform” and feels excited.<br />
While the situation is identical, they<br />
respond with very different emotional<br />
reactions as a result <strong>of</strong> their styles <strong>of</strong><br />
thinking. The essence <strong>of</strong> CBT is that<br />
styles <strong>of</strong> thinking become habits (eg,<br />
the eternal optimist versus the chronic<br />
pessimist) and more importantly, these<br />
habits can be changed. CRPS <strong>of</strong>ten leads<br />
to more pessimistic thinking. Negative<br />
thoughts may intrude repeatedly, such<br />
as “Why can’t they cure this?;” “This<br />
is awful;” and “My life is over.” Such<br />
thoughts lead to chronic emotional<br />
distress, which reduces quality <strong>of</strong> life,<br />
can increase pain intensity, and may<br />
contribute to the development <strong>of</strong> clinical<br />
depression or anxiety disorders.<br />
Changing Negative Thought Patterns<br />
The CBT therapist helps patients learn to<br />
identify their habitual negative thoughts<br />
and consciously modify them in a way<br />
that is more constructive and produces<br />
10 RSDSA Review: Vol. 20, Issue 3
less distress. A patient may habitually<br />
respond to increased pain by thinking,<br />
“This pain is horrible and is never going<br />
to end,” and consequently may feel<br />
miserable. The CBT therapist would<br />
help the patient learn a way to reframe<br />
the problem <strong>of</strong> pain exacerbations. For<br />
example, responding to increased pain<br />
by actively saying to oneself, “This is an<br />
opportunity to use my relaxation techniques,<br />
I can handle this,” would lead<br />
to less distress and may in fact result in<br />
somewhat reduced pain.<br />
While CBT is clearly not a cure<br />
for CRPS, numerous research<br />
studies in patients with a variety<br />
<strong>of</strong> chronic pain conditions indicate<br />
that it is effective for improving<br />
pain, mood, and function.<br />
Reframing helps patients learn to take<br />
the “glass half full” attitude towards their<br />
pain rather than the (more natural) “glass<br />
half empty” attitude. Learning to recognize<br />
and avoid other problematic styles<br />
<strong>of</strong> thinking is also key, including the tendency<br />
to dwell on and magnify negative<br />
things, ignore good things, and generally<br />
“catastrophize” one’s situation. Other<br />
cognitive strategies used in CBT focus<br />
on recognizing what parts <strong>of</strong> the pain<br />
problem the patient can’t control (eg,<br />
having CRPS, having certain physical<br />
limitations, how employers respond), and<br />
focusing attention instead on the aspects<br />
<strong>of</strong> the pain problem that can be controlled,<br />
such as how the patient responds<br />
to pain and limitations. With repetition,<br />
this active countering <strong>of</strong> habitual negative<br />
thoughts with more constructive thoughts<br />
can create new habits <strong>of</strong> thinking that<br />
contribute to long-term improvements<br />
in quality <strong>of</strong> life.<br />
Behavioral Issues<br />
CBT <strong>of</strong>ten addresses behavioral issues as<br />
well. Due to pain and physical limitations,<br />
patients may over time engage less<br />
and less in their previous life activities.<br />
While this may reduce pain short-term,<br />
by avoiding activities that could potentially<br />
lead to pain exacerbations, it ultimately<br />
can lead to a situation in which<br />
patients have nothing to focus on BUT<br />
their pain. Finding distracting and enjoyable<br />
activities that can be done within<br />
the CRPS patient’s physical limitation is<br />
crucial for maintaining some sense <strong>of</strong> a<br />
“normal” and meaningful quality <strong>of</strong> life.<br />
CBT therapists <strong>of</strong>ten serve as a coach to<br />
help patients identify suitable activities<br />
and overcome any barriers to those activities<br />
resulting from CRPS. Often this<br />
is done in conjunction with physicians<br />
and physical or occupational therapists.<br />
The CBT therapist may use cognitive<br />
techniques like those above to address<br />
issues such as fear <strong>of</strong> pain and fear <strong>of</strong><br />
movement that may interfere with one’s<br />
ability to re-engage in life. Beyond quality-<strong>of</strong>-life<br />
issues, it is also important to<br />
note that leading CRPS medical experts<br />
believe that avoiding disuse <strong>of</strong> the affected<br />
limbs and maintaining as normal<br />
an activity level as possible are keys to<br />
successfully managing CRPS symptoms.<br />
While CBT is clearly not a cure for CRPS,<br />
numerous research studies in patients with<br />
a variety <strong>of</strong> chronic pain conditions indicate<br />
that it is effective for improving pain,<br />
mood, and function. CBT is a “self-management<br />
approach” to chronic pain; its<br />
techniques require patient effort for them<br />
to work and the focus is on managing,<br />
rather than curing, the condition. Patients<br />
focused exclusively on externally applied<br />
“cures” (eg, sympathetic blocks) are<br />
unlikely to benefit from CBT until they<br />
are willing to alter this treatment focus.<br />
Some patients may feel that CBT’s implied<br />
focus on acceptance <strong>of</strong> their chronic<br />
pain, and working within this, means that<br />
they are “giving up the fight” and that<br />
this will reduce the possibility <strong>of</strong> a cure.<br />
However, CBT is actually emphasizing<br />
the focus on battles that are winnable<br />
in order to win the larger war, to have a<br />
better quality <strong>of</strong> life. Appropriate medical<br />
and functional therapy treatments typically<br />
continue while patients are engaged<br />
in CBT, with the hope that these treatments<br />
will all work together to produce<br />
the desired outcome.<br />
Once CBT pain management skills are<br />
learned, they can be applied any time and<br />
in any situation. Thus, the patient always<br />
has effective pain management tools. In<br />
many people, CBT can effectively reduce<br />
the reliance on medications and other<br />
medical interventions and live a fulfilling<br />
life despite CRPS. If <strong>you</strong> are interested in<br />
pursuing CBT pain management treatment,<br />
<strong>you</strong> should discuss this possibility<br />
with <strong>you</strong>r medical provider.<br />
Stephen Bruehl, PhD, is an Associate<br />
Pr<strong>of</strong>essor <strong>of</strong> Anesthesiology at<br />
Vanderbilt University School <strong>of</strong><br />
Medicine in Nashville, Tennessee.<br />
Dr. Bruehl serves on the RSDSA<br />
Scientific Advisory Board. n<br />
11
As with any neuropathic pain syndrome,<br />
the response to CRPS treatment varies<br />
with each patient. Treatment can involve<br />
interventional techniques (sympathetic<br />
blocks, spinal cord stimulation, analgesics)<br />
or medications (adjuvants antidepressants,<br />
anticonvulsants, bisphosphonates,<br />
muscle relaxants, Beta 2 blockers, local<br />
anesthetics, opioids etc.) 1 . For patients<br />
with poorly-controlled pain at the time <strong>of</strong><br />
evaluation, opioids should be considered<br />
earlier in the treatment plan.<br />
Overview<br />
The use <strong>of</strong> opioids to treat neuropathic<br />
pain is controversial 2,3 . Arner and Meyerson<br />
found that infusions <strong>of</strong> morphine<br />
long-term opioid use, as well as using both<br />
an opioid and an adjuvant in treatment (11) .<br />
Gilron et al’s double-blind clinical trial<br />
showed that gabapentin and morphine<br />
extended-release are more effective when<br />
combined with an opioid individually, suggesting<br />
a potential analgesic effect 12 .<br />
Methadone<br />
Methadone has received significant attention<br />
lately due to its prolonged half-life,<br />
potency, and low cost. Methadone works<br />
well with μ and δ opioid receptors and<br />
blocks the N-methyl-D-aspartic acid<br />
(NMDA) receptor, suggesting that it can<br />
help manage neuropathic pain when<br />
hyperalgesia is present 13 . Randomized<br />
(ECG) should be done initially and after<br />
adding these medications.<br />
Tramadol<br />
Another opioid <strong>of</strong> interest is tramadol,<br />
which produces additional analgesic<br />
effects by blocking the reuptake <strong>of</strong> serotonin,<br />
a neurotransmitter involved in<br />
the control <strong>of</strong> pain perception, sleep, and<br />
mood, and norepinephrine, a neurotransmitter<br />
that increases the heart rate, blood<br />
pressure, and blood sugar level 21 .<br />
A randomized study <strong>of</strong> individuals with<br />
painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy<br />
showed that tramadol relieves spontaneous<br />
pain and allodynia more effectively<br />
than placebo 22 . Caution should be used in<br />
The Use <strong>of</strong> Opioids in CRPS-related Pain<br />
By Ricardo A. Cruciani, MD, PhD<br />
were ineffective in relieving neuropathic<br />
pain, but the study was flawed because<br />
<strong>of</strong> selection bias, small sample size, and<br />
lack <strong>of</strong> drug titration 4,5 . Subsequent<br />
evidence suggests that opioids might be<br />
effective in treating neuropathic pain.<br />
Trials for postherpetic neuralgia demonstrate<br />
the analgesic benefits <strong>of</strong> morphine<br />
and oxycodone, while in studies with<br />
patients with non-malignant neuropathic<br />
pain, a fentanyl citrate injection can provide<br />
better relief when compared with<br />
diazepam 6,7,8 . An open study on the use<br />
<strong>of</strong> fentanyl patches showed that few<br />
patients achieve lasting pain relief 9 .<br />
A retrospective study <strong>of</strong> individually titrated<br />
opioid infusions in patients with neuropathic<br />
pain indicates that pain relief can<br />
be achieved, but the ratio <strong>of</strong> opioid dose<br />
to patient response increases in people<br />
with neuropathic pain 10 . Recently, however,<br />
positive effects have been found with<br />
studies are lacking, but many reports suggest<br />
promising results with methadone in<br />
neuropathic pain 14-18 . Dose titration must<br />
be done cautiously, since large differences<br />
in the tolerance <strong>of</strong> different patients<br />
to methadone can cause drug toxicity 19 .<br />
There are also concerns about methadoneinduced<br />
cardiac toxicity and current literature<br />
is not conclusive. Although Krantz et<br />
al report a longer QTc interval than normal<br />
and Torsade de Pointes—a type <strong>of</strong> abnormal<br />
accelerated ventricular rhythm—with<br />
high doses <strong>of</strong> methadone, others could not<br />
confirm these findings 19 . It is also suggested<br />
that competitors <strong>of</strong> Cytochrome P450<br />
3A4 (CYP 3A4), an important enzymatic<br />
pathway for the disposal <strong>of</strong> methadone in<br />
the body and the Lkr current, a delayed<br />
purifying potassium current that allows<br />
the cardiac fibers to return to a normal<br />
state, could increase methadone toxicity 20 .<br />
In these patients, an electrocardiogram<br />
these patients when antidepressants are<br />
added. Selective serotonin reuptake<br />
inhibitors (SSRIs) could increase the<br />
risk for <strong>of</strong> a possibly fatal serotonin<br />
syndrome if they are mixed with monoamine<br />
oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs).<br />
Screening Tools<br />
The fear <strong>of</strong> drug addiction is probably<br />
our biggest concern 23 . Several tools have<br />
been developed to assess risk factors for<br />
drug addiction, including the Opioid Risk<br />
Tool (ORT), the Substance Abuse Screening<br />
Instrument, and the Prescription Drug<br />
Use Questionnaire (PDUQ) 23 . These tests<br />
help physicians develop risk assessment<br />
protocol for their practices and categorize<br />
patients according to their risk. Before<br />
opioids are started, a careful clinical history<br />
should be taken with special emphasis<br />
on drug addiction issues and a consultation<br />
with an addiction psychiatrist should be<br />
considered with high-risk patients 24 .<br />
12 RSDSA Review: Vol. 20, Issue 3
Conclusions<br />
These data suggest that although neuropathic<br />
pain may be less opioid-responsive<br />
than nociceptive pain, effective pain relief<br />
can be achieved by finding a dose that<br />
works for each patient. The potential for<br />
opioid side effects might be higher in<br />
patients with neuropathic pain because<br />
<strong>of</strong> the higher opioid doses required to<br />
relieve pain. The most common side<br />
effects are constipation and sedation,<br />
but urinary retention, itching, and respiratory<br />
depression are also reported.<br />
Drug tolerance that causes an increase in<br />
opioid dosage without disease progression<br />
is an argument against opioid use,<br />
and could be encountered in patients<br />
treated long-term with opioids as well as<br />
with short exposure to certain opioids.<br />
The strategy to overcoming tolerance<br />
is to safely titrate the opioid, to achieve<br />
an appropriate analgesic response, or to<br />
switching to a different opioid.<br />
The data on the analgesic efficacy <strong>of</strong> opioids<br />
in patients with CRPS are very limited.<br />
Some <strong>of</strong> the underlying mechanisms <strong>of</strong><br />
CRPS are common to several neuropathic<br />
pain syndromes, including postherpetic<br />
neuralgia and painful diabetic peripheral<br />
neuropathy, which are used most <strong>of</strong>ten for<br />
studying analgesic efficacy. These similarities<br />
justify the assumption <strong>of</strong> a similar<br />
response in patients with CRPS, but controlled<br />
trials are necessary to determine the<br />
efficacy in this patient population.<br />
Ricardo A. Cruciani, MD, PhD, is the<br />
Vice Chair and Director for the Research<br />
Division <strong>of</strong> the Department <strong>of</strong> Pain Medicine<br />
and Palliative Care at Beth Israel<br />
Medical Center in New York City and<br />
Assistant Pr<strong>of</strong>essor for the Departments<br />
<strong>of</strong> Neurology and Anesthesiology at the<br />
Albert Einstein College <strong>of</strong> Medicine <strong>of</strong><br />
Yeshiva University. n<br />
Glossary<br />
Anticonvulsants: medicines used to prevent or treat<br />
convulsions (seizures)<br />
Electrocardiogram: test that records the electrical<br />
activity <strong>of</strong> the heart<br />
Hyperalgesia: an enhanced intensity <strong>of</strong> pain<br />
sensation<br />
Nociceptive pain: pain caused by a painful stimulus<br />
Opioid: one <strong>of</strong> a group <strong>of</strong> synthetic sedative<br />
narcotics like opiates, but increasingly refers to<br />
all opium-like narcotics<br />
Painful Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy: most<br />
common complication <strong>of</strong> diabetes mellitus; a<br />
progressive disorder that results in a gradual<br />
decrease in peripheral sensation and eventually<br />
complete loss <strong>of</strong> sensation<br />
Postherpetic neuralgia: neuropathic pain condition<br />
caused by the varicella zoster virus in a dermatomal<br />
distribution (the area governed by a particular<br />
sensory nerve) after an attack <strong>of</strong> herpes zoster;<br />
commonly known as shingles<br />
Titration: method for figuring out the concentration<br />
<strong>of</strong> a substance by adding a measured amount <strong>of</strong><br />
solution, which allows the unknown concentration<br />
to be calculated<br />
References<br />
1. Mackey S, Feinberg S. Pharmacologic therapies<br />
for complex regional pain syndrome. Curr Pain<br />
Headache Rep. 2007;11(1):38-43. Review.<br />
2. Bruera E, Valero V, Driver L, et al. Patientcontrolled<br />
methylphenidate for cancer fatigue: a<br />
double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial.<br />
J Clin Oncol. 2006;24(13):2073-2078.<br />
3. Ballantyne JC, Mao J. Opioid therapy for chronic<br />
pain. N Engl J Med. 2003;349:1943-1953. Review.<br />
4. Arner S, Meyerson BA. Lack <strong>of</strong> analgesic effect<br />
<strong>of</strong> opioids on neuropathic and idiopathic forms <strong>of</strong><br />
pain. Pain. 1988;33:11-23.<br />
5. Dellemijn P. Are opioids effective in relieving<br />
neuropathic pain? Pain. 1999;80:453-62.<br />
6. Rowbotham MC, Reisner-Keller LA, Fields<br />
HL. Both intravenous lidocaine and morphine<br />
reduce the pain <strong>of</strong> postherpetic neuralgia. Neurol.<br />
1991;41:1024-8.<br />
7. Watson CPN, Babul N. Efficacy <strong>of</strong> oxycodone in<br />
neuropathic pain: a randomized trial in postherpetic<br />
neuralgia. Neurol. 1998;50(6):1837-41.<br />
8. Dellemijn PLI, Vanneste JAL. Randomised double-blind<br />
active-placebo-controlled crossover trial<br />
<strong>of</strong> intravenous fentanyl in neuropathic pain. Lancet.<br />
1997;349:753-758.<br />
9. Dellemijn PLI, van Duijn H, Vanneste JAL.<br />
Prolonged treatment with transdermal fentanyl<br />
in neuropathic pain. J Pain Sympt Manage.<br />
1998;16(4):220-229.<br />
10. Portenoy RK, Foley KM, Inturrisi CE. The<br />
nature <strong>of</strong> opioid responsiveness and its implications<br />
for neuropathic pain: new hypotheses derived from<br />
studies <strong>of</strong> opioid infusions. Pain. 1990;43:273-86.<br />
11. Gimbel JS, Richards P, Portenoy RK.<br />
Controlled-release oxycodone for pain in diabetic<br />
neuropathy: a randomized controlled trial.<br />
Neurology. 2003;60:927-934.<br />
12. Gilron I, Bailey JM, Tu D, Holden RR, Weaver<br />
DF, Houlden RL. Morphine, gabapentin, or their<br />
combination for neuropathic pain. N Engl J Med.<br />
2005;352:1324-1334.<br />
13. Bruera E, Neumann CM. Role <strong>of</strong> methadone in<br />
the management <strong>of</strong> pain in cancer patients. Oncol.<br />
1999;13(9):275-282.<br />
14. Makin MK, Ellershaw JE. Methadone can be<br />
used to manage neuropathic pain related to cancer.<br />
BMJ. 1998;317:81.<br />
15. Vigano A, Fan D, Bruera E. Individualized use<br />
<strong>of</strong> methadone and opioid rotation in the comprehensive<br />
management <strong>of</strong> cancer pain associated with<br />
poor prognostic indicators. Pain. 1996;67:115-119.<br />
16. Gagnon B, Bruera E. Differences in the ratios <strong>of</strong><br />
morphine to methadone in patients with neuropathic<br />
pain versus non-neuropathic pain. J Pain Sympt<br />
Manage. 1999;18(2):120–125.<br />
17. Gagnon B, Almahrezi A, Schreier G.Methadone<br />
in the treatment <strong>of</strong> neuropathic pain. Pain Res<br />
Manag. 2003;8(3):149-154.<br />
18. Morley J, Bridson J, Nash T, Miles J, White S,<br />
Makin M. Low-dose methadone has an analgesic<br />
effect in neuropathic pain: a double-blind randomized<br />
controlled crossover trial. Palliat Med.<br />
2003;17:576-587.<br />
19. Cruciani RA, Sekine R, Homel P, et al. QTc<br />
measurements in patients on methadone. J Pain<br />
Sympt Manag. 2005;29(4):385-391.<br />
20. Ehret GB, Desmeules JA, Broers B. Methadone-associated<br />
long QT syndrome: improving<br />
pharmacotherapy for dependence on illegal opioids<br />
and lessons learned for pharmacology. Expert Opin<br />
Drug Saf. 2007;6(3):289-303. Review.<br />
21. Raffa RB, Friderichs E, Reimann W, et al.<br />
Opioid and non-opioid components independently<br />
contribute to the mechanism <strong>of</strong> action <strong>of</strong> tramadol,<br />
an atypical opioid analgesic. J Pharmacol Exp Ther.<br />
1992;260:275-285.<br />
22. Sindrup SH, Andersen G, Madsen C, et al.<br />
Tramadol relieves pain and allodynia in polyneuropathy:<br />
a randomized, double-blind, controlled trial.<br />
Pain. 1999;83:85-90.<br />
23. Webster LR, Dove B. Avoid Opioid Abuse<br />
While Managing Pain: A Guide for Practitioners.<br />
North Branch, Minn: Sunrise River Press; 2007.<br />
24. Passik SD, Kirsh KL, Donaghy KB, Portenoy<br />
RK. Pain and aberrant drug-related behaviors in<br />
medically ill patients with and without histories <strong>of</strong><br />
substance abuse. Clin J Pain. 2006;22(2):173-181.<br />
13
evidence also suggests that neuropathic<br />
pain does not respond as well to opioids<br />
as nociceptive pain (pain from skin,<br />
muscles, joints) and <strong>of</strong>ten requires<br />
higher doses 15, 16 . Consequently,<br />
neuropathic pain states (especially the<br />
neuropathic component <strong>of</strong> CRPS) <strong>of</strong>ten<br />
require much higher doses <strong>of</strong> opioids,<br />
which in turn greatly increase the risk <strong>of</strong><br />
side effects and adverse events. Thus, a<br />
very careful and thoughtful analysis <strong>of</strong><br />
the risk (ie, side effects, adverse events,<br />
cost) to benefit (efficacy/effectiveness)<br />
ratio is critical in the decision to use<br />
opioids in CRPS.<br />
Opioids for CRPS? Think again.<br />
By R. Norman Harden, MD<br />
Whether or not to prescribe opioids<br />
for chronic and non-malignant pain<br />
conditions, such as CRPS, remains<br />
controversial 1-3 . After years <strong>of</strong><br />
thoughtless and over-aggressive use<br />
<strong>of</strong> these compounds for pain, most<br />
practitioners have become cautious,<br />
primarily due to the emergence <strong>of</strong> serious<br />
side effects and adverse events associated<br />
with chronic opioid therapy 3-6 . Although<br />
the quality <strong>of</strong> research addressing this<br />
clinical controversy has improved, there<br />
still have been no definitive studies<br />
performed 3,7,8 . Nonetheless, this class<br />
is sometimes used in complex regional<br />
pain syndrome (CRPS) as a “rescue”<br />
or an “as needed” medicine.<br />
One has to question when opioids are<br />
used in chronic pain maintenance and<br />
prophylaxis in CRPS (around-the-clock<br />
therapy) 9 . The standard for scientific<br />
evidence <strong>of</strong> any therapy in medicine<br />
is the Randomized Controlled Trial<br />
(RCT) and unfortunately, only one<br />
has been conducted evaluating the use<br />
<strong>of</strong> any opioid in CRPS. Harke et al<br />
studied controlled-release morphine<br />
in CRPS and reported no difference<br />
in pain reduction when compared to<br />
placebo. 11,12 . In other words, morphine<br />
did not relieve CRPS pain in this trial.<br />
More research is needed to definitively<br />
address this question, considering that<br />
the Harke trial was complicated and may<br />
have been underpowered 12 .<br />
There are a few high-quality studies<br />
<strong>of</strong> opioids for neuropathic pain that<br />
suggest marginal efficacy 13 . However,<br />
Since there is no evidence supporting<br />
the use <strong>of</strong> opioids in CRPS and the<br />
literature is not particularly supportive<br />
<strong>of</strong> opioids for CRPS, we must conclude<br />
the Efficacy/Effectiveness (benefit) part<br />
<strong>of</strong> this equation does not favor opioids<br />
in the CRPS population 9-12 . Opioids<br />
are clearly not a panacea, and there are<br />
many unresolved concerns about longterm<br />
efficacy in any chronic condition,<br />
efficacy in neuropathy, tolerance,<br />
cognitive impairment (especially with<br />
“rescue dosing” or initial titration),<br />
long-term toxicity and opioid-induced<br />
hyperalgesia 3,9 .<br />
Good practice and common sense<br />
requires that we critically and<br />
continuously assess the risks and side<br />
effects <strong>of</strong> opioid therapy in order to<br />
maintain that primal tenet <strong>of</strong> medicine<br />
and our Hippocratic Oath: “first do<br />
no harm.” Furthermore, our patients<br />
must be fully informed <strong>of</strong> the risks<br />
considering that there is no compelling<br />
research supporting the use <strong>of</strong> these<br />
compounds for CRPS.<br />
Side Effects <strong>of</strong> Opioid Therapy<br />
The many risks <strong>of</strong> opioid therapy are<br />
well known, from the very common<br />
occurrence <strong>of</strong> constipation and<br />
itchiness to the more recently-identified<br />
hypogonadism (shrunken testicles) 3,17 .<br />
14 RSDSA Review: Vol. 20, Issue 3
Since<br />
hyperalgesia<br />
is an important<br />
diagnostic and<br />
clinical feature<br />
<strong>of</strong> CRPS, it makes<br />
little sense to use<br />
a class <strong>of</strong> drugs<br />
that cause this<br />
symptom and sign<br />
for treatment<br />
<strong>of</strong> CPRS.<br />
Long-term cognitive impairment,<br />
personality changes, tolerance, and longterm<br />
toxicity are unresolved issues at the<br />
moment. Any general pharmacological<br />
reference, such as a recent edition <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Physicians’ Desk Reference, will have<br />
a good list <strong>of</strong> the problems associated<br />
with opioids. One particular side<br />
effect <strong>of</strong> opioid use in CRPS is opioidinduced<br />
hyperalgesia (increased pain<br />
perception) 18,19 . Since hyperalgesia is an<br />
important diagnostic and clinical feature<br />
<strong>of</strong> CRPS, it makes little sense to use a<br />
class <strong>of</strong> drugs that cause this symptom<br />
for treatment <strong>of</strong> CRPS. Thus,<br />
a CRPS patient on high-dose opioids<br />
may have a worsening <strong>of</strong> signs and<br />
symptoms due to opioid therapy. Simply<br />
said, high-dose chronic opioid therapy<br />
may make CRPS pain worse.<br />
Optimal CRPS care preferably entails<br />
the use <strong>of</strong> non-drug therapies, nonopioid<br />
medications for maintenance,<br />
and occasional opioids for crisis<br />
management, specifically when<br />
overwhelming pain prevents progress<br />
in functional restoration and if injection<br />
therapy has been considered and/or<br />
fails 20, 21 . Opioids should never be<br />
used in isolation, and must always<br />
be used only with a comprehensive<br />
functional restoration program 20, 21 .<br />
Thus, clinicians should not become<br />
over-enthusiastic or overzealous<br />
about opioids and should keep them<br />
in perspective within therapeutic<br />
techniques. A critical assessment <strong>of</strong> the<br />
literature and the risk to benefit ratio<br />
suggest that opioid therapy in CRPS<br />
is extremely questionable.<br />
R. Norman Harden, MD, is the Director<br />
for the Center <strong>of</strong> Pain Studies and holds<br />
the Robert G. Addison Chair in Pain<br />
Studies at the Rehabilitation Institute<br />
<strong>of</strong> Chicago. Dr. Harden is currently<br />
researching medication trials for pain,<br />
post-amputation pain, psychological<br />
aspects <strong>of</strong> pain, complex regional<br />
pain syndrome (CRPS), fibromyalgia,<br />
headache, back and neck surgery, spinal<br />
cord injury, and Multiple Sclerosis. Dr.<br />
Harden is also currently the Chairman<br />
for the Clinical Affairs Committee<br />
<strong>of</strong> the <strong>Reflex</strong> <strong>Sympathetic</strong> <strong>Dystrophy</strong><br />
<strong>Association</strong>. n<br />
References<br />
1. Butler SH. Opiates for chronic pain:<br />
present <strong>America</strong>n controversy. Regul Pept.<br />
1994;52:S295-S296.<br />
2. Portenoy RK. Opioid therapy for chronic<br />
nonmalignant pain: a review <strong>of</strong> the critical issues.<br />
J Pain Sympt Manage. 1996;11(4):203-217.<br />
3. Harden RN. Chronic opioid therapy: another<br />
reappraisal. Am Pain Sac Bull. 2002 Jan/Feb.<br />
4. Turner JA, Calsyn DA, Fordyce WE, Ready LB.<br />
Drug utilization patterns in chronic pain patients.<br />
Pain. 1982;12:357-363.<br />
5. Schug SA, Large RG. Opioids for chronic noncancer<br />
pain. Pain Clin Update. 1995;111(3):104.<br />
6. Turk DC, Brody MC. Chronic opioid therapy for<br />
persistent non-cancer pain: Panacea or oxymoron?<br />
APS Bull. 1991:1(1):4-7.<br />
7. Wilson PR. Editorial. Opioids and chronic pain.<br />
Clin J Pain. 1997;13:1-2.<br />
8. Dubner R. A call for more science, not more<br />
rhetoric, regarding opioids and neuropathic pain.<br />
Pain.1991:47:1-2.<br />
9. Harden RN. Pharmacotherapy <strong>of</strong> complex<br />
regional pain syndrome. Am J Phys Med Rehabil.<br />
2005;84(3 Suppl):817-828.<br />
10. Hord ED, Oaklander AL. Complex regional<br />
pain syndrome: a review <strong>of</strong> evidence supported<br />
treatment options. Curr Pain Headache Rep.<br />
2003;7(3):188-196.<br />
11. Kingery WS. A critical review <strong>of</strong> controlled<br />
clinical trials for peripheral neuropathic pain<br />
and complex regional pain syndromes. Pain.<br />
1997;73:123-139.<br />
12. Harke H, Gretenkort P, Ladleif HU, Rahman<br />
5, Harke O. The response <strong>of</strong> neuropathic pain<br />
and pain in complex regional pain syndrome I to<br />
carbamazepine and sustained-release morphine in<br />
patients pretreated with spinal cord stimulation:<br />
a double-blinded randomized study. Anesth Analg.<br />
2001;92(2):488-495.<br />
13. Watson CP, Babul N. Efficacy <strong>of</strong> oxycodone in<br />
neuropathic pain: a randomized trial in postherpetic<br />
neuralgia. Neurol. 1998;50(6):1837-1841.<br />
14. Beydoun A. Neuropathic pain: from<br />
mechanisms to treatment strategies. J Pain Sympt<br />
Manage. 2003;25(5 Suppl):S1-S3.<br />
15. Sindrup SH, Jensen TS. Pharmacologic<br />
treatment <strong>of</strong> pain in polyneuropathy. Neurol.<br />
2000;55(7):915-920.<br />
16. Benedetti F, Vighetti S, Amanzio M, et al.<br />
Dose-response relationship <strong>of</strong> opioids in nociceptive<br />
and neuropathic postoperative pain. Pain.<br />
1998;74(2-3):205-11.<br />
17. Daniell HW. Hypogonadism in men consuming<br />
sustained-action oral opioids. J Pain.<br />
2002;3(5):377-384.<br />
18. Mercadante S, Ferrera P, Villari P, Arcuri E.<br />
Hyperalgesia: An Emerging Iatrogenic Syndrome.<br />
J Pain Sympt Manage. 2003;26(2):769-775.<br />
19. Mao J, Price DD, Mayer DJ. Mechanisms <strong>of</strong><br />
hyperalgesia and morphine tolerance: a current<br />
view <strong>of</strong> their possible interactions. Pain.<br />
1995;62(3):259-274.<br />
20. Stanton-Hicks M, Baron R, Boas R, et<br />
al. Consensus report: complex regional pain<br />
syndromes: guidelines for therapy. Clin J Pain.<br />
1998;14(2):155-166.<br />
21. Harden RN. Ed. Complex Regional Pain<br />
Syndrome: Treatment Guidelines. Milford, CT:<br />
RSDSA Press; 2006.<br />
15
For many people, the process <strong>of</strong> hiring<br />
a lawyer is fairly straightforward. The<br />
client in need <strong>of</strong> legal services identifies a<br />
selection <strong>of</strong> qualified attorneys, interviews<br />
several <strong>of</strong> those, and selects the one who<br />
appears best suited to undertake the case.<br />
In a perfect world, the most qualified attorney<br />
also possesses those essential qualities—integrity,<br />
diligence, and skill—which<br />
further support the client’s final selection.<br />
The fact is that we don’t live in a perfect<br />
world, and despite the efforts <strong>of</strong> clients<br />
to hire the best lawyer for the job, every<br />
attorney-client relationship is not a “love<br />
connection.” Unfortunately, clients <strong>of</strong>ten<br />
fail to appreciate what is<br />
expected <strong>of</strong> them in the attorney-client<br />
relationship:<br />
choosing instead to believe<br />
that if things did not work<br />
out as expected, it was<br />
entirely the lawyer’s fault.<br />
While all such relationships<br />
may not be salvageable, a<br />
better understanding <strong>of</strong> what<br />
is expected on the part <strong>of</strong> both lawyer and<br />
client can <strong>of</strong>ten help enhance the pr<strong>of</strong>essional<br />
relationship and lead to a better<br />
outcome. The focus <strong>of</strong> this article is not<br />
on how to fire <strong>you</strong>r lawyer–although that<br />
topic is addressed as a last resort. Rather,<br />
this article focuses on what is expected <strong>of</strong><br />
both lawyer and client in order to make the<br />
relationship work best.<br />
The quality <strong>of</strong> the working attorney-client<br />
relationship is vital to the success <strong>of</strong> the<br />
case. Clients and lawyers who work well<br />
together dramatically increase the likelihood<br />
<strong>of</strong> obtaining a favorable result. Conversely,<br />
lawyers and clients who display<br />
all the symptoms <strong>of</strong> a dysfunctional relationship<br />
tend to take it out on the case.<br />
Changing lawyers mid-stream—putting<br />
aside the increased cost and stress which<br />
<strong>of</strong>ten accompany such a change—tends<br />
to transmit a clear signal to the opposing<br />
side that “problems exist.” While these<br />
problems may have absolutely nothing to<br />
do with the underlying case, the opposing<br />
side may misinterpret the cause <strong>of</strong><br />
the break-up and conclude that the case<br />
is in trouble, leading to lower settlement<br />
<strong>of</strong>fers. In short, attempts to salvage the<br />
attorney-client relationship are well<br />
worth the effort.<br />
Rule 1: Check <strong>you</strong>r cynicism<br />
at the door.<br />
Lawyers are highly committed to achieving<br />
their client’s goals. Unfortunately,<br />
client cynicism can impair the attorney-client<br />
relationship early on, leaving clients<br />
questioning their lawyer’s dedication,<br />
when mutual trust should be established<br />
How to Avoid Firing<br />
Your Lawyer<br />
By Eric J. Parker<br />
Parker Scheer LLP<br />
instead. A lawyer I worked with for many<br />
years had a wonderful saying: Never trust<br />
anyone who doesn’t trust <strong>you</strong>. To be honest,<br />
the saying made little sense to me<br />
when I first heard it, but over time, the<br />
wisdom became evident. Pr<strong>of</strong>essionals<br />
who feel distrusted by their clients tend to<br />
withdraw from the relationship in subtle<br />
ways. Calls from clients <strong>of</strong>ten go unanswered<br />
or take longer to return; attorneys<br />
parse their words more carefully and speak<br />
in measured sentences. Perhaps most significantly,<br />
candor is lost and clients receive<br />
less accurate information from the attorney<br />
than would otherwise be communicated.<br />
It may require a leap <strong>of</strong> faith, but by replacing<br />
cynicism with trust at the earliest<br />
stages <strong>of</strong> the relationship, clients can effectively<br />
improve the chances <strong>of</strong> developing<br />
a stronger attorney-client relationship<br />
and achieving the desired objectives.<br />
Rule 2: Maintain reasonable<br />
expectations.<br />
There is perhaps no greater challenge for a<br />
lawyer than the management <strong>of</strong> unreasonable<br />
client expectations. Whether the case<br />
involves a serious, traumatically-induced<br />
injury such as complex regional pain<br />
syndrome (CRPS), or the purchase <strong>of</strong> a<br />
new home, a lawyer cannot be expected<br />
to deliver a result that is completely unreasonable.<br />
Clients <strong>of</strong>ten value their own<br />
cases well above the range typically paid<br />
by insurance companies or juries. The<br />
reason for this is obvious: clients live with<br />
the enormous pain and physical limitations<br />
imposed by their injuries, and insurance<br />
companies do not. It is also important to<br />
recognize that lawyers have no reason to<br />
under-value a case. Since<br />
most personal injury-related<br />
cases are handled on<br />
a contingent fee basis (typically<br />
one third <strong>of</strong> the gross<br />
amount recovered plus case<br />
expenses) plaintiff’s counsel<br />
has every motive to obtain<br />
the very best result possible.<br />
Rule 3: Give it time.<br />
Like it or not, litigation takes time—and a<br />
lot <strong>of</strong> it! A typical personal injury case can<br />
take from one to three years to complete,<br />
depending upon the complexity <strong>of</strong> the case<br />
and the extent <strong>of</strong> the damages. The best<br />
way to devalue a case is to prematurely<br />
push for settlement. Cases prepared for<br />
trial usually settle, whereas cases prepared<br />
for settlement usually go to trial. The reason<br />
for this is clear—insurance companies<br />
perceive aggressive efforts to settle cases<br />
as strong indications that the plaintiff is<br />
uncomfortable having their case tried<br />
before a jury. If true, the insurance companies<br />
believe they can resolve the case<br />
for lower values than would otherwise be<br />
acceptable if the client were committed to<br />
trial. Therefore, allowing the case to “mature”<br />
can greatly enhance the overall value<br />
<strong>of</strong> the settlement.<br />
Rule 4: Be direct.<br />
I have a phrase I use to (affectionately)<br />
describe a certain category <strong>of</strong> clients: I<br />
16 RSDSA Review: Vol. 20, Issue 3
call them “after thinkers.” After thinkers<br />
are clients who nod their heads up<br />
and down during client conferences only<br />
to telephone me later with a variety <strong>of</strong><br />
questions and concerns that could have<br />
been addressed during the conference. I<br />
suspect that a major cause <strong>of</strong> “after thinking”<br />
is awkwardness. Clients <strong>of</strong>ten feel<br />
uncomfortable challenging a lawyer’s<br />
opinions in real time. Unfortunately, delaying<br />
important questions or concerns<br />
tends to lead attorneys to conclude that<br />
there is consensus between<br />
lawyer and client, when<br />
in fact such is not the<br />
case. If <strong>you</strong> have concerns<br />
about any aspect <strong>of</strong> <strong>you</strong>r<br />
case–ask. If <strong>you</strong> do not understand<br />
the case plan <strong>you</strong>r<br />
lawyer has developed, ask<br />
for an explanation. If <strong>you</strong><br />
still do not understand the<br />
case plan, ask until <strong>you</strong> do<br />
understand it.<br />
Rule 5: Too many<br />
cooks spoil the soup—<br />
and the case.<br />
If <strong>you</strong> find <strong>you</strong>rself losing confidence in<br />
<strong>you</strong>r attorney, make an appointment to<br />
meet in person and address <strong>you</strong>r concerns<br />
face to face. Too <strong>of</strong>ten, dissatisfied clients<br />
tend to seek out the opinions <strong>of</strong> other lawyers,<br />
who have little or no familiarity with<br />
the particular facts and circumstances surrounding<br />
the client’s case. This results in<br />
greater confusion on the part <strong>of</strong> the client.<br />
Don’t expect a lawyer who has not had the<br />
benefit <strong>of</strong> working on <strong>you</strong>r case to have<br />
the answers. It’s unreasonable and selfdefeating.<br />
Instead, advise <strong>you</strong>r lawyer that<br />
<strong>you</strong> have concerns and insist on answers<br />
that help <strong>you</strong> to resolve them.<br />
A brief word about Workers’<br />
Compensation cases<br />
The two most common scenarios where<br />
people find themselves injured and subsequently<br />
seeking compensation involve<br />
injuries suffered at work and outside <strong>of</strong><br />
work. If an injury occurs during <strong>you</strong>r employment,<br />
odds are that <strong>you</strong> will be filing<br />
a “Workers’ Compensation” (WC) claim.<br />
You may also have a direct claim against<br />
the responsible party, known as a “Third<br />
Party Claim.” Clients with WC claims<br />
<strong>of</strong>ten find themselves frustrated with “the<br />
system,” due in large part to the added<br />
level <strong>of</strong> bureaucracy inherent in the WC<br />
System in most states. Unlike direct actions,<br />
such as non-work-related car accidents,<br />
persons injured at work are entitled<br />
“Despite the efforts<br />
<strong>of</strong> clients to hire the best<br />
lawyer for the job, every<br />
attorney-client relationship<br />
is not a “love connection.”<br />
to immediate reimbursement for medical<br />
expenses and lost earnings. However, insurance<br />
companies tend to question many<br />
<strong>of</strong> the claimant’s bills and other submissions.<br />
These denials are a common source<br />
<strong>of</strong> frustration for injured workers, and<br />
<strong>of</strong>ten result increased frustration with the<br />
claimant’s lawyer. Before assuming that<br />
<strong>you</strong>r lawyer is responsible for the delay<br />
in payment for lost wages or outstanding<br />
medical bills, ask <strong>you</strong>r lawyer why things<br />
are taking so long.<br />
What can I do when all else fails?<br />
Although I tend to be an optimist, believing<br />
that most troubled attorney-client<br />
relationships can be saved, clearly some<br />
cannot. Lawyers who fail to return client<br />
telephone calls promptly, or ignore<br />
repeated requests for updates on cases, or<br />
are generally unavailable to their clients,<br />
must take responsibility for the failure <strong>of</strong><br />
the relationship, and should be discharged<br />
before the case is jeopardized. In most<br />
states, when a client retains a lawyer in<br />
connection with a personal injury case, the<br />
client signs what is known as a Contingent<br />
Fee Agreement. According to the terms <strong>of</strong><br />
the agreement, the attorney’s compensation<br />
depends on the attorney’s ability to<br />
obtain an economic recovery on behalf <strong>of</strong><br />
the client. However, most contingent fee<br />
agreements also state that the attorney has<br />
a duty to take all reasonable and necessary<br />
steps to obtain a recovery on behalf <strong>of</strong> the<br />
client, and his obligation<br />
to return calls and respond<br />
to reasonable requests for<br />
case updates is implicit. If<br />
the attorney breaches the<br />
agreement, the client may<br />
discharge the attorney “for<br />
cause.” The attorney may<br />
attempt to seek compensation<br />
from the client based on<br />
the number <strong>of</strong> hours devoted<br />
to the case, but these claims<br />
are difficult for attorneys to<br />
enforce, particularly if they<br />
have failed to live up to their<br />
end <strong>of</strong> the deal.<br />
The Bottom Line<br />
Preserving a relationship with <strong>you</strong>r attorney<br />
is generally preferable to discharging<br />
<strong>you</strong>r attorney. Clients who understand<br />
their role in the attorney-client relationship<br />
tend to enhance the value <strong>of</strong> their case and<br />
reduce instances <strong>of</strong> client dissatisfaction. If<br />
the relationship cannot be saved—do not<br />
sit on <strong>you</strong>r hands—move on.<br />
Attorney Eric J. Parker is a top-rated<br />
trial lawyer with more than 20 years <strong>of</strong><br />
active experience representing victims<br />
<strong>of</strong> negligence, including those suffering<br />
from trauma-induced Complex Regional<br />
Pain Syndrome (CRPS). Parker Scheer<br />
LLP has <strong>of</strong>fices in Boston, Massachusetts,<br />
Providence, Rhode Island, and Las Vegas,<br />
Nevada. Contact Attorney Parker at ejp@<br />
parkerscheer.com, or visit the firm website<br />
at www.parkerscheer.com. n<br />
17
D o n a t i o n s<br />
In Honor<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Larry Abrams –<br />
In honor <strong>of</strong> Mark Ryan<br />
Warren Adler – In honor <strong>of</strong><br />
Suzanne Laraia<br />
Diane Bertolino – In honor<br />
<strong>of</strong> My Doctors & Nurses<br />
Dr. and Mrs. Sterling Delano –<br />
In honor <strong>of</strong> Elizabeth Simes<br />
Gerda Lannom – In honor <strong>of</strong><br />
Gerda Lannom<br />
James Prendergast – In honor<br />
<strong>of</strong> Betty Maul<br />
Dolores Spinello – In honor <strong>of</strong><br />
Suzanne Laraia<br />
Thomas Tobin – In honor <strong>of</strong><br />
Jeanne Tobin<br />
Barbara Tota – In honor <strong>of</strong><br />
Leslee Tota<br />
In honor <strong>of</strong> Charleen Garcia<br />
Jack and Jill Crevier<br />
Laurie Crevier Hughes<br />
Lynn Hewitt<br />
Brian and Ann Smith<br />
Julie Smith<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Larry Smith<br />
In Memory<br />
Grosse Pointe Education<br />
<strong>Association</strong> – In memory <strong>of</strong><br />
Kevin Stall<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Nathan Miller –<br />
In memory <strong>of</strong> Jerry Rodin<br />
Jessie Olsen – In memory <strong>of</strong><br />
Larry Watson<br />
In Memory <strong>of</strong> Irene Parr<br />
Mr. and Mrs. James Egan<br />
Mary Furlong<br />
Patricia M. Melvin<br />
Mr. and Mrs. James O’Toole<br />
Mr. and Mrs. George Pantos<br />
William Parker<br />
In Memory <strong>of</strong> Janet Anne Ross<br />
Gordon and Judy Bylsma<br />
Tammy Hadlow<br />
Patricia Kajdasz<br />
Judith Lagano<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Terrence Murphy<br />
Mr. and Mrs. George Phillips<br />
VA Community Care Center<br />
Staff – NY<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Thomas Walker<br />
In Memory <strong>of</strong> Alex Viespi<br />
Warren Adler<br />
Joseph Ambriano<br />
Marie Azzaro<br />
Deborah Caswell<br />
William Higgins<br />
Theow Lau<br />
Florence Leotta<br />
Maureen Meehan<br />
Joan Robertson<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Richard Scibelli<br />
Dolores Spinello<br />
Donations $100 and Above<br />
Amherst Firefighters – In honor<br />
<strong>of</strong> Irene M. Morrissey Parr<br />
Margaret Andruczyk<br />
Susan Blutter<br />
Buehler & Buehler Structural Engineers – In<br />
honor <strong>of</strong><br />
Kimberly Mosier-Lemon<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Philip Castiglia –<br />
In memory <strong>of</strong> Alex Viespi<br />
Philip and Mary Castiglia and Family – In<br />
memory <strong>of</strong> Alex Viespi<br />
Coal Cracker Cruisers Car Club<br />
– In honor <strong>of</strong> Joann Spalnick<br />
James A. Connelly<br />
Barbara DeMarco<br />
James and Idamarie Duffy<br />
Dori Eber<br />
Patricia Etts – In memory <strong>of</strong><br />
Mary G. Marcinelli<br />
Dr. and Mrs. Ira L. fox<br />
Bruce Gillman<br />
Dr. and Mrs. Irwin Harris –<br />
Happy Birthday to Mark Nestler<br />
Helene Jablway<br />
Mary Kenagy<br />
Becky Kosher<br />
Mrs. R. A. Lackman, Jr. – In honor<br />
<strong>of</strong> Anna Crawford and in<br />
memory <strong>of</strong> Rhett<br />
Melenie O. Magnotta – In honor<br />
<strong>of</strong> Mary Beth Ludington<br />
Dena, Bonnie, and Robert<br />
Manheimer<br />
John and Jody Maron – In honor<br />
<strong>of</strong> Charleen Garcia<br />
Betty and Bob Maul, and Nick<br />
Patrissi – In memory <strong>of</strong><br />
Jennie Cusenza<br />
Sandy Mazzurco<br />
California Office <strong>of</strong> Vital Records<br />
– In memory <strong>of</strong> Kimberly Lemon<br />
Cynthia Palka – In memory <strong>of</strong><br />
Janet Anne Ross<br />
Vera Parfylo<br />
Ann Rectorfine-Sturm<br />
Stanley Sanders<br />
Maureen and Stephen Scaring –<br />
In honor <strong>of</strong> Suzanne Laraia<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Kenneth Schieck –<br />
In memory <strong>of</strong> Kimberly Lemon<br />
Kristen R. Shores<br />
Sharon A. Smith – In honor <strong>of</strong><br />
Cathy Hartney<br />
Dr. and Mrs. Robert Tortorelli<br />
Abigail Weinshank – Happy<br />
Birthday to Mark Nestler<br />
Christine Wu<br />
$200 and Above<br />
Anthony Fitzgerald – In honor<br />
<strong>of</strong> Suzanne Laraia<br />
Warren B. Freitag, MD<br />
Graphic Arts Logistics, LLC –<br />
In honor <strong>of</strong> Betty Maul<br />
Elena Kassner<br />
Stacy Lademar<br />
Debbie Schwartz<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Ronald Scott<br />
Susan Watson – In memory <strong>of</strong><br />
Larry Watson<br />
$300 and Above<br />
Diane Keil<br />
$500 and above<br />
John Crawford – In honor <strong>of</strong> Anna Crawford<br />
and in memory <strong>of</strong> Rhett<br />
Rian Kray<br />
$800 and above<br />
Happy Birthday to Mark Nestler from:<br />
The Kleinman Family<br />
The Ackerman Family<br />
The Prussin Family<br />
The Rabinowitz Family<br />
The Spitzberg Family<br />
The Sherman Family<br />
The Mitchel Family<br />
The Shirvan Family<br />
Bounty <strong>of</strong> Hope Donations<br />
$100 and above<br />
Robert and Deborah Broatch<br />
Michael Brucato<br />
Thomas Caprio<br />
Jean Campbell<br />
Catherine Emmanuel<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Meyer Neville<br />
Julie R. Evans<br />
Filimon Benefits Group, Inc.<br />
Leslie Geneen<br />
Nancy and Joseph Gherardi<br />
Carlotta Gladding<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Victor Henningsen<br />
Marty Higgins<br />
Thomas Kelly<br />
Mr. and Mrs. John Kilmartin<br />
Donald and Marilyn Maher<br />
Anthony Marinelli<br />
Mr. and Mrs. James Murphy<br />
Sue Murphy<br />
Marie O’Driscoll<br />
Summit Racing Equipment<br />
Barbara Voltz<br />
$200 and Above<br />
Lorraine and Kenneth Ali<br />
Clare Bohnett<br />
Angela Calitri<br />
Dana Maul<br />
Police Athletic League <strong>of</strong><br />
Philadelphia<br />
Dr. William and Marilyn Bellavia<br />
$300 and Above<br />
Martin H. Abo, CPA<br />
Jeanne Michelle Bingaman<br />
Joan Blackwell<br />
Dennis J. Delisle<br />
Laurie Englander Dubner<br />
Christine/Henry Di Bona/Saraceni<br />
Richard Haunss<br />
Bob Jennings<br />
Mr. and Mrs. James Kenny<br />
Mary Beth and Hank Ludington<br />
J. M. Patton Associates, Inc.<br />
Scott MacPherson<br />
Joseph Marcelli<br />
Nubar Nakashian<br />
Dr. Richard Pearsall<br />
Robert and Margot Rosen<br />
Sandy Alexander Inc.<br />
Bruce Shapiro<br />
Dr. Carol Werle<br />
$400 and Above<br />
Quebecor World<br />
$500 and Above<br />
Joe Duncan<br />
James Gaynor<br />
F. H. Ludington, Jr.<br />
David J. Steinhardt<br />
$600 and Above<br />
Mac Byrd<br />
CGI North <strong>America</strong><br />
Dora Cardinale<br />
Case Management Network, Inc.<br />
EMR<br />
Dr. and Mrs. Bradley Galer<br />
David and Liz Lowenstein<br />
William and Amy McLean<br />
Peter Moskovitz, MD<br />
$800 and Above<br />
Fujifilm<br />
Ogilvy HealthWorld<br />
Quebecor World<br />
$1,000 and Above<br />
Alpharma Pharmaceuticals LLC<br />
Carole and Norman Barham Family<br />
Quad/Graphics<br />
$1,200 and Above<br />
Susan Tufo<br />
18 RSDSA Review: Vol. 20, Issue 3
$1,500 and Above<br />
Ronald P. Goldfaden<br />
Mr. and Mrs. William Laraia<br />
Sterling and Sterling<br />
$2,000 and Above<br />
Steven Hardwick<br />
Bounty Sponsors - $3,000<br />
Rebecca Amoroso<br />
Brown Printing Company<br />
Cephalon, Inc.<br />
Deloitte Consulting<br />
Horizon Paper Company<br />
Kodak Polychrome Graphics<br />
Corporate Reproduction Center<br />
Christine LaSala<br />
Peter McLean<br />
Medtronic Neuromodulation<br />
Patton Boggs LLP<br />
Diane Romano<br />
Seersha, Ltd.<br />
Bounty Benefactors - $5,000<br />
Advanced Neuromodulation Systems<br />
<strong>America</strong>n International Group, Inc.<br />
(AIG)<br />
Purdue Pharma, L.P.<br />
PT/OT DVD – Donations<br />
$100 and Above<br />
Arndt Acupuncture<br />
Linda R. Baker<br />
David and Judith Barnett<br />
Jean Brand<br />
Ruth Caputo<br />
Donald Christman<br />
Edward and Anna Crawford<br />
Rodney Derstine<br />
James Dryden<br />
David and Edie Faile<br />
Steven D. Feinberg, MD<br />
Bruce Gilman<br />
Norma Ginsburg<br />
Steven Goren, Attorney at Law<br />
Stephanie Heitmeyer<br />
Jocelyn Helm<br />
Sandra Helm<br />
Horizon Paper Company<br />
Gladys Husted<br />
Janet Johnson<br />
Joseph E. Johnson<br />
Linda Krononberger<br />
Mr. and Mrs. William Laraia<br />
James Lee<br />
John F. Leech<br />
Karen Marcus<br />
Mary Carroll Miller<br />
Elizabeth M. Nielsen<br />
Linda Norwood<br />
RONSCO (DEL), Inc.<br />
Mary Ross<br />
Audrey Russ<br />
Elisabeth Stillitano<br />
Gayle Tonon<br />
James E. Tyrrell, Jr.<br />
$200 and Above<br />
Jean and Gary Brzezinski<br />
Margarethe Daly<br />
Jean M. Lindgren<br />
Diane Ore<br />
Kelly Stock<br />
$300 and Above<br />
Barry Meinerth<br />
$500 and Above<br />
Eric Eichler<br />
Joav and Miriam Gersten<br />
Glenn and Tamara Gracon<br />
Mary Alice McLarty, P.C.<br />
Susan Tufo<br />
$700 and Above<br />
Posh Properties #11<br />
$1,000 and Above<br />
Mr. and Mrs. James Broatch<br />
Carol J. Batdorf<br />
Raised over $4,000<br />
Bernie Ackerman<br />
$5,000 and Above<br />
Bonaventura Devine Foundation, Inc.<br />
Mrs. Elaine Yadwin Rieser<br />
$10,000 and Above<br />
Endo Pharmaceuticals, Inc.<br />
New Jersey Fundraiser<br />
$200 and Above<br />
Apryl Basile<br />
2007 Atlanta CME Conference<br />
$2,500<br />
Endo Pharmaceuticals, Inc.<br />
$5,000<br />
Elan Pharmaceuticals, Inc.<br />
Medtronic Global Pain Management<br />
Nippon Zoki Pharmaceuticals <strong>America</strong><br />
Corporate Grant<br />
$5,000<br />
Endo Pharmaceuticals, Inc.<br />
Donation $10,000<br />
Printing and Imaging <strong>Association</strong><br />
– In honor <strong>of</strong> Betty Maul<br />
Research In Honor<br />
Jean Campbell – In honor <strong>of</strong><br />
Jim Broatch<br />
Jean DiRado – In honor <strong>of</strong> Charleen<br />
Garcia<br />
Larry and Casey Smith – In honor<br />
<strong>of</strong> Charleen Garcia<br />
In Memory<br />
Nancy Jacobus – In memory<br />
<strong>of</strong> Frank Phillips<br />
$100 and Above<br />
Monette Ashen<br />
Marysusan D. Autera<br />
Mrs. Petra Buehler – In memory<br />
<strong>of</strong> Alex Viespi and in honor<br />
<strong>of</strong> Suzanne Laraia<br />
Tita Cahn – In memory <strong>of</strong> Alex Viespi<br />
Dora Cardinale<br />
Jeff Hamsen<br />
Donna Kahn<br />
Mr. and Mrs. Michael J. Materazo<br />
– In memory <strong>of</strong> Alex Viespi<br />
Jodi Rebholz<br />
Bruce Shapiro<br />
$200 and Above<br />
Emma Dennis<br />
North <strong>America</strong>n Publishing Company<br />
$500 and Above<br />
Edward and Anna Crawford –<br />
In honor <strong>of</strong> Anna Crawford<br />
and in memory <strong>of</strong> Rhett<br />
Christopher Kinal – Wedding<br />
Congratulations to Marilyn Murray<br />
$1,000 and Above<br />
In honor <strong>of</strong> Carol McGrath –<br />
From Her Family<br />
Research<br />
2007 Achilles Walk in Atlanta, GA<br />
$100 and Above<br />
Liza Bryan<br />
Linda Hanley<br />
Lauren and Micah Vance<br />
Jennifer Lang<br />
$300 and Above<br />
Betty Hall<br />
2007 Walk in Minnesota<br />
$100 and Above<br />
Sherri Flores<br />
Carol Kiernan<br />
Caroline Nerud<br />
$1,000 and Above<br />
David Breitsprecher<br />
2007 Achilles Walk in New York City<br />
$100 and Above<br />
Susan and Ted Corn<br />
B. C. and D. E. Drake<br />
Ethelyn Geschwind<br />
Cheryl Wexler<br />
Stacy Lademar<br />
Andrea Lebbin<br />
Marjorie Leffler<br />
Malek Properties<br />
Michele Mauer<br />
I. Miller<br />
Robin Peck<br />
Jennifer Ross<br />
$200 and Above<br />
Attorney Michael Frey<br />
Thomas Tobin<br />
Gloria Renaro<br />
$500 and Above<br />
Dena, Bonnie, and Robert Manheimer<br />
$1,000 and Above<br />
Roger and Deborah Lebbin<br />
$3,000 and Above<br />
Edward Delia<br />
$5,000 and Above<br />
Celgene Corporation<br />
Research $15,000<br />
James Farnsworth – In honor <strong>of</strong> his<br />
granddaughter Katie Berberi<br />
Research $78,000<br />
James and Blanche Verunac<br />
The Rachel Tobias Young Investigator Award<br />
Lauren Kimbar<br />
$200 and Above<br />
Alma Tobias<br />
Daniel Tobias<br />
$2,000 and Above<br />
Cooper City High School, Florida –<br />
Fundraiser by Nicole Biller<br />
$100,000<br />
Anonymous<br />
Individuals who collected research<br />
donations via canisters<br />
Helga and Sal Cracolici - $80.00<br />
Rob Dryden - $203.90<br />
RSDSA Office - $68.00<br />
PENPALs<br />
Harry L. Beckett<br />
BZ1379-1100 Pike Street<br />
Huntingdon, PA 16654-1112<br />
Michelle Baum<br />
3661 Managua Dr.<br />
Westerville, OH 43081<br />
19
Please Type or Print.<br />
RSDSA Contribution<br />
Name<br />
Home Phone<br />
Home Address<br />
City state Zip email<br />
Enclosed is my donation for RSDSA Research or Public Awareness<br />
For credit card orders, please complete.<br />
Visa MasterCard <strong>America</strong>n Express<br />
Card number<br />
exp. Date<br />
Signature<br />
Amount <strong>of</strong> donation $ (all donations are tax deductible)<br />
Donation in memory <strong>of</strong>:<br />
Donation in honor <strong>of</strong>:<br />
Please check if <strong>you</strong> Do Not want this donation listed in the next RSDSA Review<br />
Please make check or money order payable in $US to RSDSA fund. Mail <strong>you</strong>r check with this form to:<br />
RSDSA, 99 Cherry St., Milford, CT 06460.<br />
Non Pr<strong>of</strong>it<br />
Organization<br />
US Postage<br />
PAID<br />
cherry hill, NJ<br />
Permit No 932<br />
99 Cherry Street, Milford, CT 06460