Camilty Wind Farm - Partnerships for Renewables
Camilty Wind Farm - Partnerships for Renewables Camilty Wind Farm - Partnerships for Renewables
Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect Development Phase Sensitivity/ Importance of Receptor Magnitude of Change Level of Effect (and Significance) Prior to Mitigation Mitigation Enhancement Level of Effect (and Significance) after Mitigation Nature of Effect Recreation and outdoor access Outdoor Access development opportunities. Operational phase. Medium: The site is currently not well used for public access and has excellent potential. Small: the extent of new footpaths that would be created is limited. Slight (not significant) - - Moderate Positive: New access opportunities may be created. Recreation and outdoor access Outdoor Access (off site) experience. Operational phase. High: The Pentland Hills is a popular recreational resource and is sufficeintly close to be potentially affected. Small:The far west of the Regional Park in closest proximity to the proposed wind farm is far less used as a recreational resource than other parts of the Park. The number of people who feel strongly enough about wind farms that it would deter them from using these accesss routes is likely to be very small. Slight (not significant) - - Slight (not significant) Negative: Some access users may be deterred by visual effects. March 2013 15-32 ES Chapter 15 Copyright Partnerships for Renewables Development Co. Ltd 2013 © Socio-Economics, Tourism, Land-Use and Recreation
Camilty Wind Farm 15.7 Cumulative Effects 15.7.1 No potential for cumulative effects upon employment and the economy and land use due to the proposed wind farm and other existing wind farms, those which have planning permission or valid applications for wind farms in the area has been identified. 15.7.2 The greatest potential for having a significant detrimental effect on the levels of tourism and recreational activity in the area as a result of cumulative effects would be on the Pentland Hills Regional Park. This potential is based on the findings of the landscape and visual impact assessment (ES chapter 9) which identifies that the greatest number of views of cumulative wind farms would be attained from within the Pentland Hills. As previously identified, the sensitivity of the Pentland Hills Regional Park is considered to be high given its importance as an established and popular recreational resource and its close proximity to the site. 15.7.3 The landscape and visual impact assessment identifies that there would be a number of potential combined and successive cumulative effects from viewpoints within the Regional Park. These cumulative effects would predominantly arise as a result of the number of proposed wind farms which lie in close proximity to the proposed wind farm, in particular the proposed Fauch Hill Wind Farm (a 23 turbine scheme approximately 1.6 km from the proposed wind farm), the proposed Harburnhead Wind Farm (a 22 turbine scheme approximately 1.9 km from the proposed wind farm) and the proposed Pearie Law Wind Farm (a 6 turbine scheme approximately 3.3 km from the proposed wind farm). However, the landscape and visual assessment concludes that the addition of the proposed wind farm into this potentially far more developed cumulative context would result in a lower level of landscape and visual effect compared with seeing the proposed wind farm in a relatively undeveloped context such as the current baseline. Consequently the landscape and visual impact assessment predicts that there would be no significant cumulative effects upon the Pentland Hills as a result of the introduction of the proposed wind farm. 15.7.4 On the basis of the findings of the landscape and visual impact assessment, as well as on the findings of the various surveys as identified above into the effect of wind farms on tourists and recreational users, it is considered that the number of recreational users who may deterred from visiting the Pentland Hills Regional Park by potential cumulative impacts arising from the introduction of the proposed wind farm would be very small. The magnitude of change is therefore considered to be small, resulting in a slight negative predicted effect on the recreational demand within the Pentland Hills during the operational phase. 15.7.5 The landscape and visual impact assessment also considers the potential for cumulative effects on the A70, including the sections to the south and to north of the site which West Lothian Council has identified as principal sensitive tourist routes. As previously identified, given that neither of these routes form signed tourist routes or scenic routes as shown on any motoring or tourists maps, the sensitivity of these receptors is considered to be low. 15.7.6 To the south, the landscape and visual assessment concludes that the addition of the proposed wind farm to the proposed Harburnhead, Pearie Law and Fauch Hill Wind Farms would result in significant adverse visual effects on the section of the A70 within 4 km of the site when travelling north in views extending from Cobbinshaw Reservoir on the left of the A70 across to the Pentland Hills on the right. This section of road includes the section at the southern West Lothian boundary identified as a sensitive tourist route. However, given that March 2013 15-33 ES Chapter 15 Socio-Economics, Tourism, Land-Use and Recreation Copyright Partnerships for Renewables Development Co. Ltd 2013 ©
- Page 448 and 449: Camilty Wind Farm 13.5.32 The site
- Page 450 and 451: Camilty Wind Farm Superficial Depos
- Page 452 and 453: Camilty Wind Farm 110% of the fuel
- Page 454 and 455: Camilty Wind Farm • Improving wat
- Page 456 and 457: Camilty Wind Farm March 2013 be nea
- Page 458 and 459: Camilty Wind Farm Table 13.18 Summa
- Page 460 and 461: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 462 and 463: Camilty Wind Farm • Scottish Gove
- Page 464 and 465: Camilty Wind Farm (as shown on Figu
- Page 466 and 467: Camilty Wind Farm at the time of oc
- Page 468 and 469: Camilty Wind Farm Criteria for Magn
- Page 470 and 471: Camilty Wind Farm • “The locati
- Page 472 and 473: Camilty Wind Farm 15.3.11 The econo
- Page 474 and 475: Camilty Wind Farm Land Use 15.3.19
- Page 476 and 477: Camilty Wind Farm 15.3.30 Tourism f
- Page 478 and 479: Camilty Wind Farm • Linlithgow Ca
- Page 480 and 481: Camilty Wind Farm were not availabl
- Page 482 and 483: Camilty Wind Farm • A 5.5 km trai
- Page 484 and 485: Camilty Wind Farm 15.4.6 In additio
- Page 486 and 487: Camilty Wind Farm 15.4.19 Given the
- Page 488 and 489: Camilty Wind Farm exploration of hi
- Page 490 and 491: Camilty Wind Farm • A705 between
- Page 492 and 493: Camilty Wind Farm of the views that
- Page 494 and 495: Camilty Wind Farm Table 15.9 Summar
- Page 496 and 497: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 500 and 501: Camilty Wind Farm the justification
- Page 502 and 503: Camilty Wind Farm 16 Summary of Eff
- Page 504 and 505: Camilty Wind Farm Table 16.2 Summar
- Page 506 and 507: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 508 and 509: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 510 and 511: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 512 and 513: Camilty Wind Farm Table 16.5 Summar
- Page 514 and 515: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 516 and 517: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 518 and 519: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 520 and 521: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 522 and 523: Camilty Wind Farm Level of Level of
- Page 524 and 525: Camilty Wind Farm Level of Level of
- Page 526 and 527: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 528 and 529: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 530 and 531: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 532 and 533: Camilty Wind Farm Receptor Effect D
- Page 534 and 535: Camilty Wind Farm site management.
- Page 536 and 537: Camilty Wind Farm Topic Landscape a
- Page 538 and 539: Camilty Wind Farm Topic Key Mitigat
- Page 540 and 541: Camilty Wind Farm Topic Hydrology,
- Page 542 and 543: Camilty Wind Farm Topic Key Mitigat
- Page 544 and 545: Camilty Wind Farm Topic Key Mitigat
- Page 546 and 547: Camilty Wind Farm Topic Key Mitigat
<strong>Camilty</strong> <strong>Wind</strong> <strong>Farm</strong><br />
Receptor Effect Development<br />
Phase<br />
Sensitivity/<br />
Importance of<br />
Receptor<br />
Magnitude of<br />
Change<br />
Level of<br />
Effect (and<br />
Significance)<br />
Prior to<br />
Mitigation<br />
Mitigation Enhancement Level of<br />
Effect (and<br />
Significance)<br />
after<br />
Mitigation<br />
Nature of<br />
Effect<br />
Recreation<br />
and outdoor<br />
access<br />
Outdoor<br />
Access<br />
development<br />
opportunities.<br />
Operational<br />
phase.<br />
Medium: The<br />
site is currently<br />
not well used<br />
<strong>for</strong> public<br />
access and has<br />
excellent<br />
potential.<br />
Small: the extent of<br />
new footpaths that<br />
would be created is<br />
limited.<br />
Slight (not<br />
significant)<br />
- - Moderate Positive: New<br />
access<br />
opportunities<br />
may be<br />
created.<br />
Recreation<br />
and outdoor<br />
access<br />
Outdoor<br />
Access (off<br />
site)<br />
experience.<br />
Operational<br />
phase.<br />
High: The<br />
Pentland Hills<br />
is a popular<br />
recreational<br />
resource and is<br />
sufficeintly<br />
close to be<br />
potentially<br />
affected.<br />
Small:The far west of<br />
the Regional Park in<br />
closest proximity to<br />
the proposed wind<br />
farm is far less used<br />
as a recreational<br />
resource than other<br />
parts of the Park. The<br />
number of people<br />
who feel strongly<br />
enough about wind<br />
farms that it would<br />
deter them from<br />
using these accesss<br />
routes is likely to be<br />
very small.<br />
Slight (not<br />
significant)<br />
- - Slight (not<br />
significant)<br />
Negative:<br />
Some access<br />
users may be<br />
deterred by<br />
visual effects.<br />
March 2013 15-32 ES Chapter 15<br />
Copyright <strong>Partnerships</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Renewables</strong> Development Co. Ltd 2013 ©<br />
Socio-Economics, Tourism, Land-Use and Recreation