07.02.2014 Views

AUTHOR COPY - Trent University

AUTHOR COPY - Trent University

AUTHOR COPY - Trent University

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Original Article<br />

Conceptualizing holism in international<br />

interdisciplinary critical perspective:<br />

Toward a framework for understanding<br />

holistic health<br />

Farah M. Shroff<br />

Department of Family Practice, <strong>University</strong> of British Columbia, Vancouver BC, Canada.<br />

E-mail: fmcshroff@gmail.com<br />

Abstract The concept of holism is defined in disparate ways. This article offers<br />

foundational understandings of this term from various parts of the world, illustrating the<br />

virtually universal, historical, as well as contemporary nature of ideas such as interconnectedness,<br />

unity and oneness. Throughout human history, holistic worldviews were<br />

dominant until the past 400 years or so. At present, a revival of holistic thought-forms is<br />

taking place in many parts of the world. The purpose of this article is to sketch the<br />

landscape of holistic philosophical foundations, discuss systems science in this context<br />

and apply these underpinnings to holistic health in the hope that it will increase our<br />

understanding of both the conceptual foundations of holism, as well as its applications<br />

to health promotion, disease prevention, treatment of ill health and palliation. The<br />

article will conclude with the recommendation that holistic health-care practitioners<br />

take social inequities into account, so that this integrative health-care can become a<br />

means for individuals to take action for wellness, as well as a means to create structural<br />

changes toward equitable resource distribution.<br />

Social Theory & Health (2011) 9, 244–255. doi:10.1057/sth.2011.6;<br />

published online 8 June 2011<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

Keywords: holism; mind-body; interconnection; systems science; interdisciplinary;<br />

international<br />

Introduction: Principles of Holism<br />

The words health and holistic are semantically related. They both stem from the<br />

same root word: the Anglo-Saxon words whole, hale and holy (Pretorius, 2009).<br />

Despite the linguistic connection, the word holistic is used in incongruent<br />

ways and has become an umbrella term that is used to encompass anything<br />

r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255<br />

www.palgrave-journals.com/sth/


Conceptualizing holism in international interdisciplinary critical perspective<br />

that is non-reductionist or dualist. Holism is sometimes spelled as wholism, to<br />

accentuate the semantic connections of this word to the word ‘whole’. In this<br />

article, the concept holistic health-care will be used interchangeably with<br />

alternative or complimentary medicine and will be defined as approaches to<br />

well-being and treatment of illness that focus on mind and body. In addition to,<br />

the term holistic health-care is used in this article to encompass both self-care<br />

and practitioner-based care. Holistic self-care encompasses practices such as<br />

yoga, meditation, Tai Chi and Chi Gung. Holistic care provided by professionals<br />

encompasses traditional Chinese medicine, ayurveda, homeopathy, botanical<br />

medicine, therapeutic massage and others.<br />

Holistic schools of thought vary from region to region, and throughout time, but<br />

have more similarities than differences. A number of principles unite them.<br />

One principle they have in common is that entities and systems in the universe,<br />

including humans, are considered part of a unified whole, which cannot be<br />

understood by the isolated examination of its separate parts (Dusek, 2006).<br />

These parts are actively interrelated. Similarly, matter is interlinked, interconnected<br />

and dynamic; it is constantly changing and it is this transformation that<br />

denotes time.<br />

Holistic worldviews do not focus exclusively on the body or organism, but on<br />

the larger world – the universe – and are often associated with spiritual or<br />

religious thought-forms. At the heart of holism, there is an awareness of the<br />

unity and mutual interrelation of all things and events. All things are seen as<br />

interdependent and inseparable. This ultimate, indivisible reality is called<br />

Brahman in Hinduism, Dharmakaya in Buddhism and Tao in Taoism. As it<br />

transcends all concepts and categories, Buddhists also call it Tathata-Suchness<br />

(Deshmukh, 2006), That Which Is, or Is-ness, the sum of all forms.<br />

In Hinduism, we find a similar emphasis: ‘a fundamental Hindu principle<br />

is one of Unity of all created things. Behind diversity, there is unity. Behind<br />

individual souls, there is the Self, one with the Divine. Not only human life but<br />

all created life including animal life is a unity. We spring from one source.<br />

Differences and divisions are unreal. The belief that we originate from one<br />

common source has ethical implications: it leads to a kinder and a gentler<br />

world’ (Goel, 2006). One of the Hindu texts, the Isa-Upanisad states: ‘[b]ut<br />

he (sic) who beholds all beings in his (sic) own Self, and his (sic) own Self in all<br />

beings, does no longer hate (vijugupsate)’ (stanza 6).<br />

These views are also echoed in other traditions. According to African holistic<br />

views, for example, the cosmos is one, a spiritual totality. Spirit is not separate<br />

from matter, as everything is connected (Asante and Mazama, 2009). In African<br />

holistic thought, all things are considered to be related through one divine force<br />

(Asante and Mazama, 2009). They are alive, giving and receiving energy, with<br />

all life and matter created for a specific purpose.<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255<br />

245


Shroff<br />

First Nations philosophies are similar. First Nations peoples see themselves as<br />

part of a Sacred Hoop or Circle of Life, not having control over it; they are<br />

careful to maintain a balance with life (Hunter et al, 2006). Just as we impact<br />

the broad cultural climate in which we live, our physical, emotional and psychological<br />

health is influenced by that very climate. Social harmony thus influences<br />

individual well-being in many First Nations cosmo-visions. First Nations<br />

healers advise people to see everyone as a family member or friend thus<br />

encouraging social integration (Musqueum Elder Shane Pointe, 5 November 2006,<br />

personal communications). The Medicine Wheel, representing harmony and<br />

connectivity, takes this concept further. It represents all of creation: all planets,<br />

stars, peoples, animals and plants. It is the basis of community health with the<br />

circle symbolizing the cycles of the seasons and of life, and wholeness and perfection.<br />

First Nations peoples’ healing circles, sweat lodge ceremonies and other<br />

healing rituals are generally performed in a circle. The circle emphasizes togetherness<br />

and community unity, without which the individual cannot be well.<br />

Systems science<br />

These ancient principles are also present in some fields within contemporary<br />

science. Francisco Varela, for example, observes that Buddhist ideas are prevalent<br />

throughout our Western culture – in physics and biology, for example,<br />

the basic ideas are Buddhism in disguise (Lee, 2006). During the past few<br />

decades, scientists from various disciplines, such as Ilya Prigogine, Erich<br />

Jantsch, Gregory Bateson, Humberto Maturana and Manfred Eigen, have developed<br />

emerging systems views of the world and made the study of living systems,<br />

organisms, social systems and ecosystems their focus.<br />

The systems view focuses on integration and relationships and sees systems<br />

as integrated wholes whose properties cannot be reduced to its smaller units.<br />

Every organism, from the smallest bacterium to plants, animals and humans, is<br />

integrated and considered as living systems. Families and communities are also<br />

considered as systems. Gregory Bateson (1972), for example, was interested in<br />

studying patterns, which connect crabs to lobsters, orchids to humans and in<br />

seeing the interrelatedness of life forms. For hundreds of years, much of<br />

Western science concentrated on isolating the world’s basic building blocks.<br />

Now that this has been achieved to some extent, the systems approach emphasizes<br />

principles of organization (Kineman and Kumar, 2007) creating a more<br />

ample understanding of matter, from macro- and micro-perspectives. Systemic<br />

properties are lost when a system is dissected, either physically or theoretically,<br />

into isolated elements. Although it is possible to discern individual parts in<br />

any system, the nature of the whole is different from the mere sum of its<br />

parts (Kineman and Kumar, 2007). This understanding ties in very well with<br />

principles of holism and holistic health.<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

246 r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255


Conceptualizing holism in international interdisciplinary critical perspective<br />

The New Physics<br />

Connected to systems science, some physicists also make connections between<br />

their work and holistic thought-forms. Notable physicists such as David Bohm<br />

and Fritjof Capra emphasize the similarities between their theories of the indistinguishability<br />

of field and force and mind and matter, with the spiritual traditions<br />

of Buddhism, Confucianism, Hinduism and Taoism. Over the past 2000<br />

years or more, Buddhists have developed sophisticated philosophical, phenomenological<br />

and epistemological ideas, and they have found a very practical<br />

way to apply them (Lopez, 2008). Some Western scientists, such as those who<br />

study the mind, have been profoundly influenced by Buddhist thought and<br />

have worked to establish empirical correlations between Buddhist practice and<br />

scientific work (Lopez, 2008; Weaver et al, 2008). Western tradition has avoided<br />

the idea of a selfless self, of a virtual self. This egolessness, or selflessness, is at<br />

the very core of Buddhism.<br />

Capra (2002) also extends the framework of systems and complexity theory to<br />

the social domain, akin to the foundational principles of holism. He uses this extended<br />

framework to discuss some of the critical issues of our time – the management<br />

of human organizations, the challenges and dangers of economic globalization,<br />

the scientific and ethical problems of biotechnology, and the establishment of ecologically<br />

sustainable communities and technologies (Capra, 2002).<br />

Bohm conceptualizes an implicate order to the universe composed of frequencies<br />

beyond time and space that has been hidden from people. His paradigm is<br />

a form of ontological holism. In this conception of order, primacy is given to the<br />

undivided whole, and the implicate order inherent within the whole, rather than<br />

to parts of the whole (Healey, 2009).<br />

These scientists emphasize in their work the same notions as holism; the<br />

whole is greater than the sum of its parts. The natural world interacts synergistically.<br />

It is thus not possible to fully understand systems by knowing the<br />

properties of their individual components – although it is useful to study individual<br />

components. Indeed, as stated by Capra,‘the basic oneness of the universe<br />

is not only the central characteristic of the mystical experience but it is also<br />

one of the most important revelations of modern physics. It becomes apparent<br />

at the atomic level and manifests itself more and more as one penetrates deeper<br />

into matter, down into the realm of subatomic particles’ (Gaan, 2005, p. 324).<br />

The observer of a scientific experiment, according to quantum theory, can<br />

change the outcome of an experiment, simply by observing, for the observer<br />

puts energy into the system and this energy has an impact on that, which is<br />

being observed. Just as Buddhist and Hindu philosophy stress, the observer<br />

and observed are seen as connected, as are mind and matter, field and force.<br />

As Gary Zukav explains, quantum theory sees everything in the universe as<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255<br />

247


Shroff<br />

related and interrelated at the most subatomic level, making it impossible to<br />

observe reality without altering it (Edmison, 2004).<br />

The new physics thus emphasizes the interrelational, indeterminate and<br />

probabilistic qualities of matter and energy, and challenges components of the<br />

scientific method related to Newtonian mechanics, such as determinism and<br />

linear causality.<br />

New science and holistic health<br />

Some physicians are moving beyond these ‘old’ scientific paradigms, however,<br />

in conceptualizing health issues (McQuaide, 2005). Although there are literally<br />

thousands of allopathic physicians whose work incorporates ideas of holistic<br />

health, Deepak Chopra, MD, and Andrew Weil, MD, have gained great popularity.<br />

Their work has successfully bridged a gap between reductionism and<br />

holism and, drawing from quantum mechanics theory, has conceptualized the<br />

differences between a reductionist and quantum or holistic paradigm for health.<br />

These allopathic physicians with holistic inclinations predict that sooner or<br />

later, allopathic medical science will catch up with the theoretical revolution in<br />

physics – as the interdependence of mind and matter is now firmly established<br />

in the model of reality used by contemporary physicists; these physicians assert<br />

that medical researchers ought to seriously take up the research challenge of<br />

analyzing how the mind and body interact.<br />

A relatively new branch of scientific inquiry, psychoneuroimmunology, has<br />

taken up this challenge. It integrates some of the ideas from quantum mechanics,<br />

psychology, neurology and endocrinology. Psychoneuroimmunologists primarily<br />

theorize the mind/body connection through studying the brain and hormones.<br />

Hormones, particularly those from the brain, are seen as the link between the<br />

mind and body. Candace Pert made headlines with her 1970’s research on<br />

neuropeptides as the ‘molecules of emotion’ and was also featured in the film<br />

What The Bleep Do We Know (2004) (Bruce, 2005). Pert’s research was posited<br />

on the presumption that neuropeptides are the molecular messengers that affect<br />

the metabolism of the cell and link the nervous, immune and endocrine systems<br />

(Pert and Marriott, 2007). Pert’s contributions have given birth to a large number<br />

of such studies within the reductionist scientific community.<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

Holistic health<br />

The aforementioned concepts of systems science and holism find concrete application<br />

in systems of holistic health promotion, disease prevention, treatment<br />

of illness and/or palliative care such as yoga, ayurvedic medicine, Chi Gung,<br />

Tai Chi, Traditional Chinese Medicine and African and Indigenous systems of<br />

health-care. What connects the diversity of these holistic traditions is that<br />

without exception, they take into account mind, body, the environment and the<br />

248 r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255


Conceptualizing holism in international interdisciplinary critical perspective<br />

interconnection between them. They recognize the interrelationship between<br />

human health and the social and physical environment. Holistic health theory is<br />

posited on the notion that life force (or prana (in Sanskrit), chi (in Chinese),<br />

mana (in Hawaiian) connects all life in the universe, and that this energy is<br />

responsible for the life of all beings. Prana is that which gives us life, or the<br />

vehicle of life, the cosmic breath, the rhythmic oscillation effective on all levels<br />

of conditioned existence. Restoring and keeping this life force flowing is one<br />

way of keeping people healthy.<br />

We may typify holistic health with various characteristics such as the notion<br />

that health is a positive state, not merely the absence of disease, and that health is<br />

tied closely to familial, social and cultural environments. Holistic health-care is<br />

also characterized by the belief that successful healing transforms the practitioner,<br />

as well as the client and that healing includes a spiritual component in the etiology<br />

and treatment of illness. Holistic health-care understands malfunctions (illness) in<br />

the context of the social, cultural and spiritual environment. Treatment of both<br />

body and mind are considered integral (Barnes et al, 2004).<br />

Tibetan medicine is similar. Religious rituals such as prayer are central for<br />

both the practitioner and patient. Because of the sacred nature of healing,<br />

Tibetan doctors of yore did not charge for their service (Dunkenberger, 2009).<br />

Such religious, spiritual and social aims of healing are combined in many<br />

systems of holistic health.<br />

The body is understood in a unified manner within holistic health perspectives.<br />

Injury to one part of the body may thus damage another, seemingly unrelated,<br />

part. Kidney malfunctioning, for example, may result from a damaged heart.<br />

If one part of the kidney is injured, another part may take over its functions.<br />

Holistic principles maintain that the body has an innate capacity to heal itself,<br />

and the role of the physician is to first do no harm and second to assist the body<br />

in its natural tendency toward balance. Andie Knutson (1961) declares:<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

Many of the ills of modern society stem from attempts to deal with men<br />

(sic) segmentally rather than with men (sic) as a unit. Specialization,<br />

which seems to be an inevitable outgrowth of scientific advance, results in<br />

institutions competing with one another for various segments of a man<br />

(sic) who is seeking to maintain his integrity as a total being. How far<br />

removed we are from the medicine man (sic)! He has strengths that have<br />

not been duplicated in our modern society. (p. 1702)<br />

Despite the fact that Knutson was writing approximately 50 years ago, the<br />

segmentation, atomization and specialization of modern society continue to exist.<br />

More than 2300 years ago, the Greek philosopher Hippocrates emphasized<br />

that doctors should consider the whole human being in order to treat and<br />

diagnose. Included in the Hippocratic Oath is an allegiance to Hygeia, the<br />

r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255<br />

249


Shroff<br />

Goddess of Good Health, who is synonymous with hygiene, disease prevention<br />

and therapeutic medicine (Capra, 2002). The Hippocratic Doctrine, which ostensibly<br />

underlies the basis for current allopathic medicine, stresses that: ‘the wellbeing<br />

of men (sic) is influenced by all environmental factorsythe quality of air,<br />

water and food, the winds and topography of the land’ (Maurer and Smith,<br />

2005, p. 597). 1 Although allopathic medicine has not generally been shaped<br />

by this complex view of health and disease, holistic concepts exist within<br />

allopathic theoretical frameworks. But theory is often not put into practice. This<br />

is, of course, true of all systems of medicine. However, allopathic doctors are<br />

increasingly using alternative medicine in their practices, and some allopathic<br />

doctors hire alternative practitioners to work in their offices. Increasingly,<br />

nurses, midwives and other health-care practitioners also incorporate holistic<br />

practices into their clinics.<br />

Holistic health-care: A growing trend<br />

Although allopathic medicine is useful for the treatment of acute and emergency<br />

care needs, holistic health-care appears to be more promising for chronic conditions<br />

and mental health-care, which constitute a majority of health problems,<br />

since chronic diseases are a leading cause of death and disability around the<br />

world. The interest in holistic care in North America is growing among health<br />

professionals and the general public. In the United States, for example, spending<br />

on alternative medicine has increased from 14 billion in the early 1990s to 21<br />

billion in 1997 (McQuaide, 2005). Moreover, 36 per cent of adults are using<br />

some form of holistic and alternative medicine (Barnes et al, 2004). If megavitamin<br />

therapy and prayer specifically for health reasons are included as well,<br />

that number rises to 62 per cent (Barnes et al, 2004). In Canada, that number is<br />

similar with one study finding that 73 per cent of Canadians have used some<br />

form of holistic health-care in their lifetime (Esmail, 2007). While studies measure<br />

different definitions of holistic health and varying time periods, Canadians<br />

are increasingly using holistic health-care.<br />

The popularity of holistic health-care is in part because of the increasing<br />

dissent with the present system of medical care delivery. Some people, particularly<br />

women, prefer holistic practitioners partly because of practitioner<br />

friendliness and interpersonal sensitivity (Kelner and Wellman, 1997; Barnes<br />

et al, 2004). Fewer side effects, the perceived lack of harm from holistic healthcare<br />

and the possibility of improved health are other reasons why Canadians are<br />

turning to holistic health-care practices (Quan et al, 2008).<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

Holistic health-care critically examined<br />

It is precisely because of their growth and interest that holistic models also need<br />

to be considered critically. Most systems of holistic health are overly concerned<br />

250 r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255


Conceptualizing holism in international interdisciplinary critical perspective<br />

with the individual and her/his mind, body and spirit, but rarely examine the<br />

health connections to the larger social world (Shroff, 2000). This is probably<br />

the most astute criticism of holistic health-care. Most systems of health-care,<br />

including holistic ones, do not include social health as a major component. This<br />

lack of attention to public health-care is a serious gap in holistic health-care<br />

practices. Furthermore, within many systems of holistic medicine, patriarchal<br />

and classist overtones are apparent. In ayurveda, for example, some interpretations<br />

of tridosha theory (which notes different body/mind types among<br />

people) have likened vata (the air/ether type) to the Brahmin caste and portrayed<br />

vata people as noble, whereas kapha (the earth/water type) is portrayed as<br />

docile and slow, as the ‘ideal’ Indian woman ought to be. In Chinese medicine,<br />

yin traditionally means the shady side of a mountain, but is also related with<br />

femaleness; under a patriarchal lens, yin and women are considered sinful. For<br />

Taoists, there is no such thing as absolute moral judgments, with neither Ying<br />

nor Yang representing good or bad (Brodd, 2009). Although this reasoned view<br />

(which states that neither yin nor yang is good or bad) is probably the original<br />

medical understanding, oppressive structures have affected modes of thinking.<br />

Most likely, the original writings were not corrupted by hierarchical social<br />

structures, but have over time, given that medicine and politics are intricately<br />

intertwined, been politicized. Upper class, patriarchal and heterosexist interpretations<br />

of holistic health concepts flourish in the literature (Lu, 2005; Lad,<br />

2006; Liao, 2006; Lad and Durve, 2008; Gyatso and Hakim, 2010).<br />

Furthermore, holism has been embraced by several groups, including those<br />

who serve non-holistic ends. Among them are ‘new age’ entrepreneurs who are<br />

profiting from the commodification of holistic health, including shamanic healing,<br />

hypnosis, trance work and so forth. Practitioners, who claim to be holistic, may<br />

excuse sexist, heterosexist, classist and racist behavior in the social organization<br />

of their work, on the grounds that the culture from which it comes is based on<br />

oppressive notions. This kind of appropriation and misrepresentation of holism is<br />

dangerous, as are the claims made by practitioners masquerading as holistic<br />

healers, stating that they can miraculously cure diseases in order to lure vulnerable<br />

and ill people into paying large sums of money for unproved therapies.<br />

Some aspects of these therapies are problematic when they fail to take<br />

into account power differences and their grafted relationship with race, class,<br />

gender, sexual orientation, ability, age and so forth. Some, such as Louise Hay,<br />

go as far as to suggests that people are 100 per cent responsible for creating their<br />

experiences (Dua, 2006). This completely negates the existence of hierarchies<br />

such as imperialism, racism, patriarchy, heterosexual dominance and so forth.<br />

Although it is pleasant to entertain the thought that individuals who create<br />

peace and harmony in their lives will have no (health) problems, it defies the<br />

experiences of many of us. There is always the danger of simplifying health and<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255<br />

251


Shroff<br />

healing to a point where power relations are not taken into account. Unfortunately,<br />

this simplistic type of analysis pervades the New Age Movement’s rhetoric, which<br />

results in various forms of ‘victim blaming’ (Crawford, 2006).<br />

Although it is true that the New Age Movement emphasizes fitness, wellness,<br />

prevention and risk reduction, whereas downplaying the vast and ambiguous<br />

external forces that influence health, we must be cautious not to confuse New<br />

Age entrepreneurs with holistic health practitioners. The critique that holistic<br />

health provides an individualistic solution to problems of health by changing<br />

the individual rather than the social causes of illness rings true. Plus, the victimblaming<br />

ideology promoted by some holistic health-care providers shifts the<br />

burden of blame to the individual rather than the social context (Crawford,<br />

2006). Yet this critique applies to allopathic medicine as well. Allopathic<br />

medicine does not encompass a social and political view of the determinants<br />

of health either. In itself, it is not a solid enough argument to dismiss holism.<br />

It is, combined with the above arguments of appropriation and class privilege,<br />

a solid basis for dismissing the New Age Movement as opportunistic, however.<br />

In closing<br />

The concept of holism is international and ancient. Crossing countries and<br />

historical periods, holistic thought and health practices based on these thought<br />

forms flourished for centuries and declined over the past 400 years, in part<br />

because of the growth in reductionist thinking and its off-shoot, allopathic medicine.<br />

At present, there is a global re-emergence of holistic thinking and holistic<br />

practices. This article analyzed the historical, as well as contemporary basis of<br />

holism as interconnectedness, unity and oneness, and its application to holistic<br />

health-care.<br />

Neither the allopathic nor the holistic model of care attend to social inequities,<br />

yet holistic practices generally take into account the many facets of the<br />

individual – emotional, social, mental and spiritual. It is partly for this reason<br />

that holistic care is popular. However, holistic health-care can be improved, and<br />

serve the needs of more people if race, class and gender analyses were taken<br />

into account. The health of the individual is clearly linked to her or his income,<br />

employment, security and social status. Deepening our understanding of the<br />

impact of social inequities on an individual’s health will contribute to more<br />

efficient and just (holistic) health-care systems. Major institutions are currently<br />

studying alternative medicines, including herbal remedies, bodywork, meditation,<br />

dietary changes and more. Various studies, including some randomized<br />

clinical trials, are available on almost every type of alternative healing practice,<br />

and they typically show good results (Jonas et al, 2006; Carlson et al, 2007;<br />

Garner et al, 2007; John et al, 2007; Maa et al, 2007; Sareen et al, 2007; Wang<br />

et al, 2007). Working together, there is great potential for holistic health-care<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

252 r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255


Conceptualizing holism in international interdisciplinary critical perspective<br />

and allopathic medicine to improve population health. Given that the basis of<br />

holistic philosophy is unity and oneness, a health-care system that incorporates<br />

the most effective aspects of various systems of medicine would have powerful<br />

potential to improve population health on many levels. If practitioners were to<br />

also take social inequities into account, this integrative health-care could truly<br />

become a means for individuals to take action for wellness, as well as a means<br />

to create structural changes toward equitable resource distribution. I have<br />

written elsewhere (Shroff, 1996) about a health-care system that incorporates<br />

public health approaches and integrates best practices from multiparadigmatic<br />

medical systems.<br />

This article also reviewed the interdisciplinary nature of the concept of<br />

holism, illustrating the philosophical and scholarly unity in the notions of unity<br />

and oneness, interconnection, inseparability of mind and body. Modern physics,<br />

particularly quantum mechanics, is at the forefront of the scientific frontier<br />

that has arrived at the same conclusions as philosophical ideas from Hinduism,<br />

Buddhism, Indigenous, African and other cosmologies. Systems science, an<br />

interdisciplinary enterprise, is also part of this movement away from a reliance<br />

on reductionist thinking.<br />

Although holistic thought-forms are ancient, they have modern applications.<br />

One of the most significant applications are holistic health practices that are<br />

re-emerging the world over. This article has explored the underlying context of<br />

this resurgence.<br />

About the Author<br />

Farah M. Shroff, PhD, is a public health researcher, educator and activist. She<br />

teaches at the <strong>University</strong> of British Columbia’s Medical School. She has a<br />

keen interest in Health for All and divides her research program into: a) social<br />

justice issues related to health and b) holistic health: mind/body approaches<br />

to health. She has written about Ayurveda, yoga, naturopathy, midwifery,<br />

nursing, health advocacy, HIV/AIDS and more.<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

Note<br />

1 Marti Kheel (1989) warns that Hippocrates’ contributions are often idealized as holistic. She<br />

argues that Hippocratic ideas marked the beginnings of a dualistic mentality that separated<br />

mind and body, human being and nature. She notes that in Hippocratic medicine, the patient’s<br />

symptoms were aggravated to the point of a healing crisis. Purgings, bleedings, induced<br />

vomitings and other ‘heroic’ feats were used in this task. ‘The notion of “aiding” nature had<br />

already led to the practice (by male physicians) of giving her a “helpful” shove. Meanwhile,<br />

r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255<br />

253


Shroff<br />

witches and faith healers were branded by Hippocrates as charlatans and quacks’ (p.101).<br />

Kheel thus links the demise of holistic healing to some of the principles espoused by<br />

Hippocrates. She also links patriarchal domination to the destruction of holistic healing, which<br />

was practised primarily by women. She asserts that the Greeks were the beginnings, in the<br />

‘Western’ world, of wararchy: cultures based on war-worship, which moved away from the<br />

Goddess-worshipping cultures of the pre-patriarchal world. This mentality is perpetuated by<br />

metaphors such as the ‘war’ against disease.<br />

References<br />

Asante, M.K. and Mazama, A. (eds.) (2009) Encyclopedia of African Religion, Vol. 1. Thousand Oaks,<br />

CA: Sage Publications.<br />

Barnes, P., Powell-Griner, E., McFann, K. and Nahin, R. (2004) Complementary and alternative<br />

medicine use among adults: United States, 2002. Seminars in Integrative Medicine 2(2): 54–71.<br />

Bateson, G. (1972) Steps to an Ecology of Mind. Novato, CA: Chandler Publication.<br />

Brodd, J. (2009) World Religions: A Voyage of Discovery. Winona, MN: Saint Mary’s Press.<br />

Bruce, A. (2005) Beyond the Bleep: The Definitive Unauthorized Guide to What the Bleep do we<br />

Know!? New York, NY: Disinformation Company.<br />

Capra, F. (2002) The Hidden Connections: A Science for Sustainable Living. New York, NY: Doubleday.<br />

Carlson, L.E., Speca, M., Faris, P. and Patel, K.D. (2007) One year pre-post intervention follow-up of<br />

psychological, immune, endocrine and blood pressure outcomes of mindfulness-based stress<br />

reduction (MBSR) in breast and prostate cancer outpatients. Brain, Behavior and Immunity 21(8):<br />

1038–1049.<br />

Crawford, R. (2006) Health as meaningful social practice. Health 10(4): 401–420.<br />

Deshmukh, V.D. (2006) Neuroscience of meditation. The Scientific World Journal 16(6): 2239–2253.<br />

Dua, A. (2006) Feminist Psychology. New Delhi, India: Publications.<br />

Dunkenberger, T. (2009) Tibetan medicine-application in the West. Journal of Traditional Tibetan<br />

Medicine 2: 12–15.<br />

Dusek, V. (2006) Philosophy of Technology: An Introduction. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell.<br />

Edmison, K. (2004) Growing a Healthy Ministry: A Resource for Congregations and Communities.<br />

Kelowna, BC: Wood Lake Publishing.<br />

Esmail, N. (2007) Complementary and alternative medicine in Canada: Trends in use and public<br />

attitudes, 1997–2006. In: Public Policy Sources, Number 87. Vancouver, BC: The Fraser Institute.<br />

Gaan, N. (2005) Relevance of Environment: A Critique on International Relation Theories. Delhi,<br />

India: Kalpaz Publications.<br />

Garner, M.J. et al (2007) Chiropractic care of musculoskeletal disorders in a unique population<br />

within Canadian community health centers. Journal of Manipulative and Physiological<br />

Therapeutics 30(3): 165–170.<br />

Goel, M.L. (2006) Oneness in Hinduism, http://www.boloji.com/hinduism/128.htm, accessed<br />

4 May 2010.<br />

Gyatso, T. and Hakim, C. (2010) Essentials of Tibetan Traditional Medicine. Berkeley, CA: North<br />

Atlantic Books.<br />

Healey, R. (2009) Holism and nonseparability in physics. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy,<br />

http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2009/entries/physics-holism/, accessed 27 November 2009.<br />

Hunter, L.M., Logan, J., Goulet, J.-G. and Barton, S. (2006) Aboriginal healing: Regaining balance<br />

and culture. Journal of Transcultural Nursing 17(1): 13–22.<br />

John, P.J., Sharma, N., Sharma, C.M. and Kankane, A. (2007) Effectiveness of yoga therapy<br />

in the treatment of migraine without aura: A randomized controlled trial. Headache 47(5):<br />

654–661.<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

254 r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255


Conceptualizing holism in international interdisciplinary critical perspective<br />

Jonas, W.B. et al (2006) Can homeopathic treatment slow prostate cancer growth? Integrative Cancer<br />

Therapies 5(4): 343–349.<br />

Kelner, M. and Wellman, B. (1997) health-care and consumer choice: Medical and alternative<br />

therapies. Social Science & Medicine 45(2): 203–212.<br />

Kheel, M. (1989) From healing herbs to deadly drugs: Western medicine’s war against the natural<br />

world. In: J. Plant (ed.) Healing the Wounds: The Promise of Ecofeminism, pp. 96–111.<br />

Kineman, J.J. and Kumar, A.K. (2007) Primary natural relationship: Bateson, Rosen, and the Vedas.<br />

Kybernetes 36(7/8): 1055–1069.<br />

Knutson, A. (1961) Psychological basis of human behavior. American Journal of Public Health 51(7):<br />

1699–1708.<br />

Lad, V. (2006) Textbook of Ayurveda: A Complete Guide to Clinical Assessment, Vol. 2. Albuquerque,<br />

NM: Ayurvedic Press.<br />

Lad, V. and Durve, A. (2008) Marma Points of Ayurveda: The Energy Pathways for Healing body,<br />

Mind and Consciousness with a Comparision to Traditional Chinese Medicine. Albuquerque, NM:<br />

Ayurvedic Press.<br />

Lee, J. (2006) Cross-cultural consensus between Buddhist reality and modern science. International<br />

Journal of Buddhist Thought & Culture 6: 25–51.<br />

Liao, Y. (2006) Traditional Chinese Medicine. Bejing, China: China Intercontinental Press.<br />

Lopez, D.S. (2008) Buddhism & Science: A Guide for the Perplexed. Chicago, IL: <strong>University</strong> of Chicago<br />

Press.<br />

Lu, H.C. (2005) Traditional Chinese Medicine: How to Maintain Your Health and Treat Illness. Laguna<br />

Beach, CA: Basic Health Publications.<br />

Maa, S.H., Tsou, T.S., Wang, K.Y., Wang, C.H., Lin, H.C. and Huang, Y.H. (2007) Self-administered<br />

acupressure reduces the symptoms that limit daily activities in bronchiectasis patients: Pilot<br />

study findings. Journal of Clinical Nursing 16(4): 794–804.<br />

Maurer, F.A. and Smith, C.M. (2005) Community/Public Health Nursing Practice: Health for Families<br />

and Populations. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier Health Sciences.<br />

McQuaide, M. (2005) The rise of alternative health-care: A sociological account. Social Theory &<br />

Health 3: 286–301.<br />

Pert, C. and Marriott, N. (2007) Everything you Need to Know to Feel Good. USA/India/Australia/<br />

Canada: Hay House.<br />

Pretorius, S.P. (2009) Is ‘divine healing’ in the ‘Faith Movement’ founded on the principles of<br />

healing in the Bible or based on the power of the mind? HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological<br />

Studies 65(1): 1–7.<br />

Quan, H., Lai, D., Johnson, D., Verhoef, M. and Musto, R. (2008) Complementary and alternative<br />

medicine use among Chinese and white Canadians. Canadian Family Physician 54(11): 1563–1569.<br />

Sareen, S., Kumari, V., Gajebasia, K.S. and Gajebasia, N.K. (2007) Yoga: A tool for improving the<br />

quality of life in chronic pancreatitis. World Journal of Gastroenterology 13(3): 391–397.<br />

Shroff, F. (1996) New directions in Canadian health policy: Lessons from Holistic medicine. Doctoral<br />

dissertation, <strong>University</strong> of Toronto.<br />

Shroff, F. (2000) Forget reform: We need a revolution! Better health for Canadian women through<br />

holistic care. In: D. Gustafson (ed.) Care and Consequences: The Impact of Health Care Reform.<br />

Halifax, NS: Fernwood Publishing, pp. 271–293.<br />

Wang, S.M., Punjala, M., Weiss, D., Anderson, K. and Kain, Z.N. (2007) Acupuncture as an<br />

adjunct for sedation during lithotripsy. Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine<br />

13(2): 241–246.<br />

Weaver, A.J., Vane, A. and and Flannelly, K. (2008) A review of research on Buddhism and health:<br />

1980–2003. Journal of Health Care Chaplaincy 14(2): 118–132.<br />

<strong>AUTHOR</strong> <strong>COPY</strong><br />

r 2011 Macmillan Publishers Ltd. 1477-8211 Social Theory & Health Vol. 9, 3, 244–255<br />

255

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!